Учимся решать проблемы простая книга для умных людей by Nel Son

YAK 005.53 66K65.29-2 821

Bee npaBa 3dllji4UjeHbl. H14KaKaR Ydcrb 3TOW KHW11 He MO)I(er 6b1Tb Bocnpoi43Be.QeHa 8 KaKOW 6bl TO Hl4 6blfl0 1/JOpMe 14 KaKI4MI4 6bl TO Hl4 6blnO Cpe.QCTBdMI4 6e3 ni4CbMeHHOrD pa3peWeHI4R Bflil,lleflbljd dBTOpcK14X npaB. 3TO 143,lJ.dHI4e ony6ni4KOBdHO C ComaC14R fll4reparypHoro areHrCTBa levin Greenberg 14 fll4reparypHoro areHrcraa «CI4Honcl4o>.

B21

BaraHa6e KeH Y4~MC~ pewaTb npo6neMbl: npocra~ KH~ra Ail~ YMHbiX fliOAe~.

nep. c aHrn.- K.: Companion Group, 2010. -144 c. ISBN 978-1-59184-242-2 (aHrn.) ISBN 978-966-1629-08-9

K.AK.AS ::1 B.Ae. ,ll.tJl.b'r.A? KH11ra «Y"li1MCR pewarb npo6neMbl» 113Ha"lanbHO 6blna pacc"li1TaHa Ha WKOflbHI1KOB, "lT06bl Hay"li1Tb 11X Kp11TI1"leCKOMy MbiWfleHI110. Ho O"leHb cKopo aana 6eacennepoM 11MeHHO cpeAI1 B3pocnb1X 6naroAapR 3cj>cj>eKT11BHol7! MeTOAI1Ke peweHI1R npo6neM, pa3pa6oraHHol7! KeHOM BaraHa6e (a npownoM BeAy~l117! KOHcynbTaHT McKinsey). Mb1WfleHI1e, Op11eHT11pOBaHHOe Ha peweHI1e npo6neM, MO:>KeT AaTb HaM B03MO:>KHOGb KOHTpOn11pOBaTb CBOIO :>KI13Hb 1..1en11KOM 11 nOflHOGbiO, Hay"li1TbCR pewaTb npo6neMbl, cnpaBflRTbCR C HeO:>K11AaHHbiMI1 Bbi30BaMI1 11 Aa:>Ke 113MeHI1Tb M11p. OanaAeB 6naroAapR 3TOI7! KH11re npeAflO:>KeHHbiM11 HaBbiKaMI1 peweH11R npo6neM, Bbl YA11BI1TeCb, KaK paHbWe MOrnl1 6e3 HI1X 06XOAI1TbCR. KH11ra AOGaTO"lHO npoaa AflR nOHI1MaH11R 11 WKOflbHI1KaMI1, HO np113TOM paccMarp11aaer peweHI1e cepbe3HbiX npo6neM fli0Aei71, 3aHI1Mai0~11XCR 6113HeCOM.

Y,ll,K 005.53 66K65.29-2

ISBN 978 -1-59184- 242 - 2 (aHrn .) ISBN 978 -966-1629 -08-9

Osaka. © 113,q;rrenba<aR A>'pet<U><R Companion Group no,Qpa3,Qene•MR 3AO «11A «MaKC>!MyM», 2010, AJ.13a~H,

nepeeo.o,.

C.O,ll£?~.AlfM£

n?£.llMC.J10BM£

:t?OK #1 OcHOBLI TeopHH o AeniX, KOTOPLie }'MeiOT pemaTL rrpo6AeMLI

1!1HCTPYMEHTAPlillil AilS! PEWEHliiSI nP0611EM llorH'IecKoe Aepeao

:t?OK #4 Koe-'ITo o poK-rpyrrrrax H o KOpHe rrpo6AeM 1!1HCTPYMEHTAP1.1Iil AilS! PEWEHI.1SI nP0611EM reHepanbHbl.;i nnaH peweHIII!I npo6neMbl

SG'

:t?OK #3 ABaHTIOpHLie u;eAH H BIIelfaTJUUOIIJ;He peJyALTaTLI

111HCTPYMEHTAP1.11i1 AilS! PEWEHliiSI nP0611EM

rlilnoreTIII'IeCKa!l OlilpaMIIIAa

:t?OK #4 <I>YT60ALHIDI WKOAa: Ja H IIpOTHB

109

li1HCTPYMEHTAP1!11i1 AilS! PEWEH1!1SI nP0611EM Kp111replillil o4eHK111. "3a» 111 <<nporlila»

SJJ.A.ro.ll.A?lfOC.'rb

114

13.,

co6HbiM pernaTb rrpo6AeMbi, 3 To -

3TO He rrpocTo YMeHHe,

orrpeAeAeHHbiH HdCTPOH C03HdHH5I. HaCTPOH, KO-

TOpbiH 3dCTaBA5IeT 'leAOBeKa MdKCH:MaAbHO pacKpbiBdTb CBOli AytJIIIH:e Kd'leCTBd ¥I rrpeo6pa30BbiBdTb MH:p B IIOAO)JGffeAbHOM KAIO'le. BMeCTO TOrO lff06bi MHpH:TbC5I C cy-

~eCTByiO~HM rroAoJKeHHeM Be~e:H, 'leAOBeK, YMeiO~HH peiiidTb IIp06AeMbl, ITOCT05IHHO IIbiTdeTC5I dKTHBHO BAH5ITb Ha oKpyJKaiO~H:H MH:p. Bbi TOAbKO npeACTaBbTe, HaCKOAbKO RHa'le BblrA5JAeAa 6bl Harna ceroAH5JIIIH5!5I JKH3Hb, eC.llli 6bl TaKlie AH:Aepbi, KdK MaxaTMa

faHAH,

MapTHH .1\roTep

KliHr, 3AeoHop Py3BeJ\bT, A,/KoH KeHHeAH: 11 CTH:B A,JI<o6c B CBOe BpeM5I He 1Ip05IBH.llli TaKlie Kd'leCTBd.

n?.e,llRCJJ.OBIU

HaAeiOCb, 'ITO 3Ta KHHra rrocAyJKRT TOA'IKOM K cpopMRpoBaHHIO dKTHBHOrO HdCTp05I C03HdHli5I, KdK y AeTeH, TdK li y B3pOCAbiX, li IIOMOJKeT KaJKAOMy peiiiHTb

3.A'i.e:J.t ?.elll.A~b n?OSJJ..elotbi?

B rrepByro otJepeAb ero co6cTBeHHbie rrpo6AeMbl. KaK TOAbKO Bbl HdytJH:TeCb 3TOMy IIpOCTOMy CIIOC06y yAa-

....,.aJKAbiH ¥13 Hac npHHHMaer pernemrn. KTo 6bi Bbl HH

~6bl.llli:

CTy-AeHT,

OTe~

CeMeHCTBa, 3d60T.llliBaJI MdTb,

npeAflPHHHMaTe;u, H.llli npe3H:AeHT CoeAH:HeHHbiX lllTaTOB AMepHKH: -

JKH:BdTb MeAKRe TPYAHOCTH, c KOTOpbiMH CTaAKRBaeTecb eJKeAHeBHO, Bbi YBJiAHTe, 'ITO 11 6oAee KpynHhle 3dAd'lli, li BbiCOKlie Me'!Tbl BdM TOJKe ITO IIAelJY.

Bee pasHo Bbl eJKeAHeBHo CTaJ\KlffiaeTecb

c Heo6xOAH:MOCTbiO pernaTb npo6AeMbl. KoHelffio, npo6AeMa npo6AeMe po3Hb. KoMy-To ITPeACTOHT CAdTb 3K3aMeH ITO MaTeMdTHKe, KOMy-TO JKH:TeAbCTBa, a KOMy-To -

OnpeAeAH:TbC5I C MeCTOM

yseAWrn'rb mor 6aAaHca cBoero

no'l.e:J.t~

l:l.An~c.AJJ. ~~~ Kl:l~r~

llepeA TeM, KdK HdiiH:CdTb 3Ty- KHHry, 5I pa60TdA KOHCYAbTdHTOM B MeJKAYHdPOAHOH KOHCaATHHrOBOH KOMIId-

rrpeAIIpH5ITH5I. KTo-To JKeAaeT c6pocH:Tb Bee, a KTO-To -

HH:¥1 McKinsey

rrpocTo HayqH:Tbc5I Ayqrne HrpaTb B roAbcp. He3aBHCHMO

raA KpyrrHbiM KOMIIdHH5IM BO BCeM MHpe rrpeOAOAeBdTb

OT MdCIIITa6a BOIIpoca, Mbl CTdBHM rrepeA C060H

~eJ\b,

orrpeAeA5IeM rrpeii5ITCTBH5I ¥I CTPeMHMC5I ¥IX rrpeOAOAeTb. Cyru;ecTByeT eAH:HbiH ¢YHAaMeHTaAbHbiH IIOAXOA K pe-

Company. lllecTb AeT IIOAP5IA 5I rroMo-

TPYAHOCTH B ¥IX 6H3Hece, HCIIOAb3Y5I IIpOCTOH, HO MO~ HbiH Ha6op liHCTPYMeHTOB ITO perneHHIO rrp06AeM. 3TH HHCTpYMeHTbl AOCTyrrHbl KaJKAOMy.

/J..MI TOrO 'lT0-

IIIeHHIO AI06biX rroBceAHeBHbiX rrpo6AeM. 3ToT ITOAXOA

6bi IIOAb30BdTbC5I H:Mli, He HyJKHbl CAOJKHble KOMIIbiO-

B KdJKAOM KOHKpeTHOM CAyqae CIIOC06eH IIpH:BeCTH: BdC

TepHbie rrporpaMMbl H.llli IIOAHbiH Kd6HHeT 3KCIIepTOB-

K 3cpcpeKTH:BHOMy perneHH:IO ¥I JKeAdeMOMy pe3yAbTary.

dHdAHTHKOB. 3TO -

Ho, B03MOJKHo, lffo AO cHX rrop HHKTO TdK ¥I He YAocy-

cnoco6 opraHH3a~Rli o6pa3a MbiCAe:H no rroBOAY rrpo-

rrpOCTO-HaiipOCTO orrpeAeAeHHbiH

no3BOA5IIO~HH

JKH:Ac5I IIOKd3dTb BaM, KdK 3TO AeAaeTC5I. llpHHH:MaJICb 3d

6AeMbi,

HdiiH:CdHH:e 3TOH KHH:rn, 5I B35IA Ha ce65I MH:CC¥110 IIOKd3dTb

B03MOJKHbiX perneHH:H.

BCeM IIpOCTOH rryTh peiiieHH5I npo6AeM, C KOTOpbiMH Mbl CTdAKH:BdeMC5I Hd KdJKAOM

mary

B CBOeH IIOBCeAHeBHOH

2007

YBHAeTb 6oAee IIIHpOKliH Kpyr

r. rrpeMbep-MHHHCTP 5lnoHHH o6n5IBRA o6pa-

30BaHHe UpHOpH:TeTOM B pa3BHTHH CBOero rocyAapCTBd.

H~H5I CKOH~eHTPHPOBaAa

JKH3HH. Ho 5I He rrpocTo IIOIIbiTaAC5I rrepeAaTb BaM orrpe-

KorAa BC5I

AeAeHHbiH Ha6op HaBbiKOB. BeAb 6b1Tb 'leAOBeKoM, crro-

Ha CHCTeMe o6pa30BdHH5I, 5I IIOlJYBCTBOBdA, 'ITO IIpHIIIAO

cBoe BHHMaHlie

8 9

~·

~ .q

E ~

~ t

BpeMJI 11 MHe BHeCTII CBOIO Aerrry B o6rn;ee AeAO. HecMO-

ypOK11 11 113 C06CTBeHHbiX yeneXOB, 11 113 C06CTBeHHbiX

'I'p.H Ha TO, 'ITO BeAym;11e .HnOHCKHe 6113HeCMeHbi, Y'!eHble

HeyAa"<~. Tio3TOMY .H eo3AaiO AeT.HM TaK11e yeAOBH.H, 'IT06br

11 nOAHTIIKH pKe AaBHO rOBOpHAH 0 TOM, 'ITO 5InOH1111 He-

oHR MOrAH Y'!11Tbe.H 60Abiiie Ha peaAbHbiX JKH3HeHHbiX

06XOAJ1MO nepeirr11 OT «06pa30BaH11.H, HanpasAeHHOrO Ha 3aTIOM11HaH11e» K «06pa30BaH1110, HanpaBAeHHOMY Ha pe-

e:aryai.J;R.HX, HeJKeAH Ha ypOKax B IIIKOAe. KorAa .H pa6oTaiO e AeTbM11, TO He Ha"<~11HaiO o6Y'!eH:ae

IIIeH11e npo6AeM», H11KTO TaK 11 He npeAAOJKHA KOHKpeT-

HaBbiKaM, on:aeaHHbiM B «PyKOBOAeTBe», C 3aH.HTIIH B

HOro 11 3cpcpeKT11BHoro cnoco6a, KaK 3TOro A06HTbc.H.

l(h.a.eee. 5I AaiO :aM B03MOJKHOeTh no3HaBaTh M:ap TeM JKe

HTaK, .H yureA 113 McKinsey, 'IT06br Han11caTb 3TY

enoeo6oM, KaK 3TO AeAaA YoppeH BacpcpeT. Csoii nepsblii

KH11ry 11 'IT06bl Y'!11Tb AeTeH. 5I nOCTaBHA nepeA C060H :u;eAb HaY'l11Tb .HnOHCK11X AeT11IIIeK AYMaTb TaK, KaK 3TO

onbiT B 6R3Heee YoppeH nOAY'!HA ern;e B IIIeCTh AeT, noKYf!a.H 6YThlAKlf C KOKa-KOAOH B Mara311He y csoero Ae-

AeAaiOT AIOAJ1, YMe10rn;11e peiiiaTb npo6AeMbl; HaY'!11Tb

AyiDKR :a npOAaBa.H

11X 11rpaTb aKT11BHYJO pOAb B C06CTBeHHOM 06pa30Ba-

pa60Tai0, nOAY'!aiOT 3aAaHRe ynpasA.HTh 6R3HeeOM o6rn;e-

:ax e

np:a6b!AbiO. AeTII, e KOTOpbiMR .H

H1111 11 B nOCTpOeH1111 C06CTBeHHOH JK113H11. 5I nOCTapaA-

eTBeHHOrO nHTaHHH, 11Me.H B esoeM pacnop.HJKeHR11 MR-

C.H o6Ae'Ib 11HCTPYMeHThr, 11CnOAb3yeMble McKinsey, B

KpOaBT06ye <DoAbKeBareH

AOCTYIIHYJO 11 BeCeAYJO cpOpMy, KOTOpa.H 6bi noKa3aAa

.H O'I'peeTaBp11p0BaA

AeT.HM, KaK MOJKHO peiiiaTb CB011 npo6AeMbi Ha npaKT11Ke 11 TaK11M o6pa3oM npeycnesaTb. 5I He npeTeHAYIO

HOH Mara3RH. AeTII eaM:a peiiiaiOT, KaKYJO eAy :a HanHTKH npOAaBaTh, rAe :ax npOAaBaTb R KaK 6opoTbe.H e KOHKyp11-

Ha AaBpbi 3KCnepTa B 06AaCT11 o6pa30BaH11.H, HO BCe JKe

pyiOIIJ;RM11 KOMaHAaM11, 'IT06bi AeiieTBHTeAbHO npOAaTh

CMeiO HaAe.HTbC.H, 'ITO 3Ta KH11ra nOCAYJK11T, no KpaHHeH

see TO, 'ITO oH:a caM:a np:aroTOBRAH RAH 3aKynRAH. TaKHM

Mepe, OTnpaBHOH TO'IKOH, KOTOpa.H nOMOJKeT pa3Bep-

o6pa30M, AeTII He TOAbKO oeo3HaiOT saJKHoeTh YMeHH.H

HYTb Ae6aTbl 113 pycAa «HaAO AH o6Y'!aTb peiiieH11IO npo-

peiiiHTh eaM-y npo6AeMY, HO B npo:u;eece oeym;eeTBAeHH.H

6AeM» s pycAo «KaK11M o6pa30M 3TO cAeAyeT AeAaTb».

esoero 3aMbiCAa np:ao6peTaiOT TaKJKe HaBbiKH AJ1Aep-

HeOJK:H:AaHHO

AA.H

MeH.H KH11ra HaiiiAa JK11BOH OTKAHK

AA.H

1965

rOAa BblnyeKa, KOTOpbiH

:aenOAb30BaHH.H nOA nepeABRJK-

cTBa, pa60Tbl B KOMaHAe, TBOp'IeeTBa, HaeTO:ii'IRBOeTII,

cpeAJ1 '111TaTeAbCKOH ayA:H:TOp1111, np11'IeM He TOAbKO

o6a.HHH.H 11 Kaii3eH -

cpeAJ1 AeTeii. TipeJKAe scero, oHa oKa3aAacb B :u;eHTpe

HH.H.

BH11MaH11.H 6113Hec-cerMeHTa, CTaB B 5InOH1111 6eCTCeAAe-

.H nOMOraiO 11M 3aAaTh BaJKHbie BOnpoebl R AalO RM Ha6op

pOM

NQl

s o6AaCT11 AeAosoii AHTepaTYPbi 3a

2007

r. Tio-

11 TOAbKO

11HC'I'pYMeHTOB

HenpepbmHoro eosepiiieHeTBosa-

noCAe TOrO, KaK AeTII nOAY'!aT 3TOT OnbiT,

AA.H

peiiieHH.H npo6AeM, KOTOpbiH MOJKHO

11 Ha 6oAee III11pOKYJO ayA:H:TOp1110.

6yAeT 11enOAb30BaTb B 6yAyrn;RX npoeKTax. Be3yeAOBHO, :u;eHHOeTh MbiiiiAeH:a.H, op11eHT:aposaH-

BbrnCHHAOCb, 'ITO .HnoHeKHe '111TaTeAH, Ha'I11Ha.H e poAJ1-

Horo Ha peiiieH11e npo6AeM, npocT11paeTC.H AaAeKo 3a

TeAeii 11 Y'!11TeAeii 11 3aKaH'I11Ba.H PYKOBOAJ1TeA.HM11 Kpyn-

npeAeAbi KAaeeHOH KOMHaTbl R paenpoeTpaH.HeTC.H Ha

Hb!X KOpnopa:u;11H, pKe AaBHO 11enbiTbiBaiOT Oe'I'pYJO no-

see rpaH11 Haiiieii JK113HR. TaKoe MbiiiiAeH:ae no3BOA.HeT

'I'pe6HOCTb s npocToM 11 npaKmeeKoM PYKOBOAeTse no MeTOAaM peiiieH11.H np06AeM.

B3.HTb nOA KOHTpOAb eAOJKHOCT11, e KOTOpbiM11 Mbl CTaA-

CeJiqae .H npe11Mym;eeTBeHHO 3aH11MaiOCb TeM, 'ITO no-

M011 11HOCTpaHHble "<IRTaTeAH R3BAeKYT 113 3TOH KH11rR

TOM 11HTepec K Hell pacnpOC'I'paHHAC.H Ha C11CTeMY o6pa30BaH11.H, a OTryAa -

MoraiO AeT.HM np11MeH.HTb Ha npaKTIIKe nOAOJKeH11.H 3TO-

K11BaeMe.H, 11 113MeHRTb M11p K AY'!IIIeMy. HaAeiOeh, "<~TO

AA.H

ce6.H TaKYJO JKe nOAb3y, KaK 11 .HnOHeK:ae "<IRTaTeAH.

ro KpaTKoro PYKOBOAeTsa no peiiieH11IO npo6AeM. 5I e'I11TaiO, 'ITO Mbl AOAJKHbi qarn;e AaBaTb AeT.HM B03MOJKHOeTb Ha co6cTseHHOM onbiTe 11enhiTaTb, 'ITO 3Ha'IHT npJ1Ay-

G l:l.A.rul~'iUII-\Ml't IIO~.J:Jl.A.lfl-\RMI'l K.£1{ B.A.~Al:l.A.S.£

MaTb HOBYJO J1AeiO, B3.HTb Ha ce6.H 11H11I.J;11aT11BY 11 113BAe'Ib 11

--------------------

~ i2"'

saTb op:HrH:HdAbHO If JKH:Tb, KdK B AeTCTBe, IIOCTOHHHO If aKTHBHO H3YTJ.d51 BCe BOKpyr.

yxoAH H:3 AeTCTBa, OHH:

eru;e H rrp:HXBaTHAH C C060H HeCKOAbKO IIOAe3HhiX CeKpeTOB AA51 perneHHH B3pOCAbiX IIp06AeM. EcAH JKe Bhi ycsoH:Te rrpocTble «AeTCKH:e» ypoKH,

2 ~ ,Q

n AoJKeHHhle Ha CTpaHH:D;dX 3TOH KHH:r:H, TO TOJKe 3 cMOJKeTe CTaTh TaKH:M «pe6eHKOM», KOTOpbiH yrMeeT

perrraTh rrpo6AeMhl (AaJKe ecAH cTIHTaeTe ce6H cosep-

::1 ~

rrreHHO B3pOCAbiM If OTieHh cepbe3HhlM, KOTOpOMY He AO 6ecrrra6arrrHhiX AeTCKH:X roAOBOAOMOK). Bac ocTa-

BHT OI.Qylll;eHH:e, TITO JKH:3Hh BhliiiAa H:3-IIOA KOHTpOAH, Bhl KperrKo B03hMeTe lliTYPBaA B csoH PYKH H rroqyscTsyeTe, TITO MOJKeTe rrpeo6pa30BhlBaTh MH:p BOKpyr ce6H. Bhr rrepecTaHeTe H:3HhiBaTh IIOA rpy3oM TPYAHOcTeH, HaBaAHBaiOIQH:XCH KaJKAhlH AeHh, a BMeCTO 3TOrO HayqnTeCh rroAyqaTh YAOBOAhCTBH:e, rrpeoAOAeBaH 3TH TPYAHOCTH. He H:CKAIOTieHo, TITO, ocso:HB AO KoHu;a rrpeAAarae-

lfi'U«)rAA lf£ no3.lllfO

MhlH yqe6HhlH Kypc no perneHHIO rrpo6AeM, Bhl AaJKe

G~A~b?~~K~O?~~

rroqyscTsyeTe, TITO cTaAH Ayqrrre, TieM 6hrAH AO 3Ha-

~££~ ?.E:lliA~b n?OSJJ..E::M.DI

KOMCTBa C 3TOH KHHrOH. BarrrH MeTIThl H u;eAH IIp:H-

~ Ta KHHTa 0

IIp:H)lMHOJKHTe CBOIO CIIOC06HOCTh BeprrrH:Th AI06hle

AeTHX, )'MeiOIQH:X pelllaTb IIp06AeMbi. 00-

.:::::JqeMY 0 CMhllllAeHhllllax? DoTOMY TITO OHH: OTieHb qaCTO He IIOXOJKH: Ha Hac, B3pOCAbiX AIOAeH, KOrAa CTdAKH:BaiOTCH CO

CAOJKHhiMH:, 3aKOBhlp:HCThlMH: IIp06AeMaMH:.

0HH: He CAaiOTCH, He orrycKaiOT pJKH, He H:Ayr Ha rrorrHT-

HyiO, KaK 3TO AeAaeM HHOrAa Mhl, H:AH: 60Ablll:HHCTBO H3 Hac, AaBHo YJKe BhiilleAill:HX H3 AeTcKoro B03pacTa. KoHeTIHo, 6biBaiOT MOMeHThl, KOrAa OTieHb XOTieTCH, TIT06bi B3pOCAhle AIOAif XOTb H:HOrAa 6hlAH: 6hl HeMHOro IIOXOJKH: Ha TaKH:X AeTeH. 003TOMY rrpeAAaraeM BMeCTe C HaMH: y6eAifTbC51, TITO BCe-TaKH: eCTb B3pOCAhle, KOTOpbie B AI060M B03pacTe )'MeiOT pernaTb IIp06AeMbi, KaK CMeKaAH:CThle MdAbllll:H. DopoiO KaJKeTCH, TITO cyAb6a HdAeAH:Aa TaKH:X AIOAeH 0C06biM TaAaHTOM H:AH: OAapH:Aa HeiiOMepHO 60Ablll:HM Be3eHH:eM. Ha CdMOM JKe AeAe OHH: TOTIHO TaKH:e JKe, KaK If Mhl C BdMH:, TOAbKO HaYTJ.H:AH:Ch IIO-OC06eHHOMY MhiC-

AH:Tb, rrp:HHH:MaTh HeopAifHapHhre perneHH:H, AeHCTBo-

6AH:351TC51 If IIOKaJKyrCH pedAbHO AOCTH:JKH:MhiMH:.

J1 Bhl

A€Aa. 3TH AeAa 6yAyr rrpo6yJKAaTh CTpaCTh B BarrreM cepAu;e If 6yAopaJKH:Th B006paJKeHHe. TaK Bhi CyrMeeTe BOIIAOTH:Tb B JKH:3Hh CBOH 3aMhiCAhl. KaKH:e H:MeHHO 3dMhlCAb1? Aa xoTH6hi Hayq_H:TbcH TaHu;esaTb IIO-COBpeMeHHOMY H:AH: OCBOH:Tb Ta:HHCTBa cppaHI.J;y3CKOH KyxHH:.

lJ,eAb

MOJKeT 6biTb If IIOKpyrrHee, CKa-

JKeM, CTaTb KaHAifAaTOM B rrpe3IfAeHTbi H:AH: rrpeOAOAeTb Kp:H3H:C rAo6dAbHoro rroTeiiAeHH:H. KaKYIO 6w u;eAh Bhl rrepeA co6o:H He cTaBH:AH: -

Bhl Hayqmech rrpaBH:AbHO c

He:H o6pdi.QaTbcH. YMeHH:e perrraTh rrpo6AeMhi -

3TO He TaAaHT, KOTO-

PhiM o6AdAaiOT H36paHHble cqacTAHBTIH:KH. Ha caMOM AeAe,

AAH TaKoro

YMeHHH Heo6XOAHMO rrp:Ho6pecTH Ha-

BhiKH: H rrpH:BhiTIKH:. KcTaTH, He ceKpeT, TITO HaBwKaM YTJ.aTCH, If IIpHBbiTIKH TaKJKe MOJKHO IIOAYTJ.HTh BCAeACTBH:e o6yqeHHH.

3Ta KHH:ra KaK pa3 H: rrpH3BaHa Ha-

YTIHTh ¢YHAaMeHTdAbHOMY MeTOAY perrreHHH rrpo6AeM.

~ tq

A;ul

6oAee HarMJAHoro o6yqeHIUI Mbi, KaK B A06pb!x

Hy BOT, HarrpnMep, rocrro./Ka 0xH-B3AOXH.

AeTCKHX KHHrax, IIpHrAaCHM BbiMbiiiiAeHHbiX repoeB, ':lT06bi OHM IIOMOraAH HaM pa3o6paTbC5l C peiiieHHeM 3dAa':l. 3HaKOMbTeCb:

•

..q

«!uo60Bb H MyxOMOphl» - HOBa5I pOK-rpynrra, KOTOpa5I 6operC5I 3a IIOBhliiieHHe IIOCem;aeMOCTH CBOHX KOH~epros;

•

/vKOH OebMHHor -

Ahl

MOAOAOH lfeAOBeK, IIOAaiOm;Hii

H~eJK

B KOMIIbiOTepHOH rpaQJHKe, erpaCTHO MelfTaiOID;HH eraTh

:xyAOJKHHKOM-My-AbTHIIAHKaropoM, H KOTOPOMY AA5I HalfaAa Heo6XOAHMO KynHTh eBOH rrepBhlH KOMIIbiOTep;

KHBH - KAaCeHa5I Q:>yr6oAHeTKa, KOTOpa5I XOlfeT 06)":1aTbe5I y A)"::IIIero rpeHepa Epa3HAHH.

3Ta KHHra CHa6AHT BaC IIOAHbiM HHCTp-yMeHTapH:eM IIpOBepeHHbiX MeTOAOB peiiieHH:H IIp06AeM. f10BepbTe, TO':lHO TaKH:MH ./Ke HHCTp-yMeHTaMH: II0Ab3YJOTC5l ycrreiiiHble .IUOAH: H KOMIIaHH:H BO BCeM MHpe. Ho rrpe./KAe ':leM Mbl IIpHCTYIIHM HerrocpeACTBeHHO K o6yqeHH:IO peiiiaTb rrpo6AeMb!, rrpeAAaraeM II03HaKOMHTbCH c AeTbMH, o6AdAaiOru;HMH 3THM -yMeHHeM, H Hx APY3bHMH.

YBd./KaeMaH 0xH-B3AOXH rrpHHdAAe./KHT K 'IHCAY Tex, KTO Y./Ke IIpH OAHOM BH:Ae MaAeHIIIero rrpeiiHTCTBHH CAaeTcH.

.ll~'rM, ~M.~I<>Il{M~

0Ha BCe B3AbiXaeT H TBepAH:T: «Hy 'ITO Bbl, 5I 3TOrO

P~lii.A'rb llPOSJl~M.:&I, M KOM.ll.Al:{MH

HHKOrAa He CMOry». XOTH 3TH CAOBa COBepiiieHHO He

HHTepecHo,

IIOIIbiTaAaCb.

':leM ./Ke OTAH:':laiOTCH B

CBOHX Ae:H:cTH-

HX AeTH:, KOTOpbie -yMeiOT peiiiaTb IIp06AeMbi, OT BCeX OCTdAbHbiX?

/vuJ

03Ha':laiOT, 'ITO OHa He CMOrAa 6bl 3TO CAeAaTb, ecAH: 6bi

TeAbHble HAeM.

HHOrAa e:H: B roAOBY IIpHXOAHT 3aMe':la-

l1 OHa IIOAMe':laeT rryTH,

CAeAyH KOTOpbiM

OTBeTa Ha 3TOT BOIIpOC rrpeAAaraeM

rrpo6AeMY MO./KHO YAdAHTb. Ho oHa 6oHTCH rroTeprreTb

rro:H:TH OT o6paTHoro H paccMoTpeTb, qero ./Ke He AeAa-

HeyAaqy H cTaTb rrocMeiiiHru;eM B rAa3ax APyrHx JUOAe:H:.

IOT 3TH YMHHKH, HaTKHyBIIIHCb Ha rrpo6AeMY.

A;ul

3Toro

HaM IIOHdA06HTCH IIOMOID;HHKH-repoH; OHH HE -yMeiOT peiiiaTb IIp06AeMbi H IIOHa':laAY MOryT IIOKa3aTbC5l 3TaKHMH KapH:KaTYPaMH: Ha pedAbHbiX JUOAeH. XOTH Mbl

l1 BMeCTO TOrO,

':lT06bi 3a5IBH:Tb 0 ce6e HAH Ha':laTb AeH-

CTBOBaTb, OHa CHART, KaK KAYllia, H ./KaAeeT CaMY ce6H. fOCIIO./Ka

0XH:-B3AOXH

KOHTPOAHpyeT

CBOIO

)KH:3Hb. 0Ha l:lYBCTByeT ce6H TaK, CAOBHO ee HHKTO He

YBepeHbi H MO./KeM Ad./Ke rrocrropH:Tb, 'ITO HX IIOCTYIIKH

IlOHH:MaeT, O':leHb ':laCTO BHHHT BO BCeX CBOHX 6eAax

CTaHyT HaiiOMHHaTb BaM AeHCTBHH HeKOTOpbiX BaiiiH:X

APyrHx. 0Ha rrocTOHHHO TBepAH:T OAHO H TO ./Ke:

cTapb!x 3HaKOMb!x. HaBepHHKa Bb! BCTpe':laAH TO':lHO pa6oTe. Mo./KeT 6biTb, 3To Ad./Ke BaiiiH 6AH:3KH:e APY3bH

e 5I TaK HHKOfAa He eMory. Y MeH5I HeT TaKHX CIIOC06HOCTeH. e 5I He 6yAy AaJKe IIhlTaTbC5I. A lfTO, eCAH y MeH5I He IIOA)"::HTe5I?

HAli ':lAeHbi CeMbli. A BeAb MO./KeT CAy<IH:TbCH, 'ITO B KOMTO H3 HHx Bbl Y3HaeTe Ad./Ke ce6H!

•

TaKH:X .IUOAeH HAH: B IIIKOAe, HAH B HHCTHTYTe, HAH Ha

Bee 6yAyr cMeHrhe5I H~o MHoii! BHHosarhl MOH poAH:TeAH. BHHosaro o6m;eerso. BHHosar Thl!

~: tql ql

•

HHKTo MeH.H He noHHMaeT. HHKTO MeH.H He AI06HT. Bee TOAnKo HreyT, KaK 6bl 06BeCTH MeH.H BOKpyr TiaAbQa.

1).11 ~I ,QI

Tenepb

rocnOAIIH KpiiTIIK. OH, HanpoTIIB, HII-

KOrAa He 60IITC51 BbiCKa3aTb CBOe MHeHIIe. 0H KpiiTIIK-

}il

npocpeCCIIOHaA. TOAbKO 3aBifAeB KaKoli-To llJ\.aH npe-

tql

Y3KIIe MecTa II 3ary6IITh B 3apOAbirne AJ06yro IIAeiO.

<I EJI 1).11 ~I

't}l

OAOAeHIIH npenHTCTBIIH, OH yJKe roTOB YKa3aTb Ha ero EcAII KTO-To nonh1TaACH qTo-To CAeAaTb, II y Hero 3TO He BhiiTIAO, KpiiTIIK nepBhiM CKaJKeT: «BoT BlfAIIITih!

qTo H Te6e roBopiiA? » OH BeerAa ToponiiTCH o6BIIHIITh

;;:

KOrO-TO Apyroro, eCAII qTO-TO He llOAyqaeTCH .

MOJKeT 6b1Th, oH

6oiiTC51 B351Tb Ha Ce651 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb, a TaiOKe llpii-

U)l

peaAII30BaTh TO, qTo 3allJ\.aHIIpOBaA.

3HaTb TOT ¢aKT, qTO II caM IIHOrAa AOrryCKaeT OITIH6KH . OT rocnOAIIHa KpiiTIIKa qacTo MOJKHO ycAhirnaTh TaKIIe ¢pa3h1: •

MAa-a-a, Hwrero H3 3Toro

y sac He BhlHAeT. AypaQKa.H H:Ae.H!

e A .H npeAynpeJKAaA, qTO BCe TIOHAeT KOTY TIOA XBOCT. Tbi CaM BO BCeM BHHOBaT.

e CAyrnaH, .H JKe Te6e Bee TaK AOXOAqHBO 06'h.HCHHA. l1 OTKyAa y Te6.H TOAbKO PYKH pacryr?

EcAII KpiiTIIK AelicTByeT Ha Bcex,

KaK Ta6AeTKa-

AenpeccaHT, TO Harna MeqTaTeAhHIIu;a BcerAa BIITaeT B o6AaKax. Eli HpaBIITCH BhiCKa3h1BaTh HOBbie IIAeii. Ho oqeHh peAKO OHa npOABIIraeTCH AaAbllie 3TOrO llYffKTa. 0Ha He yTpy)l(AaeTCH TeM, qT06hl

npeBpaTIITb CBOH

IIAeii B llJ\.aHhl, II yJK qero oHa ToqHo HIIKOrAa AeAaTh He cTaHeT, TaK 3TO 3a6oTHThCH o6 IIX ocyrn;ecTBAeHIIII. Eli AOCTaTOqHO YJKe TOrO, qTo OHa MbiCAeHHO npe6b1BaeT B CBOIIX BeAIIKOAeiTHbiX MeqTaHIIHX. l..JTO HH rOBOpH, a MeqTbl BCerAa BhirA5JA51T Ayqrne, qeM AeliCTBIITeAhHOCTb.

Y Hero

BCerAa HaHAeTCH, qTo CKa3aTb no llOBOAY

qy-

JKIIX OITIII60K, HO 0 ce6e OH npeAfiOqiiTaeT llOMaAKIIBaTb. AelicTBIITeAbHO, HHKTO He 6yAeT cnop.H:Th, KpiiTHKOBaTh BcerAa AerKo. TpyAHee qTo-To B3HTh H CAeAaTb. AaJKe ecAII HaM AOITOAJlliHHO H3BeCTHO, KaK BCe H~O AeAaTb, TOAKy OT 3TOrO -

HHKaKOrO, llOKa Mbl He 3aCyqHM py-

KaBa H He B03hMeMcH 3a pa6ory. Bo3MOJKHO, rocnoAHH

KpHTIIKACUKe He AOr~BaeTCH, HaCKOAhKO MaAO 3HaqaT ero 3aMeqaHHH

AMI

Tex, KTO AelicTBIITeAbHO IThiTaeTcH

MeqTaTeAhHIIIJ;hi HeT HeAOCTaTKa B cMeAblx Meq-

Tax -

MeqTax, KOTOpbiM TaK II He CyJKAeHO CTaTb pe-

aAbHOCTbiO:

18 19

~1ol

2 ~

e 5[ XOlJY HaTIHCdTb pOMdH! e Ax, KdK 3TO 3AOPOBO - OTKpbiTb co6cTBeHHbiH 6H3Hec! e KorAa 5I Bhlpacry, 5I XOlJY 6biTb Bpd'IOM. e 5I - reHepaTop HAeH. He AOCTdBdHTe MeHH CBOHMH HYAHhiMH IIOAP06HOCT51MH!

cocTOHT nepBonpHqHHa ero npo6AeM, H He Hrn;eT aAbTepHaTHBHhiX perneHHH. OH npoeTo He ITOHHMaeT, qTo MHOrAa oeTaHOBHThC5I H ITOAYMdTh -

He MeHee BaJKHo,

qeM npeAITPHHHMaTh AeifeTBH5I. foenoAHHa Tipo6HBHoro MOJKHO y3HdTh no TaKHM CAOBdM:

B nepBoe BpeM5I 3HaKoMeTBa e

Tipo6H:BHhiM H HaMeKa

E ~

HeT Ha To, qTo OH He YMeeT pernaTh npo6AeMbl. ToqHo,

raTHBHhie MhleAH. KorAa qTo-To eAyqaeTe5I, roenOAHH

OH He npH:H(lMeJKH:T K qH:eAy AIDAeH, o6eenOKOeHHbiX

• 5I HH 3a 'ITO He CAaMCH. 5I AOA>KeH rrpeOAOAeTb 3TO rrpeii51TCTBHe! • 5I AOA>KeH CHAbHee rrocTapaTbcH! HeAb351 ocTaHaBAHBaTbcH!

KaKHMH-To npo6AeMaMH. OH Hanpoqb OTBepraeT He-

Tipo6H:BHo:H TyT JKe 6epeTe5I 3a AeAo. Ero JKH3HeHHoe KpeAO:

«51

5[ TO'IHO 3Hdl0: 3TO cpa60TdeT, HdAO TOAbKO IIpHAOJKHTb 60AbIIIe ycHAHH:.

•

OcTaHOBHTbCH H IIOAYMdTh?

IlycrM TPaTa BpeMeHH. AeAaTh HdAO!

He MOry H3MeHH:Tb ITpOliiAOe, HO 5I MOry eAe-

AdTb qTo-To eeifqae». YnopeTBo H aKTHBHoeTb MHeTepa Tipo6H:BHoro onpeAeAeHHo AeAaiOT eMy qeeTh.

Bhl y3HaAH: ee65I B OAHOM H3 3THX THnoB? KorAaHM6YAb AOBHAH: ee65I Ha TOM, qTO B3AbiXdeTe H eAaeTeeh 6e3 6o5I? CqH:TaeTe, qTo Aerqe KpHTHKOBaTh APyrHx AJOAeif, qeM nhiTdThe5I CAeAaTh qTo-To eaMoMy? 06oJKaeTe

MeqTaTh H HeHaBH:AHTe ITAaHH:poBaTh? BpoeaeTeeb Ha aM6pa3ypy, dTdKY5I npo6AeMbl, HO OTKd3b1BdeTeeb AdTb 3dAHHH XOA, KOrAa HH:qero He ITOAyqaeTC5I? )K€

J1AH: Bbl Bee

60Abliie ITOXOJKH Ha Toro pe6eHKa, KOTOpbiH YMeeT

pemaTb npo6AeMhi? AeTH, KOTOphie YMeiOT pemaTh npo6AeMhi, o6AdAaiOT HdCT05IIIJ;HM TaAdHTOM eTaBH:Tb :QeAH: H A06HBdThe5I HX 0Cyr:QeCTBAeHH:5I. 0HH e AerKOeThiO npeOAOAeBaiOT npeIUITCTBH5I. TIOA06HO roeiTOAHHY Tipo6H:BHOMy, OHH He 0CTdHdBAH:BdiOTe5I nepeA HHMH. Ho, B OTAH:qH:e OT Tipo6HBHOro, OHH 3dAYMb1BdiOTe5I HdA nepBOITpHqHHOH eBOHX npo6AeM H Trn;dTeAhHO ITAdHHpYIQT eBOH AeHeTBH5I H AO, H Bo BpeM5I 3THX eaMhlx AeifeTBHH.

KOrAa B03-

HHKaiOT HOBble TPYAHOeTH, OHH e roTOBHOeThiO BHOe5IT

Bee-TdKH, eeAH: 6bi Hdlii Tipo6H:BHOH MOr XOTb Ha

KoppeKTHBbl B eBo:H ITAaH. YeTaHOBHB 6aAaHe MeJKAy

MHHYIY oeTaHOBHTbe5I H ITOAYMdTh, npeJKAe qeM qTo-

Pd3MhlliiAeHH5IMH H AeifeTBHeM, OHH A06HBaiOTe5I YAH-

To eAeAaTb, OH eYMeA 6bl A06H:The5I ropa3AO 60Abliiero.

BHTeAbHbiX pe3yAhTaTOB. AeT5IM, KOTOpbie YMeiOT pe-

KpoMe TOrO, y Hero eeTb eKAOHHOeTb enHebiBdTb Bee

lliaTh llp06AeMbl, HpaBH:Te5I yqHTbe5I KdK Ha eBOHX IT0-

HeyAaqH Ha HeAOeTaToqHoe pBeHHe. OH YBepeH, qTo

6eAax, TdK H Ha eBOHX ITOpaJKeHH5IX.

AID6YIQ npo6AeMy MOJKHO peliiH:Th, eeAH: TOAbKO eH:AbOH ITPHAYMaA, KaKHM o6-

AeTH-YMHHKH, KOTOpble pemaiOT npo6AeMhl, AeAaiOT CHaqaAa ABe oqeHb BaJKHhle Bern;H. 0HH yeTaHaBAH:BdiOT

pa3oM MOJKHO peliiH:Tb np06AeMy, OH HH 3d qTO He eTa-

nepBonpH:qH:Hbl npo6AeMbl H onpeAeA5IIOT KOHKpeTHhle

HeT MeH5ITh eBo:H Kype. OH He JKeAaeT Bhi5IeH5ITh, B qeM

QeA-H. 3TH AeTH PYKOBOAeTBYIQTe5I no3HTHBHhiMH yeTa-

Hee noeTapaThe5I. EeAH:

YJK

20 21

i ~

HOBKaMM M CocpeAOTaliMBaiOTC51 Ha TOM, liTO MOJKHO M3-

A Terreph IIOCMOTpMTe Ha CXeMY.

