Paris Airshow News 6-20-11 by AIN Publications

Paris

PUBLICATIONS

MONDAY

6•20•2011 Vol. 43 No. 13

Air Show News Combat Aircraft In the News

Hybrid Rotorcraft

Powerplants

Going Green

Eurocopter’s X3 Demonstrator makes its international debut

Narrowbody power struggle

Safran/Honeywell joint venture wants airplanes to taxi greenly

Call it the “X-cubed” and watch what the innovative rotorcraft can do in the flying display. Hint: It flies fast! Pages 4 and 68

Engine makers square off in fight for technology choices for the next-generation A320 and 737 replacements. Page 40

APU would power electric motors on the landing gear to taxi airplanes from ramp to runway. Page 86

Honeywell goes green with bioflight

Dassault Rafale proves its mettle over Libya Page 72 Lockheed Martin F-35 battles budget woes Page 82 USAF extends U-2’s life as Global Hawk falters Page 85

AINonline’s Paris Videos > Honeywell’s transatlantic biofuel flight > EADS Zehst aircraft concept > Superjet bounced landing at Le Bourget > Boeing 747 Intercontinental

Boeing’s new 747-8 Intercontinental says, “Bonjour,” to the City of Light as “Sunrise” kisses the tarmac at Le Bourget Airport yesterday morning. The pilots reported a virtually flawlesss flight on the 4,400-nm Great Circle route from Seattle.

Honeywell made history here in Paris on Saturday morning, landing its Gulfstream G450 jet at Le Bourget after the first transatlantic flight using biofuel. The trip’s green credentials can be measured in the 5.5 metric tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) saved in the course of the seven-hour flight from the New Yorkarea Morristown Airport. In fact, the aircraft crossed the Pond only partly powered by biofuel. The G450’s fuel system was set so that number-one (left) engine burned a 50/50 blend of “Honeywell Green Jet Fuel” and standard jet-A fuel, while the other engine consumed pure jet-A. Adding to the “greening” of the 2011 Paris Air Show is the expected arrival today of a Boeing 747-8F also using Honeywell’s Continued on page 85 u

MARK WAGNER

James Rekoske, v-p and general manager of renewable energy and chemicals for Honeywell UOP, is all smiles after the flight.

MARK WAGNER

by Kirby J. Harrison

Boeing basks in Sunrise’s glow as Intercontinental bows at show by Gregory Polek The first Boeing 747-8 Intercontinental flew into a blustery Le Bourget Airport Sunday morning, fittingly marking its international airshow debut in its distinctive reddish-orange Sunrise livery. In fact, the sun never set on 747 program chief test pilot Mark Feuerstein and his co-pilot, BBJ president Steve Taylor, during their nine-hour, 52-minute flight from Seattle’s Boeing Field to Le Bourget. Completing a 4,400-nm Great Circle route over Greenland and Scotland’s isle of Islay, RC001 landed on Le Bourget’s Runway 25 at 9:30 a.m. The pilots reported a virtually flawless first international flight for the first 7478I prototype.

“We received a lot of attention coming into Paris,” commented Feuerstein. “It’s an enormous privilege to bring the airplane to Paris for its debut…It’s an easy airplane to fly and truly is one of the finest flying airplanes in the sky today.” On hand for the event, Rob Pollack, Boeing vice president of brand marketing, explained the reasoning behind the choice of the airplane’s unique paint scheme. The “Sunrise” color, he said, represents prosperity and good luck in eastern cultures. Aiming to market the airplane largely in the Far East and India, Boeing chose the livery largely to appeal to those markets. The airplane, one of five Boeing jetliners that are on display at Paris, will remain

on show until June 21, when it will return to flight-test activity. Elizabeth Lund, 747-8 program manager, told AIN that the two Intercontinental flight-test aircraft have now flown some 300 hours, roughly a third of the expected total needed for certification. The OEM hopes to gain certification for the passenger version of the 747-8 by the end of the year. Boeing expects the freighter version of the model, the 747-8F, to arrive in Le Bourget today by about 5 p.m. Lund said the company has completed 96 percent of the testing for that program and expects certification sometime late this summer (see related story on page 84). o

Need air transport news? Sign up for AIN Air Transport Perspective.

