BusinessExaminer
NOVEMBER, 2009
Okanagan
HOW OKANAGAN BUSINESS MIXES
MoneY&MEDICINE
www.businessexaminer.ca I NSI DE
THE CHOPPER BIZ
|
A BIOD I ESEL FUTURE
|
STAR S OF E N DERBY
Cam Bastien Owner, Carousel Cleaners
WE KNOW HOW TO SPOT THE SAVINGS WHEN IT COMES TO ENERGY EFFICIENCY BEING POWER SMART MAKES BUSINESS SENSE For decades, Carousel Cleaners has provided their customers with first class service from start to finish. While looking for ways to improve their customers’ experience, Carousel Cleaners decided it was time to upgrade their lighting. With the help of BC Hydro’s Power Smart Product Incentive Program, they replaced their old lights with new energy-efficient lighting, and the changes have been remarkable. The new lighting has improved visibility and comfort levels for employees, plus, it has made the store brighter and more inviting to customers. Carousel Cleaners not only received a financial incentive through the Power Smart Product Incentive Program, they will also save almost $400 a year in electricity costs. Carousel Cleaners can now move on to more pressing matters. Looking for new ways to highlight your business? Simply visit bchydro.com/incentives or call 1 866 522 4713.
Okanagan Nation Hatchery & Administration Building The Okanagan Nation proposed Fish Hatchery/Administration building is scheduled to begin in the spring of 2010 in Penticton. The building will have four floors and over 33,000 sq ft of interior space. The ground floor is dedicated to a Sockeye rearing hatchery which will have the capacity to produce up to 8 million Sockeye annually. The upper three floors of the building will contain laboratory spaces and general administration offices as well as boardrooms and a library/archive facility. The project is being designed to a LEED Silver standard and will utilize solar, geothermal and other forms of “Green� energy to offset its consumption of traditional energy sources. The project is scheduled to be completed in September of 2011 and the ONA now wishes to begin to attract interest from individuals, companies and organizations who would like to become involved.
The project will create opportunities for many kinds of suppliers and construction trades and interested parties are encouraged to contact geoff@okanagannation.com to pre-qualify as potential suppliers/contractors for the project.
syilx
BEx11/09
www.businessexamin COVER STORY
Money and Medicine
In the U.S. debate rages over health care and Canada is picked on for its wait lists. In Kelowna one company has found a private business solution for wait lists. Is it beneficial? Is it necessary? Local business people, politicians and academics weight in on the business of how to pay for our health. 7
BusinessExaminer Prosper Media Group Inc.
President Craig N. Brown Vice President Noll C. Derriksan Grand Chief WFN, U.B.C.I.C.
101-1979 Old Okanagan Highway, Westbank, BC V4T 3A4 T: 250.862.6722 F: 250.768.8241
4
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
Publisher
Managing Editor
Sales & Marketing Manager
Design / Production
Craig Brown 250.862.6722 publisher@businessexaminer.ca
Devon Brooks 250.878.1782 editor@businessexaminer.ca
Chytra Brown 250.863.4636 sales@businessexaminer.ca
MaryAnn McCooey production@businessexaminer.ca
Contributing Photographer Shawn Talbot | 1.888.317.1403 | shawn@shawntalbot.com | www.shawntalbot.com FOLLOW US ON Contributors Dominik Dlouhy | Bobbi Menard | Mischa Popoff | Robert Smithson Mailing Address P.O.Box 32034 RPO, 2151 Louie Dr. West Kelowna, B.C. V4T 3G2 | Fax 250.768.8241 Subscription Rates 12 issues annually | One year: $27.00 | 250.863.4636 Distribution The Okanagan Business Examiner is published monthly at Kelowna, BC by Prosper Media Group Inc. Copies are distributed to businesses from Osoyoos to Greater Vernon. The views expressed in the Okanagan Business Examiner are those of the respective contributors and not necessarily those of the publisher or staff.
PUBLICATIONS MAIL AGREEMENT NO. 41835528 RETURN UNDELIVERABLE CANADIAN ADDRESSES TO: P.O. BOX 32034 RPO 2151 LOUIE DR. WESTBANK, BC, CANADA V4T 3G2
Movers&Shakers 12
Area Report Enderby’s rising stars
Small communities can be astonishing in the depth and breadth of the entrepreneurial talent and industry that they have. Enderby is perhaps the most amazing of all. Tucked away by the scenic Shuswap River, in a year when Canadian manufacturing is being pummelled, Enderby combines advantageous tax incentives with good planning to produce several winners. 13
Biodiesel to be or not to be Biodiesel is better for the air, it’s better for the environment, it’s better for you if you work with diesel motors, it’s even better for the engine and the province has mandated it will be used in B.C. next year and the federal government for 2012. So why is it that the Okanagan may not see any biodiesel at the pumps and
Up, up and away The helicopter industry has been part of the local economy for years. The recession hurts and it’s hurt the local chopper players, but their story is still uplifting. 28
how does a local biodiesel
ner.ca supplier plan for that? 22
Calendar of Events Chamber meetings,
trade shows, networking events, Women in Business, training, visiting speakers and more! 26
Yankee contract - go home! Robert Smithson can see a mile away when an employer has copied an employment contract from the United States because they carry clauses that won't hold up in
This Democracy by Mischa Popoff Welcome our newest regular, and possibly most opinionated writer. Mischa Popoff is well spoken, well written, cogent and unable to hold back. When he sees the emperor has no clothes, he tells the naked truth. This time he wonders why the environmentalists can’t reckon with the fact that the internal combustion engine is necessary for our society and its economy. 21
Canadian courts, but it does let employers here falsely believe they have all their bases covered. 24
Business Examiner is NOW ONLINE!
INSIDE CONTINUED Okanagan Biztex Inc. is a fresh new alternative to providing your Information Technology requirements & to relieve you of the stresses of managing the problems associated with computers.
Cover Story Health Care 7
Let Mis
sin
ter g th
to t
he
Ed i
tor As eP a lo utt dist ng t u tee rbed ime re Dominik Dlouhy 11 b s of s dev f St y your ident o elo c A n pm bee dre over f Lake Movers & Shakers 12 e s w n of L ongo nt of t s Gol tory “ Count L h r f i a bla ke Co ng for e Mac �. The ake Co y, I wa Enderby Profile 13 me u s d s p u n e o St A . Ho try m vera nne ropos ntry ll si l ye a w a n l y d e f t rew pot ver or ars we eh Mischa Popoff 21 e . l a s I the ntial l conn am su l share  The D s inde e e n r i cou ame, gal ac ction prised some strict ed Biodiesel 22 c n o t d dev cillors id no ion ag laimed that t f the elo had t aler ains by A he fa p d m t eal Robert Smithson 24 ing ent p to the t you t them mado ntasy o r n wit f h th oposa ever c the c or the , and Rep han onc l an ep orte u se Calendar of Events 26 e g rop a fo d rs s one their ing de rns m of a que llow u hould nt. f t n rus trat ails of y Helicopter Industry 28 an stions p artic be fai i t o h d Fr l r ns a e . e a Ope anco sked in the I wou t of M ld r rati E A x n e a ng g Offi lesio ax Tom miner ally lik Pen cer w e w n of S ho cla aszew ith so to se Lak y Ba e t An me ims ski o eC u dre to b f Am hard oun ghen w ado try , s of e Ch n Sco ief tlan d. Editor's Take 8
Let us manage the problems and frustrations of IT, leaving you to manage what you do best, YOUR business. We are a small company today serving small to medium size businesses, ranging from two users to a collocated network of 70+ users. We have set the standards of our technicians very high; to give you the support that you demand to keep your business running to the standards you expect.
T 250.300.7551 | F 250.491.0266 | E jdawson@biztex.ca
'PS BMM ZPVS "VEJP 7JEFP 4FDVSJUZ BOE )PNF "VUPNBUJPO %FTJSFT *O 5VOF 4PVOE BOE 4FDVSJUZ :PVS &YQFSUT 3FTJEFOUJBM $PNNFSDJBM ] $VTUPN %FTJHO 1SFXJSF *OTUBMMBUJPO PG 5)9 5IFBUSF 3PPNT .VMUJ SPPN "VEJP 4ZTUFNT )PNF "VUPNBUJPO 4FDVSJUZ 4ZTUFNT .POJUPSJOH -JHIUJOH )7"$ $POUSPM $$57 4ZTUFNT "DDFTT $POUSPM /FUXPSL 4ZTUFNT5FM $BCMF *OUFSOFU %JTUSJCVUJPO *OUFSDPN 4ZTUFNT -$% 1MBTNB 'MBUTDSFFOT .VTJD 4FSWFST 4BUFMMJUF 3BEJP 4ZTUFN 6QHSBEFT &WBMVBUJPOT
)PNF "VUPNBUJPO ] -JHIUJOH $POUSPM )7"$ $POUSPM *SSJHBUJPO $POUSPM 0GGTJUF *OUFSOFU "DDFTT 4FDVSJUZ ] #VSHMBS "MBSNT 'JSF "MBSNT "DDFTT $POUSPM 4VSWFJMMBODF $BNFSBT )PVS .POJUPST ] ,JSTDIOFS 3PBE ] XXX JO UVOF DB
*OTQJSJOH UIF 4FOTFT :PVS $PNQMFUF " 7 4FDVSJUZ "VUPNBUJPO 4QFDJBMJTUT T P O P T ] B O H T U S P N ] I B J
Wait lists
David Brough worked to finance the introduction of Canada’s ‘Wait List Insurance’ program.
– bugbear of Canadian medical system By Devon Brooks | Photos by Shawn Talbot
The Canada Health Act of 1984 set out to eliminate extra user fees. The issue was ensuring universal access to “medically necessary” treatments given by doctors and hospitals, but it turns out that medical necessity has turned into a swamp –the edges are hard to pin down. David Brough is the CEO at Precision Capital Partners in Kelowna. Several years ago his father was ailing with respiratory problems caused by pneumonia, but it wouldn’t go away. After several bouts of ill health Brough senior was scheduled for a CAT scan. It took many months for Brough’s father to work his way up the wait list. The CAT scan revealed previously unsuspected cancer, but it was too late and Brough’s father died. Brough says plaintively, “A guy on a wait list isn’t getting any health care.” An expert in raising money, Brough was approached by Doug Vickers. Vickers had his own “non-life threatening” health issue and he was afraid that it could become life-threatening before diagnosis could be completed. Brough says Vickers was the “heart and soul” of the push to establish ‘Medical Access Insurance’ underwritten by Industrial Alliance Pacific Insurance and Financial Services. Brough describes the insurance as a boon for Canadians. “We can do what no government can do, which is to reduce the wait list.” The premise is simple: anyone who signs up for the service and is put on a wait list for either a diagnostic test or medical procedure that is more than 45 days long is covered. The coverage will obtain the necessary service and pay for the person to get to the place of treatment, which will be the U.S. for most procedures. A single person under the age of 30 pays $36.85 a month, a 74 year old pays $109.66.
