Designing the Ciliwung River An urban landscape study of Kampung Melayu
WORKSHOP and SEMINAR JAKARTA 15-19 MARCH 2013 SINGAPORE 19-24 MARCH 2013
Singapore ETH Centre for Global Environmental Sustainability
Dear Professor Hadi,
Zürich February 28 2013
ETH Institute of Landscape Architecture Professor Christophe Girot ETH Zürich HIL H 55.3 ETH Hönggerberg CH-8093 Zürich Switzerland T +41 (44) 633 29 87 X +41 (44) 633 12 08 www.girot.arch.ethz.ch www.futurecities.ethz.ch NUS National University of Singapore Professor Jörg Rekittke Department of Architecture School of Design and Environment National University of Singapore 4 Architecture Drive Singapore 117 566 Tel: +65 6516 3452 UI Universitas Indonesia Depok Professor Herlily Centre of Built Environment Design & Research (P3LB) Department of Architecture Faculty of Engineering Universitas Indonesia Kampus UI Depok, 16424 T +62 21 7863512 architecture.ui.ac.id IPB University Bogor Professor Hadi Susilo Arifin Professor in Ecology & Management of Landscape Head of Landscape Management Division Landscape Architecture Department Bogor Agricultural University (IPB) Jl. Meranti - Kampus IPB Dramaga-Bogor 16680 INDONESIA T +62-251-8422-415 M +62-811-11-7720 www.hsarifin.staff.ipb.ac.id hsarifin@ipb.ac.id
2
CONTENT
INTRODUCTIONS
4
KAMPUNG RULES
6
OBJECTIVES
7
JAKARTA SCHEDULE
8
SINGAPORE SCHEDULE
9
PARTICIPANTS
10
GROUPS
11
DEPLOYMENT MAP
12
EMERGENCY
14
LOCATIONS IN JAKARTA
15
LOCATIONS IN SINGAPORE
16
Map of the Ciliwung River 1897
3
INTRODUCTION
The Kampung and the CILIWUNG RIVER The Design Research Studio on the Ciliwung River in Jakarta is part of the ETH Future Cities Laboratory in Singapore and will involve architecture students for one semester on one of the most challenging sites in Jakarta: the Kampung Melayu. During the course of
the semester one workshop will be taught in March jointly with NUS, UI and IPB students in Jakarta and Singapore. The operational framework and methodology of the studio will involve landscape, architecture as well as urban design thinking and will follow the
precepts of a site-specific topological approach. Emphasis of the design work will be on the role of landscape and dwelling structures as they interact with the adjacent river in the flood prone neighbourhoods of Kampung Melayu and Bukit Duri in Jakarta.
Can the widening of the Ciliwung river corridor become an incentive to doubling the population density in the remainder of the
kampong? This would avoid the problem of population displacement, but would require a clear strategy in terms of landscape and architecture. The studio will operate at three distinct scales, the scale of the unit, the scale of the urban block and the scale of the
kampung. Students will be asked to develop prototypes on given cross sections of the river to be widened. This will enable advanced design experimentation and transformation of the sections under study. The goal of this studio, with the help of design tools is to
develop methodologies capable of dealing with the physical and spatial complexity of this highly urbanized “natural� environment. The underlying thesis is that landscape and architecture can be worked-out together, to bring forth solutions that can help restore the quality and purpose of the river withinits degraded context while allowing for higher living densities. With a healthy dose of
heuristic terrain analysis, prospection and design vision, students will be asked to develop a new positive foothold on the landscape
and architectural challenges posed by the Ciliwung River. The studio results will serve as example towards a new combined approach to urban landscape and architecture in Southeast Asian cities. The goal is to set some clear topological rules that can help define generative principles for both landscape and architecture as a way of restructuring urban river profiles in response to flooding,
overcrowding and insalubrious conditions. The studio will result in a set of comprehensive architectural and landscape design proposals that will serve towards the melioration of rivers in Jakarta.
4
Ciliwung River in the Kampung Melayu
5
KAMPUNG RULES
Stay always in group No individual venture will be accepted for security reasons Be very punctual at meeting points Be polite and friendly. Greet residents with „Permisi“ (= Excuse me) or „As-salam alaykum“ (= Good day, Peace be upon you) Always ask for permission first before mesuring people‘s houses Ask people before taking their pictures Bring only the necessary equipment and focuse on your assignment Always have a native speaker with you Please report position (WhatsApp) every 30 minutes (Group number: Location) Be respectful of costums, traditions and sacred places Only enter homes with agreement of the District Chief Before crossing the river on raft, make sure to have non slippery shoes Don‘t buy food or drink from street vendors Bring bottled water with you Do not touch animals
6
OBJECTIVES
Field trip to Jakarta and Singapore
site reading, architecture, landscape and urban design - developing a design hypothesis Students will develop a preliminary design hypothesis over the course of their field trip. The goal is to confirm or question certain architectural and landscape design ideas that appeared in phase 1. The proposed hypothesis must work at all 3 scales combined and needs to define a clear spatial and developmental organization for the kampung and its relationship to the city and river.
