Yes, In god’s back yard Collin Cooper
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
a church a cemetery another church not in my back yard yes, in god’s back yard
11
12
a church a cemetery another church not in my back yard yes, in god’s back yard
13
14
a church a cemetery another church not in my back yard yes, in god’s back yard
15
16
a church a cemetery another church yes, in god’s back yard
17
18
ABSTRACT It is not the intent of this thesis to provide a reasonable solution for the affordable housing crisis that plagues many American cities today. It is not within the scope of this research to provide answers as to why the affordable housing gap has become so unmanageable. The intent of this thesis is to illustrate the severity of the affordable housing gap. The scope of this document is to illustrate the process by which I have identified and refined my resolve. The goal of this document, as well as the research and illustrations herein, is to serve as a provocation for a broader discussion centered around the future of housing and the urban fabric of Cincinnati.
19
20
ABSTRACT It is not the intent of this thesis to provide a reasonable solution for the affordable housing crisis that plagues many American cities today. It is not within the scope of this research to provide answers as to why the affordable housing gap has become so unmanageable. The intent of this thesis is to illustrate the severity of the affordable housing gap. The scope of this document is to illustrate the process by which I have identified and refined my resolve. The goal of this document, as well as the research and illustrations herein, is to serve as a provocation for a broader discussion centered around the future of housing and the urban fabric of Cincinnati.
21
22
[58] sites identified
23
24
25
cincinnati, ohio would you just look at that. 26
27
cincinnati, ohio x = church
[58] sites identified within or near cincinnati. 28
29
cincinnati, ohio x = church
[58] sites identified within or near cincinnati. 30
31
cincinnati, ohio x = church
hamilton county outliers eliminated. 32
33
cincinnati, ohio x = church
major roads and public transportation routes identified. 34
35
cincinnati, ohio x = church
outliers not located near public transportation stops eliminated. 36
37
cincinnati, ohio x = church
neighborhoods with fewer than [125] households severely cost burdened [30% ami] eliminated 38
d. 39
cincinnati, ohio
x = church $ = employment center [13] employment centers identified. 40
41
cincinnati, ohio
