r;;IASi'.b..<
J__r.;~jij U'j~Jf
~O(t ~ )
~
.Y
)..t1iJdJ)J;--18 â&#x20AC;¢
7249218-7237430:(;); ut;JI),!
)..t1iJ,Jl,)J::.IJ;~Jf
(1Jr1 J;<
)..t1iJC).f{~J.'"
U'lI' .
;.f{ ..1))1/
,1999
JJI-::..fl,!.1
,2005
(JJ -::..f l,!.1
LJ)90/Y
d..
5
c!J) ,f ~ J! ~ / ~L (i~ l:/ -~ ?) z., )JI z:; I~JidW:W __i;I1)! '-A L J;! J1~':::""":::;J 1.11.1~ ')In;; ~ ~ / ~ uiu,/.I)!.}t= L JIP / .d 1.1' ~ l:l yr J! .:::....I)!cJ'_~ r L).,JIJ?-) I)! )JJ 1.1' e f 'fI)! JIP 4 4 -'f- J~J~ J! LI) ,f cJl ;; ~ ~ I)! ..:-tJIP OJr.,--'f- C~0~ J! ')In ~~,f ~L 4-' 4-' 'f- Ji J..; 1.1' ;; L~~ -:::1 r 1.1' ~ 'L~~J
I)!
-:::J)
)~ r
ujljl
ok-- )JI
'L)JiI_;Y~ ,f)JJ OJr.,-- (i~
JI nl '..:.-yf ..:.-.,JUJr,.;)1 'J'" ~ v
J~Loo1J!I ,f)JJ
~ ILJ~,f 1.1' ~ ~
1.1' //. ~I)
-'f- u,1P
fl999
J'"
uiu,/.
L vI
'.::.:?-YL.)JI ~
,f
I)! ..:-lJlPL l:l .d u}lJ,/.
L~JJIl! f ..::)j,f
s.'f-I/~ -:::1 I)! N':::"" ~
"~Y
~)In
J! l:l ()' if)JI
(i ;;'~ dVJR;
-~J~ 1.1'
L),{ -:::)JI
~v!
7
~/
â&#x20AC;¢
II
_;.J~
-1
22
(g rc.'.JO)U,/.
-2
\
v! '-.J~ L ~J,Pz 0uJ?'V-J,Pzv! '-.J~ L uJJ! .JJI UJJ!
33 49 72
H6 96
LI.J
J""'~
-3
.JJIc.'.JO)U,/.
-4
~L(.II .JJIc.'.J
-5
JJ..i .JJIJ~ ;.JJJ~J~i;
-6 -7
9
.IJ'
J1j~:--"u,./. f Ji-)v"; -:~J...f? '( Lf .:!jJ
~'.J:~k
r.~ ...JJ JIv. v' _(.t1 ~ J'; /- ~ c}VJPzAr;' J A~~ I;-f r v. J 4lr /- /-'tL.t1 J;/ ~ J.::rCI ;; Lr L ~ C)' -L.t1 ..?/ L OP ...J r :L .t1 J! L r -4_:,"' Jif.ct' ----ki'1Iu> ct'Ic}Vv:-; ~ r
.IJ'
J.I
J,t?,J\.
~.I~ .IJ'
"J
I).I~ ~ J~
~ .IJ'
" _:, IJ,;S
OJ
Jj.'.
v. if.C)}i
OJ --~
C).ii
I c}Vv:-;
'Jv'~ J,[--.,f. '::)JJJ I)J,;f Ic}Vv:-;Lr f-:)J1IX ~ U":~J~ ~ ~ ..,...,....::)J): J(j ~1I~ if' L C)r'if.lJ' ~'./. 'J -v.- I(~If! L I)J,;f L u,),.IJ' L.t1 cfJ.I OJ L ~O).fJ
cP'JPzM (Verdict on India)
_( T-.1 (;,'.1 tJ~)iJ!_,dJ. L u,:t)i "'~
J')tei
11
v-~ "- Ji d\,.lW sI.::/', .JJJJ). v! ~L J ~J -L" (W v! ~.J~ Jt 'L" (W If v! u,u. do do (lSi J~;.;
-iOJ
L u";1'L" eJ.J}d
OJ
u_;~L
uji
t>Y"" .JJI.JJ~
P. '-/~
~J(,,-(! luf.i J..:J!?JcJI'15J/JtljJ~i~IPoLd ';.J} L J'J.J...f ~ J .::/', ...f.:iJJ VI L upu, J~;.;.;cJI'v.JJIUP!? L u";1.JJI,ft
v:! Jtlj J ~ "- a.J~JJv! u.v~ cJI -~.! v:! .JJ)f'1.::/', J~;.;"- ujp!
J~;.;2... L cJIj TLIr ~,J!3';/;1.r~L ~
JcJIv! VI -i- LlIJJ~Jd V:!' = -i- L" (/
Po L 15Jlj; .JJ1
.::/'I..t~
.Nt
J..tj J JIJi JcJIv! VI -i- J" u$ J:~~ .JJI'~ ~ '~\ ~ J't. J.= j ~ :'f- Lirt,I"- L) JJ.r~L v! ~~ cJI-i- J"~ . .;~, ~ ~I \'LIr I[ =1. r JIJi .JJId ~' \'LIr I[J4, ,y ",;I~ "- a.J~JJ~~ 4) Jr LIr ~ I.:;;G J t.:&i ~I ~ Lir I/.Ji ~Ir L -J) tf JIJi .JJIJ;.\ ~A V:!' p. f UYi .!J".!j'Llrv,!jl..tlJi ~~/.JJJ.JJI.Ntvlf 'f-=:PJ/ yJJ L ~I JIIJi ;,;;vI-L;,:, '"Ji u 'f- i'J p. rd Jr Lir V .JJJvI .JJIv,!jl..tlJi ~~/.::/" Jui,/ .; ~I L U? fl/.J~I v! ~Ji ;;; "- _;,£ 15.J1r IJ.D ,j..JL ';-I.fJ(i "- ~.l~II
12
/,J~1j1J'J~JcJ' .JJ'~" .JJJ~
J~
L U? _(~.J r U':'-~.J
-'f-.J ,:,~ rb.JLJcJ' .J'= r O~ ,.It ~ dV"JPt .s:'f- ~ (i' -fI = ~v L UP.J~ L;!" /. ~ L 15J'jr ~ -fI r b.JL~, ~ ...iJ.) if .JJ'j'~' if I~L J.J' 15}U,/. v!
=
r~f .JJJ= _( 'f-.:::;? -fI' = -~b: -'f- 'J,I J-P L b.JLJdVJ~ L JJ J' .JJ').ti' 15}1b/.r 'f.:::;? -fl1f .JJ'-'f- ~
J' _(~
L~
~fj'~'Ji ~ ~ ,,",I.J' V' ~ _(J'y = 2_ V'
~=1 r v' f /.~(i' -fI (b.JL 1V' ~~ L U_"'Jc,GI: ~ 1:5' v! J' J..JLL;!" /.1v' ~_('f- LJ1,~ J'y If =" ~ -4 ,J.,J ,f 15j'~' JJ ~ =_(L~ LlJ =~L~ I('" 15j'~' JJ ~ _(J,J..I.. ~, -fI 'J,'k.' J,J..I.. L -fI fJ' 1J-P J..JLL v' -'f-15.J~ If cl v!,y,f':',f If ~ L;11; L.JJJ j'Y:r) Yo (Ir .J'.ti' 15}U,/.v! dVJ~ fi _('f- LJ1'~ If = J'y -fI" Uk .\ji u~....;v! J-P v' .JJ'ti.J .J1j/. J-P (~L 15.J~.JJ' 'LJ1,f J ,,::..fJ~J'{ 'O..A: cflj 'jJ1 ~.J J d v! UJ.J'J'.JJ' .I';' J ":"~'J.J ~ J"::'->v~' {.I} JJ.J~'~ L/ v' 'jr J....; v! ..:..I.Y.J JYo~~J.J J.:;;,~ J ,-:"..J:i ~, v! ,-}~ '-.J~ v! J' '-.J{ V' , 'O..A: ~ -~i ~ {J' '~i ~ fi~ aJ ~i uk!..; Yov!.J' 15}1b/.-ij1.J 'JJ1 J!f3 Jcflj L .JJ"~ .I';' J..:..~IJ.J (j 'J" JUJ)J' L :~f v! u,; JJ/ L V' -~ J'~.J '.J~~ tf'. L.V' ~ ~...f ",:,,' YoaJ '-/ JJ 'v.t L'J ~ I..:..~ ~.J!~..If Yo'J -fI cJ' Y JJ ''f- c[,~ ":".JIPI":"~'J.J.JJ'~ ,;-' -fI-v.t LJ1 ,-7.~ 2J JjI. L -;'.J! -fI-'f- L~J'j~, .JJ'.::/;. J dJ v!
v~
r?
v~"
n'
v~
J!3
13
-'f- CIJW
J' r J1,.0 I)! VI f~_,J 1~ ~.Jj L f~I Y JJi ''f- t:z,
rWi j~~iifi s .JJI'f-
'f- j~!.SJ
'" f ~1J'
~ J'J ~
L .Jlpl" j
I)! ~.J~
L J; I)! U;' ~J
J;
!; ';-, ~i y; ;i~
f 'f- C~t;; !.SA-.; r~ VI Iy;CfJ; V~ "~ If~:ir .J!.SiUu~ ~ J1~ v' -f'ii? -C"i" ~ L J' .JJIv.J~ L)1tJ.J ~ ..::,..--~~I:P"JPi ~ -?J! VI f 'f- j~!.SJ J'J ~ i 'f- C~
jJ.J~I ~I
OJ ~
v.:,L J? (j .; riw ~
_ L .
J
riw 0:"" ~/
J~Jj
I)!
-0~11# J~
JJ.J L ~ ~ -'y;
JJ .JJ' '_.P..G '~I..-- ~.Ji -!.SJ.:.-? (j .JJ'
J~;(j ~
J~;!Jj ~ L ..::,..--_,j, !",:",,';;; ~ 'JIPozI ~ -~J
!do Li Jr" L ¥ (1I)! ~}~ -If'~ ~~r Lf ~~.::,/ J
",:",,';;; ~ -If.Jk#' 1Jr'I L v.J~ /. y; _;? A .JJI~ v;?Lz " J~ t".r L/.' 1uP. ?~-?J,f do '=':- ~.J'J' o~L~' J, !; L J~y!J ~ .JJ' 'j~'~
1';I)! do e:.,~ ~
L L L ~ (j-iJ,
-Ul j ~i i I)! J' v' L
v~
J.}? f 'f- C~IfJ! J'!7' ~ .; v' ,j2
f -'y; J! 1 j~JPi e.t~r~,,,?fi -i.: ":"'J~ ,;-' L ..::,;;'; 1ufloL .::,'j Ji 2.. L ;£.1 )j /.1r(;-' L ..::/;~, L u~,
v.:,f
j~ JPi L (Wi j ~J~i i fi -~iJ,;-1..-- ,;-' ~ tiL .JJ' )p'
1V~ L uJ..;~,lfi Ly;.::,'J' !.SiU,/.f 'f- ~ ~ .,L.' Ly;
V' (1) -~.J '7. ;!.J
~..J.'~)v.! ;!.J
~J
~y
u~;~ u~;
V' .;~)~
~/.J;
r
~J ",:)y, J'""
v' ~~J..:..r
~ tiL r ~JPi Jy,~ L..::,;;';
L ui.'i .JJ' uJ~'.1L ~JPi ,J~ 1/3 r ~~JPi f 'f- ~u I)! cf uj~ lJ.iU,/.~JPi 2.. V' -Ul.l ('i .,:..~IJ.J .JJ' ~)J' P ~~.1 V~
14
r -"p' 1.5)U,/. -J" J; ..;~). c.)! v' )J' ~)? c.)! ur~~ )J' .;: ..:)U, tSu:.hn'J ~ -?J tSif. J. ..;I; e;;'G ~ -?J tS if- 'i- ~J' (lS/' Llf L LJ' .::/; ,..(I" )j- Jr" -:~, -,f )J' ..::.:?~ '~ ~., r do f! "r' ~ ~,Llf tS U~Po~ ~
"r *'- f,,, -: (2)~C,,'/~
.
,.
~ -,f I.5JJ'. c.)! uf 1.(j ~!/ J'.; if"~,J~ v! (lSi J~i; )J' v"/. L ~'j Ji L'J ~ L v' i ~ cfltj 1.5)~ d~j1.5J! V' -~IJ'e;;'G ~ V' L
J~'L &, ;;f If c.)! uW -~ ~IS
un
~ -Vl)Jul c.)! If' L ';J' ~y U 4'J' AJr )rJi'V ~ JlIJ2... L d' )J' t! J ~ uJJ!;;' )J' '~)~ -:,j.' r v' -f!cf. dp,..L d' -"A )J' A~·j c.)! d'-f! L .::,.f')j
'l.5j'Y." c.)! ~)I( ulJi L
(lSi
J~ii L u';' ...t. 4;- v.! $' L J....; 1#-"~ j )J'?oC f,,, (3)-1/~
J'';-
f
J'J c.)! ~~ 0:), L 1# d~ :Ji c.)! )JJJ~J~r} .; cfltj ~?'4(~, r d,j 0:), L uil.J..-'" u~~ I/):.i'; -:)i'l:£ -"j/. f? tS~~ ~'j '~J' A..,~ r ,j?'~ ~ I.5j'.t'
)J'
)J'
..:)~)J~~
..:-sw tSt)J)p '~ iJj I,:f L 1.5;/. tS~ . u,.}! v.!' LJ'J'ji ~ J¥I'L ~~) IUJ)p c.)! 1863 '~.fd) c.)! ~;~ ~ L u~rO cJ' '''' c.)! JJ.J L U?~(/-'~J' L'y L J~ii 2... V' (4) -I.5J~J J.tj (j ~ f,:f L'cW' (j, I:f"/. Pv.!' vir t~u-v!' JiJi t)~~ Po c.)!,rue c.)! UJ)''; L cJ' 'tf'
)J'
)J'
";)J ',/.
-~)('i.;uJJ~ Uyj
jJ' ~
c.)! )JJ
v' f 'i- J! -:Ji ;;;i~
c.)! ~)~
L -;'1.5)U,/.
.
15
Yo v!;.
LvI ",/.' ~
L ";,,tJ. VI .JJ' '111";,,tJ. r ..:.11~ J .I~I J.?
(Ii Atil ",)U,/. ~ -'IJ7 I~;~.J.L ~JPl 15I:l- v/ JJjr I~YoJ 1.:)1 uf tJ. t".r ':;"y -: IUJ.I?IJL dV JPl ":::;J VI j'~ 11
VI fi -L11 ..:.v-'J-I; L 1.:)1 .IJI J"d
.:... UJ:r/t L U.,)I.:...-?J
154f'Jc)!J 15U!.IJ/".IJIU.J'J'J1.:)1 j v!' uk:'J 15v.~-?J 15
.IJI L!
~rIe}~
i.....4: .IJIE..... u)(' L!
15~/
.IJI~
~.Ij
L
~~I .IJIL! ~.IJJ ~I
15LI.I cf". (1.1-?'.I-~ f J.t;:. r ..:.!iIP L11 ~I ~ L u£i 1.:)1 -v!' .I1JI-t';15;:-- ~ ~I ~
Y'/.
~I-t';~;;~ ~
? Llf L •.J:?' J ..:.l'J.I.IJI Llj J..4: .I~ L GY ~I L if. f J~t_? 11". ~ r 'f- ~ ~ 15VI _gj L! IJ{ IZA ~.Ij L J-J tJ!1, fl11 ()v IVI j ~ ~Uv' r(- JUI.:... 15J1I~ L r.I ~ L VI j 'f- bU u 'f-IPP';; Yo v! ~.I~L J}~I 15(- JUI v! uiY J
JA
v!' ..:.I.)v bU v! I:l- f~
JI< IUPtJ!1, (Ii 1.:)1 Po L,.j 15uP 1.:)1 ,,:,,1 s» J'"~(~ -:r VI (5) ~ I.t v! ~.IJif- ~I ;-tr- L J1I.lJI
L~.f'j
Jr v! ~I
JI LVI
f'f-
"'uJJ~~
L
'v;.::);;jl (j 'v;..:.~ E..... ":,,I'~
c:C!
-'f- ":'.IJ/ 15 II-:j,; v! ~.I~ L .IJJJ~r; 2.... VI
d? tf~.:...~ VI e)~ ~
L v' .IJI ~11u~-..t?~1¢I (lSi J~~r; f 'fI,;}VJPi L
(lSi VI f'f-
":'.IJ/ JI
.IJIL11~
..:.I_/I
cC !11-: 4f' ,; -~.1~
c:C! II.1J/ -: -~ J..4: I..:.>tr- 15l:;~ j~JPl
~-v!' 2.... L ..:.Ip.L l:;ytr- ",)U,/. j ~u./'vf.lJ/ u~..; v! v!' vf;.;~ L..:v; ",)U,/. Yo v! VJ.Iv!;. L u~~ 1.:)1 Ju.IJ~ 11
~ ~ ;-tr- ';-,
J....;A J;;./(1) ~ J....; J:~J J/~~ r I:l- .IJI
•
16
,;-' IU,}..J? cJ'&J '~.1,f.! ~v
J~
Vir ~Jk 2... V' ''T- j1l.lr -1.1
o.( .I;:'
;£.1 ~v /1 .d~..;J;I cJ' JI viI ~ J~;i V' 'PI L Lf ~IP..:..L) L UJ'j; .IJ' ~/ .IJ' ~JJ J~JPi L if. !I) (1Si~' wfI ~ ~~cJJ.~ ~ J'J u!.IJJ~.A! ~JPi ~ ~J JV' ~~~£ f ~ e--,,1. vi~' .IJ' ej I UJ'j; f cJJ. L./.' ..:..1I'J" ~ L"
r~'
~ ~IP '.I~ ~ ":"~'J.IP.IJ' ur:j ~,.IJ' '" f'T-U.I.¥' 2... V' ~~.f'j~'Yol( do f cJJ. ..:..1I'J" &J ~ ~d~ 'I) L.lr ,J..ICrill( .IJ'~ ~ L~ I ~~v'-J/
...::,;_,) wfI ~ ~ 2... v'
,,; r
r
-Lvf' f ~IP~.IJ'-t.lj
~ r" wfll( v' i J:...f! -J1IP L~ J~~;.; u! cP'J~ ~ .IJ' -:<) J ~
';.I}
JI s:S(jJ ~ S4
Jtr .IJ' U}.;;, I dV'JPi L ~ V'L
(fl901)
~
V' fl) ~
0. J.li JIP! 'J'J -'T- ~ ~ e--,,1.
,;-' J~ ~~J Sif. 'T- ~.1!L c,et, f ~ ~JJ ~ cP'JPi ''T-,f ~ J; uj., S,-}Ir ~Jk ~ V' -'T-~.1 Yl (J/ ~ e'.Ij .I? ~, L ":"J-0' -.I' -cJJ. 'T-.1 Yl ~ J -:<) cJ): cJJ Jj .IJ' L (llii j ~~r.; fV ~ IJi ;;;;v' u! ub.lCJtr J~ J~" ~C1 ..:..'Ju,o ,;-' .IJ' 'T- ~ ~.II,~ .IJ' J; ~ ScJI;:--J~~ ~ J'1;Jl SdV'~ L u";'.;.I} L JI} -'T- ~ ~ ~ j~'.d L v'A.!',} ~~J; u~j ~ ";".Ii..:iJJ wfI Yof~ ..J'r I( ~ S L'J LYl u! ~, u! PI .IJ' L uJ'?'C JI~~ I~
vi
vi
-~Jf~L~J¢,iY
~'~.Ir
~ u! ~J~
J' LJI J;;i Jtr -J1IP L ~ J~~;.;
17
S LJ ,y;--, /1:)'--"Vl e'.Ij~...;/ _:,v!-'" L 1:)'f '-l/ ~(lSi JMr; f,,,,;'-t' IIr .::.;V,~,'- v' -'i-II "'~ f J: Lr L if.fl) .Ir ~ -'i- ~.1J J.,G' ~ r 1:)' 4'~/u£i S J""IP ~ ~.Ii ~JIf' L if."" ~J/'- ~ v' vfi "'~-: .::.:?fJ,I
eJ -:
# /.~
v! UJ)J',y; .IJ'UY';JJ. S..:/'; ~, fl)....ltY r1:)'":,,,'-! eJ J" ~J/ ...fi Yo"';iJV L .I'ti' 0:(,./1 '- >/ v' -~f I;J. -(j.l J!~, /.I'J ~,
L )ti'
L~;
U:t..!t .IJ'(j.l J&
oJl...;) ~ ~ f 'i-II -:~ ~ r ...fi"'~ VI
Ur. L" I~ ..:..~t,C;1v! U~ .IJIU~~VlJ',,1o.l~VoJJIf'....JJjP O.l{,.fur" (j L I:P'J;:.z -Jf.l~1 ,_, S (JLJ .IJI if~L .I{/.,.f~yvJt Vl.lfL(j~~~ .IJI~f! ~/ '- v! 1:)1 '~./.' ..:..I.,l:.ai Yo v!PI ~.f -~ ~S ..:..77'-.,lI.) .IJ'i..L Lf ,J.~ ,-uJ:t..!t v! I:P'~ _I) r if'" (j ~ r" S if'" (j -:I e: L Lf f / ui.lJ~ .IJI'u"J/'uY1z J" I:P'~ '-l7. ,.fif" (j vl-! ,,».111 J~0 J~ S if.f! ":".IJ/ C.lL ,.fI:P'~ P~ I)) v! LvI .IJI'C.lL ,.fvI '~L L ~J/~J1,J!s7 ,.fif" (J J~J;:.z"J~ vl.lJI J:...fi ,.ff~1L .IJI UJ~J ,.fl" J~ ~ >. J/ i..~I v! J' ~.I{ vI L ujt,Y' j 'J" 1:)1 v! vI (j _:, .IJI'/ ~ ~ J/i.. L 1:)1v!-::?'.I ('.1 1LL; L .11'=i.. L L~I / J.IJIC.lL PvI eJ i.. v,-J drf J/i.. L JIYI P'-l7. ~I fjy" ,., '- J.IJIC.lL ~~ ~ .lJIL",_i' r I:)I.lJIC.lL ,.f1:)1 fl" -:;.. r vl-'-lJJ ~J/tfJ1P" v!.l.lJI ~L
Y
0/
r
-v! J
J
18
-~ b: ~I
J'. d:-"JPz IJ} L U';I ~ 1.1' '~iffi~~ d:-"JPzt
:tfr ~ r~)~,J ~ ~ JPz .nl'~
J'.'-;~
~J!
U~
L
~;,
v'_''''~
tt~
cf. L ~I
oj )/'~
'J.):-~f .....;),J U~)~fJ,,- ~ r;,!/l,;
r;,f,.(tf- -?) 0:. _I" ~
r u£i ~k--,JcJ' '.::,.Lf
L ~))L U)~~,.(~ Lir L~ ~ ..::,.~..ir~I ""';iJV L r;,!/l,;:ti' J'.J="~ 1.1'-1./1 zr f;l.1./)}L r/J Jjl L U~ ,.(Po""';iJV ., -tf- Jf .!d!'IJ~~ OJ};,JU~JPz'jy ,J cJ' AX;I tJ:ti' ))1
~l.rtJJljf ~
~lr~p.LL);f
~/~/(gL~
J'. '-)~ L cJ' v! vf ;,..!I)L UhJ&i Po ~ tJJljf 1.11 L.f Po .;::....tJJljfL UhJ,.(tf- Jf f./.I~ ~ ~l,; ,-)In i 1.11~ Iflr ~ ...f ":,,,1f L ~ ,1947 tJ){ 8J 'v! vf ;,..!I).::,.~i ,J ~ (j _:,'~ (FI ~k--I~1.1' i _:, L U';I V:f ~; Po J'. v'-if}y. IUrI) L J;",)}J1j ))1J:~(j_:, ))")(,....v I~ '-;~ ~J'. 0# Jl,;'~ cJp'~"- '":,,,JI J'. ~/ '-){ ))1
-v:"~
))1
)}J:~))I',fr'~k--V~
,.(1"
~4·r 1.1'-1/~
(r
J! JIL
-~if C" ,;:L ~ /.I/. "' cJ' ))1 '1.11 a~b)C J~; ))1 )1_t;ll.5ilb/. r -:-->. v!.f='"~ 1.1' .::,.iJ(p. uPo"- i Ii IJ.:'J _:,Lj r u):t/i L u? ,.(1.112:: .::,.I./C L uhJ -tf- Cf.! ...JJ.) Jt; ))1A."" Ix _:,Lj ))1.d 8J ~I L"L.f ~ ~ ,.(tf- Cirif~~ -1.11 Jf ~l,;.f" J)) u~j ))1,;:!.t. J tJ:ti' IuhJtv!f u'i'Y.J:))1 (I;~ 'I J'J~,J cJiG"'Ii.....;1)1v! _:,Lj 1.1' L"~ I.::,.JJ., uPo"- i ~ ~ J} ",)},fr Ii cJf L U? LJi. '-x ))I-/;:/. 8J tf r;,f -tf- C" (}.p ":,,,I}~L..-~ ~ ))J
I) ))1
~I)
19
I v"i=- I.lI:!J:..::,,-*"tJJI ~
Uy.""LJIt~JQ;
£'( J~; ~I
-Vll...r)iiUit,-UP""
.41 e: V' uk-.}S VI .lJI.r: S VI '~I S ..::"-*,, tJJI ~ .lJII
Vlr '-
S ..::"-*,, tJJI
'-
U.r.::'~~I L UP"" tJ.l~~ L tJJI;rJ.£
L/ ~I JLz J~L~
.lJIc)f_;P): I:)~ '-.l~
tJ.l~4
4 4 -Jv!~J: JJitt'J
S UJ)J '-.d .lJIU~I
JI '-
,-/lr 4 4 -(L~ % LJIt u~1)":'~ '(Lf
(1/
S.::./"tJJt
L/ ~I '( L~
-JV!~J:Jr
4 ,,:,,1 -~b:o~L
U~; .lJI"'
r~
L/ ~I L v!~~ LJIt ..:_,/
J:
'-
v!JIt
('(' ~ 'tJA.d,£I
~ Jlj ~ ~ IJY.".J ~Vi JI/
J;:_lvv£1fJIJ4tJJI(I/
.lJI'(YJJ
L JY.". J ~Vi JI/ .lJIJ; S-'"L ui~ '-.lin ~ L tJJI;r}i .lJJ J~~ri -: ~ fLJIt ~(p.z Lr f _.U,. v' L J; .lJILJIt V('( e: JItJ{J.l J: ~LfJIt~ -.f1'(b.lL tJ.l~.d tJ)U,/.r:"ri '~1/~ J: .rr t..i' J: UYzjf cf..lJJ.l(,~ 131} -.f1 OJ J: ";'.lyI vI .lJILJIt ~ -i=- ~f u~1).lJIdJ.l ,-I L U-"Iy): Sui~ '-.l~ '-.lin ~ ~.....;/
L (lSi J~~ri s i=-I)j -: i';' ~ '(v'
f J".') I J~ .;j)ib L J.?" J: f1857 L/ ~ L
1:)1 .lJI'U~Iy):
'fl.? L
1:)1
-Vl Lr
J;:_Iv
f i=- L~~Jf J".') J!-:-i=- L~~ un~k- '~v(~J'v! i~.JI;~ '!~",j~ fun (,p" "'UJIb7 ~ U';I
I u-,,'Vw; J:,;i L (Y",~
''''-J ~jl
";:;/.l ~I .lJI~I.!.(fi~ ~I '- Uij
II:)I J:
uk-'~ J~L'( f
L ,-b '~ .lJJ '- U,! ';-,
';-,J} (I.; J! r:"rf i=- JlrJi i.. vI ..,.._, -: -V)} J Jjt..i'l '~ f Vl i=-.lf '::':'Iv. '-l/ ~I
v?j ..,.._, -:u_;~ L uiY
"
20
v! (!)y
:t)i
.JJ' V. (!)Ifi -,.I vf ~Iv.
