Our Favorite Wings
Lightly breaded and seasoned perfectly. Call your sauce on the side. Ranch, Creamy Garlic, Buffalo (hot or mild), BBQ, Hot BBQ, Blue Cheese. Best wings we ever tasted. 10 - 8.99 20 - 13.99
Chicken Fingers
White breast strips breaded with special seasonings.
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
6.99
STUART‟S COMBO PLATTER Pick three from basket items below.
9.99
Onion Rings Basket
2.99
Fried Cauliflower Parmesan Basket
BBQ Baby Back Rib Tips Slow roasted and smoked with our own sauce
bacon, green onions and sour cream.
7.99
Jumbo Garlic Toast
You’ll get addicted to this wonderful home made treat.
Potato Boats Skins filled with cheeses,
9.99 We prepare
A basket of sweet onion rings lightly battered and crunchy.
Hand breaded and coated with a touch of parmesan cheese and served with our zesty southwest sauce.
9.99
Fried Cheese Curds Wonderful fresh white cheddar cheese nuggets hand breaded and fried crunchy.
6.99
Best Fried Pickles “Ever” Basket Dill chips that we fry in our secret batter.
6.99
Stuart‟s Soup of the Day
Always home made by our chefs. Mmm!
Cup 2.99
Bowl 4.99
Bits of USDA choice steak and Morel (sponge) mushrooms nestled in flavorful, rich and creamy soup. Cup 2.99
Bowl 4.99
Stuart‟s Steak and Mushroom Chowder French Onion Soup
Made fresh right here without the help of anyone French. Our special thanks to the Amish for their wonderful croutons. Cup 2.99
Bowl 4.99
(*with entrees add .99) *Wedge Salad “House Specialty”
Featuring an iceberg lettuce wedge, diced vine ripe tomatoes, the dressings and toppings are listed below for each signature salad. 4.99
Choose from the following: Blue Cheese: Covered with blue cheese dressing & crumbles with chopped green onions Thousand Island: Covered with this famous dressing, chopped black olives and croutons The Rancher: Covered with buttermilk ranch dressing and chopped apple wood bacon Blue-Vinaigrette: Covered with vinaigrette dressing and real blue cheese crumbles *Caesar Salad Heart of Romaine with parmesan cheese, Croutons blended with our own Caesar dressing.
4.99
*Spring Mix Salad Spring blend of lettuces, vine ripened red tomato, select veggies and real Amish croutons.
4.99
Cole Slaw
The kind your grandma made with great sweet and sour creamy blend. This is Aunt Pearl’s recipe.
2.99
Grilled Caesar Salad
Half of a Romaine heart drizzled with virgin olive oil and herbs & Char-broiled before joining with our delicious cheeses, dressing and croutons. 7.99
2.99
Baked Potato butter, sour cream & chives Fresh Broccoli Florets herb butter Loaded Potato cheese and bacon add .99 Fresh Green Beans bacon and onion Garlic Mashed Potatoes dab of butter, Creamed Corn famous recipe . . . try it Sweet Baked Potato cinnamon and sugar Rice pilaf healthy long grain rice mix Jumbo Fresh Asparagus huge spears char-grilled and covered with our signature Caesar dressing . . these are really good!
6.99
Fried Mushroom Basket Batter dipped, crunchy and mouth watering.
huge shrimp with zesty sauces.
5.99
5.99
(2.99 sub for meal side)
Please call us for all your party or catering needs 317-758-0406
5.99
All of the entrees and steaks on this page come with our Amish toast and your choice of two side items from our sides or salads. Cup of soup or a salad .99 extra.
Smoked Prime Rib of Beef
We take the very best USDA Choice certified angus beef rib and smoke it long and slow over real Washington state apple wood chips. The delicate flavors of the apple wood smoke and super tender beef is soon to be famous! Half pound cut 16.99
“Catfish Heaven”
Three-quarter pound cut 19.99
Full one pound cut 25.99
We will take you there! We serve only USA farm raised catfish.
