Page 4A
Powhatan Today, May 19, 2021
CITIZENS Continued from pg. 1
tively – were packed with people, many of whom made their voices heard. In all, 37 people spoke during the board of supervisors meeting (all but one on this topic) and 21 in front of the school board, with some overlap of speakers. The core issue started with the question of what people feel should or should not be taught to students in Powhatan schools. But over the course of two nights and because of the expansion beyond the initial purview of the school board, the scope of topics expanded to issues of budget controls, the validity of Critical Race Theory, racism, and, in some ways, Powhatan’s very identity. While some of the topics discussed were already highly likely to be brought up at the school board meeting, comments made a week earlier by supervi-
sor Mike Byerly, who represents District 3, heightened the tensions and brought them boiling over a night earlier. During the discussion about the budget on May 3, Byerly spent 30 minutes talking about school funding and implying he would base his decision about the budget on what the school may be teaching or ideologies it may be promoting. While the broader topics were always present, many of the people who spoke to the supervisors on May 10 addressed Byerly in particular, either offering support and appreciation for his comments or expressing hurt from them and asking for an apology. His questioning of school curriculum and what taxpayer dollars were being spent on, as well as the way he approached the subjects, brought strong reactions in many ways. In the days following the May 3 meeting, two
Hello Ladies, and Gentlemen. My name is Sir Hamilton, but my friends call me Hammy. I am around 6 years old, and a very playful boy, I get along well with other dogs, and let me tell you, Toys WOW I never knew I could have so much fun with something that squeak’s Sir Hamilton HaHa. But seriously I am a very good boy, who unfortunately the owners never came for me, which makes me sad, because I was well taken care of, and I thought I did everything right to make sure they loved me. I am pretty neat in my kennel, I love office time, I love toys, treats, Just about anything makes me happy, But what I really want most is to be in a home, with a loving family. If you would like to make me a part of your family, Please call 804-598-5672 and the staff will be happy to assist in scheduling you an appointment to meet me. Hope to see you soon.
If you would like to help the animals in our care, you can do so by donating to our medical fund at Claws and Paws, 4313 Anderson Hwy., Powhatan, VA 23139 Powhatan Sheriff’s Office | Division Of Animal Control Phone: 804-598-5672 | Fax: 804-598-5109
different petitions were started as a result on Change.org on the topic. The first, which was created on May 7, is a petition in support of Byerly, praising him for having the “courage to speak up and ask the ‘hard questions.’ The second petition, which was created on May 8, called Byerly’s comments dismissive of the lived experience of people of color and asked for an apology. After the last of the speakers had shared their thoughts with the school board, the actual topic that many people said drew them to the meetings – hearing the school division address Critical Race Theory (CRT) in the schools and the use of controversial resources – was treated almost as an afterthought. The school board took a brief break between the public comment period and moving on with the rest of the agenda, and the update on the development of a new elective African American History class – the catalyst that started this discussion – was held within minutes of calling the meeting back to order. But by that time more than half of those who came to the meeting had already left. Dr. Eric Jones, superintendent, assured the audience that remained that the course is being built for Powhatan and will reflect the community, including the inclusion of local history. He stressed multiple times that the controversial New York Times’ 1619 Project that was spoken about by so many will not be used as a resource for developing the class. “We stated that back in February and we have stated it emphatically ever since then – that the 1619 Project will not be part of the curriculum of this course. There are lots of other, very valid curriculum resources that can teach a robust African American History course
that will allow students to critically examine African American contributions to our country and their role within that country. That is what our goal is and that is the goal of the course,” Jones said. Jones also stated unequivocally that they “have no plans to, have never had any plans to, and will not use Critical Race Theory in this course.”
Recent history While discussions about racism and education are by no means a new topic, the current iteration of the local discussion began to bubble over in December 2020. The school board was asked to consider the course planning guide for the next school year, and on that list was the elective African American History class. Although the final class curriculum would be built by Powhatan County Public Schools, the Virginia Department of Education, which offered the framework for the course, also included with it a list of possible resources school divisions could use to create their courses. Among those was the 1619 Project. Even before the board had its first discussion on the issue on Dec. 8, 2020, members said they had been receiving concerned emails and calls. At the school board’s Dec. 10 joint meeting with the board of supervisors, 10 people spoke about the ideology behind the terms equity, diversity, and inclusion, which have been a big focus for PCPS in recent years. While none of the speakers stated they were against approving the history class, a few did specifically oppose using the 1619 Project as a resource. At the Jan. 12, 2021, meeting where the school board actually approved the course guide, several people spoke in support of
the history class, and some even defended the 1619 Project as providing a perspective that challenges people to think critically about history. The school board did ultimately approve the course guide with the new elective on Jan. 12, but it was with the understanding that staff would be coming back with updates from the committee of educators working on it. The first update on the African American History class was scheduled for the school board’s May 11 meeting. In addition to his assurance that neither CRT nor the 1619 Project would be part of the course, Jones said people interested in the development of the course can follow its progress in posts on the school division’s website, http://www.powhatan.k12.va.us. He also pointed out that 31 students at Powhatan High School have signed up for the elective course and another 43 have it listed as an alternate in case they are unable to get into one of their other electives. He said he is happy to see so much interest in the course.
