TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
CHAPTERS 2- 7
THE BEGINNING
8 - 1 3 THE PLAN 1 4 - 21
THE EARLY DAYS
2 2 - 3 5 THE PHOTOGRAPHER 3 6 - 51
THE LOCATION
5 2 - 5 9 THE DOWNFALL 60 - 7 1
ALL NEWS IS BAD NEWS
7 2 - 8 3 A DAY AT THAMESMEAD 84 - 9 9 A COMPLETE FAILURE?
Page 1
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
THE BEG THAMESMEAD 1968 - PRESENT
Page 2
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
GINNING Page 3
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 4
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE BEGINNING
Thamesmead 1967 J A King
INTRODUCTION ‘Thamesmead was intended to be a vibrant, riverside community in south-east London. Forty years after being built, the area is known as a notorious hub of fraud, dubbed Little Lagos because of its association with west African criminal gangs.’ Phil Kemp 2009. Thamesmead is a district that lies within the London Borough’s of Greenwich and Bexley. Thamesmead is the name given to a group of housing developments that were built in the 1960’s. The idea behind Thamesmead was a positive one built of futuristic prospects of an ‘ideal’ world. In many ways it was a ‘planned utopia’, somewhere that would be social and safe. Nowadays Thamesmead carries associations with crime and racism. Years later, I’ve taken a look back at the plans and early days of the Thamesmead estates and compared them to the location today, The concrete jungle is now outdated and tired. However has the idea totally failed? I plan on concluding wether the utopian dream is alive in Thamesmead or is it just another example that those who believe in a utopia on earth are naive and chasing a futile cause.
Page 5
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 6
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - INTRODUCTION
Kentish Times 1968
‘There was one bus, every hour, it was always on time and you knew everyone on the bus. We had all moved together, it was lovely.’ June Preater, resident 1970 - present
Page 7
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
THE PL Page 8
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
AN THAMESMEAD Cherry Potts 2011
Page 9
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PLAN
Thamesmead 1960 Example of the futuristic designs created on estates.
Page 10
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PLAN
Thamesmead model 1968 GLC
THE PLAN u·to·pi·a - often Utopia is an ideally perfect place, especially in its social, political, and moral aspects. An impractical, idealistic scheme for social and political reform.
The thought process behind Thamesmead’s estates was to create social housing developments that didn’t make the same mistakes made by earlier estates. The problem was thought to be middle class civilians being uprooted into the’s developments without knowing the area or the people. This was therefore thought to be the cause of conflict and anti-social behaviour. The plan was to encourage families to develop within these ‘societies’. Therefore families of those already living on the estate would be given housing priority over others. The buildings (see left) were designed with geometric and angular structures. These structures were built with the intent to encourage socialising between residents. In other words it was harder to avoid bumping into your neighbours when walking around the estate,
Page 11
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PLAN
Thamesmead Joseph Salmassia Example of the architectural diversity on the estate.
Page 12
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PLAN
Overpass Designed by M C Escher
The Thamesmead estate was originally a mixture of medium rise storey blocks and modernist town houses. The diverse array of buildings were created by infamous architects and designers of the time who were all very keen to get involved. The new developments were fed on a wave of optimism and publicity. Thamesmead was seen as ‘the answer’ to London’s overflowing population and many seeked to move there. It was an exciting time for the district and London looked on to see how well their new ‘project’ would develop.
Page 13
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
THE EAR Page 14
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
RLY DAYS THAMESMEAD J.A.KING 1970
Page 15
How Thamesmead Got its Name
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
In its early days Thamesmead was known as ‘The Woolwich-Erith Riverside Project’ but it was clear the town needed a proper name. With the help of the local papers a ‘Name the New Town’ competition was launched in November 1966.There were 565 entries and the name of ‘Thamesmead’ was finally chosen. The winner was Mr Anthony Walton, a London Transport supplies officer from Barnehurst who won the £20 prize.
‘THAMES AND THE WINNER IS...
Page 16
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
SMEAD
’
Text and Image courtesy of Bexley Local Studies Archive Page 17
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE EARLY DAYS
Southmere Lake, Thamesmead, 1968 E.P.Kempsell
Terry Gooch and family presented with plaque. 1968 Kentish Times
Page 18
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE EARLY DAYS
Southmere Lake, Thamesmead, 1968 E.P.Kempsell
THE EARLY DAYS Transport Manager Terry Gooch moved into to Coralline Walk, Thamesmead, with his wife and three children back in 1968. They were the first residents to move into the new estate. Terry was originally from Peckham and he, along with his family, were chosen to be the ‘face’ of this new development. This particular development was spread between Bexley and Greenwich. The following text is taken from an interview Terry gave the BBC in 2008. “We thought it was going to be the be all and end all of everything - and it appeared to be at first. The plans were so revolutionary - we thought we’d be the start of that revolution. We were treated to chauffeured cars and attention from those in charge.”