Filets
Our catfish filets are hand breaded with our specially seasoned corn meal mix and deep fried to golden brown. This recipe has satisfied catfish fans for years! One filet 12.99 Two filets 15.99 Three filets 17.99
Whole
This is the way many catfish eaters love their fish, on the bones. We still hand bread them with our secret seasoned corn meal mix too. The very best!! One Catfish 14.99 Two Catfish 16.99
Baby Back Ribs
We smoke these pork ribs all day long with apple wood to create a taste like no other ribs around. The tender meat falls off the bone. Served with our BBQ sauce Full pound 15.99 Two pounds 21.99
Pork Filet Mignon Our own house favorite, seasoned and bacon wrapped.
Half pound 13.99
Chicken Breast
These are from genuine Amish raised chickens with no additives, etc. Enjoy the great taste of chicken again, char-broiled or available with Cajun, Caribbean or Honey BBQ encrusted rub. Half pound 12.99
Jumbo Shrimp
We serve them either hand breaded and fried, served with our own cocktail sauce or have them char-broiled with our delicate garlic and herb butter marinade. Enjoy them either way! Half pound 19.99
Jumbo Scallops
The filet mignon of the ocean. These huge delicacies are wrapped in apple wood bacon, basted and flame-broiled to perfection. 19.99
Portabella Steak
We season, baste and char-broil these giant mushrooms and serve as a nice steak for those who do not wish to have meat for dinner. 13.99
All of our beef steaks are cut fresh from USDA Choice Certified Angus Beef. (Add our soon to be famous creamy morel mushroom sauce for only .99 extra!)
Delmonico
Stuart’s Favorite steak is a big, super tender cut from the flavorful large end of the beef rib. Just right for the big steak eater! Full pound 25.99
Filet Mignon
Laura’s choice is the best cut from the center of the beef tenderloin. We wrap this beauty in apple wood smoked bacon too. 1/3 lb 19.99 1/2 lb 25.99
The Rib Eye
We’ve got three sizes to fit your appetite. All of them are cooked just as you order them over our flame broilers. Tender and delicious every time! Half pound 15.99 Three-quarter pound 19.99 Full pound 24.99
Top Sirloin
Here is the flavor king of beef and we do it four different ways and in three sizes. You can have yours flame broiled naturally or encrusted with your choice of: Cajun, Caribbean or Honey BBQ seasoned rubs. Third pound 13.99 Three-quarter pound 18.99
Chopped Steak
A delicious Angus offering from our flame broiler, bacon wrapped or with our creamy morel mushroom sauce. Three-quarter pound 12.99
Rare Medium Rare Medium Medium Well Well Done
125 degrees 135 degrees 145 degrees 155 degrees 165 degrees
Very red, cool center Red, warm center Pink, hot center Hint of pink, hot center No pink, hot center
Please call us for all your party or catering needs 317-758-0406
Served with your choice of one side below
Stuart's Prime Rib Sandwich A thick and juicy slice of smoked prime rib charbroiled and served on a fresh roll with our own light horseradish sauce. 9.99
French Dip Prime Rib Sandwich Our house specialty prime rib is covered with a flavorful au jus and served on homemade roll. 9.99
Philly Style Prime Rib Sandwich A mouth watering combination of our smoked prime rib, sautéed onions and peppers with provolone cheese.
9.99
Sheridan's Famous Jumbo Tenderloin This classic sandwich is the real thing and we are making it even better with more meat than ever.
8.99
Sheridan's Famous Junior Tenderloin This yummy sandwich is a third of a pound of center cut pork loin. Grilled or breaded.
7.99
Steakhouse Burger A half pound of delicious char-broiled ground beef served on a fresh made roll with choice of toppings to please any taste.
6.99
Blackhawk Burger A full pound of our tasty char-broiled burger that is nestled between the huge fresh made bun our tenderloin is famous for.
9.99
Catfish Po-Boy Sandwich Our nearly famous breaded catfish filet is fried to perfection and served on a fresh baked roll. Gonna love this one!
8.99
U-Call-It Chicken Sandwich How about we name it after you? We will grill, char-broil, or deep fry your half pound chicken breast. We can also rub it with Cajun, Caribbean or Honey BBQ rubs. We will even drop it into our delicious buffalo wing sauce.
