Schubert’s Unfinished Symphony – Season 22/23 – Programme note

Season 2022/23 SCHUBERT’S UNFINISHED SYMPHONY

kindly supported by Claire and Mark Urquhart

Thursday 30 March, 7.30pm The Queen's Hall, Edinburgh

Friday 31 March, 7.30pm City Halls, Glasgow

Saturday 1 April, 7.30pm Aberdeen Music Hall

Mozart Overture, Die Zauberflöte (The Magic Flute), K620

Schubert Symphony No 8 ‘Unfinished’, D759

Interval of 20 minutes

MacMillan Eleven (UK Premiere)

Mozart Piano Concerto No 22 in E-flat, K482

Maxim Emelyanychev Conductor / Piano

Maxim Emelyanychev

The Scottish Chamber Orchestra is a charity registered in Scotland No. SC015039. Company registration No. SC075079.

Thank You FUNDING PARTNERS

The SCO is extremely grateful to the Scottish Government and to the City of Edinburgh Council for their continued support. We are also indebted to our Business Partners, all of the charitable trusts, foundations and lottery funders who support our projects, and to the very many individuals who are kind enough to give us financial support and who enable us to do so much. Each and every donation makes a difference and we truly appreciate it.

Core Funder

Authority

Learning Partner

Benefactor

Local

Creative

Business Partners

Key Funders

Delivered by

Su-a Lee

Sub-Principal Cello

Thank You SCO DONORS

Diamond

Lucinda and Hew Bruce-Gardyne

Malcolm and Avril Gourlay

James and Felicity Ivory

Christine Lessels

Clair and Vincent Ryan

Alan and Sue Warner

Platinum

David Caldwell in memory of Ann

Tom and Alison Cunningham

Dr Peter Williamson and Ms Margaret Duffy

John and Jane Griffiths

Judith and David Halkerston

J Douglas Home

Audrey Hopkins

David and Elizabeth Hudson

Dr and Mrs Peter Jackson

Dr Daniel Lamont

Chris and Gill Masters

Duncan and Una McGhie

Anne-Marie McQueen

James F Muirhead

Patrick and Susan Prenter

Mr and Mrs J Reid

Martin and Mairi Ritchie

Elaine Ross

Hilary E Ross

George Rubienski

Jill and Brian Sandford

Michael and Elizabeth Sudlow

Robert and Elizabeth Turcan

Tom and Natalie Usher

Anny and Bobby White

Finlay and Lynn Williamson

Ruth Woodburn

Gold

Lord Matthew Clarke

James and Caroline Denison-Pender

Andrew and Kirsty Desson

David and Sheila Ferrier

Chris and Claire Fletcher

James Friend

Iain Gow

Christopher and Kathleen Haddow

Ian Hutton

Gordon Kirk

Robert Mackay and Philip Whitley

Mike and Karen Mair

Anne McAlister and Philip Sawyer

Gavin McEwan

Roy and Svend McEwan-Brown

John and Liz Murphy

Alison and Stephen Rawles

Andrew Robinson

Ian S Swanson

John-Paul and Joanna Temperley

Anne Usher

Catherine Wilson

Neil and Philippa Woodcock

Georgina Wright

Bruce and Lynda Wyer

Silver

Roy Alexander

Joseph I Anderson

Pamela Andrews and Alan Norton

Dr Peter Armit

William Armstrong

