19 minute read
SPECIAL FEATURE: LOG LOADING
from NZ Logger July 2022
by nzlogger
Logging
on Story: Ian Parkes Photos: Gerald Shacklock
IN THE GOOD OLD DAYS LOADING SHIPS
was done with a lot of labour. Crated goods were loaded into cargo nets which the ships’ cranes then hauled aboard. Stevedores then manually stacked them in the hold.
Of course, containerisation transformed much of the business of shipping, and of shipside handling operations. However, if you watch logs being loaded at most ports around the world it won’t look much different to the old-style cargo net process, except they are loading logs rather than boxes.
Logs still arrive at the ship’s side by loader or on a trailer. The ship’s crane lowers strops which are manually wrapped around the logs and the crane hauls them aboard. On the ship they are unhooked, then the stevedoring crew on deck uses small diggers with log grapples to line them up neatly in the hold or up against stanchions lining the ships deck, stacking the load height 12 to 15 metres above deck level.
Having to attach strops around logs every few minutes is hard physical work, not to mention hazardous. Releasing the strops, which could easily be under tension, can be even more hazardous, even if the closest workers are reasonably well protected in a machine cab.
While some log loading operators still use this process, ISO has revolutionised the log loading process for its customers at Tauranga and Gisborne ports, so that it now takes some 50% fewer people and less time to load the ship and send it on its way.
ISO was founded in 1995 as a stevedoring company, which fundamentally is the process of loading or unloading ships. Since then, the company has diversified into other businesses where it has seen opportunities to add value for customers. More often though, it needed to ramp up efficiency in these other operations to keep up with its ability to load ships. It is now a multifaceted logistics company focused on port operations.
The company handles around 60% of New Zealand’s export log trade. It loads over 500 log vessels a year, around 11 vessels a week. While logs – more than 25 million of them a year – feature prominently, ISO also handles a large portion of New Zealand’s kiwifruit exports, around 25% of the country’s pulp exports as well as container, breakbulk and all manner of other import and export operations.
Safety-driven A phrase like “It’s the way we’ve always done it,” stands as an open challenge to ISO whose track record of innovation shows it to be pretty relentless in finding safer, smarter and faster ways of doing things. That is better for the customers, it is clearly paying off in winning market share but, especially as it is safer, it also benefits staff.
ISO’s business development manager, Neil Weber, says that the issue of safety drove one of the innovations he introduced when he joined the company in 2014. In 2013 ISO won its first big contract in Tauranga for marshalling 2.5 million tonnes a year of logs – basically compiling ship loads of logs. It had started marshalling in Napier in 2011 but the Tauranga contract was of a different order of magnitude and really got under way just as Neil joined.
The size of the new contract at Tauranga quickly highlighted a problem. Most of the logs are marshalled on the wharves but the client company had to store some logs just over the road in an off-port log yard. That meant double-handling and a straight additional cost. At the time ISO was using conventional looking trailers, triaxle ‘bailey bridges’.
However, Neil says, the big issue was the need to repeatedly fling chains over packets of logs and unchain them again after a short
shuttle from the off-port yard. It was hard physical and “frankly” hazardous work.
“We’re a very, very safety-focused company and we don’t want people exposed to hazards or repetitive strain type injury, and with throwing chains there’s always that possibility.”
Even keeping staff prepared to do that job repeatedly was a serious challenge. Finding a solution was a priority as the Tauranga business increased from almost zero short haul logs to around 250,000 tonnes a year.
Neil had made several industry trips to Australia, so he knew that there, as in some other countries, backboards were sometimes fitted to logging trailer units. It wasn’t a big leap from there to modifying a triaxle skel and making use of the container twist locks to install cage sides at either end. The change effectively created log bins, which hold the logs safely for their short journeys. With the logs caged, the sides could remain open in the centre for easy loader access. The bin design did away with the use of chains entirely, in one fell swoop solving drivers’ biggest issue and again, it saved time and money. Above: Loading pulp into an ISOI Kenworth at the PanPac plant in Napier. Opposite: One of the 550-tonne Liebherr Mobile Harbour Cranes in action at Tauranga.
Grooved Drums and Sleeves
Neil Weber has overseen many of the innovations introduced to the ISO operation in recent years.
It seems so obvious now. It’s one of those ideas that make you wonder why no-one thought of this before. Few ports do log shuttles and ISO was so successful in winning business with this operation, it now has seven of the nine customers who use the off-port storage in Tauranga.
