10 minute read
TECHNOLOGY
UBIT AND VIRTUAL TRADESHOWS: WHAT ASSOCIATIONS NEED TO KNOW
By Jeff Tenenbaum, managing partner, Tenenbaum Law Group PLLC
The IRS has made clear that revenue from traditional in-person tradeshows is not subject to unrelated business income tax. Does this safeharbor exception apply to today’s virtual or hybrid versions? Unfortunately, the answer to that question is as clear as mud.
The transition from in-person to virtual events during the COVID-19 pandemic has raised a critical question for associations seeking to maximize sources of nondues revenue while also minimizing unrelated business income tax (UBIT): How is virtual tradeshow revenue treated for UBIT purposes? developments or products and services related to the exempt activities of the organization.”
Guidance issued 17 years ago by the Internal Revenue Service was the last time the association community received direction on this issue. Applying it to today’s world is challenging, to say the least – leaving associations that hold virtual or hybrid tradeshows exposed to UBIT risk unless and until the IRS issues clarifying guidance.
Although associations are granted a general exemption from federal corporate income tax for income derived from activities that are substantially related to their tax-exempt purposes, income from unrelated business activities is potentially taxable. Unrelated business income comes from a trade or business that is regularly carried on and that is not substantially related to the organization’s tax-exempt purposes. The most common form of unrelated business income for associations, by far, is advertising income.
However, there are numerous statutory exclusions and exceptions that can exempt otherwise taxable income from UBIT. Since 1976, one of those exceptions is for income received from “qualified convention and tradeshow activities.” To qualify for this exception, an association must “regularly conduct as one of its substantial exempt purposes a show which stimulates interest in, and demand for, the products of a particular industry or segment of an industry or which educates persons in attendance regarding new The safe-harbor exception applies to 501(c)(6) tax-exempt entities, as well as to 501(c)(3), (c)(4) and (c)(5) organizations. Before 1976, the IRS had started to treat associations’ tradeshow exhibit fees as subject to UBIT, arguing that such fees were akin to taxable advertising income.
2004 IRS Revenue Ruling
In 2004, the IRS issued Revenue Ruling 2004-112 on the subject of virtual tradeshows. With the then-increasing prevalence of the internet and the ability to offer virtual tradeshows, questions began to arise as to whether the offering of a web-based tradeshow is the type of activity that is “of a kind traditionally conducted at … tradeshows.” The guidance describes two hypothetical scenarios: one involving a Section 501(c)(6) association that offers a semi-annual virtual tradeshow in connection with each inperson tradeshow; the other involving a Section 501(c)(6) association that offers a virtual tradeshow only.
The Revenue Ruling made clear that the key factor in the IRS’s analysis of the applicability of the UBIT exception to a virtual tradeshow is whether or not the virtual show is conducted ancillary to a live show.
3710 Farnum Creek Road | Milford, KS 66514 | 785.463.4000 | acornsresortkansas.com
A unique event/conference venue with breathtaking views of nature overlooking the lake, beach and meadows. In-house catering by the Cove Bar and Grill. The Milford Lake Conference Center staff is here to serve your every need.
CONFERENCE CENTER • 50' x 80' great room seats 275 • 13' x 23' board room • state-of-the-art audio system • 3 DLP lampless projectors and drop down screens
RESORT • 24 luxury cabins • 9 lodge rooms • 61 RV sites • pontoon, kayaks, canoes • 3-mile nature trail
continued from page 34
In the first hypothetical scenario, an association conducts two tradeshows a year. The in-person shows are similar to most trade or professional association shows – they include members of the association and suppliers to the industry, and exhibitors are charged a fee to participate.
During those shows and for three days before and after, the association’s website includes a virtual tradeshow section containing “information and visual displays … and links to the websites of exhibitors represented at the (in-person) tradeshow.” The site also contains order forms and has a function that allows online purchases from exhibitors. The association charges a fee to exhibitors that wish to be listed on the site.