Fiona and Neil Ballantyne

Timothy Barnes and Janet Sidaway

The Batsleer Family

Jack Bogle

Jane Borland

Michael and Jane Boyle

Mary Brady

Elizabeth Brittin

John Brownlie

Laura Buist

Robert Burns

Sheila Colvin

Lorn and Camilla Cowie

Lord and Lady Cullen of Whitekirk

Adam and Lesley Cumming

Jo and Christine Danbolt

Dr Wilma Dickson

James Dunbar-Nasmith

Dr and Mrs Alan Falconer

Sheila Ferguson

Dr James W E Forrester

Dr William Fortescue

Jeanette Gilchrist

David Gilmour

Dr David Grant

Margaret Green

Andrew Hadden

J Martin Haldane

Ronnie and Ann Hanna

Ruth Hannah

Robin Harding

Roderick Hart

Norman Hazelton

Ron and Evelynne Hill

Clephane Hume

Tim and Anna Ingold

David and Pamela Jenkins

Catherine Johnstone

Julie and Julian Keanie

Marty Kehoe

Professor Christopher and Mrs Alison Kelnar

Dr and Mrs Ian Laing

Janey and Barrie Lambie

Graham and Elma Leisk

Geoff Lewis

Dorothy A Lunt

Vincent Macaulay

Joan MacDonald

Isobel and Alan MacGillivary

Jo-Anna Marshall

James McClure in memory of Robert Duncan

Gavin McCrone

Michael McGarvie

Brian Miller

James and Helen Moir

Alistair Montgomerie

Margaret Mortimer and Ken Jobling

Andrew Murchison

Hugh and Gillian Nimmo

David and Tanya Parker

Hilary and Bruce Patrick

Maggie Peatfield

John Peutherer in memory of Audrey Peutherer

James S Potter

Alastair Reid

Fiona Reith

Olivia Robinson

Catherine Steel

Ian Szymanski

Michael and Jane Boyle

Douglas and Sandra Tweddle

Margaretha Walker

James Wastle

C S Weir

Bill Welsh

Roderick Wylie

We believe the thrill of live orchestral music should be accessible to everyone, so we aim to keep the price of concert tickets as fair as possible. However, even if a performance were completely sold out, we would not cover the presentation costs.

We are indebted to everyone acknowledged here who gives philanthropic gifts to the SCO of £300 or greater each year, as well as those who prefer to remain anonymous. We are also incredibly thankful to the many individuals not listed who are kind enough to support the Orchestra financially, whether that is regularly or on an ad hoc basis. Every single donation makes a difference and we are truly grateful.

Become a regular donor, from as little as £5 a month, by contacting Hannah Wilkinson on 0131 478 8364 or hannah.wilkinson@sco.org.uk.

Thank You PRINCIPAL CONDUCTOR'S CIRCLE

Our Principal Conductor’s Circle is made up of individuals who share the SCO’s vision to bring the joy of music to as many people as possible. These individuals are a special part of our musical family, and their commitment and generosity benefit us all – musicians, audiences and creative learning participants alike. We would like to extend our grateful thanks to them for playing such a key part in the future of the SCO.

