Letters to the editor Marilyn Healy
the time being we need another way of expressing the creative urge. Kenneth Evans, Surrey
Yet more dances Dear Editor, When I read Helen McGinley’s opinion piece about the publication of new dances, I was astonished -- not because she defended their publication, as there must be some people who share her view, but because she seemed to ignore the essential point that there are too many dances. Of course, nearly all of the new dances are danceable, most are good, and some are really very good. But the same can be said for the thousands of dances that already exist. (I heard an estimate that there are ten thousand dances in the SCD tradition!). Given the published dances, we could devise an evening’s dance programme a hundred or thousand times over, not repeat a dance and satisfy every possible requirement except the requirement that the dancers know the dance. When I started dancing in the 1970s, it was unheard of to recap a dance at the local weekly club. Now it is usual to have a walk through at the weekly club and a recap at the special dance on the Saturday. These aids to the memory are all but essential. They take up time; the dance is spoilt because even experienced dancers don’t quite remember the dance; and more sets break down because they lack a critical mass of knowledge. Sometimes MCs even go so far as to call the dance during the dance: if this abomination is necessary then the phrasing and execution of the dance must have been lost as phrasing and execution requires anticipation. The society went some way to recognising that the large number of dances was causing difficulties when it published its list of dances for a core repertoire in 2008. My own theory is what the beginner finds impossible in week one, but doable after six months, the improver finds easy after two years and the experienced dancer finds downright boring after five years. There is therefore continual pressure to find something new. Our community has dealt with this by devising new figures and combinations of figures. However, this has become self-defeating. I propose another approach: namely to incorporate new steps - the traditions of highland dance and ladies step would be obvious sources. Helen McGinley has a valid point in saying that SCD must be a living tradition: but for
Dear Editor, I am sure that most dancers feel that we have too many books of new dances and it is not good for dancing in the long term. It therefore came as a surprise that at the last AGM there was a motion for a Publications Committee that I presume would produce yet more dance books. As the answer was “NO” to the idea it seemed quite out of order in the last Country Dancer for a member of the Membership Services Committee to submit and have published weak arguments for new publications. It may be too late to stop Book 49 but anything beyond should be put on the back-burner until we decide the purpose and frequency of publications today. This is quite different to the situation when the Society started and did such a good job in publishing dances already being danced. Following the AGM is there still a mandate to publish? Perhaps once the moratorium on publications has been lifted we could think about ‘a History of Scottish Dance in a 100 dances’ for publication in 2023! John Carswell
Won’t You Join the Dance project Dear Editor, At first reading the article by Joseph Bell appears quite innovative. Technology is ever increasing in scope, and I do believe we should expand and grow, keep up with the times, continuously go forward trying new ideas. One word of caution; in retrospect, turning to my own teaching experience through the years, we need to consider the impact on dancer confidence when they view “perfect” footwork and steps delivered by video. We used the Red Thistle Dancers video when it was first released, showing only the portion depicting feet and legs performing foot positions and steps, to a mixed class of dancers. Their reactions were almost immediate – I’ll never be able to dance like that – why continue dancing (SCD) if that is what is expected! I hastened to explain (and wrote a newsletter article) that we all dance within our own physical abilities. I do not and will not “compare student’s footwork to the footwork of a top dancer” under any circumstances. Some of Bell’s ideas are good and useful
for dancers learning/seeing a given dance and its progression. The existing animated YouTube video, Danciemations, shows dances from the side view and from over the top looking down, depicting each couple in a different colour is very helpful. Bell’s ideas expand on this, with possible widening, more useful results. Bottom line—I truly believe we all would do well by keeping in mind that Scottish country dancing is a Social Activity, encompassing people of all ages, including all abilities, being considerate, fair and equitable to everyone. Margaret (Marge) van Noos
Dundee Branch 90th anniversary Dear Editor, I read with interest the article regarding the above anniversary. My mother Elsie Robertson was a member of the branch in the 1950’s. She was a member of the team called the Claverhouse Dancers, along with Isobel Tait, George Mechan, Betty Stevenson and Bill Clement. Other names have gone from memory. She also gained her Teacher’s Certificate c.1954. My main reason for writing is to say how many memories have surfaced of those early days. My grandmother and I were always given tickets to Kidd’s Rooms in Lindsay Street, Dundee, to view the Annual Ball Grand March, Oh, the glamour of the ladies in floor length dresses, elbow length gloves, and the men in their kilts, all gliding over the floor to the magnificent music, such memories. The whole spectacle made a lasting impact, an amazing few hours for a wee Dundee lassie. I am a member of the Inverness Branch of the RSCDS. Having come back to dancing after quite a few years and can now understand how much my mother enjoyed being part of the Society. Elspeth Gimson (Elspeth Robertson)
Lady Dancers’ Dress Hello Editor, Your last issue invited Letters to the editor so here goes. Sometimes, at Scottish dance events, especially where the “general public” are present, I feel uneasy about how “unScottish” an event can look. All too often, if it were not for a couple of gents in kilts it would not “look Scottish” at all. The ladies – always in the vast majority – hardly ever seem to feature tartan in their clothing for the night. Is there any reason for ladies
www.rscds.org
27
