AI Generated Graphic by LInda Restrepo © 2024
FORECASTING FEARS : THE EVOLUTION OF UNDERSEA CABLE THREATS FROM THEORY TO
REALITY
LINDA RESTREPO
COPYRIGHT © 2024
THE SILENT ARTERIES OF OUR DIGITAL WORLD
Imagine a world abruptly disconnected from its digital pulse— financial markets in limbo, global communications at a standstill, and the essential flow of information ceasing. This scenario, reminiscent of dystopian fiction, reflects a real and present danger to the undersea cables that weave a web of data and connectivity across our globe.
Recent disruptions in the Red Sea have brought to light the delicate nature of these critical networks, underscoring an urgent call for bolstered security measures.
Nestled between the Mediterranean Sea and the Indian Ocean, the Red Sea functions as more than a crucial maritime route; it is a digital artery, pulsating with a significant
share of the world's internet traffic. These undersea cables, resting unseen on the ocean's bed, form the backbone of our global connectivity, ensuring the seamless operation of everything from international commerce and finance to personal communications and entertainment. Their silent service renders them invisible, yet they are fundamentally indispensable to our daily existence.
However, this vital infrastructure faces threats from multiple fronts. Recent damage to cables within the Red Sea region has highlighted the susceptibility of these networks to sabotage, natural calamities, and technical mishaps. These incidents do more than interrupt global communication; they expose the overarching vulnerabilities of undersea cables and the potential for widespread impact on international stability, economies, and governance.
3
FROM THEORY TO THREAT: THE REALIZATION OF UNDERSEA CABLE VULNERABILITIES
In early 2024, the Red Sea became a focal point for significant concerns regarding the security of undersea communication cables, integral to global internet connectivity. The series of events began with Houthi rebels' targeted disruptions, first by severing these cables, causing substantial interruptions in international data flow.
This act alone put a spotlight on the fragility of the world's digital infrastructure, reliant on these underwater pathways for maintaining global connectivity. The situation escalated as further assaults on maritime assets were recorded, notably the attack on the cargo ship Rubymar. This incident wasn't just another entry in the log
of regional hostilities; it underscored the Houthis' capability and willingness to target infrastructure critical to global communications, beyond just the internet cables.
Adding depth to the crisis, initial warnings from Yemeni telecom companies had pointed to the Houthis' intentions to target such infrastructure, signaling a premeditated focus on undersea cables that channel approximately 17% of the world's internet traffic through the Red Sea. A Houthiaffiliated Telegram channel even posted a map, illustrating the dense network of cables along strategic maritime routes, further underlining the potential for these cables to become focal points in broader geopolitical conflicts.
Amplifying these concerns, the Gulf International Forum released a report warning of the heightened risk to these vital cables from Houthi activities. This report not only reaffirmed the immediate threat to global communications but also highlighted the strategic
significance of Yemen's geographical location as a nexus for international internet channels. The suggestion that the Houthis might expand their target scope from surface attacks to the undersea cable network introduced a new dimension to the conflict, with farreaching implications for global communications and the economy.
These incidents collectively highlight a complex interplay of regional politics, military strategy, and the essential infrastructure underpinning global connectivity. They serve as a stark reminder of the undersea cables' strategic importance and vulnerability, prompting a call for vigilant security measures and international cooperation to safeguard these critical networks from becoming casualties of regional hostilities.
The potential targeting of undersea cables by Houthi rebels represents not just a regional security issue but a global concern, necessitating a unified response to protect the infrastructure that supports the world's digital economy.
NAVIGATING THE DEPTHS:
AI'S ROLE IN SECURING THE WORLD'S INTERNET BACKBONE
In an era of unprecedented global interconnectivity, undersea cables stand as the unsung heroes of international communication and economic exchange.
Spanning vast oceanic expanses, these cables are the carriers of more than
95% of cross-border data, enabling a spectrum of activities from high-speed internet access to secure governmental exchanges. This extensive network, often invisible to the casual observer, is the foundation upon which the digital age is built, facilitating a flow of information and connectivity that knows no borders.
5
alarms raised by NATO have spotlighted the risk of targeted sabotage against these undersea lifelines—a risk with the potential to severely disrupt international communications and inflict considerable damage on the global economy. The exposure of these cables on the ocean floor marks
enhanced protective measures has never been more pronounced.
RIPPLE EFFECTS: A RED SEA ASSAULT UNRAVELS GLOBAL CONNECTIVITY
Ai generated by LInda Restrepo © 2024The recent disturbances in the Red Sea, particularly the targeted assault on the cargo ship Rubymar, have not only spotlighted the physical vulnerabilities of undersea cables but have also unveiled the immediate and significant impact on global telecommunications. The incident precipitated a substantial disruption, affecting as much as 25% of internet traffic between Asia, Europe, and the Middle East—a testament to the interconnected nature of our modern world and the critical role these cables play in it.