U;~ L UJ:t)iL U';I
If~ (?"' L (!)}; JJI'uA",i.!I'...JL.-jluY
'-Jia f ~ i 'f- Jj -Uj'UJ~
'-Jia
(:.,i
fi s:'f- C" I~ JI"..~ L" .;£J V. cfij f ;:-- ~
0--'
v.~ L U}Y '-Jia s:'f- i? "v,.::.qrf J'-;~ uj U£ -P. J UJlji ..JiJV L (!)Iji Ai! To .:;,"p J (!)IJJI ,..i' v! '::'-J~ Ji uJIa ~ ~ s:'f- ~)..:,.~~L.::.-tJIv J£c.:!
(!)Y :t)i
eJ~
JJIJI}I (Ii eJ V. '::'-J~ vI -'f- Ji
~v
'-Jia " J)
L d .J.
L U';I J£'f- C~JJ: AJ~(!)I'Uj'.v.:tJuJlji ..p.u)n Yo ~ .:;,"p OJf~ t".~f u'9.hlJ ..:-r/JJI(!)I?J:'LJ;;r;~JJJi:!1 ~
'J" (Jf J!'i JbJC .:;,"P JvI f~ L uJ'ji'
u~v
~ J'J
~I ~,
~:t)i Yo s:L UJ1 JJf. " Ll;;1
L (I'
f,
,J;J 0--' v:'A i 'f-
JJI'-;~
J ...0: LIJ
6~fi -v/
,J;J vI
rA
JJI
LJ v.J~ ..JiJV L vI -~ ,..i' Jlv. (
L uJ'ji v! '::'-J~ f uJlji (i (';,i2_ vI -I)) L (I' Yo f If OJ -Uj' J~ J1 ~IJ bJC ~ ~ 'b (1)1J~I ,..i'f'tJ ...JI.) Ju~~L uJlji ~ 't~ (Ii JIJL~ UJ2_
u~v
c~" JJllf tJ't,Jc ,f I)JI;i ~ Ir,JC vI .J. -'f- C~Yt ...JiJV L ,
-.::'-
~JJI
cP"JP;OJ Uj''f-J/01.::.-IJC Yo v! '-J~L':;'"p U}Ib./.
J'" L !:P"JP;P. L I)JI;i -Uj' L~} ~ ~ v! (!)IL bJC L U';I v.,/' vI -'f- ~ J!'i ~ ;I.tl L fbJC JJJJ
J~J~i}L uj
(:.,yv it-- ~ f!. 4-J)jl.tl' v! JJJu:t)i Yo f 'f-~J~If u~)1 (!)I~I '~ ,..i' V. ~c)j~ do JJI,.I (jJ/01vii ~!? Yo ..JiJV L
21
~ L)IP.I 1U;'/ LYl. ~ cJIL b)C -<r- tr ~Ir- b)C ,f uf.j J? ,fb)C )JI T CYlI~ )r 6 I.)!~)~ L .::/!J:!I'1r-1.)! ~ vI i T c~r"I~ Ji L~~ ...P Ib)C ~ -T J~YlO! 2... L)r "k-- -: 'T c~IJ.:'J ~ ~fi I;lJ L uYl?)JI uVtl) ~ ~ ,f is ~)JJ J:!I'1rJk ~ -e» -<r- CYllS)~
un
v~~
"I
-T~)
r un
'YlIf.! V1V JI., b)C ,f)JJ J~i; I.)!~ I.)!~ L vI L )JI JiIf.! ~Ir- ~)Ia,,)} Yb)C ,f)JJ vI ~ ~J,f if. ":::;'J vI Yo b)C 8JA~T 0') ~ 1c!'jL cJl 0' b)C ,f Nt lSJt ~Ir-4.11 T) ~ I.)!ViJ ';-, ~,... Jt ~ 2... 41'-4.11 ~ 1tiL I.)! (/J) ,f ~ ';-, Jy s:T c~if 0' ~!I'1r-)JI Atll
J .i Tr 'tiL ')Ia\.{~ If.!701J..';-, r._f _(arJi ';I,-,,~v:' 'Yl_:,u£ 8J
lSiLJ) )JI
8J
1_ Aloysius. G. Nationalism Without a Nation in India. Delhi, 1997.P. 34
5_ Panikar, K. N. Culture, Ideology, Hegemony. Delhi, 1998,P. 83 (Footnote: 23)
34 -1./ : "~I
2
44 -!,/ : "~I
3
47 -1./ : "~I
4
22
v? ~y.J IS t;)lu jf
f 'f- Jt" I(~f
S~ /. --?JS do f
Jfy -: v! b)C
v! Vf V'~~J ,.:.!"' I:PJPi L tJJ:t/t ~ JfJ LJ1 v! ~f 1 '~ I( ..:-tllPJ:~)Jf & '1Sk-- ,;-f L
"J u1j
I:PJPi
Sdo sv? tJ~_;(
1
-: 1'JJ1 J'1P.:Jj", tJJ2~JPi tJJJ! ~ --?J )pf l;yfu)Jf ~ I(
zS
f!~ ~ efy' 1tJJJ!
t;)'V'JPi L tJJJ!
~v:
f~
1-.1(..:-G"~f)Jf ":-~JIPtf
V's:'f-tf- -:Jfy --0 ~f!~ L~
s'._il..:-IPP -: 1 '~ 1~--:~ ~ I( tJP'f)- If.!f 1 '~J;.::; ~ Jvf", dV''JPiL tJ_')fV's'f- (if tf-
Jfy -: )Jf
J1L
4-~
)Jf t;)~
tJl;-ov
~f!; 'I
OJ! v! ..:-~fy.L t;)f..f£: v.! JIP L ~f ..:-tlfy rV -: 2... Vf )pf OJ! f L~~t;)I, 1-:1' Vf fi -'f- D~{ J~JPi VI ji ~ 1J~ '{ JfJj 1,-/lr L ~J~ L JfJj f _(fJ1 (G" ~f --0 L tJ_')ff 'f- C~J11-. JY --0 tf I()fpf OJ! v! f JL~ S ~J ~ Lf "'V ),JJ t;)'V'JPi~ J. fV'", 1~ --?J,»fJ-: S )pf tJJ! z_ Vf'~ If.! JfJj I(,-/lr J~Pi JfJj ~ -I If.! L t;)f-~ 1-.1( tJJ_;( JfJ ~f S ~f tf v! t;)~JPi I( tJJJ! )Jf tJ;~ ,f u 2... L~ Vf -I ..:-j.j ~ t;)~JPi v! v~ Jf..&:f )Jf
~j
..:-)yI
f -~
?-, tf v!
23
J"IP ~y j.JI{
do ~ ~,
/
..,y ~
..,~j ~
U~V,/ JG"u.. L ~JPi
rV L u.".:, 2... L ~y ~,-~ -v!' J~~':;"?.JfL~A~j
Ui.? .JJ'uk
L uiu.. .JJ'u_,:..~ ).tl' J ..::;u, .JJ',~ .Jy( ~'.tf; U'~
.r ~
/ J{'~j;'~' L u~ $ o'J L.t1~~.JJ L~' j ~iv~L uiy j.JI{
2... ,;-' L fJA
J
~l?
SIf"~
v! ~, U f t{.
r~t,,_. ~
'-?: '1(]1, ':;".JI{J[ v!.JJJ J'k.' v' -,-.I J"IP ,-..(G (I) -1v.: JG" L Lf .:.)'u .:;.,~'j'L v' .JJ'c,j u J,{ j.JI{ tt' j ~ : u~~ "'~S~y.J JJ c,j / J[ v! I:}VJPi j J; ..::.JJ.- u;1/ ~ v! UV !LJ.JIJ,J,{ -2... L ..:.JIP Sud / 'v.:
.J~,f L
J. ,,; ~
-1UJf (.;J/ .JL..:,} L
v'
S
.JL..:,} y. U~·':;".J.i' c,j v.:, ~ ':;J
1~.J
J1~Sud9
uk .JJ',fi y.!LJ~'
.JJ'UJJ!':;J
If v! c}VJPiU'j'~
uJy. ( J.) .JJ..:::;u,
v' _(fI664) e}/ ;? ':;".JY
u/JJ-~ £ j;}f
.JJ'J~j~
v.:, ~
~..v, .JJ'"';'.Ji
s U.JJ'JIPo;: i;;i Suy.j '-t' v! ..:.,.G".JS'-/ JJ~
J.j~~rJ LifLv.:"U:~v!"';'.JiV!Uv!L~7 J[~,~, .JJ'.:;.,;; uilb/. v! b--J L UV !LJ.JIJ,-~
Y.
L uiJJ
J~
fI751",~S.:;.,i J.) v,-t{..:.)'u
v' (:)Su~ ~
.t1 J'!G""'
.JJ'to:<;
~'j' J.}_;~ L ud~
v! c}VJPi"fV ~L h,/ L J{'v! V'.JA v!
~ '-.J{ j V.!'
fi
r -,-f .J.t;:. ~ r f if- v.: JG" (2)
ct-V.!
S"'~v! f1757 J[ -r' -t!~uiJJ ",k-- .Ji j.JI{ .:;."p. L v' ~ ~ L v' -~
~ .:;.,i ",k-- ~ L
L
'-)J'
j.JI{ ~ /
J{'L
~
24
-4-Jf{;.v Lf '-~'--U)I/
)IP 15~
LcP"~
15uj~
L cJ' .IJ' '4-J J!i!-j "'sr' ~, "' ':;".JJ/ L U';' i ~ ~ ...t ':;".J~ 15O~ .:;.,~'j' L ~j fi '15 k'" J!~j .:;.,~'j'~, eJ'-- ~.Y...) L V' )C 2... L L~ J; JI L v' cJ' -Lz J! ~,j' L v' i O'z ~j 15J{ ~ -...I f '-.J{ J~ ...t f1773-1/..:::"' uj~ ~ L U';' 2... L Lf,.J{ / .:;.,~'j' 15Jl1JJ'...t J~J 15f1770-ifJ ,--'(j r Lfr3 ~.Y...) ~ J'b...t '-J / J{ J!L~J;L V' -,J (j.Jf .:;_j'u .::j r~ /.JJ .::/;
eJ fll '--ur~.1
tI-;v' -S ,-f
L
If( 2... L Lf
{;GJ r cJ' J{
J{ (./ v' .JJ' (3) -t!YI"' (fJ
~ ~ /-"~, ~, -£ 4-J
-r' ..f£'~
(rILJfF ~j~,
Lv' cJl/ L ur~.J '-- '::J 15 -0'"tf..:;.,j ok-- ~ J ~ If f (i ~ -"~, l;;' J ';;'J V' ..:lIb l$Yt,.. J! J/ f'k.' / J{ 0:' ~, -'.JYI,:,L'J Lf cJ'; ;-v L v' ...t ....a: "po 15J{ v?- f tJ, cJ'; '-- u~ ;Z .IJ' 'uJ.Jr .::.v"J'uJ.?C cJ' i ...t v' 2... L ':;"~.JJ/15J{ y. £ J!.Ir .::.v"JeJ...t cJ'-'YI o;;'G '-- .:;.,)i -£Lf cJ' LYI
(.J
(r 2... L J{ y. £ d-' .IJ' JtJJ Po L V' -£ 4. J r .J? '--.:...:? 15d-' L J{ JJ y. Po L J'iJ ...t ~ ~
LuflcJ'-LYI.I?
'-z~r Jf.lJ"Jf A(~,::')v"Jo.Jf);...t
J!....;)I} ,ij / uJ:t_)i ~ '15?i~JJ':'< ~ J!L'J ~J )"t,.. r uJJt "";iJP L ..JJ;)' ~y ...t -6. 15OJ? (4) t! YI;-v L J{O..t~j '-- -r') .:;.,'p. J)i L do f £ ~ .JJ' k
-J!
_;j "'Jy' .JJ' £ ~J
-4:.. ~
0' .IJ' k J..I? '--...t
cJ'-4:..
25
f ~I ,r
j l,r
tr v! cP'JPz J"J !J?' .JJ' ~
A,GJL VI .JJ' JfJh#' ~jtJ,
S,Jf L
Vr.
.A~I
r ,Jf ~
i!JJj L
<liil
v! V;tY ~}i -£ JI' Jj 4 v./ JJI J?til".v! c.dl -i!
.::J L ~1l-.f <:c.d!T 11rtf ~jtJ, S,Jf 1./f J~~" ~
.r JJI£c,e.-{v';~LtJJ(jJAy.fL~
JJI
'r L vI "=,,,1e: L eJI'£ (J,/ ~
fJh#' ~I'f
'-J)~
vI
L ~'y..)JJI~ V,?jtJ,.»!L JIJj L.::/;
S,Jf fl) c.d OJr JI uP-:J! L :t?'.JI ~ e: vI -Lir ~
1~"J} ~J,I ~jtJ,
S,Jf ~v L ~y~ f~
.tf .::/jtJ,
(5) -~11P
,
-J!; c.d ~ JJI
~J.6. IJ~
JI.~Sv;l' £ TJ
I,)!
~ /~
..u.- L V-tt~ e: L l;) '-i' I,Jf Jj L V)( eJIJJJL vI'- ,;I; J £
v!,Jf c.d' ~ e: VI 'I) ~fJ(jJA li~tJZ S v/i ~jtJ, v! ,Jf _y)I 0..(6~ vI "IJjL V";I j !...
L JL~}
e,,,.
L ~jtJ,
..:kP S ,Jfu s» c.d ojl;;1r vI IVJj~ JJI VJ;!jLIJ Lf J'ko' f! -:j -?J ~ Sv'-V] TJftr IJI~' J) ~ v!;" (~~,.;J. f" t ,J.,.f'£ (6 +!' j;fJ '-.Nt &, L J[ I,)! JJJ ..:&..:1 'Lf )f'J ~ eJ' c.d' i..v"~ ~JPz u I) C~~ rVJ;!j L
fl) -:v!Jril L eJ'.J:.~'-/ Lil ~j~,
JJ
_I)
c.d JC I,)!~~,
fr ';-, uf'V] TJ Li JJi ..v
JJ''Lf
J /. J! ~.:;....v'
v! l:I,jlS eJ' .»! L ..:kP v! Po '.I.~JJI 'tJJi..J 'tJi:) J,I 4 £
';-,-:'I tJ/ ~/
JJ
Oi ~JyI
L bi' J ('
J~t1" V~JPz
)JI ~
~v L
VJJI-£
Lir ~ JI' J! J~JPz
J) -:,:..}I '£ L; c.d f L l:IjJI fr
'L V~I
if' Llr l:IjtJJ{ S eJ' '£ LilJJ/
26
~ L t:)'~.r/ v' Jj ;>y ~ 1"Ylrr ,; J~~V:>'):.-.:2... v' ',J .IJ'8~{ ~):.-':v!JJ..LLtlv!.I'ti' / J[-LJ.~ Yl.l'ti' ~ v! Jy.J J~.1 jJ( y. p. L L) L ~ J'" 1"Yl 4f ~..4r'Yl~ V J'"~ e.J~JJLfr v:>" v!.1 ...;~ v! ufo. v! ~r y. .IJ' r .::.-1{ ~ ufo .IJ'Yl~, J 1:1"' v! cP'JP; .J(' L~ V'('i / /V..' I! -YlV'r ):.-':4f L4-..4rV'v!.I'ti' .IJ'~~ LJ[-J:_ eJ P. L.::,I,,;; 1"tJ~ J r cP'JP; J' v! JJ.. L U}y Jj •• ." ~i.J~ A , .IJ, ut/:/ -~.. '-'r Yl IT JP;.IJ,....~ ~J .I",".' i,.p~ ;;'-.1 ';- ~ fi~ k L .IYltJ.IJ'J'J.I'~.I;J/ r dG J:J ~/ ,-J~ v! "'" L u[..Ii ~~, JvJ 8J~ 1"Lr ":)J V' v! cP'JP; j .r -J L >'15 v' (j ~.LYl Lf t:)$J~ J[ ):.-.:2... v' -~ ~ f r ~.1 rO ,;-' j '-/JJ JI rI-'f- ~YlrVI- V:>' P. L .::,1,,;; 1"UYl 4f .::.-tl~ .J.'~ v:> dG .I~J} .IJ'y. (" oJ ~,..(£-'f-.I..J:1 ~ dG J L -!}fJ'j...;r j.IJ! .IJ'Jy;r ...Jr j.li. v! ~, y. 1"'~ (jtJ. L J[ tt' .IJ'v! J~~ .::.-~'-1'~~, v:>' cJ!jtJ.q 2... v' -~ .:5L L cfL }.Jr t:)'~ -?J V' _tJ CYl~~~'JLf O.l{ .::.-... 15~jtJ.
v:
.
¥
_tJ _;,j;I ~
dG
t:)'P.J:.IJ'..!.r./Ii' 4- (jtJ. L J[ v! .IJJJf...C~'1"Yl -?J if.. ):.-.: rI-~~, ~~~'JLf if1'::)JJ 8J~j~ eJ~jv! '::'-.I~fi 8J-~ dVJP/":,,,'1"1/YlcfJ r~ v' ~, .IJ'1/Ylf'"AX;'tfk-- r J[ ~ L .::,I,,~'..J:I.lJ' Jr J....; v! ~J.ILv' j ''f-jI ~; (j v:>' { eJ 1"~ ';' ~, ~ r v' L f r / uJC'P.J:~ J[ L V' --t.lj 4- .IJ''IY 'i.:L!' cJ!jtJ.L V' ":,,,'-1/Yl..JI.) J'i 2... L U"",~JP;
27
.; U".jLJ,L
J[ -t.lj L
.::kiJ.#I cJI ,Jt)!.IJ.I.1'J -i:- -VL L )J'{)J
fuI;!.; U.ttl:l·o..t-.I/"'L "'/
vt! '::'-.11{J f,f OJ
tjJf;:t. tj..v.~=
tj..v.~,JcJii .IJI'L v:.f J:J.; ",.::.-?.1 'L",/ ..:..-:!I-L 'Li .7.C~./I./ f t::... C" (~'),. _ '" ~I? _ y L.k ~ ., ,U'-' ~.IC (6) -L",/
=~ =
t:P'.v;.z s»v:! --:~ JI cJI'} Ji",,j},J '::'-.11{J[ ~I ~ gl OJ J'. if. ft) JL! ~ .::.-~ -L~ 1/ A~I ~I.; VI Lf e: ~ L.::kp .IJIufo. .I1J'-.Nt if' L J[ J'. ~I ,,?fi'tl. ~ L J[.I'i:- T.I '-J .IJj.; Lf J'IP ;:Ij J.l1{ J'.1:P'.v;.z .IJI yi'}L" itl J'...:..--k-- e: L ;:Ij J.l1{ ~ .I1J'-.Nt .IJIcJ!jLJ, ~;..j J'. ~ fi OJ '" -?J ,J~ .L J} .::J L.::.-~ L U';I Jii L J[ J'. ~I .IJIt:P'.v;.z ~ '" ,1784 I.JJ .s: ~f v.! .lUi/I
tl
rr;
"J
f ,J ,yIL J~ _;i j.lJ!
'" .»l L
VI
-!v.! !ri r J'. U~
-LV J'.;cJI Lf J'IP .::.-I.I~IL
s.
U~
6
OJ
=
,.:.! L ..:J!J"If"~.; t:P'.v;.z L UJ~ T v:! J( v .IJI'J( LJYl..:J!J" = -tJ~tj~ i... L ~.; L~fi v:!1 -1(f '} J.f'l ~J.A! _;iJV L C':tyv tj)U,./.~ i... vI 'J( L L L.~
un
=
"'.I" ~ -Li f cJ'. 1/.1 J'. ~C ,J t:P'.v;.z Jyl LIJ Lf ..:J!J" vI ,J..:J!J"-J..:J!J",J.I1Ziltj)Uu L J'. tjJlji ~,J ,1857 .J} I)Zil tj~ L t:P'.v;.z JI fk"1/ ..:,.t bU I ,.;~ vI", b.lC
ur.
-1(f
(*?'" J} ",I.IJIif~i
J tjv v:.J.llil'" tjv v:.Y)".."~ ~I L (Vanina) ~IJ Jluf f t::... '" L" i..lj (/J.I./ vI J'. tt.::.-y;i .IJI ~Jk '~i.IJ:?J'. cJI -v!' ":"')J,JU? Yo f v!' ~~.1 OJ ') ~ .»l L ';.
..
y
..
v~
28
J,.P IfUJ~
JJ J:i~ .IJ' 'JIIJJ' Js'- ~y ~, L uP.l.:)y Lf tP 1(YJ!J:If1.:)' _;.IJIf..:J!7 (f UJ~ L ur.s;v! V:-~IfU,¥ .IJ'U?-y' J'. ( 0/JJ -J.f 1):.0' L I.:)'A .IJ' L'j.l~ .»l L uP. {:.1I.:)} .IJ' ~ ~.::J c... ~ ~ .IJ' J .I~ ~ f'i- j; ~~ 1f.lY- J'. ( tJ/! 4tP "'r""" {:./I c... -?J ()f -v ~...». -t..Af ~ 1.lY- .IJ' vi.::.-fpjj.#, -t..Af L ~~rc... uJ~ f.; J:i v' cMJ.- ~ -i:.. OJ) ..J}c... v' OJ~) c... ,:,-/ ,J. s: IIJ) ..J}~ ..J/ _;c... ~ Ifv' -.f.f ~ ~ L Ifv' f -OJ d c...' L ";,,tJ. L u;J 1.:)' 2... v' 'tf~;.I~ (lSi .IJ' L ~ L'".. L ur~.1
1.:)' -~
fJ
c...~;
=~
cJVJPiJ,'i- LYI":"1f'
if.'i- ~ (i' ~ rt:i.JL..:J!7 (7) -, YI ,f-
t
J'.?" ~ L J'J) f I~JJ:.{ L v' .IJ' .1':.0'O)U,/. J'. dV'JPi lr r cJVJ~ Po L J'J) f f'i- V.')L c... v' -'i-L~ II.'J
v
=
JA.J' JilV' Ifv' ," (j.l J'f ~ ~ I,j.l.tf Ifv' 'i:.. 'i-.I":")
Ifv' '';~.1~ f YI ,-.I ,-.I
r~ rJ~ o:~Lv' 'v! .:::...' L -.::/f o~ v' '';ilV r.1':.0' J'. '~r1 J.,;I; l.,:..iJIp L ~JPi '-.I'J'
~J
'UP
,
~ .IJ'~
.IJ'
J~
~
(j.l
.,:..iJI., 1.:)' -"
L U_,), -~
Jr. 1 I;}.' J d"' J'. ...». '~);;I' 1 ur'.1 c... u~ 4'~1~, ~ J (fk-- L if.fJ,J Jf. 1f~1.1
.IJ' ~"'
.IJ'lJ~fij b~
0:.'
If1.:)' -'i- If~ of'", ~ v' L J'J) L u}.Iy' L ~JPi l:#. J£''i- k' c... ~ J'. '-.I~ L J'J) L uJ~ J.IJJI' L :;? J: {f% ~, If):.0' o{:/I.I; (f' ''( ~ ~ I.:)~I &D L v' .IJ J'J)
r
IIJJ'. if.f 'i-
Jf,~~L
~,f ~JPi L U_,),2... v' -JL~
29
lk..f ~.I1 J' L J'Jj .IJ'VI is.f cf. ~J.I ::,.J,.'J,,-J'Jj L~ J'" ~.IJI J'Jj ,y"J!,,~ ..;(;2...L~.::J p.L~JS('1707)~j J,JJ' S L.fF lu~ '!f.lJ]fluJ)J' J'~.1L U;'jl,; .IJ'oc« OJJ' S , .1,,1; ~ O.lJ]fS ~~.1 'J;.:;,~v! OJ'.:;,j~J J'JI,;.1 ,~, "- J) .IL .;.,j uk .IJ'J!; J}~.1 ~ OJ f 4-J 1 0'):' e~ .s' .IJ'e~ '~J{ ~j'Yl)j ~J ~ uJ-v ~OJ j (j.l"; ~ S ~~ ~ 'v/ L ~ .IJ'~; S~, 'J..l ..; .IJ'VI.IvA S ,y' f ..; v! .:;,tJIp~, ~; .IJ'..::f;.J cP~ S~, -~Jf ~) .IJ'j(jJ_MJ!1 ~.? L~' -'f-~.1Yl!{ J'Jj f!/.' JC-: v! cfij L un j 'Yl..;j''''~ ~ OJ '1i~.1 Yl21,;L un...(C.;"-.I~.IJ.IJ'',y' J'" 'e~J~J'" £r. ~ ~ ~L.I~.IJJJI J'Jj J'" ~'.IJ_(i~.If ~ J~ 1!:pJP;&-.I{ -'f- C~1-t.fJtIb,,, ,-/Ir J~J~ &-.I{~v' .IJ''f- C~~J v! .IJ'.I{;- ~~ '~J~; .IJ:!'J~'~ f 'f- JI..:,.~-:~ (j .I~.IJ L~' -~ O.l~21,;L J.J J Jr. &-.I{ J;:j v!ur~.1St{ v! ':;"~J~J t{ S.I~ J;--/ ~j.l/ J~ -~.;J/ ~u~ J/ d~.IJ'J:~ fv.' ~ JC-: v.!"-~" VI Jr."',:;,~ O.l{S J;:; JL.,.-.., J 0) I':;"~J~J ~, v! .IJJo)lb/. "- -?JV' -~ J"I): ~.I~, v! uj~ ~I ':;"~J~J~' -v.lu~'"-~'OJ fli~1-t&-J.I'i t_,Y/2... L uj.ly' L vI .IJI(UVI J'" f 'f- CYl":"~-:-=Jr.J~L J'Jj .:;-.''&-.IIJI (8) -~ 'f-.I.f -=- ~0'v!uj~ &-/ JJL !:PJ~ "'.IC(V ~I OJ f tJ.IJI?1-: v! .::/; .IJJ':;-".::./$ oJ! v! ,1917 f J uk -YlCYlJ~ ~ ~JIJ; -=- d! £.1 L~ 1 (jlP? -VI L.f'~~' ~f~,Ii,L.f
e'",-:
vir
r
30
J'~ b.lC,:--/ I«: A. Kincaid) Jc J _~I -(j' L;.1/ L 0:(9) -~ vSL!.J ~I J: ~.I~ L J. 1';- J: VI ...f,[ I)J v.! ..::.j~I U--~.1 f
l.)J)J'
f f T 0'.1'/'
JIJj r .I~.IJ
lf
1vI
~
(j
J!i J: Jy.J~~.1 .IL)J} y. ...f,[(1) v.! JIJj ( ..::.~IJ.I.IJI ~ ~ :V'~(FI ~k--LJ'Z a.l )j /.1(UfJ f J: uj~':;-"':;-" -~ J~ J'~ (!IVI elY. L I:); I)J.lJif .IJII:); J.;:./ J: 0' _:,.IJI i _:, I..::.'J! d~J'~;~ ~Jk L..::.VIP (j'k--~.1U.lW;I ( u~jJ.I rJ~~I V~ J~Jk J:.Nt~.I{ VI -V.I~ LU_";I
Vr
J: uiv I./.,.il .IJII./.J.lI)I"~
J~Jk
19 .IJIIs/l:P"Jk (;)1
J:'/
T.I
~J
(i s:T V~
~I
L (H. Goetz») / !;(fi
&" V' ~:frVI J: t\:)~
( ~_;;;
J:~ ~ L ..:/;.J cP J'~ ~ uiv J; 1.::)1;t J: uiv JJ(;)1 y. f L./ v.! .Ii...J) J' uJ~ VI .IJI~ ~
-i:. :f~~eJ ,
uiv I./.,.il .IJII./.J.lI)I..:/;. J cP J' &" vI Jl 'jj(Jy. .I{ ;... (i V -!Jy.".lf J: I:P"Jk L LJ'Z/-ii v-" ... ti .IJIJl,i '.Iiy_~JJI '~J • .;:.'" / ':;:.P'.IJ'ZJJ
Vf~
cf ./jl--,I
Ji 1..::.JJI eP" .I~I"::'.IJ,II/} LIJ
v:' y. f ~cf./.I~I
J» v~I" .IJIJ;t VI (i J~'JJ) (i VfT Ci_, J: U;;/ i~j) L.Nt VI "V' (i V~~~ lJIf I.lJJ U?' L ",:"JIjy .IJI / r;;J/ ;:_I J: .IJJ(j'I ~". J ,_J.I IJ1 cf./ ..JJ \"
~
Y
S--,j J.~y. f ~cf
-
~,_:,. ~.:::;?
