The Director’s Cut: The Capture of U-505

By Rear Adm. Sam Cox, USN (Ret.), Director, Naval History and Heritage Command

USS Guadalcanal (CVE60) Hunter-Killer Group vs. U-505 – 4 June 1944

The Submarine Tracking Room (F-21) of the U.S. TENTH Fleet was aware of the general movements of U-505 throughout her patrol due to Ultra intelligence derived from intercepted and decrypted German communications and high-frequency direction finding. U-505’s fruitless patrol off West Africa was plagued by equipment breakdowns and poor morale. Based on intelligence from F-21, TENTH Fleet knew when U-505 started home and vectored Guadalcanal (CVE60) Hunter-Killer group to intercept. After several days of fruitless searching, Guadalcanal broke off the search to head to Casablanca for refueling. Ten minutes later, destroyer escort Chatelain (DE 149), commanded by Lt. Cdr. Dudley S. Knox, gained sonar contact on U-505, between Guadalcanal and the escorts.

Chatelain conducted an immediate Hedgehog attack with no result. U-505’s skipper, Oberleutnant zur See, Lt. (j.g.) Harald Lange, put up his periscope and was dismayed to see the array of ships and aircraft around him. U-505 got off an acoustic homing torpedo that missed, just as Chatelain rolled in for a devastating depth charge attack.

When the crippled U-505 came to the surface, Chatelain, Pillsbury (DE 133), Jenks (DE 665), and two Wildcat

fighters hit the U-boat with a deluge of gunfire. Lange was badly wounded on the conning tower, two others were wounded, and one was killed. Realizing the situation was hopeless, Lange ordered the sub abandoned and scuttled. However, in the haste to abandon, the crew neglected to set the charges. Two Avengers airborne were under orders not to drop depth charges if the submarine surfaced, as the Task Group Commander Capt. Daniel V. Gallery had a plan to try to capture a U-boat. In accordance with Gallery’s plan, the screen commander ordered boarding teams away. The team from Pillsbury was underway first and those from Chatelain and Jenks were diverted to rescue the 58 German survivors. Although abandoned and settling by the stern, U-505 was still churning in circles at six to seven knots. The leader of the boarding team, “Mustang” Lt. (j.g.) Albert David, made the first leap from the whaleboat, followed On U-505’s conning tower are, from right to left: Cdr. Earl Trosino, USNR; by two petty officers. Capt. Daniel V. Gallery, Jr., USN, Commanding Officer, USS Guadalcanal; Knowing that the and Lt. (jg) Albert L. David, USN, who was posthumously awarded the scuttling charges could Medal of Honor for leading the boarding party that captured the submarine and carried out initial salvage operations. go off at any moment and that the sub could sink at any minute, and not knowing if any armed Germans were still below and willing to fight, David plunged down the conning tower ladder without hesitation into the dark U-boat, followed by Petty Officers Knispel and Wdowiak. The petty officers set about rounding up codebooks and valuable papers, while David worked valves to keep the U-boat from sinking. Continued on page 23

Continued from page 22

As more of the team came down the hatch, another petty officer found and closed a bilge strainer that was flooding the boat.

Another boat arrived with Guadalcanal’s engineer, Cdr. Earl Trosino, and a salvage party. Another petty officer found and disarmed 13 of the 14 scuttling charges known to be in the U-boat (based on intelligence). An attempt to tow U-505 by Pillsbury resulted in two flooded compartments when U-505’s bow planes sliced into Pillsbury’s hull. Finally, Guadalcanal was able to take U-505 in tow. The transit to Bermuda would feature the unique event of a carrier conducting alongside underway refueling and flight operations and towing a submarine, all at the same time.

After the capture of U-505, great lengths had to be taken to ensure the Germans didn’t find out, otherwise they would have to assume the Enigma coding machine was compromised, which would result in the loss of probably the most valuable source of intelligence in the war. Among other measures, U-505’s crew was sequestered from other POWs and denied any contact with the outside world; it wasn’t until 1946 that their families learned they were alive, and the crew was not returned to Germany until December 1947. Lt. (j.g.) David was awarded the Medal of Honor (the only one awarded in the Atlantic Fleet during the war) but died of a heart attack before receiving it. Knispel and Wdowiak were each awarded the Navy Cross. Numerous awards went to others in the Guadalcanal Hunter-Killer group. U-505 is now an exhibit at the Chicago Museum of Science and Industry.