MeHM:Th, a He Ha TOM, liTO YJKe CA)"'HAOCh. OHM COCTaBAHIOT KOHKpeTHble IIAaHbl peiiieHM51 CBOMX IIp06AeM If 3aTeM cpa3y IIpHCTYIIaiOT K peaAH3a~Hlf 3TMX IIAaHOB.

flo XOAY AeRCTBlf51 OHM IIOCTOHHHO OTCAeJKMBaiOT CBOe

~ a

rrpOABMJKeHMe K

rocnolKA OX~ · B3AOX~

Jt~lf~<> W©1t©lf->ib0~

11~~G©ll

rocnOA~H

MEYTATEJlbH~l1A

nP06~BHOC1

AET~. KOTOPbiE YMEIOT PEWATb

Ufllb

rr~~a)1Fl1

lroli(it"J.fl'A BIfl1~ illf.Jtr.Ji

V\t>~a~

-?4~ * .

8VIJ.t"'ct

~J?Po

\ I I \ I I

~o~"'' fl/-.9.\

,.,

3"~v

~J.tt,.!/1

rocnOlKA

KP~T~K

~~@-

~eAR.

rocnOA~H

\II

1'"'~"{b~ ~

Irui?©~JJil(gOO\k~

\II CTAPT

----·----

PaccMaTpHBaH CXeMY, Bhl HMeeTe B03MOJKHOCTh cpaBHlfTh II51Th 3HaKOMhiX yJKe BaM rrepCOHaJKeR M OIIpeAeAHTh pa3AM:liH51 B MX IIOBeAeHMM. B COOTBeTCTBMM C 3TOR CXeMOR, rrepeA KaJKAbiM repoeM CTOHT IIp06AeMa, KOTO-

BoT liTO MOJKHO ycAhrrnaTh H3 yeT pe6eHKa, KOTOphiR YMeeT pernaTh rrpo6AeMhr:

PYIO H~o pernMTh. f OCIIOJKa 0xM-B3AOXH XOAHT ITO Kpyry BOKpyr HCXOAHOR TOliKM If TMXOHhKO B3AbiXaeT. EcTeCTBeHHO, OHa HH

•

O'Ke:H!

5I CAeAaiO 3TO 3a TPH MecH~a.

•

3To -

rrpo6AeMa, HO BMecTo Toro, 'IT06hi H3-3a Hee 6ecrroKo-

K lleMY IIyTHOMY He IIpMXOAHT. focrroAHH KpMTMK ysepeH, liTO 3HaeT, KaK

H~o pe-

HThCH, H Ayqrrre IIOAYMaiO, 'ITO MOJKHO CAeAaTh AM ee perrreHHH.

IIIaTh rrpo6AeMY. OH 6blcTpo YKa3hiBaeT seeM ocTaAb-

•

TaK 'ITO JKe IIOCAYJKHAO HCTHHHOH rrpH'!HHOH B03HHKHOBeHHH rrpo6AeMhi?

Hh!M, liTO OHM C06MpaiOTC51 CAeAaTh He TaK, KaK CAeAyeT.

•

l.JTo6h! YAaAHTh 3To AeAo, HaM Heo6XOAHMO CAeAaTh AaBaHTe rrorrpo6yeM.

X, Y H Z.

TaKJI<:e HHKOMY He rroMoraeT pernMTh rrpo6AeMY. IlYHK-

11TaK, 'ITO Mhi HMeeM B HTOre? l.JTO y HaC He IIOA)"'HAOCh? MoJK-

TOliKe, -

HO AH B CAeAYIO~HH pa3 'ITO-TO CAeAaTh Ayqrrre?

KaMHe He OCTaBM:A.

CaM JKe OH rrpM 3TOM HMllero He AeAaeT, M ero KpMTMKa THpHhre AHHMM, 6ep~Me CBOe HallaAO B ero MCXOAHOR 3TO qyJKMe IIAaHhl, OT KOTOphiX OH KaMHH Ha

~ "'

rocno>Ka Me'ITaTeAbHHu;a TaiOKe He npHXOAJiT K

6bl'fb YBepeHhl,

'ITO ABH>KyTCH B HY>KHOM HarrpaBAeHHH.

u;e.I\H. 0Ha npOCTO JU06yeTC5I CBOeH u;eAbiO, KaK 6yATO

DoKa APyrHe repoH HH K qeMY He npHXOAHT H.I\H npOAOA-

6hr 3TO -

HpKaH AaAeKaH 3Be3Aa. CHAH B HCXOAHOH TO'I-

)l(aiOT HATH B AO>KHOM HarrpaBAeHHH, 3TH AeTH ycneBaiOT

Ke, ORa Me'ITaeT 0 Be.I\HKHX H npeKpaCHhlX peiiieHHHX

npo6AeMhl, HO HH'Iero Aa>Ke He nhlTaeTCH CAeAaTh

AOCT}iqh nepBOH u;e.I\H H Y>Ke HaMe'laiOT ce6e BTopyro. YMeHHe pernaTh npo6AeMhl - 3TO He TaAaHT, KOTO-

HX ocyru;eCTBAeHHH.

AA5I

pbiH OAHHM AaH, a APyrHM -

B OT.I\H'IHe OT nepBhiX Tpex repoeB, ronOAHH I1po-

HeT. KaK HH YAHBHTeAbHO,

To npHBhl'IKa, KoTopyro MO>KHO Bhlpa6oTaTh. I1o3TOMY

6HBHOH, no KpaftHeH Mepe, ocyru;ecTBAHeT nonhlTKY AO-

3 AJ060H H3 HaC MO>KeT CTaTh TeM pe6eHKOM, KOTOpbiH

CTH'Ih u;e.I\H. 0H HHKOfAa He CAaeTCH -

yMeeT peiiiaTh npo6AeMhl.

OH npOCTO 6e-

A,h5J. 3TOf0 AOCTaTO'IHO OBAa-

>KHT H30 Bcex CHA. BnpoqeM, 3TO eru;e He 3Ha'IHT, 'ITO

AeTh He06XOAlfMhlMH HaBhlKaMH H npaBlfAbHO nOCMO-

oH 6e>KHT B HY>KHOM HanpaBAeHHH. KorAa AO Hero AO-

TpeTh Ha OKpY>KaiOIIJ;HH HaC MHp.

XOAHT, 'ITO OH 6e>KHT He B TOM HanpaBAeHHH, OH pa3BOpa'IHBaeTC5I H Ha'IHHaeT 6e>KaTh H30 Bcex CHA B ApyroM HenpaBHAbHOM HanpaBAeHHH. 0H HHKOrAa He OCTa-

AET~. KOTOPbiE YMEIOT PEWATb nPOSnEMbl, PA3B~BAIOTCSJ 6EWEHbiM~ TEMnAM~

HaB.I\HBaeTCH, 'IT06hl HaRTH nepBonpH'IHHY np06AeMhl H.I\H cocTaBHTh AeHCTBeHHhiH IIAaH. CThiAHO, rocnOAHH

l1TaK, AeTH, KOTOpbre YMeiOT pernaTh npo6AeMhi, 6hlCTPee

I1po6HBHOH, noTOMY 'ITO y Bac-To KaK pa3 HMeeTcH AO-

rrpHXOAHT K IJ;e.I\H. TaKHM o6pa30M, OHH If pa3BHBaiOTCH

cTaTO'IHO MOTHBaiJ;HH, 'IT06hl AOCTH'Ib CBOeH u;e.I\H!

6hiCTPee. I10TOMY qT0 TaKHe MaAbiiiiH o6H3aTeAbHO H3yqaT, KaKHe noCAeACTBHH B03hlMe.I\H HX AeHCTBHH, H nocTapaiOTCH H3BAe'lh ypoKH KaK H3 CBOHX ycneXOB, TaK H HeyAa'l. AeftcTBHTeAbHO, eC.I\H He npeAfipHHHMaTh AeftcTBHH, TO HeB03MO>KHO 6yAeT y3HaTh, K qeMY npHBeAyT HaiiiH rronhlTKH. A 6e3 TaKOH o6paTHOH CB513H HaM HHKOrAa He rrpeBpaTliTbCH B AeT:H, YMe!f>ru;HX pernaTh npo6AeMhl. BeJlliKaH lfAeH B BaiiieH rOAOBe TaK H OCTaHeTCH BCero .1\Hllih HAeeft. EC.I\H >Ke Bhi npeAfiPMMeTe AeficTBHH, AI06oft pe-

·~q~

3YAhTaT AaCT B03MO>KHOCTh HX o6AYMaTh H H3BAe'lh u;eH-

AeTH, KOTOphle YMeiOT pernaTh npo6AeMhl, npHXOAHT

PaccMoTpHM 3TO Ha KOHKpeTHOM npHMepe. AAeKc,

BaM B orrpeAeAeHHhlH MOMeHT He3Ha'IHTeAbHhlM, TO, nOAb3YHCb HM 6oAee AJlliTeAbHOe BpeMH, nOA06Hbie MaAeHhKHe ycBoeHHbre ypoKH AaAyT BaM orpoMHOe rrpeHMyru;ecTBo.

K CBOeH u;e.I\H 6oAee npHMhiM rryTeM H ropa3AO 6hlCTPee,

DHaHKa H KJ\Hcpcp HMeiOT no cppyKTOBOMY AOTKy, Ka>K-

'leM OCTaAbHhle. TaK >Ke, KaK H I1po6HBHOMY, HM He 3a-

AbiH H3 KOTOphlX npOAaeT no

HHMaTb HaCTOH'IHBOCTH H

Hec AAeKca pacTeT Ha

6biCTPOAeHCTBHH. Ho OHH

100 ap6y30B B MeCHIJ;. EH3-

1% B MecHu;,

EHaHKH -

BA06aBOK KO BCeMY eru;e H HaxOAHT KOpeHb npo6AeMbl, KOTopyro npeACTOHT peiiiHTh, H TOAbKO nOCAe 3TOrO CO-

Aa>KH ap6y30B Ha Ka)KAOM AOTKe qepe3 TpH fOAa? qepe3 TPH roAa AAeKc 6yAeT npOAaBaTh no

CTBHIO. I1pOABHfaHCb K u;e.I\H, OHH HH Ha MHHYTY He npe-

6y3a, EHaHKa -

Kparu;aiOT OTCAe>KHBaTh CBOH KYPC -

roBaTb no

BeAh OHH AOA>KHhi

3091

5%,

10%. HacKOAbKO 6yAyT OT.I\H'IaThCH npo-

KAH¢¢a- Ha

CTaBAHIOT 3cpcpeKTHBHhlH IIAaH H npHCTYfiaiOT K AeH-

Hhle ypoKH. Aa>Ke eC.I\H pe3yAhTaT aHaAH3a noKa>KeTCH

579

143

ap-

ap6y3oB, a K.I\Hcpcp 6yAeT cpy-

ap6y3y B MecHu;! Ec.I\H EHaHKa npoAaeT

~ ~

g ~

..Q

E ~

ap6y3oB B miTh pa3 6oAbrne, '!eM AAeKc, TO I<A.mpcp npoAaeT MX B AB~aTh ABa pa3a 6o.l\hrne, '!eM AAeKc. CKopo eMY nOH~06MTCH AOTOK no60Abiiie, 'IT06hl BMeCTMTb see 3TH ap6y3hi. A npeACTaBhTe, KaKa.si CAOJKMTCH pa3HMu;a qepe3 6oAee npoAOAJKMTeAhHhiH nepMOA - AeT, CKaJKeM, qepe3 AeCHTh HAM TpMAI.J;aTh! CocTaBAeHHhlH HaMM rpacpMK (puc. 1) noKa3hiBaeT, KaK KA.Mcpcp CTpeMMTe.l\hHO o6rOH.sieT 6M3HeC KOHKypeHTOB, KOTOpbiH pa3BMBaeTCH 6oAee MeMeHHhlMM TeMnaMM. PoeT npOAaJKM Ha 10%, noHa'laAY Ka3aBIIIMHCH He3Ha'!MTe.l\hHhiM, B AOArOCpO'IHOH nepcneKTMBe BhiAMACH B orpOMlfYIO BeAM'!MHy.

3000

co3AaTh co6crneHHhlli 6M3Hec HAM AaJKe pelliMTh KaKYIO:aa6YAh CAOJKHYIO rrpo6AeMY fA06aAhHhlX MaciiiTa6oB.

'!rrO 31:1A'll'l'r ?£11Il'l'rb n?O:SJl.£1-i~? DoAOHAeM K perneHMIO npo6AeMhl KaK K npou;eccy. 3TOT npou;ecC MOJKHO pa36MTh Ha qeThipe 3Taiia, KOTOpble aa3oBeM: 1) ou;eHKa TeKyii.J;ei'i cMryau;MM; 2) BhiHCHeHMe nepsonpM'!HHhl npo6AeMhl; 3) COCTaBAeHMe 3cpcpeKTHBIIOf0 IIAaHa AeHCTBMH; 4) KOppeKTMpOBaHMe M BblnOAHeaRe IIAaHa AO Tex nop, noKa npo6AeMa He 6yAeT perneHa. Ha nocAeAHeM 3Tarre, npH Heo6xOA1fMOCTH, ocyii.J;eCTBMieM BHeCeHHe KOppeKTHpOBOK B Halli IIAaH.

r. ............... ............................................

2500 , ,

~ OUEHKA

TEKYli.\E~

CI<1TYAl11<11<1

2000

Bbi~CHEH1<1E

nEPBOnPI<141<1Hbl nP0611EMbl

COCTA8flEHI<1E 3Cil<PEKfi18HOrD

fli1AHAAEOCTBM~

1500

1000

500

100

fOA

fOAA

PI1C. 1. 11'A<PI<1K TPEXJlETHE~ nPOI\A)KI-1 AP6Y30B KOHKYPEHTAMI-1

TioAyqa.si KaK nOAO.JKM'I'eJ\hHhlll, TaK M OTpMI.J;aTe.l\bHblll OIIhlT, Bhi pa3BMBaeTe csoe YMeHMe pernaTh rrpo6AeMbl. CHa'!aAa yqMTeCh pernaTh co6crneHHhle rrpo6AeMhi, a nOTOM MOJKeTe nepeXOAifTb M K rrpeo6pa30BaHMIO OKpYJKaiOID;ero MMpa. TioqeMY 6hl M5J.. Ha'laAa, 'lT06hi A06MTbCH s~ HhiX pe3yAhTaTOB, He B03fMBMTh CBOIO CnOPTlfBHYIO KOMaHAY HAM IIIKO.I\hHhlll napAaMeHT? A A,aAbiiie, B03MOJKH0,

3TH 3Taiihl CAeAyeT paccMaTPHBaTh B eAifHOM KOMOAeKce. TipeJKAe qeM '!TO-AM60 pernaTh, H~O cHa'laAa oco3HaTh caM cpaKT cyii.J;eCTBOBaHMH npo6AeMhl. KorAa Mhl 3TO OC03HaAM, 6yAeT HeAOCTaTO'!HO TOAbKO HaRTH KOpeHb npo6AeMhi. H~o 6yAeT eii.J;e nopa3MhlCAMTh, KaKHM o6pa30M 3TY npo6AeMY MOJKHO AMKBMAlfPOBaTh, a 3aTeM rrpeAIIpMH.siTh KOHKpeTHhle AeHCTBHH no ee ycTPaHeHMIO. PerneHMe npo6AeMhl - 3TO COBOKyrrHOCTh MbiiiiAeHHH H AeHCTBMH. ECAM Bhl 6yAeTe AeAaTh '!TO-TO OAHO, HO He 6yAeTe AeAaTh APyroe, TOrAa HM'!ero He A06heTech. Bhl MOJKeTe nOAYMaTh, 'ITO 3TO 3ByqMT CAHIIIKOM rrpocro. Bee AeAO B TOM, '!TO Mhl 3a'laCTYJO He AeNieM roro, 'ITO Ka:>KeTCH TaKHM rrpoCThiM H oqeBlfAHbiM· Bo3hMeM, K rrp:MMepy, yqeHMKa, KOTOpbiH «CbeXaA» no MaTeMaTHKe. «5I AOA:>KeH YAyqiiiMTh csoH ou;eHKM no MareMaTHKe», - rosopm OH. Ho, KaK H MHorne APYfHe, rrpocro H~eeTCH Ha Ayqrnee, IIpM 3TOM HH'!ero He rrpeAIIPHHHMM, '!T06hi Aei'icrnMTeAhHO YAyqiiiMTb ycnesaeMoCTh. CKopee scero, ero ou;eHKM noMa27

~: ..,

~ ~

..q

TeMaTMKe OCI'aHyi'OI Ha TOM JKe ypOBHe, nOCKOJ\hKy yt:Ieffifi< TaK H He YAOC)'JKH/\.01 Haifrn: nepaorrpwnrny caoeif rrpo6AeMbi H He nOAYMa.A, tfi'O OH MOJKeT CAeAaTh Af\JI ee perneHIDI.

MJlli

TOT JKe IIIKOJ\hHHK peiiiHT: «5! AOAJKeH 6pOCHTh

¢YT60.l\.hHy10 CeK:u;mo, TOfAd y Memi 6yAeT 60..1\.hllie Bpe-

l1TaK, Bhl.siCHH.l\.OCb, 'ITO reoMeTpH.si

3TO eAHH-

CTBeHHbiH Y'JdCTOK, H3-3a KOTOporo CHHJKaeTC.si ycneBaeMOCTb. IJ;IUIAHHY

CAeAYJOII.l;HM reoMeTpmo

rnaroM

pa36HTb

Heo6XOAHMO Ha

6oAee

AHC-

MeAKHe

TeMhl-nOAIIYHKTbi, HanpHMep: nAOII.l;dA},, yrl\hi, 06neM .

'ITo? Ha YAY'JIIIeHHe o:u;eHoK 3TOT

AaAee: conocTaBHTb nOAY'JeHHbie o:u;eHKH no 3THM Te-

OT'IdHHHhiH nOCTYIIOK MOJKeT COBCeM He nOB.l\.H.siTh , eCAH Bbl.siCHHTC.si, 'ITO npo6AeMa 6hl.l\.a He B TOM, 'ITO

MaM. TaKHM o6pa3oM, YTO'IH.sieTC.si, KaKaH HMeHHO TeMa

Md.l\.b'IHK 3dHHMaeTC.si Md.l\.0, a B TOM, 'ITO OH 3dHHMaeTC.si

npo6AeMY. KorAa ypoaeHb noHHMaHHH npo6AeMhl H3MeHHeT-

MeHH Ha Y'Je6y».

He3¢¢eKTHBHO. 3a':leM JKe 3p.si OTKd3biBdTbC.si OT B03· MOJKHOCTH noHrpaTb B ¢YT60A c APY3b.siMH?

A tfi'O CAeAaeT B 3TOH cmya:u;HH pe6eHoK, Korophlif )1MeeT perna'I'b IIp06AeMbi? PaCCMOTpHM Ha IIpHMepe (CM. CXeMy).

reoMeTpHH

Bbi3hiBaeT

6ecnOKOHCTBO

nopo)KAaeT

cH OT «MOH o:u;eHKH no MaTeMaTHKe yxyAIIIH.l\.HCb» AO AeTaAH3HpoaaHHoro cyJKAeHHH «MOH o:u;eHKH no MaTeMaTHKe yxyAIIIH.l\.HCb H3-3d TOfO, 'ITO 5I He nOHHMdiO Tpex TeM: «nAOII.l;dAb Tpane:u;HH», «06neM I.l;HAHHApa» H «npHMeHeHHe TeopeMhl DH¢aropa», -

TOfAd H 3¢-

¢eKTHBHOCTb nAaHa, H KOHe':IHhiH pe3yAbTdT 6yAYT pa3HTe.l\.hHO OT.l\.H':IaTbCH OT npeAbiAyll.l;HX AByx npHMepOB. DOC.l\.e BhiHCHeHHH TOfO, KaKHe 3dAdHH51 Bbi3hiBaIOT TPYAHOCTH, cAeAYJOII.l;HM rnaroM pe6eHKa, KOTOpbiH YMeeT pernaTb npo6AeMhl, 6yAeT onpeAeAHTb, 'ITO KOHKpeTHO HdAO CAeAaTb

AJ\.51 YAY'JIIIeHHH ycne-

saeMOCTH. CAeAyeT AH eMy yaeAH'IHTb apeMH 3aHHTHH MaTeMaTHKOH, nOBhiCHTb CBOIO npOH3BOAHTe.l\.bHOCTb H.l\.H CAe.l\.dTb H TO, H Apyroe. l..JT06hl yae.l\.H'IHTb BpeMH 3aHHTHH MaTeMaTHKOH, MOJKHO BCTaBaTb Ha nOA':IaCa paHbiiie H.l\.H BhiCB060AHTb nOA'IaCa nepeA CHOM

A.l\.51

perneHHH 3dAa'I no C.l\.OJKHhiM TeMaM. l..JT06hl yaeAH'IHTb npOH3BOAHTe.l\.hHOCTb, HaAO noMeHHTb nOAXOA K 3aHHTHHM. MoJKHO nepeifTH Ha Apyroif Y'Je6HHK, nonpocHTb Y'JHTeA.si HAH APY3eif AOnOAHHTe.l\.hHO no3aPe6eHoK, KOTOpblli YMeeT perna'I'b rrpo6AeMbi, Ha':IHeT CIIpdlliHBa'I'b ce6.s~: «Ha BOIIpOChl KaKOro POAa .si OTBe':laro HeIIpaBH.l\.bHO? » 3aTeM OH pa306beT BOIIpOChl Ha KaTeropHH,

HaHHTb peneTHTOpa. DpH':IHHa yxyArneHHH

o:u;eHOK

no MaTeMaTHKe y

HarrpHMep: aAre6pa, AP06H, reoMerpH.si. CpaBHHBB.H 6aJV\.hl

KaJI<Aoro caoH. Do3ToMy, ecTeCTBeHHO, y KaJKAoro 6y-

no KareropH.siM, OH orrp~eAHT, tfi'O Ha CaMOM AeAe ero ycne-

AeT H CBOH CdMbiH 3cp¢eKTHBHhiH MeTOA perneHHH npo-

BaeMoCTb no aAre6pe YAY'JIIIH.l\.acb, no AP06.siM -

6AeMbi C pa3BHTHeM MaTeMaTH':IeCKHX cnoco6HOCTeH.

He H3Me-

HHAacb H TO.l\.hKo no reoMerpHH ycneaaeMoCTb yxyAlliHJ\acb.

CAeAOBaTe.l\.hHO, Bbl AO.l\.JKHhl nOCTOHHHO 3dAaBaTb ce6e

ECllli

BOnpocbi «no':leMY? » H «KaK? » AO TeX nop, noKa He CO-

6bi OH paccMa'IJHiBaA ycpeAHeHHyiO TeiJAeH:u;IllO no MdTeMaTMKe, TO He YBHAeA 6hl ped.l\.bHoH KdpTiiHhl.

HRMaTbCH nOC.l\.e IIIKO.l\.hl H.l\.H npeAJ\.OJKHTb pOAHTe.l\..siM

CTaBH:Te caoif HHAifBHAYd.l\.bHhiH nAaH AeifcTBHH.

~ "'

l(niOY K noCTpOeHl-110 nOrlt1YeCKOro Aepesa COCTOL-1T B TOM, YT06bl cHaYana pa36l-1Tb npo6neMy no Bb16paHHbiM HaMl-1 KaTeropL-1RMseTBRM, Hlt1Yero He ynycKaR, a noTOM crpynnlt1posaTb CXO)f(lt1e nyHKTbl nOA OAHO(;i l-1 TO(;; )f(e BeTBbiO. Bee cpa3y craHeT noHRTHO, ecnl-1 Mbl B03bMeM npocTo(;i nplt1Mep. no KaKl-1M KaTeroplt1RM MO)f(HO 06beAl-1Hl-1Tb yYeHl-1KOB TpeTbero Knacca? nepBbl(;; cnoco6 - no nonosoMy npl-13HaKy: Ha ManbYl-1KOB l-1 AeBoYeK . BTopolil cnoco6 - no pocry: «Bblwe 122 eM» l-1nl-1 «122 CM l-1 Hlt1)f(e». A MO)f(HO ell.le o6beAL-1Hl-1Tb l-1X no npl-13HaKy BeAyllle(;i pyKl-1 : «npasww>, «nesww> l-1 «Te, KTO snaAeeTo6elt1Ml-1 pyKaMl-1

~ ~· ~· ~:

B OAlt1HaKOBO(;i CTeneHW>. A BOT KaK 6yAeT BblrnRAeTb norlt1YeCKOe AepeBO B Ka)f(AOM l-13 3Tl-1X cnyYaes. BoT BlfAHTe, pernaTb npo6AeMb! He TaK yJK CAOJKHO. Bee, qTo OT sac Tpe6yeTCH,

3To pa3o6paTbCH B cHrya-

D;HH, HaHTH nepBOTipHqHHY, COCTaBHTb 3cpcpeKTHBHbiH TIAaH H -

AeflcTBOBaTb. EcAH Bbl HayqHTecb TI03TanHo

TIOAXOAHTb K npo6AeMe, pa36HBaH ee Ha qacTH, TO AaJKe CaMaH 60AblliaH H He06b!qafiHO CAOJKHaH np06AeMa 6yAeT BaMH perneHa. KaK TOAbKO Bbl OCBOHTe 06Ill;HH MeTOA perneHHH npo6AeM, TO nepeCTaHeTe TiaHHKOBaTb H

TIOqyBCTByeTe

ysepeHHOCTb B ce6e. TOrAa B BalliHX CHAax 6yAeT pe-

BbiWE122CM

r - MAilb'lHKM

KllACC

t122CMMH~

L-AEBO'lKH

nPABWM nEBWM

T£, KTO BnAAEEJ 06EHMM PYKAMM 8 OAMHAKOBOM CTEnEHM

lliHTb AID6yro np06AeMy, C KOTOpofl: CTOAKHeTeCb Ha CBOeM JKH3HeHHOM nyTH: BO BpeMH yqe6bi, Ha pa6oTe HAlf B AlfqHOH JKH3HH.

MlfC.'r1?~lf'r.A1?M~

1?£1II£lfMS n?OSJ1£M.: JJ.OrM'i£C.KO£ ;ll.E:1?.E:l30 Jlon1YecKoe Aepeso l-1nl-1, KaK ero ell.le Ha3biBatoT, Aepeso peweHl-1(;1 - 3TO npeKpacHoe noAcnopbe B npeoAoneHL.1l-1 npo6neM. 3ro HarmlAHbl(;i l-1HCTpyMeHT, KOTOpbl(;i noMoraeT onpeAenlt1Tb noTeHL\lt1anbHble nepsonpl-1Yl-1Hbl npo6neMHo(;i Cl-1Tyal\lt1l-1 l-1 cnoco6crsyeT Bblpa6oTaTb MHO)f(eCTBO BCeB03MO)f(HbiX nyre(;; ee peweHL.1R. VlTaK, YT06bl nt.1KBl-1Al-1POBaTb npo6neMy, HaM He06XOAl-1MO noCTpOL-1Tb HeKyto crpyKTypy-Aepeso. 30

CosceM HecnO)f(HO, npaBAa? 3aMeTl-1nl-1, KOrAa Mbl COCTaBl-1nl-1 norlt1YecKoe Aepeso, Mbl Hlt1Koro He ynycrl-1nl-1 l-13 Bl-1AY l-1 seTBl-1 Aepeaa Hl-1 pa3y He nepeceKnl-1Cb? A Tenepb nonpo6yli1Te C03AaTb norlt1YecKoe Aepeso «CnopTL-18Hble CeKL\lt1W> l-1 pacnpeAenl-1Tb TpeTbeKnaCCHl-1KOB COOTBeTCTBeHHO 3aHRTL.1(;i cnopTOM. Y sac nonyYl-1nOCb C03AaTb norlt1YecKOe Aepeso, B KOTopoM npL-1cyrcrsytoT BCe yYeHL-1Klt17 Vlnl-1 KTO-TO He BKniOYeH, l-1nl-1 )f(e ynOML.1HaeTCR ABa)f(Abl? KorAa Bbl cTpOL.1Te norlt1YecKoe Aepeso, He o6R3aTenbHO pL-1COBaTb ero cnesa Hanpaso. npocTo HaYL.1Hali1Te 3anl-1CbiBaTb see, YTO npl-1XOAL-1T Ha yM, Ha nlt1cTe 6yMarl-1. CTpoR Aepeso, rpynnl-1pyli1Te CHaYana KpynHble nOAnyHKTbl. Hanplt1Mep, «3aHlt1MaeTCR B WKOnbHO(;i ceKL\l-1W> - c nesolil cropoHbl, a 6onee MenKL.1e noAnyHKTbl l-1nl-1

~ ~

j ~

C KaK1.1MI.1-TO OrpaH1.1YeHI.1AMI.1 (Hanp1.1Mep, «(nopT1.1BHaA CeKl.li.1 A», «Xy.Qo:>KecrseHHaA ceKLI1.1A» 1.1 r .n.) - c npasolil cropoHbl. Tenepb crpynn1.1pylilre noxo:>KI.1e nyHKTbl BMecre (Hanp1.1Mep, «KoMaH.QHble BI.1.Qbl cnopra», «V1H.Q1.1BI.1.QyanbHble BI.1.Qbl cnopra»). Cne.QyiOU(i-111 war- 3To C03.QaH1.1e HOBbiX serselil. V13yYaA Ka)f(.QyiO rpynny Ha3saH1.11i!, HaYI.1HaA c npasolil cropOHbl, 3a.Qasalilre ce6e sonpoc: «KaK A Mory 03amasi.1Tb 3ry rpynny raKI.1M o6pa3oM, YT06bi3TO Ha3BaHI.1e HOCI-1110 o6o6U(eHHbllil xapaKTep?» npose,QI.1Te fli.1H1.110 sneso 1.1 Han1.1w1.1re o6o6U(eHHoe Ha3saH1.1e 3TO!i! rpyn nb1. C nesolil cropoHbl .Qepesa no Ka)f(.QoMy yKpynHeHHoMy 3amas1.110 cnpaWI.1Balilre ce6A: «LJTO 1.1MeHHO 1.1 KaK 1.1MeHHO?» - 1.1 ,Q06aBJ1Aii!Te BeTBI1 cnesa Hanpaso. TOYHO TaK :>Ke, KaKnori.1YecKOe .Qepeso Ha cxeMe BbiWe, sa we .Qepeso 6y.QeT pa3pacraTbCA cnesa Hanpaso (eM. c. 33 -34). B03bMeM ell.(e O.Q1.1H np1.1Mep. KaK C,Qenarb TaK, YT06bl 1.13 nepeYHi-1'-lbl BbiCblnaJlOCb 60JlbWe nep1..1a, HO CI.1Jla 1.1 YaCTOTa, C KOTOpoli Bbl rpAcere 3Tolil nepeYHi-1'-lelil, ocrasanacb npe:>KHelil? Bocnonb3ylilrecb flOri.1YeCKI.1M ,QepeBOM, YT06bl 3ani.1CaTb KaK MO:>KHO 60Jlb We BCeB03MO:>KHbiX 1.1,QeliJ (.QasaliJre ,QOrOBOp1.1MCA, YTO Bfla:>KHOCTb np11 3TOM He 1.1rpaer pon1.1) . Hy KaK, nonyYI.1flOCb? Bor O.Q1.1H 1.13 B03MO:>KHbiX cnoco6os peweHI.1A.

Yro6bl nocrpo1.1Tb 3TO .Qepeso, HaYHI.1Te c nocraHOBKI-1 npo6neMbl c nesoli! CTOpOHbl : «KaKI.1M o6pa30M A MOry yseJ11.1YI.1Tb KOJ11.1YeCTBO nepl.la, KOTOpoe BbiCblnaeTCA 1.13 nepeYHI-1'-Ibl np1.1 O,QHOM BCTpAXI.1BaHI.11.17 » ,Oanee HaYI.1Halilre crpo1.1Tb sers1.1, 3ani.1CbiBaA n106b1e B03MO:>KHble peweHI.1A. BOT ,QBa B03MO:>KHbiX BbiXO,Qa: (1) yseJ11.1YI.1Tb nflOU(a,Qb nosepXHOCTI-1 nepeYHI.1l.lbii.1Jll.1 (2) yseJ11.1YI.1Tb KOJ11.1YeCTBO nep1..1a, Koropbllil BbiCblnaercA c cyll.(ecrsyiOU(elil nnoll.(a.QI-1. npo.Qon:>KaeM crpo1.1Tb sers1.1 or sroporo sap1.1aHra peweHI.1A: YT06bl yseJli.1YI.1Tb KOJ11.1YeCTBO nep1..1a, KOTOpbiliJ BbiCblnaeTCA C 1.1MeiOU(eliJCA nnoll.la.QI-1, HY:>KHo: n1.16o (1) yseni.1YI.1Tb KOJ11.1Yecrso orsepcr1.11i! Ha 3a,QaHHOiiJ nflOll.la.QI-1, 111.160 (2) yseJ11.1YI.1Tb KOJ11.1YeCTBO nep1..1a, KOTOpbllil BbiCblnaeTCA 1.13 Ka)f(,QOro OTBepCTI.1A. 111, HaKOHel.l, yseJ11.1YI.1Tb KOJ11.1YeCTBO nep1..1a, KOTOpbiliJ BbiCblnaeTCA 1.13 Ka)f(,QOro OTBepCTI.1A, MO:>KHO .QBYMA cnoco6aMI.1 : (1) yseni.1Y1.1Tb pa3Mep Ka)f(,Qoro orsepCTI.1R 1.1111.1 (2) yMeHbWI.1Tb pa3Mep nepY1.1HOK, C,QeJlaB TOHbWe noMOil . Me)f(.Qy npOY1.1M, O,QHa 1.13 KpynHeliJWI.1X KOMnaHI.11iJ B ccpepe roprosn1.1 cnel.II.1AMI.1 B ,QelilcrBI.1TeflbHOCTI.1 ysen1.1Y1.1na csolil o6beM npo.Qa:>K 3a eyer roro, YTO C,Qenana orsepcr1.1A Ha cso1.1x nepeYHI-1'-IaX KpynHee! V1Hor.Qa nocrpoeHI.1e nori.1YecKoro .Qepesa noMoraer ys1.1.QeTb o6Ll.IYIO KapT1.1Hy . 0HO n03BOJ1AeT Bbi,Qefli.1Tb Te napaMeTpbl, KOTOpble MOryT 6b1Tb 1.13MeHeHbl.

YBE!l~YV1Tb

r· ·~~fy~~~~-·\. . ..

j KOn~YEGBO nEPI.jA, KOTOPOE BbiCblnAETC~ \ 113 nEPEYH~I.jbl ; nPVIOAHOM \ BGP~X~BAHV1V1l/ ....

r·

··...........

············;

nnOUW1b BEPXHH1 nOBEPXHOCTI1 nEPEYHV11.1bl (OTKYM BbiCblnAETC!I nEPEI.j) YBEI1V1YV1Tb KOnVIYEGBO nEPI.jA, KOTOPOE BbiCblllAETC~ C~MEIOlljEi101

nnOUW1V1

YBEI1V1YV1Tb nnOlJW1b BEPXHEii nOBEPXHOGV1 nEPEYHV11.1bl

YBEI1V1YV1Tb KOm1YEGBO nEP1.1A, IKOTOPblii BbiCblnAETC!I ~3KAJKAOro OTBEPCTV1~

(Q:lEilATb TAK, YT06bl nEPEI.j BbiCblllAnC!I nErYE)

••••• •• •••• •••• •• • •• 2 10-275

YMEHbWV1Tb PA3MEP nEPYV1HOK

• ••

•

••• 33

~: toll ~I

1QI

Pol ~I

3.Al:fH'rl1.$1 'r?£'r~£K~.ACC1:fl1.K08

s cno?rl1.Bl:f:&I~ C£KI.{l1.S1( <DYT60fl 6EI1C60fl

AMEPI1KAHCKH~ <!lYf60fl

HrPbiCMINOM

6ACKET60fl BOnEI160fl flAKPOCC XOKKE~ CM~40M APYri1E

ronb<D TEHHI1C APYri1E

nnABAHI1E

--------~

nE~ATflETI1KA

DbllKHbii1CnOPT APYri1E

TEATPAnbHAA CTYA11~ ~ 11HCTPYMEHTAnbHbii1AHCAM6flb XOP APYri1E

WAXMATbl APYr11E

s ~ ~

B03MO)t(HO, norpe6yerc5l HeKoropoe speM5l, YT06bl Ha6111Tb B nocrpoeHII1111 norii1YeCKOro Aepesa . Ho KaK TOnbKO Bbl OCB0111Te X111TpoyMHYIO TeXHII1Ky, TO HayYII1TeCb MbiCneHHO nOAHII1MaTbC5l nepsolit BCnbiWKOiiiii1Ae111111 np111XOAII1Tb K HOBbiM, ell.le 6onee TII18Hb1M peweHII15lM CBOII1X npo6neM .

cAeAyro~Hx

ypoKax Mhl paccMoTpHM,

MeTOAOM perneHHH 1Ip06AeM H

COOTBeTCTB}'IO~HMJI

HHCTp)'MeHTaMH II0Ab3}'IOTCH Ha rrpaKTHKe AeTH, KOTOphle )'MeiOT pernaTb rrpo6AeMhl: poK-rpynn • ITOA Ha3BaHHeM «J\ro6oBb H MyxoMophl», KOTOpaH 'leT )'BeAH'IHTb IIOCe~aeMOCTb CBOHX KOH~epTOB;

A,JI<v..

0CbMHHOr, KOTOpbiH IIAaHHpyeT KynHTb KOMIIbiOTep Ka'IeCTBe rrepaoro mara Ha rryTH K caoeH: Me'!Te HHMaTbCH B fOAAHByAe C03AaHHeM My. Hhlx H XYAOJKeCTBeHHhlx cpHAbMOB c HcHu/\b;ju.t:Sa..tH'le, . KOMIIbiOTepHOH rpacpHKH; a TaKJKe KHBH 3Be3Aa aMepHKaHCKOrO cpyr6oAa, KOTOpaH H~eT

rnyro ¢YT60AbHyro lliKOAY B OTTO'IHTb CBOe MaCTepCTBO.

Bpa3HAHH, rAe ORa CMu.IX\.c:

--------------------

..... ~:

f ~

I ~ H3Hh rroAHa TPYAHOCTeif. Mbi cTaAKHBaeMcH c ~rrpeiiHTCTBHHMH BCHKHR pa3, KOfAa IIbiTaeMCH AOCTH'Ib CBOHX u;eAeif liJ\.li BOIIJ\.OTHTb B JKH3Hb CBOH Me'!Thl . Mbi

oropqaeMcH

paccTpaHBaeMcH,

KOrAa

'fPYAHOCTH ocTaHaBJ\.HBaiOT Hac. AaJKe CKOIIJ\.eHHe rroBCeAHeBHhiX rrpo6AeM, BCIIJ\.biBaiOiu;HX OAHa 3a Apyroif, CITOC06HO Bbl3BaTb y

HaC qyBCTBa pacTepHHHOCTH li

6eCIIOMOiu;HOCTH . OAHaKo rraHHKOBaTh H CAaBaThCH He CTOHT! BMecTo

3Toro

MhiCAeHHO

ocTaHOBHTecb,

AaJKe

CAeAaifTe rnar Ha3aA, a IIOTOM orrpeAe.I\.HTe KOpeHb Bcex rrpo6AeM H rrpHAYMaiiTe, KaK HX MOJKHO rrpeoAOAeTh .

DpeMaraeMhle HaMH AeifcTBHH o'IeHh rroxoJKH Ha TO, KaK IIOCTyrraeT Bpaq BO BpeMH OIIpeAeAeHHH AHafH03a CBOHx rrau;HeHTOB. BcrroMHHTe, 'ITO AeAaeT TeParreBT, KOrAa Bbl rrpHXOAHTe K HeMy Ha IIpHeM, IIO'IYBCTBOBdB HeAOMOfdHHe. TipeJKAe BCero, OH 3dAaeT BaM HeCKOJ\.bKO BOIIpOCOB ITO IIOBOAY CHMIITOMOB li MepHeT TeMrrepaTypy. OH MOJKeT oTrrpaBHTh Bac CAe.ll.dTb dHd.I\.H3 KpOBH HJ\.li peHTreHOBCKHR CHHMOK . 0H

40 41

~Ill

~ ~

~ E ~

e06HpaeT HH<f>OpMaiJ;HIO H aHaAH3HpyeT ee, qTO yeTaHOBHTh oeHOBHYIO npHqHHY Barnero 3a6oAeBaHHH. 11 TOAhKO noeAe TOrO, KaK 6yAeT AHarH03, Bpaq pernaeT, qTo Ha3HaqHTh: 6yAeT 3TO AeKapeTBO OT npoeTYAhi HAH onepau;nH no YAMeHHIO onyxOAH. 11TaK, noHa6AIOAaB 3a BpaqoM, nOHHMaeM, qTQ oqeHb Ba)KHO yMeTb pa3AlfqaTb eHMnTOMbi (roAOBHaH 60Ah, BbleOKaH TeMnepaTypa) OT npHqlfHbl (npoeTyAa) HOT AeqeHHH (npHeM AeKapeTBa OT npoeTyAbi). TaK H B )Klf3HeHHhiX enTyau;nHx: eeAn Mhl HayqHMeH nOHHMaTb eHMnTOMbl H yeTaHaBAHBaTb npnqHHhi, TOrAa npo:r.u;e 6yAeT pa3pa6aThiBaTh 3<P<f>eKTHBHhle perneHHH. 11TaK, B 3TOH rAaBe npeMaraeM BaM eAeAOBaTb nOBeAeHHIO Bpaqa. TioAOHAlfTe K perneHHIO npo6AeMhi HeeKOAhKHMH IllaraMH.

• IIIar 1: A,HarnocrnKa cwry~HH H ycraHOBAem:~e nepBonpwnmhl npo6AeMhl.

0 A TiepellHCAHre Bee noreH~HaAbHhle nepBonpH'tlHHhl npo6AeMhl. OB. BbJABHHhre mnore3y OTHOCHTeAbHO nepBonpwiHHhl, KOTOpaJI KaJKeTCH BaM HaH60Aee BepOHTHOH. Oc. YcraHOBHre, KaKoif aHaAH3 H KaKaJI HH<}JopMa~HH Heo6xOAJfMhl AM npoBepKH Bameif mnore3hl. OD. CAeAaifre aHaAH3 H ycraHOBHTe ocHOBH}'lO nepBonpH'tlHHy npo6AeMhl.