Page 19
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
School pupils in Thamesmead G. Plemper Page 20
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
In its early days Thamesmead was such an exclusive estate and so sought after as a residency, that potential tenants had to be vetted to see if they were suitable to live there. The estates were built amongst nature reserves and canals and lakes were introduce as water was thought to have a ‘calming effect on the youth.’ The design of the buildings won awards in the late 60’s and the plans seemed to be working. Thamesmead was theoretically an ‘ideal’ place to live. As near to a utopia as you could get. It had the natural world, award winning architecture, chosen people and all within a stones throw from the big city. What could possibly go wrong?
Page 21
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
THE PHOTO Page 22
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
OGRAPHER Page 23
RIVERSIDE PUPILS GEORGE PLEMPER
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 24
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
GEORGE PLEMPER George Plemper was a former teacher at Riverside School, Thamesmead. Whilst there he practiced his interest in photography by taking portraits of the children at the school throughout the 1970’s. These photographs were remained hidden for decades but were uncovered and uploaded to the internet several years ago. They’ve brought in a lot of interest ever since. George’s photographs look at the children of the estate, specifically the children of Riverside school. In a world of ‘social seclusion’, how are the children effected? The most revealing aspect of Plempers portraits are the lack of smiles. He hasn’t forced the children to smile and therefore there is a real sense of genuine emotion in his shots. In many of his compositions, he uses groups of children, sometimes individuals, amongst wide stretches of land or against plain, dull backgrounds. There is a real sense of isolation in George’s work and a strong sense of place to go with this. The figures seem very ‘placed’ which of course, we know they were.
Page 25
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 26
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
Sam Uba 1978 G.Plemper
The following interview was from George Plemper 2012. I wanted to find out from the man himself what life was like on the estate and how this impacted his photography.
When you first heard about the plan to built an ‘idealistic society’ in Thamesmead, what were your initial thoughts? I was a young lad back then, full of myself, with little interest in the world outside of my own existence, I must have read or heard about Thamesmead somewhere because I recognised its location when I saw the advert for the Head of Chemistry post at Riverside School, I think I knew it was a “new town” and this excited me, I believed that the world could be changed for the better. When I stepped off the train at Abbey Wood and walked across to Yarnton Way, I did sense something new, exciting. The concrete walkways, lack of trees (back then they were only saplings) all spoke to me of the brave new worlds I read about in science fiction. I was happy to find myself in this environment. When you first heard that you had the job at Riverside, did you have any preconceptions about teaching there? No. When I told people that I had got a new job in Thamesmead, they went quiet, and I did overhear a friend whispering that I must be mad to even think about going there. Poor naive George. This made me more determined to go there. When I was interviewed the Headmaster was very friendly and energetic, he seemed to understand what I wanted to go with the camera and was very supportive.
‘There were family houses with gardens and a living space but this was surrounded by a 7 storey wall of flats, a bit like the battlements of a castle.’ What was the diversity like in the school (religion, race, sex, academic ability etc)? Well, issues such as diversity were not a significant issue back then, it was a school that taught local children, everyone was welcome. Looking back though I realise that there was a lot going on that I was not aware of. Patrick Butler of the Guardian has pointed out it, the school was predominantly white, working class and this is reflected in my picture. But Thamesmead did take in groups that had left their countries under duress. Sam Uba was from Biafra, you will see that there were a number of people from Chile who had fled the Pinnochet regime and a bit later, when I left, a large number of Vietnamese ‘people arrived’ in Thamesmead. I did not sense that this was an issue and I felt that the new comers added an extra vitality to the school.
Page 27
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
Self Potrait G.Plemper
Page 28
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
What was the area around Riverside like, was there anything unique about it? You can see some of my pictures of the area, it was a white concrete expanse of modern architecture, an island of reclaimed marshland surrounded by traditional housing in Abbey Wood and Belvedere. To the North and West this was just empty land. I was shocked when I returned to the area a year or so ago, it was completely filled with more modern housing, buses, shopping centres. When I lived there it was a quiet, empty area.
