breakthrough
ISSUE36 AUTUMN2022 NEWSOFTHEMERESEARCHYOUAREHELPINGTOFUND
Breakthrough magazineispublishedbyMEResearchUK,a ScottishCharitableIncorporatedOrganisationwiththeprin‐cipalaimofcommissioningandfundinghigh-qualityscientific (biomedical)investigationintothecauses,consequencesand treatmentofMyalgicEncephalomyelitis/ChronicFatigue Syndrome(ME/CFS).Weinfluence,informandinvestinME researchgloballybyidentifyingpotentiallyimportantareasfor futurebiomedicalresearch,andbyproducinghighqualitypro‐fessionalreviewsandreports. Breakthrough isanopen-access publicationand,apartfromimagesandillustrations,thecon‐tentmaybereproducedfreeofcharge,subjecttotheterms andconditionsfoundatmeres.uk/bt-terms. ©MEResearchUK,2022–SCIOCharityNo.SC036942
TheGateway,NorthMethvenStreet, Perth,PH15PP,UK Tel:01738451234,Email:contact@meresearch.org.uk
2/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk CONTENTS SECTION HEADER
Inthisissue Editorial...........................................3 UKGovernmentcommitment.........4 TheBigGive....................................4 Top10researchpriorities...............5 IACFSreport...................................6 Christmasshopping........................6 Meetournewcolleague.................7 EBVbiomarkers...............................8 NewPhD-levelresearch................11 Roadsnottaken............................12 Researchbites...............................16 Fundraisingstories........................20 12 8 4 20 16
Inthespotlight
What’shappeningintheworldofMEresearchandfunding
Editorial
“TheTimesTheyArea-Chan‐gin’”.BobDylanmayhavewrit‐tenthissongnearlysixtyyears ago,butthelastsixmonthshave certainlyseenalotofchange.
Despitetheturmoil,were‐mainhopefulthattheinitiative startedbySajidJavidwillcon‐tinuetofruition,andweplanto remainactivelyengagedinthe developmentofaresearch strategytoinformacross-gov‐ernmentdeliveryplanforME. Manychallengeslieahead,but wearecommittedtodoingour utmosttoeffectpositivechange. There’smoreonpages4and5.
Wearedelightedtowelcome DrKeithGeraghtytoourteam, andpage7givesalittleofhis backgroundandhisnewrole withus.Oneofhisfirsttaskswas toattendthe2022IACFS/ME conference,andhisreportonthis largeeventisonpage6.
NunoSepúlvedahasnow publishedinterestingresultsfrom hisstudylookingforEBVbio‐markers,andplansafollow-up. Fulldetailsareonpage9.We werealsodelightedtoannounce oursecondPhDgrant(jointly fundedwithActionforME)at King’sCollegeLondon,whichis focusedonthegeneticbasisfor
ME.Page11givesmoredetails.
Ourlatestcallforgrantap‐plicationsgeneratedsignificant interestfromresearchersglobally, andwenowhaveover£1mil‐lionofpotentialresearchgoing throughourreviewprocess.
CortJohnson’slatest‘postcard fromNevada’isonpage13,and providesafascinatinginsightinto threeareasofresearchthatwar‐rantfurtherexploration.
Onpage16youcanreada round-upofrecentlypublished research,acommonthemebeing thecontinuingneedtoseefol‐low-upstudiestoreplicatefind‐ingsandprovidethespurfor large-scaleresearchprojects.
Ofcourseeverythingwedois onlypossibleasaresultofyour support.Thisissue,inparticular, highlightssomewonderfulex‐amplesofthefundraisingactivit‐iesthathelpuscontinueour workonyourbehalf.
Onafinalnote,Christmasis justaroundthecorner(!)andour Christmascardcollectionisnow availableforpurchase.
Thankyouforyourcontinued supportandenjoytheissue.
JonathanDavies Chair,BoardofTrustees
Christmas Cards2022
OurChristmascardsare nowavailabletoorder (forresidentsofGB,the IsleofManandthe ChannelIslandsonly). There’sagreatselection tochoosefrom,andyou canalsoorderonlineat shop.meresearch.org.uk. Asalways,theproceeds gotohelpsupportour work. Ifyouwouldprefernot tosendaphysicalcard, dontsendmeacard.com hasagoodselectionof digitalcardsandallows youtomakeadonation tous.
autumn2022/ breakthrough /3 meresearch.org.uk SECTION HEADER INTHE SPOTLIGHT
TheBigGive
TheBigGiveChristmas ChallengeistheUK’s largestmatched-funding campaign,andMEResearchUKistakingpart againthisyear.
Supportershavealready pledged£7,000,sothe first£7,000ofdonations madeontheBigGive’s websitefrommiddayon29 Novemberuntilmiddayon 6December2021willbe matchedbythepledgers. Eachdonationisdoubled.
Wemayalsobechosenfor CharityChampionfunding, whichwouldaddafurther £7,000tothepledgepot.
Informationonhowto makeadonationwillbeon ourwebsiteandsocialmediaduringthecampaign. Asalways,allfundswe raisewillbeinvestedinME researchglobally.
Rollercoastersummer
UKGovernmentcommitstoMEresearch
MEAwarenessDay,on12May 2022,kickedoffanexciting coupleofmonthsashopeswere raisedofaneweraforME/CFS researchfunding,andUKGov‐ernmentcommitmenttolisten andbelievethoseaffected.
