짜,..~,d!~!#Y'
~I
..,J~~~')fj ~~
~e.;a
~,&WI
~~~I
~l
.b~YJ
~~"J,)~I
(lb;..b
e~ )
~16iiit-'~
.w )
(~"..J~I ~I.l.......c}
f':!~J
~IJ~j.t~1 ~
y!-.J'..A ~I
~WI
¥I.J~\.S ~\.S
~
~~~I
~l
~\j'l
F-J\4~1~1~
J:!SJJ
~}i\~1
r''f. •
• £ J!~\ - ~, V'f..
~I ...
u4-ca ~
'0 .J... WI.l.\c.
'f. '\ .
o.a••.•• 1+i~1
(~J-l
(~
•.,])'I~)
~I
~~'J
·~~~I,J~,j.A~1 ~WI '&o3.jlJa 4431~IJ! ) tJMSj./J,J"Jlll~ ~~~I ~~'JI ~I (' ~• • t J:.;:I ~,J"JI lhlb • :.~ \",.A.JlhA
~.
~• • t / ~• ~, : ~I
"':-lu.s.ll ~i 031' b..l f':I.1ij,J ~1j4 ,J ':yWI ~,
.
}hll
~,·h JI ,JIJ.;! tlJ:),1 ~,J
: ~) y'.:jSj\ \~ L5~i ~\~~\~\jยง
~!J~I~I~~~~
~~t~~~
IT"
~1~~J~~I~j~I~~~J~J~~I~~
.ki~t
,"
't
.
~ .~
I _,
r.
""\l.
l-_ 0 t" -
'~
t ~ \,~.'c"r:\
t""
). ~~
, ' J:.." ~I
.r,
\
t
t.
. ~ ~ ~ f> '= .',. ,P \..:
_" \.
~
~
I
t ~.~r ~
v
,: '"~~., ''to'> \.~.
.\(_
to! ~
~.~
If..... \~ ~ 'to.
r
~,.
~
\;'
-
~;. ~
,
tIt,'
1~
~ .
"".
"fl \.=~ .
'\\\
h
~_ "\
__
,~'"
\:' ~
.r- ..t
r- ~ .t
't
> ~
f' ~ ~\:
t. \:. ~
)0
'"
",
to
~
'-,
r
t.
> .,'_..., ,f'
",
t ~
•
0\
r,~'
~ ••.. -
f'
\
~
t'
It
I
~
~., \:: ~..~.t
I\.~
t
'i l
~
t:
to '"
'" \
f~
'"
\p
1,'
t".-
t'"
t
~
C
f'
f
e._.
t '.. \"
~
\.
~. I"
('.-r ".
~
••
,~c I
\.
-
'-
Eo ~
•.
·t·f. \. f. \
"'.
~
&:-
~
_
'" <;
ty
-t,
'-
,f
~
,\t
(,
t
'~.~,
"£
-
t
-
\.
'\'
~ t
~
-
t\
.[
•
r. ·
_
:t
:'L ~
(. _. ..
~.,('
l '-,f') ~'b ~ (. 1\·\. ,\. ,to '- ,'" '1" ,s- 't. t ~, ~~
~
";\. l.s '"
C'
r ....~ f ('
(, ~, .~. c· .~. - "
h
(L
et
n.
:=
-I ~ 'i,..... -. ~\ t,\. t:1 c:
I~
'f- .'- ,
t'
t.' ~,'"
l'l l.t\ ..~.
.,"
(. t. ~ :t.
~
.
1.
~
••
.~
'f. ~ ). ~ .~,f 'f \, J
:.
~
~
€t t' { .~ ~'t:: '"h
.•
;,.-
~ It '"
f
•.• t
tv;,.)
-
'"
l
t
.~
~~'f ;
t'"
I~
t'
_.. ~ "
.\to
E' ~
r ;; c:
f"
-
t: r.I\,.. It't
\. r., i"\'''' . C\ l. J. • " " , r ~ ~ t1 , . ". ~ "" ~. , ~ I ~
1
.~t f- ~ '[ ..r,-{- .;.~ ;. \,. \.e
· \. ~, .- I[
r
«\
< k:~
c,'" ~. .•. " to j\ ~. 1 f' \) ~"~.' ~~~ ,';'~.' \,'~~\.... ~ ~r1· r·(~\~ ~\~tf, j.t. c,r. l::~. \: , ,. ''i '" . l ~'t ~ t .~ -... • c: . > .." . '<F. It; '\ e,r r~.'- -cJ - • 1,-- '~c: ~t~ ,t: ,c' .g ~t.~ '"' ,'"'i '.~ fl.... ,.... t.~ \'. I!.I,~ }~.~;\-C{ I '\ '" ,- -- . < ,., t. 1"" ~'... \ r ,\", -.t .~ ~ t. t ,~l c. <:. \ !~. :.t! ~ ~ .~ : ~ .- '- t' ~ - t: ~r,t' (. ~ .(,. ~ ,'I> 1:: -.. .~, If ~ .l ~ .- ,E' · '-" ·c\ .t t " -\ \ .••• '" .- 1. .~ ~ \.": \ ,~.~ C\\ \.£\.
W.'
~~
~ t;- .~
x
~\~i
.
~
~ ~ ~~
-[
.
~
.,
\~
,;.
uk wyri'X ~I
~
11\ ~ ~ y.,1 01 ~)'I
.ill! .lJ:!C. . i:u.JIJ ~I··.A"II ~..J-G~~ ~ I 0~lJ ~J~
~
~
J,..,y
~w ~u
~
~
o~ ~~J
, ~\:j11o~~ ~411~I~
~~~ ~I
~j;.J'11
~I .J~\J ~L ..
I .J\:i:;,.\j,
I"S"
~I
~IJI
.-;',iiil('.~_-:II ~ ~.
u::-
.::.IL~WI •
<\J!J~ ~J' .j ~ IS"
~6.J.JJ I
I"S"
. ~~~ ($~J cjiiA ~JJ
($)
~I
. 1(' . j
~
~
'-;-1:lI.~
~ ~~J
0~ ue t\j.ill($~ t.l.l.ll· .l.l~1 , .....:.. 11 .(JA~J~
0A y.)!1 01 u-i~ ~I~
0'1J .:.
.u~l o~ ($~I . 0:!yWIJ
' ~'uUJ ~
~J
'-l)\
~l
-~...rJI 0 jl.fill
0JJ;J,,'4:JI ~~\ ~~I .~
~..
~
~.J'"'l)1 U'l~\.til ~.illllul
~41\~I~IJ
A.J~'XoJWJ' ~6.J.J ~J'
~'1
J ~
Ub.. . jJ . (.. - ,ij~"" J\ \."1r"~l...ul ,~ ,..... L ..- '-.r •.• 4.5"------;i '-F"- ~
0.).11 J 0:!yWl 0.).1\ U'l~\.til
~~'1IJ'
.;-
U'lJ:!) ~.l;J ($~
~~ , ~\:j11o~~ '-:U'XI ~I
~j;.J'11
~
~I \. ··\.N A.J.li~ "tt"'.
'.
($~I .&1"pI
.&1~lic 0~ , o_~.:;.\tI ("4'11 ~l WU w\..Q..b~1 y~
I..I.oO:.WI -r-
~.J~)'I ~I)I
~
~lic ~
~I
.ullul "pIJ
0A ~) ._:~ .ill,
.:.
. ~~
·..1 '11~I ~ u;-'J
01 ~J ' ~ .u1~H ~~J ' ~I \1\ t~..J-G 4.Ju\:i.JL ...1 ,~U .J.'XIJ c..-.-·,IL . 1S"'".fio ~I' 1J Y" J . . ~1...bi!11\ ~J ~• I.. . jj -:114...A,·11 IY'"'" .. IL. ti~'XL • I"S"I ~ '"e":' ~ IS"'" '"&'" ~ J
0A ~ ~~
~I~
~\.h;.'11y~J'
0\SJ . JAWI ($~ ,10,
,!I\ 11\0A
u~
6\• Y'"'" ..11 w\......h. Uj\S J . ~'... -: .11 ~.r ~ .b.)\jl •
. JAI ' •. -';4 tlAjlJ OJ:$. ~
~\p. f":!~..J ' 1IffJisU ~\J!
'-:U''XI ~~ ($.J:!411 ~J ~
4.J .
~ ~I..;:l
I·L wI .JWI . . . ~
.~
~ ~
~
01.p.'11 ~
wi
~I
JLt.1
..~,-~
• l»
•••••••
.
( , ..,
~
)
.lA.wi (.~ - .... All
I .~\ ~I
(f.J
~
y'}ll W.>-A'iJ ..>-AY!"J~
~ ( '\ : , ..H) ~I (.SiJ\. ( ". :
J-:..~ ( ~
~
.J.;lJI, (
N\
0 ~,
) ~~ ••.
t : t J-c ~
r0
A
~
~\
A,
.u)'1 ~J.
o~
~\
AJ"'J "'AI\,ljLb..l~ U~)'I
u
W.JA'i J..,SjJ i LAS.. ~I~\ ~J'
~)YJJ~I
~\
~
~~
I~fi
u-e
~u:'\j~ ~~'}ll r~J.
~
~
~\..w\
. ~\
~~I-,
~\
~I
w~'i
r~J
.ill. 0-:)'1~
~~I
~J y~
y\.:jSj1~ ~
~ ~
w~1
(.S~
'~ ~I
A~
.
_"'I.:.
~
~\
W.JA'iJ
~I
~\
~J'
U'"J.ll1\6)t:JI )YJJi ty:!~1
. 1'1\ r ~I w\.!~I·
~~iU~ \~
IJillJ,
WJ-A'i
~I
~i
~I
~~ ~ U:!~
LJ-AJ
WJ-A'i IJpi
~I
~\
USl..JIU'".illl CJ)~ ~~ Wtik~I.;-b:i..1
\.-:.Q ,U"l"'(t-'...r
W.JA'1
u-! ~WI .&1 ~J
~~.J'}l\
y~4.u:ib~
~J'
tl~\
y~1
U'"~)
t':!.,.bJ U~ ~.J'}l\ JJb W . U~)'\ ~ ~\:i.ll ~ J ~\
W..JA'i.l....Quy..l.JI rAft
JJI .l.i,UJ~ ~I
J.S~ u'" J !" AllU~)'I
):uJI \~ rtA1J. ~I
~,~
~
U'"~) I~
~
A..J · ••·.11
~I y).!
~~,
~w
~ ~4
r..l()-Aj U~ .wIJ .. r~1 ()-A~..? 0-:)'1ul w.e.~JJ
~
~I
~
~
~ .J~~I ~I
J ' U'"Ji.JIy\.:jSj1~ ~
. ~ ~)I
~
I...~ -~. -II
~
~J ~
..
~\jLJ-A~\
"A
U:!~\~\~I
~J
~I
~\
u~. ~.w~fi
O~
r. : , · ..H)
.(
~
.~
.
0-:J
-:'1'1 J ~ 'A'i J ~..).l.A I 'A I '1J ~\
.JI.S.iJ. J.us u'J II,JI u'...a;)'1 ~ ~JljJl ~.JA (.S~I
~)I.&I
b..•.. l~ UL....ajJ\ ~J--
()-A
\1 • U~
..J-" ~
'A : , ~)
J.SJI~G. ~
w.u ~\
\.:j~
,.
.•.. r.s~ U'" ~~\ L:u\....ul
~
r : , ..H)
o~IJ
. 6 .;ii bW\ -u ~I ,J ,~\.S
A
U (.S:WI(
.,J ) ~I.J~I
: ,
~I
-' rlWI ~liS JS U~
~I ., 0 •
r, A
0~
J '
r
r~ ~
r"
0
U'".l.iJI w~ (.Sill
rw:' C::U\:iJ\
').J'"'l)1 (,j'l~\.ijIIJ'l:!.ill1 ~u
4-9IJ 6.~
. 1"3; !t!oll u~
yc J
'il w~\
~"';..J
~,
~J. ~I
~~.;)
U'-:';I U~tj \~JJ'
IJ-"l~J' ~"';..J'i\
.)c IJ~..JLoS. (,j'l~1 yt&.ll ~ ~
f~
\.AJ~J
wU; ~ I~ JS ~ J . ~I
~
~I
W.JA'i tj-;~
A.J:.~ w~1
~.<~.~~,
W
~J. J
~
U~~
wy'il I)Jli.::lJ
I~ UA ..,; (5'.II 0 ~ ~
~L.al~\
u~"';..J'i1
I. ~. ,o.lJjc..))W. j ~"'e-""'J ~ .1..5""~
,.~.
.)~I
wy'il ~
.u~
~b ~
W.JA'i lJ-C ~lo:!';l ~Li:JI
"';..J'il fll (>..H-:! ~~
~~iJ
~~ .) IJ-O~I J
u~"';..J'i1 ~~I ~\
•
~I
UJ?i
~
.u.e.~J
'i\ LtiJ ~.
~ ~"';..J
~
~
IJ-O~IJ.
.... ':.. 11~~'iI~.lJ
~I
.J ..H-:!~ (>
~
,.
.~I~IW.JAY ~\~ ~.
..
(,j'l.l.iJI.
~ ''\1\'\ / i / 'V ~I
A_ All c:--:-
..J...>-9~. ~.
~.)
6J\.:jj\
w4 ~ wI y..c. 'il ~~ J . U)y") , ~ "k.~\ . IJ~
.
~ .l.J\ lH-l . ~\.A~"'T:"' . L:. :i •..•.\J-O~ .J
'i'U.1 ~
II' 0
~
~ ~I••••
~)IJ.
,. . i ~~
C..)JJl1..5""
"
~
W 0~~..J'i1
J (>..H-:! ~~
~...1- ~\,
.)c wI ~6...0 ~I J '
\.+is
J
~
:i.i1\~1 ~\.:jj\
.... \ .1< 0'1· 'ii-"""J ..J ~
~u~
~4J\ ~I~
.J¥:- ~I
. [~~\J ~\
o~~
o~~
~~;..J'il
u-.o~
..J'-:Wcl]
~WI..u.JI (,j'l
'-ll:i..S.l1 •
y~ Ji.o~.J:: r+i~~YJ ~41\~\~
..J~I LoS
<II :i...l:,.. ..... ~ ~...1''11 • ~. -.i wYli.o ..)-'o'lJJ
~~I ~I wy'il ~
~J.
~\
~\
W.JA)\J
' ... ': •. 11 J (> .Jt:l ~,.-*'"" r..sI.~
"'" ~
L+tJ! ~I
~~,)'JI
~,-I ~I
u~I~':i1
~
u\':'J1c~~!
~JiJI
: ~'JI ~~I ~ . ~I
,.~'JI
~WI JJJ,)J.
~I,).lll
U~J
ll..=r.~ ~JiJI
J:SJUI~ uJ4-11 I~ ~J ~I
0C ~WI
. \.h...,; (j'l:!~1~I
• ~~,)'JI
~\~JU~"';..J'i\ ~ ~I
~!
~I
:.'1) W.JA 'i :
4.i~
.L ~\..J I. ..•• . (..)'l:!~, ~l.,?~U~~.J
'il ~~l
~
-;\\w~·..
~\ ~.lNI ~. '" . \.:jJ\:j
~
. I.b.~ -: 6A JS ~b.,J~,J ..»-will ~'.)J.3\ 1)\ • c.r..J"'l
~\
.....
.~ W ...tJ -J.. . ~~
~
~l
liil (..)'l:!~\
(j'l~
~l
."'l... l.S~(..)'l:!
(j'l~
ul,J\1i Ji,J
Jj;loAl
~I (..)'l:!~l
~l ~~~.(..)'l:! ...<1\ - ·I.l.l ~\ .. ~I (j'l~.J~y:.. .. , (..)'l:!~I
.. 'WI • l.S y.;.J
.. (j'l.Ja.J~y:..
. l.S.J~
'I\ uJ..>f.
. r-il\ ~~
, (..)'l:! ~l (..)'l:!~l
I.b.~ (..)'l:!~\
• (j'lJ iJb.
,,;..;1 (..)'l:!~\
~
,J~t~I•• 4-11 a:.waLaJIfOIWi1;;' OJ ~~~J~I ~
~j
"all
:1 j "kll
:~~
lYJ:)
~w ("
~ (.i~
"'' 0
("tc AJiJ; ~ ~ 4J'JII,J\ ~I ~.J UJlo;loII,9.J..,.bI.J:1Aill ...)AI ~.J. ~I A.S~ LJ.o~.J ' ~.,1~\ CY)..lC')-Gwtss . ~~ . ~ U~ 1 . . ~ 04 . .J lY J:.J
.<'.". (.S""~.I\~L:JI lYJ:.J 1 wl~ .t!-=ill~ ..T"...;---' u,.J J-~ --II ~路.C ..~, '11 WAIA'i lY~\.til (J'l:!~1 JA.J lY J:.J'i ~ .Jt:iJ1 ~I ~).J ' ~~'i\ w~tss ~ ~ ~t lY.J:H~J: ~I.J ' lY.J.J~I ~411 ~\ lYJ:) Jj~.J -=ill~.J . u-l.J'Wl)\ ~t ~ ~I ~~il~. <;.,ill ~J:.J'i1 ~h.J (":1~\lYJ:) ~.l...o ~~.# . ~J:.J'i1 \# U:l~\
ue
~I ~I wJA'i ue ~ tsl.l;! w'it1c.~) lY~\.tit (J'l:!~1 ~~.J ~t...::J ~ u-l.J'11 .ul~.J ~ lY~\.til 0"l:1~1~ ~.J . ~ J:.J '11 A.c~1 ~ .JLSat~ . ~ lYJ:) ~b LJ.o" 4lt:i11" ytss ~ 4~ ~ ~J:.J'i1 A.c~\ .. 4:!lc ~)I.J ~J:.J'i1 wl~tc~1 A~路U'11-G'it1c.u-9 (":1~1~.l...o ~J ~
lYJ:)
~
~
~l
4..1~)1 Cr)~
~.J) ~.J
LJ.oo~.):a~ uJ ' ~ ~. '-.S.,il\~J:.J'i1 ~h, 4..;~~ ~llY.J:H~J: 4..1~)1 ~ C:~.J . lY.J.J~1 ~411 ~ u-lJ ("~ill u49.J JA 4..;.J.l&), I ~.J ' y'il b~lj.:l ~~..,ll t.r-~ ~ 0:1)'1uJ ] lYJ:) J~ . ~..,.b~1 -G*, ~ J:1li ..;#-.J ~.J 0:lJ.J ' ~1.S.u~.J ' rJWI ufi J+i.J LJ.o)1 J+i ' -G.J~ ) , .l1J: ul J+i b~.JA
~
rJ.us1.J . ( b~I.J)'~ ~.J ~~ . [ ~).JA..>#- ~ -u'1-=ill~. ~J:)
~ ~\ , ~)
("~) , ~
1. Harnack, H.: History of Dogma, VolA, pp55-60. 2.
3. 4.
Walter Nigg: The Heretics, Richard and Clara Winiston Ed. And Trans., New York, 1962, p128. Hefele, C.J.: A History of the Christian Councils from the Original Documents to the Close of the Council of Nicaea, 1894, Book II, Chapt. I, Sec. 21, p253. Ibid: PP 254-256.
~IJ .u~~.J:l.w) -, , illWlJ uy.l11o~ J ~1.,11 ~ ' o~ J .J.)lillJ c;Jl....:JIJ ~I , o~ J . ~I .Ji:. O~J ~J . ~ JSJ rJWI Jl:a.. ~J ' .J~.l11 JS ~ ~.,11 ~) .l1J l.S~1~ - ~ ¥I~I .u.)\.JH .).F'-.,11~~ ~l ok..) ~I ~ .us.1J ~ ~ o.l1:lrJ ~ - r
4..:1.l:'i l.S~1, o~ J l.S~~1 , L;~I
.Ji:. o~ J ' ~
.u
.~ ...
. ~..JP
, .).,1.,J1 ~
. l.S~ YI ~I
J ' J,olSJl JlI • . IJ.l1J 0:1~1~) JS LJe- ~
LJe- ~
~
(jl
~
~
0:'1\ - f .us.1J
. b.F'- JA ( 0:'11) ~ US: rJ ~ J utS _0 .u..i.. ~,( .u6~ J1.j ..r- . ("'" IWI u~. .. ( ~ J UA ')1 ~1.:: JlI 0.)1.J•.L ~-:'I~ u:. . 'il _i ~ J . ~ JS ~ tJl.W...a o\.k.IJ ' ~ o~ ~1l.S~1 , y'il U'" , 4..:1.l: l.S ~ , ~yJI ~1.,11, ~ JS .J~ .u'l 1 ~.J:l.w) .... - V
~..b. -
.u ~
US: rJ ~ ' ulfiYI ~ ufiJ ' ~ ' ~ JS ~ y'il U'" .).,1.,J1 0:'1IJ o~J ~J . ~ JS ~ ' .J~.l11 JS ~ .l1J .us.1J ' .l1 Ut ~~ b.F'-JA , ~j~1 y'itS ~ ~ ~~ (:AJ . y'il ~I~ .).F'-.,11~~ ~.) l.S~\ , ~ .'-- .11J Y:!~ ~, u'il ti .. ~ .( tiAl'~ w....ul.u..i.. .).1 - .11..JP. J . ~ (:A ..}1A ~ ~. ~,( y.,yw
J
~ J ' ~yJl' ~1.,11 ~ ~ I u ~ uSlJ ' 0:1.).,1JA.Ji:. ~4 UJ.)W;0:1~1 . 0:'11 ~ ~IJ' ~ JS ~ ~~ k.p ~, j:.~~1 JS J,.-l) 4..:1.l: ~ JSJ ' o4:JIJ ' ~I o\.k.Il.S~1 JlI U'" .u..i# JU; 0:'11 _/\ ~l...a .wfilJ ' ~J.S ~ ul .l:'i J ' J,.- ~I ~ ufi: ul ~ 'i JlI u~
~~J.
. .u ~
'i y'il U'" 0:'11 ul J~
~I
,-",,~IytlSJl
~."..-.i
. ~~I
~";,)~
'J~I ill l.f.4~1
~.jJ
•...
5.
u~ ' ~\ J - '\ ~4..tWI ~~
~J." ~~
t:.J~.,,)~1.!.1!., ~I u-u.u..J1 ~\:l.SJ1(,)'I~ a3~., . 0J.;~ ,)J~ <.J..I : u.l:! ~ ,+'(l;1j ~1J1:lt...C~
JJUa.J1 ~
(O)o.,~
Gregg, Robert, C. and Groh, Dennis, E: Early Arianism Aview of Salvation, London, SCM Press Ltd., 1981.
~I
~u-!~~I
J~! ~
~.J;..)'ll
lA.,JA ~I
A-:-at. •• ~'" .•• rr-...r
0..)-'<';;.o~~
tr-:tl tuUSJI "'.
~
•. _HI, •• ""Atl ~..,--..J~-::--
: ~~I ~.aJ.a.M: ~Ji JS (,:)J.fi~ ~~..)'il
0"':I~1
. ~ ~ ..)J LAS, ~
~I
l.S""
01 ] (i)(,$..)~'il
"'-cl....4i1 ... (j4 · • L-a-:-
•J
. ~.l.clyJ1J' ~L.JI ~)I
~
C';A .u~JJ O.JA-"'lJ O~J'
~
4L:JI J.".:i; -,
U-U.J..)~i
yL• ~-:.L-:-:
. _I.:. .11
~
~L.::.lJi':-!~ I~
-: II ~t:iSJ1 c.s-~.
.,. ( , , _0 : " ~)
u-l1 ..»JU~I wL:'i10~
~
~\~
~
. [ . y';l
un
U~
I.; JI
u! ] (V) U-U~~i
~~..)'il
\J~1
. [ ¥L..u)'l c.J.A ~
0"':1 ~
.y'il
~
y.~u-~.ul
01~I J-rH ~ y'il
~j'
y\~
~I~I
~
J,.il}il ~ IJ~~~I
(j'l
: (")U-U~~i
.wI ,
ws.ll ~
f~
)
ws.ll JA 0~
01~
~
. [ JIyJl ~...rbUC ~J
6. 7. 8. 9.
Ibid,P2 Ibid Ibid,P4 Ibid
] (')~l ' ~J
~~l
-" ~I
*
(.)o'Io:!J131~ f~IJ u! J~
~
[ . ( ~I c.)AI'&l ~
J:!-'-'ll.nl 0'YJil1 ~
jSy~1
~~
: 0~~..)'i1 ~~] ~I
~~
*
J~ .uli.- ~1 ~ ~ U"'-:/J131
(.51)
~m~
UJ:-~....)'llJ.;:L...J ~J
' 0L..u1 ~
~u
*
~I
~I
u~I
~
JLaS u~.,.U\'I ~)'I
uw.l
"A ,
~
~I
"V : '"
J:!)
~I
(''i\'1 ~I.JA
_r'
u-l} ~W.)'4
~I
r+il~Lc.jl ~~,
(.).A U4~
, r'l\ - r'V : ",
, ~
~
~J.,)IJ
u-i L.lill ('~ J
.("':'r'J:! j§ utS ~ ,ul...:a..j§ utS W o..,ill ..,. utS ) ] (' .) 6.J:I.M~ .... lJI J.Ji:I
~l
*
.[~~o~ WAil
tA J}II
W J ' ~I
JL
i.1G
b.».J-A ~)'I UtS..,1] (")
o.Jl;UcH .uy::. ~ ULS;J.:
j§ utS LJ J ' ( f' : "V ~
, ( 0 :
'V ~,
t',t":
, oj.»yto!I ~~'JI (.).A ~IJJ ~
I. ~ll.
~
'
' ( r''' : 'r'
) ~
jA) ('.»ll ~
~)~)'I~~j§utSLJJ
J~
A.,j..,slUSlJ . ~
··liJ~ uti~ .,~·'1 u. . 'J
oU,,(, ~ r_I tA
..b:--wa..,11 d] ojl.J)'4
J~
(1Y)
~,
~~.# ~I
'I ~.J ~I
,I~
(S'".
~
~
_I(~ ~~ ro-
tAylbjJ •
'J
14; " ~L6.t' ~, Ui......al ~~~J:!~} ~~.J
:i.J:bU bl~}
JU:1
~'J ~~}
. [~'i
:.,al ~.
*
ULS;
) oU-ul W~ ~I
",
'"t-' "'t":""""
J..".i;,J
~~'il
~tS ..".. ~ ~I ~I j ..s.;oJ ~ ULS;
y\'1 tA ( ~I
"A: , " J:! )
~~IU'J~j.(
~l
rJ (
0 : " ~
~
~UaW: ~~
u..i ~J-:.) ~ ')
~I
-,
t~ .[~\
1J~ Ail U~ , ~I
ojl.J)'4 ~)'I
~# Lf.:jrJ
Ij} ]
• [ WUI.u ...»10. 11. 12. 13.
(\T')
~
~~....)'il
J .J I·L ~
J.J.1.aJ -"
·-I,·.c. . IoU ..- LH.
Ibid Ibid Ibid., P5 St. Athanasius: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXX, (62) P427, NPNF., :!nd. Ser., Vol. IV, Michigan, 1980 .
. Y,., .
.u~I
~, ~4.u
U-A) ~
wj.JJ ~I
US:!~ ~I ~t:iS.ll
. (rV : i ul (!~!
J:1 '
(..}4J
~I
uLbL..au~ U»-.JJ .•}JI ~~
,0;1\
IYI'
"V : , , ~,
~ ULS LJ , ~4
r0 :r
~4
~
J:1' ""
<L....lc.
(j'lWI
~I
c:o ~
.u.~ ~ t~ r.s ) , ( r f
.J
~l.JI ~Jr'~1
r'~
: , , ~)
~mue JjW~1
~!t).!'11 ~J
.[(r" :' r .JA) y'il
'A : "A
0 ~,
utS~
JS ~
~~I
.J
4 1:.j
JJ1: *
' i:..~ •
o.aJ.a.aL1 4i~1 : Ww
w'J I
w~ 'i4 J
~I
*
'il J"~
'1] (' 0) u~~.J . >Au. LS u.
~L~.. ~..)AA
:
,./illJ-4 ~
U»-.JJ .... J'JI
: ~~ J.:ai:i.:..:j I~LJ!, ~.",;.",;-\1'-J'il . ~
IJ.
III
u!] (If)
~'11 >A ULS [ . t).!~
';'j
-r
J ••••
.JjW ~.J:lLHI JI , (
,r : 'i
All tJS.J4 UtS)J.
(rA: i ya)
~ 0:!.lI1 ~I
~J
WoA)
.l:l..14 ~ ~ •
:~I~~I:~b :~ ~ .~ ~ o~
~.
l·:L ~.
'~.lJ u..r-
lJ-4,wfi t"""
~
• ~I ~J ' 0:.
~I.lI\
0.J~~
~
,·.~lU ~. ~ \- r+"..r.- ~..r.&.
~J
~
~\.til
(j'l
" ( V: (j'I:!~\
f
0
..J..4) o-! jJ."JI
USJJ . 0~
~
~I
t).!'II
"'. ~ ,Uo=:l (IV)
u4 ~I
. '-tj . . ~",: .•~II ~..»C
14. 15. 16. 17.
Ibid., Chapt. XXVI, (26) P408 Ibid., Ibid., Drat. I, Chapt. VII, (22) P320. Ibid., Chapt. XII, (51) P336.
~'1'- ,
\~I ""-'..r.; ~(u
oy:. ojlj.tJ ~ ] (''I) U~~
~ t:iJ~ .uIS U'". . [~ .,y:..... ..,»JI ~I
~l.i
- ItS ~ .. ,I4"j'J • ! 0 ~ .~
~.JJ..;)~I
~k. ~I
'
~~I
j! w\..!J'I " ~'11 ,~, , o~1J u·1 ~. _:1\
". U'"
(.)IlLl
~I.
r~
: ~jJf, ~\
~I
01 (
or : r
..,1)~ ~.;I)\~\ •~
,. , ~: r~)
"~
J
y-
.
'0;1\ ~,JJ~'l\
~
Jj ~I
" J!..ul ~ " t-.i Jli" .(j~\
"
<:1, ~I
0
q • ,
r r:
~\
A r1
) ~
~\¥~li~l
. ~I JJ
(j4
t'~
o~.;I)1~ ~\
ot9tSAuk ~ ~
.~ ~.u ... +
W
~~\
J
r t1, r..\.: f'-:-l-C' f
~~~~J.(fi:
. .i~ :: \I u: .,U u·1 I.J'&' ~\J. I.S'"
~-t:.. Ji\ ~ J '-'~
*
~
.J~\
~,j.JJ'l\
(Y.)
,v : f 0 Y
I.:-lC
[~wo ..... : '1.:-lC '
~r. ~ ~
W+
;j·w\
~,JJ~'l\
..ull.A:J . ~I
~
~~
~'
.w1 ] (' ')
*
~~\
01 Iji.A:l (
~\
J" ~
.J: ~j
0~ ~~ ..u}j, 0~\
~,j.JJ'l\
;;,;;_1\ Ji\ U::.....u.<: \ ~
~o~.;I)1~J . 0~
('I.)
~li ~Yf - r
.wI '~.: . 1~
~.~ IJ
.wli~1 ~I~
~..l.I.S'c..H '11 • ~-.:t:.•l.S ~l ....>:J-C.
W\:i.II. ~ ~.-i
](Y')
. [ .u ~1 0fi::! oli.J
Iu..:i.S •
(jM..J-J~
01 .A:J
' ~
'
• .)4l..".;J\
( f. : , • ..,.;) ~ ~
o~J ~J'
~ u:'1\j. ~1 u:'11 o~.J:l lil..40Y?')\ ~
18. 19. 20. 21. 22.
rjA ~
~.JJLA
~,j.JJ'l\
L. 01 ]
r~'J1
~~.J'
Ibid., Oral. III, Chapl. XXVI, (26) P408. Ibid., Oral. t, Chapl. XI, (37) p328. Ibid., Chapl. XIII, (53) P337 Ibid., De Synodis, (15) P457. Ibid., Oral. III, Chapl. XXV, (10) P399 .
•Y
0 •
(n)
~,j.JJ'l\
)
yYf ow\>, -r
~~\
rCl..i:i Jl ~i.:i (.51 • ~1jj1 ~.fl"A~
,••/JI o~..>:l
*
(r r : A rl C':?"\.J
:~ Jr ~ Jw! ~ ~Yf, lH:o~)1 01 I~
J.!J
+ ut/lJ
4-./JI
J~ *
u-! '1J, ).,Sj'JI u-! '1 ,../,11 ~
~IJ I.,;,}J!J ~
.w~ I~J. ,./11 ~
~
~J
~
~
01J. ~L.::JI~ . [(f. : , • .Ja)
uyi ~1 ~4]
" J.i'J ~Il ~ ..r-l..S""" ,( fA·
•
i
J~
(n") U'l.Jo:i)
J
,( f •..
I
~L ~J ,\"~.Jc.s
0
~I
y'Ji ojlJi ~I
)" ~~.
.•• "
~l. ..
••• I....H~~
u'Ji oj!.J.1.~1 ':'.ul! . • 1",.1 ""(l-' J.. u'J! ~ .. [ .( f
~ ~'il u-lll
r : r r .,1)" c.s~!~I
. ~Y..'
~~J
y'Jl ~ ~I
c.sA '
~
. ( " : 'v ~) ~ y'JIJ
~'
y'Jl ~
U:-S 0~1. ("
:'
~
j)..,JI ~I
~~
~
...
~~ 1
'-fJl ~
~
y'Jl
ue (r A : 'V t1) ~
j))1
04 ~.Jt.)~1
~J
~I o~.,11
~
us 1~1](YO)
V..H ' , • :' f..H) y'Ji u-i ~1
[ .~ ~
c.s~1~tsll
U~
4.:jj
+
O~J ~
4J1 uti)i..J1
u.'l!
~~I
••.. i'll
j.JJ lAS, .&1 ~ 0..'J'J",JI ~
r~IJ ~
u~1
l.....J\(.)04 . ~ Y.. ~ l.F.~
us:J .. o\:i:1 y " ~ti
(H) ~.j-j
uSJJ ' ~y\~ ~
J.... ".11 ~\ .JA.Il..S"""U'l.
..... 'J J ~.. \..b:i:j '1 ~... . '1\ ~ ~..4..JS"(,jA.l.l
£Jjl.J1~ ~jl.J1 'J
01 ( , • : , f .Jo:i) ~
-l4~
ulbl 'J ul "
"'-'1
~Lb l,}C..'
~I
~~
~.Jt.)~1 y.Al
.JA y:J1
4....i1
~~.
LaS + ~I o~.,11~
JJ:i;
*
w ..~I
~I J
04 0yoc y
23. Gregg, Robert, C.and Groh, Dennis, E : Early Arianism Aview of Salvation, P26, london, SCM Press Ltd., 1981. 24. Ibid., P27 . 25. Ibid., P28 .'
~W'~' ~~
Eat'! ~ .a.a'J ~~'
LaWI •• U"'-:! J11l~ .~j" ~..) ~I~" ~ A~II ,--••~.. ~ : u4 ~I)I
, Jt,..aSJ1 j , pI
~I ..
'. ~JI
4431u-':!JiJIJ(,)MJ")~'
(n) (,)M~~'
ut.i...- JS Ulj. y)U LW UWlj ¥~I
I~ ~--y'il
.uj
u'.A;"i1~
• c.r-: 'I ~Lw.'il ..
0.J."...-11 yA ~,!I]
.wI u..-
~ c.s.A ~..,.l.JA ..J¥:.
f'~ j , ~~ yJl Ji,A ) ~I
. [0.J~1 ~ \ j, 0\;
0~ u' ~.J-lj ul ~'J ] (l
1I
•
~IJ "'J ~
0
[
.JI~
V) ~
~. 'I
~
..)~"il •..
.
~1.iJ1 . ~)\j .~
~"il u' (,)MLw.1 ~ ~
~
: 'T~I OJI..)} ~I..H "'-'r.i .J ~ ;. l.S~ . \tl ~ •.
~I ~ LJA o..,.i
y\j'
~I ~~y'il
~I
.1_. ~
"wI"• ~.~1.1_
~w'J
(,).l
~LlJLSJI u:J
'.
~
I]
U.
(lA)
i J - _,
1.J'l.J-:..J.J-i:l
. ts [ou.u. u.. L.u u:. ~
~ ~
y\
yA ~
u~y\j .
.wI ~
uts
o~
.u ~,!I ~~.J uJ ] (1".) u-*"" ~.J'il J~
~I.} ~Sj
.. ~';""1 A...liJ •.. 0 ~ ..
4..:i43IJ4!~1
. [ ~I ~I~
+
~~....)~I ~..>+JI L..' : ~~
A.JI~ . 'JI -:,~ (,S . ~I • •.• t..>: • '-"""""
~ ( '0 :' fi ,"'\:Aj.J)
44-31J~
(,)MJ")~'
uJ ]
LJA
~Ij ~
, 4:i~ ~ ~
A J ii}i,\\.&1 o."...!
:",t
.. (" .~ .
u-*",,~.J'il J~j
(l'l)
. Jj W
~
jA,,,,t
-",
y\ -ul ~I)I ..:itl-rjc j
.rA j .
-i
(,:r.U='.I ~
: , fi'
~I.J)
~ C )L.J1.lJ•....>-Jj~ .•.
~. . [. u=..?-.i u26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
Ibid., P50. Ibid., P50. Sl. Athanasius: De Synodis, (15) P457, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,1980 . Ibid., Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral., II, chapl. Xxi (63) p 382. Ibid., Oral. I, Chapl. II, (5,6) P308-309 .
•"(v.
y':/I O.J~ul ] .J.iiJ~ '}IJ.
u ..A~
(1"\)
~ ~ ~'
(j4
~'
' o.J..ul1 AJP,;" ~'il ~
. U t .J.iiJ~ '}I ~.
'}II U. ~ • 1. ~ ... _. o~1
. [ ( , ~ : 0.J:)
.u ~'il
ut IJ,/iJl ( .
0 : '0
~' [ ~ ~.<1\ ~ 0..:l.:l.1 J~.
~
~
(~ : " ~ d :' o~
(j4
(1"1")
~A.:U:.U:.~'i
...r.Wl~
~ ~
0J.>+
u...ilS~\
jU~1
I.:JC) ~
~
(I"l)
·<'1 U. t...-c.t
ue ~y.a:J1 iU ~yJl
o~
u-!.J' (
0" : " ..,J) iU\ ~
..r.uW l..S! . ( '" , "
ut
~
~
W ~.
'J
' wii :
,..ull
'_0 : " u-i)
('
(
V : f 0 y')
~'i\ ~J
~I ~I
_0
v-
~..HJ') ~
~'il ~J'
u-!J' ( " ~ : i y.c.) -uJl.Att4'i.u ~l
y':/I U-:H0..:l..H-..".J1 0~)1
.t ~
U
~
~j11 ~u-iJ' l.S~\ ~'il
u....u1. ~\ .J ~ t...H•
~~I
~
W -f
U~..J:.J'i1 f'~
~
~JJ
.J
u-C'~
I.A'}/l ~
y':/I ~
.J:) ~ ..:l))1 ~I
\',::ljtS.Aut u~..J:.J'iIl.S~] u~1
u~ u~.J:}~1
L
u.!J ~
: 'V J:!' i. : , • J:!) ~'iIJ
o~ ut u~J:!.J'i1 ~~ \~ , iU ~~~I ~\ .J~I 1 ~~ ~J ~UJI· ~N~ ~.UI '. ~ ~~ [Allo..:l1 . .J. ~ ~J""'"" ~
31. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book IV, Chapt. IV, (39) P267, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X,Michigan 1979 32. Ibid., ChaptXII, (161) P283 33. Gregg, Robert, C.,and Groh, Dennis, E. : Early Arianism, A view of Salvation, P69. London, 1981.
Wt:i-
~WI~I
~'~*j.U' :.:H~'JlIp1~' : ~J; : WJihii ~ ~.,,1i1 CP ~.J:
..;'ll ~~
. ~.) ~IJ JA ( ~)yJl ..Y.F)).&1 ut ~ . ~~ J
. [b~J"l
~'11 ~
cfi.: rJ ~J
uts]
~I~
: , • .JA ~ f : 'V ~)
~ o~))1 ~ ~I
U'l~)~~
~f'\ : f" ~ £ : '\ ~
~ ,'\ J ,
"V : ,'\
~)yJl ..Y.F' ~IJ.u~
(jAy ~]
o~J.u (.5~1, o~J ~I
0 : '\
~I ~
.u r:.>til ut
: ~~
~l
~1,J31 ~I
~J
U&- -,
J.J ~ ,,'\ : '" ~
(ro)J.# ' o~~ ~
, o~J ~I~.u ~
, Uy~1 , o.l.:l., J ~\.u
~t:JI : .UfJJt
.J~ u~~.J':;\
(1"£) ~~
~
'A
( ,'\ : '\ 0 ~t
(.5~1, o~J (.5~'i1 , o.l.:l.,J
(.5.i.11 , o.l.:l., J c:lL....:J1 , o.l.:l., J ~I
~~'i\ J U'lJ"lWI .wll;~L....:J1, J~WI , ~I
, ~..,..JI~~ , .jA ':;1
.J¥:- ' J,SJI~~
[~~I~IJ ~I o~I~J' ~~
jA ~
.. ]
(n)
J~
U'l~)
.[ 0:'11~ ~ts ~t
' ~~I
, ~~ Ut J:! b-'7"J"l ~
.u~rJ~'1\. ..Y.F.w.i)\ ~'11 ~J' 34. 35. 36. 37.
Ibid., Ibid., Ibid., Ibid.,
~1~.u~.&1
u-e ~I
u~
uts(Monad) P82 P88 P88 . P82-83
~~I
~# U&- J
J JU JolJ - f
("V) (JJ4.j-J••
rJ JAJ . .JJA~I~J ~j'il
u.slJ~I~.u~'1\
~
JS ~
~\)I.
~I
-"
~ I~ J . ~I ~ ~ts.&\.! u~l
oyo- J o~I.J~~ J lH'Il ] ~~IJ ~~I &:H 4lJJll. ~ Jt , ~)
J:J
~.&I
.. ~Jt,
~
~J J.!J .. ~~ Ut ~ ~~~~'11
~
~~J
~.,...JyJl
+
u-ll ~'11~~ wi ~
wi ~
l.S1) ~~)I
~J.
b.>?-JA.&I0:J ~
~ tA~ b.rJl"JA.&IwLS'" . J:i
~ J ~ J ' l.S.l;I1 ~ ~ .&1~ J! ~ ~
US:!r-l ~'11J y'iIl.S1 (Diad)
~ wY , rlJ.l11~
~
(.).0
~'11 .&1~
(rA) (
b.rJl"JA US:!r-ll.Sj,J1~I~ .uJ ~
~ 0:'11 .., r.la.11 ~ ~.&I
'\jl" ""6-' __tJ . ~J!.tt-YI·t(' u~ '.<.. _I b ~JA "-.l..!~ u-=r '.<.. _I~ u-:l,J. U.
wY. r~1 0.A .. II~I·I(', -,.11'~ ~ -:'1..:. ~ J o~Y!".YW ~ ~ J r-
'LS , r ~I' ~~ -:.t..:. .l!~.&\ J ~ U J 4.il:... J U:l..,... . .<.-: ~I.ll.u '\.S ~I ~.T".&. ~ J , ~-:.1..:.. U·1~t.q~Y!" JA .[ ~. U
: ~\tl UA~'i1~~JS-t , O~Y!"J~
0:'11 uJ
. ( n' : , · ) ~"V
] (n)
:,,
~411~J .u.I~.) u..! (j'l.Jo:!)J~
(j'lJ.)~1
UA).yll ~~ .l! ~
J.SJ ~ , .u~J
0:'11 ~~ l.S~I.&1uJ J~ wi ~\.l.J1
[ . J,-Yl ~ ~J
: ~\tl UA ol:PJl ~ " y'iL.: ~
Ji.o .ul~~
y'il
.uy.:..~ .
Lil " ~'11 J..".i ~ y'il
(.).0
l.S~1~I~J ~
[.u~ ~.) ~~I
~ l.S~1~I~ .. ~J..r-
b ~~~..?-
''il
J
.u1~bT~1 .~~
JI ~\tl
.. y'iIl.S..H 'i.w~0--:'11~J]
tAJ 4.iyy tA USlJ ' ~\.S o.)~J UJ!Lb~
~I ~
& "( 'V : , ~
U yU ~ , )
.(.).o.u~~~
~
w~ ~]il
~'il J~
_0
*
~
o~1 ~1l.Sj,J1
.y
···l':w.aW~ JU.U::"'" ~
J: d .;J:A:'J ~
I.S
(fl)
4J~1 ~
~4S ~'il - i
(j'l.J-:!) J~
*
lAW 0~1 U..>A:/ wi ) l.S~ wi ~)o; "'J , ~I~I -uiLb .)~ ol');J 4.i yy .u~ , 01~
u..! ~..;I.."JIu-lJI u--ll~ . " o~J ~I
38. 39. 40. 41.
(f.)
o~4--0IJ
o~1 rLU l.S~10:'11 wl J~ ~ , ( 0 V : i >:l)
: A,!-J':!
'i ~I
.."J]
l.S1~
*
llA
.&1, l.S.);'iJ ~
(j'l.Jo:!). [ ~I ~I
'i l.S~1.)~.l11
Ibid., P88 . Ibid., P84 . St. Hilary of Poi tiers: De Synodis, (13,11) P7, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979 St. Athanasius ; Orationes Arianos , Orat I , Chapt. II, (6) P309, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980.
~'~J 0.»'"'~.J'i\---------J}11
~\
~l ~ ~Wl
y411 ,
: ~j.lWI~ ~MJl ~
ue- ~.JAY!'-..u
JS. (j'I.ill1 (J)IJ
~
c.H'IIJyYI ]
•..• 1 L . ···L.I" . . ~~. ~~J~.~J~Y-"~J'c..JJ ~I• . ~ •.•.. -- 'I 1S"" .~ tJl••"'t-' • ~ 'i L. I..F.'I \....... ALl.l.l ~ • [ IS"" J ~ ~
(fY)(j'IJ:!)
~ ~J '1 ....
: ~~
*
J~
. 'Y\ u..!.?
tAW c..J.."........... _~I-:.:.• ,-~ J . ~ ?~ ,
:a' L !b'lJ ",. ••• ' ~
~~I ~ .;H~I-.i~! : W~ wi ~ !.51.~!Jwi Al .)~ 'i] (£\") ~.J;.ill J.,:A; *
~ c.H'I1u-o ~I yYI ~ ~ c.H'I1..ulj yYI ul " ( , ;
~IJ ~fll
'0
.u aJ!bJ 0..>AY!'~ yYI
~I ~J'
u-!J' ~\
• [ ( 'I' A ; , f J:!) J:!) ~
~.).,JIu-U\
u-i} "
~I
rAJ:I JA 041wi
I ~I " ~l!
"~~
u-!]
(£0)
(' v
~
~I
ue- ~fll
~J ' o.l.:l..J w'...s. i.lll
u-o ~
~'J ~I w~]
oL-...aJ l.A Wts ~': I.:.jj~
, ~
q'l)
i.lll~ ..
~I . A.....&JI
4JWI~
. I i.lll ~\.)I L.~ ..c..J
. [ .ubIJ: ~ II ~L:..~I J: ~y:..Y-II I.S"..
~
J.,:A;J *
~}J
•
~.a .;H~': La.fb (.)M~...JiJ~
*
J .... .l..a.J 4.....&J1 J
c.H'I1 J ~I '1] c..J.
~IJ
JA ~jl . ~}
: QJL:alL., ~
~ts
~,J-l...J'l1
;'1".,.;)" ~}J
. [ i.lll~
4....JSJ1~lU
*
••}~1 ~~
(H)~,J-l
.JA~I ~~Ifll
c.H'I\ J~
~I ~} ~I
u-!J ' ~Ifll
c:H'I1 wI..: rA~Lc.~}\J~>.J-l" ~Ifl\
().C ~
. ~IJ
JA ~}J'
~.Ii\
(£ V)
J r"-'-; "-·1
(j'IY!'-)11
J.c..r-::J ..'i.
*
.[~I
42. 43. 44. 45.
Ibid Ibid., De Synodis, Councils of Ariminum and Seleucia, (28) P466. Ibid., De Sententia Dionisii, (10) p180. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book XI, (8) P205, NPNF.,2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,. 1979. 46. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos , Orat. I , Chapt. II, (5) P309, NPNF. 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 47. Ibid.
- •...AII~I.· c.or~
(F
~Wl.
---_---_-J;~'JI~ .. ...•. ;
~. ~l~' ~ W-*"".Ji) ~I
oJ
.:H¥'~: ~~I
u!Al t';"';'J"·~.J'
(j'Ji
. ( YA :
r:A1.i:..Ji:. ~'11(j~
'0 .p- , ) <oJ
")J.J
(£'1)
~...HJ~I
•
'-~ ~~
L.S , JSJI u! JSJI All
(j~
48. Ibid., (6) P309. 49. St. Gregory of Nazianzen: The Fourth Theological Oration, (V) P31O,NPNF., 2nd. Ser. Vol. Vil, 1978 .
*
~I
~I
~'~J U-*".>:j'l.\ --------
~ ~WI
J}ll yl,J1
l!-# IjtI J _)dai.ll
~~~J~t I.W ,;;
t !,,'Lt •••ill
.,)\$w'l ~~
~~l
,,'! ~t
••~~t~t~
J! "iJt •• ~~
~I UMJl..11 y\ll31 .,)Li....1
~t......,),JI "4~1 ~4us ,,1,.,.... ~u..11 ~1j431 ()I
~
: 4J..a..JU,J~,J!NI
jJiI»
J~~ ().4 ~
w-='~' ~
~ ~
w-='~I o~ • ~l
:i
0
~l ~"" : A r1~V :
f
Y ,r
0
JLi.li : ~Ji
~ : r" ~ f : i ..::.w) ~ ..:l":JLa
:~ ~ ,r : 'i
WA) : ~ ..:l.JJLa:.JJ
~ "V : "
~~'l
'-P 1.JfiS U:!~I ,J14.....J.i UM~..Ji
~AJI
: ~.a.ial~I . ( 'i
~l
'::'211~
.~
~I .~w~I : ~~
\..i..J-
~
M
J
J'" iJ
('
.( 'A : "A ~ f i : "V ~ f" d , J r ~ _ rv : "i ~ 'A:
,.
~ rA:i.)4):
~..:l.JJLa:
~\
0" : ")) : ~
.(f" : "" ~"" : , • ~ "" J ,~ : : '" "JoJr:
0 ~
~r f : "
r
0 :
r
-'=): ~
~ r A Jr.
'v~oJ':
i41u~J
~.J-4\
. (r" : ~.JJLa:
~.JJ La : ~I
,r ~,,~: '"
~\
ti) \..i..J-
~J
(r
~
-'= ~
~J
(f
: , • ~ oV J r A J rv : i ~ r.
'f ~"':
'O~"AJ":
("
J" i J
,r~"AJ"V
.( 'V : ". ~ '" : JM.>JI JL.e.&i ~
J
•
: W~ .
.
tI) ~ ..:l.JJLa Vc "0 ~I..IJ: ~b
.( ri : "
~, , _0 : " ~
.("_, : r ~~J
~
"A :
f : ,
'0 "":JC
~ ~
"f : , 'i J
: J•••.>JI ~~ .;---S'
'0
:
~ "V : 'i ~,,~: A J.J )
i ~0
: " ~
'V : , ~, ~
'0
: ,
fi
~!"eL'
•••• ' ~ta~ ~
w..M~~'~1
:~.w. y\ 'i.
~ J.JJ ~
u~ Ji
: 4,JJj.4
f'1.l! t~
~
LHJ~I
y\ tY-'l:!Ut
0ft
') t ~l
u:".J:! ~J111 ~
?t wyiJ" (n , r. : r. >:!) ~ \~y1 ~.ill
~I ~
~)
r..1 o~
01\ LotJ. y\:iS.lll1\ u-9 ~
... i I~I _C::I u..,.... '.C::o: c..r-' <I .J .&1 . " ~L ,' ob.. ~ ,r. .&\ LHJ~I
y\ tY-'l:!
d~uLo:"I1 y\
:
uJ..+l1 .:.
~",.~I
, " ~H o~ ~i I~Jr..s.lu~ " Ut: ~,J)I ~~6.Y~J ' l.\.;.S~~\ ~
wl~
:
u:iJf.l1
u)ji)~
. '\.S-c---::---.. \ ...A II J.J.....JI U..J 'L.u L.::u. ll...=..-'=
(.}'l-:l
(J-l
oY-=J1w.J\.S~.
~..JAJ'
u.:~J.h
.illl \"..~I.u -,
..JAJ' ~jYI
~Wl
uJf.ll,J .:. .1l,J
•• J. 1'""'e-:'
~
. .J..JA.ll1J.S
~
"I
...>-A.J, ~
~
0:
II
yYI
. (L' : , -,=).&\
~~
: Ji.o ~I
~~J.
w y\ 'i. ~ Y ~~6.4 \..L....:.. -'= ~J
~I
(r >:!)
U'l.JA:l~# ~
~~J'
(
~~I~I~~J,(ri_ri:r ~I.;JI
~.:-.••A.iA u-9 t.:i jO
~
~~.J
. ( r, _r 1\ :
,r
H)
~~\
~ ~
. (1\ . ( , •
0
-'=) ~~I
,r
..H)~)
f':!...J-4 ~
ojLil . ( 'V ..H) yYl ~ .u~\.l..o~.
L-jj ~
~~
' ( , •
J..,.i:. ~
~L.....,ju-e. J..:!~~~
~ ojLilJ.
+ ~lti.i
~
~1u.eUI~I~-,=
~ ?i ~~.J
U'l.wll CJ..rJ1 ~
CJ..rJ\ (' 8 ...•iQJ ~l
>:!).u.e..J
. ( , , >:!) w.rJ1 ~
yYI ~ ~~
~~6.t ~, (
.l!.J
>:!) ~~I ~ ~~6.tJ ' (f >:!) ~jOLJI
(.S~\
~4--i11~
fV: ,
>:!)~I
u-e ~~J
.wt~
0' -
~~J
.~'\ .
.JjW ~t
~\
~
4....ol..§J ~~.J
4-::-9 . ( 'i -, f .>-=)
( , 0 -Y : 'i ~r i : 'O.>:!)
r. >:!) ~ ~~.J .( r r - ,~: r. ~) (
>:!) eJL....:J\
~4-il\ ~
w J;
~~\
8<11 U'l~\
~,,)6.\.J. ( '"
.J:!)
~p '0 ~
~
~I
~
~..):a. ~ ' ( ,,'\ -
Ll..i\'1
• U:R"
..:iJ~.J.J • •'. ~ -.a. c..-::-_ •..• 'I ~I ~ ~t.L
tll..iti
~~.
. -.i ~ 0"..)C- l..r
•
t. ~ . (0. _ tV·' ..J:! ) twll c.r.'I ~WI c.J:!~ ~
(0 t _t i :f.J-:!) ~I
~\").,,JyJl..r--:JI ~. ~ ~I
~I
~
~W ~ ',,)~-'4j'~ Y r- JiU'
.( "
uti ~ ~I
~,,)L:.. LH} ~~.
(' i -" :0..H) ~ .J:!)
~y\~)
.J:!)
c.s~.\
b .J:!~..r-. t. - 'I ,,)illl lAS +
~ ~.&. 'j ~ . ~I~.
A
~.
"i :".
~
rA ~
U:..j ~ . t. '.U'lll
( , , - , : " I~
.JjW ~ti} . (
.J-:!)
~
~:U-
rA - ,
: '\ ..H)
. ( , t - , : '" .J:!) 4...aYilI
t~}
'0~
~LJI~
: l..d..J
c.s?\
~\.j\
~
(,r _0: i.J-:)
~I.J.
LJ,,).J.J '->-iJ~
j-S~ ~~
+ lJ--4t~1
~.J~I~~\
.("O_'A:
~l
~
~I
~I
u.,,-~~)I
1,~1
C~
JJll:U
i.J:!)
u~J : u="J:f
~.a11
: ,..,WI J'; .u w~ ~ t.JliJi .J~ ( .JA )
~ ~
~ ~
~ rlWi .J.iJ
.JA
wi " (
'Y : A ~)
uti rlWi u-i u..uL." ( ° : ~~) ~I J~.J. "o~I
-f. .: •
.J~
. "rlWi •
I
J.SliJ ' ~I~ • .J~ ..
4.l"U.J~ ~
':lJ' (
tJl=J\ ~ ~
r, -rt : 'Y
I
l\ : , ~)
(
.J:I)
~\
.J.,wl.J-A .:.
.J."ill~! ~"4
~jd I
:~, " rS4l.Ju. ~ w.iJ yU u-i w~~.y
w~'Ji w~..>.J
(
t, : 'Y
~IJ
II
l:!~1
.JJ)
u~ ~ """~' 4JY'
ul ~! \.iJ.e ji r1 J "( y t
.J"
JS.J
~
-0
: A .J:I) .:.
~\t..~.,..~I ~
.:•
.•••4l.Ju.
crl! w.,.....Li~
w~'Ji ~!
~.J
t~ ~
~
JLii " ( YA : A~)
.:.
"~ ul ~J
~
~ I
•.Wi
~
~\
~
' "WI'"••••~ NI , ~ l.S l1\ ~I~ • (.)-l
1.J..>tJ ' '. ';it, 0'\ ~ l...J I
I
.J I~_.t. - ~
4.lyJ.):I
\...U.p. .:.
--r-••.. , .u...L.i ~
'1·c.J~ ...............i\"L"
,""1 .~~~
I
.
__
"'1..:.'
: uLoJ' J,; 4;jJN:/ ul ~I~!
w~ wi Ua.i rS1J."JI ~I
t~ ~
~
-
V
J\.ii" (OA : A.,.;) .:.
:JI~' 4JJ'~! -A Doejil
.u J\iJ o~.,i ~.)li. 0»ya,1~ll
~I.J ~ tJ
IM~.uJ\ii. "4 ~.J'i
. " .u ~J
t.Joi'aJ ~
" (
r A ..r 0
~ 4.J" ~ JliJ ~~ ~I
~ 4 ~JI .Y' ~ •
J,ii . .J" .J" ~
: ~ ~)
. ..&10-:lH ~
l.S.i]I.J
.:.
~
~I
(.).A
.w ~J'
.w~)4 (.).AU
~I..).,.l.".Jl~\
L;1WI A.ilLH}.w1
~(.S~I •••
~J)I
o~l
~I
~I .:•
y.)
~ ~J'
~)u
. .u~oYT~ : ,-",~
y4 ul u--i} r-S1J~I •" ~..)A
~J
~l
L.A:I t~
~\
(!..?-:!J~~J
~
~
..\e>,J'
Y4J' ~ -\
Jli9 " ( '\ , V : , • ~)
~I ~ ~..) u} . y41\~ ul .~I yJl : ~LaJ' ~'}'
ue ~
J~
.:•
c:lL-l1~I.;JIJ' c:lL-l\ ~I.;JI ~
wi " ( " : , • ~)
-,.
. .:•
" ulyJl
:o~" ~~, -" / ~ uI .. " ( w~)J ~ 0A1- 0A o4:JIJ ~4il1
"~
"0 : , , .J:) .:•
.ul~ ~ o4:J1 .u (.S~I 4..1)'\~
. ~ 0AJ:!0A JSJ o4:J1 ~J
: ~ JoG ul~I u~ y utS ~
u..A!Ul ~ dil
~
rJl.lf.ff oUt" -,
~y ~I ~.
o~IJ
~IJ
J:!..r1J1 ~
ue y'il U!y lli} ... ( i : , f .J:) y'il u-l} J.-j o~J . ( '\ : , f ... ~
. ~ f:
,
.J:)
(Jo'llill .)~
~ ~J '
r
r-S1 J~I " ( , '\ : " ~) .:.
:o~"~"~#'~ Y}y'il u-l}
.:.
wI "(
~
-,,..
i : , f ~)
.:.
U~J:!.;1J1 ~
.:•
.J:) ~ y'il l:l:1.)J ' ~.;k
Jk4 ~ ~ JS ~
~tS o4:JIJ o4:J1 ~tS ~
(.S~I
~I
u~o4:Jl
~ J ~• ~J
.:.
'Jj ~I ~j
~
rl ~I
" wlyw,JI "'~
" (,$1",L....JI~j ~
~
.: •
<.J ~ts11" ~'11r~I .Jl:Uc-4 ~\ ~I . wi)1 ~ <.J (..)4}JI ~ JA.J ",lAwJl <.J ~.JA
.:.
yYI ~
. ( 'A : , ~)"
" 'i.J1w\s. ~
0
: ~ .J~)"
~ ~,..,
~j f~L-
wl.w:J'I1~j
-~ ul Lol , rJWl I~
()ot
O~.J
4.Lo1 ,
~I . ~ ~
~~,
~I.J
CO ~..\>
vi,
w~ " ( i ~: i ~) .:.
: ~~, ~ ~i
vi' -0
~..\>
rut ... " C,. r :A .J':l)
Ji..1~
-f.
" rlW\ I~
.:.
(,)oIl ~
: ~ •• ~fJ!a.! !blfJJAM-If~ ~~f ~ MI••• i:~~ • ( y y , , , : 'V -N ~I
~I..J ) • " AI,J~~I,J\.il"
~I ~~I J.JUii" .,;'.,..!I ~I~.J ~.ul
u....J " "'-'I '+'. ~
0
~41~.J
~.J6..A
J.".ill 1.iA ~
w-c. ~
~
·l.w:J1~I .J.~\.i, ~ .•. ~ . L~ ~L_-: U.
( r. : , •
~"u.J .:.
..)~\
LJ.J ' " 0 ~..,»J ~
. ~.
!
u-,-
• (
,Jj) -,
0.J~
L~.J'-
'-R"
.
~y
rr : , · ~)
" ~~I (II.; Jii ui"..J (llli " ( ~ : , t -N) • Y . ~I.J ~'1I.Jy'il WI.J'~l
: ,t ~r It. :' '.Jo:f ~I
~
~I..) " ~ ~~I,J~~I '"
~ I..:JYI(,$y tlil(,$1 .:. wi " ( , • : , t -'":f) -,.. (Y' : 'V ~ , ,
. w."....W4 w,J'\:lU\ ~W1~ , w.".~1 ~
J oU-,
4.;i y'il wfi .:.
:...•.~ ~ ~~.w. .wI :
• •
Ll.ffJ
•
" ~.".A ~ ,J'\ Lo.J '
~."..i~
: y3u Lc Jf 4J ,J'\
Lo JS.J " ( , • : 'V
.J:!)
L, ,
.:.
~ y)\ J.fi~.J .. y~'~.J~J".J
~
l.. JS
w'~', "...~.,.. ~
,:a .:.
UJiu.tS1l.t;.....,.Jl ~
~
L. J,S" (
'0 : ,'\
W"'J~'
. ~I.J cst1'i' y\~1
~1,;4c-
.J':!) ~
~'il ~
: JoN' ~ o',l-oJI-r
'v :
" J.u;.i u'.J w'il ~ ~ ~, " ( 0 ~) .:• . J-j\ ~ c.Ya y\14 ~ ~~ ~i I~ oil.,§ c.Ya'~ rt-i"'J . ' :0 J~I }~ .:. o ( y'il ~i) ~I~J,...c. , W"'J " ~\i y)\ ~\i .• ~,:;' I~
.6.
1
. J-li ~~~I",~tJSy.. (""-: O~) UiS wi II J,JH114.1~. JL.e.' J,..,y.u' ~I
"~~'iI~I~ ~I ~",.'i
y~'
~ I~ ~ rl W~ J.u;.i UiS
.(r'A,r'V:'. ~)
II
wi
I.,.a..-Y ~
WSl.J . ~
~U'.J~y'i'(J'
'~ji.JI"i,;a:iuS1JL.e."'J4'~li
~~'il
~'il ~~.J~I.JA"'JI
r~
'i c.Ya' y~1 W.JA~
~
w' LaS4:J"'J" ~I • ( '"
~'il
L-", .:.
~, JL..e.i J,..c.i ~
: uUaL...If, 0J~' ~~i
~.).!
: 0 ~)
o',l-oJ,-r y,;J~
"
.:•
.L:&:! c.Ya
: 4o'fJ' ....;ol,l-oJ' -f. r~ ~ " ( "r' : 0 .J':!) .:•
LaS ~'i'~I
. " .,1.• a) ~~I y'i' r~ 'i ,
: .:M¥t ~i:w.~
tn.i V-.J • ~",.'l U1'~ ~
:u~"
~'NJ ~
~,
"
UIi' " .~
v
~.)~ ~
~
~J
J~' ,.
oio\>,
A
~Y' - ,
" t),;:.l w.iJP ~iJi''4i~'i1,5,;,;:. uti" ( r" : A ~) .:. "
: 4t~)t' ~ ~
ui.J ~i:;~..J
w~ ~
o~'
J.:,~ ~y~ ul.o.ty,-r
W---)!.J~'i'~.>J w--- J,S" (t. :'.J':!) .:.
.~ ~"'JI r~-·'1 II
: ~Y' J.w: ~ a.;~~, -r' . " ~
JS~t
~J.i:l~1
u'i " ( ~~ :
~ ~ b~t U:l~ 'i y'il
:y~'
ut/l
r-..f..: 'i
rj.a .
y'il UJ"l..f..: LAS ~'11~I
0 ~)
r'.f'~~Y' r'.I! -f.
r-..f..: ~
" ( ~f
:0
~)
~Y'
:y~' JLw:i ~ I¥ ( y'il ~t) ~l~~
u'i " ~l
~
'"
~tJ ~)J ~t ~J
~
y.) J~
.:.
~~~ ~Y' -,
uJ " ( ~ f
~t ~t
~
-0
.('~:0J:!) : ~lS:o JS' ~
1I.ll.c J
.:•
~~I y'il r-.fi= 'i
. " ~)
" ~~ ~'11~
.:.
: ,t
>:!) .:•
. "':l~~ i.
: ~'J4 ~ : .u.a ~~, ~'Ji~' ~t
~t
litJ u'il ~
'iJUL.. ~I
~! ~t ~
r~ ,~~
~
~t
. 1 ~t ~ J1j~l.,.bi! w...J1 ' u..il'j u. . v---::
- I 4.J'i i'
rjA!.
:
.:u, ~! .wi : '-...aLM
c:.P~I
~I
~lMl ~ -,
~Y'J ~~
t~ ~4-l9 "( 'A II J-:::. .t . -"""""":! U
~i
, ,V : o>:!)
.::<I U~ . _. I L. ~~_.. 1\ U. LS \~ ..r'i ~k...r.II~I.JJ\
" .JJ~~
: a.ow, a.;~...\1"a.o~, ~ ~ - r J..,.it
~
u'il ~J:i..c~
~LJ -Li) ~
~
~
~(.:j ... " UJJ':') U~UIJ.JJl
~
:i..c ~
I.."k:. U:l~IJ ol;pJI ~l;i u-!) wWUI
I~
~I
~I
" (~~, ~A, ~ 0 :0 >:I)
l,H) w ~
U:l~\ (!~.u~
•.
.
~
~t ~~
4k1 Lit ~I
~
.)~l
u..! cJ.:!~\
" ~ ~ . ~I ~Wi.... <.r'.II wl:u...JI ..
: o\JLw:i O~~ . " u-! ~
wl.J-A'11~
.
<\i)' ~! ~ -r
'11... " ( 'f 0
: , • ~)
"~
J~ -'""~L....JI (.)-0 ~~
>A
u4.J~1(.)-o.J' ~)
(,$~I . ~
. (""
O~.J
~I
u-a~ yiJS"
~
y:illlll.\ u-ll u~
~"il " ~
. Jil ~
(,$~
wi ~"i4
~
~
~~.J
o~1 ~I.J
.ylc. ~
·eD
~ 04:--
.
i.aLa.:t: L.i~ ..
r
u..l ~~.J"
~\i j,JiJiJ A..i.J'lA.J~
:
l\ : ,
.J:!)
II
J~ if ..r~
w~ ~ ~
~
~
,~
J:!.>.fl.' .ub.l fit' ~
o.)~ - T'
~.\AIf ~.JA~
~YiJI ~ J.,....)I L.~ ~ ~ . ( ""~ : y.
~(,$~l
.JA
y\tl ~
~..,ll ~
~"iI.JA~ .JIt
(.$~l*)\
••
~
.J:!) "
(.
~l
~Iy.aj ~
~
~J
.:•
Ui.;c-.J
:J~if t.o,i ..,-.!.\AI' ~
,
o~~
~l ~l
..bl ~} ~l
. ( , l\: , .J:!) " ~
.\AI'"o.)oef.". -
~.JJ ~
fV: , ~) ~l . (f
: ,.. .J:!) .:.
iJA.).!(,$~l " ( ,.., : ,.. .J:!) .:.
~'J
~1 rl-l.:!" ~tmJUi.1f",
,Jil~!
.:.
.u~ wi ~1.J .
:J~.r,Jf u-::ula; ~ 4i..)&- ~
~I
~I
: ~~t ..
y.>"
.ul-o
y'il " ( "'0
" Jil ~
.JA.J.u G.i.).J ~
: ~)'f
JA.J' ~1-ulb.L...
~"il ~
o~ ...~ ~"i4
iJA~'i (,$~.J. ~,
lA.J:!
4J O~.>i o~ ~
~
: J.#. ~~l " o~ ~
wl~1
: ,.. .J:!)
0.) ~ ~
-,.. .:.
u+1!.J~.J" ~\i L.';
:J~J' ~~ ~.\AIf o.)~ -( d~~~1 ~.J'J~ ~ .:••
oli1, .u ~1
0~
r.lJiI " : JLii. y'il
. (''':
, .J'J) "';:'
~'y'il ~L...a All ~14".j4
,&JPS..rio-t ~'ylJ " JLii. o4-=JI~IJJ I.jM.".. . '-~'~~l>~ •
lAtJ. ~I .
I~l r.s.1uP ~J
""IH olp. ~\
" A
I~ IS". .~~
i""-', l>~~
' All ~1c;J
~
L.S: .:.
r l.l.iy~~~
.
IM}I~ tJ
tllJ
Ut
. (r' , r. : ". ~) •
: iJlf"-'" JlalJ . ~I .JA
I~
~
y)i11 U-tj
~J
J,Jt , u1ai
~
' UYJAUI u.- W.,JPS~I
I..,.J.\" ~\.i -JAUI JA~ ~jft
~
u.- ~ u.-U" .(Y" : t ~)" ~I
~ts ~\
u1d lA JS ~ J\i ~t ~
~)"
f.S~1r+i~ '''''li ~
•
ilJlI i.a~ : ~Ia
~JAUI ot...r-JIu..l..\
yjl4
lA JS ~ J\i {jL..ulIJ~t
. ( r" : t O~
JA.wt
~I
•
~"-"I
I.JA--J ~I
~I
W~JAUI i,St.) ~
_I_n - -~.:. 'I ~I. J ~L. I~JU,it ..-~ ·L.u"1 ~I~. IS"~UJ..,J:~ . ..':< ~I .r--~ ..• 'r"~ ~ wt 0)...., WJ:!JAU\ ~1 ~4-LJi" ~)'I u.:..~~I
:;t..,..ulfl.J. ~~T~yst
~~u...J~1
"_1_' r--, ~. _t.:. - _ '''IA'I~ (,.-r--
..Ai. • ..T"
'"
otyJ\
. J. ot~__'I LJo4
*
J~
~u.-U.U:!--~~ ~
I~ U . J r--.J -,- ~
u...a...,.l.i'(,,).:10.1. w"i,'
.' ~
<.>A.)J
. ( t" _t. : t ~) •
:jj~ .•••, IaJlf i.a~ wts
"l
~t
~.J
A.-.4i11.,. ut
t~
~.JA we-
" ~I
~I
.)jW ~t
WlS.c.J..e J,SJ. ~
~Y\)U~.>"'~'6
~1 u-J""il
~.J
~JA e:a y)I
All ~1 ~I
Iti. (Y,
~t ~t
~\.ij
I"'.n~6.
41 J\,:i" . ( " t - 'V: " ~) .)jW ~
~} ~Y':! wli ~ u.-lJ ~ ~I
~
•
: LatIJ y.;.J1
~LA..,JJ ~ c.J..el c.J..e. ,&4-=JI.J
:""0: " v~l ~
~)"!
wt ~
~"il
I~~Jit, 'y ~
4,j ~
"
Uti
. ( "V : ,,~)
~w,~, ~~, ~\
~I
yLilIJ
~,
~
~,
"W'J
u--a ll.:...J:! (j'lo;l~1 ~}
~~l
$w-.,
~
¥
u..! J.JJ l.A ~
: d..M-lyl
: 4:111 : ." .&\ 4..JS..l\uts J ' .&\ .ili:. uts ~ " ~I
. " ~}J~.J
J ' 4..JS..l1 uts ~~\ ~"
~
( , : , .J:!) .:•
J..,s (
JY"l)ll.Aji ~~I
~Jl
YA : " • .J:!) .:. ,
: ( ~*J.LI' ) ~, •• J\.i.i ~I
~ ~.jA d~
l.1S· ~
to .•. ~I .) Wu • c.r::-:-.
: 4-lU
~ .J-:} ~
..wI ?r_T~1 ~-
" .&I 4..JS..l1 UtsJ ' .&I .ili:. uts 4..JS..l\ J 4..JS..l\uts ~~\ ~ " ( , : , .J:!) .:. , J,bllli .&1Jic. ~ . -i . "I . ~ l.H f ~ J
~&.
..r""
~ J ' " (J"I~.."ll\ " ~U ~I ~ ~ 1iA. J .
t.- ~-':L~llJ
.1 '.:_11
i.)o-.I
~
• ~.
(J"I~.."lll uti.- ~ ~.J:! ~~\
. ( , : , .J:!) "
.Uj#J
4..JS..l1 ~jl
~}
r-yits ~~..,}'.Il
4..JS..l\U~ ' .AIJ 4J} t.SY"l ~.J:! '1
~
J.JJ I.A ~
I
~.J
-u'i!J '
uts lA.o ~
( f : , .J:!)"
~
~
I>
~J
~~I ~"
-,
4Jji} .:.
u4i 4J UIJ ' Jl.-ij}
.&\ y\4..JS..l\ul
~j......:Ie,J)W:.}
.AI)\ 4J)'1 \~ uts ~ ~
;;4:J1 w.its ~ " : o~,
UJJ
.&I 4..JS..l\uts J " : 4iJ f ~
¥
.J:!)"
.J
.&\ .ili:. uts 4..JS..lIJ" .uji}.J .:•
~"
. (••' : , .J:!) "
:'
~
. (J"IJ.u\1~ )t::JI
~ " 4..JS..l\uts
.. ~
(,
.I::W\.&\ -.:L~
.&I .ili:. uts 4..JS..lIJ4..JS..l1 uts ~~I ~ " : ~ 3">1 f ~
.. ~\J.l1I>J~JJ' y':Jl ~ ~}11
C!
" ;;.Jl+c.J .:.
(,ST"" • U:I
'1 .&\ Jic. Ul ~J
.AIJ u\.f:..uic. J .&IJ . .&1ue ~ : ~I
" ~\
(
-"
1...a .:. y\
JS " : JOf J1l> ~. -,
~~J o~f ~i ~ - f
~ ~
.JylIJ'
(.)-'lUll.J..,ilWJts'O~I"
:~
,0,'•
• (f
u1u~
IJ~
~
~I.JJ' ~
o~
~J
)".l.S .J ~ ("'" -\ ~I
:.dJ o~I Jw
~\..bc.1j0.# U:!~IJS ~IJ"
· ( '" : , ~)" f~
J o\!
: J-iLill ~YI
tb. J ~
_0
~\
w~Y4 - i
u~ yJI (.51, .&1 ~"i)
~~
f~.JL....::. ~IJ"
. ( , f : , ~)
y ~..uf ),;JI ~
~~
~I
4J
f~)-y'i\ 0A ~)
_v
~ ,
• ~\ ..>A~.J ~ ~~UA
' y~
~
~
(.)-4
~I
~I
oJ:J.io~
o~
•
: JlQi ~lwJI 0~ ~I~~W~~'J ~) (.)-'l~1CJ)~ ~
~
,. L. I••••••.• ~ .<,ij A ~
y'50 ~I
. .u~)u~~1
~.J
•
• ~,
~J111 ~.J ~I ~ ,JAA.'i ~ • ~. t._ -: ~ ••~• ~.J;
o~
u:l ~
~)".&\
,r'r':'
'ijU
f~J
'O.J~\~:.dJI~!
A...l...UI\~ ~
A
~I
t;,>~~ -, , r'r' : , ...H) .:.
CJ)I(.5Y (.5~1~ JL9
11\u1 W~J
~I
: ~I
"~I
~"il
Wl~I (.5~1 uSl. .u..;cl~1 rJ wlJ" (r'f
(.5~1~ I¥ ~
. (r'f
~I
t.rA ~~
(p L::!~
• (J'*::
:4Jl1~!: L.Ww ~I o~
W~ ~L;ij
~f
4.!.JAA W ~)u1 W~
w.JlJ~ ... t." ~Lc.~
. t. ::" ~. t. U·1 ~
UIJ
W:ll.J ~
0A
.
~.f-C! -"
4J ~I
'0 ~I
'.\.till w. ...)-" . II JU ~ ~
••• •
. (f":'~) " .&\ LHl
w.Jl ~
y"
JLi! ~I
4.!~
~.J~1.:•
u-1c y.;J\ 'O..,..! ~I.ii.i
. (f~:'~) :~
~~I
6J~Y
~J...j'i y)ll~ul . (' V: O~) " ~1
~
~ .dJf ~! ~i ~
w\fy ~~~
~~I
~~\
ulJ u'i\ ~
uts \1\ ~1 ~"
'i~~ 0 ..J:1.&\ U. . I ~111:: ~ WI.:!
~
J,.u.; ~1 ": ~~
~~)u1
t.,.hi!
~f ~I ~\): J..aJ\~Y~~\.J~·1
~I •
tA~
~~
y)1 JU.! ~
0~1 01\ ~~I ~.l.iJ
,u..iu . LW'J
u--:: ("'"'
(''':
0
_1-:::. U·1
~
·::<1 ..r-
O~)" .&~~
-r
. .J~\
~
Jl ~I
~Y'
~Y' ~I.Jo'o'l:
u'1l <.sAJ ~L..a ~l:i
~
4+-!~~
-UJ r-S1 Jj§l ~I
~l...J.. U~ 1rW
"~~~\
~l;--.!~J
~I
~
" ~I
.u.."....-
w~I\~
~~-y
Y.J
UY'-'lL.....JIJ.,1\ c.J--:IJ w~
l>-:1~1e::...P+-!
w~1
~1,jA':i1t.t:i!
w\~'J\
u-! l>-:1~1~
.J~\
*
J~ ~
U-;~\J;;4---::J\~l;--.!~!
. ("~ , ,,/\, "0 : 0.;:) : ole. Ul ~
.u Jill. ~ iJA}l ~ .;:) " .u ~J
~
y y. iJA:
~
Y iJA)
~ uL.:'i1 ~! ~l
-r::
J.,J,JoAl1~J 1.4~
JUJ~I~y4.l . .,1\ CJ-:l~ CJ-4yl " .u Jl!
Jill. y. y. ~
~
tS~IJ ~l.J..l! (-"'"'":1
.(f/\-So: royl
~)~.uY' ~ ~
" ~.,11 l.HJ~.,1\
~
ul~j.o u~J ' .JJW ~J04 ~ Y ~ w..,.J.l ~ ~ yJl
~
l.4~J-J
~
\1\ " : y)1
JU :
(f:".;:) 4,olif.~ /,..0J~ Wf 4J~-· Mr.--•.·.tf ~,rAt
-· ..·,,"'f...wf ~~ -:tf c-::-M
o'~
(j~~ M'
T -(
: y}J ~1Qi ":"~f ~ JjW ~J ~'11 .,11l.HJC:J
" ~I
I" oJ\ ~l ~l w.l41 ~ I.Jl ~
Y~
"
(" V :' , .;:)
:ySo~f~fo~4j~~~~~~ . ( i ~: i .;:)" ~I
.,11l.HJ~I
~t. ~l
-0
W.JC J li..Gl..l! LPJ "
JU
.
:~~,:~'J
: o~J ~I
~I
~
()MAAlIyUSlI ~ "
~'il" y1l
: ~Yf 4ji ~f
" fJ~l
uJ-ifiJ ~
C-H'II r-S.J~
u!-!"
~I
LJ-A.J~
~f
.ifi tS~l-
.( fi : /\ .;:)
""I
1
,
uP ~ 0A);1-J u:'i\ (.S..);0A JS " ~.l;l\
o~.u
( t· : "\ ~~~\
0A.
~ ~\
y'1\
-'=) " ~~\
~ ~ T~\ ~~'1 y'1\
u.JA~LoSu:'i\ ~\
.( "f : " ~~ u:'i\ ~
0
o~
~'i~ u~'i~ - y u\-J
~..,;l\~ ~\
u~ " ~'i\ ~
~.l;l\
u-A ~yl.;~\ --?-
("" :0 -'=)" ~ ~\.fil\ ~ y)U -Jl...w u:'i\- j
~~ ~" -'=) " ~.)
Jill
(.S.l\\ y'1\ ~~'1
\¥ ~\~~ ~ u~ .." : J-.l\
u:'i\ ~~'1
~ y)U-Jl...w U:'i\-J-...AI (' '\ : 0 .J:!)
o~, ~
W~
Jf 41 ~Y'
4Jj ~ W~
W~ W'~,
~-r
~~
:~~y, 0A);1 (.S.l\\ .
~
o~
~
.yk ~
JS t-!j ~ -J ~'i\ Y.:lo.:! y'1\" ( f"\ , f 0 : f ..H) o~ (.S ~ ul u:'i~ 0A);1'1 (.S.l\\ -J • ~~\ o~ .u ~'i~
~
~
.:.
" .dI\
~j.lI4Jl1 J!J ~".'lJ o~~J
U" ~,J3\ ~I ~} ". ~I ~\ • U~I ~..,• I •• 'I c.r . j ~ J; ~ Jill ~. .,.- ~I.c.r j c...a1131 .<j J JJ •.. • I~ ..;~I ~
~
: JSlQJf ~, ~..,1 LoSb~.A o~
~! :L..tLa
ll;\.J-J ' \ iiJ.'
J:..-J t~
t..JS.II-J " ( ,
.J~
41 ~~f
-, t : , ..H) .:.
. " tb.-J t.uu t~.."l- y'1\ 0A
: 4J' .JA
y'1\ ~
~
.JA
(.S.l\\~..,1\
~'i\ . .h! ~\
0~
.•
.:.r '~~i
~~,-r
~.dI\ " (' 1\ : , ..H) .:•
." JS ~'1
~ ~..,1\ ~1 J~ ~
~WI.dl\~\ • " ~.l;l~\
~
~~lQJ' -r \~ ~'J" ( ,"\ : f ..H) .:• o~1
.u uP ~ ~ 0A);1 0A
: a.;~...\J'~ ~
~ w~?I'
-£
rJ.u'i u:~..u0-A~ 'i (.SilIJ, ul~ 'i ~ 0-A>.J(.Sill" ( 'A : r' ..H) *
rjA~
" ~)I
.&1().Il ~~
~,;.I' : LM.aLM ~ ~I
~I
~
' ~~
J:H.J! ~ "
~JiJI
~!
~.;JI "
,;.Sj J.)J
J~ ~~LlA
: ~.". 'i ~
" ~lJ~.)"
ue 1..>:- Jy-u)llAjj
Jill ~WI y)~.u~
lJo'l.:!~1 -l4~1
-,
. (Y A : Y. >.1) ~L.J.ilI.l..lu ~
. ~.. ,:q ~I
CJ.-.4 ~l
~I
~
~~
rJ J"
0~. .(
ul.) 4J1
" y)1
I).)
jJ
~I
ue"
~l
u~IJ
~I
~~I
c...ri9'~J""-:!~
~JA
-'= lJo'l.:!~I -l4~1
y..;JI.JA " :
.ul u~ y)I"
:'il b
l. -
V : Y' -"=)"
( 'Y : Y' -'=) " y)1 : ~I
.l..lu .~.
I~I.S
~J
_Y
J\-:i!
(,)oil ~
jJ ' Wil CJ.-.4 <L1~ Ul ~4il1 o~
~
'A : y. >.1)
-l
~~I
~4-!" (
~I) 1:U JU LJJ"
(
_r'
y. : y. -,,=)-y ." y)\
. " y)1
u-il ~
w.it
W:ll.) ~
y.)
UJ..,Po.~1 ~I
y ~"
uljA
~
(lA..iJ).u Jill" (Yo :Y. >.1)-C
JU ( 'V
(,)oil~
-J
Y' -"=) -..)
0 :
"~l : ( ~
J~
I~
. ~J ~)
(.S""'IyJ.&1 J\.iJ" ~~I ~I y~
.u!J~l
~I
~..).ill.
J.::c:' ~ ~__ 1.:.·(.&1) 0~ ~ . ~.y
(jGWI
~'11 ~"oJ+:"
-l
.uJJ&I~l .uJ~~l .ul OJ+:! J=jly..al~
. ( '0 : r' ..,Po.)"')J")!.)J")~J
" ~~ ~I rjA .JA
~.&~
t~ : ~LM
O~)
~l
(.S fij
~~I ~I
11\J ' ~'il ~J ~l
~.&I
~J ~ " oJ+:" J
~( t.J-"'l ~~ )~"Y.)':'"'W .. _11'u-! t~
Jp. (.Sill u'i ~l JAJ
~jA
~b Ul ~
11\
I" t~
~.J
'i " ~ ~ ~I
-y
•
0A ~
" ~l;~
4,j'J
~
t.J""l:!
~J
.."e.,SjJ~J
~,
0'l.l.i\I CJ..r1'
.("',
~y
o~
I~
~I.JA
~
\.b..J:l0'Y~1
~J
"':'
~" t~"
w.o)
~l
~.JJ.l.iJ
~~'1
: ~.fi~.
,° : it'
f :
°t
'A , 'V : f t f V: I.,..; ) ~ . (f:
~I
'A tn,
r,
,r - " : i
W J.( ,f : ~ t
:,r
,
tV:
rJLJ1 -ul .:•
~ t'
f:
"
t if,
.H) ~~I
"
.J-A J .:.
("
u\..bLJ\ ~L..:. JAJ. ( ,
f ,
,r :
f
-e::
:"
.J:l)
>=) ~~'JI o~' ~IJ
JAJ .:.
('~:itA:0.J:l)~' . (f f --f' : "
t f f , f r : i .J:l)~ yJI ~ <.J.-ol o~1 (r
All
~J
JAJ. (OA : A..H) ~j'JI~J.
~ ~ ~l:J1
JAJ. ( i : , f t
t ".
JA J .:.
° :i.J:l ) otrJl j.P. ~ J A >=) rJW\ .J~ JAJ .:•
(''':
. ( rv _r 0
"0 : "
. ( V : '"
~
: ~ .J:l)
>=) o~IJ ~l;.il\ JAJ .:.
. ( "r : ) f "
~ : ".
ul.S..a
.J:l)
y)1 ~
.J:l)
J .:.
: "tl.MW~' ..~, : ~w • "w-:'" ~J131
~! ~
J.J-j
~l 'i! ~l
Y.J~1.w.i!~! ~ : ~j
~l
wLSw!
yi.U1 l~ eJA-J •
~,JA
'i ~~
Wt.,J:!
: wLC.oJ!'~ ~lr wwy,~! u~'i\ ~l ~~I
0A
Jy (5:ll1'1J
~~I
~l ~
~l ~
"(' r : r>=)
. " ~~I
-, *
~ ~ (5:ll1
:~~~, o~, JL:..iwwy' ~~ w~y~-r ~ J,S ~y
~.
uL..u'ii LHJ
c!...Hul ~
.." (
'0 , ,
f :
r .,..;)
" ~~'JI otrJI .u u§:J ~ ~ 0A>.!
*
: asJ~' Yj~ ~wy,~!-r ~J
"lA...JIUJY uYI c:J.4 r--Sl J..,.!tJ.:JI J.:JI II (
~~
II
0' : ,
.J-:l)
*
'~'il, u:, . I ~ 1_· UY~J _I" . ~ill\ UJ ~
U
: a.;~..u,.0 ~WYI ~! -£ ~} 4.:J'i ~t
u~'il
II
u:~ ut ulhL clbe.tJ " (
"V : 0
: ( ~, ~I ~.;
" C~I
.u.1,jl1 " ~
c...M ~.)
o~
~l~
~
~iiJl
,;.Sj .1l.; •• ~
~,J:!
.ll.. ~l
' ~I ~iiJl
~~,J:!
~
~l
J.Jf+ll.)~1 JL1:a 'i jJl cl.Wl ~l
c ~t
'iJI ~
J
II
~I
~..\J' l.:-o - ,
0~
(J'lJI.).lJt(f'
:,
.J-:l)
c...--=-- II c ~
.~
II _
"
~~
(S,F.t ~W4~~ : ~,
w~ J .l.! .u Jl.i! u~
: La.Mw
~J!J!.; " C~l
: i.sA ~
~ ~I ~
) ~, (SjJl ~l
o~
*
~)
t •••
A
*
:~~rJW~~I-r
.u ~\:9 . ~ ~ w~
otyJl
II
A..:yl..JI otyJl ~ ~I
~.lIj,,4-
~.
"ill ~ (
~I
u.:i~~I
"i , "0 :
ut rbt
.u J\.i:! ~jJl ~ . "JA
~t
wt t~
~~I
f .J-:l)
*
lil
~ JL9
:rJw,~~,-r I.l..J W} ot~
1)\:9
c..--=-- II ~W~ . -
••••
A
II
.& \ ~
-T'
A..:yl..J1ot...r-JJ Oyl....JI J,At ~.h •
t r--J _1_; ~
U
~.
~. • w'i
~
(
. "~
UAY
f"
: f .J-:l) l....U.J.ll.l
...
*
.l.a.J
.