VI
r.VfJf
31
S
L ~.JI
I,)!..J VI ~~IJ.J (!/I .JJI. r'J.J~I f'iJ '-'-
L JIJ)
y
.JJI",:-,IJ;",:-,JII,)!
. ~ ./...; .. ,..1.si lf~. ~·7 f.:,llJ./ " .- v r -.. V.. '"'y "
V"
.I" JIr
.J:.";' i .;
J
uk-- uv ,-,-,..il
J!)JJI L 'bJ/ J uA S.,:;,~ j~J~,fl
JI~I
'V1.JIJJI (10) -\.i.t
d~Yofly;
JJA I,)! .J~.JJ I.)~)/ f
-: ;.. ~
J'"
( JIJ) L .J~.JJ
JJ$l,)!l.)r~.J.JJlujL"~/JJL~J~JY;JI);
U}.Jy 'uJ.Jrv 'uJ.J~ r' 'uJ/";'
~.f.'-J!~I;
",:-,I'v!'
-S(f {/ Sf.:,llL
..:.v'~.J f.:,l~IJul,?,
J!fyl LIJ LJ (f {/ SuJ.J(..:.v'J .JJI .JJIV~; ~.::).,j LIUflf.:,llLJrLL)JI·
.JJI;,..1.1 'e:...
L2...Luy(J! Yoe:.../- )JI IJy/,,;.
)? L JJ)
~
e.f( f.:,ll.t!;L ~
L
~
I,)! U}IJ LJ
~.f.'f.:,ll-40-J ~"';y
d )JI Ji. .Jrv J'" )? 'L r ~ ~
I,)! I.)r~.J ~Jf-'.Ju.Jrv
.r ~
~J
SJrL J.}l vI
,,1J' 4 u/.'A11r- L (~vlr J!.;)}~
(11) -I,)! u.tJ!.JJI
.JJI't3
If.! ./~~
I,)! ~J~
~){
.JJI'~I)i)
'"
-e:... ~~
I,)! L~fiYo ';-, p}'l J.Jr..:.v'J
~I
'~j{ I,)!U;'-~.J-1.1 U.J~ ~)?
L I.)r~.J )JI I.)j~.j"I
s:7- ~
~~ ~
-e:... T.J if2' {)JI
J'J
-L; -r~
J .JJ).J~J.J(r uJ'?'C
2... 1.1'" Jt SI.)fJ.
vI e)I.tl (
J; S)~J)(
)I)~ ~ Uyt ';-, fyl
f~~U''''I,)! ufll,)! ..J vI .f" (il ~~-:eJ~) J!~ vI J.,? ~ ....; t J!-" ~ tJ, I,)! u;i1f.!1 L ~Ip. ~ -£ T.J Y; ~I./I
L uJ).;:§
J~ .; )"
)JI
uJ.f'Jir-'u;~
'U~ I,)! if. " ~~/.I
I,)!,_r (~
d~-£ L~ 2... L ~)~) L )~I t.f~ ~ .;UJ)!7 'e:...
I.ff
-L 'f-) y;....c;i
r vV
tJ!1. Yo fr)~) /Jl' ~f ~
32 )Jf ~fJi ~Jf
cJlJ..-'" )Jf
'~Ly) \)J)f';
~!ti r )Jf ";,,JJ. d'~f
'f- C~If2...
. .
-r);iJL~~~
1. Marshau, P. 1. Trade and Conquest. Aldershot 1993,P. 30 36 -i./ : "~f
2
41-i./:"~f
3
103 -i./ : "~f
4
5. Rizvi, A. A.: Shah Abd al_Aziz. Canbera 1982,P. 236 6. Metcalf, T. : The Ideologies of the Raj. Cambridge 1995,P. 23 7. Vanina, E.: Ideas and Scociety in India: From the Sixteenth to the Eighteenth Centuries. Oup, 1996, P.148 8. Gordon, S. : Marathas, Maraudens, and State Formation in Eighteen Century India. Oup, 1994, P. X 9. Goetz, p. 6, 7, Quoted by Panikar : Culture, Ideology, Hegemony. Delhi 1998.P. 38 39 _i./ 40 _39
:.1J~
10
J~
11
_i./:.I
33
UJ~ ~ '-.J~LdV-Jk L'.JJU.iV-Jk~'-.J~L..UJ~.JJ' Po L LJ1 (i L )_t;I .JJI.::kP '~~ ~I
J'. cPJPz J'dl s;vf .I~'t -: OJ JC' e: C;.v L.I JJJ,- jlr. JilPIL ..:/f ~I ~ JjV I.JI_t;I VI L U";I (j _:, .JJI'fJ' 0 ..:.::? J' ..:/f -'f- k"J"~~.Jj L~ ..I: .JJI.J~ '.J~I ok-- J'. dr;,.JPi f 1 -: i J'J -f1 J' ~~r~I 'uf-vJ'. L~ 10"..1:-ti ~J.lJ~/. dl-- J t,;J!r run L uk L 0" .lv..JL~}..J) /i L ur. ti ;-~r Ui.JIJ;;.JJIuhJ.J'ui~ 'u,.Y .JJIu:;/lj J'.url.J -u:;( _:,.JJIi;_);;I' J _:, '- uP L d' -1,J: -1,J:.Id~I J~jJ'uX LUJ'?'C.JJIUJjl,.-oL uP .; U!J.JJ:~Lun L ~ '::"'.J~J'~ (~.JJI 'J':/. '.J~I vI i Li .::,.,1$Ji J:~~ 'I~ Jj .; .::,.,liW L Lh; L d' '- vI 'tJlj _il ~Y'.JJ _il r U:;J'JV.JJIu;lt! 'UJ,6 'UJ.JP -J ~ J'. .::,.,lni L un ~ J'::"',i -V'!:1'tJ J'...Y J'un (~/,yl L O'Y J'~ -1/4t/, 4~~ '-&I' U/./tl .JJIUJj J'un L .; J ~ ~J'. .::,.,tJ~d' f 1J'J J' ..:/f u~ 2.. vI L .::,.,~Ij J' d' Iun.JJI 'k",.Jj; r J. _:,j; L U";I i LJ1 J'!i L
L)J~
v:-
34
-if~ r,;;.0' I;)f J 1;(' J./,bI'
-...fl L
I;)~JPi t,J!
J'L f~
cf
~ "' t:f!_/ J.} L ~ Vi;
r?
Yo f
':! Yo f~
:J!~' -...fl ~ uJ;)i
j' -.r";'; u ':! -15
J 15 v' '-
,-:!'; -.r";'; At~
v' ~~ Yo t,J! J; .JJ' ..:l~15 L -.r";'; V' -,J 2.... v' l-.r";'; v' ;t.- ;-L,-o L -'f- CJ1Jl.?' ~..::/;. I;)~ V' '- uY!tJ..# J!:~,u f 'f-) v.: JG' V' L V' f'J1 J'Jj ~J
~J
J
)J'
~)'J
(5)'J _.j ':! ~I I)J-..;f' fL!;.I t,J! V' ~'~
s
J~L~ IVI '-h. ~~I LJ1
(i..J/ _:, l-.r";';
.:..;:? 15 ~}J L -.r";'; ~ VI u 'f- 15 uJ;)i Lf)LJI ~..:..1J~ 1;)1-tJ/ ~IP 15 VI )JIvtl(- '-
.V' )JI~f ~f (~I ~VI 2.... VI -'f- ~.:A
J'L rI;}VJPiflf
L
J...I: J J) t,J! 1;)11 '~fJ_.J( I1;)' -~f ~ & .::J L UJ}J' J ..:..1'J) 15 j.{) )LJI ~..:..1J~ L (' vI (1) 'f(5)~ 2.... L .::/;15;)i ~f 'AP- fif t,J! J,iPJ' 1;)1L j);/r ..J;~. (Richard Congreve) I.) "'{I
v.:
':!
v.:,-tJ/ ..:.J\P 15 vI
u.Jt
L)J'';-
(2)-v)f..J'p
L -.r";'; v' f~
(5).Â¥'
._f ~I -L~ 'J1';;;'J '-
'f- ifL'p
,-I
L UJ;)iI~JPi L
1"'-Jj~1 I;}VJPiuf
v.:
(J
JI
2.... L LJ1 ~)'J ~ -.r";'; 15 I;}VJPi C:)C 15 vI )JI v!~15 ~.,:..L,lv I.)! "-)~
U)){) 15 UJ?'C)JI'uJ!i 15 uti" 'uY~r
L Up~.,:..L,IP 151;)1
J'j u,-' j CJ1v,..J tJV t,J! ..:..L,IP 1;)1~ -v!' JJA ._f I)J-i:.- J~U) LL)I t,J! ..:..L,IP 15 1;)12.... vI -i:.- ~ f", JL L ~JPi Lf ,y;--' It')j J"; L U";I Po L L; t,J! AZ1' -St;J/~ "'
'-
..:..I)~
JJ
~JPi
,-I ~
J~
j~~(fL,-oy._f
~I
JI) Yo(f1746-*,1794):/Yo (-J
3S
f'(' "',j.'v' OJ P. L ,.,!IY L cJ' -" ~J '- L)i~;.n' (}w pL e: LI,;.' r" v! JI.-- Jf .JJ',J...G '",:"J' J L L)~~J~ v! cfL J.J~ t./cJ.u IcJ' 'M 'vt ~~ ,J Jp J'J J v! L)J.-tJL cJ' -~ ,J f1780.JJ'fI770..i';(; L .::.-tJ!f>cJ' -vt.J.s}f L'7 -:L Jt' T v! ~ ,J cfL P L ~Jk L ~ cJ.J'JJ7-;.J/ v! L)i~J
r r
.
r
-~ ~ ./41~ 4&.
v! '-.J~ L c;? ,J cfL L ~J~ i.J'" ~.Ji .JJ':0 '- L.) if.fLf LYI L./A.;' r f'7 ~yl.-- L L ~J~ v.!' '- L.) ",' 'vt T.J./ c;?"'~.JC,J (J.J.JJ'cJti P -T '::'-.J~,J LtJ v! If J.J,J ~./ J(i '- L)I PJ L elL I_J P JLJ~;(j I'::'-~'J.J,J cJ' .JJ'cJ~ J -:&i P'- JJV v',J cfL (3) .s,£ ~1£ J.J~ IJ' L J; .-t"'r"J~,J ~..J:i Pv' .JJ' v~ ",k-- v!;:---~ L (j j:? .JJ'c;? J ~ -: . v' u frJ J.J~ -: e: L L)J:0 i..L L./ ~; "c);-'Jk -~ 0: ~ '- d"..J J .::.-'~ ,J L)n.JJ' 'lJ -:&i ,J v' 'b.JC,J ...t. v' i..L d,IP Y v! '-.J~ L c);-'Jk.::J L ~ v' -L)YI ~'J ~J~ v~ L~; JiU,./.'- -:tJ,J do fl LV'-J/ L ( J;I ,J djP cJ' -flYl6 JlP7 rV v! '-.J~ L L)kJ .JJ''L)j~ J;I L '",./ Jj--t,.{ 2I.--LL)~~J~ufI/YlcA---; -:i..L~; (4) -",/f~ ~~JJ",="".J r..:/; .::{"cJ' .JJ""'/ Jvr'.::{v.!' i5'J L L)r. f ~ LtJ. '- L)y!J.JI;~' Jilb./. ~ Jilb./. ;; J~ -..f1-: frJ J!f> -: r;;-" ,J f~~ o,jtJ' ~ -..f1" L)JJ~ 'f-?- r "':""1'" J~ Yo v! V' .JJ''f- J.J~ .JJ'~ (:.,~, f Yo T ~ (W. Robertson)
cf ";"/.'.1 ~J
..t.",:,
"J~
36
~ '{ JIJ; L,;}
S U~J.J-: .JJI'( ,-JJA S VI ~
I» ~";;J
1.5/ JJ-: r.,J
S VI
-s~
J~I.5J-: J'J ~ S tr.J (i ".J} ~ L VI J~ S VI j f- J~~ (i ~.Jj L/.-.JJI.;:,j J.j L,;} S U~ -'f- ~ ~ J(j l.5ilh/.I.5.J{.:.GL?S if.f'f-" 1.5~ ~~I
s:~ L~Jil! -: LIJ LJ Jj v! ~
I.5J.J
s:~_~J~JiL(j v!
.JJIJfiv!Vl_,J
(g L.:/; 1.5:c.fr ~";;J
-: J'J .JJI:l.1:)'.J/-i v!
l.5ilh/. .JJI;~I JJ.J
VI
~ "UJJ~Ji ;~I
-,J "IY" ~
J~
S~
l.5ilh/.
VLr 1.5:c.fr eJa. (u;_. " U-"~J~ L J~I d-
L--:~LIY,,~ vl-k"2...LJ~Iuk" v! dVJPi .JJI~J ~JtJ,f Un L;b.JJI
ftf
;;j'.LU~I
I.5J
J;i'J"" v! d~J~ -~J tJ,( f .;:,IJt,;;J :::-1 L, I~I -
y
~
,J LI.J -: St JI v.. ,-}Lr l.5ilh/. 'v! '-.J~ L ch l.5ilh/. ~' -:,.1£ 'f- ti' ~ rf. JI .JJI'U~ 'ud~.:/;.JJI(lSi ~ d'
f
"J~ vI -'f-lJ'.J ~ -t.Jf'.JJI-r;'" ~I
L ifJI;i
~ .;:,~if .;:,~~ii
-S 'f-.J (i~.:/; -: "L)J.JIJI.JJ"::;1h .JJIJ,~ (Wi l.5ilh/. v! J~L J}1P .::.v-{.:/f...~ v! U~
Jd f ~ -'f- d ~2... L ~J':/;-:2... vI -'f- (i
J) .J} L.:/; ~}Lr J~J~i i JI,; L.:/; l.5ilh/. f ,J ~Y -: (5) -S L~ I:)'. f? ..:)JJ;~I -: ~ f'(Li .::JJ~ .JJIL ~ t:{f .;:,~~ii fr; ~~J.-:f UJ:c.fr~ ~ Li v! d~J~ Sdlv!~Ji
_r;I~~p!L":'!,,~Ji
~IJ
-:-L~k"J~
k"r f ~J.Jf' S I.5JI;iS d' ~.Jj L .;:,j .JJIJ~ P f,J
-:~~
37
L
~1J;,o Lil ~,f-I
v!y; JJI? Yo....;~L UJJl uk 2_ VI -L~
L~ tfJ~i I Un ~J", U~JfVtf.J~I :t,.:zJ.) Y JJ-V~J J( P! .JIA (Ii fly; :t ;. ( v' -u/,J~ I IjJ~i--';r( S J:d;i OJ _rr
S J vI LJ:d;i -7-".1 J;i
.J~( J 1:)1/ f ~:l cf. ~J", I:l- fL!;: d,j ~I 2_ L ((;-1 L.::/; '-t' Lt~~ii L U~I
"'J~
~JI? Lt 1:)1.JJIL~ SI~ Ij)u uV J .,:..fU,I Lt un L ~J ~.Jj L
.. dVJ.kiOJt:::-j;~JJ2
-L~ .(J.JI ~L}.; L
.J_,f. ",~J";:.JJ...;j;# t:::-~~J~iilj/JJI
.t'; '-t' eJ fi),ft:::-j;~ vI 2_ L L
,Jt :t r/ S J:d Ijj~ ~',.vI 1:)1 I:)'VJ.ki 2_
~~rv'-t' I vI .JJIL~
vI
'~.?iJ.,['Ly;
-,_;:f .f J> Lt I:)IrJ.kiI
tf J~I I ~I.JjL vI fi)
IjJ~i
c:C y; P e.tG
-L~tf J~I Ij~ .J,P: 2_ 4-J
e
ot JJJJ:t Ly; z.),JJjr ~~YoJS~~( .JJI '-t' Lt dV J.ki
Ji J.,[ Ly; e J ":"'~( 2_ vI f :l .s: Ly; L!/. t:::-I:)I ot Lt J.4 .JJIJv f:t.J:.7 -~ ?'.JJI ; /. t:::-u~1rJ.kiOJ "' nb
P
OJ
OJ
I:)/eJf~.f
t,v ~ :t L U~I i t
y; ~
.::/;
S 1:)1~ 2_ vI
.f ..::/; ~"' ~ vI OJ t:::-JA S I:l- f y; ~~ IJ I:)I.JJIJII t:::;; fi) :t -f' t:::-Lt (j 1:)1 :l f[_ ~ ~.,-v YoLt j...l.. vI -,_;:f
-L 1..1.1.JIJGJ L..::/~ OJ Lt ~.JyI v' i L~~ !;: J~ IUJ?IrJ.ki
r
:t ~ ( Ly; "':""i-' tf Li ot ~tJIY':t Lt J'J.J LvI f 1:)1 .::J L ~tJ~ ~ L v;:.f.,:..fU,I ~ S vl.f /. ~I I .::/; ljiU,/. OJ f'(
y;
y; uLi"' ~JI?
OJ ~
f'( Li
OJ
':::;'J-f'.JJI
J~
y; Jj?
Ij)JliJ
-Lv!~
S
38
jiJ uh!..; J:r- v.. ~JPz flll/:(..i -:,.'4J.) Y JJ Un ~ -L~1~rIJ~; Sun (" ~.Ij L uJ..; d' .IJ' ~~ S . .J-I.-- ~ .::/; .f YIp~' OJi Ja.r JIP ,J) .IJ' dIo' J~' v..J~j S ..::-IP~' \.{~
-LILJ
~~ S'~ v?Lz S U-"'J~.f dJ~ v.. dl;---JPzfl) -:,.'4J.) y£ S v' f 1.)'./.::.(,l7S v'",J~ v' .IJ' J jy. ~.::/; J~ C;, u JC' ILJ / ,-.tij .IJ' '..::-".!I"~~' J!J} v..";" L LIV 1U.I/. ..Ji';;1 rfi~'wf'.IJ' e: Lit'.10:), .IJ' '.zC'-"A '-"p-j v.. d,-L Lf dJ~ ~.::/; S d' .IJ' YI~i r ~ ,-:"..1/ ~ ~ .J;~ J1j y. -,-fJA u! (F' L v' U
0'
(2)
J_,J L ~JPz f tf- cC~ l/J'y -:",>/ v' (G -'? 2... L L ~J';:'l ~~;£.1 ..::-,_/c l/v.. '-.I~L.::/;
. u:t/i .IJ' uJ:t/i
un
L d' J£J ~ ..::-~ S..::-~jl tYi ~d' 2... L d' OJ1j~ ~ ,j2 -I) CYI"';~.:A ~ ~UJ~~ L u~ ~JPz ~~ .IJ'.zCtJ.!"'v.. 2.... v' -I) CYI~ .IJ' v~ 'o-?y OJ~Luti "' ~ -LYI y~~~ 2... L un U i Li i jYl {;J} Ai v.. .I~.IJ~ S uU> 'uJ.zC'u~ :Ji .IJ' u~J I.!.JI~ _,.....IJG-!/.' J?~a~d' .IJ' .:L~v.. ~.I~ L d' v.. un '-.I~L ~ L un L v' ~.1v.. .I~.IJL Jf ~ f1582 ~ f1580 y. f ~L~~, ~
.:A ,;-'
f'~'~
:f tf-~
un
(Ii ~ -?J S v~
,;-' i LYI J'J
v..J
OJ~
v..
39
J!?- .I~ J' fi -tL ~ J/ ( I.)y;(j S
Ii c[,~
~ ,; 'I.)!'J
,-:"j J -d r.)! I.)JJt) L(
t"). -:,1'
Ji LIJ/ '-~ .nl I.)~ Ly; II:)I Ji i OZ i.J S1:)1~ ~
(6) ~~ 1:)1 oW
~
....fi .nl f!y; o~L ~ -/
y;
.::..jlJOf r.)! '-.I~ L ..::.-Lr.lS1:)1.IJI -rr..l L
SVI .IJI0)t;1~ q S"::;Ib",k--....fi J{'~I
~I
1:)1~
r.)! OV !LJ.I';I
i vi L~ r.)! I.)j~ J;/ L I:)~J~ ~j Y, 'r.)! ,!: ~i '-t' L J' ....fi J~ilI..;JJ -J!y; tt.,J I.)~I.li vg
r.)! '-.I~ L~,:,II r.)! I.)n
:,1'~!,I. '! '-.IL L I.)J:I./t .~ ./ ..::.-iJlPL v· .(v. r'J.I';I , V'*. .., ~ v·,. ,1'.Po J). £r.)! ~; .IJJ L o~ ..I ~ J~;-~ r.)! ~J~ ~ J;/ ~ (i ~ J;~ L )}I J ..::.-IJ~ ~I ,;I; J ..JtC>I L I.)~ J O.lyf SO~J~ uk .IJI a.r t.I..'
J.
-d 1:)1-!J .Itt.,J ~f('i A;t;I ~I.1';1 o.t'G ~ .;.V! .I? '""~ S~ ~. r.)! '-.I~ L I.)n ,-:"j -f;~~ ,J. 'T Jy; ~ J/ JI S1:)1f -: it-J
.::.::;I.f-: ~
':;>J S
Sif.T Ci~)
if.-T Cy;'-J (- r1:)1~
JJ~
~I
-~
Li
..J~
J1 +!' ~ S oW
,",,~yf..- ~ L~ y; ":""~( r.)!..::.-V ~I u ~':;>J
,j r.)! JL 1:)1.Po ..::.-~ -fI..J/ f -,/. ..JU;L 1:)1 (7) -~
:,1'~, ';Jf u i I~.,. ,.k,.IJ~ -Ii ~.1 (,( r.)!; ~ " I.)JJ/JJ
~
~
..J~I u ,1'-: u
..
1:)1_.;: / ~ ~
( ill
Jj S(.;-j r.)! ,..f? I:)J ....fi
r.)! 1:)1,1'~C 1 tJ"II .If L r.)! J'fl
..;JJ
40
l/.Ii L v! .s: i-.1 ~ J~;-L.-- L 1:)1 JJ.IJIi:.I1r d~ ~ 1.1' v! f~ J;Ji Ij 0:.' J.I S 1:)1 ji ~ J ~ J (!)\.J S 1:)1 .s: i-.I.1'-'~v! ~; aJ -Ii~ i:LJ141.1~ ( (' J aJ _IJ1(}v ~.1 JLil ~ f i: i-.1 ; Ji .e aJ L (- S 1:)1 ~ -?J S if. .I~ I.I~L 1:)1 v! f~fJJ !;:: -i-U.I~ ~j ~ . '-/- v!)
~I
f'/ ~ i.1.I' ~
'U} ~ d'
f
Lv!JIP_"":-i-v.! ~~-:i.LLj/ 4 IJIJ;lP!IL tt~ (JYI" ~ -l/(JY v.!' ,.I 1)1 ;-~
IUYJ'" .....;/ J (1.1' s» I:)L!I!;::,..f£c v.!
if.'~~?I? J1feJ Ii~
UX ",:"IYo~ (JY '-/- L U~I_iYo
i.L 1:)1 v! JJ '-/- ~ -?J S (8) -'/
v!
'-.I~L ui'.l; I.IqJ ,::;tJ~ L UH(~v! '-.I~L UJ:tf!
:i-l/ d~ if-L JI-..f' ot (1.1~
eft v!,.;:/~~f i-J~~~ ~I~-:~ ~ti~ L '::;.1J' 0'J i. -..f' ji Ii IJ1'/ v! ..k -..f' v!
JI~ S UH~~
oE -:~ ~
f~
OJ
f
c..-; ~ -V.! LJ1 L{':;">.IJf Yoi- JJ1 ~ UJ~I U{ -..f' ;-L.--L if. f i- LlJ I~~ -..f' L 1.1' C ( 1.1'-~ JJ1 J'j~ UJ{ '::;.JJ,Il/j U{ -: .IJI~ { U)I? L 1.1' L ~ -Ii.J:!' ~ ~
J!
S J/lJJJ~
O'Ji. ;; ~ -: -L~ ,;JI OJ j(' Ii IJ11h ;-~ 1;;'
41
f 1tj.l II'(' OJ .IJIIi IJ.:'J'- u/r ~I L ':;'.11 .I d-"'UA. cJI'::;J vI L v! J2 -'f- ~;; '-:""-: ~.1 ~ ";;;IJ~ v! -r-' J2 -Ii v! ofi v!~ fli ~ .d"VL~~II ~~Lv!v!p.J£-u~ Li JI ..!.:J tJIJJ~ S UJ{L .11'" f y.IJ.:'J v! tJi'(
.e e:« {LvlL':;'.IIOii.IJI-l
L~ (9)
:f t:;_ ~I L cJ:J (.,Iv ~/ ..., , (,/. v-,.,. ~r , r: L -li'.," ..• ~ """ tt
cJ!,l '-Z
I UJJ! r V1 Lti~ LI{
~.,.1~
~~I'~~o~~
s'-v!
~I
L U~I
-e:. L~
e:. L uyjf.,-e:. L uyjf.,J2 - s: L~ 4f L J.I '-.II ~ -e:. ~ ~ '-A t./ ...f d- JG"~ 4 uJJ! cJIJ} .IJI ~J i ~
.111
tJzv!c.f.e:.~
vV~~ ('~) Jo-d- ~-:
-v! JrJi u~i~ ScJI'- J~4v! 1ft vV ~(' o-d- y. v! ~ ~ 4f "".II (10) -v! (fiJI ~ -r-I;i .IJI
IJ'-I L uyjf.,
.IJI'~.1 C~
!"
)~I
tJJ!
'tj.l
(fz .::;~S J{ ~I
',f L.J: 4f LI.I S un v! '-.I~L
44
cJI i ~L~ )vlJ'- cJI ~ un
S cJI ~ -~ L~ k"J~ '- ~lill J .:;,~UJL tt~" cJ~~" ~I vIP -~rJi Jj v! U}JJ cJII un i I~ JIij ~u?; S ~L.lJI.::./; L uJJ!
OJ
1J.I.I~I ~;tJ, S,Jf L ur.
L cJI OJ -L~ -r-I/ '-Z '-
fjl;--w; OJ '-.Ii uy!u" OUV' S cJI .IJI'ui~ 'J) .Ii
42
...J}'" L I.)~j
15cJIL (i q.
.0' i:.
