❖❖ DRILLBITS Thehumbletwistdrillcelebrates160years Cambridge Soldering Whysilversolderedjointsfail MEClock Amodernskeletonclock THEORIGINALMAGAZINEFORMODELENGINEERS Vol.231No.472622September–5October2023 Joinouronlinecommunity www.model-engineer.co.uk WevisittheclubbytheCam
PublishedbyMortonsMediaGroupLtd, MediaCentre,MortonWay,Horncastle,LincsLN96JR Tel:01507529589Fax:01507371066
©2023MortonsMediaISSN0026-7325
www.model-engineer.co.uk
EDITORIAL
Editor: MartinR.Evans
Deputyeditor: DianeCarney
Designer: DruckMediaPvt.Ltd.
ClubNews: GeoffTheasby
Illustrator: GrahameChambers
Publisher: SteveO’Hara
CUSTOMERSERVICES
GeneralQueriesandBackIssues
01507529529Monday-Friday:8.30am-5pm Answerphone24hr help@classicmagazines.co.uk www.classicmagazines.co.uk
ADVERTISING
Groupadvertisingmanager: SueKeily
Advertising: CraigAmess camess@mortons.co.ukTel:01507529537
Bypost: ModelEngineeradvertising,MortonsMedia Group,MediaCentre,MortonWay, Horncastle,LincsLN96JR
PUBLISHING
Salesanddistributionmanager: CarlSmith
Marketingmanager: CharlottePark
Commercialdirector: NigelHole
Publishingdirector: DanSavage
SUBSCRIPTION
Fullsubscriptionrates(butseepage426foroffer): (12months,26issues,incpostandpacking)–UK£128.70.Exportratesarealsoavailable, UKsubscriptionsarezero-ratedforthepurposes ofValueAddedTax.
Enquiries:subscriptions@mortons.co.uk
PRINTANDDISTRIBUTIONS
Printedby: WilliamGibbons&Son,26Planetary Road,Willenhall,WestMidlands,WV133XB
Distributionby: SeymourDistributionLimited, 2EastPoultryAvenue,LondonEC1A9PT
EDITORIALCONTRIBUTION
Acceptedphotographsandarticleswillbepaidfor uponpublication.Itemswecannotusewillbereturned ifaccompaniedbyastampedaddressedenvelope andrecordeddeliverymustclearlystatesoand enclosesufficientpostage.Incommonwithpractice onotherperiodicals,allmaterialissentorreturnedat thecontributor’sownriskandneitherModelEngineer, theeditor,thestaffnorMortonsMediaLtdcanbe heldresponsibleforlossordamage,howsoever caused.TheopinionsexpressedinModelEngineer arenotnecessarilythoseoftheeditororstaff.This periodicalmustnot,withoutthewrittenconsentofthe publishersfirstbeinggiven,belent,sold,hiredoutor otherwisedisposedofinamutilatedconditionorin otherunauthorisedcoverbywayoftradeorannexed tooraspartofanypublicationoradvertising,literary orpictorialmannerwhatsoever.
428SMOKERINGS
News,viewsandcommentontheworldof modelengineering.
429RADIALVALVEGEARSAGAIN
DuncanWebsterexploresthesubtletiesof valvegearoperation.
432ADIRTYTRAM–ABITOF NOSTALGIA
AshleyBestcreatesaBoltontrammodelas itreallywas–dirtyandunkempt.
437WEVISITTHECAMBRIDGE ANDDISTRICTMODEL ENGINEERINGSOCIETY
MartinEvansdropsintocatchupwiththe latestdevelopmentsandtohelpcelebrate thelifeofalongstandingclubmember.
441RECYCLINGA3½ INCH GAUGESOUTHERNSCHOOLS LOCOMOTIVE
RobertHobbsturnsaboxofbitsintothe Southern’s‘V’Classlocomotive Winchester
445POSTBAG
Readers’letters.
446JOINTFAILUREINSILVER SOLDEREDSTAINLESS STEEL
GrahamAstburyfindsoutwhysilver solderedjointsinstainlesssteelareproneto fallingapart.
450AMODELENGINEER’SCLOCK
JimClarkusesmodernmethodstomakea skeletonclockinspiredbyJohnWilding.
454THETWISTDRILLBIT
NeilRainelooksintothesubtletiesofa commontool’sdesign.
