i
c
01
02
03
04
PORTFOLIO Ellen Willis Studio 1: Remedial Housing for Architects Year 3 1
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
2
3
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
NAVIGATING MY PORTFOLIO
These markers represent which chapter work was completed in: i = illustrated reflective report c = charette 01 = primer 02 = staging 03 = realisation 04 = synthesis The order in which I have presented my work doesn’t always follow the chronology of these chapters, but the marker in the corner will indicate at which stage of the project that piece of work was completed regardless of where it appears in the structure of my portfolio.
4
5
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS
CONTENTS
Illustrated Reflective Report...................................................................................8 Charette............................................................................................................12 ARC3001 Primer...............................................................................................................20 Staging..............................................................................................................42 Realisation & Synthesis...................................................................................104 Bibliography....................................................................................................166 Cultural Bibliography.......................................................................................170 Appendix i.....................................................................................................172
6
7
01 i
c
01
02
03
04
01 i
global warming, it is vital that architects and architecture goes some way to tackle these. How have the technical aspects of my project informed my design? The technical aspects of my design have been very informative. As outlined in our studio manifesto, sustainable design and Passivhaus standards were key themes from the beginning and have therefore informed my design at every stage and at every scale. The earliest aspects of my housing design were based on sun angles and passive solar gain, as well as timber construction methods. As well as this, my re-organisation of Cruddas Park Community Centre is entirely centred around solar orientation. Sustainable principles are present in multiple areas of my design, including using terraced housing to reduce heat loss, having dual aspect homes to ensure south facing light as well as cross ventilation. Looking in more detail, when designing the windows and elevations of the housing, maximising passive solar gain – as well as solar shading - was at the fore-front of my mind from the first iterations to the resolution of details.
ILLUSTRATED REFLECTED REPORT
From the beginning of PRIMER, I have framed my investigation as a protest against contemporary, generic housing. Throughout, I have tried to critically evaluate the values that housing developments such as Great Park are built on, and counter them with the values that I believe housing should be built on. Too often, profit is prioritised over generous, thoughtful, and joyful design, and this was definitely reflected in our studio reading of Great Park. These issues are difficult to escape as architecture must operate within this system, but I strongly believe that architecture has great opportunity to make a political statement, and that good design should aim to make a political statement of some kind. In our society we still suffer with great injustices, and with the ever-growing problem of
How has my project been informed by the theoretical framework such as theory into practice? The theory into practice essay was a very interesting exercise that made me evaluate and question my perspective as a designer in relation to my project. The 8
9
c
01
02
03
04
01 i
c
01
02
03
04
01 i
essay made me realise that looking at design from a human scale was vital for the project to be successful. Although this was already an important strand of my thinking, the Theory into Practice essay meant that I more rigorously evaluated my methods of representation in order to create a humane design.
How does my work impact the context in which it sits - how is it relevant to the wider design and construction profession? I consider my work to be very relevant to the design and construction profession. As a direct reaction to current housing developments such as Great Park, my work is framed within a very real social, political and economic context. Clearly, as a student project that exists as purely hypothetical, the impact it may have is limited, but in furthering my thinking and my values as I am about to go into the professional workplace it is critically relevant to my own work and my future contributions to the profession.
My project is underpinned by a thorough theoretical context based on extensive reading and research, and many exemplar projects such as those we saw in our studio visit to Vienna. Particularly in the STAGING of my project, I wanted my large scale design decisions to be deliberate, thoughtful, and impactful so it was vital that they were backed up by research. I continued to read about social housing and the economic of housing throughout my design work, and benefited greatly from our studio visit to Leeds to see CITU and LILAC.
Looking back on every year of this degree, I have always been shocked at home much I have managed to learn in a relatively short space of time, and this year is no different. I feel that this year, more than any previous, I have been successful at marrying my morals, beliefs, and principles with my design which has been a goal of mine. I have always valued the opportunity to make a political statement with architecture; I remember before I even started my degree saying that I thought it was disgraceful that some people have multiple homes, millions of pounds in disposable income, yet others in the UK have no roof over their heads. I am very proud of the work that I have produced this year and really excited to find a job with a firm that really resonates with my beliefs.
My dissertation ran parallel to the beginning of my design project, and the themes overlapped between the two works. Sustainability, particularly sustainability in the home was something I researched greatly for my dissertation, which helped to influence my design work. As well as this, another area of my research was individual sustainable action and how to encourage neighbourhoods to act in more sustainable ways with design. This fed into my design work, and helped me to ground my human scale approach.
10
11
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
Charette CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE
CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE CHARETTE
12
13
i
c 01
01
02
03
04
i
SUSTAINABILITY THEMES Charette week, and the entire academic year, had a strong stance on sustainability from the beginning. Sustainable design is something I am very interested in, and one of the main areas of interest I wish to explore further in my architectural career. Charette photos by: Yew Zhi Xuan
14
c 01
THE GRAINGER WEIGH UNIVERSITY
BRIEF:
HAYMARKET
The brief for this charette was to re-design a local zero waste store in Grainger Market. We had to accommodate the beautiful existing Victorian staircase within the store, and give it a much needed redesign and rebranding.
MONUMENT
GRAINGER MARKET
THE BALTIC
15
THE SAGE
01
02
03
04
i
01 c
01
02
03
04
i
Final plan, short section, and long section. 16
17
01 c
01
02
03
04
i
01 c
01
02
03
04
i
Where The BeST COSTS LeSS QuaLiTy LOOSe fOOdS
Fu
ice
Cava
r
late sins
ower eeds
18
The GrainGer WeiGh
Where The BeST COSTS LeSS
Pistachios
Cranb
Green L
Raisins
corns
Cashews
Ba
Chocolate Almonds
Almonds
Apricots
Green Lentils
Sunflower Seeds
Walnuts
Pecans
Mixed Fruit and Nut
Oats
Yoghurt Cranberries
Chocolate Raisins
Cherios
Oats
Curry Powder
Pinto Beans
19
Pearl Barle
d
01 c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
Primer PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER
PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER PRIMER
20
21
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
The primer section of this project is vitally important as it sets up a crucial framework for the rest of my project. Through looking at Great Park, just north of Newcastle city centre, it became clear to our whole studio that our housing projects needed to reflect a different set of values than generic contemporary housing. It set up a network of theoretical thinking that frames my project as a protest against modern housing developments. Clearly, what is valued in developments such as Great Park is money. Profit takes priority over everything else, often to the detriment of resident experience. There are countless examples of this, including the tragic Grenfell fire three years ago. Profit was chosen time and time again over resident safety, ultimately meaning that 72 people lost their lives. Housing does not have to be like this. We have the money, and we have the resources, if we re-direct them in society there is great potential for residents to all have housing that they love and are proud of.