During the field trip and workshop, students will come together with students of the MLA programme at NUS, students of Architecture at U.I. Depok and students of landscape architecture at IPB Bogor. They will be asked together to think about the unit, the block and
the overall river landscape site, to determine a clear spatial hierarchy between them. The main question will be how to “invert� the relationship of the kampung to the river? The inversion of the status of the river from garbage disposer and cloaca to that of landscape riverfront will become a key element to the solution of the block, its common public spaces and units. It is, therefore, important that
students constantly work their ideas through at different scales and imagine how some of these ideas may translate from the housing scale to the entire river scale. During the field trip students will be asked to concentrate their design on specific sections of Kanpung Melayu, Bukit Duri and Kampung Pulo.
Each student group during the workshop will be asked to present a clear design statement and formulate a future vision on: - The Kampung unit and its combinatory potential - The Kampung block and its specific answer to river edge conditions - Widening of the river with volume shifting and carving - Water collection systems (wadoks and cisterns) - Flood risks and levels - The new edge condition between River Park and City - Landscape vegetation strategies, such as urban forestry, habitat and urban farming
All these aspects are to be addressed by the kampong design project: - Water types, systems and surfaces - Vegetation, types, design and structures - Spatial qualities and ambiances - Urban uses and program - Architectural edges (water/land, open/built) - Maintenance and recycling(control/freedom) - Accessibility and circulation(facilities/restrictions)
7
JAKARTA SCHEDULE TH 14.03 13:30
ETH: check-in Z端rich
15:15
ETH: flight, departure Z端rich, Qatar Airways QR064
23:10
ETH: flight, arrival Doha, Flight transfer
FR 15.03 2:20
ETH: flight, departure Doha, Qatar Airways QR 672
15:15
ETH: flight, arrival Jakarta CGK, Terminal 2
15:45 - 16:30
ETH: transfer by bus to the hotel: Aston at Kuningan Suites Hotel, Jl. Setiabudi Utara, Kuningan, +62-21 526 0260
19:00
Informal meeting with students from ETH, NUS, UI, IPB
20:00
Dinner at local restaurant
SA 16.03 7:30
Breakfast
8:00
Meeting at Aston Hotel organization of student groups.
9:00
Site visit of the kampung in small groups
12:00
Lunch break /Padang
14:00
Meeting at Aston hotel / start of discussions, working-out options
18:00
Presentations of the first ideas, with ETH, NUS, UI, IPB Faculties
20:00
Dinner
SO 17.03 7:30
Breakfast
8:00
meeting at Aston Hotel organization of student groups.
9:00
Return to the kampung in small groups for site verification
12:00
Lunch break /Padang
14:00
meeting at Aston hotel, development
18:00
Presentations of the options of the development, with ETH, NUS, UI, IPB Faculties
20:00
Dinner
MO 18.03 7:30
Breakfast
8:00
meeting of student groups at Aston Hotel.
9:00
Last visit: when necessary to the kampung in small groups for final site verification
12:00
Lunch break /Padang
14:00
groups meet at Aston hotel and complete proposals
18:00
Completed proposals (rehearsal), with ETH, NUS, UI, IPB Faculties
20:00
Dinner
TU 19.03 7:30
Breakfast
8:00
hotel check-out
8:15
transfer to the conference room: HARRIS Hotel Tebet Jakarta, Jl. Dr. Sahardjo 191 Jakarta 12960, Indonesia
09:00 - 12:00 12:00 13:00 - 15:00
8
FINAL PRESENTATION in Jakarta with Professor Hadi, Professor Herlily, Professor Rekittke, Professor Girot, Noviantari Sudarmadji, Dr Surya Tarigan Lunch at Harris Hotel transfer by taxi to the airport CGK
16:00
check-in
17:40
Flight departure Jakarta terminal 3, AirAsia QZ8268
SINGAPORE SCHEDULE 20:25 21:00 - 21:30 22:00
Flight arrival Singapore 20:25, terminal 1 ETH: transfer by taxi to the hotel: Santa Grand Hotel West Coast, 428 Pasir Panjang Road, +65 6778 6788 Dinner
WE 20.03 8:00
Breakfast
08:30 - 09:00
ETH: transfer by feet to the Create Way, Create Tower, University Town NUS, Singapore
09:00 - 12:00
BRIEFING / Campus Visit
12:00 13:00 - 17:00
Lunch Development / Desk critiques
17:00
Guest Lecture
19:00
Dinner
TH 21.03 8:00
Breakfast
08:30 - 09:00
ETH: transfer to the Create Way
09:00 - 12:00
Development / Desk critiques
12:00 13:00 - 17:00
Lunch Development / Desk critiques
17:00
Guest Lecture
19:00
Dinner
FR 22.03 8:00
Breakfast
08:30 - 09:00
ETH: transfer to the Create Way
09:00 - 12:00
Last desk critiques
12:00
Lunch
13:00 - 16:00
Presentation finalisation
17:00 - 20:00
FINAL REVIEW SEMINARWEEK in Singapore with Professor Hadi, Professor Herlily, Professor Rekittke, Professor Girot, Mahditia Paramita, Ramalis Sobandi, Noviantari Sudarmadji, Rita Padawangi
21:00
Closing dinner
SA 23.03 (free day) SO 24.03 11:00
ETH: hotel check-out (free day)
18:00
ETH: transfer from the hotel to the airport by taxi
19:00
ETH: dinner at the airport
19:30
ETH: check-in Singapore
21:05
ETH: flight, Departure from Singapore, Terminal 3, Qatar Airways QR 643
23:59
ETH: flight, arrival Doha, Flight transfer
MO 25.03 1:30
ETH: flight, departure Doha, Qatar Airways QR 061
6:30
ETH: flight, arrival in Z端rich
9
PARTICIPANTS
10
01. 02. 03. 04.