458THELATHEELECTRONIC LEADSCREW
PeterRussellmakesscrewcuttingeasywitha computerdrivenleadscrew.
460AFIVE-INCHGAUGE0-4-0 PADARNRAILWAYTENDER LOCOMOTIVE
Luker presents FireQueen,aWelshslatequarry locomotive.
466IMLEC2023
RobSpeareobservesthefinalday’srunningat AshtonCourtinBristol.
472CLUBNEWS
GeoffTheasbycompilesthelatestfrommodel engineeringclubsaroundtheworld.
475CLUBDIARY FutureEvents.
http://www.facebook.com/modelengineersworkshop
http://twitter.com/
Vol.231No.472622September–5October2023
www.model-engineer.co.uk
modelengineers ONTHE COVER... JeffBoltondrivesTedGoode’s7¼ inch gaugeIsleofWightO2locomotiveatthe CambridgeMEStrack(photo:JocelynFung). ThisissuewaspublishedonSeptember22,2023. ThenextwillbeonsaleonOctober6,2023. DRILLBITS Thehumbletwistdrillcelebrates160years Cambridge Soldering Whysilversolderedjointsfail MEClock Amodernskeletonclock THEORIGINALMAGAZINEFORMODELENGINEERS Vol.231No.472622September–5October2023 Joinouronlinecommunity www.model-engineer.co.uk WevisittheclubbytheCam &SAVESUBSCRIBE UP TO 49% Seepage426 fordetails. 423 www.model-engineer.co.uk 460 450 466
Enjoy12monthsforjust£65 SUBSCRIBE ANDSAVE >> FreeUKdeliverytoyourdoororinstantdownloadtoyourdigitaldevice >> Savemoneyonshopprices >> Nevermissanissue >> Receiveyourissuebeforeitgoesonsaleintheshop Greatreasonstosubscribe PRINT+DIGITALDIGITALONLY PRINTONLY Quarterlydirectdebit for £18 1yeardirectdebit for £65 1yearcredit/debitcard for £70 Quarterlydirectdebit for £21* 1yeardirectdebit for £82.99* 1yeardirectdebit for £84.99* 1yeardirectdebit for £49* 1yearcredit/debitcard for £52.95* *Anydigitalsubscriptionpackageincludesaccessto theonlinearchive.
classicmagazines.co.uk/ M E D P S 01507 529529 and quote MEDPS Lines are open from 8.30am-5pm weekdays GMT O ffe r e nds D e ce mb e r 31, 2023 Subscriptions will s t ar t w ith the ne x t availab le issue D ire c t D e bit p ay me nt s w ill continue on the agre e d p lan unless you te ll us othe r w ise To v iew the privac y p o lic y for MMG Ltd (pub lishe r of M o de l Engine e r), p lease v isit w w w. mor tons .co.uk /privac y Pl e ase v i s i t w w w.c l ass ic m ag a z i ne s .co.u k / te rm s for fu l l te rm s & con d i t ions . ( 8
SydneyLiveSteamers
Ireceivealotofnewsletters fromvariousclubsandthese invariablycontainsomething ofinterest.Thelatestfrom theSydneyLiveSteam LocomotiveSocietyin Australiainformsme thattheyarecelebrating their75thanniversary thisyear.So–happy birthdaytoaverylively andproductiveclub!
AtmosphericEngines
Theseweretheforerunnersof thelaterhigh-pressuresteam enginesandreliedonthe pressureoftheatmosphere ratherthansteampressure tosupplypower.Ifyouhave beenfollowingRonFitzgerald’s seriesontheSteamEngine overthelastseveralmonths youwillbewell‘uptospeed’ withthem!
DavidHulsehasspentthe last52yearsbuildingaseries ofmodelsofatmospheric engineschroniclingtheir developmentthroughthe 18thcenturyuntiltheywere supersededbythehighpressureengine,pioneered byTrevithick,Wattand theirassociates.Thefirst commercialatmospheric enginewasconstructed byThomasNewcomen inSouthStaffordshirein 1712,beginningthe‘steam age’andpoweringthe industrialrevolution.David isexhibitinghiscollectionof eightenginesatDartmouth –ThomasNewcomen’s birthplace–startingthis month.Theenginesaretobe displayedpermanentlyatthe
Dartmouthmuseum(www. dartmouthmuseum.org).