Paris

Engine Gearbox Glitch Dampens Airbus A400M’s Le Bourget Debut An engine gearbox anomaly picked up during flight testing of an Airbus A400M has prompted Airbus Military to withdraw its new military transport aircraft from the daily flying program here at the Paris Air Show. “The A400M had a small incident with the gearbox of one aircraft,” said Airbus Military CEO Domingo Ureña. “We are waiting for the full analysis before restarting flight tests.” This is a further setback to the A400M program, following an issue with cracks in its huge (17-foot diameter) counter-rotating propellers, but not serious enough to ground the aircraft. Therefore, one of the four prototypes was permitted to fly to Le Bourget and to take part in the show’s opening fly-past with the Patrouille de France. Afterward, it will be placed back in the static park for the show week. The four flying A400Ms have completed more than 1,400 hours of flight testing in some 450 flights, and a fifth aircraft is being prepared for its first flight. Certification of the A400M to civil standards is planned by the end of the year and first delivery–which will be to the French air force–around the end of 2012. Airbus Military has 170 firm orders for the A400M from the seven partner nations (Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg, Spain, Turkey and the UK) and four from Malaysia, for a total of 174. The model is anticipated to be named “Atlas” sometime this summer. –I.S.

Air Show News FOUNDED IN 1972

James Holahan, Founding Editor Wilson S. Leach, Managing Director

DAVID McINTOSH

MARK WAGNER

by Ian Sheppard A350-1000, will have its maximum rated thrust increased from 93,000 to 97,000 pounds, although the only difference from the engines powering the other variants will be a slightly larger (scaled up) core, and the insertion of various technology refinements flowing from its Advance 3 technology demonstrator program. The result is that the A3501000 will be able to fly about 400 nm farther (8,400 nm with a full load of 350 passengers), or carry 4.5 tons more payload. It will be created by adding five frames in the aft fuselage section and six frames in the front section to stretch the baseline A350-900. The -1000 will require some strengthening

With the the Airbus A350XWB delayed for two years, the A380 remains queen of the skies. Airbus said at a briefing Saturday that the delay of the -1000 would allow it boost performance to better match Boeing’s 777-300ER.

linked to the higher mtow, and a further optimized wing. King confirmed that, in return for its further investment of time and money, Rolls-Royce is now the exclusive engine supplier for the A350-1000, although not for the A350-800 and A350-900. Airbus COO for customers John Leahy said that

Editor-in-chief – R. Randall Padfield INTERNATIONAL EDITOR – Charles Alcock Pressroom managing Editor – R. Randall Padfield PRODUCTION DIRECTOR – Mary E. Mahoney the editorial team Liz Moscrop Jeff Apter Julian Moxon Bill Carey Chris Pocock David Donald Gregory Polek Thierry Dubois Olivia Saucier Curt Epstein Ian Sheppard Bernard Fitzsimons Matt Thurber Ian Goold Chad Trautvetter Kirby J. Harrison Paolo Valpolini Vladimir Karnozov

Nigel Moll the production team Mona L. Brown Jane Campbell Joseph W. Darlington Paul Lowe John Manfredo Annmarie Yannaco Photographers David McIntosh Mark Wagner press room administrator – Lysbeth McAleer

Airbus uses A350 delays to challenge Boeing 777 Airbus has revealed that first deliveries of its A350XWB-800 and A350XWB-1000 will be delayed by two years–to mid2016 and mid-2017, respectively. At a briefing in Paris on Saturday, it claimed the delay of the -1000 would allow it to boost the payload-range performance to better match the Boeing 777300ER, which is something its customers have been requesting. “The A350-1000 now sits right on top of the 777300ER,” insisted Fabrice Brégier, Airbus COO, who added that the price for the -1000 would be increased by $9 million to reflect the enhancement. According to Rolls-Royce president Mark King, the Trent XWB engine, which powers the

no customer had yet asked for an alternative engine. Currently, six Trent XWB engines are being tested, with flight testing of one of the engines on an A380 due to start by the end of this year. The higher thrust version of the engine is scheduled to run for the first time in mid-2014. o

EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT & ONLINE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT – John F. McCarthy Jr. Publisher – Anthony T. Romano Advertising Sales – north america Melissa Murphy – Midwest (830) 608-9888 Nancy O’Brien – West (530) 241-3534 Anthony T. Romano – East/International Philip Scarano III - Southeast (203) 798-2400 ext. 23 Victoria Tod – Great Lakes/UK Advertising Sales – International – Daniel Solnica – Paris production/MANUFACTURING manageR – Tom Hurley AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT MANAGER – Jeff Hartford group brand manager – Jennifer Leach English sales/production administrator – Susan Amisson Advertising/sales Secretary STAFF Patty Hayes; Cindy Nesline director of finance & new product development – David M. Leach Human ResourceS Manager – Jane Webb accounting/Administration manager – Irene L. Flannagan accounting/AdministratiON Staff Mary Avella; Erin Fogelstrom; Rosa Rivera U.S. EDITORIAL OFFICE: 214 Franklin Ave., Midland Park, NJ 07432 Tel: (201) 444-5075; Fax: (201) 444-4647 Washington, D.C. EDITORIAL OFFICE: Paul Lowe 5605 Alderbrook Court, T-6, Rockville, MD 20851 Tel: (301) 230-4520; Fax: (301) 881-1982 paulloweain@aol.com EUROPEAN EDITORIAL OFFICE: Charles Alcock 8 Stephendale Road, Farnham, Surrey GU9 9QP UK Tel: 44 1 252 727 758; calcockain@aol.com U.S. advertising OFFICE: 81 Kenosia Ave., Danbury, CT 06810 Tel: (203) 798-2400; Fax: (203) 798-2104 EUROPEAN ADVERTISING OFFICE: Daniel Solnica 25 rue Saulnier, 75009, Paris, France Tel: 33-1-42-46-95-71 Fax: 33-1-42-46-85-08 dsolnica@club-internet.fr RUSSIAN ADVERTISING OFFICE: Yuri Laskin, Gen. Dir., Laguk Co. Ltd. Russia, 115172, Moscow Krasnokholmskaya Nab., 11/15 - 132 Tel: +7-05-912-1346, 911-2762 Fax: +7-095-912-1260 ylarm-lml@mtu-net.ru The Convention News Company, Inc. – AIN Publications President – Wilson S. Leach Executive Vice President – John F. McCarthy, Jr. Vice President of Operations – R. Randall Padfield Treasurer – Jane L. Webb Secretary – Jennifer L. English

DAVID McINTOSH

x-rated hybrid premierEs in paris The first public flight of Eurocopter’s X3 hybrid demonstrator will take place today at the Paris Air Show. It is powered by a fiveblade main rotor system and two propellers on short-span fixed wings (see page 68).

4 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Paris Airshow News is a publication of The Convention News Co., Inc., 214 Franklin Ave., Midland Park, NJ 07432; Tel.: (201) 444-5075. Copyright © 2010. All rights r eserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission of The Convention News Co., Inc. is strictly prohibited. The Convention News Co., Inc. also publishes Aviation International News, AINalerts, AIN Defense Perspective, AIN Air Transport Perspective, AINmx Reports, Business Jet Traveler, EBACE C onvention News, HAI Convention News, MEBA Convention News, NBAA Convention News, Dubai Airshow News, Paris Airshow News, Singapore Airshow News. Printed in Taverny, France by Sego. Computer Services: Loc Me, Lyon, France.

BOMBARDIER BUILDS THEM: Widebody business jets perfectly suited to your mission. Bombardier Challenger super-midsize and large aircraft - proven in over four million flight hours - are intelligent, business-driving assets. And for the refined requirements of selective world travelers, Bombardier Global super-large and ultra-long-range surpass all expectation.

TAG AERONAUTICS BRINGS THEM TO YOU: TAG Aeronautics is the exclusive representative and distributor of Bombardier Global and Challenger series business jets throughout the Middle East. Since 1977, TAG has exceeded the expectations of its customers with aircraft and services tailored to meet every need. Your ideal aircraft awaits. Contact a TAG sales representative today at (514) 855-7771.

