METU ARCH 302 SHELTERING ANKARA’S ANCIENT PAST ARCH302 ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN STUDIO IV SPRING 2019-2020 Zelef, Çetin, Ağırsoy, Aydemir, Ertan, Yavuzatmaca
Image source: Hasan Okan Çetin, 2020 Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
1
CONTENT
ARCH 302 | 2019-2020 SPRING | Architectural Design Studio IV |Zelef, Çetin, Ağırsoy, Aydemir, Ertan, Yavuzatmaca
ARCH302 ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN STUDIO IV SPRING 2019-2020 SHELTERING ANKARA’S ANCIENT PAST
2
MIDDLE EAST TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE
ARCH 302
ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN IV SPRING 2019-2020 Instructors: Haluk Zelef
Hasan Okan Çetin
Gizem Nur Aydemir
Mercan Yavuzatmaca
Ömer Faruk Ağırsoy
Seren Ertan
Student List: Section_1 AYŞENUR YILDIZ
EMİNE ZÜLAL BENLİ
MUHAMMET ALİ DEMİR
SENA GÜMÜŞ
BENGİ BAYAR
EREN CÖMERT EREN KAYA
OĞULCAN DANDAN
SENA KÜÇÜKDAĞLI
BUKET SAMANCI
İREM HANCIOĞLU
OMAR EKHWAN
YAŞAR EMİR KARCI
CEREN ŞAHİN
KEMAL YILMAZ
ÖZGE GÜNDOĞDU
ZEYNEP SENGEL
DENİZ GÜNDAY
MARYAM SAEED
ÖZLEM KARAEMİNOĞULLARI
DERİN YİĞİT
MERT MANAS ERTEN
RAZİYE BERİL KALKAN
EBRAR SAYIN
MERYEM EROĞLU
SAFİYE BİLGE DOĞAN
ABDULLAH ZAMIR
MEHMET GÜLER
BÜŞRA AŞCI
SELCAN BİLGİÇ
AKTEKİN TOZUN
ONURCAN MIZRAK
BÜŞRA BALLI
ŞEYMA SEZEN
ARİF EREN YILDIRIM
RECEP SELİM YARBAŞI
DİLARA GÜNEY
YİNİNG SHİ
ASRIN ONAT ŞENGÜL
UMUTKAĞAN DURĞUT
EKİN MANSUROĞLU
ZEYNEP ERİŞTİ
DAVUT BALCİ
AYŞENUR GÖKHAN
ELİF GÜNGÖR
FURKAN TÜRKER
BERFE NAZ HAŞEMOĞLU
NADINE YOUSIF
GAZİ CAN ŞAHİN
BUSENUR GÜNGÖR
NİHAN MUTLU
Section_2
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
3
BRIEF
ARCH 302 | 2019-2020 SPRING | Architectural Design Studio IV |Zelef, Çetin, Ağırsoy, Aydemir, Ertan, Yavuzatmaca
ARCH302 ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN STUDIO IV SPRING 2019-2020 SHELTERING ANKARA’S ANCIENT PAST
4
Wikipedia underlines the historical importance of the city of Ankara as follows: “Ankara is one of the world’s oldest capital cities, having been a major urban center, though not a capital, for far longer than cities like London, Paris or Madrid; even Istanbul. When present Istanbul, then the Roman provincial town of Byzantium, was being groomed as a new capital for the Roman Empire in 324, Ankara was already an important administrative center from which most of the northern half of Turkey was run.” As you all know the history of Ankara can be traced back to the Bronze Age Hatti civilization, then 2nd millennium BC by the Hittites, in the 10th century BC by the Phrygians, and later by the Lydians, Persians, Macedonians, Galatians, Romans, Byzantines, Seljuks and Ottomans. One of the significant periods of Ankara is the Roman era after it was conquered by Augustus in 25 BC. Now the capital city of the Roman province of Galatia, Ancyra continued to be a center of great commercial importance. Ankara is also famous for the Temple of Augustus and Rome) which contains the official record of the Acts of Augustus, inscribed in marble on its walls. Today’s cityscape of Ankara offers glimpses of its long history starting from the classical times, through its Roman Baths, Augustus Temples, Roman Theatre and Julianus Column. Many excavations in the city unearth further traces of the Roman past. The plot next to the Anafartalar Shopping Mall is one of the sites, close to the main street of the roman Angora, where new findings are located after the demolishing of the building block. Therefore this area should be protected during the excavations as well as the display of the findings after. A shelter touching the ground minimally will help to protect the underground findings. This place is also a social hub of the city, close to the grand food market and many more historical hans and modern marketplaces. Such a central location also suggests a shelter for the modern day citizens, to take a short rest protected from the rain and sun.