Moreinformationaboutthe enginescanbefoundatwww. davidhulse.co.uk
TedGoode-Cambridge
Irecentlyattendedthe celebrationattheCambridge ModelEngineeringSocietyof long-standingmemberTed Goode’slifeandworkandyou canreadallaboutitstarting onpage437.Asmentioned inthearticle,KathyGoode wouldliketopassonafewof Ted’senginestogoodhomes andhasnowprovidedme withfurtherdetails.Three locomotivesarecurrently available:a5inchgauge ‘Pansy’locomotivewithdriving trolleyandtwo7¼ inchgauge locomotives–anAdamsradial tankanda‘Dart’locomotive (GWR1400).Theformerof thesetwohasanoutofdate boilercertificateandthe latterisalmostmechanically completeandreadytopaint. Anyenquiriesshouldbemade throughmeinthefirstinstance.
GardenRailShow
MeridienneExhibitionsare pleasedtoconfirmthatthe MidlandsGardenRailShowwill betakingplaceonSaturday 2ndandSunday3rdMarch 2024attheWarwickshireEvent Centre.
Thiseventattractsnearly 2,000enthusiastsfromallover theUKandoffersvisitorsthe opportunitytoseelayoutsin thelargergaugesandscales includingGauge1,OGauge,G Scaleandmore.
Oncevisitorshavebeen inspiredtobuildtheirown layout,theycanvisitnearly fortyspecialistsuppliersat theshowwhoaremorethan happytoguidethemintheright directionofthebestproductto purchase.
Savethedatenowtoavoid disappointmentandforfurther detailsontheexhibitionand suppliersattendingseewww. midlandsgardenrailshow.co.uk
TwoShowMonth
Wheredidthesummergo?We arenowheadinginexorablyinto autumnbutoneconsolation
isthattherearetwoshows tolookforwardto,bothin October.
Thereis,asyouknow,the MidlandsModelEngineering Exhibition,attheWarwickshire ExhibitionCentrefromthe 12thto15thOctober,which isalreadyinscribedindelibly inyourdiaries.Ifyoulivein TheEast,though,thereis alsoLOWMEX,theLowestoft ModelEngineeringExhibition, tobeheldagainthisyearat theEnergySkillsCentreof theEastCoastCollegein Lowestoft.Thisis–toborrow popularadvertisinglanguage -‘probably’thebiggestmodel exhibitioninEastAnglia.It takesplaceonthe28thand 29thOctober,startingat10am, andentryis£5foradultsand £2forchildren.Detailsofhow togettheremaybefoundat www.lowmex.co.uk
IMLEC2024
Thereiscurrentlya requirementforaclubtohost IMLECnextyear.We’vehada numberofeventsinthesouth latelysoideallyIwouldlikea clubinthenorthtovolunteer, althoughthatissimplya preference,notarequirement. Araisedtrackispreferred,of areasonablelength(say1/3rd ofamileorso),supporting3½ and5inchgaugelocomotives. Adynamometercarisneeded, ofcourse,buttherearemany oftheseavailablearoundthe countrysothepossession ofoneisnotnecessarilya prerequisite.
It’snousepretendingthat hostingIMLECdoesnotinvolve alotofeffortandcommitment fromaclubbutontheother handtheconsensusisthatitis averyrewardingexperience. Responsespleasetoyour ever-hopefuleditor.
MartinEvanscanbecontacted onthemobilenumberor emailbelowandwouldbe delightedtoreceiveyour contributions,intheform ofitemsofcorrespondence, commentorarticles. 07710-192953 MEeditor@mortons.co.uk
ModelEngineer 22September2023
DIANE CARNEY Assistant Editor
MARTIN EVANS Editor
428
NewcomenenginemodelledbyDavid
Hulse(photo:DavidHulse).
Dartmouthmuseum
DavidHulsecollection
LOWMEX
GardenRailShow
RadialValve GearsAgain
PART9 – SISSON’S VALVEGEAR
Backatthebeginningof part6( g29,M.E.4723, August11),thepossible useofWatt’s#1straightline linkageasavalvegearwas mentioned. Voilà,Sisson’svalve gear,see g48.
Continuedfromp.373 M.E.4725September8
TheonlyreferencesI’vefound tothisgeararegivenatthe endofthisarticle.Fromthese twosourcesI ndthatSisson’s gearwasinventedin1885and thatSissonwas ‘averyclever engineerandprolificinventor, [and]wasprimarilyconcerned withsmallandmediumsized marineengines’.Hewasnot perhapsoverkeenonhisown valvegearasI’vefoundlotsof picturesofSisson’sengines withHackworthand Stephenson’sgear,butnotone withSisson’sgear.