The cargo ship Rubymar is owned by a UK-based entity. This British ownership was a key aspect of the incident, which resulted in the ship sinking in the Red Sea after being targeted by Houthi attacks. The incident has broader implications, shedding light on the vulnerabilities of maritime and undersea cable infrastructure in conflict-prone regions.
The aftermath of the attacks saw damage to at least 15 submarine cables traversing the Bab alMandab Strait, including major
conduits like EIG, AAE-1, Seacom, and TGN-EA. This not only underscores the strategic vulnerabilities associated with the Red Sea's geopolitical landscape but also the broader implications for international communications in times of conflict.
The Houthis, also known as Ansar Allah, are a significant force within Yemen, emerging in the 1990s and gaining prominence by capturing Yemen's capital, Sana'a, in 2014. This movement led to a Saudi-led coalition's military intervention in 2015, aiming to restore the displaced government, which has escalated into a prolonged conflict and severe humanitarian crisis in Yemen. The Houthis have received support from Iran. Sources: Brookings, Al Jazeera, and the Council on Foreign Relations.
Yemeni officials' prior warnings about the Houthis' potential targeting of these cables have borne out, highlighting the anticipatory intelligence that, sadly, materialized into tangible threats. The denials by the Houthis, attributing disruptions to military operations by Western forces, 7
further complicate the scenario, embedding it within the intricate tapestry of regional and international tensions.
UNDERLINING THE URGENCY FOR PROTECTIVE MEASURES
This scenario exemplifies the fragile state of our global communications infrastructure amid regional disputes, emphasizing the paramount importance of securing these networks against the backdrop of military activities and geopolitical strife. The considerable impact on global telecommunications not only reflects the immediate fallout from such disruptions but also serves as a clarion call for reinforced vigilance and protective measures.
SYNTHESIZING THE CALL FOR AI AND
INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATION
As we delve deeper into the nuances of these threats, the role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in pre-empting and mitigating such disruptions becomes even more pivotal.
Coupled with the need for an orchestrated international response —as exemplified by NATO's focused efforts through the Maritime Centre for the Security of Critical Underwater Infrastructure—this comprehensive approach underscores the multifaceted strategy required to safeguard our digital lifelines.
AI TO THE RESCUE: PREDICTIVE ANALYSIS AND THREAT DETECTION
In the intricate web of undersea cable security, Artificial Intelligence (AI) emerges as a pivotal ally, not a cure-all but a formidable force in addressing the nuanced challenges of safeguarding this
essential infrastructure. AI's utility lies in its capacity for predictive analysis and threat detection, employing data mining and pattern recognition to identify potential vulnerabilities in the vast, murky depths where these cables reside.
Forecasting Threats with Precision through Predictive Analysis
AI's capability to parse through extensive datasets and identify patterns and anomalies that may elude human observation is invaluable. Through data mining, AI algorithms scrutinize past incidents of cable damage, factoring in environmental conditions, geopolitical tensions, and preceding events to forecast potential threats. This predictive analysis, although not infallible, allows for a degree of precision that facilitates preemptive measures.
The power of predictive analysis lies in its comprehensive examination of diverse
data sources. It identifies areas at increased risk of sabotage or accidental harm, perhaps due to heightened maritime traffic or geopolitical unrest. Utilizing tools like satellite imagery and shipping data, AI can detect unusual naval activities near vital cable routes, flagging them for further human assessment.
Real-time Monitoring: A Vigilant Guardian
Beyond predictive capabilities, AI excels in the real-time monitoring of undersea cable integrity. With sensors and remote monitoring technology, AI systems continuously evaluate cable conditions, pinpointing slight irregularities that may signify early damage or malfunction signs.
This vigilant surveillance extends to both passive and active mechanisms. AI evaluates the optical signals within fiber-optic cables for eavesdropping or interference signs, alerting operators to security breaches. Concurrently, AI-equipped autonomous underwater vehicles
9
(AUVs) survey cables for physical damage, offering instantaneous feedback to operators.
Navigating the Limits of AI
Acknowledging AI's limitations is as crucial as recognizing its strengths. The efficacy of AI is contingent on data quality and completeness. Inaccurate predictions or missed threats may result from incomplete or biased datasets. Moreover, AI cannot supplant the nuanced judgment of experts who grasp the intricate geopolitical and environmental factors influencing cable security.
AI's ability to differentiate between benign and malicious activities, particularly in busy maritime zones, introduces the risk of false positives. This
necessitates a balanced approach, integrating AI's insights with expert human analysis for conclusive decision-making.
AI stands as an indispensable instrument in the arsenal against threats to undersea cables, bolstering predictive analysis and real-time surveillance capabilities. However, its deployment must be nuanced, acknowledging both its potential and limitations. The synergy of AI with human oversight paves the way towards a more secure foundation for the silent backbone of global connectivity, ensuring the protection of the undersea cables that knit our interconnected world together.