Itstartedwiththepublication oftheresultsoftheME/CFS PrioritySettingPartnership (PSP),whichaimedto“identify andprioritiseevidenceuncer‐taintiesinparticularareasof healthandcarethatcouldbe answeredbyresearch”.
Thetoptenpluspriorities theyarrivedataresummarised intheboxopposite.
Atthesametime,theRtHon. SajidJavid,thenSecretaryof StateforHealthandSocialCare, issuedaverywelcomestatement pledgingtheGovernment’ssup‐portofthesepriorities,andan‐
nouncingacross-Government deliveryplanforME/CFS.
Thenextstagewasameeting co-chairedbyMrJavidandthe ChiefScientificAdviser,Pro‐fessorLucyChappell.
Thiswasattendedbyfunders, researchers,charitiesandpeople withME/CFS,andMERe‐searchUKwasrepresentedby ourChair,JonathanDavies.
Underdiscussionwerethere‐searchprioritiesidentifiedbythe PrioritySettingPartnership,the overlapswithlongCOVID,the needtoencouragenewresearch‐ersintoME/CFS,andhowre‐searchfundingcanbeimproved.
Thenewlyformedsubcom‐mitteeonMEresearch(under theguidanceoftheUKClinical ResearchCollaboration)then haditsfirstmeetingon30June.
Unfortunately,theseexciting
4/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk INTHE SPOTLIGHT
developmentswereputinto questionwiththeresignationof MrJavidon5July.
Theflurryofactivityinthe precedingcoupleofmonths meantthatmeetingsbetweenre‐searchers,charities,patientrep‐resentativesandtheHealth Departmenthavealreadytaken place,coveringpatientexperi‐ence,educationandtraining, andresearch.
Furthermore,astructurewith ataskandfinishgroupandthree sub-committeeshasalreadybeen established,andanumberof constructivemeetingsheld.ME ResearchUKattendstheME/ CFSResearchWorkingGroup. Itisenvisagedthattheprocess willculminateinthepublication ofawide-rangingdeliveryplan onME/CFSwithintwoyears.
Whatevertheoutcome,ME ResearchUKremainscommit‐tedtoinvestingintheverybest ME/CFSresearch.
Top10(or11)ME/CFS researchprioritiesofthePSP
1.Whatisthebiologicalmechanismthatcausespost-exertionalmalaise(symptomscausedormadeworseby physical,mentaloremotionaleffort,whichcanbe delayed)inpeoplewithME/CFS?Howisthisbest treatedandmanaged?
2.Whichexistingdrugsusedtotreatotherconditions mightbeusefulfortreatingME/CFS,suchaslowdose naltrexone,ordrugsusedtotreatPosturalOrthostatic TachycardiaSyndrome(POTS)?
3.HowcananaccurateandreliablediagnostictestbedevelopedforME/CFS?
4.IsME/CFScausedbyafaultyimmunesystem?IsME/ CFSanautoimmunecondition?
5.AretheredifferenttypesofME/CFSlinkedtodifferent causesand/orhowsevereitbecomes?Dodifferent typesofME/CFSneeddifferenttreatmentsand/orhave differentchancesofrecovery?
6.WhydosomepeopledevelopME/CFSfollowinganinfection?IstherealinkwithlongCOVID?
7.Whatcausesthecentralandperipheralnervoussystems (brain,spinalcordandnervesinthebody)tomalfunctioninpeoplewithME/CFS?Couldthisunderstanding leadtonewtreatments?
8.IsthereageneticlinktoME/CFS?Ifyes,howdoesthis affecttheriskofME/CFSinfamilies?Couldthisleadto newtreatments?
9.WhatcausesME/CFStobecomesevere?
10.Howaremitochondria,responsibleforthebody’senergyproduction,affectedinME/CFS?Couldthisunderstandingleadtonewtreatments?
10+.Doespoordeliveryoruseofoxygenwithinthebody causeME/CFSsymptoms?Ifso,howisthisbesttreated?
autumn2022/ breakthrough /5 meresearch.org.uk INTHE SPOTLIGHT
Atimeforoptimism
Keythemesfromthe2022IACFS/MEconference
Theannualconferenceofthe IACFS/MEtookplaceinJuly, andDrKeithGeraghty,ournew ScienceandResearchLead,at‐tendedonbehalfofMERe‐searchUK.
TakingonanewlookpostCOVID,theconferencewashos‐tedinavirtualauditoriumforat‐tendeestomingleandpresent theirlatestresearchfindings. Therewere58speakers,20 posterentrantsandalmost300 attendees,includingmanyearlystageresearchers.Thisgrowthin numbersreflectsincreasingin‐terestinME/CFSamongscient‐istsandhealthprofessionals internationally.
LongCOVID
Themoststrikingdifference frompreviousconferenceswas theinclusionoflongCOVID, withmultipletalksonfatiguefol‐lowingacuteCOVID-19.One peculiarupsideofthepandemic isthatithasreinvigoratedthe scientificcommunitytorecon‐
siderandinvestigatepost-viralfa‐tigue,withobviousbenefitsfor ME/CFSresearch.
Prof.AkikoIwasakifromYale MedicalSchoolprovidedanes‐peciallyinsightfultalkonthebio‐chemicalsignaturesoflong COVID,andpresentedresults showinghowshewasableto identifyanddifferentiatelong COVIDpatientsbasedonblood analysisofimmunemarkers,an‐tibodiesandhormones.
POTS
Posturaltachycardiasyndrome (POTS)–anabnormalincrease inheartrateaftersittingupor standing–wasperhapsthecent‐ralthemeoftheconference.For example,LaurenStilesof StonybrookUniversityspoke aboutthehighprevalenceof POTSinbothME/CFSand longCOVID,highlightingthe manyteststhatcouldbeper‐formedtoidentifyPOTS,and thetreatmentsavailabletotreat thecondition.