Itwillbenotedthatthe verticalmovementofthe bottomendofthevibrating lever g ismuchlargerthan thatofthedrivepinonthe connectingrod d.Forthis reason,point d ismuchcloser tothecrossheadthanwasthe caseinJoygear.Theforce requiredat d todrivethegear willsimilarlybelargerand anywearatthispointwill bemagni ed.Careshould thereforebeexercisedin thisgeartoensureadequate bearingareas.Asdrawn,the gearsuffersfromthesame problemasBrown’sinthatthe valverodslopesdownhill,in thiscasequitesteeplybecause thevalverodisshorter. Thiscouldbeameliorated byarbitrarilymovingpoint
f upwards,andmoving j downwards-moreonthislater. ItmightbethoughtthatI ambeingpedanticoverthe valverodslopingdownhillbut itmustberememberedthat thiscausestheslidetobetilted atmidgear,byasmuchas5 degreesforSisson’sgear.This meansthatinfullgeartheslide istiltedat25degreesinstead of20,leadingtoincreased loadingandwear.Onanengine withrelativelyshortstroke,all thiswouldnotapply.
Designmethodology
Layoutofthisgearisdead easy-notmanyformulaeand thoseinvolvedaresimpleby thestandardsofwhathasgone before.AtthemomentIsee noadvantageinnothaving
Sisson’svalvegear.
429 www.model-engineer.co.uk >>
Duncan Webster shedslight onwhatisoftenseenas acomplexsubject.
Fig48
df=dg.Firstthingtodoisto calculatethepositionof d.Use theequationfor cd frompart7 (M.E.4724,August25)butthen, becausetheverticalmovement of g isdoublethatof d,halvethe lengthyou’vejustcalculated. Thenderivethelengthsofthe vibratinglever gh and mh using thegraphicalroutinefrom previousepisodes-Iwon’t describeitagain.Toreduce anyangularityerrorscaused byinclinationof fdg.Isuggest thatweposition j and e such thatpoints f and g moveequally
aboveandbelowhorizontalas thecrankpinmovesalongits mythicalhorizontalpath,as showninexaggeratedformin g49.Itcouldbequitedif cult toarrangethismechanically, asthepinsat f and g cannot gostraightthrough.Imust admitthatIhaveneverseena realexampleofthisgear,even photographsareelusive.More onthislater.
Becauseoftheinherent symmetryofthisgear,the lengthoftheanchorlink fe is thesameasthatof gh,andthe
verticalpositionof e isamirror of j.Link fg wantstobeaslong aspossiblebutpoint f isclose tothelittleend c (in g48), so df willhavetobelessthan cd. Chooseanominalvalueforthe timebeing.
Nextweneedto xthe horizontalpositionsof j and e (in g48).Point j ispositioned totheleftof a by j.x =- bc+cd+dg and e.x=-bc+cd–dg (notethatxorycomponents aredenotedby.xor.yafterthe point.)
Bothvaluesarenegative becausetheyaretotheleft oftheorigin(crankcentre). Thismakeslifeeasierinthe computermodel.Nowtoderive theheightof j and e. Onyour drawingofthevibratinglever markpoints h and g1,g2,g3 Drawahorizontallinetobe verticallyhalfwaybetween g2 and g1,g3.Thencopythe wholethingtotheleftby fg and mirrorthenewbitaboutthis horizontalline.Referenceto g50 willpossiblymake thisclearer.
430 ModelEngineer 22September2023
Fig49
StraightlinelinkageinSisson’sgear.
GeometryoftheSisson’sgear.
Fig50
Mid-gearperformance.
Modifiedperformance.
Theactuallengthsof fg and df andtheheights j.y and e.y arethenreadoffthedrawing. ImustadmitthatIhaven’t goneintotheintricaciesof calculatingthe‘best’slide radiusbutresultswithradius equalto pm arereasonable.
Itdoesn’ttakelongtojust changetheslideradiusin themodelandtryituntilbest resultsareachieved
Workedexample
Fromtheequationinpart7, rememberingtodivideby2: cd =(2*0.774*40*10.056) /((1.136+10.056)*tan(20)*2 *4.25)* ½ =8.992
Thisisaminimumvalue,so wecanchoosetomakeitsay 10inches.Wecanthenchoose anominallengthfor df and dg, say8inches.