. "~WI~
:~,~,~!~,-£ ~l ~\
W,it~t W!y:. J ~i ~ " )lj\:9
.u~l (J'l~
Lr1c. t ( i" : i II
~I
.J-:l) ill I
*
: ~l.!Yf ciLc ~f
~4-~
~I
Ja-l1I)t! J ~I
0A UJ~
. ( r, : V J:!) ~1 ujic.1 u)-u1 IJ~W.li
. ("" ll~
\)t! ((.)'l.illl CJ.)l ~j-JI ~\
~
J~
• • y •" ~ _~ . ..IJ I" - <:1 u.l! W.'1 t ~ uJJ-A
.[ r A ,rv : , ·
w~1...iA ~1...lAl w.itSJ .:.
u-o UJ~"
LJ ~I
J...u 0A -u} yt6JI
: yYf
.u I)u
~ 0~
~J~I
J ~~\
~y
J:! C?-I.J] " ~ ~
W
u-o
~~y
~JJf.dJf~!
~J\~
~f-"\
"0 , "f : , · >:l)
.bt:u.\j " (
~ L:..1 . . T~
1:U
Ji: rJ1. ~~ ~\
~h!. ~I
J~i ~ ~
u-sJJ .:•
0A~~~1-u4
yo I~ I)t! UJ..?-i. ~\.>A
0AJ ' ~Jb
uLSJ .:•
u..itS ~I
ll:U u-A
1:U I~
J.J:l!) ~I
u-l}
0A ~1 w4i ~
u1 "
~I
. ( fr -f. : V J:!) "~~I
u) . Ll...£j1Jh:i ~
u=JIll~
: '\ J:!)" ~I
Ja-l1I)t! UJ..?-iJ. ~I
utS u=JI~.;i11~
~\
" I~ ~
I~LS ~~I
: ~I
~ 0Ai "~~I
-0
I~:'_ •. "AIIu..i1~
U.lI:I
c..-::--
~ ~1 ~y ~1
u1u=JIJt,..u:.\11
: ~Wf ~! ~Yf .dJf~! ~f u:} ~I
w.i1~1 ~i
~
wI "
.JjW ~1
r-:.J-A.u
.:•
~t!
(
"V : , ,
-V
>:l) .:.
" rJWI ~} ~'i\ .&1 :~~o~f~.dJf~!~I-A ~
oft?1
wyiJ"
. ._0:\ G..J:iS u·1 IJJ-AJ-'" . ~
lli.\
~'il
~J:!
LA1 J. w~1 .
~.illl
J.,.i; (
1:U ~. .~ ~
. " ~H o~ ~i \~lrSJ uP ~
r, , r.: ".
- I ll~ r.. J'&I
u:l~I
>:l) .:.
l.li t ~ ("
yo
t~
$~I " ~l-..J\u- Jj.J (.S:W\ ~\
~\
~ J)i ~I
~I
wI " ..)~ ~\
.rA
.
: L.a.fLa JU .:•
~\ . (O':i>.J)
.111\ ~.
UA~
~W\
'1'"~J~~J
~yl ~IJ.
I ~ \-<~~ r-:-:: _<._, ~
••. ~W\ u-1!
''''iil~J'
w'}[l .;y" . U
y'}[\ ~
(.).A ~~
~b
Jy
(.S~\
( 'A : , >.J) "y'}[\ ~"
~,
y! ~~\~!
~
~I ~"
J~
. ( 'f : f >.J)" ~~\
(.S~\ o~J (.S~\
: ~I ~ ~~
~l
Ll.:...;:~.1iJ1
~
J.).J
. ~~
u-! ~1.S.l\o~J
u-9 ~
II:: ••• UI..:IJ.
'i >.J) " y'}[\ ~l yA>~IJ
. (" A , "V : w\~\
o~ ..
~,.&\
~
4.J~J
~y:. ~
u~,/I ~! ~~\ ~L.J
0A
.
~L.aj~1 : L.a.aL.a
iiJ• ooUoJ .&~WJ.S.:u~'il
• I A L, .(~L~ A!.'i • """-'.J'" ~
:04 ~~fU
~ ~•...••.•... 'I .1.l..I.Ju U0lA..l'i\ L""A
ell
,l-o "'?
• ( , : , £ >.J) " ~ \~U.l1l4 u~y
~
•
~~Y' ~
fUI " ~\
y.J
ell
Y ~
~.;!\~!
J~ ~
~W\.I1I1~11iS.\ . " J...;~~I o\.;:JI
" J...;~lolp. ,~
w~.;!J
.u ~'/4 0A ~
.. o~\J
(.S~\ " (
~4i1\ ~
( 'A: :~,
y ~ ~ ~ ~ J.S ~
.u uP ~ ~ 0A~
ul " ~\ >.J) " ~~\ ~! w~ ul9 ~ 0A1J ~
~ ~T ~
( "i , "0 : "
'i :
4.J~ "(
, ~WI u-l! f.J.,J ~
T' ~ ) ~,~
~~ ur ~
•
<\if - ,
J~ .:.
: ~~y, o~' ~! ~~ ~ ~~Y' ~
.:.
f ~)
-f
.:•
0A ~
fi : f >.J) .:. y.J J~J
uts 0A ~ y "'? ~~
.:. J
~w\J' -T'
y cU ~~• • ,~w\J'-f\o;;l
M.
wI " (
£ i : '" ~) .:.
"Wl:J\ ~ . UA.J..
.dJ o~
: ~~~~ \J~
~)'li~
'1 J ~
~
0#
f"'Lb:.i.!
0A '1 J r'::' 0A ~
u-;~\~ LeaIJ"
~H
IJ.l1J ~~I
u~~ ~ u~~, n" , '" : , -":l) .:.
(
u..,:u)oJi <.Sl.&1.::.'1)
".&1 U4 .
l.
L
~.
'-H~.)
: ~w\AJ' L:1.,J'J',;J U~~ ~LA .)4Jt ~
0A <.S..r.U y~I
• " ~
~
0Aj: rJ 4JY ~.::.
.::.! c:fi.= rJ tY'l:!
~
~ U~~'-'\
UY . ~
CJyl
~
1:U J\..i . ~
.::.! c:fi.= rJ iJ'l.::.i11 CJ)\
~t
0:1 ~~
: ~ w-o~ Y ~ 0Aj: '1 <.S~IJ' ~~t
o~.u ~'1~CJ-oj: <.Sill" . " .&1~.
ujj~
~ lit ~t 1.Jl4:iJrJ
, .&10:1 ~I
UY
:~~~Y~4J~~-V .::.! 0A j: '1 <.S~IJ. ul.~ '1 ~ CJ-o j: <.Sill" ( ,1\ : f .Jo:!) .:. . "~)I.&f
ul0:'1~
u-a
Jt,§ LAS~ 0A1 0A " ( f'\ , f 1\ : V .Jo:!) .:•
Ut U:!- jA ~ u.Jl4)oJi u\S. <.Sill ~\
. 0~
-0
u1 " ~I
y.)
: ~~, ~ tY'l:! ut 1.Jl4.;J ~
.uk. .. ~
( fi : f .Jo:!) .:. . l. o~ c..s..;; ..u: .,It
J~ ~ 0Aj: '1 0A
.( "f :
ole> Y -A
1\ .J:! ) "
w.JA ~
J .:•
rS4~ ~
~W" ~ ~ ~~ u~~, .ill 0:U loAtJ " ( f' : " • .Jo:!) .:.
-\
~.II~I_<::1 • -('-: I.r" ('I ." '\.4",.A,J..06 ~~ .r U~ J
: .a~IJ .u Jill'
.&10:}S~
u~
ok..::.W , ~t
.::.)yJl ~I
. ( f 1\ : '\ .J:!) "
.u ~
•
o.a~1 4.1~ : ~'-' ~ J ~
~lli
u-! -,
4 0A jt "
.
:~~I~I~:~w
Jf <\1 -
: yYf ~ W T~
~t.J.J'
o~
~J
~
b_..~~.)L...::. ~IJ"
( , f : , ~)
,
.:.
" th J A...u.,jT~..,l4,"l\.~~ I (.)4 ~..,1
:JJ~ ,,::J-:~I~\~
o~" ("
:"
.J:l) . ..,;-U
"o~)tj.y
0,»- ~ ~
~l ~WI J;~ ~tJ
(.)4U o~
~Yf~f<\1-r
~\
ul9 ~
y~ll.+.!t~t u..i~
~I~ ~
. ( 0 :
'v
.( r. : , f
~~
.J:l) " ~
.( rA:
'A .J:l)
"rJW\ ufi J:! ~~
(.)4" ~~
~
4.:i!.}LA JS.j:i ~l
~
y.)J~
~\
~t; rJW\ I~ ~.J" ~t "oAIJ ~ ~ ~t u..J" ~.uc. ~J
:~ ~
J..,.i: .:•
.
~~
~.u
o~-r
~ ~.a.l1~J.a.i.l1JA : La....w
:~ . ( fi : A.J:l)"
~Yf y.)
U~IJ" ~I .J:l)
~Jl:..i
.:.
t~ 4-W
: ~jYf
~ uts c.s~1~4
~J
~l
~
~ ~,J;
J~J
.:•
.:•
Jl9J .:•
.
,oILaJI JA : I~L& (.,""':fJ111 ~ : l+l.a.JSli
.
( o. -f V .,..J:l.. ) ~l
~
~!.-.\.till
~
. ( 'A -J V : f .J:l) ~..)AWI ~~
Leu...?-A .u!
_,
.u!..?-A -"
oy~
' .'!
."!
uLS
~
JA ul. o~
(.S~I .l.-.ai.JI~~
~..,?-A
-r
.(H:0J:!)
-J' : , , J:!) .JjW w ~ .u!..,?-A- f
.( ) f
. ( r r , r" : '"
J:!) ~.JA:! Ul~ j.o UI.S~I ~~
.( n, , " , .: ,r J:! ~ V,
, V. , '\ f : '\ J:!) ~
. ( r /\ : ,r , f -" : ,'\ J:! ~ n
J:!) wI JA ~
,,,.:'0J:!) o~)l,:j
~
. ( f : ,/\
(.SiI~.u!..,?-A- '\
0~
w~~
~.l:lo. J
tAjh!l~
: ,oILa.lI we'; t ~I '"
" rJWI ~ ~
" rJWI 4J
J:!)"
rJWI ~';
~ ~I
~.:J';wI rl"
~rJWI
~¥
1,.;" t!~ (.Sill .dI1 ~
~l.dll
-w.!..,?-A _/\
.(,,,,,/\:n ~r, ,r . J:!) .u ~.A-:!....• a\.A ~ .u!..,?-A-"
. ( "V : ". J:!) J,...a)1~~ ~
. ( fV:
u4 .u!..,?-A- V
(.)'l~
~I
~~
.u!..,?-A_0
~I ~I
.u!..,?-A-, •
:~
Jt.i-'
~I
J,...a~rJ..w'; " t IOJI .(,v:r
~.a~
J-iJ -" J:!)
I~y\ " ~ti UIL. •••JI th.J:!.u..e.~
-r
.("":'J:!) - ''''AII ~ '" c..~
.& 11\ ·1 _I-~ ~.:Ji' . ..r LJ r-J
~...
"0 JA WI JAI
.( f":
.u..e.,-r-J •. ,:, _f
f J:!)"rJWI~
~W,~, ~1J?'tJ~'~'~' • U""
A'I JJ.•oIlo.lI~ ~ L.-=--"
•••
I, tl
A
&~
.
~
"iMW {jl~\ Wi.J:! (.)"Io:! .1il1 ~.t. - ~I~ t_
~I ~J •
C 1.Joi~ Jlh..J1 ~lbL.... ~
: 4-lA .;Sli 0JAlA
4-:lJ
~I ~Ij
0A l}jiiA
~I
~
~tA
~I
IytS ~I ~ j'il u-lc ~I
: ~Ji
~,.wUa.&..!
: daub" ~ ~~I
..
: ~l
oi.) ~
U}._ .•. - w.i}1J
~
4.ilblw -,
~4-l1HI
~ J
.(n-Ji:i~) ~YilI~pl&JI~o~~:~I~ ~ ~ 0-:11 U.YY ~
.
o...,~4.i1
~
Wi...a
4L1 r-~
'i ~I
1~. ( " .r; ) ~~.,-.. yl~YI,
""..,! ~
~
f ~,
~I..:~·u •
( ''''
~ ~
u\
4.ilh1..w - '"
ol.J:l
~
: '" ~)
u1 UJ~~I
4J,>"",? r-~I
u-lJ
4
("~uLHJ r-~J
.~~H ~
o~~J
4.i1 hi
' ( '"
utA)J ~ 0Ai 0A. o4=JIJ ~I..;ill .JA :' ,~)
"
~~I
~J
U.JA:i
: ~Jl'J O~' ~ wI " J~ : o~l ~
u1i ~ 0AiJ ~
uLS
()-ol
tI'
-
f
>:1)
: ".
~I"I" .•..
.("i , "0
&...J\
')~J
: ~l;-o yl ~lQ..;,~
>:1)
-:. I.:. ( 0 ) I.l......l.:l. ~ ...~.J-A ,~ ,-,""",,",,,J..r;
: f ~)
a.o~l ~ ~~l
($j,\1 AJ~
.AIJ u1&
~
1 - _II·~
. ( 0
~
, ( , , ~ : n
HI ~ u-k AJUJ.....a ~ . lll~\
hltl'-"
~J!
.
.wUa.&..!: ~~ 4.ilh1..w 4.r J.SJ ' ~
. (i : , f~) " otrJlJ ~Yill .JA wI " ~1
J~J
-,
~I lolLS lolJ" J~: ~~f
uyJI l.S~ ul! ~~ ~
10!.u JtL
uJ
" .. ~
.)jW ~l9J oj
t,a.i~ u\.b~.JA
1"'4
~J'
ol~J~I
o)4.)J
~
-r
4.i~~,
0' : A.J:1) " ~YI ~l
(
e::~ . ~.)~ ~
.)jL....aJ"
.(ff,fr':".J:!)
•
:~~~UaW:W~
.." .u.~.u~'i ~\ ~\ -lS1 .:. , 1.-'-1 U'I'~ , ,\~.(.)A ul 1.-'-11. . lS'J ~ U lS'. ~ ~ ~ ~
tAb.~ ~I ~.
"~I
,
~I tAb.i U 'I'~ U
~pl
tAb.'j
.('A,
e::~J. ~I ~ ~J ' ~
0A ~
rl9 ~
, ~l;i11 ~ liA
~I -u. ~
.
:"j.tl~ ~
>.
~,
J~ , o}-Of w-o ..>...JU Y ~f
l;.>~~w\QJf
'V: ".J:!) A.j~
~
I . ~, ~.ft"" -::.1:.. .11
U UJ
.:.
.• ::11
~,
~'J+W :
~f
~,~
.
~'J
w! - ,
:~~, " y\:iS.11I~ ~ ~
~
rl.u t~ ~
o~
~s ~I uyiJ"
o.)J
.:•
. ( r. :r • .J:!) -'WI U·1 U""'" '·':..1w.J!0~1 ("'"
'It U.
J 0~1 J. ~
1._~ -0 ~~...;:--~~,
. ( r 0 : r, . ~, ~
.
~,
'I LJI· t.
l.r'. ~
~~
t~1
t ~J
~I..>--
Y \ ~~
~~...r'"'" ~L.......JI ~
<.. -::.I.:. ul . . '-""""""" ~
0~
, ( '\ .J:1)
J .( "
~~, ~\S
~jiS.JI ~I
..:...~;S Ueli ~l.tT ~,~
~~Y
.- ~
.J:1) "
~I
.
.A
• u-'
0.l.J~
~~
~
~
~ , ( , , - , : r .,.;)
.
Ji.o: ~ yJl ~l91J . ( i .J:!)
0
f - fi
: f .J:1)~I
r~~ c.:HJ
~~
: ~I
~
Jlh.JI A.j\
t,I,
'i -r : 0
(
~!
~w\QJ'
tl ..J-J'1·UA-'-'U I. >~._A u- J
~) yJ1 ~l
.)jL....a.1 ~l91
~)
'1 wIJ " ••• •
..lo,<.
tlJ
• (
Ji.o : ~J'
M'j,,'41\
.J:1)
I~
il\'
A...oIJ
~S'I ,~14
~ .JJ
~l ,,) ~\.." ( , '\ : ".
.J-:!)
,a, ( " . _ 'i
,ull 'J
U1i..J\ yl ~~\ LJ-A
J.."..:...")}\..,, , ('
:i ~)
f - , : '"
.J-:!)
. ( H' : r .J;!) ~lA..JI
. .."aY'.)~
rtJJ~'~' A :
..,,1( f r d
f :' , .J;!) .JjW
~ljl.." , ( '\ ,
~
r -f i
~I
.."t • ( 0
~
~l
: f .J;!)
~L....JI~~
0j
r,,)~
LHl~~
0
~'~
.J;!) \~
~
, ~ ~
0A.." ~
1". GS .u- .,,}---AI
~lr-f
~j'l
~~
,,)~
w..,,~ -L...:j,,)\.J1
,,)~
.('\_V:"
: ~~~ u~tu ~~ ~ ~
~..,,!~
uJ ~.." . 1$ 1~
ul.."~
y'l\
~,
'jl..". ~ y~I.."y'll ~ ~l ~..,,!.l.i..=a"~I .( "
wjS
~'~
jJ
wI I~jJ.."
: , f .J;!) " ~
.J;!)
~, r~ -r y.J J~
J\,Ac.~\
u..J ~ uJ " ,,)~ JLi.." .:. J\,Ac.~4 \~U 1$ I~jJ r!w}! ~l
)li 1$1 J\,Ac.l ~l 1..,,9yU us.!
.:•
. ( r A , rv : , ·
.J;!)"
.y!
~
~~~J~I $wl ~I ~~~ Wa ~~ .w.JI . ~I 路
~.~
~~I
o~ ~ ~
j
t!'~J~I$bl J! ;81J
:a.~ ~.J .. ~I
I.J~.J
~I
.. o..;W&:J1 ~~ u-i ~J..;.J ~I
).SJ}.J ' ~l
~I
.;sl .". lA"H
6.,;J. ~u"il
~.".~
~l:!'J1 ~
~
~.".~ ..;lSJ} "'.J ~~
~l
~Ji31
~L....lJ1! lillj
~"H..;'JI
Ub~ i~
I~
~l:!'J1 ~
u-i y~ ~~l ol.J'LwA
.. ~~l
: ~ ~Li~'O~J " o-l:! ~
Lo ~} ~
y':/I ~
JS c9~J9.J U:l)'1 ~
~
~
'.l. il "( ;0
ul U:l)'1 .)~ ~ "('
()A ~
~)
+:+
'\ :0 ~)
+:+
: ;
,,~ " Y':/4 ~
ut .J ~I
y':/I ~)
"~I .J.u':/I .J ut""
+:+
( ;. .....r.: , • o...l)
+++ +
u=l .... " ( ;
0 ~.J
"
( oV : "\ ~)
~"
J9 ~
" W;1~J
f : , , ~)
+:+
U':/l " ( "V : '" ~)
+:+
" ~ y':/I.J y':/I ~ ut "(
t ~t "("
" ()A ~
~l
~t .J ~.fililit " , " lfill
.J A)iJij.,,11
, • : , f ~)
~.fillut "(
A : , f ~)
0 , , : '0
~)
.:.
.:+ .:+
" UI.......4C. 'iI " ~~.J
~l
" y':/I " ~J
.J~J
.J~t
~I
~l
.:ut
~"'!YY
.:ut ~~
"(;
.:.
0 :
'V ~) .:.
~J" ('V:",
~) .:.
u':/I .J " (
.J~t ~I ~t
: 'V ~)
: ~4J' ,~ ~ JJw.w .atMJ .~
~I
u4':/1 ~I~.J'
u4':/1 o~
. ~~.)':/I
()A
~i JS ~ ~~.)':/I
u\.....:o::alj:lc.t ~
. w4':/1
~4':/1~.J~.) -"
~~I o~
ul~\.c.~J-,
~I
~\
-;
1;-
J~9~1JQi.l1 " o~ ~
$~
..
~
~.a .a.iJ ~~,
[to: t ~]
1 .'
'1 ~~,"
J.. ~~~ ~.a .MJ ~~, ..
"o~
1tJ! ';0
~
'~
~
~~~
~'~~'J
~~, "
[to:t~]
C;.J'ooII)I 6L..:'il ~
~~
~
~~! yUSh JJi UJ~ ~
~~_;'ll :~
ro : r
" o~ ~ ~~ ~ ~.l9J 0:'11'-;-.\:l.;! y'il "( . .u ~ ~ tA ~1 ~ ~} ~~ ~.yl} ~ .l.i u.NI f'bLA~} : ~~ • .JA ~I
:~
~I..)I+tJ~J
.&1~ cJA.ulJ . ~
~JoJ
~} ~~ ~ ~
I..Wa... ~! y'il
~
~J..)J ~I
~l:!\'1UAJ
u1 rL=- .JA J t.J-"'l:!
~ ~ T~1~'i
" (
~I~ ~
r:,r~) -"
~}J '
e:::y..
y'il "(" V ''''': o~)
"u~'i\ o~.u uP uJ ~1 0:'11 ~1 ~
~l
~.u YJL..w~ J ' y'il cJAJil ~
.l.i
~ ~1
J~
.•}ll
" ~.&I
u1 tiU:J...a oLbc.1J0:?U ~ ~I
J:1-)-,
0:} .u~~I
-r
U:!~
o~ .uy'il u1~ " (" i: o.Jo:l)
-f
".wl~~ cJAJSJ ~~1 o~
" ~1
~
~ ~ ~ tiU:J...a ~1 ~}" (": , VJ:1) _0 : ~ J..)J L. ~l ~~ I~ Ja.1J ... "t.,Fl cJA~}~ ~ ~~~"
"...~.)~I ~ J ~WI ~ uU:J...a ~~}
.~~I
~I
LH>U J-A
~~
w~Iyc.1
~
w'i~I~.u
j~.)
" (' /\:"
/\64) _V
" ••. t.,Fl cJA~}~ ~ ~~ ~ " ("":' .)) _/\ 0:'11UlIJ~1 ~y4J1 o~~~'il C~~J +
J.S U1 t- ' ~~\,j ~~'il
~
(" V:' 'y,o) - i
~IA
~
~~
J.S ~
Jj..l.:ij u~J.
~ y'i\
uJljJ..!J1J
Jj~1 ~
t:-J~'i
. ~y4JIC~J~J:1.)'i1
•
L-M.,.&a ~I ~L.M.l1:~Ji
: ~~~J~I : 4J ~
...\>l .uY yYf ~ wlS.W, ~
~lo
~ ~~ wi <::~I
.fb~'
~
u~U~~
~Yf
~ ~
U:l u:'il wlS.J f)
- ,
~~ ..}JI J~
.:•
. [u:~~Ajw~~~~
u.o ~
u:'il
wi ~
u:'il
<::t:h;'i J ' ("IJ~I~
~l ~ ~ ~~ JS 'O}~ wl]
.u ~~ ~
w~
(Y)
~I
UJ-ljL..-J .:.
y'11Y\.» l.J-4 '-i~1w~. Y'11Y\.»
. [~~'-il ~wl
u:'il w~ ~ ~
~~
JS
. [ wl1J..J1I~
'O.J~
J ](I") ~\.i
.u c:fi.:~ ~
J.o.ul ~
J
o~
: cUf~~ 'O~.u y'1l ul ~ .u~" u:'il J.;i ~
J~
u:'il
J J~ ~.("'\:0 .J:!)"Ajl~~
~I~. LaJ~ ..,;:...'1I Ajl~~ J
~
'O~.u wP
w~. ~w.o ~ ~
4J ~
..,1] (f)
wi ~I
~'O~I oLk.1 '-i~1y'1l ~ t~IJ
~~....)'JI I~ J . ~
.:• ~
~Yf u~u~~-r ~~....)'JI JJi:! u:'il ~I
.w1~.JA y'11l.J-4
Aj~ ~
~J
~
, Ajl~~
'O~I ~
'-i~1~I~J'
~.JA
'-i~1
'-i~\
.[Aj~~~\'y'~
: ~~J~I t;A ~
~I ~I
~ ~~'11 ~.;b,
~ ~~
~I
~L.QIji.lJ~
~~ 'Ojc.\iS] (0) ~U31OJ~ ~.JA
'i
!
00,/,., ~I
4lr31~IJi
•
.a.,.ll : ~~ J~
dy'1l 'J JI WJ~.J~ ~I ~
.J:!.J'1\
St. Athanasius : Drat. Contra Arianos, Drat. III Chapt XXVI, (26) P408, NPNF., 2nd• Ser., Vol. IV,. 1980. 2- Ibid: On Luke X. 22(Matt.XI.27), (1) P87 3- Ibid. 4- St. Hilary of Poi tiers : De Synodis, P7, NPNF., 2nd• Ser., .Vol. IX 1979. u\~\ , ojl.fi!' ~, (~ 0"":.,J! ~ ~,.~ JS, ~I wy.'i J~) :~~lo~""':; 4411 ~I~ _0 1-
. lo()"",
1,\,\0
~~Y,
nJY\
. [ .yk. WJ.)jJ.J
rA ft
w~41 ~
: ~,JJ .•}11~~I~!
. c:fi; ~ LA ~14,j'l y'il ~'»J
A ~I
~yo~..)c. u--=a~ y'il
Jil ~ -JAJ. ~I
(jA
"~-JA
~
"~~
J~
~I
.uIJL..wJ ' ~I
u--=aJ
~ -JALAJSj'
~ -JALAJ, ~ ~
O~W o~ ~
uJ4-M.J
-1
c) ~~'11 .lS1 , (J};JI ~\.c..))'l)oW
rA.).J
uYlAS.lI~ c) ~
" ~I
LA ~
~
~
:Y~'~~~~Y~i" ~'11d~ ~');.J'11 ~\.c..)Jf'~1
(jA ~
y~l wi
~J
~ ~ ~ W~.);.J '1\ 1A..>.A!
CJ.A J. ~~ ~
'O',\lll:U ~
J~ ~
wy\ Y
~I
(' 0:' i~).
.u4.1..l.A ~J.
. ( , • : , V .);)
c) ~JL..u ~
J ' 0-:),IJ y'il
, ~
.iJ!""l1
WI.lS).l wL.o.i.lIwl:U
j.;1..4J~
y .w-JAY ~ ~LS ~'1\j. ~)'l uti.....o~
~ ~l
i:>l;IJ
~..,;JI ~t....-:a..J'
y'il uli..o JJ . ui)\ ~
y'1l <rysl ~ ~IJ U-JA~.
y'11 tY:- ~~ y'1\ c)
. ~)'I ~
y'il ~.» ul~
(jA
-JAJ' y'il .
(jA
~\S ~'11 ] ('\) '-Joil.J:rWI~1 ~J111 J.;..i; .:.
.~.. l..~. •NI u.w~J [ •..•..£.h...
: ~\tl ~.".~
~ : ~\tl
~"
.J-A
Jc ~
Jj lA...S, ~';I y'1l w~c)~
~
~
I, ~.J::CJr ... .
~
u~
AAQ ~~
~4\t1JSI~ u-J.i ~
LA~ J ] (V) '-Joil~~1
. ()4 ~
4j
~J
~~I . -I
~J111 J.;..i; .:.
~I ~~'ll w}!.(' 0:' i.);) " ~
-JA ~
~
. [~'11 W~c)~\.J""lA Y LA.u~J
" ...w~.u 67-
JJJ:! Lrl ~ 1.j~1 w~ ~?
6 4\.~ WL.5. "
4,jl.hL..a" ~I
J4.jb IIi.) 1.j1110-:)'\
.u..e. J:j I.j:WI
J-A J . (' f: V I..))
"
~.J:y
St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Drat. I , Chapt. X, (36) P327, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, .1980 Ibid: On Luke X. 22 (Matt.XI.27), (3) P88 .
.v y .
. (YV:' y) "~4Jl1 ClJ.JYI ~ JAY u~ .wY" ~\J . (Y'\:V6.A) • (' .: Y fi) "uUJ...aJ t...au .J ~ U'l1.Jy\ '-:? ~I..." J.J'"'I)I uJ.J: ~.uc. JjJ U\5.]
~I
(A)
c~)\J
4431t.-.,1.3!J~ J.lhJI ~
OJ.jlJi
~\
~
uUJ...a.u, ~u
~Jw4:Ji ~ u~
J . (t
'- r V: t jA
.-9 .. I:'I1JUi ~-._11 ~u1...- .~.w ...,--~
r.Jj~,
~I
~I
~y..:;JI
u\5.J . (YA: 'i ~n
~Yt_ YY:' y) ~~)
(YA:A) ~I
~~
~
4 JjJi
W:-JI y.J
y-A
~
~I
~ ~
¥I
~~
t:!.rJUl\ ~
j ll...1- ~I
d , : , r 6.A)
,A,.j\.il~
UUJ...a.uCO;
' (
I¥ (y'JI) ~I~~
~
. J-JIJ 0yill ~ y~1 0A Ji\
y'J\ ue Ji='i 0:'11 J] ('I)
I!·AlI~I
ry: ° w-)
A,.j~
~\y'JI~.u
UI.5. J
~\J
'.J:!)~Jc
o,;.3! ~ ~
~
r -":l)
~IJ (A: '" 6.A)
~
u'l " ~I
A,.jl~I
Ul.wal tJ..fJ.JA (,JA:!~I
~I~
U~~J
uL5.J. (t t ,r '\ ,r t
u~.w
: lor'~1~.J
0:'11
~L..:.
0-A~..JA.w UI.5.J' (rt:'
°:' , .J:!) w.".JIJ o\+-:JI~
·._1
~
w ~I
. [('AJ'V:'
(' ":°.J:!) "~
~
&...JI ~D~
~~IJ.(,r:,JoA)
~ ~J
4..•••
uUJ...a.uJ . (Y i ,Y
~
, ~ \.J-4 '1\J
...-:IID ~~ ., iJ":!:""
ul0A ~~
~ , ~~I
,rY ,YA, YY:o~) o~I)I
..('''''''6.A)~
.:.
~
I.A...)4.:iJ:u LA jA~
) ~
ul w" (i:'~).u
~I
u~~
y)1
u~~\
~
uUJ...a.uJ. (' '_0:"'.J:!) ~I
~
.wI ~~I
~ 0A ~I
uUJ....a c.J.e J
~I
~ ~'il-lor' y.J J~
~I
~).l ~I
I~ ~
J~
llA ~.J
.:.
UY, y'JI~LoJ,S~ul~~,
~~~ [ oyill
y\ ~
9-
I.A ~ " ~I
~I
JIJ] (I.) ~WI OJ~ 4l+JIt.-.,1.3!J~.J .:•
. ,.0_'I,..,.,."~lu~)''' :~~\ •.l~441\~I~ _A S1, Hilary of Poi tiers : De Trinitate, Book XI, (12)P206, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,1979.
ul.l.llJ1 ,.jlfll ~'
(-.r.10-<;)l ~ ~
r-~
JS,~I
uy.)' J~) : ~~I •.l~ 44J1 t...1~ _I. 10..,.,.,
' ••••0 ~~",
"".J'"
. y)UL-~~~'i~}, "~
oUl':il . ~~ ~
"1
~'il ..u-.; I¥ ~.u
4.1G
J9l~
(y'il) cl1l~ ~
~~U~.
, ~~ ~ ~ ~
J.-JIJofil
d
~II
J.H ~I
WI.JA'i1 ~l§} ~
4J~I
.,. (
"':0 ~)
~ ..." . ~l 4.k:.
, ~~
J.;illl~ U~, y'il Wy\'i
Oyil\ o~ ~\.ij
~,
~yJl ~
~J
~ya11o~ y.ia:i ~I 4J#1
0A ~
.wI ~
~ ~~
~l u:'il
0A ~
II~~
y'il u.e
':il (' '\:0 -":l)"~
~y)U.J~~1
J-jIJ ~I
II ~
YJ~ ufi= \~J
. 0'-:11 y'il ~
~"
! ... ti;~ ~ y'il
0:' i.J':!)
y)ULoJS.u f'b W. ('
u'i , ~
(.).A ~
. [( "":0 ~)"L0U : y~\ U,;a.. JlAS ~ .yi ..A1J1"JA
•
.;I ~WI
JiWI .&1~
.&1J,ic.JA
' lJ"l ~)11 JA
y\ J . (' A: , ~) y'il ue Uiyyl ~~ ':iJ.11 y\ J . (r':" fi) II•••
u:'il
)4 ~I
-.J ~'i\ -[
~
II
roWlJ 4...&J1 j~ ~
'i} y'il U...>---':l.l.:l.l "1 J y'il 'i}lH'il u...>---:l.l.:l.l~
4jyt-JI . ~
oUl~4jyt-J1
~y'il
~~
~I t1A\Sl1 4j..;.-l1~
"1
ue ~~'i
, 4jyt-JI ~ o~ J ~
U:'ilj. ~1y.J1 ~
. t.r~ ~ u:'il ~l
~,
JI) (.).AJ ..." lH'i~Jl.l:! ~
~,oly.J
] (' ') (Joll~J~1 ~~
~
J ...II JU (,jill
\.l.\ 4j..;.-l1. (" V:' ,
u:'iIJ ~~I
. y'il Ul ~
lH'il
.u ~
~Ji3\ J~.\lA
y\ , ~)I
CJ.J~
WA) JJ.l.:l.
Ul <::~ ~J
.:•
':iill y'il
J JLi:lUl~ USJJ . [ ("V:' 'WA) ".u ul,y ul u:'il
uWaI , J,il.u lH'il
y'il uYY':ijj\ ~)I
y\ u:'il] (\l)(JollJrloil~1~Ji3\ J~J .[ wl§."h.J1
.:•
ue ~
11- St. Ambrose: De Spritu Sancto, Book II, Chapt. XI, (123) P130, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X,. 1979 12- St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat.II, Chapt . XVI, (22) P360, NPNF.,2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, .1980
.v t
•
(:}.s~ ~
AJ..;.a.J\ ~
J] ('I")-JJil~ ~l
c.1.JJ...J.A Uo"-:!Jill J"1.I",,,
.:.
.-: .. 11 ~\...i:l..J\ . [ Uc 0 .J~J.
: y~1 t..1.;S ~ ("~~"
JLi ~
~I FlI ~ y)U .uIJI....-~I
~l
~I
,-:?~Iy'il (".ft.;)/ '-H'J1(".ft.;)/ cJ.A .y'il UJA.ft.; ~
"~)
~ ~'i\ _03
~~
'-H'J1~\
.("r: 0 .J:)
~ .u ~'JI ul ~ ),ll~
J ' y'il ~I fi ~ . ~.Jjl
c.JJ"
t..I' ~\A
J~]
~I
~I
o~\.i ~ . [ U'I~
y'iIJ ' ~ ~'JI ~I'y'
0
(I£)~I
.Ji:. J ~
~
~I
y'il ~)l
~I.fi~~~.u:.~)/. ~Jill
(,)olI~~~1
liA
IlA ~J
~
I~ . "y'il UJA.fi;. ~ '-H'J1~I
.:.
(".ft.;
~ (":USjllu4- y ~.J: )l! , ~I.fill ~ 01 JWI
~I
,-:?~I'-H'J1~} ~}. y'il
.u '-H'J1ul ~.J:
J=a.u w.JCo..:l ] (I 0)(,)olI~J,,>.lA1
Uo"-:!Jill
("? W ~'JI ("? ~}\.J.JCo..:lJ. L.:a;l •
[ l....J'i1 . <.r:II
J.,,:i:J .:.
0-:!..l;!
,-:?~I
c.r:iU·I u~
~
.u '-H'J\ J] (")J# ~I ~ ~ ~I Oo3.jlJ. ~L:JI~IJi J.1u"", ~.u ul.5...,J)/}0.J~I oiA ~ ut ~)/J' ~,:?~I ("I.?'II ~ .di ,:?~ ("1.fi'J1 ~.u u~ ut cLi..;l~ J~Ol.,~\II!J)/.u~. uy\)U1
.:.
. [y'il
JA! ~ , ~
LA
~.u ~'JI u\S.J] (IV) c.1..)~'i1 uJ.;;S
Uo"-:!Jill J"1.I",,,
.:.
13- St. Hilary of Poi tiers : De Trinitate, BookVI,(26) P107, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,. 1979 14- St.'Gregory of Nyssa : Against Eunomius, Book I, (24) P66, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V. 1979. 15- St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chap. XIV, (123-128) P239-240, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X,1979. J~\' ojlfll~, (.). 0"~! ~~~-,..6., ~\ "::'.J"'i J-"",): ~~\o~~441\ ••.•.• \,)§ _Ii .10 V"'" I~~o 0C
r+y...) (0 JfJI") "::'6.6..-!, .;~\ ~Y.J\'U:...J:!~!C~:
V""',
I. ~
~~o .J:!L..U"~#I~~.;..,
.Vo.
~.J:!'"!
n ,,"I
u-lJfi~\ .~I:il\, (~~)I\
1.j~,!1
_IV
u.o ~~ ~
J:1..b:i.l1~
'J ,:?jj\ ~
u.f.= 'J up! ~All ~I.;S: th
f.ij'J
. [Y~
wtAlfll ~
: ~'il ~.J ~l
\~ u!J ~(r.:, '.H) "~J
~
~
olSj:. o~IJo~IJ ~u£l'
y~IJ Wi" ~\
~
~l
~'11 ~
~~\J
~\
, ~J
J~
~J ~I
~Jl,
~ ~'il...A
~4
OJI.)} ~
~ ~IJJ ' o·(jil ~ ~\J lAAl. ~~
. ~I
u1.JA~I ~
~
y\~1
~ ~I.J
uiil'c29;Q~IJ
wl.J-A~1 rJ9J y~1 u1~
t4.J~ "
~I
~~
y.) J.."i dlli
. (Y':o ~) "~t4llJA o~UJ~]
('A\.>-,,~~l ~J1l1 ~
. [ ~..;#,~IJw.j'\'J
~'1IJ ~~I
J ~IJ ~.JA~
o~J u-eJ .:•
u~ o~\J ~ ~'1IJ y~1
(''') csJ.1:ULllI iJM,JJ....;.iu...J;.
~'1IJ~u~]
Uo'I:!J1lI~.J .:•
. [O~IJo~U ~u1!1~ , y~)1
1 ~ .)J
.J-GbJ ~
~J'
.
. .J (,)0'=1.)~I l.,?
...~;II~.).) .'1"J e..r--
. (yr:y.j'\) y.;.1\ JU ~
~I
~l rtAl~}
~
~I
"~j
~ul~
~'1IJ ~
~I.i ~I ..
~I o~I)1 o~\.)'1\0:U
I.,?II ~
Wjl J~J4J~Wjl
~ JSli ~J .)b:-
~
~~
~
~I ~..
.ll ~
.J
~)lJ)IJ:i..a6..))
J.Jo""l)Iu-J~ .)tu.; ~'1I.J
1:Uu~ y..\~jy.;.11.u Jld"
~
. (' o:'\tl) "~I~ ~ y~1 ue- ~
'-J~U . ..) ~
~l
YJI,W
~J
~).a.J
~'11 U1J' ~'1IJ y)U o~I)1 o~I.)'11 olSj:1:UJ,S
~'J
. oJ\.) 'II 01\
:.v,~~ o~' (~~I
~1.c~'1I)u~~.)~1
. (£:'~)
II
4J
~Y' -r
c..r~~~~J~o~I.u~'11
o~I Wjts.y!" ~'11
ue- ~I
lh~~J~I1\~.J
18- St. Athanasius : On Luke, X. 22 (Matt.X1.27),(5) P89, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,1980. 19- St. Gregory of Nazianzen: The 4th Theological Oration, (XlI) P 314, NPNF., . 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, 1978 .
u.J-4 ~
~J'
4:i1~0~1.JA LH'ill.N U~
u1u-o~
~I ~o\.;:=JIJ ~IJ
ul Oh""J ~ u..,...J1U~o~1
.JA J
' ..&1 ~
.JA
LH'i1U~J
~I
y.) J~.
y':ll
. (i:' f.J:!) "~ ~) y':ll
~!~~
J.i" La~~
J:!).JI ~ ul t~.u
: If:ilj o~1 .,. ~
0~1
LH'i1~o~IJ
~ u-oiu-oo\.;:=JI~4i11~ ul " .)jW ~I \:iyJ.uJAS J
.(0:' '.J:!) "~uLa)J ~) ~liJ ~ ~
~
wi ~
~
~~'il~I J!J
~..:i3l
J ' ..&1 o.;l.w! ] (l.) LH'i1u.e. (J'l~~I
U'Y~I J~
.:•
. [ 4:i1~ ~
t~
.w!..&1 u.e. ~
ufi= r..l~IJ
ul5. u!] (l' )~I
0~1 u11:U ~
.('
ul! u':IIJ . u:~fl".JA Wb uts;J ,.u ~G..
'1'
(J'l~~I
U'Y~I J.;---i:lJ .:.
:r'~ ~'r': , V) ~'r':'1')) o~ J
\.Ai\
..>A fl" u.e. ~.P
LHt~1
. [(i:' f.J:!) "0\.;:=J1 ~ ul" J~ (,j~1~J ' o~ JS.~ ~'11 ~
~)I
~."J..".JI..J-A
lH'il] (H)aJ
J,I~
. [ o.l1Ju-o~ ~~ ,.u) u-o.u!' o\.;:=JI ~.JA
J~J .:•
Ui......al (,j.J:J+A
lJ"l-:!~1
~I~ ~ 0\.;:=J1 .uJ ,~I)I
c:H'i1] (ll')(,j.)~'il
uAJP
U'Y~I J~J
. [06-· ~ ~ ~
~ O~J ~)I
~.JA
~'il]
(If)
~I (,j.)~'il
(,j~1 o.lJJ(,j~1 ~I~~~~I
.:.
06~
uJ..»S U'Y~I J~J
~~
.:.
~ ~,0\.;:=J1 . [ y':ll (,jl , o\.;:=JI
20- St. Athanasius: De Incarnatione Verbi Dei, Chapt. XXI, (4) P47. NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV 1980,. 21- Ibid., Orat. C. Ar. I, Chap. VI, (19) P317 1979. 22- St. Hilary of Poi tiers : De Trinitate, Book 11,(8) P54, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, . iy\1:il1,~~)'I
we-Fo-y.. (l J') w6.6..-)'\"
1..i:..J:! ~I . V. ~''IA'I
C~:
t.jy:&.)'1 u-lJfi ~I
_H'
..>.!'-\!cY'~.".wI~'~}o . v,~: ~Ut"'yJl-H
~I.JA'JI~\!j ~
-UA~.
uUJ..JI -ill, ~I~~o~I
~I
. ( oi_f ~d 'Cf. :A..,J) (J'l..HY ~j I. .••~\....a
~
o~1
~.
~b.lJt!I~' UA I~
-~"
~
routJ. (' V_' ':V..,J)
.u~.::C:: ~.: ~
-:.1L.l\ 4.i~
~j ~b.1L...=JI l.,.ld LH~I~H .~..,....J~I ~ LH~I~
~~
~Y9 ~j
. (" ~J" A: 0 ..,;) "~.J.i:!.lI1
y~1 t~
~! rout
UJ
~\J
~I .JA~I ~~~
.,11
u'JJ
0A.lJfi,l
~'i\ J ](~O).u~~m~
(J'l~lfjt
':$~I~ LH'it! ... ~~'J\ J,S ro~ J ~
~ ol;::JI~
~~\
~~I
.J ~
\.;k:. U:!~\J ~t .l.!J .:.
~ ':$iJ\o~\
~
. [~~'JI
:o~y,,~~jl U'J .~
Ji,JI LJe
~~'i.lJt
pi~ ~~,.we. ~I
'ij fll
ySU La Jf" cO ~Y'
..»C
.l.llJJWI ut (:AJ , ~'il
J¥:- '-.H~ JA
, rolJ.lII ~
illtS
utS ~
'i ~]
(YV)(,)o'I~~1
~J1I1
Jii:! ~
~ ~
l.o JS" '('
.u y~IJ ' uWU ~ ~ ~ J
~.u ~
~.;.;J\ ~~
LH'ii ~jl
U-CJ .:.
0:'
l.o JS
rol o~ Ut ~
<iJI ~I
y~\ 0.J~ ~'i~1
y~' .lJ'JJ
~jl U-CJ .:.
y~1 USJ ~jl ~ ~'ilAS11o:U U~
JAJ' Y\~4.u....&..J ~)I " ~ ~
. ~I
, b.».JA ~ US-; rolLA LJ.A j ~\..Lll LJ.S.:l ~ J
. [y~1 ~jl.u!, ~~J
LH'i\
c.r:-~J.iJ1 U'J , ..'l~)1
J~
~J1I1
rn)(,)o'I~~1
JA
~ft~J.W\
~~
J,S,uJ ~jl '-.H'it! ~~jl y~I U'JJ. Tft ~J I~j~
LJe~
y~1 ~
i..,;)"
~.J--A
utS J .lJ'J
~
l.o J,S" J~
Y . ( , ':' V-":!) ( y)U
':$iJ\
':$t )
JI .J!~Io~ J~ 'i ~ T~j~ WI..'lo:U J,S . [ y~1
()4
Yl jlA..l WjtS
~'J ~ , l.o
25- St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat.III, Chapt. XXIII, (1) P394, NPNF.,2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,1980 . 26- Ibid., Chapt. XXVI, (28) P408. 27- Ibid., Chapt. XXVII, (35Cont.) P413 .
• Y 1\ •
-r
~l; ~ ~I
."J US: ~ ~ ~ ~ill
~I
OJ,# 44031~IJi J,J1a-J .:.
] PA)~I
~.u uts, ulbl...aJ o..,.!J~I.;SJ ~
~
~J.a~ ~ ~" -ul.uc. J;! 'i~II~
~ f~l' ~ ~
w~)l11
~J.a~ •
. .y.1c. f~~
f'b W.
, [ <Ub
lJ.A
o~ll...G J.S
~y
~
(a. ''':'' fi )"'4~
w~)l1\
't..-.:;..(JA ~L,
w.b.)l1\ ..T" ~
f.lJ.l:o. ~ ,.,
,Jj'il
~J
:"~i"J"~~"~~~:WW US:~ ~,!I Wts." "~I"
~ ~1A
~UL.. ~jj
.""~"
e.;ws ~ ~~ •..ii\ ..>Si3I j.S.;;
4-:i.".~J.iL:bJ\ ,.y~\C~
~\
-U."
0
cJ-4 olJ.i LA
~~\
.~"L...si.. o
.
:~!~~yi"Jf,~Yf~~~~
~.u
JlWI ~ . y'il w~ 'iJ ~-» J ~
~ ~ .u~"4Jc J;! ~ , (f:' f'i UJ.JC'ULS.. ~\.J-"'l'i>=
.J:1)
"o~ ~
~~
~
~
.l!J CHilI ~ •~
~
~
y'il " ~\ lJA
~I
UI..S.~ ~~
0~J
.~
~4j~1
f'1 wl...A:l.Jf'1 wby...,
~~\tl
o~
~ ~
J
U~. (fo:f .J:1)
~.1iU Jji.; \~~."
~l
J,S"
~ \- J,SJI
\-J wl~1
y.J u-c J:!.i ~
'-Hill o~J.>A.wi ~.
w\~ lJA'i~\ ~\
~
"~ ~ .uJ ~ ~I
ul..fi. ~ill j] (n)~~~i
~ ue ~"'p'1
~-»
c:fi.:. ~
'i \-J'i>= Lu ~)JI
. (' i: , fi)
~Yf -\
'i~I1il1~l.>A ~I
"Uts Lo..o ~~
t~tl
0 •• ':.
~
~~I
.:.
~~\t\
. [ ~~\tl ~ ~ ~))I ~ -u\ty'il
UI~1 , oj1fill ~,
(
.r.'
()o
~l ~
9-.."s. yS, ~I
":"y\'J J~) : ~~Io..l.#>~411~I..li -" II
. '" l.>'"
,',\,\0
~.J:l"!
""
,n
29- St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat.III, Chapt. XXVII, (35Cont.) P413, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980 .
•V~ •
~ 0.J~ ]
J# "r-~ JS"
"utS. t.- r-~ ~ ~ 0~J ~~II'"IJ
utS.~ r-~ JS " lAl) ~ ~j
lAJ ..!~o~) 'i~\J4J' ~
.u ~J.
~j
~4-bl1 (jA
Aj~I
OJ",w, 44031 ~IJ!
o.J4c (1". \~~I
r-~
uLSr-~ Ji:.
~
~
~j ,
o~
r-~
L4!. (i:' >:1)
~j ~
J4
C..>4!J .:.
~~j
r-~
~
.[~I.&I~
~~"~'~~U:W'
:~Y',ySiJ~'~.>.>',J' [~4~~~~I.J4~IJ](1"')~~~1 y'il J l.Jl" y..;-11 J.,.i
~
: y'il
yt. ~'11 UYJ. wyt.)llIJ ...>A~IJ~I
~.w
~ ~IJ
~'11 u11:u.~
4t
. ~I~I~ue
~I
~
~ ' ~I
'it. (i.:' ·>:1) "~IJ
y'il ~~~.0'I~.,ll1
l¥, ~y'iI0-"t:'~J!r-~~ut
Ut ~'i
.u ~~~'11
Jl ~I
~
~
~~J
y'il 0-" ~'11 o~t
J4
.CY.'1I.J~~I.J4~1 )U ~~
~
J.$ ~l
Jljj'i ~~ ~~
JJi: .:.
~Jill 0-A jA~1
~ ~ y'il
UY]
(n)
-r
Lo Ut J\ , ~
~\~J'~l.''iJI¥
J~~ .:.
~JrWI~1 ~Jill
r-~YI o~ UYJ. ~'11 ~r-~Y\
J.S
JS.uy'il
Jlj.:
. [ y'i\ ~..,1t~ CY.'1\ ~..,1t uY . t..A;t~ ~
~~I
J::!
(jA ~
.w'j\
o.".e.~~I
J ' 0Yj A.:jJ'i J J)l:..
~I
".l.]~
] (1"1") ~JrWlJ..»'1 ~JilI~..J
.:.
.u lAll.be.t... y'il ~..,1t JLoS ~ •
[•
. _':' •.<.
.JJ£A~~f
, i V'" ~L..JI~yJl
:i .. I'JI
: .:.l~1.~~
~l
4411U.li
_1".
•
31- St. Athanasius : On Luke, X. 22 (Matt.XI.27),(4) P89, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 32- Ibid: Drat. C. Ar. III, Chap. y..xVII, (36) P414. nd 33- St.Ambrose: De Fide, Book III, Chap. XVI, (133) P261, NPNF., 2 • Ser., Vol.X,
~]
~
~~
oJ~...,.
(n)~
~ J ~\
~J
~
~
~
~
~~
~
~lh,J1 ~ ..~
) ~~
"
~
J.S ht ~,!I ut ~
~ ~ us)\ ~
..~\
LaW1 ~I.ii .t 61..
~t LaJ,
L,...t
~
"t..JS.
u~
~_Al ~
~!! ~
~~ ~
ut O\J:ac.t I.jt .. .>A
•.. ~~J.
~
~
~~
~
: y>-T J~
~ ~
J:ac.
~ ~~
0.A
~
c::: .JL:JIfl\.9
' .yk.T~~~
JQc. 0A ~I
~.l;J1~ , ~ ~ ~.JYI ~I
~~~ oU.A C:::.JL:JI fll
~
~
~ ~
~
~~I
Ji,J1 0A oht 1.j~1~WlIJ. ~
o~t , ~
ut UJ.,)J~~
~
0A ~~ ~
•••
r.1~
~t La ~ u~.J.=~~Y\ J .. ~I
~
..
../il uJ J~
J.S ~h
LH?U~~
~t
~
.>A
.:.
J,bJ\ ft ~
~Wl\ 1:U WJJ
'
.w
ut UJ.,)' J,bJ1 0.AQ'1J fu LW\· ~u'lS. La ~i oUt~<.r
I.. ~
:~UJ~, .:. ~ ~
J'~
, -..I c:fi.; ~ ~
-..I~t
J.u.JY- O\J:ac.t .~
J~
~J ~t
ht .wJ J~ ut ~},'j It'; JA . oU.A u~tJ WJ ' ~
oU.A
.li yt I.jt '+i.JJ T~
J
O~..)c.
T.J.Jo"ltJ
JL:- !! .J.Jo"l~1 o:U J.S O-.HtO\J:ac.t .li Q'1J ~.wt ) . [.yk. ~~J~\
.. 11.J'O U""~t...~.>":
.,\, ·
~1:il1.J~4411~1~
_1"£
: W-4b.Y.o 4b.lo W ":r- :r",.. li..\:>L· "I.Jo! YI -f ~I
.).....::J J ' e,jLa)1H~
~
~}J1 ~I
,:?~I .&1~)
~
~I
JA
~I
~ ,.&1' UA '-r" -;11~WYI . t:~. (,,)'lWI.&I· "F. II \1i6.l.ih1 . ~ ,---;oJ ~ u.J1 ~. U"-'o:l. J ~ ~ ~ JJ " U L,..j'il • -u9 ~ ". tc:. ~ .~~. <::1 ~ . _I.:. .11 .u Y"~~~. .<1 ,. . Ie" o~1 ~ ~. ..... .-i -uJ1 ~.l! .&1 ~ ~~ ~. L-J. .
~.J'""l\..j~
t...AJ1 . L..u'il• ~U
. _I.:..
-u9 l.aJ .. <11 . _I.:.. ~ . UY" ~r...r-J
<::1
~~J.
J~
J,S] (ro)~jL.JU31~J-l....)~~1 ~Jijl
~~
llA ~J
[ Yl jl ~.u J\..a&:.l (,,)'l.J~ y'il ] J.#
~
lLII·I-.w
•••••• c...JoA'"'
(,,)'l.J~
y'il
•
;J~
LH~
.
'iL •.
e,j~
JA
~'11e,jl 1:U ~
y ~-:.I.:..UJ.S -:.1.:.. ~ J.~
. [( "0:' A~)
~!\'.w
~
"~uA.JYI d'-.;j" .u)
~JA'i.w JA LA
u.e ~I
~ ~
~
~
A,j~.ll4
.u ~
f~l
~
~'11c.Je
~.J-""l\..j
JAJ
A,j~.lll J5 ~l
II ~
y'il e,jl,:?l . "~A,j #1 J.S~l
~
L....1JiCAJ .:.
'Y) "~Yl ~0:!~"
J+!. ( "":0>=)
c:.H'I1c.JJ J~ W)J.
(,,)'l.JLy
La ~~
-:.1.:.. ~
y'il . c:.H'I1~~
~'1~JSjI c.J:1~4.iS.lJ. (i-f:"
. y'il ~ ~
~J.~
44JI
i:' fi) "~ ~.uJ~ J,Sllll Jt! ~IJ. (": h~j.c)·
(" f - " " : , "y.c. ) ~I
~ ~l ~
e,j'S.J
~l ~J .:. . ~I . "I~. WYI JSj~Uc. . [ u:. ~UA~~ ~
':? ~1".u.e.·UI',.1 ~
e,jjJ • ('
.ul ~~J.
.:.
~tA ~JA'i o~\j (n)~~~l
y'il] J#~JA)l!1 O)~lll:u. (rV)~WI II •.•.
<::1 ,
~J ~
J!i ~
"
r4.i11
'i y'il"
.~'11~.;b
c:.H'I1c.JJ: .JLa::>l~,
..,l)jL..ail1 0A ~~I JlW.yi ~ ..1.~I ~1.fi11 ..,lJ JA.!I J ,:?..,Pli 0A J ' 0 ~l ~) ¥ ~I
..,l)u.....:J1 0A J ' jL..ail1 ~
~
11\J . ~."wl
0-AJ ' 'O..".ill
~l
J
. ~~I
~~Y
~l
~'11~~I
<\.,j~
~~I
JA
35- St. Gregory of Nazianzen : The Fourth Theological Oration, , Chapt .IX, P312, NPNP., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, 1978 . 36- St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat.lII, Chap. XXVII, (36) P414, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. . ''I (.)0'1 ~U t"'joJl : ~~I ;;..l~ ~411~I..l.i -rv
.AY.
: ~~
Jf ci~..>J,~Yf
("'0:'" ~) "c>~ ~ ~~ LA J.S.wl~ ~.u c:..H'J1J'wy\~IJ
y\.,;JIJ ~I
' ~~
. J"4'i~
j-'J' ~
~I
CJ...r11 ~ J -o~'i~
~I
c:.N. '-.H'ilu~
w ~~J
~I)I
,
,
~J.-.:!'i y'lU~
y\~1
c:..H'i1~
~
y'll 0-A ~
~
.;41 114:i ll.JHoflJ ~\.ic. ~
-o~1 ~ ~.
~J ~
u~. c:..H'i~ 0-A~ ~
~
~\J
~\S J -O~\J
J.S~
J.J7. .i. lAS. -0~.,:11~ .
l.? .ll..J II ~.dll
u:tU ~La
~
l.?1.~I
u:tU ~ ~
~J'
y..-; ~I
JJb. ~ y\J
J\-Ac.l
J.S tY .J~ l.?1,
~ r-I~I ~
~
tY.J~
u1.dl1~
~\
ll~ ~
.
~J
La ~. y\ ~I
y'll
~ I..i.\ .llll ~
'-.H'JIUJ~ u~ J
~J ~ ~jI ~ . I·-:I~· "e-'
, ~ ~~I
• ,
w\i...a 0A y)U
u1l.?1, c:..H'i1 ~ ~ r-~
~ La u1-9~'-.H'il~ y'll 0A f"IJ~1~ J ~ u~ T~.J~
II
("£:'..,.s') ".dll-o..,.!"y\ c:..H'i1 U~J. (H':£/\;I) "w\~1
. (' ':' V-':1) ~
~I
~I
~
~I ~1
•
~.J
yYf
jA~1 ~L..a.:..l.?~J
~ ~ Yy\ ~ y)U LA ~
>..
~
~'.J
~ ~IJ c:..H'JIy'll J
. ~.u ~ rJ~ ~~ rJ' ~J
•
e l' aU.JF';; ,,:
(JA
r-~ ~
~ ~. >.11
~~'i ••
J.S~ ~
wl..>¥JIJ ~I
..~
y'll
c:..H'i~
fi "",?,JI ~I
J,S ~
Yi-:!.J
c:..H'J~0-A~ u.JtA)J-"l1 ~ ~~~I 'i l.?~IJ ~~1 -o~ .u c:..H'i~ 0-A~ l.?~III
'i 0-A J,S ~ LH~ ~IJ.
~ -o~ l.?->=
uJ c:..H'i~ 0-A~
. (f'\:f -':1) ".dl\ ~ .(jJf ...W:~
cUi, "t~~! ~~ Jf ci~...uyYf ui rJL.:~, ~ .(,..: , ,..~)
(f.:' '\>:I) r-~
~
rJWl Y\J'
. (f:"fi) "FIJU:JI
("
j~~~~III
II~
£:'..,.s') .dll~ ~J.
II
.dJ f ~!,ru> y\ ~I
~I
(' ':f -':1) ~~~.J
•
r
wiUlbJ....J o~i, . ~}U
Jf ~i..u
4i~JJI
~ lw\.>i~w\.!YyYI"
(rv,rr:0jot) \)W~I~! ~)~I
4.iY0'lw\.!
~\) ~J. ("r': '" '-;-lC ~i:r'J.J~i:o. jA) uy~\ y\ Il~J.&\
~l
Y ~'11"~ JLi9~.&I
LHly\ .wlJ' ~l
~ y\1..l:J1.&1 y\ .wI~~I ~
.( "":0~) "~~.J-Y~l J.,dl u-o Jd ~ ~ .J-Y~I J ~' ~.J-Y~Iu~ y)U
.l.:l.1)1 ~I
..>A
y:J1wu...- U..o ~
JS. ~l
~ ~ T~l
~'11u1\~ ~
~
~~
J . ~l
~
ut.lJ...JI J ~I
~
ll\.k.l" ~\
~.J J~ ~ J . u~'11 ~l ~
(.)-<l
J
~T.l.:l.l C>:!~ Y
~\ ~.~~ .,11 U .~
~
J.
(,,)-'=I
oUI,)~ ol:->' 4J yYI
u1ti~
wi W'''
. (r'\:ojot) "4jl,)
~o~.u ~ ~I
WAbLA] (f")~WI OJ~
4411 ~IJ! JJi: ~11~<b.~~
.:.
. <L..:il~ ~ o~.u wl . .u.':~.bc.lJ.y1c. ~..P ~ ~ o~1 ~l ~I~
J..,i~ ~1 u~ . (t:' ~) " ol-::=JlW,j\S
~ ' o~1
y\
r1jW . ( i:' t ~) "o~IJ ~IJ
u-o ~
~LA ~ . ~Wi: wLA LJJ. ~l
~J'
.ul~~ ~ ~
~j'iI.u~~~j'illl~~JJ
.y.! " ~\lS.I1 Jr-i
~1
~..;-b11 y\ Lil" ~I
wl. 4Jc, ~J~ o~.u ... o~1
y\
.ku
<..H ,o~1
. w..J1 u..il' diU1 ~..,>JI: ~Cill'~~ 4411~I..li _fA ./\ 0 •
WI
~ .&1~~ . uW!U ~l .J~ ~
. (" v: 0 ~) "u~'11 ~l AJ'it...c.;l~
~ ol:->' 4J w,sJ wi ~i u-?~I~i~..\f
~'1IJ
y\ y:J1wu...- J,Su~ ~T~
~I ~I
. IU '~.u..J-"-'l. li.J<L...a.JI.A, t.J·1 '.. '.11 0-:1. ~ .J ~t.j
~.&\
~l~'11u~ t.j.?l ~u
~ .J-Y~\ JS.~l
o.J.l.il1
~J.
u'i J . LH'I\ UJ~ T.l.:l.lC>:!~'i ~'1\ . LH'I~ C>:!~.ul~
.uJ-'"lu ~ tA~1~'1\ u-o ~
U:l~
.ul~~ .u (fi.; ~ LH'IIul ~
. ~./11 J\Acl u-o ~IJ ~
.J~ ~l
•r
•t
~ y'il u-aJ!t ~
CY.'i1 J'~
0A~1~~~~~"
~I
~.u ~'il
y)U La Y.JJj.~~1
~U11 6-A
: ~.".~
~u:u~.J~'i
~J.
~b
. CY.'i1 ~ y'il 0A~IJ wy\)t\1 ut ~
t.."J
~..ra--JI(.)-A ~
~J.! w'il •
"LH'i1'ij y'il u
.
•NI f
• ~
~.w
y\ 'i ~
~
~I)I.&I 'il..?-' ~l ~
~r-:J\.!"'il ~
~..)o'l-'\ ~
u-c
.J-A~--
JA:!
'i ~I o..)J~1
, ~li.\I.&1 J,ic. , (.)"I~)ll , ~I.JA
~
Y!"
..)o'l-'\.
..)J.~)W
~'il u'i y'il uyy
(J.J' yyl (J.J.w'i LH'iIJy'il u~ ~t.u.e.
~I
JA:!
~J.
(":' ,~t)
J
.J¥:- ~.JA~\
~l ~
~t.S. ~'iIJ'
(J.;.11~IJ.
"'-rF1
\.1\ .
y.J ~);! ~
~t 'iJ . y'il 'il LH'i1u
'I ~ . u..- I-e-'~.J-A • i'i A.J
~~~JS~c::J.;.lI"
~I
~~
~u
j'
~G.:iA .
~\j
~'il uyy
JiL,J1.&1~)
~~I
J~IJ~I
. (' ':" fi') ".&1 ~~l U#J ~
44lJI ~~I
c:.F-~.u
y\
'i ~iiJii.,.
Jc. ~I
. .&1y\ -u'i ol.J'"'l ~l ~~ w'il . (:A o~1.Y-II~ ~ ~ y)U l1i9~. ~
~ ~'.J
QI .J.. I~ • ..,J
( "":'
~ y\ 'ijJl
'-rF 'ij y'il ~j
'.J
*)I.~'il
. 'il . l...H.
~"v:''~)" ~I
J~.
~t
~I
J~J
Lol
~'i\
J:!...rb u.e
. (' A: , ~) ".? .JAy'il
~l rl!yJ
~~.JC
~
~ ...
. (o,.JVJi:'£.J:l)"y'iI'iI.J y'il ~
CY.'i1 c:.F-l1i9~ U~'iy..t ~li 0-AJ
. (t t :i .J:l)" y'il .y~ .&1~I ~I
.J-A ~t'! Jj ~
.u~ y'il0-A
~1.JA
"wl~1
UIJ' y'il
.u u1y ul ~'i\ ..)1)0-AJ..." .u~
. ~I
'iy)U.ui~
. .h! ~t 0,>= ~ .&1".u.e.~ 'ijJl
~y ~l ~ " ~
J
.lS);! ~
WI.~. ~L .a w'il' (>C \.l:j! ~
'i.~1.o~t.J ~J -ujyLi u'il u-aJ. ~t
"~\
~I
~~
uly.c.'ill~
rJ J ~l J:iJ Ut ~l ~'i
~ (.)"I ~ (.)'l:!~1 ul.p-l ~ J Ul~I
~'i~1 '-rF1 USl~u1y~wJlA:JJ
y.J .lS1.liJ. (' i:' i~)
"~I
U.J:l~U~Y~~}a"
.('V:'i~)
. (1A:r A~)
.~49 ~
I~ J\.!] (,.,)~,
,.J.ub. WJ-W.J. ' .<-: 'jl ,J,l!'I..J-'l
yr
~~ ~
J~-»c .u~
~
~.;JI .J~j .lJj~ ... ~
L...al.
~
u~.u
l:!~I;;~
u1 ~.J~I
(ii:'
~
~
J~ LoS , ~~I .
~~
~411~WI £G.A)
<!'yi-j HIJ ~1
<!1"p-jJd~'~~~o~utbL.J\
(Yi JY Y:Y'..H) I...;~';;~
~ (.)4\S11 y~1
u~
u\.S; J . (ii: '\G.A) ~~,
WJ . .u-,,""~~J.,Q~'.u~'j ~.u'iiJl ;;~
~\
w y\)U U\.S;
"~U=.. ~;; .J~"
.u~w'j4-~T~;;~~~IJ.
(A:' 'GA) ~~I
~
.:YjA) "... y~1 ~
~
'. <I ~, .. 1 r..>-'"' J
~.uJ6.LJ.A~1
JA .us!J ' J)il ~
~1.u u\.s;. (£ A:V ."J)
4.:l..~
~'
~ uSJJ"<!.,.lW' ~~ ~ JU W ( ,
~ ~I
Jji.; ~II~
.u',~ <. I' - I~~ L.=..1 .wlli.\
~IJ-"'l: .uJ-"'l~ ~
JUwJ.
u~
443' ~,~
&J~
Ii.\J. (v:y~).wlj~ul
u~'il '-H'iull~ ;;1.;--Jl
~Lo-Jf~ ~lbL..J Jf ~! ~~ II • v
"w".JYf ~-'
ulbL..Jl f"'lLbe.l ~IJ'
UI..bL..JIIi.\ U1 ~(~l) ~
~U-}'UtbL.J1 Ii.\
(J'lJ-r.
'.:.11(J'lI~I ["~ ~ ~ ":•..LdlJ" .J, 'i .J~..r-"
.:.
1ja
,~W, _~Qi.I'
"~
~~, ~
LIt
~!~'! "1 ~
11a! ';O~,
"i~~,J.aij ~ "
(JIt ~
~~'J[
,o.:O~] : 4.t~
C~;11
lJA~WI
~ .ldJ1 r-Ijl wi
.~ ~
~J')JtA,
~
wi c:.>:'il~
lJA~
J~I C" ~I
~I
'i r-SlJ)I ~I
~I
. (' '\:o~) "~c:.>:'il yil 'i lil " : ~I ~ l.;i'
'IJ'~!4
~I
y,)
WW~~,)'i1 ~~I
~
I~ ~11:~~
J) .". J C~
wL/ll ~CJoA
JUJ tJ-'o'l:!
y~t!
W~, ~
~
'I' u4i ~ :y~ y..T u--i
'i ~~ , ~te U=:U#J0;!JI~I
~,
~
' ~I
~I
w.".'i 'JPI ~
~
W~~,)'il
J.",i;
" y~1
tA 'iJ ~
y'il ~
. (r.:o~) .ylJ I~J
~J
,.;Ipo ~ ~'ll.:lo. ~ ~
J')J .uJ
~
CJoA ~I
"~)
i:?:U1 ~
~
wi
u-!J
. 'O.Yi1' ~J~I ,~
0;!~ lJA~I
.~~,)~I
w~Ijic.I
~I ~LWI
(,)'IF
wi
~I u-k
~ FJ ' ~IJ
~y'i'JY,)J'
'0 ,).."...-1Il.l.AtAl ~
~
J
W~~,)~I ~..r1 ~I ~u.JI ~
c.sAJ ('").J(l).J(') ~4'i1li1~
~te oJc,1jl.l.AtAl ~
uY"lJ
l1.4tAl . - i.,P" <I (.)"""'"' . -:III.i.\ ~ .J ~U WJ ')J ~ ~ll ~.."......-.. - _:11.l.rr.-a. Lo J . ~. _: 111..j, ~ ~
· ...."~I '"1"~ I~~~ ~~.Jl).)~
\ .'J"C
••
U U;l"=I __
II
1. St Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book 1,(30) P48, NPNF., 2nd• Ser" Vol, IX, 1979.
2. St Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chap. VIII (68) P232, NPNF" 2nd, Ser., Vol. X, , " o~,
,'\ '\ 1 ~
''" I"1Jro wl~\ , ijlfll
~,
~I
<:'.JA'i
J~
:~Ii..l.#o
4411 ~I..li
r
: ~~j.a.J~' ~.,8
~Y' u4 u~~
: )~ Y 4i! Jli 4iY ySU ,l-o~
u~. ~ ~
t:J-l'/I.Jy'il o.Jol!J
o~l.J ~
,'~Ll.o)'l~t--.j • ~ U""':!
U ~..,'6,)' .J. ~~ ~
:~Ji
~'~Wl'
••
](t)~~
l'Ji ~
•,
.:.
••.•
·1 ..
,i.)' t.:.H . ~I U...;-; •
.1
(JA ~
[ ... ~y'il
.u ~
A)' " .u.~ ]
~.u~"
(O)~
lll ~..J
~~
.[ ~~.Joy§A..1ul
.:•
•••
~.J . .J»)'.Ju~
:~~YY'~~Y'u4u~~ [~ y'il ~
ul ~
~1' O.:l~
ul.hi! ~
~~.J~~I
~
l.or~ 1.o.J:! ~
~
~\j.b:i. ~.
o~
lJI J.ji;
.:.
~ill ] (V)~l UJ.JjL..J
.:.
~ill]
~
('I) ~~
••.
~4.JJi.Jl~.J)\j.
y.,1~
o~
[ fil
~
~ill ~~
~
J ](A)u-;!J\! ' o~I
~~
••}ll
Jl.oc. ~I 0A J.c.
: 0;> O~')!cO ~ ~
~
ul.J~)'
[ ( r t\
.u~o? o.:ll.J1 A..1 ~ : '\ ~ r.
:0
.J:!) ~)
.J~.J
W ~ ~
~l.JI.1aw:uli ~
[ uUJ...J1~.J y'il J-.d)') ~
.r
uUJ...Jl.~ I
ij ·Aa..J
.:.
~ J.-aWi
~Y' u4 u~~
•r
J~ J-.:!.us.\.J ~W\
~ill J] (.. ) u~.J:!.J'i\ l.S~I
y'i\ ~
4. St. Ambrose : DeFid~, Book IV, Chapt. IV, (39) P267., NPNF., 2nd. Ser., VoL X 5. 6. 7.
1979. St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Horn. XXXVIII, (4) P135, NPNF., 1ST. Ser., VoL XIV, . 1978. Ibid. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book 1, (29) P48, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979.
.
.a.>ll : ~~
: "~~j~I .-aL.QI;.&I ~ :~I~~~I~lMJ'
uts ~j , ~I
y.J lJAT~ J 0Ji:. ~.."l-
uLSJ.
~~).J
~~\
~~I ~~J.
I~IJ
UJ~
I.jill ~~\ J\.i9" .~IJ
UJ~~
uts"
~~\
uts 11\ ~1
~~I
"Ai4 ~
<L;l (.).AI.! 0~
uLS
~\
J wl:!l ~
~~
u~
I~w..u· ~.~.J-4
~~))I ~'j)A
u-d . ~11J1J
\1\ ~
dil ~ ~
~ ~\- /)~1 Ail u1~1 Jt! ~.hi! ~I
U
('>J ~ ~I Ul~
(.Sy..1~1J lJAJ. (' .:0 ..JJ) " ~.J:lJ'-'l ~ "~~
·1
~I ~
'~_""AII ~ '--::--
~ .):1.)--"1 J.,.,.:.j~ JU J ~
. (' ':0..JJ)
u~
¥ J u~..;ilIJ
I~~u-=a.;all
.tA:i~ I.j~\ ~·..l:"'ll: J U
. .J~ ..JA l.,?
4Jj~
t.J'"'l;l
(.).A
/)~J/)Y~J~
/)~~ J .~ 'j ~
J~
~~I
_,
~
u1u~.J
4JY /)~
~4-19" rJ -uY . /)~ ulJi.S1
~1 t.J-""l:! ~
. (' A .J, V: 0 .J:!)
J\.i9 J...:";I/)~ ~tl.a
~
~]
~
-UY w..,..JI~
~l ~Ji:.
-u1~
~
Jj1
~~I
Ail (.S~u-lj
Jt:a!~ U~ UY ~ y";1 ):a.y
~
~1" J\.i9 ~~I
U:U~~"'i\
~J
oW~
~
Lo 'ij ~
~
lAloA
u-lc ~); U1
U1 ~'11
(.).A ~
~'1\
.[ (' ":0..JJ) ~ ~I
('Lo1 ~ts] (' ')l.tJUlI ;J~
(.S~1 ~j, ~I
~4u-lJYI:
44-11 4...,IJi J."J; J...:";I ~LW ~~~.J ~/)j.}'~·!~Ju1~\:i.:...:' u~~1
'-¥: ~11J1J J-.; 1$1~ ~ y)U oWl}.•~ ~I.:ill ~IJ u1 ~.J:l~I (' ":0..JJ) ~";\ /)1\ ~ ~)I ..]AlGJ !~I -[! y)U ~'11o\}.•~ ~
. y)1 ('..JJ ~
UiJ\.A ~
.:.
0~
y.)1 ~w
u~..JJ.)";I
~
'~I!~J•
10. Ibid., Book VII, (17) P124. '0 •.•••• ' '\'\, ~
'1",1"1, 1"0ul~I.j1fll~,
••• Y •
~I
.:.
y.)\
~~.J-4
~
~cS.J-u1
L;=JI L;:JI"
I¥ ~I~~
y..-11~
u";1 ~
(' V:o >J) "~lli1J
~t!.
~1.J19.y";I~j ..fi~~ yi; 'i rSl
~
C~,UJ
~J131
UL.u1 cJ~
(Y)~I~
,:"y.'J
J-""
;~~I •.l.#o4411 ~I.li."
....~
~~
c) 4.1JLWu.j4M L..l.»a
:y~,~YLoJ:J'Jf ~ ySo ,l-o JL.w .J#-
4Jj Jli 4i'i :;yill ~ ~
~'1\u~
" ~~
_r
~~,
u-i
JJ'i1 u"'1~~1
.~ "'i Jii ~ u~.J:! ~~\ ~J
.l! rA~
~
J ~J.
y)\ ~\
~l
,:?~I~)I
~
~
~
~
~
~
JjJ
'i~laA 0-.J-:I ..&\ uJ
I~ .J-A J . ..&Y ~
YJL.w~
.(jIJ'L...w~
uJ : Jjili
~I
~ - uL-uj .J-A J
- rA~
~ ~IJ ' r-~
J.S ~ ~
~J
.u~ .J-A y y\
.u '-¥ ~' w..,..Jl
.(j\J'L...w~~
~.J:l
J
: ul ~o)..?~~~}! i.;.a1IJ J.d.,11 c) y~ JLw..t~,!I
: u~IJ
lWU
ul ~
ul~.J:l
y\'1 ~
~.
'i y\'\ ~
~ . .J~
J~
~t
J-SJ. ~
~\
~I r-~\t\ ~ ~
~'1\~~J
~I
uJ] (Il)
~
~J. (" i," 0:' . (£f,f
~~Ltit
~
r-~
~"
,~)
y\'\
·14..&u~Jfr .AQ U
~I
\~
:;fil
. 'i\~ .u:. ~
0C ~
ul ~.w\t"
wi"
~\
, y)U ~\ ~I
uJ J=!~\
:;4=JIJ ~Yil\ ~
"~\tl
Y.JJ~
~'1\ul~~.J:l
~
wl.JoA\t\ ~
wL..ca..,JJ ~ ~l
~\ ~
~\
,:?I ~ ~ 'i J r-~ 4J.c. ~ 'i ~ U.J U'~'i\• ~•. L~..··Lo '-'..r ~.QL. UA'L:l
~yJ\ ~\!l ue J. (f:'~) " u\5.
"r-\.4! lJA~
~di"
~\¥-y\,~\~~
(' '\:o~) "~~'1\
.1
~\
J~J.
~\ ("':0..,..;)
~l w.J4;l uJ!~ u-olJ~ uLS u-
f:' ,~) wlya\tl
~.a1\ JJi: :;~\J
u4 4k- o~
~ lJA .JjW ~\!I
J.,uJ1~ y)U LH'I\ :;\J~
. [ (f:' ~) u\5.~
r-~
~
"
~I
12. St. Athanasius: De Synodis, (49) P47, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980
.•• r.
.u\~1
0C J .:•
U:. ~\
~I
[('
,~
'\:0.J:!) II~
u:'il .u-.; I¥ y'll ~
.t ~
"...l!
U
~ ~
~ts110...J-"'" .,:;11 ~I ~
~
J,.'L..J .:.
y'll 0..,.9.JA ~'i\] (,r)~1
J~ j»)1 oj. ~~~I ~~t
u:'il.u-; I¥ ~I~~
~
d~II~
] (' t)~I..H UL...tcS~ ~.1i1\
I-J'll~ • ~..J
. ~~
J,.'L..J .:•
•..loT' ...! I-J'll'u-e ~ .I::. ~ 4.Jt ~. ~
J-:!
. [ y'll .&\ .u-; La ~
~~)
u:'il d]
\.::'(~~I ~tij ue ~I
tit..- ~~
~
I~ u-k ('O)~I
~I
Aj~
~.1i1\ J.1u..J .:.
~j~..H
U\S. ~\Y'"l' y'l\ .u-; ~J'
y'll
.u-.; LaJ,S~
4.Jt
~ . ulS.~~ ~t ) l;ll.biJ1 ul.;-iC) , j4~1 ~
)
.[~~J~:ill .
.I
(JA U"-ll..JA
oj'''''e'"''''":'. .•... ~:i...Wi:JI.w . ~~ ~
.wIolS·~ ~\I~I Y l.,?"
y'll ~\.bc.t ~I y'll . ~.)
J\-c.~1" y.,.rllJ...,..i; I:u. u-!J. ~
~ y'l\ ut J
~ ~
~I
ut~I ~
. (fV Jfi:O.J:!) u~' 11_
u....-.
i)~\•••• ..H
UL...t
t ~ JL..ul.,?"~.\I~L
• •
~J
':1 ('
cS~.-.1 ••• ~
~.wl
J
l....aA oj'•.·.I '''e'''''''' ~
Y'll oj~J JI-c.~I o~
"J ~~.)
.1i1\~~ .t • ~.
. _:
.- .•
uJjl ~ .
_ ....•" .lJ..t..J\ ~
'--::--
,y'll ,
4l.Si
~~I ~
II I~ ~ \•..4.iJa:i ~
. ••• t..rJ.
•.· u-:.~I ~ .w.:.1 ~ I-J'lloj'. '''e'''''''' . [Y'll
~tij .)c. ul1J..J\ Aj ul j~ II~~
lJA ~
~l u:'il ~
~I ~J
~\
ukt J.lhJI y.)1 u~
~I.J.A ~I ~;
~ J
y'll ut ~ 4.J~II .u.~ u-.:i..,.JI
~ .J~Iu:jJ ' (f f Jf f: , , .Jo:!) .JjW..:i.AtiH.u. j. ~I
. (0 i_f '\: A))
~I
olSt.liJ. (" , :0 .Jo:!)
(J"l.J;!l:!
~jJ (' V_, , :V))
13. Ibid, Contra Gentes, (46) P29. 14. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book XI,(l2) P206, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., VoI.1X, 1979. 15. St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Horn. XXXVIII,(4) P136, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, . 16. St. Hilary of Poi tiers : De Trinitate, Book VII,(l7) P124, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,
.~ t •
~\.4!LJA ~~}
~I
(\V)4iJJil~~11.$ft.::A ~J111 J1u..-J .:.
y.J J..,i~
~.JW WU:J...JI ~o~
~
~
~l~
'-iP ~\.4!U..o ~
J#
~]
. [ C~ . ~\o ..
.rA..&1W~. ~~
(':0. j;..o) W~I.J-A O~J..&\W~J
~I..,-...JI~J"
W~" .u~ W~I o~J.JA J...:J~~I
~~ ~
\~'i"
~
#1
:..u~ I~ ~ ~).l.JAJ.~
..u~
.J~I
. (r ~J" 1\:0..,;) " ~~I 'ilAc.1ut/l
oy..i11 ~
J,S ~I
J-.; wIJri",JI
~
.l!
~
~
~~~I
y'iIJ Lil".u.~ ~IJ
..>A ~IJ ~ y\)l\1 ~ ~
"J.oc.I ulJ w'il ~ J.u:!
~I" Jli ~I
..&1 J Jli ~~ 1~'l"i'4 ~~I ~I J\..i!y'il U..o ~I
~
..>A ~I ~..J
~ J. ~ wI~
~4i JJ
'i y'i\
<UjY:l~.
~Wl.....:J\
Lo J,SU..o
J\-c.1w-c 4.J1.:.. ) L. J-.; wIw\.bLJIJ
~ y~ J~ .uIJL..w~\
o~l
c:.H'i1
-y
y.J ~I
LJJ. (f.:' ·>:1) "~\J
~1.uIJ~
~.JA
olSl , (' 1\: 0 >:1) ..&~~
• (' ~: 0 ..,;) ,,~
0:'11~I
4.b\.c.
~
. y'il ~ ~~IJ
0:l~
.JAJ...:J~J .( f.: 0 >:1)
~~II).c.c. W:l~\J o~1
.w ~'11 wIW. y'il
: ~IJ
l.H b.30.1
~L.a ~LJ J...:J~\~ U..o
~
LJAJ'ut/l ~)I
~
uJe.1 .li! ~"Wy~\
~\J~uj~J'
0:l~1~
~
~4i J}
~~ y'il ~
~I
rj.C ~\
u-='"U .JAJ ' o~ J U'I~I
J 'y ~IJ ~I
l..".w 0:l~1~H
~
~~
WIJ. (r r : 0..,;) "~~
4.L\.c..ui~~
~.,::1\
0:'11 ~
(' V:o
>:1)
'i ~~ o..H1
l¥ ~I~J.oc. ~"
" .u~ y'il ~I.ft ..JwI~I ~) W y'il o~ ~ ~1.uJ (" f:o ..,;) ,,~) '-i~ y'il (".fi:. 'i c.H'I1 ("jS: 'i U..o. y'i\ W.JA.fi:. ~
".uI~~o~.uwPwl
(".fi:. ~
c.H'I1 ~I
~~I~~o~..Jy'il
wI~J...:J~"
. ("':0..,;)
~\
J~
~'1IJ ~
~ ~\)\ ~I
J
. (' ':' V~) "... ,~
~
~ ~
0A ~ J~
y\~l
~ ~
. [ J;..a y 4J~yYI
.u 0§:J 01~'jl ~I
~
~
~"
4J1~
'11]
(\'1)-~1
o~
"'-:ilj ~
I.A JSJ" y)U~1
i.S.JJ.:.A ~.all JJ-i:! .:.
yYI ~
~
~I•.•.
•.
J~
~I
(\A).JJjl~
4J~~IJ 0t:1:J'j\ I.A.\ • ~I
.
JS 0lJ ~'j4J
~.cl1 ~ I.AJ . .cl1~
'14J~ ~'jl ~ ]
-....bLI-utLw .. I~.~ . ~~.
~~
I.A JS 0'1 All JAJ
~ ' JI.Ac.~I ~ .Jt
~I
.u yYI 01LoS" .u...,s~
JA~I ~
~.uliLw u-l! ~L...:::a'j4 . (" i: 0 >:1) ""'-:ilj ~;;~
j! J-jl
OJ.jlJa
Jill J.Li. r...J ••• •
i.S~.-.I.'\' ~
. [(' '\:o~) ".cl1~ ~'jl ~ 0A] (~')~I
J-:1J ~\.fill
44.JI t.wlJi JJ.i; JA~I
LAS 4J.JA.fi.; JS.l\01J' (' '\: 0 ~) yYI ~
. [(r.:, .~) ~IJ
\¥ (yYI)
~ ~'j\J yYI ~\~J
~lj
lJ.CJ.:.
01J...H':1 'iiJ\
I.A JS J-:14J} J~
YJL..w0fi.= 01'1}~yYI 0.JA.fi.:
yYIJ 4JI) ~
:~'~~~rJ~Y'-'" y)1 ~.)AI
~\
. 4.....h! IyI)J('
~I
~~~01
" ~I
ulJ 0YI ~
<Ljl~I ~
J.-:! ~I" ~
I¥ ~Ij ~
~~I ~I
~I
I~
I~ y4-I"
0~ . J-:1 yYI ~
.l..il 01~\.J-"'l}
y.JJA ~I
o)J.i;01 ~y.S'14~
~
~\
J\..i!. (' • J'\:i ..,J) ~\
'1 ~ J..,slJ=JI J.:JI ~ JUJt~
"~~'11 ~
~I
\~'1J'
~I) ~(A:'''WoA)
J JU.u~
'1~~o~IAlI"
~
':"'.?-) l-~
~.ul
01~'11 ~
~..,J\
~\
~ ~\
0~J
J.-.9
('V:o >:1)
~J.
~(' A:o >:1) "Al~ ~ I.A '1}~
~
lJ-4 ~
. (' '\:0.J:l)
18. 18. Ibid.( 21 ) P 127
19. 19. Ibid., De Synodis, (18) P9
~'i\ o\}.•..w ~~
~ (' V:O..,;)
J-J\ ue u Y:1 01),
II~t
rJ y'i\ 01 ~ ~ ~.
J-J\ \~ ~y'i\
J.-.;
\..itJ0'i\ ~
~'i\ J-.; y'i\ J-.;
~I
~J.I.A~'i1
01J. ~~\
. ~'i4 J-J\ \~ ~J II~
~
lA 'i) ~ ~
y'i\ ~
01 .} o~\J ~J
~
~ ~
~
~
0A
~
~yJ
J..".!~
\...oS.! . y)U Ulh.JI
~~I0.AO~\JU:uJ ->FJI J-.; 01 ue fi:l'i y'i\
J-.; 01 ~'i\
o~\J oJI.J!~
rJ \~
~tll y.)\
.J~
'i II .u.,....J
.} J
~'i\J y'i\ 01 u1Y, (' '\:0..,;) 0'i . ->FJI ~
.uLU .} ~'il
~ \~\J
. (f.:O..,;) 4..a) ,:?~Iy'i\ ':?~\ y'il J\-c.t J.--,y
II
.u~ ?i ~..>-" ,:?I) ~~\
JUW0--:l'i1 ~~y'il
\~.uti...::a~ J (f:'\ y.;) ".u..-..)
0~~ y'i\ ~.JAJ~y'i10'iJ.
y'i\ ".ul~~'il
. (' • :' f..,;) JlAc.'il J-.; ~ ~ ~\ II
•'" ~~I
~••-T' Ak.~1 ~..·t:b.11 ~. •.. J..LI.JI
.. _~tl ~ ~ UlI:I.,.-...
:Jj~l.uo -:-ill ~ 0). (' V:o y.;) II~I ~~l}-40'i.
utJ 0'i\ ~
Jj'il ~y'il
y'il ol..ky LA0LSI~)u£l J . .u.e.
~
~'i\ 0fi= 01 ~)l9
~
~III ] (n)UM~~t
~~oJ~Ju-1c ~.J~
, y'il ~
0..A! 'iJ ' y'il ~t LAJ ' ~
•
(,)A
~¥l. i
.)i~
~J1l1 J~
~"0'i\
.JA0--:l'i\~
~"J'~!4
~" ~
.:.
~ 01 ~l
0--:l'i1 ol..ky
. [\.9):-) ~I
J
~1'1Su ~. ~\.~II.ue.t.:: '-F" ~':? ~I~\'
LH 'i1~'~~~I~ •.. .J..
.(" J' : , ..,;)".&1.llc ~.¥\.} 0~ \~ . .&\~I
...
J
01SJ.&I .llc 01S
21. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. II Chap. XVI, (20,21) P359, NPNF., 2nd. SeT., Vol. IV,.
o~IJ ~
~'i\
J ~IJ
4,y ~
jAy:.. ~'i
(.jl
~':JI u-e ~
u~~~. <:.H'i\u~ ~':J\.u-..;~ (.j~1 ~':J4 ~
~'iIJ y)U ~\J J-,ll u'iJ.~
.(u-a'CiJ1 ~1j&.'JI) ~)I
~~..r.l"
:.:H'1~-:Jill ~1~ ~. u-tll ~ ~ ~.J:1 '1
~
~
'lJ' ~IJ wy\'lj
~.J:1
~ J,S.9.~':J\ J,ACy\
~'il ~
~'i\ u4 ~');.J':J\
~':JI ~
QJ ••ul,J:UL...ll.S~
J~/)~~(H)
cfJ" -Gl~~'i\ Jl9 ~ ~'il ~ u~!.~'i\ ~ ~ <:.H'il ~ ~
~I.cj'i~)l9
~':Jl u! ]"~l
~ ~
~
~':JI. (' •:, £~) "~'il
I~ ~
~':J\ u1J! A
~
J-y ~l" J~
Ul-ill~, "u':Jl ~
~I
1.Au1 (.jl "~ll.il.J"
fl.);~ I~
.~l
. ["~~~'il
Lilj u':Jl
J.-:1
. J-y (.jil\ ~':J\ ~
~ts 4:J! ~
~. ~ ~':J\ ~
J.".:i: .:.
