Middle Templar 2020

Page 100

THE DIVORCE BLAME GAME IS NEARLY OVER

SOPHIE KAY

The Divorce Blame Game is Nearly Over Sophie Kay was Called to the Bar in 2016. Sophie practises in family law at 5 Pump Court Chambers. She specialises in divorce, private children and domestic violence work. She was awarded the Jules Thorn Scholarship and is a member of the Attorney General’s Junior Panel of Counsel.

The Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Act 2020 (‘the Act’) received Royal Assent on Thursday 25 June 2020, having swiftly completed its passage through Parliament. It is remarkable that the Act was fact-tracked through its final parliamentary stages, especially during Covid-19, which exacerbated tension for many couples whose marriages were already strained. It is noted, however, that there was much debate surrounding the Act prior to Parliament’s prorogation, coupled with the 30-year campaign by family lawyers and organisations for no-fault divorce. The Act is long overdue. The Act is not the first legislative attempt to introduce ‘no-fault’ divorce. Divorce law was very nearly reformed by Part II of the Family Law Act 1996, which had allowed for no-fault divorce, provided couples took part in compulsory information meetings. However, this was never implemented and was quickly repealed. In 2013, Lord McNally said the decision to repeal was based on the results of pilot schemes of the information meetings, which showed that the meetings were unworkable, inflexible and not tailored to the parties’ individual circumstances. When implemented, the Act will enable spouses to divorce without having to attribute blame or wait

98

the minimum two years in a state of limbo as separated spouses, as prescribed by the current law. This is a landmark and welcomed Act, and represents the biggest shift in divorce law in this jurisdiction in over 50 years.

The current law Under the Matrimonial Causes Act (MCA) 1973, in order to divorce couples must be married for at least one year, and must establish one of the five ‘facts’ to support the ground that the marriage has irretrievably broken down: • Adultery; •  Unreasonable behaviour; • Desertion; •  The couple has lived apart for at least two years and both agree to the divorce (divorce by consent); •  The couple has lived apart for at least five years, even if one partner disagrees (divorce without consent). Problems arise when a spouse disputes these facts and resists the divorce. If the divorce is successfully defended under one of the ‘blame’ grounds (adultery, unreasonable behaviour or desertion), the other spouse is trapped in the marriage for five years from separation. Many couples do not have the funds or time for their lives to be paused for

2020 Middle Templar

such a long duration. This is plainly unsatisfactory and unjust. The Supreme Court’s rejection of Tini Owens’ appeal, where her husband refused to agree to the divorce, is an infamous example. At first-instance in Owens v Owens, it was found that the marriage had broken down, but not because of the 27 examples cited by Mrs Owens of unreasonable behaviour, which were deemed flimsy, exaggerated, and isolated incidents. For instance, she alleged that Mr Owens had been moody and argumentative and had disparaged her in front of others. Ultimately, this decision was upheld by the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court, with Lady Hale stating that she, ‘found this a very troubling case. It is not for us to change the law laid down by Parliament – our role is only to interpret and apply the law that Parliament has given us’. What is troubling is that Mrs Owens had to go to such lengths of citing 27 examples in an attempt to divorce her husband, whom she married in


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

Temple Church Weddings

0
page 145

New Masters of the Bench 2019-20

9min
pages 127-129

Middle Temple Students' Association

4min
page 126

Middle Temple Young Barristers' Association

7min
pages 124-125

Hall Committee

4min
page 123

The COIC Pupillage Matched Funded Scheme

3min
page 122

What Have the Bar Council and the Inn Ever Done for Me?