15A,) Jlj
z....f ..JJ) If
~ <.l- f ,J d ~2... L c/VJRl ..:/; OJ! ~:i L cJI-i:. if L 1.)';1Yo s:v!~ ~ ~I cJIV ;1 ~ / -~f ~flJI P ~I z£ L.tf z.):J..!;:. .:;....IJJ OJ! ~I.)P; 15J'L -15 v!Ill;!if f1866 .s,v.! L t/ 15I.)}~ ;, ~; 15;,L; vI f I.).tf~ v! ~I 'J.1Jy' L I.)~ (I'J L I.)JJRl;, ) JIv!" J.1Jy' cJIJr'I Ix
-v!" k.~JcJ}i L OJI;;(!/ )JIcJ'u;
~"' )J)f"u T ..:.v-u; YoflJ 0:.r I.)P; )/?. )JIJJ~;Tf "'~
...J.I".:;...~ J ...J?~
15I.)#J
<.l- )JIT)
J; Ll.)rJ,; 2... L (');JU! ';-, J.tf J'/ 151"';' A -I);f ;,L; 0:.", ~JRl,_f..::.. ...._... ~<.l- L~ ~ v!..:/; 15(i po JIJ~ dV'JRl f v! vI JJ 4- -.tf k.~ ~,f'cJ}i ; u~;.::/; V'
-r- J',,',J 15J~I..,;. J ox ~ ~fYo/I"';'vl ii:.J~; Ji L~..4_;j:1 )JI(i ..:/; 0:.' )J/ '~~ JRl f~ T I"';' IS' '-:' If v! ~
_;j:I
ci'i
JRl
r;
u~;Yo ,J
~f jf (i v! ~JRl (11) -.tf
f i:. J1P L vI ;'':;'''.-?JvI
If
k.~J .::/;
L ~ Y'/. YoLI) cf". (I) .-?') -v.! ~~ L JJ1'.JL".Ui 0" )JIOJI;;"'~ v!(i J! u i:. ~
e..(GIf (IiI u.:;...cJI--" 'T~)fJ;
Yov.! If') 1)1
j;? J cf? " J~I '..::.r..? 'OJI;;u v.!
v~~f-:...J.I" cJI
z....~1.)~:(.Ji -v.! JI ,;
L cJI
43
.
I.:P'JPi II.)I; I:)J.I!.,1'£ "'" L v' OJ -Vj' Lf'~ 14~O:1..IJ'
"if
S L~ .I'J'~ e'.Ij OJ...f £~,t-tJ i~~ ct:j v! S 1:)'.IJ''L 1.1./Jr r '-1.)1-"7 ir;-' -L t.ft!J.lII.:P'JPi (12) -JJ'fr~ ~ S...t.'- ~f.L# .IJ'~ v! dVJPi ,1'1/ L '.I~ ...J1 Vr'.1 .IJ' -..fl.l~' r ..:.tJ~ ~, ~.1f J? S v(;.. ir;-' I.)_;~L 1:)' -'f- Y J S'...; tr r I.)J:t/I (13) -~, tJ'f .I').p {(~ L.::/; u:t/ll cJ;--'JPi J' 2... V' -'f,1''f-I/ 1:)k:1..:.'/C L ~ j,{ v! ~.I~ L I.)J:t/I J!L C)J!, J'{ J' '- ~
-t..lf'
J
OJ
J)
:" .:;..7.1y~.::/;
.IJ'(j 1.)£2...L
1:)'
v! (jv! ,;I.j L 11'" ,,?fi J!OJ ,1'£ Lt=..J'J ~/UZ (~ r 11'" 2... L I.)hX L 1:)'.1-£ LJ'f ,~ J,* .IJ'.1}? . t'JL;. / ...]I; L.::/; rf' -') ~ .::..:;", •
~
~. -
y
J; L ~ V' "';.1' .s:~, ..:.'.1"; 4 J,;j rJ. I.)~~ rf' JJ.;k k e~ .;:.,v-"}'/' ,1'£ ;;f f v".J 0'
,j2 _ ') ..,c:.. .:;! c:r~ '-.IL ,,:.,j S I.)J'fJ) L ,1'2... v' -UJ f J; .IL,,:.,j L I.)~~ '" 0' ....f" v.z .:;;. -£ e"v 1Ji~ u}J,./. ._.1/J j(jJ.I I1:)' OJ
S 1:)'~ I.)~
eJ •••
s: ..:..l U.l{ S 1:)'£ LIJ, v.!
1:)'J!~
~J
1.f..J'J ~/-
-if Jf ,_t..; bV ) (14)-"
""';7S
..:.,/CYo v! ~.I~ L -"ti' .IJ'(~ L.::/; U:t.-"v! ,;Lj J'M' .::/; jt..a -'f- Jr-' ~V jr v! 1:)'Vj' a L 1.).iI;--JPi .IJ'I.)JJ! J
~11
S'...; ,-' 2... v' 'if '- ~~S'...; -: ,1'L'.1
-: v! ~.I~ L
44
..f,{'~,
Jf ~I ScJII~~.Jfit 4-~~
vI -!
~IP ~lP
J[ -t J1..JJ!? L ~P! ~ 1.-.; 't.f ~JGo!~ t.f ..::..7!?~ .::/; vI J[~~I'Ii tAC JIJ IJj Yo fli .:,.r~J~ -:J '-:J ~~.::/~ S J JIP Su-"~~.::/; tJ:cI' .JJI~r~v v!,y (j ~ ~ ,.Jlp L -,f J1IJI! I dVJPz LUJJI f! ~ OJ 'f- (j ~ ~~uiJJ Yo ~~ tJ/ JJ uli cJI.J~ ~ ~ c(I -~ ~ uP J) .JJIu!- ,.;1; IJ'~ c(I
J~"
ILJ18LUr. f 'f- "" ~ cJ.t f~ 'Ii~ ~I tJX2....L -~ £. ~IP ~j L.JL ~y .JJItJ!- ,.;1; v! tJv
t.f ~ -1/(i ..JI)I J J~ uk LuJJI fli ~Jp f? .JJI~
J'~.J .JJIPo L JIJl J'" Luli c1- s'f- .Jli~ Sd'j L uli
v.:,~ -?J SVI '!
c,tl
L L) L {tp,j t.f LVI jlrJPz _~rJi t(I IX~ (cJii .JJ'...;I)' J J~ v! ~ 2....v"~ e_;;L ~ .JJIJ~'~~) OJ v! J..lP L uJJI f ~Ji ~; J ~ ~v L.::/; ScJI~I 'IJ1..::..7.J y~tr uk (UJ:cI' J) L UJ:cI' OJ -L ~~ J1 ,:5~ .JJI~~ t.f jlrJPz zb...A L tJ:cI'
~
tJJljl Yo Po
,1
v.:
)J!~~vlv!dVJPz..f,{'~;£ y~(~I}IfILJ1 Jp ~cJI,/.1. L VI -~ 'f-.J L.f .::/; " uk .JJI~ 'f-.J Lr J L.::/;tJJl2.... VI! ,,'bJ/':;;'J VI o..:r..J:iS~.Ji ..f;; fli 5; L.f.J'o?' ..::.r~~ .JJI'( J1V~J.J~~..J:i ~.Ji t.f dVJPzv! 4-t ,-.f
~_L dVJPz l.JlfJI J (q L.::/; tJJI..J) ~ LtH. J2 r:t-~ J 1IJL uli t.f ..JU; L ..:-~ f 1../ f ~~, 'Ii ~.J~ Ifd y~
45
I.)!J L
v' 'J1 vd ~..::;u,
o.i{~'..::/f ~ f I.)! JrL~' ~
r. f L 1.:)' ~ ~ 'f- JJ1 oJ,;i 0)1;,J .iLJ, L .:.tJ~ I u}'JLJ. r('7 L u.(.,.iil!:P'JRl J' f'f-",/if~-UJ1 2£.i ...JJJ;>, LU~J/ Jj.f ,J 1.:)' .iJ'.l. ,J u5.ii r. f i:.. Jr.,;' J_,J ~, '" ,;
t~
r
~ IUJJ') uk-- L 1.:)' I.)! DJ" tt!i; d!'" ~C( ~, L ur. i:..~, c.;.;.i~ ('.i jb L OV
'-lJ.ilJ, ~ ~ I.)! (j 1.:)' -i:.. 'f-.i ~ 'f- ""I.)!
:f ~) '-/ JJ .iJ'"';:~j J' '~Ij 'o~J '-/ JJ DJ~ -~ .:.);...J~
'J'i, 'J~"
I.)! I.:)~JRl.7.C L'J
L u)y ,;-' OJ _( £-~",/l/ ,J UJ.7.C L uk LJ1 L./ J' ".:.L~'.iJ'.:.1'1,J 1.:)' OJ -~ (;iJ.
f 'f- cf' 4~ -~is~ J),J .:.); I.)!uj~ ~) 1.:)' ~J1 .: J"'j ,J L./ ~ " uj~ Iu)y 1.:)' "I.:)'A .iJ'uJ1J'J I.)! uj~ OJ .r~ ('7 L u}'J ~~r DJi "u~ ;; -v(!h{ I,-:""J. ,;-' L'/ ~ OJ ~ -'f- JI/ o!l. ~ ~ i L~ ~J -~ J1t,/-~",/- LJ-'" I v'A i ~~./ ,.::; ~>. ~
4
2.. v' -L~ ~ ,; u£ 0' I.:)~ ,J 1.:)' I.)! v'
'f-f
" L~ Li "I.:)' I.)! ,..U-- L .:.);f 'f- O.i~
u'ril J); ~j L UJ.iP"''''/-' -L~,J.t~ O.k.~ ~ OJ f L~ l,{~ 1.:)' ,J. 'J1 ,; .:.;~,~ ,J L~ £~ "I.:)' J_,J" u~ v(~.i.t' L u~ u'ril .....'f-I.)! -:I.,J 1.:)' ..::;u,~, ,J 1.:)' f 'f-.i J~-vf
46
Jj S .:;.,)1{ JP eJ fi . v:' )J' -\A.. is.::.-L "'./v.! cI~" ~J ~ f cI' ~ r~'I.).t Lf v.! cI~
(15)
l5J! L') 11'''' (') ~') I..M v.. J~ v.. OV 4.l,..i' a£ .:;.,')'If L.::./f v' Yo f e: ~.fi OJ~J .e: 'f-) f ~Ll (t~ v.. UJ)~' k ~~ )1J, ~ .:;.,iJ~ ~' yf .::.-v.. cI' .s: 'f-) :f~ v../)~ )~, L,/9"" J,> wf1 r( v' jt,. -g_ z.:4-J
S .::./f
C~ v.! )J'
"Un J'!'; )J' dij~')~,~cI'V-'JPifi
J~J~ J..A: J1~Jv .:;.,)~u~(5)in c"i ~
.fi L cI'V-'JPi f 'f- rf ~OJ.::.- ..v, JI} SV'-L~ Jv J} )J' P
":)JJ '.:;.,:/
J'; uk;
.::.- ~
~ .:.5L L clt;.t, eJ ~ f ,J ..:)~V'"::;J V' SV' (16) -~J,;j ,
eJ ~•
f ~if,. j )J' ,
.. \;I
v..v' -~ v.. tt..!-fJf." ...t f1841.IJ wf1( (
0)iJ1/. f~!lj
0"
...t .J L U)!/ ~ -'f- -..J;I .::.- UY'; J ). 0/JJ .::./; v.. .::./; oJ! .R..'~c~Jr OJI".-o;t-- L k~) )J' ~ ..Jl),
r-
J'v;S v..U?;JJ.'1J1 d,j ~ o~ 2... LU5)!)J' U-"'V-'J;:-; u)V L ~.::.v' f ~ -'f- Uc) ~ JP fi~ ":)JJ Sc/VJPi ''f.::.- .:;.,k'J)
JJ' ~
f ~f 4Q.'::'-..,..,- -~ V'v.! -= L fv.! J"'} SV' v.!' ''-'1 )JJ.:,.-r:
j'V-'JPi 0)iJ1:t.
)} j'V-'JPi L~?-)
v.. ~JPi
'(17)-~
S JJr;; ~~.:;.,iJ~ v.. '-AL uJJ! )~'.::./f l5J! JJi L I.)? f.fi OJL ~ J'l' J.i>-' L '..v _)1 -~ -~ ~
J)
':;"~YoJ
~J
47
UY!~
S U~I
JJI ~
,,5}u,.I.
OJ
'v!' J[ ~;v.
J,? v!.::/;
JI s:,J J"I} « S d' JJI LJ1 ./~ '-X ~ '",:,,"..1,( ~J;(y. fF v! Jy.J ~ ;j~~ JI ~ v! P! ~ -Lb:r
/._1.l.fl
~ (lIVI Z;-'
Llf L .::/;v. S.::/; L U"':I i 'i:.. '_;;;IJ~ ..:.tJ~ J J~I OJ JJI ~ c.i' ~J:J J ~J r .::/; v! d' 2.....l.fl -z:. J~I ~ L LlPo:c o~ ;J 'J,JJ} JlP! IJIJv! U,lhlJ d' 'i:..~)' dG* S I.fl ~ lSJI;i ~ ~rJ
(18)-v.t)j
f 'f- LJ1 JJ/ 0;1.;;1-: ~ fIJi J ..:.tJ~ J~ v.., ,J.'~~)' c.i' (--' ?rY ~/.::/;
JG' J,_;':.;tJ.N-/ nl';;.t d'
L .::/;lSJI
lSJI
L '-/lr J!;:--J';;-;
S /.1. L SVlr J!;:--J';;-;Lf!. -i:..,f- v! Jv.- S ;A L ~
4».J"v JJI 'i:.. 'f-J)' ,f-Ji .; U}JJ U-,::Ij JJI U-,::} I.fl OJ ~L_~
S~
r,~1
Li L~ L)y.;!J
J
~ ..:.~IJJ
p ~L~ tJlPo1.; J1L L '";"J!~I V
_V'~/ uf.i S J~ ciJJ JJI J'.; .::/1; L ,,:,WJ c.i" ~L~~~ GY ,J. s: c.i' .J. d!;:--J';;-;JI ~ j;~ J1j f 'f- ..:.? r ..:.~ I.fl y. -i:.. 'f-J)' Jv.- v.t'J(j 2.....L J; JJI 'i:..p j 'i:.. 'f-J OJ
1. Bearce, G. D.: British Attitudes towards India, 1784_1858.Oxford, 1961,
P.17 18 'l.Nandy, Ashish: The Intimate Enemy. OUP, 1994,P. 34. 3. Bearce, P. 24
48 Bayly, C. A.: Empire and Information. Cambridge 1996. 5.Marshall, P. J. Trade and Conquest. Aldershot 1993,P. 173
-.J.t1IJ
(J ~~ jlij : .-r.) .ml)
t.j'V'JP; (
J.f : I.!.JI~
_,.,.
6
521)' _,,1999 f1996 .J.t1IJ
(J ....G~ jlij :.-r.)
~
r.;-i
,f ~I ...;J) : ~I ...;J)
7
35-1)' 38-1)':"~I
8
9. Sita Ram: From Sepoy to Subedar. London 1970, P. 13 f1996 .J.t1IJ(J~.J
: .-r.) JJjl) JI,..- Y'
L ",:,",fT : t.j;J. J({
10
14-1)' 106_107 -I)' 'f1972 .J.t1IJ' JJI k '.;c/
.:-~:.;c/
11
73-I)'-fj~
12
72-I)'_"~I
13
15 -I)' -t.j;J.
14
74-I)':fj~
16
75 -I)' :"~I
17
15.Vanina, P.162
18.Nanda, B. R.: Gandhi and Pan_Islam ism, Imperialism and Nationalism, OUP 1989,P. 53
49
J~
r..t J 4f"v?u, J:ylr- ~
Un Jr,;.
s
'f- ~ ~ ~
s
D.l S-=--~J~j;
f 'f- JJ1 -=--)~ ~ -=--~vI ,f-I r..t )JJJ'~' i v.r t'J t.f (':1 J:ylr- L (!)Ir..t )JJ JI~I ..f~ 'UJ1j( ~ L JA~ ~ nlv.r a) LI) d!' r..t '-)~ L un Jr,;. eJ 2... vI LJ1,f44 t:t -'f- J~ J1 u~J )JI LI) -: i 'f- Cl t.f (!)J~r (!)I,f-I S(!)I'v.r J~ JJ1wi d r..tj )JI ~ Jr,;. ''f- J~ "Yo.:::;u, S(!)I )JI ''f- til O.J: (f -:J) r (!)I~ l.) 0' 'v.r J~ JJ1 t'J {(!)I u~)/ eJ
t'"
LIJ L.f
(!)J~JJ~
Ji )JI '(:;7 ()
-v.r
L~J1~/
'J..,i") '..Jj._f
",:,,1 Yo
s:~
(jJ
J~'J>J '",:"].,,.1eJ ",:,,1'L
.J:)JI
L ~l)I Iun Jr,;. 'v?u, J~J~j; nl '; /. '",:"].,, eJ ..f~ f v.r z£ -:~nbJi,lVI.f 1) r..t ~ SuJ);~ ~Jr..t ;:!L S(!)IIun (!)I)JI 'f-I.5J e,f-I L I.» 2... vI v.r ~I {(j!J S(!)If 'f- ,jj Ji,lVIr el' -: ~.::.J;> SLJ1 if' )JI ; /. -'f)JI J>j,f-I
.flJ ~
-?)J
'J ~ I~JJ S(!)I)JI JL L el' 'J ~ IUJJli'~ S(!)I'",./ L (!)I~ Jr,;. fi -v.:.f(b' dL vr,;. L (!)IOJf v.:.f)_,f. ,f-I
~ )JI
-:i v.r L.f .::J!7 _;i,IV L.::/f S(!)I'v.r Lf I.5J)J_;i,IV SUb~" ''f-I.5Jn _;i,IV t.f S-=--L~IJI.» ,J. 'f-1.5)'; ~ .:::;u,J:ylr- _;/ ,; r~J1t {nb Ji,lVI~ '7 )JI'~ ~I 'ff,J I(!)Ir..t -=--)y" vI I)}I
50
-~,
s71JZ 2....
f VI) 7 C'i" v! ~J (j "G"~IJ!f ~ ('.I '~ '-.t. '-~~ dIP f ~~JI ;; (J J.tt ~~.JJ ~ Ij~ -: vI ~I ~ eJ~j~ "':-"'"-v.r LijJ (,P' .JJIJJ . L d' fl.tt "' .,::..~ '::)JJ J
VI t;f ~~.JJ
JL .JJILY' v! i~ U.t. ~~ JI~.f
-i:.. ~ ,f- .J~ v~
y rUJ~~ dIP v! J~ L
vI;; v.r L~ U~Jv! J~-S J~ -v.r L~4-J '-J.JY dV.) .JJI~;"".) 'J>J ~ -:.:i)J vI '7j.tt ~ JI/ S ~C ~"Ll}- ~ J-' Y vI fun ;!_ ~I ~J (j u)~4 4 -7 j.tt d!: JU;I Jf v! LJ f d' Ij,:, .JJI L d' ~ dIP ~ ~ vI 'j (f'.t. v» S~"' u~j '?t. z.r v! (1) -?t. .f. z:« .J~r J ~I 'LJJ...Jj "':"1j r d' 7 j~S ,yf ,f- -:v! .,::..1Jjp d' .JJI.,::..Ij~' S d' LJ J"::' v! .,::..~IJ.J It;;; ~IA .JJIL~ 1( b: "':"1j (i ..:..7'7 S d' ~ vI fr; C~V'J~ v! J...I.- vI -L~UJJr .,::..>~ -L vt'~.tt.J~.JJI "v J t.:J'. ~ r .:i)1bJ:YL.-- 8J .JJI L~.ttr
'7 C.tt(~
Y
rt
s
r
Y
J
~ tJr J1~~'tJ f uJ~iU.t. ~ 2.... L .:i)1bJ:YL.-- J~ if.f 7 jb: 4-r L ( vI ~ L LJ ~IP .lIp' u 2.... v' 7 C.tt S ub~;'L d' u;; -L~ 1£ ....;~ v! u.JJJ)".;:,If uJ~iv! r .,::..j J.:i)Ib"";jjV L d' J'-J.JY ..::..---J Jr ~IA;; vr LJ..:..7'7 -7C~~~I f I J/(~.it -: v! '-.J~';-, ..::.,,;.;J:YL.-- v!~ ~ (1.1 vI (r .JJI'j' '-"~L!'~ .JJI~r LvI '7 dIPS ....;1)1 J J..A' u 'vi~",:",;" f l,';:' 3~ .JC v.r 7.1J ..::.,,;.fo 2.... vI u 'v.r LIJ LJ
51
~ 'if' J JJ' '; /. J .I~''-/.
J h' -V-J ~ cf'{ J 1:)1--{I
('i I:)~.IJL r4 J (I Jj ~r L'J
J'j .=;-' Yo ~
Lf(r
J":"'--
J;;j S1:)' .IJ'
.IJ'~~
J ~~
L~.t1'-t; j'Yo Ju;, r Lf .::/f 2... L 1:)' Po L Lf -L 'f-.1f .::/f 2... L yL;.o t) J if' f /by' G. yL;.o
J' L J....; If.. U!J.I L UJJi
If..I:)~JR;
r ~ If..~
~
v'
J:yv L 1:)' v:' ;;'~If.. .J....L.. L Un JL;.o L u_';' Yo s,I.J!. ~ I -'f- (} J...If..;£ IJ' L J....; If.. ~v'" L I:)~JR;.IJ'd"j v' .a.r L Yo ( .IJ''(:;k-- ~ \5? '7.Lq {_./I If.. .IJJJ';.' J)j eJ~j G. eJ~j G. .::/f f ~~ ~ r 1:)' .?L q 2_ z.):~'" ..:.cL? SfY' If.. .I~.IJOJ 2... L ~ v' -v/ ~'"v?r'
u:
.r
J? -L2::-J,.j?.I.1J,._;)tj
_;'j~,
J~J~/fY'~eI?J~f
S~f)t
(:;k-- .IJ'~
-....r- ~ J~ Iun eJ
G.J)
SJ.I~S
1:)' .IJ'L
tl ~I SI:)'G.qS Sv' .IJ'L~ J~, ":::;ih
G. JA
u:
J} OJ If.. UJYo( -L zr Lf ~'" ~~Y2... L UJ'?'C L I:)~JR;G. q Suy'!j L ~!I~L (jJJ, If.. ,;I;~;; L (:)tT Yo L
J';.' v' -L Lf ~jJJ, ~ L uil/ L.t1 ,;' ...i?} .IJ',;'7.~~J.Ir 1:)' 2... v' 'L L.t1L'J Lf ~'" ~~Y .IJ' ')J.::/'}.IJ
OJ
If.. .IJJ
(~, J~:t eJ~jJ/2... L 1:)' If.. uP. 1:)1/
L I:)~JR;.IJ'~ z£ J,J o!J. .IJ' '_po J"'} L tJJi J (:;k-- J? ~.?L J? ~, OJ
-~ ~
-L .I~ J .lIP, ~k-- ":::;Jv' ;;J.t1c,J) t.t1 !{ J'Jj ~
Ji
If.. do" f Yo ( ~.I! If..J'~
-L~Sif1':)JJfl),
tT ~
Jy. ...f1 L.t1LI), e.tGG. Jfi'
e.tG G. ~v",)t
Li I:)~JR; 'L Ji?
.IJ'
u:
52
v.. ur~.1 S ~JPz S Uy'!j ;;~ .::.:;.;L '-;'.I!.v.. U
UY.
V
tf ~ rI:J.f L'/ ~ ( J.j ~.I!. cJf
LlJ.ll)f
~ U}J.) ~.I!./ (:) ~ fl) ~Jli"(£,j ..1i.
-i~-L uy;..::..:~...i.lr tf .....;~ L U~J
cJf-L 4-J '-.J (if
.IJfL Ll./
v.. ur~.1 1.5/JJ .IJf'.I~.IJaY '.IV' )/'/
/ U'Jr.
~fJ} L Ur. f ~tf ~f;;f s..:./;tJ. S ur~.1 i L jf ~ v.. -I) if~(:,,,,~?Ii~ ~ v.. i.S' cJf-UJ./ (.;V .IL.;._}L'/.I~C,j '~ U.I~,.t- ~f '~~ ~ ~f ~ (~ L /J)j '(;;.I~v.. j~ L .;k1 L if. (2)
-s.:./;~/ ;; v.. j~ Vf L0Y .I~J} q .IJf v..
.....;~ L '-/JJ ~ U.i~JPz L L./ ..::..:~ U.lfJ~J~f fl) U.I~
v..
.IJf U-5.1!. .;L; JfMf Vf
e: L U-5.1!.,.4-~ ,_/- ..:..~ ( v.. .,:;,tt nfl j~JPz /J} i..
,:r(Un cJf,.( £-LlJ./ J} 1 ~ -~ ~~f / 1L cJf~ i.. vf I) Ly;~ un L J'f ». '~II'v~ ( cJfi.. vf -I) tb '-J (lP J'f ~ v.. ,-}Ir j~JPz,_/-f
~f.l .IJf
j~ JPz ~ -~ L~ y; J./Jy' L J \).I~-~ L./.I~f
~ -L L./ tf u/t?
JPL L cJ~ JPz ~
~ ~.1 .IJf~ .Y'
/ ,-:,fl '-:'Jf L J'f ~ -~ L./ UJt? ~ ui.ll
v.. u)~;cJfi;;,.4 ~ Z-i.""';/ .; J.~;JJ.lf
i £ify S vf OJ_rr ~ !.Vf ~ if~c,.I~ L ~k--~ J~~".9 tf (~Ljf ~ df -I) 0.1.U.l~ J!f eJ~;~ uJI OJ.J':::;J vf
v..
'_r.S:-1 tt.lJL1'(;;.I~"~ '~L,.. (3) -~
u;l,;: 'if~ '(;;.I~4 i:. L y; j~JPz
Lde '~L,..
e 'J:d.l;';'
';'_/.J.I.lJf'~L,...Ifr
..$. Su~v.. '-.I~L .,:;,tt J o-r";'; S df.IJf ,J} L ~JPz i -?J ~ S vf -I),_/- .;f.;:1r ~ .;~~ ~J.I( UJ?!i tf PI L (f1757) -~ Li cJ~JPz v../ S JI.-- e.J~ ct!;tJ.jf L J{~~f ~f f,j ~
53
L fl) ell..--i :2... L el'
'v!' JJ'Zv.: ~ ,.jJ'-- J d,...f":::;J V'
-J- J.J~'
I ').;;J~.JJ' J) .I} L uk
J~Jk
J~'J~
LI.tf
'~ ~
..:-Ll.lrd"·'
'Li~;dlP v.:, 'LLJ(~'
J~' .JJ' J.,J dlP
-L L~ I(el' ;
CJ'Z~~Lf.. u}~ L
L u~'.J .JJ''':-~
2... L LJ
~
J v.:,; 2.. ~
d L ..:-tJlv L Lf.. '""'"
v.:,;
.JY' d"·' L -..f' Po L 2.. J'b Yo I) CJ'Z~J (I( ...?I..-- L J;Ll. .JJ'uJ.J'J '-..J
~
v.:,
OJ
~j'
LfiL.JJ'J~'~ 2... V' 'L Yo 'I J~~ tf If.J~~ ~~
I(el' OJ
v.:, J
'Z
J~v.:, 2... L
~ (!)' 'I) C~~
IV .JJ'uJ.;f~;
..:-Ll.lr.JJ' LJ ..::& ..:-~ ~
UH (~ 8J'-/
.I"'"
JJ (4)
...J) -..f' Jz,..'J
el' 8J fl)
o.JY'
2...
-"'./.J~' ",:",'l",:",J'J~Jk
f Jj I(LJ'Z J) ~ _::J Jif. L LJ
..JV' -I) C~J'Z -~'J'
d"o,~ 2... v'
AJ r'" 'X Lf.. LLl. J1~IUH dlP .JJ'UJJt
..:-~Lf..~;
L el~; dlP Lf..