x = church $ = employment center [1] mile radius around employment centers determined. 42
43
cincinnati, ohio x = church
[18] sites identified. 44
45
cincinnati, ohio x = church
[9] sites identified. 46
47
48
49
50
[09] sites identified
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
[ j]
[k]
library
>s4 \J
2
ool sch >s4 \I
[i]
[k]
library
s4\J
4
[l ]
s3\J
\K
[l ]
1
e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
s4
\L
5
s4
\L
5
[m]
s3
\L
4
s2 \K
s3
barM
\L
4
>s 4\
s2
3
\L
s4 \M
s
L 2\
3
s4 \M
1
s1
\L
s2 \M
2
s3 \M
4
11
2
3
s1\N s1 \O
11
s1 \M
2
s2\N
s3\N
s4\N
3
s1
\L
s2 \M
2
s3 \M
4
3
s1\N s1 \O
11 11
2
s1 \M
1
s2\N
s3\N
s4\N
>s4\N
\P
5
s1
\P
1
s2 \O
4
[n] restaurant
1
s1
2
s2 \O
3
27
s2
1
s3 \O
\P
s4 \O
1
s3
4\ O
\P
[o] publi c >s par
s2
3
\P
s4 \O
4
s3
4\ O
\P
[o] publi c >s par
s3 \O
2
k
s4
\P
[p]
1
k
s4
\P
[p]
>s
P
ing
4\
sw imm
poo l
>s
P
ing
4\
sw imm
poo l
[l ]
e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
5
>s4\N
[l ]
4
[n] restaurant
>s4 \J
4
s4\J
barM
e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
s4
\L
5
[m]
s4
\L
5
[m]
s3
3
>s 4\
s3 \Q
1
>s4 \J
\L
4
barM
>s 4\
s2 \K s3
\L
4
barM >s 4\
s2
3 \L
s4 \M
s
L 2\
3
s4 \M
3
s1
\L
s2 \M
2
s3 \M
4
11
2
3
s1\N s1 \O
11
s1 \M
2
s2\N
s3\N
s4\N
>s4\N
3
s1
\L
s2 \M
2
s3 \M
4 3
s1\N s1 \O
11 11
2 s1 \M
1
s2\N
s3\N
s4\N
>s4\N
s1 \P
2
2
s1
\P
2
s2 \O
4
[n] restaurant
1
1
s2 \O
2
[n] restaurant
5
s2
3
s3 \O
\P
s4 \O
4 s3
4\ O
\P
[o] publi c >s par
s2
3 \P
s4 \O
1 s3
4\ O
\P
[o] publi c >s par
s3 \O
1
k
s4 \P
[p]
1
k
s4
\P
[p]
>s P
ing
4\
sw imm poo l
>s
P
ing 4\
sw imm
poo l
[l ]
e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
5
[m]
[l ]
e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
s4
\L
5
[m]
s4
\L
5
[m]
s3
\L
4
barM >s 4\
s3
\L
4
barM >s 4\
s2
3 \L
s4 \M
s
L 2\
3
s4 \M
3
s1
\L
s2 \M
2
s3 \M
1
11
2
2
s1\N s1 \O
11
s1 \M
2
s2\N
s3\N
s4\N
>s4\N
3
s1
\L
s2 \M
2
s3 \M
4 1
s1\N s1 \O
11 11
2 s1 \M
1
s2\N
s3\N
s4\N
>s4\N
s1
\P
2
5
s1
\P
2
s2 \O
1
[n] restaurant
5
2
s2 \O
2
[n] restaurant
5
s2
3
s3 \O
\P
s4 \O
4 s3
4\ O
\P
[o] publi c >s par
s2
2 \P
s4 \O
4 s3
4\ O
\P
[o] publi c >s par
s3 \O
5
k
s4
\P
[p]
2
k
s4
\P
[p]
\P
sw imm > s in 4 g
poo l
\P
sw imm > s in 4 g
poo l
5
ater the >s4 \R
4 1 1
s2 \Q
2
s2 \Q
2
s1 \Q
ater the >s4 \R
2 1 3 2 s1 \Q
11
1 ater the >s4 \R
3
4
1
s1 \Q
j]
ban k
> s4
5
1
\K
[h]
s4\I
5
re dca chil>s4\H
ban k
> s4
5
s4 \H
12
ter
cen
\G
s4\J
s4 \K
4
4
4
s4
alt > h
s3\I
he
s4 \K
[g]
\G
4
[ j]
s3 \K
3
3
s3 \H
3
3
lon
5
s4
2
s2\J
s2\I
2
2
2
s2 \H
F
hair sa
>s 4\
2
\G
s3\J
[f]
s4 \F
s3
3
s1\I s1\J s1 \K
s1 \H
5