Ben Stewart, the Liberal MLA for WestsideKelowna, says, “The wait list times have come down. They’re certainly not perfect, but they’re improving.” Indeed, the B.C. government crows about improvements on selected wait lists. There are more CAT scanners and MRI units. Knee replacement wait time is down from just over four months in 2001 to two months last year. There is good news for hip replacements, cardiac and cat surgeries too, but the government rarely mentions that wait times for all surgeries has increased from just under one month in 2001 to a month and a quarter in 2008. Professor Alan Davidson from UBCO has published several papers on health care in Canada including Under the Radar: Stealth Development of Two-Tier Healthcare in Canada. Davidson wrote: “The problem is that rhetoric has centred on preserving a single-tier universal system that has never existed in the form its supporters imagine.” Davidson explains that medicare, first put in place in the 1960s expanded until the severe inflation and recession of the late ‘70s and early ‘80s had governments running scared. That’s when several provinces introduced users fees. Davidson describes what happened: “The [user] fees weren’t having a neutral effect but were hitting the poor and the elderly hardest. If the fees were hurting the people [the system] was supposed to be helping, there was a problem.” The federal Liberal government of the day reacted by legislating the Canada Health Act with the threat of a massive cut in transfer funding to any province that allowed extra billing. The provinces noisily complied. The ‘90s brought more budget cuts, which eventually contributed to the start of today’s wait lists. People are sometimes desperate and the question is whether Brough’s scheme for wait
list insurance heralds the advent of two-tiered health care. There is extra money involved, coming directly from the users pocket. Brough says, ‘No.’ The insurance offering does not contravene the Health Act because it does not ask for money that the B.C. health services would pay to a doctor. People have always had the option to cross the border to pay for extra medical service, but, as Brough points out, “The problem is you have to be one rich individual to get a CAT scan.” The concern is that private care would undermine the system by attracting doctors and other medical providers away from the public system. That would inevitably erode the public system, causing waiting lists to increase and putting ever more pressure on people to start buying more private insurance. That, says Brough, is the opposite of what his wait list insurance will do since almost all the services rendered will come through the American hospital system. He adds, “We don’t send you to jump the cue, [we] remove you from the cue. Someone taken from a wait list moves the next person up.” Brough states he has no wish to recreate the U.S. system here. “That’s a horrible system; it doesn’t work. Because we’ve already got the public system in place we can make this work.” One of the greatest criticisms of private care is that insurers won’t touch someone with a pre-existing chronic condition, which is almost guaranteed to be expensive to treat. Brough says their insurance doesn’t mimic that because “We don’t do medicals, so we offer access to everybody.” He says overworked doctors and nurses in our system are supportive of his scheme. “I’ve never WAIT LISTS CONTINUED ON PAGE 9 November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
7
A toast to beer taxes By Devon Brooks
Business in Vancouver recently released a list of the biggest breweries and beer distributors in British Columbia. Lists like these are a regular offering at Business in Vancouver, but the majority of the lists are Vancouver-centric for obvious reasons: the larger population provides a much larger market for business.
Mainland why would beer production be different?
A not-so-obvious exception are these breweries, ranked by virtue of their B.C. liquor distribution branch sales.
Unlike many other consumables consumers are willing (some say forced) to pay more for alcohol. The least expensive wines out there are not B.C. wines, but they are selling very well.
The number one and two spots are not surprising: Molson’s and Labatt’s (neither of which are really Canadian any more). Number three on the list is Okanagan Spring Brewery in Vernon. Number 10 is Kelowna’s Tree Brewing, 14 is the Nelson Brewing Company, 17 is the Cannery Brewing Company of Penticton, 18 is Mt. Begbie Brewing of Revelstoke, 20 the Fernie Brewing Company and 25 is the Tin Whistle Brewing Company from Penticton. Others come from Salt Spring Island, Nanaimo, Squamish, Whistler and Victoria while the remainder are in Metro Vancouver or are from out of province. If the vast majority of businesses have their biggest provincial representatives in the Lower
In one way they aren’t. Sales of either Molson’s or Labatt’s are bigger than the other 27 breweries combined. Many of the other 25 breweries are still a mystery though. After all, beer needs agricultural inputs and it is cheaper when produced in bulk. Transportation corridors radiate out from Vancouver.
Still, it is remarkable that so many small breweries exist and, for the most part are flourishing. Why many people will pay the extra can partly be attributed to taste. Some people, like myself, have a bias toward buying local. Then it occurred to me that part of the success of the small breweries is due –hold your breath on this one!– to high government taxes and restricted sales opportunities. Taxes on beer (and other alcohol) is so high that the difference between the biggest brewers and
What’s More Important
the Brakes or the Steering Wheel?
our microbreweries is, on a percentage basis, much smaller than it would be if taxes were less. The largest breweries do have a price advantage, but high taxes make those advantages relatively less important. If a huge brewery could sell a bottle of beer for 50¢ less than a small brewery, the advantage seems much bigger if the beer sells for $2.00 a bottle (versus $2.50) rather than $6 a bottle (versus $6.50). The other advantage bestowed on smaller brewers, unintentionally I think, is the limited number of sale sites. If you could buy beer at any corner store or grocery store as they can in the U.S., only large production can put your beer everywhere. In B.C. with many fewer places to buy alcohol, it is easier to get your product into most regions. You still may only be selling a relatively small amount, but beer drinkers have a better chance of seeing your product. There are real disadvantages to government control of liquor distribution and some rules make your head ache, but unintentionally, I think they may have given a boost to B.C.’s small producers. Devon Brooks is the managing editor of the Okanagan Business Examiner.
What’s More Important
Voice Communications or Data Communications?
The answer is of course that one is no more or no less important than the other.
Both are integral parts of your business’s overall communication strategy. They both connect your customers to you and you to your customers.
Okanagan Telephone Company &
Partners in Voice + Data Solutions
s 4ELECOM 3OLUTIONS THAT 7ORK s Business Telephone Systems s Voice Over IP s Innovative IT Solutions s Network Administration s Computer Sales & Service
Proudly serving over 2500 customers across the Okanagan, Thompson & West Kootenay’s for over 23 years. Sales. Service. Installation. Your Complete Communications and IT Solutions Company. Kamloops 250.851.0766 Vernon 250.549.7484 Kelowna 250.860.2355 Penticton 250.770.9089 Toll Free 800.595.8882
Okanagan Telephone & Connect IT make connections that make sense for your business. www.oktelephone.com www.connect-it.ca 8
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
WAIT LISTS CONTINUED FROM PAGE 7
UBCO Professor Alan Davidson says administration in B.C.’s hospitals is so efficient that the government has very few efficiencies left to squeeze out.
had a health care professional say this is a bad idea.” He also sees a market for reaching Canadian businesses who will see the benefit of making sure that staff gets quick medical treatment. Who, he wonders, can afford to have senior management on an extended sick leave? Ironically it is because of the American system’s inefficiencies that Brough’s insurance scheme works so well. The U.S. spends much more for medical care as a percentage of their GDP and on a per capita basis than any other country. Davidson says there are two big contributors to that: one is very high administration costs coming from the many competing private hospitals. In contrast to U.S. costs of about 15% of the health care budget he says, “Canada operates with a 4% administrative overhead –better than any private system on the planet.” The second are unused beds and rooms. The private American hospitals are like a hotel in the sense that empty hospitals are expensive to run. Canadians have the opposite experience at home with back ups in emergency rooms. Our hospitals are full up and patients in the hallway suggest that occupancy is more than 100%. In contrast, Davidson says, “The private hospitals in the United States have a higher cost profile because they typically run at 60% capacity. Their unit costs are sky high. They are top quality, but extremely expensive.” Brough’s plan shunts Canadians to those empty spaces. “California alone has the room to look after all of Canada,” says Brough. The money from Canadians who take up the insurance gets them off Canadian wait lists. It also pumps profits into U.S. hospitals with empty beds and unused equipment. It turns out that Brough’s fiddling on the side is nothing compared to the two-tier health care already here. WorkSafeBC administers funds gathered under the Workers Compensation Act. Every day that an injured worker sits at home waiting for diagnosis or treatment is a direct cost to WorkSafeBC.
Excluded by an act of government WorkSafeBC pays above and beyond B.C. Medicare rates to private clinics to look after those workers. It is cue jumping with government blessing. Davidson observes, “One implication is that it’s an engine of more private health care.” And WorkSafeBC is not alone. ICBC has a similar option. Davidson says these institutions don’t really like paying the extra money. That they do is a symptom of the shortage of health care professionals. He believes the real problem is that shortage of doctors, nurses and some specialized support personnel. Brough sees that as the root of the problem too. “We don’t have enough doctors, enough beds, rural doctors or money to keep the system going.”
Stewart says medical care now swallows 45% of the provincial budget, which is squeezing out other considerations. Davidson says, “The funding problems we’ve had elsewhere wouldn’t be happening if we hadn’t cut taxes this decade.” Since the federal government has cut off the private health care option, Stewart says there are only two way to go. “You can reduce costs or raise taxes.” Now private industry does what it always does best. It has found a way to give people, at least some of them, what they want with a third option that costs the individual, but allows them to circumnavigate the dreaded wait list.
Davidson says when the move to balance budgets came in the ‘90s the provinces responded by cutting expensive training programs for health care officials. A public fed up with wait lists pressured government in the 2000s to put money back into training. MLA Stewart says, “The government has funded thousands of new spaces.”
Labour Relations, Employment and Human Rights Law
A medical school was started up at UNBC in Prince George and a new school is opening in Kelowna, with the first graduates expected out by 2013. It won’t be enough says Davidson. “Even ramping up our medical schools as much as we can now won’t keep up with the number of doctors retiring. Same note for nurses.” Stewart counters that extra efficiency and savings can be found by getting the province’s health authorities to co-operate more. Some work is being taken off the doctor’s over worked plate through a transfer to other practitioners. “We’ve started training pharmacists to do vaccinations.” Davidson dismisses most of it as tinkering. The real culprit has been the government mantra on tax cuts. Faced with shrinking revenues the government had to cut services. Optical examinations were dropped several years ago and recently nursing care benefit qualifications were tightened up.
Veronica M. Ukrainetz Providing strategic legal representation to unionized and non-unionized employers throughout the Thompson Okanagan
Vernon, BC Telephone: 250.558.3393 www.ulclaw.ca November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
9
WEB
WEB DESIGN
WEB
DESIGN
WEB
TM
…Helping Okanagan Businesses
get started today! navigatormultimedia.com
250-862-9868
201-260 Harvey Ave.
KELOWNA
DSFBUJWF t EBUBCBTFT t TFBSDI FOHJOFT t IPTUJOH
succeed
ONLINE since 1993
…Helping get started today! navigatormulti …Helping
Okanagan Okanagan 2 Businesse Businesses K succeed get started today! navigatormultimedia.com succee DSFBUJWF t EBUBCBTFT t TFBSDI FOHJOF (Cuba, Honduras) get started today! navigatormultimedia.com ONLINE 250-862-9868 KELOWNA We’ve been in Kelowna a few short months, but provide over since 201-260 Harvey Ave. DESIGN
ICBC Accredited Car Shop Courtesy Cars Fibreglass Repairs Boats & R.V.’s
DESIGN
A Proud Supplier of NC Derriksan & Son Enterprises
250-862-9868
ONLINE since
201-260 Harvey Ave.
250-862-9868
20 years experience in cigar and tobacco specialty products.
DSFBUJWF t EBUBCBTFT t TFBSDI FOHJOFT t IPTUJOH
KELOWNA 521 Bernard Avenue Kelowna, BC V1Y 6N9 DSFBUJWF t EBUBCBTFT t TFBSDI FOHJOFT t IPTUJOH Ph. 250.717.1854 Fax 250.717.1855
WEB
DESIGN
T: 250.769.6651
F
1696 Ross Road Kelowna, BC V1Z 1L9
’s laman Paint & Autobody Collision Repairs
10
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
1-888-236-1266
1993
1993
Dominik Dlouhy
The best healthcare in the world The intersection of an aging population with increasing medical needs, and the relatively constant proportion of doctors to people in the province suggests conclusions that might not be pretty. The provincial government has been working to increase the number of doctors and nurses in the future, but there is lag time. In the meantime, what could we be doing better? Let’s look to the world’s top ranked health care system for answers. The World Health Organization ranked health care systems in 2000, based on a number of factors including the health of the overall population and the different demographics within it, how responsive the system was to patients, overall cost, and how it was financed. The report ranked the U.S. 37 in terms of performance of the health care system, and 72nd in terms of the health of its population. It received top marks for its responsiveness and overall spending, and mediocre standings in most other areas. Canada’s system ranked 30 overall, with the 35th healthiest population. France was ranked the best overall, and as having the fourth healthiest population.
employer funded health care plans in Canada. Co-insurance reduces the load on the system from patients who have minor ailments, like mild flus or colds, for which the only cure is rest. Opponents to the idea might call it a “user fee”, which is also controversial in B.C. The danger is that patients might avoid early diagnosis of serious problems, in order to avoid the $10 or so cost per visit. France also allows “extra billing”, where some health care practitioners charge above the standard rates for their services. The extra fees are paid by individuals or their private insurance plans, and those practitioners are themselves are charged extra for their health care coverage. While extra billing allows more of a free market approach to allocating health care resources, it tends to overload the practitioners that don’t extra bill. The program seems quite unpopular in France, and I have to conclude they haven’t been able to make extra billing work well.
France does it partly by living better, and partly by organizing its health care system better.
How much does this all cost? Canada spent about $3,700 U.S. per person on health care in 2006. The U.S. spent about $6,700 and France $3,800. That works out to about 10% of Canadian GDP, 16% of U.S. GDP and 11% of French GDP. Spending more doesn’t necessarily result in better health care or coverage of a higher proportion of the population.
