What is hybrid warfare? Inside the centre dealing with modern threats

Mysterious underwater explosions, anonymous cyber attacks and subtle online campaigns to undermine Western democracies - these are all “hybrid threats”. The BBC visited a centre dedicated to targeting a relatively new form of warfare which is increasingly concerning Nato and the EU.

“It is about manipulation of the information space. It’s about attacks on critical infrastructure,” explains Teija Tillikainen, when asked to define hybrid warfare.

She is director of the European Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats (Hybrid CoE), which was established in Helsinki, Finland, six years ago.

Ms Tillikainen says it is an ambiguous threat format, which is something nations find very difficult to counter and protect themselves against.

But these threats are very real.

Last September, powerful underwater explosions beneath the Baltic Sea ripped gaping holes in the Nord Stream gas pipelines between the coasts of Denmark and Sweden. The pipelines were constructed to carry Russian gas to northern Germany.

Moscow was quick to deny any responsibility, but Western suspicions centred around a potential Russian motive to further starve the West of energy, as punishment for backing Ukraine after Russia’s invasion last February.

Then there is electoral interference. Few people realised at the time, but after the 2016 US elections, investigators concluded there had been concerted Russian interference - again, denied by Moscow - with the aim of damaging Hillary Clinton’s chances, in favour of Donald Trump.

This was allegedly conducted using online “bots” - artificial online accounts on social media controlled by state-backed cyber activists, working out of “troll factories” in St Petersburg.

Another method is disinformation - the deliberate propagating of an alternative, false narrative, often one that appeals to certain more receptive sections of a population. This phenomenon has accelerated since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, with millions of citizens - not just in Russia but even in Western countriesaccepting the Kremlin’s line that the invasion was a necessary act of self-defence.

To help Western governments identify and protect themselves against these threats, Nato and the EU set up the Hybrid CoE in Finland. The country is an interesting and perhaps natural choice for such a centre. For decades, it has stayed officially neutral, ever since it lost a short winter war with Russia in 1940.

But the two countries share a border which is 1,300km (807 miles) long, and a nervous Finland has been drawing ever closer to the West, culminating in its application to join Nato last year.

On a cold, snowy morning, I visited the centre, housed in an office block close to the defence ministry and just a short distance from the grey, Soviet-era Russian embassy building.

There, director Teija Tillikainen leads a team of around 40 analysts and subject-matter experts drawn from a number of Nato and EU countries, including a Briton on loan from the Ministry of Defence.

She explains that a current area of focus is in the Arctic, where they have mapped a lot of hybrid threat potential.

“There are new energy sources emerging,” she explains. “There are new possibilities for great powers to protect their interests. There’s also a lot of manipulation of information.

“The Russian narrative is the Arctic is a special region outside of conflicts where nothing bad is happening - and still Russia is building up its military there.”

Perhaps the key distinguishing features of hybrid threats are that they almost never involve an actual “kinetic” attack - someone opening fire with a weapon. They are much more subtle, but often no less dangerous. They are also nonattributable in nature, meaning it is usually hard to determine who was behind these acts, such as the 2007 massive cyber attack on Estonia, or last year’s gas pipeline explosions under the Baltic. The perpetrators take care to leave as few clues as possible.

There are numerous ways one state can damage another short of direct military action.

This is illustrated by a handbook drawn up by the centre, outlining maritime hybrid threats - containing 10 imaginary but highly-plausible scenarios. They range from the clandestine use of underwater weapons to declaring a control zone around an island, plus the blocking of narrow straits.

One real scenario they have examined in detail was Russia’s actions in the Sea of Azov prior to its invasion of Ukraine. From October 2018 onwards, in order for Ukrainian ships to progress from their home ports of Mariupol and Berdyansk through the Kerch Strait and out into the Black Sea, they first had to queue for inspection by Russian officials. These delays, says Jukka Savolainen, the director of vulnerabilities and resilience, could stretch into days or even up to two weeks, inflicting economic damage on Ukraine.