22
23
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
GREAT PARK Great Park, just north of Newcastle City Centre, is representative of any and all generic, contemporary housing developments. Sprawled over a large area, the individual houses are eerily repetitive, and there is little to no green space or areas for shared community activity. It seems lonely, and segregated, with design decisions being made to maximise profit, over prioritising resident experience.
24
25
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
26
27
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
BALCONIES Focusing on the balconies at Great Park, it is as though the developers stuck various different types of balcony on to the facade at the end in at an attemp to add value and make more profit. Considering the history of balconies, they have been seen as platforns of importance, for speeches or for declerations of romance. Balconies have trickled down from being a symbol of power to being a profit tool on almost every house in the Great Park development. 28
29
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
30
31
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
MILLIONS OF HOMES ENGLAND ‘NEEDS
TO SOLVE THE HOUSING CRISIS’ 32
33
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
LEARNING FROM EXAMPLE
While studying Great Park, it was important for our studio to identfiy key precedents that we felt did housing well. In this way, we could build our manifseto out of both positive and negative examples. Our braod themes were: sustainability, inclusivity, equality, dignity and happiness. TOP LEFT - BOTTOM RIGHT: Tower Flower - R50 Co-Housing Tour Bois-le-pretre - Tibby’s Triangle - Nightingale 1 - OWCH - Naked House - Llana del Rio - Hunziker - Goldsmith Street - Hannibal Road Gardens
34
35
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
MONTAGE OF MY MODEL, PHOTOGRAPHS AND DRAWINGS OF THE PLAY SPACES OF GREAT PARK AND HOW IT IS USED AND POTENTIALLY MIS-USED
POTENTIAL USES OF UN-USED GREEN SPACE
Play spaces are an important part of Newcastle Great Park. and every town and estate in Britain. However, there are issues with play spaces that is not just limited to Great Park, but play spaces everywhere. While they are designed as safe spaces for young children to play, they can often become misused if are in areas that are not easily visible from houses, or if play equipment becomes broken or falls into disrepair. Sometimes parks can be for children by day, but by night used by gangs or young people for drug dealing, smoking and other crimes, becoming an antisocial area and not what the space was intended for. There are no other provisions of functional public spaces for people of other ages , so they often have no choice but to gravitate towards play parks.
PLAY SPACES Researched route using minor roads and paths
I sketched the gable ends of some different houses and explored the relationship they had with each other. Many were back to back with the next detached house and the space in-between had no social or practical use. Many houses were also built in symmetry with its neighbour. These sketches also try to highlight the many places on some of the buildings where the cladding changes and has been over complicated. Each time I came across a house with a complicated variation of cladding, it was evident there was damp existing somewhere.
New bike storage concept montage
City Centre BIKE LANE MAIN ROAD RESIDENTIAL ROAD
GROUP POSTERS
Existing bike storage use montage
Bdy Ward
Def
A1
Path (um)
58.5m
EXISTING BIKE STORAGE/ ROUTES
Drain
PROPOSED BIKE STORAGE/ ROUTES 62
A1
Great Park has approximately 2000 car parking spaces, and a total of 4800 planned by 2034. So according to the councils plans, there should be approximately 400 (20%) places to park/keep a bike. Taking into account private garages, I have
mapped the number of shared access bike storage units that are needed and placed them close to houses without adequate storage space. I’ve done the same calculation for bike routes/lanes and illustrated the extra routes needed.
OR
DRIVE
BARMO
Existing bike storage use montage
Ziyad Hasanin
The element I have studied is of a Gable End on a corner house. I chose this particular house because of its orientation to the street and the surrounding houses and also its size – it stuck out to me as one of the more upmarket, more expensive builds. This particular corner I have modelled is N/W facing so I wonder if the intention of the design was to collect as much northern light as possible for the bedrooms of which, the windows draw light into? Based on our visit on the 14th of October, the materiality of most houses on the Great Park seem some-what rogue and the finishes do not look like they are weathering well. The build finish quality was not amazing however it was not as bad as other properties in the area where the brick work was not pointed correctly and cement was scuffed over the face of the brick (see middle image to the left). The brick laying process in many cases has clearly been rushed. This worries me as to how much consideration went into the cladding systems shown on my model as well as how they seal together to keep moisture out. The orange ‘wooden effect’ panels are not timber and I do not think recycling the material is common. This makes me question why the developer would go for a orange spray painted UPVC cladding as it is already fading, further damaging the aesthetic of the building?
Tree grille
Pavement
Concrete Layer
Root Deflector Cover
Gravel
The top image is a photo montage to show the different houses with in the Great Park landscape. It was created with the intention of designing a new sort of typography to portray the different style housing situated in Great Park. By mixing all these differently clad houses together like this it becomes apparent that there is just one style of built form that exists there. This built form seems chaotic
Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database rights 2019 Ordnance Survey (100025252). FOR EDUCATIONAL USE ONLY
The image above is a drawing to show how I interpreted the construction of the rendered corners that feature on many of the buildings. From pictures of the rooms internally, it is clear that the external shape of the house I have modelled relates in no way to the internal architecture and space. The walls remain flush and the floor to ceiling windows in the corner sit deep flush to the facia of the render (see my painting below). These features are arguably inconvenient for residents that wish to extent their property in anyway. The corners and balcony features cause the roofs of some properties to appear over complicated in their form, where the loft space is un-usable and impossible to extend in to. If the resident wished to extend off the side of some of these houses it would be a challenge to come up with a simple extension design that engages and works with the external structure shown protruding off the face of the brick in my drawing Scale above. This suggests that many of the buildings have not been designedNovwith longevity and adaptability in 09, 2019 10:13 1:5000 George Spendlove 500 m 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 mind. 0 Projection: British N ational Grid
University of Newcastle
(GROUP WORK) We studied great park by analysing individual elements of the neighbourhood and how these elements had shaped the area.