The French are famous for the quality of their food. Americans are infamous for their consumption of fast food, soft drinks, corn fed beef and a pandemic of obesity. Better living and healthier people mean less demand for health care services. France can also do more with what they’ve got. And with 3.4 physicians per 1,000 population instead of 2.1 as in B.C., they’ve got more to work with.
France is only about 60% as big as B.C., with 15 times the population. The place is more compact, and it is easier to provide infrastructure and facilities close to people in France. Their needs are also more homogenous, while B.C.’s priorities range from areas like the densely populated Lower Mainland to providing coverage in remote areas like Dees Lake. B.C. would have to spend proportionately much more than France to provide the same level of service.
Who pays for health care in France? It’s similar in many ways to our system. The government provides primary health care insurance, mostly paid through payroll taxes and deductions. Low income families get free coverage, and nearly all residents are protected in some way. Many people also get additional health care coverage through private insurers, as many in Canada do as well.
In summary, France’s health care system enjoys some efficiencies we can’t hope to match. Like B.C., the government is the primary payer for most health care services, and most of the population is covered. Unlike B.C., France has managed to work successfully with private practitioners and coinsurance. Perhaps British Columbians should calm down and take a closer, more objective look at these issues. The number of health care professionals in the province will have to increase dramatically, and B.C. residents will have to be willing to pay more.
The issue of private versus public health care has been raging in B.C. for some time. France has both private and public hospitals, clinics and practitioners. All are paid primarily by the state, and partly from the private health care plans. The physicians’ union negotiates rates for the entire country. Clearly, private health care can work. At the risk of over-simplifying, France’s plan covers about 70% of the patients’ medical costs below about $100 per month. Most costs are covered above that amount, and people with serious long term conditions like diabetes or cancer are 100% covered. This is known as “co-insurance”, and is a feature of many private and
What would likely happen if we were to get it right? French citizens still complain about their health care system, and so would we. Dominik Dlouhy P. Eng, MBA, CFA is a Chartered Financial Analyst and planner with Partners in Planning Financial Services Ltd. and The Fraser Financial Group LLP. You can reach Dominik at 545-5258 or dominikd@ fraserfinancial.com with questions or comments. The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of Partners in Planning or The Fraser Financial Group.
Movers&Shakers Magazine for Foodie Lovers Launches
Savour, the new succulent magazine for food lovers in the region, launched its first 68-page issue last month. The magazine is the brain child of Chytra Brown, who with her husband Craig owns the Prosper Media Group, the publisher of the Business Examiner. Printed on the finest colour stock available, editor Joyce Wegner says she spent the entire summer huddled indoors trying to get every page mouth-wateringly perfect. The first issue boasts features on turkey time and Thanksgiving, a review of Summerland’s Local Lounge & Grill, the 5th Annual Wine Summit at Lake Louise, an outdoor dining experience at God’s Mountain Estate, chef Ned Bell who is a partner at Cabana Grille and two wineries, the Holman-Lang group and Therapy Vineyards.
hotel. He says, “Coast Hotels & Resorts has a very strong market presence in western Canada and the U.S., which is where the majority of our traffic comes from, so this re-branding fits nicely with our long-term vision for the property.” Coast has had a very busy year, opening properties in Chilliwack and Lethbridge. Along with the Penticton property it will be opening a new downtown Vancouver facility in January and one in Whistler next month. Coast Hotels now owns, manages or franchises 43 properties in western Canada and the U.S.
Valley First loses Giant
Lake Country’s oldest winery celebrated its latest expansion that includes new offices, more storage, a new laboratory, an expanded cellar and a new tasting room that will be the winery’s new public face. In total the new space almost doubles the size of the main building’s footprint and will allow production of approximately 636,000 litres of wine annually.
Coast comes to Penticton
Coast Hotels & Resorts will re-brand the Travelodge Penticton as one of its own in April next year. Robin Agur is president of Locations West Investment Group, owner of the 12
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
Vernon Chamber
Nixon Wenger lawyer Jonathan Jones was elected president of the Greater Vernon Chamber of Commerce in September. Jones cited advocacy for business as the Chamber’s main purpose, buttressed by education and networking in his first speech to the Chamber. He also said, “We have strong programs in place for all of these activities and we have the goal of strengthening our existing programs and looking for new programs that fit our mandate.” Other members elected to the board at the meeting were Deb Leroux as First VP, Ken Macleod as Second VP, Brent Barker as treasurer. Menza Bouwman, Ingrid Dilschneider and Alicia Kay are new board members while Jen Allen, Krystine McInnes, Caroline Radics, Duane Vankeimpema and Brian Wills are directors.
Osoyoos renews Destination Osoyoos contract
Gray Monk undergoes $2 M facelift
Jones new president of
Harley Biddlecombe, who was the centrepiece at Valley First Credit for more than three decades, has died of cancer. Biddlecombe started in banking in 1969, and came on board at Valley First in 1978 when it was known as the Penticton and District Credit Union. He was 27 when he became president. Biddlecombe was responsible for growing it from two branches, 25 employees and 10,000 members to one with 16 branches, 450 employees and 47,000 members. It is now the eighth largest credit union in the province with $1.75 billion in assets. Paulette Rennie has been appointed acting CEO until Valley First’s merger with Envision takes place, at which point she will become president for the Valley First region.
The current contract for tourism marketing and visitor services between the Destination Osoyoos Development Society (DO) and the Town of Osoyoos ends on December 31 this year. After four months of discussions the two groups announced they have a new three year deal worked out, worth $120,000 per year to DO. The new contract, worth $360,000, is considerably larger than the previous five-year, $226,000 deal it is replacing. The substantial increase is the result of the new hotel room tax in place, which allows Osoyoos to broaden its marketing efforts. At the same time DO has been relieved of one of its previous duties with its $200,000 budget for economic development, which Osoyoos has decided to bring in house.
Oliver wants respects
Oliver wants Canada Post to drop the use of rural routes in its address system for the town. Bonnie Dancey, CEO of the South Okanagan Chamber of Commerce (SOCC), says, “The rural route system is outdated and does cause major inconveniences to the business community who receive shipments from other jurisdictions. We respectfully request that the mayor and council revisit this issue.” SOCC also showed off a new kiosk in Kaleden for the Kettle Valley Trail in Pioneer Park. The kiosk includes a map of the route along with interesting historical and geographical information about the area. Above: South Okanagan Chamber of Commerce CEO Bonnie Dancey opening the Kettle Valley Kiosk in Kaleden
Birthday Number One for SOEC
The South Okanagan Events Centre heralded its first birthday in late September. Global Spectrum’s Curtis Webb says 120,000 people attended shows in that time. Global Spectrum is the company on contract with the City of Penticton to run the Centre. At the same time, the director of Marketing for Global Spectrum, Ryan McCarthy told Penticton Western News that some events have fared better than others, which is not unexpected for a new facility. So far the big winners have been rock and country music concerts.
BusinessExaminer P
r
o
f
i
l
e
Stars over Enderby
From page 13: The Shuswap River, which winds through the heart of the town, is symbolic of the lifestyle and easy going relations that define small town life. above Left: Tate Bengston of the Enderby Chamber of Commerce highlights the town’s low tax rate as one attraction for business. above Right: Behind the town’s sleepy main street facade is one of the most vibrant light industrial sectors in the valley.
Stars over EnderbY Story & All Photos by Devon Brooks
Introduction
In Canada we often rail when we feel slighted or, what is arguably worse, are ignored by the United States. We also know that human nature being what it is the Americans aren’t slighting us, they simply are more focused on things closer to home. We have to work harder just to get attention. Because that is basic human nature we do the same thing in our own backyard, giving the lion’s share of attention to the big three civic centres in the Okanagan while often ignoring notable achievements of smaller communities. Take Enderby as a prime example. A small community with less than 3,000 people, Enderby is achieving what many other communities say they want but seem to do little about. In this case the town has built a strong industrial sector providing good jobs and a diversified tax base. It is no accident that industry wants to locate there – the town has the welcome mat out. Tate Bengston, executive director of the Enderby & District Chamber of Commerce, says, “I believe we have the smallest tax rate for light industry in the Okanagan.” Bengston also pushes what he terms the ‘6 L’s’. By this he means Low taxes; Labour and Location, which allows Enderby to draw on much larger populations south and north for a bigger labour pool. Lower real estate prices contribute to an enviable Lifestyle and suggests available Land. Finally he endorses Enderby’s Licensing regime, which is a “perpetual business license” program, one of many ways Enderby works to reduce red tape. In addition while other cities say they want more clean, light industry they dither about zoning or setting land aside, Enderby quietly put aside an unserviced 16.5 acre parcel. 14
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
It also doesn’t hurt that Enderby boasts the last credit union that hasn’t jumped on to the merger mania, keeping its local roots, well, local. Ted Morrison is general manager of the Enderby & District Credit Union. He explains why they have resisted buy out offers, “We strongly feel the community would suffer if we were a branch.” The Credit Union has a hand, he says, in virtually every single event, charity and community cause in town. Solidly profitable, Morrison says last year’s recession gave pause to the credit union’s growth rate; significantly, it still made money. He credits the track record to being more risk averse than other lenders, but with a $50 million base they are the single largest financial factor in the town’s financial foundations for both residential and business loans. Nor has the town put all its eggs in the basket of industry. It benefits from the tourism factor that being on Highway 97 brings. With three small hotels, 20 odd B&Bs and eight campgrounds Enderby simply does not have the room base for a hotel base that other municipalities have used to fund tourism with a room tax. That hasn’t stopped the community from experiencing a better than 40% increase in tourism over 2008. Visitors jumped from 7,602 to 10,920. Parties had a similar increase from 4,885 to 7,446. Americans virtually disappeared from the area in 2008, but Bengston reports they are nudging back onto the radar screen. Albertan visitors are down, but the big increase was from visitors who live within a three to four hour drive. Part of the increase might be from a new service, the Tube Taxi, which started up this year. It offered visitors the chance to float down the incredibly beautiful meander that is the Shuswap River. As the river is also the town’s water source the new company met with controversy because people
are concerned about pollution from the hordes of people that floated downstream. It is equally difficult to pin down how many dollars flowed to local businesses from the new venture. While debate about using the river as a tourist draw continues, the town continues to host an industrial base that is amazing for its size. Five of Enderby’s diverse industrial stars are highlighted below.
North Valley Frameworks
One of Canada’s industrial liabilities is that it is suffering from a productivity gap, often because industry is not investing in the technology that will make the difference. North Valley Frameworks (NVF) is a showcase on how to get it right with automated, laser-accurate equipment used to design and build precision frames for buildings of all sizes. Owner Mark Ibbetson gets so enthusiastic that he can’t help boasting about one of the things the new technology is capable of: “The automated system will flip a piece of wood over to maximize the use of the wood.” Ibbetson should be enthusiastic. The programming allows every piece of wood over 5.5 inches to be used. The program is so sophisticated that if a piece of wood has an angle cut or there is a chunk missing, the equipment can turn or flip the piece to make the most efficient use of the remaining piece. Ibbestson says, “Over the course of a year this saves four loads of wood we figure.” After purchasing NVF less than two years ago he invested US $260,000 to obtain the new equipment and a further $160,000 for the software to run it. Since then he has invested a lot of time to make
the whole process run smoothly, resulting in a greater and greater cost saving. The trick wasn’t just the equipment. It is designing, numbering and marking every piece of wood in a building and programming every one into the computer so it can get the maximum amount of usage out of every piece of lumber right from the start of a project. When Ibbetson started the process, it would take three to four weeks to program in all the dimensions and pieces of wood for a job. After two years of practice he says most structures are entered into the system in three or four days. At full tilt, NVF runs a team of 19 people. This past summer the construction slow down had the crew down to half that, but Ibbetson says the material and time savings resulting from this methodology gives NVF a tremendous edge. He calculates traditional methods of construction and labour to cost between $20 and $30 per hour. His equipment has cut that cost to about $16 per hour, a 25 to 47% saving.
Mark Ibbetson, owner of North Valley Frameworks, stands next to the automated saws that measure and extract every piece of useable
Framing time drops by about a third, less material is used and less dumped. North Valley estimates that for every 10,000 sq. ft. of structure a week of labour is saved during construction.
wood down to five-and-a-half-inch scraps.