PROFESSORS Christophe Girot Jörg Rekittke Herlily Hadi Susilo Arifin
05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10.
ASSISTANTS Ilmar Hurkxkens Ervine Lin Shengwei Yazid Ninsalam Magdalena Osinska Michaela Prescott Philipp Urech
11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32.
ETH ZURICH, 22 STUDENTS Vladimir Dianiska Michael Dietrich Bettina Dobler Nathalie Ender Anna Gebhardt Demjan Haller Andreas Häni Shoichiro Hashimoto Lorraine Haussmann Edward Jewitt Benedikt Kowalewski David Kretz Annemarie Nagy Kevin Olas Oliver Roth Kylie Russnaik Pascal Ryser Mari Saetre Vera Schmidt Irene Urso Basil Witt Mélanie Ziegler
33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41.
NUS SINGAPORE, 9 STUDENTS Anna Yap Lai Fong Fu Mao Ying Heng Juit Lian Pham Le Anh Ronnie Mak Wong Ruen Qing Shami Vivek Darne Yeo Jia Hao Zhang Rong
42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50.
UI DEPOK, 9 STUDENTS Nur Fatina Risinda Feby Hendola Yudha Kartana Putra Nur Hadianto Mohammad Fazrin Rahman Kreshna Patrian Jessica Octaviani Gunawan Meidesta Pitria Nitamia Indah Cantika
51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56.
IPB BOGOR, 6 STUDENTS Budi Susetyo Sofyan Hadi Lubis Cindy Aliffia Arief Prasetyo Nugroho Arkham de Lounge Ilmy Finnuril
GROUPS ETH
NUS
UI
IPB
Group Total
Section 1a
2 Kevin, Melanie
2
…………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
6
Section 1b
2 Andreas, Bettina
1
…………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
5
Section 2a
3 Lorraine, Annemarie, Pascal
1
…………………………………………………
2 …………………………………………………
0
6
Section 2b
3 Kylie, Edward, Demjan
1
…………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
0
5
Section 3a
3 David, Mari, Natalie
1
…………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
6
Section 3b
3 Vladimir, Vera, Irene
1
…………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
6
Section 4a
3 Anna, Benedikt, Oliver
1
…………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
6
Section 4b
3 Basil, Shoichiro, Michael
1
…………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
1 …………………………………………………
6
Faculty Total
22
9
9
6
46
11
DEPLOYMENT MAP
12
13
EMERGENCY: Jakarta Police - 110 Ambulance - 118 Tourist Police 566 000; Jl Wahid Hasyim 9 On the 2nd floor of the Jakarta Theatre Jakarta Police Headquarters 523 4000 Immigration Office Central Immigration Office 654 1209; Jl Merpati Kemayoran Provides information on visa extensions and renewals. Medical Services Cikini Hospital 2355 0180; Jl Raden Saleh Raya 40 Caters to foreigners and has English-speaking staff. SOS Medika Klinik 750 5980; www.internationalsos.com; Jl Puri Sakti 10, Kemang Offers English-speaking GP appointments, dental care, and emergency and specialist healthcare services. Money There are ATMs all over the city. BCA bank ATM Jl Haji Agus Salim A stone’s throw from the Jakarta Visitor Information Office. BII bank Jl Thamrin With ATM; in the basement level of Plaza Indonesia. Post Main post office Jl Gedung Kesenian 1 Occupying an octagonal building near Lapangan Banteng.
14
LOCATIONS: Jakarta
Aston at Kuningan Suites Hotel Jl. Setiabudi Utara, Kuningan Jakarta Capital Region 12920 +62-21 526 0260
Kampung Melayu
HARRIS Hotel Tebet Jakarta Jl. Dr. Sahardjo 191 Jakarta 12960 +62 21 8303355
15
LOCATIONS: Singapore, NUS Kent Ridge Campus 1000 m Subway EW Dover
Workshop at NUS: Create Building University Town NUS Singapore
Hotel ETH: Santa Grand Hotel West Coast 428 Pasir Panjang Road Singapore 118769 +65 6778 6788
16
800 m Subway CC Haw Par Villa
17
NOTES
18
NOTES
19
Singapore ETH Centre for Global Environmental Sustainability
Dear Professor Hadi,
Zürich February 28 2013