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
5
SITE VISIT
ARCH 302 | 2019-2020 SPRING | Architectural Design Studio IV |Zelef, Çetin, Ağırsoy, Aydemir, Ertan, Yavuzatmaca
ARCH302 ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN STUDIO IV SPRING 2019-2020 SHELTERING ANKARA’S ANCIENT PAST
6
During the design process, Anafartalar Shopping Mall was prioritized as one of the crucial aspects of this design project. Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
7
ARCH302 ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN STUDIO IV SPRING 2019-2020 SHELTERING ANKARA’S ANCIENT PAST The first assignment of the Arch302 course focused on the long span structures covering large uninterrupted spaces. It particularly dwelled on the capacity of these structures in the archeological sites where the sheds over the fragile remains are required to leave minimum impact on the ground. As an initial study, groups of 4-5 students are asked to analyze two examples of such structures. One example is selected from the archeological settings and the other group of buildings are examples of long-span structures with different functions. The buildings were required to be analyzed in their structural and constructional properties. The classifications given to the students below aimed to guide them. Therefore the students asked to study the Mitchell’s groupings in terms of form-based and material-based structures. Students we expected to pay attention to the materials used and the dimensions of the spans and structural elements.
CASE STUDIES
ARCH 302 | 2019-2020 SPRING | Architectural Design Studio IV |Zelef, Çetin, Ağırsoy, Aydemir, Ertan, Yavuzatmaca
LONG SPAN STRUCTURE CASE STUDIES
8
Roof Structures: FORM-BASED Classification (Mitchell’s Building Series) 1. Truss and Girder Roofs: timber, steel, concrete 2. Rigid Frames and Arched Roofs: timber, steel, concrete 3. Thin Shells: timber, concrete (a) Single curvature : shell barrel vaults (b) Double curvature: shell domes: including doubly curved shells 4. Folded Slabs / Plates: timber, concrete 5. Grid Structures: Space Frameworks: flat, folded, curved types; timber, steel, concrete (a) Flat grids / planar space frames / space & lattice grids - Rectangular types: space trusses Triangulated space trusses: space frames (b) Folded grids and lattice plates (c) Curved grids and curved space frames; diagrid / diagonal grid - Braced / ribbed barrel vaults, lamella grids - Braced / ribbed domes, grid domes, geodesic domes 6. Tensile Structures (suspended / hanging roof constructions): network of cables with cladding (a) Cable roofs: arch ribs, compression arches, compression rings (b) Cable-supported tents (c) Tensegrity structures 7. Membrane Structures: single and double layered membranes, stressed skin (monocoque, semimonocoque), pneumatic structures 8.Mushroom Structures: Long Span Structures: MATERIAL-BASED Classification 1. Timber structures: 2-d and 3-d structural elements; trusses, frames 2. Steel structures: 2-d and 3-d structural elements; trusses, frames 3. Concrete structures: Folded plates, shells, cantilevers, prestressed elements; waffle slabs; plates ribbed along isostatics 4. Tensile-membrane structures: Tents and suspended structures; tensile-linear, tensile-surface 5. Pneumatic structures: Ribbed and inflated