‘The camera became my life-line and I decided to portray an image of a “small town teacher” in many ways the collection of images is a self-portrait.’ Did you live nearby? Was Thamesmead ever a place you would have considered living in? When I moved up from the Isle of Sheppey I lived, for the first term in a bedsit above a shop in Blackheath. I then applied for a council flat and was allocated a council flat on the fifth floor of Raymond Postgate Court, I was one of the first people to move into the block, apart from the building works during the day, it was eerily quiet at night. This changed quite dramatically when all the housing was filled. I had no concerns about living in Thamesmead, I came from a council house in Sunderland, so what was the problem? The plan was to create a close network of residents in Thamesmead and the surrounding estates, was this evident in your time there? At the time, Thamesmead was built in stages, when I arrived Stage I & II was complete and the new Stage III was being constructed. I did sense that the dream of building a close network of residents in Stage 1 & II was working, I did sense a sort of community spirit at the school, there was an energy about the place. I found living in Stage III to be totally different, the architecture was very different, there were family houses with gardens and a living space but this was surrounded by a seven storey wall of flats, a bit like the battlements of a castle. At first I loved my flat, the heating and hot water which was supplied by the council but there was no balcony and, for me, the flat was little more than a box in a wall, divorced from the community and families below. I did not like living by myself in Stage III.
Page 29
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
‘THE PICTURE BECAME MY HOLD ON REALITY.’
Page 30
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
What made you want to start capturing the children? Was there anything particular you felt needed/worth portraying? I bought a camera a couple of years earlier, in an effort to create visual aids and make my lessons more interesting. I had no real desire to create images of anything really. But having a camera in the classroom meant it was natural to take pictures of the pupils, there were no issues of exploitation back then, it was expected that I would behave appropriately and that was it. Now this is the wonderful part. I thought of myself as a complete failure as a teacher, I struggled to keep control in the classroom and all my dreams of changing the world slowly ebbed away to the point where I was in danger of loosing all faith in humanity. Amazingly, when I picked up the camera, I found I could be the person I wanted to be, I did not have to be a control freak, I could talk to the children as a person, not a teacher and when I looked at the images, I realised that my vision of humanity that was in danger of disappearing , was there right in front of me. The picture became my hold on a reality that was becoming so distant. The other thing was that people seemed to sense this feeling of humanity in my pictures and they also liked them. Of course, like anyone, I liked to be liked and I loved the sense of respect people had for me as a photographer not a teacher. The camera became my life-line and I decided to portray an image of a “small town teacher” in many ways the collection of images is a self-portrait.
‘It was as if everything feared came true. I was completely lost.’ I noticed many of the children aren’t smiling in the photographs, they also appear very isolated at times, was this a conscious choice of yours of something that just developed? The wonderful thing about these pictures is that they are a reflection of my reality at the time, this is what I saw, sometimes smiling, sometimes not, sometimes feeling isolated, sometimes larking around. This was my vision, the images are real, as they appeared before me, there is little thought and lots of emotion in the images. I consider myself to be a person first and a photographer second. If you had to describe Thamesmead during your time there, in just one sentence, what would it be? Did you see a change in yourself in the time you spent there? Did you see a change in the area as a whole? Thamesmead “A highway of diamonds with nobody on it.” I did change, all my dreams disappeared, I did manage to retain a sense of humanity though. It was as if everything feared came true. I was completely lost. The area changed tremendously, I left Riverside in 1978 and continued to live in Stage III for another 4 years. The sense of community was absent and I do think the architecture contributed to this. I left teaching and did not look back, I do not know whether or not the pupils changed.
Page 31
窶連 HIGHWAY OF
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
Page 32
DIAM
WITH NOBODY ON IT.’
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
ONDS
G. Plemper Page 33
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
Eugene Soulieman, Riverside School 1977 G.Plemper
Three girls, Riverside School 2008 G.Plemper
Page 34
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE PHOTOGRAPHER
I noticed you returned to capture the children of riverside school now, what were the main differences in the pupils and area now? The main differences were that the school management was now a professional management, with people appointed into management roles, the school sent out disclaimers and asked the parent’s permission to have their children’s photographs taken. The children were still children, I did not sense any fundamental change in their humanity but they were much more conscious of their image and the potential for their celebrity. The ethnic mix had changed and the children were eager to have their “ten minutes of fame” this was not the case 35 years ago. Would you describe Thamesmead as a success? I don’t know, I did go back a year ago to film the Great Estate sequence in Thamesmead and many of my pupils still lived in the area, so this must indicate something.
‘I went into teaching full of belief and idealism, knowing that our children had limitless potential. After five years I realised that there was no place for idealism in teaching.’ George Plemper Despite the fading dreams and ‘empty land’ that George talks about, the early Thamesmead still had hope. What we do see in Plemper’s original photographs is multiculturalism. His entire works on Thamesmead shows families and friendships from a wide range of ethnic backgrounds. However there was a risk that lie within Thamesmead good intentions. If you create an isolation, a secluded society and you begin putting people in there from different religions, different viewpoints, different worlds, are you not tempting fate? You can take a horse to water, but you can’t make it drink. The future of Thamesmead now lay just as much in the residents hands as its creators.