Inflammationupregulated
Inflammationofthebrainand centralnervoussystemwasan‐othermajortheme,andDrGun‐narGottschalkoftheSimmaron ResearchCentrespokeaboutthe roleofATG13,aproteinin‐volvedincausingdamagedorin‐fectedcellstodieoff.ATG13is stronglyupregulatedintheblood ofME/CFSpatients,indicating impairmentinthisprocess.
PEM
Anotherhighlightwasanillu‐minatingtalkbyDrDavidSys‐tromfromBrighamand Women’sHospital.Hespoke aboutthepathophysiologyof post-exterionalmalaise(PEM), andhowitcanbeprovokedand investigatedbyastresstest.He believesPOTSandPEMarere‐lated,andtheprimarycausemay lieinthemitochondria.
YoucanreadKeith’sfullreports fromthisyear’sconferenceon ourwebsite.
6/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk
DrKeithGeraghty
Meetournewcolleague
Wearedelightedtowelcome Keithontotheteamasthenew ScienceandResearchLeadfor MEResearchUK.
Hisfirstworkforthecharity hasbeentoestablishasteady streamofarticlesonourwebsite andsocialmedia,keepingsup‐portersup-to-dateonnewME/ CFSresearchnews.
Keithisalreadywellknown andrespectedintheME/CFS field.Heisanexperiencedhealth researcherwhohaspublished morethanthirtypapersandart‐icles.Buthealsobringstheper‐spectiveofapersonwithME/ CFS,havingbeendiagnosed withtheillnessseveralyearsago.
HegrewupinIreland,and movedtoWalestostudyat CardiffUniversity(partlydueto itsproximitytotheBrecon Beaconsandopportunitiesfor hillwalking).
Aftergraduating,hegothis PhDandstartedapostdoctoral
career,butthenmovedintoclin‐icalmedicineashewantedtodo moredirectlywithpatients.
DuringhistrainingKeithcon‐tractedanunexplainedviralill‐ness,leavinghimveryunwell andincapacitatedforseveral years.Hisdoctorswereper‐plexedbyhissymptomsanddia‐gnosedpost-viralfatigueand chronicfatiguesyndrome.
Herecallshowsuchanillness hadhardlyeverbeenmentioned atmedicalschool,meaninghe hadlittleunderstandingofhis ownprognosis.
Havingabackgroundinre‐search,Keithfeltcompelledto lookforanswersforhimself.He startedresearchingME/CFSby speakingtoexpertsandreading theliterature,andthenreturned toacademiaasaresearchfellow attheUniversityofManchester.
Hisworkhasincludedwriting aboutthelackofevidenceand potentialharmsofCBTand
Christmas shopping
Whenyoushoponlinefor Christmasthisyear,you couldalsoberaisingfunds forMEResearchUK,atno extracosttoyou.
Visitsmile.amazon.co.uk andselectMEResearchUK asyourchosencharity,or useeasyfundraising.org.uk whichhostssomeofthe UK’sbestonlinestores. Notonlywillyoubeaccessingsomegreatdeals, butyouwillalsoberaising fundsforMEResearchUK withoutcostingyouanextrapenny.
GET,aswellashighlightingthe methodologicalflawsinthe PACEstudy.Headvocatedfora newapproachtoME/CFS–one thatrecognisesthebiologicalfea‐turesoftheillnessandtheir pathophysiologicbasis.Hewas alsocommissionedbyNICEto presentevidenceontheviewsof peoplelivingwithsevereME/ CFSduringtheirguidelinere‐view.
SoKeithhasconsiderable knowledgeofME/CFS,and bringsawealthofexperienceto hisnewroleinMEResearch UK,andweverymuchlookfor‐wardtoworkingwithhim.
autumn2022/ breakthrough /7 meresearch.org.uk INTHE SPOTLIGHT
Signature style
Theemergenceof longCOVIDhas highlightedthepo‐tentiallong-term consequencesofaviralinfection, leadingtosymptomssuchasfa‐tigue,musclepainandbrainfog thatcanlastforweeksormonths.
Thesesymptomsareshared bypeoplewithME/CFS,many ofwhomalsoreportaviraltrig‐gerfortheirillness.Butwhich virusesareassociatedwithME/ CFS,andhowmightthisinform‐
ationhelpinitsdiagnosis?
OnecandidateisEpsteinBarrvirus(EBV),longsuggested asatriggerforME/CFS.Inhis recentwork,fundedbyMERe‐searchUKwiththesupportof theFredandJoanDaviesBe‐quest,DrNunoSepúlvedafrom theLondonSchoolofHygiene &TropicalMedicinehasbeen takinganotherlookatthisim‐portantpathogen.
Nearlyallofusareinfected withEBVatsometimeinour
lives,andinmostcasesourim‐munesystemcanfightitoff.But thevirusisknowntocausesev‐eraldiseases(includingautoim‐muneconditions),andpeople withME/CFSareoftenfoundto haveactiveEBVinfectionsoran‐tibodyreactivityagainstEBV.
Antibodysignatures
Inpreviousexperiments–using datafromProf.Carmen
Scheibenbogen’sgroupatChar‐itéUniversitätmedizinBerlin–
autumn2022/ breakthrough /9 meresearch.org.uk REVISITING EBV
NunoSepúlvedaandcolleagueshave publishedresultsfromtheirstudylooking for EBVbiomarkersinME/CFS
DrSepúlvedaidentifiedanum‐berofEBV-derivedproteins(an‐tigens)thatwereincreasedor decreasedinME/CFSpatients comparedwithcontrolsubjects.