• IIIar 2: Pa3pa6oTKa pemeHH.H. f) A Pa3pa6oraifre KaK MO>KHo 6oAhme pa3AH'tlHhlx

BapHaHTOB pemeHHH np06AeMbl. 8B. YcraHOBHre npHopHrerHOCTh AeifcrBHif. @C. Pa3pa6oraifre TIAaH BHeApeHHH. PaeeMoTpHM Ha npnMepe, KaK nponeXOAlfT 3TOT npou;eee. 11TaK, MOAOAM pOK-rpyrrna «J\.ro60Bh H MyxoMaphi» 6opeTeH 3a Bbl)KHBaHHe. 42

Ato608b ~ HYXo~OPb\ ~

c.nACl't'r£ «Jl.I-OSOSb Pi. M.~OM.O?bl»!!! Tpn roAa Ha3aA MyxoMop KpaeHM I.l.IMinKa n ABa ee Apyra - EaKAa)KaH CnHeHhKHH n To<Py-CoeBhiH TBopor - pelliHAH e03AaTb pOK-rpyrrrry nOA Ha3BaHHeM «.IUo6oBh n MyxoMophi». Bee HaqaAoeh B TOT He3anaMHTHhiH AeHh, KOrAa KpaeHaH I.l.IMinKa noeeTHAa KoHu;epT «Rolling Stones» B napKe Ha nAO:l.IJ;aAlf MeAHeOH. Cpa3y noeAe KOHu;epTa OHa no3BOHHAa CnHeHhKOMY n To<Py. Ee npoeTo paeTIHpaAo OT BOeTopra. «Bee, peiiieHO, 3aBTpa )Ke e03AaeM co6eTBeHHYIO poK-rpyrrrry, - eKa3aAa oHa APY3hHM. 51, eeTeeTBeHHO, 6yAy eoAHeTKOH. Thl, EaKAa)KaH, 6yAernh nrpaTh Ha rnTape. A Thi, To<f>y, 6yAernh 6apa6aH~liKOM, AOrOBOpHAHeb? 3aBTPa epa3y noeAe ypOKOB BCTpeqaeMeH H HaqnHaeM peneTHpOBaTh! » - MRHyTOqKy... - nonhiTaAeH B03pa3HTh EaKAa)KaH. - f1oeTOH-Ka ... - TOAbKO li yeneA eKa3aTh To<Py. Ho KpaeHaH lllAHnKa, pa3AaB Bee HHeTPYKIJ;HH, y)Ke IIOAO)KRAa Tpy6Ky. EaKAa)KaH H To<f>y rAy60KO B3AOXHyAH. «Hy BOT, OnHTh ABaAIJ;aTb IIHTh», - eKa3aAH OHH. OaR o6a no yrnn BAI06AeHhi B MyxoMop n K~I:H: pa3, KorAa e:H: qerO-HH6YAh 3a6AaropaeeyAlfTeH, OHH npOeTO li 3 KO)KR BOH Ae3YT, qT06bi oey:r.u;eeTBliTh ee Meqry. 43

~Ill

·~-

B TOT JKe AeHh CHHeHhKHH B3M a 3aHMbl y cTaprnero 6paTa rHTapy H Ha'laA OCBaHBaTb a3bl Hrpbl Ha 3TOM HHCTPYMeHTe no CaMOYlJHTeJUO. Tmpy-CoeBbiH Taopor, He OTKAC!Ab1Ba51 AeAO B AOMHH HIIJ;HK, AOCTaJ\. CBOH naAO'lKH AA.51 eAbl H Ha'laA OT6HBaTb TaKT no KapTOHHOH KOp06Ke - BeAh AeHer Ha nOKYIIKY 6apa6aHa y Hero noKa He 6b1Ao. MyxoMop KpacHaHI.I.IMJ:nKa opaAa TaKHM npornaHbiM roAocoM, 'ITO BaKAaJKaHY H To<Py npHXOAlfAOCh 3aTbiKaTh yrnH, 'IT06bl He orAOXHYTh. Ho 3a TPH Mec.si~a peneTH~Hii OHa 3Ha'lHTeAhHO npOABHHYAacb H Bblpa6oTaAa npeKpaCHhiH rOAOC C XpHnO~OH. TiocAe KaJKAOH peneTH~HH KpacHaH I.I.IMJ:nKa c rnHpoKoii yAhr6Koii Ha AH~e BCerAa 3a5IBAW\.a OAHO H TO JKe: «A Mbl HH'lero, npaBAa? >> TpH Mec.si~a crrycTH BaKAaJKaH, To<Py H MyxoMop B03Bparn;aAH:Ch nOCAe IIIKOAbl AOMOH. BaKAaJKaH H To<Py nbiTaAH:Ch paCCKa3aTb nOAPyre 0 TOM, KaK OHH HanHCaAH KOHrpOAbHyro no MaTeMaTHKe, HO Bee CAOBa npoAeTaAH MHMO ee yrneii. 0Ha TOAhKO KHBaAa rOAOBOH H npoH3HOCH:Aa: «Yry! Yry! >> MblcAeHHO KpacHaH I.I.IMJ:nKa 6b1Aa rAe-To O'leHh AaAeKo. BApyr oHa pe3KO ocTaHoBHAacb H 06'b.siBHAa: «Ha CAeAyrorn;yro cy66ory Ha3HaqaeM KOH~epT B IIIKOAhHOM CnOpT3aAe. 11 TaK Tenepb 6yAeT KaJKAbiH Mec.si~. AoroaopHAH:ch? >> - Ha cAeAyrorn;yro cy66ory? Ho 3To HeB03MOJKHo! B03pa3HA CHHeHhKHH. - HaM He pa3pernaT HcnoAb30BaTh cnopT3aA. YqeHHKH HHKOrAa He CHHMaiOT CnOpT3aJ\. AA.51 AH'!HbiX HYJKA! - BOCKAHKHYA CoeBbiH Taopor.

...

«3M, pe6.siTa, B '!eM AeAO?! - 3aBH3JKaAa OHa. - YIIIH 6hl MOH BaCHe CAbiiiiaAH! Mbi XOTHM CTaTh npo<PecCHOHaAbHOH rpyrrnoii, HAH KaK? KaK Mbl HaYlJHMCH BbiCTYnaTh nepeA TOAIIOH nOKAOHHHKOB, eCAH He HalJHeM CeH'!aC JKe? 5I npHMO OTCIOAa OTIIpaBAHIOCh K AHPeKTOpy IIIKOAbl H 6yAy npOCHTh ero pa3peiiieHHH Ha HCnOAh30BaHHe cnopT3aAa. BaKAaJKaH H To<Py, Ha'lHHaiiTe o63BaHHBaTh AIOAeH H npHrA.arnaHTe HX Ha KOH~epT. 3a pa6ory! >> MyxoMOp pa3BepHyAaCh Ha CTO BOCeMhAeCHT rpaAyCOB H no6eJKaAa B IIIKOAy. BaKAaJKaH H To<Py neperA.siHYAHCh H B3AOXHYAH: «l..JTo JKe AeAaTh? >> MyxoMop KpacHaH Il.IMmKa YMeeT A06HBaThCH caoero. 0Ha He cTecH.sieTcH rrycKaTh a XOA ace caoe o6a.siHHe, eCAH 3To H~o AA.51 AeAa, no3TOMY c XOAY Bbi6HAa H3 AHPeKTopa pa3perneHHe Ha apeHAy cnopT3aA.a. BaKAaJKaH H CoeBbiH Taopor rrpHrAacHAH napy APY3eH Ha KOH~epT, H MepollpH.siTHe COCTOW\.OCh B nOAHOM COOTBeTCTBHH C IIAaHOM. DpoiiiAo ern;e TPH Mec.si~a, H rpyrrna «J\ro60Bh H MyxoMopbl>> ycneAa AaTh TPH KOH~epTa. Ho MyxoMop onHTh 'ieM-To HeAOBOAhHa. «51 Tpaqy caoe Aparo~eHHoe apeMH, AeA.aro nocTaHOBKY rnoy, a B TOAIIe AO CHX nop BCero ll.siTH~aTh 'leAoBeK! Ha nepBhiH KOH~epT npHIIIAO l\eC51Tb 'leAOBeK, Ha BTOpOH - II.siTH~aTh H Ha rpeTHH - CHoaa nHTH~aTh. B '!eM AeAo, pe651Ta? Pa3Be He Bbl OTBeqaeTe 3a TO, 'IT06bl cnopTHBHbiH 3aJ\. 6biA 6HTKOM 45

E ~

............

Ha6H:T .lUOAbMH? HaM ITpeACTOHT qeTBepTbiH KOHIJ;epr,

••• OHH nOCEll.lAIOT \ I KOHL.lEPTbl I ... nOCTOHHHO? /

CAeAa:H:Te TaK, qTo6hl Ha 3TOT pa3 3a.l\. 6biJ\. ITOAOH! » YBH:AeB c.l\.e3bl Ha rAa3ax y KpacHo:H: lil.IUIITKH, C:Q.

•• ••OH~ KOrn;: •••

HeHbKHH H To¢y ITOK.IUIJ\.H:Cb ce6e HaRTH ITepBOITp:Q. qlfHy ITp06.1\.eMbi C ITOCeiu;aeMOCTbiO H HaiTOJ\.HH:Tb 3 a.l\.l( : ·······•···· OHV1 •.

CAeAYIOiu;eMY KOHD;epry.

j OCBEAOMilEHbl

.............

lliOAH. KOTOPbiE OCBEAOMilEHbl OKOHL.lEPTAX

lliOAH. KOTOPbiE OCBEAOMilEHbl 116biBAJll1 HA KOHL.lEPTAX

.0 ll10A11. KOTOPbiE OCBEAOMilEHbl, HO HE 6biBAJll1 HA KOHL.lEPTAX

1 .A. n.e?.ett~c::.JJ.~'r.e n.e?aon?~tt~llbi

ac.e ao3MO~lfbi.e n?osJJ..eMDI

nOCEll.lAIOT KOHL.lEPTbl nOCTOHHHO

·.............·

\ 0 KOHL.lEPTAX? /

Alf1ArHOCTif1KA Clf1TYAUif11f11f1 YCTAHOB11EHif1E nEPBOnPif141f1Hbl nP0611EMbl

• • • • • • • ,. • • • (i)lliOAH, KOTOPbiE

HI16YAb 6biBAJll1 i •• HA KOHL.lEPTAX? :

Y'1EH11KI1 11Y'111TEilH

Ha KoHu;epTbi rpyrriThi «.l\:Eo6oBb H MyxoMopbi» ITPHXO· ART CJ\.HIIIKOM Ma./\.0 JUOAe:H:. YqacTHHKH rpyrriThl XOTHT BbiHCHH:Tb, ITO KaKOH ITpH:qHHe 3TO ITpOHCXOAHT H K aK KaJKAbiH qeJ\.oBeK 6e3 HCKJ\.IOqeHHH AOJ\.JKeH ITOITaCTb

MOJKHO HCITpaBH:Tb CHTyaD;HIO.

B cBo:H: cerMeHT.

PEWEHiflE nP0611EMbl

4!)

HaqHeM c BOITpoca «TioqeMY? » TioqeMy JUOAH He ITpH· XOAHT Ha KOHIJ;epT? lJTO MOJKeT 6biTb TOMY ITpH:qH:HOH ? 0Ka3biBaeTCH, eCTb He OAHa, a HeCKOJ\.bKO ITOTeHIJ;H· a.l\.bHbiX OCHOBHhlX ITpH:qHH.

.ll.A

OHH OCBEAOMilEHbl 0 KOHL.lEPTAX? •

-+-

. . OHH KOrAA-HI16YAb' 6biBAJll1 HA KOHL.lEPTAX?

,ll.A

nOCEll.lAIOT KOHL.lEPTbl nOCTOHHHO?

lJT06bi JUOAH ITpHIIIJ\.H Ha KOHIJ;epT, OHM, BO-ITepBbiX, AOJ\.JKHbi 3HaTb, qTo TaKo:H: KOHu;epT CYIIJ;eCTByeT.

Bo·

BTOpbiX, OHM AOJ\.JKHhl 3axOTeTb ITpHHTH Ha KOHu;epT H, B-TpeTbHX, 6yAeT ITpeKpaCHO, eCJ\.H OHM, ITOCMOTpeB YBAeKaTe.l\.bHOe IIIoy rpyrriTbi «.l\:Eo6oBb H MyxoMopbi» , 3axOTHT ITpHXOAHTb Ha ee KOHD;epTbi CHOBa H CHOBa.

ll{.e'r

.oiOAH, KOTOPbiEHE OCBEAOMilEHbl OKOHL.lEPTAX

~ lliOAI1. KOTOPbiE OCBEAOMilEHbl 0 KOHLlEPTAX, HO Hl1 Pf>JY HA HI1X HE 6biBAJll1

lliOAH. KOTOPbiE nOCEll.lAIOT KOHL.lEPTbl nOCTOHHHO

l l{.e'r

lliOAI1. KOTOPbiE OjlHA)I(JJ.b1110Cffi111H WOY 11 nPEKPATI11lH XOAI1Tb HA KOHL.lEPTbl

I1TaK, ITO .1\.0r:H:qecKoMY AepeBy BMecTe c APY3bHMlf KpaCHOH lilAHITKH Bbl MOJKeTe OTCJ\.eAHTb CJ\.eAYIOIIJ;ee . Tipe)KAe BCero, HeKOTOpbie J\.IOAif B006Iu;e He 3Ha.I\.H 0 TOM,

~0 rAe-TO ITpOBOAifTCH KOHIJ;epT

(A);

APyrne XOTb H 3HaAlf

AM Toro qTo6hi ycTaHOBHTb ITpHqHey ITpo6AeMbi ITOceiiJ;aeMocTH KoHu;epTOB, EaKAaJKaHy H To¢y Heo6xo-

/1,MI 3TO-

0 KOHD;epTe, He ITOJKeJ\.a.I\.H TyAa HATH HJ\.H H:Me.I\.H APyrn:e

AHMo OITpeAe.I\.HTb pa3Mep KaJKAOro cerMeHTa.

BecKH:e IIp:H:qH:Hbi, ~06bl TyAa He XOAH:Tb

ro OHM AOJ\.JKHbl paCCMOTpeTb C.l\.eAYIOIIJ;He BOITpOCbl:

(B);

H eCTb eiu;e

JUOAif, KOTOpbie, OAHaJKAbl IT06biBaB Ha KOHD;epTe «Myxo· MOpOB», pelliHJ\.H 60.1\.biiie TyAa He XOAH:Tb

(C); KOHe~o )l(e (D).

Te, KOTOphle ITOCeiu;aiOT KOHIJ;epTbi pery.IUipHO

TioqeMY HeKOTOpbie JUOAH He OCBeAOMJ\.eHhl 0 KOHIJ;epTax?

~Ill

f) f1otieMY HeKOTOpbie JUOAH He npHXOASIT Ha KOHn;epTbi, AaJKe eC./Ui OHH OCBeAOMAeHbi 0 HHX? C) f1otieMY HeKOTOpbie .JUOAH npeKparn;aiOT XOAM:Tb Ha KOHIJ;epTbi?

~ ~

I'll:!C.':rl?~lot,e~.Al?i'\1.1 AJ).H 1?.elii.el:ll'l.H n?OSJl.elot: ,ll.el?,eSO «,ll.A/lf.e':r» lJT06bi HaRTH npH'IHHY npo6AeMbi H./ill peiiiHTb 3~a'l)', MO.IKHO BOCITOAb30BaTbC51 AepeBOM «Aa/HeT». lJTo6hi C03AaTb TaKoe Aepeso, H~o OTBeTHTb Ha p _sw npOCTbiX BOnpOCOB, Tpe6yiOin;HX OTBeTa «Aa/HeT», HaiTOA06He TeX BOITpOCOB, Ha KOTOpbie BaKAaJKaH ~ Tocpy HIIJ;YT OTBeTbi. OcTaBHM APY3e:H: Ha HeKoTopoe speM51 HCKaTb OT· seTh! H paccMoTpHM ern;e OAHH npHMep. ITpeACTaBbTe( 'ITO Bbl npocna./Ui. ITAaHHpOBa./Ui npoCHYThC51 B rnecn. YTPa, npHH51Tb AYIIIr no3aBTpaKaTb H ycneTb Ha aBTO· 6yc, KOTOpbiR OTnpaBA51eTC51 B 7tiaCOB 8 MHHYT. A BMe· CTO 3TOrO COpBa.lillCb C ITOCTe.lill B 6 lJaCOB 53 MHHYTbl•

.llA

nPr.14r.1HA: OH 3BOHV1fi, HO RHE nPOCHYnCR RYCfibiWA!l EfO, HO OTKI110YV1fi. RYCfibiWA113BOHOK, HO HAlKAil KHOnKY «BbiKil.» 11 CP/l3Y )I(E CHOBA YCHYn

.l .A[. 6YA1<1fibHI<1K • 6blfi 3ABEAEH HA 6YACOB7 •

6YA11fibHI1K 3BOHI1m

l[£':r

l[£':r (HE3HAIO)

YACbl TI1KAIOT?

KHOnKA 6YA1<1fibHI<1KA HAXOA1<1TCR B nonO)I(EHI11<1 •BKil.•? nPr.14r.1HA: RHEnPABI<lfibHO 3ABEn 6YA1<1fibHI1K

lJI-fCTHTe 3Y6hi OAHOR PYKOR, Apyro:H: ITbiTaeTech HaTHayTh Ha ce651 A)KHHCbi, a B 3TO BpeM51 rOAOBa AHXOpa,(l,OqHO coo6paJKaeT: «ITotieMY 5I npocnaA? He ycAbiiiiaA BoHKa? ByAHAbHHK CAOMaAC51, 'ITO AM:?» 3 YiTaK, CHryan;H5151CHa, BaM He06XOAHM0 pernHTh: B '!eM )l{e npH'IHHa npo6AeMhi? C5£AbTe H nonbiTa:H:TeCb HapHcosaTh AepeBO «Aa/HeT», KOTOpoe ITOMO.IKeT BaM pa306paTbC51, notieMY .IKe Bbl sce-TaKH npocnaAH. 3anHIIIHTe BOnpOC. 06AYMaHTe, KaKOR OTBeT - «/¥1» HAM: «HeT» npHBeAeT sac K o6'b51CHeHHIO (cerMeHry) HAM: APyroMY BOnpocy. f1oBTOp51:H:Te 3TY ITOCAeAOBaTeAbHOCTh AeRCTBHR AA51 Ka./KAOro CAeAyrorn;ero sonpoca, noKa He co3AaNf.Te cerMeHTbi AA51 scex sepo51THbiX perneHHR. TioAyqHAOCh? HH.IKe (c. 48-49) npHBOAHM OAM:H H3 B03MO.IKHbiX sapHaHTOB Aepesa «Aa/HeT» AA51 o6'bHCHeHH5I, notieMy Bbi npocnaAH. Barne Aepeso He o65I3aTeAbHO AOA.IKHO BblrA5JAeTh TO'IHO TaK .IKe, HOB HeM HClAO HCITOAb30BaTh BOITpOCbi, npeAfiOAaraiOin;He OTBeTbl «Aa»/«HeT» C TeM, 'IT06bl Bbi5ICHHTb see B03MO.IKHhle npHtiHHbi sarne:H: npo6AeMhi.

3BOHOK PA60TAffi 3ABEA1<1TE 6YA11nbHV1K TAK,YT06biOH WBOHVln YEPBSM11HYT

.llA

nPr.1'lr.1HA: HABEPHOE, OH 3BOHV1fi, HO RHE nPOCHYilCR

-----1

nPV1YI1HA: RHE YGAHOBI11l KHOnKY BnOJl0)1(EHI1E «BKil.»

