Jared Spears

Degrowth Gains Ground

Jared Spears

IF YOU HAD THE OPTION OF A FOUR-DAY WORK WEEK, would you use some of your newly freed time to pitch in at a community food garden in exchange for a share of the produce? How about putting your tools in a common shed for sharing if you could occasionally borrow your neighbors’ appliances? Would you forego summer destination flights if you knew that more public pools and nature parks would open in your region?

You might describe such lifestyle choices as climate-conscious or anticonsumerist. Maybe you already practice some of them yourself—but what will it take to make such shifts, and the values that inform them, widely accepted in a country like the United States?

That’s the vital concern running through The Future Is Degrowth: A Guide to a World Beyond Capitalism. Since the book’s first edition was published in Germany in 2019, the world has been reeling from continuous shocks: a global pandemic, social upheavals, heatwaves, wildfires, and war, compounded by costof-living crises, supply chain delays, and food shortages. As Matthias Schmelzer, Andrea Vetter, and Aaron Vansintjan explain in this new and expanded English-language edition, people are increasingly drawn to degrowth because they’re seeking answers about “how we got in this mess in the first place, and how we can get out.”

According to the authors, the term “degrowth” is a critique of the dominant ideology of growth in capitalist societies and includes proposals for a radical reorganization of economic life in order to dramatically reduce advanced economies’ use of energy and resources. The writers assert that such a transformation is not only possible and desirable for the world’s richer countries, but is also necessary to tackle climate change through a global, just transition from fossil fuels.

The idea of an abrupt “jump off the growth treadmill” runs against the grain of standard Econ 101 courses and corporate news. Prevailing explanations for the economy in the Global North still hold that growth and a climbing GDP are unequivocally good. But degrowth positions have recently worked their way into discussion from the World Economic Forum and the latest report from the International Panel on Climate Change. The 2007-08 economic crisis, the advancing effects of global warming, and the jolt of pandemic shutdowns have been steadily undermining ideological illusions about economic growth. There’s increasing acknowledgment that billionaires’ wealth doesn’t simply trickle down, that a great deal of modern work is superfluous to social necessity, and that ever-accelerating busyness isn’t getting us closer to a good life for all.

On the contrary, as The Future Is Degrowth details, studies on satisfaction in various countries show that “the relationship between GDP and quality of life is only stable up to a certain level of prosperity,” after which the relationship between the two unravels.

Consider that the average American’s

What’s ultimately at stake in a degrowth transition is not simply greener lifestyle choices but complex structural questions concerning millions of lives and livelihoods.

The Future Is Degrowth: A Guide to a World Beyond Capitalism Matthias schMelzer, andrea Vetter, and aarOn Vansintjan

Verso Books, 2022

annual material consumption is 23.7 metric tons—52% more than the European average and nearly three times the 8 metric tons sustainability scholars cite as a fair, sustainable global average. Alarms about the excesses of the frequent-flyer McMansion lifestyle are nothing new; still, a degrowth view helpfully foregrounds not only the harmful carbon footprint of this “imperial mode of living” but also its unjust reliance on cheap overseas resources and labor. Skepticism of capitalism’s growth-focused notion of progress allows us to see that a mode of living presented as “normal” was never just or sustainable.

The book suggests that even climate activists and progressive politicians need a reality check. Proponents of degrowth are wary of “green growth,” which hails techno-solutions and vague net-zero goals to suggest that, once a proverbial green energy switch is flipped, the Global North can continue hustling and consuming more or less as before. This single-minded focus on renewables, exemplified by the current posture of the Biden administration, ignores the fact that the supply of rare earth minerals needed for a renewable transition is finite and concentrated in the Global South. The authors do advocate a Green New Deal ramp-up of production, but one tempered by degrowth: “The transformation needed in industrialized countries—if they are to reduce their emissions and environmental impacts fast enough to leave space for the Global South to develop—will also lead to reducing the size of Global North economies.”

The Future Is Degrowth invites us to envision a much deeper societal transition than simply swapping energy sources to maintain the status quo. By recognizing the time and material wasted in capitalist competition, degrowth theory maintains that systems of care and sufficiency can improve our quality of life, offering immaterial gains such as “time prosperity” and “conviviality.”

So how do we actually ditch the capitalist rat race, restructure our lives, and settle into a slower groove? The Future Is Degrowth doesn’t offer shortcuts, but it contains more than a few thought-provoking ideas and examples. The “dual power” strategy the authors advance pairs radical policies of wealth redistribution and selective downscaling of unhelpful industries with the elevation and expansion of “nowtopias.” Self-organized and small-scale initiatives like CSAs, urban gardens, community solar projects, and worker co-ops all have a part to play, showing that the “good life” can be secured without the material waste and alienation endemic to capitalism.