Hehasnowextendedthis workbylookingspecificallyfor antibodysignaturesthatcould serveasbiomarkersforME/ CFS,andfocusingonpatients withaninfectioustriggerattheir diseaseonset.
Theresearchwasconducted incollaborationwithanumber ofotherresearchers,including Prof.ScheibenbogeninBerlin, andDrElianaLacerdaatthe LondonSchoolofHygiene& TropicalMedicine.
Thegroupanalysedantibody responsesagainst3,054EBV-de‐
rivedantigensin92patientswith ME/CFSandin50healthycon‐trolsubjects.Fifty-fourofthepa‐tientsreportedanacuteinfection atthetimetheirdiseasebegan.
Thefirstroundofanalyses didnotfindanyantibodiesasso‐ciatedwithME/CFS,butthis changedwhenthepatientswere dividedintosubgroupsbasedon theirdiseaseonset.
Infectioustrigger
Whiletherewerestillnoassoci‐ationsamongthosewithanoninfectiousorunknowndisease trigger,inME/CFSpatientswith aninfectionatdiseaseonsettwo antibodyresponseswerestronger thanseeninhealthycontrols.
Furtheranalysesshowedthat
thesetworesponsescoulddistin‐guishthissubgroupfromcontrols withahighsensitivityandspe‐cificity,andmaythereforehave potentialinthediagnosisof theseME/CFSpatientswithan infectioustrigger,specifically thoseaffectedbyEBV.
Theresearchersplantocon‐firmthesefindingsinotherco‐hortsofpatientsfromtheUK ME/CFSBiobank.Theyalso suggestthattheEBV-derivedan‐tigensidentifiedmayprovide someevidenceofhowthereact‐ivationofEBVplaysarolein thedevelopmentofME/CFS.
AsCortJohnsonpointedout onourwebsitelastyear,viruses haven’tgoneawayinME/CFS, they’vejustgotmoreinteresting.
10/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk REVISITING EBV
DrElianaLacerda
DrNunoSepúlveda
Prof.CarmenScheibenbogen
Anewclass
NewPhD-levelresearchlookingat the involvementofRIPsinME/CFS
InJuneofthisyear,ME ResearchUKandAc‐tionforMEwerede‐lightedtoannounce jointfundingforaPhD-levelre‐searchprojectatKing’sCollege London.
ThisisoursecondPhD-level researchproject,andourfirst suchfundingcollaborationwith ActionforME.
Thenewprojectisbeingcon‐ductedbyPhDstudentLuke Marney,underthesupervisionof DrAlfredoIacoangeli,andisfo‐cusedonthegeneticbasisof ME/CFS.
Thebiologicalabnormalities leadingtothedevelopmentof ME/CFSarenotwellunder‐stood,butgeneticsarethoughtto playanimportantpart.Thisnew projectwilllookataspecifictype ofgeneticvariationcalledan RIP(retrotransposoninsertion polymorphism).
Retrotransposonsarepieces ofDNAoftenreferredtoas
jumpinggenesbecausetheycan movearoundwithinthegenome ofacell,potentiallycausing mutations(RIPs)thatcanchange thefunctionofthatcell.
RIPshavebeenimplicatedin thedevelopmentandprogression ofdisorderssuchasmotorneur‐onediseaseandParkinson’sdis‐ease,andthisprojectaimstouse genetic-sequencingdatafromthe UKBiobanktodetermineifa
specificRIPorsetofRIPsisalso involvedinME/CFS.
Aswellascontributingtoa betterunderstandingofME/ CFS,thisresearchmayhelp identifynewdirectionsfortreat‐ingthedisease.
Bothcharitiesareexcitedby theopportunitytoworktogether, andtohelpsupportthisimport‐antnewresearchandaPhDstu‐dentatthestartofhiscareer.
Callforapplications
Inthe22yearssinceourformation,MEResearchUKhas funded60researchprojectsatatotalcostofnearly£3 million.Butwearecertainlynotstoppingthere.
InJuly,weannouncedanewcallforapplicationsforour researchgrants,andthesearecurrentlyprogressing throughourrigorousreviewprocess.
SowehopetobeabletoannouncemorenewME/CFS researchinthemonthsahead–moreprogressinunderstandingthediseasebetterandinfindingacure.
autumn2022/ breakthrough /11 meresearch.org.uk NEWLYFUNDED RESEARCH
Postcard from Nevada
Inhislatestpostcard, CortJohnson looksatsomeoftheroadsnot(yet) takeninME/CFSresearch
Thisispotentiallya richtimeforME/ CFSresearch.The recentlongCOVID studiespresentapictureofadis‐easethat–withissuesrelatingto lowcortisol,exercise,immune exhaustion,Epstein-Barrvirus reactivationandbloodvesselab‐normalities–looksuncannily similartoME/CFS.Itseemsas ifbroadthemesarebeginningto emerge.
That’sgoodnews,butME/ CFSisacomplexandpoorly
fundeddisease.Itsresearchhis‐tory–nowdatingbackalmost fortyyears–includessome effortsthatdidn’tpanout,some thatdid,andsomethatseemed topanoutbutforonereasonor anotherweredroppedornever fullyexplored.Let’stakealook atthreeofthoseunexplored roads.
