Share
Report Abuse
Next Blog»
Create Blog
School Design Matters
WEDNESDAY, JUNE 20, 2012
10 Current School Facility Features that are Obsolete
PROVIDE YOUR EMAIL SO THAT I CAN NOTIFY YOU OF NEW POSTS ON THIS BLOG
Submit
Email address...
WELCOME TO SCHOOL DESIGN MATTERS
I have been out of the blogosphere for the last few months but an interesting article has come to my attention that I think is worth talking about. It’s an older article on the great blog Mind/Shift: “21 Things That Will Be Obsolete by 2020” by Shelly Blake-Plock.
School Design Matters discusses topics of interest to educators, planners, and school designers with the aim of helping us to think about better learning environments.
http://blogs.kqed.org/mindshift/2011/03/21-things-that-will-be-obsolete-by-2020/ These are school related things and it got me to thinking about how many school facility “things” are obsolete today and yet are still in wide use. These are not facility features in decades old crumbling schools; rather they are features that are frequently included in new schools today. In no particular order these are:
MY FAVORITE LINKS
Hans Rosling on Global Health RSA Animate - Ken Robinson on Creativity NAC|Architecture Cool Maps and Graphs
1.
Departmental Organizations In order to break down the size of schools and to allow students to learn across the curriculum it is essential to organize schools so that teachers of various subjects are located together. This not only emulates how people work today – in collaborative groups – but encourages teachers to consider students holistically, not only as they perform in a specific subject. Yet there are hundreds of new schools being designed and built with this obsolete organization.
GET ANSWERS
Post ideas, questions & answers! Got a question / answer? Join or Sign In
View: Recent | Popular
2.
Learning in prescribed spaces When you ask people to remember a meaningful learning experience from high school, chances are the experience they recall did not take place in a space designed for learning. Learning outside, while working in groups, while on a trip, while doing a project or learning while talking with friends are all informal experiences people cite as meaningful learning experiences. We don’t design schools to accommodate these activities; instead we only focus on the formal spaces. This is obsolete thinking.
Is the concept of cultural literacy still valid in the 21st Century? Asked by: Greg Stack - 355 days ago No replies yet
See what Google says What was your favorite learning experience in high school? Where were you? Asked by: Greg Stack - 355 days ago No replies yet
See what Google says
Get this for your site
« Previous Next »
Sign In
BOOKS AND ARTICLES
Disrupting Class - by Clay Chritiensen Drive - by Daniel Pink Frames of Mind - the Theory of Multiple Intelligences - by Howard Gardner Linking Architecture and Education - by Anne Taylor On-line Learning & the Implications for School Design - by Greg Stack School - by Catherine Burke and Ian Grosvenor Small Wonder - the Little Red Schoolhouse in History and Memory - by Jonathan Zimmerman The Global Achievement Gap - by Tony Wagner At Northern Beaches Christian School students learn everywhere
3.
SEARCH THIS BLOG Search
School Corridors Corridors take up a lot of valuable real estate in a school and are unoccupied most of the time. If we change the way we circulate in schools by changing the rooms we circulate to we can greatly reduce or eliminate corridors. If rooms are arranged in groups around a common space corridors are not necessary. If you do have corridors why not make them informal learning spaces as well. A straight shot double loaded corridor is obsolete yet many new schools are planned around these.
BLOG ARCHIVE
▼ 2012 (2) ▼ June (1) 10 Current School Facility Features that are Obso... ► January (1) ► 2011 (13) ► 2010 (9)
FOLLOWERS
Join this site with Google Friend Connect
Members (37) More »
Corridors at Machias Elementary are used for informal learning
4.
Traditional School Libraries In a modern school a library should be more of a learning commons able to support a variety of student activities as they learn to access and evaluate information. Books have their place but they are not the end-all of libraries. A learning commons is no longer the quiet sanctum of old, rather it is a space that can be central or distributed, used formally or informally, and one that can stimulate a spirit of inquiry in students.
5.
Computer labs Students are connected to the net everywhere except in school. We force them to power down and disconnect and put them in obsolete computer labs. Not every student can afford a personal device but many schools are getting around this by issuing I-pods or by allowing students to use computers around the school. A modern school needs to have connectivity everywhere and treat computers more like pencils (albeit valuable ones) than microscopes.
Already a member? Sign in
ABOUT ME
Greg Stack K-12 Thought Leader at NAC Architecture View my complete profile
Students usingmobile phones in class
6.