2
111
4
s3 \F
\G
2
11
3
s2
1
4
s4\E
s3\E
s2 \F
2
\G
s3 \K
2
3
s2\E
s1
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
2
s3 \D
s2 \D
2
3
s4 \D
r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
5
4
3
11
s1\E s1 \F
1
et rk \C ma > s 4
\C
\C
2
11
s1 \D
s2 \K
[c]
s4 \Q
2
s3 \Q
s2\J
[r]
2
[k]
library >s4 \J
4 s3 \K
\K
\K
ool sch >s4 \I [i] [k]
library
ban k > s4
5
1 1 re dca chil>s4\H ban k
> s4
5
s4\I
1 s4 \K
4
[h] s4\J
s4 \H
ter hc en
\G
2
s3\J
4 s3\J
2
2
2
s4 \K
4
4 4 >s 4
alt
s3\I
he
4 [g] s3 \K
111
s3 \K
3
3 1 s3 \H
s2\J
s2\I
3
2 s2 \H
s2 \K
s1\I s1\J s1 \K
11
s1 \H
>s4 \J
5 ool sch >s4 \I [i] [k]
2
[k]
library [ j]
ban k
\K > s4
\K
3 salo n F >s 4\
hair
1
s
s4
4
1
1
3
1\J s1 \K
s4 \Q
3
4
s2 \Q
j]
[r]
s2\J
3
2
s3 \Q
1
s4 \Q
1\J s1 \K
4
2
[f]
4
5
>s4 \J
1
s4 \F
y ilit fac rtss4\Q spo > [q]
library
1
[r]
j]
s4\J
[h] s4\J
5 1 re dca chil>s4\H ban k
> s4
5
s4\I
5
5
s4\E
4
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
4
[b] gro cer > s4 y s \B to re
s4 \K
[q] y ilit fac rtss4\Q spo >
1
cer > s4 y s \B to re
s3\J
3 s2\J
s2\I
s4 \K
4
4 2 s4 \H
2
s3\J
s3\I
s2 \K s2 \H
111
2
2
1 2
3
3 3 s3 \H
1 4
s4 \D
2
r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
2
5
salo n F
et rk \ C ma > s 4
4\ G
s4\A
>s 4\
[c]
4
hair
alt
[b] gro
s3 \K
[f]
3
s1\I s1\J s1 \K
11 s1 \H
5
he
ter
s3 \F
s4 \B
hc en
3
3
s3
s2 \B s3\E
s3 \B
\G
3
4
2
[g]
>s 4
s3 \D
s3\A
4
1
1
2
s
s4\A
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
3
s4 \B
s4\E
s4 \F
\C
>s4 \A
4
s4
G
[a] foo d pantry
4\ G
s3 \B
s3 \F
4
1
3
s3\A
s3\E
1
3
>s4 \A
s4 \D
s3 \D
[a] foo d pantry
r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
5
1
5
3
1 et rk \C ma > s 4
s4 \B
3
4 2
s2 \K
s4\A
y ilit fac rtss4\Q spo > [q]
2
s3\A
1
s3 \
2
\C
s3 \B s4
s
2
\C
\C
x.\\17
2
s1\R s1\A s1 \B
3
3 s2 \F
s2\A
[b] gro cer > s4 y s \B to re
s2\J
5
s2\E
2 s2 \D
2
s1
111 11 2
3
3
s2
s1 \Q
s2 \B \C
s2\R
3 s3
2 3
G
1 2\ G
3 2
s3\R
2
2 2
2
s4\R
\G
5 s1
ater the >s4 \R s2\A
s3 \
2 \C
1111 s1\R s1\A s1 \B
s
4
1
5
s2 \F
3
s2
x.\\10
11
2
>s4 \A
s2\E
s2\R
2 s2 \D
2
3
3
s3\R
s2 \B \C
3
s2\A
s3
s4\R
s1\E s1 \F
s2 \Q
1
11
3
x.\\20
2\ G
4
2
2
5
s1 \D
s3 \Q s1 \Q
s1\R s1\A s1 \B
2
ater the >s4 \R
\C
s4 \Q
2
2
s1
66 s2 \Q
111 11
2
[r]
4
2
s3 \Q
s1 \Q
\C
3
3
s2
[r]
2
\G
4
2
s1
ity acil ts f\Q por >s4
s2\R
11
s4 \Q
2
2
s4\R
s1\E s1 \F
4
s2 \Q
[a] foo d pantry
2
s3\R
11
y ilit fac rtss4\Q spo >
4
s1 \D
5
1
5 [c]
s3 \Q
\C
s [q]
s4 \Q
s1
5
5
2
[q]
4
ater the >s4 \R
1
5
[r]
1\J s1 \K
s [q] ity acil ts f\Q por >s4 s4\R
1
s3\R
1
s2\R
3
1 11
s1\R
2
x.\
s4\R
5
s3\R
4
s2\R
3
s1\R
2
1 x.