Usethesevaluestocreate g 50andyouwill nd j.y =9.585 andmeasuringbetween f1 and g1 (or f2,g2 or f3,g3)willgive df =8.014and fg =16.028
Results
Resultsareprettygood, see g51 -togetbest midgearperformance IsetslideRad=18.
Modifications
EarlieronIreferredtothe mechanicaldif cultyof arrangingthepinsat f and g Ifwearbitrarilymovepoints e and j closertothehorizontal, itcouldbepossibletoget e alwaysabovetheconnecting rodand g alwaysbelow. Slightadjustmentto df and fg isrequired.I’vetriedthis, movingbothby2inches.I’m notsurethiswouldbeenough butresultsarenotgood,see g52.ForreasonsIdon’tfully understandyet,backgear isn’tsobadandofcourseina launchengineyoucanchoseto havewhatI’vecalledbackgear drivetheboatforwards.
Thenextexcitingepisodewill coverGreenly’sCorrectedGear.
●Tobecontinued.
REFERENCES
Ref16. RadialValveGears,K.N. Harris,ModelEngineer starting7Jan1992
Ref17. 101ValveMotions,Fred Jukes,Railwayand LocomotiveHistorical SocietyBulletin88-91. Hardcopyofthese articlesisavailable fromwww.rlhs.org,$65 pluspostagefromUSA, oryoucanjoinfor$65 peryearandgetthe wholearchiveonline.
431 VALVEGEARS www.model-engineer.co.uk
Fig51
Fig52
whichwere: Ab=4.25 Bc=40 Yvalve=8.5 lap=0.43 lead=0.05 outphase=0.774 TheCADwillgiveus gh = 10.056,mh =1.136
Takeagainthevitalstatistics of RiverIrt
ADirtyTram -aBitofNostalgia
Continuedfromp.399
M.E.4725September8
PART3
SomeNotesonLiveries
Inresearchingforthecontent ofthisarticleleadingtothe buildingofNo.420asarundown,scruffytram,itoccurred tomethatthehistoryof Britishtramcarliverieswasof considerableinterest.Bolton itselfdemonstratedfairly typicaluseanddevelopment oftheapplicationofdecorative liningtopublictransport vehicles(photo35).
Evenfrombeforethe Victorianera,liningwasused extensivelyandprobably reachedthepeakofitsusein the19thCenturyandintothe rsthalfofthe20th.Itwas particularlyappliedtorailway locomotivesandrollingstock aswellastheemergingtram andbus eets(photo36). Widespreadusedeclined slowlyat rstinthenineteen-
432 ModelEngineer 22September2023
Classictramcarlining.
AlinedoutLBSCRlocomotive.
AshleyBest tellsitasit was.
35 36
37
thirtiesandthenrapidlyfrom theoutbreakofwaronwards. Therewasashortrevival from1945,especiallyonthe railwayswherelocomotives onceagainbecomefullylined out.Thislastedtotheendof steamin1968.Somewhat beforethen,itvanishedalmost entirelyfrompublictransport
roadvehicles.Mostsurviving tramwaysdidn’tbotherto restoreliningforthefew remainingyearsleftforthem.
Theapplicationofdecorative liningontramcarswasan importantfeatureand,forthe mostpart,ofconsiderable aestheticbene t.Thiswas largelybecauseitconformed
toastandardnownolonger givenanyconsiderationby contemporarydesigners. Myartschooldesigners’ training–albeitalongtime ago–drummedintomethat decorationofanysort,but particularlylining,should emphasiseandenhancethe structureofthevehicleand
notbeappliedtocon ictwith it.Thismeantmouldings andpanelsshoulduselining toemphasisetheiroutlines. Nowadaysnoneofthisapplies andtheabsenceofliningin myviewisnotintheslightest waycompensatedbygarish colourstripesandblocks withoutconnectiontothebasic structure,appliedsweeping overtheunderlyingshapeeven togoasfarastocoverthe windows,thusruiningtheview frominside.The rststirrings ofthisdeclineappearedinthe thirtiesataboutthesametime asthetramcardesignsalso developedandmetalreplaced wood.Streamlining,although actuallyridiculousand expensive,wasadoptedand paintschemesfollowed.