Thales has 20/20 vision for cockpit of the future by Bernard Fitzsimons Even as it works toward delivery of the first flying A350 cockpit later this year, Thales (Hall Concorde) is exploring possibilities for the post-2020 generation of aircraft at its Le Haillan facility in Bordeaux. The one-display cockpit interactive solution (Odicis) featured in the company’s pavilion here is intended to help define what Thales terms cockpit 3.0, a successor

to the first- and second-generation flight decks represented by the Concorde, with its separate instrument for each parameter, and the A320, which allocated a single display per function. The A350 will stick with the A320-derived format used by the A380 to minimize the amount of retraining needed as pilots move from other Airbus models, though the displays themselves

will be bigger, lighter and less power-hungry. As Sebastien Perrignon, A350 program manager, explained at Le Haillan before the airshow, the A350 will have six 15-inch diagonal screens in place of the A380’s eight eightby six-inch screens for a 60-percent increase in display area. But the screens will be divided to present each pilot with the familiar primary flight and navigation displays side by side, using the same colors and symbology. Each screen has the same part number and uses the same software, and each incorporates a computer to generate head-up display and airport navigation imagery. The total weight saved by reducing the number of screens and eliminating the separate image generators is 15 kilograms, Perrignon said, while power consumption is reduced by 150 Watts. As four of the screens cover the functions of the A380’s eight, the other two, at the extreme left and right, are available for onboard information system (OIS) functions, such as charts, manuals and performance calculations. Integrated with the avionics rather than stand-alone as on the A380, they are controlled The A350 cockpit being developed by Thales features six large screens offering 60 percent more display area than the A380’s eight.

Irkut proceeds on MC-21 narrowbody by Vladimir Karnozov & Charles Alcock With a budget of close to $7 billion, the MC-21 narrowbody airliner is the most ambitious and expensive civilian aeronautical project ever attempted by a Russian company. Irkut, part of Russia’s United Aircraft Corp. (UAC) is leading the program. Its goal is for deliveries to start in 2016 and for annual production to reach a rate of 70 airframes. There will be three members of the MC-21 family with a standard range of 1,900 nm, rising to 2,700 nm for an ER (extended-range) version. In all-economy-class configurations with a 32-inch seat pitch, the MC-21-200 offers 150 seats, while the MC-21-300 will have 181 seats and the MC-21400 will have 212. In addition to stretched fuselage, the MC-21-400 model features a wing span that is almost four feet longer than that of the other types. At last year’s Farnborough airshow, Malaysia’s Crecom Burj Resources became the MC-21’s launch customer. By February of this year, Irkut was

claiming around 150 orders and commitments for an aircraft that competes with Airbus’s new A320neo, as well as the Bombardier CSeries and China’s Comac C919. Irkut claims that its clean-sheet design will overtake the evolutionary A320neo in terms of flight performance, while delivering operating cost reductions of between 12 and 15 percent compared with those of the existing A320 and Boeing 737 families, as well as Russia’s Tupolev Tu-204. Irkut president Alexey Fedorov told AIN that Airbus will not be able to achieve this degree of increased efficiency simply by re-engining the A320. He indicated that the MC-21 will trump the Neo development with improved aerodynamics and greater weight savings through extensive use of composite materials in the airframe. In November 2010 the MC-21 passed an airframe mockup inspection by Russian aviation authorities. In the same month,

6 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

the Perm-based Aviadvigatel engine maker submitted the core for the first PD-14 turbofan for bench testing. The PD-14 is a Russian alternative to the Pratt &Whitney PW1400G geared turbofan, which Irkut also intends to offer as powerplant for the MC-21. Irkut has followed Sukhoi’s example with the smaller Superjet SJ-100 development of using Boeing’s “seven-gate” path to aircraft development. Fedorov told AIN that it is in the process of passing through the fourth gate in which it freezes the aircraft concept design and selects vendors. “The negotiations are intense and will continue during the air show in Paris,” he said. “The signing of contracts will close the fourth gate. However, I cannot name the exact date of the completion of this process yet.” He said that the next phase, involving final resolution of the aircraft configuration, will be completed in the first half of 2012.