~Jill
~ ~ JW\ ~':Jl
-Gt..JS , ~l
~
' .wwl
j
<:.H'il~ flul (.jil\ w.!)1
~~..J-4
~_~I
fl.);~- u':Jl~~':JI
~
c~~ j~1 ~'l~ ~ ul(~)I) jU] (n)I.S,JJ.lS......."i ~..»S 1 ~Jill J.".:i: .:. -"p-i ~ -u'i , -G\~ ~ /)~J (.j~1~\~~.u UlJ. ~':JIcca ~~'i\ ~ J.cuy .wi ~
t.S ~~.-
.•
11.~
.a.. ~I,1..~~ ...r. ~..
~w'il~....;-..J-?W L~ . .wl.! ,-a...-
~a..~\•.J. /)~tU:.
II,~ uili'<.J-4..r-
. [~I ~ ~~'il ~ ~':JIcca ~, ~~
(H)~WI
. (':'~)
"~}ilJwl~\.&1
to- ~~ UJol:! Jill
4431 twalJ! J~
OJ.jlJ.
~
rJ/)~J
~\
~
ULS, ~
" J~J
~~I
J~,
u\S.~ ~~ ~" 4..ic ~ti.S1\J~
J..r7. ~ y ~-:.1.:. \1~..
.uJ ~
<:.H'iIJy)U ul ~blJ
\~\J ~
~~~\~"
~l
~!<:.H'i1 ~
~':Jl L.J.
<:.H'i4 rJWl
~
~
(.j ill
.
~
.us 1:U
(i".~) ~".(jLS
"J.."....)l
~':J\ U~! . (' i:' A . ~\
.:•
Jl:J1~~
-:.\.:.\1 ~.. WJ.S! . fll§ (.j ~I' (JAJ y. (j.~l'-"""'""'" ..
. ('I': , ~JC) "U;---JWI ~
~':J\
-GjJ~1
"~
~ kA u1.A ~"11 .
u-J,J:
~ ~'i4
22. St. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book IX,(44) P170, NPNF., 2nd. Ser~ Vol. IX,1979 . ...•..•• I ~~o.J}.L.•• ~l:ill (0.
f •
r u6.b.....!).,.;~I~fiJl~.J}. ~I
. Ii ......•••I~~i ~Ir.ro.n~i.l.ll&lI.j1fill~.~lu.JA'JJ."...:~~I ,
.~".
cyli: l.jy:&.>,/I uJ..>t' ~1.'I'i .~r •.l~~41I~I.li.'I'£
~~\ ~
~~ ~ ~. ~~]
"~I \.iIJ ... ~ ~I" ~'i\ J.,.§ ~I ~ UAJ . [ ~ \.iIJ:} y'}[\ CoN.~I \.iIJ, J-.; ~I u\S. ~\ r~ ~
JY")I uJ.Y. ~
Jl9~
~ (" 0: , J.J) "~\ .<~._Ill.ll~J . ~~\'I ~
~'i\J
y)U ~\J
~
ll.ll~. ~'i\J y'}[\ 0A)\.S ~
UJ~ <3~I
IY:c-J \.,i:i\ J ~
. Ie' <l...i.A
o~
...)"""":. I"
J~
cY":!Ji31
(~O)U"I~Jj:\Ai
~
~I
tY:-J .:.
~W\ tY:-
~,
I.,l~\
iill ~
LH~\"
-:.\1:. II .w.<. w'}[\ .<~.- l.l1.Sb Ie', '-? ill l.:"'-"'-' ..J-""!. ~ \ ~ ~
. [ ("''':' 'J.J) ~~\'\ ~ ~ '-?~\ ~'i\ : ~'1~ -:Jill ~~1~ ~;.!;;.!O~~~1~ ~.llJ!.~
~\ " ~~.u ~
"J-.; y'}[\
.(' '\: 0 ~)
_.I,·.a. u-~
~J
~
~
t.JC
ui ~
. (~I
~
J)L:...wi ~.
~J
~. ~ . ~
LH'ii ~
....[Y'l\
~~L;.~.I-,'X.ulw·l\ ~ . ~
y'}[\
" )lj\j~)
.~~. 'XI~~ ~.
~
~~~~~
J-.-e.1
, ~'i\J
.uJ' o..,s11 ~
~o~\.J'i\
~~
'~'4
.~\
~Ji31
J~ .:. ,-.9
JU
'r?
c:~ ~
o,u,J ~
o~ J ~).! r ~I ~ ~\ (~V)U"I~Jj:\A1
~'i\ dJ~
I.S]J..:.A ~Ji31
~), \ A{"'J
UA
y'}[l O~\.JluAi
~ ~J
u.·U~\·<1\•~
.
O~J ~
~I
LH'i\ ~u~~
J-.,y ~'i\ J]
.lS1
. J"' ~~
\.1\J. ("':o~) "~~ 0A ~
y'}[\ O~...H loA ui
. ~I
.I,.....j'J'
~\
J-.; ul ~'il~ 'X ~ J.,.§I ~\
u.:::al~~I) u~~.J'}[1 ~~
L.b.
,.I~-:~ J~
0A
o~ J ~\
P ~~ ](n)"';;il..H UL..J
~'i\J y'}[l ~ oIJW\ '"'4l""'
'Xl ~
ulJ-G\'\ fJ 9Jy'}[\ ul ~.w\'
~ 0.J~ljo.?' o~l.Jl~
\ •• O:~
J-J\ o~ JJ ~\
~
w'}[\~· ~
(I ~J..
("'1t"
y'}[\ ~J
\Ag~"J!bo~J
4Jlbl....a J ~ jll
J~
l:U ~J
.:.
u~). (" ,-, '\: 0 ~ ) ~~ 0-.A ~ ,.J ',.<. iiI\ .lbl....a . \' , ~l.....::..a .. <0:o~ -'I . U 1.lS.\ ~ ~ I..,? u--; U U U~ Y U. J.
"Jar,~ ~~\
-'I u~lie'
Ie' ~ ~ y
.
[~\~
y)U JL...o~
o~ J I..,? ,.J u->-' ·,CI ~'X\,.J J
I..,? ~
, ..1 ~" .<0: ~ ~~.-
II
·1 ~
U
·r~A~I
25. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chap. II (34) P288, NPNF., 2nd, Ser., Vol. X, 1979 26. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book IX,(50) PIn, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 27. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book I, Chap. XVII, (112) P219, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979.
u:'!\ J~] ~\
uc ~\:j11~\:jS ~
CJ)I
;I" ujJ ' 4.A../i1 ~ y'i\ ~ ~IJ t:.H,!IJ.(' 0:' i.J':1) ~ o~~
y'il u~ (' '\: 0 J:!) "~
y'il
~J.
o~~
~
wyy
y'il ~
~ ;IJ~
u:,!1 ~
~J.
u'~,!\cJ.C ~\:j11 ~tiS~,
,~I
u-lJ~Yt..J'-'l:l ut;IJ y'i\ 4"JI~'Q ~ " <.F~U ' .. L-:·t .J~
u:'!\ ~
~
~"J.i,~1 ~
.. w'iI~,~.-b.-'",AII~·t ... ~ ~- e-.-::--
~~~~J:!;I
w'i\ ~ ~
;I , y'il
(':<l
[ ~ o~l)1~I
~IJwy\;I
~~,
~
LIt
olJ~
~~ ~
~ ;IJ~
~
0-A
o~l.J 'II cJ.C J .:•
~JllI JAJ .:.
o:u.~
~
lJ-'l
ut A
~.uJ pI ~.u u~ ~
~!"J" J~ ~"~J4' ~
ciJl "u:,!1 yi; ;I" U ~ ~ J Y~
~I~
u:,!IJ~di]
~.J:!-S
~~~l
:"
~
".u.
JJ-l:! LJ-.:l,!1 J y)U o~\)1
u
y)U~
"~JA
~\.!u.. 'jl Ui£J 0:.
~.w~ t:.H,!\ J] (n)~.)~'it
;I ~~.bi9 ~
" ~
0:' i.Jo:1)
('
. [o~IJo~1.J!~u}!\j6-L
oyill ~ ~
o~J cJ.C
,~clk,·u;Il·t .. v-;,. U.J...
...
~~J.
(I". )~ J.l.:jWI~~ .. ).Ji.:.;1;- ~JllI
0-A
~JllI ~J.iJ.iJ .:.
-.::.li)lJ ~I.! ~)" t..J'-'l:ly~t. ('I':A~)
~
"[
.uJJ~ ~.wJ
u:,!l w yy y'il
Wfi
I YwLl.b.:i..· \.i .. L.\ _IW ~ (J.A~,
~..
A WA
oiA. 0-A~ut
JS cJ.C ~
JLi9t:.H,!IJy'i\ ~~I
~]
l.SY;It. (r:
)~.J:I
Utt:.H,!1.J~
4..t..lii lJ-'l ~
(n)~~J..)f41
~I w~
Wj .Jt U. . I" ~~
y)U ~ J,S"
"~JA
.[~
~
~JllI JJ----1:!J .:.
(~A)~~J..)f41
~ : W~
• "':If j"".w"':l"
~.
J.-=
ut A;I
J.-= utt:.H,!1A;I "(' '\:0 .Jo:1)~
0j.W:
t:.H,!1 JA ~I
~\
4J1.,§
28. Ibid: De Spiritu Sancto, Book II, Chapt. XII. (l35)P132. 29. Ibid: De Fide, Book II, Chapt. VI, (51) P229. 30. St. Gregory of Nazianzen: The Forth Theoligical Oration (XII) P314, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, 1978 . ''1'10 .J:,L., .Y'I:il\ ( 0 , f , ,. "::"6.h...:.j) ..,.i~1~j;J16.J:, ~l C~: l.S~';\ uJ..>.P U"-;!iill.n •
'Ii~
•.~
.JjWI
JS ~
,,~
~'il ~
~I
~'illJ
~
J~
4 u'i"
I¥ (y"}l) .cll~~
"ul£ t.- •.~
~ r1 ~J
ul£
(I
~
u.e ~L¥JJ \' "~y"}l
u:l1y.JI LH~
y.J J~ 0-A .ill~~J
~I
JS" J,$.11~
••~
~ ~
...
.JA J . (' ~: 0 .>-:)
. (i: , .J:!)
: ~ ~ J~ wl ~
w ,~
u-k J,l:j 'i .J~ 'i ~
WI,~ •
(.S"-
wti.....::a u-c .
I 'il r..s-J
'iJ.
1-
JjJ'i \.1\ ~
~ ''''.'';J.l,c.Jj
~
,,;j,
] (n}~li11
'i 4..o.lS9•
~
1 ~I
"
·1 L.il u..JoS:l . WI J ., J.J-S:!~~l.l~l• ...r: ~ 1- ~ 1\ ~ ,'L~I'i U ...r-
t.l.:.. .J:! l>'Y ~I
. .-! ~I .J '-t? . .••
u'i ~
~'il.)~'J "o}-:~, -i OJ",w, 44-31 ~IJi J~ .:.
~ J~ 'J
'i .&1 u.o j).J04 ~
~
u.o JS"
.&1 0-A j~..".JI
. [(~:i.J:!') ".&1 u.o j).J044J'i ~ J\,.Ac'il
~I
~
"LA~"}
~t
.J;HjJJ\ ~
0-A
~'il J ](rr) ~I
0-A ~
I:u.J.uc. 4-:!y:. •.~
1···1, (..,)-4~u
~.
'i ,oW ~
'La, 'i ~.J.
'i ,~
••~
J~J .:.
~Jill
~~
.ot" JUJ. (vJi:"u-!)~~I.W\ j.AC .J • wyJI J c~\ ut.bL.w ul I~ jA
~ ~u.i ~,,;j ,'i4JI ~........-" ''', ...L9 ~ ~j;
~j
ul ~
.011 ('
AJ 'V :' • >:1)
c L.c. l..AI... ~- , 1.:.- II
l..Aj-iA ~
~
0-A
. [ ~'iIJ y"}l l».' ~ts.\1 Jli:i'iIJ clJWI
: J..aa.: ~ t~ ~ ~'ilwi ~ y'11ul
wl.J04'i1~
~ 4J'i" ~
~I
y.J J~
• (" , : 0 .J:!)
I~
~
~
I"'p-
uL.-.:J'i\ ~
j§J' (":'
\'1 ...?' ~.lA·.('. .r
'J "
~'il.)~'J "o}-:~
~ ~
u.o ~
" ••\.4!
-\0:01
~'il
~~...?'
~I ~ 'II .cl.I~~J
~~i:'.>-:) J,$.1\~
~\
0:\1.:. II ,11::_ .. La u~ 'i ~..~.-II ~ 'La l.""-" U u-:l U(l-".
~\ 1~ ~ r 1 u'1£
w.JA'i J~: ..::..l~lii~~'-!411 U.li.n 33. 8t. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Horn. XXXVIII,(4) P134, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, 1978 . IV ..•.•• , I '\'\'\
~
I,",
n ,,"0
(j1J.Al\ ii)lfill~,
~I
c.:H) UiJ' lpo u~';1 uL5. ul] (n)UM~4
~..&I
'i ~';\ uL5. ul ~' ~I
u~';1 ui Ii.\
c.:H';1 lJ-4J..,.::a!i J~I
Ji:- ~1ji!1.w) . ~t ~ ,-:?~I~';\ Ut ~
u-Y.1i1\J~ IlA ~J
u-e.J~
~'
~I
J¥:- ~
U~) ,
) C~I .
[
WI .w~
~
u~) . ('\:1( fi) "
..&1~
y~
w~)UI
~~
ui J~
)...P"t AI L .. . ~~ ~U.J
: y'1\ ~ ~.,RJ\ O~J ~"
~I...P"
~
lJ-4J,..uy ui .J.u:
\"2 ,~, ~
ui ~
I~
.:.
i iiJ'i..&1 ~
~'il .)J1: ~ "O.)~
~
~
~
" ~I
-[
~I
uU:J...JI.h.I J J J-JI u)..91.1\ LJAJ. (f.:' •.J:!) ~'ily._/~I ~ .h.IJ ~\
y\.".;JIJ
. o.h.1 J 0yill J .AIJ J¥:-lJ-4J JJ <, J1lJ-4] (ro\s,,)L.JU11UM.jJ.Jiu...;J;. u-Y.1i1\J~
ui J~I
lI,
y)U LA ~J.
~~
y)U ~
¥~
LJA J,..uy Ut
~
~~
0:'
'..Hn
. [O.h.IJ~1.fil\J' ~~
~
LA Jd; ut ~'i
ufi.: ut A'i ~) .~
':'
V..H) ~
~~
~
~~~
] (n)~ ••ul-,:, ~11.S.JY.:A u-YJ1l\ J~J .:•
~'il ~
c.s..;;~)c.:H'iIJ' ujl.JJI ~
~
-4.J:! 'i U~). ('
c.:H'i1 A'i
. [ ~ '-:?~\y'i~ ~ ~
'i ¥ c.:H'i\ ~
L0U LA ~ U~ . (' '\:0.J:!) y'il ~
J,s. U~ , L.:aL:..~
.:.
tA ~.
~ y'}l ~
u~ ~
b~)
~ ] (rv) 1.S.)~'i1 u-J.J:SU"I:!.1i1\ J~J
41 y'il
ul-! liS.\,. ~\
~
y'i\ lJ-4..JA
. [y'il LJAy\~1
~)
UJj.J u~
.uu~. ~~l
.:.
w\~ lJ-44..J,p.
4+! ~h.o ~I
~j
~LAue
34. 81. Basil: Prolegomena, The Life and Work of 81. Basil P XXXIX,NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VIII, 1979 . 35. 81. Gregory of Nazianzen: The Forth Theoligical Oration (XI) P313, NPNF, 2~d. Ser., Vol. VII, 1979. 36. 81. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book IX, (45) P170, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979 . . ,. '\' ..•.••, ''1'10 ~L., 'O.JAI:ilI, (0, f ,r ..::..l:..b.....!) ~~ ~l C~ : l.S~'11 v-l.J:!S ~I .rv
.'.Y.
: y'il ~ ~I
~l ~~ J~ ut ~J:~I
'i
ul ] ("A)~WI
~I
44-11
Oo3,jWa
J
ue ~
J.o,c
0.A ~
ut .)~
~
. [ ~I
(J)\
y'lll ;;'!J'~'Q.Ji:- 4..-~ ;;'!J'~'Q
~J' 'i ]
J.o,c
(n) U-W~J.Jo:At
ue 'i J y'll\
J.o,c
~J1l1
~
~
ut c~
y'lll ~
~~~J,Sw~J~~~4..:iy...i,
I' ~
~~'ll' ~t ~J. ~
01\ ~
J-.; ~
y'll\ ~
W:
.
'i ;))+,J\
o:u.
j.~
_r ~\
j.Jl.S ~
~
~I
.:•
~
, !",?~IJ\~I,.&I~!.JA
'i ~ . (i:" fi ) " F1J~'
J.o,c JS ~ l~t C~
~
ut ~
~"II
J~J
ue ~
:" ~. It\.··,-,~f r-.. '~:'Lo~f"o .
u~. J-.;
-t
~-
. [ y'lll J.o,c
~I
J~ .:.
~IJi
. ~ \1\ ~~u . ...9 ~. •. . t t.i. t, w'll\ 4..b..~ 'i\~Lu...::a .. ~I
\ w...u1lit w'lll ~ .. .. ..
'-F
~"I\ J.o,c u~ ¥
" ••ul'!1 .;.1i;~"O,;4c- -03
O~JJ J.-aJ1 O~J ~
.?iJ\
~
I:u. 0.A \..::..j~CoS.>J ut .~\
: o.;l.pJ1o~ : ~
~I
J..uy ~J
' y'll\ ~
~I J\,Ac)U ~~
~"II ~
l¥ ~\j ~
4 cj'i " ~
,.4'i1 ~
~ ~ll.~
J~"JI
~
~J
•••
~Ji:!~ y'il • t
'ilAc.t J-.; 'i J' y'll\ ~ 'i ~'i\j ~I
y.)
J..,.! &
.lS),lJ. ~
~I ~
. (' "I:0.J:!) " ~~
J\,Ac~I
~;).l.:l..
t ..?ollifi ~ t~
~l
J t.:.H"I'J y'lll ~ Y'll' ~
y'll\ ~'il ~W\'iy:-
. y)U
~)I
Ufill ~
CoSt.) ~.
ul ] (f.) U-W~J.Jo:Ai ~J111 ~ ~'il
~ 0iJfi ~~J
ul . y'lll ~I
l)'lyJI ~ y'lll ~"I\ CoSt.) ~. ~'il
. ,'\ __ , '1'1'\ ~'I"
o.l.:l.. J .JA
,
~'i\j
n ,1"0 01~1,
~~~
IlA ~J
J\,Act ~ ~"I\
U~J (fA:\JA)
~
J~
Ut ~
.:. J
CjyU.S ~"II oh~ ~ ~WIu-lc. ~J
'i jAt I:u.. (f:" ...H)~~
ojlfill ~,~I':;'.JA'1
J-",,:
c.J1:il\o..l~
4411 •..•.••,..li.r A
39. St. Ambrose: DeSpiritu Sancto, Book II, Chap. XII, (135) P132, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979. 40. Ibid: De Fide, Book IV, Chap. IV, (40-47) P267-68 .
.'.r.
r.:Y.'i\ ~ jj,
~\
r.:Y.'i1 u~ ~
\j~ . (
~J.
~~I
~\~1lJAJ
~ y'll.
C:::J)II.J..4.l.1J~l
~I
Y'll ~j
.y.J:l ul u~ -Lk. ~I
.ukl ~
lo~jW 1.J..4)lij ~J'
r: , J: ) "uts t- ~~~ ~/) ~J
u.c ~
uLS .y ~~ J.S " U..l-;I
-Lk. Lo J.S ~b JS.:J ~ ~
~J
~
~~'i\ J.S ~\.l;l w..its
. [.u 'iCia
:.HI ~.;S .uJ y'l\ I.J..4~~.JA 4,.j'l ~
~
r:.H'i\ LJ-SlJ. ~~~
4LJ..w.l ~~l ~jw(.SYul~~'i . ~~ ~J
~
J9.u1 ~~~:,;
~ ~..?-AJ
~\
+JI
~ts
t.r~ /)~
~.;b ue 'i A.k:. .M ~
~~.we.
~o~~
~~LA ~j.J ~
LA U ~ J '
ui
U~
. .we\! Y'll ..H ~
~
~\
.u..uw LA dlyJ
.uiJ,
~.ii11
J~
Y'll
LH~
()..4
J +:+
!
u'l ~J'
4\.og·,J\ Ji:- y'll~.u
~
ui~ Jr'i "J\
,:?l~
~~
~
/)~. y'll ~~
J ](f ')A ••a+il~ u:a-i I.S.]J..;.A
~~b ~ ~ ~ ~ts..&\ ~J
~~I ~J.
~J1.4 ~
oy.ill ~~\
y~1\
~~W\ ~jyl . p.ft1\
u'l\ .::1 /)~ • ~ .t:: t.A'iI" ., u)\ J..J'"' 1
'" '-t? ,.J (f Y)~I •••• ~
~i
1.... ~ I.S ~ .•...
dllt..a~cs. II ~'-r?.J ..... ~\l 0 ~W\~ .r-'~. .11.u . 'i\ U. i~" u'l\ ~ 1_
l'~ . dllj ~
\~U .... ~"
J1j
~I ....
"'I ~
~\
:;.. ~f1...
1~~.J.
.ii11
: ( ,\:
~
~
w"i . J,A: y~IJll:!LA 'il ~
0 ~)
~
~
+++ +
.1::.]" ~I ...
~
1.1,II
. [ dll~0:'i\ : ~jiQli.U
J...r:J a'i.
-"'I
tAl y~
~
C l' IOU Jj ';;'1:
.
~b
~.J'~'~'~ -,
().4 J,A: •"
wi U1~I J~ 'i " loilljs ~. • ~I'" L•. I· . ~Ij ---:f ~
.
41. St. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book VII,(l7) P12S, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979 . 42. 42. Ibid, (21) P126.
y.-E.4J'i ~
, ~\
\J")\') u=~1 ..)~l ~
..).;;1 ~I
~\
.ut! ~l
.~
CY.'11 ~
~
I¥ '-:oJ~1 ~
o~\J 0..)\..;1 ~
~
~ '-:oJ~1us:- Ji; ';l CY.'1'ij
4J'i , ~
~'1\J '-:oJ~1 U!-·HA~.:!.~.1 ~IJ
us:- wJ
ut CY.'11 ~
~
J
~~
'-:oJ~1 ~
' ~'11
~
';l . /)~
~J
l-....bUb~ .
us:- Ii.\ ~
~
CY.'1IJ~
w~ ~
-~
(JA
us:- ~~
~
~\
u-t ~\~)\j,:;.
~~_
us:- ';l ~I)\
~II~
~
CY.'1'ij~ " ~
. 0 yAlI ~
~bk.
~.. ..) ~Y:!J
~J
y\~1 w~ u-e ~ JAJ ·"11 ~,,~1..i..J La ~.1_~:oJ ~. ~ ~
0~
LS~\
'-:oJ~1 ~
~
~\
. .w
, U:! . ..)t~ 1~
'-:oJ~4~
LA
.u..,! ~J
u'i c.JS..1 ' ~..)WI~j)\ ~.) ,,.,, ~,
~
_
r
\,,-~t';l uI"
. ~.-.....ii' ~ ~(J.A~U..r- L~t·1
" ~.)LS ~1·-1
CY.'1\ ~
La ';lJ "
~
: ( ,... : 0 ~ ) ~
';l ~ -~,
~o~IJ
~\J~J~IJ~Y\~u~ _~
~.;b
~ul
A';l".u~
r..1" ~'11
~\)\
u'iJ
JA~\
.l~\J~ • ..Yo
Ii.\
. ( 'A : 0 .J;1).&4~ 'i..)h..t./).Jo;lt.&\ uJ J\! 4JIJ ..)~.lJ~~'_/il~.u ul ~\ \~~\ ~I~)
. ~l.u';l~~
~J'
4..;l
~\I....l~\~.I. _ ~
U:l~_
~I
~.•.
t!"t.A:.. ~ ut ~I ~I ..)1.) ';llatS.:a..tUJ~ ~t ~ '-:oJ yl ~)..i _A.hi IJ.)..,>! J ' ~ ~ ~I ~ 4.J~ . ..II Uo""" . ~::~';l • ",.....::.< • 4J'i" • :i .• "II (..):!J . -\J"".::11 ,';Q\ .J-1ol ~~ • (V _." r ...?".)" .). Wl\ J i.S~ ~ 1".;1'" ~.JA (jll.JAw~
4J~ /)~t
0:!~1..) ~I
I....l
.Jl...w -U';l . 04hA ';lJ Uo~
~:oJ
F';l 4.-,bk. .u..i~..)ut ~t
';lJ ~
. ~I
'-:oJ'llP ~~ ';l " ~ ~ ~I
c.JA ~I " u'i . ~
/)~.fl
~
f'.J;1~ ~
~I
f'.J;1~ ~ ~I
. (" V :" .JA)
~ II ~\
~ ~
u-e .J
w';ll.AS..\\J wti...:J\ ~ ~ ~
c.JA Jdt ut yit ';l wt " ..)~
~
~ ~
'-:oJ)1JU ~
'-:oJ'llul ~
_'-:oJ'll/)~...H
ut '-:oJI.,.....J1 0.A ul.S.\~
J? 'i u~'1\
J
';l , u~'1\
';l )
~~
J? 'i ~
wJ
o.:L-:. ·.Cl
~~J
~I~~I .
~
~.
A
•••
1\.
o.:L-:.
.
C--":'~
.
J JS ~J.L ...
ut ~tJ.:-~
.u.r-~J
'1 1lA.U. 'U" ,'u,1~I.~" ~ 'l...J_l::ll ~J~
LH,!lJ . (f :'
0
. U:!~ y':/I e;tS) tAS ~
IC" ~
j.J) ~
A
j.-.i
U-W'i ...~I:;··NI~·_J'· ~f ...r-'~
~...rb~
~J
thlc. J.
("
f :" j.J)
• .;l..;i11OJ.:a..JJ L;li:il ~j; I~ ~ 4JS.l
t:fi.o: 'iJ. oJ.:a..IIJAei"J'~'4IJJ.:a..IIJ4Ie1u!y\~1 u-i ~IJ LH,!IJ y':/I e;YJ . -C••··IU J1" l...J':/i <lJc. ,~QI u'i T.)-AI·c-H.'11.1~ ~:~ ~~~~ .. ~' .. "\1\ U~ .. \J"...T.' . rW ~
~..,1I~!
y':/I
J,..a.>.l e;1 U...H~~I
oJ.:a..I..,1\ ~
O~
•
·1
_. U
y':/I ~
,
*
~~WI ,,~tSiJl " ~~Lf ~
l.iiJ ~,
~~, ~Ji
[ov:,~]
~
"
" ~~'" ~
W;J ~J
~~J ~j;
~"
[ OV:'~] :~~
~)
1.AS" ~I
y.)
J.,.! ~
u~.J;jil
. ( oy : '\ .J;) " ~ ~
~ ;;~ .w ~
~'j\
uJ ~I
I짜
~~l ~l ~ ~~
o-hWI rA~
~~I U.a.9 y'iL: ~
u-!
. ~ y'il ~ .(j~
UIJ' ~\~;;L;:J\.JA ~'jl UIIJ~IJ' ~Lc~'jll~ .
~\
~\J
0-:H().4
u~
~
'-;-J'il
\.jIJ ~l
.J;.)'ilJ~ ~ .(j~ USJ J ' .(jl~
lk.. ~~'ill~I.I~I.l!J
;;WI ~I ~ .
~~'il ~J~.)J~.J;.J'i1 ul~Lc~Jc~L:
J
w......J~
.wI ~ ~ . ., .
JJll.:i.iu.J-'o'lJ
:~
: ~Ji
: ~~~J~I ~.>8 ~I ~~I olpJI ~
~
u~J... .ul~ ~J
y'i~
~
d~U~~.J'i1
~'il
ul.J~ 'iJ,
... olpJI ~ "y'i~
~
ulJ ~I
y'i\ u i\
~~.u~~(.S~1
~I~J' ~~(.S~I
. [ .ul~ ~ J y..\ ~I
(\}WJ
~I~ul ~I¥(
UJJ~J
.:•
o~1 ~ T.Jjl.! u.fi:
~J~o4=JI~
.( f : ,
.J~
OV: i ~)
.:.
~ y'il
) , o~
u'...5. J ] (r) ~\
~
. .&I~), ~I)I
~I
jA
u.fi: ul o4=JI
~ ~
~L..QI~I ~
"",,'iJI ~I
~~I
J ..Yo~ J t.JA! ~ ~'il
" u\..S l.4A ~
~
r-lll ~J
u'i , J.j~ u\..S ~ ~
~
~'il
J.S " .u.c. ~
~ ..,,::JI o4-:JIJ
u-e ~I
J:)" (J'lt.l11 .J.iJw.itSo4=J1 J o4-:JI~tS ~ " ~I
-,
~I
~L-::.. (.S.l.:l..) ~
~I
.
.a.>ll : ~w
o~' ~ ~t"
: ~4 ~
.:.
J~J
u!-! ' ~
J~ . ~~I
J~
~ t.p..;(.S1, y'i~ t.p..;~'il ] (Y) ~~..)'il
t.p..;y..'iIJ,
: ~j.a..J~1
~
!l~..)'il
u'i ~lA:i.a
~I~
. [ ~~ "II ~
. ~~)
I
~I~
.u\~ t.p..;T~IJ
.[ .u~ ~
~ ~Ji.4! 0.A
.uj~]
",) ~"
u-C~
.&1
b J:
~ ..,,::JI o4-:J1U\ .lS.>.l1.lA.
(.Sill ~
. ~L:JIo~\
.(f:'~) \:jyJ J\i9 WJA
~
~
..,,::JI ~I~ o4=JI~ .ul ~I
. ( "0 : , , ~) " ~
~
~I
y.J .lS\ .l!J
W~ ) J ~ 0A\ 0A o4=JIJ~t.;i11~ u\ " .JjW ~\
1. St. Hilary of Po tiers : De Synodis, (13,11) P7, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979 2.
St. Basil: Prolegomena on John VI, 57, PXXXIX, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VIII, 1978. , ( i,V w6.I.:...-!) , ~~I ~j;JI, u:"J:! ~lc~: 1.S.J~'1\ uJ..>.P ~\
\ ••••/\ ~1"Y'\:il1
.\i \ c..>'"
r
wi t~.u
J:) " ~ 'i) y';;l ~l ~~ ~I ~
.( i : , f
~\..Nlu~ yA
.ukl (,S~I.J4b\r1 ~)I
~ u~ ~I
•• ~
~
.JA('sJWI y';;l ~) ~..;b ulLAjJ ~)
Jt!" . l)~ J ~
rJJ y.)\ ~ 'Xi
1Jj ~
"'1r-"""'"' - <:1. Ii ""~
~
().4
~::"llt ~
~\.&I
UJF
I...l •
II J\..i LA.lld
• .J"'
y.\~ U.o ~l y)-.;
A..;~'i\o4=JI~
. (i'\ ~ V : i J:)" ~\.&\
u~ ~
Ii.\ UIJ. ~04-=J1
yA
'"
~\
J.J-'o'l)1(,)'l ~
\.L1r...a
_.AI< lAAJ . r-r-
~4-t!. 1~
ul UJ~Y
w.il ~i W!.JCJWAf~ LP-iJ
~l ~I
~I
u'-:'1IJ
l.ii.....a .Jb!'il' ,(>C
u~
(,)'l ~
~4
ul ~
~.J
~):J\ .JA
o4=JIJ~\J
~l ~I
J
~y';;l~1.l!J
ulu~.ill\
~4J\~\ . [ ~\~ o4=Jl.JAJ.&I U J' .&10..,94,jl]
o~ J ~
t~
Lifi: ~ ~IJ
4,j)
0~1
u1-9 u';;l J . LHj~.JA .[( i : H ~
.&1u-e Jti;
,.u
~( '" :
~'1IJ' 04=J\~.JA
. 06...T".. AI). ~I
I~
.J~ ~
J~.J .:.
r : 'v ~,r : " )) LJ.e- ~..P
jA ~
J:) " 04=J1.JAwi " J~ (,S~I.JAJ ~~\rIl)1\ ~ .JA~'1\ <U.GI .... ..J:
. [.u\~ ~04=J1.u.JA ~I
(j4
(Jo'l~~i ~Jill
l.A.\ ~ t~\
~b
wi J r.s--. - 111...l';;\ .] (i) ~.J~L I t..AS" .u" J9 <.s!
j)yJI
r
J~ .:.
c.F U"'~~i ~Jil'
uts. J ](0) ~i
u11:u. ~
W\j \..its. J
uti'
(f)
y';;I.&\]
~I
y';;4 4,j1~ (V)
, .J.JJ'.(jA .J.>J, . .wI .uc.
~
."l .A. ~ (,s y":!'"
J~ ., ••• •
(OV : i J:) " y';;4
(,S.J~'11 uJ~ .. ~.w\r
~\
~~\
J~J
.:.
~I oh:J1 • /),-G.A .......:r'
. [o~
4. 5. 6. ''\'\A
St. Athanasius: De Incarnatione Verbi Dei, Chapt. 21 (4) P47, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,1980 Ibid., Orat. C. Ar. I, Chapt. VI, (19) P317 St. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book VII, (27) Pl30, NPNF. 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979
~I
• ".,;AWl.
( i.V
~6.b....:.l)• ~~1
~j.;J1 .lb..>.!
~l
C~:
t..S~,!1
~.J:!S iY':!.lil1 , i i -,i
° U""
V
: ~~y, o~, ~ ~Y' _ T' \'"t";J'UY ., ~ "1 J ~
-: IIo~1 -:IIo~1 . .-b. ~~'JI o~1 c.r"" J ,~l.·,)lJ ~~ . c.r"" ~... ..
"1
~~'i\A.;! U;~ 1~
~~ W (.$~Idll~, ~'J\ o4:JI ~ !:.H'IIJ...:lW (.$~I ~.l;JI0A CJ\5. (.$~I " ~\.9 ~ J'JI ~.J u-!lh -':11..l...J- ~ ~ J . ~~'JI ol;-:J\ ).-&.,b'J1 ~)I
oWl ~
')j u..
oWI~:i ~
•....· ~l>A
lli~1 ~~ ~
J cU..:li\Will (.$
W~
cllil~.J(.$ ill c~
" l:Ju ~.. I~IJ w'i\.lie Wj\5. ~ -:11 ~'JI -< . '\J ,.-•. =:", J llil~.J ..:l.§ . ~. oWL ~. r~ J u' :J---6"""". I~I
.("":'-':1') J.# ~~'JI o4:JI~ ~\
t~
~I
U\..bc.\~b..:l.§'&\ . \ U·l r-J .\_~" J. c...H.
II u..r-w ._~Io ~-.:.~
"'-lll•• I.F~ . ~ -.:.-II.I.F~J. j.. . ( ".
.&1~J~.&I
J.J-"'l)I L...u-':1 ~..:lAl\ ~ ~J
CJI~
~ (~\
: 0 -':1 , )"
~'J\ o4:JIJ ~I.u)'\
~1).uJ]
(A)
o4:JIt~
: O~, ~I
~.
CJIyUJ ~ ~I
ol;-:JI.JA
O~ ~J
~
'
.("i , "0 : "
: ;~I
\:i..;.J JI.! yill 0A .JjW fJ9J CJI~
-':1) " ~ 'II ~J u ~ l.Jl9~ 0A\J ~ CJ\5. 0A ~ J. ~ ~\.JJ
;~\
JA
#"ji y)\ JSi
J (.$ill 4
'IJ 1~'4 ~
~J~'
ciA.CJ'J " ~I
J~J . ( t. : i ~) " .J.P. 'II r"..,;11 u-!~\
. (tV:
~I
UI.J-4'JI?J9J.JA . ~
: ~ U--.J:! U-- JSJ (.$.);~ J.SCJI~
~Y' _ r
~,~~
.w ~\
)J ~ 0A\0Ao4:JIJ 4...o~1 ~ ul " .JjW ~I
.w\~
~J'
.l..:il~ u-90l;-:JI
~J.J uIJA'JIJ, ~
J~ .•:•
~Ji31
I.SJ~'i\~.;:S
. [~~'JI o4:JI~ ~IJ'
ol;-:JI~
~ I~. ~\
i
CP ~~
~J
'J..:~'J';~, ~ .1
Y.J J~
ulJ ~~I o~ .u CJ~
-':1)" ~lo~.u!~0A~0ArSlJ~\
utA
liA. u-9J 4..:' ~
~I
~J !:.Hill
~I"
~i
ol;::J1 O.J4£H.uj] u-a~1 ~ C}._.4;"i~~I
~
" u1(.51. ~ u~
J:! ~
~
ul ~ ~~'l\
~
. [ ( 'v : i wi ~ : ~J~~I
uJ . ~WI
.h.1~I
0'" JY(.5~1 ~I
j¥JI ~ lil" ~I
~ ~llill.S~\
o~
~~
oW! 0-".) yAJ (.5~
lJ.A "
(.5~1U"~I
J~
\~ . ~
~I
'J!bl~
Y.J
~1 J.Au . ( 0 ~ ,
(.5~\4.J5j1
.ul~~.u
~\
0'
:
Ii.\ U..a
F\
i .J-;!) "
~~llilJ~~i
i .;;)"~')II"~\
uJ.J#.
0'" ~t;0'" ~ ] (,.) (.5.J~"i1
ol;::J1 ~
J~ \~ u-9J
j¥JIJ. ~'ll ~j ~
. (Of: ~
~l9 ) " ~)9
'J.:~"J1o~l ~ • y
cJMJL.t:()AJ
o~ J:?1 0'" .u~1(.5~1(.5~
0'l':1.ill\
J~ .:.
~\ u'l . ~l i~
4..l9
. [" ~~'l\ r~..11.~ wllil 4S'"
,
:w.lw
:~f~~~f~WJf '"~ .JI
, 4Jc. I~
(!..P- ~\ ~
..J6.11~l
. ( ~0 _ , :
i .;;)liA.w ~
'.
J.
ts1A
°~
o~l
o~ J~
~ ~ ~y
u!""4JII"~ ~")t\
~
<L.UJ o~
JJli.:i.Il~1
0'" ~ U1J ' yJl l~ ~ ~I
0.J~
..):lC ~
~
~IJ .(
°J~ J WJ
~ oL.;I.be.~'l
U1~
c~
~'l
yy\ u'lJ
y)ill ~\j
.)j4-l\ 1"W:J1 'i \~ lJ.A
~ '"I
U1 U:l-- j.o \~tS
0~
~ ~ y ~l9 o)L ~\
.uA~A'a.;,,~,l.uA 'i ~1 ~ JS.:~J' ~~')l
_,
w'i'il c..-::--, "'All~l~
~(.,)-Q
"
.J
••
: ~,~ .\ '" ~J~ <.. ~ . UY-J~.
*
uJ.J:!-S 0'l':1.ill1 J~
(.5.J~"i1
o~-b.~~(")
J . ( ~V , ~ i: i
0i
- f 1\ : i .J-;!)
.J-;!)
~'l\
.(OV:i.J:!)
\'1"i ~,
~t..J1 t"?'yJl
. '\
'00
~t..J1 t"?'yJl
., •
~,
(II)
J.#~ ~. . -~III~
\~U:fl~. .. " .1.1:
-:11
~LWI c.sJ ~'il· •
...t
c:~.
J111
•• (
U-~~
~~-4)}11-..;--JI ~~(.S~~~~~u~~'i
T~l c::~)U.
~L..£11 r-:&;,
~J ~
. [ yly:JIJ r-tJJ.JI
~I
c:J.J,.iJ'J1 ~
~l
, ~\
~
(.Sill~~I
ue uyJI ~
to
•••
~\]
A...o~.Jo~
~I ~ u-a ~
(.Sl ~J
: " yY~ i$> lil " o.)~~
-r
: ~.".'i y~4 ~ 6:'i1 -I ~I
L;9.)jJ~\
~J ~
ul~u-a4JY ~)I
y'1\ ~~
y'1~
r.r u:'J1ul ~L.NIolSl
u~ ~ r.r ~ ~ ~I ~ ~I uY.J . y'1l ;;~ ~ .w\~~ (j~'J~ ~I C.J)I u-i.J;;~'i)4u:'J\u-i y'1\ u-ar-I.J~I~.J
;;4=JI
u:'J1 u~ ~.
. ( "0
: , , ~)"
;;4=JI.J ~t.;ill.JA Lil " ~
.u.J
~ jl
ue J~
. ~I y~1 ()t J."l,JA ~~ y~4 ~ 6:'itj ~j3
uY
.y9 J:.,.fl r-1o~ ~.\
(,jJ.JC
. UA
y'1~ r.r
~'\.c.(.S.L4Jc~
(,jJ
. [~I;;~ .u. y'11 u-a~)yJ\
JA ] ('~)
UL..\
~I~
~J111 J~
c.s~
•• Qw'1l·U.A .uJ-~'<' .('1 ~... 1 Jfr. ~ U~.J.
u-i ~I
y'11 .ul~u-i.u UY
~
u:'J14JY y'1~ r.r u:'JI]
('I")
UM~~I
~.. ~..JC ~ ~ .
. ~\ ~J111
. [y'11 u-a~~I (\f).u~
oj
ue ~4Jfl~'
·JI ~
c.sji
JjU11 UM.jJ~J.
y'1~~~.uJ#.J.u~ul~" (j.,9J
~J J~J .:• ~
u--;J111 .1.Sj:J .:. y'1~~
. [~~
.:.
wi"]
u-aj ~ (j.,9 y'11
,., ~~L..JI t'"~I."
12. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book VIII, (16) P142, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979.
A.i~" l...;-J'i~c.r- wi" ] J.# u-llll~ ~~ ~ ~~I-J
~I
. [ ~I
o~
~
('0)
~-J~'il
UA:!.11l1 cAJ
~-.»S
o\.::J\ .JA ~~-J (.S~Il...;-J'il ul ~
-Jwl-J~
l...;-J'il u'i o\.::JI wi (.SI. .u yo ~ ~
.JA
.:.
~i
~
: ~~u y\t4 ~ 6:'11 -y :61~4J~1~1 ~
l...;-J'ilQA.w u=:J1~.lj'il
.u~ -Jl...;-J'il().A~ j'il
~\
o~
:
L...fJJI
:
~~J
.oJ~~ . r;.Y' ~Jill ~.wl
~
~1.)1J1QA-Jl,}'lJilI C-J)I QA QA)I ~ " l...;-J'i~~
lit "
.JA
o~
l...;-J.) J.,.9 ~J u~JilI
~I
~~'i\ .)J '':'J-J ~.(j~
u=J1o4=J1ul ~
tA~
W ~l
" l...;-J'i~ c.r- wi "
AJ' a';' ,':,1\.uJIJ.~..JA . ~\
~
.u~] (1"1)
Uo'l~4
tA~
o~W\
~\
u-Y.11l1 J~J o~\
~
.:.
'-;J'i~
.[~Io~
~'1~~ JS. ~ l...;-J'il] (' V) Uo'l~~1 u-YiiJ1 J~ .\1 ••~. ~IN~ c_.M UA . t.:J ~ • ~ow\.! ~ ·:'·.l\ob 1- ~-:..L:.·I~ C-JY~ U.A:lo. ~ J""""!" ~ t..s~ [ l,}'lJilI C-J)l ~
~J
·u
U.
..JAC
, c..~ - ''''AII ~I~ ~
t.;p. f~
J=.:! ~l
.(fO
~t
~. ~ A.ii ~..J-UJU1\o~ ~ l...;-J'il~
C-J)I " ~I.)~ :))
"J:il
~ld~ •
.li!. ~I
-J.
oG.:J1 ~ ~ 'lA
oY't:al1, ( V , , ..:.o6.t.:.....)'I ) , ~~I
. - .'1 '--l .11l,}'l.li\\ • J""
Jj I~ ~ -J. l,}'l.li\\ C-Jyl
~I
J)yJl
~
l...;-J'il().A w.J-"'lLill w..:...l.o
C-Jyl ~ ~
J;jl~
~J ~~ ~
.
l,}'l-JJilI~l.cll~
~.fiJ1 '~J:!~!
C~
~
~ 4...JS.l~
~l
: ($~)'I . ",
,
.:•
uJ..>.P
o~-J ~
~I
.,
0
l.!"" ''1'11\
16. St. Basil: To the Caesarians, Letter VIII, (4) P1l7, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VIII, 1978 'I'1\ ~I , ..,1}il ~t.....)1 , ~I CJ)I ,:.;e. ..,1."..)1 U"J:!""lfj\ L>":l~1 Jjt......) : U"J:!""lfjl L>":l~1 . 'V v, l.!""
~YI
U").u.,
o~1 , ':'JI':'~.Y'u-ill ,,:-,:..,;a.J
LY.'i\ . U'l~1CJ)IJ ~'ilJ ~ ~I
u~ li.ll.JLa J.. A...J
0A" ~\
Y.J
il~\J il~\J. il~ 0A il~ ~ ~\
u~ lill.(j6 ~ ~ L-l ~w ~..
~\
~~l il~
J\.! I~ J . .IJ..G J}.1i:10A ~
~J
~
~'il ill..wJ\.u ~ r..S ~\
u~)U~
~\
" i$~~~
~
, y'i~ ~
LPJI~
JA
LoS]
('A)
Ai;;i\~ ~11,$..tJ..::A
J."l: .:.
~Ji3\
[O~~-l:~
J.T.q ~.ll~
~l('L· ~ UA."I....J)\
(Of:
~~\ ~...r'
i J:!)" ~\tl
t.;J ~~ y'i\ ~ ~t!i>~1.....
•
~bo.jj\ilb . .-b. ~~ ~ -.s-
r~\ .)~l
1....JiA.u} ~\
ilWI .... ~ ... ~. ~ I. ~ \-
y.J ~
11\ \ t..r"" -: IIil~\ .JL:,j'Jf\ •. ~. _~,.I.(!-I•••••• ~
lilJ~~lil~-iliu-4~yAJr..S~
J~] ('~)~\
-:IIil~\ ....t..r"" .. J. ~
J."l: .:.
~Ji3\
~j~.J:!
~.... ~ ~I<L ,', .. ~
A~
~
wi
[~)I ~~0A" ~
~J'
~\
Y.JJ..,il-b.~.)(Y')
~wJ-""lr..S~u-!
I,$.)~'i\
u-!~ii..~u-a
~1~'Jf~~
[ il~ ~l
J~", .:.
~~~~\
U}] "~~
U1.J~t.il\lil . :) ~tsl4
,
:~ , ~\t4 ~ ul", ~\
~~\ ~)
lAS " (
0V
~!,'O'IJJ diU: ~b
: '\ .J:!) ~ J.;I.jl\ uall\ ~ " 1ft ~
~
~t: uA!
18. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book VIII (16) P142, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 19. St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on St. John, Horn. XLVII, (1) P168, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, 1979 . ~ '~~A ~i .Y't:il\ V, iwl.:..b.......)'1 ) : ~1:i11 ~Y.J\, lhJ:!~) C~ : ($ y:&..)' I v-l.Jfi 0":!ii.l1. 'I' •
'i. _,
o~
~4VUI y'il
~~J.
u)l J!-S.w,
\'!\T',JI~I
~I.JoA~1 .~
4J.o
.W
. ~I~I ~ ,~,
'!\J1J, iiI\ ~ ~...>---AY?- ~
.J4 ~l
t:..H'I1 ~~
( ~"\ :
ul " ~ (~O :' , ..J:) "
A~"
~o~u-lJ
0
o~IJ
~
..J:) " -Glj~li~.u 4.Alftll .J4 ul
"~
y'il "
.u ~
\~ . ~\
y'il
4J~~J
ul ~
.~~l
ur:- Jl9(5jl\~.
~I~\ LJA o~l(5jll
.o:UY"'lu ~
LJA
~t
LJA
ul ~"
J.atsl4~J
' ~
~ ~~~
ul yWI ul , ~
~ ~ ~ ~~ UY"'l '
~
.J4
~J
·'1.~1
0A N.:.
~
uA" 4J~ ~J
.J~'1\ ~ J)\.:..(5~
. y'iliill(5t , li~1 ~IJ
~t
LJA
.:.
y'i\
~I. .o:UJ4'i~
.. '::'1
.:•
~
J;.)JI
~IJ
·(,,)"'-"'-'CJY~
~ ~1~'14~
.:.
~Ij li~1
~ .u c:fij r.lo~1 ul ~ 'i ~ " y'i4 ~ ul " 4J~ .)'\Y?- ~.u. ~I y'il LJA j)..JA 4J'i y'i4 ~ t:..H'I1 .
y'il LJA -G~ JU~,
'i .o:UJ".A.)L.
y'il " 4Jj-l ~J
. ("\ :' f..J:) " li~IJ ~I.J:
J.:. .
~
~J~"
y'il
ul~.J:!" ~I
li~1
~\+
~'i . li~
.:.
~
~ 1.)111
",
"J
J.;ai,l'
-"~'J~i "
[t.:~.j.J]
"~\J,-:.8IJ\.jI"
&1)\ ~I
--------
: a.t.aM j))1 u-ill ~I..:a.f~ u-!
,--;.M
~,~I
t- b_~IJ~
~l
0-./'/1uJ I)U!.
w.J-A'i LJ~J:}il
" ~IJ '-;J'1IL J it" [
o~ J uJ ~l§ LJ~ J:.J'11u~t J . J..,illJ .fiilIJ oj\3tl\ ~ ~
LJ-e ~
~I ly.M ~t
~t \.S~I ~\
~I ~~\ ~! ~t
~I
Jj ~.
la.A.J
.~,.'l\o~
~
~ ~ ~
r. : , · .J-:] u..! .u.IJ .us! , y\ y;J1
fi '-;J'11 ~ iY'I\
u-i f slob! 0'lJ.l....il1 '-;J'11 4t .. " [ , , : 'V .l! wtJ" [
rr :
'V
>:] ~t
.u.jJ." ~
."~I J
~..".;J\ ~~
~l.\
.uIJbJ ' ~I
~I
wy\
~4'1\jJj.JJ LJ~J:.J'1I~..;Ja u=J1 ~Ww.llC~
. . (.)='oJ
.J-:l]
LaS f.u.IJ
wt tAS. f~\
J
\.JJ.J-":!" -< .1
'i ~I..NI4t .l!J JJl.U.iuJ-"'lJ ..~I
- _~II_ .~~c...~~J
,.••.._1\
... ~-:ll
o~tJilt 0->->' ~
0->->' ~,
~ilt, yyt 0->->'
w~ W~~ -,
:~t,l.fb~t ~~..Ji:-
..[o~J\ ~l
,~I CY.'1\
~J
~
o~.J:1,.•/11 o~.J:1La d] (')0~~.J')\
A..a.A~
cjA
~J
..>A~I o~ J ~
..~ ~
~'1\J ..[ W\~\.J'II
~,
" ~IJ y'}IJ
uI " LH'I\ Jy!
~l
J~J'~
L;\..QJ1JJ~~ ~ ~]
..[y'}l
1-
~I
~.l:l.\J~~~J'
(f).(\")
cjA
.:•
,.u
~ 'i
0.."J~J ~\.j ~
0~~.J'}1'
OJ'
.:•
J
OJJ .:•
o.l:l. J ~ J o~\ .J'IIo.l:l. J~
~w! ~
~I ~
~
,--:-Mo~ J d f) ~I
..[ ~ ~I o.l:l. J ) ~I
~~t~
~ 'iJ'~
J~
0-?ilt, yyt
ow\>, w~ W~~
u1Y ~'11] ("I) 0~~.J'}1 J~
_r
.:•
y'}\ ~~~\J~\
St. Athanasius: Orationes Contra Arianos, OratIIl , Chapt. XXV, (10) p399, NPNF., 2nd• Sec., Vol. IV, 1980.
2-
St. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate , Book VIII , (10) p140, NPNF., 2nd• Ser., Vol. IX, 1979.
3 - Ibid., (6) pl39. 4-
ST. Cyril of Alexandria:
Commentary on the Gospel According to St . John, Vol.
II, Book VII, London, Walter Smith, 1885, P 102. 5-
ST. Hilary of Poi tiers : De Trinitate, Book VII, (24) p 128, NPNF., 2nd• Ser., Vol.
6-
IX, 1980. St. Athanasius: Orationes Contra Arianos, OratIIl, Chapt . XXV, (10) p399 , NPNF., 2nd• Sec., Vol. IV, 1980.
" AI
J
,..:J'iI
J
ul"
&1)1 J.,..:.ill
:A.Jf ~ ow\>"tr ~Yf, yYf Ow\>,w4w~~ "~~
T.l.:l..IIJ-iM" J
O.A)I Ji.ca ~
J..,.! u-!]
y)U0 ..lil
l).lilJ y';l CH:Io.l.:l..)1 ut ~
(V)
~,JJ
I¥,
( "
_r
•... iJI J..J.i:I .:.
:
'v .>:!)
. ~ .••.. 11 ~• ~. J(.)-'l;!~.<-:11 c.s~ [ u·tA.J';l1
: ~~J~I
.
.a.,JI : ~W
~L.QljI.I!~
: of,l-o..?~Yf, ySo w\>f,.fb~ A.;..)-'\~ o~J
, ~J f
'0';
~ ,~!
0-t/1J y';l
~
0-:'iIJ y';l
d--.: ~~';I
U~ ~,JJ
c,N L...o 1 A41,1.; " Ut ~ ulji.c'll
, 0-:I'Il: ulji.cJ.>A y';~ Ut ~
~..,Hl-J
.:.
~I~'il)
';l . .l.::o.IJ.wJ ~
J
~J-""I)I U'-:'1IJ .T.l.:l..IJ
~..>:!
ulji.c'lIJ.
';l c:.H'I1 U~ . y';l
.•.lJI ~~
.l.S).! LJ-SlJ(JiJI
rj-.ftJ'I1
~
u:.tJu.;aJ ';l W~ , ~
.u U~
o~J
-,
0-:1'11 ()-4 ~}J'
y';l ()-4
u-1cUtA.>:c:.H'Il: U'-:'1IJ . y';l ~~J UJ~~#
rA ~I ~I
~t!~1 , ~~.)J ~
~
, ~tiil
~
.l.:l..I~I J
d~ u.JuU ~
CJ)I ~ y';l tJAJ o~';l)\..:~'11 ~ y';l tJAo.AIJ ~I
y';IJ wt" ~'11 J..,.! u-!J. T.l.:l..Ib..;.!I~J J .w.JAl~IJ~I .AIJJ y\~l
~ .AIJ ~
~I
J U~ , .l.:l.,1.J
.l.:l..IJ.W} ~ ~I~liil J y\ ~I
c:.H'IIJy';l ] (") Wo'l~ltil
. J'~'14
~ .AIJ 4Jt ~
~Jl11 J~
.[ w .JAl~1~ .AIJJ ,~\
" .AIJ
IlA ~J
.:•
~
7-
ST. Ambrose, De Fide, Book IV , Chapt . III, (34) p265, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X
8-
St. Athanasiusn: Orations Contra Arianos, OratIII , Chapt XXIII, (4) p395 , NPNF.,
1979. 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 9-
Ibid., Chapt, XXV, (13) p401
" ~IJ y'iIJ
wI" ----------------
~\)I J.,...il\
u~t kJJI ~ 1..4J ' t kJJI ~ 1..4 yo W! .)..,Dlo..»l;LA u'i] J# t ~I yo ~'il u'i _~'il ~j.) J)l;. ()Ay~1 c.sy ~1 1iS.\. .)..,DI u~ ()A
oy~
_[~IJ lA.\ ~'iIJy~t!~J c.s~'iI.&1, ~l ()A~)I
~'il
JA
" ~IJ
u1"l~
y~IJ
~
t.:.H'i1 J~
~)I
] (")cJJla.JWIU"'J-I..J.Ji.lj!~Jijl
l.ulc. ] (' l) ~I
~J
'
U"'J-I..J.Ji.l"";:'
.[~!
~ J: 'J 4J'i
~
~~
•
~~~J~J
~'il ~
IJiJjJ Ip~~"
o~
.:.
_t.:.H'i\
J '
J:.;y!ZJ
u,jA'JJ W1j:\..tl.a wL..".r!I-
~IJ
wy\~1 _(.)'lJ~I ~ ~I
J~J
~
4-:!! ~
, Y~ ~ ~
J:)
JS.>.! ~
~
~("") U"'~J.J:'AI ~Jijl
: ~~IJ
'J J ' Ulk.o ~~
O~J
.:.
J~J .:.
~Jijl
~jil _o~IJ u)lUSlJ' ujil u-! t~
_ o~IJ ~
4-:!! ~
y~\ ~ ~jil
J~J
r. : ,.
[~jil
~ ~1 ~jil
J~J .:.
y\~~()A~~J-
_[y\~lo~J~J·:Uc.L.~~( " ~IJ y~IJ L.il "
t~
- y~\
f -) AJJil..,H UL.u1 cJ.JJ.::.A ~Jijl
_[.ui.#Jy~1
J
u-! O~\J ~)1 c.s~ ~
~I
~
~I
-\iil' ~ lAi'l.J"l y.)
_( , '\ : "A w.a ) ~\
J~
1
J: 'J
rc.'.\1y~ ·1'~ ~
I~ u-!J
CJ)\J ~'i\J y~1
10 - ST. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate , Book VII , (11) pl22 ,NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 11-
ST. Gregory of Nazianzen : On the Arrival of the Egyptians (XIII) nd
2
•
p337, NPNF.,
Ser., Vol.VII, 1978.
12 - ST. Gregory of Nyssa:
Against Eunomius , Book II (6) p107 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser .,
Vol.V, 1971. 13 - ST. Ambrose: De Fide, Book I, Chapt. II, (17) p204, 1979.
NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol X,
wi" ------------
J y'lIJ
" .l:o.I
~ ~\J
.ul 'ij
~I)l
u\.l:jjl.4Al t ~IJ
W.>A'i .>A r:.H'I\ w.>A 'i ~l . [ o\..J'-'ly;.l ~J
y';;IJ wI"
i)
0"1~~
1iS.\. ~~\'\ J.S ~~
~J: .u\', l~
~IJ.uj
CH'I\ ~]
op.-....i11 ~~..ulJ~u-e ~"
f
ul ~
~I
J~ ~.
( f.
~
~.aJ\
J.,..:.Al1
J~
(.Sill~I
.:.
.)~
'i ~ w~)lj\ u~ \~J, y~\
('O)0"I~J,,»41U"'-:/Ji1\JJ-i:lJ .:.
: , • J:)
" ~IJ y';;lJ wI" .u~ o~\)\ .oIJW\
'i o~ )\J ' r:.H'IIJy';;\ ~ ~
;;\JL...Jl . o~)\ ~h.:i" ~\J "
~
y;.1 y';;IJ ~IJ
'i o~)IJ'
~'11ul ~yoIJL...Jl , r:.H'I1 ~
. [ ~~I ~
~
y';;l
j)yJIJ j}lp
.u../il u-! ~\J
.oj'i)\ ue ~
J~
O~JJ~\
;;~J ~
l.4AI] ('i)~I0"I~J,,»41
~lJ
1.G.ll.c
y';;l ~
~ f~IJ ~
~Ji1\
J~J
.:HU
1.$ .14.;.wJ16A 1.$ .14.;.wJ1,
~~"~IJ y';;IJ ul " r:.H'l1 J.,.! u-!] ~
'i
.[
~
~I\ ~W\
o~ YJ -II
'iJ, ~IJ y';;\J ~'11J J~~] ~IJ
' 1 04)'
0';" .~,! Ul~
.:.
j:.W ~'1IJ y';;l ~ USJ'~'11 t.A f~IJ U.a~'i
.4). 0';" ,~,l\~ ~j:.W
•[J,.\S31 6A J,.\S31 ,
J
(IV)
0"1~4
~Ji11
,4..J.lol .11 4.S~.~.I\ (S".II ~~'iL, •. ~ ~.JfS ~Ji11
('A) 1.$,J~"i1
~I
uj!
J~J
.:.
~l 6A ~l ~I
'
,
'1.!""\11
~
J~J
.:.
..ul~~'1IJ ..ul~y';;l UlU.a j.i \..ijSJJ. ~ j:.W ~ .
[ ~\
\b. ~ J ...r
"~'i\
(J;!-1J,
~
14 - S10Athanasius: Orationes Contra Arianos, OratIII , Chapt XXIII, (4) p395 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser ., Vol. IV, 1980. 15 -
ST. Ambrose:
De Spiritu Sancto, Book III, Chap10 XVI, (116,117) P151, NPNF.,
2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979. 16 -
Ibid., De Fide, Book I , Chapt, II , (16) p204 .
17 -
ST. Basil: De Spiritu Sancto, XXV, (59) p37, NPNF., 2nd. Ser . , Vol. VIII, 1978
18 -
ST, Cyril of Alexandria: , Book VII,
Commentary on the Gospel According to ST. John, Vol. II
London 1885 P 102 .
: iJ~.j34~
u-a ~~I
~J'
y';\
~\ye
"II) ~
ul
I . Ie' ~LJ--A~~
~~ ~
YJ} ~
UJ..), .J~I I
~I _.
ll~
4} ~
u-a ( i
: " ~) ~
~
LoJ ' ~ ~ ~
wy\~\ .JA
~I ..
~
~ ~'il. Y
y';\ 0.A ..)..,Jya CH'i\
J' 0..)"; ~
4.l!.u\.!" _ .. "Al\ ••• c..~
JS.! ~ ~ .JA
t;Jj\ ~
~.uJ'
y~1 ~~
.
(.)C~
~'i\
u~ U~
CH'i\
u ~1.1~1 • ~J
~J,..aJ,S rb'-J.
Lo JSJ " y)U ~I
ry.§i
~.J';I o-C~ LAS
~I ~\
~
J .(JJ~\
..... I:;·· ~f "'I ~
(Ow':" ~)
t;~
Ylot::w
...
w.J---A~\
J..,i;\~ ~ J . 4.1~ w y\~\
~\
. ( , • : 'V ~) " ~ ~ ~J'
-u..)";J~.&\.JA.&\~}]
~..))ya'
~\Sl\ u-a~lS.\\,
~10.A~I,
r.s..tJ..:A ~.1i31 J..,:i: .:.
~I
(\~)~I.J:I
~\
0.A~\
~J.ll~~
• [4.11 • (.)A
•
~~} (~'i\ J y';l) ~ fi ~ ] p .) ~I -I.ul LoS . J\'Y-J..\";J ~..JC ";J ,~\
~I.J:I
~I
.... . ";J~~~...
(""'
J..,:i:J .:.
r.s.]:J...;A ~.1i31
....~I
·u JU.
o.l-:l.
• ~\ 0..)"; .J:.. ~\:j ~ ... 1.7,j""• . [ ~.
o..),,;~.u~I
~I
~I
~I
](n)~l!~I.J:I • [ ..b.\
J y';\J
( r. : , • ..H)" .l-:l.\ J y';IJ L.j " ~\
4J} ~.wl
~
. [.u}
19 20 21 22 -
~): CH'i\ ] (n)~1
u-a ~ ~
4.l)'1 U~ , ~'i\ ~
r.s..tJ..:A ~Ji3l .JA
~I
~J Jil.J:I ~I
~
~J
.:•
.ul~ ~ ~\ ~ J~
<\.:l.~
~
J .:.
r.s..tJ..:A U"I-:!.1i31 J..,:i:
";~.Ii\
o..b.J~J.
b.)j..o
ST, Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book II , , (20) PS7 , NPNF" 2nd, Ser . , Vol, IX 1979, Ibid" Book VII, (22) p128 . Ibid" (24) p128 Ibid" Book IX, (1) pISS,
"~IJ
ul" -------------
yYIJ
&\)\ J,.-ill
o.)~ ",. 6:'11 - -i"
: ~I .,.., ~I ~~I-ti.G ~ ~~
, ( f. : , • ..,;) " ~;;fY~\J ul II ~I ·L...wIW,j1 J.~\j".u W.
.
iiJl ~ A"jltS1iiJ1LHJ~
.I•• ()~
"iiJl U:. . I ~. '1-.::..l19 ~ .~ ~
~I
JU ~
~I 0y::....J:!:'" .. 10.J. ~I-I ~...1··l!l.....AJ~0 ~. . JA-+J.J. ~
~I ~ J . ( ff -n :,· J':!) " 4JJ . J ~~i _n.11 '1.u...., ~ 11 ~~ Wy.JiJ r-(.5'". .JIJ u~1 . I.j ill" U'-li:I
J ~\
. ~I.u .
YJill J
~I
. ( fi : , • ..,;) ,f}i}i." ~l~"
~\
~I
ult~..,;.J~I4l-\..c.~l ~~II~.wl
. ( Jill u::al~'il) .J~I ~
Ji:- iiJl 0.J~
"
~ ~ tS~1~)I
A"jl~I
~I
"w\.i):;..-JI~.)c.
u-e-J.J-'"'l)1~ ~ ~l
LH'I1. .hi.hl 0.);~ iiJl " u~ . ~
" y~1 tSl.J .li! ~i.J tSill " ~
J~ J~.IJSl J~J
'0 : , A"
tSill (
Y. y~1
y.)1 JU 141J . ( ,1\ : , J':!)" ~
. ( '\ : , f J:l)
.[~~IJAi'ii'i.,,!\ ~ LH'II] 4.J~ .
0.J~I ~ 0.hJLH'I1](ll") UM~~I
u-J-JP
(H)~.)~~I
~ ,-J.
I ~I
,-,,"=J131J~ ,y~1 ;;.J~
~
J~ .:.
~l
LH'IIu.."sUCJ .:.
J)l1:JJ,..u.:..1.tS I..u. . _:. '".I 0 .. - .11 0 . ..,;'iJ ,u~1 . ~~.J~
_1\
. [ J)lb'll .)c.
'i 1.49 ".hIJ y~IJ ul .u...,i0-9] (lO)~1 II
u-.o ~~I
~
~J.
..>A
~.)~'il
u-J..»S ~J131
J.,:A;., .:.
~I ~I.h J u-Ic J:.L USJJ ' o~l.J 'II u-9 Ul4..Jl ~ J\.iA"jll~ ~
I.•tli t. ,... •• (jj
cljj
.(~. _ t ~
••.• ,nAtl
J'**": ,
'--~
~ •
!~ •
JL.....&..4..,j1.J ,~I
4..,j1. ~
,·LG
v-
[lA~l.4S~ 23 -
St. Athanasius Orat. C. Ar. Orat. III , Chapt XXV, (10) p399 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser ., Vol. IV,1980 .
24 -
St. Cyril of Alexandria:
Commentary on the Gospel According to St . John, Vol. II
, Book XI, Chapt,VIII
,1885 P 509.
25 -
Ibid., Book VII,
p102.
ul "
" ~IJ y'l\J
J~.JA ] (n)4JJi\~
"~~ u.Jo-Al)UI
J-S ~
••~
. [~I ~ ~I
~
~I
-u1.u1 ~
~r..s-~. ~
..
L
wL~T ~ ~... L-:~·
'O).~.. ( L" : , ~)"
!..SI " I>YO~~.J"
~I
~I
J\!~J.
T~
~~ ~
~I!..SI,
~..m \~ . ('\ : " fi)
;J."w. 44J\ ~\J! J~J
JU] (~V)~Ul\
~ J.abJ I> yo~ ~.JJ I>~ •.~ ~ J !..S~I ~I . j~\' r..s-
J~J .:.
~\
<L..i}i " -\.Lc J!..-i J . (f. :' · .H)
~
0A J.aI.SJ ~
J.J-'"'l)\ u-JJ'! ~I
(,$..f:J--:.A
J.ac~I
~ !..Sill" ~I
Luu.w ., ~'-~~ ."~W'll
.~
0A ~I
~I
I>~I.)'I>~~.&I
TyL.-.~'ll
~~~I
('\ : , f J:) " y'll !..SI.J ~
\.jjl~ J;...'l~.
.:.
'O.Jy.al1 ~i.J !..Sill"
. [U4~ ~\J!
JJi: ' ( f.
I~t!
.~~'i ~
u~l ulJ ~}i
: , • J:)" ~IJ y'lIJ wI " ~\
~\
I~ 'O.J.,bJ~I~]
0A~~1
. ,~''? ~l\\ J;...'1 -u l..,1li , ~\
J.."il~ ~
(~")~\
;J.j!Ja 4l;W\
LJ! . I> ~
UC ~
..;:J '0.J~
.[(ff _f' :' •J:) 4-11 ~
: ~Y' ..>-A..,,;JI u~
~YLoJ:1' o~,
J-S \ "4J \<\
ul ~
n :' J: ~" : fA tP1 ~ ", : " 4-Lo J.S J ( A :
~"
: 'V J-:!)
.fb~l ~
u-tilJ ~
J.J~ , • : ,,'\
~'f : f ..H ~ , : f wI ~"f : "f .)) -Will
~
u'
, j.J ~"" : n j.J)"~
J.l.-i1\ J ' (":
(jll
tl'
~
~Y" yYl o~, _r
~I
..J-A..,,;J\ 'O~ J
)
t.H'lIJ '-;._:!1j'lLS.. ~I
< J.S ~ 4
u-!J .:.
J~
..,1IJ . ( A :'
J.S u-k '0 y.i1IJ
'."s ~ f: 'J-:! ~ ': A."sh '\: f
. ('"
:'
wI)
~I
j.J
A U-4
" ( fO : , )
26 -
ST. Hilary of Poi tiers : De Trinitate, Book IX, , (1) P 155 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser " Vol.
IX, 1979 . .)}il ~I '~;'.J~I.b4!YJ~.J:!lS.)l1 ~I
'.Y'till ,(~I
~.Y''J): ~~I.~~ H,
4t,J1t...,1~ _ '(V
. \. ua' \'\'\\~ .....• no uaua: ~l..J\~yJl _
'(;..
O~I.Jill oAJ ~~
uA
u~ill u~~(~~I
~;)il : ~I
u~uy:.~u~'>:.J'YI UlS. uJJ
~il\J y'Yl O~J ~I~"il)
~..,;JI oAJ ~
~I
L;UJJJ'
~
(Jill ~I~"il)
AIJ ~ ~illJ y'Yl l.F ~
lA JSul ~.,t;;J:1
: ~"iIJ y~ o~IJ OJIJl·1 I~ ~J'
oAIJ ~I
..JA..,;JI ul LaS.!
wl.JoA '11 tAl y'YI ul ~
~ill ill.GS , ~J
~l
Li4 ~
o~l.Jil\ul-!' ~il\J y)U ~IJ ~\
J,.j'1 " ~I
y.J J~
.(n : 0.>:) " "'~ AIJ w~'i
~
~illJ y'Ylul I..AS
f') ($~jLllI
~.jJ....)~.J;.
[~ U'lJ.ill1~)tJI ~ ~illJ y'Yl u1~IJ] AIJ ~
rb lAJ.
oAIJ o~I}~1j
44-11 L...lJi J.Jl:!J .:.
~WI OJ~
(r.)
~Ji31 J.Jl:! .:.
( r. : , • .J-:)" ~IJ Y'YIJlit" JU J,.j'J o~IJ ~ •
[ ~I ~
.~ fAI J u~ '.<'. 0.JJ~~ . --tI.a w"&..)\11 .j J"' l.S"
~J
~J'
. ( ~~I ~I~"il)
y'Yl ..JA~ wl~ lJ.A ~ y'Yl ~
~ ~
'CoHilIJ y)U ~IJ ..JA..,;JI ul ~, ,( U'l~~I)
~I.J--A
~il\
, ( 'A ....H . , ) A....l...JL.~.~..r-rr. - 1<'0: • "_b_
29 ~I,
<U.A
I.S
: ~"iIJ y~ ~
~
~ill
(.$~\
~I
AS]
w'Yl ~- 1<'0:
- y
u~ u~'>:.J'Y1 ~~ J~J ' y'YI ~
",Lc~ill1:U ~
U'J. 1
~IJ ~
I~l
uLy ~ill ul
",~'YIlJ-SlJ
l<I.~ ....:lo.IJ~1 U~0.JJ~4! •~
.. J , ~-.:
u----- ..r-
'-Wl.&1 . I
.( "f : , fil)
::- "_ &..
.G...&~·U
ST. Gregory of Nazianzen : The Fourth Theological Oration (The Second Concerning the Son ),( 12 )p 314, NPNF., 2nd. Ser ., Vo1.Vn , 1978. ~~;)il.J..4-DU~~)'1 ~I, iiJ-'l:ilI, (~I ~): ~~Iii..l~ 44J1 ~\..li _ r. ,..
U"'"
''''
j!jAl ,.) J'1\
wI" -------------
" ~I.J,.. /il.J
A .wll~ ~
~
. [y'.1\
__
'iJ ''-J'.1\. . UC ~
...1 ~l9 U":i"'
~.wl
~LS~\
wyy~1
..&\JQc. ~ , (,)"l.fl-)11 ~ ~\
~~l ~).
(r:" ~I
...?-. i~\ ..J:
~J111
...
U":i"' 1J ,~\
~I]
(n)
~WI t3.jW.
ue J.JoUl)1 uJ..J: ~I
JU ~~.
..J:
~y:. ~
44-11
~IJi
~W\
~I" ~ pI
~
~ t..&J\
. [( "t : , fil) r-fi.:J1~ y'.1l9, (" t : , fi' )..&1~
( 'V: , ~')
y.~\ u~ ~IJ ~.
~IJ ~\
(
'v : , wI)
'iJ
JJ-i:!J .:.
~ .. JiWI..&I~)
~~y.~\
~\Jt..&J\
J~ .:.
~\
u~ .. y'.1l y..fl- ue
j~
fi)"
" .wj ~I
•
Jb,.ll) ~.;a-JI~~l
'(,)"lJ~1~)\:ill~ ~I)
~
A LA u) ] (r,) U"'~~i
()..4.w~..&\~
~I)I
~I)I J,...:.il\
" ..&1
~ cY'Il ulS u1J
~\
CJ.J~ ~I
CJ..)IJ
.~\)\~\y.~I~~~~IJ
.w~~ ~
~l .wi ~
'y\~\
yJ ~
~y'.1\ ~41~JJ~\
J f':!~\ ~ ol:~ J
wi ;;~~~J".u~ " ;;..JljS lJJA .u~ .( H ,
uJcl LS~\~
~~I ~\ ~~I
w~'i 1~,.''iJl-J
~\
..&1 ulS u1J. ~~\
~~~JLS~I
~\
~~
r'\ , r t , r" , "A
, "" :
~
~l .wi ~ . ( 0 WA) "
~ ~\
~.w~ ~('" y.)
r t : ,r
>:)" ..
rS1 J~t!wi tAl .. ~tA~ ~
: ~'iIJ ":-I~I6A o~IJ ~ wl..r-=JIu-e ~
. ( , • : , • J:l)"
" ~~\ u-lj ~ 1iSA.
A..:J~ "
.u
~I
;;t.:-=JI u~
31 -
~\..)I .wj ~
J~ LS~\~I
~l
uJ J ~~i ;;~ y.J
~ uMJ;;~
~i
~\
JU
~ ufi:il w;:il " JjJ. ("
lJiJ " JU ~~I
J~ ~'14 y'.1l l.>-a 4JW
J-:l4..;ll.>-a J:! l.>-a JS ~
u.e ~\
~~\
'i ~ ~)I
;;~\
-~
:' • J:l)
u.e. J
~
;;t.:-=JI ~
.(" A :' • >:)
~j J~ ~
rJWI..&\y.:=.l
.('i :r
J:l)" J...;~~\
St. Athanasius: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat.,III , Chapt XXV, (10) p402 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser ., Vol. IV 1980, .
'\~,'\'\,
~L.,.~1:il1 ,(~,wy.'1):~I:JlI
•.)~t,.41'4.....I.)i
_n'
.u~
~ ~1.l:...bJI ul ~I
~'iIJ y'il CJA o~IJ ~
~.
~~l~IJI~M~1
~I~)~~)
~I
{,l.;o"
" .. f
~I
4:11 .. "
(j'lJolilly'il
~I
4"1) ~
LH~I,~\
y.J ~IJ
F1~
~
aU ~
f
( '" , " : 'v rSl~"
.u~~'iIJy'il
CJAo~IJ~1 ul J.Jo'"'l)1 u-J~~I
. ( " : , wi ~r : , fil ~v : 'J.J) " ~\ I~J'
l~\J~~IJo~IJ~1
u~ul
J~
cJo'l~\Z1 ~J1l1
:q..iJ ] (rr)
, ~IJ l.o.\ t~l
~I
.J~j
. I.: ~ ._.o~1 .J t~••
J..,iS. ~'il ~ J ~'i4 .&1 4...w u-1:. ~
~
]
($~\ ~
U..a ~
~I.J y'il.J ul " ~\
~'i4
[t~l:i.bl
0: II ~l ~ Lo: c.r-
:.
y'i\ ~ ~
~ t.O: ~.J
u\~ •
y'i\
.( "0 : , • ~)
o~
~
~I
,y'il "..
0.J~
u-U~
~
y"I.: ~
. ~ \~y)U
~I
~I
~~I
.ulAclul ~
.. 1_
u---
($
I ~••
~I Jl-c.1 ~I
~I ~4 ~I o~.J~ ~I
34 -
rSloLkJl
J " ~u
~
Jj ~I
wi " ~
.JA
.wI
J\.-j L.uLc.J
~I. (n , r. : , · .,.;)
Y.J~
. (rA, rv: ,. ~)" ..~~41~t!~I~y~U~' 33 -
y'iIJ
I..u:.·lJ-"l r---;.J _<.." I ~
w....J ~
J~)\
~I)~
~\ .. "
.:•
ul r-J:-.J.J
t.J'"'l:l ~
ul u=:J1~
J}.l ..,.:j!. " ~IJ
., ~
o~IJ
11 U'I~ .J
U""""""
'pI "(j'lYJ.Jfi JA ~
J.-:!.u\ ~ ~I ~~I ~~\ ~
J~
u-e.J .:.
u-Al
N. ~'il
y'iL9 ~~.wl
J.S u-! ~)
" ~ ~
~\
~I .. cJo'l~ \1i1(,Jo'Io:! J1l1J..'i.. ..r-::J
(1"£)
.( f : 'fil)"~\
~ ''''.,'j2~.
u~~.J
~'iIJ y'il ~ o~I)1 ~I
.J.J-i ul ~, .
~~J
y)IJ ~I.&\ CJA~.J
~o~IJ~1
.( r. : , · .J:1) " ~
t.J'"'l:l
.J:1)
0~.. ':( ~l..Ac.1.. " u'-"" 11::;.
wl.....<:al ~ '. (
~I
r" : , · .,.;) ~uJ
USJ.J
St. Athanasius: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat., III , Chapt XXV, (11) P 400 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser 0' Vol. IV,1980 . Ibid.: (13) p401.
W\S.\~}~J y~1
~1
~ -ul~
~'il J-.; wi ~
, .. ~'J ~'i'J y~l J.uj, ~\J ~I ~ ] (ro)U-W.J:Wl~1
~} ~~~.J:!
oiAJ,S (j..4
(.)-Q~\
y\.,;J\
w'iJ.
oy\.J?oJ~
0A
Uo'I:!iiJl Jji; ~'i'J y)U ~I)I J.-.lI 0C J
.:•
. [ ~'i4 y~1 ~J
w'i y~'~I o~J
~
~'i' ~I J ](n)~I~ ~i 4.c.m ~
4.;9 ~I
' ~
u=Jl~\
I.S#
~iiJ'
rJ ~'i\ ~
0C ~
~I
J,Jo1:J .:.
. [.(jl~~.u~ ~\ .w) ~'CJ..r1'J ~I
~\
J ](rv) I.S,)~~'
~'i\J y~\
Jj~
...~,
CJ)\
~~'i4~
. (' • : H .J:!) "
~ y~'J-c.1 J.-:l ( ~'il wi ]61 w~
" o~
o.."....hi; wi~~I
,y\ ~
~,) ~,
~~'.ft.' ( 'V
,,'0 I~}I:u.
.Y)U .(jlJl
Jl,4C.'i\ J-.;
:
<LV\S.
w\S.l~ ~I ()d"
~~,
0
.:.
1...4 J,SJ '~\J
y~\ ~
J,.:JI y~\"
) 4.:Jfi] (r,,) ~U31 OJ."w. 4L:J1~IJi
J-.; ~I" Jj W~.
, w~\ ~
u-J.J:!-S U"'-:/iiJ'J~J
-\.:i,y\~ u-k
J-;!) "
o~4-0
J,Jo1:J .:.
~1 ulJ
l.\~ ~
~
.[(''':0.J:!) : olJ~ o~1 ~
4.:J} • ~
.~~w};~~'i, olp. ~,
~J.
lilJ . ~
WIJ ' ~
-u~
~
-\.:i..,§
~~y~wl
4!..,;c.llilJ~ Y- ~
~~IJ ":-'~ o~IJ oj! - .A
~I
wi ~~~,
~I
~I
~~.>J1~'i\
~~J'
~I~
( "" , "V : , • J-;!)" c..5~ (j..4 ~11 4,b.;,;
" ~I ~J'
y.J
J~
~'i'u-l} ~
liA ~ J
wJJ ~~I
35 -
Ibid.: (12) p400.
36 -
ST. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book VII, (26) P 130, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,
37 -
1979. ST. Cyril of Alexandria:
Commentary on the Gospel According to St . John, Vol.
II, Book VII ,london 1885, P 103. ~ 0 ()'" ''1'1' .,;L.D~Ul\
• (~I
uy.'J ) : ~eJ\ Dol""':'
,-!L;l\ ~\..li
_
rA
(' £ :' f y...)"Y-4 (.)0 y)1 4y...1~..,9 ~" y~1
~I~J ••~
~..,ill &..J ~\ ~j'l.
~
~.
o..,ill~J
J~.
~
••~ ••
~J
~I (.)0 ••• " y)l J~ u'+ o~ ~J oyill tl~ ~ ••rJyJIJ..,iJ..J. (f": i c.sl" ) •• o.)J~1 .('f:I\'\jA)
.t1.~ I..s! • .u :~< ~.u ~Jj" ~. J~., ... ••L'
~ ,~.u~ Y!J
~O~IJO..,9.u ulJ' ~I
" ~IJ y'iIJ 0..,9.J4 ~I
wi
~l ~
~
~.)~
~
i.sA
~I
y.J ~J:!~J
ul ~I yi; 'i ...••
(.)0 ~
. ~'il
A
.J.)till ~t; c.s~IJ U\5. c.s~IJ ~tSlly)1
. (1\ : , j.J) ••~~ ~ ~ ~,y'il
~_.... c..-::--II .l1...JI ~ J
.J9
y'il ~ ul~J:! I~
Jj y'il
.u~ . ( f.
0..,9 .JA
, ,,'\: , • ~)
'i :'
J.J) iiI!
J~
.:•
• (" £ " 1\ :' fi' ~
w\5.) ~
J ] (n)~I...H
~IJ ~'iIJ y'il
~l
. [~.l'J1 ~JO~IJO..,9~~ul ~J:! ~'il J] (f.) ~l
O..,ill ~
~J ~
ulJ ~I O~ ~luIJ"
'i . ~JI:iA ~ (.)0
'i 0..,9 i.sA
o.)'i~ ~.u
i.sA
y'il ~ o~IJ ~I
~I
~I...H
• o~
')).JAJ~IJ~I Wo":!JiJIJjL..J
~11.S.ft=A
.uly...ue.u~ ~I
••• ( ,,1\ :'
o..,illo~
1.S.ft=A U"I:!JiJI
(.)o)i~.
.uJ
~
.:.
~I ~I
J:) ••c.s~ (.)0 ~I 16 910.;.1 'iJ ~/'il (.)0 .uly...~ Ul UL...uJ c.s'J ~ •
0..,9 U'J , y'il ~
i.sA
~'il ~ ullAS:. y'il
[ ~'iIJ Jj ~ ~I ~l.
o..,illo~J
ul . ~l ~
(.)0 ~
. [~'il 39 40 41-
'iJ ~'JI~J
c.s~ (.)0 ~I ~
Ul ~l ~ ~i.sA
] (f')(JoII~J,,*,1
~jl----J ~
~y'J'I
~
'i J ~I
Wo":!JiJIJJi;J
ulJ ~I o~ ~luIJ" (.)0
~U'J. (f._
~I
.J4
.:.
~'il
lAy o-itk.1c.s~1
,,1\:,. J:)" ~IJy'ilJ
ST. Hilary of Poitiers : De Tinitate, BookIII, , (23) P 69 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser . , Vol. IX 1979 . Ibid., Book VII, (22) p127 S10Ambrose: De Spiritu Sancto, Book III, Chapt XVI, (114) P 151 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979 .
~l)\ J.,..:..ill
" ~\J 1./11IJ \JI" ----------------
~y , 0:'110..,9~
y\~
~ y~1
OJ! (fl)
~I ~j~,J:f
Wo":!Ji31 Jji;J
.:•
.[ ~IJ
~::J:a...•(j:lJ y~\ ~ ¥I " ~\
~~
0..,9 ~ J~
~I
0..,9~ y\ ~I ~I
y~
] (fr) cS..)~'ii
0A J%. ~
~I.,.JI
. ..&10..,9w-c
Aj\.lJIUt ~
~.;;S Wo":!Ji11 JjiI..J
.. ~~ J.S y~I
j1.a:il, ~"
~I
.:.
~
~\ "J "
. [o~~SJ~4~..&\ ~ l.:l~I~ ~IJ .,Hi wjj
,
JS ~ iJ-T'ii wi ~
l.:l~IS.,:!
~
LA
JS 6-t
• ~",.~IJ ~IJ
: ~~, u-!~l "~
~0~)1
~ ow\>"s' Jio ~
Ji..o~
~ t~IJ rA I~M"
c:.H'IIJY~\ lH:lo~)\ ~
~'11
J~
~o~)\
~ ~..&I tl.Jt· u. Lu':/w " . 1.1\ "'e-'....... ~. ~ . ( 0 ,
f: f
y\.J ' ~I
Jc. , "r : A ~
~....t... ~~,
~Ulbo~J
4Jt W.
o..l-:io. JI . -.a. . y r...r-. ~
C::~II o~
~~t ~t
~I~'il)
J:1
~
~t r&- ~ ~
u-C~
](H)
'V
J:1)
~LNI~.J.l!J
uy\)UIJ ..>A~\J~\ JJ.~I
o~ JISV""~J"""" . ~. . '.. 11
~~~I
\~. ~\J
. [\.jU:.~~~1~I~~
42 -
ow\>, - r
.( " :
' (' : r J:1' ) y':ll ~J
J.J) ~J
~IJ ~~ ~
U~U~~.J~I
~Lc.~'11 1:U ~
~'1IJ y~\ o~J ull~)J Lat. JL-Ajj ~
y~'
rA~Lc.~~ UJ~J:!J. u'-:'11J (.)'l:!..fii.11
. ( ~I u-'0~.J ~
~Y"
~"RJI
' ( '" : , J:1) u-a-;Ji11 J~
~)\ ~
St. John Chrysostom , Homilies on the Gospel of St . John,
.:.
~..,J.,.JI ~,~IJ
Horn.
LXI,
(2)P224 NPNF, 1st. SeT., Vol. XIV, 1978 . 43 -
St . Cyril of Alexandria:
Commentary on the Gospel According to St . John,
Vol. II , Book VII, London, 1885 , P 101. 44 -
St. Athanasius: Orationes Contra Arianos, OratIII , Chapt XXV, (19) P 404 , NPNF., 2nd. Ser ., Vol. IV, 1980 .
,
. ,." .
"~IJ ,..,}JI
J
~
ul"
illl ~
illl~,
~I)I J.-iJ1
f~IJ \JoiM"
4~\
.uj ~ ] (to) ~li1\ ij~
f~\JfflJo.l..:l.IJ~~
lJoiM(.SI. (""
,"
:
,V
~
O~J ~J ~~
.J:!)" ~IJ
J ~I J U JAl ':l
. P~I J ~ ~yJl
JJi:u .:.
~\Ji
t.J:l-i:lt.sA y\~1 u-9 ,-i'/IJ y'Jl O~J ul (.)oy ~
, (.)"It)\JA ~I
~IJ
' ~I..,1I~\
~
~~ts
u-9
. ~I..,11 .fiillJ ~IJ
-u'i . ~~I ~IJJ'
~o~)l~1
~IJAl.&1 tb.]
~\ o~..,11 ~
~1j.;1~o~J.l:l..JI.Ji:.~Il(~
y..-J\ JA~J'
. [y'J\ JA(.S~l~I..,11 t~l)
~I..,11 u~,/I
J~ .:.