The rstattemptsto modernisetheexistingtrams wastoremoveliningand adoptmodernsansseriffonts. Somestreamlinedtramswere introducedwithmouldings curvedtofollowtheformofthe streamlinedpro le.Donewith carethiscouldbeattractive (photo37).Traditionaltrams weregivenappropriate paintworksuchascurved liningsandtrianglesondashes inafutileattempttosuggest aspeedpotentialthatdidnot exist.Thesewere,onthewhole, notseriouslydetrimentalto thevisualquality,eventhough, whereliningwasstillapplied, the rstsignsofarelaxed attitudetoitsuseappeared.
Therewasonetruly egregiousexamplethatstood outasalmostasignofthings tocome.LythamSt.Annes Corporationpaintedtheirtram, No.55withalargetriangular shapeonbothdecks.Thishad noaestheticrelationshipwith thecar’sstructure( g5).
Thetraditionalclassic liningwasactuallyofmany styles;thesimplestwouldbe asinglelinewithrightangle corners.Generallythepale rockerpanelsemployeda darkline,oftenusingthemain bodycolour,whilethedarker mainbodypanelswould haveapale,oftengoldline. Thevariationsonthiswere many.Singleordoublelines weresometimesused,often
433 DIRTYTRAM www.model-engineer.co.uk >>
Aberdeentramcar.
EgregiousliveryonLythamSt.Anne’stram.
Fig5
withdecorativecornersand frequentlyofdifferentcolours andwidths(photo38).Justa fewofthedozensofdesigns useddecorativelybyBritish tramwaysystemsareshownin g6.Almostalltramwayskept theapplicationofdecorative liningwithintheboundaries oftradition.Therewereafew systemsthatwenttothelimits, buteventhesekepttothe unwrittenrules(photo39).
Manchesterprovidesan outstandingexamplewith itswonderful,overthetop ‘fairground’liverywhich, althoughinslightlysimpli ed form,itmanagedtomaintain throughoutthewaruntilits nal demisein1949(photo40). Accurateinclusionofsuch designsdoesmuchtoenhance therealismofamodeltramcar andisworththeeffortinvolved inapplyingit.
Methodsoflining
Therearemanywaysto achieveasatisfactoryresult.
Mypreferredmethodisby draughtsman’sbowpenwith theadjustablenibthatcan beloadedwithpaintand thenusedtoproducealine oftheappropriatethickness (photo41).I nditessentialto prepareacoupleofsurfaces ofthesamecoloursasonthe model,eachbroughttothe samerubbeddownstandard asthemodel.Theseareused fortriallininginordertoget thepainttoexactlytheright consistency.Thiscantake sometime.Itisamistaketo thindownthepainttoomuch. Ifgoldistofeature,itiswise touseanacrylicpaintasoilbasedgoldwilloften‘bleed out’ifvarnishisappliedlater.If unwillingtoriskthistraditional method,variousliningtapes andtransfersareavailable andwillgiveexcellentresults. Itisamatterofchoice.When usingthebowpen,simple guidesareessential.Aruleris idealforstraightlinesbuton curvedpanelssuchascanopy
434 ModelEngineer 22September2023
Fig6
38
Rochdale’slining.
Someliningexamples.
Auseofdoublelines.
39 40
Manchester’s‘fairground’livery.
bends,astoutcardstrip xed inplacewithmaskingtapeis suitable(photo42).Mistakes andunwantedspotsand runscanberemovedquickly withasmallbrushortissue soakedinthinnersandthena secondattemptcanbemade. Decorativecornersanddetails arebestattemptedwithavery ne,goodqualitybrushdown toabout5zerosize.Icannot pretendthatdoingliningby handinthiswayiseasy,but donewithcaretheresultcanbe rewarding,especiallyforanyone keenonusinghandskills.