l[£':r

nPr.14r.1HA: 6YA111lbHI1K cnOMAilCR

6ATAPB1KA

.llA{

6ATAPE~KA·, YGAHOBfiEHA · nPABI<lllbHO?, ,

~~~~~~ HAAPYfOM

YaPO~GBE)

l[£':r

nPr.11lr.1HA: 6ATAPE~KA CEllA

nPr.14r.1HA:

l[£':r

6ATAPE~KA 6blllA YGAHOBilEHA HEnPABI<lllbHO

~ tq

~ ~

1 s. SbJ..llSRr.All'r£ rl'l.nor£3bi O'rl:{OC.H~.E:Jlbl:{O l:f.AHSOJl.E:.E: S.E:~OH~l:{Oif n~H'iHl:fbi

A reneph rrpHcryirnM K pa3pa60TKe TIIIIOTe3hl, KOTOpaJI HCHID\a 6hl, noqeMY .IUOAH: He noce~CllOT KOHIJ;epn,r. fHIIOTe3a- 3TO mrrymwmoe rrp~oAoJKeHH:e. 3To 'ITO, no BaiiieMY MHe:mno, MOJKeT 6hiTh eaMhlM Bepo~ o6'b51eHeHH:eM, XOTII Bhl 3TOI'O e~e He AOKa3aAH:. C<t>OPMYAH:pOBaB TIIII0Te3Y H IIpHBEWJ Bee B03MOJKHhlelll AOKa3aTeAbCTBa B ee noAb3y, Bhl eMOJKeTe OIIp~e.JUfi'b, TIIHHa ORa HAH: AOJKHa. TioCAe 3TOI'O MOJKeTe nepeXOAIITb rrpiDIHTino B3BerneHHoro perneHH:51, KOTopoe rrpHBeAer K ycneiiiHOMY rrpeOAOAe:mno rrp06AeMbi. Bo3hMeM rrpHMep H3 JKH:3HH. AorryCTHM, Bhr pe~IIHAH: BeCTIITb CBOIO 6a6yrnKy, KOTOpaJI JKH:BeT B 30 MHA51X OT poAa. A eeroAH51 - BTOpm1: AeHh noCAe AH5I :a no 3TOMY noBOAY Bee Mara3H:Hhl o6'b51BHAH: 6oAhrnyro IIpONlJKY. J\roNI HaBepHHKa TOAIIaMH PlffiYAHCh B MaTa3H-I Hhr, a 3TO 3Ha'lliT, 'ITO Ha AOporax 6yAyr 60AhiiiH:e rrpo6KH. BaM XO'IeTCH no6hiTh y 6a6yr.IIKH KaK MOJKHo AOAhllle, HO O'IeHh BaJKHo BepHYfbC51 AOMo:H: He no3JKe AeCHTII Beqepa, nOTOMY 'ITO 3aB-rpa yrpoM y Bac -rpeHH:poBKa no 6e:H:e6oAy. l.JTO IIpOH30ifAer, eCAH Bhi CAOM51 I'OAOBy 6poeH:TeCh AeHCI'BOBaTb, IIpeABapH:TeAbHo He nopaeKHHyB M03raMH? BhiA06:apaerech BeerAa aBT06yeoM, :a eeroAHH - He HcKJUOqeHHe. KoHe'IHo JKe, aBT06ye 3ac-rpeBaer B rrpo6Ke. KorNI Bill HaKOHer:r;-TO rrpHe3JKaere K JU06H:Mo:H: 6a6yrnKe, TO XBamer BpeMeHH: pOBHO Ha TO, 'IT06bi 6hlC'rpeHbKO 'IMOKHyrb ee B ~e'IKY, Ha XOAY 3arrphirHyrb B aBTo6yc :a OTIIpaBH:TbC51 B MY" 'IHTeAbHhi:H: o6paTHhlli IIYfb. ECAH JKe nep~ TeM KaK CeCTb B aBT06ye, OCTaHOBH:TbC51 H nopa3Mb!CAH:Tb, Barne rryrernecrn:ae MOJKer CAOJKH:TbC51 eoBceM HHa'Ie. Bbrpa60TaB TIIIIOTe3y OTHOCH:TeAbHO B03MO/K" HOCTH rrpo6oK Ha AOporax :a rrpoBepH:B ee rrpoCThlM enoco6oM, Bhl eMorAH: 6hl Haifrn 6oAee rrpHeMAeMoe perneHHe OTHOCH:TeAbHO BlfAa TJ>aHCnOpTa H B pe3yAhTaTe IIpOBecrH 6oAhllle BpeMeHH: e 6a6yrnKo:H:. Barna TIIIIOTe3a MorAa 3ByqaTh TaK: «B03MOJKHO, Mfle CTOH:T noexaTb He aBT06yeoM, a 3AeK-rpH'IKOH, noeKoAbi<Y

ABJVKeHHe Ha AOporax 6yAeT 3a-rpyAHeHo». 1\.or:aqecKH:M o6oeHoBaHH:eM 3TOH TIIIIOTe3hl MOrAO 6hi nOCAYJKH:Tb CAeAJ!Oru;ee: «A,BH:JKeHHe Ha AOporax MOJKeT 6hlTb 3a-rpyAHeHo, nocKOAhKY OTKphiTa TJ>aAH:D;HOHHaJI pacrrpOAaJKa noCAe AH51 6Nlf'O~peHH51». K eqaCTbro, B 3To:H: e:aryau;HH ~ecrnyer 6b!CfPhrH :a 3<P<t>eKTHBHhm cnoeo6 rrpoBepH:Th HCTHHHOCTb I1fllOTe3hi. f¥Ji 3TOI'O AOCTaTO'IHO IIpOCTO BKJUO'IH:Th TeAeBH:30p Wlli pC!AHO :a rrpoCAyrrraTh eBOAKY o CH:TYau;HH Ha AOporax. MoJKeTe e~e no3BOHH:Th eBoe:H: noAPyre, KOTOpaJI B'Iepa roBOpH:Aa, 'ITO KaK pa3 B 3TO BpeM51 ORa 6yAeT Ha aBT06yee A061ipaTbC51 AO CTC!AHOHa, 'IT06hl noeMo-rpeTh <t>yr60AhHhrH MaT'!, 11 pacerrpocHTh ee, Her AH Ha AOporax rrpo6oK. TioAytrnB OT Hee AOnOAiniTe.l\bH)'IO HH<!>OpMau;mo, MOJKeTe rrp11IDITb KBaAI1<!>11D;HpOBaHHOe OKOH'IaTeAbHOe perneHH:e. HaBepHHKa MOJKHO IIpOAeAaTh BeiO 3TY rrpou;~ypy eaMbiM ecrecrneHHhiM rryreM, He BAaBaJieh B rAy6oKH:e pa3MbiiiiAeH1151. BeAb Bhl YJKe YMeeTe MacrepcKH BbfABHraTh rnIIOTe3hl, He TaK AH? A 6oAbrne B AaHHOM CAyqae HH:'Iero 11 He -rpe6yeTCH.

A Teneph caMoe BpeMH BepHYTheH K Harne:H: KpaeHOH I.IlA51nKe :a ee APY3hHM. EaKAaJKaH H To<t>y-CoeBhiH TBopor BhfABHHYAH rl1nOTe3y OTHOei1TeAhHO np06AeMbi IIOeeru;aeMOCTH:: KOpeHh npo6AeMhl eOCTOI1T B HeOCBeAOMAeHHOCTH:. l\roAJ1 He npHXOAHT Ha KOHD;epTbi npe)l(Ae Beero nOTOMY, 'ITO OHI1 nOHHTI1H He 11MeiOT 06 11X cyru;eeTBOBaHI111. AaBa:H:Te BMecTe nocAeAyeM :ax AOr11Ke li paeeMOTp11M pHeYHOK (C. 52). EaKAaJKaH :a To<t>y eqmaroT, 'ITO oeBeAoMAeHHOCTh o KOHIJ;epTax HH:3Ka51, nOTOMY 'ITO OHI1 He O'IeHh-TO c-rpeMHAHeb pae-rpy611Th 0 HHX Ha BeCh M11p. 06 3TOM rOBOPHT Tocpy: «Mhr paecKa3aAH: 0 KOHr:r;epTax TOAhKO HeCK01\.hKJ1M pe6HTaM, KOTOphre eH:AHT B KAacee HeAaAeKO OT Harne:H: napThr, a MyxoMop KpacHaH Il.IMinKa, CKopee Bcero, B006~e HHKOMY HJ1'Iero He rOBOpHAa. 0Ha XOTb 11 CTpoliT 113 ce6H Ha'IaAbHI1I.J;Y, Ha CaMOM AeAe O'IeHh CTeCHHTeAhHaH» . CorAacHo HX rnnoTe3e, o KoHu;epTe xoTb 'i'rO-H:a6yAh CAbiiiiaA BeerO AH:IIIh OAJ1H IIIKOAbHHK 113 AB~aTH: (oKoAo 5%) . 51

1-4 I

~: 1111

pyrHMR eAOSaMH, see .l\.lOAH, IIOeMOTpesi.IIHe rrepsoe

~oy, rrpHXOA51T Ha KOH~epThl eHOSa H eHOSa .

YYEH~K~ ~ YYI1TEI1R

(500)

•

V ·

AA 5%

\ i

...J OH~ (25) OH~ KOrAA- (15) OCBE):lOMJlEHbl 0 ~ H~6YAb 6biBAI1~ KOHl\EPTAX?. HAKOHl\EPTAX?

lf.c':r 95% (475)

AA 60%

nOCEU1AIOT KOHl\EPTbl nOCTORHHO?

lf£'r 40% (10)

(15)

lf£'r 0%

QHH rrhiTaiOTe51 seiiOMHIITb, H3 KOrO eoeT051Aa TOAIIa Ha noCAeAHHX TPex KOH~epTax. B erropT3a.Ae 6hlAo TeMHosaTO, Aa n eaMH OHH 6hlAH CAHIIIKOM rrorpYJKeHhl s MY3Hu11poBaHHe, "tJT06hi 3aiiOMHIITh, KTO 6hlA epeAH 3pHTeAeH. «AJMaiOr S 3pHTeAbHOM 3a.Ae 6hlAH see speMH OAHH H Te )Ke AH~a, - e"tJHTaeT To<t>y. - J1rpaeM Mhl HeiiAOXO, II03TOMY 100% .l\.lOAeH S03Sp~aiOTe51 K HaM Ha KOH~epThl», PaeeyJKAaH TaKHM o6pa3oM, OHH rrpHXOAHT K shlBOAY· qTO eaMaH 6oAbiiiaH rrpo6AeMa - 3TO oeseAOMAeaaoeTh. EeAH 3Ta rHIIOTe3a HeTHHH3, TO HM eAeAyeT cocpeAOTO"liHThe51 Ha TOM, "liT06hi HaRTH erroeo6 yseAHtiHTb oeBeAoMAeHHOeTh rry6AHKH. Aasa:HTe rrposepHM,

(3)

npaBhl AH OHH.

11101\11, KOTOPbiE HE OCBE)10MI1EHbl OKOHl\EPTAX

(])

,..~· ··---

11101\11, KOTOPbiE OCBE):lOMilEHbl 0 \ KOHl\EPTAX, HO I \ti~ PPJ'/ HA HI1X HE

111011~. KOTOPbiE

OAH~bl nOCETI111~ WOY ~ nPEKPAT~I1~XOA11Tb

\ ......................___ .......

-----

( HECKOI1~MO.QI{)KilACCH~-HAW~M ) COCF.QIIM no llAI'lt;3HAYI1T, 0 HAWI1X K0Hl\EPTAX3HAIOTHEMH001E• . / \

...............

1 c,.. OI1?£~Jl~'r£, K.AKOtl Al:l.AJ1~3 ~ KA.K.AS ~l:ftO?M.AL{~$Il:{£0~0,lU'\MDl ,ll.Jl$1 I1?08£?K~ l'~I1D'r£3bl

HA KOHl\EPTbl

, «Mbl C006U1Wl11 0 KOHl\EPTAX BCErO 1111Wb \

___.

Aa.Aee, no HX o~eHKaM, H3 Tex .l\.lOAe:H, KOTOphle 3HaroT o KOH~epTax, Ha MeporrpmiTHe, CKopee scero, HsMieTCS OKOAO 60%. B OCHOSe 3TOrO pac"tJeTa AeJKHT rrpeAIIOAO• JKeHHe Harrmx APY3e:H o TOM, "liTO OKOAO 60% y-qeHHKOS Hx IIIKOAe AeHCTBHTeAbHO .I\10651T poK-MY3hlKy, a BaKAa· JKaH rosopHT: «EcAH Thi .I\106HIIIh poK H SApyr Y3Haelllb, "liTO S IIIKOAe COCTOHTe51 KOH~epT, Thl IIplfAei.IIh S .I\1060!'d eAy-qae. 5I 6hl, IIO KpaHHeH Mepe, TO"lJHO IIpHI.IIeA! » 52

uaKOHe~, OHH IIOAaraiOT, "liTO IIOKa3aTeAb IIOSTOp-

JIOf~ rrpHXOAa 3pHTeAeH Ha KOH~epT eoeTasMieT 100%;

..............1!!.~~.!~!.~~~~!..~~;:~.--../

/~Ecn~ OH~-JHA~T o KOH~EPTAX.\ { ~ 11106RT POK, OH~. CKOPEE BCErO, ) \ nP~YT HA WOY. 6bi0Cb 06 3AKI1AI\, \ YTO OK0110 60% YYEH~KOB HAWEH

l1TaK, BaKAaJKaH H CoeshlH Tsopor seTaAH rrepeA Heo6xOAHMOeThiO rrposepHTh esoiO rHIIOTe3y. AMI 3TOro HM IIOH3A06HTC51 rrposeeTH He60Abi.IIOe HCeAeAOSaHHe. l1MeHHO Ha 3TOM 3Taiie pei.IIeHH51 rrpo6AeMhl Ha rrepBOe MeeTO ShlXOA51T e6op HH<t>OpMa~HH H aHaAH3. J1H¢opMa~RIO eo6HpaiOT He PaAH eaMoH HH<t>opMa~HH, a iillaJU13 rrposOAHT He PaAH: 3a6ashl. 3TH I.IIarH Heo6xoAHMhl M5J. IIpHH51TH51 OIITHMaAbHOfO peiiieHH51. l1TaK, KaKo:H JKe aHaAH3 AOAJKHhl rrposeeTH BaKAaJi\iUI R To<t>y? 11 KaKaH HH<t>opMa~HH HM HYJKHa AMI npoBeAeHHH aHaAH3a?

AHanH3 N~ 1. KaKoe Kon111~ecrso niOAe~ OTHOCII1TCR K Ka>KAO~ KareropHI-1 no creneHI-1 ocBeAOMneHHOCTI-1?

E~e pa3 rroeMoTpHTe Ha rpa<t>HK rHrroTe3hi BaKAaJKaHa li

ocpy, Y"tJeHHKOS IIIKOAhl, S KOTOpOH y-qaTe51 y-qaeTHH53

~· q' 1QI 0• PI• ~.

,Ill }il

<• a• ~· PI• ~· O•

~·

~· ~:

KH rpyrrrrhl «Aro6oBh H MyxoMopbi», MOJKHO

11uApa.1

AellliTh Ha qeThipe rpyrrrrhi: ( 1) HHqero He 3HaiOIIIuA KOHIJ;epTax; u;epT;

(3)

(2)

3HdlOIIJ;He, HO He IIpHXONJIIJ;He Ha

IIOCeTHBIIIHe XOT51 6bl OAHH KOHIJ;epT;

peryMipHO IIOCeiiJ;dlOIIJ;He KOHIJ;epThl. KaK Mhl BHM, CKO.I\hKO JUOAefl IIOIIdAeT B KaJKAbiH H3 BcTpeqaThC51 c KdJKAhiM H3

500 IIIKO.I\hHHKOB H

paLLU U.

3TO AOMo H HYAHO. AaJKe ecllli

K orrpocy

MyxoMop, pa3AellliTh <PpoHT pa6oT

BCeMH TpeM51 yqaCTHHKdMH rpyrriihl H OIIpdiiiHBdTb OAHOMy yqeHHKy B AeHh, 3Ta rrpou;eAypa 3dHMeT IIOMOAa

(167

bl rpaHA1f03HOe H3yqeHHe 06IIJ;eCTBeHHOrO MHeHH51,

accnpaiiiHBd51 AHqHO KdJKAOfO yqeHHKa 0 TOM Ad 0

~eM. HoB 3TOM, rroJKaAyH,

ReT ocTpo:H: Heo6xoAHMOCTH.

npoHHTepBhiOHpoBaB XOT51 6bl II51Th qeAOBeK, OHH rro-

IIIHBdTh BCeX 110 oqepeAJi, K KdKOH rpyrrrre OHH C5ITC51 -

HaiOT o HeM. Ecllli 6bl y HaiiiHX APY3eli 6hiAO MHoro 3 :peMeHH H pecypcoB, TO Tocpy H CHHeHhKHH rrpoBellli

AHefl:). TaK qTo JKe AeAaTh?

1\.yqaT 6oAee-MeHee qeTKOe rrpeACTdBAeHHe 0 fAdBHhiX

np~HHax . .l1TaK, CoeBhiH TBopor H EaKAaJKaH peiiiaiOT norrpOCHTh yqHTeAeH Ha6pocaTh KpaTKHH CIIHCOK yqeHHKOB, KOTOpbie 3HaAH 0 KOHIJ;epTe, HO peiiiHJlli TYAd He XOAifTh.

Y 3THX JUOAeH MOJKHO

6yAeT BIIOCAeACTBHH

s 35ITb HHTepBhlO.

TipoBeNJ M03rOBOH IIITYPM Ha TeMy «KaK AUUb111 lfYJKHyiO HH<PopMan;HIO», EaKAaJKaH H To<Py pema• COCTdBHTh BOIIpOCHHK H IIOIIpOCHTh yqHTeAefl: BeCTH dHKeTHpOBdHHe Ha KAdCCHOM qace, Ko~~ ~· IIpOBOAHTC51 B KaJKAOM KAacce B IIOHeAe.l\hHHK Bee, qTo Tpe6yeTC51 OT yqHTeMI, -

3TO 3dAdTh CB

KAaccy Bcero llliiiih TPH Borrpoca, H rrocqHTaTh,

tt-101 LfTO? nO'f[MY? rAE? KorAa?

KO yqeHHKOB IIOAHHMeT PYKY B OTBeT Ha KdJKAhiH rrpoc (H CdMH yqHTeMI TOJKe AOAJKHbi OTBeTHTh Ha Borrpocbi). HTaK, orrpoc yqHTeMIMH:

TIOAHHMHTe PYKY· KTO yJKe 3HaeT o eJKeMec5Iqm 4 KOHIJ;epTax rpyrriihl «Aro60Bh H MyxOMOphi»;

ECJlli Bhi 3HaAH o KoHu;epmx, IIOAHHMHTe PYKY Te, KTO YJKe ycrreA II06hiBdTh XOT51 6bl Ha OAHOM H3

Ecllli Bbl yJKe II06hiBaAH Ha KOHIJ;epTe «Aro6BH H MyxoMopoB», IIOAHHMHTe PYKY Te, KTo XOAifT Ha 3TH KOHIJ;epThl peryMipHO.

TaKa51 aHKeTa rrpocTa H 3<PcpeKTHBHa. Ha TO, 3dAdTh 3TH TpH BOIIpoca, yqHTeMIM IIOTpe6yeTC51 He Aee Tpex MHHYT.

AHam13 N~ 2. no~eMy HeKOTOpble niOAI.'I, 3HaH, ~TO 6yAeT KOH~epr, BCe paBHO He npi.'IXOAHT?

AHaJWI3 N~ 3. no~eMy HeKOTOpble niOAI.'I HeperynHpHO XOAHT Ha kOH~epTbl? 4TO HaAO CAenaTb, LfT06bl B 6yAyi.J.4eM OHI.'I 0 PHXOAI.1n1.1 perynHpHO? OnpocHB rrop.5IAKa II5ITH qeAoBeK, EaKAaJKaH H To<Py cMo-

ryr IIOAyqHTb 6oAee-MeHee qeTKJiH OTBeT Ha 3TH BOIIpOCbi.

3aTeM EaKAaJKaH H To<Py AOAJKHhi ycTaHOBHTh,

0 l-IR PelllaroT

My HeKOTOphle .IUOAif He IIpHXONJT Ha KOHIJ;epT,

l'e.>u,Hhie H OTpHIJ;dTe.l\hHhie CTOpOHhl CBOHX KOHIJ;epTOB.

norrpocHTh yqeHHKOB YKa3aTh Ha IIOAOJKH-

1-1

OHM H(lAeiOTeH rroA~HTh

~eHHhle

IIOAeKa3KH

..,

e'leT Toro, 'ITO HYJKHO eAeAaTh, 'IT06hi AIOAH B

BHOBh H BHOBh IIpHXOAHAH Ha HX

11M

BeeTHO, 'ITO YAepJKaTb IIOeTOHHHhiX IIOKAOHHHKOB pa3AO rrpo~e, 'leM HaRTH HOBhiX. TioMHHTe, CoeBhiH Tsopor H CHHeHhKHH

AH rHIIOTe3y, 'ITO eeAH

K HHM Ha rnoy,

KOH~epThl.

Ho :noro

D.DtAJjnr•

YJK tieAoBeK OAHaJKAhi OH 6yAeT B03Bpa~aTheH BHOBh H

n nuub•

e~e HHKTO He AOKa3aA. APY3hH pernaiOT

'!HeARTh Beex, KTO rrpeKpaTHA XOAifTh Ha

BhiHeHHTh y HHX rrpH'IHHy. EyAeM H(lAeHTheH, 'ITO

KOH~epTbl,

Ha~aTeH rrpespa~aTh

OAHopa30BhiX rroeeTHTeAeli eBOHX IIAaMeHHhiX cpaHaTOB. l.JaeTO AIOAif BII(lAaiOT B KpaHHOeTh,

QJOpMa~HIO

eo6Hpa51

H IIpOBOAH aHaAH3 IIpOeTO IIOTOMy, 'ITO

IIOAOJKeHO. TIOMHHTe: ~eAb AI06oro HeeAeAOBaHHH eTOHT B TOM, 'IT06bi IIOMO'lh HaM IIpHHHTh perneHHe. CTapaliTeeh eo6HpaTh H aHaAH3HposaTh

a M Heo6XOAifMhle AeHeTBHH MAR AaHHhle, KOTOphle Hhl AA5£ TOrO, 'IT06hl AH60 AOKa3aTh, AH60 OIIpOBep-

ax!b rHIIOTe3hl. CoeTaBHB TaKoli IIAaH rrepeA HatiaAOM fr>J-

Aef!CTBMM, Bhl pe3KO IIOBhleHTe eBOIO rrpOH3BOAHTeAh· aocTh B AeAe perneHHH rrpo6AeMhi. K TOMY JKe, 3arrHeas IIAaH Ha 6yMare, Bhl He TOAhKO B rpyrrrre, 3TOT IIAaH IIOMOJKeT BaiiieH KOMaHAe ecpoKyCl'lpoBaTbeH Ha OeHOBHhiX 3(1Aa'lax H IIOe AyJKHT HeXOAllhiM :nyHKTOM AA5f KOAAeKTHBHOrO M03rOBOrO IIIrypMa.

Bhl

noAYlJMTe B03MOJKHoeTh eoepeAOTO'IHTheH HMeHHO

a a TOM, 'ITO saM AelieTBHTeAhHO Heo6xOAifMO 3HaTh

~JEJEJEJ~ KaKoe

6oflbW~HGBO

60M. 3TO IIOMOJKeT OIITHMaAbHO orpaHH'leHHoe speMH H peeypehl.

Karerop~~?

eaMhiM IIpOeThiM H 3QJQJeKTHBHhiM e rroco-':

l'll:f'G'r?~M£1:i'rA.?l'l~

.llJl.S ?.E:lll.E:l:il'\S n?OSJl.tM: r .tl:f'.t?A.Jlbl:f':OI~ MA.l:i ? .E:lll.tl:il'\S n ?OSJl.tM:OI EeAH HatiHeTe eo6HpaTh H aHaAH3HposaTh AaHHhle, He orrpeAeAHBIIIHeh rrepeA 3THM, OTBeT Ha KaKOH B OIIpOC Bhl H~eTe, TO IIpHHeeeTe ee6e 60Ahiiie BpeAa, 'leM IIO.I\b" 3hi. Bee KOH'IHTeH TeM, 'ITO Bhi YTOHHTe B rroToKe H36hl· TO'IHOH

HHQJOpMa~HH H, B KOH~e KOH~OB, IIOHMeTe, 'ITO

Bee Bailie HeeAeAOBaHHe 6biAO rryeTOH TpaTOH BpeMeHH· l.JT06hi H36eJKaTh 3TOH IIp06AeMhi, He06XOAHMO rrepeA Ha'laAOM e6opa HHQJOpMa~HH eoeTaBHTh reHepaAbHhlii IIAaH HeeAeAOBaHHH. B 3TOM reHepaAbHOM IIAaHe Bhl AOAJKHhl

rrepeqMC·

AHTh: BOIIpOehi, KOTOphle eo6HpaeTeeb peiiiHTh; saiiiH HeXOAHhle rHIIOTe3hl H HX 060eHOBaHHe; Bee BlfAhl aHa"

AA51

n p Mll51TM51 peiiieHHH .

flKJAeii He 3HaKJT KOfl~O niOAeii OTHOC~Cll 0 KOHijepTaX KKa)(Aoii

QJOpMa~HIO

n p o5ICHHTe csoH eo6eTBeHHhle MhleAH. EeAH pa6oTaeTe

JV1

Mbl coo6111~~ o KOHijeprax ecero

fl~Wb HeCKOflbK~M

HaW~M

COCeJISIM 00

AHan~3 Karerop~~.

AHKeT~poBaH~e

nonpocWb ~~eneii npoeecrn aHKernpoeaH~e

napre

nOI*MY HeKOTOpble fliOA~. 3HaR 0KOHijepTe, He np~XOI\RT?

noTOMYYTO OH~ eoo61J1e He flOORT poK-MY3biKY

8mb ~HTepBbiO KaKoii mo6~renb poKa He np~wen 6bl y mrr~ YenoeeK, Ha 6ecnnaTHoe way? Koropble 3Han~ o way,

6yAyrn~niO~

HoHenp~wn~

Ye~eewoy

6oflbW~HGBO

n~xo~Ha

XOTR 6bl pa3,

3p~enei1Ha

KOH~jepTbl CHOBa

OOflbW~HGBO

nocneAHeM way

83RTb ~HTepBbiO y mrn1 flKJAeii, nocernew~x KOHI.Iepr,

HCHOea?

fliOAeii CTaHyr np~XOAWb Ha KOHijepTbl CHOBa

6blfl~HaW~M~

~ no~HTepecoeaTbCR,

OOCTOSIHHbiM~

6yAyrn~oH~

~CHOBa

~HTepBbiO

npoAOroKaTb xo~ roro, Mbl nonHOCTbiO Ha HaW~ KOHijepTbl. yeepeHbl eHaweM 83RTb ~HTepBbiO y ~COOflH~eflbCKOM fliOAeii (ecn~ raK~e MaCTepcree, 003TOMY em). KOTOpble ayA~Op~R AOfllKHa nepecran~ XOAWb ~cnbiTbiBaTb nonHoe Ha KOHijepTbl, ~ YAOBneTBopeH~e BbiRCHWb y H~X <jlaHaraM~. KpoMe

np~~HY

~HTepBbiO

:3 ~

1 ~. n?OS.t,lll'l.'r.t AliA.Jl.M3

\ 00000 0 0

000

AHaiU13 N~1. KaKoe KOm<l~eCTBO niOAelil OTHOCIIITCH

K Ka>K,D,olil «Karerop111111 no creneHIII ocBeAOMneHHOCTIII))?

Y'lli'I'eMI eor.Melilllieb rrposecrn aHKeTifPOBairne M5f. JKa.Ha H T cxpy, H ,l¥lHH.bie 110./lli.Jllieb peKoif. Hai.l.lli APY3hll cyMMHPOBa.Ali Bee OTBeTbl ¥1 Bbiiiillli Ha TaKHe f1oTeHI.J;HaAbHble 110eeTH:Te.I\H KOHI.J;epTOB: 500 )"'eHHKOB ¥1 )"'HTeAeM •

Borrpoc NQ 1:

•

Borrpoc NQ2:

e 0TBerNQ2: •

Borrpoc NQ3:

e 0TBerNQ3:

Bhi )T)Ke 3Haere o KOHu;eprax rpyrrrrhl «J\ro6oBh H MyxoMophl»? Aa = 150 'IeAoBeK (30%) Her = 350 'IeAoBeK (70%) EcAH Bbl 3HaAH 0 KOHIJ;eprax rpyrrrrhl «J\ro6oBh H MyxoMophl», Bhl rrocerHAH XOrsr 6hl OAlfH KOHIJ;epr? Aa = 15 'IeAoBeK (10%) Her = 135 'IeAoBeK (90%) EcAH Bhl )T)Ke 6b1BaAH Hd KOHIJ;eprax rpyrrrrhl «J\ro6oBh H MyxoMophl», Bhl peryAHpHo rroceru;aere? Aa = 12'IeAoBeK (80%) Her = 3 'IeAoBeKa (20%)

11MeH Ha PYKax 3TH AaHHhle, Tocpy H EaKAaJKaH MO" ryT pae11peAe.I\HTh AIDAeif 110 eerMeHTaM:

1\roAlf, KOTOpble He OCBeAOMAeHbl 0 KOHu;eprax: 350 'IeAOBeK (7~ 1\roAlf, KOrOpble OCBeAOMAeHhl 0 KOHu;eprax, HO HH pa3y Hd HHX He 6hiBaAH: 135 '!eAOBeK (27%); C) 1\roAlf, KOrOpble OAHaJKAbl II06hiBaAH Ha KOHIJ;epre H rrpeKpaTHAH rroceru;arh moy: 3 'IeAOBeKa (1 %); 8 J\roAH, KOrOpble rroceru;aiOr KOHIJ;eprhl peryAHpHO: 12 '!eAOBeK (2%).

0 8

« H~eroce6e!Bcero10%?!

\ C3111MHilAO'flO·TOAefl3Tb!..• .,

e 0rBerNQ1:

,/""································-·····..\

~C'r.Al{OSM'r.t n?M'iMli~

\\ Y..et~~GI

~l"""eJljl

(500)

000

ooo-nuoooo••-·,\

«TbiCMOTpi-1,UlyxaM~J€MJl~ \

nonH~~! AR-TO AYMaJI, o

''-••••••·-T-''-.::::·.~oo•o••••-•••••••o, j

I•

«A~·TOAYMaJI, ' ·· YTO see 100% np~xo~ \ noeropHo-• j•

-.,. . . . .-;. ·-·---.... I '--; . . . . .-../ KOH~eprax JHam ecero 5% ... •

0 8b13HaeTe o KOH~eprax?

a IliO~,

!iblean~ H3 KOH~eprax?

ll{.t:-r 70%

ll{$:t 90% •

(350)

KOTopble

He OCBeAOMileHbl

(135)

4!)

AA BO% lliOA~ KOTOpble 12 OOCetJ¥1eTe ( ) OOC~IOT KOH~epTbl KOH~epTbl nocr~HHO? OOCT~HHO

AA 30% AA 10% <150> Sbi KOfA3·H~YAb (1 5 )

•

OKOH~eprax

ll;[$:t 20% (j IliOA~.

•

(3)

KOTOpble

OAH3~bl noc~~

woy ~ npeKpaOO~ H3 KOH~epTbl

XO~

oaKAaJKaH H Tocpy 110Aafa.I\H, qTO AIOA¥1 He XOAHT Ha KoHu;epTbi 11peJKAe seero 110TOMY, qTo 11poeTo He 3HaiOT 0 HHX, ¥1-qTo eTOHT TOAbKO seeX 0110BeeTHTb, KaK Ha KOHu;eprhl eTaHYT XOAH:Th OKOAO 60% AIDAeM (qeAOBeK 300). Ho, 03HaKOMHBIIIHeh e AaHHhiMH neeAeAOBaHHH, OHH 06HapyJKH.I\H, qTO 0 KOHu;epTax yJKe OeBeAOMAeHbl 30% AIOAeif, a BOBee He 5%, KaK OH¥1 11peA110Aara.I\H. 0Ka3biBaeTeSI, qTo AIOAH:, KOTOphlx EaKAaJKaH H Tocpy .1\HqHo IIpHr.ll.aeH.I\H Ha KOHI.J;epT, opraHH30BaB peKAaMY ¥13 yeT BYCTa, paeeKa3a.I\H 06 3TOM eBOHM 3HaKOMbiM ¥1 BMeeTe CHHMH 11pHIII.I\H Ha IIIOy. ~ APyro:H eTopoHhl, oHH AYMa.I\H, qTo 60% H3 Tex AIOAeH, KTO 3HaeT 0 KOHI.J;epTax, 11pHXOAHT Ha IIIOy, a OKa3dAOCb, qTo Ha eaMoM AeAe yposeHh 11oee:r.u;aeMoeTH Koau;epTOB - seero 10%! QqeHh MHOfHe 3Ha.I\H 0 KOH~epTax, HO He 11pHIII.I\H. 0TeiOAa eAeAyeT, qTO 11pOeTO~~ _UOBbillieHHH oeBeAOMAeHHOeTH )"'eHHKOB ¥1 )"!¥ITeR lliKO.II.bi 0 KOHu;epTax 6yAeT HeAOeTaToqHO AASI TOfO, ~o6h1 .ll.lOAH TOAIIOM 110Ba.I\H.I\H Ha IIIoy. EaKAaJKaH H ~<J>y pernH.I\H BbiSieHHTb, 110qeMY AIOA¥1 He JKeAaiOT XOTh Ha RX BhleTYIIAeHHSI. 59

~tor

B TO JKe BpeM51 OHR ymAH HeAaAeKO OT RCTRH

CBORX O~eHKax: OTHOCRTeAbHO KOAH'IeCTBa JUOAeif, TOphie, OAHaJKAbi nOCMOTpeB IIIOy, npRXOA5JT H a

~epThi BHOBh. B AeifcTBRTeAbHOCTR TaKnx JUOAeif

TOp hie JUOAR npeKpaTRJlli XOAifTb Ha

HaiOT 0 KOH'"'epTaX, He npHXOASIT Ha HHX? 3 Sa!<J\.aJKaH R Tocpy Bh151CHRllli, 'ITO MHorne JUOAif, KO-

rophre 3HaiOT 0 KOH~epTax:, npeAnO'IRTaiOT Ha HRX He oHli B35IAH RHTepBbiO y n51TH tieAOBeK, BXOA5J~RX B 3TY rpyTIIIY· OTseThi oKa3dllliCh oqeHh pa3HhiMR:

KOH~epTbi, If

Bbi51CHRTh, no KaKOH npR'IRHe OHR 3TO CAeAdllli. KaK BRAifTe, pe3yAbTaThi aHdllli3a RHOrAa pacxo Nft!.

e Y-ry, SI CAblillaA, 'ITO Bbl Aaere no KOH~epry KaJKAblH MeCSI~. Dot~eM)T He XOJKY? Hy, pe6SITa, SI He B Kypce, 'ITO 3a M)T3b1KY

C51 C nepBOHa'IdAbHOH rRnOTe30H. l..JTO 6b1 npOR30 11IAO,

M ~

Bbl TaM MCnOJ\HSieTe M B006~e, 'leCTHO fOBOpSI, He 3HaiO,

ecAH 6br EaKAaJKaH R Tocpy npRCTYflRllli K AeHCTBWDI,

HaCKOAhKO Bbl CaMM XOpOllM ...

RCXOA5J R3 CBOeH nepBOHa'IdAbHOH rRnOTe3hi, He IIpc)o BepRB ee RCTRHHOCTb? HasepHOe, OHR CTdllli 6b1 pa3o BeiiiRBaTb acpmrm R pa3AaBaTh cpAaepbr Ha scex

•

Pe6SITa, SI o sac HH'Iero He 3HaiO. XoAHJlli KaKHe-ro CAyxH o BarneR rpyrrne, HO SI TOAhKO CAblillaAa 3BOH, Aa He 3HaiO, fAe OH ...

yrAal

CBOeif IIIKOAhi, a B pe3yAbTaTe noce~aeMOCTb KOH~ep.

Bhl t~ero, cosceM peXHYAMCh? Bhl )Ke - MJW03ra! Kro 3TO

•

6yAeT rpaTHTh Ha sac AParo~eHHOe cy66oTHee speMSI? Aa

TOB nOBhiCRAaCh 6b1 Ha MRKpOCKOnR'!eCKYIO BeAR'IHHJ.

BCe C'IMTaiOT, 'ITO BaM e~e B neCO'IHM~e KOBblpSIThCSI, a He C

(IlOCKOAbKY KaK HR nOBbiiiiaif OCBeAOMAeHHOCTb, a Ill

KOH~epT npifAeT BCero Jllilllb

10%

2. no~eMy HeKOTOpble niOAH, KOTOpble

:x:oMfTb. qT06hi Bh151CHRTb, notieMY TaK npORCXOART,

80% no cpaBHeHRIO C nepBOHa'IdAbHOH 100%. Tenepb EaKAaJKaH R Tocpy 3HaiOT, 'ITO

3aJ\.0Cb Ko:H:

AHalllr'l3 N~

R3 JUOAeif, KOTOplie

3Hdllli 0 IIIOy). BoT noqeMY rRnOTe3hi BCerAa CAeAyf!l rrposep51Th, ecAH MOJKHO npifAYMdTh rrpocTo:H: R 3cp<f:leK· TRBHhiH cnoco6 3TO CAeAaTb. Ha cxeMe HRJKe noKa3aHhi pacxoJKAeHR51 MeJKAY nepsoHa'IdAbHOH rnnoTe3o:H: EaKAaJKaHa R Tocpy R p& 3YAbTaTaMR RX RCCAeAOBaHR51.

KOH~epTaMM BblCTyrraTh!

e 5I AeHcrBH'l'eAhHO XO'I'eA rrpHHrH, HO Bbl )Ke Bblcryrraere B cy66oTy B 12.00, a yMeHSI B 3TO BpeMSI KaK pa3 TpeHHpOBKa no 6eHC6oAy... <l>p3HK M MaRK He XOASJT Ha KO~eprbl no TOH )Ke rrpH'IHHe. e . A SI B006~e He MHTepecyiOCh M)T3b1KOH. 5I Aa)Ke AOMa ee He CAymaiO. C KaKOH paAOCTM MHe XOAHTh Ha BaillM KOH~epTbi? vb 3THX KOMMeHTapReB EaKAaJKaH If Tocpy 3aKAIO'IRllli, 'ITO C~eCTBYIOT Tplf OCHOBHbie npR'IRHhi, IIO KOTOphiM

AlOAH He XOA5JT Ha KOH~epThi «J\ro6BR If MyxoMOpOB».

KODVIYEOBO DIOAE~. OTBffi1BWVIX YTBEPAVITEnbHO

PeJynbralbl

r~noreJa

Bb1110Ab1

Bbi3HAffi 0 KOHl.lEPTAX?

Bbl Y)::E 6biBAAVI HAHAWVIX KOHl.lEPTAX?

e Bbl PEfYDRPHO XOAVITE HA HAWVI KOHl.lEPTbl?

60% (15)

--+

10% (15)

--+

0 KOHl.lEPTAX3HAET 60flbWE DIOAE~. YEM nPmnonArAAOCb DIOAE~. KOTOPbiE 3HAIOT 0 KOHl.lEPTAX. HO HE XOART HA HVIX. 3HAYVITEnbHO 60flbWE. YEM nPEAnODArAAOCb

e HEKOTOPbiE DIOAVI 100% (15)

:__..

80%

(12)

nPEKPAWVI XOAVITb HA KOHl.lEPTbl

OHM He 3HaiOT, KaKyiO M)T3b1KY Mbl MCnOJ\HSieM M 'ITO Mbl C060H npeACTaBASieM KaK M)T3blKaHTbl.

e e

KOH~epTOB He BnMCblBaeTCSI B HX rpacpMK. B006~e He MHTepeCyiOTCSI M)T3hiKOH.

BpeMSI OHM

«KaK HHTepecHol -

- HaM

BOCI<MiKHYA Tocpy-CoeBhlli TBopor.

Bp5JA AH YN1CTC51 3dMaHRTh Ha IIIOY JUOAeif, KOTO-

Phie Boo6~e He H:HTepecyiDTC51 M)13hiKOH. Ho M51 rex, KTO K HaM He IIpRXOAifT, IIOTOMY qro He 3HaeT, Km<ylO

MY3biKY Mhi

lirpaeM If KTO Mh1 TaKRe, a TaKJKe M51 rex, KOMY He IIOAXOAHT

BpeM51 KO~epros, Mh1 OIIpeAeAeHHO MOJKeM 'ITO-HR6YAb CA.eJ\a.Th!»

l1 rorf:¥1

CH:HeHbKR:H: R Tocpy orrpocRAH e~e Ae-

~.., ~

2 ~

~ El ~

C5lTh IIIKOAhllliKOB. 0Irn Bbi5ICHIDlli, tiT() 3pHTel\.eH 6hl.J\.o ropa3Ao 6o.IUillle, eCJlli Ko~epThi rrepeHecrn Ha cy66orJni Betiep. «Ypa! - o6pc3AOBaJ\.CH Eal<J\aJKaH. - Y Hac HatnfHa4 t!T()-TO rroAyqaThC5I!» B Ayrnax Ha.rrrnx APY3e:H 3a6pe3JKRJ Hc3AeJKA(l HaAyqmee, IIOTOMy-tlT() Terreph OHH HMeiOT 6oAee tieTKoe IIpeAcraBAeirne o rrpwnrn:e cBoe:H rrpo6AeMI.L

~e OT3b!Bhl HeiiOCPeACTBeHHO H3 ycr CBOHX Q:>aHaTOB.

f1o:xB<Wl BCerM KaK 6aAh3aM Ha f>Yill.Y, a BOT BbiCAyrriHBaTh

!<Plfl1U<Y He BCerM IIpHHTHO. Ho M5f. CaMOCOBeprneHCTBOBaf{WI oNfr!aKOBO BIDKHO HTO, HAPyroe. KIDKeTOI, HaiiiHAPY3DH aatfifliaiOT MbiCAHTh, KaK IIpOcpecCHOHa.AbHble M)l3biKaHThl.

J1TaK, OCHOBHaH HHcpOpMacyrn, KOTOpYJO Olill IIOAyq:HAH 3 l:f}fl'epBblO: IIOCeTIITeAH KO~epTOB HatiHHaiOT CJCY'IaTh fi MOryT B006:w;e rrpeKpaTHTh XOAHTI> Ha rnoy, eCJlli rpyrrrra 6yAf!f H AaAbiiie HCIIOAHHTh OAHH H Te JKe rreCirn. 3areM Bal<AaJK.aH H Tocpy orrpocHAH TpeX tieAOBeK, KOTOpbie npeKpaTH.Illi XOAHTb Ha KO~epThi. 0Irn CIIpOCHAH HX, notJeMJTe OOAbllie He II051BA5Il0TC51 Ha KO~epTaX. VI BCe TPH B ONffi I'OAOC OTBeTHAH: «/¥1 IIOTOMy-tlT() Bhl, pe65ITa, BCe BpeMH rrOeTe OAHH H re JKe rrecHH B OAJ:IOH H TOR JKe apaH)KHpoBKe, BOTH Hc3AOeAO». Terrepb Bee HCHO, KaKAeHD: rnoyHc3AO MeHHTb. Hc3AO BHecrn cBeJKYIO CTPYIO B CBOH BhlcryiiAeHHH. IlyreM c6opa H aHaAH3a HHcpopM~HH CoeB:w:if TBopor H CHHeHDKiiH orrpoBeprAH co6cTBeHHhle rHIIOTe3hl H rroAYtJHAH ropa3AO 6oAee tieTKoe rrpeACTaBAeirne o rrpHtiHHe IIAoxo:H: rroce:w;aeMocTH Ko~epToB. Ce:tl'!ac OHH pKe Ha OAHH rnar rrpH6AH3HAHCb K CB0eH f.\eJ\H ,..-- CAeAaTh MyxoMop cqacrAHBOH, opraHH30BaB 6HTKOM Ha6HTblli CIIOpTiiBH:w:if 3aA B AeHh KO~epTa. VI CaMH OHH /KAyr He AOJKAyrcH TOI'O qaca, KOfAa Bblcryii5IT rrepeA TOAIIOH CBOHX IIOKAOHHHKOB. A e:w;e Olill TBepAO IIOBepHAH B TO, liTO OAHaJKADI HacrynHT TOT AeHb, KOfM OHH Ae6IOTHpylOT B KatieCTBe rrpocpeCCHOHaAbHOH pOK-rpyrrrrDI.

AHamtl3 N~ 3. no'feMy HeKOTOpble niOAIII HeperynHpHO XOAHT Ha KOH1,4epTbl? 6YAYT n111 OHIII perynHpHo npiiiXOAIIITb B 6yAyU4eM?

CAeAyro:w;ee mrrepBhlO CoeB:w:if TBopor H CHHeHbKH:H Qe. pyr e:w;e yn:srrn l!eAOBeK. 0Irn HaMepeHbl Bbl5ICHH'I'b, IIOtieMy HeKOTOphle .IUOAH rrpeKpa:w;aiOT XOAHTI> Ha KO~epThi H cy• :w;eCTByeT Ali OIIaCHOCI'b, 'ITO rpyrrrra H B Aa.AbHe:funeM 6yN!f TepHTh CBOHX cpaHaTOB. BOT KaKHe OTBeTbi 6b!AH IIOAyqeHI.L •

•

Pe6.srra, H :sac o6oJKaiO! /zyM.aJO, 'ITO Bhl CKopo craHere Hacro~eif IIJXXPecCHOHaAhl:IOH rpynnoif! J1 5I 6yAY x:aacra'I'hCH BCeM, 'ITO 6m Ha Ba.IIIeM nepooM rnoy! KoHelffio, H 6yAYXOAJITb Ha Bee BaiiiH KO~e.(YI'bl AO OAHOI'O! Y KpaCHoif Il..IMnooi TaKoif AYIDeBHhlH I'OAOC c xpHII<JI'Qoii! 5I NfJKe BCIIAaKHyM, KOfAiJ. OHa IIeM. 6a.Miwf... 5I BCerACJ.6YAY IIpHXOAHfb Ha

Ko~eprbr!

• /zyM.aJO, 6oAhlill!Hcrno J\IOAeif 6hlh.H npH.srrHo YAHBAeHhl, KOrACJ.

•

yCAhlllicwr, KaKHe Bbr KMCCHhle HCIIOJ\HH'l'ei\H. Ho, pe6.srra, Bhl JKe Hil BCex 1pex KOiru;eprax IleAH OAHH HTe JKe IIeCHH. ECMI Bhl HNW>llie 6yAere IIpoAO.I\JKaTh HCIIO.I\IDITh Bee BpeMH OAHO HTO JKe, ny6AHKe 3TO HalffieT Hi!AOEWl'fb. .. 'Sar<MJKaH, H IIpOCTO 6e3 YMa arTBOero coAo Ha rnrape! AH-TO AYMM. 'ITO Thi TOAbKo HYMeelllb, 'ITO IIOAhli'phlBaTh KpaCHoif l.IJMmr<e... KaKoif CIOpnpH3! MoJKer 6biTb, y MeiDIHe KaJKAbi1i pa3 6yAeT IIOA)"'a'I'hCH XOAJITb Ha BalliH KO~e.(YI'bl, HO 51 IIocrapa!OCb HX He nponyCI<an,!

Al0608b \A

MYXOAOPb\

Barna My3biKa MHe O'IeHb HpaBifiOI, HO MHe H(lAoeAO KaJKAbiii pa3 CAyman, OAHH HTe JKe IIeCHH. f1y6hm<a.ACWKHa CI'OHTh Ha yrnax, eH XO'IeTCH KaJKAbiii pa3 CAhllliaTh lfl'O-TO HOBeHbKoe. A y Ba.C CAOBHO IIMCTHHKy 3aeAO - BaM caMHM-TO ~e He CKy'IHO IleTh OAHO HTO JKe? KIDKeTOI, o6I.I.J;HH ypoBeHb YAOBAeTBOpeHHocrn AocrarotJ· HO BbiCOK. Eal<J\aJKaH H Tocpy 6biAH CtiaCTAHBbi yCAbiiiiaTb 00"

s ~

PA3PA60TKA PEWEHlllSI

rpynm;

<flio6oBb H

4 A. ?A3?A.SO'r.AW;t.e KAK MO~lfO SOJlhlli.e ?A3Jl~tfilbl~ SA?~l{-rOS ?.elli.elf~S n?OSJl.eMDI

. 1

MyxoMop KpacHa~ Wri~nKa

)"laCTl1HKH

•.

6aKJlalKilH (HHeHbKHH

MyXOMOpbl»

oaKJlalKaH -t)I'*!HHKH

CHHeHbKH~

Y"HTeJl~

IOAH: -{

WKOJl<l

APYfl1e

-{APYf\1e

lpHTellH -{

APYfl1e

__I' lpHTellH

HAPYfl1e ~ COTpYAHHKH

APYf

naKAaJKaH H To<Py Terrepb rrpeKpaCHO IIOHHMaiOT, B

~ ~

APyrne

qeM 3aKAIOqaiOTC5I OCHOBHhle IIpHqHHhl H X IIp06J\e)( ~bHble

Ho eCJ\H OHH Ha 3TOM OCTaHOB5ITC5I , TO BeCh HX T5IJKKHA IIHTh K pa3pa60TKe perneHHH.

~ --f raJelbl

TiocJ\e rrpoBeAeHHH orrpoca H aHaJ\H3a HarnH APY3bl

IIOHHJ\H, qTO HM CJ\eAyeT He IIpOCTO C006ID;HTh J\IOA5IM 0

onbHble yrne

6yMalKHble

lKYpHilllbl

HOCHTeJlH:

11QYTa

alj>HWH

APYroe

¢naepb1

KOHD;epTe, HO H CAeJ\aTh TaK, qT06hl J\IOA5IM 3axOTeJ\OC]) rroifTH Ha 3TOT KoHu;epT. 11TaK, BaKAaJKaH H To<Py c03AaiOT J\OrHqecKoe

peri10HilllbHble

TPYA rrofiAeT HacMapKy. Terreph caMoe BpeMH rrpHcTY-

APYroe

Ae-

~WKOnbHa~

peBo, qTo6hl orrpeAeJ\HTh B03MOJKHhle rryTH, KaK coo6-

AOCKH

OOb~BneHH~:

rn;HTh o cBoeM rnoy. Cyrn;ecTByeT M HOJKeCTBO cpeACTB KOMMYHHKau;HH, BI<AIOqaH ra3eThl H JKypHaJ\hl, A OCKH

KnacCHbi€.

APYfl1e

06'b51BJ\eHHH H 3.1\eKTpOHHYIO rroqry, 3TH cpeACTBa MQryT OKa3aThC51 ropa3AO 3cpqJeKTHBHee, qeM rrpeJKHHH

TelleBHAeHHe:

crroco6, KOrAa BaKAaJKaH H To<Py J\HqHo yseAOMJ\51J\H o rnoy Bcex H KaJKAOro . Tio3TOMY 3aAaqa pe6HT cmpaTb· cH rrp:HAyMaTh KaK MOJKHO 6oJ\hrne HAeM: H 3arrHcaTh HX Bee .

Cnoco6 KOMMyHHKa~H

perHOHanbHoe APyroe

Ha~OHilllbHoe

pa3MhlillJ\eHHH no rroBOAY ocyrn;ecTBHMOCTH

3 THX lfAeH H 06 HX B03MOJKHhlX IIOCJ\eACTBHHX OHH

-t

Ha~bHoe

'aAHO:

OCTaBJ\5IIOT Ha IIOTOM. Ha 3TOH CTaAlfH Ba.JKHO He 3 apy· 6HTh B03HHKrnyiO lfAeiO Ha KOpHIO: «PaAlfO? fa3eTbl?

perHOHilllbHoe WKOnbHoe APYroe

3To HepeaJ\hHO! » AaJKe ecJ\H HeKOTOphle lfAeH rroHaqa·

-t

J\y KaJKyTCH 6peAOBhlMH, Ha AeJ\e OHH MOryT rrpHBeCTH

K oqeHh HHTepeCHhlM TBOpqeCKHM perneHHHM. fAaBHoe rrpaB:H./\.0 Ha 3TOM 3Tarre -

CTaLIHOHapHble nHHHH

Tene¢oti:

3aiiHCaTb KaK MOJKHO 60.1\.1>"

me HAeM:, a rrpHopHTeThl paccTaBHTh rro3JKe .

<!laKe

M06HnbHble APYrne

TioC.I\.e TOfO KaK naK.l\.aJKaH H To<!Jy rrepeqHCJ\.H.l\.H BCe MhlC.l\.HMhle H HeMhiC.l\.HMbie lfAeH, Ha CBOeM

.1\.0~ecKOM

pecHhle crroco6hl KOMMYHHKau;HH

(eM.

66).

KoMnaKT-AHCKH

:mrre"

AepeBe OHH BhlAe.l\.5IIOT MapKepOM IIOTeHD;Ha.l\.bHO

TioC.I\.e 3TOro

~3~Ha~ 11QYTa 11HTepHeT

IIpHcryiialOT K :HHTeHCHBHOMY o6CYJKAeH:HlO, KaK ./\.yqwe }I 3 qJqJeKTHBHee HCIIOJ\h30BaTb 3ailliCaHHhle KaHa.l\.hl,

qro6bl

ee6-ca_~

APYfDe Apyroe

IIpHB.l\.eqb Ha KOHu;epThl KaK M OJKHO 60J\hille J\IOAeH.

65 64

06CYJKAa5I KaJKAYJO B03MOJKHOCTh B OTAt:.lll>l:iU( o6a HCXONIT H3 TOfO, 'ITO HX 3C1Aa'la -

He TOAbKO

YBe:.

.MI'IHTh OCBeAOMAeHHOCTh rry6.MIKH, HO H Bhl3BaTb B .1\l()o. NIX JKeAaHHe IIpHMTH Ha KOHu;epT. HarrpHMep, e cAH: no

~ ,.Q

~ s li!

~ ~

IIIKOAbHOMY PCiAHO OHH rrpOCTO coo6ru;aT Aa-ry, B peMH: I MeCTO rrpoBeAeHHH KOHIJ;epTa, TO A06biOTCH TOAhKO noBbiiiieHHH ypoBHH ocBeAoMAeHHOCTH.

ec.MI BA06aBo1

OHH rrepeAaAyr no PCiAHO CBOIO rrecHIO, AIOAH ycAhnuar, KaKoro IIAaHa MY3hiKY HCIIOAHHeT «Alo60Bh H M yxoMa-

PA3BECI1Tb C006U1EHI1H 0 KOHUEPTE HAAOCKAX 06bHBnEH11H BKM<,QOM KAACCE

6AOCKA • 06bHBfiEHI111

nonPOCI1Tb BEAYU1ErO WKOfibHOrO PAAI10 noaABI1Tb B3$11P nECHIO •fi106BI111 MYXOMOPOB» 11 06bHBI1Tb, rAE 11 KOrAA COG011TCH 11X KOHUEPT

JWKOfibHOE PM~O

3Ani1CATb KOMnAKT·AI1CKI1, CAEilATb HA HI1X nOMETKY 0 BPEMEHI111 MEGE nPOBEAEHI1H CfiEAYIOU1HO KOHL\EPTA 11 PA3AATb YYEHI1KAM

8 KOMnAKT· A~CK

pA30CfiATb no 3fiEKTPOHHOH nOYTE C006U1EHI1H C11HOOPMAL\11EH 0 KOHUEPTE BCEM YYEHI1KAM 11 YY11TEilHM WKOfibl

3f(KllQlHAA

phi», 'ITO MY3hiKa rpyrrrrhl Be.MIKoAerrHa. 3To HaBepwr.

rK}l!A

Ka YBe.MI'!HT KO.MI'leCTBO Tex, KTO 3aHHTepecyeTcH: B

10 BE6·CA~T

C03AATb BE6·CAHT, CKOTOPOrO MO:tHOCKAYATb nECHI1 rPYnnbl, PA3MEGI1Tb HA HEM 6110rPA$1111 YYAGHI1KOB rPYnnbll1 HOBOGHYIO fiEHTY 0 nPEAGOHU111X MEPOnPI1HTI1HX

3dXO'!eT II06blBaTh Ha KOHIJ;epTe. HoBhiMH 3HaHHHMH, IIOAYtJeHHhiMH B XOAe aHaJ\H· 3a, CTOHT BOCIIOAb30BaThCH!

v v

v v•

ranOYK~, nOMe'leHHble BTa6n~~e JBeJ,AOYKO~ oOOJHi)'jaiOT OrpaHf.l;eHHYIO l¢<jleKrnBHOCTb.

ec.MI rrpOHfHOpHpOBd'I'II

HOBble CBeAeHHH, IIOAYtJeHHbie B pe3yAbTaTe OIIpoca B aHa.MI3a, TO MOJKHO CBeCTH Ha HeT BCIO IIpOAeAaHH}'IO pa6o-ry. f1o3TOMY BaKAaJKaH H Tocpy, IIOCTOHHHO YAepJKHBa5I B cpoKyce BHHMaHHH o6e yrroMHHYThie IJ;eJ\H, Bhi6HpaiOT

AAH

cBoeM AJICKyccHH OTAeAhHhle rrepe'IHB

KaHaAOB KOMMYHHKaiJ;HH.

0HH B3BeiiiHBaiOT K aJKAoe

AeMCTBHe Ha rrpeAMeT TOfO, a) rrpHBeAeT .MI OHO K IIOBhl·

OrrHpa5ICh Ha AaHHhre orrpoca, BaKAaJKaH H Tocpy A06aBRAH B CBOM CIIHCOK H3 AeCHTH rryHKTOB

4Y BbZUle)

IIIMAH rrepeHeCTH Ha II03JKe Ha'laAO KOHu;epTa, a TaKJKe

miMeTH.MI crroco6hl, KaK ocBeJKHTh MeporrpHHTHe. BoT KaKHe HAeH IIpHIII.MI HM B fOAOBy:

IIIeHHIO OCBeAOMAeHHOCTH 0 IIIOY H 6) Bhl30BeT .MI OHO B AIONIX JKeAaHHe Ha 3TO IIIOY rrpHMTH. f1peo6pa3yeM IIOAYtJeHHbie CBeAeHHH B Ta6.Miu;y:

(eM. ma6AU-

eru;e TpH AOIIOAHHTeAbHhiX AeMCTBHH. 0HH pe-

rrepeHeCTH Ha'laAO KOHI~epTa Ha

06HOBIITb penepryap Ha 20% H IIOMeHHTb OtiepeAHOCTb

17 .00;

HCIIOAHeHHSI neceH, lJ:T06bi OCBeJKHTb KOH~epT. e

IIOp)"'HTb To<Py BO BpeMH rray3 Me>KAY KOMII03H~HSIMH pa3BI\.eKaTb ny61\.HKY aHeK,AOTaMH H CMeiiiHhlMH HCTOpHHMH H3 JKH3HH rpyiTITbl.

1. YYACTHI1KI1 rPvnnbl cfii060Bb 11 MYXOMOPbl•

BbiCTYni1Tb BKM<,QOM KnACCE HA KnACCHOM 4ACE

2.3PI1TEI111

nonPOCI1Tb BCEX, KTO nP11AET HA KOHUEPT, nPI1rAACI1Tb HA CfiEAYIOU1EE WOY CBOI1X APY3EH

v Hy BOT, Terreph y CHHeHhKoro H Tocpy-CoeBoro TBopora eCTh YJKe u;eAhiX TpHHClAIJ;aTh HAeM. Ho CMOryr .MI V

OHH BOIIAOTHTh B JKH3Hh BCe 3TH HAeH AO Ha'laAa KOH-

AOrOBOPI1TbCH, YT06bl rA3ETA HAnEYATAAA 11HTEPBbiO CYYAGHI1KAMI1 rPYnnbl •fii060Bb 11 MYXOMOPbl> 11 EE $AHATAMI1, ATAKJ!(E C006U111Tb BPEMH 11 MEGO nPOBEAEHI1H WOY

H_?. peaAH3au;HIO HeKOTOphiX HAeM rrpHAeTcH rroTpaTHTh

4.A$11WI1

113roTOBI1Tb KPYTbiE A$11WI111 PA3BECI1Tb 11X no BCE~ WKOfiE

v•

5.$fiAEPbl

PA3AATb alfiAEPbl YYEHI1KAM 11 YYI1TEilHM HA BbiXOAE 113 WKOfibl nocnE YPOKOB

v•

3. WKOfibHAH rA3ETA

~epTa, YRMy

KOTOpbiM COCTOHTCH YJKe '!epe3 OAJIH MeCHIJ;?

BpeMeHH H ycH.MIM, a Ha APyrHe HAeH rrpHAeTcH

PacKoiiie.MIThCH. vhaK, BaKAaJI<aH H Tocpy orpaHH'IeHhl H BO BpeMeHH, H, l<OHe'ffio, AeHeJKHbiMH pecypcaMH. 0HH rrpHHHMaiOT peliieHHe HaMeTHTb rrpHopmeTh!, tJT06hl orrpeAe.MITb, Ha Ka-

l<lnc HAeHX HM AeikTBHTeAbHO CAeAyeT cocpeAOTO'IHThCH. 67

-:---. ,, -y'' '-''-~-,, --

.._

•

. '

,.~'

_, I

...,;

-....QI ---7Q·y :· /\

·y '

~ Q: /

-v-- -· · -y --'T' "

~~-=

--- -

·0

7. 8.

4a onP.eMJll'l'r.e Ul?l'l.Ol?l'\'r.e'r~OCQM~C'rSl'\~ l-JT06bi OIIpeAeJlliTh IIpHOpiiTeThl CBOHX Aelfcrn:mf, D<l.K.I\d)QII H Coeablli Taopor Bbi6HpaiOT AM KpHrepiDI: cHAy BoJAE!I. CI'BIDI oprmrn:3oBaHHbiX liMii MeporrpiDI'I'Ii.H H I1pOCTO'Iy 11 e>cym;ecrBAeHIDI, /!:.i3AeeAM£ HarMJAHocm co:wuarCBOeO()pil.t HyiO MffiJJHizy (Cllt PUCJ'HOK HWKe), 0-Ia.lfaJ\a Ha Be~

II.IKaJ\.e OHH OipiDKaioT CHJ\.y 0041\eHCIBIDI ~oro Mepoll{llt TIDI ar «BbiCOKoro» AO «Hii3Koro» 3HaqeHIDI 3TOro 0041\eHCIIB Ha .I\IOAeH, Ha ropH30Hrnl\bHolf II.IKaJ\.e OHH J'Kii3biBaiOr CieiiB n:pocron,1 ocym;OCI'Bi\eHIDI

ar «CAOJKHoro» AO «rrpocroro». H

HaKOH~ OI.J;eHHBalar CBOH Ill\aillipyeMbie AeHCIBIDI COOJBE!I" C!BeHHO liX BbiDOJ\HeHIDI 3a AeyM5I Bhl6paHHb!MH KpJITepH.SIMit ./\yqurn:e pe!IIeHIDI - liMeiOII.J;Ife BbiCOKHH IIOI'eiii.J;H:aA BOJAei' CI'BIDI li IIpOCrbie B e>cym;ecrBAeHHH - HaxOASfiDI B Bepl• HeM rrpaaoM KBaAPaTe, HaHMeHee 3¢<PeKTimHhle perneHHI. HMeiOII.J;He Hli3Kmf IIOTeHI.J;IiaA B03AeHcrniDI li Tpe6yro~ OOJ\bllillX ycHA:mf IIpli BOIIAOII.J;eHHH, HaxOASfiDI B IIIDIOieM AeBOM KBaAPaTe. TipoHyMepyeM MeporrpiDl'IWI, Kai'Opill! CHHeHbK:mi H To¢y HaMepeHbi ocym;ecrnHTb:

1. 2. 3.

BhlCT}'IHiTh c neCHe:ii B KilJKAOM I<Aacce Ha KAacCHoM qace. ITonpOCHTh AlOAeH, KOTOphle npHlliAH Ha KOHQepr, npHrAaCHTh Ha C.ll.eAyroiQee rnoy cBomc APYJe:ii. AoroBopHThC.sr co lliKO.II.bHOH raJero:ii o pa3MeiQeHHH HHTepBhiO c yqacrHHKaMH rpyrrnhl «Aro6oBh H MyxoMophl» 1 ee <tJaHaTaMH, a TCUOKe nonpOCHTb C006IQHTh BpeM.sr H MeCTO npoBeAeHH.sr CAeAyroiQero rnoy.

9. 10.

11. 12. 13.

II[JrOTOBHTh Kpyrhle a<tJHlliH H pa3BeCHTb HX no BCeH lliKO.II.e. Pa3AaTh <tJ.~~.aephl yqeHHKaM H yqHre.II.HM Ha BhlXOAe H3 lliKO.II.hl noCAe ypoKoB. PaJBeCHTh coo6IQeHH.sr o KOHQepre Ha AOCKax o6'b.srBAeHHH B KaJKAOM I<Aacce. flonpOCHTh BeAYIQero lliKO.II.bHOrO p~O nOCTaBHTb B 3<tJHp rrecHIO «Aio6BH H MyxoMopoB» H o6'bHBHTh, rAe H KOrAa COCTOHTCH HX KOHQepr. 3anHCaTb KOMnaKT·AHCKH, CAeAaTb Ha HHX noMeTKy 0 BpeMeHH H Mecre npoBeAeHHH CAeAyroiQero KOHQepra H pa3AaTh yqeHHKaM. Pa3oCAaTh no 3.1\.eKrpOHHOH noqre coo6IQeHHH c HH<tJopMaQHeii 0 KOHQepre BCeM yqeHHKaM H yqHTe.II.HM lliKOJI.hl. CoJAaTh Be6-caiir, c Koroporo MOJKHO cKaqarh necHH rpyrrnhl, a TaKJKe pa3MeCTHTh Ha HeM 6Horpa<tJHH yqaCTHHKOB rpyrrnhl HHOBOCTHYJO .1\.eHT}' 0 npeACTOHIQHX MeponpHHTHHX. flepeHeCTH Haqa.~~.o KOHQepra Ha 17.00. 3aMeHHTb 20% neceH Ha HOBble H noMeHHTb oqepeAHOCTh HCnOJI.HeHH.si neceH, qro6bl OCBeJKHTb KOHQepr, flOpyqHTb To<tJy BO BpeMH KOHQepra BnepephlBax pa3M.eKaTb rry6AHKy aHeKAOTaMH HCMelliHbiMH HCI'OpHHMH H3 JKH3HH rpyrriThl. COOTHOWEH ~ E C~Jlbl B03AE~QB~~ ~ nPOCTOTbl OCYll.lEGBilEH~~ MEPOnP~~T~~ All~ OnPEAEilEH~~ nP~OP~TETHbiX AE~QB~~ 6AKJ1Ali<AHA ~ TO<llY BbiCOKaR .

----, 0

~ ~

0 ~

0 E)0

-J H~KaRCno~f ...................... __ ..................... ~ npoao ~;;~~;;~~:

68 69

~ E ~

PaccMOTJH<iM rrpHMep, rAe Ha Ma'I'pmJ;e Cll..eAyffi: no. MeCTIITb AeHC1BHe NQl «Bhlcrymno c necHe:H: B KaJKAOBf KAa.cce Ha KJ\.accHOM '-Iace». 3Ta Mepa 6yA£n: HMeTb oqellla CID\bHOe B03AeHC1BHe. 0Ha He npOCTO nOBbiCHT OCBeAOl>f. AeHHOCTb 0 npeACTO.HIIJ;eM KOiru;epTe: KOI'Aa IIIKO.hhHliKJI noAYl.J:aT B03MOJKHOCTb AHl.J:HO y6eAHTbC.H, KaK 3AOPOBO nOIOT «.l\Io60Bb H MyxoMOpbi», OHH 3axOT5IT rrpHifTH 1fa KOHil;epT, l.J:T06blyCAbiii1a1'b60.hhiiie. 0AHaKO, OCyiiJ;eC1BH'I'h 3TOT 3aMbiCeA HerrpOCTO, nOTOMJl.!TO IIpHAffi:C.H YCTaHaBJ\H. BaTh arrrrapaTYPy B KaJKAOM H3 ABeHCiAIJ;aTH KAa.CCOB, a 3T() 3aMM£n: MHOTO speMeHH. Tio3TOMY EaKAaJKaH H Tocpy Pd3· MeiiJ;aiOT 3TY Mepy B BepXHeM AeBOM yrAy Ma'I'pHIJ;bl. EIIJ;e OAHH CAYl.J:a:H:. KaK Hac'-IeT nJHKTa NQ 6 «Pa3BeCHTh C006IIJ;eHH5I 0 KOHIJ;epTe Ha AOCKax 06o.HBAeHHH B KaJKAOM KAacce»? fAe noMecTHTh 3TJ Mepy? Pa3MhiW· A.HeM: cHAa B03AeifcTBH.H 6yAeT HH3Ka.H, noTOMY '-ITO B CJMaTOXe AHeM MaAO KTO o6paiiJ;aeT BHHMaHHe Ha AoCKy 06'h.HBAeHHM. l1 AaJKe eCAH KTO·TO H npoqHTaeT Co06IIJ;eHHe 0 AaTe H MeCTe npoBeAeHH.H KOHIJ;epTa, 3TO BCeTO AHIIIb nOBbiCHT OCBeAOMAeHHOCTb. flpO'-IHTa.B aHoHc, qeAoBeK BP.HA AH 3aropHTC.H ocTphiM JKeAaHHeM nOHTH Ha KOHIJ;epT - no KpaifHeH Mepe, ero JKeAaHHe He CTaHeT OCTpee. Ho 3aTO OCyiiJ;eCTBHTb 3TOT 3aMb1CeA npocTo, noToMy '-ITO see, '-ITO Tpe6yeTC.H CAeAaTh, - 3TO nosecHTh o6'h.HBAeHHe Ha AOCKy. Tio3TOMY EaKAaJKaH H Tocpy AeAaiOT noMeTKY NQ 6 B HHJKHeM npasoM yrAy.

I()T caMH· flo3TOMJ, TaK KaK B rpyrrrre «J\Io60Bb H MyxoM:Opbl» HHKTO He OTAHl.J:aeTC.H MaCTepC1BOM xyAOJKHHKa, aaiiiH APY3b51 noMecTHAH AeHC1BHe NQ 4 «l13roToBH1'h KpyThie acpHIIlli H pa3BeCHTb HX no BCeH IIIKOAe» B AeBhiM ~ KBaAPaT (CAa60e BAH5IHHe H 60.1\hllla.H Cli..OJKHOCTb

licnoAHeHH.H) . Ho TYT Tocpy oceHHAo: «A '-ITO, eCAH Mhi nonpocHM AJI<oHa OchMHHora C03Aa1'h AA.H Hac acplUIIY? EMY sEW> CAeAaTh KaKOH·HH6YAb KPJTOH IIAaKaT - 3TO pa3 IWOHYTb! » lJTO H3MeHHTC.H Ha Ma'I'pHIJ;e? COOTHOWEHI-lE Cl-lllbl B03AEHCTBI-1~ 1-1 nPOCTOTbl OCYlUECTBilEHI-1~ MEPOnPI-1~1-lH All~ OnPEAEilEHI-1~ nPI-lOPI-lTETHbiX AEHCTBI-lH 6AKI1AJKAHA 1-1 T()<!)Y

-·1

&---------------4 ------------of:)

.1 1 ~ : 0

"' : ~i U •

H~KaH

--- --,

e ---------- --

. ------

Ii ,.

-- -

·················~ npocro

c. i>A.3i>.ASO'rA.Il'r.t IlJl.A.lf Sl:l.t.lli>.tlfl'Lf

l1TaK, KaKHe JKe AeHC1BH.H Cll..eAyeT npeAIIpHH5ITb EaKM· JKaHY H Tocpy? fAaBHhlM npHopHTeToM AA5I HHX AOJ\JK}ILI CTaTb AeHC1BH.H, 0603Hal.J:eHHbie B npaBOM BepXHeM yrAY• TaK KaK AA5I HHX xapaKTepHa MaKCHMa.hhHa.H CHAa B03" AeHC1BH.H, H npH 3TOM OHH npOIIJ;e BCero B HCnoAHeHHH· CAeAyiOIIJ;He no npHopmernocm Mepbl - 3TO AeifcTBJVI. OTMel.J:eHHble B AeBOM BepXHeM HAM: B npaBOM HIDKHe!d yrAy. HaHMeHee npHBAeKaTe.hhHhiMH .HBA.HIOTC.H Aefi· C1BH.H, 3acpHKCHpOBaHHhle B AeBOM HHJKHeM yrAy. EaKAaJKaH H Tocpy noHaqaAy orrpeAeA.HAH rrpHop}f1'e'l'" HOC'Tb CBOHX AeHC1BHH, HCXOAH H3 TOTO , '-ITO OHH see AeNJ"

4D 0 0 E) 0 0

Cno~o .....................~.;~;;·~~~~;··

'fi\

........ -.---- ----~~

3aiiAaHHpOBaB nonpoCHTb AJI<oHa C03AaTb acpHIIIY, EaKAaJKaH H Tocpy nepeMeiiJ;aiOT OTMeTKY c AeifcTBHeM NQ 4 H3 Aesoro HHJKHero KBaApaTa B npaBhiH sepxHHH

KB~paT, KaK noKa3aHO Ha pHCJHKe Bbiiiie. ToqHo TaK JKe OHH H3Ha'-Ia.hhHO noMeCTHAH NQ 8 «3anacaTh KOMnaKT-AHCK, CAeAaTh Ha HeM noMeTKY 0 BpeMeHH H MeCTe npoBeAeHH.H CAeAyiOIIJ;ero KOHIJ;epTa» B CeK.Top C 60.1\hiiiOH CHAOM B03AeHCTBH.H, HO CAOJKHhiM HcnoAHeHHeM, noTOMY '-ITO caMH OHH He YMeiOT 3anachiBaTh KOMnaKT-AHCKH. Ho, 3Ha.H, '-ITO B Hx KAacce ecTh Ytie HHKH, KOTOpble YMeiOT 3TO AeAaTh, EaKAaJKaH H

~Ill ·

:~ M ~

Tocpy MOryT TaiOKe IIOIIpOC.H:Tb 0 IIOMOII.J;H CIIpaB.H:TbC.SI c NQ 8, H Aa.JKe c NQ 10 «C03AaTb Be6-ca:H:T». 11TaK, c IIOMOII.J;biO CBOHX 3HaKOMbiX EaKJ\IDKaH H CYMeJlli ocym;ecTB.H:Th Bee CBOH TPHH<lAQaTb .H:Ae:H:. 11 EaKJ\IDKaH H Tocpy, Bbl MOJKeTe A06.H:TbC5I ropa3AO 6o.l\bllle! ro, eCJlli o5neAmnrre CBOH yc.H:.llli5I H yc.H:.llli5I APyrnx JUOA~ 06J\aAaiOII.J;HX TM.aHTaM.H:, KOTOpbiX y BaC HeT. EaKJ\IDKaJiy TocpyyAaJ\.OCb peaJ\.H30BaTb Bee CBOH JiAe.H:, HO TaK CAyqae'f" C5I AaJ\.eKO He BCerAa. f10MH.H:Te: H~O CHaqaJ\.a paCCTaBH'li IIp.H:Op.H:TeTbl, a YJK 3aTeM COCTaBJ\5ITh IlllliH BHeAPeHH5I.

«My-xo-Mop! My-xo-Mop! To-cpy! To-cpy! Ea-KAa-JKaH! )Ja-J(l\d·JKaH! » - CKaHAlfPOBaJ\.a TOAIIa. 3p.H:Te.llli He XOTeJlli oTIIYcKaTb rpyrrrry co cu;eHbi. My3biKaHTbi CMym;eHHO rreperJVJAbiBaA.H:Cb. Ha rAa3ax y Bcex TPOHX 6AeCTeAH CAe3bi. YsMeB, qTo rAa3a y EaKAa.JKaHa H Tocpy Ha MOKpOM M€CT€, MyxoMOp BOCKAHKHyAa: «3R, Bbl, ABOe! qTO 3TO Bhl peseTe? A Hy He pacKHCaTb! » 11 BApyr oHa oceKAaCb, npHT5IHYAa 060HX OAHOBpeMeHHO K ce6e B 06'h5ITH5I H pa 3pa3.H:AaCb 6ypHbiMH pbJAaHH5IMH. «Crrac.H:6o, crrac.H:6o orpOMHOe BaM 060HM! » - CKa3aJ\.a OHa. qeTBepTbiR KOHu;epT rpyrrrrhl «J\.I060Bb H MyxoMOpbi» YAaAC5I Ha cAaBy. YBeA.H:q.H:B ocBeAOMAeHHOCTb rry6AHKH AO 90%, H A06HBlli.H:Cb, qTo6bl Ha KOHD;epT rrpHllih.H 50% JUOAe:H:, 3HaiOm;Hx o rnoy, EaKAa.JKaH H Tocpy npHBAeKAH B 3aA 200 qeAoBeK. EoAee Toro, 90% H3 3THX AIOA€H IIAaHHPYIOT IIpHHTH K HHM CHOBa!

4('TBE'pTbl~

Tpc-T~~

KOHUepT

nmore3a

pe3ynbTaTbl aHaml3a

--------------------------------.------------

CJl.E:.ll~I<>II{Mti KOlf.l{.E:?r r?~nnf>I «Jli<>SOBb l'l 1-t~Ol-tO?bi»

npeACTO~ll.\eM

KOHL\epre?

KaK JKe rrporneA CAeAYIOII.J;HR KOHIJ;epT rpyrrrrhl «Aio60Bb H MyxoMopbi»?

---------------------------------

MeC5IIJ;, OCTaBaBlliHHC5I AO CAeAyrom;ero, qeTBepTOI'O. KoHu;epTa, 6biCTPO rrpoAeTeA, H MyxoMop, EaKAaJKaH I Tocpy CHOBa BbllliAH Ha cu;eey. KOrAa OHH 3aK0Hq.H:AH IIeTit CBOIO JU06.H:MYJO IIeCHIO «Tpoe», 3aJ\. 3aMep B MOAqaHHIL EbiAO TaKOe BIIeqaTAeH.H:e, ~0 KTO-TO C IIOMOII.J;biO rryAI>Til yrrpaBAeHH5I OTKJUOq.H:A 3BYK rnraHTCKOro TeAeB.H:30pa. YqacTHHKH rpyrriibl «AI06oBb H MyxoMopbi» HepBHO BrNJAbiBaJ\..H:Cb B TeMHOTy, OKYTaBlliYJO CIIOPTlfBHbll JaA. 11 BAPyr 3aJ\. B30pBaJ\.C5I 3BYKaM.H: aiiAOAlfCMeHToB H BoCXJI· m;eHHbiX B03rAaCOB. CT05IA TaKo:H: lliYM· ~o Bee rroMei.QeiDI8

Bbl KOrAa HY16YAb 6b1Ban,., Ha HaWYIX KOHL\eprax?

HaqaAo XOAlfTb XOAVJ.rOM. Yc.H:.llli5I EaKJ\IDKaHa H Tocpy oi<Y· ,J.. VI IIHA.H:Cb CTOp.H:IJ;e:H:! Ha KOHIJ;ePT IIp.H:lliAO ABeCTH 3p.H:TeAell· 72

90% (450)

Bbi3Haere o

50%

(225)

--------------------------------~

90%

Bbl peryn~pHo XOAYITe Ha HaWY\ KOHL\epTbl?

(203)

--------------------------------KonH'Iecreo lOCeTHTeneiit

200+

~tor

~ .q

~ ?.A3:S.t~.t SOJlhlii~~ M.t'i'r~ ' UeT-HeT, Mhl He npeMaraeM BaM nocrynaTh C Me'I-

.1.1 TOH TaK, KaK AeAalOT HHOrAa C nocyAOH, B cepAU;ax 6poca5I ee Ha noA. HarnH CMhllliAeHhle AeTH pa36HBaiOT CBOIO Me'Iry

AMI TOrO,

'IT06bl ORa ocym;eCTBHAaCh. 3TH

pemaiOrn;He npo6AeMhl yMHHKH

AMI

Toro, 'IT06hi AO-

CTI-i'Ih 3aAyMaHHOrO, Me'ITaiOT ITO-KpynHOMY: OHH pa36HBaiOT ITYTh, no KOTOPOMY ABHJKYTCH K Me'ITe, Ha MeAKHe 3Tanhl. CMeKaAHCThle AeTH ycTaHaBAHBaiOT aexH H, 'IT06bl npOHTH HX, KaJKAbiH pa3 cnparnHBalOT ce6H: «liTo 5I AOAJKeH CAeAaTh B 3TOM rOAY HAlf B Te'IeHHe CAeAY!Olll;HX Tpex MecHu;ea, HAH cerOAHH

AMI

AOCTHJKeHHH

CBoeif Me'ITbl? » 3TH BeXH CAyJKaT AeTHM, KOTOpble yMelOT pernaTb npo6AeMhl, yKa3aTeMMH Ha flYTH K Me'ITe H noMoraiOT coxpaHHTh MOTHBaiJ;HIO. CocTaBHB ITAaH AOCTH:>KeHHH Me'IThl, TaKHe AeTH HaxOAHT HaH6oAee 3¢¢eKTHBHhlH cnoco6 AOCTHJKeHHH KaJKAOH MeAKOH

~e~

B OTAeAbHOCTH H npeAflpHHHMaiOT He06XOAHMble

AeHCTBH.51.

B 3Toii rAaae 0 ChMHHor -

HalliHM noMo:rn;HHKOM cTaHeT A;JK.oH BhlAalOIIJ;HHC51

AH3aHHep

acpHlliH

~; r.,'

~·

11)1

~. ..QI 1-tr

-<•

:=i' ..,, ~I

~· t)r

;,.., ~· ~.

M5I poK-rpynnbi «Aro6oBn H MyxoMopbi>>, K pbiif TaKJKe nnnaercH Ao6:arncH CBoeif ~eA:a. I1r~

AJKoH Meqraer B 6yAyrn;eM noexarn B foAAHBYA I<at xyAOJKHHK-MYAnTHnAHKarop H Bo3rAaBHTb npo¢ee. CHOHaAnHyiO CTYAHIO no KOMnbiOTepHOM rpa¢aJC't xyAOJKecrBeHHbix ¢HAhMOB. KoHe'!Ho, CHaqaAa el\(}' Heo6XOAHMO OBAaAeTn nporpaMMaMH no KOMITI,l(). repHoif rpa¢:aKe. A 6e3 KOMnnrorepa 3Toro ~o OcnMHHor CAeAarn He CMOJKer. I103ToMy Ha AaHaol( 3Tane ero nepBaH ~eAn COCTOHT B TOM, 'IT06bi n p:ao(j. pecr:a KOMnbiOTep.

I1 CHOBa HecKOAbKo CAOB o AeTHX, Koropnre YMe peruarn npo6AeMbi. Y HHX ecrn npoBepeHHniM BpeM, HeM nopHAOK AeifcrB:aif no AOCTHJKeH:aro nocraB.II.eH· HbiX ~eAeif. TaK:ae AeMCTBHH nOA06Hbi ruaraM BO Bperu XOAn6bi: •

liar 1: flocTaBHTb rrepeA co6oH: qerKyro qeAb.

e liar 2: OrrpeAeAHTb pa3pb1B MeJKAy IIOCTaBAeHHOH qeAbiO I TeKYJqHM IIOAOJKeHHeM Berqeif. e liar 3: CcpopMyAHpoBaTb rHIIOTe3y 0 TOM, KaKHM o6pa30JI MOJKHO IIpeOAOAeTb 3TOT pa3pbiB HAOCTH% qeAH: C)A.I1epeqHCAHTb KaK MOJKHO 60AbiUe HAeM H BapH• aHTOB; C)B. Oro6parn Ayqru:ae HAe:a B KaqecrBe r:anore3bi. • liar 4: flposepHTb mrrore3y. ECAH rHrrore3a orrposeprny· Ta, BepHyTbC5I K mary 3:

0 A OnpeAeAHTb, KaKM

HH¢opM~HH Heo6xOAifMa H

KaK ocyrn;ecTBHTb aHa.II.H3, 'IT06nr npoBep:arn r:anore3y; OB. I1poBecr:a aHaAH3 :a pa3pa6orarn nAaH.

A renepn npeMaraeM nocMorpern, KaK:ae ruarB npeAnpHHHMaer AJKoH OcnMHHor, 'IT06nr AOMTH A 0 nocTaBAeHHOM ~eAR.

SOJlblllA.S M:.E:'l'XA. l't .Il.rtFBA.S

KaK-TO AJKoH CO CBoeif nOApyroif Capoif OTnpaBHAHCb B KHiiOTearp H nOCMOTpeAH TaM YBAeKaTeAbHbiM ¢HAbM C KOMITbiOTepHbiMH cne~3¢¢eKTaMH. J1M O'IeHb noHpaBH.II.OCb: aHHMa~HH 6biAa HacroAnKo HCKYCHM, 'ITO BHpyYa.ll.bHbiX repoeB HeB03MOJKHO 6niAO OTAH'IHTb OT HacroHrn;:ax. CroJKer 6biA TOJKe norpHcarorn;:aif. C rex rrop AJKoH- Meqraer crarn npo¢eccHOHaAOM no KOMIIbiOTepHoif rpa¢:aKe xyAoJKecrBeHHbiX cpHAbMOB. Ero B006paJKeHHe JKHBO p:acyer eMy JKypHa.ll.bHbie 3arOAOBKH: «HoBarop KOMnbiOTepHOM rpa¢HKH AJKoH 0CbMHHor no.11.yqaer I1p:a3 XyAoJKeCTBeHHoif AK~eMHH!>>. I1 Ha 06.1\.0JKKe JKypHaAa - CaM AJKoH B CMOKHHre H CO crary3TKoif OcKapa B PYKax.

HO ECTb O.QHA nP0611EMKA... A.JKoa nOHHTHH He HMeeT, KaK C03AaiOTCH KOMIIbiOTepHbie cne~3¢¢eKTbi. EcAH qecrHo, y Hero :a I<OMrrhrorepa-ro Her. TaK 'ITO cHaqa.~~.a eMy H~o npHAyMarh, KaKHM o6pa30M KynHTh ce6e KOMnhrorep. OH He IIpoqh rronpaKTHKOBaThCH B poAH AH3aMHepa H C03AaTh Po~ecrBeHcKyro OTKphiTKY c ¢ororpa¢:aeif POAHbiX. A. 3To 3Iia'IHT, 'ITO KOMIThiOTep HYJKeH eMy He n03AHee Iraq~a AeKa6pH, a AO Ha'IaAa AeKa6pH ocra.~~.och Bcero lliecrh MecH~eB.

~ fq

::! ~

A;I<OH IIOHHMaeT, 'ITO 3AeCb Hy)KeH Ill\.aH. BoT KaKHe marH oH rrpeAIIPHHHMaeT.

li.l.Ar 1: nOC!":tA.S.a":t:b":t.t n.t?.tA coso~ 'l.t":tK~w Lt.tJl:o J1TaK, rrepBbiH mar A;KoHa - 3TO IIOCTaHOBKa 'leTKO u;eAM. t.ITO 3TO 6yAeT 3a u;eAh? ECAM XOTHTe Hayqlfl'L. CH YMeAo maraTh no IIyTH K Me'!Te, TOrAa rrpeACTaBhTe ce6e, 'ITO Bhl - A;KoH. A Terrepb C.sJAbTe, c¢OPMy.l\ll· pyM:Te Barny u;eAh H 3aiiHmHTe Ha AMCTe 6YMarH. t.ITO IIOAyqHAOCb? EcAM Bhl rrpocTo HarrHcaAM: «5! xoqy KOMIIhiOTep HAM «KyrrHTh KOMIIhlOTep», - TO CcpOpMyAMpOBaAB cso10 u;eAh He AyqmHM o6pa30M. B AaHHOM cAyqae O'leHb Ba)KHO 6biTh KaK MO)KHO 6oAee KOHKpeTHhiM .

llJI.OXOH npHMep: «51 XOlJY KOMIIhiOTep» RAH «KynHTh rrepcoHaAhHhiH KOMIIhiOTep».

• Xopomuil npnMep: «51 XOlJY B re'!eHue IIIecru Mec.sn~eB K'f· IIHTh 6biBIIIHH B ynorpe6AeHHH KOMIIhiOTep «Apple» 3a 500 AOAAapoB, He OAiWKHBilli AeHer». TiepBhiH rrpHMep cAMmKOM pacrrAhiB'laT. Herromrr· Ho, o KaKOM HMeHHO TIK AYMaeT A;KoH, KOrAa oH x oqeT ero IIpHo6peCTH H KaKHM o6pa30M OH XO'leT 3TO CAe· AaTh. Bo BTopoM cAyqae see 3TH AeTaAM 'leTKO orrpeAe· AeHbi.

e e e

«LJero H XOlJY?» «EhiBIIIHH B ynorpe6AeHHH KOMIIhiOTeP «Apple» 3a 500 AOAAapoB. «KOrM H :noro XOlJY? » «B Te'IeHHe IIIeCTH MeCH~eB». «KaKHM o6pa30M H XOlJY 3TO IIOA)"'HTh?» «51 XOlJY KyriHTI> ero, He OACWKHBilli AeHer y Apyrux».

AaAee A;KoHy cAeAyeT orrpeAeAMThCH co cpoKaMH: KOrAa OH 3TOrO XO'leT? flpoBeAeM HeKyiO BhlMhimAeHH)'IO rpaHb·pa3pbiB Me)I(Ay TeM, 'ITO JiiMeeM H TeM, 'ITO XOTJiiM JiiMeTh. B 3aBHCHMOCTJil OT TOrO, K KaKOMY cpoKy fyKOH XO'leT KOMIIhlOTep, OH 6yAeT Bhl6HpaTh AyqmHH cnoco6 rrpeoAOAeHRH pa3phlBa Me)I(Ay TeKyru;HM rroAO)I(eHHeM Bei.U;eH (OTCYTCTBHe KOMIIhlOTepa) Jii u;eAhlO (npi106peTeHHe KOMIIhlOTepa). EcAM AJKoH Ill\.aHHpyeT KyiiRTh KOMIIhiOTep qepe3 TPH roAa, eMy AOCTaTO'IHO 6yAeT IIpOCTO 3KOHOMHTh H IIOHeMHOry OTKAaAbiBaTh AeHhrR, 'IT06hr HaKorrHTh Ha KOMIIhiOTep. Ho ecAM oH XO'leT l<yrrHTh KOMIIhlOTep B Te'leHHe 6AH:)KaHmJiiX meCTH Mec.s~u;es, TO OAHOH 3KOHOMI1H 6yAeT HeAOCTaTO'lHo - IIpHAeTCH IIOHCKaTh AOIIOAHHTeAhHhle HCTO'IHJiiKH AOXOAa. EcAM y sac ecTh oco6hle ycAOBHH, KOTOphre Bhl BhlABHraeTe Ha IIYTH K AOCTH)KeHHIO u;eAM, TOrAa BaM He06XOAHMO BKAIO'IHTh HX B CBOIO cpopMyAMpOBKY :noif ~eAH. HarrpHMep, A;KoH KOHKpeTH3HposaA, 'ITO xoqeT KYTIHTb KOMIIhlOTep, a He OAOA)KHTh HAM B3HTh ero HaIIPOKaT; KpoMe Toro, oH He xoqeT OAdA)KHBaTh AeHbrH Ha UpHo6peTeHHe KOMIIblOTepa.

J1TaK, CHa'laAa A;KoHy CAeAyeT orrpeAeAMTh, KaKOif KOMIIhlOTep HaMAyqmHM o6pa30M YAOBAeTBOpHT ero 3aiip0Chl. B MHpe cyru;eCTByeT MHOrO pa3HhlX KOMIIbiO" Tepos. 0AHH rrpeKpaCHO IIOAXOA.sJT AA.sJ 3AeKTpOHHOif

epenRcKH I1 cocTaBAeHHH AOKYMeHTOB. APyrRe 6oAbv r+. Ule noAXOA.sJT AA.sJ KOMIIhlOTepHOH rpa't'HKH, HO MOryT oKa 3 aTbCH AOPO)Ke. Tio3TOMY A;KoH o6omeA HeCKOAhKO KOMUblOTepHbiX Mara3HHOB, IIOHCKaA B JiiHTepHeTe H aaKOHeiJ;, HameA TOT KOMIIhlOTep, KOTOpbiH eMy HaH6~Aee UOAXOAJiiT: 6hiBmHH B yrroTpe6AeHJiiH «Apple» B npeKpaCHOM COCTOHHJiiJil, u;eHa - 500 AOAAapoB. Tenepb y Hero eCTh KOHKpeTHa.si u;eAh H CYMMa, Ha KOTOpyro OH 6yAeT OpHeHTHpOBaTbCH.

l.JeM KOHKpeTHee Bhl ccpopMyAMpyeTe CBOIO u;eAh, reM 6oAee qeTKHM 6yAeT sam Ill\.aH AeifcTBHH. KaKyiO 6hr ~eAh rrepeA co6oif Bhl He cTaBMAM, B03hMHTe 3a rrpaBJiAo scerAa 3dAaBaTh ce6e sorrpochl: «t.Iero KOHKpeTHO 51 xoqy AOCTM'lh? KorAa .s1 xoqy 3Toro AOCTH'lh? KaKOBhi MOlf 0C06hre ycAOBHH? »

~..,

lli.Ar

on?.t.ll.tJl.a'rD ?A.3?biS

PA3PbiB MEJKAY nPOrH03~PYEMbiM~ C6EPEJI<EH~RM~ ~ l1EHO~ KOMnbiOTEPA

1-t.t~.ll~ nOC.'rA.SJl.tl:fflO~ I.{.tJlDIC ,a 'r.tK~Il{.at-t nOJlO~.t~.a.tt-t S.tll{.t~

.-·-··-···-···-··-···-···-···---··-···-···-·-..

f TeK)'WIE! c6epe)l(eH~H +KOflW!ecTBO Meal~eB '; i

~ Ei ~

TIOCTaBJ:IB nepeA co6oif qeTKYJO u;e;u,, CAeAyroiD;lfM

1!/Jo

AOM Bbl AOAJKHbi onpeAeAHTb pd3pbiB Me./KAy BdllleH

Ju.IO If BdiiiHM TeKy:ru;HM noAoJKeHHeM. EcAH pd3phlB 111 BeAHK, TO H peiiieHHe MOJKeT 6biTb 3AeMeHTdpHhlM.

Jio

! ! I i :

X(e)l(eMeGIYH~IeKapMaHHble AeHbr.1 t (e)l(eMea!YHbl~ AOXOA OT BblfYfl~BaH~H co6aK~) - cpeAHeMecRYHble pacxoAbl] = $150 +6 x[$20 +(S3jyacx 1Yac eHeAeflKl x4 HeAen~ e Meal~) - $15] = $252

nOAYMdTb, KdKHM o6pd30M Bhl co6HpdeTecb A 06H'fhCI cBoe:H u;eAH.

\ .....,

___.. __

'>~~-

,_,

, ,_,_,

,_,_}_,,

(~eHa KOMnbmepa- nponm~pyeMble 'l

c6epe)l(eH~H Ja 6 Meai~ee

i..

$500-$252= =$248

'-·-··-··-···-··-··-··-··-··---

nporHOl~pyeMble c6epe)l(eH~H Ja

150 AOAAdpOB. K aJKAbii 20 AOAAdpOB Hd K dpMaH·

PalpbiB

K dqecTBe

Hhle pdCXOAbi. KpoMe Toro, coceAH IIAdT.HT eMy n o

Palpble

''·,\ $252

Ceifqdc y Hero B KOnHAKe

(

MeC.HIJ; POAHTeAH AdiOT eMy no

\.... _..,.----··-··-·-··-·- ··-··--·-·-·/ .----.1

ecAH 3TO 60Ju.IIIOH pd3pbiB, TO npJiAeTC.H XOpOIIIeHhJtO

AdBdHTe npOAOAJKHM pdCCMdTpHBdTb B npHMepd CAyqd:H AJKoHd.

) ljenb (~eHa KOMnbmepa)

6 MecR~ee (Ha re~x ycnoe~Hx)

3 AOA·

Adpd B qdc 3d TO, qTo OH pd3 B HeAeAIO BhlryAHBdeT HI co6dKy. TdKHM o6pd30M, Hd6erdeT e:ru;e

12 AOAAdpOB 1

MeC.HIJ;. Ho B cpeAHeM AJKoH TpdTHT no Mec.Hu;.

AOAAdpOB I

A,/KOH nOACqHTaA, qTO ero n p orH03HpyeMbie c6epeJKeHIUI COCTdBA.HIOT

252

AOAAdpd. 3TO 3HdqHT, qTO OH

He CMOJKeT KyrrHTb KOMnbiOTep, eCAH ero ypoBeHb AOXOAa ocTdHeTc.H HeH3MeHHbiM. EMy HdAO npHAYMdTb

CMoJKeT AM AJKoH KynHTb KOMnbiOTep, ecAH ero

CIIOC06, KdK 3dnOAHHTb pd3pbiB B

248 AOAAdpOB.

HhlHeiiiHHH ypoBeHb AOXOAOB H pdCXOAOB OC TaHeT• C.H HeH3MeHHhlM? l.JT06bl OTBeTHTb Hd 3TOT B OnpOC eMy HdAO pdCCqHTdTb CBOlf npOrH03HpyeMble c6epeJKeHH5I 3d 6AHJKdHIIIHe IIIeCTb MeC.HIJ;eB no TeKymei CTdBKe. EcAH pe3yAbTdT OKdJKeTC.H 60Abiiie

500

AOA·

AdpOB, TO AJKOH CMOJKeT KyrrHTb KOMnbiOTep, H Hqel'O He MeH.H.H. TiporH03HpyeMbie c6epeJKeHH.H 3d IIIeCTb Mec.Hu;eu: TeKyrn;He c6epeJKeHH5I

~ ~ •

+ KOAWiectso Mec.sn,\eB x

[ eJKeMec5fqHhle KapMaHHhle AeHhrH

+ (eJKeMec5fqHhlH AOXOA

= + 6 X [$20 + ($3/qac X hac B HeAeAIO X 4 HeAeAH B MeC5I~). = $252

OT BhlryAHBaHH5I co6aKH) - cpeAHeMeC5[qHhle paCXOAhl] $150 $15]

~Ill

~ ~

liiA.I' 3: SbUlSli'tl:f~'rb rli'tnO'r~3~ ElKeMec!l'lHble - { Po)111Ten~

C)A.nEPE4l1Cnl1Tb KAK MO>KHO SOnbWE l1,Q,EVll1 BAPl1AHTOB nPEO,Q,OnEHl1s:l PA3PbiBA

{

POA~en~ ~

Terreph

~OH

3HaeT, 'ITO

AMI

AeAYWKa 6a6ywKa CO GOpoHbl MaTepl1

11 a~ IJ~

rrpeOAOAeHFHI

Hhle AeiicTBH51. t.ITo JKe IIPHAYMaTh? TioMorHTe P.JKo•

eMy He06XOAHMO 6yAeT IIpeAfipHHHTh

Apyrne

nos~

AOXOAbl

YeeJUtl~

-J

TpyAOBble AOXOAbl

{

floe~ AOXOA

pafloo.lee BpeMR

3a KaJKAbl~ ~ac Ha

'-~ ~--

• nepe;m1 Ha 6onee

ao~MOCTb

OO<lero

~ca

Hy-Ka, 'ITO IIOAYlJHAOCh? MAeH ChliiaAHCh,

BbiCOKOO!lfl~~BaeMYIO

pa6ory

H3 pora H306HAHH? 11HorAa O'leHh TPYAHO BhlHTH paMKH IIpHBhi'IHOrO MhiiiiAeHH51 H BhlABHHYTh HHHO

~HOHHYJO HAeiO. B 60AbiiiHHCTBe CAYlJaeB TaK H

Mo~ co6CTBeHHble

HarrHcaTh 'ITO-TO BPOAe 3Toro: IIOIIpOCHTb MaMy Bb!AaBaTb MHe

•

60Ahllle AeHer Ha KapMaHHhle pacxoAhl; 3KOHOMHTh AeHhrH;

KyrrHTh AOTepeHHbiH 6HAeT.

!l)MbKlTep 'Apple'

TiepBaH HAeH, CKOpee Bcero, He IIOAOHAeT, IIOTO.

~OH XO'leT AOCTH'lh CBOeH ~eAH CaMOCTOHTeAh4 1

Jl~Hble

np<JAaTb aKTMBbl

ly-

I KaUiotOI)' ljOOb6biBW~~ Bynmpe!ineH~~

APYI'ile AOXOAbl

lii500AQMapos a

'ITO

AOXOAbi

AeAywKa ~ 6a6ywKa co aopoobl 01\1<1

- { - '-( llOAapoK Apyrne

IIPHAYMaTh H 3arrHcaTh HeCKOAhKO HAeii. ByAbTe MOJKHO KOHKpeTHee.

Apyrne

niOAe~

::1 ~

POA~en~

JlOACTBeH ~ ~

KapM<JHHble AeHbrn

AeHbl'il OT APYI'iiX

-6ni1JK<l~W~X 6wea~ues. He

- { (KH~rn)

-r~w

(Apyroe)

(~Hble

aKTMBbl Apyrne

{~~ BllOTepeiO ~rpaTb

Apyroe

0Aii001BaR AeHer y J11¥11Xl

BTopaH MhlCAh HeAOCTaTO'IHO KOHKpeTHa. TpeThH COKpa~~ory

CAHIIIKOM MaAO H~eJKAhl Ha ycrrex. MHOrHe AIOAH

{

3TOM H OCTaHaBAHBaiOTC51, peiiiHB, 'ITO co6paTb AOII~.

llQKYflK~ ~OB

KOMnaKT~~

HHTeAbHhle AeHhrH HM HH 3a 'ITO He YAaCTCH.

COK~ ao~MOCTb KaJKAClrO~

Ho Mhl-To c BaMH, B OTAH'!He OT 3THX AIOAeii, 3Hael4 KaK C IIOMO~hlO AOrH'!eCKOro AepeBa H3 YpoKa

Pa38Jle'leH~

NQ 1 npii-

~rpbi

AYMaTb MHOJKecTBo CaMhiX pa3Hoo6pa3HhiX KOHKpe crroco6oB peiiieHHH rrpo6AeMhi. AaBaiiTe rrocMOTPHM, KOe AOrH'leCKOe AepeBO C03AaA ~OH (C.

~OH

Ha'laA C AeBOH CTOpOHbl C

87).

KOHCTaTa~HH

·- COKpa~ pacxoAbl

Te'leHHe 6AHJKaHIIIHX

6 MeCH~eB,

He OAaAJKHBa51

Apyroe

500 AOAAapOB

- { llOKYflK~~rp CoKpa~ aooMOOb

CBO't

e:H r AaBHo:H rrpo6AeMhl ( « KaK H Mory KyrrHTh 6biBIIIHi 1 yrroTpe6AeHHH KOMIIhlOTep "Apple" 3a

COKpa~~ory

--1

EAa~

KaJKAOO ~rpbl

-r-~~KOHqlerbl

Han~

Apyroe

~: 1111

~· U)l 0• ~· ~. .QI

1-i•

<• EJ• 11fl

~· tJr:l

O•

~·

~· ~:

y APYTHX? »). 3aTeM OH pa36:HA rrepByro BeTBb Ha « Ali'IHTb AOXOAbl» :H «COKpaT:HTb paCXOAbl». A,/KOH 3aAYMaJ\.C51 HaA TeM, KaK:HM 06pa30M OH MOr YBeAli'IHTb CBOH AOXOAhl, H C03AaJ\. HOBble BeTBH: rH OT APYTHX JUOAefl» H «Mo:H co6cTBeHHbie AOXoALI,.

.l1A5J

ITO BeTKe «COKpaT:HTb paCXOAbi», OH pa368A

CBO:H H3AepJKK:H Ha Tp:H KaTerop:H:H: «Pa3BAe'IeHHJ) «EAa H Haii:HTKH» H «APyroe». l..JT06bl Bailie AepeBO pOCAO B BepT:HKaAbHOM Harrpaa. AeH:H:H, IIOCTOHHHO 3~aBafiTe ce6e BOIIpoc: «CYJqeCTBYJOT All APyrHe CIIOC06bl perneH:HH rrpo6AeMhl? l..JTo6bi Barne AepeBo BeTBHAOCb B rop:H30HTaAbHOM

ll~YHble

orHOCHTCH K :noH: KaTerop:HH? » AeH:cTBYH IIOA06HbiM o6HarrpaBAeH:HH, crrparn:HBaH: ce6H: «LITo KOHKpeTHo

pa30M, Bbl BCKOpe 06HapyJKHTe, 'ITO 3aii:HCaA.ll BeAJilCCit

,...,..-·-·-····-·-·-·~.......(·····"""······

MHOJKeCTBO pa3H006pa3HbiX KOHKpeTHbiX HAefl. I&At.IOfY l)MbfibiBW~H

