8 minute read
Sensing change
How is the camera market responding to automation?
In an effort to automate or augment mundane human-based tasks, such as monitoring CCTV, production lines, or driving vehicles, existing computer vision solutions are largely based on outdated camera systems. But are these the best tools for the job?
Traditionally, cameras were the go-to for autonomous applications as they are widely available in the market place, offer high resolution output, and, more importantly, are cheap and easy to use. They are also well-understood by humans because they generally work in visible light – the same range as the human eye.
Additionally, they offer a level of variation, such as multispectral or hyperspectral modalities which can move beyond the normal frequencies of visible light into infrared and ultraviolet spectrums, which is an attractive prospect. However, they are still fundamentally similar to how a human sees the world.
For many use cases this is a good thing as the camera image is easily interpretable by human users and can also be used as evidence if misconduct was recorded in a monitored area. But in some ways this immediate similarity can be limiting when it is a machine that is the end user. By breaking this link to human-based perception, we open up
Getting a fresh perspective
With cameras, which only produce a 2D image, depth, and the precise location of any detected object, must be estimated based on available context and knowledge of the environment within the field of view. In most practical applications, this would yield only imprecise estimates of locations, especially in crowded environments where many objects are only partially visible due to occlusions or obstructions. It can also lead to misclassification of people or objects in posters on a wall or billboard, or even the side of a bus, which to a 2D sensor appear real.
If more precise and reliable tracking is needed, multiple images from different perspectives, like stereo vision systems, can be combined. We have all experienced the capabilities of such technologies in the tracking of players and balls in sports games.
Such solutions need very precise knowledge and control of individual sensor locations and time synchronisation between them. This is often impractical to achieve and can often offset the potential cost advantage of using cameras in the first place.
On the other hand, with 3D sensors, such as radar and LiDAR, depth can be measured directly providing much stronger context for perception applications. This direct measurement of distance is especially useful for the precise detection and tracking of humans, cars or other objects in complex or changing environments.
Additionally, this high precision tracking can often be achieved with a more limited number of sensors, covering greater distances and with an inherent robustness to changing lighting, including full darkness, and adverse weather conditions
which might render a camera-based solution inoperable.
Removing the human element
Another strong benefit of moving towards other sensor modalities is a reduction in Personally Identifiable Information (PII). This can allow the use of LiDAR sensors in situations where a camera could not be placed due to security or privacy concerns. For example, the image from a typical LiDAR cannot uniquely identify faces, or read sensitive documents, both of which limit the application of cameras.
This is because, commonly, each tracked object detected by a LiDAR sensor reflects only a handful of points, whereas a camera image needs much higher resolution to reliably detect an object of interest. Due to the added information of distance in point clouds, these few points are still more than enough to precisely detect, classify and track various objects.
An evolving technology
The rapid evolution of 3D sensors over time, especially the increases in both resolution and frame rate, enable more advanced perception algorithms to be run. Not only is it now possible to detect and classify people and objects, but also to determine key characteristics, such as orientation, pose, pace and even, by inference, intent. This opens both new security application areas and previously difficult operating environments, greatly expanding the number of potential use cases. Separation of discrete objects in a crowded or partially obscured environment also becomes easier as sensor performance improves.
The reduced dependence on human readable data also enables the application of efficient edge processing, reducing the need to move large volumes of raw data from sensors to the end user. Instead, the majority of processing can be performed at the edge, resulting in a significantly reduced data burden since only the resulting object data needs to be transmitted to the output system. For a single sensor this is not perhaps so important, but in a large deployment over a wide area the savings could be game changing.
There is no doubting that cameras will remain the primary solution for many security applications. In fact, with the increasing availability of cheap and reliable computer vision solutions embedded into more and more camera products, it is inevitable that both their use and range of applications will continue to grow.
However, depending on the individual requirements of the application at hand, distance measuring sensor modalities, such as LiDAR, will either greatly enhance the capabilities of the security solution or replace cameras outright as, all aspects considered, a cheaper, easier to integrate and more reliable option.