ENHANCING NATO'S DEFENSIVE STRATEGY WITH AI
In the domain of undersea infrastructure defense, AI markedly enhances NATO's strategic operations. The establishment of
AI Generated Graphic by LInda Restrepo © 2024
NATO’s Maritime Centre for the Security of Critical Underwater Infrastructure exemplifies the alliance's commitment to addressing the vulnerabilities of undersea cables crucial for both civilian and military communications. Integrating AI into NATO's strategic framework could substantially elevate these protective efforts, providing both predictive insights and operational efficiencies.
A PROACTIVE STANCE WITH PREDICTIVE THREAT
MODELING
AI's expertise in predictive threat modeling furnishes NATO with a strategic edge, enabling the anticipation of potential
assaults before their execution. By analyzing maritime activities, cyber incidents, and geopolitical dynamics, AI algorithms uncover patterns indicative of imminent threats to undersea cables.
This predictive capacity empowers NATO to fortify defenses proactively in sensitive areas, potentially deterring hostile actions.
Furthermore, AI's ability to simulate various attack scenarios enhances NATO's preparedness, informing the development of comprehensive protection measures and rapid response protocols. Such simulations ensure NATO's readiness to confront a range of threats, solidifying the resilience of undersea infrastructure.
Optimizing Naval Operations and Strengthening Collaborations with AI
AI's role in bolstering NATO's defensive strategy is multifaceted, particularly in optimizing naval patrol routes. By analyzing extensive oceanographic data, AI
algorithms can strategically recommend patrol paths, significantly improving the detection of suspicious activities and acting as a deterrent against potential threats.
This optimization not only boosts the efficiency of naval operations but also maximizes resource allocation, ensuring a comprehensive coverage of critical zones without redundancy.
AI as a Catalyst for NATO's Maritime Centre Mission
The NATO Maritime Centre for the Security of Critical Underwater Infrastructure stands as a testament to the alliance's dedication to safeguarding vital communication links. Here, AI emerges as a critical support system, enhancing the Centre's capabilities in threat analysis, decision-making, and 13
AI Generated Graphic by LInda Restrepo © 2024operational planning. The integration of AI enables a proactive stance against evolving threats, merging cutting-edge technology with strategic defense objectives to protect undersea infrastructure effectively.
THE NECESSITY OF PUBLICPRIVATE COLLABORATION IN CABLE DEFENSE
Undersea cables, the backbone of international internet traffic, are predominantly owned by a mix of private companies and, to a lesser extent, state-owned entities. The control and ownership of these cables have significant geopolitical implications, especially as the internet becomes increasingly central to global commerce, communication, and security.
Private tech giants like Google and Facebook have been rapidly increasing their stakes in
undersea cables. By 2020, these companies were expected to own about 29% of the global undersea cables, with some cables wholly owned end-to-end by a single company, such as Google's ownership of the Curie cable running from Chile to Los Angeles .
This ownership structure presents a complex scenario where the cables, although privately owned, traverse international waters and sovereign territories, subject to a myriad of international laws and treaties.
The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) provides a legal framework that allows states the freedom to lay submarine cables in international waters, with certain restrictions when crossing into a state's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) or continental shelf. Once cables enter a sovereign state's territorial sea, the companies operating these projects must navigate various permits, licenses, and environmental agreements according to local laws and international treaties .
Given the critical role these cables play in global connectivity and the mixed ownership landscape, the necessity for public-private collaboration in cable defense becomes clear. Governments, private cable operators, and tech companies need to unite their efforts to enhance the resilience of these cables against physical and cyber threats. This collaborative approach is essential not just for the security of the cables but also for maintaining the stability and vitality of global communication networks.
AI: Beyond Security to Operational Efficiency
The application of AI in undersea cable defense transcends traditional security measures, offering substantial improvements in operational efficiency and response strategies. Predictive maintenance algorithms can preempt potential failures, minimizing downtime and economic impact. In cases of damage, AI's ability to swiftly localize faults accelerates repair efforts, ensuring a rapid restoration of services and mitigating disruptions to global communication
flows.Crafting a Unified Approach to Undersea Cable Protection
The implementation of AI in the defense of undersea cables necessitates a collaborative framework that spans data sharing, research, and operational strategies.
Establishing clear guidelines for such collaboration can foster an environment of trust and mutual benefit, essential for the effective application of AI technologies.
The synergy between governments, tech companies, and cable operators creates a robust defense mechanism, ensuring the continuity and security of global communications in an increasingly interconnected world.
SOURCES: https://www.mei.edu/publications/defendingsubmarine-cables-black-sea-challenge-nato-and-region
https://www.csis.org/analysis/invisible-and-vital-underseacables-and-transatlantic-security
https://www.csis.org/analysis/natos-role-protectingcritical-undersea-infrastructure
Ai graphics Linda Restrepo © 2024
15
AI Generated Graphic by LInda Restrepo © 2024
A WARRIOR'S GREATEST WEAPON IS NOT A SWORD BUT THE MIND
LINDA RESTREPO
17