~~~H

C) B. OT06PATb 11Y4W~E ~AE~ B KA4ECTBE r~nOTE3bl

UQ,mep ·Apple"

i \

«IW<ET01, 3TO, HEnllOXAll ~AER!>

i ··.....:.............................

li 100 AOMapoe

Hy BOT, A,/KoH H C03AaJ\. AOrH'IecKoe AepeBo. Terrepb IIp:HCTyiiaeT K OT6opy CaMbiX YAa'IHbiX :HAefl H3 TeX, KOTOpble IIp:HlliAll eMy B fOAOBy, 'IT06bi IIp:HH51Tb 3a CBOIO f:HIIOTe3y OTHOCHTeAbHO rrpeOAOAeH:H51 Ba B 248 AOAAapoB.

llPil<lle fno.aHw~x 611!0\j€9, He ~AAeHery ~)

,./........~~~-~:~~..-- ...............

~HBECT~POBATb,AWAHCbl

\ ••••••

Bbl~rPATb BllOTEPEIO OYEHb

nP~PAYHbDm ~AE~ / ·-.. llYYWE OCTAB~Tb> /

··"""···-·--·-·--···-··.,-.···

CoKpa1111b

Kot.maKT- 1 ~ :

YaCTOTy llOK)'TlKH

"(~.

AJ.1CKOB

ero n;eAb -

Hrp

A,/KoH, HarrpHMep, oT6pociL'

Hrpbl

MalliH:He 3aAaH:H51, :H OH He MOJKeT II03B0Al1Tb ce6e yAeAHTb 6oAbrne BpeMeH:H 3apa6aTbiBaHHIO AeHer.

AJY-08

•1,,

\ j

...................................../..~......

01"

IIOTO~

I "(-·-~-~ ij

CTOOMOCTb Ka)I(,QO~

pern:HTb rrpo6AeMy co6cTBeHHbiMH c:HAaMR·

6poc:HA BeTKY «YBeAli'I:HTb pa6o'Iee BpeMH»,

COKpa1111b

tfl'O

'ITO eMy HaAO 3aHHMaTbCH 6eH:c6oAOM H BbiiiOAHHTh Acr

! YaCTOTY llOK)'Tl~

n;eHHOCTHM, MOJKeTe 3aiipOCTO «OTIIHAliTb» ee OT CB()e"

a He IIOAaraTbCH Ha IIOMOIIJ;b CO CTOpOHbl. 0H TaiOKe

CTOOMOC!b Ka)I(,Qoro ~cxa

COKpa1111b

Ma, HAll eCAll OHa IIpOT:HBOpe'I:HT Balli:HM ycTaHOBKaM B

n;eAyro BeTKY «AeHbr:H OT APYTHX JUOAefl», rroToMy

' · ••....._

COKpa1111b

EcAll HAeH He3cpcpeKTHBHa HAll TPYAHoocym;ecTBH·

ro AOrH'IecKoro AepeBa.

KH~fl1

'- - [ 1\pyroe

Cnopn1BHble

-f

HammH

KOH¢e1hl 1\pyroe

•KOMnAKT·A~CK~~~rPbiCTORT \, OYEHb AOPOrO. EC!l~ RCOKPAU1Y \ 3T~ PACXOAbl. 3TO 6YAET ! \'... CYlllECTBEHHAR 3KOHOM~R• •••/ (

~-.,.····-·····--··· ..--···-·······

~ "'

~ ,Q

.I-IanpuM ep , fl'IIIOTe3a A,JKoHa COAepJKHT IIOAOJKeHHe 0

TaiOKe OT6pOCHA BeTKH «l1HBeCTHpOBaTb» 1'1 «l1rp.

,, qTO OH AOAJKeH CMeHHTh pa6ory Ha 6oAee BhiCOKOTOl•>r JlJ\aquBaeMyro. OH C'IHTaeT TaKoe B03MOJKHhiM, rroTo-

B AOTepeiO», IIOCKOAhKY l'IHBeCTHpOBaTb OH He y-M a BepO.SITHOCTh Bhmrphliiia B AOTepeiO CAI'IIIIKOM M

o~fYqTO KaK-TO CAbiiiiaA, 'ITO OAHH ero 3HaKOMhll'I, KeBHH, v

«5! He YMeiO HHBeCTHpoBaTh, a IIIaHChi BhmrpaTh B TepeiO O'leHb IIpH3pa'!Hhl. 3TH HAeH AYlJIIIe OCTaBlf'I'La

noJ\)"'ae T no

8 AOA.I\.apoB B 'lac.

OAHaKo A,JKoH He 3HaeT,

I<aKyro u M eHHO pa6ory BhiiiOAH.HeT KeBHH, crroco6eH AH 0T6pOCHB

HeiiOAJCOA.SI~He

BeTBH 1'1 IIOA'IepKHYB

J1i.

pHaHThl, KOTOphle KaJKYTC.SI eMy HaH60Aee IIpl'IB.I\.eQ. TeAbHhlMH, A,JKoH BhiABHraeT CAeAYJO~YJO fl'IIIOTelJ:

fVKOH Ae AaTh TO JKe caMoe H c~ecTByeT AH

803

Bhl

«5! CMOry KynHTh KOMIIhiOTep B Te'!eHHe IIIeCTH MeQ.