American Development Fund

Erik Lars Hansen and Vanessa C L Chang

Annual Fund

James and Patricia Cook

Hedley G Wright

International Touring Fund

Gavin and Kate Gemmell

CHAIR SPONSORS

Conductor Emeritus Joseph Swensen

Donald and Louise MacDonald

Chorus Director Gregory Batsleer

Anne McFarlane

Principal Second Violin

Marcus Barcham Stevens

Jo and Alison Elliot

Principal Viola Max Mandel

Kenneth and Martha Barker

Viola Steve King

Sir Ewan and Lady Brown

Principal Cello Philip Higham

The Thomas Family

Cello Donald Gillan

Professor Sue Lightman

Productions Fund

The Usher Family

Bill and Celia Carman

Visiting Artists Fund

Colin and Sue Buchan

Anne and Matthew Richards

Cello Eric de Wit

Jasmine Macquaker Charitable Fund

Principal Double Bass Nikita Naumov

Caroline Hahn and Richard Neville-Towle

Principal Flute André Cebrián

Claire and Mark Urquhart

Principal Oboe Robin Williams

Hedley G Wright

Principal Clarinet Maximiliano Martín

Stuart and Alison Paul

Principal Bassoon Cerys Ambrose-Evans

Claire and Anthony Tait

Principal Timpani Louise Lewis Goodwin

Geoff and Mary Ball

Our Musicians YOUR ORCHESTRA

First Violin

Stephanie Gonley

Afonso Fesch

Siún Milne

Aisling O’Dea

Fiona Alexander

Amira Bedrush-McDonald

Catherine James

Second Violin

Marcus Barcham Stevens

Rachel Spencer

Michelle Dierx

Rachel Smith

Niamh Lyons

Gongbo Jiang

Abigail Young

Viola

Gary Pomeroy

Jessica Beeston

Brian Schiele

Steve King

Cello

Philip Higham

Donald Gillan

Eric de Wit

Kim Vaughan

Bass

Nikita Naumov

Adrian Bornet

Margarida Castro

Flute

André Cebrián

Marta Gómez

Piccolo

Marta Gómez

Oboe

Robin Williams

Katherine Bryer

Cor Anglais

Katherine Bryer

Clarinet

Maximiliano Martín

William Stafford

Bass Clarinet

William Stafford

Information correct at the time of going to print

Bassoon

Cerys Ambrose-Evans

Alison Green

Horn

Jože Rošer

Jamie Shield

Trumpet

Peter Franks

Shaun Harrold

Trombone

Duncan Wilson

Cillian Ó’Ceallacháin

Alan Adams

Timpani and Percussion

Louise Lewis Goodwin

Louise Lewis Goodwin Principal Timpani

WHAT YOU ARE ABOUT TO HEAR

Mozart (1756-1791)

Overture, Die Zauberflöte (The Magic Flute), K620 (1791)

Schubert (1797-1828)

Symphony No 8 ‘Unfinished’, D759 (1822)

Allegro moderato

Andante con moto

MacMillan (b.1959)

Eleven (UK Premiere) (2022)

Mozart (1756-1791)

Piano Concerto No 22 in E-flat, K482 (1785)

Allegro Andante

Allegro

Can we really call a two-movement bleeding chunk of a larger piece a ‘symphony’? Probably about as much as we can call a brief, punchy curtainraiser conceived for the opera house a legitimate concert work. There’s plenty we take as read about classical music. But as at least two of the pieces in tonight’s concert demonstrate, there’s probably quite a lot that shouldn’t slip by unquestioned, certainly in terms of how background and context have defined the musical sounds we hear.

In truth, opera overtures have been performed in concerts for centuries. There’s always been a nagging question, however, about whether they really belong. Even some of today’s conductors feel less than comfortable about severing a dramatic opener from the theatrical work it launches.

They might feel rather differently, however, in the case of the strange, symbolic, almost ritualistic drama of Mozart’s The Magic Flute . The opera (more correctly a Singspiel, virtually the equivalent of a modern-day musical) is as much a representation of Enlightenment values of knowledge, resilience and self-fulfillment as it is a fairy tale about a mysterious bird-man and a dragon-fleeing hero rescuing a damsel in distress.

It was Mozart’s last great completed work, and an unexpected success when unveiled at Vienna’s Theater auf der Wieden on 30 September 1791, just a couple of months before the composer’s death. Mozart’s fortunes had been sliding downhill rather dramatically

as notoriously fickle Viennese music lovers shifted their attention to the latest musical fashions. The Magic Flute, however, provided Mozart with the greatest operatic hit of his career, and may well have launched a period of new creativity and innovation – had he lived longer.

And just as The Magic Flute ’s fantastical storyline was designed to convey Enlightenment ideals, so its Overture serves to introduce those ideas in music that’s at once grand and playful. Mozart and his librettist Emanuel Schikaneder were both active Freemasons, and Masonic symbolism is embedded deep within both the opera’s plot and its music. The number three has a mystical significance in Masonic tradition, and it’s with three confident, sonorous

Mozart’s fortunes had beenslidingdownhill ratherdramaticallyas notoriouslyfickleViennese music lovers shifted their attention to the latest musical fashions.

chords that Mozart launches his Overture, in the three-flat key signature of E flat major.

After this somewhat reverential slow introduction, however, Mozart launches the main body of the Overture with a scampering theme that’s quickly passed from instrument to instrument in an increasingly rich and complex texture. There’s symbolism here, too, since every musician makes a crucial (even, perhaps, equal) contribution to the overall music, or maybe simply knows their place in the bigger picture. Mozart’s towering harmonies return about halfway through, but the Overture bustles to a busy close with the faster music, while rather magically never losing its sense of ceremonial grandeur.

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart

If the musical symbolism of Mozart’s operatic Overture makes it a particularly fitting work for the concert hall, Franz Schubert’s two-movement Symphony established its place through the strength of its music alone.

Schubert’s ‘Unfinished’ was, however, always intended to end up as a conventional, four-movement Symphony. Alongside its completed first and second movements, a reduced version of a projected third movement exists, though there’s nothing at all to indicate what the composer had in mind for a finale. Scholars and performers have put forward various competing completions down the centuries, but none has stuck. That’s perhaps because Schubert’s two existing movements exhibit a strange kind of balance and

unity on their own, as if they’re two sides of the same coin.