.PTU PG VT BTTPDJBUF ²XPPE IFBU³ XJUI QPMMVUJOH UIF FOWJSPONFOU VOQMFBTBOU TNFMMT MBCPVS JOUFOTF BOE VOSFMJBCMF FRVJQNFOU 8F UIJOL XF BSF PO UIF SJHIU USBDL CZ CVSOJOH GPTTJM GVFMT BOE CZ SFTUSJDUJOH PS FWFO PVUMBXJOH XPPE IFBU
)&"5*/( 8*5) 800%
'JOL .BDIJOF *OD 1 0 #PY 0ME 7FSOPO 3PBE &OEFSCZ #SJUJTI $PMVNCJB 7 & 7 $BOBEB 5FM 'BY & žOL!KFUTUSFBN OFU XXX 'JOL.BDIJOF DPN
#Z TFSJPVTMZ MPPLJOH BU UIJT JTTVF XJUI BO PQFO NJOE XF XJMM žOE UIBU PVS PQJOJPOT BCPVU XPPE IFBU BSF PGUFO CBTFE PO BTTVNQUJPOT BOE OPU PO GBDUT 5IF &VSPQFBOT IBWF EFBMU XJUI UIF QPMMVUJOH PG UIF FOWJSPONFOU GSPN XPPE IFBU BQQMJBODFT JO UIF QBTU 4USJOHFOU FNJTTJPO MBXT IBWF CFFO FOGPSDFE JOTUFBE PG CBOOJOH UIF VTF PG XPPE IFBU BOE UIF NBOVGBDUVSFST PG XPPE CVSOJOH BQQMJBODFT IBE UP DPOGPSN UP UIFTF TUBOEBSET
GPTTJM GVFMT 8IJMF VODPOUSPMMFE XPPE CVSOJOH TVDI BT JO BO PME TUZMF XPPE TUPWFT PS QSJNJUJWF JOEVTUSJBM CPJMFST FNJUT IJHI MFWFMT PG QBSUJDVMBUF NBUUFS UP UIF BUNPTQIFSF UPEBZÂľT NPEFSO XPPE CPJMFST BSF IJHIMZ SFHVMBUFE BOE VTVBMMZ IBWF TUBUF PG UIF BSU FNJTTJPO DPOUSPM EFWJDFT 5IJT UFDIOPMPHZ BMMPXT NPEFSO CJPNBTT CPJMFS QMBOUT UP SFEVDF UIFJS QBSUJDVMBUF BOE DBSCPO NPOPYJEF FNJTTJPOT UP XFMM CFMPX UIPTF PG UIF PME GPTTJM GVFM GVSOBDFT BOE CPJMFST UIFZ SFQMBDF
Every piece of wood coming out of NVF is coded using an inkjet printer so that builders know exactly where each precision-cut piece or section goes.
Delta-C Technology
If you think that Enderby would not be the place to find cutting edge products serving the oil and gas industry that’s only because you don’t know about Delta-C Technology. The firm manufactures watercut monitors that accurately measure water content, a key concern in oil production and transportation. Says owner Dhane Merriman, “Our primary customers are those that move the oil or the
DPOTJEFSFE $0 DBSCPO EJPYJEF OFVUSBM %JTQPTBM PG XPPE XBTUF XIJDI PGUFO DSFBUFT MPDBM QPMMVUJPO QSPCMFNT DBO CF SFEVDFE BOE JOTUFBE IFBU DBO CF QSPEVDFE 5IF MBOEžMMT BSF žMMJOH VQ GBTU FOPVHI XF EPO¾U OFFE UP TIJQ IVOESFET PG UPOFT PG QFSGFDUMZ HPPE ²GVFM³ UP UIF EVNQ TP JU DBO CF CVSJFE
DPNQMFUFMZ FMJNJOBUFE BOE BOOVBM FOFSHZ DPTU SFEVDUJPOT PG VQ UP BSF BDIJFWBCMF (SFBUFS TBWJOHT BSF TUJMM BDIJFWBCMF GPS GBDJMJUJFT XIJDI IBWF UIFJS PXO XPPE XBTUF GSPN NBOVGBDUVSJOH QSPDFTTFT (00% 3&"40/4 '03 48*5$)*/( 50 #*0 &/&3(:
4BWJOHT #JPNBTT FOFSHZ TZTUFNT HFOFSBUF NVMUJQMF TBWJOHT CZ VTJOH B NPSF FGžDJFOU IFBUJOH TZTUFN SFQMBDJOH *O POF PG UIFTF ²NPEFSO CPJMFST³ NBEF JUT XBZ UP &OEFSCZ 'JOL GVFM UIBU JT JNQPSUFE PJM HBT .BDIJOF IBT JOTUBMMFE B ,0# #0*-&3 QSPQBOF UP UIF DPNNVOJUZ XJUI MPXFS DPTU MPDBM GVFM XPPE DIJQT TBXEVTU ,0# JT NFNCFS PG UIF 7*&44."// QFMMFUT (3061 GSPN "VTUSJB UP IFBU UIFJS TR GU QMBOU XJUI XPPE DIJQT 3FMJBCJMJUZ #JPNBTT UFDIOPMPHZ JT NBUVSF "GUFS FYQFSJFODJOH UIF CFOFžUT PG BOE SFMJBCMF XJEFMZ VTFE JO NBOZ .PEFSO FRVJQNFOU UP QSPEVDF IFBU UIJT BVUPNBUJD XPPE DIJQ CPJMFS GSPN CJPNBTT IBT CFFO BWBJMBCMF 'JOL .BDIJOF TUBSUFE UP JNQPSU NPSF BQQMJDBUJPOT JO &VSPQF BOE BSPVOE UIF XPSME PO UIF &VSPQFBO NBSLFU GPS PWFS PG UIFTF XPPE CPJMFST BOE CFDBNF ZFBST UIF TBMFT BOE TFSWJDF BHFOU GPS ,0# 4FDVSJUZ #0*-&34 JO $BOBEB 4JODF UIFO UIF 8F NJHIU KVTU IBWF UP ²QVMM PVS IFBE ,0# #0*-&34 IBWF CFFO JOTUBMMFE JO 4FDVSJUZ PG TVQQMZ JT BO JNQPSUBOU PVU PG UIF TBOE³ BOE TUBSU MPPLJOH DPOTJEFSBUJPO #JPNBTT TZTUFNT TDIPPMT JOEVTUSJBM QMBOUT IPTQJUBMT BU IPX XF DBO BQQMZ NPEFSO XPPE HSFFOIPVTFT BOE PUIFS BQQMJDBUJPOT CBTFE PO MPDBMMZ NBOBHFE SFTPVSDFT IFBUJOH UFDIOPMPHZ JO B HSFBUFS XBZ QSPWJEF NPSF FOFSHZ TUBCJMJUZ ,0# #0*-&34 IBT CFFO POF PG UIF JO #SJUJTI $PMVNCJB 8F BMM BHSFF TIFMUFS VTFST GSPN QSJDF TIPDLT BOE NPTU JOOPWBUJWF QSPWJEFST PG XPPE UIBU XF EPO¾U MJLF UIF JODSFBTJOH FTDBMBUJOH QSJDFT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI žSFE IFBUJOH TZTUFNT GPS BMNPTU FOFSHZ QSJDFT UIBU XF EPO¾U MJLF UP PUIFS FOFSHZ TPVSDFT BOE BT XFMM BT ZFBST 5IF DPNQBOZ IBT SFDFJWFE CF EFQFOEJOH PO UIF BWBJMBCJMJUZ PG FOBCMF MPDBM JOTUJUVUJPOT UP TUSFUDI OVNFSPVT BXBSET GPS JUT JOOPWBUJPOT JNQPSUFE GPTTJM GVFMT BOE UIBU XF SFEVDFE CVEHFUT FWFO GVSUIFS JO UIF FOWJSPONFOUBM TFDUPS 5IF EPO¾U MJLF UIF GBDU UIBU PVS BJS RVBMJUZ FNJTTJPOT PG UIF ,0# #PJMFST BSF 8FBMUI $SFBUJPO JT HFUUJOH XPSTF QSPHSFTTJWFMZ XFMM CFMPX UIF GFEFSBM BOE QSPWJODJBM 6TJOH CJP NBTT DBO IBWF B QPTJUJWF TUBOEBSET 'JOL .BDIJOF JT FRVJQQFE ²,FFQJOH UIF FOFSHZ EPMMBST BU IPNF³ #JPNBTT FOFSHZ TZTUFNT DBO CF B NBKPS JNQBDU PO UIF BJS RVBMJUZ *G CJPNBTT UP QFSGPSN FNJTTJPO UFTUT PO UIFTF SFQMBDFT PJM PS DPBM 40Y TVMGVS PYJEF CPJMFST BOE UIFSFGPSF JT BCMF UP TIPX DBUBMZTU JO DPNNVOJUZ XFBMUI DSFBUJPO CZ EJTQMBDJOH JNQPSUT VTJOH MPDBM FNJTTJPOT BSF DVU TIBSQMZ CFDBVTF UIFTF PVUTUBOEJOH SFTVMUT UP FBDI SFTPVSDFT BWPJEJOH XBTUF EJTQPTBM XPPE DPNCVTUJPO QSPEVDFT WJSUVBMMZ DVTUPNFS PO TJUF DPTUT DSFBUJOH KPCT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI VTF OP 40Y PG MPDBM GVFM TPVSDF BOE HFOFSBUJOH OFX &DPOPNJDBMMZ BUUSBDUJWF JT UP TXJUDI "DDPSEJOH UP UIF TUBOEBSET PG UIF 6 4 UP CJPNBTT IFBU FTQFDJBMMZ GPS CVTJOFTT JODPNF &OWJSPONFOUBM 1SPUFDUJPO "HFODZ DPNNFSDJBM JOEVTUSJBM JOTUJUVUJPOBM 5IF &OWJSPONFOU JOEVTUSJBM TJ[FE XPPE CPJMFST QSPEVDF BOE EJTUSJDU IFBUJOH BQQMJDBUJPOT MFTT /0Y OJUSPHFO PYJEF FNJTTJPOT #JPNBTT FOFSHZ TZTUFNT BSF CBTFE %FQFOEJOH PO UIF BQQMJDBUJPO UIF UIBO DPNQBSBCMF TZTUFNT CVSOJOH PO B SFOFXBCMF SFTPVSDF BOE BSF GPTTJM GVFM DPOTVNQUJPO NBZ CF
*OTUFBE PG CVSOJOH MBSHF TMBTI QJMFT JO UIF CVTI XF DPVME VTF UIF DIJQQFE XPPE UP IFBU PVS DPNNVOJUJFT BOE BMTP MPXFS UIF OFHBUJWF JNQBDU PO UIF MPDBM BJS TIFE BT XFMM BT MPXFSJOH PVS FOFSHZ CJMMT $BOBEJBO QFMMFU NJMMT QSPEVDF NPSF UIBO UPOFT PG IJHI RVBMJUZ QFMMFUT QFS ZFBS 0WFS PG UIFTF QFMMFUT BSF CFJOH TIJQQFE UP &VSPQF *U XPVME CF B HSFFOFS PQUJPO GPS UIF FOWJSPONFOU BOE GPS $BOBEB T FNCBSSBTTJOH SFQVUBUJPO BT POF PG IJHIFTU QFS DBQJUB QSPEVDFST PG HSFFOIPVTF HBTFT JO UIF XPSME UP NBLF VTF PG UIF QFMMFUT JO DVUUJOH FNJTTJPOT BU IPNF BOE OPU UP TIJQ UIFN IBMG XBZ BSPVOE UIF QMBOFU 8F IBWF B EFTQFSBUF OFFE GPS B $BOBEJBO TUSBUFHZ UP CFUUFS UBQ JOUP UIF DPVOUSZ T JODSFEJCMF BOE MBSHFMZ VOBQQSFDJBUFE CJP FOFSHZ QPUFOUJBM 8F IBWF UIF XPPE UIF UFDIOPMPHZ BOE XF IBWF BUUSBDUJWF HPWFSONFOU JODFOUJWFT BWBJMBCMF PO UIF GFEFSBM BOE QSPWJODJBM MFWFMT 8)"5 *4 )0-%*/( 64 #"$, 'JOL .BDIJOF *OD JT B TVQQMJFS PG IJHI RVBMJUZ NBDIJOFSZ GPS UIF CJP FOFSHZ JOEVTUSZ 8F PGGFS OFX SFWPMVUJPOBSZ UFDIOPMPHJFT UIBU IBWF B QPTJUJWF JNQBDU PO JOUFSFTUT TVDI BT HMPCBM XBSNJOH BMUFSOBUJWF IFBUJOH BOE TVTUBJOBCJMJUZ
November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
15
producers who must prove to the pipeline companies that they have little water in it.� Merriman is not talking about much water either. More water than 0.5% is a problem, but DeltaC’s instruments have a resolution of 10 parts per million (ppm) with an accuracy of 100 ppm or .01%. In fact Merriman says these are the most “sensitive units� available on the market. Merriman bought up Delta-C in 2007 from the previous owner Herman Doublet who started the company in 1989. Merriman used to be in Alberta until he retired from business. Settling into the Shuswap he was soon bored, prompting him to buy out Doublet. But Merriman has expanded on the old Delta-C by also buying up the company in Calgary that made the electronics control devices for the monitors. Merriman integrated the two companies in to the Enderby facility. Now the electronic controls and monitor construction occurs in one facility under the strictest quality controls. Delta-C’s Dhane Merriman explains how one of his units detects water in oil, critical to producers and pipeline operators around the globe.
