THE LINDWORM FESTIVAL
MERGING NOVEL GLULAM STRUCTURES AND LANDSCAPE IN MUNICH
BARC0175: ADVANCED ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN II
SVENJA SIEVER
20113419
UNIT PG 14
2021/2022
DESIGN TUTORS
DIRK KROLIKOWSKI + JAKUB KLASKA
Project Statement
Wood performs best along the grain, making bending timber more resource-efficient, durable, and structurally effective than cutting it. This project examines the technical abilities of large-span glulam structures and their integration as part of a continuous structure in Munich, Germany.
Spatial Definition
The overall spatial definition is investigated by categorising abstract spatial sequence iterations with the help of SubD. In addition, Live Physics engines are used to create shell structures from hanging models to optimise enclosing roof structures.
Structural Investigation
Structural hierarchy is established through stress trajectory from load analysis, resulting in different beam and lamella dimensions for primary and secondary structures. Implementing different timber species and cuts contributes to efficiency and the legibility of the construction hierarchy. Options of creating planar stiffness are examined through diagrid variations generated through the collection of simulation data. Mimicking the dynamics of branching networks, the Lindenmayer System helps to create bifurcating systems based on the ‘shortest walk’, therefore, saving material.
Brief and Site
The brief investigates Germany and China’s economic and cultural relations within the Bavarian context. As a city that embraces traditional and innovative values, Munich is the place where a project of this scale can be most likely realised. Also, timber is a deep-routed traditional building material in south Germany and has regained popularity in recent years.
Taking the concept of the diverse ‘Volksgarten’, the project helps to facilitate international exchange on the Theresienwiese, where celebration brings cultures closer together. As reflected in the Olympic Park by Frei Otto and Günter Behnisch, landscape plays an essential role in the city’s urban planning. Respecting the heritage of the Theresienwiese, the design facilitates celebration spaces while bringing back greenery to a site that was once lush grassland.
The challenge of the project was to synthesise the early material and spatial investigations with the given cultural backgrounds and contextual constraints.
Files submitted:
BARC0175_22_SvenjaSiever_PG14_ProjectStatement.pdf
BARC0175_22_SvenjaSiever_PG14_Portfolio.pdf
SIEVER | PG
SVENJA
14
Spatial Tectonics
Structural and Spatial Investigations
01
1.1 Artefact Case Study: The Doecker Gymnasium
The Hetzer System
BENT GLUED LAMINATED H-BEAM
STEEL STRAPPING PURLIN ROOF SYSTEM
LOUVER CEILING (BARREL VAULT)
DOECKER GYMNASIUM WUPPERTAL 1911
The hall was built in 1911 by the largest manufacturer of buildings in wood panel construction as a model gym for the international hygiene exhibition in Dresden. The dismantlable “Doecker system building” has a supporting structure made of parabolic laminated timber arched trusses that go back to Otto Hetzer, the inventor of curved glue-laminated beams made of several lamellas.
7 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
1 3 4 2 GSEducationalVersion
1 3 2 4
1.4 Spatial Sequences I Transition Spaces Catalogue
CIRCULATION
PINCHED SURFACES
FOLDED SURFACES
ROOF/ENCLOSURE
13 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 D1 D2 D3
14 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
GSEducationalVersion
A3 - INTEGRATED SPIRAL STAICASE
Abstract Continuous Surface Grid Structure
Top View
Investigation of the Lindenmayer Branching System
16 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
PARAMETRES THE L-SYSTEM Region definition Proximity definition Start point Shortest Walk Seed points (random) Nurbs Curve Seed Point Count: 10 | 70 | 250 Number of starting points: 1 | 2 | 3 Number of closest points: 50 | 25 | 5 Curve degree: 1 | 2 | 10 Region size/Seed points random distribution 3 10
1.5
18 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations WATER LILY I ICE CRYSTAL WATER LILY II MARINE SPONGE GROUND CONNECTION GSEducationalVersion
1.7 Spatial Sequences II
Multi-Floor Continuous Surfaces
19 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
A1 A3 A5 A7
A2 A4
A6 A8
1.8 Detailed Fragment Testing
Continuous Surface with Lateral Bracing Through Branching
20 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
A4 - DETAILED FRAGMENT: INTEGRATED STAIRCASE
Top View Elevation
1.9 Construction Hierarchy
Material and Dimensions
Timber species: Beech
Average density: 720 kg/m3
Flexural strength: 105-123 N/mm2
PRIMARY Beam depth: 500mm -1200mm
Timber species: Yew
Average density: 650 kg/cm³
Flexural strength: 85 N/mm²
SECONDARY I Beam depth: 400mm - 900mm
Timber species: Spruce
Average density: 800 kg/m3
Flexural strength: 80 N/mm2
SECONDARY II Beam depth: 600mm - 900mm
SECONDARY III Beam depth: 500mm
Timber species: Spruce
Average density: 800 kg/m3
Flexural strength: 80 N/mm2
TERTIARY Beam depth: 250mm
Timber species: Oak
Average density: 670 kg/m3
Flexural strength: 90-110 N/ mm²
DETAIL
22 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
A4 - FRAGMENT AXONOMETRY: CONSTRUCTION HIERARCHY
1.12 Overall Structure Experimentation
Minimal Surface Definition