4J"j1 ~~
(ti)($~
ta.o
~'il
~\..,11 ~I
JWIJAl y\~IJAl J
:~~
ep'o")! diU: W~
. " ~'~ Y~'~ ui " (r. : , •~) JA y'Jlj . ulj;l.cUA uLo~t ~t
':l! LJ:lj;l.cUA ~~I
u-9 ~\J ~t ~
~~ JAJ,o~':l~ ~
" ~IJ y'Ji J ut " ~fi
.u~
~J . ~I ~J
~.u
y'Jl y\~
~l
y.J ~)
~! ~,/IJ ' ~! ~J
~,/Ij. uJA)\jIJ ~IJ
.( r : , yc ~,/IJ y'J\
(.)0
JS,! . t;.1jI ~,/IJ y)U
~'v : , ~I ~"v: "
"i : "
, " : 0 ~,
(,,\, i: 'f.J:!' ~, f :
r
~..,1t ~
J.J) ~I
tt ,
"0
) ~y\~
~~
yl
y\~1
~.JJ y'Jl JS.J
JAlJ~(' '\ :' fi ~ r : , .J:!~'\ : A fil ) ~I
J.J' , • : ,,'\ (.St, ) ~ j'il :".J:!~ oV:'
ro : , ) , " : 'V
~ "':
I ~ ~ I ~L.,
c.".)1~t......J!.J• ..l.".........)!.~u.-~I
0
.J---A
J ~(
~I
Jj
• .;AWI, (~I
~I
~.".\.r>. IAI
"f : ,
.J:!)~IJAlJ~(
.J:!)(.)"IJ~1 JAlJ~( '" :
-ul " ~IJ y'JIJ ut " ~l
.Y f cJ"""
, ( ~I
y\ ~I
t.sA ~\
-,
(.)0
0
fil,
JAl
"f
4.;
,\:'~"
.J:!)~I
~~I ~ j§J .( V :
.JAJ
r
.:u
uJA'J) : ~Cill • ..l~
~411 ~I..li
_ f0
-.-i d:ll..\..:;) : l.S~
~YI ~~
- fi
cJ"""
Y •••
J.!y,J, .)."YI ~I
u1-9 ~ (
A : ,r ~
CJ)\ u-9~~./i\
d)~" ~I
L-t >A >A ~l
) " ~~\ u-l1Jf'~IJ
u·tiIJ~l.5iJ\
0-Atji.J-""'\.,j~~4·U
(,)"l1~1~
J~ ~, ~
~~I
~I
~
Ut
t~"
~\)\
~)\
o~J.
~l ~I
."~~ ~ ~.
~I
~\
u~1 f'J+i~"'!~. ~1' ~..,-l\~ .J' o~1
0.)..,..-1\~
~l
(' f : , 0
.ii~.
("
~~I
~
~l
~\
.H) ~o~~~, -, : f
u.its ~ Uy ¥\~I4.:j~ f'uJ' ( "f : "
.:lLc.\ .. o.l..Yl\j~
w... ~ 'A : , · ..,.J ~ r. : , f .Jo:!) tt) ~.".JI t~) L..::.9'U y..;J1f'u
(n :r~)~~f'tiJ,(f o\..bc.t, ),,'1'.JI u·ljl u-9~~1
o~y)1
~~L.be.t.{".
~~.&o~\
ul ~J.
\J~
~ ufi~ ~ '.AI)I~I
~
~\
.)'\~I ~ ~
( V: f
1:U . (
~J.
~l.5iJ\
~\
liA.
: 'V ..H) ~U~j:u;illJ.J4b~1
J.,c. ).&\ 4..:i.J\J~fi:
u~f.AIJ \J~
~~\
~I
:'~)
Ut ~J
('V, ":
Ut ~J'
( ,r , '" : , .J-:!)
( ,~ : , fi' ) ~I
"fi'
"V : '" .,.s' ~"r ,"" :' wt)
~';IJ yYI O.AJLAt • f~\J 4li ~J.
tJ..;Jl~
)4l...o.:lJY)\~~J}.l.:il\ U~..;..J\J (,)"It.;JI>A
~~t ~\J
U'-;';\ u-9f~IJ .~y\)uIJ~IJ
1;~
IitJI J.ifaU I-
" OJ a is IQJ ~' [t.:1.~]
JUJ"
:a..••• ~l
r=..;--J ~I
JU , .Jjl-.l
~I W.J-A
4.J';1 ~ ~~I
u~
~I
J t..j:W1 JI)-.o.JI~
~
r--Ai.JL.~
J u~~.J'i1
~
~ ..AiJl
~I II ~
J~
~
d ~~.J'il rJWl ~I
u.J'"'lJ.(" f:' fi' ) ".&1~J.&I ~IJ'
~
JU. (r'f:' '>:l)" Y Il~JuJ'"
4J'1 ¥I~IJ ~
. .JjW ~ ~ t..j~1U\.S.JI ~
,U.)l'-;~J~~
, L..a--
u~ ~.J'il ~L...J 1~4 ~I ~~.J,- ..)jL..a.l
~ .>A
y'il ~
~ '1J ,~I
r-A~.J~~~'iI.lSI..uJ
4.:J'1 U~ u-SJ ~
'O..,.§" .>AJ' (r':"..,.s)
~~'il ~J~.JJ'~II:U
~\j
~ ~~.J'il
t.iI.bci .~.~
" r-W1Jtkll
j..¢
wl~W:.~J ~1y14 JJ~ . (,)4lll~1
J
~.,.M~I
: ~~~J~I
~W41 :iJi
:~f~y,4.oJOf~~~f~fw~w~~
-,
~~J...:uI~)~I~u~uI~~](')u~~.J';1
J~ . [ U.J-:!
: yYf a.o.s:>~ ~ ~
IjWi~I.ilIJAJiiJij""'1 y';l ~~
" oJ_ •.••. o, •••..•• ....:1-.. J U:! • I" .J.J'W'UC
uLS~I
.J..J-A'JI ~
~f
~f
h£ ~ ~. ~
'I ~ ~
l.S"". ~.
ul _r
w~ W~~
uts)](Y)U~~Jil
If UI..l.Il
.:•
J~ ~I•
~
.:.
.u..c.
u~ ~! UP. (f f: , , -":1)
~ J U:JI ~
. [ u.U~';1~
~ ,
: ~~J~I
4.oJOf41)" ~
: ~oJf . (' f: , ~) "~
'"
J:..J T~ ) .•.- ~I
"'1"'1 ~ ~...:ul ("Spl ~
~J .(,\:" fi)" ~ ~W'il .....•
~~)lll
",-:_"uI J~f:0,·"11 ~~
u-c \.::..yj..A W)\c! ("S~
.u:.~J y';l ~ •• [
J-A
J " ~)'I
~ ~"
~J,.oJS ~ .L....c:.
(JoIl.u.JI y\:i..Sl1
I.1.:l.~
J~)I ~~}!
.l-~o~l ~
J]
_, J..,..e;
u"y~l ~
J..,..e;J
u-J~ u"y~1 ~
J..,..e;J .. ( 'i:f ~l)
" ~I
c..~ ~·I ..
.J ~_''''A'I ..•
(r)(JoIl~~1
tiWI .J l..::.J.4'1 o~1 I :'-'1' T~ .. 1..lb..1·I.JA.~I ~ J~";-I.JA
T~.u
~l
.l.i!
,oLJ)'l ~
U~
L';l ..
J~
~l
.A.l'r'~
j! f)~l
.[ obts~l
2. 3. 4.
~,~,
~I .:•
j! ' CH)'IJ-A "...,jIJ'4.1!L,jb ul£ "...,jl ("SI.~l
\.l4.'J (jL..u!)......-J ~ t...-l:a..
1.
.a".ll: ~W
~L.QlJi'.'I~
~
J~J
J .:•
I~ ~~
St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXVI, (27) P408, NPNF., 2nd• Ser., Vol. IV 1980, Ibid., (26) p408. Ibid., (29) p409 . Ibid., (31) p410
c:.H'Ii
c.JA j).."J1 ~)I ~ ~Ifio~
~J
JA
.l.::l..IJ(C)LG.Jl:!jUlI ] ~~.J~..);.
LJAlJ ~.JC'jj
Y ~J.
c.JA.lIJ ~ ~(.jill
~I~I
. [~.;j;. lJ.:kJ!b~4,
T~J
~IJ~~
~IJCJ)I~I
~J~)l
hi] (i)~JjJb
L:..J.J~I
~
U'l-:!.illl J~J
.:.
y'Xl
~tAtAi~
!Ii;.) U'l--:!.illl J~J
.:.
.. ~~O.l.::l..J~J.ssA..;AI .[~IJ~,~I.JJI~
ul~.
~l
~~J~I
. u-W1 ~l , ~ (j:l
~ ~
JL ..,p-\ J .JjW rul
.l.::l..I~J
:yYf ~ ~ ul" ~
~.uc
~
~~ ~
~ r-l]
~
d'iJ
u~T~.JL....:a~1 y...Ui
(V) ~
~~l
~L..:J'II~l U'l-:!.illl J~
J (j:l" uL..:J~Jl9(.j~l ~
"0 ~
ue Jl9(.j~1~J .. ~
~ Jl9LG~I~J ..("'r':'" j.J) "~l li:l..~~~I
~l
u~ ~I
~ o~
. [4...a1..i1 "'¥ J!
~lill
¥~~I
~ ~ J
,.JWf ""yf ~ ~f ~
~f
rlWl .u'jl ~ ~I
~
_ T'
~I
~~.l.::l..IJJS~~J
Jl9J.. (' V:""~) "~JS
.:•
. y)ilIJ~1 yJ ..l'
~l
~~ u...Ja.o
-u~ U ·L..:JYI ,'~ ~l",~" '!6..ti:- U'""'":! '.<. ("'" - l-.,j~J .~ ..,A_IIu-r" UL.l ·LS-.,j~" "-iYI • I.r" -r-::U. U ~. J.J-"'I)1~.J:
~
t.l....J...A .u...e. JU J .('" 0 J'" £ : ", ~) "uL..:J'I1 ~ . (r':"'fi)
u~ U.JC (t •:' •~) Uj.J~1J:IC ~ A
4J8JI ~~
-uIJutA .JjW u} ~
"rWIJ~I
o~
(':-4
o~
~I
uts. t.A rb
j~~~~I" ~I
uLS W~U
JUJ l;Jc. ~~.)
~
.JjW
. (' L' , :' ,~) 5. St. Gregory of Nazianzen: Against Apolinarius, (EP. ell) , NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, p443,. 1978 . . 6. St. Augustin: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Tractate XLIX, (18) p276, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. VII,. 1983 7.St. Athanasius :Tomus AD Antiochenos P485, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,. 1980
.H'"•
l.s!~ ~
J Laji ~ .us.)'LA J . ( "V:' Vw..e.) J:i'-"l)/I J 0 .JL.JI ~
~
,""
J.A!J .:.
u\.#J4.us.)'LALJe] (')~Ull o~.>i~ ~~\ ~I~
Ajij~~y~,
' 4.u.!.)'LA J.
(' , :' , .J':!)
(joY ~
.JjW u ~.u.!.)'LA J . (" V:" • .J':!)
. [ (' A:£ J:! ) ~j'\I....J\ ~~.us.)'LA
J . (0
•- £ V: , J:!) ~"
~)\
W:..:i ~\.till
0'!i" y}l Jl;w ~
~"o~,
-,
: u yy'&l ~~ -'
~I JI , uyy 'i ~I t!)l..b}~
~
'i I~ ts...t LJe~I .. ~
"~'iY\ ~y!T~t\¥0;I0-0"
~y)1
~
~
J~
"J
.9)
I~ ~ J. :UytA ~
u1 ~
jA JA lA ~
~
~I
~
lAili:.
AJ)IIJA ~'J .. :U.;-11 4l\-b
~I
~t~lt~}o~~
Ul5.<4.lS.l,
u~
~ ~
rJ ~
I~ JU W}J " ~)/I
JA ~'J ~
(o:i.J-:!)
I.l::..J:!
U'Y.ill1
. (i:iJ:!) .>A
~I
. 0 .. ~II
LJA J:-w
~I
Ul 0-" 0~\
t ~-~II ~ "l.! ~I
t~1
. 0 '-' ~~A.ii ...ruk, '-i'~II ~U.~"·I.lw.J
~ jA
J:!) UlA
JA lA ~
.JjWul ~
~'J ~I
U~
ul
~ ~ ~~\
LJA ~
.. (' £:"
~
U~~
u~
.
I
J j-.JI \~
~i.l1" ~
"t("
":11'
~
~
J •. ~J~
JAJu~
y.)1 ~I) .ul 1- ...r~Ul\ l"'-'"'-' -:11.:. 114.1:11 •
I..s-
<. ~ .. 1\
..-",11 ~
y..;J1Ul5. ~I
Ul5. (f £:' , .J-:!) Y 0~ .uyJl0A.JjW~c.?l~~J'
J
'~J.
0-;1 ~
1 ~l
.J
~\ lAili:. J
~ul
8. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book 7, London, 1885, P123 A. 0"'" ''1'1' .J:!L.,.y\Ul\(~lu-",)').::.II:ilI.J~~41IU~ 'I
,(r' f:" ~)\'.JjW ~ . ~
J
~I ~
u
u..>-lt·:Hii..l1d11~ l ~I
I~J] (' .\.)olI~~1
o~ (,)--0 ~,
~
. [4!.;a.: ~\
: u~
t~ ~~li
.>AJ .. .w~ 'i ~ ~LS.>A W.u J-Io'lli~
~ .JY'1~
o~J . u.;a.: uSl • o~
lJ"='l:a.. ~
~
~~
JLu.J .. ~IJ ~J'
~
t3JJ' ~~)lll ~ ~
u.! ~ T~6.
~
rJ "i~l ~
~
.>A\' .JjW
P
u.,;d~"i~I~.>A'
. (" o:"~) u~'il
~J ~J
.JjW ("\!IJ ut....u~~
0-:1 u~
uLS~.
'.&. ~ ~.• t:.··1 u ~..J04..r J ~".u
O\·\Q
u~Wu~d~l)
T~ T~
~IJ JS ~
" ;) ,-:}1IJ yYI ~ lil " J~J yYI u.J--A:! o~J
.[~
y)l]
\' " o~J ~
~
~J
~J
~fi
J~ .:.
(j'l-;~I
uLSJ-:' pyJl ~~u.A!~
~ LAu~
ULSJ
~mU..o~I.>A
LAJ
(H)L..::a:1UoM~~1
uLJ~~1
J~J
.:.
.l.:l.1 J~J
.:.
<J'l:!~1
0-:1" ] (''")~~l
l.i ~.• ,:.. u ·1~111~4J'itl .J
(I\:"~)"
y
~I
'iJ ~~l:J1 ~
~4.4JJ~"iiJl
~ u1.5.Lo u~J'
u.:a~
J 0-:1 JL,.a(.SiJly.;J1 . ~
~Lo ~I u.JCJ (' f:' ,~) " ~Lo .JjW" Jl! ~J . ~1.Jts!1
y"b:
~
'i uL:J'i1 ~~ -
~J
i' ')UoM~~1
~
.JY''i1
~LS ~I
~tiI, ~ ~J
~~)lll ~
~'i
o.JJ~
~
J~ .:•
~I
.. ·\ll:a~ • J UI.J""'"
~~J~!"
~~
. .u~'i .[~I
10. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral. III, Chapt. XXVII,(37) P414, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV1980 , 11. Ibid 12. Ibid., (40) p416. ~ ~ ~,.y.t:ill , :!'.JI:!.udJ'O ~I '-:-':!yU' ~~I ~y,J1, Ua..J:! J:;..l! ~: r..SYA ~ ''" . oi u-:a~~;}il
.
'J'-' ~1:tA .. ~U- .•.
.~
I~ ~
~J
t~) JSO~
~~I
~ ~
~All
L:i •• ~
CH! ~
. ~}i)9.,,11 ~y-JI ~
, .JjW~J
u:t u..;a.:lJJ,Sl1Ylb.. uyt.;! JA] (\t)(Jo'I~~t
'i~1~I~\
I~ ~'J ~JS~I ~~
~J~I
~\All
~4~W
~)I
~ ~J131
AllJ
.~y-JI ~
. ~t·
UA
~)I
~I..\
0-:!:l\ilJU.wt U~__L U·~U ~
~t
~
. .J~I'~
~J (''J' .:f~)
JSb'i ut~) Jly.J4
JI~ JS ~)
" ~ ~t
('\: f~!
~
ylb ~
o~,
~J'i~\
¥t ~~
~I
.,....-
.:.
~
~
rlJ
". . ( ~'<it~)
•
~I u:-=a.J'JI
uli ~
Wjtu:t" ~uf"~i yy\ ~
~1;;~I0A~t~"!"
W! .. u..;a.:lut Jly.J1 0Ay)\
4L:J\ L..IJi ~
u..>--:! Uto~
•(S"'.II'C.J L....c~t.ww • ,(.).A
~i" Y)' JL ,~w _r
Jl-,..a r-:!~I
~t
~
~
~J .(' 'J'\:r~)!"
~
. [A.1J ~ U Jia:! ut t.-.) f"~~ ~ !" o~Ju:t"
~ut~1
. u..;a.:l~
~
~I
~~~I
.JjW ~
y~'J1
tilb r:fi.: ~ J U..;a.:l ~ J~ : .;jW
u.=t"u~1
.:.
~
OJ~
" ~t!
"~
J~
~~~~t
(' ")~
~I..\
y)1 ~
~~J
. [JSl\ ~~'JJ~'J
: ¥"
[
W!
~JAJ4.J'J.~
~pl
W_
L .•.
~~~\ C~ u\S.~I
~J ~I
->i!~!ytA:ill~I
u.e JU L.u.p. ] (' i)~
.JjW CJ.J u1& u..;a.:lu\S.'iili . ..;:illu1& ~ ~
t
ut \.J~t.J $'J:!.l
OJ.jW. 44-1\ L..\Ji ~ ~
~
-I .:•
~ !"o~.J
14. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Drat. III, Chap. XXVII,(38) P414, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, ~1 ! ~ ~I wI Uf. • "I" ~\:ic..J 4.[Jy.'1 ~I • U"LilI ~I ~ wi""" : ~~1 o~~ ~411~I.li .' " . £'I~. '1'•• , ~..Y.! • oy\till. ~}11 . o. ~~UI~yJl
.'1
u1 ~ ~1 .. ~ ~
J~
u-l} t~)4 \.i\JAY ul u J'YJ
ji9 \.i\~
(.j~l U\S.J1 u-l} U: l;l\ : 4.31 ~ J~l
u.iJ!~\
o~
~ \' ~\
.[ 4.31~~~(.j~\
~
J
.JA • \' " 0~
~ Jj ~ , ..?oi ~ ~ .JjW
~J'
~'"L~~
u-;1 " ~
J:!illu-l}~~
0:1" ~\
\' " o~J
. . -<.•c-:A_~'\\ \~ J .JA~\ (.)AU~
~
ol;:JI oJtc} 0~
., A...utsA\~I [ ~ ....U...
(III)
u~
oJ~1
,- U-.J.J k ~ f..r-'
ci.J~'i1
t- ~"'<~'
C ~':i~
'-P ~
-~
.:.
l;l\ Ji:l rJ.>A . ~4fil0""'·~.wfil
JL.a]
~I
*
] (I V)ci .J~'il uJ..»S ~.1in JJ.:i:f w~ UjC .wI (.1-b:l ...»ill ul...5..t. ~
0'....5.J .JjW
.
~
~ \~J .. ~I
:el.l4il '-P c1a ~
0-:!1u
\~
U~
.
.L.
• L.
~\ooWiI
:~~tJ~y~
-[
~..»S ~J1n J~
.:.
~
~
~':i jA
••~
(\ UJ'Y ':i .wtsJ c.r-
rA..;:i;- 0"'"
ys1 .w1Jc.1
.~-,Ji -ul. .ue. u:" . I.~ . [ u-u
u~ , uw}-u1.JLpc.41~ ~ .u.~ u1 .J~~.
o~
~
\' "
~1.u.~ u1~~ . [ 0~I
':i ~I
1JJAl\.4lJ ~
1~~
:&
ul
4 ~.w~\' "
~
J--S t-0
) ~
(.j1 0"'" 0 ~I
0~
I
"J ~
J 0-:!1"
Jl,..a] (l -) ~I
CJ--S.1 J .J..?-:
\~J
' ~
' oY)
~I J~ u1Vb~. '''J (.jiJ\
0-:!1" ] (I'I)~~
O~J
~
J:!ill~
w..J:!
~L.it u--o 0j ~.JCJ
.li.c. ~
.
UJy..QW\
~I u-- o~I.JH
~j
.:•
_J
~Ji31 JJ.:i:f ?
JS ~
JI
.:.
J.--,.uy ~ ~
-[~.J 17. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book 7,London, 1885, p122 18. Ibid., p123 ~US ~ ":"'J~ ' u...J:! ~! Cy:. , ~~I ~y,JI , ~"11 ~ "'" J.411 ys11 : li~! ~J .)~1 .1'1 . ''Il l>"" ''I VI" , r.?"i1 J~I 20. St. John Chrysostom : Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Horn. LXIII, (1) P232, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV,1978 .
"'J.""
u=l" .ul~]
Y "/l~J
.us tiyJI 0C ~
l~
ul5..w1 WI)\ 0~I
uyJl LJA.JjW("\!1 \~l ~,uyJ\
:i. ,,~. .Ie' .~ ~
J ~15. J,~ ,
'.~
\J~
~tAJuyJl
•. ,c.S~~~(jC [
~ ~ 0 ~l:w.yJj
~.wl
J~
~ ~
~.)
1:U 0-A ~
~LAJuyJ\
~tAJ
'-'-'~. 1('.
yJl
..»i=- ~~I
.[ JA~I~~~~
p!J
. ~J"'"
..11 .J.J'W utA ~ '
r:JA4~ 1..1_ "6'::!"""'
~ "t"'"
'"
.u...ra: (,jill
~'
~
'-J)I y",~ "b
.I:.~~\.!,/l~,
'._~II I
J~ '
t.r~
.wtsJ JL.a ~
.1('11 ~., :11("l..AI ~ ~J
u~ ~J ~I
.JjW ("\!Iy)\
:.:.,
ul ~
ul
A I~
(,jillJ ' ~
~J
~I
• oy\\:ill • 1A.J:!~
~)'I
: ~
~I
JL.aJ
II _". ~ ~JUI.a.I,
~l J~
oy\\:ill, ~JI~..,..i.>"~1 ~.;Li'
tAJA~J
w" '.. I',l.! ~"'. A_ II <U.b , iJ':!:"" '
u.iJ,fiJ~o~.)ll 0~I
.).J"Y .)~IJ
.JjW u ~
lJ-4
~
UJ..r.u
~~(,jl
~
o~~ ..,sjJ U".J:!.)~y:. y.~1 ~l:!J .'1'\ . fOf~.
. o,~,
~ ~J
J 0:!1u yy ulS. .lil
,0.»-11 ~~)I)
u).a..ll.)1J
~\)
~O"...».::-. J 0~~.
<"yl~)
" . b\
b~
"
y" /l~J0:!I"
J ' .JjW ~
'.u' r-+JJC- ~.1.~
';;'1: ~IJ
~I
'Lul U...
.
'~I ~_ .. 11'UA.J:t!'"" ... < .l.h \._. ~W Jeo::" "t""""J~ ,
u=1uyy.wl ~~ , ("yl
u yy ~
.:.
(J:l
~J~oUJA~
,~
)blji
e;:1 Jl!J
~\
~
CJ.J
.1.=1.1 J.,,:L,J
l: ~ I",n!• O~J
UI&~ytA~lA!r.l~J,
'-f,il& lJ-4 ~I
o~, ,"t""'J \. ~l,~
ep'a!IJl
J, (CJliI.wj~~)
~
u.e.J
UIJ' .JjW~J~
~~~I
WJJ' ,. (jC l~"
LJAyfll
U~' ~\
UY(,j~\
~.J:!~
~
I. '115.JJ
.' , ~J
JW ~
~ue ~ul
~~~ljJ-.:oU~~
~IJ
' A...Jc. ~L..:~
~
:~ • ('" t : , 'J;) "
ulA.~1 u-!
ut.S..t. u.e. JL.a ] (H) u-a~1
~I
'-:J-'\~
0:!~\~~I
.:•
.11 U,I ~_. _. .II " t..l.ii oU..r .b.~ U'lbl...u. ~ ...< ~ Jeo::"....,;;o
w.i15. 0~',- -
(,jJ"
4·i~1JJ\.;-i J"J;
~J;~"";:'
(l\)UJ~iJ
~~1 ~fiJl, 1A.J:!~!
\'\/\'
~(.S.fJA";'"
.'1"1'
1i-
~ .aI..i.U ~i.I'
w..a~' .w .~
.·i~'"
u ,,'8; ••
i~'"
~i . Jjii ,~l.tJ. ~~i .a.i ~ ~L.rJ' o~ J! ~i ,~ J+~~J
. ~L.rJ' o~ ~ ~
~~,
[ fV: 1f ~ ]"
:a.~ uYI "
J! ~
~I
y.)
J~ ~
u~~.)'i\ ~L.J~\ uy'il ~ l.J.4
'~lijl 11\ J::...Yu-sJJ. ~L.Jl oiA l.J-cl ~ ~ ~
~y
~y... ~
f~
~
ULSJ~J LAS~ ul ~)
JW"
y'il
~1.u~J.
w~
Jy.il l~tAJ. ~~\
( YV : 'Y ~)
y..J )41! r~ ~ .
~
4-:11 .
c.r-a
u-sJJ . (,)'ll.sJ\ oiA ~
"~L.J\
lJ~IJ
~
I~l
~
~i
uJo~l
~
~~
~
'iJ'
~.;-Si ~~
~l
~\
uJU)J4! uy'il
~\
~I
~
~ WA
o~ u~~.)'il
\J~4- LH.l11 J~I
t.J-"'l:! L\ 1.) LJ!
J ~
LAS.uyJI LJ.G
-UJ
..}JI ~~l
: ~l:~1 o~ ~
u~ ~
JUJ ~J
cJ..;J4 y~1
I~
t~
"(ff : "
" ~A\"'J'"
JU LJ " ( n ~
fAIJ
J':!) .:.
uS-lJ(,)'ltsll 01\ ~
'f
J':!) .:.
'f yr.) .:.
uIS.Ju4.)YI ~
.»i.! -ill t~
:
yJ
uJ r-S1J~I ~l
~1~l,uy.Jl~I~~y...~~JW"(fi_ff: ~L.J\.uc. ~~~
u~1
~J.
" y.;LI J CJ)4 ~ ~\
y )ljl§
~
Ui <:::~ 'i..&1Ui
l..Ji.o ~
($~I ~~T ~~
~
, uyJI
UY . oI".j~'iJ..&\~~
'iJ u~'iJy~'i..&1
. ~I
u-lJ
Yi ~ ) " u.il
. ( f'\ , fA: 'i J' ..&1 ..J-A
01\
~
y..J)41! r~~.
JS y'il ~l
" ~i
y JUJ.
\J~IJ ~l
J.J~Y ~ tA u: l. ul J.J ItA ~.)
uJ
'i ~..('.\
~.J
~J
~
~~.J
..~I \ '1 ~·.('~I ~J. '.('1 t.r.J.
~
J...-,i,jIJ" (
~
(J'l WI 01\ ~ .
~.
"'1c.J ~
f" , f' : "" .,J) .:•
. \ otul L )ljL! ~J1._ c.J.... ." ~~I.JJ ~
~ J,otS~I ~,
jW'11 ~
'1J W~ ~
~I
La·~
'1 ~
wi
u..a o~IJ ~.u ~..J-A)l11 ~
>. I." . -.i 1~•. ~ ~ 4.F" """t':'
~
1.~.~
. ~
~I.J
' ~
~.J:jil
\~IJ'
.J*'l
LJ-4 ~~.
~I~\.c.jj ~
.u.J-'"'lu
WIJ' 4.:i-JA'1u-9 J,oLS.J-A~
~~IJ
WI ~,-:-•......c.J.A ~ .. ~
~lNI j.J"uJ
~)TI
J . ~ ~ .. '1 J
('1~~lo1\o~.j·I
W-;J.J1l.,l\ ~~
uL:...J .. '1 J I...l' . ~L ..
. 4.F"~J.
lA.l::l..
J
._.
~\
..
~L~i'JlJ.JJ..).J , 6:J:::-~ •... i~1~1~L&.JIt-IJ~4 J.Jll:U U.J-'o'l.J •~
~~J'll
~Lw.1 ~I ~l:~ ~I
: O)~, ~ y~' J..oJ.( ~ u:~1
~~
.( r ~:
UY1" Jl!J
IJ~I]
~.JA
"i U-t.) L)-'ltsllo~ .uc. ~ JJil
ul ~IJ
[ ~ (.Sl~J ~~I ': -:-: IIJ ~ ': ~
I II ~o.YW.JA .::11
Ijl..AJu:~1
~~
~I
o-! ~
•. <: •. ~ U..J-"":!
~. ~ ]
. (" v :'"
uJ ] (Y)
~i
'-
J:!)"
u,JjL..-J
ul jJ ~'11
(r) I~
.:•
~ uLS uJJ
' I~ ~
WLS ~'11 uLS
~
J~
••.. ]~1
(\)~,J-l
[ " yYI A..JS) 4JJU~ IjJ~
~ uLS LJ1111~
w~w~~ -,
':I, le'!~~,~,
~
~
"tl J...r-=:.J .Li.
·1' ~..J:.J •
.:.
j
••••
U'JI" J..,i;o\..Q'ji wiJ o-! (.Sj,J1 .JAJ. y)U ~J 411i.A J..::..~u-SJJ ~LJI o:U U..o~ y'Jl 4-:!1 " J.,.!l 0
~i
wi J o-! ~I
WJ"
0
(
r~ :
uJrSl J..,il~I
uLS W
o.,ill .JA
~
0
(
"V : '" J:!)" 4..c.L......J1 oi.A
"i U-.l) " i.J"ltsllo~ ~ ~I
JUJ ~JCJ.;J4
uLS .,l! .. [
0
[~"-.c~~~ ~l
JL!J
uJo~l ~ " ~I
0
(
'"
:
,r
~
~l
uJot:i..:ll:!"
y~ll:U
-":!)"
t.J-Ul:!
u-l"\"'J'" ~
f~IJ
I ~ uLS(.S yJ4 ~ uh ~
~..P-'J o.,ill ~ ~..>:~.JA] y.J J..,...i~
(f)
(0)
~..J:}il~.J
.:.
~,J-l~'iI~.J
( f" : "" ) ~rO: 'f.JA ~r~: "iU-.l) " i.J"ltsll oU ~
0[" ~j ~~J o-! ,.s\'~'JUl.u ~,
Ju
0.J~I ~.JA
.:.
~
uLS Un u).J¥
1. S1, Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Ora1, III, Chap1, XXIX, (54) P423, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 2. Ibid., Chap1,XXVI, (26) N08. 3. Ibid., 4. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book X, (9) P184, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 5. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt. V, (41) P228, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X,1979.
•,tl\.
:yY' O~'.)1 co·~ ul " . U"l
J~
~I
i
-uu \\.1 . ~
J..
~ ~jlj
J.>'J'-S""" ~~-:11.cll:i J ,(
.J:)" ~)
~ (fA:
"i
'1 u--s=J
~
..
~
o~ll;
O~'.)1 u~ u~
~,
f) ~.,JJ
~ ~
~l
>
J,AcY ~
~ -r
J~
.•..iJl
f •. .0 .J: )" ~.~.
($~I ~
w'Xl ~
~,
~1 ~~
yt:iS.11 wl;i
(j'l~1
w1"Y J! ~ 'Y"
JD\]
.:.
'1
~Lw.J1
US ~.~~'1J ~~\...b1i'i u:. . '11 ~ ~ ~ ~ " ~U -LJjlj ul-c. y'X\ ojlj
. I.! u.
~
.[ ( f" : "" ...,1)"~jlj : rJW ~l§ .ill, y'XI.&\ ~ .[ ~~l
.#' yY' ~ U.o~jl ~
41~
~,
U.o.u.fi1]
(V)
~,
••}il ~
~.,JJ
I~~~~.u~]
. [u:!~u~~) ~l.l;y~1
(A)
~($~I
~I
~l UJ.l~.....9 .:• ~I
'~lt!JI¥
~~J~16iiI~1jl.i!
: 0.)w\QJ'
~
1..-it.:...uY ,o.J.l.i11~.u'il JA ~
d~~
j~
~J.
utsJ'&I ..l:lc. uts ~IJ J-Al.»
~.w
~...,1lAS f~
~I
\.:yl.JJ~
~I
~I
(JJYI u-41~'iI) uts ~.¥I u-9" ~I
\.S.iJ1 ~...,11JA o~
0' a.oJr, 41)"
($1 ,
y'Xl ~J
J,:.J f~.JL-
~
~
.a.>ll : 4-iw
~,~,
-,
u~ u~.J:.J'X1 u-C~ w..,..,JIJ~I
()..o
-~
y~IJ
-Ll)ll , (j'l~.,lll JoA~I JAJ. ( , : , .J-:1)" .&1~I ~IJ"
y'Xl WJoA'iJ~J
. ( , f : , j;) " lb.J ~
6.
.:•
(,,'i'X1 o~ ~ o}uJ . ~y;J1 (,,'i'X1U.oI.!y;.. ~)
(fA :"'UA) wyJl ~
~I
_r
U~ U~~
f~...,.L-y'X\ U.o
Gregg, Robert. C.and Groh, Dennis, E. : Early Arianism, A view of Salvation, London 1981 P26-27. 7. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book X, (9) P184, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979 . 8. Ibid., (36) P191.
, (1\ :
'j.)) ~ JS ~
~.w~
.)~I.ill~
u..! ~lS ~I
"i
eN J
~I
: w.,.J1 Ub.:!
: o~I Jl!J . (f"
.
)"
~
o~I ~ ~'i ~,JA11u~
~J
~t.S oWl ~ J oWl ~ ~t.S
\.ill . (,,)'l.)Y
JU J . ( ~ : , f >;) "o~1 J L;.:JI J ~.;JJI JA U " ~
~~
JS4 0A . o4=J1 ~
'11r ~I u..!
f , f 1\ , f V : i.J:!)" ~
i_ f , : V ) )
(,,)'l.J:ly
~lJ ' (' 0
~l
lil J
~~l o~
A.:ilj u.! o4=J1 -,
':
V ))
.u~ l.J~l ~~
, ~I ~
~ ~I
l.Jt.Sl.Jl
u...9 4...JSJ1 Y' l.JLSl.Jl ~ Y' ~~I w..,.,J\
u~
~
.
~.J-A
~Ld1\~J
<\..LQ ,
f) Uo'l~~1
IjLJ ) . yu~
~
ryl ~)
wi "
JjLilI
.J-A
ul " ~i
~Yi11~
ul! ~ 0AiJ 0-A w..,.,J1
~
~l
(,)0
I.;
] (' ') ~I
y .J-.::a:u J+9
u-a
.)jW rulJ
J.Ji: .:. U~J
.will .wfi.lJ .:.
as ~l FJ ~J ,o~\ A_II ~ ~b.. ~ c::-:-
OJ.jl.J. 44.JI t-iJi J,J-L..J
.:.
Jl! ~ . (i :' f >; ) " o~1 J L;.:JIJ ~.;JJI
l.Jt.S0A JS J
u~
~Jill
~
] (,.) c.s..)~')ll· . u-..;::...1 •• ( UJoI-:! Jill Ja....'i.. ..r-;:
~J
(.S""l~
0A l.>.l....;:..i .)y:. ~~IJ 'o4=J1
. [,-~~ y:.. JJ .J-A
4..19
~I
.u 0A w.,.JI ub.:!
UL...ul.wfi.l W..,.,J\
J '
. [ Y w.,.J1 Ue. J ~Lo~1 ~.
y.;J1
~u ~) ~l rl!l <U.A ~
. y (' , ~)
~
(.).c
~ ul . ~~l o~ -ill ~ 0A ~ 0A r-SJ J..,!l ~I
w.,.JI ub.:! J,\J. Y~~'1\ o4=JI ~J' , ( 0
')l -I
4...l.! . I .:: ~ "<L.l.c. ~
" ~l . ( 0
"i J
~
~
w\..o ..,J J ~ 0-Ai 0-A . o~IJ
..( .,.'\, .,.0 :
"
>;) " ~'11u-ll w.J-A:l [!Y~II~J~
9.
St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat.III, Chapt. XXIX, (54) P423, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980 . . ,n
U"'" It i ~ t , ,\" ul~\
~..>-!J '" , ,
,"•• 'f 0y\\:ill( U""'WI ~j.,J1 ) li.,J
, ojlF!1 u;...! .::..."...JI ••••~
~I
J.;,..iJ ~ ulS. JA
: ($y&.)'1 uJ..>fi~I : .::.J1:il\ O..lp 44.l1 ~I.~ "'U"",''I'Ii
." ."
. o.J-'li
j~
,
~u! ~
o.;;C
u!] ('~)~I.ii
o.J.l..i\\ -LJ
J.jl.t..J
.: •
V .,1) " r! J..,!i ~ yL::J\ 4-:1i" 0±!li Uoa) C-H'i JU LaS , ~J wlJ-A'i1 (J 9J y'il ui LaS " ~ l>C- JUI.S~I Ii.\ J
.. ( , f :
I~
.[ ('"
:0 ~)"
Ui u.i+i:!"
" wlJA'i\ 0-" ("~
~J
:"ti)".u.a ~ ~I w ~I ~
j~IJo4-:JI CJ-4
~~\
("jJIJ ~\
~J~!
":-lC)"
~ ~ , w Y'"" - _II j"u,J~.~
..»ill y~ u\.S.J ..»ill CJ-4
~
Lo~
~\J
Ui J..J""l)1 uJJ: l1J....o
~l I.S~\
t~
~I
F oW ~
Ii,.,!,;" ,,"
u~
~j
~I
~
JS ~
W:..j ~~
.&.
.T'
~
~
\yl.S
w ~I
".
~)
~i .l!J
JU! ~JL.w.J\o~l
.wi LaS . (' • : , ~")
~ I.S~I ~\~ w~~
(.)'ll~~
("Ij .(~:
" ~'il
~ j'''JJ'il ~.Jwu ~ ~~" J.J-'"'l)1u-JJ: ~j£,\\
l.Si w~1
f :"
~~ ~I
"1 -'":-'
~4-
~\
(fi: rJ~! w~\ t~) ~li"
ui ~
li.J..>-=>J li.:i JA
~
~I
("Ij. (i i :"V ~)
;\j'i
.JliiJ w~l ~i
U~
(' 0, ,
w..,..J\ ~
..»ill u\.S.J ' (i. :"V WoA ) ~
\..b~
. (" f
0-"("Ij .ill ,
u~
~\! ~'J ~~I
: ~~I
~y...J ("Ij . ~I~I .u~ w ~I
~i ~'il
~~ 0-" ~
J~
~
J:
~\ u~1
cl1~
~i
JA
0-" \j..? U:!~l dJ)
! \' w~\ 0-" u~ w ~I b ~I] (''") (,)oiI...H- ~l ~ Jill J.Li. ~ • I.S J"'7
0-" u~ OJ,JoW. 44-11 ~I.ii J.;.1:
y,1j ~
••••
[. \' w~\
w~1 ~
~ ~J'
.JulJ ' w..,..JI ~l ~li
oYj.J ~
"
(H)
~I
.w! y\:i.S11 .uc. JU .l!J ! \' w..,..JI
~
.:•
~ 4-
u~ u\.S..u1. (' • : , ~" ) " j.."l:JIJ o~1 tl) " <U..4 ~ ui ~ US: ~~! ' w..,..J\ t4-) tl::..~ o~ Jtj 1.S~111\ , w~1 0-" u~ ui 'i~ u\.S.
("~
J,A • (
~]
"f :"
""j
[ . ( 'A : 'j.J) " w~IJ ~J4-l\ ~1..iG u-l " 'T'~,
~L.JI ~.;JI
.n
13. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIX, (54) P423, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. J.!J-!J \" ! \ f , \ T' ~;1.llA.l1, 0jl.,.rS.ll ! ..::...,..JI••..•~ uLS. ~I J,A : ~~I oJ ~ ~4J1 4.....1..li . \ f
u,....
.\T'~,
\'\'\'1
,~~~I
~I
ULS] (\0) :
~i
OJ",w.
'i w..a) ~4i
t.S~\j . ( , " , ,1\ : ".
~ '"
.[~ u..,.JllJA I~ u~
J,\, ~4i
\ ,o\';'4r~Ju~1
,~~~I
U~ r'..
.~ ~.1<.. ~J
~4JY
1:U I ~I
II
"
~#
LJ...4 rW L.J! . o~
(\1)
~
uLS Ijj ]
J...i.J-A
u..,.J1 uJ.!'
o~
(\V)
•
I
II
II :: ~~ U'-=
ULS!.J-A l-I J " "
, 1._·-1
IS"'J ~
cs..PJ+A ~J111 J,J-i:.J yc..J.u
~I ~Y " ~I Y.J JJ4! ~.wJlj.~.wJA ~ l>..oLAI I u.~L~ ~I ~.... 1 ~I u'I'~U IS"'. ~ ~lj'(J-4 Lill._·-I ~ ~I ..~
: ~l ~ u~1
~j IJr-4- W u~..;ilIJ
4J.4~.J:! lJAu..,..J1u~
'v : , · .J:) " ~11.A~i
~
ul ul.lJ....,
~..>.fCS.il1 ~l y)l .". ~'J ~..,..JI u~ 'J - ~
r-I.J..,JIu-111~.J.>A Lil~1 " ~ ~l
.:.
~j ~ J.J Jl.d O~J .uJI)·u ' O~J .c.iJI).~
.( ,1\ ,
~
¥l
.fi~ ulJAYI
. [A,.jl.lJ...., ~ utS 4JY~~
L\~\' ~
.:.
~C.#~Il.AI
..J-;
~i
~l~
4JIu~
~IJi~.J
. ( "" ~ " :" .J:)" I~ Jt.9 4JIo~ uLo
.:.
~~
r~
J .... id_J \.i:jl .J J.' ~
u--c J~
~
JJ1;.J
LJ.eo~
u~J'
~JA
~~ 4JYu..,.J1 U""!~ LHAWI uJ]
, ~~
44J1 ~IJi
r-~j.J rl.lil.J ~I JU tAJ.l.aj.t~ u-k ~
J+9. (
¥ll
i - , : ,1\
J....:i.J! \j..H-:!~J
.>-:) "~.JY\ u-k I~J . ~C)l.J~u~J.J\
(f , - f :
rv .JA) ¥WI
C y)1J ~4J1 .HI 4J.4~.J:! lJAu..,.J1 u~
. . ~J ~ ~ u·1·(J-4 ~. ··l:.".will ~ uJ=l'" ~..L~I~ ul..,aJ1JS -lAtAI t jc. jJJ lJAu..,.J1 u~ 'i J . (" V-"r
'i J
~.(J-4 u· ~ .11ul.:..J'i ~ J
j-J
: , .JA) ~~ ) ~ .( r. , "" : "f w..a )
.~I~.~I~yJl .~I~.~L..JI~yJl
.\0
.\"
17. St. Hilary Of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book X, (11) PI8S, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,
1979.
.
(.S ~I ~I~W,j~
.J-A
~~\ ~'}/.JAly ~
JA ]
I
[ . 0~I ~
°ll~
II::. U ~""'":"-'.J
UUI;!
#6.
'_~I
~
(.S~I ~I~ ~ ,
~."
0
~ j l.S~1
~.,.b~
~
lA~
~
•..•.1 UC 1.J~ . ::l'T":'".JA
..)'-'ly
wI ~
0
JA.J '
Wl..J
V :
.u..J ' c:::k. j-il ~
~
w~
I
.:.
~\.."...J~.liJ 0
(.S~
0
~
(.Si.J
'~~i ~~
.o::.tl
(1'1) (,,)o'I~1..!ooI
J"~
•
•••
) w."..JI~ ~ WLS.w} .ue.
~I
JS Id,O' oJ']
~. w.."...JI y ~
, ~I
~4
0-l..;:.s:- U~.C. ""1] •
[ y \Yl (' '}/.J
wr'
I.S.JJ..;.A ~J111 JJ.i:!
!loll
_1"1 r-
II ~
I
.
u.:i-.wi
~I.J:I
I~I0-:!~1
~
.I.C ~II ~ I "'I .~4J~ ~ \.
(I A)
r A (.Si) o).J ~
(Yo) ~i
; ~~I
w41.Jo:l
~J111 ~"",
(,,)o'I~~i
(.S~I, y.,>ll~)I
~I.J
~I
wi
~
.:.
.J-"'I~
~.;.J ~
(.Sill.J
[. wl~I JStjc5iJ.J wl~I
: u.jiJi (lJ&,. ~ ~~I
().o
1~~
'}/.J " ~
Jill . w.."...JI \~~
wI
W . ( "A : , • W..A) " \.AI ~
~
w'i ~I
~l u:..:i
~\
o~
'}/")ljlj
'}/" )ljlj \Yl j:JJ.J,fi
~ ~ oj~I
Jli.J. ( , • , '\ : 'A ti) " ~~~ o
(,
•• •
". .J.J):\"
<U.
~
o~
~
W.J.J.l.A:!'}/ ~I
wfi!.J4
. ( r" : '" ~
'}/i
~'J ~,JA31 uli.:! ~ -
~
rA~.J.J
y.)1
..,1)" wfi!.JI fS)'--: wi J..J""l)IuJ.Jo:ly)I ~
_1lJ:j U. i .l.IJc, ~ ~l t..- ~I . ~
')/ " ~
0
W~
~~ u-lc
~i ~ ~ '}/.J&..0 ul u-i'i ~
I"""
wLS
u.s!.J ~I
u~I
u
~
J
~y
rS41
..)'-'l ~
.l!.J
'}/.J~
~
~
~
~
18. Ibid., (27) P189. 19. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Drat. III, Chapt. XXIX, (54) P423. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,1980 20. Ibid., (56) P424 0
j~'il
~b 1 ~\
" '-l-"",", ~ - .11 ~~~~
!~o~
y)! u-9
. 1'1' UA J!~
~ ";I "
LJ.4
-li.G
u~1 I·
wyJl u~
. ~.~ ] (n) ~ (j'I~~
'i ] (n)
wyJI ~ ~.);
LH~\ 0.A I..,!W 'i "
.u~ w..,.,J1
~,
u~
"1'II
I
JI~~ 1)4-:1 'it ~~I
~~J'
oili.
( " : ,,,,j.J)
J~..J
" .u~ LJ.4
u~ J,.\ ]
j~'il
~
J 4·JI 0J.u~
(Yr)
rAY 6....-w~.J
w yJl
~
\1'1'11 U~
~J LJ.4 • uip"'''J ~ ~J
u-k ;;~~
~~ l.- u~
~
~
ul w.,..Jl ~
J,..\ J.
o~
c.s~\ ~J
u~ '-¥] (If)
u~ jiSt.dJI t~ ut ~"
~.;b ~
wyJ\
u-9 ~~
~u
0-:lt "
w..,.,J1
c.s~
~Iil\ OJ~
.w.,..t
~
ut ~
u-J~
44-3\
rAJ j~'il
~~I
0.A
u~ ~ ~
,. UA)"~I
1~LS ~ !~w..,.,JIu"'!~
u)~
.:.
t L.4t
c.J.A.u~
,[(",A:
J~
~~ 'i LJ.4
~
c.si11 JAJ'
~
yo
ty c.si11
c.s~1~I~ w..,.,JI0.A ~~
U:!~I c.J.A 1..,!Li.:i 'i " : ~u
u~
UA:!J11\
~.J
4Jt ul=aJ ~t c.stJ.~(rl\,r A :' • UA) " I.A~ ~t 0-:I~1 ~)
.:.
c.J.A ~;;.,.9 JS ul
Ul.w.1 (S..tJ.:.A
~\..H
•
•••
~)I
[ . ~.Jl..4 ~\
~I~wyJl LJ.4
"..A
U:!~I
UA:!J11\
Ut UJ.J~ 'i u4J1 u5JJ \
" I.A~
~.l.9J
~f!1UA:!~.-.:.t\ J..J-A; ~
I
u-J->=S
(s.J~"i\
JSJ U JS ~I
JS u-9~~
~ u~yJl
. ~~J.~J.. _'\1.:. II t.Ji.1\ ~YUJA-l.);,-J 'I ~, '
("jc tJ-l.JC ~
,
~
c~ ~\
~ 4Jt, ( f : ,,,, ..,1)" \
~
.. ('" A :' • UA)
I~I.SJ'
-," ~.~ 'I
JJi:l~ JA
[ . u~ ~
~l u~~
w6.~
ul . ('" l\
~\J!
'i o~
J~..J
.:.
~
w.9J u..9w..,.,J1 : 0
t1 ) "
tJ-lW1
21. Ibid., (54) P423. ,n ~, 'f 1 ~ , Y •• , oy\\.ill(0"""WI ~j.;JI) li) ~ ~: t3y:&.'11 uJ...J:!S 0":liill .n 23. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book X, (10) P184, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,
J.lA
1979. 'Y
i ,f ,
u..... ! u..,..J1u~
'I" ,:).l.l.a.ll , • jl.;.SJ1
~I
ulS.
JA : ..::Jt:ill .~ # y\.,J1 •...•••I~
. 'I",
,y ~~,
' ••••1
.Y f
..,.s' ) " ! y ~JtA Y ~
. ( 00 : '0
~1~_""All '·<1 (.-::---' ~U~J~
-:.iL:I·II.~"·1 U ~~
0-:!1 ! Y '-S""
W.J-"'1
Y~ ~
\")ljUw··\1.>-- ~c..H ~"I.
[ ( "f : , ~) " 1~ ~I :~ AI ~
(IJ) ~
JS ~
y.J ~~
J
A " V :' • ~) " ~I
~'tll
~\
~I
" ~ ul " ~.u. ~ U:.:J4-c.J ()4 ~AI
~\
~(IJ)
4.3)"~
~ '1" .u.y-.::<
tA~'i ~. ~
010~
~ l.ul\ ~
01 ~\
......:i ~
1~~\
()4dS.~J
~ }:ll u-.lc. ~I
~I.illl ~
~J
~- .A
d 0U:J.....a ~J ~I
J' . 0\1 ~
~
~I
AI
...\ . ~I ~ (.)"::' L\~i
.J:!-!illi U! J 0LS ' ..
A.c~wyJI ()4~01
~
'i : "V ~)"
'-1·1. '-H ~ . tA~L~ ~I
~
WAI • ('
o..,i1l: ~
4.3e:JJ~J. (
wi\.-
\ ~ ~I~'(.JA <.r.
4J ~'J ~..,..JI u~
U~
.uU:J.....a4.3 y'il ~J.w'tlI.JA
~I
0~/)~J
~
(~I
w.,...JI~) ~
. .)~~~\
lA~
~
~\
0LS.usJ . ( i : 'A ~ ) .~\ ~ .U
• ~..,..JI6A
u~ ~o~.J ~JI.)~ ~,JA31~)
J\.! lASwyJI ~
\~~~ --,-11
LA~L~ ~I
.•
"~ILA~i ~
01~)t,\I!'J015.]
'I'~ UU
(~O)
~.....\ ~I
\ 1--'-1 ~J~UU
~
t.r-:.J ~
vw.J:-WI~1~Ji11 ~
L\~'i.~ ~~~
'I'~
w~
~
4J
tJ ~I
w!
.:.
·1 .~"
\ ....,:jl~· <.r.~u-
ul
[.('A,'V:',~) ~
' ~L,y ~
.J
I.SI]
(n)
~I.H U1-1 tJ.]:J..:.A ~Ji11
J..,:i: .:.
[ . /)~J o~\ .u.)\J~ wyJI ~ I.S~I~I~, wyJ\ f''ii
.ul~ue
J\.!J ~
LA~~ ~I ~.
~I
~I
]
~I tA~'i ~
(~V)
~UJI OJ.".w. 44.11 L.ulJi J.Ji:!
~I ~~ , y'il ~
.:.
I~ "
25. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIX, (54) P423, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 26. St. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book X, (11) P185, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. J.!..>-!l '" I ,t , '''' 01~1, _jlF!1 ~!! u.,.JIul.i.:!~10I.S.J.A: ~~I-~~li4J\ ~I~ ."v
.'''~''~~'
u~
-ul y::.
UIJ' ~
~.&.
u··11 ~ J.,J-4'
_I... c.sI . ~ r-
Ul ul.hLJl
.u c.s~1JA ~.
..T"
~
..11' [ \'u.JA" UA UjG.. ~ ~ Ij~
u:JJ' ~fll
.:0
.
J I~
~.&. l.S""" ..T"
c.s~lljJA . ~
I~ ~.
~I
~ Ij~
u-9J' U~I
~I
J ..
~ -u:.l.JlljJA "
~ ~
~
Ul5; ]
u~
bl,t!
(lA)
J.",L..,J
~IJi
JtL.(jk, ~J
o~
.(jl~
u...a) " yji.'ii
: ",
~I
LJ]
(l~)
~
d-dJ'I1
0.A Uj~ ~
.. !\' u~1
~IIJJI)
.:•
uy.4J
~~l.S~1
G!)I
~IJi
J",.L..,J
~1
.:.
. I". r-'\.c. JAJ t.J-'-'l:!~~ .. UI.:IJ. -u.lc ~ ~ ~L ~La ~
. _.I ." ::
~ . ..IL~.
UA • ~
J ~1.))1~J I~.;i
u~
, u.rJ1
U1 ~'l
.J ~ .1.
UL.l'l5; ~ U.!y.II u..r" U J.. ~I .
~4-liAJ. ( £, , £ 0
~
U'
~
1,J-A,.,9 , oLh:J1 c.s~1u-lJ~
u-lJ~~
" yl.::l.S.ll J~,
I~
LA~T Ul
~lib'UA .(j\j ~
.[!\' ~
• U~
~ ~
,-:..o:u I~ U&" . u •• ~I ~ tA~L~ y::. \..:;w ~ u-::
c.s~1UI.S.JIu~
~.t.:lJ ~~ . U. t:i....u•
~. -.J~ ~
u- wi ~I
u-l. ~Ij
rJ:-..;; rJ JA ujJ .(' A , , V :' • ~ ) " ~I
, u yJI ~ .... 1 U"*'
u1 u~
~1
~J
... [ ~
.. JA wi ~ Jli . c.s~\.lll
t.J-'-'l:!0.J:l4.1
ULS."J! ( , -i : 'A ..H) ~.)'ll _I...J , r-
L:.
(.)A.li:!
..I~
_I~" r
u-k
~ J ~ . wliJ~ ,-
: ~~4 6.,) WlS 4.J'i ~~I u~ ~-J "~l.J1 4.:J'l"
o~
.us rJWI
.u ufiJ ~ ~1 ~J
~
~J '~ljill~
4..]
~I ~~I
J,;.'l" Jli jJ .(j.JAJ4I,..o'i~ 6..;i ~I
y\.h:a.. UI.)C.J ' ~I.illl ~
0A.J:!0A ~ ~
'i ~
~ ~)I
l.Sy:J~'iJ{i
t!4
1
u-lJ0-:!.):aw"y.)1 ~ ~I
~I
uts
~I
.wjA
~ L..a.. (" V : '"
~J
J~ ~
~WI.&I ~II~
:i~) "~~'ll
J,;.10A 4I,..o'i~ 6..;i y.)1 ul5;.ul. ("
u~'11~.)
~I
~.l.!J.
41,..0\...01 ty.4yJl
( , :
'i )~I
~)
o~1 u-lJ
.)J,y-JI J,;.I 0.A c.siJ\tJ-'-'l:!
. (" : '" yc.)".&1 ~y::. ~u-9 . ~I~, . ~I~,
~L..JI~yll ~L..JI~yll
.lA .l~
iSJ .. ~I
elil"
CHl~
JLi9~~
. ( it:
"i ~)
6..) 0ts ~\
( , • : or
~
~I
(1".)
~I
~1 ~
~I
0'11"
~j£-
01 ~
l
~I
is ~I.J~I ~.J
.'J'
1
..,\~
hi
~I
]
(n) A J J;I.,H
: ~I
~0'l~~\ ~·010'l~y..rll
.(",
,.: . " ~\
~ _<I .11 ~ ~ I...J~ 0.J
~
~I
~ ~
(n)
~IJi
Ui.....l t.$ ft::.A
O..,ill~
JJ.l.a...J
~p.J
~.&I ~
ue ~
.:.
0~1
J ' 0L..u)'1
JJ-i;
~J111 0~)'I
.:.
CHl
y6~0~ull.)tc
•• e: .. .J~J~. 1
.wjl~~1
u~
wi .)Jl! ~'J u~1
el+Jl~
w.!J~~J.("r
.)-At!, ~\
'A~~O',O.
1~.u.JA0ts
t 4) Jh:Y 01.J.)Li11 ...J)'I~
0LS:.w) 4.lc. J:.! .. ~~I •.
~
JLi' ~
: ,r ~)"
0A.lIJ (,$~I~IjJ'
1("
.:.
' (,$...:r=J~ \ iJ4! ,,'4
L.J]
.[ ~~I
.1(' • ~J~JA~~J
ue L..J4- 0L..u)'1
OJ."w,44-11~IJi ~
u-! ~
~
.( r, , r. (,$ J-i
J 0L.u)'1
01 ..J-'o"l" y'll 01 WJ . .....:i.JAJ
~~ 4.Aill\\j~
o~
~
~iJ o..,il\~
. [o~ ~.)J'
uJe.l
~~jy..rll
yJl .JJy.JI ~1 0A " ~)'I ue J!i ~~
" .&1
\iSAJ .(" :'" ~)
y6
~
t~
JAhI 4.AL.l
~I
" ~~I
0~~
~)'I
J\..iJ . ( r, : ,r ..H)" ~.&I
~I]
~1 ) "
L.~
Ij~~~
0'11()-4 " ~1
LHl 0J~
4.A~~
' -u..) Y:\-'-'llits -LJ.JAJ 0:U y...rll ~~i
ull ~.;.b uts ~IJ
~.
~I
-J
"i
~I
I••. ~r-::~
l. L II . 1(' • _ L. ~I...A~
_
:tU-G) ~\
~~ ~y~J
~.J~
:""))t.\I...HIJ~0jl~J'0~u-!~ JSJ ~JA ~ ~
.u.J~ 0A wyJIJ ~~'l\u~
• , I"
. ~\
c.>" : ~
~UI ' ~UI
~
t"l".;..1\.I" • t"l".;..1\ .1"'
32. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book X, (33) P190, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979.
'OJ...re ~~
~.)
(.S1 ] (1"1")
A; ;il,J:I ~1
J,\ ... y Wa.b!~I u~~1 ~~l ~ ~
j~
U1~ .J!b\l-LJ~ .)~ (.Sill ~I~ ~
J~
1.5..PJ..:.A ~Ji31 (.S~\ ~\~ ~
.)~
u-9UAJ ~1..l.A U1~ jJ U1 ·>·.11 t b [ y ~~Y"'"!" .JI ~ts
: yYf eo o.>.>f, ~J
L}'lJ~1~)l:ill'O~I)1
u'il ~~ .
~~
~~I ()4
wi ~l
.u."iJ . (
o~f.)!.0
.oYf ~
U1u-k ~jJ
~l
~'il ~~
w\.J"l~\~
.&. ..r
U1'0 .)~I .u ~I
w.il ~
. I .l.l....Il W " u~....
~WI ~ 1_ ~
>
J
~I'~
~I
U1U ~
.u . II ::;. ,
I •. 1_
U\-¥:I
l...J"l L}'l ~
.L.
U1U~
~j;! , ( ,.
: , • ...,;)"
. II - ~ u""""
. II::;.
UUL:I
~IJ y'iIJ
. J-JIJ 'O~I.)'i1 ~ ~IJJ'
~l
()4 ~
"
~l
(.)'l:!~1uts ~ J
•
~ WI
," A :'
wi "
WI ~ •••. ~
I-.&ll ~.
f~)
~I
~
•.
,L::u ~
~J ~
~i·l Q U ~ .~,....
" t.J"-'l:l
~)
.;;41
w.Jk>)l1I~IJ J
y\..".;J\ u-9
J~
.:.
L}'llsll U1L}'lWI . [ t1kil\
~~~~~.w ~ ~I
~
y.) J~ 11\ ~J.
33. Ibid., (28) P189. 34. Ibid., (38) P192.
_Io~. ~'.<. I"
~l
~'il ~
.
~ . ~~.
..
y.) J."i u-!J
Ul..u~ .Jk> ] (rt) ~I,J:I ~11.5.JJ..::.AUA:!Ji31
y'il 'O~I.Jl t.A 'O~IJ .u~I.Jl.!.w~u-sJJ' 1~
u-l. ~\~
y'il U1~.lJ~
>. - .1
.(""
~IJ ~1
'O~\.Jl
.("':0.J;!)
. L.
J~."iQ
~~l-S
y.) J..,iS, '0~
J.J'"'I)I L}'l~
~~~~~
'il ~
(~\i11 ~I~~I)
~ Lea ~
_r
~\
.l.J U~...,;.) . U.
L}'l.ll.J1yw.s1\~~J.
, ~J
~f
~I
~ ~ I.A.~~~1 ~ " ~.u~ ue ~I 'A : , • ...,;) " ~11.A.~i ul U\..bL.., u-lJ ~l
" ~L4!()4 ~
1L.. ~
~f
'O~IJil~ ~'O~'O~I.Jl.u
~.~~'i J~ ~ \..b:i..:j 'i c..>-:. . 'il ~ ~
~I
.:.
'il U·11..l.A ~'...i ·1::..J'i ..T U . J
~ ~I y'il ~
~
uts ~,
y'i\
~
.J. ~.J~L
o~
~
1.J"l. ~~I
I (5 ~I~~
~~I ~~I
u---
~l. ~ ~'..
l_~
~~~Ul:il
..•
1 lA..J\.U4 ul" Y
Y u-itbcl tAJSul~)
~ 0A~.J ~'l\ (5..); 0A JS ul ~)
ul.J~~I oy.:...uuP
jj
U"':!"' ~
(5i.1\ y'11
(5i.1\ ~
r.s.A o~
.( f • _ i A : i ~)" ~ ~I ~~\
.. ~~I oy.:..~'l~ 0A~ 0A JS JU: ~'l\.J y)U ~I o~I)1 ~\ ~ ~ U..a~ U..aJ,S ~
Y ~
~)\
J~ ~
~}
w,~"
~
~I
o~
.w~"
~WI All y.=...1 I~
.uuP
.(' i : i ~)" ~~~I ol;pJ\
. Yl.J ~ ~. ~ U.4 ~ LH,
~
~~I
rA
0A u'11u-i~i
UI.J' ~~ 0A ~ ~
~
~
(5~\
y'11 ~
u1-9'
y'11 ~
~'l\.J y'11 ~
y ~l ]
.. ( '"
:
~'ll ul~.J
o
(r
)
~~J...»' I ~
.. y y'1\ ~~.J
~m. ~'l\ A"J'::'Q
t.' "~! ~
u1-9 ~~.
J-.; ~I
y'1\ ~
~
+ +••
U..a
LH'l1~ui ~I.J J.-JI y'11 ~,
~Yl U~.J. ~\
~I
J"~
yjj$.A.>A LAS~~
0 ~)
.>A..hi! LH'l\ ~.w1-9 ~LH'lI.J~ tA U~
Jill
y'1\
~Yl ~
LH'l1~
LH~I . [ o.h.\.J
Ui ...>i:- y'11 ~
r.s.A LA] (1"1)
U} " ~ y~\ wLJS~}
~) "
t~
,..ill~-,,,.A\\~·I c.s- c..-==--
~
~)1.J" v--
.[ ('
~
0 :
~I ~~J...»'I
y uyt.h=..LJ.4 u~
~WI ~}
y~i.!. ('I': AWA) " u-i~ U.J ,~~. ~
'i ~)"~ ~
~~,
y\·1U
y)U tA JS" J~~.J.
J.,,:i;J
~Jill
~4 t~
Ui .J.li:i Wj) (5.>J~yi . ~..
1-
y'1\ ~
~'lI.J y'11 Ul tAS] (rv) ($Jl:!jt.lll ~~JJi.:";:' ~Jill .[ ~o.h.l.Jojl.J'l\j,
.:.
J.,,:i; .:•
.h.1.Jw~y
36. Ibid., (51) P229. 37. St. Gregory Of Nazianzen: The Fourth Theological Oration, (12) P314, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII,1978 .
: ~"....u,.)~lS ul(.Si . .u.J""lwu-i J.,atS~I ~ -J '
u-i\:i.\\~..:ll-u} ~I
~.J'J\
~ .u.JA~ u.! J.,aLS~I
u-e ~
~\
Iill.l\ . UI.c
~I C-J.J
" . " (.)A
~I
~
~\
u-i I~
J-J'J\ ul....u'/I " . " ~
• ( £V, £0
,
~-J
\~. ','1 ,
(,)-.I
.~\
. ~.
~
Y"lL~~
~I .
~
~'i\
~..:ll-J ' ~
o.JI.;Uc.H ~I
~
(fo)
~I
~I-J
. ~I
~
\1\ u} ~ ,
'-:JC'.J
~ y~}-J
~i
UM~
..:li ~
u-i\:i.\1ul....u,/I, ~Iy
WjtS 4.lSl-J ' y ~}-J
~
~I
-tJfi-J. ~I
~I
1J"l~}
~oLi~.JA
~}
1:U ~~(.SI
~~oj~})
.[ ~W\
••••
(.)A
u}
tS .J.".......... -- ".11
c..wJJ:oSU"l.:!JiJI
~I..:l~
~
(.Sill .JA ~I
~J~"il
~I ~t::J~ \¥ ~~~\ ~~'J\ ~
'- .
J~...J .:.
~i
(fl)
rl! lJ"lls.ll .u.e. ..r.uUul
] (fY)
J....L -T"7
)4 .JA
. [ .u.ul....ul ~ . ~u '.
t~~
~1j
C-J)I-J ~I
U"l.:!JiJI
~ ) ~
uLS u}]
~..:l.i
u-i u.JA~I ~
J-J'J\ ul.,.."j,/I
Lii
.utH.'w Ab.~ Lol . u~-J ,~ ..r \-IlL~-JI...J' ,~-JL
.~]
[ uyJl ~\..i t~
~I
u.JA:!~..:llu-i LAS-tJ'J u\.J-A'11
~.J-'"'lw. ""1" 'j 0.11 t..JS.\1 "...1'/1 .J-A~I
o~
,~ U·1 ~.. <..~
~I
~\
, u.JA~1 ~-J~l....u,/I ~
ul L&
J..,.iS u\.J-A'J\ ~~
n' , '" : '0 fi , ) " ~lA..JI (.)A y)I
t~
~-J
~-J.J
-i
~I
(.S~ ~
Ul....uHUl....uHu..,.JI ~}-u1-!" J.J""l)1 uJ-.J: ~
~\.:! ~i
~..:ll.J~
~
~I
J~
.:.
0-A y~
.. :~I\-u
(,,)""-"",~
~. ~
40. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral. III, Chapt. XXIX (56) P424, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980 . 41. Ibid 42. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, London 1885 Book 8, P151.
~.u
uts ~I
~\
u} tb.]
~I
(£1")
w4-WI c.)o t.J~
W ':l}J' ~I
~
J.Jl:! .:.
u:".J:! ~Ji11
~j
4.lS.1. ~l
c.J.A..>AU::.
. [~.uuts ~J.ut! ~
o~
~I
~
oft ~~4.w} ] (ft) ~I
J.Jl:!J .:• . [ ~ rlb
.... ..\.",; ·u ~ A...JS.11~ " ~)I.&\
~
' ~
c.J.A o~1 J ~
~} " JAJ~}
w.AI ~
. "4JI~·_·I~I~:; ~,
~1.A...J1c.)o Jj.i (.S~I <J~
~
(.S~I "i
u-l} ll.A. ~
~.AI
. ('
JS ~"i
~
.&1~} " ~l t~)A.
rl~
~)\
yi111f'~1 "i
~
uts ~\ ~I
c.r
rlWI .&1~t
..J
,~
~'
~1.J
~l
(.Sill uW';\
r ~I ,. 4JI"- .us U~_<1\ A.A'
•.
I~
'1
4J'Y" .u.;! ~ J
~~'YI ol.;.:JI
"
w~)lll Ul~' <JI~.u~J'~~
.u u~ ~ ~ ~.J:!
y.;J\ f''ii Jl::-~" *)1
tJSlll ~ .... ~. w .J-"'l WI U-.l.L......:a.:.. ,{' ·1 ~~ ~U
~I
~ - W5.l1 - uts.~
.
JA
'''',?~lOI\
c.r'WI .? . \II .J
(.)'l~J~.u..;!
........,-;.
u.. ( 'i : r .J:! ) "
c.)o
V
a.
A
.J"'
~ ... _":11 'W"il~
~J"
. It _1..1 '-J-i.
~\ ~\ L.otftJ.
". UW"i\ . I" • LH.
",',t.....u"il"u!"~
J~ ~
~}
J f' ~I
r : r ..H)" ~Lo....J\~ •.
c.)o
~J .
U~....,....lLl....i.I\.ll1 ' ~~
y.;J\ ~
.. 11 • .J.J-A I· (.)-C
~
"i} ~1.A...J1~}
.u ~I <L...iii
'~t.....u\ .1"i\.Iuil ~ ..J-Y' I· UC ~..._":11 <se-'. . f' ~ ~
~
]
.J.J-A'YI o¥. y....:i; UIJ ~
UJol~~t
(£0)
(Jo'l:!Ji11Jji.;
.
.:.
UIJ ~Gy Ul ('s.JJ~1 .[ ~I
tA.yl} ~
~I
43. St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Horn. LXVII, (2) P249, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, 1978. 44. Ibid., Hamilies on the Gospel of St. Mathew, Horn. LXXXIII, P497, Vol. X, Feb. 1983 45. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Drat. III, Chapt. XXIX, (56) P424, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980.
. •••
t
[:
•••
C£
~
yl ~
rlJ
w~4
wj41u~II¥J.
~I~I
o~
. rlWI \1\ 0A ~\lijl ~
_lb.a
• \
~
4.\S o:u. ~\
1y.i~.;I
~
rlJ' 0.J:lA..;;.;Io..,!~
l.J:l~
~4
.• ..r&..
.J:!:C
u-lJ t4-;'JI
LS ~I
01\
~mIS" ._Q> ~
.•••I~~ •••••• J
'\j, ("'11 U.
.~~ ·>··\1
~
~
0A T)~IJ ~b.a"'>:p- ~l
~I
wl;1..l::a.:a.. t!..;; ~
~I~
u1U~J"
... w~4 w.,..JI j~l LAS 4.J'i] '1 U1lJo'l\.ll\ ~IJ
~I
(0,)
~i
' \..j!..?- ty , u..?-
~~~l
~
4....JSJI ~
.l..iI] (0') c.sJ~"JI·
J
. [ ~ u~'1\ ~ LS~I ~I
~
w.JA ~
~'i\ u-lJ ~
04 u-lJ ~~J
rl
.
~
Uatsll
J~
~l
I~
j~\
.:.
u.;!~ IJjy.;
Jill J"~
••••
~~'11 ~I ~I Jii:lJ
(or)
r-J ~
~J
U"YJilI
...\ .. < ~ u-...;:-
~4.u~]
~~I
~J
~
u-C~ LSi.I\ I~
[. ~ l4 w~1 (':-'"
>.•••, •
~J
\.1Jc. LAS ~'il
i .J:!' ) " ~
0 :
I ..
~
~t!~.J:!
. [(
• \:j.JA
La.llc , ~~\
~ ~\ uJ] (t') ~..,H.wI~i ~Jill J~ .:. ~J LS..rJ4 J:' ("'J'i\ o:u. ""-:!~yulUJj JA LAS ~J ..
rlt:ill J:t!...>:pI.A~
w.,...JIj~l W J
tJ-i ~~ , .l".,j~
'JIJ uj.=J\J u~1
.:.
o..,.:! u1 Ute . [olpJ\
.
:~~~'~:W~
(rv: ,r ~)" ~~'.>.i .u~'J ~ T.l:l..IJ ~J ~l ~
~I ~~
~ ~J. ~t! ~
(CJ.JJ ~J
~LS \:j~w
.u~w .J~J' uts o~ u'i . ~I
u-aWI T~
~)
~"oJ~
~
~
-,
USJI WI ~
'JJ ~\~\ ~ ~L,y ~I
'JJ ~I
~
("'J'il .u~1J ~
49. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral. III, Chapt. XXVI, (34) P412, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 50. Ibid., Chapt. XXIX, (57) P424. 51. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II,London 1885 Book 8, P152. 52. Ibid
ul j~ ~I
11\ u~,
~ yl~"Ii
lAC..J ~
)\j . 0.J~4.J
w41~ .#6.
,
~I
~\
0"
wyJl
ue
~.J'
..,:ill u-.1c r-!Y\~
~,
(.)A W,i\S
~jiiAw41~\
rJS:i]
c.s.J~"J\
(or)
01\ USl.J' y~l.J
~
.J.JA\11 o~
~\
.J~.J
'
u\S
~
J~
(.$1) r-t!.J
.:.
l~
J~
~Ji3\
" 0.J~4
(.$~I~ ~I
t4-) ~
01\ ~I
fA
'S'.I\J .Jo=l'-U~~~
.
y)1 Ul ~.J
tit...w) .J~
uJ ~
y)1
~41 (.)A #
u-J.J:S ~Ji3\
] (Of) (Joll~~l
tA~
lAS .ue
~.A:!
~ ~)\11 o..,!USl.J' ~t...w)y~
J1.i:!
~~
'~IJi!.J. (j'l( 'V:
"V w..a) r-~.:U~1.J~.J ' ~.illl
~.u)
Y~\.J
.us..!.J ' ~
~ ~
[u-.:.II ~ ~ ~~.. ~ bl\~~~
.
~
:
tA~
(.$~I~.J ' w yJl (.)A 1..:-lC.J ~
~ltA~.J.
. ( 0f
J~
~ ~"
~.J:! tA~
' ~~
.u.a~)
~C.J)I
'.J~\
" ~~I
•
~l
.:.
~\
u-i~
~ , Ut...w) (.)A
lAS J\lj.J
.[~ u=J1 ~
. y~
.
iJC'
~Lu l..\ Lu:...L • ~
(.$~I ~~ ,
~\
.• :'0: -II ~.J:!C
.J ~
uJ ..
..
I....J
~
~I •
~WI
. .uYI Aa.. • ..T'
]
(00) (Joll.J;Jh.J;..Jl
L '_0: 1. ~I.! ~~"1
"t-'. ~
~Ji3\
•... II.l.l...J\ ~ 0:1\ '_--::-~ ~ A
&~I.Jl ue.&\ o~I.Jlr-~.J .. ~I ~
~
~~
CA.J
J~
.:.
'. tAl ~I
,Ut...wl • .J ~. Ut...wYI • ~-:.1.:.
. [ ~l
t16.~) ~~I
Jij.J
53. Ibid., P150 54. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Drat. III, Chapt. XXIX, (56) P424, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,1980 . 55. St. Augustin: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Tractate LII, Chapt. XII, (3) P288, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. VII, 1983 .
\'-&':' .. ~
. I ~\
~U
~ U
wy\~ILAI
~
r, ~)"
(fA:
. ~~)
":"~l ~ ~ -:'I
(.)-4
l~
~L..u'i\ ~ . ~I ~.
rA')~J'
~"o)4c~
~j>
(..>-J.L..:t.::;,.'L>'-4
r+ij..:...J~'i1J
_r
.;-d,'
u~ II '. -
rA.JCL.t.ca ~\
~')~J
_\~ \ . 1.1j • r""""'" I..H
: ~ l:lh:i.. ~
~
ul ~.
~
! .)y\~1 ft1
~~I
o~J
ub. o=Jl~I
~
.)~I
JS~ ~I
~~Y\ ~
~
~\
~\
l..S.lJ1 .)4-11t.J-'lJ.l.i.\1 ul ~:
yA
~J roj1 LJA
t.1.l-~~
~J
J.J'"'lY\ uJ~ \Yl:l.illl J..,i; . ! ~)I
<U...4
ue- ~J
~
wl:!,Aj J
~
Y'11 ~
~J
11.\ J..,j j..:...
I.'), all ~I
oL4LAI t~yJ\
ul-! ' ~I.ull roWJ ~ ~I
')J~I
(.)-4J" •
t~• A..i.J~..;::. • ~ '. " UI.:!. . \1:: <u1] <U"'("
..;::.
_\ ("'" •
~
, U...F"'"' ' '.- 'I ~1~ "t-' .:
'i ~\.sJIJ
Jr 'ill' J\
ul
~~
LA
~
w··11 Y"'" ~f~~' ,. ~&.
.J""
<\,.j
()AJ
~..
UL...i
(OV)
JI .) . <U .? •
4JY ~I
uJ J~
li,jSJJ.
I...JC •
~
)
"
'. ('\ U""*' J
uY
Uo'Y.ill\ Jy.i;
'.':' IL f~~.• -: .. I..S...J'"""',
, .It. UA:! J11\ J~..Li..
••••
~ .11 ~~
,w" ~..'I ~
. [u~~~J uJ..»S ~Ji11
t.J.J~~\
..>#-
•• '"
"
t.J ~ .'"
J~yl u-J~
'..U.lII;! 1-.:.\_\ J "w'
~..;::. ~
,I <\,.j .JA U... .JAo:I
. rbU ~1j
liJ'~ U I ~
~\ •• •• ~. ,
u~1 t4JI uJ]
.
JA
o-1J ~~.Jl
.:.
~
~I JS ~ ~ ~Y .~ ul 1- ~..r' ,Q' U L. l..S ~ ."..11 c::-•• Lli t.J-'l~ Wi lS'.II ~ ., r.s-~
,",,'iJI ~I
.j u---: "("'oUl U
(0'\)
(
,~~
y.;.11 o.J-'-'IA
t..rA
'
~J..,jY"
: Ofi")"
.u.JAo:l ~
,.:..L...,4JJ
~llH'I\
AA
. ~I
~LSJ
~I)I y'1\ ~J
.. ~Y ~~w~~l..S~1 '.e'l _'.:1\ ~ , ~ ~ ~~~. ." .. 11' ·.\1 wl....::.J i.S"""-:11w Y"'" .. 11J jL£l1 4.16.. •• I~ u-""'J . .b ..,.......... .('"
'
L&f.lJi
~
~J
,
.Y.F ~
,~J , U.? "
.w1·1.-.:~ . U:l'.lI.:I •• (,~'""' ~ ," ..II·,LlI c::--
l..S I)·~
~
;[~~ 56. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book X, (36) P191, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. ,n U.G' 'f 'I ~ '1'•• , .J:!l.J:!'0Y'I:ilI'(uuW1 ~j;JI) li)~! ~: t.S~'I1 uJ..>fi ~F .ov -'-"\"\-
'i
4..i~ ' ("~.JJ
~t..- yyl u'i]
UY- ~ lA JS.: ~'i4 .Jt..-
~J
c.s~I c.s~.•...11~.~-
~.J)
(OA)
..M 4..ijJ1.1 ' ~ II
~ 1-
~ ~
~J111J~J
~)fiJ~..)'l-4
.:.
u~
6..) ~
t!~1 . .J.J'W ~. 1- w y.11 ~ <:. ~
c.s..;-; JAJ U?.uj J~
~~ 'i ~
~I u-J..»S
..
I~ , w~IJ,)~~.) T~ o~~ w~W ~ w.b.Jji
~J
. [ 4J ~y... ~
uh T~
~\
"JU] (O')~l OJ.joW.
("'ii ~j ("~
~ .J4-W1 c.s~\ ••••.•
<: ~
T~
~y... ~.
I~ ~j ~~I
J~J
0:11 ~I
.L" ~
c.s-""
(f A ~
. 1._
~~
ylb
J-S .l:.....i9 ..H r-J.wj .. (
'.1._
: ( r'\ :
~
~ ~J
u-sJJ. ( o~
. .ul~~
.u~\..j JW ~
\~)
J y)U ~l
~y...~
w~IJ
,I .. :,) 1. L .,
J ~~
.•... 1\ w~b,j
l.,
~
. J
ulS"" 0J~ ~
.u~'i ~ ~ts ~\ ~ ~
~
&J~ .loS\ "uJ.
~I (f"
y.J 0)L.:. ~l;I'il ~
~\
y)U ~ J-SJ' (f ':'
~
~)I
d ot:i:1~" , f'
"U
-r
0..,5JA .u'i ?i C>-a
y'i\ )~IJ
(",Ujw."..J1
y.;J1~I
~f~ ,fA :"i W.o)" U'lts1\ o~ ~ ~I
~
'0 : 'i .J-:l).w
u.e ~
"w~l
r, ~ )"~
y'il ~ .AIJ· ~J . (" f: 'fi') 0.J~\ ~ftl
U-4 )
"i : V("I ) " ~y..,5llA)ti.j J-SJ . [ ~J\-~
0..,5~j c:~1 ~ ~
~
"i
<.s' ""'e"""".J!JJ~
~
~fi'o
~ytA)
:
44J1 t-lJi J.,J; .:.
tl~\
'.J-:!) ~~
~l§ u1-J 'Y-¥.J
..,J ~ fi - f f :' f..)-A
: ""
J . ~\iJ1
(",)i .J-A
.cL,j\J' 4...:i~)4
..• ~'il ~'I,hjl ~ L}J
'n" ~, J.!.J~) '"
!
It , H' wl~I.,
.j1.fi11~,
I.Y'tslI.:u ~ .
~
w\ ~
tJJ : ~~
• .)~ "o~,
~L..JI~..,>-J\
~'-:JI~\~ ",'\
.01\
.0'
"uLwu)'I~!" ~~-i ~~\
o:U ~~
)~\
J
o..,i ~
c..) c.5.)~'il
~'i\]
~
~ ~'J . y;.i
J~
~J:!-S ~J1l1
u..! .wts
o..".i u-lJ ~ ~I
0-'" uJoC )
. [ 0.J~I ~
~ ,
4..:;J~'i\ ~I
~\j
I. _.
•
ts
41
1_
A _
f'\ : '1". UA)"
~,(
'
(j'llsJ\
~
~"lA~
o:U ~
~
. [ " .&\ i,S.lllfi-
\ •.
J,~
_ •.l....::t..::..
. ~ts , u-: I . .wts , i,S1JA ~1" ~~ ()4 4..:;Jl.SA'i1
..;:C ~
U
: ~ ~,jAJi - I•• 1\.ll......J\ 1_ .'_. ~l\ I..r'" . -A. b •.:o.., ~ ~ ~~
4.-J._~.I· ,~u.>->-~.
~J
o.s.l~
~'J
~USJ'
.:.
uJ o~1 y
~I
~_L" _I<~ .. , LS ... ~ < .. J.A.J,..j'J.r----:tu
. I . - ·.&1 u. 1 ~ ~
'-:JYI
~I ~J ] ('I') ~~,J,,*,i CJo'l:IJ1l1Jji;,J
~
~UJ----r:-J~~J~~
.:.
'-:J)I ~,
~'i ~
-y
~I' ~
uLS
~ U~
41";-J uJ ~..r.-=J\oiA.~.J
~I
.f+l'Lul~.~"';
uJ-'"'l '-:J.;-l\ ~'ii (j'lls]
~
,;1 (j'l~
~1
()4
(H) ~
u:a.-i c.5.1J.+.A
AJ Jil~
~J'
~
~
ULS ~\"J
I
(j'l.J
.wI ." -L:i ~
oj4-'?-
~.
It'';''
o..!]
U~
pI ~I~m. ~~J
'ts J.,\..lb.l· (.)04 U
~'~ ] ('\\")~I .• ~...,; t .1.
~\
~
('It)
~I
,~r, !~m';
~
~
~ltil J.,.a)l J~ Uo\J. (0 ul)
ItV
u.e..
44-31 t-IJi
OJ~
-LJ' . <--II .~.."..... o~
Y •• ' .J:!l.J;lWii.JAlill «(,)"'"WI~~I)
~
u)~!
~IJ' ~:
.:.
u..A!
~~
~
[ . ~I , ~ u.its ~ [ . Uc. 4.-JLu
~
J~
~J1l1
••••
J,;.1.a...,; .:.
L'J t .J L-J~
~
~\ ,-"~)'I
uJ.J:!S ~I
.'1.
H'V
61. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt. V, (42) P228, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1980 62. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book X, (38) P192, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 63. Ibid., (41) PI93. ~...H! 'Y ! \ f • \ r wl.u...ll iijl.;.Sl1 (,)"ls.lII:U~ y,.a:ili u..:; J :~~1 ii..l~ 44J1 t..-I..li .'1 f
u......
It~.
\'1'1'1
o.)~ ~
~f J.J..j W' ~ Uf J.J...,fW' ~"
(r~ : ''"\ ~)"
o.l:l..IJ:i'lJ'~14J o.l:l..IJo~lj
.u USl'
~I
~I
~
~ u\:j~I.Jl~~
_0 ")/
. U'lJ~1 ~)t::JI4'IJ'~'4Jo~l.Jl~ ~I
~\
4J1.!~I 0 .)4aJI~
o..#-
~ ~ ~
. ( r'\ : ~ i WA) " w.il
t .)tS91 ~ L/il r~ ~ J
\..is ~ wI ~)
~ji
\..is ~
: .)W"JI O~~..P :~
rW ~ ~ ~,
Ul UJ~' ~~ : 0 ~
y'1\ ~
~ )
.)4JI U'lJ'
rWJ ~.J:! ~
uts
ul ~
ill
.JA
t4.J
~
c.Jo'l\s .).,JF~ ,.1J.i.11~W! ~1.S.t! - \
WI
~I.illl~
"
ul ~I
4......J'x , ~
I~ ~ J . ( ~A ~
~\
~\
~.F
,sJ ts-b~
~ ~ i - , t : ~V ~
y'1\
~ ~ : ,~ ~
.~~~\
ul " o)~
~ .;i~lj ")/ 1.JS:il]
(i'l)
~I 1.J-4] (v·)~.)J.lS....'i1u-J..»S ~J1l1 J~.J
. [ .;i~1 j ~ ~I ~~Ij ~" U'ltsJl
~
.u ~I
~~I .)W\ ~ ~ (fi.: ~
-u1-9' ~I.J:!C
~J~
J ' ~~
~Lb
~J
~y'1\tL.bIJ(~:'~
~~I
r~J'
~
~
.:•
o~
~
~~
")/1
~)~~ytjJ4'j1l14'.lJl.allJ,.u.:..\
: ~~T .uu§:J ~~~); ~~.
c~
Ul ~.J:!(fi.: ~ -U1-9 ' 4...4")/1 ~
• [ ( A : ~ ~)
r")/l UJ.J:!~
J,Jl: .:•
6JUlI OJ,jW.44JI ~IJi
~ JS ~")/ ~\
u1-9' y'x\
~~
u.JA u yJ\
~\
~o~wlA;! J~~I
tilJ ~ USlJ . (
::<. -u'x " t.r 1)1 w. ~ . 1 w. .,......-
~~
1~J....,...
~I
~I ...
. ( r, : ~i (;0. : n u..) ~.:l))\~I.)c.~:
.,;lJ:!'
0y\ WI, ( U""'WI ~j.;>J1)
U)
Jr..JJ ~:
~4-~
'i : r ~)
·I..AJI·" '" ~_
~
~-~
WA )
~~'xl o~\ ~
'-.ll...JI ..
A..;c)1 wI
y..
011:i110.:l~4411~\.:li .1'1
'-' y&)' IuJ ..r.6 U":l..lil\
.V •
.w~ ~
~
u-!L: .,)~J
~J
rS~
ut c.s.;;
~
u-i 0'l..J¥ JU ~
~\
w.J.b ~<I . ~J.
~I.S
. ( r", r,:
"".,l) " ~ ~l W/J
J...A'ii~
_<::1. ~
y.J
<I _<::.IL
~
~.J
'it ~
o.,)IJi\ i..sA II~J. ~I
~
o~
J~
,=j. !;.,
0'ltjS~.>:!
.u.,)\.Jl u~ ' 4.11
()A
A,..jYl
"i ~ ) '~" U
'i ~ ~t
~
u~, ~
us=J"
y.)1 ulS.!
'-:.1 ~t.~
~
~
.•
()A
f'~
) -w.J~ cJ.A u-.::a c.st
.ui:! ~.
ut UJ.,) W yJ\ ~
L:.:.y.A ~
••+
~ ~I~
~\
.JA ~\
~ .ws..I~'JI ~I
~\
I~ JLi--+ d
~ . .ul~~t
. ~1~1.u~ -w.,)1j.~1:U
~
~J .
~
y..;J1 ~~I
uLS ( ~I
, • - , : f ~)
JAJ
y'il 0.,)1.Jl ~ ~I.S
[.u.orli l.:'"-:lb~1
'!"1' 'i J\
~
~I
: ~J+~ ~
0A
J\.! I~J .. 0'lJ~1 ~)I.:ill 0~1)1
4.1J.S .ws..IJ ' 0'ltsl\ ~
~.wl ... Ula.iIl
II~
~\ ~
c.s¥ ~4-..l.ici.,ll ~
-W.JAo:l ~~\
.
ut LAS
I~..;-U ~a. . ~
](V\)..I··'!I .-.1.... ~.Jf-,:~.·.t r.S~~~
'It!'
~L.c. JJ~
•• , ( r f :
Ujt J . ~~
~
. " ~.,)I.Jl ~ ~.,)I.Jl 'i
,I
ut ~
,~\ ~
r-:.J"t..r""'~U
~ ~~
1._. ~.Lt· c.JA~u~P~
w.p. , J.,.....)I 0'l~
lA~ ul.JA'J\
cJ.A y..» lA..ll.c. J
U~\
")J.,)..;JIJ~ . ~ y..;J1 .,).>:! ~ LA~...H'":!ut 0.J..l.iu~
A..J ._-:11 ~ J U'~I ~ ~ 'L.u'ill.·~ u. ~ ~u't ~ .. ~-:1\ uw6.'i\ ' ,. .ws..IJ. 4..J....?":! U • t ,~ L.cw.:.. ,~, A..J....H"-J~ f'LAt~ ~..re-' '.. II ~. L.: ~. ---i ~'. < . U ~ ~ ~ U ~ _\ I....J)I r-.
, ~~I
'\
U.,.~
~,
~ \~,lj)\.:J
i" N.J
'i ~
u~1
\)..-J IJ~l " II~
uk .,) y
~
Li.:l..»l~...H'":!Ut U~
y..;J\ JU ~~.
I.A~
. ( f' :
cJ.A ~
~
uSlJ
"i .:.w ) " ~~
71. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate. Book X, (38.39) P192, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979.
o~
-I
. . ._-:1 •• "( ~~U--U,
'1" -..1~ ] ~
" ..m~I.J! J: ~~I.J! 'i ~
USlJ " .u.~J .