But it is in the field of disinformation that the centre’s experts have found the most surprising results. After collating and assessing numerous opinion polls across Europe, they have come to the conclusion that in several Nato countries, Russia is winning the information war amongst substantial portions of the population.

In Germany, for example, the Kremlin’s narrative that its attack on Ukraine was a necessary reaction to Nato provocation has been gaining popularity as the war continues. In Slovakia, more than 30% of those polled believed the Ukraine war was deliberately provoked by the West. In Hungary, 18% blamed “the oppression of the Russian-speaking population in Ukraine” for the war.

Jakub Kalensky, a senior analyst from the Czech Republic, uses the analogy of water to illustrate the need to suppress Moscow’s disinformation campaign.

“I wouldn’t evaluate Russian disinformation as particularly sophisticated,” he explains. “It’s not about the attractiveness of the message, but the way they achieve success is through sheer numbers. There’s no reason to give these people access to social media platforms. Everyone wants to have access to fresh water, but we don’t allow them to poison the water.”

Ms Tillikainen says it is not the centre’s role to undertake measures to counter hybrid threats - but to assess, inform and then train others to do what needs to be done to protect Europe from this growing phenomenon.

Source: BBC

Public Notice

JANGERU FAHIMTAR JUNA DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR REMOVAL OF TRUSTEE/SECRETARY AND APPOINTMENT OF TRUSTEE AND SECRETARY UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1. BALARABE JIBRIN ( CHAIRMAN)

2.YAKUBU HAMISU ( FINANCIAL SECRETARY)

3.JIBRIN SAIFULLAHI BALARABE ( TRUSTEE)

4.HAMISU YASIR (TRUSTEE)

5.ABDULLAHI KABIRU ( SECRETARY) - REMOVED

THE NEW TRUSTEE IS :

1.MR. YAKUBU HAMISU. - NEW SECRETARY REMOVAL OF TRUSTEE/SECRETARY AND APPOINTMENT OF TRUSTEE/ SECRETARY.

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES REMAIN THE SAME.

ANY OBJECTION TO THIS APPLICATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION.

SIGNED : SECRETARY

ADDRESS : NO.32 ,AHMADU BELLO WAY,KANO STATE,NIGERIA.

PUBLIC NOTICE

PERAZIM EMPOWERMENT INITIATIVE

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR REGISTRATION UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1. OLUWAYOMI CALEB OLUWADAMILARE - PRESIDENT

2. AWOLALU OLUFEMI BENJAMIN - SECRETARY

3. OYEWOLE BUSOYE ABIOYE

4. ADE FUWA ADEPEJU ABIOLA

5. ADEOYE SUNDAY OLAYINKA

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES ARE :

A. TO ALLEVIATE POVERTY, HUNGER AND AGONY THROUGH ASSISTING THE NEEDY AND UNDER PRIVILEGED.

ANY OBJECTION TO THIS REGISTRATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT , OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION.

SIGNED : SECRETARY.

PUBLIC NOTICE

NATIONAL GINGER ASSOCIATION OF NIG CAC/IT/NO.17625.

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR CHANGE OF TRUSTEE UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE NEW APPOINTED TRUSTEE IS :

1.GAGARIN KAZANSHIYI MADAKI

THE TRUSTEES WILL NOW BE; THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1. SENATOR HARUNA AZIZ ZEGO - CHAIRMAN

2. ENGINEER BAWA MAGAJI - SECRETARY

3. GENERAL YUNANA NOM(RTD)

4. MR. JOE MATTHEW ITAH

5. CHIEF ADENIJI AKINWUNI

6. CHIEF PRINCEWILL CHINA ONYEGBU

7. MR. UMAR FARUK JAKADA

8. GAGARIN KAZANSHIYI MADAKI

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES REMAIN THE SAME.

ANY OBJECTION TO THIS APPLICATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION.

SIGNED : SENATOR HARUNA AZIZ ZEGO.