The trailers were built by Patchell Trailers, and Neil remains a big fan of their work. Clearly the bins are more enclosed than conventional trailers and although it may seem like it would be a solution for longer distance log haulage, it’s not. Neil explains that the bin units are heavier than conventional trailers, so they would reduce the payload, and the empty trailers couldn’t be loaded onto the trucks, which is necessary to give the trucks enough traction on forestry roads.
ISO operates six log bins, two per B-train trailer set, with more coming later in the year. However, even now, that short haul business is not full-time, so the trailers can also be swapped out for curtain-sided bins. They are actually modified containers with a curtain on one side, for handling bulk pulp, effectively creating bins suitable for packaged pulp.
New Zealand exports over one million tonnes of pulp each year through the Tauranga and Napier ports, in both containers and in bulk. The pulp is all baled, but the bulk cargo is shifted by clamp forklifts which grab bundles of pulp bales using paddles at each side of the machine.
As Napier is the other port that needs log shuttles, the log bins and bulk bins combo is in use there. They can be exchanged in just a few minutes. ISO handles 250,000 tonnes of pulp a year in Napier. Neil says the Super-B units mean they can run 60-tonne gross weight loads of logs and pulp 24 hours a day, five and a half days a week in Napier.
And that’s not the end of the innovation with these trailers. Not all logs are of the same length. While the current bins are fine for logs of 3.9 to 5.9m they have room and payload capacity to handle more 3.9m logs per load. So now Neil and Patchells are developing a sliding mechanism making the back end of the bin moveable to allow two packets to be carried per bin.
On the road ISO started out as a family business initially by the late Les Dickson and then later on by his son, Greg Dickson, and then his son, Liam Dickson. The family-run business branched out into trucking in the early 2000s when they won a contract from Carter Holt Harvey to handle 500,000 tonnes of pulp that all came into Tauranga on the rail.
Neil says the 10-truck fleet was an aging “fruit salad” of second-hand trucks in the early years: Mitsubishis, Scanias, Sterlings, bought first for pulp handling (bulk and containers) and then for some container transport between Auckland and Tauranga. A couple of leased Isuzus were bought in around 2015. The first new trucks were two Freightliners mainly for line haul, which are still part of the fleet.
That fleet was also servicing the ISO warehousing and container packing operation in Tauranga, mostly timber into 40-foot containers – again mostly short haul, around 5000 to 10,000 containers a year.
The pulp side was around 20,000 containers a year plus 12 to 18 ships a year of bulk pulp.
As the innovations that have transformed the business started to stack up, I ask Neil if he can name a top 10. “Easy,” he says. “This is a shipping business, so they are nearly all three-letter acronyms.”
He rattles them off: “RSMs, ATS, MHC, Pre-Advice, Com 90, MLS, LMS, ShipSys, Log bins and pulp bins, Super-Bs, debarkers… how are we doing?”
More than enough.
One of them was ISO’s move to a fleet upgrade focused on running at HPMV loads.
At the time Neil says there were not a lot of options but the Australian-built Kenworth T410 fitted the bill. They opted for four 6x4s and four 8x4s for container haulage. Neil says a lot of drivers prefer having a bonnet in front of them rather than the cab-over design favoured in Europe, partly for looks and partly for perceived safety, along with easier access, important when you are getting in and out frequently each day.
ISO completed the order in March 2020 and the new trucks were all on the road by the end of November 2020. Neil says the Super-B configuration is a smart move for New Zealand and it reduces the number of loads on our roads for the given freight. The distribution over more axles avoids any increased loading on the road but the extra capacity reduces the number of truck journeys.
“The focus on axle loadings here is much greater than just about anywhere else,” he says.
The fleet upgrade gave ISO a new look on the road, but the company was also making another move to expand its truck business significantly. This change was much less visible.
In January 2021 ISO completed a deal to take over Gisborne-based Williams & Wilshier/Pacific Haulage which runs 100 logging trucks, mostly Kenworths. They will remain branded in Pacific Haulage livery as the company has such a strong legacy in the region.
Onward and upward So, with the fleet sorted, ISO got back to looking at other ways to improve the business. Most of the innovations are home grown, but some have simply been ordered and shipped in, like the massive Liebherr MHCs, or mobile harbour cranes that dominate the skyline at Mount Maunganui, their jibs reaching 75 metres in height.