Mature trees in towns and cities contribute significantly to our health and well-being in many ways; large trees can intercept more air pollution, store more carbon and contribute more leaf area to the tree canopy. However there is a declining number of larger trees in urban areas. Older, larger trees are routinely being replaced by smaller trees, and poor planting and maintenance also mean that some trees seldom live long enough to reach maturity and provide meaningful ecosystem services.
OVERVIEW
TREES
GEORGE SPENDLOVE
EXTERNAL WALL GABLE END
Newcastle City Council published in an official document that it “aims to develop a cycling culture where 20% of all trips under five miles are undertaken by cycle by 2021.” Therefore I modelled this scenario using the map above.
Bike route suggested by Google.
2
Charlie Barratt
Great Park
53
BIKE RACK
Rachel Sexton
The RootSpace® system (RSS), developed by GreenBlue Urban, is essentially a pavement support system – designed for maximum soil and rooting volume, to be ‘utility friendly’, with economic freight and industry-leading strength characteristics. It provides optimum conditions for soil biology maximising root growth & tree health, while being very fast, simple, and easy to assemble reducing installation time & costs, and designed for easy integration, and re-excavation for maintenance, of utilities. Comparing a tree planted using a ‘RootSpace system’ (RSS), which provides uncompacted soil for root development and growth, and a typical street tree planted in a small tree pit, surrounded by compacted soil, a standard street tree will cost much less to plant but will usually be replaced every 8-15 years. This means that it will never reach the size at which it can deliver maximum benefit and provide a return on investment.
Arborvent to allow air flow Membrane
Root Deflector
Tree guying system
RootSpace Airflow Lid RootSpace System
Soil
Support
The two farther trees are the ones planted in GreenBlue Urban soil cell systems. Clearly doing well, with good shoot extensions every year, and no difference yet between them in size, as neither will have reached the limit of the soil cell systems 20 ml Geonet for increased stability
Gravel layer for services
Benefits provided by trees with a RootSpace System (RSS) are generally greater than those from street trees when compared like for like (based on diameter at breast height). This is because the leaf area of trees with adequate rooting volume are proportionally larger than for street trees with the same trunk diameter. In one trial, four identical trees were planted in different systems at Blackfriars road, London, to be monitored for atleast 10 years to establish empirical evidence for the effectiveness for the different systems.
This nearer tree is the one installed in a structural soil, an urban tree soil type. it is clearly suffering from both the lack of water availability in a tree sand type medium (shown by the poor leaf colour) and the lack of nutrient availability shown by the significant reduction in canopy size and density.
36
37
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
REMEDIAL HOUSING PRIMER SHOW
Our studio primer show focused on representing Great Park in all its fragments to portray a sense of the elements that make up a neighbourhood. Alongside this we presented our studio manifesto of our own beliefs going forward. 38
39
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
LOCALISATION for ACCESSIBILITY for SUSTAINABILITY for COMMUNITY
WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN DEVELOPERS DON’T WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? DESIGN WOMEN DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN DEVELOPERS DON’T WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? WHO IS STANDARD? DESIGN WOMEN DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN WHO IS STANDARD? DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN DEVELOPERS DON’T DESIGN WOMEN
HOUSING STANDARDS SHOULD NOT BE STANDARD
i
c
01
02
03
04
FLEXIBILITY leads to LONGEVITY leads to SUSTAINABILITY
CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE CLASS, CULTURES, AGE ECOLOGIES WON’T GROWN ON MANICURED LAWNS ECOLOGIES WON’T GROWN ON MANICURED LAWNS ECOLOGIES WON’T GROWN ON MANICURED LAWNS ECOLOGIES WON’T GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GROWN ON MANICURED LAWNS ECOLOGIES GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE WON’T GROWN ON MANICURED LAWNS GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE GIVE PUBLIC SPACE PURPOSE
CREATE TO INTEGRATE
‘CLIMATE CRISIS?’ GREEN MEANS MORE THAN GRASS HOMES ACT LIKE IT NO MORE NO-MAN’S-LAND PEOPLE NOT ACTIVE DESIGN, BEFORE DESTROYING GENDER STEREOTYPES STARTS AT HOME PASSIVHAUS HOUSES PROFIT 40
THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN 41 FOR EFFICIENT HOUSES THOUGHTFUL DESIGN FOR
i
c
01
02
03
04
Staging i
STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING
STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING STAGING
42
43
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
In staging, we are first introduced to our site. This section includes extensive site analysis covering geographical analysis, demographical analysis, historical analysis, and user experience analysis. As well as this, I continued to read and research about contemporary housing developments after visiting Great Park to strengthen my project’s theoretical framework. A vast amount of decisions were made - almost subconsciously - at this point, some of which didn’t materialise into physical outputs until as late as the synthesis chapter. It became clear at this stage that although the architecture would be modest, the ideas would be very significant. There is a strong, radical agenda behind my project, much of which was developed within this stage of my design and my research, which continues to underpin all my thinking until the very end.