s4\R
5
s3\R
4
s2\R
3
1 11
s1\R
2
x.\
[f]
\G
>s 4\
2
F
s3
11
s4
[g]
\G
he
1
s4
ter
cen
\G
alt > h
s4 \H
3
s2 \H
s3 \H
4
ool sch >s4 \I
2
3
s1\I s1\J s1 \K
s2\I
2
s3\I
s4\I
4
[ j]
2
s1
\L
111
2
2
s2\J
1
1
>s4 \J
s2
11
2
s1\N s1 \O
11
2
s1 \M
11
\L
s1
\P
1
s2
\P
[ j]
1
4
library
\P
1
s3
ool sch >s4 \I
3
1
s2 \O
s4\I
4
5
3
>s4 \J
library
s2\N
3
4
1
[k]
3
s3\I
s2 \M
1 s3 \K \L
s2\J
s4
s2\I
s3 \M
4
3 s3
2
s3\J
5
s2 \K
3
s3\J
s3 \K
> s4
4
\L
s2 \K
s4 \K
4
s4\J
s4 \K
ban k
\K
3
s2
3
\L
s4 \M
s1 \L
1
s2 \M
2 s3 \M
2
11
1 3
s1\N s1 \O
11
s1 \M
2 s2\N s3\N
s1
\P
2 s2 \O
20
s2
3 s3 \O
\P
s4 \O
1
s3
\P
2
s4
\P >s
\P
in 4 g
poo l
[l ] e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
1
s4\J
3
s4\N
> s4
4
sw imm
s4 \K
[p]
s4\J
ter
cen
\G
1
1 2
\P
2
111
3
s1 \H
s1\I s1\J s1 \K
4
s4
alt > h
[i]
2
11
>s4 \J
library
s4
[i]
s1 \H
1
[l ]
s3 \H
[ j]
1
s2 \H
5
\L
5 [m]
s4
s3 \K
[g]
he
re dca chil>s4\H
ool sch >s4 \I
1
s4 \H
4 4
s3 \O
re dca chil>s4\H
2
s3\J
k
s4\I
s3
3
4\ O
s3\I
barM
>s 4\
4
\L
s2 \K
lon
\G
2
3
3 3
s3\N
5
1
2
2
[h]
4
s2\J
[o] publi c >s par
[i]
2
poo l
4
s2\I
s2
3 s4 \M
\L
2
22
re dca chil>s4\H
3
s1
\L
3
s2 \M
4
11
2 1
s1\N s1 \O
11 s1 \M
2
s2\N s3\N s4\N >s4\N
s1
\P
2
1
s2 \O
1
[n] restaurant
5
s3 \M
2
111
>s4\N
[h]
s3 \H
s1\I s1\J s1 \K
[n] restaurant
s4 \H
11
F
5
s4
[h]
3
s2 \H
s1 \H
4
5
3
2
>s 4\
s3
\G
hair sa
4
lon
\G
hair sa
s4 \F
s2
1
s3 \F
[f]
\L
5
5
s4 \F
\G
s3
4
\G
1
s2 \F
s1
4
s3 \F
5
ban k \K
[h]
[k]
> s4 \K
ban k [h]
5
[k]
5
[h]
re dca chil>s4\H
s2
1
4
3
3
2
s2 \F
3
4 s4 \H
re dca chil>s4\H
[i]
3
4
re dca chil>s4\H s4 \H
[i]
3
1
s4 \H
s3 \H
[i]
\G
\L
s4\E
s3\E
s4\E
s3\E
s2\E
s1
s4
4
1
s2\E
2
11
s1\E s1 \F
11
s1 \D
2
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
1
s3 \D
\C
s2 \D
s1
2
s4 \D
r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
5
4
3
2
5
4
3
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
s3 \D
s2 \D
2
11
s1\E s1 \F
[l ]
et rk \C ma > s 4
\P
[c]
\C
\C
\C
s4 \O
ter
s4
s3
s2
s4 \D
r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
1
4
3
2 s3 \H
s3 \H
2
s2 \H
11
s1 \D
s4 \M
alt
G
hc en 4\
in 4 g
he
>s
>s
[g]
\G
et rk \C ma > s 4
2
s4
h
[c]
\C
\C
s4\N
3
salo n F >s 4\
hair
\G
>
alt
cen ter G
s4
s3
\C
\C
1
[f]
s4 \F
2 s3
barM
5
s3 \F
\G
>s 4\
s4\E
4
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
1 4 3
3 s2
[m]
s4 \D
r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
5
s3\E
s2 \F
2 \G
[g]
he
s4 \
e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
et rk \ C ma > s 4
3 s2\E
2 s1
s
sw imm
[c]
s3 \D
2
11
s1\E s1 \F
11
s1 \D
3
salo n F >s 4\
hair
1
4\ G
[p]
ter
4
s2 \D
\C
[f]
s4 \F
s
k
alt G
hc en
4\
\C
3
s1
1
s3 \F
4\ O
he >s
s4
\C
\C
2
5 s4\E
4
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
4 3
3\ G