,~..:-~~ L0;/.Lf.. el' L V' '~itf.IJ~Jk U' ...?I..-- L el~; _(,{
d~ ...4 4-J LJ'Z v.: I(LJ ?i ~JJ; ...J) -..f' v! d!;Ll. L J{ Po L ..£. J lf~ 0/ JJ .JJ' ":-?.J '..:-.;If J L U_,), 2... L ~ V' "J'Z,~ d{.J -:l.J Lf.. ,-/lr
~.J}
OJ
v! el' U' ...?I..-- L V' 'OJ J C,;.,) ~J (}~JJ J JL ~.Jj L U~'j.P):
2... L LJ ~Iv (~, J..:-:I Lf.. ,-/lr J~Jk f'J'Z'~ el'f.J-: Y JJ ;7~ UIif-Y' J~Jk if- _rr L~ ~~IP ..:-~UD~ .J~.JJ,f OJ
~'J ...?I..--
JuH v.:, Lf.. J~.::/;JJ{ fl)
~.,J~I
-L~
fl) ;;f> 8JtJ!. do ~' ..JJ' (5) -'J'Z.J? ~ (~Ltt",:",~ l' U~Ji Velt:Jj,
L ..:-~IIJ.JJ' ~JJ
~' Yo
IfL ~ ;:...~'J J'Z./~ ~ ":-~'J L L .JJJJ'k.' el' ~J ~ Li (6) L~ IUH~ (' J! L Uhl(
,;-'
54 Un
~vf ji j Jfj (/ J.I"' u~1;
dt;.1f (fjf
S.IfJ L
df .lJfuJJ!
t SU_';~J~~f.lJ~fj S)J fV~~",
.I~fIfLuJJ!df
JiJ i.lp:Jr -0 -fl. cf. 4 df I.)! .:..tJ.lr.IJf.:..v,r ':;-f .IJf~)' :f ~ , ~(Trevelyn)
S J/ L
U~f
-e: Jv .IJfJ~J ~
'J!
Jf;;f
u;), f ~uk '~ ~ r I.)! .IfJ ,;-f I ujiJ~ (V Po L df Jt -~ fl. J1j~ J J? eJIf I.)! .:..tJ.lr J'v
.IJf'JfJ L)'(~'~
(7)
J? J'.;; fV~I;:~
eJ~;~ eJ~;~ fi JfJLi
-jif., JJ1J~
~ -: ~.IfJ -:-,fj
u;),
J!f",.I}
L uJJ! L .IJJJf;;f
If C)!;tJ.L J{ LJ1 L)' ()J,6S vf f_U,t d()lf ~.::/; S JYL,J. ,f-' S uY';tJ.L J{ ~fj ~f f_U-fl. ~ LJ1
I.)! dfYf):
-t J.~I.)! tJ'f :# L d~J~ J~
J
fit"
.IJfuJJ!
"";J"" ,; d~.IJ
~ ~
L uiJJ df
d)J
J?-;.I1
-'f-.I .:..~ ()Jl,...o "' .I}
-0 Ifl.)! t;:f J/. ,J.'~ LJ1 2...~ ~ l;.f~~ ~~f -~ J~ ~ b.lC S vf .lJf~L L d~J~:t,Ji ~ ~.I~ L un df f ,f-' JG" vf r Jt 'u.r f J1uk:fj I.)! (j vf f ":::;Jvf -~ ~J
.J''v~~/
,;-f ~ .:.....: ~
rL
JJ
U~f
J'£'J!I;.. ~ ~ILJ Lf.l
JI ~f I.)!
(8) -Lb: ~)Jf .lJf4-J ~
~f JJ1~;
J.J? ~
'::::;Jvf ~i
~i
I.)! -:J.IL UJ:t,Ji
'~0'b.lC Sd~J~ eJ'Vv: CJ1t".If;1fJ'::::;u,Sdf f fl. & ",)P/ vf.IJf fl.~ LJ1";;;fJ ~ l:h.l J(.I.lJf .If}f J
.:..fJ~Sun u~
ti
dfj
55
.J"L-- L V' (j.J rf-' ":;'.J~ 8J~;,JJA,J U.i~jk rf-'I v! .11""1JUVI
Jfi cil; 'el.Jj ,,:,,1
~I
'~.JO..4:.::JL ":;'.J~ J! {IPJ ( ..:v-~.JJ~J~ii .J"L--
J '.;1;,11j":::;u, IJ}J -t} .::.-!Ij f 1U.i~jk ~ if.s:~ 4-J
_V'~I..:;,L--~IL.::Jj .Jjl 'rJ)/. '..:;;/,.1
-:,..4' 't} rf-' ":;'.J~,J~.J L rJ/.v..JjlrJJ~
",.I} J:1r- ~
-v
J1( (j
J
.JJI":"~
_i J_,J j~Jk
~.J.;I~I?J'L (d~jk
.JJI'f-)
f ~
U.i~Jk J
d'
~I
,-:",..J.:i,J d~Jk
fl.i ~Jf ..::..:~-: L uj.J""- ~.JiJj....f
-t} ,J J;1 ,-:",..J.:i r?~
~ .J~Ii ~ VI 2_ VI
.JJI
r4 .JJI",,;P iG ~.J
f L~V..::..:~ -:f~ rJ.J~ 2_ L £.1 (~ 1--:..4:J J '-:"".1 V'
-V,t J>J
e
v! d' L;L L
,,:,,1 _(_;;
L V' .JJI'f-
f trJJ -: JJ 2_ V"~ rf-' ''f-~.Jrf-' t:? JI~ ~..J.:iV' ( ~ (j ,,:,,1 ,.f ~ L ..::.)P J dl? ~I,.p ,-:",..J.:i p,J
d~Jk
,tv /./
~,_,.IJ1'.)or..J...G Yo dL--.JJ L V';'L .JJIL d"~ , 0-"~ ..
£. J1 (J/ ~ ~".J'?-
L~ d~Jk
f 'f- c:C ~ ~~ ~ VI 8;I~I( VI rJP J'PI J~ -V,t
1u)w ~u,
~I (j _; .JJI'~irf-' d~Jk
-v! vP J;! JJd~Jk
(
JI ,J J'L v! d~Jk
rf-'I
~..lf
J~.JJIJ'L ~j V,t ;(;.0
~
J! 2_ V' tVJV~I
( rJ) f{.J}
v(:
t.f.Jj)
L VI _( J{: I/i.L d~Jk (9)
f~ rJ.J~
l;-I~ ';'L 8J ~ v
f / ~~tfr' (Ii ~' -:dl.JJJ V'
z.JJ Ii";; (Ii ~I
(..:;,Y
Ji~.J
P Yo 2_ V'
-JLi v.!_Ii ..::.-.:'J.J
J~ 1 d~Jk
JI
2_ L .:..7'7 ~ .::./f rJiU,/.8Ji LJ1V~I ( rJ/.v.~'rJ)/. rf-'I
.It
~ 'Lf,.J1Y ((.)41J,Jd' i 'L~V~
1 JJV L d' ~ '?-.J.J~
-Lf ":;'J~i'L~ 11(.JJI~~JId' ~ 'Lf
i;;'?'" i 'J~,J J7 ~,J
d'
56
.JJI.::/;
OJ
JC ~ rJ.J~ ~JI~
.,:..v(?1
L rJ; f tJ.-;.; v! el' 2.... vI
(' ",(a: el' .JJIv.:J ..:.J~IJel' 'I./.!.J,-:,1/ ~ L)J-"J~.J. LvI
fi -"v.:J ,; ":"~Uv' L P L el' ~L~J1.J/V'...:;./I}.JJJell fi' t,././
,::.v"'}.JJ~ el' 2.... L vI ~ J1~J ~~ ;; -UJ1)J
~ J~~J~
el.JIJL
J? f ~Ij
rJ.k.~J.JI;I J .,:..~IJ.J
(fI783_93)
J7- ;.1/
J'i/(
J-"J....t Uy']tJ.L J{.JJI J..::.J!~
.JJIeli~ t.-~I J Uy']tJ.L J{ f
t} ~J2J J
VI
-~I;:~J
J LJ
-~r jJ1 ~ uJJ~ J U}yPl ...k U~ -v!ijJ ~ ~ uJiI;--J~ eJJC ~r jfl~ rJA J)J (10) -~r~j ~ ~ J~L el' ~I ~ 'f-:r r u~I;--J~ .JJIrJ-"~L!IL J .JI; r u~IP' ~ ....tel'
(:)J.Jt.JJIVi...J/
If f U¥
~ UJ.J
~I
JJeJ~ L I./.!.J~ UJ.J
.J}J1JVIeJ.f 'f- ~~JJ vl'L
f ~~VI L J'i.Jr ~I jl;--J~ fi J£-L~~ f uH v.:J~ el'P'~~IJ J.J....t J.J:::-"
.fV'.J~1
f ~ J~VI 2.... 4.1' 'I./.!JP.....t...J~1 JL'(~~'I./.! e~L~~ dL .J,Jz: L J.J~ ~ UJ.Nf? ...J/ ~I 2.... Vi -L~~ ";"'tJ.J=
~el'
-t. r VI -L~ ~I/(r (11) -rL I:)'. ~.;{l) L1 jl;--J~ J} (.)'J.JJIVV ~
uy']tJ. L ~.JJ?...J/
~IJ r UJVi flJ1 ~
; ,-:,Ij ~ ,-:,Ij el~ elJ .,:..tl~ L UJJ! ....t~.J~ L u~1;--J~ ell;--J~ j'. .f 'f- V'L (John
Shore)
.I? el~ ~j r vI
-rL ~
LJ1
...k J7- ;.1/ ~ -"~.J ~I L J{ ....t I./.!Li ell;--J~....trJ/ f-"~.Nf L J{ .f 'f-l;1'rV' (f1799 _f1837) ~IJ ~ r el' (.)'Li ell;--J~ -'f- ti.J JJA IX ,j r el' ...k ':::;'JVi ~.JCJ (r ....t Ur;:: ~
el'....t ~.J~ L ~J~
~ ~I.J,L ~I ''f- C~~ U0 .nl Uy']tJ.
57
-v.r ?-.I-f ':::;Jjr ;: v.r L~ y{~ .::..'JC L .:::..... J;~ L j~ ,_;!cJ' 'v.r Ji L( U)JJ '-/' J h' ,_;! cP'JPz f f(G,.IJj{.::..~V'
OJ
u:u:- J:",fj Iif. .::..~ (i' -f1 ,_;! ).J L
-~~ jf (i L'.1 -f1,_;! '-.I~ L U.i~JPz (V'..u 'f- JjIf :f ~t1'OJ f- jr J...; If,_;! .::..1l~L.I? cJ~ ;-1.,.- L':::;J ~ (12) U.i~JPz
Z-i. ..:..YJ: L ..if. .IJ'(/ ~ OJ f f- ~~~tf uP. ?.:::..... .Ii v'1i f- ,_;! uP. (V JJ J f~ -v.r (13) -f-
U)"tjX ~,.P ~ i ,_;!
.::..~..ir~ L tjJJ.JIZ,_;! '-.I~ L UJ2~JPze: L
U}'J LJ,_;! Po
viJ ,_;! f1786 -~
':-J L'.1 ,_;! '-.I~ L cJ' L ..;;,;
f-.1
u:- ,f-
v.r LJ'l ,-I....f ~ V' ~-v.r eJJ'l4- .IJ'';?J: '~ ~ flJ if LJ'l V',_;!":".I{.1-f1 JJ{eJ~' ( L'.1 If' -f-If ~Ju:- If ~!.V, JcJ' f
tjJL L cJ' ~
-i.J' JtJV' _; ~J' f- VI.?' 0;1.,_;!
Un cJ'
fl[
l)' _;
,:r ( tj.l';:L!'...f tJlK. -v.r L~ J~1.1; JtJV'fi ~ i v.r Lr .::..'Ju.. J' L J.J JJ'l ,_;! -f- u:- l...f (t ,_;!cJ' i f(HoI well)
f1759
Ji ~flJ
I;!rt J1.:::......I~ v'
OJ
if,_;! '-.I~
L tj.l';:L!' .IJ' cJ~JPz
(l4)-v.r ~ '-J.l1j '-:"~). .IJ''cJv). 'J>.J'J~1~JPz J' ~ {~ U)JJ cJ' i ''-/ -".,j,1.£' .IJ'',-:"k' 'cJv ,_;! J.l;:- L cJ' .IJ' -1/
:cJi
'.I'-t.J'
Jr -IJ cc: J'lu:- .IJJ;: I[J'l,~ Jj L:1' -f1 cJk-".lJL
V'~ { U~ j ScJ' ~
u",j
i C~~~, u:-',_;!
S.::..rJ ,;-' I~JPz J' U~ # .IJ''j~J (!{cJ',_;! Jy#J J uA 'C~
..:..yJ: u! cJ' Lf/.;;'
4-} ;:L ~!7 i.. L ~ .:::..... U~(;'"J)i
OJ
-L ~
,_;!(/ J.I
58
C.ttJ~~.::;... ..:.-LI;IJ'";.::;... U)L.! J uk _;j;/ )JI'~ 0'1/ j,J.' '~i. L ~IJ./ u~Ij ,f )IJ L cJI )~.d' :c/t/ A'; Ji'!7 cJI ,f cJI -~ -L;£" / r'i JI;:--J~ U){" )hs--I.I' )JI L U";I i If.tt ~ I.I~I r U;/. o: UJ:c/t ..f/ ..f' ~ 3fi,f u.il;:--J~ ~j L cJI,,:,,1 -~fttv v»JJdj/ u.il;:--J~ ,f C)I 'LIJ'L cJI 'I.I~ r cJI '~t,.. J~ ,f cJI -J' ":'-/.J -+! Jt; )JI L.tt '-./ .::;... ~..;.;;"":-"'" -: ":,,Il ":,,JIL cJI)JI '..:.-IJ~,f cJI'cJ~j :,1'''''11 L)? cJ~ " -:J) 1.1' L cJ' -L ,;~J .s J/,f ..:.-~..ir)JI ..:.-t,..~1 L u.il;:--J~ u! UJ:c/t ,1'~IJ~
1/,f vI v:''' ,1''f-
0:' OJu! ..:.-tJ,~ .::;...~
C~"-:Y'
tt~v1~Y
-'f- 0') ,J:! 1/Jy JlP
,;~, vI; i u! U~ ,f cJ' ~~ ;: ,1'v1 Lf J!!? ..:.-~..irOJu! un u! J'J) L cJI cfl 'u.tt (f: -'f- C~ J) u! r?,1J":'-:/ U)Ia.::;... do s,4.11 z:; ,; -:J) r cJ'...J) ,f un JlP u! .:.tJ,~.::;... ~ C.tty. II .::;... ...;1)1 -" 'f- C.tt 1./ .::;...JiJPI ...J/ I~
I.I'.::;.../' );
J"Ji JlP ,1''f- C.tt" 1.1' ~
-'f-
f 'f- ~j u!~ -:" )} (~-v1 Lf .:;,.;,u /';:)j ~ tJ,}i ')L i
-4.11 ~,./
u!)p~..(" Lui;:,.p
JI
,f.)J' v1 J~uJ u~1(.::;...1 i 'f- Uc,tr' U)lt; ..... 'f-C~ II~
~ ,f do f v1L.tt ":,,uCLu~ " u~ Y' Lf r~'~,f cJ' jJ) / u~ )J' v1 Lf 1:1'/. JIP!
59
t:JI}t;
Jf_;-j uj 'f- C.lJ,;;;_/,JI JI JI ~
-Vl
i ~~ ,;;;_Ij ,-.I~ff'v"/.j( ''f- C.f.l~ r U~ ~Vl J~JJ U~( Jt:JI,J. ''f- ~.fL.t~ I~~~ 0:), L t:JI..;/
,; -: j L~ IJ.:'J -Vl L~ '-.I~;!
J
(15) -'f-
uk JI
JjI_~I"J ~
v- J.t;
-e» L ub.l L ~.I1P7 .IJI4 v- '-.I~ L u..ti~J-"i
d~'I.t;;; IUJ(.~JPiu -i:.. ~~ t(I~~~ ~7 (V" ~Ij ~I .IJI'J~I'.:;.,..7 '~ JJI;i V- t:JIuLN. r.i:.. ~~ ~tJ._f~ / vI uJJI".I} d~f j J~ IJ~~ vI 2... vI -L~ r Vl.?1r ';-, L ~/ '~J,;;;_ --:r..J,;i ~I f U~~JPi )JI vL?' r J;/. J Yo s.J.,J u V- L~;L t:JIs'f- JI11J.I" vI V- U--:r..J,;i {i" t:Jj'V .fl)".I}
_,.r
_,.r"
k"v~JJI
r ~J-"i
V- '-.I~ L t:JI:i:.. L_,.r £. .I~I I--:r..J,;i ~' :~t:f
LI" L (j J.I~.f
_,.r
v.! l), r ~.I1P7-?.IJJlj L
r ~cJJ.li~"
(f~
4 J J1
Vl L.f
UJ} ~ Yo Vl jl". L.lk. ~JPi
f Vl ::£-;£.1
.II:)r- ;-~ V- LI1 jl". L .Ik. -Vj' ~ " cJ!; J v.! V- ~;~ J t:JI;?J/-Vl LI1 ~11,;;;_;-~ LvI & I''f- vV r t:J'r.l; If",;;;_ u?J-'f-Vl j;._f .IJIu~ IS ~
~I v-j ~.k'~
tFJ!-:Yo 'f-......:~
V- J. V- rf. '-7. ~
~ .....
1:;' ~J-"i;7 ~I) ~ i:.. -V ~ U 'f-IJ.:'JIvI L "':-"'"",;;;_../. .IJI~)lP J. _t./i
4- vV Jj
60
If.! dk: ~!~0" Ii1) L ;£.1 v...;(; ...;'I 0'.. r ,jj -,:J'1P;;.:;;t. ') L~l.j.J/,fi..:.f r J1 L'.; L(}l5.J~7 c:c:,: .I; if- ~ ~.Ji (16) -cAl..!)' J(; If
f ~Z£ ~ ji -c:c:,: JLi If d' fr; rv( J/-7
~ 1.1' -7 If ~~
>. ,fh'.J~,f If ~J.J1.1' LUJJ!
L ~/
.JJ'~ J~ L d' .a1'1.-- L d'V'JPzJ' v.. .;L; L d' f 7 L,: (}v ~L uJ.J'J t:-.d J!-r; ~.J,: J)r- ~;.,.,. .) 1./.; b: If L,: tYJ ',",I J.JL,Lj'. '},",I v..JI Ld' J'V'JPz~ f ~tt..J/, J~' / .JJ''"'~ ,: t:-Y...J) ~ L Jy '}~ LI I~r.., v.. ;,.-'.1fi r; UIf.!~' j'.'~J(tY J;' '},:.I',.., v.. J~~ t:-)/JI fi\}- ~ ~.:;.-' -cA ef ~l,';'J,f v.. ..J_..l.. 1.1' L ~/ -I) L~l./~::-74-~'
< ~..
.• 1" ,-j'. " ';'Y'
.,JI tt .. V'r :,..) V.! 2!!!It &J 1.1" ,...# D
cAj 4- ~ ~.JJ/ If.;L; .JJ'~ If':::;J~) j'. (]}I,y. .JJ'7 If.! 2_ JI ~7 (]} v..J If,y. .JJ' IfJ cf I j 1.1' &J ):.I? 'ri" If.! ,...v JI ~ ~j J~I d'j'.; ~ I.IOr' / f U,: 7.1 j 4~"-'.;/ Lv' JIJ;I Lj'.r .Jr .J~J'V'JPz~ L J~ Lj'. .....1£ !:J'~ ~, I1.1' J ..;.:;0 ~ .JJI Lj'.'}L~.JIJ ()i ~Il ...Ju;t~ v..t:-/o" L ~I~ L d;~ j'. '( ,: ~r r ~ 1.1' ...J/ 1)IJ L~J~ I."" r' 1;~ 1 -'" '.JjV j'. .....7.Jf'" ,;:;_ J t:v 1.1 v.1J:v' t:-r' ....... ...!;t ') t:-J POJ~;e:_'J L iL If ~.:;.-' If
j,~,
A'~
..
fA~
61
(-~ 1VI ~'-Jl}. 'Ll)I
J' 2;.
vII
el) ~ '-J(J
f'" iLJ
LIJJ( Ij'( LVI
.IJ'
JIJ JJ vlJrl/ .I,.J')".
~ 1/,f- (tV 1r L VI s.'-J ,; .Jt'.f;( r./.. (1. jlf "t}l; L d- tf J)~ ~ ....;)u' '(~J'Y U:' eJ
\'
/Y r./.. ....;l)I )JI ~..J:i S ~;JI.J' JJt -v.r,f(17) -0;::... ,
-fI )~-fI f v.r;£ )JI I)I,f-
_;;IJ
-:
..::.r.~
S -:J) U' L ~JJt
,-J/ f ~Iljl Yo
~
r(J.:.. .JC/
s:1J' -fIL~.y. ~I
/.~1r ~ e~i ( fin flf L~ z£ .:.---d ~I 1/,f- (tV ~I ..:..~~ S -:J) VI tt_L iLJ 'Y d I( r i L J)I,:, a: ,-J/ :s,v.r;£ .JC/ r./.. tt(tV '( J"Uj" j7 15' L// f 'f- ~~J C~,:, ~.t-{15' ( ( ~ eJ
)JI ~
,f-
eJ /)JI
~I,..
i ,-f
S ~b)L ~JJt
1~I,..
fi )JI ~ j~JPz
0;::...
r./.. ttPz ":"J~ ~~.A )v/' ':;-"L.JC/
i:... Lf ..:..:1 S~.i~JPz )I~.d .::..>1)J &) L Ijl 'i:... Lf J)IJ)IP ~ J"JJ -:J) '( Ijl )JI Ji ~J ~
(tV
)JI
£ V-~j..:%Li u:1~ JPz f ,
Ijl'
~J.I1j
~ ~JPz.Ji.}
S Ijl )JI ~ -: .J. ',j J.'7 .c .JJI JiJ.7t{ S ~I,..
(18) -' v.!l' L~ ••
~
eJ~
..::.r.~ If......;/ 'f- JIJ-{~ VI
r~(,Lv ~ Ij~
..:..G" JII..;L ,.;; VI
L~ L .Jiy )Jl.i ~I,.. jJI
(tV '( VI ~
fr ~,f-
S
-:
L~ ~J
Jt fi
L )JJ J'N.'
f 'f- SI5'J
S Ijl" 'i:... a) ..:..l1.W J.~
J....; r./.. ~_,JIJLi L Po,j2 tt_i:... L~...vr./..
S....~ L fI857 ~
I-:J)
vI eJ -~
JJ:
r./.. J.'7J: ~
62
:V,t
uj IXc-
~x f 'f- (p,. ~ I ..;..;}.I/ u)n V
c- ...J} L J7 4- .IJIUl;)
.Il(JI
c- ((> J~JPz.:;.;7
...Jyl -..fi f'f- JJ1 0$ .:;.;~ -:V.lJI\'~ UIr-; 2~.IJI'f-~.1
) J~}jy,jy,
.J. J1I ~
c-IjJ (I;:J
J»~U ~lr-L
.IJIJ:!i"): (19)
~~
S~~ -'f-
f 'f- ~.1 C~ CJ.Iv! JJ
L V;J.I VI?I l(U; f IUY..~JPz -: -?J J..IC -..fi -VV Jjj.-If v! .:;.;~y,Jok-- .lJI J~0 'J..IC ;Iy, l( . .I} J1j 2... VI V,t'f-.1 v! J~...f ~/ ~} -..fi J~JPi...f~ f j UJ ..:.51rJL?:? l( U;~fl'J (J./Jy' L L~ 1.1l1-V,trl. J1 o-tL ~ -:" ,V' L VI -V,t J~;~fl'J eJ~;c- ~ v! eI~JPz2... VI ''f- CU.I/ ~ U.I/JL? f~.I~ -:"l(,;L; d...1~ v!~ ~ L J:-.? Vl.J. V~lIJ~
v! Ij
.:;.;iJ,~
-'f-...JJ!?L
L el'~
ell ftf..J 1f".I!:v VI
IUY..~JPz.L. .::/f
U}U,./.
Cz.l.IJJC- .,:...?!i" Sell ~'v.t 'f-.I) .,:...?!i" el/.lJI v.t 'f-.I} elJ~21r-
~U!.IJ'./.\J"'; d'- 2... VI -v.t ?-r u;j ~u".;~ (12 .I~ l(el' 'f-.1 o~ C- el'y, .IJIv!JJf v!; y, --G. ~ J.lL
el' .::/f
OJ
~J21r-l(el' .L. u;j
~ .IJJC- t;; S ..::./'f y, J~JJ):,;I; C-.I} '-II; _IJ1v!
":"'?!i" Sell t!
J1r til v! ~JIJ L eI}'i ~I ~I
.IJI,J
J1r t~i.'i"
-t!JJ1JlfS~{"elIY~L
-~ rl. if.~.1 v!.:,ji:t J~JPz?'./Iv! fl;;1 f V,t~ fif' ~ ,J? ':;';.IJ/-: "=,,,1 i ~/.' .:;.;Wl L u!7 .IJIiij;./. el' ~ ,j2
63
Ji Jj",.Ii'd~v..l)n
~-.3i>, -.3/ ,; .IJ' a.r
(j .IJ'v.. d' f J.'1
; /. .IJ'if"~ u~;~ _! j'V'JPi_!Jt f.'1
vl.?' t.f -:..J. .'1)l}, .IJ'l.!' ~.It../' 'f- ,-:"j ~ ~ fVt.£J t.f l/ v' 1Jj v' {P -'fS I)}II ~.Ii >. S d' .IJ'~ .'1~ ~ LII j'V'JPi-'f- ~~ S~..;.; ~ JY .Il}, ~~l~ ?- ~, Jt L .IJJ-:.I~ -vi L.'1 ~..; Yo Ji
Ji ~ 4- .IJ'15J,;i?-15y. v..1)~'V'JPi~' 2_ V'-~ LJ -J'.'1JdJ SJ;:L ~ J~'Sd'
t~"',;_,}~.Ii L I)"':'t.f 11).'1'(J~.1 '-t'
~d~ ~d' -~JJ t;~
eJI)~ ~ C.'11t{ v...J~ JU..j' J ~J;t.
..11,,; L cJ!;JJ..IJ'd';:!;~'
I)~J~iS d'
-I ~J e~ '-t' S d' .IJJ~ V~ j'V'JPi-: -~?-.1
d~_Vi j,j
~.Ii v..1)}~
-vi L.'12
.IJJ.lJ'~_! j'V'JPi~' L "::"'.11:>' .I/}!
"' J;L L I)j'( L d(;ij,
'J:'~ J,/.1
v..1)~J/
-~JJ
S 1)~.I1tJIJ,. L /.IJ' I)jJ
I)"':'~ Ji
J;. ~':::;J v' v.. J;:; S I)JJt
cf ~d' ,-:,'-t,j'_JJ t;; jf I)~J~~
I)~)I ~.Ii Llf
(20)-~C.'1 ~ I)"';JJ.j'V'JPi-.3/ v.. d~!;
Jt ~ J'J ;:;-.1v.. 1.1'.1..1. ~ f
L un d'" f~
",:,,'Yo ~
~~ ,-/-l)i';'~ (21)
v' fVl.!-t ~ f 'f-P n~'~ J;eJ' -v.. '-.I~
V'~t.£J k-'"J! d'V'Jp.L
(}p ;; ~
u-'f-r I)i ~, ~
'f- ..::..~ S J~JS f1830-:
.IJ'~ (
J/l:R. f 'f- J~~ ''f- J'i') 0
~~~ ~v' v.. d'.IJJV' '~.1v.. .1.'11)JL,.- -..fi '-.I{
I
if. (G. R. Elsmie)
";.1'; L tJ~' -.Ii -J. -'.'1-.3.1~~ ~ -.3/ ~ v.. I)n
v.. __,#/ v' ''-.1';/
JI,,; J}i; J! dVJPi ~ q
S)'J
Yo
,-d
if' L
64 .IJ'U-"~Jk
uk .IJ'Sd/
UY';JJ.....;/ ~'J
I( 1.1'
S
I)!~~I:)j.lt .IJ1iJL. I.I'.I~~....;/
i ~; I:)~Jk ~~ ~ -JJ. ~ ~.:t;1 k' (22)-~.1~
o: UH "",;-' J-t; S1:)' f'J1 -: ';:<1( J~ 1.1' '- U-"~Jk :L e.J f J14 ~ J.?" L y-JJ.Iv.. J-t; S1:)' -,f 0.1 f J1JJA LJ1
o~
v..1:)' tAlv../~
15~.) Yo '-
J-t; S1:)' L.if-'~
~
v.. U~.I~",:"y ~uV
L);/
J~.IJ''tf ~;JJ. ':;;'J OJ~;l;y' OJ s:
':;;'J
L '-/ JJ ~ OJ'~ LJ1 o~ 15JI?Yo -~ ~J~ ~i. .IJ'J'J.) I ~ Po L J"" .::-""IU~ -~ L.I';/ ':;;'J ui~JJ.Lf~ ~ Ui'-tl;
v..