AJ\..SI Hero

tviOJKHOCTh ycTpOHThC.SI Ha 3TY pa6ory. 3aM eTl'IAI'I, ecAH BhlABHHYTh 'leTKYJO rHrroTe3y H

n;eB, eCAH .SI rrepeHAY Ha 6oAee BhlCOKOOIIAa'!HBaeMyio

pa6ory, IIPOAaM HeCKOAhKO KHHr 1'13 CBOeH 6H6AHO'I'e-

xoAHMyro HH¢0pMaiJ;HIO 1'1 IIpOBeCTH 3¢cpeKTI'IBHhlH

KH, He 6yAy IIOKynaTb Hrpbl 1'1 KOMIIaKT-AHCKH».

aHaJ\1'13, 1'1 TaKHM o6pa30M rrpoBepHTh CBOIO fl'IIIOTe3y

o6ocHoBaHHe, 6yAeT ropa3AO Aer'le co6paTh Heo6-

Ha HCTI'IHHOCTh. CBOH MhlCAH A,JKOH 1'1306pa3HA rpaq:m'leCKH B BJW «fl'IIIOTeTH'leCKOH IIHpaMHAhl»

(eM. HUJKe) . 0Ha

COAep-

~l:IG'r~A.?~

JKI'IT OCHOBHYJO fl'IIIOTe3y ( «5! CMOry KynHTh 6hlBIIIJii B ynoTpe6AeHHH KOMIIhiOTep «Apple» 3a

500

AOM4·

no ?.elll.E:lfi'\1-0 n?OSJJ.£M:

pOB B Te'!eHHe IIIeCTH MeC.HIJ;eB»), KOTOpa.H OIIHpaeTCI Ha KOHKpeTHhle YCAOBH.SI (OTBeThl Ha BOIIpOChl

I'~O':r~~'i.te.K.AH ~?.A.l-U'Ul.A

«Kalt

HMeHHO? » HAH « KaKHM o6pa30M? »), BhlCTYIIaiOin;He B fJ.HIOTeTH'!eCKa.H IIHpaMHAa - 1 BeAHKOAeiiHhlH HH-

Ka'!eCTBe 060CHOBaHH.SI rAaBHOH fl'IIIOTe3hl.

CTpJMeHT

1.\1111.

AJ\..SI CTPYKTYP~'~POBaHH.H Baiiieil apfYMeHTa-

ee IIOMO~hiO Bhl MOJKeTe '!eTKO qpOpt'fyAHpO-

BaTb CBOH BhiBOAhll'I l'IX o60CHOBaHHe e~e AO TpfO, KaK /·····K~·;~~~~~~; \

KaK~M o6paJOM? .J .................................. :·:.,.

...

nepe\irn Ha 6onee BbiCOKoonnaY~BaeMyiO

pa6ory

c roAoBoil

..···\

rrorpy3HTech B c6op AaHHhiX H HX aHaAH3.

TaKoli IIOAXOA pe3KO rroBhiiiiaeT rrp0113BOAHTeAhHOCTh.

AaBaliTe Ha HecKOAhKHX rrpHMepax pacc:tytoTpHM, KaK 3TO pa6oTaeT. fiOCMOTpHTe Ha pHCyHOK. florrpo-

6y1he crpynrrHpOBaTh IIyHKThl B KaJKAOH 3~a'le TaKHM o6pa3oM, '!T06hl o6pa30BaAaCh rrHpaMHAaAbHa.H CTPYK-

npo,l\iiTb HecKOnbKO noAep)l(aHbiX KH~r

Typa, OTpaJKaiO~a.H peaAbHhle OTHOIIIeHH.SI.

C~ecTByeT ABa ocHOBHhiX THna rHIIOTeTH'!ecKHX rpynrrHpyro~He CTPYKTYPhl H apfYMeHTHPYio~ae CTPYKTYPhi. 3~a'la 1 (eM. HUJKe) OTHOCHTca « K rpynrrHpyro~RM CTPYKTYPaM. YMo3aKAIO'leHI1e

napaMfiA: Bo3HHKaeT Borrpoc: rro'!eMY :no Bcero AHIIIh runoTe3a, a He OKOH'laTeAhHoe peiiieHHe rrpo6AeMhi?

fJI·

IIOTe3a 6yAeT OCTaBaTbC.SI fl'IIIOTe30H AO Tex rrop, noJC8 A,JKoH He AOKaJKeT, 'ITO TaK OHO 1'1 eCTb.

Mae HpaBHTC.H IIIKOAa» BhlTeKaeT 113 OTAeAhHhiX, Ho

MoaanpaBAeHHhlX J1Aeil: «MHe HpaBHTC.H IIIKOAhHhle

~: IIJI

laAa'la1.

()TBeT1.

·. . . . . >. / i '

tQI

MHe HpaBRTOI WKOnbHble

MHeHpaBifrCll

COOpTIIBHble

WKO!Ia

CeK~~~

MHe HpaBRTOI WKOnbHble nepeMeHbl

(""~~~;··:::::;~

MHe HpaBATCA WKOnbHbley~

MHe HpaBI1TCll WKOna

MHeHpaBRTCll cnopTIIBHble

MHeHpaBRTCll WKOnbHble

ce~~

nepeMeMeHbl

MHe HpaBRTCll ypo~

laAa'la2.

()TBeT2.

nocOCb xopowo

nococb -

nnaaaer

3TO pb16a

nococbxopowo nnaaaer

PbifibiXOpowo nnasaiOT

nococb- 3ro pbl6a

~ Pbl6blxopowo nnaaaiOT

CIIOpTHBHble CeKIJ;HH», «MHe HpdBHTCH lliKOAbHble De· peMeHbi» 11 «MHe HpaBHTCH IIIKOAbHbie ypoKH» . TioMepJKHBaiOm;HMH 6AoKaMH 3Aecb MO:ryT CAYJKHTI>

IIIA.l' 4: n?OS£1?~':r.b .r~nOt:r£3~

OTBeTbl Ha BOIIpOCbl «rroqeMy?», «KaK?» l1 «qTO?», KDTOpble OTHOCHTCH K Bepi.IIH:He IIHpdMHAbi.

apryMeHry, pd3Mem;eHHOMY Ha

rpyrrrrHpyiOIIJ;HX CTp y K'rypax

apryMeHT He rroTepHeT 3HaqeHHH, AaJKe ecAH: OAHH H3 IIOMepJKH:BdlOIIJ;HX 6AOKOB BApyr OKaJKeTCH Henpa· BHAbHbiM.

HdilleM CAyqae Bbl BCe em;e MOJKeTe Bill·

ABHraTb apryMeHT «MHe HpaBHTCH IIIKOAa», A aJKe eCAH yTBepJKAeHHe «MHe HpaBHTCH IIIKOAbHble ypoKH» oKa· JKeTcH AAH Bac HeBepHbiM.

3~aqa 2 TypaM.

I1TaK, A,JI<OH CcpOpMJAHpOBaA rHIIOTe3Y OTHOCHTeAbHO TOro, Kill<HM 06pa30M OH AOCTH:rneT CBOeif IJ;eAH. CAeAyiOIII;HM lliai'OM A,JI<oHa 6yAeT BbiHCHHTh, KaKOH aHaAH3 HHHcpOpMa-

Im51 IIOHaA06HTCH fl1I5I TOro, qro6bl rrpOBepH:Tb 3TJ rHIIOTe3y. KaK Bbi YBJiAH:Te AaAbiiie, fl1I5I BbiHCHeHHH 3Tl1X BorrpocoB Afr<ou BOCIIOAb30BaACH reHepaAbHbiM IIAaHOM pei.IIeHH:H

OTHOCHTCH K apryMeHTHpyiOIIJ;HM CTpyK:

3THX rrHpaMHAax HeCKOAbKo yTBepJKAeHHH

(«J\ococb -

OA. OnPEAEJU1Tb, KAKOVI AHAJ1~3 ~ KAKASI ~H<l>OPMAU~ SI HEOSXOA~Mbl AfiSI nPOBEPK~ r~nOTE3bl

3To pbi6a», «Pbi6bl xopoi.IIo rrAaBaror»J

BeAYT K o6m;eMy YM03aKAIOqeHHIO:

«J\ococb

xopoiii0

IIAaBaeT». EcAH: B apryMeHTHpyiOm;eii CTPYKType, BoTAH:qHe or rpyrrrrHpyiOm;Hx CTPYKTyp, OAHO 113 yTBepJI(· AeHHii AOJKHO, To 11 KOHeqHoe YM03aKAIOqeHH:e 6yAf!f HeBepHo.

!Ipo6AeMbi.

3roT HHCTpYMeHT IIOMOJKeT A;Koey rrpOBepH:Tb

CBOIQ I'l11IOTe3y l1 ee 060CHOBaHH:e, a TaKJKe BbiHCHH:Th, Ka-

Ka5! HHcpOpMau;HH l1 KaKH:e BJ1Abl aHaAH3d eMY 1IOTpe6YlQTCH. lJ:T06bi 1IpOBepHTb CBOIO rrepByiO I'HIIOTe3y «5I CMO-

COKpaTH:Tb 60AbillyiO qaCTb CBOHX paCXOAOB, eCAH:

nepecTaHy IIOKyrraTb Hrpbl l1 KOMIIdKT-AHCKH», A,JKOH Pelllaer CAeAaTb aHaAH3 CBOHX pacxoAOB 3a rrpeAhiAY-

~ae TpH: MecHn;a. 0H COCTdBHT CIIHCOK BCeX CBOHX pac-

90 91

~ ~

XOAOB Hd OCHOBe KBMTdHu;:mi M Mdrd3MHHbiX qeKOJ\

Ilpo.

[loCAe 3Toro AJKoH ITpMCTJIIdeT K dHa.I\H3y. CHdqaAd oH

KdTe~

IlbiTaeTCH ycTdHOBMTb, HdCKOAbKO MOJKeT COKpdTMTb

TdiOKe HdiTp.SIJKeT CBOIO ITdMHTb, qT06bi 3diTOAHMTb 6eAbi. KOrAd OH pdCITpeAe.I\HT CBOM pdCXOAbi ITO

OB.nPOBECTIII AHAJU13111 PA3PA60TATb nllAH

pMHM, KdpTMHd ITPOHCHMTCH, M OH YBMAMT, rAe MMeiiJro CAeAyeT ype3dTb pdCXOAbi M KdKOe BJ\HHHMe 3 TO OIIQ. JKeT Hd KOHeqHbiH pe3yAbTdT.

caou pacxoAhl路

AHaAH3 N~ 1. Ha KaKyiO cyMMY MOX<HO coKparuri> CBOH pacxoAhl?

El ~

flo ABYM OCTdAbHbiM rMITOTe3dM OH TdiOKe COCTilBIIA

f:VKOH HaqMHdeT C TOrO, qTO BCITOMMHdeT M 3diTMChl-

ITOA06HbiH ITAdH AeHCTBMH, B qeM Bhl MOJKeTe y6e AH'l\.

saeT BCe, qTO OH ITOKyrraA 3d ITOCAeAHMe TpM MeCHIJ;d:

ITepb eMy HCHO, qTo AeAdTb AdAbiiie:

c.SI, M3yqMB reHepdAbHbiH: ITAdH A,JI<oHd

e e e e

(eM. HUJKe) . Te-

芦J.1raK, B ITpOIIIAOM MecHu;e H KyrrMA OAHY BMAeoMrpy 3d

9 AOMdpOB M OAHY IIIOKOAdAKY 3d 1 AOAAdp. l.JTO eu:r;e? Ax Aa, KaJKAbiH MeCHIJ; H ITOKyrrdiO ITO OAHOMJ JKypHaAY 4 AOAAdpd M

COCTdBMTb CTPYKTJPY pdCXOAOB M ITAdH COKJ>a路 u:r;eHMH pdCXOAOB;

c KOMMKCaMM 3d

IIpOBecTM ITOMCK dKTMBOB M5I IIpONlJKM M aHaAM3 ~

THBHbiH HdiTMTOK禄.

ITOCAe KdJKAOH TpeHMpOB-

KH no 6eH:c6oAy ITO cy66oTdM H IToKyrrdiO ce6e ciTop-

OITpOCMTb APY3eH: OTHOCMTeAbHO MX ITOApa60TOK; OITpOCMTb

COCeAeH

OTHOCMTeAbHO

B03MOJKBo-

l.fCITOAb3YH 3TOT CTporo HdyqHbiH MeTOA, pdCITMCdB CBOH ITOKyrrKM, AJKOH ITpMIIIeA K TdKOMY pdCKAdAY ITO

CTeH ITOApd60TKM y HMX.

CBOHM pacXOAdM 3a ITpOIIIAbie TPM MecHu;d: Bonpoc

1. HacxonbKO RMary COKpaOOb CBOO paCXOA!>?

MeCJIUHalall

CnopTHBHbl~ Han~OK:

CnopTHBHbl~ Han~oK:

CnoprnsHbl~ Han~OK:

CnopTHBHbl~ Han~TOK:

CnopTHBHbl~ Han~OK:

CnoprnsHbl~ Han~OK:

CnopTHBHbl~ Han~OK:

Cnop!HBHbl~ Han~oK:

CnoprnBHbl~ Hafl~OK:

CnopTHBHbl~ HaflHTOK:

(nopTHBHbl~ Hafl~OK:

Kot.4HKC

KOM~KC:

KOMHKC:

MaraJ~Hbl;

llbtoflaAKa:

WOKonaAKa:

WOKOflaAKa:

BiiA~rpa:

KoMnaKT-AHCK:

npo.Q<JTba~sbl

KHIOO!ble 11HTepHeTMaraJHHbl

llroro

s18

11roro:

$18

11roro:

pac ecn~

2. UOflbKO RCMory BbiJlY'l~

HaBepHOe, RCMOf)'

a~BOB,

Bblp)'l~

or npo.Q<J)I(I1 KOTopbie MHe 6onbwe He ~bl?

CocrasneHHe nnaHa COKpaiJ.IeH~R paCXOAOB: pac~~aTb, HacKOflbKO RMOf)' COKpaOOb CBOO paOIOAbi

flol1cx a~BOB AflR

MORKQMHala;

TOflbKO KOM~KCbl

npo.Q<J)I(I1: onpeAen~. KaKHe a~Bbl MOJml BbiCTas~ Ha npoA<JJKY

M<li1110Asa11

AHanl13 ~eH: HJ)'I~. no KaKO~ ~eHe MOJml

6~HI1CTlfll'OII

3. HacxonbKO 6onbwe RCMory Japa6oraTb, ecn~ nepeiiAy Ha 6onee

RCMO!)'

HeJHao, ..eM

On poe APYJe~: mpoc~

OnpocAPYJI!Ii

ysen~~

JaH~MaeTCR Kes~H.

(8010 lapnnal'f

HO RCflbiWan, 'flO OH

y flRT\1 APYJe~. CKOflbKO OHH JapafialbiBaKlT

Onpocc~

BbiCOKoonn~~BaeMyKl

c3Aonnapos

Japa6alblsaer no 8

pa6ory?

B~A08

AOnnaposs~

AOnnapos B~

MeCRUil

RMOf)' npo.Q<JTb

OKOno15 AOnnapos

I 1311E'CR\li! HaJall

CnoprnBHbl~ Han~oK:

~ac

nepecraH)' noK)'naTb ~rpbl ~ KOMnaKTAOO<H

__J 12t.II!Cll(la HaJall

Onpoc COCf'Aeii: on~ nRTepbiX COCf'Aeii HBbiRCJj~, ecTb flH y H~X pa6ora AflR MeHR HCXOflbKO OHH nnarRT

3aTeM A,JI<oH ITOACqMThlBdeT, KdKyiO CYMMY OH B CpeAHeM TpdTMA B MeCHIJ; Ha KaJKAhlH BMA ITOKyrrOK, M C03AaeT TdKyiO KpyrOByiO AlfdrpdMMy:

lJTo6bl onpeAeAHTh HaHAyqiiiHH cnoco6 ype3aTh

GPYK1YPA PACXOAOB 3A nOCilEAH~E 3 MEC~l.(A 100% = $15

cBOI1 paCXOAhl, AJKoH AOAJKeH paCCMOTpeTh 3TOT BO-

•

WOK0fl3AK~

Ase caMbte KpynHble CTalb~

~rpbl

~ ..Q

n p OC C ':Byx TO'leK 3peHH51:

paaOAOB

CMOJKeT AH OH OTKa3hiBaTh ce6e B 3TOH

u;11H AO TeX nop, noKa He AOCTHrHeT CBOeH n;eAH.

110311 T o'IHO TaK JKe, KaK H poK-rp ynna «./\ro6oBh H Myxo-

r.fOpb!» H3 npOIIIAOfO ypoKa, A,JKOH CHCTeMaTH3HpyeT

E ~

'/.OAOB H

CnopTI1BHb1e HanffiKl1

20%

1) HaCKOAbKO ycTpaHeHHe

J(aJKAOI1 n03HI.J;HH nOBAH51 eT Ha COKparn;eHHe ero pac-

CB011 M biCAH npH nOMOIIJ;H MaTp Hll;bi: KOMnaKT - 1100(~ CPEAHEMECHYHbiE PACXOAbii\)I(OHA nPOT~B B03MO)I(HOG~ OTKA3A OTH~X

f l OCMOTp eB Ha CBOID KpyrOByiD AHarpaMMy , AJKOH Ha'IHHaeT nOHHMaTh,

'ITO

ero

nepBOHa'la.AbHa.SI rH·

BbiCOK~· !

noTe3a 0 TOM, 'ITO OH CMOJKeT COKpaTHTb 60Ablll)'IO

'!aCTb CBOHX paCXOAOB, npeKpaTHB noKyrraTb Hrphl H AeHhrH B ocHOBHOM yxoA.SJ:T Ha noKyrrKy cnopTHBHbii

'; l

HanHTKOB H KOMHKCOB. XOT.SI 3TH TOBapbl CTO.SIT AeiiieB·

~ :

HX ropa3AO qarn;e. A,JKOH 03a6o'leH CBOHM OTKpbiTHeM.

" : -~ !

AYMaeT oH. -

MH, KOTOpbie HX TOAbKO H 06CyJKAaiOT! » 0Ka3hiBaeTCB, eCTb BeiiJ;H, OT KOTOpbiX A,JKOH fOTOB OTKa3aTbC.SI, HO

•

lKOMnaKT·I\00(~ 3

~rpbi

••

~ :

WOKOfl3AK3

" '

u~ ~.

•

eCAH .S1 nepecTaHy 'IHTaTh CBOH

KOMHKCbl, TO MHe He o '!eM 6yAeT noroBopHTh c APY3hll·

•

~ :

TiocAe TpeHHpOBOK no 6eM:c6oAy MHe

TaK XO'leTC.SI nHTb!

CnopTI1BHble Hani1TK~

•

Ae, '!eM BHAeOHrpbi H KOMnaKT·AHCKH, OH n oKyrraeT

HanHTKOB? I1 OT MOHX AI06HMbiX KOMHKCOB TOJKe? -

KoM~KCbl

KOMnaKT·AHCKH, oKa3aAach HeBepHolf. Ha caMOM AeAe,

«HeyJKeAH MHe npHAeTc.SI OTKa3aTbC.SI oT cnopTHBHhii

H~JK~

--1 O

Mary OTXaJalbCll

He Mary OTXaJalbCll

................................................................~ Bb16op 1\JKoHa

eCTb H TaKHe, OT KOTOpbiX OH He OTKaJKeTC.SI HH 3 a 'ITO. KaK BHAHTe, A,JKoH paHJKHpOBaA CBOH cpeAHeMeC.SI'l-

I1TaK, TO, OT qero A,JKOH fOTOB OTKa3aTbC51:

Hhre pacxOAhi no BepTHKa.AbHOH ocn. Ha ropH30HTa.Ab-

CAyniaTh HOBble KOMnaKT·AHCKH;

Hoii OCR CAeBa OH pa3MeCTHA Te n03Hll;HH, OT KOTOpblX

e HrpaTb B HOBble Hrpbl.

OH He MOJKeT OTKa3aTbC51, a cnpaBa -

Teneph nepetieHb Toro, oT qero A,JKoH He r oTOB

01'·

Te, OT KOTOpbiX

MO)KeT 0TKa3aTbC51.

Ka3aTbC51: e nHTb CnOpTHBHbie HanHTKH nOCAe TpeHHpOBOJ( no 6eM:c6oAy; e 'IHTaTb KOMHKChi; e

eCTb IIIOKOAaAKH.

KaK TOAbKO A,JKoH pa3MeCTHA Bee no3HI.J;HH Ha Mal'p»u;e, e My MOMeHTa.AbHO CTaAO BHAHO, 'ITO B nepByro Ol!epeAb eMy CAeAyeT OTKa3aThC51 OT KOMnaKT·AHCKOB H IllfA,eon rp. 0HH nonaAH B BepXHHH npaBhiH yroA, a 3TO

~ 1IJ

3Ha'IHT, 'ITO OT HHX .1\.erKO OTKa3aThC51 H OHH 0Kd3h1Jie. lOT CH.I\.bHOe B.I\.HHHHe Ha cpeAHeMeCH'!HbiH 06neM

Pat.

XOAOB. C Apyroi:f: CTOpOHhl, IIIOKOAdAKa IIOIIaAa B AeBiili

'faKlfM o6pa30M, AJKOH Hallie.!\. B03MOJKHOCTb COKpa-

rJ:iTb cBOlf paCXOAhl C

AOMapOB B MeCHI.J; AO

AOA-

apOB B MeCHI.J;. 3TO yse.I\.H'IHT o6rn;yiO CyMMY ero c6e-

HHJKHHH yroA, a 3TO 3Ha'!HT, 'ITO AJKoH TpaTHT Ha ~~

~e)KeHlfH

He TaK yJK MHoro AeHer, Aa H OTKa3hiBaThCH OT Hee lie

Tenepb A»<oHa OTAeMeT OT ero Me'!Thl pa3phlB BCero

XO'leT. l1 IIOCKO.I\.bKY B.I\.HHHHe IIIOKO.I\.dAKH Ha YPOB~III.

:3 ~

paCXOAOB HeBe.I\.HKO, AJKoH peiiiaeT He MOpO'IHTb Ce()e

AOJ\..1\.dpOB ( 10 AOJ\..1\.apOB X

MeCHI.J;eB).

188 AoMapoB. TaK BhirMAHT cxeMa, rAe YKa3aH pa38 pb!B Ha 3TY CyMMY:

rOAOBY H3-3a TdKHX Me.I\.O'!ei:f: H IIOKyiiaTb ee H ACl.l\.b!Ue. pAJPbiB MEJI(AY nPOrH03V1PYEMbiMV1 C6EPEJKEHV1HMV1 Vll.lEHO~ KOMnbiOTEPA Ho BOT KaK HaC'!eT KOMHKCOB H CIIOpTHBHhlX HdDHT·

$188

KOB? AJKoHy He xo'leTCH OTKa3hiBaTh ce6e B 3TOM YAoBO.I\.bCTBHH, HO, C Apyroi:f: CTOpOHhi, ec.I\.H eMy pelliHTClJ

$60

BCe-TaKH He IIOKyiiaTb HaiiHTKOB H KOMHKCOB, 3TO OKa·

$500

c6epelKeH~R 01

JKeT 60.1\.biiiOe B.I\.HHHHe He o6rn;Hi:f: ypoBeHh paCXOAOB. AJKoH peiiiaeT rrpoBeCTH M03roBo:H: IIITYPM Ha TeMy:

Pa3pb1B

AononH~TenbHble COKpa~eH~R

$252

paCXOAOB

«KaK COKpaTHTb paCXOAhi Ha KOMHKChl H CIIOpTiiBHHe HaiiHTKH?» l.lenb (~eHa KOMnbiOTepa)

nporHOJ~pyet.4bie

B pe3y.l\.bTaTe y AJKoHa poJKAaiOTCH 6AeCTHrn;He HAeH. BMeCTO TOrO 'IT06hl IIOKyiiaTb CIIOpTHBHhie HdiiHTKH B

cflepelKeH~R Ja 6 Meal~eB (npo.QOJ1lKa~HaT~X ycroB~RX)

6ape Ha CTdAJ.IOHe, OH BeAh MOJKeT KyiiHTb 60.1\.ee Aeme· ByiO BHTaMHHH0-6e.I\.KOByiO CMeCh, H3 3TOrO IIOpOIIIKa rrpHrOTOBHTb AOMa CIIOpniBHbiH HaiiHTOK H rrpHHeCTH ero C co6oi:f: Ha TpeHHpOBKY B TepMOCe. l.JTO KacaeTCJI

AHa.11.u3

NQ 2. KaKyiO cyMMY NKOH MO.>KeT BbipY'JHTb or npoAa.>KH

HeHy.lKHbiX aKTUBOB1

KOMHKCOB, TO OH peiiiaeT IIOKyiiaTb HX B CK.I\.aA'lHHY' C ApyroM. AJKoH IIOAC'lHTaA, 'ITO, BHecH TaKHe H3MeHeHHH B CBOH 6IOAJKeT, OH C3KOHOMHT Ha IIOKyiiKe cnop· THBHhlX HaiiHTKOB H KOMHKCOB u;e.l\.biX

11TaK, fyKOflY OCTaeTCH IIOKphlTb pa3phlB B

Bem;e:H:, KOTophle 6o.l\.biiie He HYJKHhl eMY H ero ceMhe.

50%.

OH Ha'!HHaeT co cBoe:H: KOMHaThi. HaxoAJ.IT cTorrKy KO-

EMECHYHbiEPACXO!Il noJ~~R

YlOAeJlalb

PaHbwe

CM!ac

3KQHOIIII

MHKCOB H HOBeXOHbKHH C.I\.OBaph, KOTOpbiH HH pa3y AaJKe

Cnopn1BHble Han~~

nepeiffi1 Ha nopoWOK, ypeJalb paCXQAbl Ha 50%

He OTKpbl.l\. {IIOTOMY 'ITO rrpeAITO'lHTaeT IIO.I\.b30BaThC51 3AeKTpOHHbiMH C.I\.OBapHMH). l13yqaeT Be6-cai:f:Thl, rAe

KoM~Kcbl

noKYnalb BCKJlaA~~Hy, ypeJalb paCXOAbl Ha 50%

npeMaraiOT KHHrH, KOTOpbie KTO-TO yJKe IIpO'IHTaA H

Km.maKT-~C~

OlxaJa!bCR, JKOHOM~R 100%

Vlrpbl

O!KaJalbCR, 3KOHOMI1ll100%

WOKOJlaAI(a

npoAOI!lKalb noKynalb

~10

Vlloro

PeiUH.I\. rrpoAaTh. Tiopa3MhlC.I\.HB, fyKoH rrpHXOAJ.IT K Bhi-

S15

BoAy, 'ITO CMOJKeT BbipyqHTh 3a CBOH KHHrH

25 AOMapoB.

3aTeM AJKoH oTrrpaBMeTCH B rroABaA. TaM, pa3o-

6PaBIIIHCh

c rraYTHHOH, Koe-'ITO HaxOAHT. CoBceM ern;e

A.o6poTHyiO CyMKY

188 AOJ\..1\.a-

POB. 0H o6cAeAyeT CBOIO KOMHary H IIOABaA B IIOHCKax

A.J\.51

ro.l\.b¢a. Ee KOrAa-To BbmrpaA

QTo6pa3HM AeftcTBHH A,JKoHa Ha cxeMe: pA3PbiB MEJI<AY nPOrH03~PYEMbiM~ C6EPEJKEH~~M~ ~ l.lEHO~ KOMnbiOTEPA

~ .Q

::! ~

$50 $60

AononHHTeJlbHble

$252

nporno3~pyeMbte

roe~eH~~ 33 6MeOIUeB (npono~01J111001

no-

OTeD; A,JKoHa Ha KOprropaTHBHhlX COpeBHOBaHIDIX. TOM rrep'IaTKY AJ\5I. 6eftc6oAa, KOTOpYJO A,JKOH OAeBaABa nrpy ern;e B rrepBOM KAacce. A TaiOKe aKKypaTHO CAOJKeHHYJO OAeJKAy, H3 KOTOpoft OH AaBHO yJKe BhlpOC. « 3Ta CYMKa AJ\5I. ro.l\.h¢a, AOAJKHO 6b1Tb, CTOHT K'f'IY Her! - MbiCAHT BCAyx A,JKOH. - 5I yaepeH, 'ITO y ~ ecTh APyraH CYMKa, KOTopoft oH AeftcTBHTe.l\.hHO rroAJ>· 3yeTC51. A 6eftc60J\.hHaH rrep'IaTKa H CTapaH OAe~ AOAJKHhi 6hlTh KaK pa3 Brropy MAaAIIIeMY 6pary Moel'O Apyra. 0TAaM-Ka 5I eMY BCe :no - BOT OH o6paAyeTOI!» MaMa pa3peiiiaeT AJ!coHY ocyrn;ecTBHTh ero 3aAyM· KY· ECAH '!eCTHO, oHa eMY AaJKe o'leHh rrpH3HaTeAbHa 3il y6opKy B IIOABaAe. «TaM BHH3Y TaKOH 6ecrrop.HAOK, rOBOpHT OHa. - Y HaC CKOIIHAOCb CTOJ\.hKO pa3H01'0 XAaMa, KOTOphlM Mhl HHKOrAa He IIOJ\.h3yeMC.H! » A,JKoH IIOAIIPhirHyA oT PaAOCTH H TYT JKe rroM'IaAc.ll ll 6AHJKaHIIIHH CIIOpTHBHhlH Mara3HH, 'IT06hi IIOHHTep6" COBaTbC.H, CKOJ\.hKO OH MOJKeT IIOAY'!HTb 3a CyMKY fJI-J ro.l\.h¢a. EMY rrpeMaraiOT 25 AOAAapoB. l1TaK, 25 AOAAapOB 3a KHHJKKH H 25 AOAAapoB 3a c'f"' Ky. «TipeBOCXOAHO! - BOCKAHKHYA A,JKOH. - 5I coKpl" THA pa3phlB ern;e Ha 50 AOAAapOB! »

c6epe~eH~~ 01 COKpalJ1eH~ ~

Pa3pb1B

AoxOAOT

npoA<IJI(l1 31m1BOB

paCXOAOB

npoool~pyeMbiH

AOXOAJa6 MeOIUeB

Hal~X

ycnos~~x)

Terreph A,JKoHy AJ\5I. ocyrn;ecTBAeHHH ero Me'IThi HeAOCTaeT 138 AOAAapoB. l.JT06hi IIOKphlTb OCTaBIIIHHC.H pa3pbiB, ·eMy rrpeACTOHT HaRTH 6oAee BhiCOKOOIIAa'IHBaeMYJO pa6ory.

AHaAH3 NQ 3. Ha KaKyiO cyMMY A*oH MOJKer noBbiCHTb CBOH AOCMeHHB pa6ory?

XOA,

~ "'

~ ,Q

~ E r!

A;KoH Ha'!HHaeT c Toro, 'ITO paccnpaiiiHBaeT

IUrre.

phlx CBOHX APY3e:H: o TOM, KaK OHH IIOApa6aThiBalO! CB060AHOe BpeMH If CKOAhKO HM 3a 3TO IIAaTHT.

96t

aTeM f:Vl<.OH o6oiiieA CBOHX COCeAeH If OCBeAOMHA-

" ae rrpeMaraiOT AH OHH KaKyiO-HH6YAh pa6ory. BoT C~>r

q'l'O oBJil eMY OTBeTJiiAH.

'ITO eMy YAaAOCh pa3y3HaTh. Kai< BJiiAJiiTe, A;KoH JKHBeT B ropoAKe, rAe ycTaHOBHXyaH

«~ nowa6alb1Bal0 ryeepHaHTOM y CBOOX COCe,Qe\1»

hJICb aeBhlCOKHe pacu;eHKH Ha HeKBaAHcpHIJ;HpOBaH-

B~n~H

«Y MeHRABa po.QHbiX !13b1Ka- RflOHCX~~ ~ aHrn~Va~~. OOTOMY YTO RAflloiTenbHDe

!IbiH TPYA· HHKTO He npeMOJKHA eMy pa6ory, rAe oH cMOf 6h1 3apa6aThlBaTh 60Ahiiie 3 AOMapoB B 'laC, KO-

BpeMR )I(Wl B~flOH~~. ~ npenoAaiO RflOHCX~~ !13biK BfOpo,QCXOM OOpa30BaTenbHOM ~eHTpe•

Xaebep

ropbie OH yJKe If TaK IIOAY'!aeT.

·~ mo6n10 co6aK, a~ poAlllen~ He xom KYnloffb MHe ~eHKa. no3roMy MaR rerR pa3pewaer MHe Bblryn~eaTb ee co6aKY. ~ roros AenaTb 310 6ecnnaTHO, HO OHa HaCTa~eaer Ha

onnare Mo~x yCJJyr»

KeB~H

«~ COJAall ee6-ca~ AflR ¢~pMb1 MDefO 0~ ~ o6 3TOM Y3HaJ1 BeCb fOpDA. Tenepb R BblnOJlHRIO HecKOnbKO JaKa30B Ha pa3paOOfKY ca~OB OAHOBpeMeHHO»

n~ana~

«~ Bblryn~BaiO COCe,QCKyiO Co6aKY, HO nnam MHe MaJlOBaTO»

A qTo6hl 3apa6oTaTh 138 AOMapoB 3a IIIeCTh MecH~eB, eMY Heo6XOAHMO noBhlCHTh cBo:H: eJKeMeCH'!HhlH apa60TOK Ha 23 AOMapa B MeCHIJ;; 3TO 3Ha'IHT, 'ITO IIO3 qaCOBaH OIIAaTa AOAJKHa B03paCTH IIO'ITH Ha 6 AOMapoB. KaJKeTCH, noAoJKeHHe 6e3BhiXOAHOe. TaK qTo JKe, Teneph A;KoH AOAJKeH CAaThcH? MAH Bee JKe cyru;eCTByeT KaKOH-TO CIIOC06 IIOKpbiTh OCTaBIIIHH-

KaKHe BhlBOAhi Mhl MOJKeM CAeAaTh, H3Y'!HB H rrpoa·

CH pa3pbiB?

HaAH3HpOBaB HHcpOpMaiJ;HIO B Ta6AHu;e? CHaqaAa A;KoH 'IYTh 6hlAO He Bhi6pocHA 6eAhl:H: A;KoH IIpHXOAlfT K BhiBOAYr 'ITO eCAH 06A~aTh OCOOY· MH 3HaHHHMH H

YMeHHHMH, HanpHMep, Be6-Alf3almOM

¢11.ar, HO BCe JKe peiiiHA IIpHMeHHTh TBOp'!eCKHH IIOAXOA K IIOHCKY pa60Thi, rAe OH CMOJKeT IIOAY'!aTh 6o;u,-

HAH HHOCTPaHHhiMH H3hlKaMH, TO MOJKHO 3apa6a'ThiBMI>

liie, He YBeAH'IHBaH BpeMH pa6oThi.

OT 6 AO 8 AOMapOB B '!aC. EcAH He'!eM oco6eHHO 6AeCIJY'l'b.

6AecrHru;aH HAeH.

TO If OIIAaTa 6yAeT 6oAee CKpOMHOH. 0H TaKJKe OTMeqaeT, 'ITO

AOMapa B 'laC, KOTOphle eMY IIAaTHT 3a BhlryA CO"

6aKH, -

3TO AaAeKo He TaK YJK IIAoxo, TaK KaK APyrHM 3a

TaKYJO JKe pa6ory IIAaTHT BCero IIO

2 AOMapa B 'laC.

«A qTo,

11 ero TaKH oceHHAa

ecAH H 6yAy BhiryAHBaTh Ha ABe co6aKH 6o;u,-

liie B OAHO H TO JKe BpeMH? BhrryAHBaH TPH co6aKH OAHOBpeMeHHO, H CMOry IIOAY'!aTh IIO

AOMapoB B 'laC!

KorAa-To B Hhro-HopKe H BHAeA IIOA06HyiO KapTHHy. Coce.Q

KOMMeHTa~~

M~ep Pa~

TaKTe6e ~a pa6ora? MO)I(etlJb Bblryn~BaTb Hawy Co6aKy, HO Mbl He BCOCTORH~~ nnaTM1b MHOfO. KaK Ha<:'leT 3AOMapoB B~ac)

M~crep KeH~

Tbi MO)I(etllb n~Marp~eaTb Ja HaW~M~ AeTbM~) Hawa HRHR nepeeKana BAPyrOO ropoAMb16yAeM nnarloffb re6e no 2AOnnapa e~c

M~ep n~Kacco

X~b crnpaTb ~ rnaAlllb Hawe 6enbe Ja 2,5 Aonnapa e~?

Bor 3AopoBo! » NKoH cnpaiiiHBaeT y coceAeH pa3peiiieHHH BhiryAHBa~h Bcex HX co6aK OAHOBpeMeHHO. Bcex TpoHx coceAeH 3TO ycTpaHBaeT, OHH AaJKe p~hl IIOMO'Ih A;KOHY I<ynHTb KOMIIhiOTep If ocyru;eCTBHTh ero rOAAHBYACKyiO

M~c~ WaHenb

no~ny~. Tbl MQ)I(etlJb Bblryn~eaTb MOIO Co6aKY. He 3Hal0 TOnbKO, cnpaB~WbCR n~ Tbl-~·~ 0Ha AOBOnbHO KpynHaR, naer Ha niOAeli ~ 6pocaerCR Ha APYrltX co6aK. Tb1 MO)I(etllb flOI"'' "'~ ~ 6yAy nn.Jrloffb re6e 3AOnnapa B~c

M~ep K~Hr

MO)I(etllb y{iHpaTb CeHO c Haweli n~HK~. a OCeHbiO crpe6aTb n~CTbR. KaK HaC'ET 3AOMapoB B~)

~e'lTy. «KOrAa CTaHeiiih 3HaMeHHThlM, IIpHeAeiiih - IIIYTJiiAH OHH.

MIUh HaM aBTorpacp! »

,...Teneph y A;KoHa ecTh 3aMe'IaTeAhHhlH nAaH! ·pH~cxeMY.

CMo-

101 100

nPOrH03HPYEMbiH AOXOA 3A 6 MEO!LtEB

'\\I

~ .Q

~ t

---. $252

$60

$50

AononHmenbHble c6epexeH~R 33

AoxoA or npoAilX~ 3KTl1BOB

\\lt1

noBbUI~I'ie

AOXOAOB33C'leT

Bblryna 6onbwero KOn~COOaK

,\It''

C'leTCH~eH~R

paCXOAOB

BamH c ~OHOM AeRCTBHH MOJKHO Bhlpa3HTh cpop-

npon«>3~pyeMble

c6epexeH~R

MYAOR. BoT KaK paccqHThiBaeTcH pe3y.l\..bTaTHBHOCTh

Me014eB

33 6 Ml'Cll4eB

(npoAonxaiOUjHOOI

AeHCTBHH

HaT~

AJ\..51 AOCTHJKeHH51 u;e.I\..H:

ycnoo~RX)

PBYnbTAT = 3<l><l>EKTI!1BHOCTb nnAHA x KA'-IECTBO 111cnonHEH1!1!1

K?l'l'rM'i.tc:lKM SA.~~bi~ lllA.l'

l..ITo6hr A06HThC51 HaHAyqiiiero pe3y.l\..bTaTa, BaM He-

~OH TPYAHAC51, HH Ha MHHJTY He OTCTJITd51 OT ycTa·

o6xoAHM KdK 3cpcpeKTHBHhiH IT.I\..dH, TdK H 6AeCT51Iu;ee

HOB.I\..eHHOro ITOPHAKd AeHCTBHH, OITHCdHHOro B Haqa·

ero HCITO.I\..HeHHe. Ec.I\..H 6yAeT qTO-TO OAHO, HO He 6yAeT

Ae 3Toro ypoKa. OH ITOCTaBHA ITepeA co6o:H qeTK}'IO

'iero-To Apyroro, TO BaM He yAaCTCH AOCTHrHJTh u;e.I\..H.

u;e.l\..b, oiTpeAe.I\..HA pa3Mep pa3phiBa MeJKAy cBoen ~e·

BaM o6SI3aTe.l\..bHO

Heo6XOAHMO H TO, H Apyroe.

.1\..biO H TeKyru;eif CHTJdiJ;Heif, CcpOpMy.I\..HpOBa.l\.. rliUO"

KorAa y Bac YJKe roToB KOHKpeTHhiH ITAaH AeifcTBHH

61i

no AOCTHJKeHHIO u;e.I\..H, He 3a6yAbTe COCTdBHTh KOH-

ITpeOAOAeTh 3TOT pa3pbiB H ITpOBepHA BCe ITO.I\..OJKeHHJI

KpeTHhlH rpacpHK. 3aiTHIIIHTe BCe, qTO HaMepeHhi CAe-

cBoe:H rHITOTe3hi Ha ITpeAMeT ocyru;ecTBHMOCTFL Ta·

h.dTh R KOrAa HMeHHO.

KHM o6pa30M, OH ITOAOIIIe.l\.. K CdMOMY BdJKHOMY mary: HCITO.I\..HeHHe.

llpOABRJKeHH51 K IJ;e.I\..H H ITO Mepe He06XOAlfMOCTH BHO-

Te3y OTHOCHTe.l\..bHO TOrO, KdKHM 06pa30M OH MOr

He 3a6h!Ba:HTe

ocyru;ecTB.I\..SITh MOHHTOpHHr cBoero

CirrJ, KoppeKTHBhi B cBo:H II.I\..aH. QqeHh peAKO B JKH3HH

~OH pa3pa60Ta.l\.. Be.I\..HKO.I\..eiTHhiH IT.I\..dH AOCTHJI(eHH51 CBOeif u;e.I\..H -

KyrrHTh KOMIThiOTep Apple 3d meC'I'i'

MecHu;eB. KoHeqHo JKe, Ha 3TOM He CTOHT ocTaaaBJ\11· 0 BaThCH! TIAaH Heo6XOAHMO pea.I\..H30BaTh! BeAh HMeHII OT HCITO.I\..HeHH51 II.I\..aHa 3dBHCHT pe3y.l\..bTdT Te Bhl u;e.I\..H H.I\..H ReT.

102

AOCTHfHII•

Bee JiAeT ITO II.I\..aHJ. l..JTO, eC.I\..H BAPyr KTO-TO H3 COCeAeH PeiiiRT,

:Th,

CaM 6yAeT Bhlry.I\..HBdTh CBOIO C06aKJ? EC.I\..H

TaKoe C.l\..yqHTCSI, Bhl TeiTeph He CTaHeTe ITaHHKOnoToMy qTo YJKe 3HaeTe, KaK HdAO peiiiaTh ITpo6Ae-

~ l. Or Bac TPe6yeTC51 Bcero .1\..HIIIh B oqepeAHoif pa3 ITpH. elilin, MeTOA, KOTOphiH Mhl H3yqaeM B 3TOH KHHre!

103

~: ..,.

~· 0• !).II

lQI ~.

,q•

}oil

<•

:a· tql

!).II

~· tl•

~· :s:•

;;: eTH, KOTOphle YMelOT pernaTh npo6AeMhi, OTAH'IaIOTCH 3aBlfAHhlM YMeHneM np:aHnMaTh perneHHH. TaiOKe OHH peAKO CO)KaAelOT 0 CAeAaHHOM Bbi6ope.