Page 35
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS ON- FILM
THE LOC Page 36
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - FILM ON
CATION Page 37
A CLOCKWORK ORANGE 1971
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
‘Goodness is something to be chosen. When a man cannot choose he ceases to be a man.’ PRISON CHAPLAN, A CLOCKWORK ORANGE
Page 38
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
A CLOCKWORK ORANGE In 1971 a controversial, violent and cult classic called ‘A Clockwork Orange’ was released. It was based on the earlier, 1962 novel by Antony Burgess about a future dystopian Britain. The choice of setting therefore had to represent this idea of ‘the future’ along with dystopia. Ironically, the ‘planned’ utopian society of Thamesmead, was picked out as the perfect destination to film such a movie. The plot revolves around a youth gang and follows them as they undergo violence/rape and psychological torment on those they meet. Director Stanley Kubrick felt to fully represent futuristic London, he needed several locations. Thamesmead estate was chosen as one of these. Initially this seems like a positive and a sign of fulfilment for Thamesmead. After all, Thamesmead was built to be a ‘futuristic society/utopia.’ However if you watch the film or know the story, you know that the future we are told about is far from a utopia, it is, in fact, a dystopia. So why did Kubrick choose Thamesmead to reflect this? The society in ‘A Clockwork Orange’ is suggested to be a communist, perhaps socialist one. The idea is that everyone is equal. This is reminiscent in the ideas proposed for Thamesmead, a developed society with ‘ideal’ relationships. The plot however questions morality and what happens to a persons morals when they’re told what to think. What Kubrick’s film shows us is that what’s good for society, isn’t necessarily good for every individual, and that has consequences. Was A Clockwork Orange therefore predicting the future for Thamesmead?
Page 39
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
‘The concrete high-rises that surround the project were the setting for Stanley Kubrick’s violent film, Clockwork Orange. Its bleak, futuristic depiction of violent youth has stained the town’s reputation ever since.’ ‘The fraud capital of the UK’ - BBC NEWS 2009
Page 40
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 41
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
Thamesmead South Housing Estate J.Bennett
Page 42
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
The above image is of Thamesmead South Housing Estate and South Mere Lake into which Alex throws Dim and Georgie in the film.. It is also just 200 yards north of where Alex walks home at night (kicking rubbish) through an elevated plaza. This has since been demolished.
Page 43
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
Misfits, E4 Thamesmead
Page 44
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
Misfits is a British Science Fiction drama series about a group of young offenders on community service. During their community service they developed super-natural powers after a mysterious electrical storm. The series was shot in Thamesmead, predominantly by Southmere Lake, Bexley. Many of the shots contain the trademark shot of the four multistory buildings of the Southmere Lake Center. Page 45
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
Misfits, E4 Screen Shots
‘If they actually knew anything, they wouldn’t be dicking around, sticking notes on lockers. They would have gone to the police.’ Nathan, Misfits
Page 46
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
The Guardian’s print reviewer was also enthusiastic, saying: “Misfits is indeed silly — sillier, even, than it sounds — but it’s also brilliant: sharp, funny, dark and, in places, quite chilling.” Thamesmead was the chosen location for Misfits due to its association with dystopia. Therefore set choice for Misfits echoes the same ideas behind A Clockwork Orange. The series follows ‘delinquent’ young offenders on community service who struggle to keep control of their life after they develop super powers. The series features murder, ‘dodgy characters’ such as drug dealers, masked men and a disillusioned priest. As the series progresses we find out more about the characters and their dark pasts. Despite being humorous and un-realistic at times, there’s no denying Misfits has a dark, rebellious nature and Thamesmead seemed like the perfect place to host these subjects. This being a far cry away from the original intentions for the estate.
Page 47
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
‘Sam: Inside your head you can build... Mark: A skyscraper Sam: Aye... a palace.’ The Optimist’s 1973
Page 48
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
The Optimists 1973 Film Shot
The Optimists (otherwise known as ‘The Optimist’s of Nine Elms’) is a British drama film about a musician in a poor area of London. The film was shot in Thamesmead and despite being called ‘The Optimists’, the scenes in Thamesmead were of despair and the real optimism is through the characters. The hope only arises when the characters leave this area of London that you can see (above) was portrayed as very grey and run down. Apart from Peter Sellers, none of the actors went on to have particularly stimulating careers and little is written about this film. It remains as forgotten as the estate it was filmed in.
Page 49
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
‘A Beautiful Thing’ 1996 Film Poster
‘A place is just somewhere where shit happens.’ Tony, ‘A Beautiful Thing.’