V' .JJ'~
,; JJ'"
SUH J~Jk
'2£ ; ( IJ} OJ s: ~
OJ)L'~
C~~Jtf~,
2... L
tf If.! IU~ ,;-' 0Yo -~.1 .IJJ~
JrL
L/ J_,c., v! u_,_; 15j~ v.. "" I:)~J~ 2... L u~ L 1:)' '~ (23)-L
err: '.::-.1'" I)! ~
'~ ?.1 I)! U.,J
J"" Jt I)! ~L;J';,'
2... L 1:)' ojSu.,J 1:)' --?fi -~ ~ v.. u.,J .I'> ,;(t .IJ' 1.1'.1.), J~J Sf1830 .s.Lf ':;:";'u I1.1' OJ .::J L .::-iJ~.It] ':;:";'u J~t 1.1' -~ L~ ~ L.);/ ( (24) ~
".1( u~
C~ d,-
.IOJ u~
Vlr J~J~
~q SiG Jr f~ 15.1~2... L -: 2... 1.1' -J.;_J o~ ..:&.::-~ 'UJ1,; JP.
1.1' -~ UJ.d
,;
.IJ' ;1;-" ~
L~_;15j~ L. u~, v.. v.. U~ / ;;f Jr ~ Jf
L.f ~;
S~ ;/..IJ' J" f,f S?I
U-"~Jk ~ '::J
v.. JI!' 'UJ1,; I:)'P--':A~.d
l/ SUH (~ ,f-' JI
.;U-"~Jk
)L "'/
b~' I)! I.I~.IJ' L.f
J" -~ ~V(Li1' 1.11; I(.::.:;0; J ~ 2... L tfJJ.I.t'.: 2... L ~
65
rfi L ~jJ'
'jj~'
\)}f, ~;:" LJ'i ",:",If" ~ l.)Jj'J~' tJ (jl { Oj~ J (j' v! d:-'JR; -i: LJ'i ~~
L ,:J L ~ ..:: jp dL if.1/ ",:",C(~ Jt "Warrant of Precedence" 2.... ,:r ~ if. f I)'v _3 -" LJ'i
tf '--tlr
-I JOk...::jJ J(jl ~ ?) J} c[J:' _2')1 v:' -u -Ji _1
~y. JJI ~
~-;-L.--
L Ui.'i JJI U~If'j'UJJIf/
_5 _jl~~ Oji c[J:' _ 4 -..:,.:)j~wjif;J ~
JJI I)'v
~.¥
c[J:1
f~~ -?/ ~U}IJ;£j,:r ~ rfi ~ -i: zs L'J;£j ,y~ uh '-/ JJJJI .zL
'jl~~ L~{ v!ji -"
v! Vir o:tft v! ~ J L-llji '..:.v-I;/. J.;:..-!)'~":"~ '",:",'l '~J' a: Ok. ':;>jJ v! ~ f v! t.f ":"~'-t-: 2.... L UJJr -~ .L1fIPG Jj ~jJ' J &, 2..L.-- L U/,Jv!.,:..)1v J':; 8J s:7-0jV' 2.... L .Lf(r; Jr-li!' ~I 1)"
~ (j'
'~j
JJJ ~
U/,J(~ jJ'
'u/.j:i{ ~
Jl) JJI
'-? -l.C\
_;
-~ _;.,:..~ J~ f'J-ojV' t.f -: 2.... L;£j 2.... L ;£j (r; !JL 1)'1 -Llf ~~ tli J ~
'(jl;:)! UJ:tft
Jr
~
'I JJ:z {J' ~
JL.-- 50 OJ~i5%"";/
&! I)''v' L
0;/.
J~'p d v! OJ~i~j!...i f1901 '~~
J
f J'i;~j v!/ S JL.-- 50 .,.I~~ liJ!~)i LIJ-U}~o;r{t! 2.... L U/,JJ(;." : f~ II
.L ~ j;,.';;1 2.... 1)'1 -tJ elfif ~I ~t
(25)tt_~,
-7- ~j;fJ(il Jf~":";11 v! Ubj J~JJI ~ ~ U..r.:~JR; 2.... 1)'1 -I .,:..'/ S (.!)f.tl; ":"jl ~ J~JR; JI v! vir J.. ~J{ ,Jjl,f :# &' u! (j~JR; J.;; -J'i (!/' ~1)'1 f~ OjV'
Jt
66 2....
v' -~ LYl f
.::,A ~
.0' v! (j1.1 J~~ J-'1/":;',_f. ~' J! L JJ:cfi
J.~L ~f fi~
~ _/OJ,.f. ~ (26) -Ih nJ ~
~
~';:IP
J~L/ t.).1{~ ":,,,fl ",:",J' 2.... L ~, i ~ ",-.I,,;,'...f- (j_:,'Jv.l ,f-' ~, ~,.f} -J!J.J ,f-' ..:;,'.Iijy OJ{t,o -~ CYlt.).1~ ~
v.. fI9112.... L~ v' '",-.f..:.&..:;,~ ~ ~ Ji.ll:cfi J~J-'1-J v' (English Etiquette for Indian Gentlemen) if s~ ",:",Cl~ J,!;-' ~ J'~,J ~ '~j '..:;,liWf~t':::;'J L.f fit f V1,f t.)J":;'~'1 v.. f~ JI? v.. J!-:~ (2&) -L~,J ,f-' ..:;,~ JI v.. '-.I~ L J"" ~ -:~v' J,[L~,J _:,..JJ.} ,JLli ~ _:,IP~ilP"'e". L ..:;,/J (28) -'1- ~~J}L JL .J.,f-' L JA tllfi( Yl t.)fi .s.r _:, Jl (- ~":;'.11:cfi sv t.).1~ v.. ,.U.- L v~ .IJ'J.J v~Y' ,_l.ll :cfi s;v! "'-J ":;'~'1-:~.l.Jb !.lIPL J.lU J~J-'11 Ji.ll J'J L.f ,,/.1 J'[-v.l _:',,/.1 2.,.1..-- L J.i~J-'1 JJ:c)i f if J~,J ,f-' J'1' .::A ,J..:;,~ v' (28) -V1;£ Jk-"J~t cI...ft.)JI?~ J~J-'1":;'.II:cfi JI fi -JYl Dh:t.)JI?v.. J~~J.h1.1J' ,.U.- L":;'.I14 J~d~~,OJ.lJ'~ (GJ.fJ.I~' Vb--:cfi i if (jJJ, ~.Ii f if _:, ..:;,j~1v.. J}!; ",:",y f ~vI? ...f v' OJv.. if DJ~j.l)'v.. '-.I~ L..:;,liW?- -v.l JJ ":,,,y IJ~~J-'1 ,_l.ll uk -~ _:,..:;,liW?- ~ J~~J-'1 f if t.)k.~",JjJ,} ~.Ii: if ~ CYl JC 2.... v' v.. '::-J ..:;,j~',J L~ ";'.Ii IJi.'} n' JJ~'.1 f ...f ~J v' -L v.l ('i -=-liW?- ~ Ji.ll ~.Ii .IJ' Jr.f ~ J~J OJf {.Ji~~~ J-'1v.. ,.U.- v' -J L~~v.. '-,? ..:;,:/ n' ('/' ~~,~ ~ (Maud Allen) V:';L~';.I"?-- ~ -?/ ...fI f~ J~~ .I; v' Vb-",:",J'
.N1
67
,_i.l V'./~j J J~ JP; s:~.I;
v; i b: (,);"
r ,_i.l
v! d~ Jp;
v,,.f£, J1':' (,_I;" fVc.-f' ~ L ui.ll Jy JI 'J ~,:,I c.-'.1 lS}lb/.L r:JC: J~ .IJ' "J1 ,_i.l -: J1 f ('/'r .::,,;f ~
J2 -'(
(29)
-~.1 (~ Of
,~ ..:.-W.I L ( JJ v! U.i~JP; ~ _::JS-:J.I VI L UJJI L.I .: ..:.-~ J.~~ d' .IJ' L~ ~.1.IJJ~ UJJI f -: i ~ -LJ1
''':;'~lSJI f~ -:dlf.l Y JJ -'f- JJ1J;t ~ Sd' ~ v,,.f £'J!~ -L~J.::,.,) Sd' JL L~V.I~' 1 c.-'J.IJ (.I .IJ' J) .I} L d' .IJ'
v!
tt
...
"."
~..Nf (f
~.JC/ - It£..J ~?.. lSzOf •
..
~ d'.f.l V' ~ ••
UJ~/If ,
if-IJ! LJ1J}i ~ ~Ji IJ! L./.I~'~";;; Sd' J}~ f 'f- ~ :f IJ! ;£U -1J!.1 v! ..:,.JIP S..:,.Jj vI s:'f- -:~ r lS/.v. lS.lVl(~ -: 'f- rr Jy, ~ v! d' 1uJjI
r
.r
u.;:'''JJ.I~ .::.-r'JJ
Aft::-
J
1J1ul.i./,.
L./
-v.!' ~ v' r US UY'JJ L/.v. .IJ' '=':-
i?'z '.I1Jiiu" f~
V v! J;lPJl d' L dJ./L!,-J'J .IL.$,r V'
tt-UJ1 c[,'J1 LII~II ~ LrlS~ IU.i~JP;~ f 'f- LJ1
d~JlSJt y, fVi
2... L;;f
Cilv '''L -t::,. (~ V+,.,
'.IVlf 'f- Ci~ (~ -: .....-IL./ ..:.-'AJ.~ VI L
(30)
(31)
,
v!Jy,J~ ,:;~~ ~.I! ~ v! U.i~ J-"1~
V' ",:,,1 i ~"';;;'J~ Of ~ .I~, J":'-y;i ~.Ii .IJ'13CJi Of
I.,:;,~~.Ii L
U~, f U£"~.1~
6 ''f- d~
~ .IJ'
'J~-:f~-:
2... L J~ .IJ' J) ",:,,'2... v"~ ~.f.l~IOf ~.I! " .I} d~.IJ' ;i~rfi f L~ V ~~ -: .IJIL~ ~lP'Y. Li 1~ L~
f~ lS.lJ/
./2...
L u.i~JP; ~fi -IJ! ; f".I}
~ J~JP; Jy,J~L ?
68
.0' ~ Ly; ~, 8J~j « ",:,,' ./(1) ~ Ly; ~, ~ 1'1848 J;AJ r (Nigger) ~ r v' ,_, ~ /i r~ (32) -vy;.1 v! uJ)1,J (j' j(;.-J~/i ./iv! ~~iC:>'-: e: L v' 'y;~ j~ ,n' (j'.;:(;0"v! (jc:Jj, ~J~
(33)-I)C~y;~ ~/i Uk)J'~L~y;( )J' ~)t. v! v' .J.1j),f-JJA J U~(;.-J~"";_.,.J"p./.j) -:
Li 'I) C~ l/,f- I.;, v! ~VO)r_r If I(j' -~ r If ~.1;I~' .J.'~ L~ 4-J ,f- if- '-.J 0" v! l:) U./. J u/·1Un (j''/ ~ (34) -I) C'/'y;~.::.J> ,J)J '-.J J~ )J' Jj J.l r (j'
,J J~uJ-: J'J
v! (J L~~v' "";u; L ~)t.
)J' ~.1;1 ~,
L u_,J) JJ v! (j(;.-J~ J£'IJ! L./ ~; ~ (j' if- (j(;.-J~ J' f e. L (j' e: v' ,_ C~II(" J1t~, ,_ Jy; ,~ JtJJ' Yo ~ "i"J.),
0" L.::/; I un
(j' ~ ~J
v' -,_,f-
(~, JI v!
v
lr j(;.-J~
v!~ ~ L v' -'(Li Jj v! ~~,J.::/; ~'::-J '-.d J" i ~) U)~"i"J.), -: v! u_,J) JJ fi fl) ~)./(rif-~ r u/./. j) ,J
uJ~
,J (j' Yo Jy;
-:-J'-J''/
"'iuJ)1 r u;J~ v' ~ ''( )JJ")~'r un 1.::/; I~' ,J
~
JJ~
,J
~ wfI f,J ,:,~j~' OJ
/./.v! ~
J' ~
"i"J.),
y;
,J (j' L'/(
-:
/i ~ u~(;.-J~
(j' ~
)J''':''>(;!
Ijlj ~)t. f ,J ...f ~ v' ~; j) (35) -,-./ '£lr I~)I IJ} ~ fl) jiJJ )J' u/./. j) -:
L L'/.::/; -:fl) ;C-:v!'-)~L u.ti(;.-J~ )J' ~;£ ~ v! ~Ib' ,f-' )J' L~,J .::/; ~ (j' f ,_ U)-?? i..J" -IJ! ,fr J~()v! UJ)'J' ok-- J U)~ ~ U~(;.-J~ v! f1885 ~ -L~ ./.::/; f ,f- Ji J" j(;.-J~ f j UJJ'J If.. if- ~J v' i l/..,!UY'
69
-I.f
-Jr 1.1' J",j I L-'f- / UJJ'.....;/
J(2....).::/$-uf
f v1 JG" 1.1' j~JP; fr;c£ L.I.I -: Yo r;tf. ~I¢, ~ /), V:' -?J 1.1' -: JJ' 'i:_; Oi.l~ -::t..Ir (36) -L uf .1.::/$ C)J ~ j~JP; f i:;£ JJ' -i:;£; f/~ .IJ'..:,j~j~JP; eJ fr;~ (37) -~, cc: J'Z _; .IJ'~,.~ .::.r...J"";: .IJ'~ ./~ (J eJ
,,~L
1. Sale, P.: Conquest of Paradise. New York, 1989.
.I~!J'~Jp. ( ~
Nt
Uji
:
if ~~ ji~:~ 2... L
~
2
126'125-t./ '91996 144.IJ' '131'123-t./ :"~'
3
4. Spear, P.: The Nobobs, London 1980,P. 32
32-t./:"~' 27 -t./:
"~'
5 _6
7. Hutchins, F. G. : The Illusion of Permanence: The British Imperialism in India, Princeton, 1967,P. 29
8-t./:"~'
J'J J-{ J.I~t. ~.I;fi The Intimate Enemy: J!, -U.J/
91996
_8 _9 17-t./
31-t./:~'
10
70 38 -1.1 : "~f
11
12.Maclane, R. D.: The Rebel Bureaucrate, Delhi 1983,P. 139_140 156JJf 155 -1.1 : "~f
13
A"
585_86 -1.1 'f1963 J.trJJ
105-V:JJL
14
87-V:~
15
..:,..JJ(;.:.;.c/
16
581_83 -1.1: "~f
17
-1.1 : "~f
18
-r.v.: k :.;.c/
532_33 97
-...I 'f1962 J.trJJ' { k '«/
..:,..~:.;.c /
19
35 JJf 34 -1.1 :_&'f
20
21.Wurgaft, L.: The Imperial Imagination, Wesleyan Uni.1983, P. 43
27-V:"~'
-22 23
54-V:cf:
24
27-V:~
25
57-V:~
26
57-V:~
27
54-V:cf:
28
57-V:~
29
109-V:~
586_87 -1.1 (yC k).;c /
30
lO-V:~
31
112-V:"~'
32
71
33.Ballhatchet, K.: Race, Sex and Class Under the Raj London, 1980,P. 97 98-I.! :"~'
34
121-I.! :"~'
35
t:f':
36
49-I.! : 88-I.!:h
37
72
L
JlJI .nl .JI.JeJ f j y; (i LI.J
I)! '-.J~L u~I;:--J.-'1
-: ~
L .::./, eJ f 'f- ..::.:?J..L.1 -: I)! cJI 0' ,; .JJI v.t ,f-' U~I;:--J.-'1P! L VI i 'v.t ~JIJI).J /Y Jy; ~ I~
4:--'
-v.t
Jl;i> JJ L LI)I
JI .JJI
cJL!' 4- .JJI '..::.---'JI('J'~
.I.~ J ~"
Ji ~ J;~
I)! Uyl( (]tall
? L .::./,tJiIb.l.l)! '-.J~L
~.J} J.JC
S.::./,.J-Lr- Lj.'. J -:::;u, ~ cJI .JJI L~ .::./, L Ui~
.J~I
~ cJI I)! tiL
-&' -Ly;
jl;:--J.-'1 f -: i
JIP L cJI IcJI I;J ..f£'v.t tJJ~ -: L J. f L~ ~J j~
~
-v.t LJ tJ)u uLj J ..::...fU,1 SUi~ 0' ~I -: .JJI'f- S 'v.t....uL L .JI.J.J~.JJI v.! cJly):jl;:--J.-'1~ji fl) -: y JJ I)! uiJ~ ScJI ''f- c:c: ~ v): I).J L cJI -'f- c:c: ~ '.Jt,..v I cJI.f
-:J
f 'f-
J'~-:-'f-
k"J~ ,f-'I
c:c: ~ 1~Jv L (I( ,f-'I
L J ~J..L.11SUJ)J'
.JJI ''f-
.JJI ..:..Ly.J'i~1
t~ JV J~
'..:..l'J.J ScJI ~ -L~
? tJiU,.I. ";".Ji .JJI '",:"JI '~.JCScJl;:--J.-'1-:-J JJJi'tt~r"Yo f J u -&' ~
..::...fl.? ~
I:!y; I~,:r J~ v'.JJ''f-
I)! cJI -il. ..!.r.1)! UYl.? JJ ~ )p/ vI
tJiLJ.JI(cJI ~
.:JIPSUn L vI e.tL~
v~
SJ. i:.._/~ '-Yo .JJI cJI;:--J.-'1 L JJ eJYoYf J J-J ScJI -I) tiL
jv-J.-'1
L cJl;:--J.-'1~
-?J
.I
f~J(~ LI.J
-: I)! '-.J~
L cJI i~.J:/z!
73
v.. ~L L UH do -7,f- ~.lJ
~
'4Jl ~
J1j Jy L
f".I}
tL J;! "';'1 L.2,) .lJ"~"" 'o.!.-.li '..-:."JI 1)IJ Lf J~ .lJIAt~ ,f- ~.lJ if.?Ji .lJIb fJ.I /-1UJ)J' .lj ~k'J.I S1:)1'o»
1~LLI:)If 7o.lJ/2...L;£ 1d'jLtJHL~J~-T jl;--J~ J _,['L~~ ~Uv' r UJJ~ StJJ.lIJI .lJI~k'J.I S1:)1'L~ IP(
Vlr v.. ~.I~ vI i 'V~J....; II:)I)i
.lJI.I~I
-~f tf(~1 "/
,-I
r tJJ)JI.lJI~k'J.I 1:)1'-
f ""e~
';.lJ
-7 !:i'",f-I
~J vI -'(
'Lv:.f I:)JIiJ'-~;
Vlr
L~"".I~ r JJ~
v.. ~.I~ vI
~Jk
-Lv/?ISLf f toJJ!
tJ~j
J' '(-I '-
dlj
L.:.JlP
If tJJ.lIJI.lJI~k'J.I ~J~
f'-fv.. ~tJ,lrL d' .lJItJ~ ,f-
-kJ JJ .lJI
J-J~".I}
.lJIUJAV
tJ~J.lJIkJ.lJj "
L d' 1yfl.lJI
1f",j J~v.. IJ~L
Lf J'''' .II) ~
"
.I}
JLr L tJ.,/I
J'''' 2...L ~.l1f 1f~I 0/ JJ (1) -~
'1-.1 .dL
,,~~ vI S~rv.. .lJJJI~I 0:), '-.I} tJ'1V -S,f- ?1SL~1f",j J~L dl;--J~ SLi 2...L Lf5! IUt? Jk- '- ~J ~I -tj.l .lJJ'- ~tJ,lr oilb/. .lJI'I"" J'
L ~;
U
,; JJ
v.. ~tJ.lr
~k-- J{'~I
~I
J~L '-/lr
~J~
~ "::;Jv'
f ! J!
v.. .lJJJI~I -OJ ,f~ ~J ~
S'1-.1 .lJJ.lJI'::-J
JStJH (~~ v.. tJJ.lIJIJ'k.ltJi/.~ -!J"",f':;-, f Yo ~ I
r
~P!
r~tf ........0" tJJ)J'-.Nf jl;--J~ ,-I
~j~I
'-
.lJ"::;Ib".I} ~J
Sif.!
-L,f- p J"I} L J....; t/ v.. (Wi
J....; v.. ~tJ.lr 0lV' f~
tJ1.?IJ! r ~ vI ,f-I '-/
JJ
74
V- ~IP P I(~ L ~.Y..J L U~I ~ ~J 0'" -i- (/ do ~ V- ;I~I Lt'J.J L~ IUJ-"J' J"! f~ / J} IVI .JJI~ ?-.J eJ~;~ eJ~;.JJI ~L{ J-JI ~ J{'V- LL; Jlk.I VI -L~ 1£
.r tv-~
If.! ~J JII VI ~ U,..;~
L ~tJIP
~I
..!JIJ~
Lb:~.kt
.JJI J.J/ _,..
V-
I un ...f ":::;'JvI
JJ-
O"k-- If ~IP~I
'13 ~1' ?i~JJ
J}lr
.JJI
-"
v' -~ ~ J _:. dL
j..I..
V- ~IP~I J;lr .JJIJ:1r- r)i fti t;f~(Mounstuart Elphinston) ~ l(- ~ LY/ cJ' Iui.Jl .J!h~ Y r f'( Y/i t.f.. i :£. Y/ ~k'"~ ~j L J' 60 V- ~.J~ J~P! ~-P. i~ LY/ (~~ )i J2 -L -L ~.JL V- -P. J} I:)VJR; j/ J~ If -:.,:..fLz -: OJ~ L ~~y.J J:1r- J O"k--I;)I ~.J-¥, J..:.JlPJ vI ~I I.)) 'i- ~ Y/ I{ ~~-"",.J)' Y ~...l/ J L .::/!JiU1/....f ":::;'JvI -i- If.! Jr.f JI J~~I c.)! v' -i'L~~ ?-.J ~ U O"t I ~1J1Pf " If'" ~ vI ~yr J~
f"
v.:~
J ~~vI vI ~I
r
,J. 'L~ J If.!~ I JI J L1'~..f I ~}lr -Y/ .:;)f. J.::/$ V- d' .JJIY/ ~IP J~I r ~~.Jf L~
J~Jk
-s~
~.Ji V- i:P'JR; fti ifL J ..!.-I.Jrl ~
LY/
I
a.J ~.;, I~~
J (:) .::/!-:-i- J' 100 h;; J' J J. i- .::/! J J.J-¥' 2.... L.::/! 2.... vI -i- JUX;t:--JR;~yrIf V- (:) vI 'i('; "' ":::;'Ib
.::/!Jilb/. i Iy/ If.!l.::I)i 'Y/~
....;~I eJ~;~ (2)
J1;)1",.I)' O"k--~ Ji J.}? ":::;'Jv'
-J~J
uiY
(}lP OJ f i-
/J~I
~I ~"' (II
V- -:J.JL .::/!Jilb/.
75
'~.lr .I '-J d i ~IcI~rV ';-, L U';I .nl ,f Yi b;i- ~ 1'1828.1 L ~ 1'1784 I.))-J.I (i ([Jtl~" ~I L.I '-~ ~ ~I ~ rJ. ,1'(j.JJYi b;i- ..:Al. OJ .JJI'(j.JJi J~v! -:J.JL .::/; ...f SO~I JIii) v! ~I.I' L~ 1£ i J~IUJ)J'J~~ -,?fi ,1'1) J~ S~I ~ JPi ,,:-,1-~b:b,?-- f ~j S v! ~I L (g.I uk-- -L~ uk ,,:-,1 ,.4 I) v.! 2.. L ..:.. ...JJA u'(g r ~I v! J vI -I) uJ~i;
iG
2..L~iv!J~LJ"1.JJI'~ J!.:/P...f .J'/J.}~v.!' Yi IL~ J~ r L.I .:/P ~ v! ~I~ I.))-I) ~ Yi r ~I ~~JPi L ":"~.J~'-t' I'-;~ J~JPi ,1''/ Yi u.J~ -: ,,:-,1 i ''/ v! ...!.-.J{.J ~ S1'1847 Sje .J~Iv! j;~1 t'J .11,$1 r VI -L~ -~CYi , .::J '..:..!t1'r. '-/.J ~ ~~~ ~ ,1' LYi ~J u ,,:-,1,:,17 r ~~ -i:.. L~ Ly ..:..j~ J I.JJI vJu,
tllPoj(}.~
J;?
r
r
L ~I.JJIL~ ~b: I~IP S~I -'f- .J.tLl ui? '~.lr .JJ ~ ~JP; -L~ ~ J~I I J~Ii.JJIb.Jj
-+! ~IP
JYi 0$ v! vI '~.I
Jl. .JJI~ Sui? ,
(3)-~~JJ
L..g V' S..:..IP~' ()! ~~ .f J7 ~I.ljiIJr.Li.....;~Lu~JL,,:-,JP),~ -v!' uY:;? JIJ
LY/ ()! ~I
()!~ ~
I ;;f 'Jj.J1. L ,,:-,JP)I ~. -i:.. 'f-.J./.' ..:..~ L L ~ -I) ~ L~.:/P,.f~' .1'1)p J"'} u,,:-,' -I) ~y{v v!.J.~ L .J'A 'Jj.JI.-:-L~~ (? I--?.J Lv'v!'-;~ .JJ'L~~ ~ v! J~'~,-~i.I L IL.J;J~'(j 2.. L w L ..:..'Ju,o .JJ'~Ll ~I ;;f
o:~
76
r V'~..4'7.':::"'"""", r ~I), ",:,,'',J J' (r ~, u~;.:::.....,..,. v.. UJ.I; 1j.lJ/ 2... L (r -J L L ~; J' ~ .IJ'~ -f J"; ".,r (r
»;
J,). L
UJ.I;
J~''Ji.li.~'
I.JJ -L~ V'...?L-L ~j.lJ' 'ljAtle'.:::...'