[o] publi c >s par
salo n F
>s 4\
hair
[g]
\G
s3
s2
r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
5
s4 \D
s3\E
s
3
24
[f]
5 s4
et rk \ C ma > s 4
3
s2 \F
>s4\N
5 s4 \F
1 \G
[c]
s3 \D
s2\E
s2
[n] restaurant
1 s3 \F
s3
alt > h
cen ter G
4
s2 \D
2\ G
s1
4
3
\G
[g]
he
s4 \
\C
3
2
2
barM
s4\E
s3\E
1 s2
salo n F >s 4\
hair
1 s
s4
\C
2
\G
3
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
1 1 3 s2 \F
2 \G
[f]
4
4\ G
s3
2
s1
>s 4\
s4 \D
s3 \D
s2\E
2 s1
5 s4 \F
s
3\ G
\C
11
s1\E s1 \F
11
s1 \D
[m]
s2
3 s3 \O
\P s4 \O
4
s3 4\ O
\P
[o] publi c >s par
2 k
1 4
s2 \D
2 11
s1\E s1 \F
11
s1 \D
4 s3 \F
s
3
s2
\C
e ffic t o 4\L pos >s
\C
1
\C
3 s2 \F
2\ G
s1
67
5
r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
s4
\C
s1
s4\E
s3\E
s2\E
2
2
1
s2\A
s3
\C
2
5 4 3
e [e] laundromat >s4\E
s3 \D
s2 \D
2
\G
111
s2
s4 \D
s4
\P
[p] r g sto oth>sin4\D [d] cl
5 4
3
2
s1
>s4 \A
et rk \C ma > s 4
\P
sw imm > s in 4 g
poo l
et rk \C ma > s 4 \C
\C
\C
11
s1\E s1 \F
11
s1 \D
s1\R s1\A s1 \B
11
3
[c]
s4\A
[c]
s4
s3
s2
\C
s2 \Q
s1 \Q
2
1
1
2
s3 \B
3
x.\\13
2
s2 \H
2
s2 \H
1
1
ool sch >s4 \I
\\21
s2 \B
2
2
2
R s1\A s1 \B
111
s3 \Q
4
s2\R
s3 \B
3
3
3
3
s2\A
1
3
s4\A
s4\R
s4 \B
4
1
1
s4 \Q
1
s3\A
s3\R
4
s3\A
3
s2 \B s1 \H
s1 \H
s1 \H
3
2
s1
1
1
s4 \B
4
4
[a] foo d pantry
>s4 \A
111
[b] gro cer > s4 y s \B to re
2 1 ity acil ts f\Q por >s4
s [q]
s4\A
3 ater the >s4 \R
[r] [a] foo d pantry
x.\\18 .\\7
[b] gro cer > s4 y s \B to re
5
s1\R s1\A s1 \B
11
2
2 2
2
s3 \B
3
3
s1 \Q
s2 \B
2 2
s2\A
s2\R
s3 \B s3 \Q
4
s2 \Q
3
3 3 3 s2\A
2 s3\A
s3\R
s4 \B
4
4 2 s4 \Q
2 R s1\A s1 \B
111
2
s4\A
5 2 s4 \B
4
4
2 s3\A
s4\A
s4\R
cer > s4 y s \B to re
6 cer > s4 y s \B to re
111
3 s2\A
[b] gro >s4 \A >s4 \A
[q]
[a] foo d pantry
[a] foo d pantry
s1\R s1\A s1 \B
11
5
5 ater the >s4 \R
[r]
y ilit fac rtss4\Q spo > [b] gro
5
5
3 s2 \B
2
2
2
x.\\6 \\23
s2 \B
2
s3 \B
3
3
s1 \Q
2
2
2 2 2 R s1\A s1 \B
111
s2 \B s2 \Q
s3 \B
3
3 3 s3 \Q
4
s2\R
3 3 s2\A
1 s3\A
1 s4 \B
4
4 4 s4 \Q
1
2
5
s3\R
1 s3\A
>s4 \A
>s4 \A
3 s4 \B
4
1
[a] foo d pantry [a] foo d pantry
s4\R
[b] gro cer > s4 y s \B to re
3 7 s [q] s4\A
5 ater the >s4 \R
[r] ity acil ts f\Q por >s4 [b] gro cer > s4 y s \B to re
1
2 11
s1\I
3
1
1
ool sch >s4 \I
11
2
4 3
1
ool sch >s4 \I
2
11
1
s2\I
2
s3\I
3
s4\I
4
5
s1\I
1
s2\I
2
s3\I
3
s4\I
1
5
s1\I
1
s2\I
2
s3\I
3
s4\I
4
1
68
welcome to madisonville
69
70
st. anthony parish 6104 desmond st madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
st. michael cemetery 4725 settle st madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
st. margaret of cortana 6000 murray rd madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
71
72
st. anthony parish 6104 desmond st madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
