International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
OPENCOURSEWARE
April 20, 2006 Clock Tower Centennial Hall Kyoto University, Japan
Proceedings of the International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
OPENCOURSEWARE
Clock Tower Centennial Hall, Kyoto University, Japan April 20, 2006 Organized by:
Japan Opencourseware Alliance (http://www.jocw.jp/) Hokkaido University, Keio University, Kyoto University, Kyushu University, Nagoya University, Osaka University, Tokyo Institute of Technology, The University of Tokyo, and Waseda University
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Cosponsored by:
National Institute of Multimedia Education
Sponsored by:
Japanese Society for Information and Systems in Education, Society for Art and Science, Information Processing Society of Japan, The Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers Japan, Society for Educational Technology, Nippon WebCT User Society, Japanese Society for Engineering Education, and Japanese Association of Higher Education Research
Foreword Welcome to the International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto, Japan.
Early spring
is one of the best seasons of Kyoto and many tourists enjoy experiencing traditional culture of Japan. We have two purposes of this conference. One purpose is to exchange information among universities providing OCW. OCW project.
The other purpose is to encourage other universities to start up their
Owing to the effort made by MIT OCW team, the number of universities that
provide OCW is gradually increasing.
At this time, it is honorable to have this conference at Kyoto
University, Japan.
The purpose of OCW, to my understanding, is to create human knowledge repository available to all the people in the world without any cost.
Since all the people have right to get educated, OCW
contributes for the people all over the world.
Kyoto University joined this activity with other five
universities in Japan, and formed Japan Opencourseware Consortium (JOCW).
Since then, we
made effort to make up the system that covers all the work flow of the OCW activities, including the intellectual property right, the way to make up the OCW from the materials obtained from professors and the software system to open the digitized courseware.
As a result, we have published 40
courses now.
For the first day, we plan to have the audience from universities, in which we discuss our experience to OCW project.
We have an invited talk form MIT, and two panel discussions, one is from Japan
and the other is from the other countries. From these discussions, you may find out what the OCW situation now, and which direction we proceed. Please enjoy yourself in this new world created by OCW, a new media for knowledge.
I would like to thank all the members of organizing committee, particularly Executive Director Anne H. Margulies, Dr. Steve Carson, and Prof. Shigeru Miyagawa from MIT for their continuous contribution to prepare the conference, and I would like to express my sincere appreciation to Prof. Yoshimi Fukuhara, Secretary general of JOCW, Keio University, Prof. Haruo Takemura, Osaka university, and Prof. Naoko Tosa, Kyoto university for their efforts to make the conference happen.
Michihiko MINOH General Chair, International conference on Opencourseware 2006 Director, Academic Center for Computing and Media studies, Kyoto University
iii
Conference Organization
Conference Chair: Michihiko MINOH
(Kyoto University)
Steering Committee Chairs: Yoshimi FUKUHARA Haruo TAKEMURA Naoko TOSA
(Keio University) (Osaka University) (Kyoto University)
Steering Committee: Shigeto OKABE Masayuki AIKAWA Hitoshi AIDA Jun NAKAHARA Emi YAMAMOTO Masahiro MOCHIZUKI Takaya YAMAZATO Miyuki KAWAGUCHI Hitoshi INOUE Megumi DOSHITA Rie SUZUKI Chiharu KOGO Tsuneo YAMADA
(Hokkaido University) (Hokkaido University) (The University of Tokyo) (The University of Tokyo) (The University of Tokyo) (Tokyo Institute of Technology) (Nagoya University) (Osaka University) (Kyushu University) (Keio University) (Keio University) (Waseda University) (National Institute of Multimedia Education)
v
Table of Contents
April 20, 2006 (Thu)
1. Opening Session (10:00 – 11:30)
Opening Address of the President at Kyoto University (10:00 – 10:15) ............. 3
Introduction of OCW by MIT (10:15 – 11:15) ..................................................... 5
2. Lunch / Demonstration Session I (11:30 – 13:30)
3. Panel Session I (13:30 – 15:30)
Panel Discussion of Japanese OCW................................................................. 11
Coffee Break (15:30 – 16:00)
4. Panel Session II (16:00 – 18:00)
Panel Discussion of OCW by Europe, Asia, and United States ......................... 37
5. Reception / Demonstration Session II (18:00 – 20:30)
vii
Opening Session Kazuo OIKE (President, Kyoto University) Anne H. Margulies (Executive Director, MIT OpenCourseWare)
Opening Address by Kazuo OIKE, President of Kyoto University
Biographical Sketch for Kazuo OIKE BORN: 1940, at Tokyo, Japan; Male. EDUCATION: B.Sc. in Geophysics, Kyoto University (1963). D.Sc. in Geophysics, Kyoto University (1972). POSITIONS: Research Associate, Disaster Prevention Research Institute, Kyoto University (1963-1973). Associate Professor, Disaster Prevention Research Institute, Kyoto University (1973-1988). Professor of Seismology, Graduate School of Science, Kyoto University (1988-2003). Dean, Graduate School of Science, Kyoto University (1997-1999). Director, Former Research Center for Sports Science (2001-2003). Vice President, Kyoto University (2001-2003). President, Kyoto University (2003-).