44
45
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
VIENNA
46
47
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
KARL MARX HOF Karl Marx Hof is one of many monuments to ‘Red Vienna’ left standing today. A physical memory of the socialist principles that drove Vienna towards its sensitive and generous social housing model today, Karl Marx Hof shows how social housing can work on a massive scale. 48
49
c
01
02 01
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
SOCIAL HOUSING IN VIENNA
In Vienna, 60% of people live in social housing. Compared to any area of the UK that is astounding. In the UK, there seems to be a certain stigma and reputation around living in social housing that there isn’t in the rest of Europe. Challenging this reputation and designing in a way that allows this reputation to change is very difficult. There is such an abundance of social housing in Vienna that each one can have its own style and architectural langauge, allowing personal taste and preference to be integrated into social housing. Social housing is allowed to be ‘out there’ and unique, because there is so much of it that there will always be another option if one doesn’t meet your personal taste. 50
51
c
01
02
03
04
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT
BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE BUT IT’S EXPENSIVE
BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT BUT THE PEOPLE LIKE IT 52
53
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
THEORETICAL CONTEXT
54
55
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
(a) Architect
Adolf Loos
Steiner Haus 1908
American Bar 1908
Timeline of notable works
56
Loos’ Flat, Lina Loos’ bedroom 1903
Villa Muller 1930
57
Cafe Museum 1930
i
c
01
02
03
04
(a) Architect
Raumplan: Space Plan
‘I do not draw plans, facades or sections’
The Secessionist Movement, Vienna
c
01
02
03
04
(a) Architect
William Morris
Pre-secessionist architecture, Vienna Künstlerhaus Genossenschaft Villa Muller, Prague, 1930
The way in which Loos designed was to imagine the spaces and the experiences first, then translate that onto two dimensional drawings. Raumplan as a theory is something Loos concretised later in his career, but as a way of working it is still evident in his early designs. You can see by studying the facades of these two buildings that there is no clear elevational grid, or any organisation related to how the facades are supposed to look. Every window placement is based on the interior experience and the spacial sequence that Loos had designed. Rufer House, Vienna, 1922
i
58
The Ringstrausse boundaries around the city became symbolic of the oppressive neoclassical style that was favoured presecessionism.
Charles Rennie Mackintosh
In pre-secessionist Vienna, the art and architecture favoured the recycling of classical style over new, modern styles, and artwork that was modernist or impressionist in style was rejected over classical academic works. However, throughout the rest of Europe, modernism was beginning to be embraced. In response to this, a group of artists and architects came together at the end of the 19th century to form what would become known as the Secessionist movement. This movement aimed to bring together different disciplines, like fine art and applied art, and different styles. It is this ‘pluralist approach’ that makes the Secessionist movement different from its counterparts, the Art Neavou and Jugendstil movements. Secessionists believed that returning to hand crafted art was a solution to the moral decay caused by industrialisation.
The Secessionist Building, Vienna, 1898, Joseph Maria Olbrich
‘Kiss’ 1908 Gustav Klimt 59
i
c
01
02
03
04
Structural concrete hidden by material covers.
(a) Architect
(h) Structural Strategy
Loos was against ornament as he saw it as unintelligent and unecessary. He believed that the beauty of modernism is that it was functional and understated. In addition to aesthetic preferences, ornament meant that buildings could go ‘out of style’, whereas Loos’ buildings had no style so they would be acceptable for much longer. Also, because Loos predicted that ornamnetation would go out of style, it meant that any craftsmen would now not have their work appreciated and would be underpaid.
Cafe Museum, Vienna, 1930
Lack of ornamentation on the windows
i
c
01
02
03
04
Loos Huas is an iron reinforced concrete frame structure, but this is concealed by the lavish interior and exterior finishings. The way in which Loos developed his design was that he imagined the experience first, and the emotions he wanted to evoke through his designs, then designed the structure to hold up these experiential spaces. It is clear from photographs that the structure is not expressed, and is either integrated within, or hidden from, the experience of the interior spaces. ‘interior is a form of covering. But it is not simply the walls that are covered. Structure ‘the artist, the architect, first sense the effect that he intends to realise and [then] sees the room he wants to create in his mind’s eye.’ s a seconds
Loos House Elevation, Vienna, 1909 “in a reaction to the florid forms of Art Nouveau, Loos declared that decorative details were for degenerates – he believed that real design should be strong and stolid and stripped-back. His buildings, such as Villa Müller and the Steiner House, were economical, utilitarian and pure of form.”
Steiner House, Vienna, 1910 ‘Do you not see the greatness of our age resides in our very inability to create new ornament? We have gone beyond ornament, we have achieved plain, undecorated simplicity...Soon the streets of the cities will shine like white walls!’
‘Since ornament is no longer a natural product of our culture, but a symptom of backwardness or degeneracy, the craftsman producing ornament is not fairly rewarded for his labour.’
Matt Gibbered, author of Ornament and Crime
Adolf Loos, in his essay ‘Ornament and Crime’
Adolf Loos, in his essay ‘Ornament and Crime’
‘The architect’s general task is to provide a warm and liveable space. Carpets are warms and liveable. He decides for this reason to spread one carpet on the floor and to hang up four to form the four walls. But you cannot build a house out of carpets. Both the carpet on the floor and the tapestry on the wall require a structural frame to hold them in the correct place. To invent this frame is the architect’s second task.’
Photographs of the building showing how structure is hidden, or integrated.
Exploded axo with highlighted load bearing elements. 60
61
i
c
01
02
03
04
(h) Structure
i
Photograph from construction
Structural drawing by the engineers, Pittel & Brausewetter
NOT STRUCTURAL
What are these columns if not ornamental?
Lack of ornament on Loos’ windows compared to the building opposite, Hofburg Imperial Palace.
Loos wanted the four marble columns (shown with the red line) at the base to not be structural elements, which meant that all the support for the structure above came from the two corner-most concrete columns. It is all supported by the horizontal concrete beam, which is just over 14m long. The area shaded in red is actually suspended from the above concrete frame, as the iron reinforcements were hung from the horizontal concrete beam.
The facade, like the rest of the building, is a reinforced concrete frame. The use of concrete rather than stone or brick allowed the windows to be completely ornamentless, because structurally there was no need for lintels. However, the bottom half of the elevation is not as simple. 62
63
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
64
65
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
MODERN APPLICATION
66
67
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
LILAC L.I.L.A.C stands for: ‘low impact
68
living affordable community’. As a model for how housing can be done sensitively, sustainably, and affordably, LILAC is an incredible precedent for our studio that we were lucky enough to go and visit. It is a cohousing development with a particular economic system where tenants only pay a very small amount for their housing. With shared outdoor space, kitchen, and laundry facilities as well as beautiful individual flats, LILAC is a key example of sustainable co-housing.