Although the Alberta oil connection is the obvious one Delta-C also sells around the globe, boasting customers from China and the United Kingdom. Merriman sees no contradiction in selling to the world from a small town on the Shuswap River.
Competitors sell their units for around $50,000, while Delta-C’s two series and five models of monitors are in the $30,000 range. Price alone isn’t enough, suggests Merriman. Delta-C’s solid reputation is good but he wants to get the word out. Little marketing efforts were made in the past, but that too is going to change as the Merriman works on marketing and licensing agreements around the world.
Fink Machine
The Fink Machine Company is named for Burkhard Fink. This kind of light industry is the kind that every municipality hungers for. It is highly skilled, in a growth sector and it is more than green. It is one of the firms setting the standards for green. The core of Fink’s business is the KOB Wood Boiler, which is an ultra-efficient wood burning furnace built for large scale buildings. Fink says the energy costs are equivalent to a natural gas boiler. Wood –partly thanks to the pine beetle– scraps are readily available for making fuel, and; the boilers fit in with society’s continuing push to reduce our carbon footprint on the environment. The boilers achieve a 90% efficiency rating and heat buildings from 10,000 sq. ft. and up. A boiler generating 3 million BTU (units can put out up to
www.enderbycreditunion.com & Y D F F E J O H & Y Q F D U B U J P O T
XXX NBCFMMBLFHPMG DPN 5FF UJNFT BOE JORVJSJFT 'FBUVSJOH Â…3FHVMBUJPO IPMF 1BS Â…4MPQF SBUJOH Â… TFUT PG UFFT Â…'VMMZ TUPDLFE 1SP 4IPQ Â…-JDFOTFE $MVCIPVTF BOE 1BUJP Â…$BMM BCPVU PVS 4UBZ BOE 1MBZ QBDLBHFT 'BDJMJUJFT GPS NFFUJOHT XFEEJOHT SFUJSFNFOU BOE HPMG UPVSOBNFOUT 'PS 3 7 BOE DBCJO SFTFSWBUJPOT BU .BCFM -BLF 3FTPSU BOE "JSQBSL XXX NBCFMMBLFSFTPSU DPN &OEFSCZ .BCFM -BLF 3PBE &OEFSCZ #$ 7 & 7
CONSUMER & COMMERCIAL BANKING SERVICES LOANS & MORTGAGES WEALTH MANAGEMENT SERVICES 24 HOUR DRIVE-THRU ATM
Lending Services Specialists
.BCFM -BLF (PMG $PVOUSZ $MVC
16
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
Member Services Specialists
Tel: 250.838.6841 703 Mill Avenue, Enderby, BC
8.5 million) will use 500 lb. of material per hour. Fink’s facility is 16,000 sq. ft. He has one hopper outside that provides sufficient fuel for the whole building throughout a winter and shoulder seasons. The burning process is so thorough that total weight is 0.2 to 0.3% of the original wood source. Fink, with a staff of four, have sold 38 of the company’s KOB wood boilers over the past nine years, but sales have increased sharply of late. Says Fink, “A quarter of them were in the last year.” Unfortunately none of those sales are local; although Fink says, hopefully, “I think they are doing an energy audit in Vernon on municipal buildings.” Mostly though, the Okanagan simply isn’t looking. The closest sale Fink has made is to a school in Quesnel. Fink believes the challenge his company needs to overcome are old-fashioned, negative connotations associated with wood burner technology. Ideas like the one that wood burners need someone at the side stoking the fire in a smokysmelling basement all night. Fink’s burners are self loading. Even the feed units are designed to automatically back up in case a piece of wood jams. Heat distribution is also far advanced from anachronistic notions of one room hot as a furnace. Fink’s units can heat one building or be designed to heat an entire complex of buildings over a larger area. Fink doesn’t actually manufacture these units. Parts come from Germany, but it is Fink that puts them together, custom designs them to meet client needs and sells any or all support equipment necessary. Support equipment includes hoppers to store wood supplies, wood hogs to cut wood into smaller pieces suitable for the burners and even briquette presses that can turn tiny scraps or sawdust into easily transported, more compact wood pellets.
Peter Sperlich explains that his mid-to upper end log homes are sold in Japan, Germany, Austria and the U.S.A
Sperlich Log Homes
This firm, which manufactures beautiful and rugged log homes, is celebrating its twentieth anniversary. CEO Peter Sperlich, who took over from his father, says the company sells medium to high end houses. Despite the worldwide recession, he says, “We haven’t really experience any slow down.” That is because the company is so thoroughly diversified in its markets that if one area, such as the U.S. where sales have dropped off, is suffering, others pick up the slack. Germany and Japan have been two major markets over the past two decades and at the time of this interview Sperlich was working on a dozen contracts for Japanese customers. Agents had just opened the company up to new markets in Austria, Italy and France. This was part of the business model from the beginning says Sperlich. “The long term plan was to have some diversification and position ourselves globally.” Sperlich explains their ability to shrug off the downturn as being their top of market placement. “The reality is we’re using a premium softwood so we’re top of the food chain.” Sperlich only uses western red cedar logs of a certain size, which he describes as the “best wood possible”. The custom designed homes are constructed on the Sperlich site in Enderby, then taken apart and shipped to their final home where carefully trained local agents put them back together.
Top: company owner Burkhard Fink, stands in front of the fuel hopper that has enough capacity to keep his plant warm for 12 months.
BotTom: This KOB biofuel boiler is the heart of the ultra-efficient wood-burning fuel systems that Fink is selling throughout western Canada.
On occasion, for particularly complex or large structures (up to 10,000 sq. ft.) someone from the Enderby head office will go over to supervise. Despite its ongoing success Sperlich says the company, like every other business, has to move with the times. Logs “must be harvested with minimal impact to the ecosystem and the harvested area must be replanted.” November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
17
Okanagan Fertilizer
Art Clancy has turned over the operation of Okanagan Fertilizer to his son Ken, but he comes out to show people around the packaging and loading facility of the company he’s been around since it opened in 1976. Okanagan Fertilizer is the only fertilizer manufacturer in the interior and the last independent service in the province. The company offers bulk custom orders, packaging and product specialities to match the needs of many local growers from farmers to golf companies. The company prides itself that all “fertilizer products [undergo] high analysis, are uniformly sized and dust free.”
These logs are western red cedar, the most desirable for log building and the hardest to come by, which is why Sperlich homes are sought after for their quality and durability.
He says the amount of top quality fibre that meets their ecologically oriented specifications is the only limiting factor they have but says the company has reached what the Sperlich family terms a “comfortable size”. Here he says income provides secure employment and rich opportunities for his family and his skilled employee force.
If Canadian companies are often accused of not keeping up with new techniques or improved efficiencies Okanagan Fertilizer leans the other way to ensure manufacturing is still profitable. They will sell to farmers directly to stay cost competitive, they have embraced GPS technology to improve spreading accuracy and speed the process at peak times and uses Roundup Ready Corn products and Duration CR, which is a polymer coated urea. This, says the company’s website, “…is engineered to release nitrogen based on soil temperature regulated osmosis. Nitrogen is delivered to the plant with maximum efficiency needed for optimum growth. Concerns about
Taking care of the things that you care about most...
MCLEOD AGENCIES LTD
18
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
Commercial Quotes | Residential Quotes Roof Trusses | Floor Systems | Wall Panels
Independently Owned & Operated Insurance Agency Business | House | Farm | Boat | Life | Motor Licence Office
601 Bass Ave., Enderby, BC
Monday - Friday 8:30am - 5:00pm Saturday 9:00am - 5:00 pm 250.838.7333 | 904 George Street, Enderby
Toll Free: 1.866.403.8787
T: 250.838.9903
leaching, denitrification and volatilization are eliminated.” The company has suffered from the downturn last year, but, says Art, their biggest concern is the recent closure of the Canadian Pacific spur line. Without rail transport of raw ingredients into the area input costs will rise steeply, perhaps enough to kill the business and SureCrop, the Grindrod based company that is also dependent on the rail line. The rail line decision was sparked by the closure of the Lavington glass plant, which CP says takes away the profit margin from the spur line. Originally CP obfuscated as to whether they would sell the rail line to competitors, which bothered many in Enderby. Tate Bengston says, “CP wants out of the spur line business, but they don’t want competition to make use of it.” Finally, on October 8 CP announced it was putting the 51 km line up for sale. SureCrop indicated a month earlier it was interested in purchasing 13 km, but admitted it couldn’t do it without government support or some other kind of backing. Local politicians have been getting involved but so far the $4 million price tag and ongoing maintenance costs are proving a challenge.
Enderby Snapshot Incorporated: 1905 Area: 4.2 sq. km Located in the North Okanagan Regional District Employment
In 2006 out of a total labour force of 1,265 persons, the three biggest employer sectors: construction (170 or 13.4%); manufacturing (160 or 12.6%); health care and social assistance (150 or 11.9%). Statistics
Population 2,890 (2008) Population aged 65+ in 2006: 27.3% (B.C. 14.6%) Population growth rate for 2007-2008: 0.6% (B.C. 1.7%)
This fertilizer, one of a dozen products that Okanagan Fertilizer developed for the unique needs of particular kinds of customers like golf courses or farmers, is the only fertilizer made in the region. The Okanagan Fertilizer plant in Enderby reduces costs because of customer proximity, but is threatened by CP’s decision to close down the spur line that brings in crucial raw products.
Income
Labour force breakdown:
Median household income (2006): $43,804 (B.C. $54,840)
Total labour force: 1,265 (2006)
Average income from those filing tax returns (2006): $28,578 (B.C. $38,523) Main source of income for residents in 2006: Employment (58.5%), Pension (17.9%), Investment (8.4%), Other not counting selfemployed (6.1%), Self-employed (5.5%)
Labour force as % of total population: 44.5% (2006) Percent of labour force self-employed: 5.8% (2006) Building Permits
New residential units built: 6 (2008) 21 (2006) Business
Business incorporations: 9 (2008) 6 (2006) Business bankruptcies: Unknown Total # of firms with no employees: 176 (June 2008)
Typical house value: $419,722 (2008) $174,700 (2004) Value of new residential construction: $1.6 million (2008) $3.9 million (2006) Value of other construction: $1.2 million (2008) $0.5 million (2006)
Total # of firms with employees: 188 (June 2008) 170 companies had 1 to 19 employees, 15 companies had 20 to 49 employees and three companies had 50 to 199 employees Chamber of Commerce members: 115
November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
19
Small Town Spirit, Boundless Opportunity The Enderby and District Chamber of Commerce welcomes your inquiries about entrepreneurial and investment opportunities as well as business expansion and relocation. Enderby truly offers it all. Location | Enderby is strategically located as the the gateway between the Shuswap and the Okanagan. Lifestyle | Natural attractions, year-round recreation and urban amenities make Enderby attractive for your employees to live and work. Land | Commercial and industrial land in Enderby and the surrounding area is available for your business. Labour | The local labour force embodies the full skills continuum with post-secondary training institutions in close proximity. Low taxes | Enderby’s taxation rates are the lowest in the valley on many classes, most notably light industry. Licensing | Red tape and expenses are reduced with Enderby’s unique “perpetual business licence.”
Come discover the welcoming spirit of Enderby today.