Gyms without Natural Daylight A typical refrain you hear when designing a gym is that glare is such a big problem that we don’t want natural light. It’s true that glare is a problem if you have poorly conceived natural light but with energy costs what they are, being able to turn off lights in a gym can be a big savings. Designing glare free gyms is possible but typically requires more natural light not less. Skylights, well placed windows and ample light produce a great experience and a functional space.
7.
Teacher Centered Classrooms Classrooms were designed for lecture and crowd control with the teacher as the central figure of knowledge and authority. The teacher had knowledge to impart through direct instruction and the classroom works pretty well for this. Teacher at the front controlling the board with a good view of the room - has been the model for over 150 years. Today this is still the case with the chalk board replaced by the “Smart Board.” This is an obsolete notion. There are times when lecture is the right approach but now there are so many other approaches that center on the student. Small groups, project work, problem solving, presentations are all activities that don’t work as well in a teacher centered classroom.
Learner Centered Classroom at Riverview Elementary School
8.
Isolated Classrooms Tony Wagner of the Harvard School of Education and the author of the Global Achievement Gap says: “Isolation is the enemy of improvement” and yet most schools are planned so as to isolate teachers from each other. Teachers often learn to teach in isolated boxes and emulate that style throughout their career. Interior windows get “papered over” and blinds are shut. Out of school people work in teams to solve problems. They are visually and often aurally connected. Collaboration is a vital skill. Isolated classrooms are already obsolete.
9.
Institutional Food Service
School food service usually involves folding tables that are placed and replaced throughout the day. With cleanup activities it takes the commons/cafeteria out of action most of the day. Why sacrifice this valuable space when it could serve multiple purposes? Creating spaces that require less movement of furniture while remaining flexible will allow them to be used more effectively. Commons spaces can also be less institutional which in turn increases their flexibility. Decentralizing food service allows students to eat in smaller groups and also allows multiuse of spaces. Even if the food isn’t better, the space can be.
Food Service in this Helsinki middle school is more like a cafe
10. Large Gang Restrooms Statistics show that a surprising number of students try to avoid using school restrooms even in new schools. Concerns over privacy, bullying, and cleanliness contribute to this. To avoid restroom use, students stop drinking water. Without water they become dehydrated. When dehydrated their learning suffers – with performance degrading by 10-15%. There is an alternative. In Finland and other parts of Europe they use individual restrooms that are located in the shared learning area between classrooms. Although it may sound funny there is a feeling of ownership for these and so they don’t get trashed, they do have privacy, there is no bullying, students do drink water, they do not get dehydrated and they do achieve.
These are a few of the things that are obsolete. Can you think of more? Posted by Greg Stack at 11:39 AM
1 comment:
Recommend this on Google Links to this post Reactions:
funny (0)
MONDAY, JANUARY 30, 2012
interesting (3)
cool (0)
$1,092 Alabama&spends&less,&so&do&Colorado,&Illinois,&Iowa, Minnesota&and&Massachusetts.&&Ohio&spends&$8&more, but&Wisconsin,&Arizona&and&Virginia&spend&less.&&In&fact, 33&out&of&the&50&states&and&District&of&Columbia&spend less.&&Some&big&rich&states&like&New&York,&Texas, California&and&Florida&spend&more,&but&surprisingly,&the biggest&spenders&are&Wyoming&and&DC.&& According&to&the&February&6th,&2012&issue&of&Time Magazine,&$1,092&is&the&amount&the&average&US&worker spends&on&coffee&each&year.&&&I&like&coffee&as&much&as the&next&person.&&In&fact,&people&worry&if&I&don’t&get&my coffee&in&the&morning.&&I&like&straight&forward&coffee, that&is,&I&like&it&black&without&sugar.&&I&do&indulge&the&fact&that&I&spend&a&lot&of&my&time&in Seattle&–&coffee&town&USA&and&home&of&Starbucks&–&by&ordering&quad&Americanos,&but&I eschew&more&extravagant&and&expensive&coffee&drinks.&&I&do&not&know&how&much&I&spend on&coffee,&but&it&wouldn’t&surprise&me&if&I&spend&at&least&$1,092.&&Many&people&I&know have&several&coffees&a&day&and&likely&spend&more&than&I&do.&&How&much&do&you&think&you spend?
But&this&post&isn’t&about&coffee,&is&it?