Ontheworldstage,British Tramways,althoughnotalone inthewaythattheyrose andfell,didsoinauniquely precipitousmanner.From apeakin1927therewasa rapidlyincreasingdeclineand onlytheinterventionofthe
SecondWorldWarprevented thenearextinctionthatleft onlyBlackpoolTramwaywith itslinkstothestreettramways
thatoncedominatedthecity streets.Manyofushave beenpleasantlysurprisedand gratefultoobservethegreat revivalofstreettramways thathasoccurredinrecent years.Thedeclinecannow, withhindsight,beregarded asunwiseasisclearlyshown bythewaymanytramways, particularlyinEurope,choseto moderniseanddeveloptheir systemsratherthanabandon them.Itisnoweasytoassess thedeclinebylookingbackat whathappenedtothetramcars duringtheprocess.Although somesystemsdidcontinue tocarefortheirtramsand someevenintroducednew
trams,mostmanagedthe declinebysimplyallowing alackofmaintenanceand caretodominateinthe nal years.Thusallunnecessary expenditureceasedandthe tramsbecamerundown andclearlyunloved.This fallfromgraceisperfectly demonstratedsimplyby lookingatthetramcarinits prime,withobviousmunicipal pridetobeseeninaclean, digni edvehicle,linedout inthemosttastefulmanner (photo43)andthen,within afewyears,reducedtoa drab,plainlypaintedanddirty, rundownend-of-lifetram (photo44).Thisarticlehas
435 DIRTYTRAM www.model-engineer.co.uk >>
Civicprideandtaste,1930livery.
Thebowpeninuse.
Neglectanddecline. 41 42
Guidefixedreadyforlining.
43 44
beenanattempttoshowhow thishappenedandhowso manytramsendedupwhilst stillbeingabletoprovidea publicservice.
Inwritingthisdescription, Ihaveattemptedtocorrect, inmodelform,theway historyandrealityareusually presented.Mydeveloping BoltonTramway eetnowhas examplesoftramcarsinall mainmanifestations,fromcare intheirprimetotheendofdays whenthelackofprideledtoall tooobviousneglect(photos45, 46,47 and 48).
REFERENCES
Bolton66Group-HeatonPark ManchesterTramwayMuseum.
TramwaysinBoltonbyTony YoungandDerekShepherd.ISBN 078-0-948106-58-3
BoltonCorporationTransport –HarryPostlethwaiteISBN9781905-304-165
TramwaysofSouthEast Lancashire (booklet,nowout ofprint).
Thanksinparticulartothelate DerekShepherdoftheBolton 66Group.
436 ModelEngineer 22September2023
StandardBolton‘tramlivery’.
Boltoncarsbeforethedecline.
Abitofgrime.
Theend.
ME 45 46 47 48
WeVisittheCambridge andDistrictModel EngineeringSociety
Whereyoureditorlives isabitofawasteland asfarasmodel engineeringsocietiesare concerned.Theareabetween BurySt.EdmundsandHaverhill appearstohaveacquired somekindofimmunityasfar asourclubsareconcerned andthenearestclubsareall
atleasthalfanhouraway. Theseincludetheclubsat Ipswich,Colchester,Brandon (thenearest)andCambridge. Iwaskindlyinvitedovertothe Cambridgeclubonacoupleof occasionsrecentlyanditwas verypleasanttorevisitaclub I’vegottoknowquitewellover theyears.
TheCambridgeclubisnow 75yearsold,havingbeen foundedin1938,andacquired its rsttrackin1950.However, itsoonmoved,eightyears later,toitslargerandcurrent siteattheendofFulbrooke Road,ontheGrantchesterside ofthecity.Thisallowedthe constructionofacontinuous
437 www.model-engineer.co.uk >>
Martin Evans drops inonhis localclub.
Thespaciousnewcarriageshed.
Thenewtraverserandscissorsliftinthedownposition.
TheCambridgeclubworkingparty–(fromleft)NormanWells,BobPrice,JohnHolmwood,DaveHarper,SteveHallam,Ian Stenning,RoyBirch,JulianGarratt,DavidWright,JohnKegworth,JeffBolton.
1 3 2
438 ModelEngineer 22September2023
4
Theliftraisedtofullheight.
5
Thenewsteamingbaysawaitinginstallation.
6
Onepadpouredforthenewsteamingbays–twotogo.
Theratherneatmicroprocessorcontrolledsignallingsystem.
7
Amonitorinthesignalboxdisplays thestatusofallthesignalsandtrack sections.
8
Thenewraised3½ and5inch trackisstakedoutinthenorthern extension.
9
10
TimColes(centre)steamsuphisnew7¼ inchgaugeLMSJintyobservedbyclub chairman,JulianGarratt(left)andyoureditor(right).
11
TimColeslooksalittlesmugafterhavingachieveda rstlapofthetrack.
track,whichwindsthrough thewoodsandisverypopular withyoungfamiliesonsummer Sundayafternoons.About tenyearsagothesocietywas offeredfurtherlandtothenorth ofthesitewhichallowedthe constructionofanextensionto thetrack,whichnowacquired a gure-of-eightshapeand alengthofaroundathirdof
Theentirerailwaywasalso resignalledatthattimeand isnowfullyinterlockedwith microprocessorcontrolled signals.Thisofcourseisno lessthanyoumightexpect intheUK’shi-techcapital.