..··1 L.ul.:i W r-~ J. ~ ~u.. o~ ...r.uU ul ~ rJ u} o~1 \.: " -..1~
(j'ltsll
~L,1aju-LY.w~~( . [ ~} ~
..u ~
t" : ", ~) "
u'jl "
JU ~
~j:l.
~"
f~
(j'ltsll
o~ ~
] (vr)
"'...Ja..J •. c..J.~ . L.u'il· La tJ.C- J~
. [ ~)' 0';' ~
.i,.lj~
W ~~
I~~, ~~.
~ll.cl
" ~ .. LoJS~
~I ~
'~'Q
~ ]
(V£)
wl~1
wyJl "
. ( f'\ , f /\ : ",
U-4 )
~
Lo~}
(,$~
c.,wJ..,»S ~Jill
JjJ;J
ul"":H1 o~I.J'j ~..;a.JJ w..9J(,$1 u-!
JS (,$..rH
tl~
J.,..ajiili ~ (,$ft ~
b" ~.
. ~I U:!
(,$1~
' 'j'",',) '~,Q
..JlJ
~t~~Y\
[ ~~
U-4)
Lo.ll.c
c.$..)~'il
•
~~I
u~
Lo.llc. ~}
ul coy ~ LA W~..J¥;. w~~
I_I
J.J-I;J
: ", UA)"
U:!j:l.
ul '. ,Ib jl9 (,$ ~~ . Y ~ I . - ~ LA uY-J.'i lliY"
Y\J'
~
. y'jl o~\.J!CO .u~I.J!
.u.;a.:! Lo ~
LAS ~
~
~~I ul'i}
~
J~ ~~)
ul 'i ..111~}
) ~
'~"
1=..L 4I,.,j1.! (f '\ .. ",
~~
ULSJ'
J
i;h . ,J.,. JI ~Jill
uL.u'j1 1:U u~ I~J
ll..4 ~Ifi
ul W Lj'i ( tl~1
~ 1_
,tll .u~I.J!lJC ..111o~l.J!~
4I,.,j~ '
.
" (j'lls11
u-i J . '"l_ull ~} ~
~I ul o~1 y" ~(f/\
~
Jill ~ . I a"A.
L.Q.;IJ. ("V: '" .H)"
" ~~I.J! ~ u..:i~I.J! 'i ~"
~
~
,oSt;,,)
~J
w..J:~
4t......u} ~I
~m& ul ~J
J r-IJ~I ~
~
4I,.,j1
~6'1. .....1b.j
\lJ'r
1...l)1 .
Lo.llc.
\,j~
(VY)
~
Wl..Jr-.J.~J ('"
: /\ J.J)
~ J.~ ~ll.cl
...r A~
72. St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. Matthew, Horn. LXXXIII, P497-498, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. X, 1983 . 73. St. Augustin: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Tractate LII, Chapt. XII. 27-36, (3) P288, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. VII, 1983. c.>""
,tV
u.e." .. , ~~, •.JAWI
,( U"'"WI~j.;JI) Li."l~!
~:
l.S~'1I~.»S
~\
.Vt
,rA
: If..lA ~
1_
.lf~,·u'il •
'i ~I ojl3ilJ o...,ill\.¥ (jJl~J
. w.,.JI y~ ~~I
r-.lIIJ~\
, ~l
u-9j'iJ\t1 ~.J~
1·jl
, w.,.JI
:
ut..bl..a (.5~1~\~ w.,.J4 ~
u~'+:'i
\.j~
\.jj41 u\.5;I1t.
s:- I~I
~I
~I , tJt......u1• I....l....)-" . II .) ~
•
,j.
1
;.,\4( ~)'I
r-1A1 tc~
u~
) ~WI
w..,...J41.>i~1 o.»y
I~~I
~ ' ~~b
tAW Jt..=.. I....l'il . .&1 ~ ••••
.
1
;.,\1 .wI~~I
( ~I .
~
_ .ul (':"l ,
~
(.)A
: 0
.I,.,j~'
: " '-;-lC
~.U~
J..'L. ..r7
)
L
~
••••
u~
u~ I~ .. w..,...J\
rJ ~I ~
)iS1.&1t U:a:! ul ~
(.)A
i.J J ~~\
o1t. .wLJS~
.
... .t "
U-J:t"'"
"
J...... •••• 'T'"::-J
< lJo'I-:! Jl1\
\t J ~ us.l J . rJI JS lJ-4 .:"Q .ul ~.. ,,:"'i ~(.5~ ~ '''·''1 ~lA, u-~
.J:H~I ~
r--..
s:-L.....::u ~I ul
.)..
lJo'I-:! Jl11
u-9 .).JA\t1
o~
(.)A ~
(.51 ~
'i -wli ~
: ~IJ-'ll ~
4-:l~
~
jJ) ~ ~I ~. \Y" .: IIJ ~.~~".·'1.lll~.- II 4..c lbll LW . I .. ,-: ",f .l.! .l,.,jl. tb.
. [ t.-WI ~
~
~i
~~
~j\ L <\.1.l1 •
1:U~ \t J '
u-:!:u4.,hl\~)\
(Vi)
\1t. ~J
I~ .(jj4H uSl ' (.5~1
t I) " (jJlWI
u.. I ]
~I
(JJl~
~\
U:l~1d1:J}~I)~
. [ ( ,,'\
(Vo)
~
.wjl j ~.) ~I
ul uW)'1 ~
o~
,
~]
wt.h.....:a
'0 , 't
(.)A • (
.~
f~
.J•I
' ~ ~~I
uSl ~
-J
1.>i\.5; w.,.JI (.)A \j..?- U:l~1d1:J) ~J
JS ~
U:l,j ~~
U·W'iloj\ •
J.J'"'l)1uJ~ (Yl:l.illlJ~
.u
(.51w ~I
" ~j J
~ ~~"
~J!J! ~
~I
u~~ ~ 4J..o \.j.J~J
w··11 Y"'"J(""".l\tl· U"l
b~ J. s:-.
<-r..
~JH
s:-~ ~\
(jJlJ.l..i\1 ~)U
O-Wl.\)\ ojl.))'1~
4.A'i1ue (jJlJA:!j~ (':"l ~I
'i u-' (1 u ·W'i. 1u:. . \.t!~ u .\ ~ .. I~ ~~~ "'1 u.! . WI ~
~I~J!J! ~)'I
~I
~~
~.JA
. t!.)
ojlj
~I.S - ••
ul
I~ J .~~l ~
J
"Jill. (""" 'WI
75. St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIX, (57) P424, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,1980 . .»l~.jAt:il1 ,( (.)"AWl ~~') Li)~! ~: r.S~~'~..»S ~I .vi
J~ ~
rJWliill ~II~
J: rJ 4J~
~I ~
.
~
·.CI
yo ~
J.
4..J.10•• 11 . _"'1.:.. ~~
. 1_ ~
~
~
010J~ ~I.illl ~
01~I
. ( r i : "r ~.J)
..,1)" 0~
~~'J) ~101
C--::--
~
~I
~~) ojO
f>. ~J
-
" ~~I..>J ~ ~~I..>J '1 ~"
y.J
~~I
\~.J~~' o~\
J
o~1'JI'~ .J. U
~
. ~
~
~I
y.)
W:... ~ .
~I
~
~I.fi
~
~ .Jo4~1t.i:i
~
..riCJ o~1 y " ~ ~~I
I.
IJI. oil ~
0~ c.sy;.1 ~\.j
0.A J
~~'JI
UJIj
Y ~.J)
I • .:..I ,j
~b.~l .,
~
~
~
~J
u.
~
.1J' . oil
JU \41J .(rA, rv
:"r
(r'\ :
~~I..>J'1 ~c.sl.
~~ ~~I
~b\.J.I.~ 1i.
~I
~yJI41.JJ
"wi.~. I" -<: I~Y:! ~ .<~..1~ ..b. l.ll ~-I I •• r-::-:' .r-. J ~Y r J ~
!
c.s~1~
'1 ~'J ~
0A y)1 o~l..>J 1~.J
~
U~
o~l..>J w..its I4JJ.
I~LA0~
rA ~
Jlli
'-:! " ~
~
.l.S~ '-- J. T~
~..,11 4J.:J
~
~.J04~~
~I
J.".,§ ~~
~
~
~ rJWI 0:!~ rJWI ~J ~ts _ .. "AII.l.l..J1 '1\ . \
r .,;)" rJWI ~
:
c.s~~1wl.,»J1 0.A ~lA ~ J ~~I
J.1- ~ J y)1
'1 ~
~~~I oL;p..l1 .u 0fi:j ~ ~ 0A~ 0A ~ ~
. ( 'V - , i .l.l....J1 ~
J.i."i~~ 0.A ~
~~~I oL;p..ll.u0fi:j
4J~ .
Y ~ 'l..AS
w...o)
"i ~)
~.II4..J ,10.• 11 __ "'I.:.. WI. ~ill:i~1 1 J." . _"'l.:.. ~~ ~ ~ • ~ .J.. . ~-
IS'"
.~ ..»i:- ~ ~
~
W-its ~~
..b. ~..)'-'J. \"·1 .r•
r-l ~'J\ , ~~
w..its c.sy;.1 ~
\" U~ c. U·1 -',.,j~1.J.1 ~" Co: r- I . .u~
o~I~~~'~
~ J ' o,-:!\.hc. ~ , ~WI
d ] (VV)~J~,,!I
~
.J-l-:! ~~.
~.u
[ ~I
~
c.s~I..>J
~_.. II c-:-• A_ AI ~
J ~
u..! . ~.ill1
.J
.I~U • .J U.I
01 0.A ~..,9.]A J t:t~
~ lA LA.,; 0\.5 .wI
JJ.1:l
t:;:A ,
0.A ~I
.wtjl:U~.w~.w •
~~.
0~
u-J..»S ~JiJI
~I
~J ~4-.)1
W;.J..,1IJ' 0 ju:...o J ' ~..,11 ~
J
.:.
•
t!,'o'lJl 'Hn: ~b
:~~
: ( rv : ,r ~
',J' ~'~
o:u. 0-Au-4J y'1l 4:!1 . J.",sl I~LAJ . ~~I
. ~UI
~
~I
u,;"'jji~
~I
~
A.t:.UIylfll
u-eo~
.w.JA:l~AI ~
uJJ .
~j~
o~
~I
~.
~WII~
~ ~
~Yl
~.b. ~J
-.i ~
~
. ~
~4-i1..\ .J~~
("'1l""
~I.w\.!" '"
4..J••~.~ .. II ~ r..s-.Ill.~_··-· ~ (j4
'-\ ~.
. .-.i
~I
c....J.I-._-: • ~
y ~ u=JI
~AI J.::..Y
4..c.l.JIo~
~
~Y
~J"
I_.u ~liJl I...J..l1....:JI ~.JA:l
JUI~J.
~J.
4J.c. W~
w JA.I -.II'UA 4..J.•.~ ~.. II 0 b.,j .
. ..>41 4\.b:. ~) ~
UI~J
".u.i.-.i ..r IS"J
~I
uJ ..
~
-:II~I
~..
w ~- .II'U.A
u..A!Ul 4:!~J ~AI c.)C
~
.1.. ~ ~ '~I ~jts J..
.u~1
~
4-lk ULS J w."..J\ 0-A o~1
• ~- 4..JlJ.j.u w .r" -.II (j4.. oWl 4..J..~ .~. ,11 ~••. UOULI UILJ • ,"t-""" ••• .JA:l .J.
w~
wl..JS..\\
••
ULS
.w)
.>:.11(.)'IJi-l' .
y'11~I " )lj\! y'1l 0A yl.b ~..>41c.)C ~llS:J
" A.t:.l.JI o~ 0A ~
c.)C
~I i:..L
~\:j •••
''11 U
~
~
~~\
~I uLS J
rAY)l§\.j
~~I •
y.1h9. ~
~'{.\
JL! ~
~J
IS"'
USlJ
u
~~
1·< ~
~Y
u-AJ. W'{.\
r :' ".J:!)
4..4~
(.)'I.r
1..\1 Y ..>iJj"i ~I
y~
y'1l
~ '~.1-
••
~~
J . u;J. ,"i)19~~
~~Y~ ~I~)
.. Jjljll ~WI ~1.JjjlJ' ~J
ue
_.1
,-J
~I
0A .. " ~I
~
u~ ~I ~Ll..\ Lil u.."...sl~ ~l uJ . (" '\ ," 0 : '" .H)"
IS"
I~
~~u-1I'A.t:.UI . (" f ,"
, ~~I o~ ~l ~
~l ''''iil
~I
~
u'11"
.l.i ~
" 4..c.l..J1o~ LHl ~
-,
L.sS ~.)
~' ...
~
(j4..
t.J"'lwyJl
j~
JS ~ ..~
.~
"i .u.JA:l ~
4..J ·~·.l1. _"'1 .•~
~
.:..
u.J ~ "i ULS 4.JY ~ ~l' O.J¥:. ylb
-: II A.t:. WI
1•. ;'''
~~~
<I liJI .L.
UA ..
y~
~.u
~WI.&I
~
o:U
ylil ~L.Q.JlJ' ~l '-1 ~ .1..
~
"w..ul. J.AU
'\::JI ~ji.S 4.J1•
\Jc.~4-iwyJl j~IJ
. o4-:J1o~ ~ll..\Y )l§\.j~I
~"i'11JI..&..
jL.wi ~
~YI
: (f', . ~\J~\J4A
\~J'
wyJ\ ~
uLSJ ~J
~
~Y ~ ~
" ~i
(n
,f' : n'
~
~
~~l
~
)),
~./,.,'~'
~.?-J)4J!
wi ~) ~
(fi .!f: H..)A) ~ j))\ ~\
. '.- 1\ \ .Ie ~ ~~.~ .. Il· UC.
U...r- . ~
uj.:J\ \i.\ . ~I
(.)oJ W yJ\ (.)0 ~~\
~
J
j~\~
-...AiJ~ ~ '~' jj J
1:U
~ .
\:i....u. ~ .~
U
r...S...H .w~
~~l
4..:i~
~\
I.
uSlJ ' (J'ltsJI
~\
Wjy
r...S~\ lJI ,.01\ ~
~
f'.u:i ~
~
~
wjws. c..--::-- ....AII .l.1..J\ ~
w.,..J\
~
_r
~
1~~~~t~~JLi9
uJ ow.:i ~ ~\j
J:ULili ~i
1)1\ ~
fA: r"\ ~)~
u
~
J-"'l
jL....i\\ u~J ~'i
~\
~,o~~
(J'lifi y)\
u=J\ ,.~ ~\
1-
"'~
~\ ~i
" u-wtS.lI o.iAl J ..»o~ cJA ~\ u..lc- ~J
, ~J
~J y'1\ f'Lai4+!
(.)0
.ue.
f''i i ~
~\
(J'ltsJ\.J~
(J'ltsJ\y ~
-ui ~
ojl.)} 4.:i.)i ~ " ~i
~i
ui "
(J'ltsJ\01\
u!J . ~
l~
,uj\j.-:J
~bSJ
' ~
j.....-
~
c:fi.:. rJ " .. ~l
uJ " .u.,,!~ J
'i
rJW\ .". 4.i'i
.J:!) ~
~
ui ~
~~j.J ~
~i
~bS J ' ts-b~
~J
~.JJ
ue <.r.411\ ,uYOJ ~'ii UiJ ' ~\£
~\
~
~J
'iJ, ~J
f''i'1\ c..rA WJ . ~~J.u
~J)\
..)Ai.". ~~\
~
\ ~~ ~~
YO~
l.;-I~\ 6A l.;-I)\ ~
f''ii ~
wLitA! lJ-'l ~\
.". J .. ( f. :
" f'\~\J
4.:i
oUJ
~ ..\~ 0...H..)A (J'lls c..rA (J'llsl\ •
~ts.aJ ~
~\~\ Jb.:! ~
C ~J
~i wl 0 ~i l: " ~t:i
~
wY~J
~
c.s-
~ r...S~\.J'-:J\(J'lJ.lil\ .". -ui ~ ' ~'i
. O~J ~ ~~
~
~
uJ " .u~ ~
y'1\ f'Lai~
~Wl (.)0 Jy ts-b~
' (J'lJ.lil\ ~)t::J\
.". J . ( i : ,~ .J:!)
ui UJj
~~\
~
~
~ .J'-:J\(J'lJ.lil\ y)\
y'1\ f'Lai ~J
' ( 0 f : n' )) WJ:JI wI.,,! ~ t) .. ·~l ~ . ( f' : '" .J:!)
)
~ ~
u\£
'~~ 0
)';~:'..IJ
4-}_~ rJW\ \1\
~.J
•
J!J
: (T'T': " ~) ~
4--ly4, 0-:!~1 .:I~IJ
CJY,"=,~ j.i) 0k
~)''',~,
t~
~
_ £:
~ \.Ai.; LJi "
" y~IJ
4-- J '
~1
w.J'O ~
.( ro : " ~) "t~ ~ J.,aLS. 'r!,?"JI ~I ~
J ~I J ~~
~
tP
.;jW ~1 CijA ~I
~"
~IJ
<..H'
y~IJ
c:.H'Ii ~.,l!I':'" ~I
f.:l~I w.., •.. a\..l1,"=, w y\)UI ~I
J
~I ~I
u ..>a:!J' wLo ~
J.,a\S w Y"Ili ~ (,S~I~1 y\ J . Aj y\ 'i 0~
"~)I.. ~~J 0~
\.A .;c, ~ ~
~ .. -".,11 ~I ~... ~I
.;jW ~
.;jW
.:IiJ
~
.:I~I
01 .:l.S).!JA~I l:U
. Aj Y"Ili ~ J.,a1.S J
4.:jy\
'i
1 L...ai.i~1J~...r1 "I •..••'il ~. t.::~'i o~I J 01u~ (,S~I <U'/I ~
wi .J-A~I0.A .;jW ~
'L...:..:.. .1" ~ CJ';J ~
(JAol
w.J-A
(,S1.; Lo~
CJ),"=,~j.i) 0~ ~I
'.- -:11 . ~ ~J~
.:Ii J . 0~
~I
t:i.;\S ~Lol " ~
~I
~
'. J ~' ,U.A
(jlI-LI
~ ....
"J " CJY,"=,~ jJli .
.:1~~J .. ,11
.1"
~1 ..
~
L\rIL.wi.U
_~-I
" ~ ~~IJ~~I~ ['.:'t~]
wi "
-"~'J-,.~,~ wi ~i .. ~~'J
[ ,.:, tM ]" ~
~i "
~j;i
d! :;" ~,
:~~
ul ~I
w...JI"( , • : 'f ~) ~ ~))I ~I
(jAy
JWI y'J\ lfiJ ~ ~'il
u4IJCo~JJ' ~I
.JA~
"'_ o~1 ~
u...J ~
~l
(jA ~
~I
~'il uJJ' ~'JI tl...r! ~
~
uk r~'
~
" ~~I
~
-JA ~
u-c Y-;l..;C
jA~
~~ y'Jl ~ ~ ol~1 -U1J ' y'J\ 0A
~,Job,)fJ1 M-11..,i1 ~~.)~I
W"1~
'ilJ. ~ y'JIJ y'Jl u..!~I ~..,i~
~..,i~
. ~ y'JlJ y'J\ u-!
uJl)uJ. y'Jl
. ~I : ~~I
~I
~11.5~1
W-JA'i
r~l
U~~.J'JI
"("
~J
:' f ~)
J!J
.'
."~~~I
~
4Y rl u}i J,.4CI WJS uJuSlJ" (f A :' • ..H) ."
~y IpU ~ IJi
" "'uS ~ ulJ ~~ l.r.I..-J'JI
·11 . .~
U .JJoAYJ 1...rY-J~ ~ <I
" r¥ ul J ~ fUl J ~I ~ ul ~I U~ r ~I ~~ ~ ~ lilJ ~ y'Jl 4=1W"jl cl.il w: b.~IJ~I U~" "
rlW1 ~
~~L ~.J
J ~I J ~J ~
~11.5~1
~I
~
:' f ~)
.f
('" :' V ..H) . f
I ~I ("'" . 'WI tJA.J'J' . --.I ~ ~ f~1 J t...::..JI ~ I '.<.1 ~ " .>J~ I~ ~
U~
" ('"
~ W"jlJ ~
L.il "(" " ~ .~ llAS. ~J~.J ~ I
~ y:.L J
~J ~
f :' V
..H)
.0
~~L I~
y:. J " ( "i : 'V J:l) . i
" ~ ul UfilJ ~ (.)-'I."...-lll
b~
JS u..9 ~
~ ul .. "~I
IJy.JJ ' ~~.J'JI ~IJL-J ~I ~I
~I
J..,ilrA~
wl~\.c.~J u-lc u~.illl wy\ 'i ~
().4
~4'J1~.J.l!J
Ijl./:JIJ' ~\
~ ~y'Jl~1.l!J. ~'il
jA~1
~\ ~L-i.
~I)I y\~IJ
u.!o~I)1~IJ
u..,N1~
~
ut u-k
. ~)l1 ~I...-:;.. - :~
1,./iIJy'il
"~
~J
4J~
~I
'
If.=..~ ~I JS~I ~ ~,J
,.4~I J,JJ.),J ~~.)~I
:~~~J~'
~,JJa ~,
~Wl' : ~Ji
:~~, t.'} ~ w\>',",' w~ W~~
..ri-'iIJ,..ri-'il~I)I (.S~
ut ~
f) UJ.:.-~.)'llJ~
~
-, .:.
[! J}il (.Sy..; ~I)I ~,
~'il
. , y'il tl.) ~
~~I~t...riJ
~)l1ut ~.
J.S] (Y) ~16,JJ~,J
~
~.}.i11~I}il
U6. ~ LAS ..ri-'il
[ ~)lI tl.) ~ y'il ufi.:
ut J6. ~4 ~
~ ] (r)
[ . J!t ~
~\i
~t ~
I~ , y'il u.! t~IJ l?-i . y'il ~
JI...- J y'il ..JA~
u.£i IY'
~t
I~J
.u4 ( ~
~
.:.
(.S~I
~¥':" 6J ~Y' w~ W~~
..»-i us ul ]
u~ >A ~t
y'iIJ
UJ.:.-~.)~I~...J
(.S~I ~)lI u.! ~~
:y~' ~¥':" iY- ~~
.:•
(1)
UJ.:.-~.)'llJ~
-
r
.:.
. t~IJ UWfi.: y'iIJ >A
yJl ~I
U~
-'= )
U.JoC~
~. ! "~ y'iIJ y'il u.! Lit " J" ~IJ y'ilJ Lit " <U..,,! (.)-4.w ~)lI U~
Ut) y'il y\~ ~
[ • .u:. ~ W•.)Co.
1. 2. 3. 4.
(.)-4
~t
. •~
~
~
U~
,~....r~
UtLA) ~~
'I I~'
(.)C
Lu' .•..)Co
St Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral. III , Chapl. XXIII, (1) P393, NPNF., 2nd• Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. Ibid., (1) P394. Ibid., (1) P393. Ibid., Chapt XXV, (17) P403.
~ ,•:.}'J\J
\ "S
y"Jl ~ 'WI~I UAY u..J1
1;".-: cJ..e u~
~L..JI J..aiJ1
,->-:'1IJ y'll
d ] (0) ~I
t.SJAY!-
~jL..J
.:.
,[~\
ut ~
u-9.>A 0-:'1\
]
(i)
6JlH ~lflo~j!
'" .1.:. .11 ~ '.l:lo.1 y.11' UC , [ '-'..,......-
u~( .iillu-9 )
.y9
u...9.>A ~
'
I~)y'll
u~
Loti ~\
Loili. ill) ]
•
~
••}'ll
J.w:a1.J:!J
• \.! 1...J'l1 ...r Y!- U. .
[~)..,..JI ">:p.iill ~Y!-
us:- ~ ~
u-9'r:.>:'1' ufi.: Ut
: yYf 4jO o~f J4 ~Yf w4w,.:~ .k t.S.llILo] (A) ~.j.l ••..li' J.J.1:l .:.
" .l:lo. • ~ ~J '"• ,.JJJ
~I
T~y!-.u
u~'
-u illY " Lie. I...J. YO-..r .-:<. Lo .J~. 'iI' ~
~"'.
.&.
. [( '( A : 'V
: yYf ~ ~ of~' ~Yf y'll~ y'll u-9~ .u) JIj.ut \~ ~\)\
~. J: ~
~ 4J~
ULS ~I
[ o.;ill olb::.t t.S.ll1Y'l' u-9Y'll
.u. y'1l <.JA ~ ~t
~J
t.S~
<.JA]
~I
)\,j
~
~I
~.Jl.oc.
('I)
~.JJ
_r
\..i~t
tt)
w4w,.:~ _i .:.
~t
YI 'iJ ' y'll US
WJ·t~J· .:.
t.Sij\>Ay'lIJ . .u.;,1~
t.Sill
f .J:!) " Jl.oc.~\
y'll
..}JI J.J.1:l
\41J "~
Y~Y!- '-.H'I\] (") ~I
i.:Jl..JSj~ ~
w....J ~ ~t
. [ ( , • :'
5.'
~J:
~1.J:l
l..o liAj. wl~1 ~~
.:.
C!jJ...o;l 'i \..i.JA Y!-
t£lb)
~
.:.
0 ""
U+tJli ~.J~}JI~..J
(V)
0-:'11 Ji..o LoW . o.JA
~.j.l
~I
" 0-:'11 wLJS ~
J.u.:.JA ;SS Jb.\1
y'll USJ J
St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunomius, Book IV, (8) P168, NPNF., 2nc~.Ser., Vol. V, 1979. 6. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel Accordingto St. John, Vol. II, Book IX, 1885. P277, . 7. Ibid., P284. 8. St Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIII, (1) P393, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 9. Ibid., (2) P394 10. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book IX, 1885, P267.
: ~~J~I
:t.'} 4J)~,
~
l.Wb~
~Y"
..»t-
~)I
~I.S.IIJA"&\
~\~\
ul ~I Lal" J~ ($~I ~
~,~ ~ ~J~I
~I~I
~bJ
J!!J .. (" f :
~I~I
\~y\".ue.
.a.>ll : ~w
.-L.QljI.&l ~
"r )"
y~' -,
y)1
J~
~.JY\J
.(" V : 1\ J.oI)" ~ .h.IJ yTJ.u} " (i : f wi) ulSA JS u-! ~6..u}
y'il
."~ ul~} ~J~
~y\'i
~I ~"
J¥:. J-AJ' "tll",JI ~IJ-A
JU
(j'I~~~
($~\
" ~La....J1 u-! .J-A($~I u~'il .j I..r
• ·<1 ..ill:.;' . L~ U.,.. .•.."1"'~..
~I
e:1.) ~~)\.!;
: \..tj\• ~ J1 U
U~~.J'i\
".u..!. . '-J'ilJ.'-J'il u..!.. . wl" u!.s.J' ~'iltl.) ~J
(J~
.~~ul.h.Y
Ji:- ' ($~I
o~
J,.S.~
~ I l~J':"'''.u'i II:: ~ .r ~ . "\....,Q,JI. . ~ UI..:I J . (' r....".;
'i.~
~~
lASy'i\
WA) "
: ,1\
~~I
~'il ~ 'iJ,
o~
y'il ~
e:1.) ~
. [ ~y\~\
~J.o y\
~Jil'
~A..J~J
~~
~'i\J' y'il
~J
~'i\ o~ .:.
'i I¥
~'il ul.~
.uIS~ LAti''iJ ~l,S ~
)
oi.\ 0.A
.u.J!~ u..! . .] (").~~ . ~I Uo"-:! Jill J..:L.. ~ .
y'iIJ,
.. ~4YI ~b
U1...t...i y\
~
ul W
0-:l} , ~La....Jll.J...o Jj.j ($~\ ~} ~La....J1 ~} ~
~'i\J y'il ~~J~
.. ( J-J'JI~I~'il)
($~\ JSll
'iJ., uLS...o
~
( ":
y'il ~
~.l!J
~ J JSlI ~
~I
uLS...o ~
~.
(.)C
'i
~)lS
rtiJ J.ots y\ y'i\ ~~J~
r~ ~J
.:.
~'iJ~JS($~J~.u}]('l).jJi'.J:I
Ji:- ' ~yJ' Ji:-' U~
,oJi:- L>.o.uL- ~.~
-!I o·~Yj.1~~'
'i ($~' ($~·NI~\
. [.u'~~J~ts~~~.J.l.a..::au}
..»t-
~lS11 , ~.J.i.J' ~J'
11. St Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral. III, Chapt. XXIII, (1) P394, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV; 1980 . 12. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book III, (2) P62, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,1979.
~J-.oJ,.S ~
.w~ J ~I
J~
is..f:J+A ~JiJI
W .....
J~
<L,j\j . "
.11 Y'
J.."..s:~ LAS] (' r) ~I
fill
fill
J
~
.Jf
.. (~ : Y .,.s) " ~~
~..,JyJl~'11~
J,oLS.lI~)I
~~ J.l..:l..A f'~
~I
.:.
u:L....1
~."..)u1
. [ t.$~ 'J I J,otSJl ~) yJl .)#- y)U t.$~ 'J I , <\.1'11 0A .u'll
~tJ
.J-A
~I
~I
' y'Jl ~ ~.I11 ~.
4-:t ] (''') ~'il~~
.;:i:- ~...rJ1 .;:i:-
""-:l
J.bl.: 'i t.$~1. ~I
~WI
4~1 ~IJi
JJi.=
,( fr: yr ..,J) U"lJ~..ril1 ~J(Oi
y. : YA U.A~ ,r: r
e.:,,~J JS.~
<L,jl LoS
t.ri:
~
)~
..;:i:- t.$~I
Jr" ll.)#tlA
f'~
cJ.e J
..;:i:- ~I.S ~l
~I
d]
~I
.:•
J
o~
~~J~
~I
.:.
: V ~ ~ : , tt ~,r: r -..H)
~~~I
u.i)\ ~u-!J
u-!J' :;~4-aJ1e,j.SlGt
. ( Yr : , f
JUi:l . ( y. : r :u) oyL-J
,~lp..'J1 ~ ~ . ( y. : Y Jc.
J,Ji;,J
~\
-..H) u:.a.J~1 ~
u-!J' ( y. : 'A U-A) ~>-Jl y..,J! yl..,H1~
~.&I
~JSlI
~ : e.:"lS.. JS. u-! ~..H-.JoG ~J~
~J(
~JiJI
.)#- t.$~ 'J I ts ~I
. [~I (' '\) ~WI ;J~
0:'11u.! ~)'JI ~
~.
iS~JLiJI U-W.J:J~
.)#- . ~ 'i t.$jj\ ~)I
(.)0'=1~I
.:.
J,otSJl 0A J,otSJl , t.$~'J1 0A t.$~'J1
. [:;~IJ ~)t uSlJ' ~)'JI ~ b~ ~I)\
J~
] (' f) U-W..,H-wl,J.,):'A1 ~JiJI
y..,J!
J-:!) ~
we. ~~I
J
~I
~J ~ e.:".fi.:J' Ji:UJ ~ ~ll ~ ~_t::-:~IU:l • jjl •[ ~J
13. Ibid., (3) P62. 14. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book I, Chapt. II, (16,17) P204, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979 c..>"'"
~~I,
~1~1 ~1.J:!..l'
,.u"a:.JAl1 u-1JilI, ~1-.r.-YpJl:
.s~jUlI
u-~.J."a:y:.~I
.'"
. rv~ t t -ty
c..>"'"
,~~,
~L.oy\1.il1 (~I
U,JAY): ~I
O.l,#o
4411UJi
.' '\
~ ~f, ~ fb~ ~Yf, y~' _r
: ~~f 144' ;.,.~
~I ~~
u-c 0~
d~0~~.J'i1
c:.H'ilJy'il t..sJA.»
USJJ (~1iJI ~\~~\
) y'il ..>A.»u-c
00
: j:.\.c.~'il I~ ~t...d ~y ~~I
~ ~.;:'(r. : ,. ~)" ~IJy'ilJul" O).~~1..,1J\J:i! ~I o
JS ~
I~ O.J..,..b:.. ~~I
~"
0
(
,'\
..w~JJ ' All ~
~
r ~ , ) ~I
:
~J
y\ ( ,
~~ yo\)\J\.y..!.wfilJ
£ : , • ~)
o
~I..,11 y..» J ~
~
~
4..,1IJ y'il 0.J~
~I
I*,
0
c:.H'il ~
0
~
.u ~..,1..,.JI 0'i
~~
y\
~..,1~ ~'il 01 ~J:]
~
I
0
:
••••
~
"
,~
~t!
..,..s)" t:~
YJ
y'ilJ y'il u..i
t
~
_:~••.
0
~ yo\)l1\j:.J,...a
y w'il .a. -- 1\ . CO ~....rfiW
~I
J.,.i ~ J
01..>.lLo:i...o 01.A~1~l
~
cJ:!y..» ~ J ~I J l...u\ Y. ~
c:.H'il
.:.
ti#
o
[
[
wi" uL.Q1 ~
y.~1 o~JJ ' ~..,1'i1o~J
4i
(JoII~~i ~Jill
.w'il ~
Jlj.; Y ~
(\A)
~ ~IJ y'iIJ y\J '
01 T* u...)lY ~IJ ~
0
y'iIJ ui " ~) J..,i:01 yl.".....JI0.A 0lS.
( , • : , £ .Jo:!)" ~
y'il ~ yo\Y yo\ ~'il
1..,1I.!J O~~
("\Jo'I.J:-Wl~i ~.1A3\ J,JJ:
01 ~J]
o
"'p'i
(
y'ilJ y'il ~ ~'il 01-9~:ll,
, ( r. : , · ~) " ~IJ ~~
0t....u} ~IJ~}.u
.u c:.H'iIJ' o~'il .u y'il
0
J..,9~
~y\)\JI ~ y'il ~ ~IJ.w1
0
y'il J y'il ~ ul " ~I
" ~
~'iIJ y'il USJJ o~I
~I
~ JAu:JIAll y\ ~I
o
~b
u-:'il ..>A.»0lJ
j:.~'il JI..,9IJ(.}'l~I y~\
~~I
~
rr - r, : , · ~) ~}~
(
~y:.
u-C~
J,J1.a...;
.:.
y'il ..;:S:-
o~I..,11 ~..,!'il ~ ~WI J ' ~I
~ yo\y 01 ~
(JoII~~1 ~.1A31J..S,J:U
.:.
c:.H'ilJy'il 0i ~.J~ t..s~1 0'i] (\"')J#
17. St Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral. III, Chapt. XXIII, (3,4) P395, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 18. Ibid. (4) P395. 19. Ibid. (5) P396.
~'I\
r.sAJyYI 4.A)t r.sA0:'114.A)t u~ , 0:'11~ yYIJ yY\ ~ (.St..) .l.i! ~'II(.St..) (.S~Iut ~
~i
c.s.f:J..:A ~.all
uJi-a.:!J' ~\J.wl .~
0
. [ yYI 4.A)t ~I..)~l~
0:'11~ J..J~.yYI
Jji; 0:'IIJ ~
~~I
yY\ ut ~
~ r.sAo~I)1 ~I
~lJ . ~
4...i}! I:u. ~..)~ (.S~\J ~'II u..!
~
~\J
O~J UCJ
ulJ-'-'l)1 uL..t.:'I1 ] (YO) ~I.J:
~I
Ut ~
~lJ ' .t.tly. 0:'IIJ ' .t.tly. yYIj
uc ~.t.tl
" ~I)I
, ~IJ ~ ..uIJ' .?YI ~ ..u1)1u~ .ill~. u411~t
o
(.)A
~'II~'IIJ
.t.tlJ ,.t.tl r..s!. All'I]
"i yYIJ . y...YI~ o
[
(Y')
~1)1.t.t~ ~~ 4.A)~1~J [~'II ~
(.S~I]
~
LaJi•• ~I.....J:
ut ~ W~ ~
~I
(n)
~t
~
.all ~..J .t • ~.
..uIJ ~tJ
0:'11~ J..Jt ~.u
~~...;l:-
~I
~I
.•.• 1 .A. ~ c.s..Y":t"" 4,.j~ •
.u'll "
.ill~ ~
o~I)1 ~'II
o~
1i.4 0:'IIJ.
L;:J\ ~ ~
wt.i....:J\ ~ ~J' ~'II
. ' ~~l
'
' ~~yJl
US o~I)1
yYI CJA.u~ ~
~'I4
. ..uIJ .wl.ut
"i J . .t.tl~.t.tl ) , .u'll CJA .u'll . ~'IIJ yYI ~
. [~I)I
.:.
,.t.tl
~
~Jill
~
JJ.la..J
~I.S o~J ~ (.S.l\\~I~ ..u1)1 ~ (.S..H ~I ]
(n')
~J'
o4:J1~J'
~.;rS
c.s.)~'il
~.all
(' • : , £ .J;!)" ~ yYIJ yYI ~. ut " "yYI(.St..) ~ ~l..) (.S.l\1 " ~.u~
[~I .••
J~
yYI
ut
~J'
J.".:L..J
CJ.C 4l 'a.:"
~W 4.J;! 'i u.sJJ' yYI ~ •
~~l
r..s!'~I"i
J,! ~l
wy.~
,=:-,.'
J
~I
ut ~
¥I.l\l o..)y-o:JIJ..Jt ~
~t
20. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book VII, (32) P132, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 21. Ibid. (41) P135. 22. St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunomius, Book II, (4) PI05, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V,1979. 23. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book IX, 1885, P285.
" w'i (
'0
..>#- All0.)..,..-" ~ ~I
fi) " .)~I
: ,
. ( 'A : , ~) " .J-P.. ~ ~
.).,bIj:\A'I1~J
~
w'i . .).,bI..J:IA'I1~ (.SI wi ~
~
~~]
(H)J.# i
. U~
~l
~I
wi ~
.u ~
J.S.:s
(.S I.)
0 .)~I
.0.)~1
wi ~ ~
.).,bl j:\A'I I (.S.J:!
o.)."....JIw'i
,1. ~ ~,;,i, U
11\ ~
o~~
~
01'; lAJ. ~
~I.).,bl~
~
u'Jl 0.)..,..-..rAb. ~I .
'0:'11 tJ#
(i : "~)".&I
.u J~
0.)y-1l ~
~l(.S~I"4.ic. J:!
"'-'t.A "
o~IJ
~.u
~
'fi')Allo"'!~J'
"S•.•!l.u'i
lJ-A
~~':1 ~t.c. ~
(l'I)
(JolI~J..»A1
(i:' f~)
~I
IUJ
J,,:L...J
.:.
~.,.1yJI0-:'11. ~
. ~W t..r'~. -:11 ~I [u'Jl 0"oJ ~~ \..l::a:j J (JoI
0.)..,..-~ (.S~ 0-:'11(.S~ (.Sill]
. ("f:
y'JI
~
y'Jl " J
" ~
0.)..,..-11~ 0:'11 ] (lO) .JJil~ UL...I cJ.J;J..:A ~Jl11
~ ~~ ~J'
w~
w.fi.;
lA J,.S.rA
. [ ( , • : , f ~)
~\
lJA
. ':11u ·1lA.J. u'~I. . ~ ~J ~1.\ u:.
~
0.)..,..- ~ W\5.
w1-9
.J:! lJ-A
\1\ ~ 01'; lAJ
o~~
i
~
(.S~
y'JI 4.A..,Ii wi o')Jy..;.J~ ~~
~~J
t.sA
~
.:•
.wI ~.)ol:!
JA
. ~ ~J ~ wi ~'i , " ~IJ .).,.bI..»-o'lIJui " 0.)~1
~~ '""-:UJ. ~
rJ All
.).,bl ..»-0'11 ~
~
. 0 .)."....JI~ (.Sill~
wi ~
0.J:!
y'Jl 0.)..,..-~ 0:'11 wfi
. 4+! .).,.bl..»-o'll(.S~ 0.)~1
r-j.c ~J
0.)."....J1
~Jl1I~.u;
(.S~I~ 0.)."....J1~ (.S~I~IJ
.).,bI~'11 (.S~ 0.A~IJ i
~ ~ (.S~I~..,II 0:'1\ .1:ai ~I
y'JI ~
<U.)""'-J.).,bI..J:IA'I1 ~ \leu (JolI~~i
C~
~1.9 . ('\ : , f.Jo:l)
01\
0oJ.i ~
~Jl11 J~J
~0.)~1.
~
.:•
y'JI
, ( , :' ~) tJSJI .u'i"ti.c.L...-~
24. St Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Drat. III, Chapt. XXIII, (5) P396, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 25. St. Hilary of Poi tiers: De Trinitate, Book VII, (37) P134, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 26. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book I, Chapt. VII, (50) P208-209, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979.
ul~I
~ \..,}~I.J,../~l ~
UAY
u.J1
oY:J14..:J~ CJ.) 0J.l} ~J' . ( "0 : "
. [y'il (.)oIl
~4-il1
.J-:!)
o.)~ ~.illl
~.)~ji;.
~L..ll~I
0.,,&11 4..:J~tc.J.i ~J yA
4....j~
u..,....J1
~ ~'11 0~ ~
r~ ~'11J ~
'~O
.)~ .--11 U·1' ~J t"::I(YV)
. ( '\ : , f
yA ~
y'it!o.)y.c:JI ~
•• L. ~
..H)
lA~J
~I)I u y\)U ~ ~
• A.~.II . C-~ 1- 4j.)~ .A.~.II C--~
. (" f : , fi')
u-!J
_11~. _-.~II c.s .lI\ ~_~..:..II U'-WQ ~
., ~ •.••••~\I~"';J.jLJ....JS'
.o:.tl (Jo'lo:!~ ~t.'a .•
•••
II A...Jc. •• L .lI1· A.~.It! '.l.:l..1\-\ -~...:.. II . ~ ~-~..:.. ~ ~c.s C-J ~...>-b-J T~'JAC-• A.~.II. jl._~ - ·1 ~ -:11 UJ~J.b:i.\11~ -~..:..II ~ ~ r--. _~..:..IW r..s-~u ~l.S""" ~~ ~\:j ~
~ ~.
~
'J ( '\ : " u...!).Ii1 o.)~ II
0..>A~
y'il
~r~y'il
.(" V :'\ ~) o.)~
c.s:U1 ~I~ 01-9I~
~~ ".wl
o~
~')J
~
~~J,.Ii1 II ~
~
0~1. ( ~ :' f ~)
~'11 .JA~
04 ~
.(jl~~ y'il
~J'
II
y'il LJ.et..!)Lbj ~
T~jA
0-:'11.. (r :'~)
o.)~y\
y'il .IiI I~ 0~
II
. r\.JJ1~lrJl
~'11
uLJS. ~
y'il c.sl.)~ u-i1.) c.s~1II
c.sy.~1 yLil\T1 J,SJ ' ~I y'il ~
ji ~
W:a:1
J~J
~~J ' C~I
c.s.lll~I~ 01.. y'il .JA~ ~ ~ y'il J y'il
. [ ( , • : , f ~)
y\ ~ ~
t:.H'IIJ y'il 0..AJ.S] (lA)(,$JJ.lS..w.'j1 ~..»S U"'-:fJ111 J,J-la..J
~
~ c.sJ W:a:1 y'iIJ y'il u-! c.s~ 0-:'1t!. -'...JI~ u-! c.sl~~
'JJ' y'il
un":"
1~.lo~1
0.)~1.rA
. [ ~.':"'1 '-'JI ~.1- ~L.Z r ~ ~I.) ~ Wjt!
,II
o~J y\ ~~ ~
y'il ~ lil "] ~.l!1 . ~~..JC
(l'l)
J
I ~I
~I ~j
y.'il
~'1t!
.. ~'11
N 1·1_11~_ I ~U~.
w....,;
.l! ~~
~4
.:.
II ~
J.,:L..J
(Jo'lo:!J11\
.:.
y'iIJ ". ~ . [.JA~I
27. St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunomius. Book IV, (8) P169, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V, 1979. 28. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book XI, Chapt. VIII, 1885, P509. 29. St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Horn. LXXIV, P272, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, 1979 .
, ..
.~
4431 tw.1J! Jji; y'J~ ~ u .Jt" · "u\.iSJ. l..-J'JI
~
J
II::
U\o:I
~I
W ~' ...u. '-J.J'".11' ~J ]
y ~yU
.ill u-3i.J",,~t y ~
~.rA~ 4..:..~
~I
(T'.)
_",~C::: Y_I" r--
· ( V : , f .J:!) " 0 ~I.J
~ J ~."i yU
w'J I LJ-oJ.
LA I~ J.aJJ. ( f : , ~
0,>=
~ JA ",,~I ~.,11 ~';I . .hi ~t .[~
(~~I
~.J:il U:!I.J""I (
~I~'il
~ W~ " ytlSll J~ ~ ~I
J.".as~1~o~1
~"
~';I tjC ~J.
rJ.J:i1"
: ~l(
~,
lU.J:!
JA y'J\ ~
4jf~ ~
~~.,1:-
>A CH';IUSlJ. (
(i :'
.u.~~';I
.J:!)" ~
'iJ, ~I
~
~4uojA~
) o~
'A : ,
) W~.J:!.J'JI~~
~I r~'YJ
~t
~ y'Jl ""y w} th
~.J JAJ. y'Jl 0.J~ JA ~~ , ~} ~ U'Y~I.ue. ~
. y'Jl ""I.J
_ A .. , f ~ ) " ~' ~~ '-J'JIJ
. II :: (" UI.:IJ.
o~ ..
.:.
wt " y4,t
y'Jl ~ ut u-3t0AY w...Jt. Y y'Jl u) u.it J~ ~ ••.••. ~. ~..r-.JC'
J
oJ ~ ••.
~I
rlJ.(j.l.o o~ Ul.Aj ~
~
o~f
4J~t'f
_,..
~';\ ~ o4-:J1d
~
~4S y'J\ 0Ao~1 J\.l.:!'i ~';IJ .. Y.
A : 'V
f .J:!)" o4-:JIJ~IJ
tl)"
~~J
~~J
~
~..rbll >A wi " ~
~\
. (f :' .J:!)" (j'l\.lll .J~ u.its o~\ J o~1 u.its .~ 0A)'! 0A JSl o~1 ~IJ · t(' ~ J. ~.. ..
~I.A Y_IJ \SO . .....l. i· (.)A (.)A • (
>A W,-=';Iu,uJ' utkl ~.J:i\
~t
Y.
i , Y.
JA .(jl~~ o~1 ~ ",,~I ~I oWl .b. ul" •• J ~Li11 ....r.J.J
0 : , ,
.J:!) " ~~I ~} ~ ~
~I~IJ ~I
.J:ilwi o~~1 t,sAo~ J " J.# ~} ~ ~
~IJ
'W ~t
\:i ~.. 1.11:: UI.:I~
wl! ~ 0AiJ ~ wts 0A
~tt. wi JY"'l)1 lU.J:! U'Y~I ~).!J ~ \.ii~ ~I
~ ""t , ~~~I o~~
F1
0AJ o~1 -ill ~';I ~ 0A . ~} ~ t,sAo~\ o~ J ~~I o~
. ( 'Y. , " :
0
.J:! , ) "
o~1 ~
y'J\ ~ 0:'1\
~ \.S~I~l: y'Jl t~
.JA '
, o~
(.)A ~
Js.10~1
(.)A.wfiJ 0:'1\ 0~" '}/
04=J\ 0~ , ~~~I
~..,.iJ ~~J
JS r..;1JJ~
\.Sill ~ ( ~'11) illlJ,
~
~J11\ J.Jl:!
~.J:! '}/] (n)(,joII~~1
'Y" ~'JI
~
~ \.Sill, 04:J1 '}/4J~ '}/)J
o~ 0~
•
~)\
..)).."JI .JA
0:'11]
. [ /),,),\ J (.)A
[
Wl..,\ ~
••
~I~
u:L...11.Sft.:.A
~
t:J~
~Ij ~ 04=J1 .uJ ' .l:l..\)\ ~
y'J\~ ~ 0\..)1 • ~\.»--JI
ue ~ u~J
. ..&1 (.)A.w~
" (
0:'1\
..)..r.-.JA
~J'
~\.u'lI.JA
~J'
i : A'\ jA )
I~
(n)
~.a11 J.Jl:!J
:01~~ ol~i ~~.dJI (~I)I ~I~'il)
04 0~.J:!.J'J\ ~\
rJyJl J.."iS ~I "..&\ ~u:1~ y)\ ~
.J-JA j.J1
~
~LJSll: ~\.S~I.JA ~I
.:•
~
~
.:•
~YI _f. u-C'~ JbJ\ y'Jl ...
01 ~l:'J1 ~I ~J ~
~
.u ~ .wI LAS
0A. y)1 J..)I.Jy ~W\~
~'il-I
: ~I ~.,. j~ 'Y ~I
~
~ ..?-~\ " .JAJ ' (
u...J 'Y ~I
J.-.J:! obI .wI ) , ~
\.S~\ ~I
~
~\
"f : , fi , )..&1 ~ " y.)1
J.,.i
~l
.JA ~I
u-9 J . (f : .,.~)"
~\
J
~l
01~
'}/ 1:U , ( , • : , f .J-:) " ~ ~ \~J ' " ~ y'JIJ y~1~ wI " o~\.:.o 4-4! Jli.w~ ~j. (j'lW\ u-!J y'J\ ~ .JA y'Jl 'YA lAJ. ~ ~ cWJ ~ u-t-l'll y\~\ ~L-:.. ~ ul ~).! ..&\ ~-:.L~JI ~-:.LW\..&I ~ .1".:I, (j'l~.Y' _11\ ~~. "-'" • '}/I'~ . '}/I-w. r--:: _I<-:·LA ~ '. \.S U J.~. . 0:'1l: A y'J\
u~~J!WI
31. St Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral. III, Chapl. XXIII, (1) P394, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 32. Sl. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book II, (8) P54, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979.
~"~I"
~I
. ( ,r : ,'\
j.J ~ V :
..&1 J,.ic.~ J-A
~I 0
t.?~](I"I")~I
..H , ~, : , ..H) LI.A ~I
~ J " (j'l.r:--.."ill" ~l.i ~I u-! ~
I:UJ.~~IJJ.W1
~u-t!~
';I ..&1 Jic. ul ~J.
ue-~
OJ~4431 L..lJiJ~ yo ~
o}+c J
~I
J!wI..&I~)
(j'lJul
~WI
~)t:l11u..i~'il pJ
. [ ~I J ulf:. -Uic. J..&IJ ...&1 ~.
.1i! ~..T"~.b.'
u.. I ] (1"£) UM~ ~l
., LA t..H.';II.u .JA:!
. [...:i.JY-J ~J
y'il ~.»
.u ~
y'Xlj LH'i1UJ~] (1"") ~I
~I
U~ , ~
UJ~ ~I
~
~.u
) , 0';' UJ~ '-S~I.S .
LH'iI]
(n)
';IJ~
ul '-Sl . y'il
';I y'il
J.-.; ul ~
fi')
~J
~
J~.J
';IJ ~.»J
0..,9 ~
..&1 ~J..&I
uJ..>.rS
~,)~'il
U!-! lo!ll~.LH)LH'iIJyl y'il ul \~ ~ wLJS~~
~ Jj';lJ LH)~
UM.JJ...J,Ji.:J:. ~JiJI
. [ (" f :'
~J~'»
~.
Jill J.~...J a..'i..
~
~JiJI
J~.J
~\.:i Ut..-ll . y'i\
uJ
wLJS~ ...:iLJS J~
';I y'il ul W . ~'il
w~
~'il
u-c ' AI",.;,", . [ LH'i~
o~\J
~)~I
y'il c.JA ~ ~
ul~] ~
(I"V)~1
~,)~'il
uJ..>.rS
~JiJI
J~.J
'-S I uJ.!. (j'l.lill CJ..;JIu..iJ ~'i 1u..iJ y'il u..i
. [ (j'l~1 CJ)I ~ LH'i\..;:c W\~ ~b
II ~ .,"'"', ~L.. "Y'l:ill.(~I uy.'J): .::.It:ill''.:l~ 4411 ~I.:li .n34. St Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIII, (2) P394, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, . 35. St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunomius, Book II, (4) P105, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V, 1979. 36. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book IX, 1885, P262. 37. Ibid
~I ~I
USlJ.~ I~ji)l! ulJ ~ y':JI ull~jiJ y':Jl ~l
~I
\.S~I
~'iy
o..,! (.)A ~l
U~J
~.JA
y.J Ju
~ u~ ~I
.(iA ,iV:'
~
.~
~I
u-ll ~LJI J.=~ u..9 LASo~~ .. 11'" J U~
y':J\.!. ~\Jc.
o~l.A~J
._11'J UJ~
~...J""""
{,j4..ft'
ul
'J:!)" ~
~,!\ ~~J ~.JJ\..bL
c;-tJ:U ~..;JI ~
_. _II J UJ~ . .. L. r--
. u.JA ~ai.. ~ ..~- .11'J u~
U!" ~~ ~\
I~i.! ~ \~ji
~J:!)l!.
. ( " .J-:) ~
.JJ~J
<.::US
w~'1 ~);1~II~
~I
. (i'\ -iV : f .J"l) ~4J1 ~I ~
w....J
l..,!yW~
~.JJ'i
.J"l4 \.S~I~,!I
~I
~ ._1\
... ( 0 : , , WA)
'(' f:' •J:!)" ~
'il ~
~ ~ JWI y':JI" ~\
. ~'!\J ~ ~Ji.1I ~,
~IJ ~~'1
"~~L.a..ll
t:J~~1
u'i u-:,!IJy)U ~I)I
. I]
0"J-! u--!. ~.dIi..~. c.s4 ~,!\ .I,c ~
~I
uLS"]
~.dI\
uk. (1"'1)
~I
J.-.:!
y':Jl ]
(£.)
~l
~
.:.
UM~~1 0
..,s " )
' .dI1 t-" ~I
~I•••• ~ ~l
..•.. 1 •••....•• ~tt I.$,,;-:-~'~...J
ue ~
~ ~ ll~
~
ll~
AJJjl~ l..iL.ull.$.ft.::.A ~~l
. [ ~l
~I
~
~I
J~
.:.
~\.!J
u'i , y':J\ ~l .[~~
~
o\~1 ~
~I y':Jl w~'10.JY- ~ ~,!I u'i
u~ ~~J . ( y':JI) .dI1 ~
c.s4 ~I ~,!\
y':J\ ~ ~
u-:,!Iu'i .( , '\ :
y.A
J~ ~~
J.-.11u.eJ
(r,.,)
u=J1 J\,..4C. 'ili \~J
c.s4 ~,!I ~
. [J~'il
ul ~ ' ~ ~
.l:l.IJ~I
w.:Jl....4i ~ \.S~I~I~ y':Jl JAY?, y':Jl J~l
~I
~IJ J.J-i:!J
.:•
~,!I USlJ' ~,!\
38. St Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat III, Chapt. XXIII, (6) P396, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980 . 39. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book VII, (26) P130, NPNF., 2nd. Ser.. Vol. IX, 1979. 40. Ibid., (40) Pl35.
0'l..ill1 CJ)\J
J,:! ~~. [(
0'l..ill1 CJ)\
,.
: , f ~)
(~\
~I
(.S1).wfi]
J.-:! ~I " JU LJ.
·1 ,::<1 ·.IL. ~ ...,.........;u~u~~u
"0 _1-:::.
~l
b~
.u..~ ~~
• [(
~l4!tJ.4 ~
: 0 ~)
"
J".:i:J .:.
J'-c.1 J.,.u.;
( i~ - iV :' • >-:)
ftt!. ( 'v :
c~'11
U..ou-wWI
~I
~\Ji
'1.Sl~ ~u-~ .1_ 1 ,'LAQ" 0
_•. 11
I"J9Jy'i\ Ul w" '"
~~l
.:.
L.o J.SJ ~IJ.ul
Q,;j~'1u-k ~~y'il
~~. y)U .uIJW \..Vlcll:U ~
c~
~
;.~"w.44-3\
(£~) ~~\
~l) ~~.
" ~I ~I ulJ u'il ~
~
~..;:S ~Ji3\ J,Ji;J
JlAC.\t1J.-:! ~ ~ JWI y'il " ~\
"
!j9JUI~~I
OJ
u!] (£'}($..)~~\ u! ~'14~ y'il
0t;IJ y'il
>-:)
"l...Io4l.\.AJ .1.;'; .. u:-"
u-!J. (' A:
LJ-...4 ..rSiiJ . ~I
0
>-:)
y...;-11tJ-4
o~
~I ~'11~~,
0
wlJA\t1
~J
,
:" ~,~ ai~ ~
: ~ljYf
..»i:-
J.eal£11 .l..:l..\)lw.J-Al~\
u..! Ul~
~
"OJ~~~:W~ ~"o)~
~"4f
y'i\ u..! ~'1\J ~'1\ u..! y'i\
~\ ~'11 ~# JS Ul~ t~\
y'i\ ~ ~'1I]
tJ.4 .JY:i1\J' .Jy11tJ.4 t~1
Ul ~.y
~t.:...J y'il tJ.4 ~
. [ t~l
~'11~
y'i\
~.
4J1..ASu...!u)\tl
] (H) 4:JS
~\~
c.Jo'I~~1 ~Ji3\ J,Ji; y'il
~'1\ Ul~
u! .JY:i1IJ' JWI u! ~
ul ~
(£\")
_,
y\~
.;:P J
~J~\
.:.
tJ.4 ~
~
~'11 u-! y'il U\tJ .
WS.l\J ' ~\
u:a-i ($.JJ.:A
u...!Ul( i A : , • ~)
u! t ~I
~.1iJ\
J":L",,,
.:.
y'il u...!~'1IJ
41. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book VII, 1885, P103. (0) ,"0 U"'" ' ,'\'\, J;!L., oy\l:i!l,(~I u.J"'Y): .::.J~lo~~4411~I~ .n 43. Sl. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Oral. III, Chapt. XXIII, (3) P395, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 44. Sl. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book III, (23) P69, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979.
~ul ~10Ayu..Jl
~,.:.8IJy"Jl
• (j-4
0~
•
~.
-
• ~I~J , c..H . \t\t ..>4 c..H.
~ ~~~ .<
&luJl~I
~ w'il ., ~-:IL ~II
~
. [y'il oll....a(~'11~) .y!y'il ufi ] (fO)~1 J,....;:a!1 J.a.lJ. u~W4
~
~
'
l.S'"
~I
Jyh
~
.fii11 J..,h ) . .)WI
J.J"'l)1 uJ~ <J"l:!~1 J.."i
JyWI . ( '\ , A : "
u-' 7>-".;-=JI Jyh [ . AIJ ulf!.
.,.s ) t:~
) , ~I
~I
oU.cI ~
.)yJI Jyh
~
LU -,.. L ,r
w.~ , A~f •.• "'-tl~I~...
~
JWI ~
'
, ~ 1i;i·)ll., hi .JA • 0-+1'11 ~I
uJ~
<J"l:!~\
" ~I
J~J
J~
u-aWI
I~ ~J.
. (' "\:
r ~')"
~I
~
~
• ~,Llai•• ~I
~~I
~I~I
All (.Sp\ ~
. ('\:" fi)" t:~uylI)U\ ~.6w!~11 • ~
~
( 'V , ,"\ : '>
... ~ J. l·· o..)b:iL<U!l.< 'ii""""" '"(hI • ~ ~.).
r u.o)
0"" ..))Y" ~)I
u..)}J1 ~
~'11fi) ~,)~~I
'uJ . o.l.1J (.S~I
.)'l.....:a
~ ~
~I~~
[ .u.o-J ~ ~
JSi. ~~I
-"~YI ~
L ~L •
~4
uY "
J.J-'o'l)1~~
~
CJ)I ~
~4 J~.
.
J-A~
o~1
(.S.i1\
" JJ-""Y\
~J.oJS~~4.,j!-9 ~.L
,.
lS"U.::ll.
WJ
J.Ji: I~
~,J
CJ)\
.:•
..,....y'il All .>A.»
~~
..r.J1(j'lJ~1 -u..JJ:U# t.)j: (.S.i11~I
~.
0""
4l....u! u-k. J,:.. (.S.i1\(j'l.ill\
ylIJ
LU.·)11.,1 o..)b:i4T~
(j'l.lill CJ.;JI ~
. ~I
0:l.i11 ~
•
w-J...>=S ~Jl11 LJ-A
~I. r".r~ j.
~
0-" : ~I ~ ~
~
o~)UwQ~.)A
~ ~
_r
~"~ J L...: .
UI
Iooor-
. UJII~
~
I~
U ..,...)UI
~
• ;-:'
~l
ul
.JA
:.dJL ,.4.,t'a9~)A_.'.a".dJ' ••
.:.
uJA)U\ ..)~I (.SI, uJA)U\ ~
ue
" u! ~l
HJ.c, JS ~.y!
4411 t-...IJi ~,J
OJ,jolJ.
~
~'14y'il
(.)-4 :
Ll;i~I,J
0""1.i:J! .)~
W~
u~'14.JA ~U ~.)~4
t~
~I~
(.Sill
. (r) n (..)'"• ,~~, J:!L. •• ~I:iJI.(~I'::"y\'i): ~~I •.l~ 44114....l.li ,to 46. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book XI, 1885, P549.
~
~y
~~I
,( 'i : i
fi' ) " r-¥
~
y->_.~:U(,,5~
'~l!'i)~..)
Jc.) " ~I .111 CJ.JJ .111 ~ ~I i
( YV :
~J,
J.S4 (.)-4" ~I
~ 0J~
~
U.:.J]
(tV)
~
0~
y.J J~
~.JW)'I
, ( 0
~I
~y ~~I l...ol " (j'I~1 CJ"';-u
~
~
ulJ u-9
i : i .J:!) " ~
oJ.»S c.Joll:J1l1J~
~.)~'il
.AIJ ~ (,,5~1~I~ li..)41 ~ JJ\..i:i.iwi ~
' (j'I.li.JI
~J
.:•
J)L;..
o~
[ ,~ I' ~'i ,
..u :8;'1: La.flJ
-: ~~t!''4JI ~
l.S~1 r~l
" J~YI ~~
~ J~l yYI ~ ~
c-a .u (,,5~It:.H)'\~ -ul ~ -u~ ~ ~y'iIJ
(,i~
y'il ..}-4
~t:.H)'\j,
'1I I~ 0'1 J '
u-# ~j
~~ 4,j
o~ J~
~j
01~
~4:i..J""'lli ~\
w ~)ljl
~~ JS .y! ~ (,,5 ~I ~\
~ ~ ~i ~.A ~\
~J~I
,£. ] _ \
~ ~I
~ ~ J
u)'J1 y'il
~~o~I)1
~I.J..))'I .111 u-!
t:.H)'I (,,5..H~ y..)\.c. l.i~l (,,5..H 'i .wi
,J\,...aijl ~
t:.H),IJ~
y'il u-9.w1 ,t;;.>.:J J--,1IJ J.;il~ L..a~ US1' ~
" [ , .:
u-# \.c...) ~I 0~ ~(,,5..)W\.Jy4JIJ ~l (,,5->: u-# d's. ulJ, ~ 0~)'IJ 4i:!~J
~I
~I
~i
'i J JL.-;.j'i I JU:! 'i ..)..:..1 J 1...AA...>A Y?'- 0'1 c:.H)' I
~I
~I
;:; J6,l1 y'il
~¥
: ~ yYI" yYI ~ lii ~i
~'rb~I
w..J ~
0A ~ ~i
(,,5~1.AI)I w~)ljl y.J r'~1
r&JS1(,,5~1~I
(.)-4.}.l
. ~~
ol.!J
" JLiS ~
y'iIJ
, " Jl4c. '11 ~ C,H),IJ,.111 ~ ~~J,
~I
~ ~ ~~ y'il
~
, t:.H)'1w~..;;i:-
~
~
~I
~I
JAJ, JiW\ .111 ~ w~r'~
~ ~
(,,5~1~u
Ji , L;.bWI .11\J,ic. JA ) "'1";011
'i y'iIJ.
y'il
w~
c..sA
t:.H)'1wL.JS!
0A ~I
~
"1 A.:J~ .
~~
~1
( , , - , : " ..H) ~ ~
J
wI~
~u~
.u.JI
~J'
, ( "i : A ~)
Ul ~I
Y.J
(
~
J;..~J . ( "A ~
J~
~LJI
<L:j~I.Jl.~ .J~
~..,JyJl U#-
U" - f. : , .J-4) ~J-NI ~J
~J.u ~
) ~
'0; ,=:,11
~I
' ( '\ ~)
J,..w~..,.:i ~~
o~
ul.ulhL...aJ:lj
0-A u'iYI ~J
~
"11 wl~\
~I~..,.:i
~ill
'(""
c:.;...rll...*U:!J' ( H' - A : A ~)
~IJ
~I
~>.!ULhl..JII~J
"1 "
~i~~i
.u~ .u.o4!J A.,j.JA
( ,'\
~ Lii~i ~~
: ".
~)
yl~~IJ ~I
~
AIJ
'A : , f
.(
'0 : ,
~! ~i u-i! ~\:i:l
"
~~I ul! ~
f ~)
Ul ~
~I
. ~4!J
w y\ "1 4-ilJ ' yY I (':"l ~
~I
"1
~y\l
~I
~
~~I
~~
CJ...rJY
L,)SLJI~I
_(
.Jul
~I
~~ u.!\.51: ~I u.!L.iI~I U~
0'\~ ~ ~I
-
~)
~J,.caJS~
H.~)
(r.:
u.!~I
~A
(J'l.ill\ CJ)I .uL....aj ~ o~Yl-'- d1~
~~ ~. A.,j~
r~l~~~" t"""
:lij}i." ul1o~
. ( 'V _ ~I
u-e
~
0-A ~.?-:!J ~I~I ~ ~ w..,.,J10-A ~~J
~..,allo~.
0A (J'l.illl C J)I Jl...a.J~ rA ~ J ~
~ ~~I
: i ~)
_,
. ~illJ y)U\.5~1AI)I wy\)U1
"~Lii~~
~J
A.,jA
rSS ~l
yYI ~
d1~ u.! ~\.ull ~W~ o~
~I
~
J u-1c
J
~.»1\
-.u.o4! J
A.,j..JAJ
. ~AIJ~J
u.~
.~,
.olJ.9 ,"-;~
\.5~1~\.
j
U-~
~ ~IJ
, ~~'il ~ u.PJ ul
".
(,)-A
"1 J ' ~
·'1" '-~. - ''''All ~~I
J..r.. Ai ~I
~I
~
hi,
~I
'f : , ~)" 1~.J~
(
~.l.:l..IJ ~
, ,,,•••. ·,4.11 :i....o.1S.llJ~J
li;i.j.,b u~
ul
~I
u~J
~ •.
o~
~Wl
'i..,J J
LJ CHilI ~
4...JS.lI" .Jl......-ll~1
' ~
li ~
~
'.~.olJ.9'
• U:!
(J'l
.illl
\.5~
~ - ,. "A II.l.l...JI ~<... ~I C J )L . I""'" '-~. ~.
JS~
y..,rll J.."i ~J
(,)-A "
, ( oV , oi : i ~)
.( ". : " Je. )"
" ~ ~
~ ~
~I
~ . ~
~
•,
"- <:: ,. lil "
~..,.lil 'i..,.h ~
~4 ~ ..~
~ lil
"1
\"'::'"
~
'
.u..rAi u. J j
J .) ~
~l ~
lilJ ~ '.'''';j ~~ YJ- •.t:!.J
lp.t!" JY'l)1 uJ~
.,~~.
•
J
u.J-
J~
I~J
4,j~~l
~ ~J.
~'Il
. )~~l~
~
~~l
:;~J J)G. y'il o..!~\
(,)'l.illlCJ)I ~
t¥ ~J
~
CJ)\ ~ ~ ~I)l
~I
hi _0
f?
~
Ut y'i\ 0-A~l
~
.»'-:l
o..! 0-:.;/J5. ~Wae.tu~yJl 'oc tJ ~I
~
-'WI·~7='~.,t;.J- i~1 ~ loaJi...b. I ·A("'.I - f""'"" ~:r-::'
:~l...i ~i
~.J
:;~J u-i.y u~yJI
" 1.)\.)toj'
~'I\ ~~
'
w~" [r\ ; \v ~]
ui~:J yYI ~i ~i ~i LoJ"i~l~ ~I "
~t!
y.) ~
ut ~I~IJ ~I
~t LatJ" . £.S~I ~I
CJ...rl1U-!.& ~
J ' y ...rll~ ~~
~
ut ~I~...H
~~'IIJ y'il ~.>A
~I
~
~
.(
~W. (.}'l.ull 4iSJI u-i £.St
"V : '" ..,..s')
( "" , '" : " wt) \~
.us IiA.J l~IJ
eN ' y\~\
~'I\
~l)\
..>A~I ut '-S!
l~IJ \..j~lJ' :;~IJ L...£iJ,
U~J'
~ :;~J ~J
~
l~IJ 4.l9 ~
:;~J CoH'IIy'il J u-i 1~IJ
~
u~ u~ u.l.\j;!
. o~J.&1 ~ .-u! _
1~1J co.::-- .."AII ~I-
~ ~t ~
0~
- >. ~ y.....u -'
\~
\,j
~
~
_ . ~- .)W'il. ~ ~
£.S~I j:dJI . ~\
w~ ,~l
J.~
~y'J'~~ .l:l.IJ~\
f'.) ~ ~
,~I J ..;:::. .... ~~ ,>,e'1\ ~.•
\.l.it! .'
o~
_. "'All ~~ . c-::-
,.,.s') ."
c)'i J .(' V J'
~l
I~
4S.)\.iJ u-=:Jl ~...r.J1(.}'lLs"
~t
c.sA
~--:;~ y_II
j4i
i :' •
~I)\
~
..»-=JI u-!
. 0:'IIJ y'il ~ 1~IJ LP-.i ~ ~'I\J y'il ~ ~~JJ'
~I
f& 'o~~
~4-.)~~.)
LaS~\J CJ.)J ~IJ ~"
uk £.S~\ ~
~IJ yiJ
~)~~WI
u~
..u}. :;~IJ
.u.~J.J-"'l)l u-J~ ~.illl
~.).JAL'I
~~uP:;~)1
o~.
.~~\
lH:l:;~)1 oiA.
~yJI
~IJ (i_f:f
~y'il
u~l
~\J yj.
wt)"
~~J
0AJ..aj44,jtJ~1
rJWI~~,~I~~!~I';~:J~i~~Ui"[rr; . " ~--.-..~i
~)
~I)\
~~J
\v~] W"
~iA
IV<;J"-.-.-
J~.J :~l..• i
>
~i
~.JC.)
~\
~I
-,
~.JA y'Jl W-JA'i~J,.c.JS.J. ~I.J ~Y!".J ~I.J W.JA'i~ o."ilL:~).JI
~.J:! y'J I u~ (.S..;.:..I ~l.i
( 'V, ,'\: r wi) ~.Jl::,j'l~
~..,.l! ~ u~'1~ ~I
~
~I
~.J
.(
(.).A.J. ~l.i ~
c.H'II.Jy'Ji
'",1" ' 411 ~
(.).AI:u.,
'II
~411 u~'11 ~ (jII.J~\ -u.J~
"V : r J-,c. ) ~j..,-..J~
~\
I~.J
.(O'\:'\~) .' u~).JI~.J. ~I
~I
~
~~\
y'J\ ~.J ~
o~)1 .1~.J.JA ~I
~ ~~ u=J1 o~.;.lll ~~)I O~.J UY (.S~y!" ~.J
~\
u~ 1~.J
J)l:.. y'JI.JJ1 ~ jL:..:i'l1u-9 ~tS
~
jL:..:i'l\I~ . *)1
(.S.JUSlI~\ . o~J.JJ1
~\
(.S~ LA~
J..,iS . ~).JI l.il~l
~I
~I
~l
LJ-A.J:!.J ~W\
w~
y..,.l!~ (J'l.u11C.J.;J~ '-H'II J)l:.. y'Jl (.).A~l
(J'l~\ C.J)~~..,.l! ~ ~I
, ''''1'',,JI.w'ii ~~ ~
~~~
y-A
(.Sj,jl~I
~I
~I
~.JJ\ ~
~I.J
~ J ~ )~\
UY" J.J-"'l)1 uoJ~ ~
UIlJ-A.J:!.J ~\
y.J JA.J . o~l.J
w..,)-£:!
l.i...A..J .( 0
l.S..\Jf~f
~
~~i.w~~!
~~
~~~"
~j ~y:..J" ~I .,-Jil.! . '-' ..t:l...u'il .11 0 YI ~,.. ~..r. .J o·~ ~.J.r: ~"-uY.J.
y'Jl W-JA'i.J~Y!".J ~
w-c ~I
.I~\ (J'l.J~I ~ y...)-JoJl.
~.u
Ul~'11 jl) U- J ~'11 'i} y'Ji w..>--: ~l ~.J
' A..;I~).JI
.JAy'Jl ~
W~
~I
_"\1.:.
~'1\ .hi ~I
II c .J::C•
_V
ui ~,s1~ 4.! J~ ~ -LJ.· ~
•..II ~'. -""'"'"'
I-I
~'1I.J. ~jl ~
.w~ly'J\ 'i J . y'J\ 'i} ~'11 w..>--: .l-.:o.l
Ul .JjLi1\JA O~.J '-H'IIj. (" V :' 'W-.4) "
~ -JA(.S~I *)1
.J.J) "
J (.SjLil\
(r,: IV,.:)
"~ wi ~"
: 0
~...r1J1 JA J . ~\ . ~.
~i
l.i.A.
0~
.u u1y
r-l.JJ\ " yt:l.S.l\J.."iS y'J\": . (' A :'~)
"~
~ '-/J1.J ,.,}'11~ ul~l WAY u...J1 , o.;iJ ' C~
J' ~
y'Jl ur:-~I
.u uP
~
l...s:. ( ,'\ ,
JS ~
'1 ~
A : f ~ , ) ~I
~)I
~J
~.us
J~
~J
J.,....i.ll
u-lc- Wy
~I A..:y\..,.;JI .uti- J ' All ~
~II.liY
~ ~ .0AJ= 0A
t'lL..J1
... ~J
~W\ ~t
LGil\
. (' '\ :' ~) " A..:~'ilo~I y'Ji ur:- L.li~ ~
(.)'l~I CJ~
~ ~H
JS ~
~lA....JI ~J
y'Ji ~ ~
LG~I~l
~\
CJ)I
~I
~ ~yJl
}....i:J~)~
~
~
t.:H"ilJ
LG~I(.)'l~I CJ)I LG J-JI LatJ " ~
. ("'\: ~
o~~
~IJ
'f~)"
u-! u~
JU LGil\
rSJ.uliLa~rSfi~J~
ut ~l
~I
~I) .l!J
... (0 : 0 J.J) ~I
cJy4~)!
u..!
. ('" , "" :0Jc.)
Jii:! oUt'JJ' ul~I ~J ~ ~4-.Jl.-짜" JAJ' ( 'V : , wi)
"~
ut ufit J"
'"
'?
01\
. ( 0'\ : '\ ~)
~).~.i"il
~
~ ~I u~"i4
~ ~J
~
uLS uJJ
~I
U:)! u.! J=..:
~
oUIl...s: . ("v:'
'~!!"'J
fi)
1ja
~L.W' ~iJ' ,.
"~
,.
,t-_wl ~I"
~
~~
~~.
~I
"~ ,..1 ~i ~i
"""
"
#
~I ~ •••• :alwi ~
-i~'JI ~1
-..Ii
"
-..Ii~' ,a;'w"
~i ~~
[f*,:UM]
:a..w. Jc ~ -~\<\ ~~ •• r--
~I
~I
~ r_~i< Y_I . ("""':". -<.\\ i..F~J
-<\ ~ rw,. I....lA.jt . lit r-
~1
y.J
~\S -\.il ~1
J..,i ~
~J
~l
s,'}ic u~~.J'J1 ~
i..F'l ~~
" o~~
~l UYyYI ~l ~l
("A:' £~) "~~l
.uy\ ';/ ~
Jc r
UJ-A'i .JUjJ
~ A.-4Jl ~I
.(''\:f ~') ~I
u\S IjlAJ Y J:i u.J J ' ~II~
~
J:i ~\
)SjYl ~ lAJ Y ty.GyJll~
u~l
d~ uJ
~ y\~l
All ~
~lWl U ~
~~'Jl~
~J
! y ~..,.b..>sJ\~~.J'JI ul~
I-J)\ .
U~.):J
~~'J ~\)I
J.i or
~J
~.u~li ~ ~\SJ
U1~'i"~ ~t
~l"
Y I~.u~ y)1 ~
Jc
~)l
Lt.JA~
~l
: yYI Q,si 4J ~ y"Y1d
~ ~'11 ()4 ~t
, Godhead ~
f
\;c
4.A.J~q ~J
t ~)
,A::,;
Ut ~t .J~"j
]
Dignity ~l
'
(Y)
w~w,e~ -,
J (\)~,J:U~I
J~
,Honour
~J
'-i~1y"Y1~l§ ~
~YI
.:.
~\.fill
~'11. .ul~ y"Y1~} ~ J
~
.[ (Y A: H.J:l~Y '\:' • .J:l) ~tll y"Y1..&'-! ~ ~.ul .•.
.'
.)..r-- ~
C'>- ~
~
~~I
Uc."jl . Ie"
~
I~J. IA~
~
~
~'11] (r)~1
ul~Uc."jl
.•
.)~~J..,..iJ~I4..-~o~ ~
~'11utJ . ~I
y"Y1ut ~t ~
~
~t
..,.. y"Y\()4 ~
~tll y)1 J.J ~
J:9 ~I uJ.;l:J1~.J4:ic-1 ~ ~IJ
o~~ut
y)I.)\)
l~ . ~.J:l.J';1 ~ 12345-
•
-
1:.••.1
~\"""""
ut U~J .~.
(,j4~1..AJ
(,,)-.l
w~w,e~ - r J~
.:.
y"Y1UtJ' ~'1IJ y"YllA>\u; ,.,';',::,
'ew,o.;,l ~I ~
: ~j.a..J~' ut ) W; , "~
II
J.
~I.fi ~
~.~-'I .u'i\ •
J,Jl;,J .:.
~t ~.l..:l..t "j] (f)~.J;.)'J1
[~y"Y1 [ ~t
~
Ii]
~Jii ~YI
: yYf ~ ~
y"Y1()4 J§I¥.JA
··u
C~J(J.
'-i~1~I..,11 ~} , 4J'j1~J [
~.J;.)~I
~~\t\
Jit ~'11]
(0)
~~
u,3~,J .:•
~L.Q'~! ~
.
.a.)ll' : ~~
Iy~t ~ U~.J:l.J';1d.5.
u!
..;# , y\~1 ~ ~'11 ()4 ~t
y';l
~I ~tbJl ~ LoJ~o)~\ o~ y)1 Jl§\~WJ~~\
.))\ ~ ~\..NI~
uoGyU
u.J""l\.i.i~~ ~I
\~ J)6.
()4
St Athanasius: De Synodis, (28) P466, NPNF, 2nd. SeT., Vol. IV, 1980 . St. Hilary of Poi tiers: De Synodis, (11) P6-7, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. Ibid., De Trinitate, Book I, (29) P48. St Athanasius: De Synodis, (28) P466, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book VII, (6) PI20, NPNF, 2nd. SeT., Vol. IX, 1979.
~~I ("I~\
o*, ~~ ~
LJA
0.J~
~w,
O.a~ LfL.tJ' ~'.a.i
ul ~..>.!'-i~I] ('\)J.# La0* 0.l:l.1 J ~T
yl.:iS..ll~L: ue ~
~
~
.J~
~
~~
yl.:iS..llLJA 0.l:l.1)\
~\
1i.4 ':/J ~
~
ul ~
tA ~ J~ ~~ ~~
:~~w" ~"
~
ySo ,t-o ~?" - ,
d~u~
- : ~I
~I
jb~'
~.J~I ~~
~
~ J ' y~\
"
w~ ':/ ~
w~)U w\:j~} ()4 ~4~\~"'La
~
.u ~'1\
La;!J. (JJ'i1 ~I';'-'il)
: ~U..)l1.&31 J~
~
ul......:J'Il LoIJ, ~.Jti.J\ '-i~
~u.J~(":!..rSJ\
()4
(J.J
M
~'1\
~'11
~L: tA ~'11i;J ' ~ ~'11
. [ ~'11
4J} ~
'-i~Lsj4J
~IJ
",.,.!.&\
u1] (V)u-u~l.tii
J~ .:.
u~'14u.J~
,~u.J~~IJ'
'I". .,~." J ".(.)-A ~ .".<.1" J ", ~ loA U-C.JI...J.A:!
(JA:!.1il1
~ -I
f -
." ~, u:..J-l W~
't"
,'~ ("-"
!
10 ~ ~
,,1 I "'-'
,~ II .<'11 .JUIA.I.I J .(":!~
[w~'11 ~~ ~"~
"~I" U("'';'I"t\9t~\ ~~I ~~'i\ <.,FI" Ji:! r.1 0-:'11u1 ] (")~i u-u~l.tii (JA:!.1il1 J~J .:.
~I
~ ~ "~~I
~I LJA o~
wl~1
.wi JIjJ . lJ.A)1
~
. [O.l:l.IJ~
, 'v
~I" JIj LJ.Sl J' y'i\ ~ LJA )~4
,ojl.fi.ll ~
(" ~
~
~'1IJ y~1
~1..r.1" ~
u.c. ~y:. .wI.J~
lJ.A ':/ J ' ~I
u'i . y~\
L.,
y\~
8-
lJ.A t-i\)\ LJA -ul ~I
~
yl.J-?oJ J..,....): ~~Io.)~ ."~'
7-
~
ul
443' ~I~
- '\
''\'\'1' ~L."! '"
81. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat, I (57) P339 NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. Ibid., (58) P340.
~~Ilftl ~
--,--------
u.-\:JI ~\
~ ~I w\..i:ltsll~ ~~ ~ wUJi..J\ J] ('\)u-a~4
yt.bJ ' ul...U)0A ~~I ul...U}J' ~ ~.u
~'il
u~
~'il
~Jill
.u} ~
0A~I
u.c
JJo1.!J.:.
J~ , ~\
4...i} y')[l u.c ~ Ij1-!'" yt.b u-otJ-'"l1
u-o~I
[ y')[l
: ~US A9;'h u.".jjlJ ~I
I~ ~lNI
c~
~IJ
~~I
~J . (f.:' ...,;) ".AIJ y')[\J
~ {.>liIJ y~1 ~I~J-y
ul
II
: ~'i\J y)Ll ~\ .hi! ~ ~I
~
~:
UlVt,~!.,ii y')[l ~
~
~I
,!.JL=..~
y.J
J~
y...".;J1 O.AJ~~)A
~llJjJ.;A
.AIJ y')[\J UI] (' ')~I~
y..»
(Jo'I:!JilI JJo1.!.:.
~ jJ)L! ~~\j
u.c
Aj~
[ w\..JSj\ .u)0A.u}~(j~\ ~\
~\
~I
J]
(II)
~I ~\~
o.l.:l.J JJ . .&\ ~
[ ~I ~J ~I o~
~\
. ".AIJ y')[IJ
ul"
JJo1.!J.:. Ul ~'i
~I
0.J~
~
~
~
~
'i d1\.J~'i1 ue
OJ~
443\
~\J! J~J
fY) ~\
~J w.j'\)l11~ .AIJ
w ~'l
~llJ.JJ..::A ~Jil\
.uj 0A ~M\~
~
I.A I~J . y...".;J\
[(f':' •..,;) "0~~O.J~ : ~"i\ .y')[l ~)I
~.u
~
u.".jjlJ
9-
~~I
~y')[I0A~1
I~III
~ ~"i\J y~\ ~\~J
ul ~I (f.:' ...,;) ".AIJ y,)[IJ ul" ~I . ~.ftl
to -
~IJ
.:.
~~'i\j
-[
y.J Jt! I.A~
~o.AIJ~.ft\
ul ~J
S10Basil: To the Caesareans, letter VIII, (S) P118, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VllI. 1978. S10Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book Vll, (6) P120, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,
1979. 11 ! ''',
Ibid., Book IX, (2) PISS. W 01~1, .j1fll ~(" ~~!
.t.,•..."JIy..): ~~I.~~~4J1
cr.!" .,1o-oL., ,.:.
, • (j"
,
~I~
''I '1'1' ~L."
- 'Y
~ ~"i J ~}
~
~J'
~ ~"i o~)1 ~ jJ ~
~J111 Jjl;J .:.
] (' r) O"'~JJ:AI
U:'iI.J y'J\ ~ ~~"i
\ 461. oiJ 4.A)\t1~~}
[ o~1
... J
JilJ ~l
t.J:.c. J uU:J....a
:f.~~YY'~Jii~~y, . ( u-l-ul\ ~\~"l\ y'Jl 0A Jil ~ djyuJ\ ~
) y'Jl ~
u:'il
0A "iJ,
0A Jil u:'il ~
J ~u:'il 0A
U~ U~ ~.J'JI'-ij~
y'Jl ~~ '-il ~ : u:lil.i ~4'J\ ~L..u;J
~l
~\.fil\ ~ Jl ~\
-r
~ "iJ,
J-,ll ~)
Oyil\ ~ "i ,~~ .
.(r: , ~) "UI5. t..- ~~ ~ 0.J~\ ~ y)U .u\J~
ul5. .y ~~
r1 0~J
~I
(' ~:o~) "~u:'il
~\
~l .iiJ.
~" ~I
( A:' j.J)
J
ue J:9
~I " ~~
~
y'Jl) ~I~~~":
~I~(
~\i
~
Jc. y1.£l\
"
JI.i~J-j\J
J ]('f) O"'.»-JJ:Ai ~J11\ J.".:i; .:. \¥ ~~~ ~ U~ " y'Jl (.)C J~ ~ .,s"'\\J
o~l J CH'i\ J y'Jl 0 y..!J J,A:. J oj\j
"~
c.H'i\
A \
~
[(' ~:o~) y'J\ (.)-4 ~jl
CH'i1 uL5. \~}]
·ul ~
!! ~
~
ul-.:.Ji J '-il ~ ,-'\
~
~~\
,-9o..l..:l. J ~
~-
('Or,)
.,t.1t
O"'.»-JJ:AI ~J111 J,.~..J .:.
~y'J\ 41-:! ~\ ~~~\ ~
A J,.\ !Y 0 pi~~}J . ·<··1 ~V'llJ "<"'~ u~u
_ •... All.u...J1 ·L .I...~ ·1 \.lJc. ~-:.1-0:. ~ .. c..~.. u. r-- U ..
14 15 -
~
J..-,ll ~ JJW ~ ~
IY r--t:.,..~\.S~I·L.:..,j"ilo:u,..J.. ~ ,'.\1 Y ...r~ \b..- 'I ,.J ~I..l..:l. ~ .• '-r? • J-J
u-.
. [ y'Jl 0A ~l
13 -
J.-:! ul ~
t.r~ul ~
"i
.u~)4
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt. VIII, (73) P233, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X.1979. Ibid., De Spiritu Sancto, Book II, Chapt. XII, (136) P132. Ibid., De Fide, Chapt. VIII, (70,71) P232 .
.".A.
~J o~
~~ ~
~J
u~';1
~J ..."
U~';I
u!-!II ~I
~I
y)1 J~ ~I
J~ y'il ~
~
~';IJ y'il
~ ~';I ~J
. (Yi:'\)) IIy'il
(YV:'iWA) "... ~~~t ~I/(A.fi: ~"
~I
~I
J~ 4.A1.fil1 ~ ~
~~~~UY'l
~';IJ y'il Ut~
. (Yf: °~) II4.L.) (.j~1y'il (A.fi: 'i ~';I (A.fi: 'i 04 ' y'il DJA.fi: ~ ~';I
. ~"p-'i\
~.iJ9""i1
~
~
' ~
'i U"yill upl
~
(.j~1J-jl . ~ )il ~ !.ill~Q wt II ~
uJ]
~~~~';I
~J ~~
L.~J
~~I
(")Uo'I~~l
~.jC-:!J I~W"
!~
~\
(.j~1~
~I
J-,..ac. \t ~
~\J-'"lJy~J" ~1...A....J10.A wJ Y
~t"~U~I- .. ~)(.j:W1
y4t! .li
r-\< J . (fA'i.
JJ.i:~~
CH'i1~
~Jy'il
~~\t ~
'iJ WL- ~t
~
~ ~I ~)I ~ JU J . (Y '\ : , Y.JoA) "~I J c..J---!.... ~
~I
J~.
~';I ~
u!-!~(~';\ ~ ) ~ ~ y)U
~I
Uit ~
y'il ~
~';I Ut~J
J~J
.~ ~I ~ J U~';I ~J ~ d~I" (fYJf':' f ~) "~.J-""lo~J ~I~~ o~ ~I (':' V~) "~I ~J !~"'?~ ~J ~" J~....-....u
. (o:'V~) "~I ufi~~
16 -
~,
°~)
~ (y'il) ~I u\S. J
~I o~\.1o ~J. u'iIJ" ~t
y'il ~t
,.
JUJ ~(YA:' f.H) "~~t • [ (Y • : , f ~ ~Y f:
~\
~t
U&- .:.
~ ~ ~
)",\c.r-.J ... 1 (.j~I~·l ..
(A~~.fi:(.jill~t
~';\j
y'il ~
U" .JAW\
~\t" t~ ~
J~ II~t
Jli
JSJ
(A~t
. (f:'V~)
~J Jy..,~ b.JJ.(' '\:'A)) II~IJAJ~IJ
y.J ~J y yl
~
~u\S.(.j~1 ~~I~~
y'il ~t
St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos, Drat, III Chapt XXIV (7) P397 NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980.
J:JI CJ.J~I~ ~4-~
tAlJ II ~I
~I
. (' fJH':'
o~ . > lA.JI~I~
(1V)~1
~
J,J7' .i. ~ ~
.,
J~
0-:'/\ ~
y'Jl (':"l.(j~J ue leJt.i ~I
"~~uIJ.
~~~y\
Jil ~
tAJ,
u~} .(' 0:' i.J:1) "~ y\ ~
~
...