Enderby & District Chamber of Commerce P.O. Box 1000, 700 Railway Street, Enderby, BC V0E 1V0 T: 250.838.6727 F: 250.838.0123 www.enderbychamber.com
Mischa Popoff
THIS DEMOCRACY
Environmentalists still trying to kill the internal combustion engine Remember when globalwarming activists screamed for the electric car? They weren’t bothered that it could only go 100 miles, or that it could only carry kids and golf clubs, or kids and groceries, but never all three. This new breed of green believers was willing to lead the way by vastly inconveniencing themselves in the hope the rest of us, overwrought with guilt, would follow suit. According to the 2006 documentary 'Who killed the electric car?' blame for the demise of woefully inadequate electric vehicles rests at the feet of nasty automobile companies and evil oil companies. You’re supposed to believe that a dirty, inefficient technology is being artificially propped up while a clean and perfectly viable technology is being suppressed, all in the name of greed. Appreciating that people need to go further than 100 miles between charges, some manufacturers took a giant leap backwards and combined a small internal combustion engine with a generator and an electric motor. Nothing new there, but the marketing department dubbed it “hybrid electric technology,” which is like calling yourself a “hybrid vegetarian” because you sometimes eat vegetables.
But whatever the guilt trip, this revolutionary crowd has never found time to contend with actual science. They haven’t because they can’t. The amount of energy required to move a given weight over a given distance at a given rate of acceleration is immutable. The eternal hope that there will someday be advances in battery technology won’t change the laws of physics as described by Isaac Newton in his 1687 work Principia Mathematica. In fact, this should be recommended reading for any hybrid owners who wonder why they get such abysmal mileage. Switching our fossil-fuel based economy to a sometimes-electric economy will not save any energy. None. It will only change the source of energy. For the faithful, 35 or 40 mpg in a hybrid seems reason enough to brag, in spite of the fact that many gasoline vehicles do just as well. Then there’s the diehard hybrid owner (perhaps one who practises the fine art of grannydriving) who claims to get 50 or 60 mpg. Many diesel cars do that well, but evidence shows that such mileage is actually a
pipe dream for a hybrid. Don’t take my word for it, or even Newton’s… Phil Edmundson, former New Democratic MP and author of the Lemonade Car Guide, says categorically, “We don’t recommend electric and gasoline engine hybrids because their fuel economy can be 40% worse than the automakers report.” That should rock anyone’s faith, unless of course Edmundson turns out to be in the pocket of ‘Big Auto’ or ‘Big Oil’. Think that’s likely? Clearly it’s not the cleanliness or efficiency of hybrids and electric cars that propels their sales. It’s an avowed hatred fostered by some for the oil industry, and nothing more. Never mind that all the CO2 stored in fossil fuels once floated harmlessly in the earth’s atmosphere. Never mind that the oceans absorb 98% of CO2 emissions and that burning all known
oil reserves tomorrow would barely elevate atmospheric CO2 levels over time. Never mind that manufacturing batteries for cars is detrimental to the environment and that disposing of them will prove even dirtier than the dreaded ship wrecking business. No, never mind all that. You’re supposed to invest in this inefficient technology in spite of Edmundson’s warnings that “long-term reliability is unknown, battery replacement cost is estimated to run as high as $8,000 (U.S.), [and] expensive electric motors are predicted to have a high failure rate from corrosion.”Go on, the selfrighteous environmentalist says, Take a financial hit and do your part to put a nail in the coffin of the internal combustion engine! In the public relations campaign to advance a “green” agenda, it hardly seems to matter to politicians that doing so could lead to the crime of the century against civilization and nature.
A new “hybrid faith” was born. Emboldened by government purchases of huge fleets of hybrids (province of B.C., the cities of Penticton and Kelowna), the environmentalists started to attack the naysayers.
Mischa Popoff is a freelance political writer with a bachelor’s degree in history. November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
21
Biodiesel to lubricate the engine of industry in 2010 Story by Devon Brooks
Diesel is the heavy lifter for industry in North America. It fuels most big trucks on the highways and most heavy-duty equipment on the continent. But the old industrial workhorse is changing.
hauling. The City of Kelowna asked him to provide B100 for a test fleet of cars, which he did, but only after making the City sign a waiver saying it knew the fuel would automatically void the warranty.
By 2012 the Canadian government has legislated all diesel fuel will contain 2% biodiesel as part of its long term commitment to reducing CO2 emissions. British Columbia leapfrogged that with a 5% diesel (B5) requirement to be in place by January 1, 2010.
Another issue is that biodiesel has a lower gel point, meaning it will turn semisolid sooner than petro-diesel. The difference is only a few degrees, but it can be crucial in colder climates.
The benefits of biodiesel include: fewer emissions of unburned hydrocarbons, CO2, CO and particulate matter, and it acts as an engine lubricant. Current diesel engines need no changes or modifications; although older ones might need some part swapping (see note under 'Warranties' sidebar on page 25). At the moment obtaining biodiesel in the interior is limited to Dean Buse, the franchise owner for 4Refuel. He notes, “We’re the only company in B.C. selling legal, marked biodiesel.” The literature on biodiesel reads like a panacea, with no issues and no considerations. That isn’t quite true and Buse is keen to acknowledge both the benefits and considerations to watch out for. “There is the operations side and the sales side. I know both. Salesmen tend to say everything is great and the more you buy the better off you are. I see it from the operations side too.”
Top: Autogas on Highway 33 in Kelowna is the only station in the Okanagan currently selling biodiesel. Photo by Devon Brooks. Above: A 4Refuel truck is seen here filling up heavy equipment at a mine site in the dead of winter. Photo contributed. Below: Local 4Refuel franchise owner Dean Buse has good reason to believe that biodiesel use will increase as government’s push it for its strong environmental benefits and he pushes its engine-prolonging qualities. Photo contributed.
4Refuel’s own brochure blithely states: “Currently blends up to B20 are covered with full warranty.” Buse provides a more accurate list of what diesel motor makers actually say (see sidebar on page 25 for a partial list of manufacturer warranty requirements). Angela Reid is a councillor with the City of Kelowna, but is also a board member for the Alberta Biodiesel Association and the VP of BioStreet Canada. BioStreet is opening Canada’s first commercial scale biodiesel plant in Vegreville, Alberta. According to Reid, “At this point a lot of the big truck diesel manufacturers are testing higher grades and have no problems.”
In the Lower Mainland Buse says operators can use B20 all year round, but in the interior he tells customers (if their warranty allows it) to use B20 in the warm summer months, B10 in the shoulder seasons and then B5 in the winter. “A B5 blend will never cause any problem. Never,” he asserts. While Buse supplies the only station in Kelowna, Autogas, with biodiesel, his bread and butter is supplying the fuel to industrial sites. He is frustrated by how often people balk about the half penny per litre for the biodiesel. Never mind all the environmental benefits, Buse contends that the fuel, which acts as a lubricant, will likely extend the life of the engine by as much as a quarter. “Diesel lubricants are much more expensive for what biodiesel will do automatically.” On the price differential, Reid says, “There is a little bit of a premium.” The difference between B5 and petro-diesel at Autogas is a half cent a litre. B20 is 2¢ more per litre and B40 is 4¢. Adds Reid, “The goal is to get the prices at par, but realistically the market will drive it. As oil prices go up our prices will be closer.” When prices for fuel varied from 80¢ a litre to $1.50 as they did in 2008, Buse shakes his head when potential customers raise a fuss about the half penny. He points out that by delivering the fuel to customer work sites they more than make up the difference because they don’t pay one of their workers to drive equipment, or vehicles, to wherever they normally purchase fuel. He says the biggest problem is “getting peoples’ heads around something new.”
Buse agrees, saying there ‘should’ be no such warranty numbers. “A lack of knowledge is behind the warranty issues.” Biodiesel not only won’t damage modern engines, but will extend their life span. Even so Buse doesn’t recommend using B100.
With the province mandating 5% biodiesel it might seem legislation will solve Buse’s problem, but the 5% figure is a provincial average. Buse says they might pump 8 to 10% into Lower Mainland stations and distribute none elsewhere in the province.
He says Summerland tried running one of its trucks using pure biodiesel, but there was insufficient power for the loads the truck was
If biodiesel is distributed by other retailers throughout the province, he suspects there might be other problems. BIODIESEL CONTINUED ON PAGE 25
$PSQPSBUF &WFOUT $ BUFSJOH
HURRY BEFORE THIS OFFER HANGS UP.BEFORE THIS OFFER HURRY DISCOVER SHAWUP. SOHO DIGITAL PHONE HANGS
DISCOVER SHAW SOHO DIGITAL PHONE SHAW DIGITAL PHONE LITE
PER
**
MONTH
SOHO DIGITAL PHONE LITE
PER
TWO MONTHS FREE
MONTH
SOHO DIGITAL PHONE LITE
3535
$
95
*
$
PER MONTH
SOHO DIGITAL PHONE
SHAW DIGITAL PHONE
TWO MONTHS FREE
95
*
PER MONTH
SOHO DIGITAL PHONE TWO MONTHS FREE
TWO MONTHS FREE
The perfect plan for the light long-distance business user. > Voicemail, Call Waiting, Call Display, Call Forward, 3-Way Calling, CallThe Return, and plan Anonymous Call Blocking. perfect for the and lightSelective long-distance business user. > Voicemail, Waiting, Call Display, Forward, > Anytime calling Call at 4¢ per minute withinCall Canada, the3-Way U.S. Calling, and to 50 Call Return, and Anonymous and Pacific, Selectiveand Call South Blocking. countries in the U.K., Europe, Asia America. > Anytime calling at 4¢ per minute Canada, the U.S. all andaround to 50 > Access to Shaw International Directwithin – competitive rates countries in the U.K., Europe, Asia Pacific, and South America. the world. SHAW DIGITAL PHONE LITE
**
:PVS 8FTUTJEF $POOFDUJPO UP UIF 4FB
> Access to Shaw International Direct – competitive rates all around the world.
This plan is great for heavy long-distance business users. > Voicemail, CallisWaiting, Display, Call Forward, 3-Way Calling, This plan great forCall heavy long-distance business users. Call>Return, andCall Anonymous andDisplay, Selective Blocking. Voicemail, Waiting, Call CallCall Forward, 3-Way Calling, > Anytime 4¢Anonymous per minute Canada, the U.S. and to 50 Callcalling Return,atand andwithin Selective Call Blocking. > Anytime calling 4¢ per minute within Canada, the U.S. and to 50 countries in the U.K.,atEurope, Asia Pacific, and South America. the U.K., Europe, Asia –Pacific, and South America. > Accesscountries to ShawinInternational Direct competitive rates all around Access to Shaw International Direct – competitive rates all around the>world. the world. Also included: Also included: > 1000 minutes per month of long-distance calling within Canada > 1000 minutes per month of long-distance calling within Canada and the andU.S. the U.S. > One>Distinctive RingRing number. One Distinctive number.
0VS GVMM 4FSWJDF DBUFSJOH QSPWJEFT UIF žOFTU PG EJOJOH GPS DPSQPSBUF XFEEJOHT BOE TPDJBM FWFOUT XJUIPVU SFNBSLBCMF DPTUT &YQFSJFODF BXBSE XJOOJOH &YFDVUJWF $IFG .JLF :PSLF )BSEZ¾T EB[[MJOH NFBMT
SHAW DIGITAL PHONE
19$1995 95
$
$PNF JO UP 'JOUBTUJDMZ 'SFTI 5PEBZ 'JOUBTUJDMZ 'SFTI QSPVE UP CF TFSWJOH UIF 0LBOBHBO
††FREE! Calland today and receive your first months installation Call today receive your first two two months andand installation FREE!
CALL 1.888.472.2222 OR VISIT SHAW.CA CALL 1.888.472.2222 OR VISIT SHAW.CA
BN UP QN .POEBZ UP 4BUVSEBZ 3PTT 3PBE 8FTU ,FMPXOB # $ 1IPOF &NBJM žOUBTUJDMZGSFTI!MJWF DB
Offer subject to change without notice. Shaw products and services are subject to the Terms of Service set out at SHAW.CA as may be amended from time to time. *Customers who sign up for Shaw SOHO Digital Phone will receive the first 60 days of service at no charge and then pay Offer subject$35.95 to change withoutthree notice. Shaw products and services are subject to the of Service SHAW.CA as may amended for months to four. Beginning in month five, customers will pay $65Terms per month; pricesset are out per at line. **Customers whobesign up for from time to Shaw time.SOHO *Customers who sign upreceive for Shaw of for service at three no charge then pay Digital Phone Lite will the SOHO first 60Digital days ofPhone servicewill at noreceive chargethe andfirst then 60 paydays $19.95 months to four.and Beginning in month three five, customers will pay $35inper month; prices per line. will †Installations at residential addresses or on-net commercial locations. $35.95 for months to four. Beginning month five, customers pay $65 per month; prices are per line. **Customers who sign up for
TSX 60 / NYSE
XXX žOUBTUJDMZGSFTI DPN
Shaw SOHO Digital Phone Lite will receive the first 60 days of service at no charge and then pay $19.95 for months three to four. Beginning in month five, customers will pay $35 per month; prices per line. †Installations at residential addresses or on-net commercial locations.