3
Unlocking Knowledge, Empowering Minds Anne H. Margulies, Executive Director MIT OpenCourseWare
Abstract
MIT OpenCourseWare (MIT OCW), available online at http://ocw.mit.edu, makes the MIT Faculty's course materials used in the teaching of almost all of MIT's undergraduate and graduate subjects available on the Web, free of charge, to any user anywhere in the world. MIT OCW is a large-scale, Web-based publication of educational materials. Educators in the U.S. and the developing world utilize the materials for curriculum development, while students and self-learners around the globe draw upon the materials for self-study or supplementary use. With 1350 courses now available, MIT OCW is delivering on the promise of open sharing of knowledge.
Sharing concise data and case studies from real users of MIT OCW materials from around the globe, Anne Margulies will demonstrate how MIT OCW, and the "OpenCourseWare" concept, is gaining momentum around the world. She will explain the origins of the OCW project from an MIT faculty committee, how a simple but powerful idea has benefited people all over the globe, and how the burgeoning OpenCourseWare Movement and the OpenCourseWare Consortium promise to transform global education.
5
April 13, 2006
Unlocking Knowledge, Empowering Minds Anne H. Margulies
Unlocking Knowledge, Empowering Minds
Making a Difference — Access Traffic by Geographic Region (in Web hits, since 10/1/03)
35.6 M 330.1 M
115.2 M 26.0 M
Region North America East Asia Western Europe South Asia Latin America Eastern Europe and Central Asia MENA Pacific Sub-Sah. Africa TOTAL HITS
Hits Since Hit % 10/1/03 330,059,127 43.0 157,994,658 20.6 115,185,921 15.0 47,950,584 6.2 38,748,917 5.1 35,647,543
158.0 M 48.0 M
6.1 M
38.7 M
10.2 M
4.6
26,041,359 3.4 10,184,134 1.3 6,068,554 0.8 767,880,797
6
Unlocking Knowledge, Empowering Minds
14
Demonstration Session I
John Dehlin (USU eduCommons: OpenCourseWare system) Marion Jensen (USU OCW) Sukon Kanchanaraksa (JHSPH OCW) Steve Carson (MIT OCW) Cec d’ Oliviera (Consortium Web site) Majid Daci (Paris Tech) Mary Y. Lee (Tufts U OCW) OOPS Open University (UK) (Tentative)
Keio University (Keio OCW) Kyoto University (KYOTO-U OCW) Osaka University (OU OCW) Tokyo Institute of Technology (Tokyo Tech OCW) The University of Tokyo (UT OCW) Waseda University (Waseda OCW) Nagoya University (NU OCW) Kyushu University Hokkaido University National Institute of Multimedia Education
Memo
9
Panel Session I Panel Discussion of Japanese OCW
A Brief History of Japan OCW Alliance: Nobuyasu MAKOSHI (Tokyo Institute of Technology)
Current Status of OCW in Japan: Yoshimi FUKUHARA (Keio University)
Current Issues: Moderator: Haruo TAKEMURA (Osaka University) Shigeto OKABE (Hokkaido University) Hitoshi AIDA (The University of Tokyo) Takaya YAMAZATO (Nagoya University) Naoko TOSA (Kyoto University)
Issues in Near Future: Moderator: Michihiko MINOH (Kyoto University) Yoshimi FUKUHARA (Keio University) Chiharu KOGO (Waseda University) Haruo TAKEMURA (Osaka University) Hitoshi INOUE (Kyushu University) Nobuyasu MAKOSHI (Tokyo Institute of Technology)
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
A Brief History of Japan OCW Alliance Prof. Nobuyasu Makoshi Global Scientific Information and Computing Center (GSIC) Tokyo Institute of Technology
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Introduction „In this presentation, we introduce a brief history of Japan OCW Alliance, made up of loosely coupled multiple universities, focusing on how such an alliance is organized
13
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
A bit of History (1/2) Press Conference on MIT OpenCourseWare
April 4, 2001
Visited MIT (Joined the NIME’s study tour to MIT OCW)
May 2002
GSIC held an International Symposium, whose main theme was MIT OCW
June 2002
Asked to be an early tester of MIT OCW (by the recommendation of Prof. Miyagawa)