Brainsonfire? Neuroinflammationsticksout herelikeasorethumb.The2014 Nakatomistudy–whichcon‐
tainedamerenineteenparti‐cipants–washeraldedasoneof themostpotentiallyimportant studiesinME/CFShistory. Therewasgoodreasonforthat: lowlevelsofwidespread neuroinflammationmadesense givenwhatweknowaboutthe disease.
Sincethen,neuroinflamma‐tionandactivationofmicroglia (immunecellsinthebrainand nervoussystem)havebecomehot topics.Theywerefeaturedprom‐inentlyinthreerecenthypo‐
autumn2022/ breakthrough /13 meresearch.org.uk ROADS NOTTAKEN
theses.Researchersarecurrently huntingforeffectivemicroglial inhibitors,whilemodellingstud‐iessuggestthatneuroinflamma‐tionmayneedtobeaddressed firstforothertreatmentstosuc‐ceed.
Yetdespiteallthisinterest,in theeightyearssincethepublica‐tionoftheNakatomistudy,only twosmallstudieshavebeenpub‐lished–aDutchstudyand JarredYounger’sthermography study,whichproducedconflicting findings–leavingtheME/CFS fieldinthedarkaboutwhether ornotitreallyexists.
That’sashame.Thefinding ofneuroinflammationwouldpo‐tentiallyalignME/CFSwith well-fundedneurologicaldiseases suchasmultiplesclerosis,Parkin‐son’sdiseaseandAlzheimer’sdis‐ease.Researchersareactively searchingforwaysto‘quenchthe fires’intheseconditions.Docu‐mentingthatneuroinflammation existsinME/CFScouldfurther
CortJohnson
legitimiseit andultimately openupnew treatmentop‐portunities.
Neuroin‐flammation studiesare thankfullyun‐derwayinlong COVID.Per‐hapsJarred Younger’son‐going,MERe‐searchUKfundedstudy
lookingatimmunecellinfiltra‐tionofthebrainwilltakeafew morestepstowardsanswering thisquestionforME/CFS.
Theparadox
Evidencesuggeststhereisapara‐doxinbothME/CFSandpos‐turalorthostatictachycardia syndrome(POTS).
Thelowbloodvolumefound inboththeseconditionsshould triggertherenin-angiotensin-al‐dosteronesystem(RAAS)tohelp maintainbloodpressure.This systeminvolvesanincreasein renin,leadingtoproductionof angiotensinwhichthenstimu‐latesthereleaseofaldosterone.
However,reninandaldoster‐onelevelsarelowinthesecondi‐tions.And,tomakematters moreconfusing,angiotensin levelsareveryhigh.
Hencetheparadox–inthe midstoflowbloodvolumelevels, theendproductoftheRAAS system,aldosterone,which
shouldbeincreased,isactually lowerthannormal.
Thearetwoarmstothe RAASsystem.Oneturnsonan‐giotensinIIwhichtriggersa bunchofactivity(bloodvessel vasoconstriction,sympathetic nervousactivityandinflamma‐tion)weprobablydon’twant happeninginME/CFS.The other(lessactiveinME/CFS)is anti-inflammatory.Twostudies haveimplicatedaculprit:re‐ducedactivityoftheACE-2en‐zyme.
Allinall,it’saprettyimport‐antsystemtohavereceivedal‐mostnoresearchinME/CFS. Buthere’swhereitreallygetsin‐teresting.
Inabizarrecoincidence,it turnsoutthatthecoronavirus enterscellsthroughthesame ACE-2receptorthatappearsto bemalfunctioninginME/CFS andPOTS.
That’sledtothesamescen‐ariobeingsuggestedfor COVID-19,ME/CFSand POTS:reducedACE2activation andincreasedactivationofthe classicalorinflammatoryarmof theRAAS.
ThereducedACE2activa‐tioncouldberesponsibleforalot ofmischief.It’sbeenassociated withimpairedoxygenuptake,in‐creasedoxidativestress,leaky gut,problemswithlungperfu‐sion,reducedvasodilationofthe bloodvesselsandinflammation.
It’sevenbeensuggestedthat theincreasedangiotensinII couldbecausingnegativereac‐
14/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk ROADS NOTTAKEN
tionstothecoronavirusvaccines. That’saninterestingpossibility giventhehighangiotensinII levelsfoundinME/CFS.
There’sabigproblem, though.Despiteitspotentialfor mischief,letaloneitspossible connectiontoCOVID-19and longCOVID,becauseonlytwo smallstudiesoftheRAASsys‐temhavebeendoneinME/ CFS,wedon’treallyknowifthe RAASisarealproblemornot. Surelythoughit’saresearcharea thatcouldusemoreexploring.
Thegenderissue
Fromtheverybeginningsofthis illness,it’sbeenclearthatit strikesmanymorewomenthan men.But,decadeslater,it’sre‐markablehowlittleweknow aboutthisphenomenon.
Hamperedbylowfunding, smallsamplesizesandthecom‐plexityofthehormonalsystem, genderhasrarelybeencon‐sidered.SomeME/CFSand
fibromyalgiaresearchhascoped withtheissuesimplybylocking menoutoftheirstudies.
Ifyou’renotamanthat’snot abadstrategyasthegenderissue inME/CFScouldbeahuge one.Studiessuggestthatmen andwomenhavealteredgutmi‐crobiomes,heartratevariability, responsestoexerciseandmicro RNApatterns–andthismay justbethetipoftheiceberg.