The&21st&Century&School&Fund&just&published&a&report&on&capital&construction&spending&in every&state&and&the&District&of&Columbia.&&http://goo.gl/xKPEf&&It&ranks&the&states&by&how much&they&spend&per&student.&&The&range&of&expenditure&ranges&from&a&high&of&$2,355 per&student&in&DC&(Wyoming&is&second&at&$2,066)&to&a&low&of&$298&per&student&in&Hawaii. The&study&gives&additional&information&such&as&how&much&the&state&contributes&versus local&school&districts,&how&funding&occurs&in&each&state,&and&how&much&debt&for&capital construction&is&outstanding&in&each&state.&
There&are,&of&course,&regional&variations&in&construction&costs&that&explain&some&of&the difference,&but&the&variation&across&the&country&makes&a&statement&about&both&economic health&and&the&value&each&state&places&on&building&schools.&&I&think&it&also&goes&further than&this&to&make&a&statement&about&how&we&value&education.&&The&facilities&in&which students&learn&go&far&beyond&just&providing&shelter&for&the&activities&of&learning.& Fundamentally,&they&tell&students&and&teachers&how&we&value&what&they&do.&&We&build palaces&for&our&sports&teams&often&at&public&expense&because&we&value&sports&in&our culture.&&We&spend&money&on&our&military&facilities&because&they&are&important.&&We select&our&homes&with&the&idea&of&maximizing&space&and&utility&but&also&to&make&a statement&about&our&status&and&values.&&The&physical&manifestation&of&our&stadiums&and homes&reflect&our&values.&&Why&should&the&physical&manifestations&of&our&schools&be&any different?&
If&we&are&serious&about&improving&results&in&our&schools,&part&of&the&solution&is&to&let students&know&that&we&value&learning&and&the&places&that&house&it.&&The&condition&of&our schools&sends&students&a&message,&and&whether&that&message&is&positive&or&negative&is up&to&us.
$1,092&is&a&lot&of&money&to&a&lot&of&people,&especially&in&this&economy.&&Having&the&little pleasures&that&get&us&through&each&day&is&important,&but&aren’t&student’s&futures&even more&important&than&our&daily&dose&of&coffee?& Posted by Greg Stack at 9:59 AM
No comments:
+2 Recommend this on Google Links to this post Reactions:
funny (0)
interesting (0)
WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 28, 2011
cool (1)
Another Great Article on Education in Korea The&December&17th issue&of&the&Economist paints&an&interesting picture&of&what&high stakes&testing&has&done to&kids&in&South&Korea in&the&article:&“The&onec shot&society”.&&Rather than&focus&on&hagwon or&cram&factories&like the&Time&magazine article,&The&Economist piece&discusses&the&one high&stakes&test&that determines&every student’s&future.&&It goes&on&to&explain&how&the&Korean&government&and&economy&encourages&this&testing&by their&hiring&practices&and&in&so&doing&discourages&innovation&and&risk&taking.&&Finally&it covers&the&increasing&dissatisfaction&of&students&in&South&Korea&with&the&pressure&to succeed. Korea&does&very&well&on&international&exams,&but&at&what&price?&&The&level&of dissatisfaction&in& South&Korea&is&very&high.&&According&to&the&article&less&than&half&of&Korean&workers&would recommend&their&company&as&a&good&place&to&work&whereas&three&quarters&of&workers in&the&article’s&global&sample&would.&&Women&feel&pressure&to&work&and&raise&a&family, but&they&veer&off&the&advancement&pathway&if&they&take&time&away&from&work&to&do&so.& The&result&has&been&a&plummeting&birthrate&that&threatens&to&leave&an&older&generation unsupported&and&leave&South&Korea&irrelevant&as&a&global&power. If&nothing&else,&this&analysis&shows&that&you&need&to&be&careful&what&you&wish&for.&&South Korea&has&achieved&on&tests&and&graduates&an&astounding&63%&of&its&students&with college&degrees&but&life&satisfaction&is&low&and&unemployment&is&relatively&high.&&Even though&South&Korea&grew&by&6.2%&last&year,&40%&of&college&graduates&had&not&found work&four&months&after&graduation. When&you&review&the&kinds&of&schools&that most&South&Koreans&attend&they&look&very similar&to&the&kinds&of&schools&prevalent&in the&United&States.&&The&desks&are&in&rows, the&teacher&is&lecturing&at&from&the&front&of the&room,&and&students&are&madly&taking notes&except&for&the&one&who&are&asleep.& The&classroom&environment&is&perfect&for this.&Those&motivated&to&pay&attention&are memorizing&material&through&their&note taking.&&Those&who&learn&differently&or would&prefer&to&talk&about&their&learning&in groups&aren’t&doing&so&well.&&If&not&asleep they&are&daydreaming,&or&drawing&or&taking notes&ineffectually.&&The&high&stakes&test will&weed&these&“laggards”&out,&but&in&so doing&may&miss&the&creative&genius,&the orator,&the&musician,&or&the&next&high&tech entrepreneur. This&picture&is&too&true&of&many&schools&in&the&United&States.&&Some&schools&in&the&US&are more&innovative&than&this&to&be&sure,&and&there&are&signs&of&change,&but&we&need&the system&to&change&to&show&the&progress&we&say&we&want.&&The&school&environment&can&be an&important&part&of&that&change.&&By&creating&spaces&that&foster&collaboration, creativity,&and&communication&we&can&help&educators&and&students&teach&and&learn&in new&ways.&&A&space&that&is&configured&for&small&groups&but&can&be&changed&to&create large&spaces&for&gatherings&or&projects,&or&a&space&that&allows&comfortable&seating&in&a variety&of&lounging&and&formal&configurations&helps&change&the&way&teaching&and learning&happens.&&It&can&help&wake&up&the&sleeping&kids&and&turn&daydreaming&into productive&reality.
