Rye Country Day School gets tax exemption for off-campus faculty housing

BY BILL HELTZEL Bheltzel@westfairinc.com

An appellate court has ruled that Rye Country Day School is exempt from property taxes on off-campus faculty housing.

A panel of four Second Appellate Division judges decided on Jan. 25 that a Westchester Supreme Court justice erred when he upheld a decision by city of Rye officials who denied tax-exempt status for six townhouses on New Street.

“There was no rational basis” for denying the tax exemption, the appellate court ruled in reversing a 2020 decision by Supreme Court Justice Bruce E. Tolbert.

The elite private school, founded in 1869, is organized as a not-for-profit educational institution. About 900 students are enrolled in programs from pre-kindergarten through

12th grade.

For at least 25 years the school has offered housing to faculty and administrators at several off-campus sites.

In 2015, Rye Country Day School bought 29-39 New Street, next to its campus, for $2,275,000. In 2018, when the six townhouses at the site were fully occupied by faculty, it applied for tax-exempt status.

City of Rye Assessor Noreen Whitty denied the application, finding that the school had not established that the housing is an integral part of education. She assessed the property at $58,100.

She also determined that several previously exempted off-campus properties will remain exempt.

The school protested the decision to the Board of Assessment Review.

Rye Country Day School argued that housing is a critical recruiting tool for draw- mer colleagues at his old job, Ken Pellegrino and Bob Nahmias — Pellegrino is now chief strategy officer while Nahmias is president and CEO.

“What our product does is it allows an organization to define the goals and objectives that they want to achieve, and to be able to measure those in a really quantifiable way,” said DiGirolamo. “So, with Shibumi they’re able to know exactly how well they’re delivering on those goals and objectives they’ve defined, and also better able to identify all of the activity they’re doing as an enterprise in support of those objectives.”

Last month, Shibumi launched a companion app that allows executives to get a holistic view of the entire organization, thus enabling access to the latest updates and metrics across the company to allow for better time management.

“The world is impatient now,” said Kim Lewis, chief delivery officer at Shibumi. “The world has gotten so comfortable with mobility. In your home life you expect to be able to take Netflix on the go. You expect to take whatever you’re doing on the go with you. It should be the same at work, and we’re enabling that now with these new apps.”

“Shibumi Mobile is another way to take advantage of the many solutions Shibumi offers, so we’re excited to provide our clients with another way to make full use of these tools,” Lewis added.

She also stressed that as a cloud-based solution with offices in Norwalk and London and distributed employees all around the world, the company has a “follow the sun” ethos, which pairs well with the mobile application.

“People don’t work nine to five anymore,” Lewis said. “If they’re working outside their normal workday, if they’re at their kids’ soccer practice and they need to respond to something that someone in Australia has flagged for them, the mobile client allows them to do that when they need to.” ing and retaining talented teachers and administrators, as well as for competing against other private schools in Westchester and Fairfield counties and New York City for sought-after talent.

The review board upheld Whitty’s decision but reduced the assessment to $45,900.

The school petitioned Westchester Supreme Court to declare the property tax-exempt.

Justice Tolbert found that the housing is not an integral part of the school’s education process.

He noted that Rye Country Day School does not board any students, so the logical question is, why would it board its faculty?

He depicted the housing as a perk and found that the school had not established “that the only way to hire the best and the brightest faculty is by offering housing.”

“Offering a perk to employees and them liking that perk,” he reasoned, “does not rise to the level that it is part of the educational process.”

The appellate justices noted that New York law has long recognized that properties used for staff housing by educational institutions are entitled to tax exemption.

The justices said the city had failed to show any meaningful distinction between the new property and several other residential properties that have been tax-exempt for at least 25 years.

Without the housing, the justices found, it would be difficult for Rye Country Day School to recruit qualified faculty, thus undermining its primary educational purpose.