It’s not even clear why Schubert left the Symphony unfinished – although it’s hardly the only one he failed to complete. He began 13 symphonies in total, but only finished seven of them, leading to all manner of inconsistencies as to numberings (you might find the ‘Unfinished’ referred to as No 7, No 8 or even No 9, depending on how editors viewed the other symphonies –complete, sketched or partially completed – before and after it).

Various theories have been put forward as to why Schubert seemed to stop after just two movements. Perhaps it was for reasons of health: he began to feel the first serious effects of the syphilis that would kill him six years later around

That’sperhapsbecause Schubert’stwoexisting movements exhibit a strangekindofbalance andunityontheirown, asifthey’retwosides of the same coin.

Franz Peter Schubert

the same time he began work on the Symphony, in the autumn of 1822. And there’s little doubt that the sense of turmoil and despair that Schubert evokes in his opening movement feel rooted in genuine personal experience. Or perhaps he was overawed by the remarkable achievements of Beethoven. Schubert would have no doubt heard the premieres of the elder composer’s Seventh and Eighth Symphonies in Vienna just a few years earlier, and he clearly took those bold, pioneering creations as models for his new work.

And, it seems, he may have intended to complete the Symphony after taking a break from working on it. In 1823, he received an honorary diploma from the Graz Music Society, an honour he felt obliged to recognise by dedicating a new symphony to the organisation. His friend Joseph Hüttenbrenner was a member, and Schubert sent him the two symphonic movements he’d written in 1822 to be getting on with – then did nothing more. Hüttenbrenner later passed the score on to his brother Anselm for safekeeping, and it remained in Anselm’s possession until 1865, almost four decades after Schubert’s death. The conductor Johann von Herbeck had been tipped off about the existence of a mysterious, incomplete Schubert symphony, and visited Anselm to find out more. Flattered by the suggestion that Herbeck might include a work of his own in a prospective future concert, Anselm Hüttenbrenner miraculously remembered the music by Schubert he’d hidden away in 1823, and Herbeck duly gave the ‘Unfinished’ Symphony its premiere on 17 December 1865 in Vienna (with a finale tacked on from Schubert’s teenage Symphony No. 3). It went down a storm.

It might well have been that delay in performance, coupled with changing musical tastes, that ensured Schubert’s ‘Unfinished’ its success. From the hushed murmurings of its sombre opening on cellos and basses, and its melancholy oboe melody, it feels like music ahead of its time, but very much in tune with the high emotions and drama of the Romantic movement that was in full flight by the mid-19th century. A single held note from the horns acts as a pivot into the brighter music of the opening movement’s second main theme, a graceful cello melody, but the new-found contentment suddenly comes to a halt, interrupted by anguished chords from across the orchestra. After a turbulent central development section, the two earlier themes return to propel the movement to its stormy, unremittingly dark close.

In many ways, Schubert’s second movement is the lighter, brighter twin of the heavier, darker first, in the same three-time, and even passing by at a similar speed. And though it’s tempting to see its dancing, lyrical melodies as the mirror images of the first movement’s melancholy, brooding themes, in many ways it’s just as turbulent and unpredictable. Its calm, floating tunes are often interrupted by violence, so that its conclusion, though reassuringly calm, also feels somewhat provisional.

It was the SCO and conductor Maxim Emelyanychev who gave tonight’s next piece its world premiere in Antwerp last year, and who now give Sir James MacMillan’s Eleven its first UK performances. The composer writes about his new work:

"There have been various pieces of music inspired by sport over the decades, and by football (soccer) in particular. This short concert overture is another one, and is particularly inspired by the local teams in East Ayrshire in Scotland where I grew up. In fact the work is dedicated to the supporters of five teams in the area.

Eleven is the number of players in a team and is the number which shapes a lot of the musical choices here: themes made up of eleven notes, chords consisting of eleven pitches, durations of eleven units and so on. The piece begins with the sound of a referee’s whistle before two eleven-note themes are thrown around between wind and strings, as if they are two opposing teams. Gradually melodies which have been appropriated as archetypal football chants start to appear,

always underpinned by a restless physical energy.