Therearesomecluesasto whatishappening.Anincreased incidenceofME/CFSduring timesofmajorhormonal changes(adolescence,pregnancy, perimenopause)pointsatthesex hormonesbeinginvolved.Sodo thehigherratesofgynaecolo‐gicaldisorders,pelvicpain,men‐strualabnormalitiesand surgeries(especiallyhysterectom‐ies).
Modelssuggestthatthe highertestosteronelevelsfound inmenmaybeprotective,while highoestrogenlevelsinwomen
mayincreasetheirrisk.Likewise, highprogesteroneandtestoster‐onelevelsappeartoprotect againstpaininfibromyalgia, whilelowprogesteroneandhigh cortisolpromoteit.
Withsimilargenderimbal‐ancesfoundinME/CFS,long COVID,fibromyalgia,postural orthostatictachycardiasyn‐drome,migraineandmore,it’s clearwe’llneverfullyunderstand thesediseasesuntilthegender imbalanceisexplained.
Inafieldscrappingforfunds, thegenderimbalanceproblem presentsanaddedcomplication thatmostfunderswouldunder‐standablyrathernotdealwith. Thecureforthatproblem–as withalloftheseunexploredav‐enues–isastraightforwardone: morefunding.
LongCOVIDshouldbeget‐tingthatfunding.Andifthose scientiststakethetimetocheck outME/CFSresearch,theywill findsomerichveinstomine.
autumn2022/ breakthrough /15 meresearch.org.uk
Researchbites
Ourround-upofrecentresearchfromaroundtheworld
Whenthebodybreaksdownnutrientstogenerate energy (aprocesscalledmetabolism),itproduces substancesknownasmetabolites.Thestudyof thesemetabolites (metabolomics) cantellusmore abouttheactivityandstateofcellsandtissues,and hasprovedusefulinunderstandingthecausesof diseaseandidentifyingbiomarkers.
Someexamplesofitsapplicationtodateinclude advancesinknowledgeaboutischaemicstroke,hy‐pertensivenephrosclerosisandglaucoma.Andthis istheapproachusedinarecentME/CFSstudy conductedbyresearchersatColumbiaUniversity.
Theinvestigatorsfoundthatlevelsofanumber ofimportantmetaboliteswereabnormalinpa‐
tientswithME/CFScomparedwithhealthycon‐trolsubjects.Somemetaboliteswerefoundtobeat lowerthannormallevels,whileotherswerehigher thannormal.
Accordingtotheresearchers,theirresultssug‐gestthatlipidremodellingisimpairedinthesepa‐tients.Lipidsareimportantcomponentsofevery cellwallormembrane,andlipidremodellingisin‐volvedinmaintainingthecellmembranes,aswell assignallingbetweencells.
Thesefindings,ifconfirmedinotherstudies, mayultimatelyhelpusunderstandmoreaboutthe diseaseprocess,andpotentiallydevelopbiomarkers fordiagnosis.
16/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk RESEARCH BITES
Readingthesigns Cheetal.,InternationalJournalofMolecularScience,2022
Mitochondrialsupplement?
Cash&Kaufman,J.ofTranslat.Med.,2022
OnemetabolitepotentiallydepletedinME/CFSis oxaloacetate,andanecdotalreportssuggestthatan oxaloacetatesupplementmayimprovephysicaland mentalfatigueinsomepatients.Whenitwastested inatrialof76ME/CFSpatients,treatmentwith thesecapsulesdidappeartoreducefatigueby around25%(assessedusingaquestionnaire).How‐ever,thestudydidnothaveaplaceboarmandit wasnotrandomized–bothconsideredvitalinas‐sessingtheefficacyoftreatments.Amorerigorous trialisthereforeneededtosupportthefindings.
IsfibromyalgiasimilartoME/CFS?
Ramírez-Moralesetal.,Autoimmun.Rev.,2022
Thereismuchdebateaboutwhetherfibromyalgia (FM)andME/CFSaresimilarillnesses.Whilethey sharecommonsymptomssuchaspainandfatigue, therearedifferencesintheirapparentcausesand presentation.Ananalysispoolingtheresultsof21 studiesfoundawell-definedclinicaloverlap betweenthetwoconditions–almosthalfofFM patientsmetdiagnosticcriteriaforME/CFS.The authorssaythismightreflectasimilarunderlying cause,suchasahistoryofviralinfectionleadingto autonomicdysfunctionandchronicinflammation.
PredictingsevereME/CFS
Jasonetal.,JournalofRehabilitationTherapy,2022
Around10%ofindividualswithinfectiousmono‐nucleosis(mono)meetdiagnosticcriteriaforME/ CFSsixmonthslater.Toinvestigatewhetherthey couldpredictthis,researcherslookedatseveral factorsincollegestudentswhohaddevelopedME/ CFSfollowingmono.Patientswithgastrointestinal symptoms,anirritablebowelandabnormallylow immunemarkersatthetimeofmonohadanal‐most80%chanceofdevelopingsevereME/CFS sixmonthslater.Thesefindingssupporttheim‐portanceofthesefactorsinthedevelopmentof ME/CFS.