by the same keyboard and cursor control units as the main screens, so the pilots can share information by moving it to one of the center screens. They also provide automatic backup if one of the center display units fails. Alongside the A350 cockpit mockup that functions as a representative test bench, Thales is using a PC-based simulation platform for preliminary development and testing, plus the iDeck demonstrator that was shown here two years ago. The iDeck was developed originally to demonstrate the company’s technologies and display know-how to Airbus during the selection process. Now it is being used to develop new formats and to demonstrate new symbology and concepts to Airbus and airline pilots. Prototypes of most system hardware and the first version of the associated software have already passed acceptance tests in Airbus’s labs and simulation benches, Perrignon said. The first full specification software standard, including HUD and airport navigation functions, has been integrated on the test bench at Le Haillan ahead of delivery to Airbus this summer, and the first flying hardware will follow before the end of the year. Thales’ Cockpit 3.0 research, meanwhile, is aimed at developing Beyond that, Irkut needs to prepare manufacturing documentation for the MC-21 prototypes. These are due to start flying in 2014 and in 2016 obtain certification from both the authorities of the Commonwealth of Independent States and the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA). Fedorov said that work has advanced well and that the company faces “no insoluble problems” in achieving service entry before the end of 2016. The commitments made to the MC-21 program to date also include a memorandum of understanding for 50 aircraft signed with the state-backed Russian Technologies group. This would see deliveries made between 2016 and 2022. According to Fedorov, Irkut is now working to finalize this contract. At the same time, Irkut has confirmed that it is responding to a request for a proposal from European low-cost carrier Ryanair. The notoriously hardbargaining operator also is looking at the Comac C-919, having so far failed to extract what it considers to be sufficiently low pricing from Airbus or Boeing. In anticipation of MC-21

concepts for use on military aircraft, helicopters and business jets as well as the next generation of Boeing and Airbus airliners. Denis Bonnet, head of innovative cockpit design, said the idea is to design the cockpit around the crew, so the Odicis cockpit has a single screen that can be tailored to what the crew wants to do. One idea is to have a new mission management display for the left-seat pilot with the PFD and 3-D terrain on the right to support a division of responsibilities that would see one pilot flying and the other managing the mission. “Most mission management is head down while the pilot is usually head up,” Bonnet explained. “They can also interact with the screens,” he said. “We wanted to test the ability to take benefit from a touch screen.” The screens enable imagery to be rearranged, while maps can be zoomed and manipulated in the same way as an iPhone screen. The Odicis cockpit uses five projectors behind the screen to generate the imagery with a new, higher level of contrast and brightness. The ideal configuration would have a depth of just six inches behind the screen, but that would have required prohibitively expensive folded optics, Bonnet said. In a real cockpit there could be twice as many projectors. o

Irkut president Alexey Fedorov thinks his MC-21 narrowbody will outperform the re-engined Airbus A320.

serial production, Irkut is modernizing its Irkutsk Aviation Plant, which will serve as the final assembly line. It has already invested some $340 million in the facility as part of a process that saw the company approved by Airbus to make parts for the A320 family. Meanwhile, in the military domain, Irkut continues output of the Sukhoi Su-30MK fighters and it is working on a further upgrade for India’s air force that will incorporate BrahMos antiship missiles.

EIGHT TIMES MORE COVERAGE. HALF THE COST.

MEADS covers new ground in air and missile defense. Eight times more ground to be exact. After spending billions of U.S. tax dollars to upgrade Patriot, more upgrades are needed. It will still cost twice as much to man and maintain. The solution is MEADS, with advanced capabilities and reliability the 40-year-old Patriot system canâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t provide. MEADS 360-degree coverage defends more area with fewer assets, with the lethality to defeat advanced threats. All at a lower cost than upgrading Patriot.

Defending more. Costing less. Only MEADS covers it all.

meads-amd.com

news clips z Honeywell Tenders Buy Offer To EMS Technologies Honeywell (Hall 3 B56) announced earlier this week that it has offered to acquire EMS Technologies for $491 million, pending shareholder and regulatory approvals. The acquisition should be completed in the third quarter of this year. EMS Technologies’ corporate headquarters is in Norcross, Georgia. EMS’s aviation division (Hall 3 DE161) is a provider of satellite broadband communications systems and satcom antennas, but it also offers asset tracking and management, military/ government, space and mobile computing/data collection products and services. The company provides satellite voice and email, using the Iridium and Inmarsat networks, and voice and high-speed data on Inmarsat, as well as voice and data services for air traffic management and safety services. For military/government customers, EMS uses Inmarsat to provide intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance, airborne command and control and roll-on/roll-off satcom systems. Honeywell CEO Dave Cote described the acquisition of EMS Technologies as a “strategic fit” with the company’s own stable of satcom products, including Ku-band and Swift64 systems that run on the Inmarsat network. But buying EMS instead of developing these products in-house accelerates Morristown, New Jersey-based Honeywell’s move further into the telecom sector.

