4 minute read
Can the January 6th Committee Become Another Watergate Committee?
BY JOEL MCNALLY
Illustration by Michael Burmesch.
Once upon a time there was a bipartisan congressional committee investigating a terrible crime committed against America by the Republican president of the United States. After the committee revealed shocking details about the crime in live television hearings that riveted the nation, Republican leaders told their president he had to resign. He did, leaving in disgrace.
That certainly sounds more and more like a fairy tale after the hostility President Trump unleashed against American democracy within the Republican party. But we do know thanks to good journalism Republican House and Senate leaders Kevin McCarthy and Mitch McConnell were just as disgusted as the rest of America by the violent mob Trump sent to attack Congress to prevent the House and Senate from certifying his defeat by President Biden.
But the January 6th House Committee will need to recreate the true horrors of that assault on democracy when their televised hearings begin on June 9 because the official position of the Republican party now is that the violent insurrection killing nine people and seriously injuring 140 police officers, many with permanent physical and brain damage from beatings with flagpoles, iron pipes and other weapons was simply the result of “citizens engaged in legitimate political discourse.”
WHAT DID THE PRESIDENT KNOW?
That’s a far cry from the Republicans serving on the 1973 bipartisan Senate Watergate Committee investigating the burglaries, illegal wiretaps and other crimes committed by President Nixon and his henchmen. Republicans considered it their patriotic duty to determine “What did the president know and when did he know it?”
The House January 6th Committee is bipartisan because Wyoming Republican Liz Cheney, daughter of former Vice President Dick Cheney, and Illinois Republican Adam Kinzinger were appointed by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi. After initially telling Republicans Trump’s actions on Jan. 6 were indefensible, McCarthy refused to appoint any Republicans to participate in the investigation and shamelessly begged Trump’s forgiveness for criticizing him. Cheney and Kinzinger were among the small Republican minority of 10 House members voting to impeach Trump for inciting the insurrection and seven Senators voting to convict him. Cheney and Kinzinger have been publicly shunned by Republicans ever since who closed ranks in support of Trump and now pretend January 6 never happened.
CHENEY IS DEFIANT
Cheney is defiantly running for re-election as Republican Wyoming’s only House member. Kinzinger decided not to run for a seventh term in a heavily Republican district. Cheney tops Trump’s hit list among Republicans he’s targeted for defeat for criticizing him. She vows to “do everything I can to make sure the former president never again gets anywhere near the Oval Office. This is not about policy. This is not about partisanship. This is about our duty as Americans.”
The January 6th Committee, chaired by Mississippi Congressman Bennie Thompson, also includes Adam Schiff and Jamie Raskin, the leaders of both House impeachments of Trump, one for threatening to withhold military aid protecting Ukraine from Russia unless Volodymyr Zelensky started a criminal investigation smearing Biden during the 2020 election and the other for urging the violent mob attack on the Capitol to overthrow Biden’s election.
REPUBLICAN HYPOCRISY
Both organized powerful cases outlining Trump’s guilt, but McConnell’s Republican Senate had no intention of convicting him. After joining Republicans voting to acquit Trump for the insurrection, McConnell hypocritically denounced Trump for inciting it and encouraged the Justice Department to prosecute him.
Most Americans probably don’t expect Trump ever to be held accountable for his crimes. They watched Trump bob and weave through one of the most personally corrupt presidencies in history filling his own pockets by using the office to funnel millions of dollars into his private businesses and cut his own personal and corporate taxes by millions more.
Trump never understood why even his own family members didn’t enjoy the violent insurrection as much as he did, watching it live on television chortling over the best parts. Trump reveled that the riot was all about him.
But there really is an outside chance well-crafted televised hearings by the January 6th Committee like those presented during both impeachment trials could have a major effect on voter turnout in November.
The hearings will be part of a one-two punch in June reminding voters just how dangerous returning Republicans to power could be. Americans have already seen a leaked first draft of the new Trump Supreme Court’s majority decision expected in June destroying the Constitutional right of women to make their own life decisions that has existed for a half-century.
Republican leaders know how dangerous the violent lunatics Trump attracted to their party really are. They were running for their lives from that crazed mob on Jan. 6 just like Democrats were. But Republicans need their votes to win back power in the midterms.
But what if the dangerous lunatics decide they want to be the party’s leaders? Will we be able to tell the difference?
Joel McNally was a critic and columnist for the Milwaukee Journal for 27 years. He has written the weekly Taking Liberties column for the Shepherd Express since 1996.