JS '-r' ' .J I..J'JLJ . YI 011.....wl4..:l.. ~ >, ~-J ....! . c..H. J
"y'JI ,:?1.J.L...i! ~i.J (jAil oU..,,! ~ ~~~y\
CJ..;JIJ
~ ~~.JY ~~~\~
i.J:1) "rS~J~ >
~\
~\}-;I-~Iji.S1Lo]
tAJ,S.J"y)U.u.""!J. (~:' f.Jo:!) tAJSIIl>~
11\ue .u.""!J(' ':' V.Jo:!)
• [ oU y\ y)U tAJS rl~tA~~ ~ y'Jl : ~I",
~l
UY-;l
~J
II
~I
.("v:' 'WA) "oU ~
y.J
J.."A;. ~I
ul 0:'/\
~J
~U(jAJ 0:,/1Y} y'Jl
,:?~IY\J. (r':" fi) " ~.;a-JIJ ~I
. ("0:' V.J:1) "
~y.! ultAl ~yy
y\ y'Jl ~
~ y\ ,:?~I~)I
~l
~y:.~J~}
~
uM
j~
[ IJc
0.J~1
• ~.:_4~IJ
~l YJ. y'Jl YJ0:,/1 J;! ,:?~Iy\J
4.,jc
0:,/1 .l:J ~ll>.); rl.&I" y'JI ue lli-.H ~4-J ~y:.J
t:Y.,/1 ol} .•...w
t:Y.,/1
rl rJWl J .J4J1 y'Jl 4-;1" J\! ~}y'Jl U.?:!
.(j4-~ ~J.
"JLi y)U
.("i:' V .J:1) . ~.;a-Jl ~ ~
uyy
o..;!-.?-iJl"
~
Jc ('A)~l~
"~ul
(' A:'.J:1) "~
UfilJ ~ ~l
u-w;.1i11 ~J
~11.ijj..:A
~J. ~I l>~J ~
~ ~IJ ~y\)lll
~ ~\J ~'l (jA
~l
~\
u'lJ . JiIJ ~l
, t:Y.,/1u- ~l lJA
~l
~.J:1
'A , 'V 01~\ , ojlfll
4J;.,... ( " ~
rkl
-.r.1 "
~,.,..'i-r
Y ~y\)lll
~.J:1
Y .ul ~
~
~
C~ Y ~ J!"~ ..11 • ~..Y-.
(jIl~J~IlJ'l:l~1 •• >
l>~ .J ~
•• j3 J
'
..,1t..o L., yly..J Jly..) : ~e.llo.l~ ."~'
18 -
.:.
~..H 'iJ, y'JI lJA ~I'~~
• ~
!
,:?~I
J ]: J..J-¥
~.bl:UJ1 ~.;a-JI ~ U1.5. ~ ~
: ~~, ~ ~i )ij ~t:Y.'/IJy'Jl
cJ.4J - ~
~jL&l1 ~
~.;a-JI ~ y)U J~
lJA
44.1\
,'\'\"
~\.l!
-,
V
~L.A
St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book VI, (26) P107, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,1979. <II
~\~ JUJ" ~~} t-"~I
~I
~]
,-:?~I.cl\~ui J.J-"'l)\ ~.Y. .l.S)'!J. ('
~
LY t.r.·\~u~""""'!l.w .r--
"f ~..,:<-:~ y-J ·':<1 ~ ~ ~
~l
.>A ~\
. (' i:i~)
u~
"~'i~
. [ .&\ 0A ~l
JJ' ~~'1 ~ u~! ui ~ , .(jl~
.AI "J
~
o.JY- ~~
LJ.4 ~l
~I
y~\
0A ~
(j'IW\ ~
(y.)
~J1l1
(jIl.J:-WI,J..):\Ai
J--,..ac. .us.lJ'
J
y~1 ~
~L..:.:.'1~. (£:'
~~} ~'y'l" .&\ u:} J\.! ~m~} ~i '-:? ~\ ~ .cl.l~~
J.J-"'l)1 u~IJ . .wl~
~ 0A ~ (j'I\..il1ui Lc. .J~J
~i
~u
A~
Jji ~I ~\ " ~li u:'11 ~
~]
(y,)
: ~li
~ J\.! ~
" ~ Jji ~\
~I
, ~\
~~!
J":i ..,.;')
oi.J
,-:?~I~J
.(j\~
~l
.>-A ~I
~ "~
u:'1\ ~l .cll~
~\
UY J
~\
" J~ Lc.~ . (i:' £ ~)
. [~~4,1G~i
20 21-
~i
~
~\~~i
. [ "~ Jji ~\ ~I"
19 -
,,;.~
.:.
t.l.:..,J:! UA:!J1l1 J.;..i: .:•
~I ~j
. ~i ~y~\ Ui~J~.y~~I.u~~.wi
.uY .(jl~ ~.u}9
I
' .; ~
~~J . (0 i :A..,.;)" C..;.! J '-:? i..;.!~ ~ '-:?..>:! . [ ~~\
~Y:JI ~ ui " .cl}~.J\~
.w\~
u~} . (' £ J n": i '-;-LC)
"J
u1-!" ~
, ~
J]
~l
"J
.. -l:.•..l.u ~\ '.<._1 .~r--
.J.
J . ~I
\~
i:" ".cl.:i) "y..;J1 J~ ~i
, ~l ,-:?l LJ.4 J,!l u..A! u1 ~
~}~ I~} .&1~ J W .u}9 " J\.!\~
J.;..i: .:.
('~\,.\oII~,J..):\Ai UA:!J1l1
~(.j~~J'
"
o~IJ ~IJ ~\
~
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt. VIII, (71) P232-33, NPNF., 2nd. SeT., Vol. X.1979 Ibid., (72) P233. St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Epistle to the Hebrews, Horn VI, 13-16, (2) P418, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, 1978 .
. Y, , .
- :" ~
~l uJ)=J1uyJ
J ~'J ,
f"j""
0
•
•
: ~f
~
~,~,,,
T~
t.J'"'l:!
OJ~ ~
JJ ~f
y)1
W~
•
~
: W~
~lMJf ~
-,
~
. w\..JS.11 o~ ~ w\..JS.11 o~ y.aii u-=aJ] (n).J ..~I-.Hu:a......l
'i.JJ.:.A
y.;Jl d..s. ~
uti };l1 ,:?i
~ J'~ ~ 'I ~.'-- ~.U:..J. • ~ ~~ uJ~ .,~
.
~ .I
..T' ~
0"-:!Ji11 ~
~':II
. :~.'\.S
U
Ilk. ~J
t~ ~
. .J
~ ~.
'-r? Y-A
~..rb
' ~,119 .:.
u.e
-I<~··LS ':? iJ r-:: u
.[ w\..JS.11 (':A
~i ~,
~I
y)1 ro'Ji ~
~
~~.
(,r..,;) o~~~~,:?~1
,:?~I
~ ~ ~ J . ,:?JWI y';ll ~
~.."l§
y.J
b· 0; 'J ~
u-llll~
JA 0A~y:.J.~)
~I
~ t,j\.S..a ~
~J'
o~
u-:=atA .6J1 y)1 ~W:. ~
~
~\.bc.iJ . ~':II ~J
~
J
JJi ~l ~lW\
~
~
~
~I
CJ.J
wi I' _<I wl! t.T'1"~ ,,~ti ~,...J > ....d ~ .. WJ. (H:\ .J:) t.T~i~> I....ll\~i . .. .6J':I1 Y.?". ~ -t:..,..l t..Fl'11'-J';I1 ·.. ~_..... <1··~ ~ .. I'" _..•.•< Y-' . r--::-: _<.n r-u . "F' II ~ . lwl! t.T.~. U..?-.)AJ . (Y A:' f.J:) : ~f~f
roWJ ~i
0A
~'il
'-J'}[lj.,ill~ ~I . ...
~~! all> ~
US-lJ. wJA)llIJ ~IJ
4..UL..a.i'J1 \.:Ua.ubT~i ~ ~ ~.
~Yf ~ ~f
yYf
_r
y.~1 ~ y)U JI...- ~'i\ . J
,.u.&. 'J ..T'
~.•
UA
.u\~ ~ l.:..l
~ I.illl
.o~~~JAJ-UA~i
~':I ~I
22 23 -
~\
J ] (Yr).J
u:a......i
'i.ft.::A 0"-:!Ji11 J.jl; Ilk. ~J .:. ::; .."II::;' ...II'(JC.. Ll:..:i'\.S, _<. _'\I..:. ~ u ~[ .~,.
..~I-.H
St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book I, (3) P48, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. Ibid., Book IX, (51) P173
: ~ OJ~ ~I "~'il ~ li.ll ~ •
utS ~!,:?~III ~I
c.}
~ .&\ 0.J~
,.J fY.~.lIe ..J~0
tJoll
(A_ i:" c.})
"~
J# ~II~
CH'II ]
·~
J Ut..u'll 0.J~
_ I o~1 ~t. , ~-,':.'\\";; (""
(Y
i:..:i\ .&10 .J"""'o~~..,J1 t~!
~Jil
.
c.} utS ~!,:?~III]
~.&I 0J~
.u U"':!"... 1LA ~t.us.1.J ,'i~\
•
• ~
...1 •
(Y 0)
~~J.»41
t:. t.us.! '-.r-'
II~
~ ~tS ,:?~I tL.Q'j'l1
~J111 J~J
~
~
~~ ':?t ,
w:.. ~
c~~,
~\
~t~,
Jc ~.
tJollWI
~
f.)At c:fi: ~ ~
[ ~I
y'il ~
~\ l;',9 , .u'jl .wI ~ ~I " • (
. ~.,,; '1
.:\ II:::~.J.. -:Lf (f,' • of .)A)
.ula..:.~I .. c .<\-:
(jU~~u
~
~
·.<1 ~J.
~
Jil .wI ~
J]
4,.jfi
J'
0J.."...-
~I
c.} ~ c.}
~)l;..'11~
I~I .J II
~yUC~("" ·1'~.. 1
.w
.
"~'il ~l:..~
u-\.QI~J b.\ JJ I~
·'1·
'i~'--
..Ji:- J~ 0J~
ll~
w.JU ~~ 6. . ~~
II~
'fWA:\'J
•
ll~WI ~
U.tJil ~J
(jA
JJL..J .:.
~.JL.w.JAJ~
~
..Ji:- J '
: ~I
•
YJL.w '-"
Ii.\ U.A~I~~t,
~ JL- , ~~I
f~i"
0J~
OJ.jlJa 4431 ~IJi
c.} (Y'\)~I
<b.~
.:•
.& 'i~l..A U..,.-; . . <. U·1 ["~
(A_i:" c.}) c.} ~j)1 u-ill
)l;..w.J
~.
wht ~J'
[ ~t
w:.. ~
.:.
~
~
U"'"
~
c.} ~J ~JJ
'l..tJ..::.A ~J11ICA
USlJ. c.l.lJ,:?~I ~
~I ~....J"""'.lJ.c, 0
c.} \+i..,i ~).AJ.
0J~
~Ill:u.
~t
w:.. ~.
ut..u~~1
~I
£)4;;il.,H
~'il - I
J~
.& 'i~l..A. -<. ·1 UJ'"":i U
WY' wyJl ~tlbtJ~~J
~
.JAJ
J.J"'l)1 uJ ~ ~
~. t:..I.us.I
f~i ~
I.,?
,:y;.
~I
~
J'il
.JAJ
~'il - ~
u:'1\
~J
~ 'l.•.,.:JI" ~\
.u\~ ~\
.ul~~I
•
-:.tI.:. ""'..••.. J
,.J ~J~ • I.,?
~,.J.wt~· I.,?
·L...u~I.b. ,....,Q" U'L...u~\' • ~u• UC~ .,11~Jbo··~ll~b ~ ~.
J:!
\~ J
.
J!t
~I
(j4
24 - Ibid 25 - St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt. VIII, (62) P231, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X.1979 !
'A,
\V J~I,
.jl.fi11~("
~~I-r.III';'"
L.., .,...l..P-'.J JI';"):
~~1.~~ ."~'
44.11~IJi ",.,.
,J;L..A
_
n
(0 Jt:Ay) ".ulS:i
~4..u ~J
ue ~
cfJ J" J.J'"'I)IUJ.~ lW.w..oJ~ \...as.,
I~ ~.
~I
~
J
'$~I
~l
ue ~
L;J~~ , w.."JI ~I ~I c.J.a
~ '1w.."J1 .&1 ~
~J
0
uL....i)'1
'9i9'; ~
~I.illl..J'Wl ~
~\.fillJ ~4
~
~
01y tY"':!
. C': '"1..;-lC) "AIJ ~ ~.&l c.J:l1 J] ~l9~I..w1
~~J
~\'
iJ"l
Jil'U-:.~'1,I... ~..
"0 '2
I" 0-A J
U,I ~~ .' ~
I oit
~\
[A..JjW"iI~~,~' ~ • ~,
(YV)Uo".J:+-WIJ.,»41~Jl1I J.)oJ..j .:.
tsvLJI (J-4 ,1::1c..J-:I W:..JI 1::1.hi! ~ WI.J ,I....J~I' , (J-4 c..J-:I
y..u..,•.A:l.J~
~"
A..JI.~I\ ~ ~ J ,~'"e-"'"
•
~
LH~I
o~~~~,.-9tsvLJI " '-r-
.,.
W~ ~
iJ"l
~JiJ e.~IJ
~ wy\)UI ~ • A.lA
" . ~I
U.
~I
J JU ~L.u1 ~
y~\
U.
J~
~~'il~ ~ O~
~'il- [
"'J
~~I
~
O~
JS
J~ .:• .w1.u1c.J.:po.
u- t-I . ~LS J ~
lc~ U. .L..u"il ~'-t?..r-J ,,. ,.-9
J
~ ----.. - l.i I~.J .,'6.' r'!.AI~L...:.~. '"' r-
,I UJ ' ~-lb.uLu ~. r' . Y"-l
(rA)Uo".J:+-WIJ.,»41~Jl1I
"i I>~ ~ \,jltAl" ~l9 'L..u\ "i I>~ ~ ~
J
.~)
~U
~111~!J
Jil (c:.H)'I) y. u~ ~
.;. J ~\
'\ ' ("'t" , U1
: oWaJ OJJJ ~J •~
,.uJo4 '
J
~&.
~\ l.,?II (,j~W o~" W:..JI (i', '"'". ) ~ ..)-A
[ . (v:or ~I) "0l9 .~ .. r~'l:l:i , ~'I~.li.1 • ,JAJJ J.. ut..:i:i·1,'.(•. u v-: 'r ... u-Q~
u-Q.J'1\~
~I.J ~ . "Uj:JI "
t
I
0
]
~Jt4-)
~j'
~,,~,,':.i.i~,1~~. "i J ,. ~J
~WI OJ.jl..J.4L;W1~IJi
JA.u ~ ~ J . ~LA4:iIJ~~
.01
"O\j~
(r'I)
Jl~
II. U~
~~I ~.
.u I> .J.,...- "i""
JALAI~"-L,jj
.
....! A&. ...,-..rJ~. lu
~
J (j'lWI wl~'
uts.u1 ~~I ~~.ue. "i J
~
~J
~I_ J .:.
gi i"i
J;!J. (' · :A~)
(j'lWI'(J-4
"'--"il ~ ~J
••
JJ~
J ~~~"
. (r J"':Or~\)
. [(v:or ~I) 27 -
St Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt VIII, (63-64) P231, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X.1979 28 - Ibid., (61) P231. ! 'A , 'V 01~1 , ojlfll ~ ( " ~ ~1..r.1 " .;... L., ylJ'!"-' Jly..) : ~Io.l~ 44.11 ~I.li _ r"
. ,. ~"""y
~L.A
~.jlII1\ ~
wI ~
~
: ~.jll
.u~
~b:il ~~ 4.J! ~.
~
(~~I
~I) oj..p wI Jjii wI ~
J1i; ~ ~~'il ~~ ~ .,.'" 6:'i1- .A
D4 ~
.u.1i.'i 4.,? ..J
1lS; oUt c...~ _ •... II ~~ - lJ.iL.u1~ L-t.A~ -..-:_..UI ·l......:..::...l_":o~l4.....u.b. .J~W'i1 ;;.. "1\ ~...,,:... L!I .J J . ~ L.>-J ~ J~. 4.,? ~ • J ~f
rJ ~~I
. .uc. ~
..T'
ut ~'
~
~~I
~ u\S., .ul~
~
A
UA
~
~..,J.".JIAll] ("-)QJJjl~ ~I
~JAlllJA ~} ~)I
li.4.,? ~UA 1lS;J
~",
lJA .ul~ ~t
.us.lJ,
-Wlo .~~ • J -u~, l.iWI~t '\S.~ [ '-' ..JY- 4.,? . ~ '-'
¥- O.JY-
.J:
:aa;oJ'~' ~l~'..JoG 0~ ~
U\S.,:?~I ~
. ...b. ~-J ~
.ul~ ~\
..
~~J
ul uLJ ~ u~"
.J.
~I
f'L!J '
~
. y'il ~
uy\)U\y~1
c.J.e. ~
] (n)1!.J1i11
-* ~Lcw.JI~} J
~I ,:?I.("1\:' f.J:l) "~~I l.S~~~~:
y~~\
~t 1~~J'
~
~}
to!.)A ~
y.J
JA
~I
t.J"'l:!
J.J.1J 114 ~'" ul5.
uJ!~'i
.: •
~A\
- r-. 1;.••.1~ I" J.J-.: a..-i. -I l.:: ~ '-' ~
u~y'il~} ~t
~.u
rJWI ~b
~J'
oJ.,w. 44011 t-IJ!
.,~~
.~ .<::1~~ •. ~ r.~•• <:: J-' - \" 0 ~. "LA UI-:I ~::" r-
~
Jc ",I.illl ~
~l
-l4~ ~
" y'i\ All ~
. (' ':" ~)
~
yY' - r
oyj ~ ~~' ~~' ~
~
0A {"l,t,
.,~ 0~,";Q ~\..tjt I....H. - 'il' lJA ("""""""" .1;.•..t '--J'il _
. ~
. ~Lc~1
~
~ii11 J".'L...J .: •
. [.uJA'i oj
~
~I
uW~
~
~ J . ~t~
J ](1"\) ~~",..»-I
~
T~
cJ.ft:.A ~ii11 JJl; IlA ~'" .:.
~.uj.S ~
~~ rJ ~I.J:WI lJA .,~t ,:?~I~\
(' f:'.J:l)
J
u~~
u'il~ly..
u>AtJ~L~~
30 -
St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book IX, (51) P173, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 31- St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt. VIII, (64) P231, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X. 1979. ,1\ , 'v 01~1 , .J.?!I ~ ( " ~ ~I -r-I" ~ L., yl~J JI.:,.....) : .::J~I • .l~ 4l,J1A....u.1..li _ n ."
0""
, ••••" ~L.I\!
uJ:..l •• c..j ~I ~..:l • ~
I.J i.F"I~ ~-.',~.:..\~ y"La c..j ->=''1 • .J . ~I " L--0-:-..•. (j4
~
.u} y'Jl ~,;;c.. ~~.J
~"
. [(r':'
~)
"~\tl
o..:l~
J:i ~
~.ue.
-11-11 .J (""'-
... ~
4..i.A
~~u-4u4I.b=JT"p~
~~I
,
:~ '1" i.F~
ul \_(I ~ -1.:.•..1 I·r-J '-J'JI II ~ • r-~ u . '-1". ~
•• •• -~;( _I _( .11 ••~ "~~ ~~r-.Y.~.i.F~.
"
..:l~
~
(..S~I..,. e,)4o~
J1il1.Jyl~'il
~
yJI
tY:! U~ T~
CL''C'I.Jl ';;'1: " ( Y 1\ .• , f ~ ) . 1~
uy:. .. -l4'ii ~
yJI
~I.J . (
'•. r-_"••(1 i.F.~. u~.)AJ I~ Ut5.
~
r'. - ~q : 'r' ~)
. ( 'Y : 'f ~) rUl.Ac.l e,)4~l (..S~I ~I
.uL~~IL . J=~ ..'-J.l1 '.Y l""f-J.~
~~
'il.Ac.lU~
(.JJI rUl...a.J~.J ... ( H ,
~ co.J . ( Y V : , f ~) ~I
~
••• ~I
'r' : H
..,. ~
~)
r+il).-
••al.~rA..:lc.J~
~~
. ( Y i , 'i : , f -J:)
tl..J::A~.J.J
"I,i ~..I•..~I '-'..r
~
.. ~I l""f-J->='"..
'}J,' (jJ:JJt...;.l~ .~~(l •• ...11{ 6t .( ,II "'" •• ~jl C-~.JP-J ""r~.r-r: ~ ~ '
. tjQ1IJ
r' - ': 'f-J:)
rA..:lc.J.J.(
.- 1~1..:l -'I o~
~~.Y
: ~ J\ii . ~} ~~.ul 'i} ~ ~
o~
I..JiM ~WI ~ ul.SA~ ..:llyl ~1.A.u~ rA..:lc.J.J' rA1y.J ~~
~
~b
~I~ Ut5.
J.J
ulr .(1~ "" ~'j ~
"
" y\tl~!~j
ul ~ ~
~\t
USJ.J ' w-JAl.J~L
(..Sy...l~
e,)4.J. ~I
,~~~l
~
(..S~I~..:l~I.J.
~ ~
U'JI ~I"p- ~} ~
rW (..S..:l9L ~
~1.J
~WI~}
J~
.u\s.J
e,)4~\t I~ fi
(..S..:l~.J~~~I~~} •• (..S ~~~'~I " .,
, ~l
~ ~l
~1.J.ul ~
y'Jl ul ~
T..:IS.J.o .(
, I~ rUj e,)4..:l~1 ~ co~.J
~I
I.AI~.J . ~~I
y.)..:IS1~
..,. y)U I.A~.J"
~
.(r":'
y'Jl.J ul " Jt! rl..Iii~I
~.J ~I
• ~) " o~.;;l
rUj.J .. ( '\ : , f ~)
"y'Jl
(..S
•
~l U\t " rUj ~.J
'i .Jti: "~~l
r'. : , · ~) " ~I.J
~jiL
~I
U\t
~.J w..,.)U1 ~ y'Jl ~
oJ~
lfi...wl " o~
w ~\t
(..Sl.)..:li! ~i.) e,)4" rU~ y'Jl
ulS.~ " ~~I ~~ u~ ..
T~l ~
~..JY0
~"~~l o~
~. ~-J
~
~1,
~j
4.b. ~ " ~
~l
I.d.us.1.il 'i~L. _<.. c..J ·1 ~ t..r"'" c..J~
~t" ~ .•
4\:j1~
JJu=JI ~I.
..i~1 ~.JP-J'
(V,
'\ :
O~.JP
t6.. .J'~.J I . L ".ul.ue. .l.~ ~..~ • U:P
~
~l "
~.
r ~)"
0.JY- ~ ~
~ (_If~.· '.jAJ-J ""...•.• -J.~
JJ ~ ~l -I.ill 0.JY- IS" .i ~ ("'" U'lUlI~~Ty~ ~,o~
c..J·1~'.<. .. ~ ~.II~ ~.
&
~l
'i-J.u O.JY- 'i " " U'lUlI lJA J~ -Jj1J::- " " u...?J1 ~ ~~.••.• 11 ~ I~ ~IJ'"'W ~ <.14\:j J'" • .t.'i ~I.• ~...••~~ ~I .J..~. L~~l •• -J. \.jj1~L~, ~ ..
"~
~
'i-J' ~
~j o~~~1
.u ulS.~~I
ti)4~ ~I
~-J ' ~I
ulS., ~~I ~
~~~~I
~l C?".JI~-J .( 0 :
~I . y'JI ~
ul ~ ur:-oIw..l~-J~WI
'V ..J:) rlW1 ufi ~ y'JI ~
9i-
~w.U_~~1 [\:\O~
]"to'~'~iJa!i!i'tla.~,ui" [o:\O~] "~L.ai~'~iJ a.~, ui"
,
p: 'O~]" [ 0 ,,:,
" r-l..;---Sll~tJ
~JjjJjj•• ll
~'11u}9l!1l~ ~J' y)l J..,i lJA~tJ ~
~
4.Afill
"I~I ~IJ 11il;'11 4.t~I wi"
o~ ]" ~L.ai~I~iJ 4.t~I
4.Afll Lit "~I
' c:.~WI
~.
~
.u ~
_I..:. _II u..J""l...J""l \,j
UlWJ. .y)I
~
U~~.J'i1
4.Afill ~
rAfi u~~.J'ii
c:.L.J
uJ I)li!, (':'
~~.l!J.
~,wi;.u ...
y'il
~.u
01\
~ll ~L.....u"1~I '-r""
0
>=)
~
\A~I
U"l~l CJ.;J1~
~
( r-I..rSli) y'il ~.Jj
~ ~I
~41 u}9~4.Afll
CO o~IJ ~
y\~1
,.~~I JjJ..).J UJ:.-~....)~I~~
~ y'il
~I
•••
c~
c:.~'il
~ ...
.l!J
~""1S"":"' UoA u-: .1. -I..:i A"'j ~ ~ .,-:-
\,j
-f
~u '~YI
·t.....ul• ~. ,'u'jl! U
v--
ul IJ~IJ ' ~~I
y)I
. uy.)lJIJ ~IJ ~
J."i ~
wi"
ut W I)u J . (0:' 0~) " uL-i:. YI ~t J 4.A..;-SJ1 Lil"
~
4.Afl~ ~
y.J
0-4 ~
r-I:fiJi~
.
u-o~
,
A'"
A ••
(jl.11 J-A ~
~
~
u-ouL-i:.YI
CO ~IJ ~ <Jy.'j ~
JSL..J...JIt-1.;.1l4
(4.A.;.SlI)
JJ~
·~~C~j
u-oLAI UJ-Wlj
'\jl..-c.YI
ul ","
~IJ4...fill
~'o ~~~
: yYf;,r :(')~~....)'il ~
r1fill u-:lIJ~JjjJjj,1\ 4...fill
: CH'IIJy"iII.S.J-A~ ~4
~
t""tJl ~I
u~U~~
~)'f
~l~
~ ~..,rSJ1 \_£l:U:it.J~.A y"il ~
y\~1
ul ,,-----
~U:.~} ~
y\~1
~'
~
-, .:.
it;; 4 ~'11]
[lfill Ul ~J.
rl:.,slly"il .JC-~J ' ~.fiJ1 ~.JC-~
~'11]
O~J.UL...u} ~~IJ W~ J}1l! ~rl~1 ~ ~~I
.u ~ t~
~'11U}.!I~J
~}
Uilli:-
~J
Lcu\~~
J~:
I
o.>:!lUJ~1. 09;4 414.?-4 ~
;.,~
U}.!Iill~J. y"il ~ y\~1
~4
CH'IIJy"il ~
Y' y"il Ail UIJ~..,rSJ1 Y' .wI~
~
~,
UIJ' ~
l;Sl1 UJ~ ~
0A
~
CH'IIU~ I~J.
t.i Jt.......;.j 'J ~I
t.....:l ~~
~..,rSJlSa Y' J ' y"il ~
ue~.,;e. ~
ue J~
0A ~'1l! U~} , lfill
rb LA]
~~
(t)~l
~ lfill u"J...tL..." .:.
~'11 U}]
c).C ~
~
~J (y"il)
(0) ~~....)'il
~ o~IJ ~
0A ~ . [y"il
12345-
.:.
rl..r-SJI Ulbl.....J ~l;.
[t..A ~) .rl~1 y"iIJ ~.fiJ1 .u} ~
,Lcu\ ~
..u ~I d]
~4-b 0-A lrSJlJ ~ ~I
it; ;.! 4,.;j~'J ~
UlSa d
~
~L.c~} ~~J
c).C ~
[o~IJ ~ ~ ~I
~..;5J\
u.£.i 0A ~
..p- "iIJ ~.fiJ1 Lcu\ ~I
[ lfill (r)~~....)'il
'e
.'4i ..!!t, ~
(~)W:yi UJ.1...tL..." .:.
' i; ~JJ .:. ~.fiJ\J ~
St.Athanasius: De Sententia Dionysii, (10) P180 NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980,. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book X, Chapt. II, 1885, P 367. . Ibid. P381. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book IV, Chapt. XII, (158,159) P283, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. X,1979 . St. Basil: Prolegomena on John XV. 1, PXXXIX, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. VIII, 1978
.yy,.
~..;-Sll-L.i} ~
~J
J~
~
0-A 0-/'1 \ u)....! ~ ~..;.Sl\ ~
~4 ~~~ - r
~ ~ ~,~ ~Y'
yt>~' ~ ~,
u-t;ll u} ]
o..u.1J ~
J".:i: .:.
••.]il
(V) J (i)~.jJ
0-A u\.....-c. 'i I u'i J . u\.....-c. 'i I [ l.ia.A OA\ J ~ ~.
~(0:'
°J:!)
~.fill
eN .
"
l.ia.A
J..,§ ~]
~IJ ~.fil\ ul " l.>:'il
u~'il
J..,.:.'i I ~
.uJ
' l.ia.A ~
[AI)\ J..,.:.'il~J
~\
4•.~:o ~,,~
~~,
~
~~I
~Y' ~
~ji.;J .:.
.u ul ~).l
~
~
~ u~'i\J
~
:~~J~I a..;~! ~
(")~I
•
.ajill ~w
~L.Qli-'!~
y~l "-'~~
~~Y'
-,
:I~IO ~~\
~ y'1\ ~
~J:!.J'1\ ~Lc~} ul ~
l.>:'i\~~ . ~ . ~I
~I ~\
~ j ~
ul" : .u~ ~\:fi ~
u-a J!I c.;~~}
JC~
J.J'"'l)1u~ 678910 -
Jill
~I~~I
) ~IJ
l.>:'i~ J~ 4J'i : U#J ~lA! JA.I
c.;.l1\ uJJo:I J.J'"'l)1u-a~.J
~\ jJJAl.u.o ~
' (
JJ:i: .:.
~tA} JA] (~)'-""Jr'-'lJ..»'1 (.)o'Io;Ji31
iJ,.J'i ~
[ ( i: '"fi
oj~
4..itA} ~
~~'11is).l
f'I~1 ~
~~ ~l.(i:'"
') "~
Jjl
uts ill\ uSJ ~
c.;~~}
y'1l
u\..5.u} ] (,.)
fi') f'\~\
~
uJ Jo:II J~
y:.
J..A 4J'i :~l ~bU~lA!J.
'-""Jr'-'lJ..»'1
~~
u-:'il
~I
":I
(.)o'Io;Ji31 JJ-i:! .:.
u-JJo:Iu~
~y'1\
Ibid St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book IV, Chapt. XII, (161) P283, NPNF, 2nd. SeT., Vol. X,1979 St. Athanasius: De Sententia Dionysii (10) P180, NPNF. 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV 1980. St. Ambrose: De Fide. Book IV, Chapt. XII, (160) P283, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979 Ibid. (162,163) P283.
~l ... y';J\ ~J~ 0-:'11ul UJ..P ~
'
[ ~I
.ul ~ (' : , .J:!) I~ ~
~
ul.SJ " .u.e.
.&\ ~\
"
y';Jl (';-4 ~~\
~l
~~
~jSl~ • AQ
'UJ"~
~
~•
~
c;~
".
.l......:ac. \11
U
(jA
~ ~'11 ul) ~)\TI
~l ~
0-:'11ul
-J~
,~
y';Jl
~
~
...t •• U-.J:"""
<
:U"~,
~I
~~~.J
... "
~ ~~l .k y ~ J..iJ~) ~~.J
o~
~
' ~ ~\:j
J,..ac.J'~\11 ~J'
c;~~1
LJe
~
C::.J)\ LJe.J '
~Y!
~
UIJ' uL-i:. \1~ ~.J
~
~\
y)\
(':"
I"S1:.q,H ~
(' ':"
~~.J.~ .
0 _ , • '0
..J:!)
:\
~l o~\11
.>.<. ~~ I
#0
J
_ T'
~4-
..H) "~\
~l ~\..,.J
u.e
\.J"-'?'\~.J
.H) "UJ..>Alb~I u';JI"
~~I o~
t:i~.J ~
LJe ~.J
~
t~.JA
~l9. ~
~
~'\
u.-. ~
~W\1:U
I.J-l~~ ~L
~~\1\
ol:JL...:..JJ' ~ ~ja.J\
fl~~ ~ ' ~ ~ LJl.u1 ~
.(
11 -
~
~
y.)\ ~~
o:u. ~'
~J,:~,!'11 .J-'-'l ~IJ.
4:J~Y J.J"'l1
(.}'l~\
~I
\.j~
~'~I,;.oJ'
~
~o~(';-4
~.;;Ul\o~
O~.JC.J("~J' J
J. lJ.:j,·Jlh
<....iJ~\ ~.
~I ~ ul.S~l. y';Jl ~l
ul y..;J1 ~\)
t.;.....£i o~.l.a.:!
~J-JJ
oJA ~
~FI ~\ ~I
~WI ~ 0;~1.u.-b
J.....i... ••• ..r-::.
0-:'11 (';-4 Ji..,.al
~ I..i..fj~c;~l) ,[
~.ue.~ul
. wi
~ll.kiJj wi LAj.9 ~ ~jSl\
~
( ~I
:;. Ii,
'""'e-' U::..l
iiJl
~
ul JI , y';J~ ~\:i1\~t.-.II ~l ~'1\ (';-4 ~
o-Jy-oall ~l
~\
olJ.J. ~~
4...ulii ~
wi LAj.9 ~ (, • :' '.H) " ~I.J y';J\.J wi " J~ 0-:'1\ ul ~
~l
I~
.1.:.- w\1 ~lt~..
u.'1] (") 'l.J ~'il·
W"j1.S
~
u..U~
y';J\
'III,? ~, JI ~I
J!.i ~ ~\
USlJ (0:' O.J:!) UL.-c.\1\ ~.J
~
~
"t;;):l ~.J
-I...l!' ~ \:j \ ~ ~
' ~ .11.:. i ~u I
•
St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II. Book X, Chapt II, P375, 1885.
,\:"t..-.:. \'1 fU!J ~..fill u! ","
rl..fill ~! J :i J' J" II ~..fill
: ~~Wf, .fb~f, JS ~ ~I.J
~,
~\yc.\1\
) ~\.J
ul " ~\
y'll.J
y\~\
~l
_T'
~ r-~
Lc..J. ~
~~~..JA
u~~.)'ll
~ ~~
~Yf
y.) J~
w~)l\\.J jA~I.J
~'1U.(' .:'V~)"
W~0Ay)UtAJS~
y\~1
~\:ill J.,..:.ill
~ yYf ~ ~f,
~I ,:?I.(r.:,. ~) " ~\.J
.Jt! ~ ~ tA JS" J~ y)U .u~l.l.o~.J.
u! "--__
~~
W~.J'
~I
. (J}i\ , ..&\ ~
o.)y-o:a
4.AA
0A
.u\~~'11~I] (''')AH~I..HUL...\ ci~
~'11utS~
~I y'll
~~.J'
~ •
~\
u'J
tA
~I.J Y\.»
0A ~
y'll ..&1tA ~\.J Y\.»
~ ~\
[~
~JiJI
tA.ili:. ~\ "
~
,4.1l ~
~I.J
~
.~~-,~~~ (""
uL...u'lI] (H)(,)oU~~ ~.J
J,Jl: .:.
~~.
~JiJI
0
.J
JJL..-J .:.
uL...u'l\ u'J
,~\
.[~I~I
: ~I
~'1\~~ ~'1\ ~~ , (r:,
V~ ) O~.J ~\
~\ ~~
JS ~"i\J
~
.u)tl ~~
~~I.I
y'll ul Lc.S.!
-'..ill.. ~ . ~ '-'""""'" ':-'1 ~ .~. (".?-l.J . , '-'""""'" ':- 'I u~._~, 0~ lilk.1 .J.r- h..&\ ~. . I U·1-,-~" r-.J . ~':- 'I
. (".:o~')
14 -
~\
~ \~ ~\
t.Y"'l:!
44-11u~ -'" .H'lJ"'"' St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book IX, (38) P167, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979 St. Basil: Prolegomena on John XV. 1, PXI. NPNF, 2nd. Ser., Vol. VIII, 1978 .
",w ~1.A.)J'i1~I 13 -
"~~'JI o~I.J ~\
,.~till,
~4aJ1 'r'i'il t,*"l..,i ..::DL.o\:;te.~: ~I.~~
•Y Y t •
~\~ ,J~
~
4.1)'\ ~
~I
'
~)'I
IN] (' 0) (.)oU~J.J:'A1 (.)oI';.1i31Jji; .:. [ y'Jl ,:?l , ~\
~)'l
.JlS..i} ~.l::..1~)I
y'Jl ~,:?~I
"~I
~\
u~ ~ ~)'I u~'i ~
.JlS..i}
~
4.1)'\~ ,:?~\ y'Jl u~'J
~ I~ ... " J.J'"'l)1 \.h.-':10'1:lJi.l1 J~
y'Jl4.1! ~)'~ uJia:! lJA.1' ~I
y'Jl4.1 ~
I~
u'l.1 ~.1.
y..'J1
lJA JS. ~)'I.1
~)'I ~
('I'i .1'1''1':'1'-':1')
~
~
~)'l
4.1 ~
~)'I
uts u}]
~)'I ~)I
.JlS..i} ~
(Ii)
'i.)~~1
~,;;S (.)oI';.1i31Jji; .:.
.JlS..i~ .. 4.1~I.&\ .JC~
ul 4.1~
~ y'JI . [y'Jl
~\j
J.ac. ~
Ai'i " 4.1~ y'Jl J.ac..1 ~.J~ . ('
~
'\: 0
~~ ~ y'Jl ue Ji;'i ~)'I u} ] (\V)~I~ y'Jl ~
. [~.JJi.l1 ~ ~ o.J:i.U
uts ~
uL.-c.'l1 u'l#:.
r-~
"'1.1 ~.<I\~ 15 16 17 -
JS" UI.1'
r-~
.y.9I.1i/i; ul ~ o~
'i , ~~ .u6 •• ~ ~
4.1u'l
ul "
o~
.
, y'JI
-':1) " ..cl1~~)'\ ~ UL...11.S.ft:A ~
JS ~ ~
La
t ~'.' ~(,)A~U
J-.: ul ~
.J~li ~I
..
- •..• All .l1...J1 J ~ 1'" t c..-==--.. ~ ""6-'.
• ~ • ~:. ..J4l-4~"
I¥ ( y'J\ )
(.)oI';.1i31Jji; .:•
~\
.li9 ~ ( i:' -':1) "
...uc.
. t('
4.1ul ~)'I JS~
~~
u'l.1
uts ~
"6'U~ -<-:•• ~
-:.•.•1 '-'il (,Y'-"'". ~ I,..
~
r-~
~
., ::lI ~ .<1\ c...J-l-o'
~.1.J
~
I,.J "r?
:,"b'-F
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chapt, II, (28) P288, NPNF, 2nd, Ser., VoL X.1979 St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, VoL II. Book X, Chapt II, P372, 1885, St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book XI, (12) P206, NPNF, 2nd. Ser., VoL IX, 1979
ul UJ.J~ 'i ~J~ ~~
A ~41~ , .y! wlJ ~
~
.. ( J\.l:! ,-:?~I~ .J~I u} y)1 Ji:! rJ ] (''')~I ~j
~-'= rJ .J~I
I~ ~
~
~I
1;'0\;4 lA.lic ,
~I
.uc.~.ul
~
.~ (,,?" <II~
UL-c.~I yUJ ~
0A
~J ... ;;~IJ ~\
~ -'= ~
,
w'll' . OC ~I~.
ll~ ~ WI.:!
4.1A •
, 4.1A
~.q ~
~
~w ~
'j
10
~.~
..c.
.
~~
ll~
•
18 19 -
~I~'il)
WY\~J ~
~~ 1 .L~-:
U
"'$"
A.:i.;3
~,;:S U'":!J131 JjL..J .:.
. .J ~
_I•. U·1
.ulll~~
'-r?
~
~~
I....·L-c.~1 ~Wc.\S -ulc. U ~ ~ CJ)I }..2J ~
~
~~I
~~
.::11.1-I. ~ e.r~.II;; yw U'-'=' loT -
~I;; ~I
~.u
~\
~I
:;,.I'iI~I ~.
""'*'
~~
·1
U
~Y' _ t
~'11U~ U~-'=.J'l\ ~~
. .i.u~ U·L-c.~1 v,.~ J ~ ~.<Il.J .~
W ,'u'il ·1 ,-~~ .J . 1",10 • U
.a.'i'UA ~ ... 1 tJ~I . A.:i .r J ~.
te. J..r.i'~
IS"'
JS
~J~~I
: d:'Q:'Q~' a.o;:" ~ ~oJ' . (~~I
",~
'\S.J\
It:~
ul ~ 'i ~IJ'
UL-c.~I L?J J ~I~I y'll J ~.fill ~ ...)AJ ~
-'= )
~J ,-:?~I ~I~~~J ' ~.fil~ ~
Il~J.u,-:?~Iil.II~J.
. .J )1 [ \..jj6 ~ '-r? C J
•
rJ] (''1)'i,)~'il
W 'ijJ ... lfil~
Wj ~li ~I U'Ill~ ~
J I,
~
I.AS u~'1~~ IJ~
U~ ~
'"
" Jt! ~ , ~I~I 0A J..;~.J
UIJ . " u~~1
. [ ~.fil~ uL-c.~1 ~
0,'
u:".J; U'":!J131 Jji; .:.
1.1._. ·1 _.~c. 'i.uL . ~_'AI•.. U~ 'il• ~ U ~
. .ll ~
UJ.
,~,t'J'-:?~\. u~~\
~. ... UA
. --' ~l.J'l1~I
IS"'.
. w ~\LA , ~ ~.
~J
.l:i..1
St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Homily LXXVI, P279. NPNF, 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV 1978 . St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II. Book X, Chapt II, P368-69, 1885 .
• Y Y,\ •
. u.a:wl ... ., t.~~.(tl 4J'iJ . .u {:jy.oU ~~)'I
ue
J\! lAS~I
~\
<.JA ~\
4J'i , ~.fiJ4 ~
~ 0:)'1 0'iJ . ~I
• .\
y)1 ~
wJ-"'lu~ oUJ-"'lU! ~ " •••••. ~IJI~I
L.fiJ~.L....£j
W:.~~:u, (i:' f~) "
~}J r~IJ ~l
~ ~ ~I
o4:JIJ ~IJ
~
~.):JI ~ ul " ~
t.J""l:!" 0'i ~l....£\1 ~~J
~I
~~
4 JiiJii,.l\
(A:H'yc) "~'il .AJ
~
<.JA ~\J
w'-:U~.fiJ1 0'i , 4j9jg,1\~.fiJ4 ~ ~I
~~I ~I
, oUI~.u~~ ~
~
oJi\S:i.a~J.J
~ ~.fiJI ~
~J
.)A.J I~ ~J
T).~ ~ . ~I
~.;b ~ yJI I~ 0~J.
~I
y)1
T~J T~ ~J
,4J~~
~1
~} ~.J)
4JllAS . ~.J'il
~
~
r~~}
~
Jp1i
k.~ ~J
J!l~
~ts
<iJ1 yJ\ 0~1..A~
<\..Q~ ~J
~.JGj)'1
.~l~wtfill
: ULiJI t..fill r.P ~ lj;:..u ~JiJh'I t..fill .,. • Io:J
0* ~ft
~tsJ'
f':!~1 ~I
t~.JA
~.fiJI o~
I~.J
I~~ ~.JJ
, ~ta.J1~.• ~ y)1
~..
J~
~tsJ . ~I
'~!j} ~1 ~~I
~I~l
.&1~
~
•
J ~~
~
'iJ ~
~.fiJI Aj}'::"0ts
~1, ~I
~
y.J rft USJ.~
'~1"""9 ~..,9jO
"oIw.Il' .JC ~
~4...a tyl . ~~ ~
~
~)A
o~J
.J'v::J)'1
,
' .&1I.;-.l.::o.
~..r-*' ..-:11 'I..J...-,J\ ~~ ~ . L I.,? . ...! IY""" _I.:. ~J r I'~.<1\ ~Uc. J U ~ ~
I~ ~J . ~..?-J ~.fiJ1
~
~
.\J)'4 0~)'\
.I':"-:~I ~I I~W '" u·1 w ~.
We.'~
r~1 ~)l . ~
(jC
~.&I ~
~1
~I
r~.<11' (jC
I~I..A ~.JCl
'i ~I..?- ~IJ
(i_f:oJ:al)
0l\~~} lfill
"'I.;b~
~
.•11~~I ~
0'ili .
. (,)'lJ.ill~
~'i
~IJ
01 ~I
• ~
.
~~.J ~
4JI.J~
~)J
~
13
L
= "3
~
,J
")
J
--s ~ -<\...
-
"3
~
")
,J
,t. 50
j 'J
] '")
•
tJ"
~
_
-
.,
<:'}
:'I
.
"
'!l,
~
~
-I\...'
,J.
VJ,
-
,
] ':
,
~
..•
.J j
•
.'.
~
~
1
"l'~'
~.<>J
;
'\
'OJ,
.~
~
.
-
,-
>;-~
~
"l ,
~
~
..;.J'
-
1·
.:!J
J
~'?J"~
,J
~
0.:-
;J
~
C'
.~
I}j
•
7J
ld
.,
'S,'
j
"
-
'}
-
J -,
<:'}
~
0
-
'A
J
J'J
~
.J' ~'.1
"
3...
-
-
,:3
-
l,
'.::J
.,..
J)
,.
J ~.~ J' -'") ,..-... .:).'
'\
J
J
,,'
-:J'~'
''"
I\...
J
~
>-
~.
~
~
~
'\:,\
~
j~ =
~
j,
~
"J)
~~;
~
J.
~
'0
...:
>
0 tZl
•..
ci
I 0 N
01)0\
"'f<'l ='00 <:='-.....• c15>
'a
c
t: 0
.s0
0
'"0
Q.
Q)
tZl '+-< 0
...
0 .....
oJ::
<:.s •... Eo-<
~
•..u
~ ><: ...:I
~ ~
'"
i~ ~ ~ ~-
,
,
1 1 ~"
:
.'
,J ~
-
~
~
J
... ~ "]- .,~~ ,
'J
~
~J.~ ,J -
'\
1 -"...~' - 't .· j i·3J ,~, ~ 1;.:).\ .~
J' ~ .~ .:J >- . ~ ~ :J'
-?';" _ .." :'J ~
-
J'
.; 4, .;,;; '3; 'j j {;J,;a, J 1- · ~ J 1· J, ~ J.J ~ .~ j \~ J ~ .~ 1: .? ]:'1 j j ~,1' 1~ -:J ~ .~ ? l' :..,~ ' ,J " ,~, ~ ~ 1 :3' ,~, ~ ]:'~ ,VI, 1; J -;lJ~ 'j -! J' Y1- - . . ,J ':: ~ .' ~ ~:' ~ ~ _ '. - ~ . 1 1· : ~ -? .;- ,J. ~?: ~;},J VI, 1, 1 .'1 "3, }: J u"", • J "'" 3' '- '} ~ ,J -'" ;3. J; .'1 1 j ~ 1; " ., ~ ~ ~..:J j , · ,1'.,-! ,') J - ' ~ . !" :-' J. ;"~ . ].~ j. ., ..", :I;,~ .'1 ~ = .~. "~ ~ ?J, ,j' :3, .. '. ']..:, ~ -! 1:;. 1 ~.~ 1 ~~' ~., :J']- '\- ~
- J
"l
J:
...J' "'
<' J]
:'
~
'.
-
~~1~ ,J ~,.,
-='i
.~,~
:'J,
;"I.
.
~ -= 1· e.- ~ .:)'
. ,J
.., i ~ '.'t~ ~.~~'1· 1 "..,~.' ~ -!. .~
•
•
<
~ ~
•• Q
Jfr
,'u:ia..ub' ~. ue ~,.J~. '-r ~
. ~\ ] c.Y..
(Y')
Ltil
(.jIl~
J1l1 J~a'i. ••• •
~
. r~1 ~:u~~J
'
~
O~) "rl.fill ~IJ ~}iJii.,,1\ ~.fil\ wi" y)\ J~ La~ J
~ ~ (';'
u:.=..J'i1 yly
wi ~
0A uj§~
~ ~ y':;\ 4..JS
~J J: ~)I
[ ~WJ ~~ ~~'IJ
wi "
~.<I\ ~
~\
I~J. ~I
0A ul.-c.'i I ul
J.J!~c.r.]
u)\ .
~
..
(n)~1
(.jIl~
Ltil
~J
J1l1 J" ••• .JA:J.
~
y)1 ~ wi ~~.wJ.! (0;' O~) " ul.-c.'il
~ J (" " ;" " jA n ";" yc.) " ~ ~l ~~ JP.I " Jj
4J ~I w~4IuJ.! I~ ' ~J ' ~.fill .JAY?u)1 .[\.lI J,.-ls .lul.:J\ . 11\\.lIJ .(' i·. , ~J,\4' (..)A 1i..tJ wt! ••
~ o~\J ~
149 ~ T~
u'J ]
.J'u.- t.JS.l\
(Yr)~1~
~I
~. ~.
. l.
(..)A ~
.wt~I
.u
(..)A
b J...r.i li...J
.J4ic~ ~ ~I
, (' O;ifi') J!W ~~
.fA ~.
..T'
" ~I
0A.w'J .
~I
J~ ~
tw.lJiJ.Ji:! .:.
.wt!, (
0,'.
0
~
)
~ ~L.4c.1 wJ J~ L.J:i.o . ~~I rS~4t uluyJa:j ~t
J . (" V;, " fi') " T.~I.)I /)jL.4c.tJ ~I
4JiiJii." 1\ ~.fil\ wt "
•
~ ~
4431
OJ~
t wi ~. . . ~ L.4c.
~L.4c.t ~
. [ ~I
~
~
(H)~I
~
c.!..JJ..::A ~J1l1 J.Ji:!J .:•
. [ ~.fill ~ ul.-c.'its ~W)'l ~ " ul.-c.'il fUlJ ~.fill wt" .uj§ ~]
~
(,)"II.)..JA
~IJ'
~I
La.we.]
(YO)~I
OJ~
0A ~
~ ~
~
fUt Lat J"
~
4431
~ (';'
" . ~\
0~
~
~\
tw.lJi JjL..J .:.
) "
rl.fill ~IJ
21 22 23 -
St. Athanasius: De Sententia Dionysii, (1O)P180, NPNF, 2nd. Ser, Vol. IV, 1980. Ibid St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, , Book IV, (55)P175. NPNF, 2nd. Ser, Vol. IX, 1979. -.r.IJ ~JiJ"i,1\~fill wi" , ~~)'I ~I ~ ~.J,l}il ~ ,::.".;-:..\-0 : ~Ci.ll.~~ 44-11 ••..•.•I~ - Yf ",
0
(j"';L., oy\U11''',"Ifill ~L....l1t!:?' yo.\l
_ Y0
" ~ y'JIJ y'Jl ~ ~\ " (i.:' .~) " ~\J y'JIJ IJ\" J~ ~I . lA.JAC
~I
(" f:'
fi') ~
0
u~
~
~ lfi.1\ ~ y'J\ . ('
'-:1~1~ ~~I
~.)J ~
r~1 ~~I
y)U~~1
U~ , " rl:fill " y'JIJ ' " ~.fi1~ " ~
y'Jl A.c.)j '-:1~1 ~\ , ~~I ~
~I .1('A
~
u=
~ ,.i-II
.~y
~I
~
c.rJ
. U".illlCJ)I ~
)1
.. =:IL
~.
" y'Jl
~"'?Jrl U} ~}
~
~I
IJ::,~
~I
~
~i:JI'"e":' •• ~\.WI ~ J
I.-:.IJ::,
~
~.fi11 U".YY
~
1'.<11w'Jl ~ r../""'. ~
~~J t.u..i JSJ'~J">
~Jb
~I.J:I '-:1~1 y. .u~ ~~ rl:fill t.r1; y'JI ] (n)cJo'l~~\ .u..JS~I.J:I '-:1~IJ' ~\
"
Ul.-c.~\J. U".ill\ CJ)\ ~ ~~
cJ:'1~y'Jl LJA~} .)~
w ~\
~~ ~J
~ ~.fi1\j . 4-il.-c.4 ~J
A.c4 ~
'-:1\, ~yJ\
~\J
F ~ ~~l
. [ " y'J\ .& ~\
'-:1~1 ~ rl~\
'J' .:H~)
~Jill
J.Ji: .:.
uyoaIJ'-:1\, ~.fi11 t..>j ~\
U\ ~\ .)~
'J[ "
..u.,iS ufi.W1 ~}
~~
. [(f f:i~) " rl~1 " y'JI ~I
~I
IJ::,~ ] (YV) ci.)~~t
JSJ CJ)I y1J ~t:lj}o..,! J-\J
u~'1~ u.JC'~~~I
~ J\ ~J
.)~ ~ ' rlF
~I
~I
U\ ~
J.Ji: .:. ~
y'Jl IJ'J[ ~ . \.1j~ ~ ulS...r.JI
"[~I 26 27 -
u-J....>P ~Jill
~ .~ ~t..r.)
u.Jj
S10Athanasius: De Sententia Dionysii, (10) P180, NPNF, 2nd. Ser, Vol. IV, 1980 S10Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gosp.el According to S10John, Vol.lI, book ,X,Chap1o II, P369, 1885 .
"U~~I p.iIJ~flll.il "," /"Ifll ~lJ ~Jjj}i.,,\1 ~fl\ l.il ,,----
C""\:jl\ ~\
: ~IjsJI.". ~'il • ~ ~
u'i . f'I~I t.r~
~'1IJ y"i\
~~)\j
('
~I
~'11
V:o~) " J,..u:.1 wlJ u"il ~
. y"il ue ~
~ F~
~'11 ~
[
(j'l
. (j'l.illl CJ)I ~
. U~J
~4.J
<:~
!!!AII' u.~
"
I
...'::1 ~
~I
~ ~~.•... 11 L~ ~
~
uti.=..,·U::J~ ~'w • \.:... .l.l.l'V c:;--: ~. I..~
~
~I
,U
y~ •
uti.=..~ ~.~. ~I-\.J ~
J..,§~J.
.<1\ I.,? ...J U'L.-c.ts I..iJ .~ .wI., f' 1".<'<' w"il ~1_ JS.~,....I". . ~ ~. ~4ii1 u"i\ ~I"
~
' y)I
~
CJ.J .JA~ ~I
~
~t! ~I
~
c.j~\ ~I
y.J ~
c.j.;::'-I~w
uL.-c.ts \..jJJ\ij! . (f:' " y)1
J..,iS~~
J
w.JA)u1~~ JS ~
...>:P-• ~\
,I ~
U
'i ~I ~ f' 1".<1\ ~ r.r lJ~
-\.J'
yo-
~IJ.
0 ~
~
~
' f'Ift
c.j~I ~'11 , utS '-- ~~
y"i\ ] (Y")~,)~'il ~
rl I> ~J
Q ~ (".,
)
"
~
~
J~
28 29 -
Ibid P365. Ibid. P381.
0
:\
c.j~1 t.rJ.J
~.J:S Uo":!J131 J~ JS c.j~1~~
. f' l.lll I....~ . ~ ~W~IIo. Ie'~ w"'1 II' .. ~ ll.l! 1".<1\ ~I J ~ ~ I~ u=. . 1.1 (,,? '"t""" ~J ~ f' ~
(.)A
.~)
UooJ.CJ)I ~
o~ ~} t¥
utS ~ ~~
.J
(' '-~:" fi)
. ('\f:'\~) c.jl '~~J ~I
.:.
w,ljL..u~ -;11::·· l'il ~.
_I~. ,I 1.<'111(""""':: U f' ~ ~
JS (j'l1.J.JAc.j~I .y! UJ)l-
J,..u:.
Uoof'IJ.ll1
~
.JA J
~
J.J
A ~~<I}ii; A ~4 ~ JS"
" Ji-SI ~
JY'"'" .~<.~~
~
~'1~ y"il
.illl CJ )1 I.,? ,.J ~. . 'il ~I
,'Ll'il U. 't! ~..;:-..•.. <. -F-'......:u'-r?,.,:jh! ~.<I\ 'L.-c.1 ~ U
.wi.!" U"'".. 1~
y.J J..,iS~IJ J,..u:.
~.J:S Uo":!J131 J~
(YA)~,)~'ii
I.r..
4.J! ~
~I " ~I
J,..u:.~ ~ 'i J ' ~'11 UJ~ y"il ~
JS ul UooY ~]
~LWI ~\:hj wI c.j.J: y"ilJ
~
u}!~f'1p.11y"il t.r~ L&!
. Ie'
~
"O~J
.:.
, (f:' O~)
liJ9iJ ':$jjl ~I
~
"[ (1"·)UMJi;hllJ;.JI U'l:!Ji31 J,Ji;
(f:' O~) [~fll ~I
~':$jjl
II ~
~Jrlfll
~ y'il
~
~.u
~
~J'
~ ~l J ' ~w
1~
ue J
~'11 0fi
~4ii10'i1 ~l
~~
y'il
'-J'i I ..& ':$Y-J . ~ tl....£.iL . 4...lLW\ ~ J
, r1fll t.rl; ~\
~I
~w (jAJ .lfiJ1 t.rl; ~
0'1 . ~'11 ~IJo:l
~ ~l
II
.:.
y)1 J~ I.A~]
0L.-c.'J1~~y:.~~
(jA , ~'11 01 ~
~
I.AJS (jA
JS d1.\jjJ.J.uJIJo.J.ill1 ~J'
1i.1-u'J0L.-c.'J1~J
w~~\J
t.r~~I
~fll
~~IJ
~'11 0l-!':$~I
·w~41
~
f'
~I ~
0 ~)
II
rtF' ~i,
4tij.:l~'
NO
a.o;::Jlui
..&1~I ~ , .u.J""'lW ~ J,.otsJ.u~'1 ~ J,.otslltJ} ~l
't...-:... ~. I .- ~ o~1y~. -'I ~I
01\ .
f' : __
"0 ~!) a JWII!-.I.III.....
: ~~ : (':'
,
II
~I .
. ¥L..u'lIJ~'11
~ ue
~'11 J..,i ~l
~
d1.\~ ~).!J . (':'
(jA ~ tj:J~'1 ~I ~ ) "..&1~I
_,
~l
~W'1I.AJ· ~.u, . LJA o~1J~.
..&1 ~ -u'J , y'il w~'1J y.Y?-J~
I ~ U-\
~I
~I
0tsJ
II
y\:jS,\1 J.;s
(f.:' .~) ~IJy'iIJwlll II
. rl~1 y'iIJ ' ~fl4
'r=Y ~.illl CJ)I II
II
~I.J~I (jA (lfiJ1) y'il
~\.J1Jl~I
..&1 ~} t.rl; ~
30 -
tj:J.J""'lW ~ ~
~I
~I~
~)..,.JIU'lJ.illl ~I
.ill , 1~ o~
.J~
':$jjl ~I
~'11 0fi1J ~I
~
~
J..,i d1.\~ ~).!J . U'l.illl CJ)I ~ d1.\:ili .illl1:i ~I
o..,iJ ~
~
4.Afll
~4 U'l.illl
St. Augustin: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Tractate LXXX, (2) P344. NPNF, 1st. Ser. Vol.Vn, 1983
\.c~ ..li9 ~ ("':0.J:l')
~
o.ll.:l.. .< w)1 1~y:. •. ~. ~ ~. ~
~ f'r·<I\ ~ ~Lic. ~ ~
t.Jj
.J
. o.llWI ~J)I
J
~I
4
c.j t,
~I~ ~
~
.u u~
f~
y'll
o~1
~
ut
¥~j
"
.~.<I\ ~
~I ~
-u:.A ~ r-:WI
•
~ts
~
I u.1~ (.,?"'. -
~~~t
A.:i1..JS ~I~ ~
c.j~1~I
~yJI4;9ij!~Lic. ~,
~I ~
c.jt , o~
~I..;iitu'll ~t"
~ I...i.lS.! ~ • \,~ 1('
••.•
y'll
~
~\t
~
~ ~ rll~jJ.
~
~ ~J.J
~I
ue
JS 0A y'll ~
~~y'll f'1:fil1~~
y.J J~
. JS" f'~ r·<I\
~ 11t.. (":' 0.J:l)
~~)U~.)
~f'I:fil1
~I
uts..r.JIJ
·L.-c.\tLJ~ll,J1 U ....J
~tsA'il o1t.0A ~
~~t
~
c.j~1y'll ~ f'1:filIJ
. J\,AS11 ~l tAA J.,..:u\ ~ ~~I
o~
AII .lJ.J.J1 c...--::-~
-lil..AiljJ ' ~I
ut o~1
4Jc
~I
J~.
t"fi~l.F~",,--~ > ~L':/: ..J.
~4
~I
.&.
..T'"
~
1.-:.~~-:,~ ~ ...."
c.jt , ~.fi~..;;
A ~tJ
uL.-c.\tIJ . jiSt
~ ~.·<lLJ
c.jt , uL.-c.)U ~J)I
u4t-1IJ 1..;l1-.l1~'i1~I~
•..• AII.lJ.J.J1 J.,i, ~~ c..- --::--.. ..J'7,
JS. ~I
U)Jwt::iJ~'il
." t)" ~.~y:... . :i..ih tJ..)'-'l ('" ..J
",>·<1 > ~LJ4.Ji:u > ~LtA JSJ ...r- ~l.F~ ~ ~~l.F~ 0Aj.4
l.NJ
~ ~l~ ~
~ y)1 4Jc
~)
o4:J1 1.J:!=I'o:! ~ , ~yJl
,'lC.
t-"'"":!
~I
UC .u T' ~
o1t.. ~..,9..>"~.fi
)1 ~.<I\ ~
. uL.-c.)U ~J)I w'll .1• ~....,-
,,-II ~. ~
""'e-"-'
~y:. wlJ" .
~!
Jill
\. I... ~. JAJ.J , W\tl ~J~<I , ~":.-II .u,:/LJ-LANI .. U ~. e.r-
~fll
~.JY'l~.fi
--.11~. ~ '-r'.•II ~~ r-
.u,:/I ~
'-r'~.IIr-:.illl
'
rlJ ' :iJ'i;9' ~.fi ~ ~
~I
11t.~J.
utsuj ~t ~IJ
~'il uJ.! ~I
u-a~.AIJ~
~ ~I
;;Jlili. ():'O~)"
~~~~ts~yJI
~
. 0t/~ \-:'}~\ y}J A
~~ ~ .. ~ uij :.J .."
/
: ( 0: '0 ~ ) "~ y\~1
f,J.W
~ .AI)\ Jj'il ~\
~ y'il
~ij a.oFf ui" _ r
~JJf w~Yf
wi
~)I
Wjy),Q]
.&1~I .JA~\
~I.J1JI ~Y' u-aJ (.)'l~1CJ)I u-autA)1
~J,a~ ~
~ ~~" JY'l)I uJ~ ~
J..,i; I~ ~J.
~
J..,i;J. (' f:"yc.)"
~~
~
~I
J} ~~
f~
.JA~~\
" ~y:...} ~H
~1
w.JA)\j\J ~IJ
~~IJ ~I
uts
y:.~ ~I
'--l)I ~ . ~ ;;.AIJ... ~
~I.! .uy:...}rAy:.~ U1~
~ ~"iJ~1~.J~
ul ~
, UL....:.i:.. ~I ~ J ~.fil~ ~
.u..b.)\jw...u1.L....:.i:..1 ,·,.,.ii ~ .. U ~..
.
~I
u-a~ts tY'lw ~I /l~J
. (' V:"yc.) " ~~ J$ ~ .uy:...1 ~ A iiJij.,.
Y ~j,"",? ~Y
~
u-a" ~I
~\
\.1 w~~1. U ·1J /l~ . ~
"i " ~~ ~
~.uJ""lll1~J
. (" . L....-c. ~I ~L.:..;jts -L..J • • '- .11~ ·1 /l~ ,. uYA~ .. U
U
~~41Ul u..,.Ja:i~I /lj~IJ~1
.
" JJ""l)1 uJ~ ~
~~I
tAIJ,,'~1
.1"'\~ '--l)I ~ L,..I J.9J
~.
J..,i; I~ ~J,
J..,i;J(,o:'fi')"
~.fil\
~I (" V: , "
~
~
, ~I
'$1 ,
~I
~
~~I
4,,;,).,,-..,J1 ~ ~
•••• A-;\\ ~ •• c--
\.lI"<'U.,,-.;J,(A_)·' ' J.J ) WWI
u4~
' 4,,;~~1 ;;lpJl ~ 4,,;~~\;;lpJl
\.¥
0:) ~)
~~I
~
fi') " G.)I
u~yJIJ
A..a...u1JI ~.l:U ...
;;.lJ~\ .. .
.JAy.JI I~ , ~).~j)'1 '$~
UJ~
~~
CJ)IJ ~WI u-a;;~"i)1 '$1 4,,;,)~1
;;lpJ~ ~
~J
,(
~ ~
:"":-lC)
<\...Q')J y)1 ~
~
-;\\ ;;.lJ~\.
I.F"'..
~ 4..;S..,.LJI ;;~WI A.SA
u-aJJlrJ~ . ~I
~ w.JtJ1
~ 0.Jt.....:-.l1 L.JY...)'-'l L.JlLc.SJ . L.J~ 'J I ~} ~.fill J..,al (.)0 ~I
~I
~.Jt.:..9'i1 ...)'-'l ~ I~ I~ ~J . .J . ~~I
. r-¥ o~
~I ..
~
~
js4 (.)0 .~'JI ~
~I
, ~l
f~
. .Jo ~ ~
-l4~
' tt+iJ 0) ~I~.>'!J' ~u ~
~ ~.. ~~l
A ~4.y!
~
_''''AII ~. .J wUillt~ c..--:::-. (,)lIljJ"
l)Sb ~ L.J}" ~I
ulJ A..;~lo~ -ill ~~ Y~J
(0\0£,0r':i.J:!)
(0:' O~) "..>/JS
"
~J
I~Y:;UJ L.J~'i1 ~I ~
~~I ~ ~l
Y.J ~}!J.
~J
0.Jt..-a.l1
c;~
".y! ulJ ~ '''1/;) ~~ ulJ ~ '''I/i) c;~1 "
Y.J J~ JS4 (.)0
Y~J
c;~
.u~ w.JtJI
I~ ~l
~.. .Jt.:..9'J1 ,a. \.WI -l4~ ~J . .J ~ - II c..--:::-- ,..'AII~ . ~. .J ~I ~ ..~I ~ , ...)'-'l ~. .J ..r t . 1"'\ .:. . t ~
~
-- .
\oSl , ~~
It:'
'":f"~
~
1 4..iJ••J""'. L
~
••
• .JJ
'J 4,j'J
~ \oS~1 ~I~ ~
~
•
. ~ UJ
~.,..
~La , ~~
(..p..l
~J
. \..i..l! ..
WjLa ~
(.)0
.a.
.T'
~
o4:JI ~
. ~IJ~ly)l~ ...}'lJ~
I~
\.ll U~J .. <.
,Wl.....::a YtAc.l ..)A-lJ~" U~ tili..~ w~-.':11I~ J ~b:i'JI • I~ ~'J"
L.JlL.JJ.J~'J ~J~
o."ill ~~J
0.J~ .
~I
~"
~I.i y)\
U~) .ill ~~J . jits:i.JI CJ)I
~ Lal , ~~
\.i1S\..i:wW..J ,\.i1S liJ~..
wl.JAl ill'J (0:' O~) ",~
.a. c..--:::-_ .... II .u..JI .. J . ("
.T'
A
'\ .. £.
~l)"O~
(,)'l
~
.':<.
o~'~ o~J"
~.a.aJyjl;''1 ""~'••••i ~tiJll!f~i~.a.,i'
~Ji ~;a.I'~,
[f: 1V~]"
~~~~\
~'~)I, .u'il ~i ~..,9.JA:l ut ~~~,
~I ~ )t!
~~.)~I .fiill fi~J
uti'
~i , ~I
. "hIJy.)~l
o~1
~
J::..~~
~
J! ~~I
-:1' ~~1.S.l1:: .1':11~ "'"&"
I.S'""".
AJI (.0.::-_ .. " II ~I ~ A
~
".uL)
~J
•
~J('I
o~
,.&1
JA
.•. r..s. j tliLuI . _:\I •.• ~
~
tY"":!J ~hJ
~I .u'il w.il" o)-F . .ulJA 'iJ, ~ .ulJA
J(f:'\.:.u) '\ja
wi wi" ("'~ :",,,.:.u)
'\ja
LS~t!" (' '\:'\ o~t)
'ii'
ui UY"":!~I ~~';;\ ~)
~'h ~
~I
LS~I~\
("~:'''j4)
.uH~.k~.)~I ~~.k
. " ... ~I
~
'-;oJ';;1 UtsJ' "~hJ
. '\r.cl.ul
)S-il
o~J"
y)1 ~1J"'l1 y~l"
A '-;oJ.) J..,! ~~
u~~.)~\
~~')J~(jAJ'
. ( '" :' V ~)
.u'il JAohJ
~J
1-.llShU J c.s~ •. . j
·.('1 ~J
L';; I ~t J!J
J"'l r..s- ~ •
. ~, .u'il
~J
, ~. . 'il
W·1i. ..r 'i
.•...11 1.~ - ~~.
. ~ (jA
\
~I .u)'\JA
: ~~~J~I 4Jyf ~
: ~f -cl..;A!lS~t.9 " ~
~
J~ ~~} 0'1 ~I
~ ~
oiA>, yYf
~~ W~~
u1 ~~YI
.AIJ 4.l}c:.F- 'i} ~
u1 ~
~
o~1 t..sA O~J " 4.l~ ~i/I , V .J:!) "
4.li/1..::.ul " 4.l~] (l)~.J-i...J~1
4J}!" -cl.AJ~I
_,
.u'i\ y. O.AJyYI ] (I)6Jl-H .:.
. [ (':
~~}
~WlI :~Ji
. (' i:ioJil ) "J:JI 4.lH -cl..;A!~.JYI
y)IJ
4.li/1..::.ul -cl..,9yt;!
-cl.AJ~I
~.,aa ~I
uY . AJ9}i ••.I1~)YI
'1 o.J4aJIo~
J.Ji:!J .:• t!IJ 0'"
. [~.) : -dJf ~
~n (r)~I~1 ~I~
~)l
u1J
. (f: i~)
~l
W'?Yf
w~ W~~
UL.w1r.s.ft:A ~J131 J.Ji:!
~'i~ c:.F- ~I~
0'" ~i/\ uLr.~,.ki9 y'il ~)l ".AI J y.J 4l} y)\
t..sA Lr. : 4.l~ lS~1
~
~yali.1\
~I
~
c~~)a
j'ollp.:! ~}"
O~.J ~
~
I~ ~J
~)JJ
~i/\ u\S) 4JY.. ~.&I Y. ~i/\
d u)~
~,~: n~) ".L..,.".\ J
~.J
4l}" "~4.l}
~ ~, ~"
~
1-
.:.
dl~ c:.F-
dl~ .J.fi ~I
~J:fJ~1 JJYIJ ~)IJ
Jj ~.&I
r
c:.F- I)J ••..
~\
. [ (" ~:, "y) 0'lyali.11 ~ ~ 4J}.uc. J1.i:l'&1u1 Wlb] (t)~li
-
J
~.J-i..J .:. .AI)I
U\S W .&1Y.
St. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book IV, (8) P73, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 2 - Ibid., Book IX, (28) P164. 3 - Ibid: (8) P72. 4 - St., Athanasuis: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt., XXIV,(7) P397, NPNF.,2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980 .
• Yfo. .
JA .ulJ
' C~J
~I
.u)ll JA y'il
u4 u~
~)ll u!] (O)u..J.Ji:! .:•
. [ .ulJA 'iJ,
u1u.,l}·~~l ] .ufiJ
(i)~IJfJI
.bi! ~)l~
~J
(,p
4J) ~~
~I~
~\
~fl:A Uo":.1ill J~ .:•
~l ~I
.ulJA'i ~
~
u4 ~~
~):.J\~).! .[ ~\
~ ~ .un
(V) ~I ~j
u1 cyl ~.J
u..,L-IJ:l\~J
~J: Uo":.1ill J~ ~."l1JfJI jS.i.!I I~ Yi;h
4J) ~)l\ u.fi.;
ull~.J
. [~)l\
: ~Y' ~ ~ uc
La~
y'i\
~~
~ ~ ~
u!]
~)l\
4-.iS.lJ~)ll ~ ~
(A)~~IJ
~~y,
~
o~,
.u)l\ (,p J .:.
"~~J"
4Jl u.fi.; \J4 \J~~
- f.
~."l1JfJI (JollJ:AJlJ: J~ .:.
~~':J\ o\.,pJI
u! ~ .
~~':JIo\.,pJ\
. [c~J .fiill]
('\)J-.H ~J: ..;'ll
JA C~J
y'il
uts "~~J
,,':'lI..w:lI~I ~1i11oJjlJ. 4431 ~IJi ~ ~I
.u)ll G.il" o}-F ~
.:.
jS~ ~J:l.J'i1
Ibid., Book IX, PISS. St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on St. John, Horn. LXXX, (2) P297, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, 1978 . 8 - St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunomius, Book X, (2) P222, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V, 1979. Jf ') LJI~I , ojlfill ~ ( ..!k..J ~I 4.1)'1Uj\ : ~I "::,,y.'J J~) : ..::J~lo~~y4Jl A......I~ _ •• ,. (jQ' ' ••••0 Y.JA\ '(v ,(n
67-
: JJYY ~~ U"' ••~~.H y~f ~
~I
0:'11UtJ. o.l:l.J~I
y\:iS11ut I~) '.<.. ~J
.~
~ 411~
.u'jl ~ y'll u4 u~';;.J'l1
~ ~4'l1 ~J
. (
JiJI
~I~'il
~~
) ~J9}i."l\ ~~I
~I
.l:l.1)141.1'11 :~y-lll
o~ 4:!} ~ : ~~
~I
y\
y'll
r~1 ~J
~-.II 4j..?-A
~
~l.£.JI lJ-'IJ
~T I.JC'~ U:l~IJ' ( u~}il ) f>A'JI : ~I
~~4
u-o
t_ ~ II:: • IT" "41.11" ..••. uJ ~ 0 ~.. :..< ~ y-J. -\..l. (..)'l~I ~ 'la..o.UA:lIo-I""'"e-' J . 1...Jil1 . '"e":i'"
. ~ . - ~II ~I .J ~.(JA
~TJ'
_,
.l:l.1)141.1'11 uti.-
u-11~
~\,J3\ ~\
~..,..-.i
o~~
I~
-I
1.,..;, 1\.)\i;. , ~J.l:l..J1.Ji:- ' (.5~y.JI , JlWI ~ .&1u1 u\.i.-ll o~ u-oJ
...u'ldl .. "tY:a.J'JIJul~I.&\
"u~'i
.u}
(.5~J
rl ~
.J~
"(.5.Ji:-
I~~ . tY:a.J'J1 ~
I.b. .&1~
~
~~I ~" (':'
. ~ ut" (' .: f r ~1) : ($~~I .u} 'i J
JA.
.u'J" (" V:AJ,o') : jJ~1
... U J:UJ f"'P".J .u} y)\"
ul~1
~~J
. "UY.l!1~ .&1u'J
~
JS 41.1 (.5~1.l:l.1)1.u'jl ~ .&1ut ~
.l:l.\J ~'J
0:'IIJ y'll
u-o JS ~
~
J:F.
'ija
ul~1
(VJi :r f y..) : \.:~I ."~IJ
uti.-
'ija
y.. '11u1JJJ'JI u1" C': f f ~t)
"...~'i
~'I\ .)\i;.
Ilt) : J1W\ 'ija
J\i;, 'ija
~;Iow ol\J
..." (i: 0 • )4)
: u\.:.131 'ija
IA.Ji:-J ~y-lll
o~
uti.-
c.sAJ.4;9;9.,,1\ 4.A)'J\
.~)'JI
4..1';l1~I " o)~ ~\ . .&1¥\.l:l..J: ~)
~I
Ji:l ~] (' ')~lill
U:lyl ~
uts wl'
~)\
~\.S ~
J
4411 ~IJi
OJ~
.u~';l ~"~.l:l..J
Jji; .:• ~\
4..1)'1 ~ .&1 ul : ~\:j
~l
J
..,-~~I.:i. ~ tT _u.
•... ~ .tl
J~.~ wbS.\1
- .~... w)I"
~.
. (0 Jf:~ijA)
.1
~:i.
t.
W, LH .....
u'i . ~'i\
~'i\ ~I ~
"~~
11\ r.s1... ~I ~ ~J. -:..L ~.
"u......:.1 F' ~
Jj.o ~
~J
J .. Uy:..ii~I
II w....u.l.... ~
~
. (VJi:A" jA) "U~
U:l~1~';l)A ~J
~ ~
y..*4. I~~J
. .: '1 (.>~
'il:l ~ .11 ~.1" U . 'i"
~I ~l Jil ~I"
'
.11 ~ 'il:i.~ It!
y
~
.~ . Y~ c..s-J r.r)1 J..,§~\
.J-JAj.J1 ~
.l:l..tsJ
~~j)1
. A..iJi:JL:l·l1 ~ . ~ r.A 1~..•
' U';yOj ~\
1
.L::. U~J
: ~T ~~ J;! \1\ ~
J .
Uy:.~ U:l~1~';l)A
~I
(':A" jA) "~~'i\ :l .11 \ ~ ~.JJ
-ul! ..Lj . U-
~J 0
~
l....U U '1"
~
'\ ..soAI...AI LSy..1~I ~
ue ~I
~
~ U.J-l~
u:~1--+
ybS.\1 LJSlJ
F'~\
J) ~
uS ~\! .&\" ~L..J\ .J-JAj.J\
. .&1 ~
~ ..r-;o~ U'I...A'.J . J 6.l:l.. 4J\ r::-- .c:::_ II . ~ u ~ l.S""
cfij';l" yk11 Ylw:.)1 ~ J;! ~~J
(f:' , J,.a')
.
.1.1;
,'\C,
u::= J
v-
•
"LS ~I
. (V:O..::..G) ,(r:".~) .• ~I 9' l.u.il . ••• ~ .&\ t.JS.\
~I
~~
Aj)'1 ~~J'
~
,
l.S"".
'-'~
J#i ~ ~ ... ~ ~J~"
Aj
U
~~I ~
Y.J~~I
~~,
(':V y..)"uy:.y.l4Jl ~ .~.. 1\ . .iWS ~ .1..:.. ·l....UI..b. ~
.&\
•~
~lw:.
~
ul" ~\ ~
.~1\
uQ
4J4 ~~)~
~I
~I
4..1l ~
~
~I
LaS.
~~Wl
y)1 J..,§\1\ ~
(S""lyJ
~ ~.
ulc
LiJh 1.11 .. .1 ~~
F'l;il\
J\!J o~1 UJY\ y)1 otk.1
"'6"'.
V'::" J .
ue ~
-JA
UAJ ... Aj T.l.wl ~
.J~I
¥ .('·:fy..)
~
W
~I
_.I
~WI
dl
.•.•• J ...
Ul...JlIJrill
~
~J . u~
\jLa L&Jc.IJ Y ~J ~
. (' i, , 0: f
Leu-u.l\
. ~.~.Ja
.ul·
~WI
~
.,
~ . II ~.AJ ~I ~~\tl
~
y:.. )
,
\.h .Y-"•.~
~~
I .~\ 1 -:.lwl.u1 . ~'i Li.\II -'..11 II ~
I.S'.J
~\tl ~1
•[
II -'..1j II ~
LiIJ . Y u! wLaKlI
II ~} -'..1 ufiJ W,jlJ . W ~ ufi:! ~ J . & ~\ J '-'"'
-'..1'11 II "i..J4c ~
()4 )
~ ufil
()4
~I~ ~
~JiJI
I~ . .yj} ~~
~1
\.JC~
A.Ay-I\tl
~\
~
~J
.
J
.J~
uH
0:!.lI\ue y'il .&1~I
~
~I
_A
~I J'j....a ".ki! ~ 'ill .•-'..11 II J.1l...J'its. II ~.;;.;;-II -'..1'i1 II ~b.
I·
J~
J.J'"'l)l uJ~ ~~I
~ ~~
~
~ ~'I~ 4J} ~
"~I"
, ~~
(.51II ~\tl ~\ II , ~ II ~~J r~1 Lil ~} . [ l~
J'j....a II
... ~Li..-\tl) ~~I
II ~\tl ~\J ~~\J ~I
~I
(A:H\";'1Co)
II r~IJ II . ~.l.cl.Y-"
W,jtII L0U y'i\ J..,! u!J . ~IJ~I uk 4J} ~ts11
A, (v:" y)
II ~~I II ~I ~.l.cly.JI.&1~} Ul ~I
. ~\tl ~I r-i\~IJ uts.~.lIIJ ~ts11.&1~ ~I
.(r. :'
. t..A1
U-!.
U:!y -'..1} II
~I "~ ~" .
~I .ul ~
.:.
Ls~)\ (J'l.Ja)u~
t.J""l:!II J.#
4-i~} \~
~
. ~ 'iJ. ,1..Jil\\ \1\ ~ .1... 0""""' -:'11-\ . .lIi U:l
(' ')cJo'I~J",HoA1 0'":!J111 J~
~]
.J~
'.Ja) ".AIJ y'iIJ Lil II Jt! ~.lI1~.
~I
~~
l...AS~J
Li.\ ()4
"i..AIJ~}i}i .... A.A)Iy'il ~ -'..1 ~.lI\
: JJf ~~
~ ~ ~'I\ d~u~.Ja.J'i1
ul ~
Lc+-o
Jf ~Yf,
yYf
-
r
~'IIJ y)U .AIJ w~'i
• I Lic.'il ) .&\ .. ( IF·1i!1 ~..r-. ~I
t.J""l:!~.J ~I.&I ~.J~II J.J'"'l)\ uJ~ ~ -'..1"'!J . (r:, wt) "~I
~I
. (":"
11-
J..,iS.&1~~
u! wYJLa..JIu! ~J.J
u!) IIy'iI.&1 ~
y.J ~ ~I
A.S~~
y'il LiS.J~ ~.lI1
t.J""l:!ut ul.....J ~ w~.J"
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chapt.I, (21-24) P287, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979.
"~
.u'i1 , y..i ~.J
~.J
u~}. (i:'''fi')
Ji\ ut
~'i" JA .u..,.....iS ~\.J
"~I.J Ji\ USl.J ... "J.J"'l)\
J..,!.J. (~:fiJiI)
uJ.Jo:I ~
. ~}'i\ ~
uLS d] (\Y)c!.J~\
~\.J .u} <.S.J"'l ~Ja.'i
o.:l~
~f • :f .J.J ~" " .Jn .Ji .J0 : f
~i:~n f:V~t)
"\!~
. ~\)\ .u'i\ \1\
o.:l~.u}
~\
~
~.J
.u} 'i" ~~\
"<.SJF
~\.J ~'i\.J y~\j
J.Ji= .:.
~\Ji
(j'l.:li.J\ y\.:j$J\
.(i:'" fi'
~\.J
u~} , (' i:f ~\ ~0:~.J.J
JA ~\j
J~ ~\
(y:- ~)\
443\
;J,jlJ.
°~h f :i ~~f :" • y..) "\!~
y\.:j$J1 ~
Ji\ u'i.J
~"A:". n:,
Ja.
~ J~ Ji\
~
. [ (i: ~~t ) ".J:l.:l!.u} 4,j}" ~\ : ~f JA'i.J
~.u}
u~, (f:'
VJa.) o~.J ~I
.u'i\
... " J.J"'l)\ lhJa. \J'l;l.:li\\ J~ " ':t;~'il o~\.J
J.:JI
.u'il
JA
~.:l:l
Jr
~
d~~\ ~\~!
~'il
JA 'i
.o~f ~~
~
y~1 Ut ~
11\ ~.J . J.:JI -U'il t~~}
11\. ~\
yYf _r
~~f,
U~Ja..J~\
: J..,ii ~.:l:l
~~
.:.
.u}
~.J
~'i\
~t
~ J.:JI ~~.J
. ("':0Ja.') dl..I~J~
~
~ J.:JI
.u'il
JA
~'i\ u'i]
(' 1") (Jo'I.J:!-'-'I,J~1 ~J13\ J.Ji= .:•
. [ y~\ <.St , ~\
.'If -!I. U"" ,~~,
13 -
St. Ambrose:
1979.
.J:lL.,
oy\\.ill ,
~I
wy\\1 :
-U'i\
JA
<.S~\
..::.ll:illo.)~ 4411A.....loli
_ \l
De Fide, Book V, Chapt. II, (28) P288, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X,
Jf ~'t'f,
: ~~~f o~f '" ~ ~)t.:i.Il~I..!I ~ ('"y!1JSJ .
~'1\
~'1\ u-! ~
u4 u~~.J'l\ ~~ ~
~~~I o~\
uti.-
y\~1
i.,SoAJ ~
~~~\
~J
yYf _ f. o~\
~ .u\~ u-! o~\
4..1
. ( &\)\ ~\~~\) .,.", ~Ij ~ ;l.pJ1 #J '-;J~\ -I
: ;l.pJ1 ~
~'1\ ~i
~~ .u\~u-! o~
4..1
y'l\ ui ~
~Ij ~ ;l.pJ1 #J '-;J~I
4J~ "
. ("i: 0 ~)
~\
.&\ \J~
uI::JJ~\~ .&\ ~\ . ("
~~
J.'\ . ,
~')"
(.)oIl.l
" : ~I ~
;; .;;-
4.A~1
JA
wi"
1\
'-;J~I",
~I ~'1\
.,.", ~Ij ~ ;l.pJ1 #J ~~I
: ;l.pJ1 ~ wLo )J ~ ~i ~ o~\J
u~ ui
lA...J\. UA.,A..lJ\ \ J~J~ .1.:.•::-:
. (n:o~) "~~ ~ ~
"I rJ,,·9
4..1
.,. '-;J~I",
y'll Ul~ 4J~" : ;l.pJ1 ~.,.
w\.JA~\ ~
, ~J
'-¥J
~.J
".u\~ u-! o~
-'-;J
;l.pJ1 .,. ~~\
. (" 0:' , ~)
o~\
JAJ '
.&\ 4..JSJ
'
.&\
o..,! JA ~'1\ ]
('£)U"l~ltjl
U'l:l~\
J~ .:• .[4:i\~
o~
wl.b::.IJ
o~\J
~\
~~
4..1'1\
~.&\
JA \~
~J Ul ~J" •
~I
:
~~"l\
t~ ~J
;l.pJ1
u-! ~\
~I .,. ~~\", u-! Lro-iJ. ~\
WyU1
. (" .:o~,) ,,~~~\
~'1\ ~~ , ~J
~
yJ\ ~
y'l\ Ul~ 4J~ " ;l.pJ1 ~
. (",:o~)" 14-
.,. ~~I",
~~~~~I
St. Athanasius : De Incarnatione Verbi Dei, Chapt., 21(4) P47, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV1980 .
~.JC't I..itJ~Y-
~l
~I..A" ~jiS ~~'il ;~I ~
~
. (" AJ'(,V:' '.J:l) "~'1\ u-ll ~
~'il-J
ulJ' ~~i;;\.p.. ~II..iIJ
~
: ~,JlWI,.Ik.~ ~~'il;~\ -~ ;;\.p.. ~ ~'1IJ ,./. i\ U.o )ts (jl tAS.! , U'lJ.ill\~)~\
~
( r':r' fi " ) " ~I .&1CJ.J... " #j=.. ~ ~ ~.JJ~ ~;;\.pJ1 ~
~ ;;.b.IJ;;4=JI
~ U'l.illlCJ)I ~~ , ;;4=J1 ~ ~J.
(":AJ.J) ";;l:-=JICJ.J" ~J
. (' " C\:r'V j=..) ~yJl ~
;;6 ~
(j} :
~I
U.o); lS~1 (jt :
¥ .U'l.illlCJ)IJ
~'11ue J . ( r':' V.J:l )
. [ (f\ f A:V
(jt
L ••• ••
JI..i:llS~1u~: U'l.illlCJ)\
~.u-J
~~'1\ ;;\.pJ1
~I
y.J
lS~\ ~I
~ \.4.5. (~. \ ','..;;),,~)
~'1IJ y'il ~ ;;.b.IJ
y'i\ ~..>-~
ue J . (fi:f
.J:l) (' f: f.J:l)
t..sA c~J"
;~I-J
'':II] (' 0)c.r-::-ttl (Jo'I.J-l~~ •-' .e. u-a:! Jill J~...L •••
.~\I..i. L lS? ~I:.~ wiL~~,
J~ y'i4 ~
.
~.wl ~\
lS~1
• (Jo'IJJilI~,JlW1 ,.Ik. ~ ~~'il ~.lJt ~.
~J .ul~
J)
.J:l)
~~t ;;\.p.. u-ll
~~'11 ;;\.pJ1
t..sA
~~t
;;\.p.. ~ ~
~La t~.y!
~
cy::J4 ~4'i\ JJ\..i:j
~\J
tY"'!:!J~.b.J ~I
~I
-.:.wI. ~..,9.YY
.. -~\\ 'w'il ... ~-:I\ • U"""""'" ~ • ~
:JJlasp~~YI~I._ ~I
(j'1
~.JA
15 -
lSY
~J • ("
JL ~
C\ : ,
(jl
J .
.J~
c\ ~
(jt(j~'11 .J~':I
,
~.JA
.Ji:-
.u~)4
':I " y)1 Jt:9 . ( 'A:ff ..A) d.~.~."Q~)
"'-:JC ) " ~i .J1..ilitJ} (j'1 " . (" • : f f ..A ) "
~J
, .&\ )ljl§
y)\
~I ~ ':I (j\.....,j':lI
St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunomius, Book X, (2) P223, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V 1979"
~1 II..>: ~All" y~1 J~ ~.lI.