VIIi VV' -::j r ~tJlpL i:PJPi ~.d L if.V"~I ~ J' (;, i 'f- ~ .,r J...; v..~' eJ fi 2... v' ''f- L--...fi-f /i d'j jI)' f d'j -J/ .:.:::... Jf v' L J..; -'f- ~ ~ V' J...; if- v..i:PJPi .:::...' v' -L~ V'J...; if- I~~'J.I.IJ'uJ)J' L ~;lr J. L~ VJ...; I '~(>I,..jv IuH L ~~ JPi 2... L~ v.. Jj v.. j. L if. o» J';; .:::...~lai ~ ...rr L~ JlIJ ~lf .:::... v"~ ~ do IjJ~;}._fii:PJPi..f.;: (4) S.,r ,~ 1j.ll,.J,J} .IJ'IjJ';; 1j.lJ/ ~~Ll,I' j;lr J J:~'2... L J; J' ~~JPi fVlI~j. -:: 2... U!.Ilt; .IJ'uJ.I'~; 'u}~
I~Jt v.. ~~JPi ~ s,(.)J (/
",:"k-"r ":::;'Jv' ~~Ll,I' -:: .IJ'(.)J (5) -L~ lIlPoj J./JP' L t)J..I;;(j~' Iv' .IJ'L~~t)V~J.I if- L (Utilitarianism) c1", ~G' O'J L/.' v.. Ijv ILYi' ~
~lIp L c1", ~G' -lI'jJ, "' Ub.l L ~!.IJ'~ 1j}1b/.v.. ~~JPi ~~ flJ{ ",.I~ V' IUJ)J'.IJ'~~'J.IJ'i:PJPi L U~, J, /; L -:: ~ '(.)J ~ J'i ~Jlr v.. J; J' ~;lr -::V'~'f- V' ~G' J' ~, v.. ~1I~ .IJ''J£/'..!?._fi q J' ~, ",:,,'.IJ'La? / ..:.r."G' .IJ'~'~' ,~ S;;; .IJ''J)CJ/.:::... V~JJv.. if.f 'f-I.f J' z... L ':;;>.IJUyj Lb: ~~ .IJ';;~ J; I~;lr J~JPi f ,J ~J I{~' <:(/ ~ J' If.! '.16;.:::... c1", ~L 'L~JlIJ~lf .:::... ~lai .:::...' f'f- 1j.lJ/ 2... L ~_;; J~JPi v.. ~tJIP uYoy"..f£ L~ V"~I (S,y?L-- .IJ''L~~lIJ . ..... -_
-'f- JI; .:::...~G'
77
r:fb di'
OJ
J LlJ)()I v!
L dt:Jil L if. --fi ~ o-?Ij Yo f if --fi 0:1. S(Evangelican)
I./;~f '-/lr
4·L ~J¢I
J) 'SZ_J) f ..:-~ ~J¢I v! (I'
L
vI
-J.,z
J? v! oN' Ll~I
./~J; L up.? ~ vi fl./ ~ ~ L) vI f.tllY 0:1. a: . _::;..., t.,z~ 2_ L 4-/lr fJj f~ -:1 J;j) r'~ d' -L.,z _I.,z,j" r:PJPi ;1 ~ u£i )JI uJ;? d' JIJ L.,z v! ~I ~ ~J JIP ,-y. ~ "':'"'" L ..:-1Pu",IJ/lr )JI J:1r- v! t,,:)VJPi jl.tll f);' J ..:-~IJ)S d'V'JPi -: -i:......J~ )JI L~ (f1828_f1838) O)¥' -:2_L~vl_i:...?-,tJ ~ "JjL~)ifvlr'LJ r ..:-1Pu",I f d' )JI L~ S ~IP -=-cLlS 1#. Jy?, L d'V'JPi si:...;£ ,j;.~t;f .J. 'U.,z ,:, LSi J/lr
)JI
J:1r- ...J/
..:-1Pu",I-L~ ~~~)j
-L~~ifvt! J) f d'V'JPi JI
,j ~ ..:-IJlf;I
O)¥' 2_ L L) O)~f J' L ..:-1Pu",If~,j -:1 j;;i
~ d'
f ~ vI I;,'J''f- J.,z ~ .:A..$. J£'L~ 1./;:;" ~..$. f 'fL r:) O}Ib.l. f ~~vI S;:;"~ ..$.-L~ 1./V v! jl;i L ..:-1Pu",I .,zJr. J,UI L d' ~...f1~ L.,z,:,..$. ,.1£'1./ ~ ~ L U~I UJ)I~..J
L -::"uV1 Jy )JI t J~.,z
f ~I S d' '-/
.:./,L ,.71; L J,; fl./ .::.r.~ L ..:-ul.> ~fi
f ..:-IP~I v! '-/lr
JJ )JI i:... L~
-,J jl:> Il>y. ~I S
~~r
fl.,z,Jt -:~ --?JS vt jJI f ..:-ulP JL L ~ --?JS vI ~J.,z ..1>. dWI v! f1838 ~ ,fl -£ ~~IJvitJ) Ui)~ S..$. OJ'~~).,z V "dl Yo ~ OJnl l/~ J' I){ I( ..:-IP~I (6)-1/J v! ~~ ~ v! d'
'ff. L~
4-r Yo 2_ L L~~;"" f ui'V'JPi
J1
r
78
Jj Lf), el~.JJ L.::./'f
L el~JP;
frJ
o='~V'L ~~~,.:-.!,I)! .JJJJ';,' -L~ JIf.! O;'.t'
-::J : r d' -'f- f f.J~'
I)! ..::-LJ.lr 0;), L U/Y
"::-.JyIJO'J: .JJ' J.J?
'''::-J~
O;'.t' "J
.Ii frJ
.; J~ V'
_;/'" I)! vIP L ~ I)! .JJJ V' J;; -L v:.f If.!
IJ} ~ ..::-LJ.lr Lf), J J:~L U~,
I)!
I)! dL;1J,
2.... V' 'rJ J~IJ' J_,P r~,j
u.ii 0;), d' i...f' ~~ r~J
O? ,fo:. eli' .JJ' I.!..-S~
;£: .JJ' -L ?-f
J...; Jlr
I)! ..::-LJ.lr Lf), -~ .JJJ
"J
-v!' J' (l/
t~;J/ r ui'J.J.Jr ~, Iel~JP;
I)! dL;1J,
,,:,,'Po
L ~~r
cC ~ ~~_7-/..::-J~ J~'Jel' f ~J~ I~JP; f L
if.Jf -~
Lv'
"J
0;), .:;-.'./'L v:.f J} i I J"J 1J~ ok--
.JJ' j){
Yo frJ
JC' L~ ~~J~ If.!, frJ:
k".J~' I
I)! ..::-LJ.lr 0;), J£L~
I ~'JY
.JJ'('1
s» if. Llr J~ (l.i I'"':"'l), J~ 2.... L
u.i~JP;
~'J
J
J J'::";-'; J 0' .I,' JJ1_7- ..::-J~ J~'J d' -L UJ1.JJJ
..::-Ini .JJ'J"JtJ~ Uyri./. 'J" .; ..::,;;'..::-~..::-'jiJ> u~'j '"':"'l), Jp; ?-.Jj
L d' Yo [)'
(7) J1
-JL~ J1.JJJ
J~ j~JP; fi f i if: JJ...f'I)!,.U.-
.::./'f ('1 .JJ' L ,,:,,'Yo
v.:~
J1 k.
v.:~
Yt )JGJ 4.5'~'
L u.i~JP; I)! ,.t. L ..:.il.-! jI
J) If.! .JJ; .; Lf J.}l .::./'f ~~"
frJ I;fr ~'./
",..A' If.! ..::-~~ok-- I)! ,.t. L V' '))/'f-
~
f I)!
if'f { v'
J1, 07- Ju.;, -: -'+-
ef'; If.! I)!~;V I..:.v-h--~ JI ,9 J~':-L lut? J~ L ~ v! f1813 I)! ,.t. L J~JV'
(8) u_'f-
JLi el~JP;
'f- ~";:J
~'.J L ":,,JJj1, I)! "::-.JyIV' i ~ L~
L J'"" V' -LJ1 v! d(;ii, f 4 L
~ L v.:f k"i t-LJJ.J ~
JuJ1ll L ~\f~~
8J
79 J
J
j'.
0:'" ~Ut?JI..-: v!? ~ L~;~, 1.1' ~ -t5J'-J ~;~,
/,Jp t5.1~ J!2... L Yl
r
J? S~
d~.IJ' 0:'" '-
1.1' i ~ L~ Yl JI..-: ~~
1.5.1»
~~ Yl.l'.,uJL 1.1' Lf
L '-/» ~ Lj c[,OJf ~i-~
,;-'
OJ
('i Jj d~.IJ' 0:'" ...f ~ J£ -I:..
U)JJ ~
v'L~».ILJ'~
"'-'~
vi~
~»;-vL~.I!~'-~ OJ
I:..~.I", ~"'.~'
J!~ t5~/.
~ ~j
v'-L~;
'i-1.1#
2... L 1.1' j'. 'U f iOJ
J~Jk...f ~ f~ r/J!~..!.J.''/ (9)-~;ff
'-.I{ '-.I{
JL~
1.:)' ('/.lJ'
J.lJ -i- ~.II1.::,j/~~' ~
-!0'.1
ji
r-?.::/;~' /.::/; S
i-~ '-~
cI'/.~f
ifh-- ,;-' / 1.1' J{ UrJ'~~..ir
~ ~ '-U)~
v! 1.1' "Yl t,;.,} ,.U.- j'. ~tf. O:"'.j~
-:1.~~
..JL...I"~ .I? ,;-' L Ifo j' v./ ~.I~ 1.1' -£ ~ .:f,v.!r+;£OJ -~ , l)"; "" c~ ~P!. .. .. v-
"'r /t5.1V1f £
L
~J
(
/
U~;JJ.,;-' ~
Jj -" CYl0' 1.:' .IJ';"- ~J
frJ C;~ ~
_v'
~ ~L"
~"
t5.1J~f1.:);
,f J/f ,J t5J( J; 0:.' L 4 1.1'
('i "":"1'" ~ J~J' t5.1V1~ '.IV1v! t5-"J J' S..:,..:).11 . (10) n_f i-.1
0:'" j'. L ~ t5.1J~ft"l LYl Z_'j c!J.I"' 1.1' .I:)" Lv. / f t,;.,} ~!?' "'"":"1'... '-/ JJ v! 1.:)' /- t,;.,} ~li!tf. L~ u;:Cr' ~ ~ j,~'~; ...f! v! '-.I~ 1Un 1.1#
L 1.:)' .IJ' 4-J ~11' 1 Jr S~ f,J -:~~Sut? (11) -'Yl &.11un '- do -: .IJ'L~ ~J.I",.Ii' Y 1 (JY' .IJ'.::/Jk f i- t5.1~ 2.... L Lf .IJ' uy.$
80
_;LUt? i...L~V'_v.rJIII/ ~I_j-:f4~..:,.t VbfJJ; JL ~.flr J; UJ.Jlj~ .JJIUK ....cc.~ ~ .JJIv9' -4-J.f~.v ~"' cJk: L t.j v# J5'..J/ J; bfJ~ o.JJ~ v# .JJIIun v# L ~_j) ....cc.£ L.f v.! (12) -£ L.fJ~ ~ ~ .JJI J'..t. .:;..< Iu,,-t;. J; fl855 ~ f J11 ~-{ ~ .:iJJ V' Iun J; '-.J~L ~ r do f tt. _;'J.Jb~ L ( v'v~L ~jJJ. o.J~ L~4' o.JJ~ ..J/
':f~~
..,..,..~ J..t. .Ies:11oA.J,f' ~ ':;).Ju,r
J; ~JPj
(Ii ,-:,'
J>.~ ~ Jy ,-b ',f 11~ j J>.
? r.tf-~2...v"~~~~~_j',f11~ (13) -~
11~_j ~
J~~~
cJ'..yr~L~'_ju;JJJ~.JJ'~ v!J. L5! J~_jJ~ L ~'_j cJ' >. >. ,-:,'-'11 r !flr-' ~ -:tJJ if.Lr ,j J; .JJ'Jr J~_j ,;-' ll'J ~_j/i v! do L L11 ,-Jlr-' cJjt.JJL f~ I.:;,>~ O}_j~' ~ v! cP'JPi L U~lr-' c,I' -" L./.I~",r ~v J''7' .;_t~ L ~_j..J/ _;v! cJ' -if v.! ~ ~ V' Yo f~'~ ~ J; un ~ if.! Jir J~ ~"'L)~Lh'.JO}_j....cc.'£ L11 -J!11,~ Jj 0}_j..JtJVL '-/ JJ .J~'1~..:.-/ J.Jr rt r v' -'11 .I? .:;..<V ~ v!U~lr-' cJ' .JJ"cJ'/''J!I-: ~ ~ v' _~rt:)/'J~ J; fl839 ~ J'j J5!-:'Ii d f ..Jv dIY' L (lSi J~~r;~ J1 .s;; L v' -" ~ 11.1 v! J;
'~1
81
I,jJ~ Jtlj JI v! VI ,,:",1s»~b: e.J,1. ~ J; VI /. ~J
2... VI"
J...; ~ ..." J} J1j J'5l J'~ v! ~;~ JIYI ji JIYI J; J3#' J' 'TJi s» Ji J! r V' -£ J~ 2... L -I ~.If f /t"J J./I ~I (IYI JJI-J d I ~;~ -J .If ~.r I.)! 5l J' ~ ...J~ .::....~I L V' JJI ){:.IJ' ,;1; ~ ~Jj L V' JJI,J.~ Ir JJ~ J'~ ...J~ II:)I ~Jj L L)j,c..,tJ?
Lf
eJj ~
eJ
r
tLfk"I~1
~J
~
JJ v!~J~L~
~J
...LI:)Iv!~
.:J~~ (j
k"C'J J!-:"L)W -v.'"f.lf J~" ~ J~ fj/.:.J,~ ';-, eJ,JC J'":"'/"f.lf J~ eJ _.) T" V' Jvil rJ; ~ J u~J' 1:)1 ,1''( ~ L ~ Lly 2... L 1:)1 ~ ':;'JyIJ/ JJ J£'J /,~ IJj v! J;
r':l
c,tYs» ~rfr L ~y. J:;;'., ~ji (14) -T ~ ~IJ J/JJI f .If V!- eJ v! ;.. L if. I~ tf ~ r~ ~ .::.... ~ J' ~
.if1f.::....~JPz ...J) wf' v! ~JPz'::"" A L~ ...J....; JJI.::...._::JJ' L)~I:--I:)I J~jJJlifri
I~J11t~ILL)r~...J)
~ Lf ~J
Ji ,.J;ji O!'"
.::....
J/JJj~
{/J J./lr ~
eJ~j.::....J;.;} IJ U~I.:;,LJ,~
L
L~ ~ -J.If v! ~ L ~ ~ I J/ JJ J' ~f.L#I dV'JPzI.::/; J}.b./.frJV-II"J} C'Jv! V' J' ~":'-J{J ~I v! J,_r .f .If~Ji j "J} J1jYo ,1'T ':;'JJ/ J' J/! .:J~~ ~ Iwf' I.)! ,.1835 Yo L
J' ~j
JJ~ .::....1JJI f b: ~ ~Jj I ~j J:JI-J~JPz
v! ':;'JyI
-J~":"'/U/" ~~ J' I:P'JPzL.::./; J}.b./.'f f:: L ~;~ JJI !~ J'VI '!;;~ ~(tlJJ Yo ~ JI" ;; ,.J;ji rV' 'Jr ~.:J~ ~ ~.Ji(j Yo ~ J' 1:)' -~,r J,t .JJI .J~JIj' eJ ~
eJ
r
~J
~J~
~
82
,;L.::/;
L r"~ -I) u·., .e ./ ~.J/? _ .
,(jib/. ,_,J.Jj '-1' _
./(i -".til~11f "' J:.1"" '~1.::lJ
~.Jj L VI
VI_IJ1.Jl;.1 ~(t":"'JII.5:/1"
..t.~
'-.I}
~
. Ur ~IJ.J
I~ t:)p. ';-, -J/
Ifi'v! ":,,,L.-i L -~
VI S VI v! t:P'JRi 'I)C!~~,..;:: ":"'JII.5:/11f v! UJ.JIJI~ ,:;~ ~
.JJI!..
iJj 1}I.5:/1.JJI ) k ~.Jj
L VI )t
'- .Jti11 ~.Ji -t~
eJ ~
..f/'~
,.1£ -sLI)I
L
! ':;'.JJ/ 2...
-L~'V''; v!~~.Ji",.J}J1jl
O"k-./ ~ Lr ~,:;~~ ~.Ji fl/V'AJI
_,•
~
~,>.Ji VI ~fi
;Il
2... L ~IY
f L UJ11f Ji VI eJ.JJI'( Lr If.Jr O"k-v! t:)1] L uJ1 V~J.J I)IILJ1 L./ " "(.;,;,,. VI v! fl833 L L~ -u/.J..l;o ~ .::/; f -:",),/s'.v! e/~ L L./ ~IP ~ ~.Ji S UJ.JIJIL .l} ~.Ji If "';::1 f V! ;f./ -l1Y ~.J~L VI '( a.r ,flf t:)J~ ( VI V'-'f- ':;'.JJ/ ';-,,;v! '- -?J SVI t:f.-,..;::(}v ;; ~ ] v!
r
t:)JeJ,f
fi
Ji OJ~;'c);-'JR; L VI ]
t:f.-'( uJJ.J
,-I,;
-=-"" ~'li.JCS ~I
v!J1~tl,#1
.JJI'( ul1 '-
t?! t:)JeJ]
_;;;".
cr
''f(16) _'( J1t:)Jj
J)~ J (j:~'- ~! S.::./; ~
S.:;,1Ptl,#1t:)' ,.I£~./I~ .1"" ~ v!c,,~L 1.5/JJ 'I/V' ~ I.:;,I.J~I L I.5.JJI/. J (fd'.JJI'c"IJ.JJ (Y'.J'uJIhI.J f JYI '::'-.JJ/S .::.-~ VI.JJI'I)] IJr. L ~}lr L U.J..; t:)' ..J)
cJ!;,]..J) ~ '-
JR;
-?J
L..J1; L J' ft.-
-v."! ~
L/.
'- U)J.)Lv! .::.-1)1" L
83
'I c?-Jt Yo IS'~.I;
J.}ll,-/Ir '4.1./J.}llv' u~'
~ L 1.:)' fl/.I,f. "' LYI
~~,
)jr~~,
~ 1.:)' v!k ~P! W' Lv./ L ,1856'15dI ~ -!" JCt v! ,-/Ir J~~'"'t.:1- f 7-"1/ :f 1.l1;£ tJJ~;~' IS'tJ~ Iuj.l; e.fJ~.Ij - v./ ./v"1 ., L c,h.lJ (.I
V' ~
k.~eJ~; '"' ~.J Yo Jj ~/
~74.~'Y~.J.-~ Lf
~.::.d)
~ f ~Lf jI/): Ui .IJ' L:~~
r 1.:)'.;;(; tJJI,/.
YI .I~
Jj
V:'.fJ~
v:
IdI .IJ'
f 7-" 'YI tJ.I~ '"' Jy V' dI (17)
__,,;I Lf Y' ~~
Yo JJ'
V:~
uP. ;lY If LV' YI~~, Yo v!~'y...) JJ' ~tJ.Ir JISl' r uA u! ~.I~ IS'Lf,:, 'J' ~'y...) 'J? tf uA~ 4(J~ f (~r u;J'~'b-_,Iu}l,f I:)!; Lff I ~ L~).liW J'. JIIJJ' '(1lt "' .Ii J'ij Jj 2... L v'
r J....;
If"J'.c,h.l
J
(.I
v:r
U~-..iYo '"' ~~,
1.:)'
-y!J I.:)}I; L
~~ .e: v:! .I~ L v' '"'(/ if. 'ti v.! p J"'j
.IJ' ~~'J.I
J:~Vir
ItJ;'.;;'JJ IS'.::/; u! ~.J . II.'J '"' J1 tJ~ f ~u.I' u!l:)J.IJ (.I ,;-' L v' (/ ~,'1/v:! J} . ~ '"' ~~, 1.:)' J;; 4(v:! J}ItJ;v I.:)}I; '"' ~1rtf~; .IJ' J2y eJ~;'"' ~ 2... v' ~ LYI J~ ~'p. L 1.:)' .IJ' Jj L~,
~ IS'uJ~ L~ ~f
~~,
~
JJ, '"' ~;
4(L J ~
'j~.IJ' ~J
,{ J'. uii v.!' J~ .I.,! V'I,)p ~.I~ L ~~, 1.:)'
tJ)U,./.r u_;;"~.1~~ .IL,$,r~tJ~ 1.:)' -tf..~1/~.IJ
fl/I/
I~J1,p
...!IY ~ '"' ~'j L 1.:)' )t
L 1.:)' .IJ' tC..I/""!"! ~J.:.1,;-' J'. u_;;"~.1J~~ L .::/; tJiU,./.~
84
i·~ VI , O~ J< YI.)!.:-~ J.,).tl IL);~ -:I.::/', J)tb/. ~ VI ~ ,., t:_ )JI ""J~ f ,., Jljr ~.:-!}J /, ,.I'"J: J.,).tl ~I eJ' L,., ~Ij .:-lMr L ~~),j'~ f tJ, t". J.,,,,,cJ~
fl,., -:
(fJ()LvlJ~cJ~
LL)r~~-?)Jvl_£~f
~{Vl
-!~.JJI ~cJIOJ?;' J .::/', o)tb/. )JI £{ )JI .::/"·O}.J,/. f if- J,.,~'~ -:~ ~ O){ VI J t.-u,,1 L cJI)JI~ ~
J".v.j ~ {JI{.I} j;i 1..:ku,,1 cJIL ~
L VI
L)~~~fi -ifv:! )~~ 2Jr.) J.f { .I}J1j IL)/; )JI ~}Lr 2,j'I.)!.::/" )JII.)!cJI.I' v! ~1/vii J t.-u,,1~~ I.)!L)>>-'" )JI .J)
v:! cJ'; ~(
L cJlf if- c,.,~, If-:~ ..:ku,,1cJI L)/;)JI ~}Lr ~~ f _; £.~ J (1"/ ;;-, L (:,ylr- o)U,/.)JI
.::/', O)U,/.I.)!)i:'"~
IL)/;Lc:P'~ fl) -:~ JJI~ cJl,.1£ -JY."-Jt.-UiJ f Po Lf ~ J:i L IL)?tr.)JI L)P.cJI'L! ~Jljr ~ ~ ~ )jl,., ~J! -: ~ ~}Lr ;r '£. if-) ~ {L)J~L L)/; )JI L)A J~I' J L)/;~I 'I)!JL )~Ije f~ -" J; OJ;)1 J ~ I.)!J
~IJ) J()
r
~ ~I
r
2_ L .:-Ip.1fr )JI ~I
L~; Ivl)C ,J.,:-~J/ J
I-~ ~ (j ~ -?J 0'" -Lf vLr L vl.l' v1) v:! ~~ 'J~ ..:ku,,1~ f if- cr ~I ,;; ~fi -1) POx Lr /.I/..J. v:!~)J' ~ vI 'Il' IJY- )JI'JI~..::.h Pol.)! 4:» ~..:ku,,1~~ L vI )JI 'I" ~
~
-~ JJ:)1/ I~Y J .::/',
o)U,/.L.:-p! J
,1857,.:f-
85
~,.J'Y â&#x20AC;˘ 1.Stokes, E.: The English Utilitarians and India, Oxford, 1959,P. 27 2. Bearce, P. 292 220-,j:H~1 29-,j:~ 34_,j:H~1
-3 4
-5
6. Bearce, P.I65
7. Hutchins, PP.12_16 13_14,j:H~
-8
154_157 -41 :HI;fI
_9
68-,j<{>-;;:/
_10
68 -41 :HI;fI
_11
69_,j:H~1
-12 -13
73_,j:H~ 14.Powell, A A : Muslims and Missionaries in Pre Mutiny India," London 1993,P.I54_156 40_4141~ 34_,j:H~1 76-41:;;:/
_IS _16 17
86
~
-~ J;.1
1JI 1.1' L ..:ku,,'
L ~JGo! ~ uJ'ji ~
Jf1857
u,[!}.p ~ ,1I/1/~1.r 1.1' ~ ~f J.::/f uilb/. j "" ,.JI; r~ rJ.I 41~'t~ L ( 1.1' 2.... L e.Jfi .IJ' ftv! ..:1ftJ 1/J 1.1' ft,,, J,['" 2.... 1.1' A '.IV « ftJ ~ jJ1..Jij1 ~ I)! J,.J... 1.1' YLf .IJ''v;?Lz '2/! rV "J-~ j~ Il:)j'j L'-;~.L I:P'Jk L ..:ku,,' -~~ ~ L ..:ku,,' 1~,p. L do f f.!" -JtJP L .::/;J!)'
s:
f
1:)' & ~~J.f 1 ~'.Ib#' L 1:)' L" j".It 2.... 1.1' I:)Y L ur~.1 (lSi L U.luf L L 2.... 1.1' -"~ j -"A!.ir -~~.f ~ .; ur~.1 J 2.... 1.1' ~ .IJ'Jk..::..r''; .::/'; -'-lJ.f( ~y .IJ'~i J1:)' L 1.1' ~.~~ ~ ~ J JJ I)!l;)J.I J (.I .IJ';;'~ 0;), L 1:)' L u-t'"1PL 1.1' -V-Ih (J/ ~ u?jtJ, J UJNf &, ~, f 2.... f J' ..::..r'.IJL'.1 I!c,l? I)! J,.J... L ~IP!LI' fl/~' ~ 1.1' I!1:)'1 UJ.I'J'J ~~'J.I J1:)' .IJ'Lf ~,_i' JJ I)!~tJ,~ L 1:P'u:-z -LIP. Ih .I';/. /., ./ ~
s.
s.
-I uit' ~1.
0'/ -?J J~JGO! s» ~-::J Y JJ ~ ~/. L 1.1' ~1Pu,,' _; .IJ' 'j~ ~ Il:)j'j L '-;~ L ~IP!LI' -,J ~
4- ~(P'.It
o
JJ
UJ JdJ L"~ ,,:If r ~JGo! L u';' -'" ,~p,(.Ji I)!uli ~ '_;>J L.::/; uilb/..IJ'-(j.lJJ.Jf.1- cJVJk ~ ~.Ii Ifi' ~JGO! ~ f
87
"y;,_;.! --V I.)!1.1':# .:J~~ r~ -f-.1 J;}f .:;_ 1.1' ]_~ "-/
JJ
" b:If J'J 1.1' -~, o..(G .:;_ ~~, eJ~;.:;_ "':"""L U';' J,( J!J'I "-/ .IJ'I.)!~ 4fi L 1.1' .-t.',/. ,_;.!-?JIf ~P! ~IP~' 'f- ~of! r ..:1YoJ d>.1.)! PI ~P! W' .J.....1L ~/ -4: f-.I.f rr JJ
"
~~~JM~I.)!~
J...; Ozl.)! GY If ~ .f J; ('h" r~~,
L 1.1' .IJ' ..::/; 0)U,/. -6. If ,1857 j)~ J J:~L U';' .:;_.A.1l L 1.1' -Jr L
J,(
IfUt?J~
tOJ.f J;
~Ll
I.)!1.1'
tJb: tr-'~cJ
Yo ~I -~
(.?/ 1.1' ~ 0/ 4 Cy;./~ AJ Jk r..:/;.:;_ 1.1' )i -,_;.! ~.I-짜, J/If,,~, If UJ.I; JtJV' .IJ' J:~If uitJ..-'" .IJ'U~JPl If ,,~, Ly; z.),v~ / ~J-짜, JLL; .IJ' ~J L'J ~U U}JJ= :if If~; ~~'.:;_ .l'J'.I' r'.IJ'.I' .,v. ...,J} i '_;:;-' ~ ~.I-짜, c.;., .,., c,I' -, v.. fV~.f
JJ
-,_;.! ~.I-짜'
JIll' LIf If ~~, j}~ J J:~ L ..:/; 0)U,/. ~, fOJ-?i..J)
OJ~Y'O/JJ.lJ'~'J~'~.I~I}/('1
L..:/;
')J
If ~IP~'
~'./Ch' L c,I' I.)!"-.I~ L..:/; JC ~! -OJ "-J / (J'" ..:/w ..fIf J~ ,JJ.I L J...; cJ ~, (1) -Uy; P ~, U.IJ'U.I1,~
'~.I'JJ .:;_ _.v .::.v-.v.; ~
.IJILb: ~Jf
rc,I' /
/
cP'JPl
/ ..:/;
o}lb/. L "':;'JL ,1857
"-/Ir jlrJPi U ..t.lj L ~1,LI1 flJ
J~r1.1' J,(
J' f 4: z....f eJ"= u i.. V"~..JJ/"
I.)! ~J
J;
r~P!,_;.!' ~ Llf L 1.1' f -~, ~y;P~' ~~ J ~JJ~ L c,I' LV' -,,-/a' I.)!'"' If J~1j ~, i.. L c,I' f'y;'~.1~ ~ r J~.:;_ Po L 1.1' -~ "-'.f J~/ UiJ.I L c,I' .IJ' Jt:-JPl i'~~.f~
88
:r f'-f'-
h .ok;~ .JJ' '41/;
u~t:--~
cJI'4 ~.J.JJJ'-
-4,J .::/,
"cJI L
.JJII/"ri .ok;~v. ~J JJIU~ ~ V. uP.u~ JJI':"--~J":,,,1 -!"JI, cJ~ JJ L u/; JJI':"--~.J Po L ,1857v!~ ~ ii' --tf "';j .JJIA JJI ! J! .:;,j '- (I' j~
d ,-(IIU~
e
-,JJ!'1 ,JU~~~I L.::/; lS)U,/. (j 2.... L ~I ~I L .::/,lS)U,/.V. ~~ Po L ,1857 ~~ J" .JJI'IJf)'I;~J{ ~I ~I V. ~. L VI -ifJI)' 1UJJIj. S~.J ~~ f J"J>1~'- Po L VI -J LL 1;"'"ij,/. r:J >. S
r:J lSA,GJ LVI .JJI! dL L VI J{ t) .::/~ S&1 .Jltil./' tf" v rt ~ I/. " dL L ~~ lS}1J,/..:..--1.1 .!.t. ~~ ":,,,1 -!Jf .::/! "rt £01~~ JI .JJI'I/~ ~ ~tt~I...;r VA'" 1~J;r,.J. ..J/ J ~Ui S-" vI .J .JJI'T- ;.:J..JJI~ lil4- '- ~~ 11- fl/~~J -~, Cu i,GJ ~ vI J!1U~~ 1;1-v.r JJ1'. SvI 't) ~ lS.J!.....t ~ Po 2.... L U~~ L 1- Po L ,1857
'T-'
''''~,f~ '- vl,.l£ -4lSJ./
~
'-
:--"ij,/.