TSX 60 / NYSE
WouldWould you you Would you make atherrather make rather make excuses or or excusesexcuses or sales? sales? sales? Would you
Trade Show U Business Identification U Vehicle Graphics U Site Signage U Banners U Common Signage U
Sandler Sandler Training utilizes reinforcement through Training utilizes continualcontinual reinforcement through ongoing training and individual coaching SM
Johnnot Glennon sessions only to help you learn but also to ensure your success. With over 200 training centers
ongoing training and97support, individual coaching sessions not only to 109B-worldwide 3677 Highway Northyou won’t fail‌because to provide we won’t let you.
rather make excuses or sales?
Kelowna, BC, V1X 5C3
Glennon 250-765-2047 / F: John 866-314-3410 helpP:you learn but also to ensure your success. With over 200 109B- 3677 Highway 97 North
www.glennon.sandler.com
utilizes continual reinforcement through ongoing training Kelowna, BC, V1X 5C3 and individual coaching training centers worldwide to provide support, you won’t fail... 250-765-2047 F:Sandler 866-314-3410 S Sandler Training Finding Power InP: Reinforcement (with design)/and Training are service marks of Sandler Systems, Inc. Š 2008 Sandler Systems, Inc. All rights reserved. o help you learn but also to ensure yourwww.glennon.sandler.com success. With over 200 training centers because we won’t let you. S Sandler Training Finding Power In Reinforcement (with design) de support, you won’t fail‌because we won’t let you. and Sandler Training are service marks of Sandler Systems, Inc. Š 2008 Sandler Systems, Inc. All rights reserved.
hn Glennon 7 Highway 97 North na, BC, V1X 5C3 2047 / F: 866-314-3410 ennon.sandler.com
John Glennon 109B-3677 Highway 97 North Kelowna, BC V1X 5C3 John Glennon 109B- 3677 97 North P: Highway 250-765-2047 F: 866-314-3410 Kelowna, BC, V1X 5C3 P: 250-765-2047 / F: 866-314-3410 www.glennon.sandler.com www.glennon.sandler.com
103-2307 Enterprise Way Kelowna BC V1X 7E1
250.861.1897
Sandler TrainingSM utilizes continual reinforcement through ongoing training and individual coaching
n Reinforcement (with design) and Sandler Training aresessions service marks of Sandler Systems, Inc. also Š 2008 Sandler All rights reserved. not only to help you learn but to ensure yourSystems, success.Inc. With over 200 training centers worldwide to provide support, you won’t fail‌because we won’t let you.
www.speedprosignskelowna.com
S Sandler Training Finding Power In Reinforcement (with design) and Sandler Training are service marks of Sandler Systems, Inc. Š 2008 Sandler Systems, Inc. All rights reserved.
November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
23
American contract clauses have no impact here It is a common occurrence that Canadian employment contracts contain clauses originating in the United States. Canadian contracts adapted from American precedents or downloaded off the internet will often feature this error. Canadian employers need to know that certain American contract clauses will have no impact here. One such example is the inclusion of an “employed at will� clause. 
The appearance of this type of clause is a reliable indicator that the contractual language originated in the United States. Employment which is “at will� typically is meant to give the employer the right to terminate the employment at any time and without working notice (or pay in lieu) obligations. This concept is deeply engrained in American employment law and applies in most states. It represents a significantly different legal approach to termination of employment than prevails here in Canada. Here, the concept of reasonable working notice of termination (or pay in lieu thereof) is at the heart of our employment law. This is arguably our single most significant implied term of employment.
Contracts which purport to allow the employer to dismiss the employee, without just cause, with no working notice (or pay in lieu) are unenforceable in Canada. An example of this principle being addressed by a Canadian court occurred in Newfoundland.
As a result, the use of the phrase “employed at will� does not take away any entitlement the employee may have. The Court concluded that the “at will� clause did not even come close to rebutting the presumed common law entitlement to reasonable notice of termination.
The employee, Coombs, was employed by Charles River Consultants Corp. pursuant to an employment contract containing an "at will" clause. The clause stated, “Unless otherwise expressly set forth in writing, the Associate shall be an employee at will�.
The Court awarded Coombs five and one half months of pay in lieu of notice.
Coombs’ employment was terminated only months after it had commenced. He sued for wrongful dismissal and his employer raised the “at will� clause in its defence. The employer argued that the existence of the clause allowed it to avoid complying with the common law obligation to provide reasonable working notice of termination. The Court determined that the “at will� provision was void as an impermissible attempt to contract out of providing any notice of termination. It concluded that, while the employment relationship may, effectively, be terminated at the employer’s will, the absence of reasonable working notice will entitle an employee to claim damages.
Trade-Marks Experienced Legal Counsel
Industrial Designs
There is an easy lesson here to be learned by Canadian employers: avoid contractual language which originates in other jurisdictions. And, if your existing employment contracts contain anything resembling an “at will� clause, it’s time to seek out an employment law expert to develop some appropriate Canadian language. Robert Smithson is a partner at Pushor Mitchell LLP in Kelowna practicing exclusively in the area of labour and employment law. For more information log onto www.pushormitchell.com. If you have a labour or employment question e-mail him at smithson@pushormitchell.com. This subject matter is provided for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be relied upon as legal advice.
Robert O. Levin - " 8 0 ' ' * $ &
Trade Secrets
& Technology Transfer
Copyright
Patents Wesley C. Shields
Heidi Taylor
250-869-6017
250-869-6014
B.A. (Hons), M.P.A., L.L.B.
-EMBER "# 4RIAL ,AWYERS !SSOCIATION
DPNNFSDJBM MJ U JHBU JPO
B.A., L.L.B.
„ "USINESS )SSUES „ #ONTRACTS „ %STATE ,ITIGATION „ #ONSTRUCTION „ "UILDERS´ ,IENS „ 0ROPERTY
- Commercial Litigation - Family Law - Land Development - Estate Litigation 2nd Floor, 215 Lawrence Avenue, Kelowna, BC Phone 250-762-4222 . Fax 250-762-8616 www.fhplawyers.com wshields@fhplawyers.com . htaylor@fhplawyers.com 24
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
PRACTICE RESTRICTED TO INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW L A W C O R P O R AT I O N R E G I S T E R E D P AT E N T & T R A D E -M A R K A G E N T P H O N E : (250) 418-3250 F A X : (250) 418-3251 T O L L F R E E : 1-877-943-9990 E-M AIL : gordonthomson@shaw.ca
SPCFSU!SMFWJO DPN 'BY %PMQIJO "WFOVF ,FMPXOB 7 : 4 -BOENBSL #VJMEJOH
XXX SMFWJO DPN
BIODIESEL CONTINUED FROM PAGE 22
There are also good, better and best ways to mix biodiesel with petro-diesel, which he has learned over time. “When the mandate (5% biodiesel) comes into place we have the knowledge. Some of these other guys are going to stumble as they learn.” Buse likes to looks at the near and long term business potential. While B.C. may or may not address the averaging issue there is also the federal government’s 2% mandate, due to start up in 2012. Reid estimates the 2% figure will require a billion litres of biodiesel in 2012. The $200 million plant that BioStreet is championing will produce 227 million litres a year, or little more than a quarter of the country’s needs. There are other plants in the works, but none as far along as BioStreet’s and in the short term at the very least, the biodiesel will have to be imported, which is what 4Refuel does today. Even though the CO2 emission reductions from biodiesel will only be a drop in the bucket nationally, the numbers are still large. A billion litres of petro-diesel generates 2,868,000 tonnes of CO2 gases. Reid says, “I think a litre of biodiesel could reduce CO2 emissions by 60%.”
save time & money
Biodiesel & Engine Warranties
If her calculations are correct 2012 should see a drop of 1,721,000 tonnes of CO2 from burning diesel fuel assuming the same rate of use as today. The other big hurdle for biodiesel is the fuel source. Reid says of the Vegreville plant, “We are designing a facility that will use 5% or 20% of waste vegetable oil materials.”
Most auto-manufacturers at this point will only allow a 5% blend (B5) to be used in diesel engines without voiding the warranty although Volkswagen reports it is doing tests of up to B20.
Other diesel manufacturers allow biodiesel blends of:
Ethanol faced charges of being a green wash when farmland was converted from food production to fuel. Reid had to think long and hard to make sure she wasn’t supporting something that carried its own environmental dead weight. “You need to look at diesel in the whole context.”
Caterpillar
B30
Cummins
B20
International
B5
John Deere
B5
Besides waste vegetable oil, Reid says the main sources will be the discards from agriculture, not primary food products.
Kubota
B5
New Holland
B100
That answer is probably only partly true because farmers tend to grow the most profitable crops. If food and grain prices are much lower than fuel costs, they will probably go where they can get the best returns. In any case, with traditional petroleum sources expected to decline, biodiesel’s importance is going to grow.
reduce your fuel costs
Note that there are other considerations. Older vehicles (exact years vary with the manufacturer but none are newer than 2002) using rubber and certain metals (brass, bronze, copper, lead, tin, zinc) in the fuel tanks or fuel lines may react with the biodiesel. Biodiesel can also dissolve the sediment that builds up on the bottom of old fuel tanks, which should be cleaned out prior to using biodiesel.
take control of your fuel
®
1.888.4Refuel www.4refuel.com November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
25
C a l e n da r VWIB Business Luncheon
VWIB Evening Networking
The Westbank & District
Downtown After 5 - Nov
Nov 4 - Schubert Centre,
Meet Nov 18 - Best Western
Chamber of Commerce
25 - Okanagan Heritage
Vernon.
The monthly daytime meeting of Vernon Women in Business runs from 11:30 am to 1 pm. $14 for members, $16 for nonmembers. More information by e-mail from meetings@vwib.com or go online to http://vwib.com.
Vernon Lodge.
The dinner meeting of Vernon Women in Business starts at 5:30 pm. $14 for members, $16 for non-members. More information by e-mail from meetings@vwib.com or go online to http://vwib.com.
Location to be announced, Westside - The chamber will have its annual AGM at a dinner with an address from Mayor Doug Findlater. Location and cost to be announced. Call 250-768-3378 for information.
Museum, Kelowna.
Business After Business
KWIB Networking
Lvl 1 Nov 21, 24, 26 - First
Business 2 Consumer
Nov 5 - Tara Morris
Nov 18 - Summerhill
Response Training,
Expo Trade Show - Apr 4-5
Photography, Penticton.
Pyramid Winery, Kelowna.
Kelowna.
-Peachland Recreation
The Penticton & Wine Country Chamber of Commerce’ monthly networking event from 5 to 7 pm. No cost for members, $20 for nonmembers. For information contact the Chamber at 250-492-4103.
A networking event held by Kelowna Women in Business running from 5:30 to 8:30 pm. The event, called ‘Out with Schmooze’ features business coach speaker Rhonda Victoor. $35 members, $45 nonmembers. Advance registration online is required. www.kwib.org
“Occupational First Aid Level 1 is a one day course designed to provide life saving first aid skills to workers in industry by providing training in basic first aid and CPR.” $105 per student. Call 250-762-9023 for information.
Business After 5 Nov 17 Monashees Bar & Grill,
The Vernon Chamber of Commerce’ monthly networking event from 5 to 7 pm. $5 for members, $15 for non-members. For information e-mail the Chamber at info@ vernonchamber.ca or call 250-545-0771. Vernon.
UBC Distinguished Speaker Edward Greenspon - Nov 17 Rotary Centre for the Arts, Kelowna. Edward Greenspon is the former editor of the Globe & Mail and will be talking about economic, social and cultural issues affecting Canada from abroad and within. Tickets are free but must be ordered from the Rotary Centre box office. 250-717-5304.