z Eurocopter Tiger Extends Thales Training Thales announced last week that its contract to support training systems for the Eurocopter Tiger attack helicopter has been extended by another four years. The contract is undertaken by Thales (Hall Concorde) in partnership with Rheinmetall Defence Electronics, and was awarded by Europe’s defense procurement agency OCCAR. “Thales has been working alongside the French and German forces for a number of years in the Tiger training capacity,” said Pierre Segretain, the company’s v-p training and simulation. “The extension of this contract confirms the high standard of support services required by our customers.” The support contract for the Tiger aircrew training means (TATM) began in November 2006, and covers the support and integrated services for 26 Tiger simulators and associated Thales’ Tiger Trainer systems that are located at the Franco-German joint training facility at Le Luc in the south of France, and at national facilities at Fritzlar and Roth in Germany, and Pau, France. Support activities include the daily servicing and maintenance of the simulators and ensuring that they are in the appropriate training configuration. The support services are provided in such a way as to adapt the TATM assets to the live training program, which can vary according to weather and aircraft availability.

z IS&S Gets STC for Boeing 757 Cockpit Displays Innovative Solutions and Support (IS&S) has received European Aviation Safety Agency supplemental type certification for its cockpit flat-panel display system (FPDS) on Boeing B757-200 and B757-300 aircraft. The U.S. Federal Aviation Administration and Transport Canada have already certified the display. The IS&S FPDS retrofit offers an engine indication and crew alerting system, as well as Class 3 e-charts, providing real-time positioning. Exton, Pennsylvania-based IS&S (Hall 3 D94) is also providing the flight management system to Eclipse Aerospace for its Eclipse 500 very light jet. “Eclipse twin-engine jet operators are now able to upgrade their aircraft with an integrated flight management system through Eclipse Aerospace,” said IS&S president Roman Ptakowski. The FMS features include en route GPS navigation, missed approach and procedure turns, as well as holding patterns and automated airway entry.

8 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

The Hermes 900 is based on the systems of the highly successful Hermes 450 UAV, but offers greater payload, range and altitude capability.

Elbit shows prowess on Hermes, Skylark UAVs by David Donald Israel’s Elbit Systems has announced a number of important developments in recent weeks, covering a range of the company’s diverse capabilities. A selection of its services and products are showcased on the company’s booth in the Israeli Pavilion. UAVs are an area of considerable expertise for Elbit, and recently the company achieved its first sale for the Hermes 900 MALE air vehicle, to a Latin American customer. In another UAV development, the company has successfully completed a series of tests with its Skylark I LE man-pack UAV controlled by a new lightweight forward ground control station (FGCS)

using the Dominator hardware. All of the lightweight FGCS’s four-component units (FGCS computer, handheld display, operator stick and active Skylark Rambo transducer) are attached to or carried in a soldier’s combat vest. For covert and on-the-move operations, the handheld display can be replaced by an eyepiece. The new FGCS is 66 pounds lighter than the standard GCS, and is at the heart of a new operational concept in which dispatcher units launch and recover the UAV, but hand over control to dismounted soldiers in the operational area. Electro-optical systems are

an important business area for Elbit, and recently the company announced a large order from an Asian country for the Compass 15-inch multi-sensor turret to equip a fleet of maritime patrol aircraft. Here at the Paris Air Show Elbit is showing its C-Music system for the first time, a multi-spectral fiber laserbased directional infrared countermeasures system. It is being displayed in a pod that also includes the Paws passive IR approach warning system. To illustrate another capability, Elbit gained a contract last month from the Romanian Ministry of Defense to upgrade the air force’s C-130 Hercules aircraft with various advanced electronic systems from Elisra, an Elbit subsidiary. The work is being performed over the next four years, and is being undertaken in conjunction with local industry.` o