Transmissionelectronmicroscopy
Jahanbanietal.,PloSOne,2022
Transmissionelectronmicroscopy(TEM)repres‐entsastepupfromtraditionallightmicroscopybe‐causethebeamofelectronsusedcanprovidemuch higherresolutionimagesandsocapturemuchfiner details.Butwhatcanthetechniquetellusabout ME/CFS?ResearchersatStanfordUniversityused TEMtolookatimmunecellsfrompeoplewiththe illness,andtheirfindingssuggestthatanincreased numberofthesecellsaredyingduetoapoptosis (programmedcelldeath)ornecrosis(causedby damage).Theyalsofoundabnormalitiesinthemi‐tochondria(whichgenerateenergyinthecell).
autumn2022/ breakthrough /17 meresearch.org.uk RESEARCH BITES
Changesinthehippocampus
Thapaliyaetal.,J.ofNeuroscienceRes.,2021
RecentresearchfromAustraliasuggeststhatsymptomsofME/CFS suchasfatigue,painandsleepdisturbancemaybelinkedtostructural changesinapartofthebraincalledthehippocampus.Thisregionis involvedincognition,memoryandregulationofthehypothalamus. Usingatechniquecalledmagneticresonanceimaging,theresearchers foundthatvolumesofspecificareasofthehippocampusweregreater inME/CFSpatientswhometthestrictInternationalConsensusCri‐teria(ICC)thantheywereinhealthycontrolsubjects.Thiswasnot thecaseinpatientswhometonlythemoregeneralFukudadiagnostic criteriaforME/CFS.
Furthermore,increasesordecreasesinthesizeofdifferent areasofthehippocampuswereassociatedwithsymptomsincluding fatigue,pain,sleepdisturbanceandphysicalfunction,andtheselinks werestrongerinICCpatients.Theresearcherssuggestthattheirfind‐ingsindicatethehippocampusmaybeinvolvedinsomeofthesymp‐tomsofME/CFS,includingbrainfog,memoryproblemsandthe abilitytodocomplextasks.However,theresultsneedtobereplicated onalargerscaletoconfirmthis.
Orthostaticintolerance
Vernonetal.,FrontiersinMedicine,2022
ME/CFSandlongCOVIDmaybothbeassoci‐atedwithorthostaticintolerance–abnormaldizzi‐nessorfaintingafterstanding.Inthisstudyof patientswitheitherillness,symptomsandother measureswereassessedfollowingaNASALean Testinvolvingperiodsofsittingup,lyingdownand standingup.Thetestworsenedsymptomsinboth patientgroups(butnotincontrols),andcaused narrowingofthepulsepressureandworsecognit‐ivereactiontimes.Theresearchersthereforere‐commendanorthostaticstresstestforallpatients withME/CFSorlongCOVID.
Measuringsleep
Yangetal.,QualityofLifeResearch,2022
Sleepdisturbancesareasignificantbutperhapsun‐der-researchedsymptomofME/CFS,soitisim‐portanttobeabletomeasuresleepqualityandits impactonqualityoflifeinpeoplewiththeillness. Thepatient-reportedoutcomemeasurementin‐formationsystem(PROMIS)hasbeendesignedto assesssleepdisturbance,sleep-relatedimpairment, paininterferenceandpainbehaviour.Thisstudy fromtheUSAshowsthatthesystemperformswell inpatientswithME/CFSforallfourofthese measures,andtheauthorssuggestitcouldbeused bothinresearchandinclinicalpractice.
18/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk RESEARCH BITES
“hippocampus maybe involvedin someofthe symptomsof ME/CFS”
Immunefunctioninadolescents
Jasonetal.,ChronicIllness,2022
Thereissomeevidenceofimmunedysfunctionin adolescentswithME/CFS,althoughthisisvaried. Toinvestigatethequestionmoreclosely,research‐ersinChicagotookbloodsamplesfromyouths aged5to17yearswithME/CFS,includinga groupwithseveredisease.Ananalysisofthecy‐tokinesintheblood(whichareinvolvedinregulat‐ingtheimmunesystem)identifiedapattern suggestingactiveinflammatoryresponses,andthis wasparticularlystronginthosewithseveredisease. Theresearcherssuggestthismayhelpinidentifying abiomarkerforpaediatricME/CFS.
Ionchannelfunction
Sassoetal.,MolecularMedicine,2022
TRPM3isanionchannelresponsiblefortrans‐portingionssuchascalciumbetweencells–apro‐cesswhichiscrucialfortheirnormalfunction.The findingofimpairedTRPM3activityinimmune cellsfrompatientswithME/CFSsuggeststhatthis maybeanimportantfeatureoftheillness,and couldpotentiallybetreatedusingadrugtorestore theinfluxofcalciumintothecell.Now,research fromAustraliahasfoundsimilarlyimpaired TRPM3ionchannelactivityincellsfrompatients withlongCOVID–moreevidenceofthesimilarit‐iesbetweenME/CFSandlongCOVID.
autumn2022/ breakthrough /19 meresearch.org.uk RESEARCH BITES
Fundraisingstories
Recentfundraisingactivitiesbyoursupporters. TosupportMEResearchUK,pleasevisitourwebsiteforideas.
VikingCoastalTrail
Watchingoutforlongboatson thehorizonthisAugustwere GraceMitchellandhermum Tracey,whowalkedtheeightmileVikingCoastalTrailtoraise fundsforMEResearchUK.The TrailbeginsnearRamsgate, followingclifftoppathstolink numerousbaysthroughMargate andalongtheseawallto Westgate-on-Sea,untilitreaches ReculverCountryPark.Thank yousomuchtoGraceand Traceyandtheirsupportersfor
fundraisingforus,andfor keepingthecoastofKentsafe frommarauders.
100milesdone
TerrySmithandhisdaughter Poppycontinuetheiradventure crossingthecountryfrom LiverpooltoGoolebycanoe. Takingitsectionbysection,asof writingtheyhadcompletedmore than100milesofthe162-mile trip.Terry’sbloghaskept supportersuptodatewiththeir progressandsightsalongthe
way,includinglotsofbirdlife suchasducks,geese,heronsand swans.KeepgoingTerryand Poppy!Youcansupportthem here:bit.ly/3odEvg9.