Page 50
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE LOCATION
‘A Beautiful Thing’ 1996 Film Shot
A Beautiful Thing is a 1996 film adaptation of a play of the same name. It is about a teen boy from South East London and his battle with his own homosexuality. The film, originally made for Channel4 was filmed and set in Thamesmead. Like previous films shot here, the film focuses on poverty, drugs and violence. Alike to Misfits and A Clockwork Orange, the film uses Thamesmead to portray a ‘tough upbringing.’ However the final scene in A Beautiful Thing shows the boys acceptance of their sexuality and they advertise it to all the residents on the estate, some proved to be very accepting. It showed that hope can come from anywhere and its the people that make a community work..
Page 51
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
TH
DOWN Page 52
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
HE
NFALL THAMESMEAD 2006 J. BENNETT
Page 53
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 54
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Thamesmead S. Whipps
Different levels Thamesmead J.Salmassian
THE DOWNFALL After decades of broken promises residents were ready for a change. Thamesmead had promised to be this change. It was seen as ‘the answer’ to London’s problem with over population, crime and discrimination. There was a lot of pressure on Thamesmead and therefore a lot that could go wrong. Thamesmead was a world of social isolation. People were ‘vetted’ before they were given residency and priority was given to families. The marshland Thamesmead was built on meant that flooding was a risk and therefore walkways were built above ground and no-one lived on the bottom floor. Optimists called these designs ‘streets in the sky.’ What this really meant was there was a no-mans land beneath, Thamesmead was designed to be a safe and friendly society however people began to fear the ‘world below’. “When people came out of their cars, they were walking into ‘no man’s land’. Over the years it became a place where people felt uncomfortable where it was dark, where sometimes vandalism occurred.” Terry Gooch 2008
Page 55
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 56
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE DOWNFALL
I hate the cold Thamesmead LoXs Photography
The original plan/dream for Thamesmead started to fade into the 70’s. Money shortage meant the original plan was significantly scaled down. The plans for a shopping centre, a train station and bridge across the Thames were all scrapped. Before long, Thamesmead became a dumping ground for all other estates around. ‘Problem families’ were moved here and this encouraged original tenants to go elsewhere. This meant the dream to create a diverse community, a mixture of class and race was quickly slipping away. South Mere also began to go downhill. Properties soon became abandoned and consequently, vandalised. Families that couldn’t afford to move out felt trapped, the dream had failed. Thamesmead G. Plemper
Page 57
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
1980
THE QUEEN VISITS
THAMESMEAD
Page 58
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - THE DOWNFALL
Thamesmead Estate J. Bennett
Her Majesty the Queen Tavy Bridge, Thamesmead May 1980 (Bexley Local Studies & Archive)
In 1980 Thamesmead received some positive attention, something not very common for the estate. The Queen visited the area which gave a real ‘boost’ for the community. Despite this, it was only a matter of time before media would continue to focus on the negative aspects of the area and the community would begin to re-segregate.
Page 59
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - ALL NEWS IS BAD NEWS
ALL NEWS Page 60
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - ALL NEWS IS BAD NEWS
IS BAD NEWS Page 61
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Rolan Adams march D. Hoffman
On the 21st February 1991, fifteen year old Rolan Adams was murdered by a white youth gang. Rolan Adams was waiting at a bus stop with his younger brother Nathan when he was set upon by fourteen youths.. They had been at a local youth club and were waiting for a bus home in Thamesmead. The youths were between the ages of sixteen and twenty six. They hurled racist abuse at Rolan and his younger brother. Rolan was stabbed from behind and tried to run, he cried out for Nathan to run also. Nathan escaped the area however Page 62
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
returned after his brother had not caught up. He found Rolan in a pool of blood, he died soon after. The youths were known to the police due to their racist behaviour toward other residents. The main attacker was sentence for life for his part however out of the other thirteen youths, only four faced trial. They were given community service for their part. The attack went down as a ‘territorial’ issue and not racially motivated.
Page 63
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
On June 1st 1991 (just months after the death of Rolan Adams), the BNP marched on the site where the fifteen year old was murdered. Their focus for their march was entitled ‘rights for whites.’ Thamesmead, the estate built on social ideals, was overrun with segregation. Photography by P. Dee
Page 64
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 65
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 66
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - ALL NEWS IS BAD NEWS
Rolan Adams memorial 2011 D. Hoffman
‘On a grey February day, along with fellow photographer David Hoffman, I attended the 20th anniversary memorial to the little-publicised racist murder of Rolan Adams, 15. People at the memorial told me about their stories from 20 years ago, how the racist BNP had moved in and how scared they were. Nobody of colour could visit the pub - if you did it was a gamble with your own life, and Rolan’s peers all had a story to tell on how, once, perhaps to watch a football match, or simply try to have a drink with a friend, they bravely ventured to the pub only to be chased away by white youths wielding knives, bats and chains. In Rolan’s case it was to be fatal, just like Stephen Lawrence, 18, two miles away and two years later.’ Steve Silver Rolan Adams’ family, family friends and their supporters meet on 21st February 2011, the twentieth anniversary of his murder by a racist gang in Thamesmead, to lay a wreath in his memory. During the ceremony racist youths in a passing car threw a takeaway milk shake at the group. Rolan’s murderer, Mark Thornburrow, has recently been freed
Page 67
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - ALL NEWS IS BAD NEWS
‘Thamesmead was intended to be a vibrant, riverside community in south-east London. Forty years after being built, the area is known as a notorious hub of fraud, dubbed Little Lagos because of its association with west African criminal gangs.’ Phill Kemp, BBC reporter
Page 68
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - ALL NEWS IS BAD NEWS
Ten Years of Crime, Thamesmead.