Public Notice

CONTRACTORS ASSOCIATION OF KADUNA STATE CAC/IT/NO.34236

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR CERTIFIED TRUE COPY (CTC) OF ORIGINAL CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE CURRENT/NEW TRUSTEES ARE :

1.HABILA DAUDA

2. MUSA MAGAJI

3.ADAMU ABDULRAHAMAN

4.ANTHONY BALA

5.KASIMU GARBA

6.BABA AHMED

7.ABDULRAHMAN SHITTU

8.MOHAMMED USMAN

9.SANI MUSTAPHA

10.MOHAMMED ABDULRAHAMAN

11.AISHA GWANDU

12.GANBE SANI.

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES REMAIN THE SAME.

ANY OBJECTION TO THIS APPLICATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR_GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT , OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION.

SIGNED : SECRETARY

PUBLIC NOTICE

GOM SIGHT AND HEALTH FOUNDATION

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR REGISTRATION UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1.DR. ONYEKACHI MADUBUATTAH -. CHAIRMAN

2.NONSO HELEN OBAH - SECRETARY

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES ARE :

1. TO HELP THE LESS PRIVILEGED.

2.TO IMPROVE LIVES OF PEOPLE LIVING IN DEPRIVED AREAS AND PROMOTE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT HEALTH PROGRAMS.

3.TO WORK FOR THE PROMOTION AND IMPROVEMENT OF THE HEALTH AND HEALTHCARE OF THE CHILDREN, OLD PEOPLE AND ADULT IN NIGERIA.

ANY OBJECTION TO THIS REGISTRATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT , OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION. SIGNED : SECRETARY.

PUBLIC NOTICE

ALPHA INTEGRITY SOCIAL CLUB

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR REGISTRATION UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1. IKOKO HENRY (CHAIRMAN)

2. AKHIROME IDONIJE EROMOSE (SECRETARY)

3. IDEMUDIA BOBMORTON MATTHEW

4. ATUDUHOR DIECHOMORA OHWOFASA

5. EKABA DAVID

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES ARE :

1. TO PROMOTE PEACE AND UNITY AMONGST MEMBERS.

2. TO SERVE AS A FORUM WHERE MEMBERS CAN INTERACT, ARTICULATE AND FORMULATE IDEAS FOR THE PROTECTION AND PROMOTION OF THEIR GENERAL WELFARE. ANY OBJECTION TO THIS REGISTRATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT , OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION. SIGNED : MOHAMMED ATTAHIRU TEL: 08036492700.

PUBLIC NOTICE

WOMEN VENDORS PROGRESSIVE ASSOCIATION NIGER

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR REGISTRATION UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1. JAMILATU ISAH - CHAIRPERSON

2. ZAINAB ISAH - TREASURER

3. SALAMATU MOHAMMED - MEMBER

4. HAUWA MOHAMMED - SECRETARY

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES ARE :

1. TO IMPROVE THE WELFARE OF THE MEMBERS

2. TO CREATE JOB OPPORTUNITY AMONG THE MEMBERS AND ENCOURAGE THEM ON SKILL ACQUISITION IN ORDER TO BE SELF RELIANCE.

3. TO FORM A NETWORK AMONGST OURSELVES AND BE READY TO SUPPORT EACH OTHER IN ANY LITTLE WAY WE CAN.

4. TO ENCOURAGE OR EMPOWER OTHER WOMEN AMONG US WHO ARE NOT STRONG AND EVEN THOSE WHO ARE NOT PART OF US.

5. TO CHANGE THE NEGATIVE PERCEPTION ABOUT WOMEN BEING A BURDEN IN OUR SOCIETYE. ANY OBJECTION TO THIS REGISTRATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT , OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION. SIGNED : SECRETARY

PUBLIC NOTICE

The Elect Faith Tabernacle

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR REGISTRATION UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1. ADAJE JAMES - CHAIRMAN

2. ADAJE GODWIN OWOICHO - SECRETARY

3. ILECHUKWU OZOEMENA EMEKA - MEMBER

4. AKADE PHILIP IORTYOM - MEMBER

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES ARE :

1. IMPARTING TO MEN MORAL, MENTAL AND SPIRITUAL VALUES.

2. TO TEACH AND PREACH THE WORD OF GOD.

3. TO PROPAGATE THE GOSPEL OF OUR LORD JESUS CHRIST.

ANY OBJECTION TO THIS REGISTRATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT , OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION.