September 2002
Had a telephone interview from MIT OCW (by the recommendation of Prof. Miyagawa)
January 2003
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
A bit of History (2/2) Invited Prof. Shigeru Miyagawa as a visiting professor at GSIC
June 1 – August 31, 2004
GSIC and School of Engineering of Tokyo Tech coheld an invited lecture by Prof. Miyagawa
July 2004 GSIC Invited Lecture No .1, 2004
MIT OCW Consortium WG (later became JOCW Alliance), which consists of four candidate universities, was held at Tokyo Tech
Keio University, University of Tokyo, and Waseda University August 2004
Prof. Miyagawa contacted candidate universities during his stay in Japan
President and four executive vice presidents successively meet Prof. Miyagawa during his visit at Tokyo Tech President and some executive vice presidents meet Anne H. Margulies, the executive director of MIT OCW, at Tokyo Tech
August 2004 GSIC Invited Lecture No .2, 2004
14
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
How Japan OCW Alliance is inaugurated? (1/2)
MIT initially thought selected US universities, CORE (Chinese Open Resource for Education), and some organizations from Europe as founding members of OCW consortium Japanese universities were not considered as initial partners! So, why Japan OCW Alliance exists now?
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
How Japan OCW Alliance is inaugurated? (2/2)
Prof. Miyagawa, a MIT OCW advisory board member, suggested to consider Japanese leading universities as OCW consortium members, and the suggestion was accepted His initial plan was to incorporate Japanese four universities
15
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Initial Contact Points of Candidate Universities (1/2)
Keio University
Acquainted with Prof. Sugiyama (Director, Information Technology Center)
Tokyo Institute of Technology
Acquainted with Prof. Makoshi
The University of Tokyo
Charles M. Vest (President Emeritus, MIT) was acquainted with Prof. Sasaki (Former president)
Waseda University
Directly contacted key persons
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Initial Contact Points of Candidate Universities (2/2)
Osaka University Kyoto University Prof.
Sakai, Director of GSIC, mediated between Prof. Miyagawa and both university key persons
16
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Difference between MIT OCW and Japan OCW Alliance
MIT OCW Need
to publish all courses Time schedule is limited (by 2008)
Japan OCW Alliance Need
to publish at least 10 courses Do not have any obligations to publish all courses both in the mid- and longterm
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Japan OCW Alliance Founding Members
The Japan OCW Alliance (JOCW) was founded on May 13, 2005 by six top-ranking Japanese universities
Keio University
Kyoto University
Osaka University
Tokyo Institute of Technology
the University of Tokyo
Waseda University
http://ocw.dmc.keio.ac.jp/ http://ocw.kyoto-u.ac.jp/ http://ocw.osaka-u.ac.jp/ http://www.ocw.titech.ac.jp/ http://ocw.u-tokyo.ac.jp/ http://www.waseda.jp/ocw/
(in alphabetical order)
17
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Japan OCW Alliance Website http://www.jocw.jp/
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Japan OCW Alliance Activities JOCW Alliance held a joint press conference at Hotel New Otani in Tokyo
May 2005
Having regular meetings
The first meeting was held at Tokyo Tech The second meeting was held at Keio University The third meeting was held at University of Tokyo The fourth meeting was held at Keio University …
Participated in the 2nd OCW Consortium meeting at Utah State University
September 28 – 29, 2005
18
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
New Members to Come More members are ready to launch Kyushu
http://ocw.kyushu-u.ac.jp/
Nagoya
University
University
http://ocw.nagoya-u.jp/
Hokkaido
University
Coming soon!
