NCJ Daily Online

Excessive Force Alleged in Local George Floyd Protest Lawsuit

Alocal woman has filed a federal lawsuit against the county of Humboldt and the city of Eureka, alleging police officers violated her constitutional rights when they shot her with less-than-lethal projectiles as she peacefully marched while protesting the May 25, 2020, murder of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer.

In the suit filed last month seeking unspecified damages for physical pain and emotional distress, Molly Crane Conso alleges that she was peacefully marching, locked arm-in-arm with other protesters, on May 31, 2020, near the Dutch Bros. parking lot on N Street, when — “suddenly and without warning” — officers shot pepper balls into the crowd and they struck her in the “head, buttocks and breasts.”

“At no time did plaintiff violate any laws or present any harm or threat of harm to the officers or others at the scene,” the lawsuit states. “Upon information and belief, (the officers) gave plaintiff no verbal warning or command before shooting her with projectiles. Upon information and belief, at no time was an order to disburse issued to the peaceful protestors by defendants prior to unlawfully and unjustifiably shooting plaintiff with the projectile.”

The suite alleges Conso suffered injuries to her head, a concussion, post-concussive syndrome, bruising, chemical burns and hearing impairment from being hit with the projectiles, as well as emotional distress as a result of the incident.

On June 1, 2020, EPD Capt. Brian Stephens released a video recorded statement detailing the police response to protests — including the one in which Conso alleges she was injured — that had occurred the prior weekend. Regarding the May 31, 2020, protest, Stephens said EPD officers had been standing by as those participating in the protest marched from the courthouse to various parts of the city. But as the day drew on, Stephens said officers documented numerous incidents of vandalism, including one businesses with a broken window and others that had been spray-painted with graffiti, and identified a suspect.

“At this point, I made the decision to remove the person who we knew was causing the vandalism,” Stephens said, adding that officers with EPD and the sheriff’s office moved into to affect an arrest at the intersection of Fifth and N streets.

But when police took the suspect — later identified as Brent Clark — into custody, Stephens said the crowd turned

Crabs Keep Winning

Photo by Thomas Lal Crabs outfielder Tyler Ganus (#34) jumps up and celebrates in front of the crowd after scoring against the visiting Seals Baseball team at Arcata Ballpark on July 9, 2021. The Crabs picked up five wins last week to move to 22-5. Read full coverage at www.northcoastjournal.com. POSTED 07.12.21

unruly, with at least one person — later identified as Oliver Winfield Perez — allegedly trying to forcibly remove Clark from police custody.

At that point, Stephens said that “given the escalating circumstances and the safety risks to the officers” police opened fire on the crowd with paintball guns that fire projectiles filled with a powdered pepper spray, commonly referred to as pepper balls. Stephens did not specify how many officers fired or how many people were struck but said there were injuries and police spent “several minutes” on scene trying to de-escalate the situation and offer medical aid.

The county and city have yet to respond to the suit, and no trial date has yet been set in the case.

— Thadeus Greenson POSTED 07.10.21 Read the full story online.

Make us a part of your daily life

For the news as it develops and all you need to understand politics, people and art on the North Coast, follow us online.

Shooting Suspect Surrenders: Shaun Patrick McMahon, 49, of Trinidad, turned himself into the main sheriff’s office in Eureka after police had identified him as a suspect in the fatal shooting of Benjamin Scott Thomas, 40, who died after being dropped off at a CalFire station with gunshot wounds on June 23.

POSTED 07.07.21

northcoastjournal.com/ncjdaily northcoastjournal

Pearl Harbor Sailor Laid to Rest: As this edition of the Journal hits newsstands July 15, Navy Radioman 3rd Class Earl M. Ellis is scheduled to be laid to rest with full military honors at Ocean View Cemetery, nearly 80 years after he was killed during the attack on Pearl Harbor. Read more at www.northcoastjournal.

com. POSTED 07.11.21

ncj_of_humboldt ncjournal

Arcata Seeking Councilmember: Anyone interested in filling the Arcata City Council seat left vacant last month after Mayor Sofia Pereira stepped down to become the county’s Public Health director has until July 19 to apply. Whoever is appointed to the seat will serve the remainder of Pereira’s term, which ends in November of 2022. POSTED 07.12.21

northcoastjournal newsletters

Digitally Speaking

The amount in millions that the state of California has pledged to invest in Humboldt State University to fast track its shift to becoming the state’s third polytechnic school in a move University President Tom Jackson Jr. called “historic” and “transformational,” with the potential to “revitalize this region for decades.” POSTED 07.13.21

They Said It

“These acts should serve as a reminder to us that we still have a long way to go to ensuring the equity and safety of all of our LGBTQ+ community members.”

— A joint statement by the Arcata City Council denouncing the recent cutting down of a tree adorned with rainbow flag ornaments and a “Love Joy Peace” banner, which had taken the place of a LGBTQ+ flag destroyed at the same site. POSTED 07.09.21

Comment of the Week

“Thank you for making the public records request. This settles the question of how a public entity could keep the full terms of a settlement secret when it involves public money. It cannot.”

— Andrew Jones commenting on the Journal’s Facebook page on a story detailing the terms of a settlement reached between the city of Arcata and Charmaine Lawson. Read more on page 7. POSTED 07.10.21