One of these (which has its origin in ‘Auld Lang Syne’) eventually establishes itself as a slowmoving chorale over which the violins swirl around and up and down. The central section becomes an energetic moto perpetuo before the whole orchestra blares out eleven violent repeated chords.

The referee’s whistle heralds a brief recapitulation of the opening duel between the sections of the orchestra before the music eventually settles to a calm codetta, marked 'serene and warm'."

We return to Mozart for tonight’s concluding piece, and there’s no question that his Piano Concerto No 22 was firmly intended for concert performance – and, in fact, for himself to perform as soloist. Mozart did so on 23 December 1785 in Vienna’s Burgtheater (having completed the Concerto barely a week earlier), with an orchestra conducted by Antonio Salieri, and in the presence of none other than Emperor Joseph II.

Six years earlier than tonight’s opening Overture, Mozart was at the height of his popularity in the Austrian capital – or almost. He’d yet to unveil his opera The Marriage of Figaro, which he would do to huge acclaim in May 1786. But while opera might have brought Mozart fame and prestige, it was the humbler piano concerto that first established his reputation – and, crucially, provided his day-to-day income. As a result, he wrote no fewer than 17 piano concertos for himself to perform for enthusiastic Viennese audiences. Irish tenor Michael Kenny, who’d go on to sing in the first production of The Marriage of Figaro, summed up Mozart’s playing

Sir James MacMillan

at the time: ‘His feeling, the rapidity of his fingers, the great execution and strength of his left hand particularly, and the apparent inspiration of his modulations, astounded me.’

No 22, however, stands apart from many of Mozart’s keyboard concertos in terms of the freedom with which the composer uses his musical material, and also in his use of his orchestra. It’s the first concerto in which Mozart replaces the customary orchestral oboes with clarinets, lending the piece a distinctively warm, mellow sound. A drumrolllike, military-style idea kicks off his opening movement, followed by a more lyrical melody on the violins. When the piano finally enters, however, it’s with entirely new material all of its own. In his central development section, Mozart pushes his pianist (or himself) hard,

with virtuoso figurations that make flying visits to several distant keys, though when the military-style theme marks the return of the opening material, the pianist feels free to add their own distinctive contributions.

Listeners begged for an encore of Mozart’s deeply melancholy second movement at the Concerto’s first performance, and it’s a particularly moving creation, its dragging melody low in the violins’ range closely followed by what feels like an improvised response from the pianist. Mozart plays a few tricks on listeners in his bright and breezy finale, however, swerving unexpectedly away from his perky main theme to more mysterious, dreamier music, before a smiling, sunny conclusion.

© David Kettle

The opening page of the autograph manuscript of Mozart's Piano Concerto No 22, K482, in Mozart's handwriting.

Conductor / Piano

MAXIM EMELYANYCHEV

At the Scottish Chamber Orchestra Maxim Emelyanychev follows in the footsteps of just five previous Principal Conductors in the Orchestra’s 49-year history; Roderick Brydon (1974-1983), Jukka-Pekka Saraste (1987-1991), Ivor Bolton (1994-1996), Joseph Swensen (1996-2005) and Robin Ticciati (20092018).

Highlights of his 2021/22 season included debuts with some of the most prestigious international orchestras: Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia, Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra, Rotterdam Philharmonic, Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester, Toronto Symphony and Swedish Radio Symphony Orchestra, as well as returns to the Antwerp Symphony, the Orchestre National du Capitole de Toulouse, the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic and a European tour with the Scottish Chamber Orchestra, followed by appearances at the Radio-France Montpellier Festival and the Edinburgh International Festival.

In October 2022, Maxim toured the USA with the Scottish Chamber Orchestra and made his debut with the Berlin Philharmonic. Other touring in 2022/23 includes the New Japan Philharmonic, the Osaka Kansai Philharmonic, the Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra, the Helsinki Radio Symphony Orchestra, the Czech Philharmonic Orchestra and the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra. He also returns to the Orchestre National du Capitole de Toulouse and to the Royal Opera House in Mozart's Die Zauberflöte.

He regularly collaborates with renowned artists such as Max Emanuel Cenčić, Patrizia Ciofi, Joyce DiDonato, Franco Fagioli, Richard Goode, Sophie Karthäuser, Stephen Hough, Katia and Marielle Labèque, Marie-Nicole Lemieux, Julia Lezhneva, Alexei Lubimov, Riccardo Minasi, Xavier Sabata and Dmitry Sinkovsky.