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Summary We have introduced a brief history of Japan OCW Alliance Current status, issues, and future directions of Japan OCW Alliance will be discussed in the following sessions
19
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006
Thank you very much for your attention!
20
International InternationalConference Conferenceon onOpencourseware Opencourseware2006 2006ininKyoto Kyoto
Current status of OCW in JAPAN Prof. Yoshimi Fukuhara Keio University
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Number of Universities 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
2005.5
2006.4
21
2006.xx
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Number of Courseware 250 200 150
English Japanese
100 50 0
2005.5
2006.3
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Number of Visit 140000 120000 100000 80000 60000 40000 20000 0
May05
July05
Sept.05
22
Nov.05
Jan.06
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Characteristics/ Challenges of each Univ. • Keio University – All of the first published courses are in humanity and social science disciplines – Japanese/Asian related courses has been mainly selected – Every course is published in both English and Japanese – One unique course about Keio founder, Yukichi Fukuzawa, is about to be published
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Characteristics/ Challenges of each Univ. • Kyoto University – More than 60 courses will be launched newly within 2006 – System by which faculty members can launch their lecture directly should be developed – To handle the copyright of the quoted contents.
23
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Characteristics/ Challenges of each Univ. • Nagoya University – All courses (25 Japanese, 3 English) are primarily selected on the recommendation of deans of faculties. – Feature contents: • Teaching tips – the instructor's thoughts and insights on teaching the course, being a testament to his or her dedication.
• One-minute Video Summary – a quick rundown of the course on video, given by the instructor
– Integration with • Nagoya University Portal (MyNu.jp) • Nagoya University Academic Knowledge Factory (NU AKF) • Content Management System [under consideration]
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Characteristics/ Challenges of each Univ. • Osaka University – Planning to Integrate OU-OCW with OU’s Student Information System, Online Syllabus and Course Management System by the end of FY 2006. – OU-OCW Project is now a part of Osaka University’s Campus Wide e-Learning Infrastructure Development Project To guarantee a sustainable operating structure without increasing cost for OU-OCW. – It is necessary to increase presence or awareness of OU-OCW among OU faculty.
24
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Characteristics/ Challenges of each Univ. • Tokyo Institute of Technology – 300 courses will be launched within 2006. (currently more than 120) – Weighted course listing mechanism based on the access counts and the fulfillment of content requirements- e.g., "syllabus-only courses" get lower weight – Smart contents-registration support system which enables faculty members launch their course materials through the authentication process using IC cards
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Characteristics/ Challenges of each Univ. • The University of Tokyo
– Our policy: Quality matters more than quantity – Strategic selection of distinguished lectures
• “University Lecture: Global Focus on Knowledge (GFK) series --- Science of Matter” by Novel Prize winner Prof. Koshiba and the President Komiyama • “Gender Theory” by Prof. Chizuko Ueno, etc.
– 26 courses - Japanese:24, English:22 - (April, 2006) – Lecture materials of 10 courses provided every year – 7 million hits and 200,000 visits (May, 2005 - April, 2006) – Technology
• The installation of MIMA Search which enables us to get a panoramic view of our educational resources • Todai Podcast
25
International Conference on Opencourseware 2006 in Kyoto
Characteristics/ Challenges of each Univ. • Waseda University – To negotiate with the oversea professors who were involved in multi-point distance learning courses – The system which allows faculty members to launch their lectures by themselves will be in operation this April. – All faculty members will be requested to select from internal disclosure, limited disclosure and/or OCW-disclosure.
International InternationalConference ConferenceononOpencourseware Opencourseware2006 2006ininKyoto Kyoto
Conclusion • Now we have more 2 member universities – Hokkaido University – Kyusyu University
• In near future we will welcome new member – In detail to be announced shortly
• Next session: Panel Discussion – 1: Current Issues – 2:Future Vision
• Thank you for your attention
26
Challenges of JOCW
Haruo Takemura Osaka University
JOCW Implementation
of OCW using each universities’
own budgets. Glass roots movement / Top down decision. Not Necessarily aiming for publishing all courses of participating universities.