As a final note, intelligence played a critical factor in each of these incidents. The Convoy Escort Commander of TAW-15 was warned that U-boats were waiting in the Windward Passage, and the convoy escort commander of ON-166 was warned of the large number of U-boats in his path, both thanks to intercepted German communications. Each took action as a result and did the best they could with the resources available. Card and Block Island Hunter-Killer groups were where they were because Allied Intelligence knew the location and timing of the Milchkuh refueling rendezvous points. The boarding teams were armed with information on the workings of U-boats, derived from the capture of U-570 by the British in 1941 and from interrogations of captured U-boat crews by Naval Intelligence’s Special Activities branch, which treated the Germans humanely and were rewarded with a bonanza of useful intelligence.

Long-Time NHF Members to be Honored

National Maritime Historical Society (NMHS) to Honor Capt. Sally McElwreath Callo, USN (Ret.) and Rear Adm. Joseph Callo, USN (Ret.) with the David A. O’Neil Sheet Anchor Award at New York Yacht Club on the evening of October 28, 2021. Both recipients had successful careers in the Navy Reserve in the area of public affairs, though Captain McElwreath Callo also served with Navy Reserve Combat Documentation Detachment 206 that currently supports the Naval History and Heritage Command. Rear Admiral Callo is highly regarded as a foremost authority on Adm. Lord Horatio Nelson on both sides of the Atlantic having written three books on the subject including Nelson Speaks and Nelson in the Caribbean.

They will be the first couple to receive the award, in partial recognition for their work in furthering the special relationship between the maritime communities of the United States and Great Britain. As chairs of the American Friends of the National Museum of the Royal Navy, the have used the New York Yacht Club venue to host annual Pickle Night dinners, which honor Lord Nelson’s victory at Trafalgar. At the dinner, NMHS will also present its Distinguished Service Awards to Steven Kalil, the president of Caddell Dry Dock & Repair Co. in recognition for work performed to restore numerous historic vessels and to David K. Elwell Jr., a director of the Youth Sailing Foundation of Indian River County of Vero Beach, Florida. For further details about the annual awards diner visit www,seahistory.org.

Naval Historical Foundation at the Washington Navy Yard P.O. Box 15304 Washington, DC 20003

The Best Holiday Gift for a Friend Sharing your Passion for our Naval History – A Gift Membership to the Naval Historical Foundation!

Unless otherwise specified below, NHF memberships are open to anyone interested in the history and heritage of the U.S. Navy.

Gift Member Contact Information

Student (Free): Complimentary Individual membership option available to high school and higher education students (USNA/ROTC/ Midshipmen/Cadets). Must use an email ending with “.edu” to register. Teacher ($35): Discounted Individual membership option available to educators.

Digital ($40): Benefits include a 10% discount on Navy Museum Store and online purchases, as well as a subscription to our Thursday Tidings newsletter for one year. Individual ($50): Benefits include a 10% discount on Navy Museum Store purchases, as well as a subscription to our Thursday Tidings and Pull Together newsletters for one year. Family ($75): Extends Individual benefits to multiple family members (not to exceed two parents and their children). Supporter ($250): Benefits include a 10% discount on Navy Museum Store purchases and a subscription to our Thursday Tidings and Pull Together newsletters for one year, as well as a special mention in an issue of Pull Together. Life ($1,000): Benefits include a 20% discount on Navy Museum Store purchases and a subscription to our Thursday Tidings and Pull Together newsletters for life, as well as a special mention in an issue of Pull Together. Gift Giver Name (to be noted in the new member’s welcome aboard letter)

Name (& Call Sign)

Title (Rate/Rank)

Address (Duty Station)

City State ZIP

Phone

Email

NHF is funded by the amazing gratitude of our members and donors!

Membership & Donation checks can be mailed to:

Naval Historical Foundation, P.O. Box 15304, Washington DC, 20003

If you desire to become a member or donate via credit card, visit us on-line at www.navyhistory.org. The Naval Historical Foundation is an IRS-approved 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. incorporated in Washington D.C. with a mission to preserve & promote naval history.

Pull Together is published by the Naval Historical Foundation.

EDITORIAL BOARD

Chairman: Adm. William J. “Fox” Fallon, USN (Ret.) President: VAdm. Frank Pandolfe, USN (Ret.) Executive Director: RAdm. Edward “Sonny” Masso, USN (Ret.) Historian / Editor: Dr. David Winkler Designer: Marlece Lusk Copy Editor: Catherine S. Malo Address submissions and correspondence to Executive Editor, Pull Together, c/o NHF, P.O. Box 15304, Washington, DC 20003. Phone: (202) 678-4333. E-mail: info@navyhistory.org. Subscription is a benefit of membership in the Naval Historical Foundation. Advertisement inquiries for future issues and digital content are welcomed. Opinions expressed in Pull Together are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Naval Historical Foundation. © 2021