WakeboardingforME
Congratulationsandmany thankstoFinlayScottwho completedhischallengeto wakeboard50kminonedayto raiseawarenessandmoneyfor researchintoME/CFS,which hashadadevastatingimpacton hisyoungersister.
20/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk
MontBlanc
KathrynAveyardhassetherself themonumentaltaskofclimbing MontBlancinaidofME ResearchUK.Thismulti-day hikeisasignificantchallenge requiringtheuseofspecialised equipmentsuchascrampons andiceaxes.“Ihavebeen trainingtotryandimprovemy enduranceandlungefficiency. Supposedly,duetothealtitude,
thesummitdayismore challengingthanrunninga marathon.”Thankyouandgood luck,Kathryn.Youcansupport herhere:bit.ly/3zDvvrA.
24-hourwarriors From9a.m.onFriday27May, aspartofTeam24Hour SportathonWarriors,Chrissy Nazifcompleteda24-hour sportathontoraisemoneyfor
MEResearchUKandTheLink Foundation(whichsupportslocal childrenandfamiliesin Maidenhead).Overthecourse ofthisperiod,theteamtookpart inmorethan24differentsports –“adreamcometrueforsome, anightmareforothers!”Thank yousomuchtoChrissyandthe restofthewarriorsfortheir efforts,whichraisedaterrific totalforthecharities.
autumn2022/ breakthrough /21 meresearch.org.uk RECENT FUNDRAISING
01 02 04 03 01
02
03
04
TerrySmith reaches100 milesbycanoe
FinlayScott wakeboarding forME
24hoursof solidsport
Kathryn Aveyard faces uptoher challenge
MegaMayMiles
Maywasahugemonthfor fundraisingastheMegaMay MilesforMEteamwalked,ran, swamandcycledatotalofmore than1,000milesoverthecourse ofthemonth,inaidoftwoME researchcharitiesincludingME ResearchUK.Congratulations andthankyoutoeveryonewho tookpart.
SwimmingtheLakes
JoeWelton,WillMcCausland andTomGilbertsonhave
recentlycompletedtheir challengetoswimthefulllength ofeveryswimmablelakeinthe LakeDistrictoverthecourseof oneweek–atotaldistanceof 66kmacrossthirteenlakes.The threefriendsjoinonlyahandful ofpeopletohavemanagedthis feat.Whatafantastic achievement–wearesograteful fortheirfundraisingefforts.
Anautumnofreading Herearesomesuggestionsif you’relookingforyournextread.
01 Joe,Tom andWill headinginfor theirlastdayof swimming 02 Whatwill youreadnext?
03 Rackingup themilesthis May
Theauthorsarealldonating someoralloftheirroyaltiesto ourwork.RobertMcMullen’s StrangerandStranger tellsofan encounterinthelifeofaman withME(amzn.to/XDVnyK).
InJackCroxall’sacclaimed TethersTrilogy,KarlandEsther discoverananonymousjournal filledwithbizarrescribblings (amzn.to/1oqY9N2).Merryn Fergusson’s WhatisWrongwith ME isastoryofMEthroughthe experiencesofhersonChrisand hisfamily(amzn.to/X1Hw5w).
22/ breakthrough /autumn2022 meresearch.org.uk RECENT FUNDRAISING
02
01
03
Tosupportourwork,pleaseconsidersettingupastandingorderbycompletingthisformand sendingitto: MEResearchUK,TheGateway,NorthMethvenStreet,Perth,PH15PP
Pleasetickthisboxtoindicateyouarehappyforustocollectandstoreyourpersonal information,inaccordancewithourPrivacyPolicyatmeresearch.org.uk.
InstructiontoyourBankorBuildingSociety
Tothemanager,Pleasearrangetodebit my/ouraccountwiththeamountdetailed below,onceeverymonthuntilfurthernotice.
Payto: VirginMoney,StJohn’sCentre,Perth, PH15UH,UK,Account:MEResearchUK,a/c no:50419466,Branchcode:82-67-09
Tick ifyouwouldlikeustotreatthis,anyfuturedonations toMEResearchUK(SC036942),andallpaymentsinthe previous4years,asGiftAiddonations,meaningyour donationcanincreaseinvaluebyaquarteratnoextra costtoyou.YouconfirmthatyouareaUKtaxpayerand understandthatifyoupaylessIncomeTaxand/orCapitalGainsTax thantheamountofGiftAidclaimedonallyourdonationsinthattax yearitisyourresponsibilitytopayanydifference.Pleasenotifyusif youwishtocancelthisdeclaration,changeyournameorhome address,ornolongerpaysufficienttaxonyourincomeand/orcapital gains.IfyoupayIncomeTaxatthehigheroradditionalrateandwant toreceivetheadditionaltaxreliefduetoyou,youmustincludeall yourGiftAiddonationsonyourSelf-AssessmenttaxreturnoraskHM RevenueandCustomstoadjustyourtaxcode.
autumn2022/ breakthrough /23 meresearch.org.uk SECTION HEADER StandingOrderForm
Nameofaccountholder(s) Addressandpostcode Telephonenumber NameofBankorBuildingSociety Branchaddressandpostcode Signature Accountnumber
Branchsortcode Date
MEResearchUK–SCIOCharityno.SC036942
Debitamount(£)
Paymentdateeachmonth Dateoffirstpayment