ELEVATION
28 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
SECTIONAL PERSPECTIVE
PERSPECTIVE
29 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations
1.13 Glulam Application to Minimal Surface Spaces
Principal Stress Analysis and Spatial Qualities
30 1 Structural and Spatial Investigations Public Private Semi-Public
Stress Trajectory Tension Compression Rationalisation Structure Projection Glulam Application LEVELS OF PRIVACY/PUBLICITY
Spatial Tectonics Brief and Site
02
2.2 Sino-Bavarian Correspondance Economics
CLOSE ECONOMIC TIES
- China is Bavaria‘s most important trading partner, replacing the US as the EU‘s largest trading partner
- Bavarian companies account for a fifth of the German-Chinese trade volume
- Trading volume 2020: 33.9 billion Euros. For comparison, the USA: 29.4 billion euros
- 2,000 Bavarian companies have economic ties to China. In return, around 400 Chinese companies are active in the Free State
OBJECTIVES OF CHINESE INVESTORS
- European market access and access to technological know-how
- Expansion of research and development capacities and long-term establishment of new sales locations
- Expansion of customer and logistics network and product portfolio
- Circumvention of EU customs and import regulations (Free Trade Zone)
BENEFITS FOR THE BAVARIAN ECONOMY
- China as a solvent investor
STEADY GROWTH IN BAVARIAN-CHINESE TRADE
- Further development of technologies
- Access to the Asian market
BAVARIAN FIRMS IN CHINA
Agency “Invest in Bavaria” helps foreign companies to settle into the area
35 2 Brief and Site GSEducationalVersion
CHINESE COMPANIES IN BAVARIA
Bavarian Import from China Bavarian Export to China 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 0 4000 8000 12000 16000 20000
Billion Euros Bayreuth Würzburg Regensburg Nuremberg Ansbach Augsburg Landshut Munich
Source: Bavarian State Ministry for Economy, regional development and energy (2020)
Source: Invest in Bavaria
2.7 The “Nymphenburg Volksgarten”
The Neighbourhood Funfair 1890-1916
A POSTCARD OF THE NYMPHENBURG FAIR
In 1890, the “Volksgarten Nymphenburg” opened on the former site of the Nymphenburg brewery. At that time, Nymphenburg was not a district of Munich, but a suburban area. The Volksgarten was in the immediate vicinity of Nymphenburg Palace.
Although it was a permanent amusement park, the attractions changed very frequently and rarely lasted more than two to three years.
44 2 Brief and Site
Sports fans and keen competitors got their money‘s worth at a trotting track or at the velodrome, which was intended for bicycle races.
Particular value was placed on culinary diversity. There were different theme restaurants in the Volksgarten.
Dance balls and band stands were offered for the music lovers. In variety shows, the guests were entertained with dance numbers and funny pieces.
An innovative highlight was the observation tower opened in 1897, which had an electric elevator. From a height of 35 meters, around 30 to 40 people had the opportunity to admire the panorama of the Alps.
Nymphenburg was a popular excursion destination for working society and the terminus of the so-called steam tram, which stopped at the main entrance to the Volksgarten.
Fig. 20
Fig. 22
Fig. 23
Fig. 24
Fig. 21
2.8 Programme Investigation
Festival Culture: Celebrating Together
Winter Solstice
45 2 Brief and Site
PLACE FESTIVAL DURATION (DAYS) J F M A M J J A S O N D Oktoberfest Theresienwiese Munich Bavarian Festivals and Fairs Chinese Festivals and Fairs 17 13 37 10 16 15 16 14 3 3 3 5 Spring Festival Kleine Wiesn May Celebration Maidult Autumn Festival Herbstfest Carneval Fasching
New Year 春节 Lantern Festival 元宵节
Boat Festival 端午节
Chinese
Dragon
Festival 清明节
Tomb Sweeping
Festival 饿鬼节
Hungry Ghost
Festival
Wintertollwood
冬至节
Fig. 24 Fig. 24
Fig. 25 Chinese New Year in January/Feburary
Fig. 26 Oktoberfest end of September
Fig. 28 May Celebration on the first of May
Fig. 29 Lantern Festival end of Feburary
Fig. 30 Winter Tollwood Munich in November
Fig. 27 Mid-Autumn Festival (Moon Cakes) in September
Spatial Tectonics
Detailed Design
03
55 3 Detailed Design
Axial, Linear, Radial 01 - AXIAL 03 - RADIAL Undergrond Station Connections to Existing Infrastructure Indoor Central Hub Plazas for Festival Setup Plazas for Festival Setup Building merging with landscape Building Connection Green Belt Connector 02 - LINEAR Building Merging with Landscape Plazas for Festival Setup Trees Conceiling Structure (Privacy) Outdoor Central Hub
3.1 On-Site Global Form Iterations
3.2 Integrated Landscape Iterations
56 3 Detailed Design 1 2 3 4 5 6 Greenery Transition - Buildings Greenery Transition - Ground Building Roofs Building Footprints Outdoor Circulation/Plazas Interconnections
A Permanent Structure as Part of the “Wiesn” 1 3
4
CANYON PIXEL DEVELOPMENT OF THE CANYON PRINCIPLE
2
FLUID FOLDED
3.3 Site Plan Iterations
Mediating Between Building and Landscape
57 3 Detailed Design
3.4 Masterplan Configuration Infrastructure, Programme Massing and Landscape Integration
GROUND PLANE FORMATION
The terrain steps down towards a central plaza, simulating canyon and rock tectonics. The tier system enables the construction of multiple stories without having a significant impact on the cityscape. Within the building, the terracing of slabs helps to evenly distribute direct sunlight on all floors.
INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR PROGRAMMING
Offices and exhibition areas are located and face west, as the adjacent area is more quiet. Nearby buildings are either residential or used for similar purposes. “Louder” programmes face the centre of the site and are located east, where they are better connected to infrastructure and near commercially used buildings.
58 3 Detailed Design
Central Plaza
Offices, Exhibition, Auction
Brewery, Hippodrome, Tavern
CIRCULATION NETWORK
The different programmes are connected through an interwoven path system, which form the plaza in the centre. New tram stations bring the barren place back to life and relieve the surrounding underground stations during festival season.
New Tram Stations
THE PARK AS PART OF THE URBAN FABRIC
The landscape is integrated into the urban layout, which is stongly connected to the idea of the “Volksgarten” (people’s garden). The outdoor spaces can be used for specific building programmes (Biergarten, Restaurants, Sports,...) or simply to socialise - similar to the function of most of Munich’s parks.
59 3 Detailed Design
(existing)
Entrance
Theresienwiese
Main
Biergarten, Bandstand, Leisure Activities
3.15 Roof Covering
Paramentric Tiling for Landscape Connection
ROTATION REQUIRED
BENDING REQUIRED
80 3 Detailed Design 2 4
1 POINT ATTRACTOR
3 TWISTED LOUVER
LINE ATTRACTOR
TWISTED LOUVER + LINE ATTRACTOR
Tiling Aluminium Shingles Slate
3.17 Structure Study I
Implementing Glulam Branching
82 3 Detailed Design
Tiling Roof/Enclosure System Integrated Slab System Roof Substructure Structural System Rationalised Marine Sponge Structure STRUCTURE SYSTEM FRAGMENT
Spatial Tectonics
Final Drawings
04
4.1 Site Plan
The Urban Park
THERESIENWIESE MUNICH
88
4.3 Bird’s-Eye View
90 4 Final Drawings
“Welcome to the Munich Oktoberfest” - An advertising poster of the city to promote the annual Oktoberfest.
91 4 Final Drawings
92 4 Final Drawings
Perspective
4.4 Site Section
SECTION AA
93 4 Final Drawings
A A
4.5 Site Section Frontal View
FLUID PROGRAMME TRANSITION
The section shows the programme and programme distribution. Areas with high ceiling height are used as bier halls and exhibition spaces. Areas with lower ceiling height are used for the kitchens, serving and dining spaces. The idea is the fluid transition between the programmes. The shell roof automatically creates differential zones through its waved shape, therefore eliminating the need for physical boundaries.
94 4 Final Drawings
SECTION AA
95 4 Final Drawings
A A
4.6 Fragment I
Interaction Gründerzeit Context
96 4 Final Drawings
97 4 Final Drawings
4.6 Fragment I
Interaction Urban Park + Beer Garden
98 4 Final Drawings
99 4 Final Drawings
4.7 Roof Fragment Parametric Tiling System
100 4 Final Drawings
4.8 Roof Detail
Parametric Tiling System
101 4 Final Drawings
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 Closed tiles Opened tiles Tiling 1 Heat-reflecting clay tiles (white) 50mm 2 Substructure tiling system 3 Steel fixing rod Ø 20mm Intensive green roof Vegetation 4 Growing substrate 200mm 5 Filter layer 5mm 6 Drainage layer 60mm 7 Root barrier 5mm 8 Protection mat 10mm 9 PVC waterproof membrane 1mm 10 Expanded Polystyrene insulation (EPS) 140mm 11 Vapour control layer 1mm 12 Timber cladding 20mm Roof structure 13 Pollmeier® Baubuche GL75 beech LVL beam (secondary) 200x60mm 14 Spruce glulam beam (primary) 600x120mm Skylight 15 Triple-glazed laminated glass (LG) 10mm 16 Aluminium window frame Roof Structure (no vegetation) 17 Timber battens 20mm 18 Pollmeier® Baubuche GL75 beech LVL beam (secondary) 200x60mm 19 Spruce glulam beam (primary) 400x120mm
4.9 Interior View I Intersitial Space
102 4 Final Drawings
103 4 Final Drawings
4.10 Interior View II
Mezzanine Level
104 4 Final Drawings
105 4 Final Drawings
4.11 Interior View III
Main Hall
106 4 Final Drawings
107 4 Final Drawings