From Literary Lore to Modern Luxury, a Tale of Timeless Charm

Written by Colleen Guilfoile Richmond

In the heart of Sag Harbor, where the whispers of literary giants and the strokes of artistic masters once echoed through its streets, lies Baron’s Cove—a timeless retreat that has undergone a remarkable metamorphosis. Once a favored haunt of luminaries like Truman Capote and Jackson Pollock, Baron’s Cove emerged from a two-year renovation as a beacon of luxury and hospitality, inviting travelers to immerse themselves in its storied past and contemporary comforts.

The Rebirth of an Icon where in 2015, after an extensive renovation led by Cape Resorts hotelier Curtis Bashaw and his sister decorator Colleen Bashaw, Baron’s Cove emerged from its cocoon of nostalgia, unveiling a vision that seamlessly blends its rich heritage with contemporary elegance. From its whitewashed façade to its subtly nautical interiors, every detail speaks to the hotel’s storied past while embracing the demands of the modern traveler.

Step into Baron’s Cove, and you’re greeted by luxury and tranquility. Sixty-seven plush rooms, adorned with monogrammed bedding and serene coastal hues, offer respite from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Whether lounging by the heated saltwater pool or indulging in a seafood feast at the award-winning Restaurant at Baron’s Cove, guests are enveloped in a world of comfort and sophistication.

Beyond its comfortable accommodations, Baron’s Cove radiates warmth and charm as palpable as the sea breeze. From the row of wooden rocking chairs on the porch, offering panoramic views of Sag Harbor, to the intimate lounge where guests can unwind by the fire with a cocktail in hand, every corner of the hotel exudes a sense of welcome and belonging.

As Baron’s Cove recently celebrated its 65th anniversary, it remains steadfast in its commitment to preserving Sag Harbor’s cultural heritage while embracing the innovations of tomorrow. Through partnerships with local organizations like the Sag Harbor Partnership, the hotel continues to support initiatives that honor the area’s history and foster community engagement. From offering transportation to John Steinbeck’s historic home to providing access to its sister property, The Pridwin Hotel on Shelter Island, Baron’s Cove serves as a custodian of Sag Harbor’s legacy.

In a world where change is constant, Baron’s Cove stands as a beacon of continuity—a testament to the enduring allure of Sag Harbor’s shores. As travelers from near and far flock to its whitewashed walls and sun-drenched verandas, they become part of a narrative that spans generations—a narrative of elegance, hospitality, and the timeless beauty of the sea. As Baron’s Cove continues to evolve and thrive, its legacy as a symbol of Hamptons sophistication remains unshakable, ensuring that its place in the annals of Sag Harbor history is etched in stone for generations to come.