What’s ultimately at stake in a degrowth transition is not simply greener lifestyle choices but complex structural questions concerning millions of lives and livelihoods. What would make oil and gas workers feel good about foreclosing their industries? What conditions might empower a pilots’ union to refuse to fly private jets? What would it take to build majority consensus for a maximum salary or an eco-tax on harmful consumption?

Simply imposing such measures from the top down is a likely recipe for resentment and right-wing outrage. The authors’ most radical remedy is the insistence on degrowth decisionmaking to expand and deepen democratic practices. If you want people to endorse your eco-revolution, they’ll need a seat at the table. Regional councils and citizen’s assemblies could offer a forum for informed deliberation on economic transition, breaking down partisan bubbles and exercising the agency stifled by the current market-state paradigm. Self-determination and participation, the book compellingly argues, are key to society pulling through climate-induced transition without pulling apart.

Beyond our current “climate versus the economy” paralysis, the promise of degrowth beckons. y

Jared Spears’ essays have appeared in Jacobin, It’s Freezing in L.A.!, and elsewhere. He works as director of communications and resources for the Schumacher Center for a New Economics in Massachusetts. Twitter: @ThusSpokeJared

Patrick Blindauer

ACROSS

1 Sound of rushing through an airport? 6 Bygone U.S. gas brand 10 Glove part 14 Emulated a cow 15 Lioness in The Lion King 16 Operatic highlight 17 Possible solution to improving 40-Across 20 Base cops, briefly 21 Some exams, or the days you might take them: Abbr 22 Magazine monthly 23 Shows one’s fallibility 26 Catherine of Beetlejuice 28 Wise 31 ___ test (pH indicator) 35 Remove entirely 36 Where to see stars? 39 Certain NFL turnover: Abbr. 40 Equilibrium between one’s career and home 44 First aid provider, for short 45 Activates a magic lamp 46 Grown-up 47 Place for pedicures, perhaps 50 People from Pittsburgh or Penzance 52 Man known for his morals 55 Was present 56 Accumulate, as a fortune 59 Stare in wonder 61 Operators who may be standiing by: Abbr. 64 Possible solutions to improving 40-Across 68 Destination for Marco Polo 69 Posting by a drive-through window 70 Misleading move 71 Ring-around-the-rosy flower 72 Secretive sound heard in the song

“God, That’s Good!” 73 Surrenders, as territory

DOWN

1 Two-band radio switch 2 Place for pigeons 3 Residential bash 4 Above, in odes 5 Not even 6 Irish singer from Gweedore 7 Took care of 8 Sound of liquid splashing 9 Blade for some boats 10 Plays with, like a kitten 11 Counterpart of Mars 12 In ___ of (instead of) 13 Earn, as money 18 Part of NAACP: Abbr. 19 Opera’s ___ Te Kanawa 24 Take a chance on 25 Cousin of a jig 27 Thomas Edison’s middle name 28 Did some quilting 29 Olfactory stimulus 30 Source of protein 32 Big name in orange juice 33 “Enough!” 34 Some editorial notations 37 Lincoln’s state: Abbr. 38 Recipe meas. 41 Fidelity offerings, for short 42 Tomb Raider heroine Croft 43 Congressman Schiff 48 Glide down the runway 49 Bit of Mexican bread 51 Wedding cake artist 53 Dungeons & Dragons creatures 54 Potential queens, in chess 56 “Don’t delay” 57 Flavoring for Japanese soups 58 x or y line 60 Look sullen 62 Unit of force 63 Fast fliers, once 65 Ballpark figure? 66 Col. Sanders’s company 67 Start to dream?

EQUILIBRIUM

© 2022 by Patrick Blindauer. www.patrickspuzzles.com

WE WANT TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE

That’s why we’re leaving a legacy gift to YES!

We are concerned about where our world and planet are headed. We want to make a difference and that’s why we’re leaving a gift for YES! in our estate. YES! is so aligned with our values. It offers us viewpoints and information that might otherwise never come to our attention—and inspires us in the process! As society struggles through the greatest challenges we and the planet have ever faced, YES! guides us to take actions informed by love and interdependence rather than separation. This important work needs to continue even when we’re no longer here!

—Peter and Melinda Lucas,

YES! readers and supporters