Posted by Greg Stack at 4:52 PM
No comments:
Recommend this on Google Links to this post Reactions:
funny (0)
interesting (0)
cool (0)
THURSDAY, DECEMBER 1, 2011
$290,000,000,000 This&is&a&big&number.&&It’s&over&a&third&of&the&TARP&bailout&fund.&&It’s&a&little&over&a&third&of what&we&spend&on&Medicare&and&Medicaid.&&It&also&about&42%&of&what&we&spend&on Defense.&&What&this&number&is&is&2%&of&our&Gross&Domestic&Product.& This&is&a&significant&number&in&that&it&represents&education&spending,&and&is&what&parents in&the&United&States&would&collectively&need&to&spend&if&they&wanted&to&match&parents&in South&Korea.&&But&this&is&not&the&cost&of&education&in&Korea.&&No,&2%#of#GDP#is#the#cost Korean#parents#are#willing#to#pay#for&after#school#tutoring&for&their&children&over&and above&what&the&country&spends&on&education.&&In&the&States&we&spend&about&$625B&on&Kc 12&education&now&so&spending&another&$290B&would&amount&to&almost&a&50%&increase&in expenditures.&&This&sort&of&increase&is&unimaginable&and&yet&our&educational&system continues&to&be&excoriated&over&the&results&it&produces&while&no&one&is&willing&to&spend more&for&better&results. Time&magazine&talks&about&this&in&Their&December&5th&issue&in&the&article:&“Teacher, Leave&Those&Kids&Alone” http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2094427,00.html&which&paints&a startling,&and&perhaps&frightening,&picture&of&where&teaching&to&the&test&can&lead.& Students&and&parents&are&so&concerned&about&performance&on&high&stakes&testing&that they&spend&many&hours&and&dollars&on&tutoring.&&It&has&gotten&to&the&point&that&the&South Korean&government&raids&“hagwons”&or&cram&schools&that&operate&after&10:00&PM&in&an attempt&to&break&this&obsession&with&cramming&for&the&test. This&obsession&with&achievement&is&telling&in&two&ways:& 1. 2.
South&Korea&is&always&near&the&top&of&the&OECD&PISA&scores&and South&Korea&is&trying&to&break&the&addiction&of&teaching&to&the&test&in order&to&ensure&that&its&students&are&competitive&in&the&future
In&fact&South&Korea&and other&Asian&countries that&are&top&scorers&on the&PISA&tests&are concerned&that&they are&turning&out knowledgeable&but&dull students.&&Students who&know&facts&but have&not&been&taught to&apply&what&they know&in&creative&ways.& Believe&it&or&not,&many Asian&countries&are looking&to&US&schools&as&an&example&of&how&to&better&teach&creativity&to&their&students which&they&know&is&key&to&success&in&the&21st&century.& “Not%everything%that%can%be%counted%counts,%and%not%everything%that%counts%can%be counted"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Albert%Einstein
The&PISA&tests&may&be&measuring&knowledge&but&the&knowledge&they&are&measuring&may not&be&what’s&important&for&success&in&the&21st&Century.&&In&the&meantime,&the&United States&is&moving&toward&the&Asian&model&and&increasingly&teaching&to&the&test&which&has the&potential&to&harm&the&acquisition&of&the&very&skills&our&students&will&need&to&succeed in&the&future.& What’s&all&this&got&to&do&with&school&facilities?&&To&me&it&reinforces&the&need&to&create facilities&that&encourage&both&academic&rigor#and#creativity.&&When&America&finally
wakes&up&from&its&testing&obsession&schools&need&to&be&able&to&accommodate&curricula that&encourage&creativity&and&the&use&and&analysis&of&knowledge.&&This&is&likely&to&mean project&based&learning,&collaborative&learning,&and&technology&rich&learning.&&Learning that&encourages&exploration&and&analysis,&critical&thinking&and&debate.&&Facilities&that accommodate&these&endeavors&will&not&be&desks&in&rows&but&rather&agile&spaces&that&can change&as&do&the&activities&of&their&occupants.&&Facilities&that&show&that&education&is valuable&and&a&priority.