According to the IRS, these web activities fit within the safe harbor for qualified convention and tradeshow activities because: • The web activities are “ancillary” to the in-person tradeshows. • The content of the web page serves to “augment and enhance” the in-person tradeshows by making available “in an alternative medium the same information available at the show.” • The web page is available “during essentially the same limited time period that each tradeshow is in operation.”
Thus, income generated by the web page will not be subject to UBIT in this scenario.
In the second hypothetical scenario, the organization offers two-week-long virtual tradeshows without any connection to in-person events. According to the IRS, such activity will not qualify for the safe harbor because the show website is “not itself a convention, annual meeting or tradeshow” within the meaning of the tax code, due to the lack of an in-person component.
Today’s Virtual Tradeshows
Fast forward to 2021. Today’s virtual tradeshows are much more interactive and, in many respects, resemble their inperson counterparts for which the safe harbor was written. But with no guidance since 2004, it is difficult to say how the IRS would interpret the safe harbor today and apply it to the 2021 virtual or hybrid tradeshow.
As the COVID-19 pandemic starts to abate, it is likely that at least for 2021, and perhaps into 2022 and beyond, associations will plan to hold hybrid conferences and tradeshows featuring both in-person and virtual elements. The virtual tradeshow in the Revenue Ruling’s first example featured only “the same information that is available at the [in-person] show” and a function that allowed purchases
from “members and suppliers represented at the tradeshow.” But if an association offers a virtual show in connection with a live show and allows companies that are not exhibiting at the live show to participate in the virtual show, for example, would the IRS determine that the virtual show is no longer “ancillary” to the live show and thus not covered by the safe harbor? This is unclear, as is the application of the 2004 Revenue Ruling to the modern-day virtual-only or hybrid tradeshow.
It should be noted that a failure to qualify for the safe harbor does not necessarily mean that the income generated from a virtual tradeshow will be subject to UBIT. In most instances, the IRS likely would take the position that the net income is generated by the sale of advertising-type services and thus is subject to UBIT, but there may be instances when an association can demonstrate that its activity is substantially related to its tax-exempt purposes even without the help of the safe harbor.
Further, if the arrangements with potential exhibitors are restructured accordingly, other exceptions from UBIT may apply. For instance, it may be possible to convert potentially taxable virtual tradeshow exhibit fees to tax-free corporate sponsorship income or royalties, allowing associations to retain more of their much-needed revenues.
Unfortunately, the 2004 Revenue Ruling will continue to pose UBIT risks to associations in the virtual or hybrid tradeshow environment. That being said, the ruling does not supersede the clear intent of the federal tax code to provide a safe-harbor exception to unrelated business income where an association conducts an event to educate attendees or stimulate interest and demand for products or services of the membership. Therefore, it may not matter whether the activities traditionally conducted at tradeshows are done in person or virtually. Until the IRS provides new and updated guidance – which is not likely anytime soon – it would be advisable for associations to document how the activities of their tradeshows meet the tax code definitions of the safe harbor. F
This article was originally published by the American Society of Association Executives’ at www.asaecenter.org.
showcase
kay mcfarland japanese garden and venue riverfront community center
635 S.W. Gage in Topeka, 785.783.4264 topekazoo.org
The Kay McFarland Japanese Garden features traditional Koi ponds, bridges, lush landscapes, and exquisite architectural elements. The contemporary event center provides modern amenities and seats over 200 people at round tables. The dedicated private suite opens to a secluded garden, promoting peace and relaxation. Overlooking the largest pond, an openair pavilion offers a gorgeous outdoor location for overflow seating.
the jayhawk club
1809 Birdie Way in Lawrence, 785.842.2929 thejayhawkclub.com
The Jayhawk Club is a family-friendly community with amenities that feature a newly designed 18-hole championship golf course, six beautiful event venues and a resort-style pool. Accommodating groups of eight to 300, The Jayhawk Club is the perfect venue for your next meeting, retreat or social event. Our experienced team will provide you with an unforgettable experience. Contact us today! advertising/promotion
KSAE
Association & Meetings
five top picks in northeast kansas
123 S. Esplanade St. in Leavenworth, 913.758.2948 visitleavenworthks.com
The Riverfront Community Center is a beautiful, historic Union Depot Train Station built in 1888 and lovingly restored in 1988 as a multifunctional facility. No matter what type of event you are planning, from receptions to reunions, meetings to promotion parties, we can help you arrange the perfect day! The Community Center is only a 30-minute drive from most areas of Kansas City.