26
| www.businessexaminer.ca November 2009
Free Tools for Building a Website - Nov 19 Community Futures,
A three hour session beginning at 6 pm on a number of free tools that will allow you to effectively improve and market your website. Designed for people interested in building their own website. Run by Charleen Edis from Edis Computers. To register call 250-493-2566.
Penticton.
Nov 21.
Occupational First Aid
Penticton Chamber AGM Nov 25 - Penticton Golf & Country Club. The AGM begins at 11:45 am and will be followed by the election of the 2010 Board of Directors. $30 for tickets, which must be purchased in advance. 250-492-4103.
A monthly networking event put on monthly by the Downtown Kelowna Association running from 5 to 7 pm. Sponsored by Doak Shirreff but put on at the Heritage Musem. $5 entry. 250-8623515 for more information.
This is the Peachland Chamber’s second annual trade show of this nature with both indoor and outdoor venues. There will be 10 workshops of product demos to reach buyers. For more information contact Scott Wilshaw at 250-767-2455 or swilshaw@shaw.ca.
Centre.
A s k t he Pr o f e s s i o n a l s
A s k t he Pr o f e s s i o n a l s
Michael Dias
Alan W. Phillips, M.Ed.
Owner
Registered Clinical Counsellor Stress Management Specialist
This Column is not going to be a question and answer but more of an information spot. Everyone is getting ramped up to the new Windows 7, basically what Vista should have been in the first place. Winodws 7 has many key points to it making it better than Vista and the obsolete XP. Windows 7 will be more Secure than previous editions. Windows 7 also will make it easier for users to be more productive with faster boot times and faster software startup times. Does this mean Windows 7 will be flawless, no but it is a big improvement over Vista.
Q - I have been diagnosed with stressrelated Overtraining Syndrome. Stress management has been suggested. What would you recommend? A - An holistic approach. Besides adequate sleep and plenty of REST, to promote recovery I recommend learning any or a combination of the following: breathing exercises; progressive relaxation; yoga; meditation. As well, I would suggest massage therapy and if your emotional (mood) state has been impacted to seek professional counselling. Also, request a review of your nutrition and supplement intake with your health care professional. “Promoting good mental health & ensuring emotional wellness�
107 - 3640 Gosset Road, Westbank, BC 250.707.1153 www.discoverycomputers.com
250.491.4684 www.stresslessspecialist.com
TD CANADA TRUST SMALL BUSINESS ADVISOR
8F 1SPWJEF 0LBOBHBO #VTJOFTT 0XOFST 4UBGG #FOFžU 1MBOT *OTVSBODF 4FSWJDFT
Putting the Money Back in Your Pocket... ...where it belongs
We’re a licensed and bonded collection agency serving the Interior of British Columbia for the past 33 years. We specialize in the recovery of delinquent accounts. Contact us to find out how we can help - now.
Sabrina Sutherland Dilworth Shopping Centre 2339 Hwy. 97 N., Unit 700 Kelowna (250) 712-3350, ext. 256 sabrina.sutherland@td.com
1I 5' -BLFTIPSF 3PBE ,FMPXOB #$ &NBJM ECžOBODJBM!TIBXCJ[ DB XXX CDCFOFžUQMBOT DPN
3316A 30th Avenue Vernon, BC V1T 2C3 Telephone: 250-545-5351 Toll Free: 1-888-628-3328 Email: collect@bccreditbureau.com www.BCCreditBureau.com November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
27
Business Profile
Okanagan Mountain Helicopters uses the mountains around Kelowna as an ideal quick-to-reach, but sufficiently challenging training ground for novice pilots.
By Bobbi Menard | Photos contributed
Bird’s eye view of the Okanagan
helicopter industry
The mountains of the Okanagan Valley not only frame the scene, but are viable business opportunities for the local helicopter industry, both for pilot training schools and aerial service. Location and a solid history mean that two Kelowna companies struggling with the recession have good reason to believe it will not be fatal. Okanagan Mountain Helicopters has a staff of four and operates three helicopters, as a pilot training school and charter service, based out of the Kelowna Airport since 2000. Two groups of six students go through the training course in the fall and spring. Students pay up to $60,000 for tuition and flight time, a bargain when compared to the cost of a four year university degree says operations manager Johannes Vates. The school has made a conscious decision to focus on quality and not quantity and being located in Kelowna is a strong component of that decision. The mountains are only moments away, when compared to many other locations for helicopter pilot schools. That means students do not waste valuable time in the air travelling to training locations. “With the hills and mountains, they are a great training tool. We focus on operational flying and preparing students for the industry that is out there,” explains Vates. Forestry, oil and gas, remote utility construction and maintenance have the money and demand for helicopter pilots. Graduates from Okanagan Mountain are prepared for the fact that 80 to 90% of all students will find their first job in a very remote
location, usually in Canada’s North. First jobs are generally found on a contract basis and it can take time to accumulate hours. The industry is beginning to see the demographic grey wave advancing as experienced pilots enter retirement. “There is definitely a lack of medium time pilots out there,” says Vates. “The posted minimum hours needed for jobs have come down in many advertisements for positions.”
landscape since 1995, and works to provide safe and efficient helicopter transport services to the public and industry. The primary focus for the Kelowna staff is operations, says Systems Safety and Company Check Pilot for Skyline, Rob Gallagher. “All of our flight operations, maintenance and logistics as well as administration are based in Kelowna.”
The need for practical experience is a reflection of the temperament requirements for the job. People who fly helicopters shoulder a tremendous amount of responsibility and decision making capacity. Okanagan Mountain often counsels students right out of high school to wait a few years before taking the training. About 10% of students are female.
Often the primary call to Skyline is for fire suppression and Hydro infrastructure work in the Okanagan region. The company also operates bases in Terrace (heli-skiing) and in Edson (fire suppression). “We move aircraft to meet the requests of our customers wherever they may need our services.”
Vates says Okanagan Mountain identified a shift among employers as the workforce demographics changed. “Employers have recognized they have to get the young group going. They tried hiring foreign workers, but when the foreign visas ran out you still had to train younger pilots.”
Skyline remains in the Okanagan due to steady demand for its services and a large pool of qualified labour. “When we cannot meet our needs to fulfill positions locally, being located in the Okanagan is another positive attribute to attract quality people.”
Okanagan Mountain draws students primarily from B.C. and Alberta. While the recession has been felt the lure of a job that can make between $50,000 and $80,000 per year after an intense five month training program keeps qualified applicants coming to Kelowna.
Gallagher admits Skyline is “not immune” to the current economic climate. The company is re-evaluating its business plan and strategies to “ensure survivability.” In the Okanagan, Skyline sees potential in aerial construction, Hydro infrastructure maintenance and the need for an air ambulance service.
Eventually some of Okanagan Mountain’s young pilots may find their way back to Kelowna for work. Skyline Helicopter has been a part of the local
It is not just the mountains that create opportunity for Skyline; the industrial base and infrastructure all play a role. says Gallagher, “The Okanagan provides all kinds of support to meet our needs as we continue to grow into the future.”
Skyline Helicopters is a full service company doing everything from tourist winter trips (pictured here) to industrial maintenance.
November 2009 Okanagan Business Examiner
|
29
Collaboration is a process of participation through which people, groups and organizations work together to achieve desired results. In an effort to help each other expand their capacities to enhance the local business community the Kelowna Chamber of Commerce, Okanagan Science Specialthe Advertising Feature & InTechnology (OSTEC) and Central Okanagan Economic Development Commission an effort to enhanceCouncil the local business community the are Centralcollaborating Okanagan Economic to host a series of six seminars and workshops. (COEDC)
Local Organizations Offer for local businesses to gain access to expert knowledge on how Resources toinBusiness Community to maximize business opportunities and revenues the current economic climate. The ‘Thrive, Development Commission, Kelowna Chamber of Commerce and Okanagan Science & Technology The seminar series was created Council and the offer a variety of resources.
The Survive’ Central Okanagan Economic Development Not seminar series, which is being sponsored by the Business Development Bank of Commission (COEDC) works in partnership to Canada, will offer guidance to help ensure businesses are fit for future growth. facilitate a healthy, dynamic and sustainable community economy by supporting existing
“Now is aandgreat time for new businesses encouraging appropriate business investment. of theaudit businesses to The dothree anmainstays internal COEDC are Business Retention & Enhancement, and plan for their future growth,” Investment Attraction and Economic Development says Robert Fine, Manager of the Facilitation. Economic Development The COEDC is a clearing house of information Commission for the Central for business and creates economic profiles Okanagan. “Our outlining vital demographicregion information on the experienced digitEfforts growth communities of the double Central Okanagan. to enhance the regions businesses2008 are donewhere through from 2004 through one-on-one site visits and “Business the Park”with local businesses were infaced seminars that address current needs. Investment challenges ofinclude keeping with the attraction activities promotingup our region demand. morelevel than ever on a national Now and international and working to support the growth and development of key businesses should plan and industry sectors through collaboration with implement systems and regional, provincial and federal organizations. programs to help sustain their For more information visit the website at www. company.” investkelowna.com The Mission of the Kelowna Chamber of Seminar and workshops will be Commerce is to foster a positive business held on the first Tuesday environment by providing members with monthly starting October andof Value. will The cover Leadership,in Advocacy and Services Kelowna Chamber is an advocate for its members such timely topics as accessing through lobbying municipal, provincial and federal capital, business planning, cash governments. Because a united voice has far more flow management, marketing and impact than a single one, the Chamber is in a networking strategies. position to influence outcomes. The Chamber also educates the community about
“Our members have business issues, and exposes the requested public to our that webusiness offerenvironment. learning thriving The Chamber also works to promote its relevant members through opportunities toevents their like the Business After Hours held monthly every needs, and we feel that this third Thursday from 5pm to 7pm as well as series do just that,” said through will their website and online directory. For Weldon LeBlanc, CEO of visit thethe more information on membership benefits website at www.kelownachamber.org. Kelowna Chamber of Commerce.
THRIVE NOT SURVIVE SEMINAR SERIES Prepare your business for a growing economy
With recent economic unrest, it is essential that business owners know how to keep their business on track for success. The choices that businesses make now will determine how they will fare in the growing economy, so make the right choice and join us for the first Tuesday of every month from October 2009 – March 2010.
October 6, 2009
Accessing Capital
November 3, 2009
Business Plan Workshop
December 1, 2009
Cash Flow Management
January 5, 2010
Small Business Law
February 2, 2010
Marketing Your Business
March 2, 2010
Pitch Your Business
The Okanagan Science & Technology Council
The Executive Director of (OSTEC) is a membership driven organization. OSTEC fosters an environment that supports said OSTEC, Douglas MacLeod science andexcited technology initiatives acting as a “We are to bebyworking representative and advocate for the interests of with the Kelowna Chamber and members and the business community as a whole. the Commission on hosting this OSTEC's Mission Statement is to lead the will seminar series. Attendees development of thriving technology-driven sectors benefit greatly from the expertise in the Okanagan. They strive to be a conduit that of brings the people top together, notchpartnering speaker list.” with industry, agencies and government to promote the science and technology industries in our region. For more information on membership benefits visit the website at www.ostec.ca.
.
Location: Coast Capri Hotel, Kelowna BC Time: 2:00 pm to 4:30 pm Registration and more information: www.ostec.ca/events.asp Package Price for 6 seminars: $100.00 (SAVINGS OF $50.00! Get yours NOW, limited packages available) Individual Seminars: $25.00 each
series sponsored by:
refreshments sponsored by:
BENSON SALLOUM WATTS LLP L
A
W Y E R S
Rea l Estat e Law | Busi ness Law | Li t igation | I nj u ry Law | Abo r i g i nal Law
E X P E R I E N C E
I S
T H E
D I F F E R E N C E
200-1455 Ellis Street Kelowna, BC V1Y 2A3 Ph: 250.861.5678 Fax: 250.861.5642 270 Highway 33 West Kelowna, BC V1X 1X7 Ph: 250.491.0206 Fax: 250.491.0266 Estates Square - 102A 1979 Old Okanagan Hwy. Westbank, BC V4T 3A4 Ph: 250.769.4949 Fax: 250.769.7070
www.bensonsalloumwatts.com
Act Fast - Now Leasing Call Ed Lugossy Licenced Commercial Real Estate Agent 250.870.2801
NC Derriksan & Son Enterprises www.ncderriksanandsonenterprises.com