SIGNED : SECRETARY.

Public Notice

ANATOLE EMPOWERMENT AND ADVOCACY FOUNDATION

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR REGISTRATION UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1. OLATUNJI EMMANUEL OLUWOLE

2. OLATUNJI COMFORT

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES ARE :

1. TO PROVIDE SUPPORT TO TEENAGERS AND YOUTH IN THE CHOICE OF THEIR LIFE CAREER AND SELF DEVELOPMENT

2. TO PROVIDE SUPPORT AND GUIDANCE TO TEENAGERS AND YOUTH AGAINST CRIME AND OTHER DESTRUCTIVE LIFESTYLES

3. TO PROVIDE MENTORSHIP TO TEENAGERS AND YOUTH.

ANY OBJECTION TO THIS REGISTRATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT , OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET , MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION.

SIGNED : SECRETARY.

Public Notice

IFEMED 92 ALUMNI ASSOCIATION

THIS IS TO INFORM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT THE ABOVE NAMED HAS APPLIED TO THE CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION (CAC), ABUJA FOR REGISTRATION UNDER PART ‘F’ OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, ( CAMA 2020).

THE TRUSTEES ARE :

1. LOTO OLABISI MOREBISE (CHAIRMAN)

2. AYENI OLAWALE OLUGBENGA (SECRETARY)

3. OLARINDE OLUFUNSO YETUNDE

4. OLADELE AYODEJI OLANREWAJU

5. ADEDIGBA MICHAEL ADEWOLE

THE AIMS AND OBJECTIVES ARE :

1. TO PROMOTE THE INTERESTS AND WELFARE OF ALL HER MEMBERS WHILE MAINTAINING A COMMON BOND AMONGST ALL MEMBERS.

2. TO ENCOURAGE ALL ASPECTS OF THE GROWTH OF THE OAU COLLEGE OF HEALTH SCIENCES.

3. TO ORGANIZE REGULAR ALUMNI EVENTS.

4. TO PROMOTE PROFESSIONALISM AMONG MEMBERS.

5. TO COOPERATE WITH OTHER BODIES WITH SIMILAR AIMS AND OBJECTIVES. ANY OBJECTION TO THIS REGISTRATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR-GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420, TIGRIS CRESCENT , OFF AGUIYI IRONSI STREET MAITAMA , ABUJA WITHIN 28DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION.

SIGNED : SECRETARY.

CHRIST OF GOD MISSION. CAC/ IT/ NO 3335

1) ONYI ABRAHAM NNAJIOFOR - REMOVED.

2) NWEKE DAVID - REMOVED.

3) UGWU CHARLES - REMOVED.

4) ONWURAH HENRY - REMOVED.

5) NKWOCHA VINCENT - REMOVED. NEW TRUSTEES:

1) OZOUDE KELVIN IKECHUKWU - NEWLY APPOINTED

2) OKEKE UGOCHUKWU GAIUS - NEWLY APPOINTED.

3) NWEKE ONYEKA EPHRAIM - NEWLY APPOINTED.

4) ANICHEBE MICHEAL IKEAGUN - NEWLY APPOINTED.

5) UKATU IFEANYI DESTINY - NEWLY APPOINTED.

6) UKATU OBIORA SOLUTION NEWLY APPOINTED.

7) NWEKE NONSO STEPHEN - NEWLY APPOINTED.

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES ARE STILL THE SAME.

ANY OBJECTION TO THE APPLICATION SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO THE REGISTRAR

GENERAL, CORPORATE AFFAIRS COMMISSION, PLOT 420 TIGRIS CRESCENT, OFF AGUIYI

IRONSI STREET MAITAMA ABUJA WITHIN 28 DAYS OF THIS PUBLICATION.

SIGNED: UGWUOKE MARTINS CHIJIOKE. 08039228273.