PHD ASSISTANCE Lab
PHD ASSISTANCE Lab
CSR AND BUSINESS ETHICS Are they one and the same? 2019-2020
PHD ASSISTANCE ASSISTANCE Lab Lab PHD
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
>
This article attempts to draw a fine line between the notion of CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility) and business ethics.
>
The article draws from past literature to highlight the subtle variations between the two concepts.
2 | CSR and Business Ethics
Business and Management
PHD ASSISTANCE ASSISTANCE Lab Lab PHD
INTRODUCTION
Ethics in business generally takes into its ambit issues pertaining to corporate governance and codes of conduct, moral principles and decision making. It has been argued that there is scope to find that business ethics might comprise of a fundamental dislocation associated with phenomenal experiences that emerge in the event that things might not be in place. At the time of recognizing practices that project ethics in business, researchers often find themselves in the domain of morality and a definition pertaining to what actually makes up morality. Later, actions in business would be judged not on the basis of actions that are effective or efficient but whether the actions were defensible from a moral perspective. It can be comprehended that ethics in business as a notion is gradually changing, with regards to innovative manner of how resources are being mobilized and utilized, innovative technologies, evolution in practices within the society and gradually growing towards a business network which is connected globally. An increase in the awareness of the limitations of natural resources, the growth in the divide of wealth and the ever pervading existence of business within the life of an individual citizen through technologies like cloud computing and big data, bring to the fore the issue of ethics in business within conversation on societal norms.
Nonetheless, is it possible to recognize ethics in business as an array of standards that organizations are known to practice? How different is business ethics from corporate social responsibility (CSR), a term that has become a buzzword across corporate circles today? Apparently ethics and CSR has been perceived by some as one and the same however, there is a fine thin line that dissects the two, this article attempts to explore CSR from a business ethics setting.
3 | CSR and Business Ethics
Business and Management
PHD ASSISTANCE ASSISTANCE Lab Lab PHD
CSR from a Business Ethics Context
The normative stakeholder theory within CSR has been known to draw its idea from ethics. Thus it confirms that organizations involved in business are obliged morally to consider any concerns expressed by a bigger stakeholder group comprising of customers, employees, owners, vendors and community instead of the owners exclusively.
The notions of CSR and business ethics have unique identities. Nevertheless, they are frequently utilized in reference to the very same code or argument. Business ethics as a term is meant to be an amalgamation of two well-known terms viz., business and ethics. Business people might reach the very edge of or even move over to traditional standards of morality, while pursuing a creative destruction, in pursuit of an objective that could be a form of the ‘means being justified by the end’. Source : PTTEP 2013
CSR is then viewed as a fee that has been levied on the outcomes extracted through the wrongdoing by business as a penalty to pay for some of the rights. Thereby, the income generated through taxes linked with wrongdoing and exploitation are frequently reserved towards restoring the environment and health, if not providing downright incentives for manufacturing products that are more salutory in nature.
4 | CSR and Business Ethics
Business and Management
PHD ASSISTANCE Lab
Present Pertinence of CSR
CSR for long has been an integral aspect of responsible and ethical practice of business. Nonetheless, the notion has gained increased traction in view of the economic environment which is rather globalized currently. CSR functions as per the rule that businesses are responsible to cater to their responsibilities towards a wider spectrum of stakeholders as compared to its shareholders. CSR should never be a policy that is added-on by an organization, but it is something which is incorporated within the strategy and structure of governance. According to a report, it has been observed that CSR initiatives the world over has witnessed a remarkable increment in recent times as
“Businesses realize their value not only commercially, but also in terms of boosting employee value, cutting costs and attracting staff�.
5 | CSR and Business Ethics
Business and Management
PHD PHD ASSISTANCE ASSISTANCE Lab Lab
Equating Good CSR Practices with Ethics
But the question here would be; will complying with every regulation and standards as laid down in CSR essentially ensure that the business entity is practicing ethics in business? Is there a correlation between the activities initiated by the organization from a CSR setting and business ethics? There have been several instances of organization that adhere to all the prescribed standards of CSR outwardly, but there is no indication that they have been ethical in their business practices. Instances where unethical business practices have come to light is evident through the ‘Enron’ fiasco. During the year 2001, Enron was a leading giant and vociferously advocated and practiced CSR. However, it was later revealed that business practices at Enron were not entirely ethical as they manipulated their financial statements. This instance and several other clearly indicates that adhering to CSR is one thing and being ethical in business is an entirely different thing altogether.