69
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
THE GIROSCOPE PROJECT
Giroscope is a charity based in Hull that rehomes the vulnerable and the homesless. They work with the future homeowners to renovate, or to build their new home from scratch. That way, not only do people benefit from having a new home to live in, they also have a basic level of training, qualifications, and confidence to set them up for employment. 70
71
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
CITU
CITU is a housing development in Leeds. The production factory for the housing is a mere five minute walk from the site where the housing is built, so we were able to understand the whole process of home building in more detail. Visiting a construction site is incredibly insightful not only into the technical side of how housing is built, but the entire life cycle and process of construction. 72
73
c
01
02
03
04
SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY i c 01 02 03 04 SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY On the North side of the community SUSTAINBILITY SUSTAINBILITY centre there will be community services such as therapy, careers, and child services. These require a level of privacy to maintain dignity and anonymity for individuals. On the North side of the community centre there will be community services such as therapy, careers, and child services. These require a level of privacy to maintain dignity and anonymity for individuals. On the North side of the community centre there will be community services such as therapy, careers, and child services. These require a level of privacy to maintain unity services.
TIMBER CONSTRUCTION TIMBER CONSTRUCTION TIMBER CONSTRUCTION
THE GIROSCOPE PROJECT
74
WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL WALTER WALTER SEGAL SEGAL
BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES SELF BUILD TIMBER MODULES
i
75
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
SITE
76
77
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
78
79
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
CRUDDAS PARK
Cruddas Park is a collection of 1960’s flat tower blocks. On our studio site visit, it was clear that the site lacked life. Cruddas Park Shopping Centre itself (right) was especially unwelcoming and unfriendly from the outside with extremely closed off facades. If you didn’t already know what was inside, I think you would be unlikely to venture in or even realise that you were allowed to go inside. However, the site had lots of green space to work with, and is south facing, 80
81
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
SITE HISTORY When T Dan Smith was elected as city council leader in 1960, he took the opportunity to radically transform Newcastle with his international modernist ideals. He impemented the highways in the sky and the metro system that still shapes Newcastle today. Our site used to be fully terraced, but during this time Cruddas Park was an area that was transformed in accordance with this. The buildings that remain are a monument to that time, and the values that were held, even if they are no longer succesful in today’s society.
1970 1950 82
83
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
RESIDENT EXPERIENCE
Despite the heroic modernist ideals that Cruddas Park was founded on, the resident satisfaction is very low. The small flats barely meet the British Building Regulations, and resident’s don’t benefit from much direct sunlight. As well as this, there is a reputation of petty crime and a general lack of safety in the area. Cruddas Park had a particular problem with petty fire crime, to the extent that on the second anniversary of the Grenfell disaster, they projected a message on the side of the building about the lack of safe fire doors. 84
85
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
Cruddas Park:
04
i
The Locality of Services Within a 10 Minute Walking Radius 1. McColl’s Convenience Store 2. Cruddas Park Post Office 3. Oasis cafe 4. Boots pharmacy 5. William Hill 6. Gezena Cafe 7. Convenience Store 8. St Michael’s Church 9. St Michael’s Primary School 10. Seventh Day Adventist Church 11. Cruddas Park Early Years Centre 12. Elswick Park 13. Elswick Pool 14. PC Fix North East 15. Centre West Community Centre 16. Cruddas Park Surgery 17. The Metropolitan Bar 18. Central Hall Gospel Church 19. Hawthorn Primary School 20. Ashfield Nursery School 21. West End Youth Club 22. MA Brothers Supermarket 23. Eagles Community Arena 24. SEAT car dealership 25. Ford car dealership 26. Mechanics car garage 27. Orthotic Medical Services 28. Howdens Kitchens 29. Tool Station 30. Greggs 31. Car Wash 32. Gym Elite 33. Audi car dealership 34. Whitworth Pharmacy 35. Newcastle Central Mosque 36. Pakistan Islamic Centre 37. Eemaan Restaurant 38. Fish & Chip Shop 39. Silver Dragon Chinese Takeaway 40. NCG Educational Institution 41. Redhill Castle Nursery 42. Life Transformation Church 43. Computer Repair Service 44. Newcastle College 45. Wedding Dress Outlet Store
= 10 Minute Walking Radius = Site (Cruddas Park)
Create to Integrate: Age, Class, Culture
SITE DEMOGRAPHIC
(GROUP WORK) The vast majority of residents are older men, who live alone. As set out in our manifesto, inclusivity of all was important to us, so this very specific demographic was a concern for many of us. Also, almost 75% of residents have no qualifications. This immediately was an important issue that I wanted to address with my design work. 86
87
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
POTENTIAL VISITORS One of the biggest problems I identified with the site was the lack of life and vitality, the lack of people around the site. I investigated how many people there were living on the site and nearby, as well as how many people could hypothetically visit nearby attractions - such as the basketball court on the south of the site. The site has two schools, a nursery, and a college campus which also provide many people to bring life - provided they had a reason to stop and stay. 88
89
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
INITIAL SITE RESPONSE
90
91
ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PEOPLE BEFORE PROFIT PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE ORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE PROFIT BEFORE PEOPLE i
c
01
02
03
04
92
i
c
01
02
03
04
PEOPLE BEFORE PROFIT FLEXIBILITY LEADS TO SUSTAINABILITY
VALUES GOING FORWARD At this point, I identified what values I wanted to focus on with my design. I feel that this can be mainly summarised in ‘people before profit’. What I mean by this is putting resident experience, happiness, and personal growth over maximising profit. Every design decision is focused on providing a joyful and enriching resident experience, whether that be manifested in providing flexibility to people or designing ample green space to benefit both the community and the environment. The overall goal is to create a place to live that residents can be proud of.
ECOLOGY FOR PEOPLE AND FOR PLANET
HOUSING TO BE PROUD OF 93
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
FIRST SITE RESPONSES
My first response to the site happened at two scales: the masterplan scale, and the individual house scale. At a masterplan scale, I wanted to create a ‘community hub’ on the site, perhaps on the road splitting the two potential housing sites, or within Cruddas Park building itself. At an indivudal housing scale, my priorities were maximising southern light, and all my intial sketches show rows of south facing housing. As the site is sloped, I worked a lot on section to investigate how I could have stepped housing, or a stepped landscaping strategy.