Jr,
:ft..P' V. ~J~ L.J~'
v' Lv./ -!~ .ft;'-:";~ ~
If ~;
./ cJ! cJ~ v. -'T- JjI, ~ ~.J;r, 1- lS.J~~ ,t,l.Ji -iflS.J!L,)" 1-lS.J~Po Sj.PI (.I " VI ~ cC -" 4- -'T- ~ ~ l.Ii ,,/ L,)" (2)-'T- I"
'-.J{ "
1- lSJ~-"
lS.J!'- (VI .J~I
e". L Jy. cJ)J/ V. ,18872.... L ~
4-
(.I ~
{ ';:')..,p ,J 1-
89
t".LJr._t.,_'j~ ,1898.1. )J' ,fJ"'" Jj
t:::-)?)1)
"
~ L)}~
t:::- ~ .Po I:P'JPz
)JJ
1/"0; .Po Po L
t:::-''~
~ I:P'JPz
V' -:-if~
J' f " (j,j ~ ~
r
J-?
L ~~ 'v! Lr l...1'O)'JiJ -L~ ~ ;lJiJ t:::-:",oU,..t.rJ II:)'L1'
..)I;
)LJ, r v' si- O)~ 2._ L ~? J t.:P ~ ,-)'J' L ~~ V./ L" Ltc 4flJ ~ ':;'P! ~ ,1857 ~ -" ~ ('1" J:I /~
~
)~)J
l'~,-
L L)~~
)J'
,;-'
J n' ~?
,;-' s'T-Iz ~
f" J
t,,,.
:f~tJfL .:;,)i,a ~ PI
t.:P ~ ~~
J'
-£ l..."
jL;, ~ .A ~ -£ z:« J j
s:'T-~~-:''T-C"JjJ,1' J t:::-....6L)J'~~ .:;,,!) )J' rJC L v' r -t:;- ....6L')In )J' ~~ ')In -: J" o~.:;,)i~ V' t:::-,a IPI J' f.I,;J,,, 'v! (3)4
~, J£'I/,~'r .::.r.'J)V' ~
)~)J
L..::/;
,,:,,1/ t:::-)IJ, L.::)JJ )J' ',,:):JJ~)
l...1'". I:)~'J~
'-t' ~
'~?
t
0)U,..t. ,,:,,' ~
J t.:P ~JPz
t~
L .::./'; ~ if' 1'L t:::V' J'£" .:.t" 0% ~ L L!;1'J ;I~.J
)~)J'-/. )J'
)~)J
i;_ l...r L
J: t:::-J)~~ L!,r1'J~
~
)~)J -:
s» ,j!. -1:. L)"
t:::-)} JI; -i;_
J ;~ )J' ui)~)J,;-' ~ .:,.r'1)
.::.r.'J) -: _i;_ l...1'I:)~'r O)'JiJ rV L I:P'JPz ~ if-f-'" )~)J)?rJJ~ ,1903 ~)JJ L I:)j1' j, JI ~ d)~v' ;-v L~' J~ 1l'J) L' L.:,.r'1; I:)~'J 4~('~J -: ~ '-~~ L)~)J V' Lo~r )J'
,1860
90
S C);) r I.)! tr. S ~ .:;;~I.)! I JJ
,
~
., A"
., AI
J? ':' V1 }" -r'j 'i- Ai Ai
S
J
-:>'.1 J /-.1
C)_Nl ,.:.
? ~ (i V1 zs 'i- Ai Ai S JJ.I ,.,.
'x
..y'_'-
!Y ~ ,v- ... ~
S I:fZ/.
'i- Ai Ai
J'j
J
(jll ~
'i- Ai Ai
f
S
.IJ'
J J
L
Y/ .IIJ
L)! UJ.l1;-o
...."...z •
e
J
v.! ,j
I,;/-'vf ~
f
-.;~
Pi
.
L)!
~
fA2 .. ~ II.!
V'
L V' f~fll.tj /.::.<.'J.IJ" L _p,.j, v' L UJ.I~.IJ V' .IJ' 'IiC~~ "";!i" ( .:;;L.» SC)' .e: L~ ~J .:;;1J.,i' J ~ 1 UJ.I~.IJL L!r-1'J ~ ~ C~~~.:;;7~.IJ' .Ii~ I.)! Vb--- ~, vJ-
UJ-"J~J..t.lj
'v! J~OJ vA '£. ~ ~UJ 1U}'J Lf C)JIiJ~ ~; I.)!. L V' -13 Cf JIj' .:;;7 SC)' f ~{ JIP .IJ' f 1J, ~ ~ C)' L!r-1'J
.IJ'
.e.L!JJ ~
( o-"J~J~,
1.;:.,,0; L'J
Li v! .I~.IJJ'I'
~,L ~; oju,/. LY/ Lj Yo J,.t.. ~ ':;;~'J.I -4" SU;--
,; r"~ ~ j;~ J.llf .:«-~f ?JJ L)! ,.1911 ~.:« .::..,;j'-"J r:J ..t.'I 0'.1 v.! J.llf .:;;1L L J;'~,~, ~; oju,/. -r' J"13 ~1l1.)! JJ 1~j'-"J 2... ~, '1.::,,-0; ~ .IJ' lf~ .:;;1 L ~u,/. ~ Ul.v .J.1i ~ ~, ,j..IC ....;/ -:,J ~J',['1i JIP ( ~, ~ J.}lv' ~ ~~ S..:)? J ~ .IJ'~ ( ujl/ L ~JPi
0''
91 ,nl7
Y j Yo ~"
~I '-
tiL L
I:P'JPz L U';I
£.
-7 IS'"='-}J L
?-, tf
..::.r.~ = OJ
IS'C)I"=,,I
U,.,. ~
~!~I J);"I L JJ L C)I,.A."I; ~ /i ,1'';~;C,:._f ,,=,,1 ,1'~ ,1't!;ll JJ (j If L .::/;o)tb./. L,: Lf J' ,,~IJ" vI _.; ,,!j./.If ~yil IS'C)I;r k"t!"k#'12V c!~1 ~I v! .,:..1,,11 IS'if-~ ~ IJ.'J If':? '- ~IJ" rC)I"JI 7" t#
..f.~J
,1''; ~I I,,{ I,,{ r vI 1.::/; o)U,./. L L.k OJ ...f ~ ~ f v.! .::/; '- ,.lI)' /".
J'I " ~JPz
J"'I, c),; r un
"JI .,:.;-'~"C)ylJ L
8J
L
~JPz
U';I
2... L
~
-v./ v.!
vI
v! (I' r C)I,1''; J~ r C)IJ',f'oJ'::*}""';) IS' l,)JA~ "JI UJ"I~j v! ,1820 -T c:c: ~ l/; (I." 1.::/." ~"j L C)II)) 7s,"JI (~I
1.::/; L,: Lf8}~1.....;)IS' ~I IS' ..P. vI
L y ;,,/LvI".;,
:,1'';~8''? '-'::J vI _.~,
,,!j./.I o"I~j"
~
?·JlPf Yo v!,-}~
u:'
~/i
& ..jyl ..P. ~ IS' J/!? *) j,: o"I~j fi -J 7" If 7 o}JGJ IS' C)I'- .::/; o"~ "JI J L~ ,:"=,,I} ..:JI" (4) -JL~,: "yf I)!/IIJJIL U';I *}t!(;J} J' r.,:..1,fl,#1 ($~ L .::/;o)U,./. ~ C)I,1''; J~ r C)IJ',f' ~y I uV L ft I (lSi ~)..lA.h;
r
"JI '( 7"
OJ
~J
"JI '( L ~J
v! .:;..%f,:
8J~j
Jlj;
,-)J.A..W c).rf''- '::J IS' .,:..1,fl,#1
uV C)Ii J5 ":"J~ I)! ,1857 I)! /IIJJI~.I-J "IJI r lS}JGJ~ 1,)J).liW LI{ ';-, Lifo
,:"Ii~
IS' ';-J
(/,,,j aJ~j
fr r .::/; L
.
92
r (II s:dr J....; J'. ~Y J ..:;.,-"$ Po L ,.h L .::..~ 2.... V' -if L~ .nl ~.!t ~I r.Po 4 ~ J,~ f uJ.h;~j LIf: J 4:-J ;1..,f- I.i /,. cJI'- -?JJ LJ1 J'. i~ JJA JJI' L cJ1J l:P L ..:;.,-"$2.... ~I'~I LJ1 ~J fr d.-I cJr-JJ L ~J JJI.;:.,;$ -: -t £! ~ ..:;.,-"$J'-~ '::"JJ/ ,f- ~ JJI L ,_/;J!j./. ,f- ~I J l:f"1 J'. uj~
-
-L "'/ ,f- J.J,J
do s:U ,,-,j 2.... L Lb:!""
; ~~
J1
iP -IJ]J jj~ l..li';!J cJI~Jj L
r?-:f cJli r ~IJJ Jii'!
'rISl,rJ'';!
~JjLj;fJ_;r
f ~ v' L":;"-"$ ~
~J/ J'.'::"JylJJIA&t'Yl'_:,r
\
f
L if. f (Alienation Act) dI';:'J.I J'. ,1901 J'. "'r'f" ~ J ~V' (5)-y!Jo...v.~"LJ:.j d!j" UJ.?LLJ JJIUJJr..ri'V ~Jj
-(g r ~
b';I.J.LWJJIJYltJbr I:f J;I /.'=1 b'~2.... L ~; J
~J V' ~I J UJ;fA JJI UJJIP.'"jJ'. U~ J.;:.,;$ O~./.
J'. dV'JPi ~ f ,f *- JJI V' IJJ -ti~Lf ~1Y,f-r J;~I J'.~~ .J. 'tiJA" J} U"~ fV'if LYlv! IJL UJJIP.'"j-:JJ r":;"-"$ 2.... L LeI / ~I J ~ ..J.I' _:,Po 'IYlI~ .:i~~ ~Ji JJI .Iv?
L ;£J J!j./. /o;fJl;J
ScJIL ..:;.,-"$(6) -L )Jl;J L .;:.,;$ Yo
SJf./oJ{ ScJI~Jj L if.fl) IhfJ~I f ~~J ttJJ..)" 2.... .J J! OJOJj ~ SV' j JYl ~ ~ ,f- 'Jj J'. -:JJL cJI}i'l J!
L.::..I._.w J cJILYl Lf r-? f OJIJl;JJ cJI.;:.,;$ eJ~ L V' L ..:;.,-"$'I JYllJ'f 2.... L cJIJ'. J~JJ 'I Jjl; '- ~UJ ~I (7) -L Lf JJ ._;)r.; i... L cJIJJI Lf .:;..G"tJ, ..J} '- cJIJIJ:.~ _if; J'. Jif ~' f~ V' L U~I ~Jj L JJ..) (lSi V' IJJ
J'I
93
L L/I~ vV' r~ v! L)/; ,Jjl;£)
r
i ~I J el' v!c:P'~
-.If ,j./,)~O'JL/('nl15)I,;,1/.,II/.' 1 15)~ L .::/'p 15)U,/.2...
-p. rL))I,.) :;i~.~ iflu L/ V~,pl L ~ 2... L ,j./,)~ 1)1
U .:...: )JI V!,t" ifl JcJl~ C.lf :;i~~ r~ )JI j)pt ,.,II) cr eJ(I) r J cJ,c..,,)JI '4:..21-) J! ;1,;,1/.1-:'-':;>J Jdo ,I v? J.If~!t ~I v!/ J~ 20 v! J' VI L ,j./,)~ .s: 1-;1;/ J! J~j .If;;iY 2'400 ,If JvI v!/ J~ 30 'I)~ ,It" ;;iY 300 uf.lf ~. o.,f '. C.lf )1" r~ }t 1000 u! .If~ _3'500 v!/ J~ 50 )JI '!J! -.If (j' eJ~j'- cJ.!j U ,II)15)~ 2... L.)I hI ~ v!,j./,)~~ 'T- C! If -i:.. 1-.If !....,:..I)~Ir;-J v! L)j~ ';-, f L)J;lJ'-.d cJl(8) . '- uf J~~v! L~';-,'v! -r'fY cJi.;,i -vd'-J-' v! *,1860 ,I
J'-<:- uf VI"
( '-5,11) t1'(*,1906)
J)lj
JL" u f ~
cJ~)J L 0::/.) )JI ,j./,)~-" ~I
L)L ,I~
'T- (jl)!.1 2... L cJlo::/.) ,I 4:.. ~J
~
f L~
C/ ..Jl)1 JI.~ 4 'T- C.lf
(t r
-:I L
tt~
-JvJI2...L
~':t.!'-
..:.fU,1 I~p! u ;1,.; L -:J) L ()(/ )JI ~ JL
,j2
J~u.:...: l)!.' -4:.. 1-/ J' ,,~~JJ_&j f! v! ..,:..)~ J~ J
v! *,1872 n:-- -if Jr ,;l7) I:- 21.-- L L)~ ';-, L L),)I ~ ,I U1 .A°,- ,,;,i f 49 )JI ,f 15;JLJ/f I:)'fi~ v! ';0 L..,:..p! v! -r'fy rI (9)"'"iSJ'-J
j~ f L)Ji 16~
L VI i~r;:J J~Jj ~
f
-if~J 1)1
L J. f'T-·~ J~~Vl ~,Jr0. ..JI~ v! *,1919 15Jljr4 v! 15v"'-~ ~ .J./I/(? J;:J )~ L~ L ':-J ~ f k. ) ~ V. L)J~,f Jf! "L)JVtI.l u~.IJll:)'fiu;..v! vI i J.If ~;
J'j~
))1 ~
94
-::"UVI Jr _;/,:,!.I. ~t
J'
...£ jv:.1 L .::;_
VI -V1I,j.J ~
J..6
J'o J'VI 4!V' ~I If 1(:)", L~ ~.J~..t. '1,j.J....(,> .-'f- ~ r,tJ ".JL 2... L ;( 14 (.fk--!.I. .JJI'_;tJV L IJJJ'
!.I.'JIJ-Y
~7
t~.Ij /.:
dV JPi IIJJ~
cJI .JJI'( 'f-.J ~ Atil
vI LJyl
~'
.::;_~J
J'1:1- s:v? ..:1ftJ V'
U jf
r cJI J'.£.;£ -:ft ~
~
L.JJJ Jlk.I _I~
s:LJIl.J,f. "' vI lJ£ujf ''(JIl':' I-'IJyl J' JIJj
~v:.Jj~1 '-p ;..-;f ;..-;f !.I. ,;." L .:k~I
f ...£ IJk 'f-.J LJIl....(,>
,f..r s:-:j -f1 : V1..:1ftJ JJ J'vI !.I. rUV' .JJI.J~J.Jr L ~; cP'JPi JI
s
2... L.:;,o; .JJIIJJ)J '-.J Jilb./. f JIl~.J~ ~ !.I. J~J J',1940 (.fk--O'J 2!I !.I. V~ ~lr- ~lr- L VI 4! JIl J! t/, (i )1)1 '" 2... VI -1/JIl~t If c(.::;_ J..61 cJI .r.JJIl.JJ .:::;u, .I; VI vii LVI 2... L vI! ~ JIl~ .JJI Po L IJ? JJ ft ~; Jilb./.
r:
-L~ JIl.JIJ.tfJ'::;_(lSi J~fi
~I
IJ
f~ ~ .=--1.1J/.JJI IJ~
r J. LttJJ'JVt Jr 'lJ£i (.fk--f!
'.,!..~
/'t .I} ~
1 ~JPi
'L IJr
-: ~J (il J/JJ JJIl J.l-I !.I. ~JPi .JJI'4 J:,r
J',-.t'~2... L :",-ib./. r vI I.lA-'f- ~.J~ ~ .a!i. -f1.::;_ .J;~ J}'~;;'2... L
cJI -: ...flYl-: -:f. rcJI .JJI~ b: y~r~
f 'f- !.I. (.fl"
J'~IP J'vI
LI(-
'~ Jfty".::;_~ IJk ftl-:v
Jilb./..1'-J JJljf
.::;_I
-L~
J) --?/ vI f~ ';IJ (il rl,.JC J'cJVJPi -: j IJIlJljf J ~ 1 J~ ~I ,J. 'LJIl ~ ( !.I. '-;~ L vl.f cf. J~JPi 1J!7 .
-~ JIl~.J
.::;_uk LJIl ;£.1 .IIj./.
95
I. Wurgaft, P. 7
106-V JI962.J.t1D'{
..:.-DlP:-:.JoC'/
2
100 -V
3
:/I~I
4. Bearce, P. 137 ~1997 .J.t1iJ
\5).d'1:-!~..j,~ji;: ~ 2... L ~
5
6. Hutchins, P.187
8. Dewey, Clive: Anglo_Indian
Attitudes. Cambridge, 1993,P. 5
39-V:..J~
9
96
.n' -:f ,~,....~,~ (uzj J1J~ii £ -=--::J,J if. 7 ...Jti>,J Jj v! L)",j .n' L);J v! k=Jro V1J.IJ; J Lt' f)J -8.;:L";;.IJ'~~) J; f £.IJ' u.;~~ .IJ';./. J Lt' v.P "..:-~ v' v! if.lJ )i~,J}
/ £'.; v!
(jL~' IL);J (j_;/) 8Jf 7l5)J
_.j
=,J L);J ~~
L~rIr J J.;:; ,J .IJ'~~ ~~ ,J if. 7) .IJ'~Y?vv!)'.IJ' ,-:,,"..;;i 0v' flJ;t U:"..:-~v' r J; 0k=J'..z,v -7 r -=- ~ 71( JP (~tYo L L)yl, -=--::J I,-:,,"..;;i ~ -ILJ JAv!
(j'
H
ji
JJ' L L)yl, ji I(J,?--' 1.1) "
-7", (bt v' .I'AJ.I'J ..:-1J~ii ~,L L)f. ~ ~ ')}J
-=- (j' ".If Ii';;8Jfl('~ Ivl?' v' v! L);J .IJ' L)",j (I '-/ JJ-7 ..:-0. J d y~2... L (j' 1.1) r ~72... v' -u.; 4i ~'j L)H L ..:-1J~ii-=- -::J,J if.'(y j L)i1j".If " L L)_')' r~~)'~, '~/. r ..:-Inji -I J1":-/ -=- L)J.I;J ..:-1'J.I .:A
~'.l~,~,
-~a.rJi ~/.r ..:-1jJ ~J'~'.IJ'/"
..::/,' -=- L)J)J'L '.)/. .IJ'vd{ '{;,J...J/ ,; L L)iY J1J~ii bt ,;-' ~.IJ L L)J)J'~ 2... L L~ (I ",.If J1j IL)H .J. '0 ~7.IJ'(,j, ~.I,! v! if. ..f:£. L~ ~L..ai L( v' -I(;.it j ( J1
~"v'
.IJ'-V do JjL r J; '":;'.I,!f'J1
= _..;:.r v'
u:
-J1
('i'.);./.,J
97
J' .f1) ~"U.f11)
"~'f-
,fl~ 'f- J' .f1J; SJ!'fi fl/
f .::.dJ))JI ,-)IJI JlPJj L 1J) )JI ~ V' L ~t -I) V: ~)i JlP ~'.f1d jti )JI J~J i)i '.f1J; (II); &J'f-f -~J)F ) ~ .:)7 J ~ ~ fl/~) r-? Iz, VI o: ~ Jj L J~;-.f1 JJ'if IJJ -V,t...J~ J -'1.:::;_ U~ (V jJI e~'y r,j;J (# )JI JJ'if )JI J J~J} Sr,jl L V,_),f )hP'~";; ~)i ,-/(r j~J~i}...k ~
&~L ~
-J.f1 cflt
J;
J L ,.;4!JI J ~I ~,,)} uk--~ 1.f1,.JI; r )JJ j~J~i} ~ f~ v! 1J) )JI;I;(; L ,-:,7 -:,,)} tJJ )JI ~Ir- 'J(r J J.1r' ./'£..f1 JI;i
,:;~ t L ,-:,7 f L ~ Yo
J~";;
,j L ..::.r~~
~
)JI '-)JI
&J -:
~i..JIo r,j!7
Yo v!
ufo r,jl -'f-) 0'
wf,y L r,jl -L ;~.:::;_~";; ~ )JI L
L )JJ J~J~i} t/- P. L l!J,;i
fJJ -I) t))hP'
11..jJf
r,j_i
-t::....) . '-L ..::...LI J) , L.7. ..
..::...)~ IUJ)J' )JI ..::...~IJ) JlP u!7 JI v! )JJ J~~i} ~ ~ )JI UtY' ~' &J-'f- C))1.$1r..::...~~ ,flifl ..JIo I)n t/- r:l L~ .:::;
d~_I~jJI
'J~/(1'':;-1 )JI 'f- if. ~.JiIJ}':::;_ )~I LJ jJI ~I IJ} &Jv! J ':;-f i.vI -'f- f.f11.7..:::;_,-:;,,)i d"j r V',,)} -V,t._i;! .:::;_ un (I.: "':-"'"-: ;f~I r .c;-) 'v~'r,j~; Sv' -'f- if.) J>J
L J )JI un (I.: I)r UJJI
~
f 'f-,:r 0' ~I .:::;_J vI t/- r r,jl
w~v! -V' J ~)i) ~
-L~
V
I.::)JJ )JI L~ J~I
r
b)j
'r:) -V,t O'Jt.f J) .I} L L).::./$ L r,jl ...J) tJ/ JJ -L~~ v! .::)~S~J J...J} I(I' ~)j L UJ)J' ,.? L ,...1.: tA' -L~~ v! j~J" .I} ~ I("~)j L ,...1.: tA' ~I)j )JI t}~)Y.: 'vd{
98
L .::./; y- -'7- Jl7 IUYij L L~; -~L~J1-!:f-'L ~I/
L "':"~ v.. UJ)J'
~
-'7-
('1 .::./; Lf
d~ .JJ' .1''; 'JJ
r~11;:..Y~~J~
J~' le'.Jj ~
J r.,.~
U ~...;JI,;-
S('11(';'fi
-'7- jf ~- ~ U.?; ~ LJ1 LI;: e~l) J'IIJ} .::./; fi ,.;!.Jj .JJ' L/.Ji '~Y ~'f(J uYij L ~ d'Y-i".J~ jy;i e.;:L ~ 1.v.1J.J".J~ J'lj Vlr '.lin f '7- _':;Jif.. -'7- ~.J ~ Lf ~
~Jj"
-'7- ~.J~ 1J: rJ1 v.. ('1 .JJ' uP. uY u '7- tJ, v.:' Y- !;'.JJ.JJ' ....fi~ .JJJ j1J~ii
~ 2....
t,y L .:.~v' I~ L d' .JJ' ~)J'
~ u;Jr 1)~~
d' ('1
.JJ' ~.J'J'
L .::./; -'7- ~o.JJJ f ~,f- f ~~ .::.:;.; J ~ &, eJ f
"t ~
I
L I.f' ..::,..r'~.J f '7- 'J1-: ";:'1( v' -~ ?-.J (Jj
'",:,,;.,../J} LJ1?-.J" t I.f' -~ L~ J1o.J~~ ",:,,'Ji ",:"J'.JJ' )?'",:,,;"") 'J~v.. u~ S --by L ('I-'7-,f J1/"J .JJ'.:.f v.. uP. uiJJ d' ~ Jj .JJ' o.JJJ 2_ L &, :# f ~-'7- c:!J ('1 .JJ' Jl,..J--, ',Jib -::,"UC" .JJ' ..::,..r'~.J '7S..::,..r'~.J '))J -~ c:!J .JJ' L'J Lfey 1..::,..r'~.J 'JJ "::'>;J ('1 "::'>;J I UJ)J' J'1.JL v' -L~ 1~J.JJ' JJ(~ if I ~I,;- ('1fi f ~ .J~JI v.. Lf ~ c/.JJ' L~J ,;£ I ('11.)'i=: '7- ~ b: JJ d'
('1 f ~'~;£
~
J; .JJ'.:i~ ~
o='~
-'7- jJ1
S..::di,;v.JJ'j,P'-":'J;f ~)J' L I.f' .JJ' ~~.J ~/....fi f ~ S~Ij ,;'.J'J .-3 'j! &, 'o.J'.;:!.!'v.. ~}lr A i v(~de .::./~ -'7- r~ J1 vl?' ~Ji'J' ~,....f ~ f'7- 1]1.1 d~ .JJ' Jt'i v.. uH....f"::;J V' v.. vlr
r
99
u~..; S.I~.I~~ .t'i
~ -{ ~ ~ V~I.::.-vt.. ,.:!.Ij L
V
J)J, J"?' .IJ' if" 4- v! lr
-:::;J
J..; .f
.t'i ~I
V' ; \,I,(~ -'"((t v! L~I.::.-vt..
-IA L~~.v .::.-~~ L LJ~"; I.::.-vt..v! UH .IJI f- r~ 21.-- L -:::;J .f f- r~8.1 ;'1.1 U' ~ 2... L UH v! .::.-Vt..cJI 'cJly~Ji v! ~J.Af S~VI -L~S~J.Af 2... L ~~'LJ;:,/' -IA ~ ~ L.t'i LJ.I~I IJ:l4- .IJI..:::z;~ '.),Ij} -f- .I~JJ Vlr
l.;In
cl o;;::_ if..f f- Jt.. '::'-.I~eJ 0:.