It takes a company with serious backing – which ISO got when it became part of the Qube group in 2017 – to fund the purchase of not one but six of these 550tonne monsters, 18 months ago, each of which travels on 80 wheels. Three cranes are in operation in Tauranga and three in Gisborne.
The 12-tonne safe working load capacity
cranes are equipped with the world’s largest grapples, specified by ISO, which lift an entire trailer’s log packet at a time. No log wires are involved and there’s no one around on the loading berth. Queried as to why the largest grapples are found here in New Zealand, Neil says it’s all a question of scale. “We handle a lot of logs here.”
At Tauranga and Gisborne there’s the volume to justify the massive investment in the cranes. The economics only work if there is more cargo to move and the shipping available to take it when the extra speed increases the throughput.
The MHCs can load a ship with over 35,000 tonnes of cargo of logs, faster than the ship’s own cranes – that’s when they are even working. Neil says the frequency of shipboard cranes being inoperative is increasing due to a number of factors, including that they’ve been used for years on all sorts of bulk cargoes and operated by people in ports all around the world with widely differing levels of skill. This is a prime example of ISO taking control of a new area which benefits everyone involved in the process.
The new mobile cranes highlighted the need for another innovation. Traditionally the 30- tonne max ships’ cranes hoisted tracked machines – diggers – aboard to distribute the logs evenly. Typically, being the smaller 16–20-tonne machines, they struggle to keep up with the capacity of the mobile cranes. As the mobile cranes can also hoist heavier diggers aboard, ISO is moving to using a 30-35-tonne machine which can handle a bigger grapple and reposition many more logs at a time. Neil also says ISO is also developing a remote-control digger, which a driver can operate from the safety of a room onshore, anywhere.
“That’s really one of the drivers of innovation. We are always looking at the safety of staff and if we think we can find a way of doing the job while making it safer for staff, we’ll do it. Or we’ll take a look at a completely different way of doing things.”
Another bought-in innovation are the Com 90 devices developed in Sweden,
Above: Logs are checked through an ATS (auto tally station) before being loaded onto a ship. Below: Containerised pulp on the move from PanPac near Napier.
another solution to the perennial problem of chaining logs. The Com 90 unit, the first in New Zealand, has both hydraulics and a worm gear built into each stanchion of a log trailer. The hydraulics fling a pair of arms mounted at the top of each stanchion across the load of logs and they grab each other with a simple hook and loop arrangement. The worm gear then pulls the arms down tight, and it keeps up the pressure, hugging the logs even tighter if they settle.
Neil says at around $100,000 per unit they are not cheap, and they have to be mounted on trucks with hydraulics to the trailer. The one unit ISO is running is currently under evaluation.
Scaling up Other innovations have been developed in-house or in association with a partnering company. Robotics Plus is one such partner and one of the big breakthroughs it has been involved with are the RSMs or robotic scaling machines. Three have been installed in Mount Maunganui. There are now 14 machines working in ISO operations with others due to be installed at other log ports soon.
They are an integral part of ISO’s LMS
ISO has been trialling a Swedish Com 90 log securing system on this Isuzu at the Port of Tauranga.
EXCLUSIVE EXCLUSIVE NEW ZEALAND NEW ZEALAND DISTRIBUTOR OF DISTRIBUTOR GB FORESTRY PRODUCTS GB FORESTRY PRODUCTS
EXCLUSIVE NEW ZEALAND DISTRIBUTOR OF GB FORESTRY PRODUCTS
EXCLUSIVE NEW ZEALAND DISTRIBUTOR OF GB FORESTRY EQUIPMENT
EXCLUSIVE NEW ZEALAND DISTRIBUTOR GB FORESTRY PRODUCTS
" "
PITCHGAUGE
3/4
PITCHGAUGE
EXCLUSIVE NEW ZEALAND DISTRIBUTOR OF GB FORESTRY PRODUCTS
Above: ISO trucks can be quickly converted from carrying containers to having the innovative log cages fitted for short-haul loading work. Right: Driver, Levi Rahui, checks the twist locks after the log cages have been fitted into place.
or log management system. Today, every log has to be measured and tracked. When logs are loaded in the forest the driver is supposed to count each log, which is harder than it sounds, says Neil. It was a constant headache, trying to reconcile packets of logs when they arrived at the port.