Potential housing sites
94
95
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
CIRCULATION
STRUCTURE
I decided the first thing I wanted to resolve on site was the experience of the current residents of Cruddas Park tower, before bringing new people in. After studying the demographics, it was very important to me that these people were given the housing that they deserved and something they could be proud of. 96
THE TOWER:
Currently with 8 flats on each floor, the residents will be moved out on a floorby-floor basis into the new housing. The tower will then be converted to emergency temporary accommodation with 12 flats per floor. 97
01
02
03
04
PROPOSAL: 12
EXISTING: 8
PROGRAMME
c
£££ £££ IDEALISM VS. PRAGMATISM i
c
01
02
03
04
i
98
99
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
Y: r TL floo EN each RR on CU ats 8 fl
Spare houses for flexibility Community space Flats to houses Flats to houses CURRENTLY: 8 flats on each floor Each flat (8) is moved into two housing blocks (12). The leftover houses (4) allow flexibility for other people to move in to the scheme at this time
PHASING
PHASE 1: Rehome the residents of Crudaas Park Tower
an
th wi : or chen AL h flo kit OS eac nity OP ts on mu ce PR fla com spa 12 red ving sha d li
Community space Flats to houses Flats to houses PROPOSAL: 12 flats on each floor with shared community kitchen and living space Each flat (12) is moved into two housing blocks (12). Alternatively, each half flat (6) can be moved into one housing block (6) at a time.
PHASE 2: Use the now empty Cruddas Park Tower as emergency temporary accomodation for the homesless. Gradually, these people will then be moved out into new housing across the site. 100
101
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
CREATING A HOUSING PRODUCTION FACTORY
One of the key site demographics that I wanted to address was the lack of qualifications. Based on the Giro-scope project, where homeless people help to build their new homes, I decided to create a housing factory on the site where residents can train and work, as well as receiving a beautiful new home. The factory will be in the current Cruddas Park car-park. By creating a production hub, life, noise and excitement is immediately brought to the area. This helps to address the distinct lack of life on site.
102
103
c
01
02
03
04
Realisation & Synthesis i
c
01
02
03
04
i
REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION REALISATION
104
SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS SYNTHESIS
c
01
02
03
04
REALISATION SYNTHESIS REALISATION SYNTHESIS REALISATION SYNTHESIS REALISATION SYNTHESIS REALISATION SYNTHESIS REALISATION SYNTHESIS REALISATION SYNTHESIS
105
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
For the realisation and synthesis portion of this project, my aims were to finalise the systematic workings of my project, as well as fully develop the community centre and the housing. Taking the theoretical context, the positive and negative exemplar projects, and all of my research forward, these two stages of the project are where all my ideas manifested into physical designs. Whereas previous I had a set of values and beliefs, these are now supported and intertwined with intentional design moves. In a sense, this is where I really began to ‘design’ my project and really be able to interrogate at a detail level the atmosphere I wanted to create. Ultimately, up until now most of my work had been answering the question: what do I want to create? Whereas now, the question is: how do I create this?
106
107
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
TTMW
108
109
03
04
i
c
01
02
04 03
04
i
OLD VS NEW: INTERACTING WITH THE EXISTING BUILDINGS
My first sketches (left) explore the idea of interacting solids and frames. There are multiple different ways in which these two different forms can meet, miss, or merge with one another. Given that the TTMW output was a 50cmx50cm cube, I had the opportunity to explore multiple differenet combinations of these from different viewpoints. My first maquettes tested these ideas with different finished on the plaster (representing the concrete) and different frame placements. 110
111
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
04 03
04
i
c
01
02
03 04
04
CONCRETE VS TIMBER CONCRETE VS TIMBER CONCRETE VS TIMBER CONCRETE VS TIMBER CONCRETE VS TIMBER CONCRETE VS TIMBER CONCRETE VS TIMBER SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS FRAME SOLID VS TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING TWO FRAMES INTERACTING 112
113
i
c
01
02
72 TO 75% OF THE BUILDINGS THAT WILL EXIST IN 2050 HAVE ALREADY BEEN BUILT 03 04
04
114
i
115
c
01
02
03 04
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
ZONE 1: COMMUNITY CENTRE
116
117
i
c
01
02
04 03
04
i
THE PODIUM
1.0 BASEMENT
On the North side of the community centre there will be community services such as therapy, careers, and child services. These require a level of privacy to maintain dignity and anonymity for individuals. On the North side of the community centre there will be community services such as therapy, careers, and child services. These require a level of privacy to maintain dignity and anonymity for individuals. On the North side of the community centre there will be community services such as therapy, careers, and child services. These require a level of privacy to maintain unity services.
1.1 FIRST FLOOR 118
119
c
01
02
03 04
04
i
c
01
02
04 03
04
i
BRINGING LIGHT DOWN Given that the existing car park will be used as a production factory, there needs to be sufficient light for that space. To create that, I want to essentially create a huge skylight out of much of the existing first floor. Not only does this mean the production factory get ample light, it gives the building a new form and an exciting new character where each part of the building can be distinctly different. 120
121
c
01
02
03 04
04
i
c
01
02
04 03
04
i
HAWKINS BROWN FREEMEN’S SCHOOL SWIMMING POOL I was interested in this precedent because of the structural glulam columns and beams which span the building. The wide beams create a staggered language that would be very effective used in Cruddas Park community centre along the long sides of the building. 122
123
c
01
02
03 04
04
i
c
01
02
04 03
04
i
STRUCTURAL AND ATMOSPHERIC WORKINGS
Based on these precedents I worked through concepts for the design of the building using a similar glulam frame as used in Freemen’s School Swimming Pool. 124
125
c
01
02
03 04
04
i
c
01
02
03 04
04
i
On the North side of the community centre there will be community services such as therapy, careers, and child services. These require a level of privacy to maintain dignity and anonymity for individuals.
On the South side of the community centre will be the library and a new cafe. These functions are much more public and the facade will be more open to reflect this, as well as to maximise passive solar gain.
126
127
c
01
02
03 04
04
i
c
01
02
03
04 03
i
c
01
02
03 04 03 04
GETHSEMANE CHAPEL EXTENSION GETHSEMANE CHAPEL EXTENSION GETHSEMANE CHAPEL EXTENSION GETHSEMANE CHAPEL EXTENSION Gethsemane Chapel Extension was completed in 2012 by Olson Kundig Architects.