For further information please visit https://cronai.ai/
The ASSA ABLOY Group is the global leader in access solutions. Our offering covers products and services related to openings, such as locks, doors, gates and entrance automation solutions. This also includes expertise in controlling identities with keys, cards, tags, mobile and biometric identity verification systems.
www.assaabloy.com
Innovating for a smarter, safer world by combining intelligent technology and human imagination, at Axis Communications we offer solutions based on sight, sound and analytics to improve security and optimize business performance.
www.axis.com
azena accelerates the next generation of smart security and safety solutions through joint innovation with customers and partners. Our goal is to be the leading open platform and marketplace for smart security and safety solutions. The platform we offer is based on a camera operating system that powers cameras from various manufacturers on the market.
www.azena.com
Club Car boasts nearly 60 years of industry-leading innovation and design, initially focused on golf cars and then expanding to commercial utility vehicles and personal-use transportation.
www.clubcar.com
Hanwha Techwin Europe, formerly Samsung Techwin Europe, offers robust and reliable video surveillance products designed to meet the current and future needs of security professionals. Our cameras, video recorders and other devices are built to exacting standards which reflect the heritage of precision engineering associated with the Samsung brand.
www.hanwha-security.eu
Buildings today don’t only provide a safe, functional place for people to live and work. They can also cater for – and even respond to – their needs, while helping them work more efficiently and sustainably. At Bosch Building Technologies, we are at the forefront of these new developments.
www.boschbuildingtechnologies.com
With a full HD camera and an optically stabilized, 40x zoom lens from FUJINON, two high-performance components are integrated into one system. This innovation is the result of years of experience in digital cameras and a dedication to the highest optical quality.
www.fujifilm.eu/fujinon
HID powers the trusted identities of the world’s people, places and things. We make it possible for people to transact safely, work productively, and travel freely. We are passionate about helping people use a verified, trusted identity to make it more convenient and safer for them to get to where they need to go and achieve what they want to do in everyday life.
www.hidglobal.com
Maxxess Systems delivers innovative SaaS and security management software solutions that combine otherwise disparate physical security, communications, business intelligence and data integration capabilities onto one unified management platform.
https://maxxess-systems.com
Panasonic i-PRO Sensing Solutions Corporation of America a global leader in professional security solutions for surveillance and public safety, is launching their new name, i-PRO Americas Inc., and taking a unique approach to best navigate the evolving business environment and technology demands of the professional security industry.
https://i-pro.com/eu/en
As a trusted advisor and reliable partner, as a system integrator, service provider and a product vendor, Siemens offers energy-efficient, safe and secure buildings and infrastructure. With our people, our global footprint and our technical expertise, it's our passion helping you to create the perfect place – your perfect place.
www.siemens.com
Transforming teaching and learning with creative solutions to engage and inspire every student. Learning’s becoming more interactive. More immersive. More collaborative. At Sony we’re working with universities, colleges and schools to create richer, more rewarding educational experiences for today’s students and teaching staff.
https://pro.sony.com
At Mayflex we lead the way in the distribution of Converged IP Solutions. Bringing together ‘best-in-class’ Infrastructure, Networking and Electronic solutions. We’re a growing international force, enriched by the skills, expertise and unique personalities of our people. Globally owned but with a family and local feel.
www.mayflex.com
With over 30 years of experience, we design and manufacture marketleading security solutions for a range of buildings. Around 25,000 buildings each year are secured globally with Paxton products. Our global Head Office is based in Brighton, we have colleagues in 12 countries and we export to over 60 countries worldwide.
www.paxton-access.com
From its inception in 2001, SALTO was created with one objective: to devise a world-class access control system that was simple to use and extremely efficient, giving users the ability to control all their access needs and secure all their doors without complex and expensive wiring.
www.saltosystems.com
Videx Security is a leading manufacturer and supplier of access control systems across the UK. We are experts in the door entry market. Videx and our team of estimators, technical support and designers are focused on making and providing high quality products and support to customers.