March 2002 - Man jailed for four years for running a ‘forgery factory’ in his Thamesmead home. April 2002 - Double bigamist from Thamesmead escapes jail. July 2002 - Notorious train robber, Ronnie Biggs, lists Thamesmead as home address on marriage certificate. February 2004 - Paedophile convicted of numerous offences is banned from Thamesmead home. March 2005 - Thamesmead man arrested on for ‘acts of terrorism.’ October 2009 - 22 year old male is stabbed to death by five youths, Thamesmead. August 2011 - Thamesmead woman makes false slavery claims to stay in UK. August 2011 - Community Support Officers attacked by youths September 2011 - 16 year old male is hospitalised after being stabbed in Morrisons, Thamesmead. February 2012 - 43 year old male from Thamesmead is charged for helping a prisoner escape a hospital.
Page 69
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
“They were shaken by the events however they continued to patrol that night and have done so since.” PC Martyn, Thamesmead
Page 70
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - ALL NEWS IS BAD NEWS
Burnt house, Thamesmead 2011 G. J. Brydon
In 2011 London and many other major cities in the UK fell into chaos as youths took to the streets to riot and pillage. Thamesmead, being a hub of crime, was no exception. During the 2011 summer riots, three community support officers from the Abbey wood team received reports of masked youths causing disruption in Thamesmead town centre. Following up on their report the officers discovered a group of youths, masked, hooded and carrying suspicious packages. After questioning the gang, the three officers were set on by almost thirty hoodlums. They were hit and one officer fell to the ground, all officers however managed to escape without serious injury. This was a reminder that Thamesmead was not the safe haven it was once dreamt to be, instead it remains a crime ridden society with a lack of authority.
Page 71
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
A DAY AT
THAME Page 72
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
ESMEAD Page 73
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 74
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A DAY AT THAMESMEAD
I decided that I couldn’t get a strong enough idea of what Thamesmead is like and how it has lived up to its expectations, without visiting the place myself. I therefore picked up my camera one day in the Easter holidays and got a train to Abbey Wood, Thamesmead’s nearest station. On arrival of Abbey Wood station, I was extremely apprehensive due to the Thamesmead‘s reputation with crime and gang culture. Unfortunately I wasn’t reassured by what greeted me on the platform. Eight police officers were lined up on the platform edge and shortly after a man was arrested. A part of me wanted to get back on the train there and then but another part of me was excited, excited to see the things I had read about, the leftover dreams of many. After I navigated myself from the station to the main estate I found myself in complete recognition. I felt like I’d been there before. The things you read about, the atmosphere you get from the photographs, it’s all reality. There were stair wells going off at all angles, dark walkways and most obviously, a complete lack of ‘community.’ One thing I didn’t expect was the vast amount of horses that seemed to ‘wander’ through any patches of green as well as the surrounding park. They seemed to sum up the air of neglect that was felt throughout the estate.
Page 75
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
The main thing I noticed in the Thamesmead estate was the complete feeling of isolation. I explored for about an hour and a half and saw a handful of people within that time. The people I did see seemed reluctant to smile, to make any sort of eye contact. People walked, head down and with purpose. It was the Easter holidays, there was a park, a lake and the sun was shining. However I didn’t see a single child in my entire time on the estate. In my time there, I heard many echoes through tunnels and Page 76
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
underground walkways, echoes of voices. The estate was built with the intention to make people bump into one another, to make people socialise. Instead I felt a fear of the residents, a fear of the unknown. I felt unwanted by residents of Thamesmead. When I walked along the long walkway by the lake I saw people peer through curtains, it was like they weren’t used to seeing people there, like they feared me.
Page 77
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 78
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 79
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A DAY AT THAMESMEAD
‘PEOPLE MAKE A PLACE ...AND THERE WEREN’T ANY.’