6 | CSR and Business Ethics
Business and Management
PHD ASSISTANCE Lab
SUMMARY Perceiving CSR through the normative stakeholder theory, it can be proposed that CSR is actually as subclass of business ethics. Stakeholder theory commences on the assumption that values could be openly and essentially an integral aspect of conducting business. CSR is restricted in its definition of the responsibilities and mandate for a business towards their stakeholders. CSR is what the organization is expected to do to give back to society or being socially responsible whereas business ethics would require business owner to be sensible in all their business actions or being morally responsible.
Future Scope Research in this domain in future could possibly explore strategies that can be set forth to ensure business ethics are being followed by organizations.
7 | CSR and Business Ethics
Business and Management
PHD ASSISTANCE Lab
. . . . . . . .
REFERENCES Beduschi, L. C., Contreras, R., & Holz, R. (2017). Innovation for Sustainable Rural Development. Retrieved from http://www.fao.org/3/a-i7769e.pdf Boundless Business. (2019). Business Ethics. Retrieved October 8, 2019, from Lumen website: https:// courses.lumenlearning.com/boundless-business/ chapter/business-ethics/ Bradley, J. R. (2011). Remembering “Green” Enron (Part II: Corporate Social Responsibility). Master Resource. Retrieved from https://www.masterresource.org/enronken-lay/remembering-green-enron-part-ii-corporate-social-responsibility/ Camilleri, M. A. (2017). The Corporate Social Responsibility Notion. In Corporate Sustainability, Social Responsibility and Environmental Management (pp. 3–26). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-46849-5_1 Carroll, A. B. (2015). Corporate social responsibility. Organizational Dynamics, 44(2), 87–96. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.orgdyn.2015.02.002 Knowledge@Wharton. (2011). Corporate Social Responsibility in India: No Clear Definition, but Plenty of Debate. Retrieved October 8, 2019, from https:// knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/corporate-social-responsibility-in-india-no-clear-definition-but-plenty-of-debate/ Management Study Guide. (2019). Resolving an Ethical Dilemma. Retrieved October 8, 2019, from https:// www.managementstudyguide.com/insider-trading-and-strategies-to-combat-it.htm Metcalf, J., & Crawford, K. (2016). Where are human subjects in Big Data research? The emerging ethics divide. Big Data & Society, 3(1), 205395171665021. https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951716650211
ABOUT THE DEPARTMENT Business and Management Lab at PhD Assistance is involved in exploring novel research areas by conducting dynamic research. It promotes innovation in all fields of engineering by advancing the technology with structured and continuous research. The problems and challenges faced by the existing technologies and trends are explored by our researchers exist in scholarly literature, in theory, or in practices that needs deliberate investigation These problems are identified and fixed by our researchers by suggesting better novel alternatives with appropriate tools, technologies and approaches, thereby proving their effectiveness in real time applications.
ABOUT US PhD Assistance, is world’s reputed academic guidance provider for the past 15 years have guided more than 4,500 Ph.D. scholars and 10,500 Masters Students across the globe. We support students, research scholars, entrepreneurs, and professionals from various organizations in providing consistently high-quality writing and data analytical services every time. We value every client and make sure their requirements are identified and understood by our specialized professionals and analysts, enriched in experience to deliver technically sound output within the requested timeframe. Writers at PhD Assistance are best referred as ‘Researchers’ since every topic they handle unique and challenging. We specialize in handling text and data, i.e., content development and Statistical analysis where the latest statistical applications are exhausted by our expert analysts for determining the outcome of the data analysed. Qualified and experienced researchers including Ph.D. holders, statisticians, and research analysts offer cutting edge research consulting and writing services to meet your business information or academic project requirement. Our expertise has passion towards research and persona l assistance as we work closely with you for a very professional and quality output within your stipulated time frame. Our services cover vast areas, and we also support either part or entire research paper/service as per your requirement at competitive prices.
Format type: E-Book © 2019-2020 All Rights Reserved, No part of this document should be modified/used without prior consent. UK: 10 Park Place, Manchester M4 4EY. UK: +44-1143520021 Email:info@phdassistance.com Web:www.phdassistance.com
Business and Management