Il~
~';I
~
. (' A:'.J:l) "~~ r.:..>c y'il
•.u;.."rb
u-i~.JC "y'il
u..,;aJJ
~ ~
)
.u~ ~
~.."rb r.:..>c
y'il ~
. ~ 'i} y'il
.)1 ~~ ~I ~
(,,$1.J .L.i9 u-ii.J(,,$.lI1 . 1l~1.J
~J
~ ~ (,,$.lI1 ~)l
~LillI r~ ~
J ' ~~
All W!.JC
~
~';I..b§
~';lj
" ~I
y.J
~J .u..,syU 0'i1 UocaJ ' ~I
J~
~.lI
~I ~~
. (\V, i:' ~WI 0} .J411y'il
~I . ,...-.JCJ ~. ~-:L . ~.J
. (\'i,
\'0,
1 ~1 -cl.il
i:' v.J:l)" ~
I..:r.JC ftQ 'i ·ft/). ~..T'J
UI0fiIJ~
~I
~1 y'il (,,$">:~';\ (,,$">:(,,$.lIIJ' ~I . (i.:'
~1 ~ ~
y'il
'.J:l)
UY-:! ~';\
, ~I
ul " J~ ~
w ~I
4-=1. (J'llill~}
"~\J y'iIJ
f.J:l)
.u4-~ ~ J ~"'§ ul \....il . ~
~
(,,$.lI1 ~I
y'i\
u~
~';I
ul " : ~';\
uyy (,,$.lI1 01]
~ y'il (,,$~' i}iJJ • y'il.u
~
0M
u~
~
_I ("'"
~~LJ
(,,$.lIlj ~IJ ~'1
J..,iS ..,JAly;JI ~
(''\)u-w~lZl
~
Jji: .:.
~J:ill
(,,$.lI\~ ~
~';lj
[.y~ ~tSll A..!.;a-JI j..P-:l 01 ~1 .J~'i] (1V)~..)~'i1 o-J.J:S ~J:ill 1l.:l)JAA..!.J'l'A:' LJA ~ ~J uyy 010J~
~
~
~.)I
~
JjL~ .:.
0\S I~}'i} , y'il
r.:..>c
.J~'i y'il ~ Uoca uyy 01 .:II) I~}0\....;j';10'1 . ~';\ (,,$1
[. ~~~';I
: ~~y, o~, J''; ~,~ 0Lt.:';1~
~~'1\ ;;~I
Jlyl ~~
~I
I~ ~ ~I
• (,,$.:1\.£11
16-
~4
~I
0Lt.:';IJ,
-r
.:I~
~1.u';4
St., Athanasuis: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIV,(7) P397, NPNF.,2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, . 17- St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. 11,1885 Book XI, Chap. V, P487 .
• YtV.
: ~\
u~ ~~J
. ~I
.~)'il
~ ~\J
-\.1)'1~~
~4
u'i , 0:),IJ
4.lA )tS
~I ~.;AJ'-;oJ'll~..)"-"l ui ~
ue ~
Ji:- '-;oJ'll
u'i . ~~'ilo~1
wl.A:~1 -i
'-;oJ'l~ul.A:)'1LS!
ul.A:)'1LS!, 0:),IJ '-;oJ'll~..)"-"l
~~'i\ o~l
~4
'Jy~'i\ o~\
~
Jly
] ('i\)(JoIl~.J..»"i~.all J.Ji:l .:. ~I ~.;AJ 0:)'1
~i
~..)"-"l
I~
. [0:)'\ ~
0:'1..0~I Y_'I ~\....
11" U ·1
~
U~
'I -\.1'j\'(JA .. -u'i, ~.::.::-
. [ ~I
~)I
~ ~~I o~ ~..)"-"l ~
~i
~ y('j\ ] (' ~)~\....~
.u)'1 ~ ~I
~.J:l'j]
~~'il
~~~
o~1
~
Jill f'.. ~ ~
.J
. 11:: I.4...JI ~....• ~ UI.:IJ~
, ~I
~I
t.J"'l:lJ O~J ~I
1 LS1 ".uL .J 1 LS~l l..--=-....AII
~1. ~I ~1 ~~
~~
~\
J:! ~~I..>4\~ ~J"
~JA~.J
-\.1uP
'-;oJlJS.II J.,,! ~I
~ ~ ()AJ:!()A JS
()A JS ~'j
~
~)I
~
~
'j ~
~1
J~ ~
. (' i.' 18 19 20 -
-\.1)'\
I.SJW\ ~
wl.A:~1 -y
... t.J"'l:lJ ....II \...J)I J.# ,",lil LS~\ '-J..l1.-lw . .u.e.~ -.::.u....r' . .. .
~1 ~.
.(" , ':'V.J:l) II~I
~ .ul~ u~
J.Ji:l.J.:.
UJ~ '-;oJ'lliiJ~ ul.Jlc'j\
~\
A.! I\~, y - 1<:0:11 ~-.JJ -cr:~.J"'l:l r--
uUJ...a ~I
JS ~
~i
1.Sft-JA ~Ji31
: ~\.J ~ .. ~.••.• 11 ~I
•••
.J"7I.J.
Ul ()Ay ~ \~1.bi!~~'il o~\
~i
[~~yJI
J a'i.
Ji3\
.1::1 .. .1 c....-=-_ •... AII.l.l...J\ L - ~ ~ .. ~ .
U:I
~I
(T.)~\~
1 .~ I.S~..•.. ~
A.t:.WIUji ~ '-;oJ'll~I
()AJSl~~Io~~~
uUJ..JI -\.1ul ~I
'-;oJ.J~ J:! \.1\ J
\~ ~J:! LS~IJ . 'Jy~'il o~1 uW)'1 0:1 ~~ ~WI iiJi
~I
ul ~ I~
f:i .J:l)II~~'i1o~\
I~
~ 'Jy..r.JI~
-u'i . 'Jy~'il o~1
-\.1 uP
~ ~ ()A).!
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chapt. I, (17) P286, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979 St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book IX, (34) P166, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. Ibid. (24)PI69 .
JS ~9'!1"4J ~I \~ ~
~
~jL...:. II J.J""l)I uJ.J: ~.
. ul ~)
11\ ~J
~I
rJWI ~I ro4-t~
U:!~IoU:..:JI~
·1 .
oL.:Jl "-.oJ I '. ~ . ~~
J~
Ul J~
~I
~.. 1.:..1 w.o.:.. .J
.liWl 'i~ oul ~ . Ie' 'J JI ul ~ .-i - •... AII~ l.r c:::-- ~~
U ~ ~
. ("J'O:'<Si')
f.J~
~
~ ~
uU:J...J~
~I
~I]
LJA JS.! . ~
~L...I ~~
,;.1lS.w.,,/1 ~,»S
'-' ~ JS! ~I
4.l..l . [
~
(l') ~
~
~I
-:11
~I
J
~Ji31 J.,Ji; .:.
..bi! ~I.J""I} ~
oWI . .-i 4..JS ~ .J Wu~ ~ . _I.:. -II ~ l.r ~
~J]
~I
.us..1 ,
j§
~"il U~ JjL...J .:.
(n)~~
:A.;~'ilo\.pJI I."lU: uSl ~IJ I.A.JY- ~
~."ll
~ ~\..:... j~I
~I
~I
JI ~'il ~}..4
. 0j'lUI J I~~ ~
~~I
~I
~J
ul.A;!"/.4
rol.illl~
t~ ~
. [~I
u~)uI rJJ'
~
~IJ
o.JY- f~i ~
' ~
~~y)1
~rJJ.
~rol.illl
~I
~
~I ~I
'.'J1, 01\ ~
~I
~I.Jha ~
J~
ro4- oUl~
I.A~\' ~
~I
21 -
~'ill
~l
4.:lj6, ~
FI :~~,J
'ija
~ ~ ue Ail ubi
0!"/.1ukl
~4
~I
~~~WI
~~'i ~
~.;:l J:l ' ~ y.J J~
'ija
r-\....£jl
Ail o.J:4
~I
LJA ~ ~
\1\ ~J . .uc.~.J
~~
(.Jo'l\.ill LJA I~
.j~
II
r-\.:.4
~I
rol.J""l 4.l~IJ
. (f , :°~) J:§I u..J (.Jo'l\.ill LJA I~"
~
b~
.u;t4 u~"/.I :L.fJ,JI
oj4aJi~YJ ' L;lWI ~I ~
"4..;~'il
~ ut
J:i:l
tA~J
~
~J
~m~
rJ
o~J oUlbl..uJ
St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, 1885 Book XI, Chap. IV, P486.
f.Jr u.a'
,~~~ ~U:
I..l..l.b,t ~~\
~I
, w.Ji.JI u.".~\ ~ U1~t-:
.Yt •••
'i~
t,u"il~\,/l
- 'I''I'
'-I LJ'I'~LJ
1J 1._ ~
I.S"
1
I.S"
,~LJA"Ij'
ul 1._ ...1 , l..4JI ~ '-1~. ~ . I.A~L.. Al U"::" •. "~I
, (' AJ' V:' .~) mL:il\
Jl9.u1'iJ ' ~I
o~
IIW1.J-4~'1
u-!
<J~'i ~
u:J rJi; ~ ~I.J ~
0A Ul......u'll
~I.ufi
~J
'i
1~Lc. U:l~\
0A ~
IAII~
l.A~i Ul U\..h.L
II
~\
. (~:' iu.o) 0A .JjW ~
Ul ~I) LA.ili.! , yYI ~
"..&1~
~i
U:ly
..&1~)
uJ
.y! ...?-~\J ' .u~
~ u-l ~
.u'i\~I
~I
Jij 4JS.\ .
II
("
u-&JI u-lc J
~...rJJi:1rl wl"":'il ~
~'11ufi
~J
f:' fi ') ..&\ u-:"J ..&\
\.S~I ~\
.u.H
uJ
~i
U:ly
\.S~
~I.:JI ..&1Jic. . ( ': , ~) LJolly:.)11 ~
U:JI jYS ~ ~
II
uts ,
WI~y)1
II
. (" f:'
~J
~
u-!
~'1\ uts~(~r)(JM~~1
~I
'
fi) rWlJ
V J:!)
\.S~\ II
Jji; I~ ~J
~Ji.1)
JiWI
fJ:!) "~) , (':'
~'i
(f ':' 'J:!)
0.;5~J
JJi; 01 Y . (':"
yYI I~
~I
yYI ~
.
~AJ
.:•
. [yY\~~~ ~.::,::_11 .u'i\~I II
.uL) \.Sjjl ~\
II
.u" .-..1 .. J! ~J .~ (H)~I •••• ~ UL...I t..S~ tY'l:!J
II
~\.....Q~U'
I.
Ji.1lt~..J. ."A.
~
~4 JVUI F':!.fiill
~
II
•••
~AJ
• [ AJ9J9,!1 4..\ ..,1''1\ u-! yYI ~ A\J.u1 ~~
: W'!o:.ij~' yj. aes~,~ y~, ~IJ
1...J#Ai ~
o~~ 4.:..>41 y~ y~~..&1 ~
~\
~I
~J
' ~\
1)~IJ'
~\..&I
~,Ji ~
4Jl9
II
~AJ ~l
.Ji:-
24 -
~'il
o~~ lfiY.l9
. (" 0:' 23 -
~
"~~~" 4.oJ.( .u'il
~I
II
t
o).-:,C
U:HJ' 4J9Jij...!1 y'il 4..\)1 ~
lyts..>41 UY , ~I
J.J) L;lWI UJ~L;~I
IJ~J
4.l'I1 \~IJ
St., Athanasuis: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIV,(7) P397, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. St. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book III, (14) P65-66, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol.
IX, 1979
\
0'J".u~
~)I
~I
01~
0';~1
0J~~ (.)-'lUll ~
JS ~
0J~IJ'
ue- y~I
-: ~~tsll ~I
we
.u)tl U:H..»d ~yJI ~
U:HJ' ~I
~i JS 0'1 . ~I
"f"1..l..-1 y~I ~I
~I
~
J~ ~]
I~
~
, IJ~Wa ~
~
~i ~'J
IJ~I J ' ~I
. [ ~ ~~J ~ ~I ~I f"~
J!i (f:' V.J:!)~I
\~]
~.J
'I .u"il
~.J! ~~ dSt.
~I ~.
iiJl·\·1.· ~,J.
\.til,~ UM.J:!'Io'l
~
~ ~}~1.l;JI
~\.1\ ~
26 27 28 29 -
JjL...J .:•
~ J ~i ~Ili:!j 0.JCo~ 0:l~1&J)
I~
0:l~I &J JI U:HJ~
~I
I~ ~
, A.,ij1)I~I
(yo,)(.$,)~'il
oJ..>:S
~ ~.J\.W4 OoAJ~I
~iiJl
u~ o~')tj
JS.J:!,J .: •
.u)tl y~I .Jil
. [ t.h=J4~~ '11 I.,k.1 0:l~I &J)
25 -
u~
~WI
~
. [ ~'JI U:Hojl.fill
.u)t\ jJJo'j ~
uSJ .
(.)-'lUll f"t! tA~
~'J JIJI"'JIo~
•••
J.JI;~ .. ] (YA)·"I . .....1JI,hA .jJ~ iiJl ~,J. .t.1.. ••• r ~
.Jti ~ ~i
.JCo~ ~ 0~}] .u~ ~I
J~ .:•
-::\tsll ~~I
(YV)(.$jlJ.JLl11 UM~~..J:. ~iiJl
. [ ~~ I~ ~oA J~. ::.::-
(Yi)W:u1 ,.I
y)I
.u)tl ~l " J\!
(Y0) UM.J:!'Io'l\.tii ~iiJl
0'1 , 4-Jl} ~6.
~)I
~
~
~J. (O,£:'\ijA)
" ~oAJ ~I
.u)tl ~ ~l IJ.J:!~J
" ~~ ..\ ''''I o~ .~-u...a..ul ~I.\::. _'1".11 ~ . f"~~ Ul':l r "TJ
~mu! o~~.JA
' T~ ~J
0)J'JI ~4~I ~I
~)I ~
. [ ~I
~)I
~ y-*,
~J
u.o ~I
St., Athanasuis: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt., XXIV,(8) P397, NPNF.,2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, . Ibid: (8) P398 . St. Gregory of Nazianzen : The Fourth Theological Oration(The Second on the Son), (XIII)P314, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, 1978. St. John Chrysostom : Homilies on St. John, Horn. LXXX, (2) P297, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, 1978 St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, 1885 Book XI, Chapt., V, P487 .
• Yo, •
~ ;;,;;-114.1')/1" .
~'il ~i
0.J.We. ~ '. 1\,.\ ""Ir.' ]
CJA ~i IJC~ U:!i\l ue-y'il All ~I
[~}i}i."l\4.A}'i1 ~
')/J
0\.S (r:, V.J:l) ~
~Il~
~I
~I
~l
~
4.1';/1o}~ ]
J".JA:..J..+.
LtLtJ\ ~\J!
4-: ."~.b..J
~
U:!i\\(jC'~'i1
(n)($~
L:u~\
~
CJA)
JJ~ J.Ji:!..J .:.
4.11 I 14.11, ;;,;;-11 .."'1-')/1J~ '·-'14.11'• UH 4j ~.~-:II\'it":' .. .J~~ • ~~.
~..JA (.)-'l
oJ ~..."
(r·)~W\
~ - -;;.,\ ~
.l..iJI ~L.::&.\I' . ~- JI.! '-S"""-:II ~ya.. Y I ~ :;. ''1I' UHJ,. ~J. -"'1:.. 'I w.:JI.u\ • ~ .J
. [ (" i:' i~l') "r~l ~')/\~i JS 0J "
: ~' ~l "
~~Y' ~ ~ ~ .u~ (r:,
y'}\ ue
~
V .J:lJ ~ ~)}\
~i\l ~I
\~ JI.! "~)
~Y' wi ~"i ~I
~
~\
y.J ~
~I .us..lJ"
tY"l:lJ " )ljl.!
ue-y)\ JI.!J~.l9J.
~..\>~ "4.oJ.( _ 0
"
:i}iJ0."I\ o.b..I}1 4.A}'i1 ~
r1
4.1';/\
~.b..J ~I
~.w
y'il ~.wl
~
olpJIJ ~I
4.1';/1y. " .ul 4.ic. J:!J . (i: , f.J:l ) " 0lpJ1J~I J ~Y=JI .JA ul "
y'i\ U~
A..;~'ilolpJlJ ~I
4.1';/1c:.H';/1 uyy CJA JS.! . ("
':0.J:l' ) "
A..J..lJ'i1 oWl ~J~. ...
......
tY"l:lJ " 4.1~ uyU
y'il ~ ~
c:.H';/1~
CJA .wl.)c
01 u\..bc.IJ, y'i\~
. [ ~\
ue- c:.H';/\ ~~I
~')/J
'
(n) U"'~~I
~~]
.tY>~
~"
~I
;;,;;-II 4.1')/1
~J11\ J.Ji:! .:. ~i\\ ~I
~)
y'il CJA ~I
w.JA)l11 ~y;.. ~
,
A..;~'i\
~}.,.J\.wI 4.1';/1o}~
0J
. .b..IJ tA.\ ~y;.. 0'i y'il
~ ~\
o.b.. J C~
~J
.J4-il1.J~
Ul.u.all , ojl..;-SJI u,...:
4J:.~ J y.
33 -
~
~.b..Jul ~I
"~.J
• £ 1..>"'" \ '\ '\ '\ ..>.lU:!'~
32 -
~I
~I ~~'il
(rr)
U"'~~I
J~ ~~]Jlli
<U)!I..::.ul :~I ~I
UJA'i
~J11\ ~J! J!..J +:. , c:.H';/IJy'il ~
J."..." : .:..JI:ilI o.l# 44..11~I.li
- r •
• \. 1..>"'" \'\'\0 _.Hj£.1 'l'V, £'1',£\ 'uj.i..ll uy\)lJ1.) uly.:..6.. :'i~ 4iYI A.sy.; _ n
St., Athanasuis: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIV,(9) P398, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980 . Ibid: (8,9) PP397-398 .
I...JJ
•
U• tsJ wW$JI ~ . u: . \ l.Al1~ I~ .. \~.- ~ U:f2 U. \.
.~.JC ~
..u\• " ul ~
- ~
J}JI J ~ )\J ~\)\
l-':~- \ \ • ~\.!
.~
ue ~..u~
~\
WI
IS" ~
\~ c.,s! "J}i\
. [ .J~\ c.,s! t~\ ~
\ . ~II .J.>J . ~ll.\ r" '"6'"'.... c.sJ::C. .J'"6'"'"'"'
UlU
~
\.A
~ ~fi
~~. ~'iI ~I JS.ue ~
~)\ ~ c.,s! ~
" w.."J\ r-~ ll~J..u c.s~\ " .&\ ~
0:';\
()4
JS.J y'i\ ~ ~\ . [ ~I
JU lo~
] ..u~ ~\
~ -u'i ~
~
.&\
..)#- ~'i\ ~
..u';\J ' ~\
~\
c.,s! ~JA'i
ukl
c.,s! \JI" ~IJ
~\
J\! lo~
(I"V)~\
u~l . (' '-":'
Ujl : ~
J~-Ul.
ul ~I
~I .u.oJ
..u,;\ ~~
J ~\
y..1
44314.-1J! JjL...J .:.
OJ~
~ "~~J
f~) "y'JI c.s1.J ~ ~i.J
\' ~~J ~I
~Ji11 ~.J:fJ .:.
ufi:J . ~4
(f.:' .~)"~\J y'J\J \JI " ..u..,i4-.i.o
L;!~ ~
~I (I\:"c.sl)
yd{J'i
..u,;\ JA y'i\
oj-:\,J\ ll~ ~JA'i ~
-u'i
" . (' "\:"\~')
u-JJ#.
..u,;\~JA
]
LPJ
~ USJJ' U'l.ill\CJ)IJ
(n)($.J~'i1
• [ ll~
Ujl" ~
~l
.:.
y\ ~\
wt..JS.~
J.J) " ll~J ~I
~ -u~ ll~J ~I
..ul~~'i -u'i ~)\
y~\
.:•
y'i\
U"I:!Ji11 J~
Uo'I~4
(J'l~\
~
\~ ~
~'i
..)#- J U'lJ.ill1~'i\
~
~411 " , ("V:'"\
" ll~J w\~1
L,Uts ~\
..)#- J U\~
(1"0) ~\
J~\
c.s~\
~"'t-'"'"" .
] (rt)Uo'I~-J,>.IAiU"I:!Ji1\J~
~I'i
.oU)'\ " 0.J~ u} ]
" ~~J ~\
,\.
\JI"J " c.s~J \JI "J " ~\ J
. [ UJI. 09;0
~
• ..1.:.-: \ . ~('l .J.>J ~ ~ J
. o~
()4 " "~
..u';1Ujl "0.J~J
~\
..u,;\ ~\.JA
y'JI J y'J\
0:';\ wJA'i ~
34 -
5t. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chapt. I, (18) P286, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979. 35 - St. Basil: Letters, Letter VIII, to the Caesarians, (3) P1l7, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VIII, 1978 36 - St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, 1885 Book XI, Chapt. IV, P488 n', £, ul~, .j1fll~: "~.J~I~I d :~I uy.'1 J~": ~CilI.,)~4411A....1.)i _ I"V , , .J' • ~
~!
,'\ '\ 0
Yoj>S.1 '( v
!
1 -.:.L1.l11 r.. ul • -III , ~I 1"' l.>"" ~ 1::_11 y;...,...
~I•
~J.&Io~utJ'
'-:Y.;e.
~J~I
w....J , ~
~I
ulJ ' ~~J
.ill ~1.J 0A (Y , :' V~) ~ ~)'I ulJ y'il
~I
~ ~\.Sjl ~)I
(
r:,
~)'I ~ ~I o~ rJ.&I II
y'il ~
•
ul. ('A:'~)
Lo~
oY:JI t,sAII'»'J ~).J
~~ ul .~1.J
"~..,.,
y'il ~
J
II
w1 ]
0 j~
. [ ~ ·\.!')rl,'-r...iL . ~ ... II~~.J"
~
oY:J1t,sA0'»'
~JI.J . (' 0:' fi ) .J~I
c.sl
. [~fil
ue ~.JJ 0J " ~~
wi ~y
OJ.jU.
.w~ ..
.J
. (''\:'fi) II
~.J~I
~
1·uc- uLi' I.~ "t"'ti, . ("~"•• .. u..
.,.iJ ~
y'il ~ .:.
,,&.~I ~u......JI
....T'
¥..,.~I ~lL.:J\0A ~I (,JA ~
.<~
.
UA ~,
~4'i1~.J) ~J
·\.!')rl ,...iL
'-r . ~ ...
• ~
~II
.
~J.J
t.~1 ~
OJ~ ~
"&:..~.uJ'YJS,JI" ~WI ~)'I ~J"
~..,s~
4431 ~IJi~...J
1•
~~
,~I --..11 ~w)1
'
\.1\J
Jjj u~IJ'
: ~I ~~I
.J#. .&\ O.JY-
AijJij." ~~
,-US.&I~
(1"") ~I
.. 'F'" Lo ~lL.:JI0'»"
• ~I
,&
~ ~\.Sjl ~)I
0J t,sAJ~4'il 1.A.fi~~I.A ¥..,.'J
u~1 Jjj ".&1"~
.&\
~.J~4 wlJ ' ..b.iiy'il ~.J~4 ~
... (..}'lJJiJI ~)~I
w1
~.JJ ' ~~
ue .. \' ~..,s~ U;S USJJ. ~..,s~ wi ~~~I
ul . ~.;.b
~
w....JJ
ul .& ~
~y\y;.
)
~I
.(Y f JYr:, fi')
.u)'1 ~I
~IJ ' ~
I..;-lC
~\. J ~-:'.-:'_11
JiW\ ~ul),
~I.
~I
... ~(..}'llillilli.J~~1
wi
ulJ ,~~
(..}'l
J.JJ
we-
J.,.aJi
II
~
"t"'. ("~"••1·uc-
1 .~\.!
.". O~.J ~I 'J ~I
.1
~
-11-'1 -':'I.:..&\.! . r-- '-""'""
J#J. ('\:rr J.4)" I.A~~JS ~WI ~I
CJ)I ~J
\
. (r. :' • f J.4)
.h•.• A~I" "
~-:.I.:.II" UC
~~ JS ~~
~
-:.I.:. • _I
~
I>
("'" ~J
~
(1"'1)
(JJ'~
"
,-:.
I.:. ~
'-""""""
..»-:l ' ('I'f: f f ~i) •• JS 4.J .lI1.u..JS ~~ . "i
Lil" .JJIJ~ ~~ ~J ' ~4 ~~
]
~l
••••
".. "i~J wl.."....JI ~Li 1\ t.....:::ul •.~" ~" i.,?
"i
~.J:1-'"'U
wi1=.. ..)! ~~'il JS ~ts
ul ~.lI
wl.."....JIwil:.. 'Y "i.lll ~'il ul ~~ ~
.JA
J.~ili
U"I:f J1!\
y)1 Lil " .JJIJ~ Lo~J " (A:~"il ) " I>~J wl.."....JI
ul ~i JS1~IJ
o.)~
.~ll J..JI:l ~ Lo~
J
. ~~
~).! ~ ""i ~ J
.[~)I ~Li ~~ JS ~~
y)1 Lil" .JJIJ~ ] (£.)(JJ'~J..»J
'~'il UJ~ wl.."....JI ~ " Lii~liA.~ ~.)'il
~.¥I ~
II
J~.JJI ~
yJ-:! ~iJ"~'i1
.JA
~
y)I"
~'il
y'll ui ~
"i.lll ~
~'il
II~~
~
~
wl.."....JI J
yts J~ y'll UJ~I>~Jwl.."....JI ~
"i
~
wl.."....JI wj:Ji,~.)'i\
liA.U.a " (' ~:f ri) "~4
u).! ~~ ~ J . y'll UJ~ ~'il ~i
u'i
ue J:! ~J . ('I'v:Arl)
~t::J4 ~).! ~ 'i I ue \1\ J:! ul J .(' •: h:-JC) u-'li ~4
JJi:J .:.
~ ~t::J4y~1\. ('I'f: f f ~l) ""i~J wl.."....JI
wl.."....JI wj:JW
~i
U"I:fJ1!\
J ' ~'il UJ~ wl.."....JI ~
I>~J
.[ I>~J ~) J:! wl.."....J1 ~ "i.lll ~I~ .". ~~J ~I -~
: ~\
Lii~ill J~J.
:~
ue J~ ~'I>~J
('I" :fo~l)
II
'i1.J"'"l ~J
~J.)4.u)
. (f:' f .JA) ""i Ji:- ~ Lo~ ~'il
u~
~I~I
~4 ~J"
~'iIlF-
u)~
39 -
('iJ1i'J1 ~
~I.JA
uts ul
"i
. "iJi:- ..Pol.u)"iJ y)1 J ' uyU w....J "i 1.J"'"l .u)II ~i
] (£\)(JJ'~J..»t1
I~W. I>~J~I
~I)I.JJI
U"I:fJ1!\
4.1';1 .JA Y'll ul
Jji; .:.
uJJ=
St., Athanasuis: Orationes Contra Arianos, Orat. III, Chapt. XXIV,(9) P398, NPNF.,2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 40 - St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chapt. II, (29) P288, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979. 41':' Ibid: (38) P289
~ (jIlWI~ ~I
~
~ &I~)'I
~
~ ~WI ~
y'il
~
UJ~
[~)'I UJ~ ~~I o~'iJ'
u'J . ~I
-'p-i ~j ~
! (''1':£tl)
~.
oJi:.
"~ul
'i WSJ!! ~
y'il UJ~ ~~.J:!
: OJ\,taJlj J~I
~~I
uiJ
u~
~I
~I
41!
.u ~'i
ul ~
~I
J,\J !! ..bii y'il ~
'-i~I uJ~J .
~Y
4J U~ ul ,..,;....,,,.!
\..0
'J~.J U~
Ul ~j
-ili~.J ~
.u("~ ~t!
t:~j. (':'
Jc.) " ~I
.;Iu~
~ ~I
~1..iA ~
.u ~J.
~I
t~
".&1 ~j ,..,
it ~
'is11~I
.u w~J ~~" . ~.J'JI
;;; ..•.14"
~
o~
1)\.9J
~
(t I")~I
uJ~
'
~ (jIl~
... (ff:o.JA) ~\.Ua ~ J~)I
oU)'l
u.J-
CJAJ ~.J'JI ~
(" J' .:'1'~) "y'il.&1 ~
" 'i J I, ~--.. ~ 11
~
.ul ~
OJ~ ~
~I
\..0 ~
y)I"
~~IJ
J o~4c~~
~)yJl
.u ~
~
("iJli'Ji~I
~
utsJ .o~
~\..o ~\:it W ~I
~WI ~ U'l:!~1
o~4aJi
4431 twlJi Jk .: .
.u ~J
. (ff:HWA)
("~IA.!jU.u w~J
. (A:O))
J~J ... (~:'1'AWA)~4il1 ~ U~yJI \..oJ~WI ~ U- ~.J ~ t~ y.J y\ ~I
t~
''',1;9 ujJ ' wy\)UI ~
~H
Ut Ul.J ~ uY"~U
. [.uy\'i ~ ~
~I
~ Ut..uH'iJ (jIlWICJA'i "
&l~ utsJ . ("\ji:a..j ~~
(fA :~.J:!)y.-;J\ ~
41!
t~ ~ .u4 Uyc.j
~ ~I
]
~
('1'0:' OWA).u w~
. [ o~J ~I .(jIlWICJA ~ ~I
yjjS..o"~I "O~J
01 ...,yw .. 11&b W,its.I ·.('1 ! o~Wl.u U. u-"'J. . ("~·IU
t.u~1 ••
.J;
y)l
-+
J-ii:! .:.
Jj ~ ](t l) (,)MJ:!o4oUj..»t1 ~Ji31
(' • :£WA)"-¥u O~J OYJ~
~.
~ O~j ~I
J~ I~ ~ ...
J\.i:i"o~J" tJS
f~!
. .'i I't.»O ~-"'!"'J . U:!y:. 42 -
Ibid: Chapt. III, (47) PP290-291. , 0 J 1£
V"" '\ '\, J:!Lo' 0~till , ~
.:. JA 'J : ~I
003..#0
4411
t..IJi
-
t'I"
I
: ~.."..JI~$. AJ ~~J ~I _03
, ("':0 J:!)
.ul~ ~ o~\
"
.(r: r fi") "~I r-jc ~
~
.u " y~\j
~ ("
:'~')
~J,a';',tl\
y)U ~
~
f
(,)'l.illlCJ)1J ~
OJ .u ~
I
'-¥! ~~'1IJ ~l
~
~)/
o~1 ~ ~J
~'11
~.J:lr-l'-:?~\" y~\
ue ~
Lai
~
w y-JI
.:•
: Y"~'11 ,-:?l".u\~
.u ~~ uS! ' ~
y~\ ~ jl ~
y~1 ~
F~!y ~~ J y)U ~
~.u
~'1\J
ue ~ u~
Ufi ] (H)~J:!olollJJo:Al Uo":JiJIJ~
.u.i# ~.u ~ ' ~
. [Y .u ~ LJA
~t!i
" wyJI r-jc .u ~~J ,-:?~I" .uJ y~\
~ o~1 .u LJA wyJ\ r-jc ~)/ '
~)~I
.&1cJ.J" ~ (,)'l.ill\CJ)I J (' :' f ~" 0: , , J:!) o~1 ~
. ~i
.u ~
. wyJ\ r-jc ~
J ~
~
.u~J. ("':0 J:!)
~J:!)/
ui .Jy4U ul
w yJ\ r-jc .u ~~ J y~1
uJ ] (to)~U11 Oo3,j!Ja
4431 L-.IJ! J",L..J .:.
)l! . (' , :, ~ ') "w..,.J\ r-jc .u ~~ J '-:?~\" .ul "~I.J:!ul .J~ )/ J (,)'lUll , ~l
~
~
.(" 0:'
'J:!) (':'
u
Jl.l::a:i 1 ~
~ ' ~~J y)U ~
f J:!) o~1 ~ ,-:?~IJ.(f:'
w..,.J1r-jc ~
J~
ul
~
o~1 ~ts ~"
J:!) "
("':0 J:!)
~J.
uJ
wyJl r-jc ~
,-:?~I
.ul~ ~ oLp..u ,-:?~IJ
" wyJI r-jc .u ~~J " o).~. f~J. o~1 r-~l ~ ,-:?~I(,)'l.ill\CJ)I ~
[~~J y~1 ~)/ : ~I ~ y~\j .
CJ.J ~
~~1
~
(,)'l.illl CJ)IJ
(" v: , , J.J) " ~~ ~,-:?~I,.u~~,
~J
'
~I
y\~1
' (" f: , fi') .&1~
J I"J ~l
s, II .&1" ~~~I
.uJy~1
w~ ~
AJ ~~J ~I -..A
LJA ~
~'1\J
~\
'(' v: , ~')
ue ~ u~.(' V: h ..iII) Ul I~ ~~
~I
~
II
~ ('V:'~')
44 f'
AS,
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chapt . II, (35) PP288-289, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979 01~1, ojlft\1 ~ (~.J ~I oiJ)Il u\: ~I ":"'y.'i JY") : ..::..lelll o~~ yl.;JI ~I.li _ f 0
" u""'
''1'10 y'jJSl '(V! f,(.J
~I
~.y!
j~
y.iJl
£:'..,s') " .&1~J.&\
" JAJ '("
0..,9 " ~l
.uc
. (i:"..,s)" F1J , c:.H'I1 r~t ~t
~
J:'o~J y'i\ r~t ~'1
"o~J ~I"
oj~
f~l
r~I J
.\J'l~1<:: J)I .o~ J
~I
.u'jl
JAJ ,y'i\ ~
~I y'i\ ue- J!9 ~
]
(£'I) (,)oII~JJ:-41 U"l:!J111
~'110.J~ o~J JA ~I
o~J JAJ ' ~I
c:.H'I1 illl~
. [.&\~J.&I
o..,9o~J
JJ o~J ~I-J
: ~JiJhll ~~)I '1 "i~J
~l
JA y'iti.
\1\ y)1 ul" o~J.&1 ~bl
y~1 ~~
yI..U'1\y.JJ
~I
~..,w\~
~u")rl
(.)4
~l ~ A}i}i,1I ~~)I
u.- J-SJ. (A:£" Jjl) "y.'1 ~I
. (' i: £ AJjI
JA y'i\J
J~ .:.
~ "":A
rl
n :' , · joG
) y)l
. (' i_' £ :i~') ~l
JAJ . ( A:"..,s' ~ i' :' itl ~"A:" • J:! ~"i -'" :V~
.(' V: i ..,s"') y)\ ~1J'""ll Y ~l
JA \J'l~1<::J)IJ . (' i -, ,:, '\j.J) yI..U'1\y.JJ ~).JI .ill.a
" ~I)I
y)\
~
fiy ~IJ
~
~J'11 ~)IJ
. (£:i~) ~\ J y.JJ ' ~IJ ~l ~
~.) ~
J.#~.J ~
(.)4
JAJ~.J ~~
.f~IJ '11y.1 ~1~
~I
~J:!
, ~ ~J
~
46 -
~J 411~
~~'11 ~
Jl ~~\
"~IJ y.J ~l
~ J.J'"'l)1uJ~ ~~l
()J r-lW\~ JjJ ~
~.J'11 ~
J!9 u~. (i_£:A..,s') (.)4
) y)\ JA c:.H'II+J
JAJ411~~ ul ~
~),lJ
(.)4 ~
illl~ f~
ut:i]YJ~~ tA ~I
~ u1.S ~1.J'"'l ~I ~
y)1
~
()A!"
tA ~J ulJ ~'1
~ "i~1 y'il ~\J ~11..lluSl. UJ..;/J5. yl..;!)J UJ.;#. ".y ~J
\J'l~1 <::J)I ) y'il
j~l
~~'11 ~.y
~
'1 I¥
"i~1 ~I "~\)I
y)I"
t.J'""l:!~\J y.JJ JA ~l c:.H'I1 ue
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chapt. II, (33) P288, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979
~~J ~
~';I
'1 \¥ "~\)I
.u,;\" .ul y~1
uc
uJ ~I
J:!i
I~J
. ~~)\
. ~~\)I ~j'11 ~ U'l.l9J\ CJ)\ ) ~
~~IJ ~
~ ~fi.\
~';IJ y~1 ] (tV)(Jo'l~,J.J0:-41 u-w:!.1il\
. [lJ:H.J
.u'jl
O~J
~
y~1
ul ) ]
.ul ~ J:! u1.S.uJ ~
~I
(t")~\~
~I)\
u~ ul
y)\" ~ J!I ~I ~'1
uJ.
~
~';I
~
, y)U ~~I ~\
U'l.l9JI CJ)\J'
Ul ~
I~J~~)\
.u
o\.J! ..J
.u,;\ ~
lJ:H ~\
U~
~.J
c.l~
~)\
~\)\
u..f;j
.u.o .u~'1~ L.1·1 ...J ~ .•
~\.u.o•
u-w:!J1l\ J.;L..,J .: • )\j
,~I
rJJ ' y~1 ~\J
.uJ l:J"
'1 "y~\ ~\J
[ ~~.u\ ~
• ~
~\.u'jl
y)\
y-\'11
~\J.ul
u~)U\ , J:i,J~J. "~\)\
~J ~
~\
4.J'l . .u.o ~
~
~
y~\ U1.S.uJ] (t")c.l~
O~J ~I
)\j ,
~
~J
u~
y)1 ~ ~I
•
~~I
~J
~\J Y.JJ'
u~ \~ . ~J u~ ul ~
ul ~9}i,uSl. (i:Afi')
ul ~I
~J
J~ .:•
.1::1_ •...AII
U"
~o.;:--
l:u~\
~YJ J~ .:. ~~'l\
~.u~
t~
~ ~I
y)1 U1.S.
~I uc -.~.IIJ1 ~'ll ~ ~I t ~ ~~I ~UI
u~-<.
~ \.j~\ .•
. 11 _:~\ • [ • U~.~
•
•
:~~
tl'aJlJl 'Sin:
" ~\,J y.; Uf.l! y)\
~I\~•• Y_II~~Wa.l\ L~,I .
(S""
~I
~ ~ tAS. ~I
. ~ , All ~\~ ••
J
-"" r,s-
I~ ~\
~\
~~..
47 48 -
J=,i\..>"J'I! l.:! ~!
"
~ I_~. .J:! ~ . _~I\\1\
~.JJI~J. y~.J~\J ~~I
. All ~I~J ~
~b
~~
l.S~\1j
W.ill ( ,,~ : '" .JA) ~~I
Ibid: Chapt. III, (45) P290. St. Hilary of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book IX, (34) P166, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol.
IX, 1979. i ~,'
'\'\'\ Ja~'~
~~~I~'
,u.Ju..J1wy\~'
.Yo".
.; wly:..6..0 :I..j~
4i)r1 4j~
_
f '\
~I Y-II .&L. U~. .~"it!
~.
0:'11.1' (r:
.&1~
('I : fit~~ (JA
:fo~l)
11\ •
Lli
""'&"
~J,.aJS.y!
w~~1
... 1 ~.1
,~I
0:'11.1(~~ : A ('I t , : "
~~
~I
o~
~"
w.lA"i .1..T'
~ ,-
• j.G) y)\
. ( ~ '\ : ,~
j4 ~
·1..9~1 'Lw\ u.
~
~~
y'il
~!J ~
~iJ
~I
'.J:l)
~~ "i\ ('~'.1.;'
u}! ~-.?-I~w lJA.1
.J:l~ ~ r -n ~
.(
: V WA )
ui . f.TA ~! ~J
y)\
'V : r fi
f : i ~) " .L-:..I.1 y.J ~!
: (r\ : rr :..,.;)~
~i
:
:f.J:l).&\ ~ \,)'l~1 C.1)\.1
" yt:iS.l\ J.;s ~\.1 y.J ~ , ylUI ~
~I Jo"'l!y~!
w~~\
~ 0:'11.1. ('
~I
y)1 ~ \,)'l.l....i\1 C .1)1.1. ( A : ~ fi' t ~A : ~.
1-
I..S"*"
~1..9~\~ ~I)\
,r:o tl tH
~I.1.&1 u~.1. (f ~
.I U
6JrJI ~ ~~.J . L..::u "i .&\ ~I~ ~.1
, wl).&1 ~ y'it!.
. ( '\ : ~ fi) " t;~
6w' ~
.
~)
y)\
,:).J',s'~' ~
_r
~ ul ul r:.;'J1 IJ-pi " " ~lS~UA~J
I.~IJo"'l.~ I . 1.1 ~ "'e"" f'
U:!-l
-:11~~ y-II ""'&":;.I'il h.....,Qt!~•
i.S"'"
.....,)1
~
••
<U.
.J;l
....., -:11:;· "II 01\·1U ~.1.1 . 1 . wli.l...::J.l 1Y-...r. ,. ..•~ o~W\ .~.1•.~ ~ 'L~\ . ~ ". ~ICb i.S""'""'&"0II ~ . r A , rv .. r ~ ~) \."'e"".~(JA.UC 1.l.uU.J' j\.ijl· laW o'y:.~. \.c. \ . :('1 .....,jl..S....J\ . ( ~ . .lA ..T'
wi
Wi ••• " T~·.(j ..JA
" ~
~~
'-5'"I.J.~\
" ~I 4.Jul
. ·tS.Ilo~
(JJ
~I
~~I
-.?-i .u! ~.
~.1
lJA ~.1
"0 .1.Jf:l
" ~I
'.u.Jc. ....<. ~ . ....r-. ~I
"
~!.1 ~
1
.•.
~.1
~
~
,.('11,_I.d.:jjL ••• •
(.)->"
. ~ _A
~
~I.1
. _.:. II ~I r..r- ~.
~.1 ~YJ
.u.1c1~~I
uLhl..J1 ~L....::.~)I • ( 0 : '\
~
L .1.(j ~ .
i
~" ~!-S
~I .lA ..T'
. .&1U""'":!.1 ·.L . UC
.uJ ~.1 . ( r'\ : r~ ~)
wi . ~
wi wi " JY:l.. .J#. ~~~I
~.1 . ~I
.u'l\ ~.
(
'0
, ,
. J.J
U:! ~ ..•
r
.Po)
j.G) L»b~ ~"il ~i JS u~, ~W:
.1. J.J~I II .. .1 •. ('I..:..u..u-=.IL.II.u~ U:. '-5'".~ (.)->" ~ ~ ~
.1... r-:: _< .•.., ~1 ~ .
f :
. ...i1:u C~. - II ,-II ~.1
. ( ri : r~ ~)
,~
~'1\
.
u-!.1
'I
~U....., . .~ ~\j4
~
.Jl...-c.s~1~
~
~
Loal ~ ~ ~\
" ~'ll ~}J r~IJ
c.s~'i\ ~Jil ~1.Sl\4J';l\\~
... ..»UJI ~
t.J'-'l:! "
.we.
J:9J ' ( 'f
: , ~) T~ . ( A : H'
I..;-lC)
:(" :'0 ~i )~ ~ ',s' ~,~
-r
J
~~ ~..>A!~jil
~ .ill.J ~I
Uh: ~ .. iJI ~ ~
~ ~..>A! ~.ill! " "~I
r.l~ u~ ~I
~I
\fi.J~ rl ~
()A u~ .( '0
J . jCJI
~~ ~\ -
"
:
4.l';l1o~4c lfiy
, ~I
i
0
y~
J ~\
w~·..
... I u~J'U:l.JJ
~); \.1\J . .us~J ~I
4J';l\wyyu ~J
c.s~1~t.9'i1 ~
~I
~I
~t.9HJ ut:i.fjJ ~l:~\ ~
0AJ ' ~~\
IJ.Jl...wl~\
4JH~...r.U:! ~ .J'll ~ ~...r.U:! c.s~t!" 4.1..,9 ~ J
. _11..lJ _,;<:1, ~0::_114.1'11 • ~ ~ UY .. ~
9'9..•114.1'11 w'lt! • ~.
.Jy.4J Jil
UIJ ' ~~
. (j'lJilI CJ)I wYYUJ.&1~
( 'i : i 0 ~I ) " ... ~I
(.S..
JSIJ ~'i)1
4J?U~w.o'll~I . Y;l.) ~
~I)
~I)I
U:l~1J:jIJ'o"l}~
~~
•
y\~1
r.lJill
'ull ""(i-"-'
CJ.J ~ (j'lJilI CJ)IJ ( ".
:
~l.:iA
'\'s'1 .' .--11-I U.J U::J-'l~ U ~~-
U~
wti....:a~I ~ ~IJ :...·1~
u.!- W ~ 0 ~,
)
u-k rAJ ~
~.J'll . ~I
4J';l1.u1.&1
-;11 ~ ..~"""(to'.I ---II:; _1'..1\ ue - o'~
4J';l1~ ~';lIJ ( '" : 'V~)
~I
. ~IJ 4J} ~ , ~i ~
~
.(
"i : '0
~)
~J',s'~'~ -
~.ill ~I
E.-M.J ~~.J ~I
: (r: 'V ~) ~ ~I ~1 ~"iJlL:! wI 'J..:~'ilolpJI
f. c.sA o~.J"
,,~) : ~j41
~'J..:'JI
. .&\ ~I~J
&JJl ) , ~)I
~i.s ~ J '
~I
"..l';ll ~
o~~1
~I
u-k ~bll :~)
~\)I
.&1Ul : ~t:i
:<. Ii I.JC ~c.s ~I • t.iJ..~ :... """(to'
~ 'ija 'ija
: ~~'il olpJI ~ ~
.. 4..;~'i1o4=J~~,o4=JI
u-!J. ~I
~I
~I ~bJ)1
~I
~I
wt.tJ\ ~l uy:.~ y.J <-r iiI\
.u~.y!
. .J '11~ 1- (jA .. Y"'" -~II ~ . ~ ~ (..)-'='
••
~
w-~I\ Y"'" I..S ~ ~
J1w:l1..S.l\1 ~I
+
j)~
J
, (jA . )\ JJ ~ I..S Ja,jj
~1J11 ~IJ o~J
-:11 oWl ~
I..S"'"
<-rJ)1 c.;il~J iiI o~~
0~'j\ ~
' <u'J.JJ~
~W\
. 4..;~'i~~ : ~I
Ull ~j.J&:!wi
~I
01.J:! 01 ~I .J~ 'i .uy.)4 iiI\ 0'iJ . 4..;~'i1o4=J\~ iill 4.!.JL'l ~'jl .1J ~i O.J:!~ .&1"o~ u-! ~'j\ J:!.;b ,jC iill li!y:. ~ ~ (" .: n" y..) ~J
~
iill
~J ~
. ~'j\ J y'il
J~
~ .('
C"
y. y'll
~~'i\ o4=J~F
4.!~
..::J ._1~.r.•...;;~y:. ~ 1 r-~
A :'.J:!) "~
~J '
.J~J
1..S~'i\w yJI
4.!y-o ~
' oJ.fi"A ~
.J:!)".&I ~
~
~
...1" c..-::-- ....AIIJJ....JI ~
U"':i'"
4.!.JL'l~
iiI\ ~
y.J . 1..S~'i1 ~ ~
~
"
~'i\ ~1 JS 0'1 . ,",~I y. J . w yJ\
r-Jc J
~I
JU I..S.l\I ~.
y'ilJ
y'll
u-! ul
01~
'i I~ "
..y'il
~~J
I..SI.J Ji! ~1.J 1..S.l\1 " ~I <l1';1Ujl" y)U.u)
'6.'6 ••.tl ~I
..>:F J.\WI ~)\
.
Ujl
JUJ ~
.u'jl ~ ~I
JS u-! ~lSJI, ~
~.ill~I
y)U 1..S.l\\ wy\)\JI ..JA~ ~.u
~I
~~
J)::oJI.u 1..S.l\\ ~)\
" ~)
ul "
~ 4.!~\J
.u'jl " o}-;lC
.. 0~
y'ilJ
w• J l:..:j . J
~ o~ I..S.J:! ul ~'j~ (.)0); 'i 1..S.l\I.J~~I
I..S.l\I wy.)\JI .JA~ ~
.JJliU, (.)'lJ,ill\~L-l\
~
~H 0~'j\ • ~~
..».u.J
~I
4.!y..J\ 01\
. . ~'il ~1 JS ,jC
4..;~\
(.)0
J!J .u.,,!yU 0'11(.)oJ'
1 1 I. I""..: -:11 .=- .. 1\ ~. -""..:I ~~ Y-II A..lJ1· ~I~ . ..r-:.• U"-'l.J ~ I..S"'" o~.u ~'j~ (.)0); 1..S.l\1 " 0'1 ~WI u-l=- ~)I iill
( r'\ : r
u-! y. 1..S.l\\ ~}\
J! r-~;< Y-' . ~ ~I•.w'll c.r.II ~ ~L ~ ~I
V, '\ :' f.J:!) " y'll I..SI.J ~ ~1.J 1..S.l\1 . 0~I.J
,",J~J
~
~I
.(r. :'
.u'jl
JS
e.~J ..." ~IJ '.J:!) " .~_::,.IJ
.(' • ,,\ :' f.J:!) " ~
~l
~l
.JA
.ul " .ue.J:i ~ . ~JiiJjj..•.\1~.Jil
ue- ~
~
~I
~I
~I tY"l:!J " ~\.i ~':JI y)I J.SI ~ I~J . ( ". : 0 .J:l' ) " ~~YI o~IJ y':JI(,)A~I ~..,lyJI.uIJ' y':Jl ~.~ (,)A.ul~ ti.\~" ~) (.5~I
.~:.:- '\ .tJ'l~.."ul , ~I wlJ' ~~ J ~I ~I ~I : J~ ~I ~I wts.J wIJ ~~ J c.r-:--.. : .:- 'I .uyl ~I J!"WI~ JI, ~ : .:- 'I .uyl -:'-WIJWI wI . \"-.' ""e'" '-""'" w...J , ~ wlJ ' ~~J ~I ~I ~I . ( fi , ).&1 ~J .&1 o..,,!
"f : ,
~ ~ 'j. .J
(JA ••
(n· ..J:l 'v ) ~~ ~I J ,~wl .. IS"
~~I ~..,ll ~';I wlJy':Jl ~I .(r :'~) .. ~ tJ'llill&:i.J~ ~I
.
w...J J &. LJ...~.
&. ~
~y\~ ~.JJ ~~
(.S~IwI. ( 'A : ,
.J:l)
~~ wI. ~j.J
y':Jl I~ ~
~
~
~:Ji
~.alat1,~,
"~,:a ~ ~~, ~i ~i ~_ .. [ 0: 'V ~ ]
~~'J
~,:a w ~~, ~i ~i ~~
~L.J
,v~] "~L ••U ~~
[ 0:
~!
~~'J"
-.1w ~ ~~ ~:aJ'
~
~~'J
An~'
:~~
~ ~J.,11 un ("b LAJ ~\ ~I
;11
~I
~\
Wy\'i
U~~.J'11
~,/I u) L.J:!ljli" ... y'11 la-:llw.il ~~
/ljyy
~ ~I
tsbl..::.. ~
U:H L.J.4 J
. y)U yJb
:~LA ~t...- WI)~;lC'(.j~ J ~I
~,/\j ~ .u
~
c9.JJ
I~
M ~I
I"";
~
T~
ra"'Jbc I
(.j~1 ~I
~
~,/\
~.J'11~~
t~ ~ " [':' V~]
" ~I .. ~\ .. ~~,... wI LAS b:lo.l J
u'1IJ " [0;' V J:!]
Wy\ 'i IJM U~
~I
.:ijl ~ y'1l 4-:1Jli 1 J ~WI ~ ~
r"la-:l
~I ...~
~ ulJ
'U'
. ~l..JI
" ["":'
V J:!] 'U'
".~IJ~
~ ~ u..,.;~~I •••
l...!t'l
UL...i'/1 ~} ~
u'11
"-IWI ~I . ~~ .1.:: i ~ ~..&I ~J
" ~..)Ul
~I
~
L.J.4
/l~J
(.j~W\ ~\
~~J ~I.illl ~I oUAY!~J. \._.L ~Y'"'
t~
Jli
ul ~~I
IJ~ .\:.:.\ul U~ . ·<1
~y...LJ9 "[f" ,f' U~ ~ ~
/l~
~~
~I\ c..?
11\ ~'i Ul ~J
~)G..,/\ ~~} .1e"U,JI C::~. .>.IL
(",)->0
O.J-Y- T~i ~
. rJWI ~
~~'11~I
.u (.j~1~,/\
. ~~
~I
~
~~I
JJ \J:ij uJ-".llJ...L:iJ-".llu C::~J'
~
~
(.j~I
~ U~ (.j~IJ' rJWIU-P
: (,,)oCI~\
~J
~I 4JS.l..& 'i~t-U~ ~IJ '
L.J.4 ~
/l~
:H'J:!] 'U'
~..&I U~ u)
~
..&1O.J-Y- ~ U~ ~}(.j~1" ~I~ y\ 4JS.lJ
J).jJ J (V '''\:'' ~ ) " ~ y~.JA '
~ ~;~.L...I (.j~I (.j.
.ul~~ /l~..&1
~,/I
~J.):lo.A ~
rJ '
y'1\ la-:ll" [" f:' V J:!] 'U'
U:!~I ~'i~ Ul ~)
~.u
Ul ~
~l
~
,...,.i.. ;.,1\0.J~ U~ (.j~\ ~\
A.JI . ~ I... ~I
--
/l~
~J
~~'11~J~.JJ U~J:!.J'1\
: ~~~.;~, IM~ ~, ~L.:.L': ~Ji
: ~jY' a.a..LO' ~ ~ .uJ.l;!':?~\ ~\~\ y'i\ tJS y\ wfi:lwl ~ ~.J:! ) WJ~
" ~)
~"
~
~~~I
~u
~
LIS y'i\
) -~IJ
W~ , ~I
~
wi JL
~
[~)11
~
~~"
~\! ~I
-0t;1
~
(I)~J-l..J~\
J..;i: .:.
41
~
~ ,:?~IJ '
,:?~I y\J ... ( ~yJl
[ (0;' v.J:!) " y'il 4-:1..:u1 ,:?IJ WJ~
~
~]
~Y' w4 w~~ .,
wtS wJ ]
y'il ~
~
w~.J:!J'i1
~J
(" A;'''.J:!) JjL..J .:.
P)~J-l...J~\
W , .&1tA
~
~wtS
Y1) llitS ( ~4J1 WJ' y'il tA ~I
~I
\~ 4jwl
~'Oj~~Ylw4w~~ .~
wtS ~~
~ ¥:-)I
~
,:?~I.~I
I~
~0ti\
d~..>:( y'i\..: ,:?I)
.r J,Ji: .:.
w1] (\")~.J:J~\
~~4l~
wfi:l wi ~
~ J
. [ 0.;.11 " ~1
~
A.t:.UI Wjl ~ y'il 4-:l1 " [ . ~I
J~
,:?~Iwl ] (")'(t)~1
oj.J'L:!) , ~~ wi ~\:i:-y\ (';'
:yYl ~~l-t 'Y~Yl J,\ (0;' V.J:!)o~
wi y'il
(.)A ~
. [ y o~
1-
I.
UJ3,Ji:J .:. V.J:!)
w4 w~~ • r
,:?~I I~ ] (i)W~.J:!J'i1 ~~ ,:?~I y)Ll4JI-A wfi:lwl J~I
0A
St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos , Orat III , Chapt. XXVI, (26) p408. NPNF 2nd. Ser, Vol. IV, 1980 2 - Ibid 3 - St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book VIII, (12) P65, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. 4 - St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt. IX (83) p234. NPNF, 2nd. Ser, Vol. X ,1979 5 - St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II,1885 Book XI, Chapt. III P479. '(' f.J'l'') wl~1 ,.jI.fi11 ~ ,( ... y'Jl '+.1\d ~, yl.,p...JJly..) : ~tJl •..l~ y4J1 ~\..li _ i .1" 0"'" I~'\'I' J.!Y.\
:~~J~' ~L.Q'~! ~ .aJ-l': 4-iw ~m.} ~ " ~~ " ~'11 ,
uY , . .u~
T~
cfi.; rJ
~
u~)U\ ~~ ~ ~.y.9"
~
'L.:u. ~ .1-
~J'
~~
~l
~l9
o~
rJ ~\
.} y;\J:JI.&\ ~ ~\
u~)u1 ~L.:u.
~J
o~1J~.~.u
~
0A Y.Jk. ~
~..JA
, (' i:f ~') ~I
uy .•A.lll~L.:u.
.} ~
u.J~ J ~ '
..Q
~I
~i ~
~I
Jr..
~ u~)u1 ~~
~1
o~
~ ~ .u ~'11ul ~ ~~'11 ~J~.J
~
~J
UYJ ,~I
.u USlJ' ~I o.h.A· . LJo4
~\::JI f'J:!l\.} f'~ ~ ~\
" .lJ.lJI ~. Ie' ~? I.AS; ~~.J'11
• " ~~
" ~
10
f.
~
.wl~ e.rI.:..i
~I.ill\ ~
0)9;,,1<\
.lJ.A
~
b.~
.wl~ \.:.1
IJ"<l~
I.AS; • ,../il
u~l.Jlci.)c
: ~~.J'11
: yW lo JS' 4J ~Yl . (' 0:' i~) " ~ ~ y)U LA ~
.} J~J o~
• ('
V~) " ~ ~
• :,
~jl ~.u
"
~'1l9 . L.0UJ' y)U ~
~I
o~
.ill ~ LAJ ' .ill ~
ui
e.r- ~ ill rA~.J.} ~~'11~I
.l:=..1 ~
~
~~
" y~
A...JSJI 'YI ~,
I~ , rJW\ ufi ~ y'11 ~ ~I
~J'
~\
ui ~i . (~:~fi)
~
. U . '11..b. :: .. IYI ~ ~. YIo(:jj U ,I UJ ' ~~.J~_I~: .11 ~. .. IYI ..T" J . ~.
~jY\
J~
y)U
~ LA ~
-,
Jl§
Y.J
" y'1\ ~ .w~1.1G
uti...::. ~ Ul ~y JI)YI
~'11 y;~\
. y'1\ ~
~.uJ ' y'1\ ~ji ~'ilJ
u~~.J'i1
~~
I.AS;
~jYI
~J'
~1 J--A
~I.&\
. ( Jill u~Y
. (0:'
. uts ~
'~',l=;'"
l.+il~o.J4JI oU ]
V~) " rJWI
rJWI
uY
ufi ~
.ill~. ~
~.ili:. ~
.}
(V)~I
ij~
uts ~ill
~I
~.»J"<lJ
'rJW\
~\
~IJi'-~I ) 41jl ~
4431 "
~I
J,Ji: .:•
~IJi
J~ ~
,~I
ufi ~ ~.»J"<l ~ u~J
4J4
.u ut.S
y'il
~
i.j~1 ~I
~
l~ ul ~'iJ.
(r' J'
I~ lAl .
(r':'''-:-lC)''
• : ,~) ut.S ~ ~~ ~.JJ
o~.»
JS ~
~4-:l".u1~
o~
[ . oIJL.....JI ~
4-i.o
0~
J~ . ulA)\ ~
fiii U'l~1 H.~ ~
, \~~ u)l
" JJ'il ~yl~
y~1 J '
o~
~
~~
f':1.ill1 ~
~ i.j..,p.l(,)0'=1~
y'i\
<.::.UIJ ' ~l.)l ~
..4J. ~IY-'ll ~
~)~
ut;1 ~ jlJ
Y
J'il ~'i\ o:J'i J
(jA ~
ul o~
I.A~
~l ~
~\ ~\
''''J.'Y <.::.UIJ " o.J:llll
u~
~
i.j~\ ~ ~~
.(":o~) ut.S ~.¥I~ "
.u~
u.J.- ~l
~'il ~ jl ~
~\:jJ!1 ~ J
~):l \.h..J:l
. (':'.J:l) " All ~ ut.S ~IJ' " c}1t.Swi ~I..HI u~ ul ~" ~
(OA:A~) ~l
..lli'i " J~
LJe ~\
i:" "j.J
y)U .w4-WA ~ J . ('
J~J
~l
) "
:JJ\:JA.·:U~J J.-l " .uIJ
rJWI ~t...::ul ~
. (" f : , V .J:l ) "
Jj'il
~l
JAo~'i\
JAoJ' y'il 0.J~
.J..,ill ~ j'il t 1.a..t1t.S, ~IJ.lII ~
:J.».JA
] (")(,)oII~~1 ~JiJI J.j1; .:•
.us1J '
:J.».JA
rJ J
Ji:- .hi ~ . [ ~)
JAo i.j~1
: ~I~I ~I
.u ~'i\J
y'il
ojYL:!~'il
(jA
JS! ~~ , ~'il
d~U~~.J'i\
~~
~I
~.,.::JI w~ lAS~J
~ ~~I-y
JAo~I
(jA ~
~ ~'il JlJ Jj'il
(jA
~I.lI1~\
. ( t..r·~I ~~• I .-:e."J1) .A.JI . i.j~1w411~ fUll~" J.,.i;J (' r','\:iWA)
o~
~l
" ~l .~'il ~l ~IJ
" ~l c:.H.~'i1 ~l ~l ~I 8-
~\
.u i.j~1~IJ
J~
~I.lI1~I
o..,ilIJ~I
All o:Jlj ~
~
.u y'il
u'i ... wl~l
~
" y'il LJe uJJ: u.J.-
St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos , Orat I, Chapt. IV (13) 2nd. Ser, Vol. IV, 1980
p314. NPNF,
.u'jl ~.J1.'iJ ~
'i ~jjl .Jy\.l!I ~J
" , (V:" tjA)"
~I
~"
~ U\S ~jj\ ~I
A:"fi')
J~
" y)U .u~1.lA ~
uSJJ" JY"")\ U'l~
~~\
(".,;~lJ u'11~I.u
~I
. (0, t:' Jc)
4.-a1.fi,l\ .u o.l:l....' ~\
Y\J: ~I.l!\ ~I.u
. (':"t:!~ ~~
J~J
" ~1 .Jy\.l!1y\~ ~l ~IJ
. (' V:'~') " ~I.ul
" y'11 lP ~I
~I
"~I
~'1\J
y.J" (1:"~jA)
~'1\ ~
~)11
u-eJ
lP J . (0:' V.,;) "~Wl ufi ~
J~ ~\.l!1o~
t.J-""l:l1;lol':'4J Ll:.J 4.!...>--'l ~J ~I . (' A:1~")
" ~1 y\.l!\
~4 ~ ~'11 ul u.J-""l:l~1r-4'11~JI
~ t~
ul J: ' .u ~
o~
~ ly<Jl
~J
. ~'il ~) ~bJ U;S! ~ t:lk. t~
~
u'11~I ~ u\S ul ]
.u~ ~WI ufi J:!.u u\S~jjlJ ~I
lblb " '-¥J
r ('
. Y (0:'
('I) (Jo'I~illl
~~ ,:?jjl ~Ijjl
V.,;) " ~WI ufi J:! ~
1J":' AjA) " ~I
y\J ... ~.J
~
o~
'i ~\~ o~
~'11 Ul
~'i "'*':' ::.."'1 ~, ~.
~
U;S! , ~ ~~
~
~l ~ ~~
~J
y~J
~ .u Y""UJ ' ' ~
4..JS11 ~\ W'1" ~ .ul
~
LJA
0.JJ~~I
~'1\ "
Jj.iJ wlyuJ\ y.J" y\J
~ o~ ~
.. ~..
o.l:l..
J.
w)I W,.\]
u\.....aii.\\)
(")J
~. ~L .#..
o~y)4r- \ Y"" J1~ ~.»~
ul r
~1.SJ4 .u y\ l~ ~ l~l W 4J.A .iliJ..,._I o.l:l..AJ. .ut..lJ·I ..u ~'.<. ..
] (" )~I •••••• WI.J:'UL..ai ~ ~.•..1 .A. U"I:! Jill· ~J. t .1. y\ t~
•••
.JL..a ~J 4..JS11 u}.9~( y'11 ) .&\ ~
910-
Ibid, Chapt. XI (38) P328 St. Hilary of Poi tiers : De Trinitate, Book III (13) p65. NPNF, 2nd.
11 -
Ibid, Book IX (38) P328
1979.
.:•
~I.J:' UL..a1 ~jj.;A U"I:!JilIJS~J .:.
~ .~ J:C.
o~ . [ ..
. UA
~
~l
J u\S ,:?jj\ ~I
[r (A:" fi') " ~I ~J
U"I:!JilIJ~
Jji
Ser. Vol. IX ,
~\
tY"':!
ut.d.J'I1J, ~\
~
~ W.J""'l\.l1\ uts \j).! . (y'i\) ..&\
~\
c.} ~\J~\
. [ y'i\ ..&\ ~ ~
~
~\
.u~ ~\
tY"':! "
J.J""'I)I uJ~ ~
o~
'iJ ~j: 'i ..&\
~\.J""'I ~
~jl
T~ ~~ 'i . .y! ~ I.-
[t(j~'i J1.,AS ~
\~
un
'i
~.J:!
u~ , ~
4J~ ,
'iJ .
J!J
~~\ ~}J~~\J~1
443\
OJ~
('l)~\
~
~Jl
. (A:H'~)" 0A
~
Jl ~\ ~
~j: 'i . o..;:p
.u ~J,h,.'i ~
J,J1:J .:.
~\Ji
~ u~ , ~jl
: ~'l\ ~~~~'i\.~ l.Sj!\ y'i\ l.SJ~ 'i ~I
o~
. y'il w~'iJ
"Y~ ~
~~J
.~
uc 4l,h,.
c.} Jill
~,h,.\J ~'1\ ~J
. J 0~.~ ~~,.J
" •••••<.l:Io..A
~
ut.d.J'I\ ~} ~~ ~J" " 0'
•••
A
~.ft ~
( ~W\ ~\~'i\)
~J.
4J).! " J.J""'I)\ uJ~ ~
~.us ~ ~
~
<.r'~
J..,i:
~ ~'1\ ~.#\ wl.i.- JS ul ~).l \~J
~ w; ~
. o~yj 'iJ ~
~.u ~'1\ u} J.,ii
~
~~ JS ~.y!
w~)l\\
l.Sj!\ ~'1\ u4 u~.J:!.J'i\
~
I.,P
'ij!\ ~\J
' y'il ~ ul ~\
y'il ~
tJ:j\ . t.d.J'i\ . \ UJ~ . ~ u . 0:.
U"
' •••J ~
~ ~
~\~..,l
J!J
~J\
\~ .
fi) 'ij!1
'-F''\:jjl~ ~.
("v:'" ..,1)
t.....s..nLJ\ ~
<U.A ~~\
. ('\:"
~
~ ~ J "~ ~ . ~
.u..,i ~~ ~'1\ ~ ~ ~\
UCJ
o~
J
o~
c.}
.(r,:"O~)
~l ~ c.} ~~
u).! " ~ ~~ '.'
It'
••••
,h,.\J
JS
'ijl.::--; ~J
U.J""'l 4J}
~
~I
y.J
~ ~l ~
J..,i: .?o\ ~
c.}J
c.} ~~
ut.d.J'i\ ~}
U.J""'l
. ("v:' ,,~) " 4c ut.d.J'i\ ~J
~
\~
~J
0A u~ "
~ ~\
J..,i: ~t:i ~
. ("":'\..,1)" y'il
, 'f,,""' 01~1.j1fll
~.1;O-"" ( ...•.. /'11\+.!t..::.ul
~,yl~"
~J
Jly..): ~~I.~#
c.}J o~
~4-~
44.11 ~I~
, AU"", ''I H J!yl , •
-
\l
y)\ o~
';I ~I
J.."iS, y:,.'i .&1~
JS 0A u~}. (A:
f"
~l
.AIJ ~)';I\ ~
\~J'
~l) " y:,.'i ~l
I~ y)1 wi " ~
';I ,-?~J~}
ul ~
0til ~
... J';! ';IJ .AIJ lA.\ y'i\ ~J
: (JollJJ11\ ~,J3\l11 ~1j"J J.=i.IJ ¥\
( " f:' VJ:1)
"
'-?~ \J~
t~ " y~
" ~.J J~]
~ LoStaw, y'i\ ~
~l >A ~
~ J1.A JS "
y)U 0:,/1 J..,i
..?>UQ~IJ J
~
~
. (if J';!
II
J"
O~"
~I
~I
_i' :"0 ~ "V:' iUA)
~~l ~
y'il
~
u'l , 0:,/1 ~
~
~f
~
J,.-ii
,-?~l ~I ~
~
y'il
ue
~
~\
~J
U}]
(I"\)~I
~~
ue
~
UIJ '~J
JjL..J .:•
~.A
~"
~l
~
u'l
~I '\j'lij ~..
.A.J\
L:u~1~~
~
~
.
JjL..J .:.
0:'1\ utS U~. (i:''-;-JC)
~~ ~
. [Y y'il CJ.J " .wI (j'l.ill\ CJ)I
.:•
yilJ. y'il ~ .A1)l ..?>y:J1 ~.u
~\
'-¥9 y'il
.~ ~
~
.:.
u-a:J111J~J
L:u~1~~
('O)~~
J=9.ill
(j'l J~I
~)t::J.l .AIJ ~\
~J
u'l J
(' f:f~') 13 14 -
,~I
J!J
~~
J ~ ~1.A JSJ'
0:}.w1 .J4ic~ ~I •
~JI
y.J ~ ~\
u-JJ.+S
~Y:1.ill ~~I ~
• \\11.A.J\
"o~ ~~" ~.w~ ~\ 0:'1\ ~
JY:1rJ]
~.~.&\ [•
wi ,.4'i\
~ .AIJ.w1LoS.. .AIJ ~\.bL
~I ~
u) ] (' f) ~.)~'J\
O.AJ JLoSUl ~).l"
~I
.[ ~
"y'il
~y.a..il\
u-a:J11\J~
(,r)(Joll~J~1
[.(":"~)
0';1J
"~l
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book II, Chapt.IX (82)P234. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X,1979 St Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II , 1885 Book XI, Chapt. VIII, P509 C.J)l.uL....)!.J.~."..........)!.~ u--~I ~I ~~.J.~..,J d)l.,\.:;: I..j~ y:.YI~'+i _, 0 ''IV ~ ,'\" ~ ~t...J1 ~yJl
: I..j~
4iYI ~y; _, '\
~'11 .&IJ ' ,-:}j\ .&1~
~\
.u4! 'i
~ r-l....£j}
] (IV)'iJla.JLll1
~
(JJI-~...J,Ji.:.J;. c..J-I:!J:i.lI J,Ji;
, .l::l.IJu~'i ~ ~lit ~ [ . ~I
, 0"I~I (Jyl
~t
~'1~~
J~~
" ~t~}
~~~}
~
~ y'JI ~
~
y'JI ~
~'11~~I
y':J\J' y':J~ ~
".u~
~
.&\J
J ' y\..,;JIJ ' t.ol.fillJ
: ~,..,\QJf~"'Wf ~Li' ~ ~);.
.:.
y':JI ~J
_r
~:';Jf
~ti:JI JjlAl Jj\+w ~l
~
ut ~'11 . ( ':'
V .J:!)
~~ ,
~'1\
~ y)\j ~'11 olJ\...-<.11jJj\..:lJ\ ~IJ
UtJ . ~I
ut (.jt . (f:' yc.) y'JI ~
~~ .ut ~'11 ue ~
..-i ,:-.. 11 ~I .~.. 'il '-r~ ~
y'J\
(jA
~I
~'11 yl.6 ] (''')~I..H
. .-i"'-A y~ -"'Io.li '-r ..r ~ It"'· UtAt ~
.us.!,'~.~I ~tsA·
[ ~'1IJ y'J\ ~ ~)YI (.jt ,y)\j u\.S~
~
~'11~
~'1IJ y)\j ul~I ~IJ
. [ ~'1~y'JI ~'1lj , ~'1l ~
~
~~
18 19 , 'fJ'"
(jA
y'JI ~
~
~.;:S c..J-I:!.\iJI J,Ji; .:.
.u
~
(.j~I ~I~
~~J
YY\~
OJ"w. 4411 L..alJiJ,Ji;J .:.
" o)~ J:! ~ . ~t
Jj\+w ~
LL..::a:ic.\
Jj\..:lJ\ ~.
y\..,;J1 ~
' y':J~ ~'11 (jA
y'Jl uU u} ] (Y')~I
c..J-I:!.\iJI J,Ji; .:•
~lLUI 'i J... ~
1Ji~
t.ol.fill ... ~ b~J
(,,)A
u) ] (''')'i,)~'il
wt " J..,i; , " ~~
~ ~~ . ~'11J 17 -
o.l::l.J ~
UL...1 'ift:J.A
.J
~ u~} . ( f:' v .J:!
y'Jl ~ ) "
u:.::a }il
St. Gregory of Nazianzen: The Fifth Theological Oration-On the Holy Spirit , (XXVIII) P327. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, 1978 St. Hilary of Poi tiers : De Trinitate, Book III, (12) P65. NPNF., 2nd. Ser.VoL IX , 1979. St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, VoLII, Book XI, Chapt. III, P481.1885 01~1 ,ijlfll
~,(
... ,., ..'11~l
U,jl ~'
yl~J
JI.:,...):
~Ii~~
'A~,''\'\''
4411~bi J.s....>ll ,.
-".
~}
~~
~}
~
ul ~ '.:.J'JI 4;1" :;4-t.W1 ~~ ~ J~
.~L.JI
.[(':'
V J:l)
"~l ~'i\ - i
: y~\ ~
~
~t
0A ~ U'lJ~I ~ )t.:ill ~,ij
ul" Jt! 04.A'il ~ ~ ~
.utAS}~J '
y)U ~\
l!.~
~
.U~'il ~jJ 0:lH ~
T~
~
~
~
~\
~I
y.J
UlS
~
:;4t.i4
yYI ~
~ ~I
rAJ LhJ:lJ y~J
~J
~J
.&1
.
.J~} ~J'
U'llill~} ~t.J :yYI ~ rA ~\
U'l~
~I
~J
~
VJ:l ) " ~)JI ~
0:l'i\ . (f:'
fS AJIII'; ~J'
uJ
4..JS.I1 .&1 0:l} ~
o~
&~
~~
~I.illl
~ 0:l'i\
0A ~
01.J. O~J yYI
" .JY'"-:IlS ~ ~ ~.. 4..ltli .01 • ~ u.J ~ J ~..-:OIlS "'a"":"'J ~~I J f+A I~ <W.\ ~ W ~J. ~ " ~ I- ~.II '.ILAS . ....9. ~I ~ I... ~W;(jW:a.. ~ls ~~ '1 ~u . ("., V~) '+" J~1 .-:.It:i.A I..,?~.J .. ~ ~ (.)AJ •• " .u~ ~'il
~
T~~
LhJ:l ~~l yYI
(.)ol
o~ILA 11\ . yYl LAST~
~)
O~ uW ' Jl.b.JI
~fi
(.)ol
O~ li;i.JJ ~
T~
~J
~.\S.lIJ
.J~
. (' f:'J:l)" .&1C~
~I
~I
~J
' ;(j.,,!J' ~J
:;j~1
I..4-iI
u.~ .. (f" . yYI
(.)ol
~)
~
' ~.JJ
;':J..I ~.JJ VJ:l)"
~.J.
tAST~ JS ~ ~I
~.cl\j " yYI ~
(.SI.J] (n)'lk ~"il 4.i~
~I
"~I.J~}
' ;(jul J..".1J~~J
fj::.J Jjc.J ~
ul "
~\ ~ I...&~ .
li;i.JJ " ~)\
~I
UlSJ ... ( 'f:'J:l)"
~~I J-..\I ",u.,,! ~~
~~
~} ~ ~
~bil\ ~
~I
C.J)l.ut...j.J .~~
JJ .~
C>-o ~I
dlb ~.~. ~ yYI ~
tb.J ~
T~~
V J:l) "
Wb
~4
J!~~~I,
~ILA~
. (f:' , ~I
~LAJ 'U'lI.l1\ ~
.J~}J ~JLo....J\ ~I ~
0:l'i1 ~J~~j~\
J,Ji: .:.
.u.....a1~J, o...>U
:;.l1WI w~1
o~
~I. U'llill~}
. [~)I
(.)ol
tb.J
yYI ~
0:l'iIJ
.u.I.oS1~ ~~
~I t..~.J.~ ~ <.::UL.I.J:
t.j~
~\'I ,oo_,o1"~
~l ~\.:.l
- '1"
J-JI 11\~ O.JJjr~t JSlJ '(J'lJj£JI~)t:i1.I~IJ ~
.~I)I ~
'i ~
~)I.u:}
J~ ~
(" A:". 6A) " 0:..#
ue ~~ ~
. wlJA'l1 U:H {.)4rL!J ~I J.Jo'-Il)1 u-J..H ~
~ ~I
~I
~';I ~
)
o~IJ ojlj
J.J'"'l)1uJ.>: ~
J~
~
All ~.J
~
{.)4J~~I
All ~
~';IJ y'ilj
~ Ty~
, ~1.l9..\1 ~ ~t
¥- o.J.J"-'=l I~i ~
~ t~
~I
Ut Ut...J~ u~J.
t~
~4 ~
, Al 'J j\.-
~
~J
~.J'll
~
'-i.l11~1.l9..\1 ue
Ul....J.j~ y\
~} ~ L;..,! ~l
~.
(p
y'i\
lei~
y'il ~J
~t
tLbtJ ~
~ U-~.J
~I
J-JI 11\
wJA w.."J1~
wJA w.."JI ~
-Uj\j.~
~';I J~ (J'lj£JICJ)\J
r-l All o.J.J"-'=l ~ uts jl '-i.l11" ~';I ~t
~.l1 , ~I
y.J ~
4J~J
uts ~)t:i1.I'-i.l11~I)I ~
wy r-l d~'il
"ulj ~
oy\Lb ~~
11\ ~J . ~I
~ ~ J j}J . (J'l\.lll~ ~t
~"'-:I {.)4~ {.)4 ~
~ r~
~
J~ y'il
r~ ~ jl CJ~ '-i.l11" ~I
Al ~
J . All ~l ~
Ut ~I
U~ ut ~
)4, ~
~
~)4
"
r~
J~J
~ l;9jJ ' ~I
J,Ji;.
. ( , £: ~ I.:JC' ~
4J'l "~)I.u:}
I~
J~ ~';IJ. (' i:r ~) " ~~'ll o4=JI 4.l u~
~} " ~ ~J.
r-lWIAl1~t
~ ~1.l9..\1
~
oLbetJ
0-taJ~.J'll
.(' , -i :"~ ) " y'i\
y'il
~
~IJ
:t.\.ftl
~
All ~~ . y'il ojl) lei ~ > u·L...wtsjAj . ..J""'l
~J' ~ ~J
~I
All I"",r.,'ul•• ~
~
~';I ~t
~I
u'l
~~ y'il
~J111 J,Ji; .:. ~
~';I .~';'J
,....9 ,j, All 0 .J" AQ ·.CI '-r 1oT~J
·l....J.jts jJJ •
U
All ~} . ~t...u';1 4.llAct~ ~ . ~~I
~ All <.:Hl . ~I
. [<.:H';4y'il ~~~I
22 -
lei ~
\ --:.11 ~I ~ c.r~
' wJA:!All <.:Hl ~I
Ul....J.j';1 ~J'
~I
] (n)~I..H
wJA All ~ ~ ~
~
Jj~)1 ~~.
All ~J ~I
'-i~1 ~~I~}
~ ~I jyy
St. Hilary Of Poitiers: De Trinitate, Book III (15) P66, NPNF" 2nd, Ser., Vol. IX, 1979,
LJA
.l:l.10";:~ " y'il .&1. o~~
ul
JU "ijjl
.JAJ . (" f : f.J:l) " CJ.).&I "
.&1~
U~';I
ul ~I
uA
" 0..>".»~')J o~
~b
uyUJ y'i\ ~} ~~ .l:l.1~
~~"
~ J .u .r..?-J Ail •• ''i\' U c.JAJ ~"
~
LJA ~
~~I O~
~I
~\
t~J
j} y'il ~
o.l:l.J.u1~\
J:JIJ J:!).JI
.JA
ul " ~\
y.)
~I •. c..F1..:i9 ._1 r- Y'"'"
~.l:l.J ~I
~
-';;< r-
Y_I
c..F YI.. w'i\ <.,r.II
\~J ~~~\ O~\ U)\J: y'il
u\..bL ~I
-.:ul~~~
~I
~} ~ ~ ol.J:!J y.J ~I ~J . (f:' I..:JC) J~ . y'i\ i.?YJ y'i\
i.?1.J ~ ~1.) i.?jj\ ... 0~1.J
" y'il
:\f.J:l)
JS ~
~
y.)
••.••",i1-.F- ~ ~..r-
J~. ~';4 y'i\
~
~\..;: Y uWY1 "
"ijj\ , ULA)I ~J.o~ ~)\
.JA
.JA
.
~';IJ
i :i ~') " 01..;: Ul .J~ YJ U'lli1\
~J. ('" :ff..Po) " ~J
U~ LA~J. (\V,i
U~yJI
u~. ('
~
"ijj\ J:!).JI
""='
. o~\J
~yJ\
""='
j} . ~I
.ul
~
i.?j JS ~
J:!..;.b
ue
~';I J)G..~
u\..bL y'il
~
~\
~
ul "~\
~I
~I
~
" ~1 ~
y.) J."AS
ul ~~
~I
: U'llill~}
ukl i.?jj\ .JA ~\ " tJSJ . (j~';\J
" ~}
~li
~~~I O~\
u4 y'il
ul " ~\
~\
~I
~'1\ u1l!Uj . "
~
o4..1lAc.1 ~ ~
.JA
(~'1\) ~
~
~';\J
O~\J O~~\ .y9, ~liil
J~ ] (H)c.iJ~'i1 " LJA
~
. (i:' V.J:l) " U'llill
.
~~I
"w'il .
~J
W!iA o.l:l.J
A,ql" f'.r-
~JP U"I:!J1l1~
"i ~ " ~} " tJS ~~ 4..ifi.-!I ~~)
.:.
~';I ufi ~ ..4j yU
[. y'i\ 4.!yt.A ~J
~~I
i.?j,\1
" ~)
Uj}] (YI") c.ifl.:A U"I:!J1l1~
y'ili
LJA ~
~I
ul ~~~\ O~\ ~ O~J.
. (f - , :, V.J:l)
~
~J
~} ~~
I" w'i\ .
J
.:.
" LJo'llill~} 4.!\.S~ y'il
~
.[~\
23 24 -
Ibid (13) P65 St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. 11.1885 Book XI, Chapt. VII, P499 .
• YV,\ •
~~
,../il
~l
~I
~'il
l>A J ~ )il ~ .u }WJlA
~I .&1o~1~l ~
~,
J
] (ro)~l
'i,)~~1
~1 ulJ . y'il
...:u~. ·.II . ...! ~~ ~ . (JAy I.,? ~
~ J=JI .u'il -Lifi yj~ .u..ub [ , ~,~
~I
uJ ]
" y'il " ~ ~~ I·~I "(t-' ~,
~,):!S (JoIl:!Ji3\ Jji;
(n)'i*
4J~\ ~~
.l.l.::l.. -'I ·.. "'11 ~ Y ~
.:.
"
JjL"", .:.
~j'1~ Ll'I ~.J ~ [~
ul ~}';;I!!JutS l>A ] (rv)~l
Ji:- .&1~ •
0~ •• ~ [ UJi.:J1.&1
IW-
~I •
'1*
4J~1~~
. ...! .• 1~c.; .il1.&1 ~ I.,?..)t-"""
Jji;.J .:.
'1\. .J~.1~~.11
: ~'il ~y~l~
ul t.J":'l:! y4,1 " ~'il
y'il ul ~I j~1
~
~ y)I~.h.
y
~
" ~. - <. II -Lil ~"'1 Uy~ ' .1 ~~ c.;.ill c.r... '.h.AJc.;.ill ~Aa. t..F. 1 W~ c.;, .h.A~...I~ ~ . ( 0
y"
c.H'i1J..,i ~j ~J:!J . ~~I ~lJ u'iIJ Jj~1 ~ ~l ~
~
~Ij .ll.c. y'il 4:1 Wjl ~~
ula:! ul y'Jl c.JA yl.b -Li}i ~'11 ~ ~I
~I .
~I
~IJ
tAj~
-'=) " r3WI ufi ~
V
~I f"'1'i1UIJ ' ~j~1 ~I
y'il
J..,i ~]
. wyJl c.JA ~
f"t!1.ill ~ ~4
ul o~1
~~ ~ utSc.;.ill y.J U~J
<::1 ~jl e.,,-
..»: ~ jj"
(r")'i,)~~I~,):!S ~.JA
f:A-,=)
.u c.;.illy'il ~l ~ -Lil ~
. tJ..~.•...11 ~1.liJ1
~J ' .ul c.JA.ul ~ ~'il ul La.J~ -Li~ .
~I,
~1 ~
~ ~j J."i: utS ~I
~ ~Aa.'1 U'UJ....u ~ ~... . f"~J w~
~1 ~~
u'iIJ . ~I
• (0, , : ,
y'il
"
L. 1.,1""~
.J•.
(JoIl:!Ji3I'Jji;.:.
~l o)~'il ~
c.JA I¥
o4=J1 ~ c.;.ill~Ij c.JA oj)yJl o4=J1
25.... Ibid, P500 ()4'
~I
C..ull.uL...Jl.J.J.,...... ~l.~
()4' ~I
~I
~.J.~';
~\:i:
",.k ~y~~l:!-l
- '1'1
\0"
\ o~ ~
28 -
J.!l.J1 ~yJl
_ 'IV
St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book VIII, Chapt. I, PISS 1885
: 6:'11 ~ .#
~I
CJ.J ~l~ ~~ ~
.< . ,~J
.w. ~ _I<~. ~
~ ~. .1(' ~
rA~ wi)l
u4
~I ~';I ~
c.} ~
~
y.J
~~.A.;l
\...u
.)
.)c ~
JlAcIJ wl.J~J w~
~~\
(,)'l.ill\CJ)\ ~\.JA
~~\ y\ (j'l.ill\ CJ)IJ ' ~)I
.) \...u
.l:..~.u'i ~~
(,)'l.illlCJ)\
~)yJIJ . y'i\ CJA ~I
~~
¥\:j 0JAJ .. Y
c~.u
.
~
ue ~\
~\
f;' i.J:l) " .
(,)'l.ill\CJ)I ~
'-¥.u'i . (,)'l.ill\CJ)I 'i) ~';I ~ ~l
c~
Jt! \~
rS~J
~
J~ .:. y'iIJ ~)l
~~ <.S4J . l.hYU ~~I
ul..t:.;';\u~
~
J~ .:.
1.~ ~..
~
ufi.:. ~';\ u~ ¥\:j oJAJ' ~';~ ~
'i) y'i\ ~
J:1J~
CJA ~~
vY.jJ-Jiy.J:. ~Ji11
~';\ ] ("')~I
(,)'l.ill\CJ)I ~IJo:l ~';l ~J
. [ ~';I ~\
, '\ f U"" J,il..J\
30 -
~ ~
JlAcIJ wl.J~J wli....:a
y'il
.••~
[. (' 0_'
~.us L;:J\
l;u~1 U~
~';I f'~ w\j~~
~\~ ... "
(,)'l.ill\CJ)I ~\Jo:I ~
JS ul
(~~)'i~
::··''il LLbJI ~I -·'1 \ '11 ~I"I~ UA . I. . ~. ~ J...Y'"" J .J.J-'-'l ~
~I~. ~1 .J.JA4
).J-'-'l4~
u'i , ~';\
u) ]
~
~~I (,)'l.illlCJ)I
CJA y)U ~
y\~l
II _<~
<.,? I'
~
.l:..~.u'i~~
u1l.aS. wy\~\
. (j'lJ.ill1w)\:ill..l:lo.IJ ~'i\ ~ ~
y.J J~
UA ~
~\
(,)'l.ill\CJ)I
~I
_I<~. 'i.u'i L:P-' -=. 'I
~.
. (' f , H'; , i.~ ) " rS ~J
.)) rA~~
ue
~IJ " (,)'l.illlCJ)I
vYJi11 CJ)I-~
~Ww
~~J
Jo:I y'i\ ~J
t'" yJl
: I.j~
4i~ \"-i\,/.i
- ~~
St. Gregory of Nyssa: On the Holy Spirit, P324, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V, 1979 .
•"-VA.
,
: "~.a+t"~~Lw
w'~'~~'~~'lS~'O~~' •
•
•
.u ~
T~ o~lk.l ~
~~
ul "
·
~~
4-:!1"
~I
_.~,.-
.
I~ ~J
J.,9 I~J
.
.uk1 , o~
A:'"
(.$1, " ~I
~ (j'l
~ .... ~ I..uc.
WI ~ . "
,.J TY'L- ~..J~0
\.AS ~
y.J 1~
~I
~
1...
~.JC'
~
~IJ ' w~
'.'J1. 01\ w,JA wyJ\
'./-11
" y'Jl ~~l
uts ~I
" JU ~
~~~)
~
~~
y'JI
~
ul....U~ 4\ ~
~J
"
,:?~I ~\
~I
0A ~
• ojlfll
~.
~
~1.u'J\
~.u
uJ~ J.J'"'l)\ J~
Iill~~
( ... '../111+.11.:...;\~:
uts,:?~1 u:'j\ ~
.J4-l:a)
y j'
\.AS"~I
~ . (A:" fi') " ...~\
J uts,:?~l
ufi ~ ~~
] ("")~J~'il
~
c.r'.AA" . 0 .J.W
U"~\.tjl ~.all Jji; .:.
(n) ~~)I
ylb ~]
0A T~i~..r.Y rlJ
(' t-,' \")ul~1
\.:..I.us.1iil"-l~k...t... <:. U·1 U~
L.J' . 'il ~.L •• u'J\·1U ~ ... 'i" •••.JC' Ji.u ~,..1 T.AA . Ut.
W \",!.JC' )
o~~)
~
tU:.IJ
~
[ . ( 0:' VJ:l) "rlW\ tJS1\
~JP
u~... ~I
~J131 Jji;J .:• ~ ~J ~
ylF"-' Jly...): ~~Io~~
(t )'
32 -
.