Page 80
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A DAY AT THAMESMEAD
Despite seeing a lack of people, despite feeling alone and fearful and despite the sense of neglect, I saw potential at Thamesmead. I was lucky enough to be there when the sun was out and it certainly picked out areas of beauty. The lake with the swans and ducks, shone in the sunlight, the horses grazed on clean green grass in the park and the stylistic buildings seemed so powerful against the bright sky. I got a feeling that if the estate had been better maintained, if the original plan of large family residents had worked, if the area had better links to London, this could have been an urban paradise. Sadly people make a place and from what I saw, there weren’t any. Many of the buildings were now abandoned, many iconic structures (like the pyramid club) had been torn down and in many ways, it seemed the dream had failed.
Page 81
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 82
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 83
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
A COMPLETE
Page 84
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
E FAILURE? Photography courtesy of Local Bus Driver blog
Page 85
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 86
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A COMPLETE FAILURE?
THAMESMEAD TOWN FC Approximately two miles from Abbey Wood train station lies Bayliss Avenue, home of Thamesmead Town FC. Thamesmead FC was formed in 1969 as a community team for local youngsters. The club merged with Thamesmead senior football team, Southlake FC in 1973 to become Thamesmead FC In 1985, Thamesmead FC was renamed Thamesmead Town FC. Thamesmead Town FC are a relatively small club. They currently reside in the Isthmian League Division One North after being promoted as champions from Kent League Premier Division in 2008. However Thamesmead seems to have a great spirit toward Thamesmead Town FC. The clubhouse, pitches and car park and other original facilities were constructed at a cost of £450,000. In 2009, a whopping 4.2 million pound regeneration project on Bayliss Avenue began, part funded by Thamesmead Trust. The work is still being carried out. So why is Thamesmead so eager to promote their local football club? What is it they feel Thamesmead Town FC brings to the area? For a small club, Thamesmead Town FC seem to have a big attitude. They have a mascot, ‘Tommy the Toad’, who makes an appearance at every game, a supporters elite called the ‘Thamesmead Hardcore’ and most importantly, the club seems to have a future. The generation project will produce a 500 seat stand with balcony, a bar, changing facilities ,indoor sports hall and gym and most importantly, two additional football pitches and multi-use outdoor sports facilities available seven days a week to the local community.. Thamesmead Town FC seems to care about its community and creating opportunities for their own which is why Thamesmead Trust is willing to invest in them.
Turnstile Bayliss Avenue D. McCreery Page 87
‘Our players are very committed and loyal. They would run through a wall for the club.’
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 88
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A COMPLETE FAILURE?
I was lucky enough to get an interview with Thamesmead Town FC’s manager, Keith McMahon. I wanted to know what the club meant to him and get a better idea of the impact it has on Thamesmead as a ‘community.’Below is my interview with Keith. How long have you been at Thamesmead Town? Nine years. What made you want to become manager? I got a serious injury when I was 21 and it stopped me playing. I couldn’t be without football so I started my coaching badges. I wanted to be part of football and if I couldn’t play then management was the next best thing. What’s your favourite thing about being at the club? The spirit of the club. We are like one big family and we are very ambitious. Everyone works for each other. What do you think is the best thing about working at a football club? The club let me run things from top to bottom and always 100% back my decision. How would you describe the fans? They are very passionate and want the best for the club. How would you describe the players? Our players are very committed and loyal. They would run through a wall for the club. Thamesmead Town FC D. McCreery Page 89
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
‘IT’S AN UP AND COMING AREA.’
Page 90
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Thamesmead Town FC D. McCreery
What’s your best memory of/at Thamesmead Town? Winning the Kent League for the very 1st time for the club. It was very emotional for everyone at the club. What do you think the most important thing is for a football club to have? A future. Security of tenure is very important. Also strong foundations. I think a good youth set up is very important. Do you live nearby, how would you describe the area? I live about 6 miles away. Its an up and coming area. What do you see for the future for Thamesmead/ Thamesmead Town? I hope Thamesmead can rise up through the leagues. We have a new development being built and hopefully this will attract more supporters and the club can grow.
Page 91
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A COMPLETE FAILURE?
Page 92
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A COMPLETE FAILURE?
THAMESMEAD WEST Thamesmead West was built in 1990 onwards. It features buildings that are significantly newer and more desirable than that of the original Thamesmead estate. Located far west of Abbey Wood, by Plumstead train station, is Thamesmead West a sad reminder of what Thamesmead estate could have been? Thamesmead estate contains an eco-park, a pioneering small social/affordable housing development with homes built to high energy efficiency and environmental standards. Like the original estate it has its own lake and the area itself looks undeniably more clean and more modern than Thamesmead south. This estate seems more fitting in todays London and is in a more desirable area of Greenwich. However there are similarities between the two estates. Both areas don’t feature an Underground station and bus is the most common transport. The nearest Overground rail station is a fair walk and both places have social problems, higher than the national average. So despite being newer, closer to London and more desirable, Thamesmead West seems to be failing also and perhaps one day, will end up like Thamesmead estate.