a = food pantry b = grocery store c = market d = clothing store e = laundromat f = hair salon g = health center h = childcare i = school
j = library k = bank l = post office m = bar n = restaurant o = public park p = swimming pool q = sports facility r = theater
82
83
CONSUMER
RESOURCE
SOCIAL
food pantry grocery store market clothing store laundromat hair salon
health center childcare school library bank post office
bar restaurant public park swimming pool sports facility theater
84
s4
[g]
\G
h
4\
ter
cen G
eal th >s
[h]
3
5
are ldc chi >s4\H
s3\
s4\ H
[i]
H
H
3
4
1
sc>sh4\oIol
2 2
s2 \I
s3 \I
s4 \I
5
[ j]
s2 \J s2\
3 K
3
4
>s 4\ J
library
\L
s3\
4
3
s2 \L
2
3
s3 \J s4\
1
>s
[k]
4
2 K
4
K
s4 \J
1
ban k
4\K
5
s3\M
s1
4
\L
3
s2\M
2
111
s4\M
s1 \I s1 \J s 1 \K
s3
s2\
H
\L
3
2 2 s2\N s3\N s4\N
1
\P
2
1
s2\O
Os 1
1
s1\N s 1 \
11 11
s1\M
11
s4
2 s1\
[l ]
5
salo n
\G
5
>
hair s4\F
1 s3
f t o 4\L pos >s
[f ]
s4\F
\G
e fic
5
s3\F
1 s2
>
s4\E
1
s2\F
2 \G
[m]
1 s3\E
3
dromat e [e] laun>s4\E
1
s3\D
>s4\N
s4\D
tor ing s loth>s4\D [d] c
\P s3
\P
2 park
\O
4 >s4
publ ic
s4\O
s2
3 s3\O
[o]
1 4
3 2
s2\E
2
s1
[n] restaurant
s4
\P
[p]
et rk \ C ma > s 4 \C
1 s2\D
2
11
s1\E s 1 \ F
11
s1\D
bsa4\rM
>s
P
ing
4\
sw imm
[c] s4
\C
\C
2
2
s3
s2
\C
85
s1
111 11 Q s1\
x.\\6
B
s1 \R s1 \A s 1 \
2
B s2\
2 2
3
3
s2 \A s2 \R
Q s2\
3
B s3\
1 s3 \A s3 \R
1 B s4\
4
3
3 Q s3\
4 poo l
s4 \A s4 \R
cer >s y s 4 \ B to re
3 7
4
4 1
>s 4\ A
5 ity acil ts>sf4\Q r o p s [q]
Q s4\
gro [b]
[a] foo d pantry
th>sea4\tRer
[r]
86
st. anthony parish 6104 desmond st madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
st. michael cemetery 4725 settle st madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
st. margaret of cortana 6000 murray rd madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
87
88
st. michael cemetery 4725 settle st madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
a = food pantry b = grocery store c = market d = clothing store e = laundromat f = hair salon g = health center h = childcare i = school
j = library k = bank l = post office m = bar n = restaurant o = public park p = swimming pool q = sports facility r = theater
100
101
CONSUMER
RESOURCE
SOCIAL
food pantry grocery store market clothing store laundromat hair salon
health center childcare school library bank post office
bar restaurant public park swimming pool sports facility theater
102
s4
[g]
\G
h
4\
ter
cen G
eal th >s
[h]
4
2
are ldc chi >s4\H
s3\
s4\ H
[i]
H
H
1
4
1
sc>sh4\oIol
2 2
s2 \I
s3 \I
s4 \I
1
[ j]
s2 \J s2\
3 K
3
4
>s 4\ J
library
\L
s3\
4
3
s2 \L
2
3
s3 \J s4\
5
>s
[k]
4
2 K
4
K
s4 \J
5
ban k
4\K
5
s3\M
s1
4
\L
3
s2\M
2
111
s4\M
s1 \I s1 \J s 1 \K
s3
s2\
H
\L
3
2 2 s2\N s3\N s4\N
2
\P