128
129
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
COMMUNITY CENTRE
Focusing on the south side of the community centre, I wanted to use coloured glass (as in Gethsemane Chapel) to bring life and joy back into the building. Given the amount of direct sunlight at this orientation, the colours would be bright and striking, hopefully attracting visitors to the centre where there would be a library and a cafe. I chose to develop this further in my ARC3013 Integrated Technology assignment. 130
1:20 Plan from ARC3013 Technology Assignment 131
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
COMMUNITY CENTRE
Looking in more detail at my 1:20 section, I wanted to conserve as much of the existing concrete as possible to minimise unnecessary waste. However, the unfriendly, closed off facades would be stripped off and replaced with the coloured glass. This glass would sit on a glulam frame supported by wide columns as seen in the Freemen’s School Swimming Pool precedent. There is a deliberate gap between the concrete and the glulam to accentuate the two separate periods, and two separate materials. It also means that the coloured glass wall can be seen from the inside as a full height wall.
1:20 Section from ARC3013 Technology Assignment
To limit over-exposure to south light, there are translucent polycarbonate louvres all along the south side. 132
1:20 Elevation from ARC3013 Technology Assignment 133
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
ZONE 2: HOUSING
134
135
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
CREATING COMMUNITY AND HARNESSING LIGHT
1.
My initial massing of the housing was very much centered around passive solar gain and reducing heat loss. I made the south face taller, and the north face shorter, to aid this. Also, I decided to work with terraced housing to maximise space efficiency and to reduce heat loss out the sides of the houses. When looking at the form of the house I tested multiple different slopes and combinations.
The proximity of the housing was always at battle with maximising direct exposure to southern light. However, by partly closing off the sides of housing blocks, I created a form which encourages a tight community while still leaving enouh space between houses or them to get enough direct sunlight. 136
2.
137
3.
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
COMMUNITY AT DIFFERENT SCALES
138
139
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
TESTING COMMUNITY AT LARGER SCALES
After creating the basic housing blocks, I wanted to test how these would work on a much larger scale. As part of my phasing work, my proposal would eventially cover much more of the site so it was important to understand the effects of repeating the housing form. I decided that for the housing to work in this way there would need to be certain landmarks to prevent the site from becoming a lot of paths that led to nowhere. Luckily, the site already has multiple landmarks in the form of the tower blocks. Ultimately, I decided to limit the amount of housing blocks repeated in this way to avoid the site becoming homogenous and repetitive. 140
141
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
TESTING INDIVIDUAL HOUSING LAYOUTS While developing the individual housing layouts, it was important to test them together on the masterplan scale. I created inset doorways to allow residents to have shelter when looking for their keys or getting into their home. The stairs in the centre of the plan split the house neatly into two distinct sections which can be used for different functions. 142
143
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
RESOLVING HOUSING IN MASTERPLAN: BRIDGING THE GAP
Through resolving my design in two parts (the community centre, and the housing) there was a design ‘blind spot’ in the gap between these two parts. In order to resolve this and make my design more applicable to its context, I opened up the first housing block to connect it with the outdoor space. I also made this block taller to allow balconies looking out to the North, preventing it from seeming so much like the back of someone’s house as you walk down the site. In making this block taller, it also allows the north side of the ground floor of all these dwellings to act as small shops or businesses. This too helps to open up the north street. 144
145
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
GRID LAYOUTS: CREATING ADAPTABILITY At this point, I needed to go through another iteration of housing design to fully resolve my ideas. I decided to open the front doorways completely so that they were shared between neighbours. I also extended the width of the house from 5m to 6m to allow more space and flexibility. I wanted to create a grid that could be filled in multiple different ways, allowing the houses to adapt to each families unique needs. The final key move I made was to add a porch at the north of each house in the centre. This mean the back rooms could be double aspect, and also opens up the north streets to make them friendlier.
146
147
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
RESOLVED HOUSING LAYOUT
Using a grid layout, my housing design works in multiple ways. The south side remains the same each time and holds the kitchen and the bathroom. The north side can be one large room, either a bedroom or a workspace; two rooms, a bedroom and a workspace or two bedrooms; three rooms, two bedrooms and one small workspace.
148
149
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
YOSHICHIKA TAKAGI -
HOUSE IN SHINKAWA
This precedent in Japan was very influential to my ideas of my internal housing finishing. The use of the grid columns and the way in which the grid has been re-emphasised into the floor, are ideas reflected in my own internal housing finishing. I was also inspried by the pale, warm colours and neutral, minimalist finishes.
150
FUJIWARANURO
- HOUSE IN TEZUKAYAMA
Despite being only 3.74 metres wide, this house works as a succesful multipurpose space for the modern family. The staircase, set in the centre of the thin plan, is at an angle of 45o and acts as vertical circulation, storage, and work and play space for the children. 151
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
1: Prepare the ground and mark out the foundations
5.
2: Dig the foundations 3: Fill the foundations
THE BUILD The construction element of my proposal is very important as it will shape the area for some time in the initial phases of the design. Keeping a balance between the friendly, completed housing blocks and the juxtaposing construction sites will give the area a very unique character.
7.
4: Put up the structural walls 5: Landscaping, paths and tree planting in communal garden begins.
1.
6. 4.
3. 152
6: Put up the non-structural walls and other interior elements (mezzanine, stairs, bathrooms)
2.
7: Building finishes, cladding and windows 153
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
CREATING HOMES
It was important to me that the variety of different activities that might take place in each home were considered. The finishing of the interiors is deliberately neutral to allow residents to put their own identity on their homes. These ideas are key to creating a proud ownership of Cruddas Park area.
