A Work of Beauty PHOTOGRAPHS BY CHIN-PAO CHEN
Jo-Mei Taipei County 2000
A Work of Beauty Taiwan’s young and controversial betel nut girls PHOTO ESSAY / LABOUR PHOTOGRAPHS BY CHIN-PAO CHEN
some of the most curious landmarks on the roadsides of Taiwan are small, brightly lit glass stands that sell betel nut, a mild stimulant. What they are perhaps most famous for are their saleswomen, called betel nut girls, or, by another common translation of the local term for them, “betel nut beauties.” These young women stand in the glass enclosures wearing revealing clothes to attract customers, who are primarily working-class men. In his series A Moment of Beauty: Betel Nut Girls, the photographer Chin-pao Chen captures documentary portraits of more than 100 such saleswomen. Chen, who is from Taiwan himself, was 26 years old when he began shooting Moment of Beauty, in 1996. He travelled throughout the island over six years, photographing the women in their workplaces. “Most girls would agree” to participate, he said, “but I
also had to gain the permission from the owners of the stands.” A strategy for securing permission, Chen eventually learnt, was to chat at length with the owners before quickly moving on to the photography, taking as little time with the employees as possible. He would later go back to the stands to give the women copies of their portraits. Betel nut girls are a source of moral controversy in Taiwan. The government has passed laws regulating their profession—including a dress code that requires their breasts, buttocks and bellies to be covered at all times—and prohibited them from working within the city limits of Taipei, the national capital. The betel nut trade is often criticised because the saleswomen frequently face abuse. Many of them are under 18, the age at which one may legally become a betel nut girl. Chen said his subjects were, on average, 22 years old, but some
were underage, and one was only 15. While some claim that the women’s work is a form of sexual exploitation, others say the betel nut girls are simply making free economic choices. Moment of Beauty is ambivalent on the matter, and refuses to categorise its subjects as either deviants or victims. In Chen’s shots, they engage comfortably with the camera, surrounded by the mundane clutter of their work—stuffed toys, cosmetics, extension cords, refrigerators. The photographer does understand, however, that betel nut girls often endure severe hardship. It is not uncommon, he said, for them to be swept up into complex and painful relationships with their customers, or their bosses. “I did see some girls have some scars of self-injury on their wrists,” Chen said. “Maybe a more accurate title of this project,” he added, would be “A Brief Moment of Beauty.”
73
Anonymous Nantou County 2002
Wan-Hsuan and Hsiao-Ling Taipei County 1999
Anonymous Taipei County 1998
Hui-Chuan Taipei County 1999
Anonymous Taipei County 1998
Anonymous Taipei County 1998
Yi-Ling Taoyuan County 2000
Shu-Hui Hsinchu City 2001
Ssu-Pin and Yi-Wen Taipei County 2000
Pao-Pao and Hsiao-Ying Taipei County 1998