439 MEVISITS www.model-engineer.co.uk >>
amile,of3½,5and7¼ inch gaugetrack.Theextraland alsoprovidedspaceforanew carriageshed.
12
YoureditorinchargeoftheJintywhileTimtriestolookunconcerned.
13
NormanAtkintakestheclublocomotiveforaspinaroundtheextendedtrack.
14
AboardcommemoratingeventsandmodelsfromTed’slife,includingacoupleof captioncompetitions!
15
KathyGoodediscussessomeofthepictureswithBrianApthorpe.
16
Ted’sIsleofWightrailwayO2locomotivedecoratedfortheoccasion.
Soonafterwards,furtherland becameavailableallowing asouthernrelieflooptobe added.Thisloopcutthrough theoriginal3½ and5inch gaugeraisedtrackwhich thusbecameredundant.The acquisitionoftheextraland tothenorthhadalsoprovided roomforanewcontinuous
raisedtrackandIwasableto seetheproposedrouteofthe newtrackstakedout.Mostof thisroutewillbeconstructed usingrailsretrievedfromthe oldraisedtrack.
Thepurposeofmy rst visitwastoadmirethelatest developmentsattheclub.Ona previousvisitIhadbeenableto seetheconcretepadnewlylaid forthecarriageshedbutIwas nowabletotakealookatthe completedconstruction,which isindeedveryimpressive.It’s oddhowtheseconstructions alwaysseemlargerwhen nishedthanthesizeofthe bareconcretepadmight suggest!Sixtracksallowthe storageofalargenumberof passengervehicles.Iwasalso abletotakearide,forthe rst time,ontherecentlyextended track.The‘folded gure-of-eight’ routeallowsforatwolapride whichdoesnotrepeatitself.
Thehighlightforme wastoseethesiteofthe newsteamingbaysand,in particular,theverysmartnew traverserandscissorlift.It occurredtoyoureditorthat combiningthesetwofunctions,
astheyhave,couldallowfor steamingbaysofvarying heights,whichmightbehandy fortheshortermembersofthe club.Thenewliftwasoutside awaitinginstallation,along withseveralnewsteaming bays.Theliftiselectrically operatedandcanliftuptoa ton,whichshouldeasilycover eventhelargest7¼ inchgauge locomotives.
Theoccasionofmysecond recentvisittotheCambridge trackwasacelebrationofthe lifeofTedGoode,alongstandingmemberoftheclub overmorethan60yearsanda highlyskilledandproli cmodel engineer.Aswellasseven completedlocomotiveshebuilt anumberoforrery’s(three,I wastold)andseveralclocks, includingtwoCongreveclocks. ThreeofTed’slocomotives wereinsteamontheday, offeringridestothemany visitors.Theseincludeda7¼ inchgaugeGWRpanniertank, anLNERJ15andanIsleof
WightrailwayO2.A5inch gaugeGWRpanniertankand ridingtrolleywereondisplay intheclubhouse.Several otherlocomotiveswerealso insteamincludingarecently completed7¼ inchgaugeLMS Jinty,oneofapairconstructed byclubnewslettereditor,Tim Coles.Itwasgoodtoseeone oftheselocomotivesnowfully paintedandinsteam.Itwas accompaniedbyaridingtrolley previouslydescribedin Model Engineer (M.E.4685 etseq.).
Theweatherwaskind andtheeventwasverywell attended-androundedoffwith anexcellenttea,which(forme) includedaverynicepieceof lemondrizzlecake.
KathyGoodeislookingfor newownersforafewofTed’s engines,includingthe5inch GWRpanniertankanddriving truck.Anyenquiriesshouldbe madetotheeditorinthe rst instance.
440 ModelEngineer 22September2023
20
Teatimeatthewell-attendedmemorialeventforlong-standingclubmemberand proli cmodelengineerTedGoode.
19
Aline-upofTed’sengines–thepannier,theJ15andtheO2.
17
Ted’sLNERJ15locomotiveiswatered atthestation.
18
Ted’s7¼ inchgaugeGWRpanniertankawaitsthe‘off’.
ME