The public speaks On May 10 and 11, a combined total of 46 people spoke at the two meetings (11 people spoke at both) regarding these topics. Both meetings saw some high emotions, including small arguments among speakers at the board of supervisors meeting and the school board addressing outbursts and trying unsuccessfully to make everyone in the audience adhere to the mask mandate. While there wasn’t a strict dividing line that every speaker fell on one side of, many of the comments tended to lean to one side or the other. On one side were people who agreed with Byerly’s comments; spoke of the need to keep CRT out
CHURCH DIRECTORY St. Luke’s Episcopal Church
SUNDAYS Live Stream Worship!
www.stlukespowhatan.org All are Welcome For more information visit www.stlukespowhatan.org Route 711 at Three Bridge Road 794-6953
EVERGREEN COMMUNITY CHURCH (PCA) Proclaiming & Practicing the Gospel of Jesus Christ
Outdoor Worship Service at 10:00 AM Meeting at 2895 Lower Hill Road
The Bridge
Genito Church Presbyterian “Building a Bridge of Hope” Isaiah 58:12 Church 2910 Genito Rd. Powhatan, VA
372-9074 Worship with us this Sunday Church service @ 9:30 AM Sunday school @ 10:30 AM
Sundays: Morning Worship 10:00 AM Wednesday: Family Life Night 7:00 PM 2480 Academy Road 598-7159 Pastor: Johnathan M. Whichard
Powhatan Christian Fellowship
All Are Welcome!
3308 Pleasants Road, 1/4 mile off of Route 711 Russ Cress, Pastor 598-0733
Sunday Morning Worship “Worshiping and Witnessing 11:00 a.m. in Western Powhatan Sunday School 10:00 a.m. since 1825” Wednesday Night 7:30 p.m. Worship Service 11:00 am
598-4970
598-8844
Located 1950 Ridge Road (Rt. 627)
Rev. Robert Barnes
St. John Neumann Catholic Church Worship Service 10 AM Meeting in the gym
Meeting Sundays in Amelia, Farmville, Fork Union, Midlothian, Powhatan and Online. Visit pccwired.net for services times & locations. 598-1174 pccwired.net
Rev. Walter G. Lewis, Pastor Living As Christ’s Disciples Within Our Hearts and Beyond Our Doors 2253 Rosson Rd.
Just off Rt. 13 in the Village
598-4438
Worship: 8:30 & 10am
www.powhatanumc.us Weekday Preschool (ages 2-5)
598-6090
Mount Calvary Baptist Church 2020 Red Lane Road
Powhatan, VA 23139 1801 Huguenot Trail Sunday School 9am Pastor, Larry B. Collins Sunday Worship 10am Sunday School 9:45 a.m. Wednesday Bible Study 6:45pm Sunday Worship 11:00 a.m. Wednesday Bible Study Bryan M. Holt, Pastor 7:30 p.m. 378-3607 www.EmmausChristianChurch.org Office 804-598-2398
Community Church Dr. Cavell W. Phillips, Pastor Where there is Unity, there is always Victory. A church “Where you are welcome” Wednesday: Bible Study Join Us For Sunday Worship 6:30 – 7:30pm ( 60 Minute 11:00AM – 12:30PM Warm Up To Sunday ) Powhatan Village Building 3910 Old Buckingham Road ucc4me.org Powhatan, VA 804-256-4411
see CITIZENS, pg. 7
Advertise in Church Directory.
Providence Presbyterian Church
ECCPCA.ORG
of Powhatan schools; said they did not want to encourage issues that cause obvious divisiveness in the community, and said that since it is the board of supervisors’ job to oversee the budget, Byerly had a right to ask the school board for transparency. On the other side were people who said they were deeply hurt by Byerly’s comments as dismissive to the realities of racism they face – both in the schools and the communities; argued for the need to have the African American History class to offer people the opportunity to learn more about the contributions of people of color; argued for the inclusion of more perspectives when looking at history; outlined examples of racism observed by students in Powhatan schools, and requested the board of supervisors fully support the schools. Sarah Taylor, who said she started the petition in support Byerly, spoke at both meetings. While she believes racism still exists and children need to learn about other cultures, she said that CRT and the 1619 Project are not the ways to teach it. She and many other speakers said these theories focus on oppression and division and deny the principals and freedom on which the nation was founded. Rebecca Courtright, who started the petition asking for Byerly’s apology, told the board of supervisors that his approach to the issue didn’t involve good budget questions. She said she thought he was a supervisor elected to represent all of his constituents, “not a Fox News commentator.” She also said his comments hurt people in the community because the words dismissed their experiences. Joe Ordia, who spoke at both meetings, shared the story of his father emigrating from Nigeria to the
Saturday - 5 p.m. Sunday - 8:30 a.m. & 11 a.m. 598-3754 www.sjnpowhatan.org Located behind Flat Rock Village Shopping Center
Call 804-746-1235 ext. 2 for details.