2min
page 119

Behind the Lens

8min
pages 116-118

Temple Residents' Association

4min
page 121

Valedictory: The Rt Hon. Lord Carnwath

7min
pages 114-115

Temple Church During Lockdown

7min
pages 112-113

Lent Reader’s Feast: The Highways, Byways and Blind Alleys of International Law

11min
pages 108-110

Temple Church Choir Summer Review

2min
page 111

Becoming a Barrister

15min
pages 103-105

Autumn Reader's Feast: Current Challenges in the Criminal Justice System

8min
pages 106-107

Talk to Spot

3min
page 102

The Divorce Blame Game is Nearly Over

6min
pages 100-101

You have the Right to Remain Unidentified

7min
pages 98-99

Levelling the Playing Field

8min
pages 96-97

A Day in the Country in Lockdown

9min
pages 92-93

Confronting the Challenges Presented by the Covid-19 Pandemic

8min
pages 90-91

Impeachment of a U.S. President

8min
pages 94-95

How Middle Temple Helped Me

3min
page 88

Don’t Let Commercial Awareness be a Bar to Success

4min
page 87

Student Life at the Inn

3min
page 86

In the Shoes of an Out of London Student

4min
page 85

The Inns of Court

3min
page 84

The ICCA Bar Course

3min
page 83

Troubled Journeys on the Path to Justice

3min
page 82

Turning the Tide against Corruption in the Congo

4min
page 81

My Journey to the Bar and Becoming the First Kurdish Iraqi Barrister

3min
page 80

Qualifying Sessions

4min
page 79

The Role of an Inn of Court

3min
page 78

Five Perspectives on Sponsorship

8min
pages 76-77

Advocacy at the Inn

7min
pages 74-75

Outreach

3min
page 72

Sherrard Conversations

3min
page 73

Mock Pupillage Interviews

7min
pages 68-69

Volunteering at Call Day

2min
pages 70-71

Mooting Trip to Cherokee

9min
pages 65-67

Education Update

4min
page 64

100 Years Since Helena Normanton's First Qualifying Session

2min
page 58

MTYBA & MTSA International Women's Day

2min
page 59

Créme de la Créme Climbing Rose

2min
page 62

Celebrating a Century of Women in Law

5min
pages 56-57

Circuit Societies

15min
pages 53-55

MTYBA Dark Waters Event

3min
page 63

The Rule of Law Under Attack

7min
pages 60-61

Working in the Seychelles

4min
page 52

An Increased Use of Technology in Gibraltar's Legal System

2min
page 51

Access to Justice during the Coronavirus Pandemic: The Malaysian Experience

8min
pages 48-49

Cross Border Practice in Europe and Brexit

4min
page 46

Business as Usual at the European Court of Justice Pending Brexit

7min
pages 44-45

Reflections on a Declaration of Friendship

7min
pages 42-43

Mind the Gap: The General Adjourned Period and the Coronavirus Pandemic in Hong Kong

4min
page 47

Amity Visit to Canada

6min
pages 40-41

Book Review: Equal Justice by Frederick Wilmot-Smith

3min
page 39

Book Review: Court Number One: The Old Bailey Trials that Defined Modern Britain by Thomas Grant

4min
page 38

Book Review: Simon Brown's Memoirs by the The Rt Hon The Lord Brown

4min
page 35

The Ceremonial Plate of the Middle Temple

4min
page 32

Lord Carson of Duncairn: Barrister, Statesman and Judge

11min
pages 27-29

Unshaken & Unshakeable

7min
pages 30-31

A Personal Collection of 15th Century Documents

17min
pages 23-26

Justiciability – A Forgotten Saga

9min
pages 33-34

Readers of the Temple: From the 16th to the 19th Century

9min
pages 20-22

A Potted History of the Office of the Under Treasurer

5min
pages 18-19

Equality and Diversity at the Bar Council

4min
page 13

The Spanish Influenza Pandemic

3min
page 17

Racial Equality, Inclusion and Anti-Racism Working Group

2min
page 12

Black Lives Matter

4min
page 11

BAME and the Bar

4min
page 10

From the Treasurer

6min
pages 8-9

Speech at the Inauguration of the Middle Temple LGBTQ+ Forum

11min
pages 14-16

Under Treasurers’ Forewords

8min
pages 6-7
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.