Posted by Greg Stack at 12:15 PM
No comments:
Recommend this on Google Links to this post Reactions:
funny (0)
interesting (1)
cool (0)
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 15, 2011
Lessons from School design in the UK This&past&week&I&was&in London&for&the&Annual CAE&conference.&&Every few&years&the&AIA’s Committee&on Architecture&for Education&has&a conference&outside&the United&States,&and&this Does architecture matter for learning? year&it&was&in Evelyn Grace Academy by Zaha Hadid conjunction&with&the BCEF&c&British&Council&for&Educational&Facilities.&&We&saw&some&interesting&schools&and also&some&that&made&me&question&why&they&were&on&the&tour.&&Presentations&covered sustainability&and&a&little&bit&about&pedagogy&and&the&built&environment,&but&the conference&seemed&to&be&under&the&cloud&created&by&the&drastic&reduction&in&the Building&Schools&for&the&Future&building&program&in&the&UK.&&This&£55&Billion&program&was the&creation&of&the&last&liberal&government&but&has&been&drastically&reduced&by&the current&conservative&government.&&In&general,&the&British&architects&and&builders&who were&at&the&conference&still&seemed&to&be&getting&their&heads&around&the&fact&that&the ambitious&building&program&was&essentially&over. This&made&it&all&the&more&interesting&that&one&of&the&key&note&speakers&was&Graham Stuart&an&MP,&Conservative&Party&member,&and&Chair&of&the&Education&Select&Committee for&the&new&government.&Considering&he&was&addressing&a&group&of&architects&and builders&who&focus&on&building&schools,&his&pronouncement&that&school&environments are&inconsequential&compared&to&the&quality&of&teaching&was&stunning.&&He&said&the&last government&had&wasted&a&lot&of&money&on&some&schools&thereby&depriving&other&needy areas&from&getting&any&help.&&&He&said&he&knew&of&no&credible&research&that demonstrated&that&the&school&environment&affected&learning.&&He&was&vehement&in these&beliefs&and&went&unchallenged&except&for&Alan&Dunlop,&a&Scotsman&and&recent
Visiting&Chair&in&Architecture&at&Kansas&State&University,&who&suggested&that&although teaching&is&most&important,&the&environment&is&also&an&important&component&in learning.&&The&MP&would&not&grant&this&point&in&the&sense&that&he&said&the&focus&must&be on&teaching. This&is&an&argument&I&have&heard&before&in&the&United&States&in&various&guises.&&I&believe that&teaching&is&the&most&important&thing&but&not&the&only&thing.&&Environment&matters.& A&good&environment&attracts&teachers&and&students,&allows&them&to&do&their&jobs&more efficiently,&and&tells&them&they&are&valued.&&This&is&no&different&for&teaching&and&learning than&it&is&for&any&other&kind&of&endeavor.&&Human&activities&benefit&from&purpose&built environments&designed&to&house&them. These&benefits&might&be&considered&“higher&order”&benefits&but&research&has&shown&(see Earthman’s&work&at:&http://escholarship.org/uc/item/5sw56439#pagec1)&that&even improving&bad&environments&improves&student&performance.&&The#significance#of#this#is that#even#with#bad#teaching#students#will#do#better#in#a#good#environment.# Times&are&very&difficult&right&now&and&educational&providers&are&being&forced&to&cut&back severely.&&&Prioritization&is&necessary&in&times&like&these&but&denial&of&evidence&to&justify priorities&is&bad&policy.&&Solving&the&problems&we&face&will&require&cooperation&and&new thinking.&&Einstein&said: &“The%significant%problems%we%have%cannot%be%solved%at%the%same%level%of%thinking%with which%we%created%them.” We&need&new&thinking&about&how&to&deliver,&pay&for,&and&accomplish&the&mission&of educating&our&children&if&we&want&to&solve&our&current&problems. Posted by Greg Stack at 2:42 PM
No comments:
Recommend this on Google Links to this post Reactions:
funny (0)
interesting (0)
Home
cool (0)
Older Posts
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)
Simple template. Powered by Blogger.