townsite topeka
534 S. Kansas Ave. in Topeka, 785.213.1904 townsitetower.com
Townsite Topeka features full service, newly renovated, event spaces that are sure to be the perfect fit. Townsite Avenue Ballroom, located in the former Bank of America lobby, can accommodate a 500+ event. Townsite 16, located on the 16th floor of Townsite Tower, can accommodate a 200-250 event with an incredible 360° view from downtown Topeka. Schedule a tour today!
GReat overland station
701 N. Kansas Ave. in Topeka, 785.251.6945 parks.snco.us
Built in 1927 and restored to its original grandeur, this former Union Pacific railroad station offers several event spaces: the Main Waiting Room and Mezzanine (up to 200 people), and the East Gallery (up to 100 people), which together, can hold up to 300 people. A conference room, suitable for small business meetings of up to 12 people, is also available.
CALENDAR
To register or for more information, visit ksaenet.org.
JULY 21
Member Retention
AUG. 2
Implementing Video Production Solo
AUG. 25
Leverating Adult Learning Theory
SEPT. 8
Creative Improv for Member Retention and Board Development
SEPT. 22
Advertising, OnBoarding and Retention
AD INDEX
DoubleTree by Hilton-Lawrence ........................... lawrence.doubletreebyhilton.com .................................................................... 29 Geary County Convention Center........................ marriott.com/mhkcy ............................................................................................... 35 Glass Decorators .......................................................... glassdecorators.com.................................................................................................17 Great Overland Station ............................................. parks.snco.ks................................................................................................................37 Great Wolf Lodge ........................................................ createyourowngreat.com...................................................................................... 26 Hilton Garden Inn-Hays............................................. hilton.com/en/hotels/hysiigi-hilton-garden-inn-hays/.............................21 Hilton Garden Inn-Topeka ........................................ hgitopeka.hgi.com......................................................................................................31 Hilton Garden Inn-Wichita Downtown............... wichitadowntown.hgi.com.....................................................................................31 Holiday Inn Express-Parsons...............................................................................................................................................................................27 Holiday Inn Wichita East I-35................................. holidayinnwichita.com............................................................................................. 16 Hyatt Regency Wichita ............................................. wichita.regency.hyatt.com .....................................................................................13 J.O. Sundstrom Conference Center..................... visitlindsborg.com......................................................................................................17 Kansas Star Casino & Event Center .................... kansasstarcasino.com/gather............................................. inside front cover Kay McFarland Japanese Garden ........................ topekazoo.org .............................................................................................................37 Marriott Wichita............................................................ marriott.com/ictwe.....................................................................................................5 Milford Lake Conference Center........................... acornsresortkansas.com ....................................................................................... 35 Prairie Band Casino & Resort ................................. prairieband.com ...........................................................................................................9 Riverfront Community Center ............................... visitleavenworthks.com ..........................................................................................37 The Jayhawk Club........................................................ thejayhawkclub.com ................................................................................................37 Townsite Tower.............................................................. townsitetower.com............................................................................................33, 37 Treefall Marketing (Allen Press) ............................ treefallmarketing.com ...............................................................................................8 Visit Emporia.................................................................. visitemporia.com/meet.......................................................................................... 23 Visit Kansas City Kansas........................................... visitkansascityks.com/ksae ...................................................................................15 Visit Leavenworth ........................................................ visitleavenworthks.com ...........................................................................................12 Visit Manhattan ............................................................. visitmanhattanks.org ............................................................................ back cover Visit Salina ....................................................................... visitsalinaks.org.............................................................................................................11 Visit Topeka..................................................................... visittopeka.com ..........................................................................inside back cover Visit Wichita.................................................................... visitwichita.com.......................................................................................................... 19