U- .J
~l
J:l) "
T.l=..i ~
l.,?
w.J'"'lWI ~ ~IJ
· ~~
.~
!!
.I".o~ ~
· (A_ i:"~)
o~
Jji; .:.
wl . ~b.
r4lJhCI . ~l
(.$1. ("
_,
.
4431 ~IJi
ul..,jic'il o~
... (' VJ:l) ~
~I
.~"
.u ':?~\ J j~\ u:'j\ r ~l ~ ~\ ~\ 0.J~ .l=..IJ' o~ 0A .u\~~I ~\ .)c ~I.ill\~ rl iill 0.J~ ~ uts ~l ':?~\ " u:'j\ ue- J.J'"'l)1 uJ~ ~~\ J~
. ~
~ . J ~\.J.
~I
o~
~
J};tl ~ y'J\ ~ ~I
~ J.
~
. M"
.J.~
•
4.:i.ilc.1,~.AA...J&-"" W .. 1.:..1 . \A~" •
. [ dm w~1
~
M
] (n)~U31 OJ~
.J~l )
~\
~J
•
'i iill ~
U.r Y'Y ~
~)\
••
o.J4a-9 . o~
• A~"
"
•
: W~
"0""
~4J\
A.....I~_ n
''1'1'1' J.!..>!I, •
St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos , Orat III, Chapt. XXVII (39) P415. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, 1980. 33 - St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commertary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, 1885 Book XI, Chapt. VI, P497.
-t
•.•.
I
-t
o
I
. ~~'J
~ ~Y"'l\,j ~Y4!':?t , ~\
~
WI ~ Y"'l\,j.J.J~,~. . lJ"'=l (,j.lll ~.J "~~ t~
ut ~.J:!
~
·&..J.JI .II'.:.w Y"'lWI ~. ..r. u~
~Lo.lic .J
"J..,i: ~ ] (n)~~)1
ii.:i\ Lo.lic .J
•
lJ"'=lWIo~
u-.1:. ~
.II~.~ u.~ , u~
• ~ W~I ~
~
~~~t
(!I..:b..J~t~ . ~
.&. .J.J\II'.:.~I ..;~ u~.
~I .
(Jo'I:!J111 J~ .:.
·1 ..
U.A"""':l1~. ~
<\. U:!....>=". ~\ ~ • ~
II~. Lo.lic ~.lI ,tiL....ul u~ , .J ~ . [ ~ ~ JLi:l,:?.lIi~I
J..,i: Lo LJ!]
o~t .J.J!~I
u~ . ~I
w~I
[. ~ ~ .1. u:
~I
~~
uSl ~
U\S.,:?.lIi~I
~... 1 ~\,j ,:?.lIi ~I
~
[. ~WI ~oJ)yJI ~ y'll
~t .J.J~ill.J ~
~
UM~~I(Jo'l:!J111J~
~~
o~4 ~ ~
~
~\
t~
~
.-.1 •.lo. IJ..J-:!!"
J111J ..r-I...J. ili ••• (Jo'I:!
~
~,o~
(1"'\)UM~,J~1 (Jo'I:!J111 JjL...J .:.
~]
~
.J~
.•:.
~.1w(~y'l\ c.JA olba..JI
~~uSl.J4)t
~'11C-Y-:!
~ (':'
V.J:l) " ~!
~
~l...JI Wjt
6.t:i:- ~ ~e.r.J \ '~I .JY'" .~II 'J .J UA . jll ~ .' ~'J A.A .JJ:I. "'I
~ [ .~.. Ut ~j
c;~)1
] (r")~1 .•.•~ ULut
~~~I
'+:It " ~tj
u~.\,j~
(rv)~t
" ~~
~"
~j JY"'l)I ~
~
~WI ~j ~ ~
" O.J4c- ] I~.J.
(f.
)~I
~I
,:?.lIi~I
OJ"u, 4~1 L...IJi J~,J .:.
~Y4! wY"'lWI
~ w~)L\I ~ ~I
I~ ...
("':f ~ ) " o~ [. y'll ~LJe
: ~ ~!,y.;~j" ~~" ~USo~
~ " ~~
~.J
~
UjWI ..>#- ~I
t~ 36 37 38 39 -
~j
Ut ~I
~I~ ~ ~I
~t . ("
A:' ".J:l) "
_r
y.J ~).l
UL....u'Ji ~j ~
~l...J\ Wjt
St. Athanasius : Orationes Contra Arianos , Orat III, Chap XXVII, (38) P415. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, Ibid (39) P415. St. Hilary Of Poitiers : De Trinitate, Book IX, (40) P 168 . NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,1979. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book V, Chapt. II, (37) P289, NPNF, 2nd. Ser, Vol. X,1979
,(I f.J'r) wl~l, ijlfll
~,(
.. y'Jl 4;I.:.ul ~:
yl~.J
J.,...): (')
~~I
'A
va'
i.l~
44.11
~I..li - f.
''I 'I 'I' J.lY.\ , •
.uUJ....aJ".:iJA '1 ~I
~I
(to:"V~ .. ':<' ~r-
) ~.)~I
0\5. " ~I.! ~I
~4!
~J
~I
~
JA
J ~I
I~ ~
~J
t.J.l.:a ,.,;1 .011 ~\..iil W~ ~ . wy-oJl ~
~
-0:;'1 , .• ,jjjj.~r!.)~J _.:.. -'I ~ J'jJ ..\...(...)0"1.) . ~IJ , ~. ..'''1 ~ .'e' ··'1 ub .)~J .. J
I.! J~
~I
~
~I.!Uyc.\ ~ J . (0" JO, :" V~)
0..,5~
".:iJA'1
.~
(r''\:' 0.JA) " .&\ ~} u~'J\ I~
~IJ.
~
j41 0A
U:!~I)I ~~\
UC
~ y'il ~
wl~1
~~J
~}
oj~J
: c)}'il~I..H ~~I ~
y'i\ 0A ~ ~'il ~ .~
'-T-
.ul '1} ~
I~J . y'il ~y-
.J...~I'
o~
.ufi
~
cJA ~.1"1
tJ.lIl
...
tAi :
~~I
c)}'il wI LotS
~
':i' , ~.l:~\ o~1 ~
06
..
~ L•.I.lo.ol:lo.' . ~ Ie'
':i~1 CO; 'ull t..J""'l:!J ~J
" ~)
~i
. ~'i4 y'il
~
~
~~Y":!
~ ~I Jjt....a)1 ~
~.
: ~~Jf"" ~
\"lji LotS t~IJ I,JJ~
<i.i31~
~i
1,.iJk.i
u~
~ ~
I••. uUJ....a ~I e.r...
.u'J1 w.il
~I
-~
~I " ~I.!
01 ~.l:~1 o~\
(r',":'
V.J:!)
~,~
.f'
Ji ulJ " [ Y Y:' V ~] " ~IJ
~
~J
':i~1 ~I
. ~IJ y.~1 0~ (j'lJ~1 w)~1 ~~ I~ jb:i'11 I~ ~I
~
~
".:i JA)4
.y td •
~IJ ~I ~I
".:i.J""lu
~\ 0~ ~I
r-.Jli\
(y.,. v~)
.)~ Lb ~L ~ I,..~...
~~ ~ ~I
~1.u~
oi.)
~. ~\.1i11....l)1 . .. ~I-*
'O~
~ ~ ~I
I,..'0. -'·\1 ,~·"··\I er-...r--.J ..~ ~. -"'-'.:..ubl ~ ~ I~ . (' '\: r~') ~I
~ ti.) ~I.J
. " ~11.j~1
~
.uh
~I
\.l.J.- J .JA:!.. l!U~ • f" .l11wti~L
. (' V:o fiY) "
'O~~
'0.~.II ~.J .lJ~1 .. . ~
t-""":!
~
1.j.iJ1...r.JI~.J
.(o:r ~)
Uy-
(YV, y.:y ~ ') ~~I
~I
~ ~
~ f"~ .
I.j ~I_""AII c..--::---
~.J
t -""":!.1....l)1~
oLbc.II.j~1~I
~I
)..J'Wl~1~.)t.- ~.J
rA··-4 u~yJl.J
val)1
.JA
~I
_ ....AII ~\j c..--::--••
~\:i.I1~I
~
c.J.).J'&
~~~I 'O~I ~.J' "J)I~
f~l.J IJoi M " ~I
~ JS1I~
~ ~.&I
uM'
illl ~
~I
. ~ c..Jo4
uJ~
(yv:rJc. ) ~..)..,.-...J4 ~I
"o~~O.)~~
~)\:i.I1 ~ 'O~)I : " ~I.J ~ -4~)-Jl
.
~.\.:..-:.~~ ...
Ab. ~
,Y .:r~)
uts d " J~)I
va~1 C.J)I ~~.J
. (0\ o£:'\~)
~WI ~4i1I~.J
. (Y'
~ ~I
~I
(' '\:r fi')
Jill ~).i::,j'l4.J.
t.JSJ1..)\.c.1 ~ wts ~.J ..11 r-- ~IL..J ,'--l..l1.....J1 ...
uLbc.1 ·~I~..) .. ~ .J ..)l...a.i.ll· c..Jo4.J <..J..
~I
~ wt;J1 ~
"r"~II~WI ..
. w..,.J\
Jti 1.j~1.JA ~I
y.) ~
J1:.. ~I
' . lill
.,.9
~
f"ti ~1~4i11 ~.J
~
~ ul.J" ~I
• ~
~
~I '--l..l1.....J1 ~..J . '-'"""""'.J -:.-II ~I ...
U.o ~~I
1.j~1 ~1.illY ~~
w~
I~ ~
I.j
.. ~
rd"IJbcI
~ oi.) t.JSJ1w ~ u,uu c..Jo4
uS! . ~'11
...1 U'""~
~ ~I
\.l.J.- J J&'" .::<
~Iji~~ ~I
J~ ~
4.1~
' Uc.ts'O~.J ~ -~I)I
u~'i4 - ~
~I
~
. ~11.j1
. Jlb.J1 J.)UlI ~ ~'1I.J yY.1 ~'O~)I
~I ~'O~)I
~
~~I
o~. ~~~I
'i
~ ~
" -:; -
_.,Y
V)
]-
,;;; ~
:I)
V)
1,
~ -:; ~
'J
..:)'
''\
<t'
"
•
" 4
-,
~
-1 ••
'\
J
~ J'
•• -
~
~
-
••
-1'
-:1.
~
< .,'
V)
'-"
Y
-
J
~'*) '.~
~;I:;:J
. '3
V)
'-"
;:
~
':v
~,
V)
.\
4
V)
VI
.:.::J
~ "~ '3 ~ -:J
V)
~
.•..•
'J
J' ''\
Q.
.~ ~ J' j= 3 ~l..1)
=1 -.,] ')
~
~
~'J
,;I'
,
II
'J '4'1
~
-
..,
~. '!), • •
~":J
-
''':)
,-
y
...1
')
'-"
-
;:)
-
,-
'4'1
1 V)
U _
_
.
-
V)
V)
-
V)
-
0 ,-
~ -
V)
J.
~
.,-
~.\ 1._
J)
=
"?
.j
•
~o
,-...
~
~]
~o
-
'~:
0
-
::Jl
J
~
'.o!f
V)
-:J
";I' J
1, ~
-...,
~
,
V)
-:J
~
V)
1)
t:."
-:) -
•
'
j'
1j l .
~ -=
:.-.
•
!I J'
=
-
•~
-?J "~
~
:
:;:J
1· 1 -\' 1 ~
-
-
~.o!f~.
t ~,A· -=' '1.
'!),
_
.:;)
]
..
-
_
V).3·
'
0).
. It..
]
~";I' JI:.:J
~
~
X -·1
l~.·1
V)
JI'
.
~,J -" J'
'*)
l JI1. sa- ~_ ;jo ,~
~
~
~. l - ~ ~ )\ J- '7j.'" ~
.,.
.,..
~,1. ._
\.
)~:
~
~.
~
~
J';J).
:
~
3
;;1
j
~
1..
'1 ''\
:!l .~
'c.
~.;;I' 4:' '~ ...., ~
'c.
•
'1 - ~ l.,.,
i
'1; j, .~ '\ = j j, ,~,:;:J!j;3 "1
_
"
~,.
1j .~3' .].' =
~
;;I'
~j ~ ''\ ~j
1 ,- ::I' ~o
0
') ~J'-'" .3
,0
..1 .~.~ ~.
,l;l'
'"\0
;-'~"~
~
-a.
1 ~~. VJ JI' -:J '-" ~ -
"(.J '''L
0).
-
-
.~ ~
VJ
,,';
l' ~ JI' ~
V)
/0).
l'
,
.V)
-a
-1' ":J
't1. ~'
:J'
''!I, . ')
V)~' ° ')
o~
~~, ..., V) :1 J.,\ ~:=:! ~. 1. 'J ~ -;IV) ,~, ~ V) ~ JI0 ~/ -:J -l ~ . J _ _ -:J / :J .~~ ~':J 1.'?';:) .~.~'~ . 'l..;;j' JI 1 ~ A ~....:J V) -
1
:;
~,-
?:;....1 l' ~ _ l' '-" 1
.J'''')
::Jl II?
'''!-::Jl
1~ •~
3
n -
>; ~ ~ -'
~
-
~
1.. . ,
l' -
~
11 V);:)
':J~.
1
'.
•.
~.3. "' ,J~ ",: --;;~', ~ ')
-./
~ ...•. :il,
V)
:I)
~ ':.
::Jl
:J' -
-'I',:;:J,
)J
:.1' ~ .~ ,-...
- ,::' '-
~, ':J.
j t1 ~ ~....:J'
J ~ ~. S C:-
l---
3 ':.
'A ~
J' "3. ~ J'~
,,;:)
~
~ 1- ~~ '~. ~ ~ 1- l' .~ ~ 1~.~~' i -\j 1. ~~. ! ~~ '~. ,~, ,J' ;J -:s ~ = :;.~
~
J.
')..:)
I~
~
-,.,.
·3
';;-'J' ~
'1
.••••
....":
.CO)
~~
;";J
'.3 .-
•
::s' -. J j'
; 1, ~. '-l; : 'J
~
"!.I
8
.o!f
~
.J'
-
'
-
"1
'J '-" j
-
l---
~, ~ ') 1) _kJ
, ~ •
't~
0).
V)
-
.:.. .~,., '7j. .~ JI' - '*)
o~
~
0
~. ·V).1
.o!f'
~
-::5 Vi~
0
' <t' "\ ,;I' j.
~
~. ,~ 'J ~ - 3 7'
.•1
• \
'3
;\
,0
~ "\- ',f'J
• >oJ
-=.
4\ ., ~
~
,/0
'J
l
.~
. .
~
V)
'\ 0'\ .~ J "L''\
~:
~. ~j1'\
J
~:] ~ ~ ~ : . ."}0.::J -~ ~')
~
J.j -, ~ ':.J
o~
,]-
~
•'1
~I
~
.JAo~
':$j,ll~\
USJ. ':$.);'1 w.JA~1u~, ~j.) ~'i
. ,:.l'l~y'll
wY"llll ~I
~I
()4'
:~
~I
w\.sw! • ~ 2»1
w~"':ll (.).I!~
~.J
• " ta.:J-II ~I
~~j.)
.ili:.
()4
dil
0 J+4:!.J
;(jYGJ.t..A'ii J)L:... ~\
illJ ~I ~\
.~
~
\,.;(j
~
4J~
("r':'n~) ~IJ ~~~I o~
~~~ ~.us!,
'~'il
U.~..
.\~
.)WIJ Ul~\ ~
~J
~J
I w~ ~
lYWI
'+l..? ~I
'.IJl.a\~.bi9
~J
w~Ie.~ Jl:!-I
U..?J ' ~I
u~"I\
••••
.\'1\
~"P'". ,_"'1.:.1
wi..,! ~
wyJI oblJ. ~..r.J\J~\J
. ~J
~.)J
A..;I()4);! ()4
' ~
JS ~
~J
'1 ~ ~)\
~~J
oUJc,J iill ~\~
~J J~ ~
r-lWIiill
~
~J
Jyu-l~J
.
y'll oJlj elbl ':$j,ll~J w~
~
~Lu.J\ ~
~J.
." y ." ~I ~ wYGwyJI ~
~ JJlI
~
~I
. ~I
~\.ill
o~\ ~
r-lu~"I1 0:J uJ t!1)\
~
u6. ':$1
':$j,l\w!)\
~ ,'-..11
Ji
~.)l\J
~
..... ~~
~
\j-*:! ~..;.:..
ul..U!U ~J ).....::1 WiW\ .J#- iiI\ 0:J .JA
w~
~
y.) ~ ~
_ 0
[ ~~- ~, :' ~.J: ] ~
: w~,!1(.).I! ~
~
~(r':'A~)
: ~~JUb.J1~~Jt.J'"'l:l~
~I
, ~\
~.),~,~,
0~
~41 te.y...w
r-I~J ~~
':$j,ll~\
e.~ Jl:! "
~Ij ~
~\
~a
"
.
_ ~
y'llj
0:"11 lJlc.1~~J
~I
I~
4J~ " ~
. (' i:r'~)" ~~~\ o~I oU ufl ~
~ u' ~ .u-.J ~ ~I 'i~1 ~j ~ ~ ~ '.i.:J1 .&1uts d rJWl WL.-.o ~I ~ uts.&1 " d:J , ~J ~ ~I U:..waIu~ ~ ~IJi J ~Ij ~ ~j ~ y'Jl .&1u~~(' ,\:0 fi") " ~Y\..\:a:..~ ~6. .;#- , ~ ~'il ~
y. y'Jl ~
u~~ w.d. ~y.:i1IJ
~IJ
y\~1
~ "-a.A
. y'Jl ~.JA
~IJ
4,.j~
~'il ~J
:~O~J-J ~I
~I~ ~
~~IJ
~.".JI ~
o~IJ
. ta:J'-'I ut...u':J1 ~j
~I ~J
~ ' ~
u' ~
I~J
~tc.l..i~ ta:J'-'I ~
1ja ~fli
"~!t~!t
.,,J WI J.taiJl ~iJ ~i~! J'tci~!" [ ~v:~. ~]
~iJ ~i J!.w..i~! ..."
" ~!J~!J
[~Y:'·M]
: a...ait u.£i
.u ~):-
u~~.J"J1
'l
...
~l~} ~
~
" ~Lill.. ~
~l
U-'~-' '
~
~I
.la..l.... ~~I
~I
y4.}·i\ c,)4 _ •... ~..r.. 1 ~..
~..,i-,~y..}~} ~I
u\S.-,. All ~I
~~} ~-'.
uk u.J""'l:!~1~4"J1~.J~-,. ( : u-ill~1
~\
wy.'l u~~.J"J1 AJ9J9,1\ ~.lil
Jyw _:1 ~~ LWI ~l~}
~ ~l
.u ~-" . y.
~
~I
~ rA ~
~ ~~ ~
'v : ". ~) " ~}-' ~}-'
\.JA~-,~\
..M
~l-, ~l ~!
wy.'l I~l-, ~~.J"J\
:~, ~'1 , ~l~ ~
.u!-t
~tS .bi9 ~IJ
~ ~.JJ\.AS~)I
yl, 4J1 ~ 0Ay ~
~)yJI ylJ .uJ.JA
~"
4J1 ~~~
• ~JA
...# J '
~y ~
_IC::~-'1 lUIJ r--
.&..l11 . .J..r
JS
" ~JJ ~JJ ~IJ ~I
~)l
J.,li. 4..1G ~ y~ -' - • II c.~ - •... II A
~I ~J ~I
ul " J\.!~
J\.!\.AS JSJIJ~ ~IJ.uJ ~~ ~I
-,
J,ji: .:.
] (')~.J:u'il
...#
~c.S~
. [('
JSJI~LQ y'll , ~IJ .uJ~~J ~
W~~
V: " • ~)
] (,.)'(Y)~I UJ3,ji:J .:. t~
\...iJ.l.l:ar. ..J ~ Y-II oUJl.•J
LN '
y)1
~J
ue
'V : ". ~)
141. (
.[( i. , ,,'\:i J.J)
~IJ .JA
~I u---lJ~I
~J " ~';l J...,..i ~ ] (t)~J:U'i1
~JJ ' ~.J:I ~I
.JA
041 (,) ~ [!.&\
~ (' V : ". ~) ~0A~.JA
:a.i~' ~ y)1 UIJ ' .u yl
.JA
\.AS,UI yl y'll ul ~
~).l.u';IJ y'll ~ ~\ ,\!~.u
U~J'
01\ ~
L;lWIy.)l t........:::ab ~J'
~!
.JA ~
~IJ
4J ~)"
] (")~~
~JijJij.."l\
.. ~.'
' u.J:IJo.J:I.JA
~
~)\tl.u
123456-
w4 w~~ - r ..iJI J,ji: .:.
• '-'~~.
~
.JA
ul
U!iA ~ . ..r' .. 11 IS" . ~ 4..1G t.r'~IJ Y'll ]
(i)~i
,~_I':'.<:.~~.~~~lo
[
.: •
" ~JJ ~JJ ~~J~J ~I
U1.us.J~ 4ljly.c.J u1-9.uJ UIy.J
1[ oUJI -uts oUij ... .. '-J'll u·1·iJA rc')1 cs~JJ
~
~..J
UJ3jL..J .:. •• Q~~
IS"
~.Jr
St. Athanasius : De Synodis, (26)(3) P463. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV 1980. Ibid., (28) P466. St. Hilary of Poi tiers: De Synodis, (11) P6. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX 1979. Ibid., De Trinitate, Book XI, (8) P205. Ibid., Book 1 (33) P49. Ibid., Book XI, (10) P206.
0:'i1 (.)4.JS.l 4",\)Jyts U.;a.; .&1 ,,) W~ ] (V) ~~...)'JI [ ~I.~.
•
-.i fi-'~'U • 4..lJJ~I)l! ~.
ul ~~.J~I
~\
~I
~
~\
y~\ o~l U:H"-'.).11t~.}<l
.11"1\::.1. II \~.II c..stt"".U~u:~.~,
Ill::.
L::.~tY'lW 0:'iI1A~1
_\
~1..N\~)
~~.J~
~IJ
II
~l
: ~4~\ ~J~.J~
~J.
~\
~I
y'll
w~"iJ
~~J
~I
u\S. ~~l ~
~I
~
II
~)
~I
~I~'il ~
l.h~
t~.}<l
JS Jl~.&I"'..i'l
~l
(.)4~
~IJ
II
.&1~I
0:) ~~\
J: w.".JJ ~
~
yJI I~ II Jill .JjW ~ JA ~
w.il II ~I.i
0:) ~I
~~ (j'l ~
1..AS.( f : "
4..1~.J
~)
. ( "0
II
'...4~
w\S.~I.J II
~\.J .&\ 0:) "'..il ~l ~
~\..b;J4wlJA'l \ ~ ( i'\ : i ~)
y~1 ~~
~
l.S~1o~
w:1.Jl.S~1~."ll
.('i :r ~) ~~'ll 7-
c.st3l.J~.J
~.&I 0:) ~.&I
: 0 ~)
.&10:) ~ ~\
~~
' ~~k. y)U .
u\S.J.&1~
~\ uL~ ":'J . ....:.~"iJo~~.J~~(.)4.&1 y)1
~I-i
~I
. (" A :" • ~)
'&10:) "'..il~
_,
~I
(J'l:!~1 J."iS.&1 ~ ~I
JY'l)1 '...4ji J."iS.J. (':'~)
~
".J. 4..1
II ~)
~l
~).J
II
4..1) ~ y~1 u~ u~~.J~1
) o~IJ ~
I
.>.. \\.u
4..1,~I ~)J ~I.".
~
o~ u~ u.JC'~ 1..AS) , ~I . ( Jill
II
~
~l
II
~~J
4",\)~ y~l u1 ~
:.dJl ~!,.dJl ~ 1..AS ~J
J\.§ ~
II
"'..i11..AS .. t-.i.lL ~ ~::I\J\.li ~I . ~
~L..u"i\ ~~\
~I
.a.,ll : ~w
~L.Qlj6.&I~
wl..::aljicl~
.:.
~ ~\~.J
IS"
: ~~Jil II ~~~\
~J
II ~\
J:,.'i l.S~l
.&\
~I.J
o4:JI JW:~ (.)4):!(.)4JS U1J ( , f : , ~)
St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunornius Book XII, (1) P241. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V, 1979
~
0AJ
0A.&1 u:!
o~.»
\4u .. ~\
-uli..- ~
. ( ~ : ,£ ..,.;) "
oJ.~.=o.~~\
.~I~
"J
Y
~
u}! ~~ . ~I
~:u . o.;.A-Ho u:'il
~
~
J~ ult ~I
~~\
, • ..,.;) " AIJ y'iIJ ul " Jt:9 ~~J
u~! '
-u~
~)I
n 1\
:'..,.;
u:'il
~
Jt:9~I
" ~I.u
0Ajl " Jt:9~
~
4\!.JC
\~
o,H y~
Gu ~
(.SI. (~: £ ..,.;'
y~I" "All u:~0Ayl
" .u ~J
.u
~
, " : , • ..,.;) 4-1! ~
0A (.S~I ~)I
uLa:'i~ I.i.o~\lj
' -u~
. ( ,.:
(,,, o~.»
-I ] (")~1i11OJ.,u. 4431 ~IJi J,J1; .:.
y'il (.SI.J .ill ~i.J (.S~\ "
~{j
LH!.u! .we. J.;!
~\
4JY o~~
o,H c:.#J ~
~I
n 1\
" i :' ..,.;) ~)\ All
~bl.AJ . -u~"JJ ~J ~)yJl~
~:
Y~
W!" " 4..;l0AjY ~
~~\J 0A" Jt:9J
.(,1\_,0: ~\
..JAJ ' ( "
o~\
, ,.
:'"
..,.;) ~'il
.( ~ ~~ ~.JJJ.
4J!
Jli ' y~
~I
~~
i: ,~ ~ 'i: ' ..,.; ~ 'i: 1\..,.; ~ ",
. (1\ _ , ,£
u:'il
:'..,.; ~0 £ :"
V WA)
~
u.l.A ..JA~ uLa:'iIJ
,.'i·' i
,1\
~..,.;)
-
WA) ~I
~I
\~~.. 1_
.~
JI~'iJ -
-+
..
~I
n: 0..,.;) -u~"J uk J.fl ".:'A~i
A..;j.::~JU",:::J~1.i.o~ J.l1
~! "..J!~I
c:.PJ:!!J-J (" V :' , ..,.; ~ £ ~
~"t':!" 1 ••
j, ~
~
..:.
~\.c.
~.... w....u.I, ~~\.c. 0~ •
0 .
w....u.I1 • ~I ... \~ .1('
.. "t"" ~
•
~lJ"l
. [~j.JI ~ ~\
~I
4JIJ, ~
] ('\)~\
~)yJ\ AJ'j1
~~!
~\
ue ~I~ ufi ue ~"J
UL..I csftJ.A ~J131 J,J1; .:. y'i\ All.!
~~J
.u!0A.u!
. [y'iI~0A ,," •• \ J.!y.!
o..>--"I:ill ("I" ~\:ic..J~.".,.\' ~
,U"WI
~1 t;A.::..I~):
.;.JeJlo.l~
44-11~I.li '\ \ ..J),\
9-
_/\
U""
St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate Book XI, (11) P206. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX,l979
:~wY'~!~'~' U:s}~1
Jfi ~
y';l
u-o ~) J~
~..,1yJIAll U:sl<Ufi
tA
~I
_r ~I
utA)1 ~~ ~ ~1.J:W\-0A ~..,1yJlu~';\
" ~I
\A~ ~~I
I~ ~J.
" 1~
.JL...c A....JS.11 J . All A....JS.11 0'.5.J Al\ "ljc. u1.5. A....JS.11 J A....JS.1\ u1.5. ~ ~I ~
.(H,':'J:) -u:l All ~) ~I
~4-W
utA)1 ~~
J\.lil (jIl.JAUlI~
LJS.1J " : J.J""l)1 uJJ-;ll.l.Ja.AJ~J
0:!~1 (.5~
(jIl.JAUlI~
t~ " ~1
" ~~I ~lJ ~~IJ t....w1~ ~ ~I
<.r-~~
u1 u~~.J';1
utA)1 ~~ ~ ~~\
~J
b..,1.JA olYl u-o b..,1.JA J~J
(.5.l4y.J1~~I ~ ~I
~4
~I
~
c.J:I}J' All c.J:I},
4l.o
~J
' (
~J .
~4~1~
~4..i~ ~ /)~
~j
t~
JlU ' ~1~
o4:Jl1~
~1 u-o~J . ~)4
~
utA)\
~ .~)
~~
~4-W
• 1~ ~
uLp.. ~ 0:!~\
.:.
~ . (.5~
~
~t::JI /)~
J
~ J . ~ Y u1.5. (.5~I
(")U"I~J..»'i
<ltCl1
u-o ~ JJ
(.)o'I:!JilIJ,JL..J.:.
-u:} " ~j ~. (t : t Jc. ) " .. olYl u-ob..,1.JA-U:l
~ ~"
~::'~J u1-u:} ~J.
LH' ~~
LJS.1J "]
w . ~_:.\
y1 Ji:- u-o~J ~t::JI /)~
. [ w..,.Jl ~~ All ~)
~
tA.\~1 : Ul~
u-o ~J JJ~I /)~
/)~
~)
. > t!.~ c.s!~ •. >..\\. we u..u
) ~}
.. ~~I I~ (jIl~'
~ J ~ Y Ji:- U1.5. ~\
) ~~
')U"IJi;h' ,J;.J1(.)o'I:!JilIJ~
( ~)
y';l
( A : ",.
. ( ~ll\1 ~I~'il
] ('
Ya-';IJ
) (.5~
JJ~I /)~
~.J
t : t Jc. )
0 ,
~\j.
. ~I . ~I.illl c.s!.. ~ U~';I
.(
~
u-o)1 ~
/)~J
~
o~~..,11 u1 ~
LH 0:!..#~,oly}
u-o ~Ifi
~
~~
0A ~J ~m::"y ~
.[~I~~~'; J.u~l' ~~, t..,J.J1, j"WI
e,,\,/yJI ~
, t.~'.J
lJ"1.haJ1.J ~I
~I:lc-I j"1,w : lJ"~.J'~'
_, •
. ,,, U""' ''1'1''
11 -
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book I, Chapt. XIV (94) P216, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979.
u~'i\ ~! ~ ~\ ~\ r-~\] (IY)~\ OJ~ 4431 ~IJ! JJi: l:lb=J1 ~ u1 uLbl....a .u u~'i\ ~~ ~ : .u~ 'i ~ J~ w~\.l.o ~ (n" : f .J:) b
Y.JJ' (A :
y-A ~\
~ J ~L..a...J\~ ~.J:J ' (i -'I'
~);II
(0' _ fA : , .J:)
u.a) ~\
''I'
u~'i\
~I ~
U..,.J.Y:!J UJ~
.u ~ '
u~'i\
~!J .
~'i\
·( i0
- if:
'I' i u.a ) ~lA....J1Y~
· ( f i _f'
· [('i-' f
:f .J:)
.u~
u.a ) , (
[ .( "
~J
.
'
~'i
o..,ill ~
I~J
ue ~
~l
u~'i\ ~H ()4); ($i1\J
~'i
4431 ~IJ! ~J
OJ~
~ t!,) ~ u~'il
u4 '
'J...;~I l:lh:.. ~
: 'A u.a ) " ~
UIJ. All
u.a ) ~WI0:!~ u~'il ~~ J
~.nl ~I
\.c.,) ] (I r)
~y;. ~J1
~~J
uP ~
~..;iJ\ I~ -uj . ~1.li11 ~
I~
~
J:b I~J
~\
A ,)~-u1
($,)\.c.
'l'V : 'i
'J...;~~I0~1.u
~! ~
-u~ u~'il
~4-~
: 'I' 0
~\.fi1\
u.a)
: '\
Y.J~J . .u~'i ~
~ Lo ~
~
~ 4-
~
.:.
ue Y~ ~W\ ~
~! U~"
u~'il
:.dJ .r.~,Ho~
L~\I .
~(JA
~.
t'Y..r:-~ Al \..ii .i.Q
•.
~1~ \Jyww ·\..:.~1"~I. ~.
Lo1]
.:.
oJJ-W..~. ." l.lW\
(\t)~Iil\
\h..J: ~ ~l JI.! . u...>: 'Lo' ~
~\J!
. ..)A J ,
_r
.I.'A ••••
I......iJ~...r--' ·~·~\I J
.J:' ) " Al ,)'i) ~,lj ~ y~1\..j\.bc.l Ul tiLbl....a ~ Lbe. \j 0.# 0:!i11 JS Lo1J" ~1 J1! J . Wl Al I ~ JLoc.I ()4
J-S \~ ~,) u~j. ( , : f
o~ ~ ~ ~J'
u~j. (' 'I' : , .J:) "
()4j.}~..)A
~H
o~ ~1 LoS ! ! ~i \..j~ 'ijJ' o~~ •
~,lj
~
WljLo ~ll:1\..jjfi ~ \..jjj 1)...,i9 , ~
uylAyJl($1All ,)'iJ1IJ~
] (Ie)
Y •• ''- ~y..1••••. ..r\:il\("I"W\.ic. _.J
4...:i •.••"~I, _.r'
\..jjt...ul.•• ~. I.J: [ t.!i..l,) ~ JA'LAJ
L..a;l
~..)A1 Lo JS ~
()4 ~
l!:llil\ OJ~
~ U"WI~I
" J~ t"'"
wi'Y-'"
•.<~
0,)
4431 ~\J! y)\ ~
I...)-'-'
~.JA
JJi:J .:. . 1~
)·~t:iJI'~ ··L.1.J1 . Y-'" ..
••..•.•• 1~
. rv....rr~
rv ~ : ~I..JI ~~I i. ,
. ,.,. ~ ,0, 0" .>aL. '.J4\:il1 (~I .Y ••" •
00, ~
~:
~I..JI ~~I
wya'i ) : ~t:iJI.~.#o4411 ~I~
- IY _ Ir _, f
_,
0
~
.) ~~I
J . ( , • :'
wfiWl ~IJ . ~I
~
V ))
~I
~li
"~
~~I
~~
u\S lA \..lk.
~
~
J~
lJA ~
ti:-ol ~ wl . (
~I
1..i1S.&l..U~ lJA ~)I
~
.
Wl W~ . u)~
y)\j
'*' I.JC~
.
~l ~" c.) ~l J~J ~ _I.:. .11 wt:i _I.:. . r..r .ll~"i '-'~ J . ~
l»o~I ~L-11 ~I
"r : "0 ~ ) " ~~ . [f."t"'II.
.
: ~'~:WW ~
~
tJSjl
J.o\S . .&1 LHl ' ~I
J'
~ • ~
,! "1";J\
tJSjl ~
r~l ~
~I
U1 ~I.NI ~~
~I
.u . .u.J""'lU ~
t.s" o~1J ~
J.o\S J ' .u ~
"J
. ~ 'S""" -:11u""""" tL ';~I JS . \j ~~ ~~"il tli ..A)UI UJh~. . ~. ,,1.,1\(,,)a.l.I....:U. U. J. ~ . J ~-r-
WI
.~ • "
•
" ~IJ ~I ~l ~l
~l "
~I
. J.,j~ 4..JI~..~
O~
~(" •••,
"
~,~
J.,il ~~
y.J
•.•
" *
4..JSJ1
I _.
0.J~~
-
~ ~\./:ll~
y'il o.J:IJ' .u y'il o.J:I~ L;')'; LH'ii U1~
y'il o.J:lu~ . ~ . ~ ~ .:;~ .. NI c..s.J.fJ ~ ~I
'-- ~~ u-"
. u+9 . ~..J: .~..II w'il 0
(,JA
,
UJ~).!
llAL ~o ~~..J: I t.s" ~·.."'11 • 1....:.i"J I
. U
~j~1 o..AJ1~
~
L;yJI .&1LHl
~ L;yJI 11\ . " ~IJ
] ('i)(,)oII~J..»'1
~
~l
~I
~I
yl ~
. [ Uil~ ~ ~I
y'ilJ ~ .&1LHl Ul lJA ~)~
\.ll41 U~ ull~.&1 U1 "il ' ~\ .• [
16 17 -
. t '_: .•. ('1,
~~
]
~I ~I •••
~l " .u~
~~
~.uJ !
J.Ji:! .:. o..AJIJ
' ~'il
~
(,)oII~J..»'1 ~Ji3\
(\V)~I
(.;S
c.s~1ul
~Ji3\
•
J.Ji:! .:.
' o.J:l~. y'i\ UIJ ,~IJ
0;90).~
... 1 •
,'u"il
.....,..~
-'
\J~ ~
,'"" v--
St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book I, Chapt. XIV (90) P216, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979. Ibid., (91) P216.
, " ~l " J..,i: 'J
" ~l " J..,i: ~
. [ t-.lly " r5.~l J " , ~y
- .JA]" ~IJ ~I ... J ~
.J:i) "
~'1y ~'11
"~l ".JA...,P.i~
J\! ~ ~I
~
u.a ~\..l:l~~J. ~,
1J~t:i ~, -\ ~\"J
J\j ~,
4 t~
"
~
)1
.. 1 U""'~
.y \.S~\ , ~I
: .~IIJ\.ill
r5.~l J ~
JJ1:! .:•
" J' ~
wi! ~
w.JA)UIJ
~IJ
w.JA)U1u-i
(' A :'.J:i ) (' A " i :r' .J:i)
rA\..bc.t.9 , 0.# U:!~I JS ~IJ " u~'11
(' :r'.J:i') ".&1 ~'JJI~~ .J""'l
. ~~IJ
~~
~l ~l . ('\ : f .J:i')
\.Sl.&\ ~'J)IJ...»-:! Ul U~
yl
" ~l
u.a
~IJ I.-:N\Jul " ~
u-i ~~
~ u.a ~\..l:li¥- ~~ ~.J:i
('A)UMJi;h. ·J:.JI ~JiJ'
~l .. " oJ.~~4l..:lo.~ u-i (")~, iJ~ 4L:U't....'Ji J~ .:. . .u. ~_.~1i"'l •.._ ... ~--II" ~ ~.UA ~ I .Jt!. J'.. w'XW~· r...>.H'-'Y:1
~\J . ( r'. : , · ~)I
.JA ]
(''':
'.J:i)
y'X\ u\..bc.l~
U~yJ\
~l \J.):ul " J.J""'l)\
t . UA . 0~ .
~::1\ ~.JJ
~H
"
. ~ .J r..r
CJ.J ~~l ~ , w..?ll ~l
~w
,.J.
~~~I
CJ.J
~I \.S ..lliJ". I.': . (' o·.. AJ.JJ:\" w'X\ .• ~J .
U'lJA \...i.I\ W:.:j ~.
~l .JAU~}. (0: 'wI) (0:
'\
J.J) ~l
.):ul . (0
:f
Jc.)
i .. . [ ~~.. . ~
~.&\
~
~4- .
~..J:. ~
.&\ ~}J .&\ ~ .
~
~\
~
(oU.JA 'J ~
.JA
[ .u~u\..bc.lJ ,~~
y'X\ o~l ul (')-11 u.a] ) ~Y.&1
~} .JA~\
20 ~,
~\
~JiJ'
\.S~\ ~I~ , ~I
('(')(J~ ~\j
.
•
18 -
u-J..>P
~)I ~)..,.JI] ('(.)(JJ~'i'
~
...
~
~
'~
(J<'IJ
4-a"i' ~~ "'p'i ~
JJ1:! .:.
J~ .:. oU ~IJ
[ ~. :.~IL.&\ ~.tllt.9·L.?-l. ~\
St. Augustin: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John Tractate, CXXI, (3) P438. NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. VIII, 1983 . . t 0 ~ , ( "I" ~Uc. J ~.". 'i 4Jl...\ , u-Ul\ 4Jl...\ t'" d jwJ ) : ~1:iJ1 .~.#o \.i411 •••••1..li -, '\ St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book XII, Chapt. I, P663 1885 (J)\ ~t.....J!J.~-""""".)!.~ Woo~\ ~I ~J oy......,..i..:.)l...l:i: l.S~ ~Yl ~l:!J - '(,
no
~I)
uL..u!Uo~I ~I
11..1]
~I
t-lyJ Jtj ,~ . ( ~ ~~, "~~J
~~J
'
J
~
~,_.1
u~
(.S~I(,).II~' CJ)I ~)
" I ~ - II
~.
A
Leal • o~
"o)~
-ufil ~
rAJ'
" ~. t:. \.J _,
~\
~
A
~J'
~J'
" o.J4c ] (r r) cJ Jls,jUJI
.&\ ~
0J4c ~ .A.JI •
~
y'Jl
1-l.J •
ul
-
r
11:: U~
~jjJ9' ~
ul ~~
.JL...::. J ' ~\
wY"!u .u~J: '
~I
' .&\ 0A
" ~~ O.J..J"'4 11..1
(JoY:!JilI J.Ji:l1~ ~J
(.)J4~~....J.
u.J taJ~ .&\ u~ '-¥ -uY .
~WI
~\..:...~.&I
uY , ~\.u~ ~
, ( , : , .J:).&I ~ ~\
~ " ~~
us~l
U~J
_c::: 'I . II " r--e-. .J ~.
. " ~~ " .JtS' (,).II1l11 ~ ~
(' V: "'.J:)
~
.& b~)
,"
~
.u.e.y! ~ ~~\
~~, .& o~\
u1=-~~
( ~
:" ~!,~!"
_ c::: 'I .u AGQ r--e-~ ~.
"
wl.JA YI 0A
u-i~"
. [ .ut:i.o J .&1O.J..J"'4
~
u\..hc.lJ'
) .& o~\
~l ~~ ~
~"il U~ J.jL...J .:.
cJ~
uL..u!Uo~1 ~ US.J~ ~W\ 0A .uJ~.
~~ o~~J. ~~~I
~l
(rr)~l
.:•
.u~
~I
.[!Y~~ :¥ i~ L __ .1.:.._'\ ~ r::--'"" ~
• NIt ~..J'-'l ~\
~
(H)
~I"'''' ~
~ ~ J .u taJ~,
UI.S(.S~\j . UW\S ~\ -UY I.l;lc-
]
rJ .JtS ~~ ~
.li.l 4.J"i ~l (,).II
J ' .l;lc- O.J..J"'4
~
"
~!J~!
cJ ~."-I.~ (JoY:!Jill
yl ~
J~I ~
~l
.l;..J '
" i.)~ Jti -I J.J"7:. a1u •••
(.S~I~\~
.&\ O.J..J"'4
u-9
• [ AJ)II ~~ .u)'\
Ul ~.;
O~~
~
~~" .u# . UW\S
23 24 25 -
~~\ \~
~I
J~
]
c
(r
)
-U~ , " ~~
(.)J4~J..»al "
-ul
(JoY:!JilI J.Ji:l .:.
.& ~JCo~ u-9 ~\
. n" U"" : ~1.uJ' ~ yJl _n St. Gregory of Nazianzen: The Forth Theological Oration (VIII) P312. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, 1978 St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate Book XI, (13) P307. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979. St. Ambrose: De Fide, Book I, Chapt. XIV (92) P216, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, 1979.
" ~) ~l ~l ~ 0A ~l ut....u}S¥~I
ul ~
l.S~1 ~I~
(.)A"
~l
~l
(.)A
~
jA) "
~t .ul ~ .. ]
~)4'
~)
~~) (n)
u~,
All
J~
(.)A "
~I~I
~(.)A~~l
tJt....u1• .)l.....:.J.)~\..ij
~4.u1
( , :""
~ J ' ut....u}S~~ ~};iI:;.)~I
" ~)
. [~l
~IJ'
~y
~l
I~W
~ . (' • : "" jA) I~ J . ~l
lA.ili:.
~
JA I'"IJ~I ~o~l
...t ••( ~ Jill J.'.r::. ..-L. ••• u-~
~'il·
CSJ.
~~I
JA
yJSJl ~ ~~ lA ~
.ul
. [ All (.)A ~..,1ya~ -LiS.lJ ' T¥ ~
~l
JA lAl , ~)
.cll~,
JA y';lj
*' ~
~4
. U:!~~¥:;.)~
J~ " ~)J
(YV)
~l
~
I'"~I
(.)A
~L;.
W yo- J ' U"\.lI1 ~
~
~I
(.)AJ.
(.)A ~
ut....u}S~I
~
OJ.,u.
" oJ4aJ ~I
~)
4431 LouIJi ~ (.)A
JA ~
:;.)~
~l
~ .:. JA ]
w~l ~) A..;~I . [ ( A, V :" ~)
~JJ lAl
'
..••• _t..:.
•. u::-~
~
~JJ
t.l......::aJ ~ "'.J ~1.1\] ("") csk 4-a~1 lj~ JjL...J .:. -< t.l......::a J \--:' -(-, ~ ... V--.. .·, .••..•i .l.lc.:; .)~ ~l l.S ~I (.~ - ....All .l.l...JI ••
Al ~
o.)~
' ~
4.-olfi J ~I ~ I~ (.)A
~I
u~ "
'psI ~I fi ",.).11
JA
~J
~I~ ~\
(.)A ~I
" All '
l.S~\
~41lA JA
j~
u+ill ~ ya J ~I
'
~
ya (.)A
, ~I
'psI ~
ut....u) 4lJi)J U::
JSJI ~4 ~J'
~I
~
'
4.-o1.fil1~
~
~\
ut....u}S~I
u+ill ~ ya ~
<l:l. ~
. [ ",~I
26 -
L;1W\..,.s~I
4.-01 fi ~ ",.).11 . ul...Ul'J~) .)l.....:. J
Jl!J JY'l)1 uJ ~ l.i.Ja.A
. (£,f : f~) ~
1~i
~l
ut....u) ~
u~ . ~I ",.).11 ul l.S1
4.-olfi J JlWi 4.-olfi
St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, Vol. II, Book XII, Chapt. I, P663 1885 f 0(.)"'" ("I" ~\:ic. -' ~.,.'J~l , U"U11 ~II':' wl~) : .::.J~I.~.#i 4411~I..li _ l V <::.J)I~.)b .~.,..... ul!.~ 0-0 ~I ~I ~.J.~..,.i ~t:;: I.S~ \.,u'Y1 ~\.:.l - '1'''
no (.)"'"
~I
-u~
~
(.)1 ~
~.J-"'lu
~IJ ~l "
CP~US"
" ] (~~) (,,)MJ;;1, ..i- Jl
" ~}
°
.u ~
~l....u'i\ ~\ ~. ~ •
~H
'
~)I .dl\ ~}
.~ ~
~ y....u ~>.
IS""
~I "
.J.JA j.JI
" J.J-"'l)\ uJ~ \.1J- J~J .
t·< .
U:H ~.Jk>
. ("":""
. .<.1 wI., ~ /).J""'-
~.
U~
~l:J\
~
0A ~\
•I . . U y:.., ~ ~
J~ ~~ . ~WI
~
~,>!" o.)~ Jli _r
.Jk> ~ .Jk>~\
'o..:Jj~ -\,j
~\
l...- 4..JSl\ U-'""" .. <1 J {:j.J-"'lU 4-iA ~l ~I
,t.lt.al.:l.
. .J
-\,j.J-"'lU ~
~I
j.o ) "
J~ .:.
"- j1l"'".J ell "
\t
:~wY'~! ~" lfil . -.?J
~.1i.1I
-c::; ~..b.J....a "1 ~ . [ r-::-:J ~. ~ J ~
.
o.)~ Jl! - ~
~~\
\Y'.<.1 ~ ~ . . ~~
~
J ~ . ~ -.?} . . ~\ U. ':J
~ ..yo! ~~
U:!
. (" '\ : AJ.J) " ~..iA o-.?l ~J
0A.u o-.?} rA ] (r')~U11 iJ~
~.J-"'ll:J\ ~
'
4411twalJ! ~ . [~.Jk>~\
~~
~
..AI uA' (jo'lJ'G ~
~I ~~
~
" t~
(.)l....u'jl , (jo'll:J\J.dl\~ ~.JA:! 01
°-.?} .u .dll d ]
, l:J t=..1 .Jl...- -u~ ~\ . [ 4S\ .J~}~
~JJ
(rl)
~I..).l ~1
'.J:) " ~
~ /)~~)
] (rr) ~I
'i 4.J~ Uc. ~
~\S
I.;~
ue
~.J:"
~\J.u}
r~ liA.
lS# ~J1]1
J:.. J t~
.:•
J~J .:.
.Jl...- 4..JSl\ " 0 ':J lh.J:! ~J1]1 JJi:lJ .:.
~j
t....1:J -u~ -\,j.Jk>'i ~ ~ uSJ J
St. Augustin: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John Tractate, CXXI, Chapt. XX. 1029, (3) P438. NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. VIII, 1983 . t 1U"" (
32 -
uAJ'
~'i-u~J ' 0l....uj,S U:a~)\ ~
[ . (' i :
29 -
r~
~I.ill\~
~\J
0A
4411twalJ! ~J
~I
uJ~ U'l:!.li!1 Jt! . (' v :" yc. ) ~\
. [ 0l....u'j\ -\,j.J-"'lu ~
rA J ] (1"\)
~ ~ (-\,j-.?J) ~~J.
/)~
(0 :"~')
.Jk> -u':J -\,j-.?}
~
.:•
"I" ~I:ic.
J~
jo\
'i ~\ , lJ"UlI ~l ~
d';""
) : ~I:ill oJ~ 41..il1~1..li t1 -i 0 U"" : JiL..JI~ yll
- r • _n
St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate Book XI, (15) P207. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IX, 1979.
" y\:iS..11 J~ lA~
~.¥I ~
~...?l.u
~
(.5~1~)I
· ( 'f : , ~) "
]
~ ' (' : ,~) "
.J'.......::a ~IJ"
~
~11\
.I~ . [<J y:.,.
.j
lor
:uwY'~!~" "
'1J ~
'1.&1 u'J
Jj ul.S.A
oUA J
(.JoII;JU
..))..,.J\ ~.ul
T~
~l ~I
(JM~~.J.
(1"£) ~\
.b.
.r- J
, ~l
\.;, J '1
<J.Ul.....i1 ~ ,.~
• I . 1) y:.,
~~)u1 ~
. ul.S.A ~ ~
").J-4.JA
~I o
1)~I
J
y)I
, <l..cY
0A
JJ 'JI ~
~ ')l:j .JI.S!I ue ~lc.
'
"
~.
-yll ~
~l
~ ~
.. I~I' ,(,JA • ("e-'
~'~l;..oJ'
Uj\S.~I
t..r,II <:: t:i.:..J~. 1-l)1 ~ . ~u~ ~~~ .!\ Uj\S.~.-:II ~ tJ...)?-J... ~ I-l..IJo..u ~• • 'WI J (.5.r
I-l)\ . ~t~ ..)J
.J~- . I~. ~
~
~b~~J
~~ Uj\S.~I
J 1)~
_t .:.
~IJ ~I JS.lI uJlA .u'J , JY:!
y~ ~
: ~, rot! ~
.u ~
443\ tw.\.ii ~
'1 ..)~\j,
. [ ... y~~WI
y)I
u\S.
~l~!~i~!"o.J~Jli
" (.5.Jft:!.ft.\1(.)'I1.ill1~.u J~ lAS.
<J~ '1 1)~
~I
. <J~'1 ~
lA~J
~\..il\ 0A ] (\"O)~eJ\ OJ.jlJi
J\.i ~~I
J~,J .:.
~I
_0
~4§
01\ • ~
~
JA 1· U\S. J . .uaii .
. .L.'- .II 4Jb. ~~
'J
~\ ~l ~~~ 4-£1SJ~~\ ~..;J~ u~'il ~ ~l ~# J~ ~J . " ~1.J ~lJ ~IJ ~I ~l ~1 ~l ~ ~~J ~..?l ~l ~~l ... ,,~t!
· ~ u~'il ~ 1.J4i:! r-l t...aul ~ ~ ] (\"1) ~\ • r-::J _1<::-:. . ~ ~ Uu.I .11~~ ~u· ucJ ~ (,JA ~-:-':_-:-:1, L~ ~.
ul J~\
0A ~
... (
,r -'\ : ,"\ JA)
oJ.jlJi
~
~ ~~ .
4431 tw.\.ii J~ .:. ·1.ll ~Y~ 01JA,1·1<::. U i"""":: 1.J1o~ r-l
.b. '1' ~ ~~~ [ Y <J .r-cJC-
~ > ..l::lo.J
33 -
St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, Horn. LXXXVI, (2) P324, NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, 1978 34 - St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunomius Book II, (8) PI13. NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. V,1979 f '\e.><> ("I" ~I:ic.J ¥jA'J ~I • U"UlI~l t'" wi""") : L.J~I.~.#>~411"""bi _ \"0
w.....J\ ~ : ~t...l\~
yJ\
_n
,r -•.: ,'\ jA)
: ( , , : Y t -Jl ~ I .r &Q1.:... \ ." J.JC..Y?" ~I
.
_<:1
_"\I •.• _.
I" ,-
~WiJ .•. .1 ~\~ ~.I~-'*'
. ( "A -"
I . II:: ~I~
~I ~.J
~ ~ r''\
f : ".
"f
( r'V ..
...
: "f
. -.i u)\ f'ti J <or.
~
~ U~J
L.~\ ~ \Ji~
CJ..r.JI ~JA
))
Lo.llc. ~J~
t:...J.J \J~.1.:.: ~
.1)"
.J'"
IJ.J:J I~J
~I
r-;JA~ ~~\
~ ~J
~I
' ~
r-;JA 01
~~
~
01,S~
r-;JA I~
~
-.r.'
I
'i
o~JJ
o~
u-lJ
l:i~J
~~
~~\ ~ I~1,S
LoSJ
tA~~
...
y)' ~4! ~pi ~~I
JA ~
~
':'1':II \A
W!~J
.u\~ y)\ 4-l
\.S.il• r..s1- I. I ~ ~.~ '"e-' ~.Y
.J
~
I~J'
J.Ji:! .:.
~WiJ ~.
~~I I~
A
~jA_~
J ~\
<':'lAI. ,t•..•I
~~
\ijl '-_-::--.... II (.)'I~·1-.·<:1 ~
.wLil ~
t...:.:.JI ~J .
".u
01 ~lc~J
F 4l..S1~~.J.u wjti,
•
. [Lo 0tsA ~
Jj ~\ l:i~I
. ('\ :" AWA)
~
443\ ~\Ji
I"""e-' .. :'I·ti \~J.J:lo. .. . ~J.• ,u)\
'0 , 'r' ," :" ·~) ~I
I' U .J~
~
J tc.
0A JJ'-'l ~ ~\
,~I JA Io...U\..l .>.,' >.uosb..o
LJ! . (
OJ~
~t....a j.J \A y::u ~ 01,S~\ ' ~I
01 y)1 ~, \\~
II:: u)\ U~J.
l..S~\ ~J
~.A
. ~Yill J.J=l" ~I (.)'II yJ\
0A t:;...J:lo..l.o ~I
LoSJ,-_"\I ...
l:i.A~"
J
(rv) ~\
r-;JA ~~]
'11.:.,.....,.J 1.:. ,~~)
: L.~\ ~ ·!.1.'iu ~~I l..Sy.YI
-I
~ ~\
-uJ : 01..A;';1
~Lo l..S.:llc ~
: ~"L~~--+ 'i l..S1 " ~ ~~ ~J
~IJ ' ~\
'i " y)1 4-l JU] (rA)~~1 OJ~ ' ~
~I.J
W:!I.J 01 ~J
II ~ ~I . [ ~ 1'-5"'..
01 ~
' ~I
' l..S~
\~J
'I , -A'I U"" ' 'I 'I 'I U".)1.. , • y\ lill ( ••••\.,lill ~
:"'~'i
' ~Y-
~\
.:::.uL.b) : ..:.JCilI
J.Ji:! .:.
:,JJ ~~
.:l~';1 I~
~t....a~ ~J
_I .~ ~\ .<: . ..i i~ ~<or~.
4431 ~IJi
'O..l~
~J
o.:ll''it"'"'' •. >. 4411 ~I..li
'I' U"": ~L..l1 ~~I
_
rv
_
rA
ue ~ w~'11 w~
wt ~I
~JA uSJ . .l:..IJ y'ilJ \~
J
,~~.
~I ~
.J::C·.wt
.J
W~ Y (.St" ~
~I) ]
(n)
.w~ w~'11 (.St '~J') .)..lJ::lc. I ~ I~
4.J
.
.u~ ~
Y " 4-l
'i (.Sjjl t~
CJAy \.+JY. ~I.:JI ~J'
~ , t~
J~ I~
[~
0';'
-""
JI Y '''Y WjtS U~l .. . ~
rJ
~Y "
~t:J~
~
I~,I\~\.c.~} uk ~
<..r.~~
J\y
WL...u~~
ut u. .JL• ~-...r "u.i...c.'~t.A~
All
Q~J'
.
• ." (j'l)J
Wt ~..;b
~
wt CJA ~
" <..r.t ~} ~ ~t •
OM:I.all J.Ji:! .:.
~JiJt,";"Jt
'-S ;,,,,01,,,, .. ,
:~ • <..r.t ~} ~ ~t . " ~}J y)1
USlJ, ~~
~
. tSi .. ~ U I
cali~
'i
t.J'"'l:!
.
t ~.".;
e}.iI1 ~I
(j'l
o~.)
~
~} ~~} ... " 4-l
~ ~~J WjtS ~I
~~I
\,j~t
t~
~I..
II I.....JtA jjL. 1~- - ~\(' J . " c.r..
Ij1 ~l
I~
. ( , • ~ : "A
wt.) \.+J}~
39 -
.wJ.J:!~\.1\J ~\
~'i
JF-:!
Ajjli ~I
~} ~ ~ ~ J ~~}
.."..ti 'i : t,JoloY; l+l JLi "
wtiilb l4Al\.4J . y)\
w..a )
~
. IL '- -II J t..J:H~
~} ~~
(":lJA~~
~t
d
cali. ~
"'WI U::!i.I
t ~t ' ~t J <..r.~}
.u \,j~ .J... ~~
4.A4§
USJJ
wt ~I..i\\ y)l
w~'11 ~
~} (.Sy..Y\ (":lJAJ ~~I
l4Alli'i
~~}
WjtS I.....J)I4.AW! ~ .
tJ.~... .. ~
J\.i .wtJ . wi JAYI CJA ~I..i\ly)1
J ~I
~~}~}
~ y)\
" ... ~I """1~ ~I ~ t.-r'i ~ tc.}! ~I
.J:]
.u....oW ~
(":lyJ ~
~}J
'V : ". ~l
.)tSit, UC U\.c.
.~t WjtS ~. ~II -l1l...o (.S..r
. " ~}J
" [
J,:...\~wus.YI f£),j ~
~~ J ,~I..
4JL...a..H ~J
4-l J\.i
<..r.t~} ~t~}
Wt ~'i wtS .WJ' 01.;. 0.11 ~J
-.I~I· ~ <::1J . ~
~
~tJ
~ ~"lll •..•0~-.~II
4J4=a-Y~
~}
~Y ~
~}J
o~
.u~'i
rJ
.aiJJ: ~JJ
Cj"cltJJ
wt ~
4.A~ ~\
l4AlAJ
-"L, J\.iJ J tlA.li::l!" t.A$.l 1"~}
\.J:I--A ~
Wt ~ 'i~
St. Augustin: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John Tractate, CXXI, (3) P438. NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. VII, 1983 .If.If.
La~ (J'l1~1 utS ~, ~
4..;Jl.b ~~
I~ ~ ~
~J
~I
~J
u. I·UA
~• .>J~ ~
"'t-'
u-o
~I
1- I. 1 l::...JJ
~
utS u=JI
~l....aJ)1.Ay::u ~
~I
I~J'o'l ~I
~~l
~..)A~.)
1. - ~. , ~
~
~~I
'~11!1"r\,,,1
~I
'i ~IJ, ( ' tA UlSA u-9 /)~JJ
~J
~..)A
ul IJCul ~,~4i11
Jya..
"A
U.4)
. (
'0 -"
:
t
w!Y-J~J :Lut:i \"'t-'. I ...>t""" .. I:. l.J! ~ I..-J)\ .
~
'0 , H' , " : ".
Ul j~ ~ ~
~~
/)~
I~J
J:!)
..J-'O'I:!
~4i1 ~I
1.A).$.iJ
' utA (.5j\.c~.ul
:
u~'l\
~J ~~ ~ ~ ~Ji.!~! ~ jl USlJ "
, ~~'i u-9 y'il (.5~
~l ~
" ••• JLi.G1
.u ~ , ~'I~.
f"'f-J 'I/)~~
, Oy..,J 'i
j~1
~J
.Jil ~J
~)I
~ ' ~.Y-'IUu-9 JC
J,.atS J ' ~ ~ 'i u-9 J,.atS ~I
.l.I'I·L~·-\~L....a.il~,·<1 ~ u ~ r ~ .'
I~
'i ~\
U1 ~
rAJC~
U~, /)j~ ~ U-OJ ('" ' JSli uJtA.u'1 , JJ.i:l 'iJ ~
~J ~j~
~J
~jiJ
, I..J"*'J, ~·.ll.'i~o·l ..T" •
" " J.Y-'I)I uJ~ ~ :"~)
'i .Jil
u'1 , ~)11
" (.5.J~..Ji.l1(J'll.lill u-9 .u
"
J~
I~J
" ~IJ t-.:. _\
.Ai
.Jfr '
~
~
~I· .u ~)I
t_.
~
0~-~.II ,U~.J'\tl 0~.~.II·~ J
.Jil ~J ~
, " ~l J
, ~,r , '" : , J:!) ~I ~
~..:II
II"
UI..lo.I,
~
~I ~.. :II t .>J'. UA 0~ . ~t.
~.Jil , ~
~,.
~
Iftl
~l
jP.1
u~)\jl ~Jy~
JLi.G1
~ .~II.Ji1. '-'? <-H.1~
~1 " " JI.!.usJ " 4Hl
u-9tyL..- , ~ O.Jy-a t~i ~I~ Wfil"
~J".u.)
u-9 J '
u~
~J
ul~l
~ l1\ ~J
~1
~J "
~li:ll,pJ tAl, y'i\ u-JA'iJ .JAY!"J 0~ . u...u.l~, (' 0 ',J.J A ~,. ' r J:!
" JI.!.usJ " ~J " ~
~l ~ , y'i\ u-oj)yJl ~J .JL..- J uL....a.i~ ~I , ~.Al\ u-o UilbJ
~'l~ y)U
u+ll " #Jji ~J
" ~IJ
" JI.! , " ~JJ
~
~l " #Jji ~J +
, (J'l.lillCJ)I u-9
.ufi ~ .u'1 " ~J
~I..§
utS /)j~
' ~~
JSlI ~
.~..
J~ I~ u-9J
~y..,J~~
, "
, " ~~)4
UM:l \
~I
~l
~ ~ ~I
~~
u-9 ~ JJ ' U'lW1\ ~
u~
~J
/)~
~
'..J
~~ -N
'-"
< .~'") ,... ~. ,~
·3 Y
.~
~
...,1 l .. ~
.~
~1 '~
.~ .~~ ~.
~
_ 'J
.':/ ~ ';J '-J., ,~ ~
,~
J _
~
-~ l
-
1 11 J ~~i
...(
..
1-
~
~
~
~
~
.4fl.
_~
,;. ].
'")
-!I
1., .~
j •
J)
-
~.
'J
-3
0
-)
---
.
_ 1;:-'
,0
-N 'J
:J.:.
.
~..:: ~ ]~
'~'~.'
" Vl '"), 1) ,1 :-:) ~ ''I ?; ~ ,;. _ ~ ':J -":) j, ]. '4 . -1' 'l " .4fl. _ :J"J
.~
1.:]1
1 -!I JJ' ~.'1 -
..•
j.
.
-3'
•
.
"0"
j
10
I
•
J)
]-..
~
,
~
'-"
J)
.-
..'
~.;
.'1
~, ,0
-.
...,
'-" A
~
.J)
'..J
J)
,,-...,
oQ ."1 0,
A
,0
'")
-
'")
~ ~
'")
-=5
•
,0
cr')
A
J -
<I)
,0
,,/'I
-)
;;
~
.::"
A
.,
.
-.""
r()
,:J'
--=- ~ J)
.,-
..
~:~
~
'1
'J
'-:'
~
,
II "J
•
~'~
;;> ~
'''1.
=
---
J)
.-
..
<r"
:;].
~
~
..
"
,1
~
'''I~ -.
.~
-
'~
n
~
-
~_
~
~
4
J)
---
> .,-
~ ~
'")
1;
.::" ~
'") .. ~
"'I rf
<\..
f
~
'1
~ _":),~ ,...~ 1., .~",1 t:..- ,]
E
'") ;~
Vl
,0
"J
~
VJ ,J
J
~
J)
~~
.••••
'?I"~
-)
•
:-:);. ',;;:0..
c).
'"' ~
'4
'-3'
~
-
:-:) '1 J'
~
10 -
'''J.,
J
'")"1'
II:)
, J::',
1
.
"J
~
'")
.
,7{ ,~ J -l ]- ~ ..
~]-'J'
•
~ ,.~.
~,
-.
c).'
~
l]_'J
.::" ~ c.\
J
~
~l
-
.~
'")
<\....
oQ
~
1::1' ~:
.::"
_
v~·3
_
.•
..
'''I~
,1
A -
-,
.3
~
~
~,
.3
I
~
,4
1
~
:'1
=.~
~....:1..
J
?' :'1' , J;
~
~3 ,j
0
0 _.
,0;-)
•
'") ~
'").~
.3'\
~.
-J
....:1..
'5
-1'
If,
~
.::"A.] -
4 :
'1 ":J
-.'...J'
]-
_
1.
"1'
,0 .::" 'J
"";j
_
J
.4fl.
~
.~
<L ~~
J.
I
1.
~
J
''I .::" 1... '4
,0
1~'
'").-. _..J
~ -
~
~
~
.
,
'") '") '") -
1)
A
"J ,0
,0
"";j
..:1'
1...'1
,
. ~~ ~ ~ .~.
II.~
,0
-
-
J
~ ,f
-~.]-.
A '0.::" ~ - ~ _ A.)·J '-" ,;:-.'-" -
~
i'")
.. _
.3 "
,1 -
'")
.":)..
~,
.~
]-
1
-:J..
'J ~ ,;;I' ~ .••• ") J 10
-
l"
].
.:.
-
~;;:o.:
~:.:J
~ •
,\;..3
_.],
,
II
,]
j 10
-.
fI;:-' .••• ~
~~.
~
~
~
-
. ']. '\ .::" ,1 ~~ ~ ~ '") '""t. ~ :::J = J)
fI I~:'~.::"
,..'
0
,...
1·;:-.
..•,
':J
.,;)
~
° ~
.;:-.
. -
.~
'-" .~ .. ~
0
>
J):2
~ j, ~ .. ':Jj'~';" ~
?-...
., ~ '4 Y ~, ~ """"'" "b
I.
1 - ---. '")'-" I
''1;i.
~
'J ':J ~ ,j .~ ~
.'"
~
V)
~
J)
~
<\-
~ 'J
~'J
-q]
"'J.. J
]-
J -
1. •
11 -
,~
:
o
..
~
1 >
.:)'
.~
~
'\
'\j
: '-:' ~ '") .'
•
1
JJ'
...,
I
c).
'-3'
.:..,
1. ..
.J
1 ] '")~ '1~ ,- ~~ .~~.
'-
-N'
J)
''1
'j
':;I' -:-, "
:;:J
-;
'r'
'''J.,
1-
"-:" .~ 'j
..1
:.:J
-
1~. -
A' -1' --= d)
'':1, :;:J
•
>
~
.. '-.11..hJ" -:1\~.(,~IIo.l:o.. ~~ .Y c..s-' JJ. ,~I
wi LaS, T.l:o..ITftJ o.l:o..IJ~ J
o.l:o.. . J I,S'r ~~ b~
••
rA IJ-iM ~
.11'~
'-
J~
o.l:o.. JI Lal y
~\
~\
UtsJ. ~
. o.l:o..I~J J
:~ ~~
J.,uy ~
• ( ,~
<••
~J 'lj.a.i ~ .aJ~ LaYJ ~
A ' y~1
.uLac.1J.,uyJ y~1 w~
~
l.J.4
,
.:H~'~4~~~ : L..t~
/il ~ ~ , A.:i.J~ ~ 0:';\ ~~ J~
.J:) " J.,uy y~'1 ~
: 0
.l:o..Iwy.Y J
.J:}i I (.S~U:
u~
J.,uy ul 0:';\ .J~ Y " .u..,!
~ ~ 01~10:';1 u4 ~1
UJ~U:J .( , • : , f
· 0:';\ ~
Ty;.J ~4b u~1
~
" ~~\
J! ~
I¥ . (
u~I".u..,s
r A : "i
WA )
rAft
~~,
w yJI ~
~
~\
("~J
U~.J:.J~\
("Yil.J.4 y~\J
-uJ \)lli
ub.
" .u..,sJ
b~ ~..? ~
.J:)
"V : '" .J:)
. (
.. ~ • ~ _ .. U\· oy:.&-I....J.:U:!
~I
J..,s ~
.u.9.)JLA ~
U:!~
" .JjW w Y' 0~
rAi.J La~ ~
0:';\ ~~J~
U~.J:.J~\
\J-i1.SU:!~\~~I
J .JjW w=..1~YJ ~\
.( r f : 4i'i1 ~lWl ~ .l.....:=o.I Lak..JA~ U~J . ~';I J d!..;h ue- ~
.l:o..\)\~';I
• ( ,~
: 0
: , ,
y~\ .JA~ ~
I~ ~
0:';\J . .l:o..IJ~I
.J:) 0.J~I ~
.J:)!"
~\
A.:i~
.u 0:';1 ul 'U~\
y~IJ
A La ~
y. y~\ .y
. y~1 JLac.1 J.,uy ~
( r A : "i
~(
A La JS
. y~\ JLac.1~
0:';\ Ul 'U-
"f : , fi , )
U1J . (
"f : , fi' )
0~
(jS.1, ~~W\ ~j)\
.&\ U.:a. y.J ' ( , : , .J:) lJ'l~)11 y. -u~ .&\ ~ ~ 01~1~ · 0:';\ .y
J
0~
.&\ o..,sy. 0:';1 0~J
0:';\ JLac.1u~ , 0:';~ J-.;
.u,;\y.
0:';\ 01
u..? (.S~\ y. tJS.\1 0 J-+ic~ tJS.\\ cfi:! r1 ' ( "V : '" .J:) y.J
b 0\ J
~I
~\
WA) 0..p- -u} ~ ~
J!J .~I
La~ J . ~\
~~
. 4.l.o \j.J~J
l.J.4 o~
~\
0:!1
Slo4'i1JSl ~ISlo~J'i1 o~ JL..J c.PJ
~Jijl
A.:iYLaS ~ ~\
(.S~U:J
tJS.\\
UjI.S o~
I
(jS.1J ' y~IJ
t4-) ~
~
o~
~
'U-
U'i\ u.il " ~
~\ ~
~I
: 0 ~
')
~I
~I J..,§ulc. ~ ~ ..fl1 fill
~I
..Jll\ ~ lloAJ y~1 ~I
ut5. J
0
(
\~ ~~
~I
0A 4.JSlI \A~}
'"'",AlI 4.JSlI~
~
~ ~~\
u=JI~L..:Jlll ~~ t..sA '
~)
~I
~"~oA ..
-'..:i.J'"'l u·ue ~ .I -; ~. r'"_1 -'..:i..rAlA;/
01 UJ
~\SJ'
~
... \;/ . ~ ... ;/ J ~ \ YA.
U~J
.u w:ioA~.:,:; .r j~1
~~
~J.
.\..JS.lI ll.J~H 4.JSlI~
,",,,".4.114..JS.lly...uJ ~ .~
~J.
4L..:J} ~
U.J~
~
uyJI ~
~J
. ~ . -'..:i.lA;/ ..r- ~
~~
;/JooAIJ~ .~
U J
4..JS.lly...uJ
~ ~ utAJ, rltJJ ' ~IJ '
~~
~\.J:WI
~\j
J ~I
tL,.. 4J}J:! U}! . ~I
0
~
A
' ya:iJ ~J
~I
..J)"-J
. .. ~ ".II ~~ . -~II~Ie U. • \j ~ oAIJ ~..r-. •. AlA c..-::-_ •... II ~I.. y~IJ
.J
~J
~\S ~I
.~ ~ . ~
~~
,,~
u~} 4.# .~I
~I
-'..:i~;/
0
lo JS' ~
~
wY-J.'t.lI ~W}~ 0A ooAIJ~
4JIJ. -'..:iYNU ~
.J
~~~I ~)
.~).'b'l loAIJ -'..:iY'lU ~
~~J
..Jll\ ~ y'JI
~I
~w~ u~!
~I
,V ~) "
f :
UJl9J;;'"ulc. ~ J:! u\S
-II ·.... -:1 ~ I..-J~\ ~.... Y~.J.
..
.)(,01 ~ ~~;SJl'p'
~'~~"1
4JI ~I
,'\C. ~
v-
fi..>:!
~ ~\/il u5JJ
u~~(f : ,V
u:lll
..Jlll ~ ~I
....::.::-II ~ill:.:i~.1\11
~I
,
..Jlll ~ lloAJ All UIJ ' All ~loA J ~
. ~
.. ~,
1
ul I~JI
~\
ul~ . ~I ('"
;
tJ-"'l:!J ' ~I
I~ ..J..,§~ ~I
..J~,.••.tL."t~;W .• ~.. : La.lL-l .
.~ .. u ..;an ~~,,. ~~ ~~.
:
~J' r;/~\
ll~
~\
~\
u~
rlJ
.J.JA~\
ll~
~\
y\:i..SJ1.)..:l, o..;-AWI , .l..;!~\ ~\.J
f'"':!..:lil\ ~I
~
: U'l.l.i.J\ y\:i..SJ\ (' . ,'\i '\ , U'l..:liJ1
, U'l..:lillC.JY\ ~
~.J-'"'l)1 U'l~ltsl
(.)"I-:!..:lill Jj~.J : U'l~ltsl
. (C:;.Jti u.J~) ~\l1 U'l.)~' ~\ ,
o~1
~.L - ,Lh.,; ~L ,\. .. U'l..:liJ\'-l~\ .
, ..:l.Jbud.JA ~I
. j wl....al..:l. .J. U'l~. ltsl w\l1 ~w,
, ~\.J
..):U~\
..:lYe I .JA~:
Uyy.J1 .J:!..:l , ~YilI.J U'l\.ki3I.J~\
~,
~I
~..:lill c..s.)';:.J ~I
~~.J
o~
~
ys..J.b~..:l ¥\.;b,
~Y"'I
U'l.JiJ t,
• ,'\ '\ A J:l.;:l ' ¥~I CJ-A ~\
'-:-l:1~
4S
. ,,\VO
~lll~
(.)"I-:!..:lill("
~\..:i:
I
"c)
~I
c..s~
ISI\, U.JLW\ w.J-A)lJ1 ~
, .JAWI 4J\l1 ~~
~'il,
wl~b..a:
c..s~
4JSJI , c..s.lilk.l\w.JA)IJ\ ~ w\~b..a:
u:l.J\I\ ~4'J1~b.J
, ~.»J.A ~\
4..4'
~
~\I\
~'
(i
4J\I\ ~~
""",~ U'l.J..:ll:i~\
(V
(A
(~t::J\ ~.fiJ\, J.J\I\ ~.fiJI), b.,; ~
U'l..:liJ\y~\
U'l~:
U-ul~ ~.)~
. ''\i'\ : ~I)I , ~4aJI , r-'i'JI t~l
~~
~~'il c..s~
y~
c)A: ~
, ~~..:l
."· ·r , ~.J ~~\ u! ~~\
(0
U'l..:lillC.JYl,ul....aj.J Il..:l~
. ,'\ '\ '\ .J:!~ , ~
~~)'I
~
(.)"I-:!..:lill(£
. ". • • J:l.;:} , ~.J\I\ ~I ~J
(r
u! ~b
tc.~ . ',\AV
~I,
\II ~I .Jji.$...:l11('\ ~..:l\ll
: ~t::JI o..:l~ 44..1\~\..:l3 ( , •
.,;lA, ~.J\l1 ~I
, o~W\
~~'11
~\,
oy\W\ ,~I
w.JA"i
. '''''' ~~
~~'11
~I
~till
:
o.:l~ ~4JI ~I.:l! ( "
U-£~';}:I\~~
~Lo., ~}~\ ~I
'0 jAlWI , ~I
~
. ''''''
: ~till o.:l ~
...>:l.jiSl,
~}1\ ~I
~411~\.:l! ( , "
U-£~';}:ll
,
, ~I..rl\ 4W\ , oJAWI, ~'+iJl ~ W)Lab: 6..1tillo.:l~ ~4JI~I.:l! ( • '"''''
tJ.;ljw:' "i ~l, ~ J 4.J.J.&o ~..r o
.:ll~
"
•
f.YJWI ~l
\II , 0..r,&oWl,0.J01 ~.('11
, (' A J , V ~ 'i J ,
~
o
~l
'"''''
o
o
,ojl.fill
~,y
'\
,
0
,
,'\"
~~'11
i~ ~I
~I
o
,'\"
'I 0 ~till o.:l. y.....alo LLJI~\.:l! ( 0
(
,
0
f J , r)
J\~:
w.JA"i
"V ~(
0
0 ~
f J
'0
r)
," " . ~4Jl ~I.:l! (
'i
Ul.:l~\ , 0j\ .fill
6..1til\o.:l~ ~4JI ~I.:l! ( 'V
~I
, '"
J~:
)
Ul.:l~1 , 0j\.fill ~
'A
,
6..1tillo.:l~ ~4JI ~\.:l! ( '"
f" , f' )
UI.:l~1, 0j\.fill ~,
utS J,\: ~till o.:l~ ~4J\ ~I.:l! ('" '"''
w~
, r , ( ri , r 0 ) ~
~
I"
w~"i J..?: ~til\ o.:l~ ~411~I~ (
~I
...H.;sl
.J~ "i ,
, 0 jAlWI , "
~Lo. A ~ ( 'A , 'V ) ub~1 , 0jl.fill ~
o
o
•
wyJI w~~1
u..a J,..uy Ul C-H'II
L
I ~I
~ , • J" ~A J V ~i J
0 ~ ~ " ~ ( ""
'"''
'"
~o
~
Lo.: yl~J
JS,
JJ'II Wjt
~~J ~I
,I.i=..
0
~~}
~l" ~
(;}.:l~ ~
~~'1
, Y\~J J\~ : 6..1tillo.:l~
. '"''''
~l u..a~}
o.
0
J "
0 ~ '"
4-:l1 ~l ~~
, y';ll
,y" ~
~
f.YJ.JLo.
(:;A wi·y.....a . ~till o.:l. y.....alo L\..JI~I.:l! ( H
~...H} , ~4aJl:
.,
,r
i ~...H} '" "i
, ( , f ,
J..? : 6..1til\o.:l~ UI.:l~\ , 0jl.fill ~
,r ) Ul .:l~1 ~4JI ~I.:l! ( " , ,~
~
~~.J';II uc wly..:::.b.A: ~till o.:l~ ~411~I~ ( "" 0
f.YJ.JLo. , 0jAlWI , " ~I.fill
~l
J ~}i}i, II ~.fill
wI " ,
, ~I
ul...J~)j,
u.J...m' ~I
Y...J: u.Jy.i.J u-i1y\WI<,Sjlill~
(
.,.r
. ti·U.J.') .l.I\ .(<:::u , <'s...J~yJl U"ll~1 , U"l~1 ~:I..PJI
: <,Sjl.:jl..:J\U"l.J:u~..rC u"y~1 ( .,.f . ",~I
u"y~
~)'I
:~
...JY\Y j , oj~
l.i..:=..~.J ...J~
~} uJ.»S
, U"l~.,hil (Jo'Y~I'~
u).Jt.JI
Ai,
,'\
.Jb , 0y\ WI , \.h. ~
(Jo'Y..\il1 Jj~.J : <'s.J~)'1
j.A ,
0..>AWI , ~U ~I u-e
~
J~
r;-- jJ...A ,
o
, uJ ~
u-i\::J1 ~~I
u6.~}
, u-i\::J1 ~~I
, U"l~.,hil(.)'l:!~1~
j.A ,
, \.h. ~ ~}
C~
0y\ WI ,
¥u ~I
: <,S .J~)'I
0y\WI , ~~)'I
j.A ,
ue r;--,jJ.A ,(
c~ : <'s.J~)'1
, \.h.~ ~l
, U"l~.,hilu"y~1 ~
j.A ,
0y\ WI , ~~)'
~j';
r;--J1A'
(.)'lAWI~~I
, lJ) ~l
~:
o
~I
(
ul...J~.Jb,
u.J...m' ~I
~
'\
r)
0 ~1..A
'\'\A
.,.
•
~I
~l u"y.lQ1I ( r.
0JAWI , ~~)'I
j.A ,
'~4'il
.,
~\::JI ~.RJI , \.h.~ ~l
t;:Uti U.J~) , ~j';...J':;I
f ,
0 ,
<'s.J~)'1 uJ~
o
'-:-l:!~ '
u"y~1 ( .,.A
I u.e. r;--,jJ.A , ( V , i )
.J':;I j.S yJI , U"l~.,hil (Jo'Y~1~
, j.Jb·~..)A ~I
r;--.Ju.
uJ.J:!-Su"y~\ ( .,.'\
0' ue
ue
,'\
~~ u"y~1 ( .,.V
uJ ~
o
u6.6...-} , ~\::JI ~~I
~l:h:J':; I
(.)'l:!~1JjL....a...J : <'s.J~)' I uJ ~
A '\ ~ ~ ' U"l~.,hil(.)'l:!~1~
,'\
c; (Jo'Y~1( .,.i
''\AA
o
,(r, -')
...J:!j
c.s-S j , U"l~...J~..,;.i:-~':;I ~'y.j ( .,.0
0
o
, ~I...J~Io~l
~
: <,S.YA ~
~I
~~I:
uL....aI.J.ill
~ 0
r,
' oy\WI
r 1, 0
(
~jy\
(r.,.
, '\ A. ,A.:i.I\::JI ~I, ~l
C~'
~\::JI ~j.;JI, o
,'\
~)'I
~~
vr , u-ij':;1",~I
~I ~US ~,
fil:
<,Sjl~.J.j u.J...m' \.h.~
(rr
: 11! ;?~,
1)
~'jJ.':~w
St. Ambrose: De Fide, A Select Library of Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers of the Christian Church (NPNF.) 2nd. Ser.,
Vol.
X,
Grand
Rapids,
Michigan,
Eerdmans
Publishing Company, Aug., 1979. 2)
St. Ambrose: De Spiritu Sancto, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. X, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1979.
3)
St. Athanasius: Incarnation),
De Incarnatione
NPNF.,2nd.
Verbi Dei (ON the
Ser., Vol. IV, Grand Rapids,
Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1980. 4)
St. Athanasius: Contra Gentes (Against Heathen ), NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1980.
5)
St. Athanasius: In Hlud { Omnia} Ete. ( On Luke X. 22 , Matt. XI. 27), NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1980.
6)
St. Athanasius: Orationes Contra Arianos, NPNF., 2nd. Ser.,
Vol. IV, Grand Rapids, Michigan,
Eerdmans
Publishing Company, Aug., 1980. 7)
St. Athanasius: De Synodis (On the Councils of Ariminum and Seleucia), NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1980.
8)
St. Athanasius:
De Sentenia
Dionysii
( Defence
of
Dionisius, Bishop of Alex. ), NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,
9)
Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1980. St. Athanasius: Tomus AD, Antiochenos ( Synodal letter to the Church of Antioch), NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV,
Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1980. 10 ) St. Athanasius: AD Epictetum, (Letter LIX LV Epictetos ) NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. IV, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1980. 11 ) St. Augustin: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Aug., 1980. 12) St. Basil: Prolegomena, the Life and Works of St. Basil, NPNF., 2nd. Ser.,Voi. VIII, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Nov., 1978. 13 ) St. Basil: Letters, Letter VIII, to the Caesarians, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VIII, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Nov., 1978. 14 ) St. Cyril of Alexandria: Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John, 2nd. Ser., Vol. II, London, Walter Smith, 1885. 15) St. Gregory of Nazianzen: Theological Orations, NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Sept., 1978. 16) St. Gregory of Nazianzen: On the Arrival of the Egyptians, ( Oration XXXIV), NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, Grand
Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Sept., 1978. 17 ) St. Gregory of Nazianzen: Against Apolinarius, ( The Second Letter to Cledonius) (Ep. C II ) , NPNF., 2nd. Ser., Vol. VII, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Sept., 1978. 18 ) St. Gregory of Nyssa: Against Eunomius, NPNF., 2nd. Ser.,
Vol. V, Grand Rapids,
Michigan,
Eerdmans
Publishing Company, Aug., 1979. 19) St. Gregory of Nyssa: On the Holy Spirit., 2nd. Ser., NPNF.,
Vol. V, Grand Rapids, Michigan,
Eerdmans
Publishing Company, Aug., 1979. 20) Grgg, Robert, C. and. Groh, Dennis, E.: Early Arianism A view of Salvation, London, SCM Press, 1981. 21 ) Harnack, H.: History of Dogma, Translated From the Third German Edition by E.B. Speirs, D.D. and James Millers B.D., Vol. 4. 22) Hefele, GJ.: A History of the Christian Councils From the Original Documents to the close of the Council of Nicaea, Translated
From the German and Edited by W.R. Clark,
M.A. Edinburgh, T. & T. Clark, 38 George St., 1894. 23 ) St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Synodis, NPNF.,2nd. IX,
Grand
Rapids,
Company, Sept., 1979.
Michigan,
Eerdmans
Ser., Vol. Publishing
24 ) St. Hilary of Poitiers: De Trinitate,
NPNF., 2nd.
Ser.,
Vol. IX, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Sept., 1979. 25 ) St. John Chrysostom: Homilies on the Gospel of St. John, NPNF., 1st.
Ser., Vol. XIV, Grand Rapids, Michigan,
Eerdmans Publishing Company, Dec., 1978. 26) St. John Chrysostom:
Homilies on the Gospel of St.
Mathew, , NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. X, Feb., 1983. 27) St. John Chrysostom:
Homilies on the Epistle to the
Hebrews, , NPNF., 1st. Ser., Vol. XIV, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Dec., 1978. 28 ) Mears Henrietta, C.: What
the Bible is All about, the
Living Bible Edition, Part Two, The New Testament, Wheaton Illinois, Tyndale House Publishers, Inc., 1987. 29) Walter Nigg: The Heretics~ Richard and Clara Winiston Ed., and Trans., New York, 1962.
---------rw~
U'l~I--------
.....
Sl-l'
oJ ~ ."
~l
.........................................
Oa}
..
.
lJWl ~1J11 lo..lUS11
..................................................................................
,~
~l
~l
~
~1~J
~IJJI
""
~..#o~}
"V "~ ~~I
~I ~.,H ~J111
~0
rA
~l
to
~l
tA ir
~)'l
.ul~ ~.,H.)'J1 ~.,H.)'J1
'\ V
~..,ill: w.1t::J1 ~\
..,;jl~~
~l
~l
~l
~I
u..,.)U o~~l
~l ~I ~l
y\.i1IJ
~1)1 ~l ~.JA'i : ~Wl :
'":-'431
J}'J1 ~\
: ~t::Jl ~I
~Lwal : w.1t::J\ ~\
uti.-: ~I)I
~l
~\
UlbL..a : (,)"IAWI ~l Sl-l...i ~l ~y~ ~.1iJ1 SI-'-:'Jl ~ : ~Wl '":-'431 Sl-l..;l ';iiiJ Ll:a..,H ~.1iJ1 ~} ~ ~ J
~l
~I
~l
.....................................................• " ool) ~
i~
~! ~
~l
:
UoIl
u..,.'J .)1SJ)'
~l
~l
'":-'431
: J}'JI ~\
uy'il ~\y:;J ~:
~l
rr
~
: Jill
~IJ 0:1)'1 : ~t::JI ~I
~l u~~.)'il
oi
l,)A
.;:J1jJ.;s.JI
~.jJ."J'J1
~~.)'il
~ J1j
~
JS ~~
~J
~~lll~
0:1)'1~ (0r
~
y'il " : J}11 ~l
: r ~)
--------rwl
~
.1.:..~. lA
(j'l~I
'il• ~~ ~'
a.
(",)A
~'I'~
( ,a. :
A
c.r ulJ ~\
" y'i4
--
0 ..,;)
(
,r 0
........ .
, £0
. ( ~
~,a. .(
(
r£
.•
, , ..,; ) "" ~J ~
V : ,~ ..,;) " ~~}
.( ,• : ,
£ ..,;)
( ~A
" ~
• 1 •••• lJ:l
.
" .•
(,Jo'lA
J.-..:ai11 WI ~.,:
'I
u'il " : (j'l~l.....J1J.-..:ai1\
~ ~
y'iIJ y'il ~ ul " : &L.JI J.-..:ai11
~I
~I " : 0--~\ J.-..:ai1\ ................" rl.fill ~IJ A;A ;A' 1\ ~.fill ul " : t-""t:i11 J.-..:ai1\ 0 , , : '0 ..,;) " U~\tl ~IJ ~.fill ul " J : , £ ..,;) " ~
.u)'1WjII:!1~~
~rv
" :
~Wl
J.-..:ai11
( r : 'V ..,;) " y'il 4-:l1 Wjl ~~ ,
u'ilJ
" :~
( 0 :
'V ..,;)
" ~!.J ~!J ~IJ ~I ~! ~I ~ A a.
~ " : ~~\ J.-..:ai11
r. : , • ..,;)" .l:l..IJ y'il J ul " : ~\)I
" I:!1.l:l..J~I
~i 0
y'il
( oV : i ..,;)
, ,V
~.r
J.-.:!
"
y'il ~)
, •V
, A'
'il .J JiJ~ 'i ".• c.sJ'~\'~ , :,\
U~.
~! " : ~
(.S~WI J.-..:ai11
~~I
J.-..:ai1\
( 'V : ~' ..,;)
...................................................... ~---,II~I