Maxim is also a highly respected chamber musician. His most recent recording, of Brahms Violin Sonatas with long-time collaborator and friend Aylen Pritchin, was released on Aparté in December 2021 and has attracted outstanding reviews internationally. With the Scottish Chamber Orchestra, Maxim has recorded the Schubert Symphony No 9 – the symphony with which he made his debut with the orchestra – which was released on Linn Records in November 2019.

For full biography please visit sco.org.uk

Biography

SCOTTISH CHAMBER ORCHESTRA

The internationally celebrated Scottish Chamber Orchestra is one of Scotland’s National Performing Companies.

Formed in 1974 and core funded by the Scottish Government, the SCO aims to provide as many opportunities as possible for people to hear great music by touring the length and breadth of Scotland, appearing regularly at major national and international festivals and by touring internationally as proud ambassadors for Scottish cultural excellence.

Making a significant contribution to Scottish life beyond the concert platform, the Orchestra works in schools, universities, colleges, hospitals, care homes, places of work and community centres through its extensive Creative Learning programme. The SCO is also proud to engage with online audiences across the globe via its innovative Digital Season.

An exciting new chapter for the SCO began in September 2019 with the arrival of dynamic young conductor Maxim Emelyanychev as the Orchestra’s Principal Conductor.

The SCO and Emelyanychev released their first album together (Linn Records) in November 2019 to widespread critical acclaim. The repertoire - Schubert’s Symphony No. 9 in C major ‘The Great’ –is the first symphony Emelyanychev performed with the Orchestra in March 2018.

The SCO also has long-standing associations with many eminent guest conductors and directors including Conductor Emeritus Joseph Swensen, François Leleux, Pekka Kuusisto, Nicola Benedetti, Richard Egarr, Andrew Manze and John Storgårds.

The Orchestra enjoys close relationships with many leading composers and has commissioned almost 200 new works, including pieces by the late Sir Peter Maxwell Davies, Sir James MacMillan, Sally Beamish, Martin Suckling, Einojuhani Rautavaara, Karin Rehnqvist, Mark-Anthony Turnage, Nico Muhly, Anna Clyne and Associate Composer Jay Capperauld.

For full biography please visit sco.org.uk

SUMMER NIGHTS WITH KAREN CARGILL

19-21 Apr, 7.30pm

St Andrews | Edinburgh | Glasgow

BEETHOVEN’S FIFTH

27-29 Apr, 7.30pm

Edinburgh | Glasgow | Aberdeen

TCHAIKOVSKY’S FIFTH

4-5 May, 7.30pm

Edinburgh | Glasgow

BRAHMS REQUIEM

11-12 May, 7.30pm

Edinburgh | Glasgow

SCO.ORG.UK

4 Royal Terrace, Edinburgh EH7 5AB +44 (0)131 557 6800 sco.org.uk

The Scottish Chamber Orchestra is a charity registered in Scotland No. SC015039. Company registration No. SC075079.

Find

WE BUILD RELATIONSHIPS THAT LAST GENERATIONS.

Generations of our clients have trusted us to help build and preserve their wealth.

For over 250 years, they have relied on our expert experience to help make sense of a changing world. During that time we’ve earned an enviable reputation for a truly personal approach to managing wealth.

For those with over £250,000 to invest we o er a dedicated investment manager, with a cost structure and level of service, that generates exceptional client loyalty.

Find out more about investing with us today: Murray Clark at our Edinburgh o ce on 0131 221 8500, Gordon Ferguson at our Glasgow o ce on 0141 222 4000 or visit www.quiltercheviot.com

BE PART OF OUR FUTURE

A warm welcome to everyone who has recently joined our family of donors, and a big thank you to everyone who is helping to secure our future.

Monthly or annual contributions from our donors make a real difference to the SCO’s ability to budget and plan ahead with more confidence. Each and every contribution is crucial, and your support is truly appreciated.

For more information on how you can become a regular donor, please get in touch with Hannah Wilkinson on 0131 478 8364 or hannah.wilkinson@sco.org.uk.

SCO.ORG.UK/SUPPORT-US