Cengiz Bektaş - Aphrodisias Museum Annex (Group 12) Ahlbrecht Felix Scheidt Kasprusch - St Antony Industrial Archaeological Park (Group 11) A3GM Arquitectos - Clunia Forum (Group 10) Amann-Cánovas-Mauri - Roof for Molinete Roman Ruins (Group 9) Jean Nouvel - Gallo Roman Museum (Group 8) Turgut Cansever - Karatepe Aslantaş (Group 7) Savioz Fabrizzi Architectes - Coverage of Archaeological Ruins of The Abbey of St-Maurice (Group 6) Bernard Tschumi - New Acropolis Museum (Group 5) Atölye Architecture Office - Zeugma Dionysos and Danae Houses Protection Shed (Group 4) Atölye Architecture Office - Çatalhöyük Protection Shed (Group 3) Erkal Architects - Necropolis Museum and Archeological Park(Group 2) Kreatif Mimarlık - Göbeklitepe Protection Shed (Group 1)
Renzo Piano - Paul Klee Center (Group 1) Nicholas Grimshaw - Eden Project (Group 2) Renzo Piano - California Academy of Sciences (Group 3) Cedric Price – London Zoo Aviary (Group 4) Frei Otto and Shigeru Ban - Japan Pavilion EXPO Hannover (Group 5) Grimshaw and Samoo - Botanic Greenhouses at the National Ecology Center (Group 6) Calatrava, Lyon Train Station (Group 7) Calatrava, Gare do Oriente Railway Station (Group 8) Richard Rogers – PA Technology Center & Inmos factory (Group 9) Jürgen Mayer - Metropol Parasol (Group 10) Shigeru Ban - Japan Pavillion Expo 2000 (Group 11) Hariri Pontarini Architects - Ontario’s Celebration Zone Pavilion, Toronto (Group 12) Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
9
Groups
ARCH 302 | 2019-2020 SPRING | Architectural Design Studio IV |Zelef, Çetin, Ağırsoy, Aydemir, Ertan, Yavuzatmaca
ARCH302 ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN STUDIO IV SPRING 2019-2020 SHELTERING ANKARA’S ANCIENT PAST
10
Group List: 1
Berfe Naz Haşemoğlu, Fukran Türker - Safiye Bilge Doğan, Ebrar Sayın
2
Ayşenur Gökhan, Zeynep Erişti - İrem Hancıoğlu, Zeynep Sengel
3
Elif Güngör, Nihan Mutlu – Özlem Karaeminoğulları, Sena Küçükdağlı
4
Aytekin Tozun, Selcan Bilgiç – Özge Gündoğdu, Mert Manas Erten
5
Gazi Can Şahin, Yining Shi – Ceren Şahin, Derin Yiğit
6
Asrın Onat Şengül, Arif Eren Yıldırım – Omar Ekhwan, Sena Gümüş
7
Umut Kaan Durğut, Onurcan Mızrak – Zülal Benli, M. Ali Demir
8
Dilara Güney, Davut Balci – Buket Samancı, Yaşar Emir Karcı
9
Abdullah Zamir, Busenur Güngör, Mehmet Güler – Meryem Eroğlu, Maryam Saeed
10
Nadine Yousif, Şeyma Sezen- Deniz Günday, Bengi Bayar
11
Ekin Mansuroğlu, Büşra Ballı – Ayşenur Yıldız, Eren Kaya
12
Recep Selim Yarbaşı, Büşra Aşçı – Eren Cömert, Kemal Yılmaz, Oğulcan Dandan
GROUP 1
GROUP 2
GROUP 3
GROUP 4
GROUP 5
GROUP 6
GROUP 7
GROUP 8
GROUP 9
GROUP 10
GROUP 11
GROUP 12
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
11
Group 1_Case Studies
12
Group 1_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
13
Group 2_Case Studies
14
Group 2_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
15
Group 3_Case Studies
16
Group 3_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
17
Group 4_Case Studies
18
Group 4_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
19
Group 5_Case Studies
20
Group 5_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
21
Group 6_Case Studies
22
Group 6_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
23
Group 7_Case Studies
24
Group 7_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
25
Group 8_Case Studies
26
Group 8_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
27
Group 9_Case Studies
28
Group 9_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
29
Group 10_Case Studies
30
Group 10_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
31
Group 11_Case Studies
32
Group 11_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
33
Group 12_Case Studies
34
Group 12_Student Project
Sheltering Ankara’s Ancient Past
35
MIDDLE EAST TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY
DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE 36
