INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY A telemedicine check-up

A telemedicine check-up A look at some survey data

BY DAVID HOLT, JD

Telemedicine use has expanded rapidly across the United States, largely due to pandemic-related necessity and the challenges posed by in-clinic visits. President Donald Trump declared a national emergency on March 13, 2020, and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Minnesota health agencies, and professional boards quickly moved to loosen restrictions and issue “waivers” for compliance with telemedicine guidelines. Following Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz’ Emergency Executive Order 20-01 declaring a peacetime emergency related to COVID19, the Minnesota Commissioner of Human Services was granted temporary authority by the Governor to waive or modify certain requirements in order to provide essential programs and services during the pandemic, and the Legislature enacted several laws. This article will look at some of the challenges and benefits from Minnesota’s experience with telemedicine thus far.

Pluses and minuses

The benefits and drawbacks of telemedicine quickly became apparent as some medical providers were forced to quickly adopt telemedicine to keep their practices running. More data is accumulating rapidly, since the COVID-19 pandemic introduced many Americans to telemedicine for the first time. In 2019, in the pre-COVID-19 world, a telehealth study noted that while 9.6% of Americans had used telehealth services, nearly three-fourths (74.3%) said they either don’t have access or are unaware of a telehealth option, according to the 2019 J.D. Power Telehealth Satisfaction Study (https://tinyurl.com/mp-jd-power). Unsurprisingly, patients 65 years old and older—among the populations at highest risk from the virus—were less likely to use telemedicine, representing the lowest utilization rate of any age group (5.3% of those surveyed).

The main benefit during the COVID-19 pandemic, of course, is that patients can continue to receive medical care from the comfort of their home without risking exposure to COVID-19 during an in-office visit. Another benefit of telemedicine is the increased access to providers, when distance and geography are eliminated as a barrier. When the telemedicine laws were first passed across the country at the state and federal levels, lawmakers emphasized that telemedicine would increase access to care to rural communities. One limitation of this benefit is that the rural expansion of telemedicine generally relies on a stable internet connection, which is not always reliable. This may not all be about the delivery methods, but rather

OB & GYN CARE

FOR ALL STAGES OF LIFE

Low- and high-risk obstetrics, including advanced maternal age. Certified nurse midwifery. Gynecologic care, including well-woman screenings and in-office procedures Gynecologic surgeries, including minimally invasive surgeries and robotics for conditions such as endometriosis and pelvic organ prolapse Menopause Clinic, including management of peri-menopause Center for Urinary and Pelvic Health, including urodynamics. Nutrition and wellness consultations. Infertility evaluation and treatment.

Early, late, and Saturday appointments 763-587-7000 OakdaleOBGYN.com MAPLE GROVE BLAINE PLYMOUTH CRYSTAL

Compassionate, Comprehensive, & Personalized care for adult and pediatric patients with neurological conditions, including:

           

Head Injury/Concussion Epilepsy/Seizures Headache/Migraine Neck/Back Pain Sleep Disorders Movement Disorders Parkinson’s Disease Tremors Alzheimer’s Disease Dementia Muscle Weakness Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Sciatica Neuromuscular Disease Muscular Dystrophy Dizziness Numbness Stroke Multiple Sclerosis ALS And other neurological disorders

612.879.1500 NoranClinic.com

Blaine | Edina | Lake Elmo/Woodbury | Lakeville | Minneapolis | Plymouth

an awareness issue. Awareness of telemedicine was lowest in rural areas, where 72% of respondents were unaware of telemedicine as an option.

Not all telemedicine services require an internet connection. Some services are delivered through a simple phone call, but this, along with other electronic delivery modes, is still subject to HIPAA requirements. The Office for Civil Rights (OCR) at the federal Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has issued guidelines for compliance with patient privacy laws (https://tinyurl.com/mp-hhs-ocr). During the COVID-19 National Public Health Emergency, patients and providers may use popular apps that allow for video chats, including Apple FaceTime, Facebook Messenger video chat, Google Hangouts video, and Skype, to provide telehealth without risk that OCR might impose penalties for noncompliance with HIPAA. In addition, Minnesota modified state telemedicine guidelines to include phone calls for eligible providers who render services via telemedicine and can demonstrate that it is safe to do so. (See the Minnesota Healthcare Programs Provider Manual’s webpages on “Telemedicine” and “COVID.”

Also, to account for the increased frequency of telemedicine visits, the current limitation of three telemedicine encounters per week is suspended in Minnesota. And finally, much to the delight of physicians working from home, when delivering telemedicine—including via telephone—the distant site (provider’s location) can be the eligible provider’s home. The originating site (patient’s location) can be their home. This is a large departure from previous restrictions.

Across state lines

Rural areas are not the only beneficiaries of elimination of geographic barriers via telemedicine. Providers may, in some cases, work across state lines, creating a new legal maze to determine which services are covered based on patient and provider locations. Beginning on March 6, 2020, Medicare started to temporarily pay clinicians to provide telehealth services for beneficiaries residing across the entire country. It also removed the telehealth stipulation that telehealth in rural areas can only be provided with specific audio-visual equipment.

Minnesota law generally provides that a physician licensed in another state can provide telemedicine services to a patient in Minnesota if their license has never been revoked or restricted in any state; they agree not to open an office in Minnesota, meet with patients in Minnesota, or receive calls in Minnesota from patients; and they register with the state’s board. These requirements do not apply in response to emergency medical conditions, if the services are on an irregular or infrequent basis, or if the physician provides interstate telemedicine services in consultation with a physician licensed in Minnesota (MN Stat. § 147.032). All providers using telemedicine are held to the same standards of practice and conduct that apply to the provision of in-person services (MN Stat. § 147.033).

Minnesota physicians are also exploring whether they can practice telemedicine with patients outside of Minnesota. Each state has different regulations, which are monitored by the Federation of State Medical Boards (see https://tinyurl.com/mp-state-regs). This is largely a state-by-state consideration and may implicate laws outside of Minnesota.

Patient and physician feedback

One drawback to telemedicine is that some patients report that the two types of “visits” are not the same. A remote telemedicine visit will never be exactly the same as an in-office visit, and that is a concession all providers make in adopting telemedicine technology. Nearly half (48.7%) of patients in the J.D. Power study believe that the quality of care received in a telehealth session is lower than that of a doctor’s office visit, while only 6.2% perceive the quality to be higher, and 45.1% believe it to be the same. Another 43% also believe a telehealth session to be “less personal” than an office visit. The metrics to measure “quality” are certainly up for debate, but a large percentage of patients do report a difference in service.

As another drawback, primary care providers in community health clinics in Minnesota are reporting difficulties faced by older patients and

A telemedicine check-up to page 304

When loved ones need to be close

THE SAINT PAUL HOTEL

has a long-standing special pricing policy for guests with loved ones that require hospital stays. If you have patients from either out of state of suburbs that require hospitalization at any of the outstanding St. Paul area hospitals, please let them know that family members and loved ones are welcome to our discounted health care stay pricing.

SAINTPAULHOTEL.COM | 651.292.9292 | 350 MARKET ST., ST. PAUL