2
1
s2\O
Os 1
3
s1\N s 1 \
11 11
s1\M
11
s4
2 s1\
[l ]
1
salo n
\G
5
>
hair s4\F
4 s3
f t o 4\L pos >s
[f ]
s4\F
\G
e fic
1
s3\F
3 s2
>
s4\E
4
s2\F
2 \G
[m]
4 s3\E
3
dromat e [e] laun>s4\E
5
s3\D
>s4\N
s4\D
tor ing s loth>s4\D [d] c
\P s3
\P
1 park
\O
4 >s4
publ ic
s4\O
s2
3 s3\O
[o]
2 4
3 2
s2\E
2
s1
[n] restaurant
s4
\P
[p]
et rk \ C ma > s 4 \C
3 s2\D
2
11
s1\E s 1 \ F
11
s1\D
bsa4\rM
>s
P
ing
4\
sw imm
[c] s4
\C
\C
2
2
s3
s2
\C
103
s1
111 11 Q s1\
x.\\10
B
s1 \R s1 \A s 1 \
2
B s2\
2 2
3
3
s2 \A s2 \R
Q s2\
3
B s3\
4 s3 \A s3 \R
2 B s4\
4
3
3 Q s3\
4 poo l
s4 \A s4 \R
cer >s y s 4 \ B to re
1 5
4
4 5
>s 4\ A
5 ity acil ts>sf4\Q r o p s [q]
Q s4\
gro [b]
[a] foo d pantry
th>sea4\tRer
[r]
104
st. anthony parish 6104 desmond st madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
st. michael cemetery 4725 settle st madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
st. margaret of cortona 6000 murray rd madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
105
106
st. margaret of cortona 6000 murray rd madisonville CINCINNATI, OH 45227
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
a = food pantry b = grocery store c = market d = clothing store e = laundromat f = hair salon g = health center h = childcare i = school
j = library k = bank l = post office m = bar n = restaurant o = public park p = swimming pool q = sports facility r = theater
118
119
CONSUMER
RESOURCE
SOCIAL
food pantry grocery store market clothing store laundromat hair salon
health center childcare school library bank post office
bar restaurant public park swimming pool sports facility theater
120
s4
[g]
\G
h
4\
ter
cen G
eal th >s
[h]
4
5
are ldc chi >s4\H
s3\
s4\ H
[i]
H
H
3
4
1
sc>sh4\oIol
2 2
s2 \I
s3 \I
s4 \I
5
[ j]
s2 \J s2\
3 K
3
1
>s 4\ J
library
\L
s3\
4
3
s2 \L
2
3
s3 \J s4\
5
>s
[k]
4
2 K
4
K
s4 \J
1
ban k
4\K
1
s3\M
s1
4
\L
3
s2\M
2
111
s4\M
s1 \I s1 \J s 1 \K
s3
s2\
H
\L
3
2 1 s2\N s3\N s4\N
4
\P
2
2
s2\O
Os 1
3
s1\N s 1 \
11 11
s1\M
11
s4
2 s1\
[l ]
3
salo n
\G
5
>
hair s4\F
1 s3
f t o 4\L pos >s
[f ]
s4\F
\G
e fic
1
s3\F
3 s2
>
s4\E
4
s2\F
2 \G
[m]
4 s3\E
3
dromat e [e] laun>s4\E
5
s3\D
>s4\N
s4\D
tor ing s loth>s4\D [d] c
\P s3
\P
1 park
\O
1 >s4
publ ic
s4\O
s2
3 s3\O
[o]
5 4
3 2
s2\E
2
s1
[n] restaurant
s4
\P
[p]
et rk \ C ma > s 4 \C
3 s2\D
2
11
s1\E s 1 \ F
11
s1\D
bsa4\rM
>s
P
ing
4\
sw imm
[c] s4
\C
\C
2
2
s3
s2
\C
121
s1
111 11 Q s1\
x.\\7
B
s1 \R s1 \A s 1 \
2
B s2\
2 2
3
3
s2 \A s2 \R
Q s2\
3
B s3\
2 s3 \A s3 \R
2 B s4\
1
3
3 Q s3\
4 poo l
s4 \A s4 \R
cer >s y s 4 \ B to re
5 2
4
4 1
>s 4\ A
5 ity acil ts>sf4\Q r o p s [q]
Q s4\
gro [b]
[a] foo d pantry
th>sea4\tRer
[r]
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
YES...
IN GOD’S BACK YARD 272