A l1

~TO nepeA 3THM yAeAHlOT AOCTaTO~HO speAA5l TOfO, ~T06hl TID;aTeAbHO B3BeCHTb BCe HMelO~HeC5l BapHaHThl H Bbi6paTb HMeHHO TO perneHHe, KOTOpoe Han6oAee BbirOAHO AAH HHX caMHX.

Bee noTOMY, MeHH

Ha 3TOM ypoKe Mhl paccMoTpHM, KaK Knsn, lOHaH 3Be3Aa cpyT6oAa, pernaeT sonpoc Bbi6opa cnopTHBHOR

108

109

"' ~

g ~

:3 ~

IIIKOAbl. K11B11 - )'MHilll AeBO'!Ka, 11 OHa H11KOrAa He IJo. Ae3eT B BOAy, He 3Hilll 6pOAa. l1TaK, K11B11 BAI06AeHa B ¢YT60A c caMoro p oX<AeiiJia f1peACTaBMieTe, OHa AIDKe OAHOBpeMeHHO 11 Haq<L\a!(). A11Th, 11 B ¢YT60A 11rpaTb! KaJKAbiH AeHh, n pH: A106oi norOAe, no AOpore B IIIKOAy, OHa, nepe6paChiBCUI CJIOi MHq c HOr11 Ha Hory, oTpa6aThiBaeT AP116AHHr 11 BbJAe. AbiBaeT C H11M BCHK11e ¢11HThi. EM: He MeiiiaeT HH: CHer, H11 JKapa. K11B11 - AeBO'!Ka CAHIIIKOM M11H11aTIOpHilll 11 xpyn. Killl AMI ¢YT60Aa. Ho 6AarOAapH CBOeH MOAHHeHOCHOH CKOpOCT11, AOBKOCT11 11 BhiAaiO~eMyCH 11HA11BJ1AYCIAJr HOMY MacTepcTBY oHa C)'MeAa cTaTh BeAHKOAeiiiWM 11rpOKOM 11 ceH:qac HBMieTCH BeA~eH HanaAaiOru;eH &a· IJ;110HaAbHOH C60pHOH KOMaHAhi IOH110pOB no ¢YT60.fLy. l1 3TO TOAbKO HaqaAo, BeAh K11B11 yq11TCH BCero AHUU. B AeBHTOM KAacce! Bne'IaTMieT, npaBAa? K11B11 KaK pa3 BepHyAaCh CO CBOeH KOMaHAOH H3 MB· poBoro TYPHe. BciO AOpory o6paTHO 11 ceH:qac AOMa oHa AYMaAa TOAhKO o6 OAHOM: KaK nepeexaTh B 6pa· 311A11IO, qTo6b1 TaM TpeH11poBaThCH. f1o'IeMy? AeAO B TOM, 'ITO APYJKeCK11H MaT'! c KOMaHAOH IOHHopoB Bpa311A1111 ee KOMaHAa ChirpaAa yJKacao: n poHrpaM co C'IeTOM 0 : 10. A rAaBHoe - K11B11 ae MOrAa a6co· AIOTHO H11'Iero noAeAaTh. Bpa311AhiJ;hi 6biA11 npocTO Ayqiiie B AI060M acneKTe 11rphi. l1 TOrAa, nOCAe H:rpbl, K11B11 nOHHAa: ecAH XO'Ieiiib CTaTb 11rpOKOM MH:pOBOro KAacca, HaAO TpeH11poBaThCH 11 11rpaTh B 6oAee rrpo· AB11HYTOH KOHKypeHTHOH cpeAe.

~,r-tSVl l:IAtfl'tl:IA.£'r noPtC.K I(uBI1 AI0611T np11KAIO'IeH11H. KaK TOAbKO oHa np11H11r.faeT KaKoe-H116YAh peiiieH11e, TO 6e3 npoMeAAeH11H epercH 3a AeAo. CHa'IaAa IO;raH cnopTcMe~Ka cn~oc116 ;.a pa3peiiieH115I y pOAJ1TeAe11, MOJKHO Al1 e11 nepe11T11 B lliKOAy. ToAbKO AMI 3Toro HyJKHO 6yAeT nepeex:arb B Bpa3HAHIO. f1oTOMY 'ITO oHa, K11B11, Me'ITaeT TaM yqurocH 11rpaTh B <Py_:r6oA. TpoHYThie peiii11MOCThiO 11 oAep)l(H:MOCThiO CBOe11 AO'Iep11, pOAJ1TeAH COrAaCHAHCh. Ho oHI1 B3HAH c AeBO'IK11 o6e~aH11e, 'ITO Ta He 3a6pocur yqe6y. KpoMe 3Toro, npeAAOJKHAH eM: HaHT11 TaKyiO crropT11BHyiO IIIKOAy, rAe CT011MOCTh o6yqeH115I He npeBbllllaAa 6h1 3000 AOAAapoB B rOA.

APyryro_

PaAOCT11 K11B11 He 6biAO rpaH11u;! O aa TYT JKe 6poc11;.acb K KOMnhiOTepy 11 CTaAa 113yqaTh BCe 6pa3HAbCK11e cpyr60AbHhie IIIKOAhi no 11HTepHery. Bb16paAa ABe 113seCTHbie 11 B CBOeM 6AOKHOTe HaqaAa 3an11CbiBaTh BCe «3d» H «npOT11B» C11CTeMhi yqe6hi KaJKAOH 113 H11X. K11B11 3Haer: rAaBaoe - 3TO c caMoro Ha'IaAa Bhi6paTh npaBIV\bHhiH IIYTh·

f1YTeiiieCTBYH BMeCTe CO CBOeH KOMaHAOH BOKpyr cBeTa, npoBOAH MaT'I11 B A31111, IOJKaoH: AMep11Ke, Espo" ne 11 Ha BAHJKHeM BocToKe, K11B11 aa6AIOAaAa MHOrD scero 11HTepecaoro 11 He113BeAaHaoro. A BOT 3Ta n oe3AKa ~ rpaH11IJ;Y CTaAa AMI K11B11 nepBOH, rOAa OHa o6Hap~ AMI ce6H, qTo HeAOCTaTO'IHO TOAbKO Ha6AIOAaTh. Tenepll OHa xoqeT JKHTh B ApyroH: CTpaHe 11 B COBepiiieHcrse OCB011Th ApyroH: H3hiK 11 APyryiO KYAbTYPY· 111 110

,.q

KRBR HaqaAa CBOe RCC.i\eAOBaHRe CO IIIKO.i\hi «Jla1 KOMaHAa KOTOpo:H: B npOIII.i\OM rOAY CTaAa no6eAHT~ qeMnRoHam Epa3RAHR no ¢YT60AY cpeAR CTapllllll IIIKO.i\. Be6-cafiT CTapiiieH IIIKO.i\hl «PRO» npOR3BeA Jia KRBR 6o.i\hiiioe sneqaTAeHRe. 3AeCb MOJKHO 6bl.i\o n~ qRTb RHQ:>OpMaiJ;RIO He TO.i\hKO Ha nop~aAbCKOM, HO Ba aHrAHHCKOM, RCnaHCKOM, RTa.i\bHHCKOM, Q:>paHIJ;Y3Clt())( R HnOHCKOM 513biKe - A.i\51 RHOCTpaHHbiX rpa)KAaH, l'ftl JKe.i\aeT nOCTYfiaTb B IIIKO.i\y. KorAa CTpaHRIJ;a OTKpy. Aacb, 3a3ByqaAa npRHTHaH MY3biKa R noc.i\e n puser. CTBRH Ha 3KpaHe MOHRTOpa nOHBH.i\aCb RHQ:>OpMaiJ;IUI

asOAJfl' B nORCKOBOe OKHO pa~Hble C.i\OBOCOqeTaHHH, aaiiPHMep, «CTapiiiaH IIIKOAa «AMa3oHKa», «Q:>YT6oAB Epa3f{J\.l'lli, sropoe MeCTO, CTapiiiaH IIIKOAa», HO HHKaK He MO)l(eT nonacTh Ha AOMaiiiHIOIO CTPaHHIJ;Y IIIKO.i\hl. K cqacThiO, JUiBli yqHAa nopryraAbCKH:H: H3hlK. 0Ha rrpo6yeT eru;e , BBeA.sJ B nORCKOBOe OKHO Q:>pa3y Ha nopryraAbCKOM 3 ~azonas Escola», R rAe-To BHH3Y ciiHcKa sce-TaKH Haxo!Vff Be6-CaHT crapiiieH IIIKO.i\hl «AMa30HKa». B OT~e OT ae6-ca:HTa crapiiieH IIIKO.i\hl «PRO», HHQ:>OpMau;HH Ha 3TOH crpaHlil.l;e noAaeTCH TO.i\bKO Ha nopryraAbCKOM H3biKe. BoopyJKHBIIlliCb nopryraAbCKO-aHrAHHCKHM C.i\OBapeM, MBR ar «a» AO «H» R3yqaeT se6-ca:H:T cTapiiie:H: IIIKO.i\hl «AMa3oHKa» li AOKaiibiBaeTCH AO TaKOH HHQ:>OpMau;HH: e KOMaHAa CTapiiieH IIIKO.i\hl «AMa30HKa» AeHCTBRTe.i\bHO CTaAa cepe6p51HbiM npR3epOM qeMnROHaTa Epa3HAHR no ¢YT6oAy B npolll.i\OM roAy; e B IIIKO.i\e HeT HR OAHOrO RHOCTpaHHOrO yqaru;eroCH R, ecTeCTBeHHO, HeT HRKaKRX cneiJ;RaAbHbiX nporpaMM A.i\51 RHOCTpaHIJ;eB; e IIIKO.i\a HaxOAifTCH BbiCOKO B ropax B AByx qacax e3Abl OT PRO-Ae-)KaHe:H:po; e II:I\.aTa 3a yqe6y COCTaB.i\HeT 5000 AO.i\.i\apoB, qTO Ha 2000 AO.i\.i\apos npeBbiiiiaeT 6IOA/KeT. AHWKOnA«P~O»

HaxoMJCb noA sneqaTAeHHeM OT se6-ca:H:Ta IIIKOAJ>I «PRo» - RHS, KHBR peiiiaeT, ~ 3TO HMeHHo Ta IIIKOIIilr rAe e:H: CAeAYeT yq:HI'bCH. A rAe HaxOAlfTCH IIIKOAa? B PliO' Ae-)KaHe:H:po? EoJKe, KaK oHa Me~aAa no6hlBaTh B 3'1'())( 60.i\biiiOM ropoAe. «Kpyro, 3TO JKe PHo-Ae-)KaHe:H:po! BOCKJlliKIIYAa KHBR. - HaKoHeu;-To H eMory 3aH51TbC.si cepQ:>HHroM Ha IIA.si)Ke B ropOAe Moe:H: Me~I! » KlfBR noCM~ Aa B HHTepHeTe, CKO.i\bKO CTOHT o6yqeHHe, R OKa3a.i\OCbr qJ'() 3TO KaK pa3 3000 AOAAapOB - OHa TIOTe.i\bKa B ~ BnRCbiBaeTCH B CBOH 6IONKeT. Hy ~ MOr.i\0 6b1Tb .i\ynnei 3aTeM MBR IIpRcryiilfAa K R3yqeHHIO crapiiieH IIJl(O" «AMa3oHKa» . B rrpolii.i\oM rOAY «AMa3oHKa» 3~! qeMIIHOHaTe Epa3H.i\HH no Q:>YT5o.i\y BTOpoe MeCTO. .IV"'"'"

.i\hi

112

KIIACCHAA

iiiYT60nbHA51

nPOTI1B

u- . .. --- -

nPOH1B

KllACCHAll il>YT60/lbHAll

AOPOroE 06Y4EHI1E (5000 A0/1/lAPOB BrOA)

KOMAHJ\A (4EMm10H

KOMAHAA ( CEPE6P~Hbl~

'OilY)

BnPOwnoM roAYl

~A3WIHH BnPOwnOM

HAI1nYYWHE YcnOBH~ MH ~HOCTPAHHbiX Y'IAU\HXQ!

lcnEl11WlbHA51 llPOrpAMMA All~ r'J10GPAHljEB; MHOro

nP~EP 6PA311/11111

411CTO 6PA31111bCKOE Y4E6HOE 3ABEAEHI1E; cnElji1AnbHAll nPOrPAMMAA!lH 11HOCTPAHljEB OTCYTCTBYET

AHrnorosoP~lJ1HX i'WJ1HXC~)

IW<OA11TC~ BPHO-AE·

~El1PO

HAXOA11TQ! AAnEKO OT PI10-AE-lKAHE~PO (ABA YACABAbiHAnOBAEl

liOnEE IIEWEBOE 06Y4EHHE (3000 ~MAPOB BrOA)

113

wAt 1: n£?£1f~c.Jl.~~£ sc.£ s.A?~AJ::Prbi

LlT06bl cpaBHllTb o6e IIIKOJ\bl ll B3BeCRTb BCe «3dlt l «npoTRB», KRBR BOCITOAh30BaAach cneu;RdAbHol{

1a"'

6MIIJ;eH. 3aiTRCdB B COOTBeTCTBYJOI.D;:_H KOAOHKe

(IIaqaAa nepeqRCMITe Bee sapRaHThl. HanpRMep, y Bac

Ta· Bee

ecTb Bbl60p ll3 Tpex IIIKOA: CTapiiia51 IIIKOAd «ApMdAHj\bO»r cTapiiia51 IIIKOAd «DRBep» ll CTdpiiia51 IIIKOAd «Ky-

npeRMyi.I.J;eCTBd ll HeAOCTdTKll KaJKAOll IIIKOJ\bl, OHa C

AefKOCTbiO onpeAe./\51eT, KdKa51 IIIKOAd npeACTdBJUlet

ryap».

co6oH A )"'IllllH BdplldHT .

UIAl' 4:

n£?£1f~C.Jl.~~£ BC.£ <(3A» ~ rt?O~~B» .D.Jl.S K.A~,llOtO SA?~.AJ::Pr.A 11

B3f./\51H)TB Hd CBOIO Ta6Miu;y, KRBll 6hiCTpo np11• HllMdeT peiiieHRe: «CTapiiiaH IIIKOAd «.AMd30HKd» Be

3aTeM nepeqJ.iCMITe BCe «3d» ll «ITpOTllB»

TOAbKO MeHee npRBAeKaTeAbHd, HO ll He BITllCbiBdeT·

cH B MOH 6roAJKeT. AyMaro, cTapiiiaH IIIKOAa «PRo» -

KaJKAO-

caMbiM npRBAeKaTeAbHbiM , B03bMRTe 3d npaBRAO 3d-

3TO TO, qTO MHe HdAO! » KRBll BCIO HOqb 3diTOAH.Ilet

AdBdTb ce6e sonpoc: «Cyi.I.J;eCTBYJOT All 3AeCh aeraTRB-

OHAdHH-3dHBKY Hd 06)"'eHRe B CTapiiieH IIIKOAe «PRO» R AOJKRTCH cnaTh TOAhKO B qeThlpe qaca YTpa.

A./\.51

rO sapRaHTa. AaJKe ecMI cqRTaeTe KaKoH-TO BapRaHT

Hbie acneKThi? Cym;ecTBYJOT All APyrRe no3RTRBHble

XoTll

acrreKThl? » Be eM HaM CBOHCTBeHHO noMaBaThCH no-

yJKe no3AHO, oHa He MOJKeT coMKHYTh rAa3. KRBR ae

pbiBY nepsoro BneqaTAeHRH. EcMI HaM qTO-TO c caMoro

MOJKeT OTBAeqbCH OT MbiCAll 0 TOM, KdKOe BOCXHTH·

HdtiaAd KaJKeTCH npRBAeKaTeAbHbiM, Mbl CKAOHHbl RC-

TeAhHoe nYTeiiieCTBRe B Epa3RARIO e:H: npeACTORT.

3a <Apr.43AHnbOI

~l:IC.~?~£l:{'r.A?~~ .D.Jl.S ?£1II£l:l~S n?OSJl.£M.: «3A» ~ «n?o~~s». K?~~£?~~ ~ OI.{£l:IKA

BbiCOKCle KaYeCT1lO OOpalOBaHHR

Her nporpaMMbl no MeliCAYH<lJlOAHOMY OOMeH)')"liliJ11.1MI1CR

(HnbHaR 6ei:tctionbHaR KOMaHAa 1\aiieKO OT AOMa 6ecrmaTHoe OO)"*!HHE> ( Tapoe JAilHHe WKOnbl BoJMOlKHO, CKlAa nepef\AyT HeKOTOpble MOH APYJbR

•OIIeep•

BbiCOKoe KaYeCTBO o6pa30BaHHR

1\aiieKO OT AOMa

nporpaMMa no MeliCAyHapclAHOMY OOMeHY

(Tapoe JAilHHe WKOnbl

KorAa saM Heo6xoARMO ou;eHRTh cpa3y MHoro sapH· dHTOB ll Bbi6paTb ll3 HllX CdMbiH A)"'IllllH, CTOllT BOC·

)"lil1J11.1MI1CR

ITOAb30BdTbCH CAeAyiOI.I.J;llMll llHCTpyMeHTdpllHMH. CMbHaR 6ei:tctionbHaR KOMaHAa

L-1HCTPYMEHT N~ 1. «3A, L-1 «nPOTL-18,

6ecrmaTHoeo6)"*!HHe

MHOf\1€ MOO APYJbR nnaHHPYIO nepeKT\1 BJTY WKOny

DepBbiH RHCTPYMeHT HOCRT Ha3BaHRe «3a» R «npo· TRB». OH noMoraeT paciiiRpRTh Kpyr sapRaHTOB B

•Kj!)'ap>

PRAOM CAOMOM

)"'eCTb KdK IT03llTllBHble («3d»), TdK ll aeraTHBHile ( «ITpOTllB») CTOpOHbl, npeJKAe qeM npRHHTb OKOWia· TeAbHOe peiiieHRe. DpeAcTaBbTe ce6H aa MecTe KHB R nonpo6y:H:Te Bbi6paTh

A./\.51

Hosoe JAilHHE' WKOnbl

HHJKoe KaYeCTBO o6paJosaHHR nocpeACTBeHHaR 6e~c6onbHaR KOMaHAa BbiCOOR nnaTa Ja OO)"*!HHe (15 000 AOnnapoB B rOA)

ce6H HOBYIO IIIKOAY· KYI'P

XOTeMI 6hi nepeHTll. 11HCTpYMeHT «3d» ll «npoTHB'

HHI(!O H3 MOHX p,pYJei1 He COOHpaeTCR f!HTbCR BJTOO WKone

ITOMOJKeT ycTdHOBllTb pa3AllqJ.iH MeJKAy RMeiOII.l;Hfoill• CH BdplldHTdMll.

115 114

KaTb A?Ka3aTe.i\beTBa B IIOATBepJKAeHRe :3TOR MbiCJul, C

a 0 ~

B.l\.eKaTe.i\bHbiM, Mbl eTpeMRMe51 IIOA'IepKayTb TOhLlQ

TOl\fY Bbl IIpReBaRBaeTe RM Bee

HeraTRBHble eTopoHhi. O'IeHh BaJKHO R36e/KaTb

TeHAeH~RR

3Tot

R rrpRH51Tb pa3-yMHOe perneHRe. flpR CJ)a!.

HeHRR TpeX lliKO.I\. Balli errReOK «3a» R «IIpOTRB» MOJKet

BblrJ\.51AeTb rrpR6.1lli3RTe.i\bHO KaK Ha Ta6.1lli~e (c.

117).

+ /- 3),

a B03paeT 3Aa-

I-Il:iSI IIIKO.l\.bl RMeeT BTOpOeTeiieHHOe 3Ha'leHRe (T.e. Bee roro rryHKTa 6yAeT 3

+I- 1).

UIAl' 4: S:&1S£?Vl'r£ ~AM:&l~ J1?Vt8Jl.£RA'r£Jl:bl:f:&l"'t SA?PtA~

3: S3S£C.:b'r£ RA~AblH no3Vt.'rVi.Sl:f:&lH Vi. l:f..trA.'rVLSl:f:&l~ n~'r Vl-3 e.so..tro e.nVt.e.RA

Jti, HaKOHe~,

He Bee apr-yMeHThl «3a» R «rrpoTRB» KaKoro-To BapHau-

IIIeHHbiX «3a» R «rrpoTRB» R3 Barnero errReKa.

Ta RMeiDT paBHOe 3Ha'leHRe. CAeAYJOIIJ;RM BarnRM Ina·

aoM eAY'!ae, IIO/Ka.l\.yR, eTORT Bbi6paTb eTaplliyiD lliKOAY

roM 6yAeT rrpReBORTh Bee KaJKAOMY rryHKTY· AaBa:ire B03bMeM B Ka'!eeTBe IIpRMepa TaKOe B3Bell1RBaHRe:

«EHBep», Ha6paBlliyiD HaR60.i\bll1ee KO./lli'!eeTBO Il.l\.lO-

lli.Ar

A.J\.51 Bae O'leHb 60.i\bll10e 3Ha'leHRe

APyTOR eTopOHhi, ee.llli 'ITO-TO rroKaJKeTeH HaM aenpa.

DpeAII0./\.0/KRM,

al\felOT Ka'leeTBO o6pa30BaHR51 R ero eTORMOeTb (II03-

+++I - - - QqeHh npHBJI.eKaTell.hHO I HenpHBJI.eKarell.hHO ++! - - YMepeHHO npHBAeKarell.hHO I HenpHBJI.eKaTell.hHO +I - CAa6o npHBJI.eKarell.hHO I HenpHBJI.eKareAhHO

IIOeAeAHRR mar eoeTORT B TOM, 'IT06bl

Bbl6paTh eaMbiR IIpRB.I\.eKaTe.i\bHbiR BapRaHT R3 B3Be-

+++BbiCOKoe Kil'1eCTBO o6pa3oeaHHI! tt

(llllbHaR 6ei1c6onbHaR KOMaHAil

+++ 6ecnnaTHoe o6~v.e t t

lt1HCTPYMEHT N2 2. KPIIITEPIIIIIIIII OUEHKA CAeAyiDIIJ;RR mar Ha3h1BaeTeH «KpRTepRR R o~eHKa». 3ToT HHeTPYMeHT ReiiO.i\b3yeTeH AJ\..51 Toro, '!T06hi yeTaHO-

rf:Mef.J }'l<JU111MOOI • Aafiet<o OT AOMa • (rapoe 31\ilHVoe WKOnbl

lilroro:10+

lilroro: 5-

+++BbiCOKDe Kil'1eCTBO o6pa3oeaHHR +++nporpaMMa no ~poAHOMY ri:Mef.J }'l<JU111MOOI

· Aafiet<O OT

t tt

onpeAe.llliTb eTeiieHh BaJKHOeTR Ka)KAOrO KpRTepRH; 3¢<PeKTRBHO o~eHRTb RMelOIIJ;ReeH BapRaHTbl.

lliA.r 1: n..t?..t~Vte.JlVL'r£ SC...: Vl.M£J.OlltVt£C.$l SA?Vl.A~:&l

A0Ma

· Crapoe 31\ilHVoe wKonbl

TOl!HO TaK /Ke, KaK R B eAY'lae e RHeTp-yMeHTOM «3a» R «npoTRB» r rrepBbiM Ae.I\.OM rrepe'IRe./lliTe Bee" RMeiOrn;Re-

(llllbHaR 6ei1c6onbHaR KOMaHAil

+++6ecnnaTHoe o6yletiv.e

CSI BapRaHTbi. Mbi eHOBa 6yAeM Bb16RpaTb MeJKAy eTap-

t t MHOOE M011 J\PY3bR f1113HHP)'UT

lliHMR lliKO.I\.aMR «ApMaAH.i\bO», «ERBep» R «Kyryap».

~BJTYWKOny

lilroro: 14+ «Kyryap•

APYfRMR C.I\.OBaMR, Ka'leeTBa -

Heo6XOAJ1MO ReiiO.i\b30BaTb B XOAe O~eHKR BapRaHTOB;

803MO:ml, OOAa nepei1AyT HeKOTopble MOI1 APY3bR

«6\lsep•

• • • Her nporpaMMbl no Me:«A)'HilpoAHOM)'

AaH-

COB R HaRMeHblliee KO./lli'!eeTBO MReyeoB.

BliTh, KaKRe KpRTepRR -

·~·

i'RAOM CAOMOM

Hosoe 31\ilHVoe WKonbl

lilroro:2• • • HHJKoe Ka'leCTBO o6paJOBaHHR • • nocpeAC11l€HHaR 6ei1c6onbHaR KOMaHAa

n..t?..t~VLC.JlVL'r£ R?Vt'r..t?VLVL

~..:~Vt

· • • BbiCOKaR nnara Ja o6yletiv.e

(15 000 AOMapoe BrQA) · HHKTO H3 M011X J\P')'3ei1 He co6HpaeTCR

)'MTbCll B)TOO WKOJ"re

lilroro:2 +

lUf}r

lilroro: 9-

KorAa Bhl roBOpRTe: «3Ta rnKoAa Il.l\.OXaH» R.llli «3Ta llii<O.I\.a XOpOlliaH»,

KaKRMR KOHKpeTHbiMR KpRTe-

PliSIMH PYKOBOAeTByeTeeh? Mbi opReHTRpOBa./llieh Ha CJI.eAYJOrn;Re xapaKTepReTRKR:

117 116

&J@~•p@•'

e e

Ka'!eCTBO o6pa30BaHH51; HMH'!He nporpaMMhl IIO Me)KAYJiapOAJiOM)' 06MeHY

Y'!ai.IJ;HMHCH; CHAbHM 6eiic60AhHa51 KOMaHAa;

•

KOAH'leCTBO APY3eii, KOTOphle co6HpaiOTCH

nporpaMM<l flO MeJKAYHapoAHQMy

nepexoAHTh B ry JKe IIIKOAy;

~)"!1J111MOOI

•

paccTOHHHe oT IIIKOAhl AO AOMa;

(WlbHaR 6ei1c{ionbHaR KOMaHj\a

e e

B03paCT 3fl.aHH51 IIIKOAhl;

I\PYJ€i1,

~ :a l\!

lll.A.I' 3: on?.t.ll.tJU'l'rs

c.'rsn.tif:b

nJ)I1BJ1€1(aTenbHOCTb WKOnbl

+++

l(aYeCfBO o6paJOBdH~R

BbiCOKaR

+++

BbiCOKaR

+++

(He!)

(Aa)

(He!)

cpeAHRR

+++

H~JKaR

PacOORHHe AO WKOnbl

S.A~ifOC.'rl"l K.A~,ll,OtO K?l"l.'r.t?l'\$1

BoJpaaJAaH~R

:I"' I

(25 M~HyT)

(30 M~HyT)

(5 M~HyT)

H~JKaR

BbiCOKaR

+++

(6ecrulaTHO)

(6eci1Jl<llllO)

($ 15000)

CAeAYJOill;HH mar COCTOHT B

onpeAeAeHHH CTeiieHH

(TOOMOCTb o6yYeH~R

BaJKHOCTH KaJKAOrO KpHTepHH H3 CnHCKa, KOTOphlH BH cocTaBHAH B npeAh!Aym;eM mare. MoJKeTe HCnOAh30· BaTh TPH ypoBHH BaJKHOCTH (BhlCOKHH, cpeAHHH, HH3· KHH), HAH socnoAh30BaThCH AeCHTH6aAAbHOH m KaAOH. Mbi npHCBOHAH HamHM KpHTepHHM TaKOH sec:

e e

Ho OI.J;eHHTb OTBeTOM «Aa» HAH «ReT» (B HameM CAy-qae

HMH'!He nporpaMMhl IIO Me)KAYJiapOAJiOM)' 06MeHY

3TO -

CHAbHM 6eiic60AhHa51 KOMaHAa - cpeAJi5151 CTeiieHh

•

BaJKHOCTH; KoAH'!eCTBO APY3eii, KOTOphle co6HpaiOTCH nepexoAHTh B T'f JKe IIIKOAY- cpeAJi5151 cTeneHh BaJKHOCTH; paCCT051HHe OT IIIKOAhl fl.O fl.OMa - HH3Ka51 CTeiieHh BaJKH()C'l'll; B03paCT 3fl.aHH51 IIIKOAhl - HH3Ka51 CTeiieHh BaJKHOCTH;

Tenepb ou;eHHBaeM KaJKAbiH BapHaHT Ha OCHOBe

KpHTepHeB, KOTOphle onpeAeAHAH. MoJKHO ycTaHoBifl'b CTOAbKO ypoBHeH BaJKHOCTH, CKOAbKO BaM yroAHO·

BAeKaTeAbHO) AO «

TpexypOBHeBOi

+ + +»

(o'leHh

+ » (HenpHBAeKaTeAbHO).

SbiS.t?l"l'r.t C..AMbllf n?M.SJl..tK.A'r.tJ1:bilbllf S.A?1'\.A~ HaKoHeu;, Bhl6epHTe caMhiH npHBAeKaTeAbHhlH sapHe~e pa3 y6eA1fTech, 'ITO y-qAH sec KpHTepHeB ou;eHKH.

lll.A.I' 4: OL{.tifl'\'r.t K.A~.llDllf S.A?1'\.A~ C. noMOII{:bl<> S3S.tlll.tl::P:fbl~ K?l"l'r.t?.

ou;eHKH, KOTOpaH BapbHpyeT OT «

lii.Ar S:

dHT. ITepeA TeM, KaK CAeAaTh OKOH'laTeAhHhlH BhlBOA,

CTOHMOCTb 06Y'!eHH51- BhiCOKM CTeiieHh BaJKHOCTH.

MeTOAOM

HaAH'lHe nporpaMMbl MeJKAyHapOAHOrO 06MeHa

Y'Jdiu;HMHCH), OTMeTbTe H 3TO.

BOCnOAh3yeMCH

IIIKOAhl»). EcAH y sac ecTh KOHKpeTHbie AaHHbie, BKAIOHOH TO'lHOCTH. EcAH KaKyro-To xapaKTepHCTHKY MOJK-

Ka'leCTBO o6pa30BaHH51 - BhiCOKM CTeiieHh BaJKHOCTH;

npHMepa

Mo/KeTe A06aBAHTb K CBOHM apryMeHTaM KOHKpeTHble u;mpphl (HanpHMep, KaK B rpacpe «PaCCTOHHHe AO 'IHTe HX B CBOIO Ta6AHI.J;y, 'lT06bi A06HTbCH MaKCHMaAb-

Y'!ai.IJ;HMHC51 - BhiCOKM CTeiieHh BaJKHOCTH;

e e e

Kon~ KOTopble cOOiipallTCR rrepeXOAffib Bry lKe WKOny

CTOHMOCTh 06Y'!eHH51.

W·

BbiCOKaR

npJI•

11 CHOBa,

B HameM CAy-qae, HaBepHHKa Bhl6epeTe CTap-

lllylo IIIKOAY «oHBep». BeAh y Hee 6oAbme Bcero O'lKOB no TdKHM BaJKHhlM KpHTepHHM, KaK Ka'leCTBO 06pa30BdflHH H HaAH'lHe nporpaMMbl no MeJKAyHapOAHOMY 06MeHyy-qam;HMHCH, XOTH H MaAO O'lKOB no MeHee BaJKH:biM KpHTepHHM, TaKHM, KaK paCCTOHHHe OT AOMa AO lUKO.I\.hi H B03paCT 3AaHHH. 06a HHcTpYMeHTa, KaK HHCTpYMeHT «3a» H «npoTlfB», TaK H HHCTpYMeHT KpHTepHeB H ou;eHKH, npHBe-

119 118

~: ,.,.

~· O•

1QI

P.•

A'fT Bac K OAHOMY H TOMY )l(e pe3yAbTary H rroM oryr 113 MHO)I(eCTBa B03MO)I(HbiX BapHaHTOB Bbl6paTb CaMLiii ATJillHH.

3TH

HHCTpyMeHTbl

rrpeACTaB.I\JIIOT

COOQji

He'ITO 60.1\blllee, '!eM llOACITOpbe B opraHH3aiJ;HH C06.

CTBeHHbiX MbiCAeH. 0HH llOMOralOT AOITOAHHTe.l\hHo

Bbl'!AeHHTb HHcpOpMaiJ;HlO, KOTOpOH BaM, B03MOJKHO

KaK pa3 H He XBaTaAO. 0HH 3aCTaB.I\JIIOT 3aAaBaTb BO:

rrpOCbl OTHOCHTe.l\bHO TOfO, 'ITO Bhl C'lHTaeTe

A.I\JI

Ce6g

AeifcTBHTe.l\bHO caMhiM Ba)I(HbiM. BoAee Toro, B np0 •

u;ecce aHaAH3a Bhl MO)I(eTe H3o6pecTH HOBble c noc0 • 6bl rrpeOAOAeHHH HeAOCTaTKOB, rrpHCYIJ..J;HX

HeKOTO·

pbiM BapHaHTaM.

":t £Jl£.Sl'\31'\0l:fl:lbi'If:t KOMM£1i":t A.?1-\il, :KO":tO?biil .SC£ n£?£.S£?1i~Jl Ha CAeAyiOIJ..J;HH AeHh KHBH CMOTpeAa Be'lepHHe cnop· THBHble HOBOCTH Ha KaHaAe

ESPN -

3TO 6hlA ee eJKe-

AHeBHhlH pHryaA. llleA crreiJ;HaAbHblH BhiiTYCK ITOA Ha· 3BaHHeM «f10'leMy aMepHKaHJ..J;bl He MOryT rro6eAJITL». 0AHO H3 BbiCKa3biBaHHH KOMMeHTaTopa Bceu;eAO nofAOTHAO BHHMaHHe AeBO'lKH:

CBOeM aKTHBe CTOAbKHX 3Be3AHhiX HrpOKOB? f1ocTaBb'l'e ce6H Ha MeCTO HrpOKa, KOTOporo He BhlllYCKaiOT H a nQAe

KOMaRA. HoBH'!KaM rrpHXOAlfTCH

TIOAYMaHTe caMH: 3THM pe6HTaM rrpocTo He

Bcero.

c~eHO

BbiHTH Ha llOAe BrrepBbie. KaK )l(e OHH 6yAyT pa3BHBaTI> cBoif TaAaHT, ecAH He 6yAyr HrpaTh? HeAb35I c TaBHTI> cpeAOH

AA5I

Me~y CH.I\bHOH KOMaHAOH H HAeaAbHOi0

HAeaAhHOH

cpeAOH

A.I\JI

BeAh KOMMeHTaTop co-

pHH OHa 3aAO)I(HAa B OCHOBY CBOeH ou;eHKH CTaprneif liiKOAbl, B KOTOpyiO OHa co6paAaCh rrepeXOAHTb?!

HOBH'IOK, a BJ..a.Ae-

CMbiCAHT B 6eifc6oAe) pernHA HaH5ITb fOTOBbiX 3 Be3A H3

3HaK paBeHCTBa

KOMaHAOH H

BeprneHHO rrpaB. KHBH CITOXBaTHAaCb: aTe AH KpHTe-

KHBH rrepecMoTpeAa cBOH u;eAH:

Aeu; CITOpTHBHOfO KAy6a (KOTOpbiH, KCTaTH, HH'!efO He

APYfHX

CHAhHOH

HHAHBHAYaAhHoro poeT a ... »

«TaK llO'leMY )l(e 5IHKH He MOryT rro6eAlfTh, H MeSI B

BrrepBble HMeHHO ITOTOMY, 'ITO OH -

«Moe:H u;eAhlO

He 5IB.I\JieTC5I Hrpa B ATJilleH cpyT60AhHOH KOMaHAe.

Xoqy CTaTh ATJillHM HfpOKOM, KOTOpbiM TOAbKO

Mory 6biTh, a

A.I\JI

3TOf0 MHe He06XOAHMO HaHAyq-

IIIee ¢yr60AbHOe OKpy)l(eHHe. BTopaH MOH u;eAh B COBeprneHCTBe OCBOHTh 5I3biK H KYAhTYPY Apyroro HapoAa».

HHAlfBHAYaAbHOfO pocTa. He YAlfBHTeAbH •

'ITO MOpaAbHaH aTMOCcpepa B 3TOH KOMaHAe AaAeKO ue

KliBH 6hlCTPeHhKO Ha6pocaAa Ha AHCTe 6YMarH CITHCOK CBOHX KpHTepHeB Bbl60pa IllKOAbl H OTMeTHAa CTerreHh

Ha BbiCOTe». YcTaBHBillHCh Ha 3KpaH, KHBH pacTepHHHO npo· 6opMOTaAa: «HeAh35I CTaBHTh 3HaK paBeHCTBa r-1eJJ•

B<iJKHOCTH K~OfO KpHTepHH. f1oKa OHa rrpOAe.l\biBah.a 3TO, B ee fOAOBe TO H AeAO BCllAblBaAH HeO)KlfAaHHble MhiCAlf. 0Ha Ha'laAa CTaBHTh ITOA COMHeHHe BeCh MbiC-

121 120

•

a ~

JUITeJ\bHbiH npou;ecc, KOTOphlH npi-meA ee K BbiBOAy, trr() CTapiiia51 IIIKOAa «PMO» - He TOAbKO CaMhlH A)"'IIIMH, lJO M eAifHCTBeHHO peaAbHhlH C ¢MHaHCOBOH TOqKM 3peHJiSI BapHaHT. KHBM CTaAa 3aAaBaTb CaMa ce6e BOITpOCb! M ITOAJ3epraTh COMHeHMIO co6cTBeHHhle npeAfiOAOJKeHIDI.

/ . ~;;;;~~~;;;;;.~~- ........

~ $JKTopaMH \ 6naronJlllllTHOCTI1 \ , QJyltionbHOH CpeAbl?

; ./

................

KpMTepH~

-BbiCOI«<~

6naronpHmHa~ CpeACI An~ OOBbtWeHH~

HHAHBHAY3nbHOro MaaepcTBa BljlyrOO!le

~JbiKOM HKynbrypoii

(peAH~~

(He AOI1JI(H3 npesbiwaTb 3000 AOM.{roA) )l(enarenbHO il06nHllle KPHO-Ae-)l(aHelipo

~b HHJKa~

.........;r ,.... .r

' i+++

+++

!(3000AOM.{roA) j +++++ /

cpaKTOp». KMBM

CAeAaAa

OAHY

oqeHh

pacnpocTpaHeHHYIO

()qeHb BaJKHO y:MeTh noABepraTh coMHeHMIO xoA co6? ..-

;.,

crBeHHbiX MhlCAeH, KaK 3TO

CAeAaAa KMBM. l1 BOT yJKe BTO-

pyiO HO% ITOAPHA KlfBM He MOJKeT COMKHJTb rM3 AO paccBeTa. Y Hee TaKOe qyBCI'BO, qro oRa 3aiiiM B TYfiMK· Ee MbiCAM BCe BpeMH KpyJKaTCH BOKpyr OAfiMX M TeX JKe BOllpOCOB.

(5000AOM.fi'OA)

+ (2 'laca eJAbi)

r··--·--··-~--------,,

no)l(allyi1, ~ HeCJ(onbKo

~...

------·····-~ . . . . . . . . . .~,; . . . . . ......

.................................................../

BbiCOI«<~

(TOOMOGb OO~H~

..........

KaKa~ Hl WKOn H3 caMOM Aene n~we?

6naronpHmH3~ CpeACI An~ OBnaAeHH~ Y~HM

......... u

:MOMX u;eAeH, 3TO He TaKOH yJK BaJKHhlH KpHTepHH. DoJKaAyH, H HeCKOAbKO nepeou;eHMAa 3TOT

oii1M6Ky. Mbi qacTo npHHMMaeM BaJKHhle perneHMH, He yAeAMB AOCTaToqHo BpeMeHM TOMY, qTo6hi Tiu;aTeAbHO J:i yqMTb BCe HMeiOIIJ;MeCH BapHaHThl M co6paTb TOqHY!O 3 J:iHcpopMaiJ;MIO.

·~---·--,

EAM30CTh K PMo-Ae-)KaHelipo: «C ToqKM 3peHMH

~eHHna3TOT$JKTop j

............::,.............................-:..............................L..............................................; ,

(,_~:::~:~.~:~-~=-~=~:~.~~;.;;!.E~~~;.;I~.~~~-:~::~:·.:~.~-~::J

EAaronpmrTHa51 cpeAa AJ\51 Mrpbi B ¢yr6oA: «C no· MOIIJ;blO KaKMX KOHKpeTHO KAIOqeBhlX cpaKTOpOB

•

H onpeAeAHIO, 6AaronpHHTHa 3Ta cpeAa

AA5I MeWI

HAM HeT?» EAaronpHHTHaH cpeAa AJ\51 OBAaAeHMH qpKHM H3hlKOM M KYAhTYPOH: «To, qTo B cTaprne:H mKoAe «PMo» ecTh cneu;MaAbHaH nporpaMMa AA5I HHO" CTpaHIJ;eB, 3B)"'MT 3aMaHqMBO, HO XOpOillO .1\11 3TO Ha caM oM AeAe? Ae:HcTBMTeAhHO AM TO, qTO B IIIKOAe )"'MTCH 6oAee 30 aMepHKaHu;eB, HBAHeTCfl

AJ\51 MeHH npeHMYIIJ;eCTBOM, ecAM H eAY B Epa3H· AMID, co6cTBeHHO,

AA5I

Toro, qTo6hl oKa3aTbCH B

«MHe Hlfqero He AaCT, ecAM H 6yAY TOAbKO HepBHM'laTb M pa3Ay:MhlBaTb HaA 3THMM BOllpOCaMM, KMBM caMa ce6e. -

CKa3aAa

HaAo noAy:MaTh, KaKMe AeifcTBMH H

Apyro:H KYAbTYPHOH cpeAe M BbiyqMTb MHOCTpaH·

Mory npeAfipHHHTb, qT06bi npHHTM K npaBMAbHOMY pe-

HbiH H3hlK? CTOMMOCTb o6yqeHM5l: «51 He MOry ITOBAMHTh Ha C'fO" MMOCTb o6yqeHM5l B KaJKAOH M3 IIIKOA, HO, B03Mo)1(•

llleHliiO».

HO, H MOry ITOA)"'MTh KaKYIO-HM6YAb CTMITeHNIIO? »

l1 KaK TOAbKO ORa HaiTHCaAa CITMCOK npeACTOHll\liX AeA, y Hee oTAerAO oT cepAIJ;a, MoRa cpa3y JKe npoBahlfAacb B COR. KHBH CHMAOCb, qTO ORa, npeHCITOAHeHHa51 123

122

s ~

[:ill

H(lAeJKA, HaxOAJITC.H B a3porropry. TO.IlliKO 'ITO 06'h.HBlihlf IIOCClAKY Ha caMOAeT, OTIIpaBA5IlOID;HHC5I B Epa3HAHIQ, Ee coH YAJiBHTe.llliHO peaAH:CTHlieH: oHa .HBCTBeHHO CJ\.hi. IIIHT, KaK poACTBeHHHKH H APY3h.H JKeAaiOT e:H: YAaliH, 11 orn;yrn;aeT me KperrKHe rrporn;a./lliHhle o6'h.HTH.H .

i ~

lill1t. 0

6naronpH!ITHaR cpe,ilil )111R COaepweHCTB()BaH~R

~IWIBHAYilllbHOrO MaCTepcrsa Bq>yT6one 4TO )111R MeHR fli-1'!HO RBflReTCR KlliO'IeBbUo4~ q>aKTOpaM~. Oflpe.QeflR~M~ 6naronpHS!THOC!b q,yT6onbHOO Cpe.Qbl?