Page 93
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 94
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A COMPLETE FAILURE?
A picture of the proposed Thames Gateway Bridge. © Transport for London 2007.
GATE TO THE FUTURE - THAMES GATEWAY First proposed in the 1970s, Thames Gateway Bridge was intended to connect Beckton in the London Borough of Newham with Thamesmead in the Royal Borough of Greenwich. The bridge would have given Thamesmead residents a quicker route into central London, saving them travelling to the Greenwich and Woolwich foot tunnels or the Blackwall Tunnel for vehicles. Unfortunately for Thamesmead, the proposal never came to fruition. In November 2008, Boris Johnson, the current Mayor of London, formally cancelled the entire £500m scheme. It’s hard to determine whether the bridge would have resulted in the positive regeneration it had intended. Either way the plan caused much controversy and due to insufficient funds, it didn’t seem worth the risk. Thamesmead therefore, remained isolated and couldn’t feel further away from central London. Mayor, Boris Johnson has promised however, a ferry route between Thamesmead and Beckton. Unfortunately, the ferry is not due to come into action until 2017 so for now, Thamesmead remains very much south of the river.
Page 95
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS -
Page 96
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A COMPLETE FAILURE?
Riverside Pupils Thamesmead 1978 G. Plemper
A COMPLETE FAILURE? There was no denying the good nature and potential that lie in Thamesmead at the end of the 1960’s. It seemed like the answer to London’s overcrowding and run down estates. George Plempers photographs showed children from many backgrounds and ethnicity. In many of his photographs the children are smiling in large social groups. So what went wrong? Why was Thamesmead such a disappointment and has anything been achieved? Having visited Thamesmead myself I would say it still has potential. As a designer I appreciated the stylistic buildings and seeing the lake and birds in the sunlight made me saddened that no one was around to enjoy it. The estate itself was a forgotten world. I saw a handful of people there yet hundreds of property’s. It was clear to me what had gone wrong. The layout had created dark, intimidating pathways, the contact with residents seemed ‘forced’. Rather than promoting socialising and a ‘safe haven’ the design had created a fear of others. The truth is the future forty years ago is not the same as the future now. I think the dream needs to be re-thought. The futuristic buildings are no longer new, people need a new dream, a new future. I for one felt extremely isolated in Thamesmead, partly due to the lack of people and partly due to the poor transport routes into London. For Thamesmead to have a future, it needs to have better connections. Perhaps the bridge would have created a regeneration, perhaps not. Maybe the ferry plans for 2017 will improve things, maybe not. Until dramatic changes are made, until a method of regeneration goes underway in Thamesmead, the estate will remain the forgotten Utopia.
Page 97
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A COMPLETE FAILURE?
Page 98
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - A COMPLETE FAILURE?
‘If we don’t intervene now we could go into a spiral of decline or we could capture the growth and excitement thats happening in the Thames Gateway. We have a fantastic legacy here that from a planning perspective forty years ago was a place people would come and visit. I think the new buildings are going to be futuristic in their own generation.’ Alison Breese, Thamesmead - 40 years on
Page 99
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS
Thamesmead Postcards, GLC 1970
Page 100
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS
Thamesmead 2012 T. Bennett
Page 101
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Acknowledgements www.filmmasterjournal.com http://www.flickr.com/photos/7718785@N06/ (Mak’m & Mrs’ photostream) (George Plemper photography) http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/gallery/2008/may/14/communities www.guardian.co.uk http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/interactive/2008/jun/04/george.plemper.audio. slideshow http://www.hoffmanphotos.com/ - David Hoffman Photography http://www.diggerdee.co.uk/index.php - Phillip Dee photography www.ideal-homes.org.uk/bexley/assets/galleries/thamesmead http://www.flickr.com/photos/nakedcharlton/sets/590817/?page=2 (Jons pics London) (photography by Jon Bennett) http://www.flickr.com/photos/50780708@N02/sets/72157625561398298/detail/ (John A King photography - Thamesmead) http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8193884.stm - Thamesmead ‘The fraud capital of the UK.’ http://www.bbc.co.uk/insideout/content/articles/2008/10/08/london_ thamesmead_s14_w4_feature.shtml - BBC Inside out London - Thamesmead http://www.northeastphoto.net/?p=1192 http://hidden-london.com/gazetteer/thamesmead/ http://www.smokinglensbarrel.com/ http://www.trust-thamesmead.co.uk/sub_page.cfm/section/history/editID/204 http://www.thamesmeadtownfc.co.uk/#/supporters/4522366507 Local Bus Driver blog - http://localbusdriver.blogspot.co.uk/2012/01/thamesmeadtown-fc-1-2-cheshunt-fc.html
Page 102
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS - ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Page 103
TOWN FROM A WILDERNESS
TOM BENNETT