154
155
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
ELEVATION PRECEDENTS TOP: Marmalade Lane Inset doorways to have shelter when finding keys and coming in and out of the house. Residents could also choose their door colour, giving ownership, identity, and individuality to the each house. RIGHT: Cowan Court Weathered oak cladding, contrast between light and dark woods to add emphasis to windows and doorways. 156
157
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
RESOLVED ELEVATIONS These two south facing elevations show both the three story housing block as well as the more standard two story housing block. Neighbours share a deep-inset doorway, as well as a balcony. It was important for each house to have a balcony because the houses don’t have private gardens. Resident’s can choose their own door colour to continue adding their own personality and identity to their home. To limit solar glare, there are red vertical louvres on each house. This also links the housing back to the new community centre with a harmonious architectural language. 158
159
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
160
161
c
01
02
03
04
i
01 c
01 02
02 03
03 04
04
i
162
163
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
164
165
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
BIBLIOGRAPHY 6A Architects, ‘Cowan Court: Cambridge’, 6A Architects, 2016 <http://www.6a.co.uk/projects/ more/cowan-court> [accessed 3/4/2020] Alberto Garcia Marin, Jorge Barrios Corpa, Javier Terrados Cepeda, Juan de la Casa Higueras and Jorge Aguilera Tejero, ‘Selfsufficient Pre-fabricated Modular Housing: Passive Systems Integrated’, Renewable Energy in the Service of Mankind, 1 (2015) Alice Min Soo Chun and Irene E Brisson, Ground Rules for Humanitarian Design (Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 2015)
Ceylan Yeginsu, ‘Coronavirus Nearly Ended Street Homelessness in UK Maybe Not for Long’, New York Times, 6 June 2020, <https://www.nytimes. com/2020/06/06/world/europe/ homelessness-uk-coronavirus. html> [accesed 07/06/2020]
Duncan Bowie, Radical Solutions to the Housing Supply Crisis (Bristol: Policy Press, 2017) Ellen Dunham-Jones and June Williamson, Retrofitting Suburbia (New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc, 2011)
Frances Holliss, ‘Space, Buildings and the Life Worlds of HomeBased Workers: Towards Better Design’, Sociological Research Online, 17 (2012) Harlina Mohamad Ali, Mazuiyah Cornelia Dorries and Sarah Zahradnik, Construction and Design Mohd Dom, Muhamad Shamin Sahrum, ‘Self-Sufficient Manual: Container and Modular Buildings (Berlin: DOM publishers, Community through the Concepts of Collective Living and Universal 2016) Housing’, Social and Behavioural Daniel Bentley, The Land Question: Sciences, 68 (2012) Fixing the dysfunction at the root of the housing crisis (London: Civitas, 2017) Chiara Briganti and Kathy Mezei, The Domestic Space Reader (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2012)
166
Hilary Osborne and Sophie Norris, ‘Pop-up village in southeast London to house homeless families’, The Guardian, 18 March 2016.
Kristen Gram-Hanssen and Claus Bech-Danielsen, ‘House, Home and Identity from a Consumption Perspective’, Housing, Theory and Society, 21 (2004), pp.17-26.
Ivor Davies, Sustainable Construction Timber: Sourcing and specifying local timber (Edinburgh: Forestry Commision, 2016)
Leslie Kanes Weisman, ‘Women’s Environmental Rights: A Manifesto’ in Making Room: Women and Architecture ed. by Barbara Marks and others (Vermont: Capital City Press, 1981), pp 6-8.
John A. Dolan, ‘I’ve Always Fancied Owning Me Own Lion: Ideological Motivations in External House Decoration by Recent Homeowners’ in At Home: An Anthropology of Domestic Space ed. by Irene Cieraad (New York: Syracuse University Press, 1999), pp. 60-72.
Miranda A. Grieder & Amy Chanmugam, ‘Applying Environmental Psychology in the Design of Domestic Violence Shelters’, Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment & Trauma, (2013)
Mohd Shukari Midon, Chu Yue Pun, Hilmi Md Tahir, Nor Azian Mohd Kasby, Construction Manual Prefabricated Timber House (Malaysia: Forest Research Institute Malaysia, 1996) Mourao, M. C. Moreira, T. C. Almeida & L. M. Brito, ‘Perceived changes in well-being and happiness with gardening in urban organic allotments in Portugal’, International Journal of Sustainable Development & World Ecology, 26 (2018) Neave Brown, ‘The Form of Housing’, Architectural Design, 37 (1967), 432-433. Nick Gallent, Whose Housing Crisis: Assets and Homes in a Changing Economy (Bristol: Policy Press, 2019)
Kathy Mezei, The Domestic Space Reader (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2012) 167
i
c
01
02
03
04
Norton, B. A., G. D. Bending, R. Clark, R. Corstanje, N. Dunnett, K. L. Evans, D. R. Grafius, E. Gravestock, S. M. Grice, J. A. Harris, S. Hilton, H. Hoyle, E. Lim, T. G. Mercer, M. Pawlett, O. L. Pescott, J. P. Richards, G. E. Southon, and P. H. Warren, ‘Urban Meadows as an alternative to short mown grassland: effects of composition and height on biodiversity’, Ecological Applications, 29 (2019)
i
Peter Malpass, The Housing Crisis (Kent: Croom Helm Ltd, 1986) Pier Vittorio Aureli and Martino Tattara, ‘Production/ Reproduction: Housing beyond the Family’, Harvard Design Magazine, 41 (2019)
Unknown Author, ‘Coronavirus: All Rough Sleepers in England ‘to be housed’, BBC NEWS, 27 March 2020, <https:// www.bbc.co.uk/news/ukpolitics-52063939> [accessed 01/06/2020]
Thomas A. Dutton and Liam Hurst Mann, Reconstructing Architecture (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 1996)
Wendy Steiner, ‘The Joy of Less’, Harvard Design Magazine, 30 (2019).
Tim Brindley, ‘The Modern House in England: an Architecture of Patricia Arcilla, ‘RSHP Reveals Exclusion’ in Ideal Homes? Social Plans for the ‘Ladywell Pop-Up Change and the Experience of the Village’ in Lewisham’, ArchDaily, Home ed. by Tony Chapman 2015 <https://www.archdaily. com/590285/rshp-reveals-plans- and Jenny Hockey (London: for-the-ladywell-pop-up-village-in- Routledge, 1999), pp. 30-43. lewisham> [accessed 5/12/2019]
168
169
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
ILLUSTRATED CULTURAL BIBLIOGRAPHY Multiple visits to the BALTIC art galleries
Red Vienna Gallery in Karl Marx Hof
Judy Chicago ‘Autobiography of a year’ 1993-94
MUSA Gallery, Vienna
170
171
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
APPENDIX
172
173
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
174
175
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
176
177
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
178
179
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
180
181
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
i
182
183
c
01
02
03
04
i
c
01
02
03
04
184