6naronp~I!THaR Cpe.Qa )111R OBf1aAeH~R 'l)'JK~M RlbiKOM

~ K)'flbT)'IlO~ To, 'ITO B crapUJeli WKOne «P~O> ecTb Cflel.l~bHaR nporpaMMa )111R ~HocrpaH~eB,lBY'MT JaMaH'4~BO. HO xopowon~ 3TO Ha caMOM Aene?

• Cn~yrpeHepaA;tOHCa (rnaeHOroTpeHepa KOMaHAbiiOH~poB CWA). 'ITO OH C'l~aeT KlliO'IeBbiM~ q>aKTopaM~ •KnaCcfiOO q>yT6onbHOO Cpe.Qbl'

• OrocnaTh no 3fleKTpoHHO~ OO'lle Janpoc Bn~ KOM~C~IO CTapwe~ WKOflbl «P~O> ~ nonpoc~ BOJMQ)I(~ n~TbCR CHecKOflbK~M~ ~HocrpaHHbiM~ ~~M~CR WKOflbl « ~>

'ITO eCTb KOMaHAbl, KOTOpbie CKAOHHhl BeliHO AepJKaTh IifpOKOB BTOporo H TpeTbero 3IIIeAOHa Ha CKaMeHKe 3a-

A~~enbHO n~ ro, 'ITO B wKone ~~CR 6onee 30 aM€p11KaH~eB, RBnReTCR )111R MeHR npeHt.4)'lllKTaQM, ecn~ ReAY B 6pal~~IO. Co6cTBeHHO, AM TOro, 'llo6bi OKaJaTbCR BAP~ K)'flbrypHOO Cpe.Qe ~ Bbl)'4~ HOBbl~ lllbiK?

0 ~ HE' Mary llOBil~RTb Ha CTOOMOCTb OO~~R B Ka~OO ~ WKOIL

Ho, BOlMOl4<HO, RMary non~~ KaK)'IO-H~YAb ~ne~10?

TpeHep ITOA6pocHA KHBH ern;e HeCKO.IlliKO HAeH, KOrophle paHhiiie He rrpHXOAHAH e:H: B roAoBy. OH cKa3aA,

rraCHhlX, H ITOCOBeTOBaA e:fi ITOAbiCKaTh TaKyiD KOMdH-

AYr

KOTOpa.H AaeT B03MOJKHOCTh YlJaCTBOBaTh B MaTtiax

HrpoKaM Bcex ypoBHeH. Ern;e oH CliHTaA, liTO BaJKHyiD • Ce!llaTbCR CnpHeMHbiM~ KOM~C~RM~ CTapw~ UJI(OO c~> ~ <AMalOHKa» ~ BbiRCH~. npeA~~araiOT ~ OH~~neHA~~

• ~l~~. Ka~e ~neHA~~ npeA~~araiOT npae~enbCTBO CWA, 6naroTBOJli1TeflbHble q>oHAbl.

AMep~KaHCKaR ~epa~R q>yT6ona

pOJ\b HrpaeT KalieCTBO TpeHepCKOH pa60Thl, HO Ha nep-

BOM MeCTe CTO.HT BCe JKe KOHKypeHTHa.H cpeAa H KOAHtJ:eCTBO HrpOBOfO BpeMeHH. KHBH CIIpOCHAa y rpeHepa /)¥KOHCa, KOTOpyiD H3 AByx liiKOA OH IIOCOBeryeT eH Bb16paTh. TpeHep OTBeTHA, 'ITO 3HaeT TO.IlliKO, liTO o6e OHH IIpHHCIMeJKaT K liHCAY

KI'\Si'\ l:IA.~O ,lUit':t SJl.ArOn?i'lH':tl:I:tlO t:t':tSOJl.hl:I:tlO C?~,D.Y

AYlJIIIHX B MHpe ¢YT60.IlliHhlX IIIKOA, HO He BA(lAeeT HH<J>opMau;HeH HaCTO.IlliKO, liT06hl BbiHeCTH C06CTBeHHOe cnpaBeAJUiBOe cYJKAeHHe. 3aTo oH rroo6ern;aA CB.H3aTh

Ha cAeAyiDrn;ee YTPO KHBH rro3BOHHAa TpeHepy tyKoHCY

KHBH: C 6pa3HAbCKHM TpeHepoM 3HKO, KOTOpbiH B rrpo-

H IIOIIpOCHAa y Hero COBeTa. 0H OTBeTHA: «CaMOe rAaB·

liiAOM corpyAHHliaA c o6eHMH IIIKOAaMH.

Hoe -

3TO liT06hl Te6H eJKeAHeBHO oKpyJKaAH: cH.IlliHhle

HrpOKH: H Te, C KOTOpbiMH Thi Hrpaeiiih B OAHOH KOMaH·

KHBH cepAeliHO no6AaroAapHAa TpeHepa fyKoHca.

Ae, H Te, rrpoTHB KOTOphlx Thl Hrpaeiiih». Ern;e oH no-

Dopa3HTe.llliHO, cKO.IlliKO HOBhiX B03MOJKHocre:H: H u;eH-

coBeTOBaA, liT06hl KHBH IIOCTapaAaCh IIpOBOAJiTh KaK

liofl HHcpopMau;HH OTKphlA rrepeA HeR 3TOT rrpOCTOH

B ee B03pacTe HrpoK11

AonoAHHTe.llliHhiH IIIar. Terreph KHBH pacrroAaraeT KOH-

AYlJIIIe BCerO pa3BHBalOTC5I KaK cpH3HlieCKH, TaK H TeX·

R.peTHhlMH KpHTepH.HMH, C IIOMOID;hlO KOTOpbiX e:fi rrpeA-

HHlieCKH, HO B OC06eHHOCTH -

YMCTBeHHO, KOrAa oHll

CTOH:T OIJ;eHHTh 6AarorrpH5ITHOCTh ¢YT60AhHOH cpeAbl B

HrpaiOT B HaCTO.HID;HX MaTtiax C CHAbHhlM IIpOTHBHHKO!d·

crapumx IIIKOAax «PRo» H «AMa30HKa». K TOMY JKe 6o-

M:oJKHO 6o.llliiiie BpeMeHH B Hrpe.

124

125

~ .q

Aee AeAbHhlli COBeT B 3THX BOnpocax MOJKeT AaTb

Tpe.

Hep 3HKO, Ha npaKTHKe 3HaKOMblli C OC06eHH0 CT,SI~

gaqHHaiOru;ero HrpoKa».

06~eHHH B 3THX I.IIKOAax.

B TOT JKe Be"'Iep, KOfAa KliBH B03Bpan.J;aAaChAOMOli C TpeHHpOBKH no ¢yr6oAy, eli no3BOHHA TPeHep 3HKO. «AM.o 3TO KliBH? TpeHep fvKoHc nepeAaA MHe, "'ITO Thl

pa3AY~

MbiBaeiiih, B Ka.KylO CTap:rnyro I.IIKOAY nOCTYfiaTh -

«l>Holl

HAH «AMa30HKa». l..JTO Te6H KOHKpeTHO HHTepecyeT? H MOry Te6e nOMO"'Ih? » AOAbiiie -qaca.

cnpoCHA OH. Pa3rOBOp

l.JeM

AJ\HACJI

B KOHe"'IHOM HTore TPeHep 3HKO CKa3aA, trro

nOAHOCTbiO COfAaCeH C TeMH KpHTepHHMH 6AarOITpiDITHOH ¢yr6oAbHOli cpeAbl, KOTOpbie Ha3BaA TPeHep /:vKOHC.

- - i f i iHhl

Kp11rep11l1 6naroopii!ITHaR cpeAa

BbiCOKaR

t Kp11Tep11l1

BoJMO)I(HOGb yYaaBOBalb BOOnbWOM KOni!YeGBe

KaqeCTBa. Aa, «PRo» cAaBHTCH CBOHMH 3HaMeHHThiMH rpeHepaMH, HO nOCKOAbKY OHH OAHOBpeMeHHO TpeHHpyroT Ha~HOHaAbHyiO c6opHyiO KOMaHAy B3pOCAbiX, Ha

UII<.OAY y HHX OCTaeTCH MaAO BpeMeHH.

npOTHBOn0-

1\0)KHOCTh liM, TpeHepbl «AMa30HKH» B 60AbliiHHCTBe cAyqaeB AH"'IHO pyKOBOA.sJT TpeHHpOBKaMH H yAeAHIOT roMY MHOfO BpeMeHH. «3TH pe6HTa He 3HaMeHHTbi, HO 3 ro eru;e He 3Ha"'IHT, "'ITO OHH He BeAHKOAenHbll fO3 BOpHT TpeHep 3HKO. - 5I nOBHAaA MHOfO TpeHepOB Ha CBOeM BeKy, HO noBepb MHe: 3TH TpeHepbl -

AoBOAhl TpeHepa 3HKO

tiaH

A~I.IIHe

npo3B~aAH AAH

KHBH o"'leHh

c HHM noo6ru;aThCH. Teneph oHa MOJKeT c "'IHCToli

coBeCThiO 3anoAHHTh pHeB H

BbicOKaR

O~eHOK,

ry -qacTh

cBoeli Ta6AH~hl KpHTe-

KOTOpa.si OTHOCHTCH K «6AaronpHHTHOli

cpeAe».

BbiCOKaR

--~~··"m '• GLJWlf

MaNel1 KaYecTBO lpeHepCKOI1

1\araeT TpeHepCKHe ycAyrH ropa3AO 6oAee BbiCOKOfO

y6eAJiTeAbHO. 0Ha 6h1Aa O"'leHh paAa, "'ITO eli BblnaA CAy-

k':

KaYecreo llrpoKoe e Moel1 KOMaH,Qe

TpeRep 3HKO TaKJKe OTMeTHA, "'ITO «AMa30HKa» npeA-

H3 A~IIIHX! »

AflR llOBblwettiiR IIHAHBIIAyanbHOrO MaGepcTBa B!pyTtione

6naronp11RTHaR Cpe.!la AflR llOBbiUJeHIIR IIH,QIIBIIAYanbHOro Maaepaea e Q>yroone

MOJKHOCTb ~aCTBOBaTh B OAJiHaKOBOM KOAH"'IeCTBe 1303 t<JaT"'Ieli. H 3TO - KaK pa3 o"'leHh BaJKHO AA.sJ Te6H KaK

(pe.!lHRR

pa6oTbl

6naronp~t!ITHaR ~a AflR

KaYeCTBO llrpoKOB BMoel1

noeblweHIIR IIH,QIIBIIAYanbHoro Maaepaea e !pyTtione

KOM<JH.Qe

BbiCOKaR

+++++

npeKpaCHO,

npeKpaCHO.

KOM<JH,QaYeMniiOH

KOMaH,Qacepe6pRHbll1

BbiCOKaR

npiiJeP

«51 HaCTOHTeAbHO peKOMeHAyiO Te6e nocTYflaTb B «AMa30HKy»,- cKa3aA eli TpeHep 3HKO. XoTH, no ero

BoJMO)I(HOGb yYaGBOBalb BOOnbWOM KOOIIYeCTBe Mam

BbiCOKaR

KaYecTBO rpeH€pCKOI1

(peAHRR

CAOBaM, o6e I.IIKOAbi MOryT nOXBaCTaThCH 6AeCTHIIJ;Hf>fli HrpoKaMH, npH 3TOM OHH npeAAaraiOT

~aiiJ;HMCH

Bepi.IIeHHO pa3AH"'IHbie paMO"'IHhle YCAOBHH. CTapiiia.si IIIKOAa «PRo» H3BeCTHa TeM, qTO

co·

abl·

+++++

(KMaNM AOOYCKa!OTCR TOnbKO llrpOKII nepeoro JWeooHa)

(KMaNM AO!lYCKa:OTCR llrpoKII ecex ypoeHei1)

+++++

(rpeHePblleeJAbl,

pa6oru

nycKaeT Ha HrpOBOe noAe TOAbKO CBOli 3Be3AHhlU co· cTaB. EcAH Thi He B nepBOM 3IIIeAoHe, Te6e He c BeTifl' CAHI.IIKOM MHOfO HrpOBOfO BpeMeHH. C Apyroli CTOpo·

BbiCOKaR

(BelliiKonenHble

HOpeAKO OORBnR!OTCR Ha rpeHIIpoBKaX)

rpeHepbl, YAenR:oT MHOro niiYHOro BpeMeHII yYeHIIKaM)

+++

+++++

Hhl, «AMa30HKa» npeAOCTaBAHeT BCeM CBOHM yqeHHI<.afd 127 126

j{allUeB B lliKOAe: «B «PRO» TplfA:qaTh C JllilliHHM aMepH· I<aiiCKMX yqeHHKOB, KOTOpbie BMeCTe XOA5IT Ha ypOKH I1 aceii TOAIIOH 3aBMCaiOT rrocAe lliKOJ\.bi. OHM He rycyroTcH c MeCTHbiMH. l1HOrAa y MeHH CKAaAbiBaeTC5I TaKOe BITe· qaTAeHMe, 'ITO H HMKyAa 11 He ye3JKaAa 113 ClllA. MHorHe

:aac rro-rrpeJKHeMY roBopHT rro-rropTyraAbCKM qepe3 3 neiib·KOAOAY• XOTH JKHBYT 3AeCb yJKe 6oAee AByx AeT».

TpeTHH yqeHHK qyBCTBOBaA ce6H He Ayqllle: «Y MeHH

E ~

geT HM OAHOro Apyra H3 MeCTHbiX. Ec.llli Tbl AeHCTBMTehhHO xoqeJllh y3HaTh MeCTHyro KYAhTYPY 11 B coBep-

weHCTBe

OBA~eTb HHOCTpaHHbiM 5I3biKOM,

Te6e A)"'llle

nocTYUMTb B lliKOAy, rAe yqaTC5I TOAbKO MeCTHbie pe65ITa. TaK Tbl 6biCTpee M3YlJHlllb TO, 'ITO XOTeAa». KHBH 6biAa B lliOKe, IIpO'IMTaB 3TH IIHCbMa, HO BCe yqa:rn;HeCH 6blllli eAlfHbl B CBOeM MHeHHH. Ha CAeAyiD·

Ki'\Si'\ l:I.A~O,llH':t SJ1.AI'On?Pi.S':tl:{~:FO C.?.t.D,~ .D,Jl$1 OC,.SO.,tl:{i'\$1 K~J1h':t~?bl Pi. S3b!K.A .D,?~tOI'f C.':t?.Al:fbl

yqeHMKOB, HaxOAH:rn;HXC5I ITO rrporpaMMe MeJKAYHapOA-

Terrepb rrepeA KHBH CTOHJ\..a 3~aqa orrpeAe.llliTh, KaKOi

TO'IHO TaK JKe, KaK H Te yqeHHKH ¥13 «PRO», C KOTOpbiMH

~MR AeHh OHa CIIpOCHAa HeCKOJ\.bKHX HHOCTpaHHbiX HOfO o6MeHa B lliKOAe, rAe YlJMTCH KMBH, HHe OHM C'IHTalOT HaHA)"'lliHM

H3 BapHaHTOB A)"'llle c TO'IKH 3peHHH ocBoeHHH KYAh· TYPhi H H3biKa Apyro:H: cTpaHbl. 0Ha CBH3aAacb c

npn·

eMHOH KOMHCCHeH CTapllleH lliKOJ\.bi «PRO» H IIOA)"'HM

AJ\.5I

~aKoe OKpyJKe-

yqe6bl 3a py6eJKOM.

ycneAa noo6:rn;aTbC5I KHBH, BCe OHM IIOA'IepKHYllli BaJKHOCTb IIOJ\.HDrO rrorpyJKeHH5I B qyJKepOAHYJO cpeAY· Tenepb, HMeH Ha pyKax BCIO 3TY HHcpOpMa:qHIO, KHBH

TaM KOHTaKTHble AaHHble Tpex aMepHKaHCKHX yqa~HX·

3aiiOJ\.HHAa OCTaBlllyiDC5I qaCTb CBOeH Ta6.1lli:qbi «KpMTe-

C5I, rrpOXOAH:rn;HX KypC o6yqeHH5I B :noll: lliKOAe. DocMB

pHM H o:qeHKH» (C.

132).

3.1\.eKTpOHHOe IIHCbMO OAHOMY ¥13 HHX, OHa IIOA)"'HM TaKOH OTBeT: «Crre:qHaAbHaH rrporpaMMa AJ\.5I HHOCTpaH· HhiX yqa:rn;HXcH cocTaBAeHa xopolllo. Ha Bcex ypoKax rrpenoAaBaTe.llli

roBopHT

MeMeHHee,

qeM

o 6hl'IHO,

'IT06hi KaJKAbiH ¥13 HaC, AaJKe He BA~e5I B COBepiiieH· CTBe IIOpTyraAbCKHM 5I3biKOM, MOr CAeAlfTb 3a XOAOM MhiC.Illi. Ho ec.llli TBOH :qe.l\.b -

B coBepllleHcTBe ocBo-

HTh 6pa3HJ\.bCKYJO KYAhTYPY H nopTyraAbCKHR H3b1Kr 5I 6bi IIOCOBeTOBaA Te6e IIOCTYIIaTb B CTaplllyiD JliKOAY «AMa30HKa». MoJKeT 6biTb, rrpHeMHOH KOMHCCMH

He IIOHpaB5ITC5I MOM CAOBa, HO 5I AOAJKeH 6hiTb C T060H 'leCTHbiM. Te6e CAeAyeT AeHCTBHTe.l\.bHO IIOAHOCTb!O norpy3MTbC5I B APYTYIO KYAhTYPHYJO H H3hiKOBYJO c peAY»· BTopaH lliKOJ\.bHH:qa M3 «PRo», KOTopo:H: Harr:Hcahil KMBH, JKaAOBaAacb Ha 6oAblliOe KOAH'IeCTBO a M epJI·

129 128

~· 1ol

~ 0 p.

1-4

~1'\SVl l:I.A~O .D.V\':t Vl<!':tOYl{V\K ~1'\l:I.Al:f<!V\?OS.Al:IV\S O:S~'f£1:1V\S

ll(pMTepMM 6naronp~!ITHaA

CpeAaA/lA

KaYeCTBO ~rpoKOB B MOe~ KOMaHAe

BbiCOKaA

Bo3MOJKHOCTb )'1<laBooalb BOOftbU.IOM

BbiCoKaA

noBbiUJeH~A

+++++

npeKpaCHO, KOMaH)Ia· YeMn~OH

npeKpacHO, KOMaH)Iacepe6PAHbl~ nPI1lep

+++++

(KMaNaM AonyCKaiOTCA TOftbKO

~HA~BHAYanbHOro

MaCTepcraa B

<!JyiTiolle

< :a

KOn~MaNe~

1ol

KaYeCTBO TpeHepCKOO pa6o!b1

tJo:

(peAHAA

~~nepeoro

(KMaNaM AOOYCKaiOTCA ~rpoK~ ecex

3WellOHa)

ypoeHe~)

+++++ (Be/I~KOJlenHble

(TpeHepbl· 3Be3Abl, HO peAKO noABftAIOTCA Ha

:S:• :s:•

TpeHepbi, YAeflfiOI MHOrO ft~HOrO BpeMeH~ yYeHIQI)

TpeH~poeKax)

BbiCOKaA BbiCOKaA

+++ ++

+++++ +++++

6naronp~!ITHaA

non Hoe

CpeAaA/lA

norp)?KeH~e

(6onee30

OBnaAeH~A

BA3b1KOBYIO ~ KYftbrypHyiOCpeAY

aMep~KaHCK~X

(see yYa~eCA - 6pa3~bUbl;

)'1<l~XCA)

H~OAHorO

~MA3biKOM~

~HOapaHHoro

KynbrypOO

)'1<l~OCA)

(new1anbHaA nponpaMMa A/lA

H~A

)'1<l~XCA

(orcyraeyer)

BbiCOKaA

++++

BbicoKaA

+++

(3000 AOM.jrOA)

(5000 AOM./1'0/lJ

(He AOnJKHa npeeblwalb 3000 AOM.jroA) ;l<enarenbHO no6n~JKe KPHO-Ae-;l<aHe~po

(~MeeTCA;

xopowaA nponpaMMa)

~HoapaHHbiX

(T~MOab OOyYeH11A

+++++

O;etib H~3KaA

+++++

(OOnbWO~ ropoA, / C~Hr)

! +++++

(ManeHbK~~

ropoAOK, ropbi)

ll .....~····-·-·-··'- ···-·······--

( \

Cyweaeyer n~ B03MOJKHOCTb \ nonyYm ~neHA1110? }

' ···-···---········-·····LITo JK, Teneph ace HeCKOAhKO ycAOJKHHAOCh. KHBB nOHHA.a, 'ITO Ali'IHO MJ1 Hee 6oAee npHBAeKaTeAbHOi KaK C TO'!Kli 3peHHH ¢YT60AbHOrO OKpyJKeHHH, TaK H C TO'IKH 3peHHH KYAhTYPHOro H H3hiKOBoro onhiTa, HBNI· eTCH cTaprnaH IliKOAa «AMa30HKa», a aoace He «P:so». Ho aonpoc IIAaThl 3a o6YtieHHe no-npeJKHeMY ocTaeTCfl OTKphiThiM. EcAH KHBH AeHCTBHTeAhHO xotieT nonac'J'b B CTaprnyro IliKOAY «AMa30HKa», eli HaAO HaRTH HCT0q· HliK cpHHaHCHpOBaHliH.

Caa'laAa KHBli nonhiTaAaCh HaRTH opraHH3aD;HIO, KOTOpiUl MOrAa 6hi npeAOCTaBHTh eli CTHneHAHIO MJ1 Y'!e6hl B cTaprnefi IliKOAe «PRO», HO noTepneAa COKpyrnHTeAbgoe qmacKo. IliKoAa «AMa30HKa» TaKJKe He npeAocTaBAHAa cTHneHAHH HHOCTpaHHhiM Y'lam;HMCH. KHBH gaiiiAa HeCKOAhKO npaBHTeAhCTBeHHhiX CTHneHAHH li rpaHTOB OT o6m;ecTBeHHhiX opraHH3aD;HH, HO cpOK noAa'lli 3aHBAeHHH no HHM yJKe HCTeK. AMepHKaHCKaH cpeAepa:o;HH <iJYT60Aa TaKJKe He npeAOCTaBAHAa HHKaKHX CTHneHAliH Y'!ai.IJ;HMCH CTaplliliX IliKOA. KHBli He li3 TeX XAIOnliKOB, KOTOpbiX MOJKHO AerKO Bbi6HTh li3 CeAJ\.a, HO nocAeAHHe Tpli AHH OHa XOAHAa, KaK B BOAY orrym;eHHaH. HeyJKeAH nocAe acex cTapaHHH eli ace-TaKH npJiAeTCH nocTYIIaTh B IliKOAY «PRo»? Teneph 3Ta MhiCAh Bhl3hiBaAa y Hee tiYBCTBO rAy6oKoli AOCaAhl- BeAh oHa 3HaAa, 'ITO «AMa30HKa» npeAcTaBAHeT co6oli ropa3AO AYtiiliHH aapHaHT. Bo apeMH YTPeHHeli TpeHHpOBKH B cy66ory TpeHep Nr<.oHc noA03BaA KHBH, eMy 6hiAO HHTepecHo y3HaTh, KaKoe perneHHe npHHHAa cnopTcMeHKa. «Hy, KHBH, 'I eM 3aKOH'lHACH TBOH pa3roaop c TpeHepoM 3HKO? » liOHHTepeCOBaACH OH . KliBH OTBeTHAa: «TpeHep AJKOHC, 60AhiliOe cnacH60, 'ITo Bhi MeHH no3HaKOMHAH c TpeHepoM 3HKO. OH AaA MHe MHoro AeAhHhiX coaeTOB. Teneph H y6eJKAeHa, 'ITO CTaprnaH IliKOAa «AMa30HKa» - 3TO HMeHHO TO, 'ITO MHe HyJKHo. Ho, - cKa3aAa oHa c oropqeHH:eM, - ecTh OAH:H Bonpoc ... » TpeHep A,JKoHc o3a6oqeHHO B3rAHHYA Ha AeBO'lKy: «KaKoli sonpoc? » «AeAo B TOM, 'ITO 3Ta IliKOAa MHe He no KapMdHY. 06TJeHHe CTOliT nHTh TbiCH'l AOAAapOB B rOA, a 3TO Ha· 131

130

MHoro rrpeBhliiiaeT MOH 6IOAJKeT.l1 co cnmeHARe:ii Mae TOJKe He IIOBe3AO ... ».

,.q

i ~

TpeHep MOA'Ia CMOTpeA Ha KHBH, HacyrmB 6pOBH. J.1 BApyr rn;eAKHyA IIaAhiJ;aMH. «Hy-Ka, IIOAOJKAH CeK)'ll. AO'lKy, KHBH!» - CKa3aA OR H Ha6paA KaKOH-TO HOM:ep Ha M06:HAbHOM TeAe¢oHe. «TipHBeT, <DHA, 3TO H. Kill rroJKHBaeiiih? CAYIIIali, rroMHHIIIh KHBH, HaiiiY HOBem,. KJlO Harr~arorn;yro, 0 KOTOpOH Thl crrpaiiiHBaA IIOCAe rrocAeAHero Mana? » KaJKeTCH, TpeHep AJKoHc roBopHT c KeM-TO, KTO BHH· MaTeAbHO cAeAHT 3a ycrrexaMH AeBO'lKH. KHBH MON!a CAYIIIaAa H HeAOJMeBaAa, K 'leMJ BeAeT TpeHep AJK,OHC. «Aa ... To'IHO ... CTapiiiaH IIIKOAa «AMa30HKa» B Epa3HAHH. Aa, oRa xo'leT exaTh rrpHMO ce:ii'!ac. TIHTh ThlC.Hli AOAAapOB B fOA. 0TAH'IHO, H rrepeAaM e:fr, 'IT06hl OHa K Te6e 3aiiiAa. CrracH6o, <DHA. AaBali KaK-HH6YAh BCTJ>eTHMCH, II006eAaeM BMeCTe». TpeHep AJKOHC CYHJA TeAecpOH B KapMaH H IIOBepHyACH K KHBH C IIIHpOKOH yAhl6KOH Ha AHIJ;e. «KHBH, naKyH '!eMOAaHhl! - KpHKHyA OH. - Thl eAeiiih B «AMa· 30HKy»! KHBH He 3HaAa, 'ITO H cKa3aTh. ORa HHKaK He Mor.r.a B3HTb B TOAK, 'ITO JKe, C06CTBeHHO, IIpOH30IIIAO. «f10CAY" IIIaH, - CKa3aA TpeHep AJKOHC, - 3TO 6hiAAM:peKTOp DO MapKeTHHry KOMrraHHH «Nike». KoMrraHHH xo'leT 6bl'l'b TBOHM CIIOHCOpOM. 0Ha OIIAaTHT Bee: TBOe 06YlJeHHe, pacXOAbi Ha JK:HJ\be H rrHTaHHe. ORa AaJKe o6ecrreqH'l' Te6H MOAHhiMH IIIMOTKaMH - Bee, 'ITO rroJKeAaeiiih. He· IIAOXO, rrpaBAa? f1eperOBOpH CO CBOHMH pOAM:TeNJMH H CTYflaH IIpHMO B oqmc K <DHAy». KHBH He IIOBepHAa CBOHM YIIIaM. HeKOTOpoe Bpe· MH ORa CTOHAa, KaK BKOIIaHHaH. fJOTOM AO Hee AoUieJ\ CMbiCA CAOB, rrpOH3HeCeHHhlX TpeHepOM. l1 oRa OOA" rrphlfHYAa oT p~ocTH: «BoT 3TO Aa! KpYTo! EoAhllloe crracH6o, TpeHep AJKoHc!»

s A.~?ono?r~ MecHu; crrycTH l<.HBH cToHAa y TepMHHaAa a3porropTa HMeHH AJK,oHa KeHHeAM:. ORa ompaBAHAaCh B Epa3HAM:IO. 1\HBH rrpHHHAa rrpeMOJKeHHe cpHpMhl «Nike», KOTOpaH o6.H3aAach oiiAa'lHBaTh ee o6YlJeHHe. KorAa HaCTJIIHA MOMeHT paCCTaBaHFIH H AeBO'!Ka Ha'laAa rrporn;aThCH C pof\IITeA51MH, 6paThHMH-6AH3Heu;aMH, TPeHepoM AJKoHCOM H ToBapHIIJ;aMH no KOMaflAe, ee rAa3a BAPyr paciiiHpHhHCh OT H3JMAeHHH. «51 yJKe rAe-TO BHAeAa 3TO, HMeHHO cu;eHy! .. » l1 TJT BCIIOMHM:Aa, 'ITO BCe 3TO yJKe CHHAOCb ea B TY HO'lh, KOrAa oRa HarrHcaAa CBOH CIIHCOK rrpeACTOS!UJ,HX AeA H peiiiHAa crrpocHTh coBeTa y TPeHepa AJK,oHca. EMiHCTBeHHOe OTAH'!He COCTOHAO B TOM, 'ITO ORa OTllpaBA51AaCb B CTapiiiyro IIIKOAY «.AMa30HKa», a He «PHO».

3:f

l<RBH IIOAYMaAa: «TioJKaAyH, Mhl AelicTBHTeAhHO MOlReM li3MeHHTb CBOIO cyAb6y, eCAH CTapaeMCH 6hlTh KJ3· l!e~a~m co6cTBeHHoro c'laCThH». ORa yAhl6HyAaCh H llJoliV\.a no TParry caMoAeTa, rrpeHcrroAHeHHaH 6oAbiiiHX l!<iA,eJKA.

n MoJKeT 6hlTh, Mhl ern;e BCTpeTHMCH c KHBH Ha 'leMlioaaTe MHpa. CAeAM:Te 3a co6hlTHHMH. 133

132

~1ll

~ .Q

tJo:l

O•

~·

;J"I

AK~MS~O~O?.KM?~~~

KaKHe KOHKpeTHhie KpHTepHH MHe eAeAyeT B3HTh 3d oeHOBy? BepHbl .1\.H MOH KpHTepHH? f1paBH.hh-

C.SOI-0 C.~ .D,hS~. MC.nbi~biSAH ~A

HhlH .1\.H Bee 5I npHAdlO KaJKAOMY KpHTepHIO?

n?01fii'OC.~h e.ose.~s~~bl~ ?~lii~~RJl IToxoJKe, 'ITO Kmnr npeAcrmrr JKM3Hh, no.I\HaH 3CIXBa'I'hiBa. 10rn;mc npmv\I<J'Ie!IHH:, He IIpaBAd.llli? B hl MOJKeTe nOAYMirl'L, 'ITO e:H: npocro noBe3J\.O, HO Bee 3TO 11pOH30lli.J\.O HMeHHo DoTOMY, 'ITO AeBqoHKa noABeprM eoMHeHHIO eo6eTBeHHoe npeAB35ITOe MHeHHe H npeAIIpl:IIDIJ\d ai<.TI:IBHhle Ae:H:CTBwr, a ern;e nOTOMY, lfl'O OHa 6hll\a He TOAbKO Ta.l\aHT.IlliBOH cpyrt)o. .llliCTKOH, HO H TPeHHpOBa.l\aeh B noTe .MIIJ;a MHoro AeT DOAPM, tfl'06hl oTlli.J\.HcpoBaTh eBoe MaerepcrBo. KoHe~o. ee MH.I\.hlH H A06pblli HpaB TaKJKe ehlrpaA He noCAeAHIOIO poAL: .I\.IOAii qacro lliJ\.H e:H: HaBeTPeqy, OeTaBHB Bee eBOH AeAa. l<aK eKa3aA CeHeKa, «Be3eHHe - 3TO TO, lfl'O CAyqaereH, KOrAii noAroTOBAeHHOCTb BCTPeqaereH e B03MOJKHOCTbiO». KHBH npenOAHeeAa HaM HeeKO.hhKO ~eHHhlX ypoKoB: •

•

ITpoBOAH MeHhllle BpeMeHH B Tep3aHHHX H coMHeHHHX H 60.1\hllle BpeMeHH noeBHill;dH 06AyMhl· BdHHIO Ae:H:eTBHH, KOTOpbie MOryT n pH6.1lli3HTb Te6H K ~e.I\.H, a 3aTeM - AeHeTByH. CnpalllHBa:H: eoBeTa y eBeAyrn;Hx .I\.IOAe:H:. He HilAO eaMOMY H306peTaTb BeAOeHneA. Vlrn;H HHcpOpMa· ~RIO, KOTOpaH nOMOJKeT Te6e npHHHTh Hdli.l\.)"1" lllee pellleH:He B AdHHhiH KOHKpeTHhlH M OMeHT. CTaBh nOA eoMHeH:He Beeb XOA eBOHX MbiCAeH H CBOii -yM03aKJ\.IOqeHHH. 3dAaBaH ee6e TaKHe Bonpoehl: LITo roBopHT «3a» H qTo - «npoTHB»? CoeTauea .1\.H MHOIO :HeqepnhlBdlOill;HH en:HeOK? K aKOH I{J BapHaHTOB BhlrMAHT HaH60Aee npHB.I\.eKaTe.hl>11° e yqeTOM Beex «3d» H «npOTHB»? 5IBMIOTC51 e<PO~?MY.I\.HPOBaHHhie MHo:H: «3a» H «npoTHB» AeK· eTBHTe.hhHO «3a» H «npoTHB»? KaKHe Ae{lcTBK51 5I MOry npeAfipHHHTh, qT06bi MaKeHMH3Hp0Ba'l'l> cpaKTOphl «3d» H MHHHMH3HpOBdTb .I\.H60 no}\}IO"

eThiO yeTPaHHTh cpaKTOphl «npoTHB»?

BepHa .llli MOH o~eHKa? Ha KaKOH HHcpopM~HH 6a3HpyeTeH MOH o~eHKa? Ae:H:eTBHTe.hbHO .llli oHa ToqHa, aKTYa.hhHa H o6'heKTHBHa? KaKHe Ae:H:eTBHH 51 MOry npeAfipHH51Th, tfl'06hl nOBhleliTh npHB.I\.eKaTe.hhHOeTh HMeiOrn;HXe51 y MeH51 BapHaHTOB? Mhl yqHMeH Ha npHMepe KHBH, HO AaJKe oHa MOrAa 6bl ITOHTH Aa.hhllle B eBOeH o~eHKe HMeiOill;HXe51 BdpH-

aHTOB. Ae:H:eTBHTe.hhHO, eTaplllaH lllKOAa «AMa30HKa» - npeKpaeHhlH BapHdHT, HO eaMhiH .1\.H AyqlllHH? KHBH AOAJKHa 6hiAa H3yqHTh APyrHe lllKO.I\.hi B Epa3H.I\.HH H.I\.H AaJKe B ApyrHX eTpaHax, B KOTOphlX XOpOlllO pa3BHT ¢YT6oA. KoHeqHo, y Hee 6hl.l\. orpaHHqeHHhlH 3anae BpeMeHH Hd npHHHTHe pellleHHH - Bee Mhl orpaHHqeHbl Kpa:H:HHMH epoKaMH. Ho BaJKHO BeerAa noABepraTh COMHeHHIO eBOH Mhle.I\.H H HeKdTh ApyrHe BapHaHThl, KOTOpbie MOr.I\.H nepeA 3THM yeKO.I\.h3flYTh OT Halllero BHHMdHHH . HdAeiOeh, qTo H3 HeTopHH KHBH Bhi H3BAeqeTe AAH Ce6H HeeKO.I\.hKO npaKTHqeeKHX eoBeTOB, KOTOpbie noMOryT B Aa.hhHeHllleM npHHHMdTh 6oAee rpaMOTHhle pellleHH51 H Bee .1\.yqllle o6yeTpaHBdTb Barny JKH3Hb. PelllaTh npo6AeMhl He TaK yJK eAOJKHO, ee.I\.H HayqHThCH CTaBHTb nepeA eo6o:H: qeTKyiO ~e.l\.h, pa3pa6aThiBdTh ll.MH ee AOeTHJKeHH51 H eAeAOBdTh 3TOMY ll.l\.dflY, no xoAy Ae:H:eTBHH oTeAeJKHBaH eBoe npoABHJKeHHe K ~e.I\.H ll: BHOeH He06XOAHMhle H3MeHeHH51.

EcAH Bhl eAeAaeTe pellleHHe npo6AeM eBoe:H: npHBhlqI<.ofi, TO eMOJKeTe HdHTH npHMeHeHHe Bee~eBOHM Ta.\aHTaM H B351Th eBoiO JKH3Hh noA KOHTPO.I\.h. Bhl eMoJKere peumTb He TO.I\.hKO eBOH npo6AeMhl, HO H npo6AeMhl CBoe:H: lllKO.I\.hl, cpHpMbl H.I\.H ropOAd - a MOJKeT 6hlTh, AiiJKe Bcero MHpa. 135

134

"'~0 p.

~ .Q

~· :s:•

;;:

~Jl.Al'O AA?\fOG':r.b XO~ II06AarOAapHTh BCeX, KTO HerrocpeACTBeHHO npHHHMaA TJaCTHe BO BpeMH C03AaHHH MOeR KHHfli, a TaKJKe IIOAI'OTOBKH ee K rre'laTH, 3a OKa3aHHJ'IO MHe rroMepJKKy. TipeJKAe Bcero, orpoMHOe crracH6o MOeR ceMhe, APY3hHM, HacTaBHHKaM, OAflOKAaccHHKaM, TJRTeAHM, KOMeraM ITO KOHCaATHHfOBOR qmpMe «McKinsey», KOTOpbie pa6oTaiOT B pa3HhlX yroAKax MHpa. OrpoMHaH 6AaroAapHOCTh COTPYAHHKaM HIIOHcKoro H aMepHKaHCKOfO H3AaTeAhCTB, rAe BhliiiAH HIIOHCKHR opHrHHaA ::noR KHHfH H ee aHfAOH3hl'IHaH BepCHH, ee :HAAIOCTpaTopaM, MOeMY areHTY H BCeMY rrepcOHaAY «Delta Studio», 3a Bce, 'leMY oHH HaTJRAR MeHH, 3a TY H3hiCKaHHJ'IO H rrpHHTHJ'IO aTMOCcpepy, B KOTOpOR rrpoXOAHA Bech MOR rrpoeKT. B 6mJKaRrnee BpeMH H IIAaHHpyro HaHeCTH KaJKAOMY H3 BaC rrepCOHaAhHhlR BH3HT, 'IT06hl AH'IHO Bhlpa3HTh CBOIO IIpH3HaTeAhHOCTh.

XoTeA 6hi TaKJKe BhiCKa3aTh oco6yro 6AaroAapHOCTh 6hiBIIIeMY pyKOBOAJiTeAIO rrpeACTaBHTeAhCTBa «McKinsey» B 5lrroHHH Macao XHpaHo, MOeMY peAaKTopy KopTHH 5IHr, HMIOCTpaTopy .AM.eey CaHAepcy H COTPYAHHKaM «Delta Studio» CeHTe lOR H TaKaiiiH 5IMarnHTa. Macao Bceu;eAo rroMepJKHBaA MOH rrpocBenneAbcKHe HHHI.J;HaTHBhl H C03AaA MHe BCe He06XOAHMhie ycAOBHH AA5I HarrHcaHHH :noR KHHrH. KopTHH B.I\.OJKHAa TaK MHOfO BpeMeHH H CHA B peAaKTHpOBaHHe :noR KHHfli - 6e3 BarneR 6AaropOAHOR H TeiiAOR IIOAAepJKKH 3Ta KHRfa He CMOfAa 6hl ysJiAeTh CBeT . .AM.eH, 6AaroAapro Bac 3a rrpeKpacHhie pHCYflKH - oHH rrpHAa.AR KHHre oco6hlR rnapM. CeHTa H TaKaiiiH, crracH6o BaM 3a BeAHKOAeiiHJ'IO IIOMepJKKY CO CTOpOHhl «Delta Studio» - Bhi CAeAaAH 3TOT rrpoeKT TaKHM rrpHHTHhiM, AYllieBHhlM H 3aHHMaTeAhHhlM! 137

136

Y)J,K005.53 66K65.29-2 B21

HayKoBo-nonynRpHe BI'!AaHHR

KEH BATAHA6E

.S'il'tM.OGR .Sl't?llli~.B.A.~H n?OSJJ.£Ml"l Poci~ICbKOIO

MOBOIO

KH11ra «BYI-IMOCR B11piwysaTI1 npo6neMw>cnOYaTKY 6yna pmpaxosaHa Ha WKOnRpiB,ll\o6 HaBYI-ITI-1 'ix Kp11T11YHOrO Ml'!cneHHR. Aile AY'JKe CKOpo BOHa CTana 6eCTcenepOM CaMe CepeA AOpocn11x 3aBARKI1 e¢eKTI1BHii;, MeTOAI'!Ui B11piweHHR npo6neM, po3po6neHii;, KeHoM BaTaHa6e (B MI'!HynoMy npoBiAHI'Ii;, KOHcynbTaHT McKinsey). M11cneHHR, opi€HTOBaHe Ha B11piweHHR npo6neM, MO'JKe AaTI-1 HaM MO'JKni1BiCTb KOHTponiOBaTI-1 CBO€ 'JKI'ITIR UinKOM i nOBHiCTIO, HaBYI1TI1CR B11piwysaTI1 npo6neMI1, cnpaBnRTI'ICR 3 HecnoAiBaHI-IMI-1 B11Kni1KaMI1 i HaBiTb 3MiHI1TI1 CBiT. 0BOnOAiBWI1 3aBARK11 Uii;, KHI13i 3anponOHOBaHI1MI1 HaBI-IYKaMI-1 B~-!piweHHR npo6neM, BI13A11BY€Tecb, RKpaHiwe Morn~'! 6e3 HI-IX o6xoA11T11CR. KH11ra AOCI1Tb npoaa AnR po3yMiHHR i WKOnRpaMI-1, ane np11 UbOMY po3rnRAa€ B11piweHHR cepi;,o3H11X npo6neM niOAei;,, RKi 3ai;,MaiOTbCR 6i3HecOM. ISBN 978-1-591B4-242-2 (aHrn.) ISBN 978 -966 -1629-08-9

KepiBHHK npoeKT}' noriHoBa IHHa nepeKJJa.Qa'l KypYeHKO niHa flireparypHe pe.o.aryaaHHR nes11UbKa MapiR KoMn'KJrepHa BepCTKa fiKOBn€B AHTOH .a1o13ai1H ManiDHKiB Kon11nos MaKCI'IM

3AT « B~-~AaBHI1YI1i;, 6yA11HOK «MaKCI'!MyM» syn . I. Ma3enl1,10-a, K11'is, YKpa'iHa, 01010 Ten. : +38(044)494-25 -01, cpaKc: +38(044)494-25-05 e-mail: books@companion .ua shop.companion .ua CBiAOUTBO AK N~1734 BiA 30.03.2004 p. 3aMosneHHR N ~ 10-275. BiAAPYKOBaHo Ha BAT "6inouepKiBCbKa KH11'1KKosa cpa6p11Ka" . 09117, M. 6ina l..(epKsa, syn . necR Kyp6aca, 4. CBiAOUTBO cepiR AK N~ 567 BiA 14.08.2001p.