Now drivers send ‘pre-advice information’ to ISO when they pick up a load of logs in the forest. The logs are graded there, and the large end of all logs receives a painted mark. The driver sends photos of each load to ISO’s pre-advice system, which is unique to ISO, so it knows what’s coming.
In the past the load would be manually checked when it arrived at the port, and the logs ‘scaled’ - that is the small end diameter of all logs would be measured with a ruler and a scanner would record the measurement. The amount of millable timber in each log is obviously important, and that has to be measured at the smaller end.
“In the past it was a process that could see drivers hanging around in a queue at the port for an hour or more depending on a number of factors,” says Neil.
The first process when a truck arrives at the port is for each log to have a barcode ticket stapled to its small end, a key ingredient of the LMS. Then the drivers simply drive into the back of a large shed containing the RSMs. They stop under a caged gantry and the RSM’s powered boom laden with cameras rolls down and up between each packet of timber. It scans and photographs all the logs and tickets on both truck and trailer for the scaling software to process every piece.
On the control screen you can see the RSM has automatically measured the dimensions of every ticketed log. In a few minutes the driver is through and heading onto the port to unload. With three lanes in operation, the RSM shed can handle more than 300 loads a day, so there’s virtually no waiting. ISO’s 14 machines are currently processing 1200 loads a day through Marsden Point, Gisborne, Napier, Timaru, and Bluff.
Logs on the move.
“It’s been a real boon to the transport companies – not that they would ever admit that,” says Neil. “They love coming to ISO; it’s four minutes for scaling every time.”
The E-scaler operator, Midas Te Kakara, who comes from one of several families with more than one member working at ISO, is also happy to admit it was good for him too. A job in a nice warm office beats scrambling about in the rain, measuring logs with a ruler and a scanner.
Some RSM images also came in handy when one of ISO’s customers, a log exporter, received a query from an overseas customer who complained its order of logs of a certain volume turned up about 10% less than ordered. They wanted a substantial discount. As the data tracking is so comprehensive the exporter simply asked ISO for the scans that showed every log in the customer’s order. The complaint was hastily withdrawn. “It must have been some other supplier,” says Neil, with a grin.
ISO also receives 40-50% of the logs it exports through the port of Tauranga by train. The track terminates at the edge of the log yards. The train can’t go through the RSM bays, so the measuring process is still done manually, as described above – but not for long. Again, working with Robotics Plus, ISO has developed a mobile log scaler, the MLS. This fully automated driverless machine, which looks like a big square letter ‘n’ on wheels can find the train, straddle the carriages, and roll along the length of the train scanning as it goes.
The space given over to log marshalling yards, and of course the off-port yards, indicates the scale of the marshalling operation required to keep sending a log ship out every day. That’s where another piece of ISO innovation comes in. Shipsys is the ship-side equivalent of the LMS.
As the LMS tracks and accounts for every log coming into marshalling from the forest, Shipsys manages the packaging and loading of logs onto ships, ensuring the right consignments go on the right ships to the right ports. And it has a simpler version of the RSM, the ATS. The ATS or auto tally station is a shed containing a drive-through scanner which checks every log into a consignment going aboard a ship, again replacing people having to scramble around a trailer with handheld scanners.
Embracing change At the beginning I mentioned how in the good old days when the wharves were swarming with people manually handling cargo. Advances in freight handling have removed much of the physical labour and ISO’s innovations have reduced much of the risk in the tasks that remain. But this doesn’t necessarily reduce jobs; the raw numbers say otherwise. By increasing efficiency and moving into other operations and making them work well too, ISO has increased its staff from around 600 in 2014 to 1100 now. The jobs have changed and become much safer.
It’s almost an afterthought when it takes minutes to drive past the log operation at just this one port, but we end up at TKL’s (Tauranga Kiwifruit Logistics) cool store, run by ISO, where consignments of kiwifruit are marshalled. Here ISO manages all of Tauranga’s bulk ship kiwifruit exports on behalf of TKL and Zespri – scanning pallets into the cool store for night loading and, during the day also loading directly onto the vessel.
As we leave the port gates, Neil gets a scheduled call to meet a contractor at another large shed sitting on a large yard just outside of the port. It is being upgraded to further refine another part of the log-handling process.
It’s clear there’s always something on the go at ISO. “I never get bored,” says Neil. “There’s always something new to do. We’re never satisfied with what we are doing today.
“I personally get a lot of satisfaction from helping make people’s lives better and especially safer. That’s always a big motivation.” NZL