7.99
Grilled Cheese Everybody’s favorite is made on our jumbo thick bread.
5.99
Add to any sandwich:
cheese
.99 bacon 1.49
Cottage Cheese Onion Rings Potato Salad
ala cart 2.99
French Fries Kettle Chips Slaw Spring Mix Salad (add .99)
free refills
1.99
Coke Classic Diet Coke Sprite Mellow Yellow Mr. Pibb Green Tea Lemonade Iced Tea Milk Coffee Decaf Coffee
Domestic Beers Budweiser Bud Light Coors Light Mich Ultra MGD Miller Lite Premium Beers Amstel Light Blue Moon Corona Fat Tire Heineken Sam Adams Draft Beers Coors Light Blue Moon Sam Adams Lager Killian's Red Wines A wide selection of wines available, please ask your server for a wine list. Spirits House Brands 3.99 Call Brands 4.99 Premium Brands 5.99 Cordials
2.99 3.99 varies 4.99
Our 'House' drink is a perfectly crafted Premium Gold Margarita made with top shelf liquors and mixes. It is aged to reach a smooth and rich flavor on the rocks, frozen or straight up.
Only 5.99 “Please drink alcoholic beverages responsibly.”
Please call us for all your party or catering needs 317-758-0406
BLACK PLATE SPECIALS Sunday through Thursday evenings
ONLY 10.99 EACH (Complete meals with 2 sides & bread) Boneless Pork Chop
Char-Grilled Meat Loaf
A half pound of center cut pork loin grilled to taste. Top it off with our bbq sauce if you desire.
Just like mom made only better with the slight crunch off our charcoal grill. Add the home made brown gravy on it!
Italian Chicken - 3 to choose from A half pound of boneless chicken breast lightly breaded and sautéed Picatta style
Marsala style
Parmesan style
White wine, lemon, capers
Red wine with mushrooms
marinara sauce covered with fresh parmesan
Fish of the Day
Mushroom Shopped Steak
Every day is a great day for fish with our talented chef and his staff preparing it. Enjoy it grilled or fried to perfection.
A classic comfort food dish. A half pound of char-broiled Certified Angus ground chuck prepared to your liking with our wonderful creamy morel mushroom sauce on top.
BLACK PLATE SIDES Onion Rings French Fries Creamed Corn Broccoli
Substitutions: Baked Potato
Garlic Mashed Potatoes Kettle Chips Green Beans Wild Rice Potato Salad Cottage Cheese Slaw
Baked Sweet Potato Wedge Salad Spring Mix Salad Jumbo Char-Grilled Asparagus extra 2.99
Cup of Soup
extra .99
Our Story Stuart’s Steak House is creating “destination dining” in the far Northwest corner of Hamilton County in Sheridan, Indiana. We offer the finest in casual family dining with a menu that includes the finest and freshest ingredients. Our beef is all USDA Choice and Certified Angus with no expense spared for quality cuts. Our breads are all fresh baked for us in an Indiana Amish bakery and what chicken we have on our menu is from the Amish farms in Northern Indiana too. We have morel (sponge) mushrooms in our signature steak and mushroom chowder and in our wonderful mushroom sauce for drizzling over our meat offerings. “The Bull” is our signature cocktail and it is a splendid top shelf, gold margarita that has been aged to perfection. We have wines by the glass and bottle as well as beer and all popular spirits to add to your dining enjoyment. Even our logo is very special as the bull in the center was once at the center of Taurus Foods, Inc. from Indianapolis. This fine meat company had served the best steak houses and country clubs in Central Indiana for over 20 years. The company once employed six young Sheridan residents and they helped it grow to a major company in the food service industry. Our dear friend from Sheridan, Steve Hadley (1955 - 2004) worked his way up the ranks to vice president of sales. Our entire team is truly excited to bring great food and flair to our community and we strive to make your visit very special.. We also have carry out available. We’re open to serve you daily from 11am to 10 pm. Kitchen closes half hour prior to closing time
Please call us for all your party or catering needs 317-758-0406