27
Problems to be solved Increasing
presence of OCW internally and
externally Searching for Financial Support Some technical challenges Copyright Issues based on the difference of legislation Increasing Incentive for faculty to provide course materials
Searching for Financial Support Difficult
to search for external funding source
No
Hewlett Foundation nor Melon Foundation Personal Donation to University is not so common. Higher
priorities are give to e-Learning systems and/or SIS.
28
Technical Challenges Integration
with on-campus e-learning system and other student information system Access analysis Supporting courses in Japanese and in English
Copyright Issues Is
Creative Common Copyright enough? Who’s responsibility to clear copyright issue. OCW
Can
Providers, Course Contributors or others?
we track every usage of OCW materials
29
Increasing Faculty Incentive Rewards Acknowledgements Prize,
Certificates etc.
Collecting Top
course materials
down approach
President
Bottom
-> Dean -> Professors
up approach
Directly
recruiting volunteers
30
Panel discussion : Issues in near future
Moderator: Michihiko MINOH (Kyoto University)
Problems in future Which
direction we will go? What is the motivation to continue? Will the intellectual property right problem be solved? How do we license the OCW? How do we evaluate the OCW projects?
31
Cost: Who pay the cost of OCW? Government University Society Contribution Volunteer
Strategy for sustainability What
is the benefit of OCW to the Professors, students, and university? Who decides to continue if the president of the university is changed? Could
How
be a kind of university activities
to make the system for sustainability?
32
Software system for OCW Database,
Web service, etc. EduCommons is a good example To
maintain with less cost
Content quality To
get involved is more important than the quality of the contents?
How
to maintain the quality of the courses? How to control the quality of the courses when many university join the JOCW?
33
Intellectual Property problem Who
owns the course material?
Copy
right has to transferred to the university Copy right is licensed to the university Who
owns the lecture archives in video format?
Relation to publisher How
to handle the legal quotation ?
In
Japan, the quotation is allowed to support the main idea of the contents
Publishers
are with us or against us?
Books
are the competitor of OCW? OCW could be a new media between the lecture and the book/e-learing
34
Licensing policy Copy
right notice Copy, modify, distribution have to be allowed under OCW What happens, if a course ware contains material without copy right but the permission to be included and/or legal quotation?
End-User support Are
end-users the customers of OCW? Should the questions be answered?
35
Evaluation Number
of Access Number of courses Number of feedback
36
Panel Session II Panel Discussion of OCW by Europe, Asia, and United States
Moderator: Shigeru Miyagawa (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) Mary Lee (Tufts University) David Wiley (Utah State University) Pedro Aranzadi (Universia) Andy Lane (Open University UK) Majid Daci (ParisTech) Fun-Den Wang (CORE)
Universities working together to advance education and empower people worldwide through opencourseware.
International OpenCourseWare Panel • OpenCourseWares currently exist in: – – – – –
China France Japan United States Vietnam
• OpenCourseWares to be launched in: – India – Spain – United Kingdom 2006年4月11日
OCW Consortium - Kyoto, Japan
0
Universities working together to advance education and empower people worldwide through opencourseware.
International OpenCourseWare Panel • Panelists: – Mary Y. Lee (Tufts University OCW), Majid Daci (ParisTech), Pedro Aranzadi (Universia), David Wiley (Utah State University), Andrew Lane (Open University UK), Fun-Den Wang (China Open Resources for Education
• Topics addressed: – – – –
How OCW fits with mission of institution/organization Goal of the project (all courses, exemplary courses, etc) Status of the project (# published, number to be published) Unique challenges and features of implementation
2006年4月11日
OCW Consortium - Kyoto, Japan
39
1
Demonstration Session II
John Dehlin (USU eduCommons: OpenCourseWare system) Marion Jensen (USU OCW) Sukon Kanchanaraksa (JHSPH OCW) Steve Carson (MIT OCW) Cec d’ Oliviera (Consortium Web site) Majid Daci (Paris Tech) Mary Y. Lee (Tufts U OCW) OOPS Open University (UK) (Tentative)
Keio University (Keio OCW) Kyoto University (KYOTO-U OCW) Osaka University (OU OCW) Tokyo Institute of Technology (Tokyo Tech OCW) The University of Tokyo (UT OCW) Waseda University (Waseda OCW) Nagoya University (NU OCW) Kyushu University Hokkaido University National Institute of Multimedia Education
Memo
43