Smart bomb heads IAI line-up Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) is showing off its latest precision-guided munition here at Le Bourget. Known as MLGB (medium-weight, laser-guided bomb), the weapon has dualmode guidance and is intended for use by light attack aircraft, as well as by multi-role fighters. Weighing 253 pounds, MLGB has a number of advanced features corresponding to key requirements in the modern battlefield. It is five feet six inches long and is carried on standard

14-inch lugs. Fixed cruciform wings of 17-feet-four-inches span give a good standoff glide capability when released from altitude, and the relatively light warhead provides low collateral damage effects. MLGB employs a combination of GPS and semi-active laser guidance, the latter providing better than one-meter CEP accuracy and a capability against moving targets. If laser guidance is not available, then the system guides the weapon to GPS coordinates with slightly reduced accuracy. Fuzing options allow the choice of air-burst, impact or delayed (penetration) detonation. Some of IAI’s other capabilities are also on show here in Paris, including sensor turrets from the Tamam division. The latest products are the MOSP3000 14/15-inch and MiniPOP eight-inch stabilized turrets, both of which MLGB’s wide-span wings bestow a healthy standoff capability on this dual-mode precision weapon. can accommodate up to

five sensors and are integrated with INS/GPS systems to enable geo-referencing and geo-pointing capabilities. Additional IAI capabilities in the spotlight are the company’s work on nano-satellites, which are typically less than 22 pounds in weight, and the ELM-2288 AD Star mobile air defense and threat alert radar. AD Star is a product of IAI’s Elta subsidiary, which among its wide electronics portfolio produces ISR (intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance) systems. Elta’s ELI-3120 manned compact ISR system has recently been installed in a King Air 350 aircraft and delivered to a Latin American customer for missions targeting drug traffickers, illegal logging and mining, deforestation, border crossing and pollution. –D.D.

Your mission: smart business

You didn’t get to where you are by compromising. Neither did Bell Helicopter, which is why there are no compromises in a 429. With impressive range and speed, plus an astonishingly smooth and quiet ride, the 429 gets you where you need to go in comfort and style. Spacious and adaptable, it was designed precisely for your fast-paced, high-stakes world.

Call 1-800-FLY-BELL or visit www.bellhelicopter.com to find the solution that’s best for your mission-specific needs.

www.newairplane.com/style

Spacious style and comfort Unrivaled economics Perfect fit for the 400-500 passenger market See the new 747-8 airplanes on static display 747-8 Intercontinental Mon.-Tues. â&#x20AC;&#x201D; 747-8 Freighter Tues.-Wed.

Rolls-Royce on target to deliver ‘mature’ Trent XWB in 2014 by Ian Goold With positive early test results and an accelerating work schedule, Rolls-Royce is confident it can deliver the Trent XWB as a mature engine, ready for full production before the end of 2014. Related technology programs are said to be on track in terms of high temperature and thrust. The new engine is to power the Airbus A350XWB, for which orders from nearly 40 customers number more than 570, having risen by over 60 in the past 12 months. Later this year, the manufacturer expects to have optimized its final Trent XWB manufacturing methods, drawing on lessons learned from construction of eight development engines (see box). Rolls-Royce claims that its preparation for manufacturing is the “fastest ever” large-fan production ramp-up. “Proper production” will start toward the end of next year, with a maximum rate of almost one engine a day (315 a year) being achieved by late 2017 or early 2018. The 118-inch-diameter fan is Rolls-Royce’s largest and provides a lower hub-to-tip ratio, enhanced by use of a narrower hub than that on the Trent 900, which powers the larger A380.

The fan blades have an increased surface area–“as much as 50 percent” more–providing higher air flow and reduced drag-toweight ratio, explained Trent XWB chief engineer Chris Young in a briefing ahead of the Paris Air Show. The large fan is combined with a smaller core to produce a higher load differential between the various bearings in the three-shaft powerplant. The “optimized bearing-load management system” sees greater loads carried further forward, where larger bearing balls provide better mechanical loading, which in turn is better for fuel burn, said Young, who acknowledged that this “more capable” solution is also heavier. The Trent XWB’s “rising line” compressor sees considerable innovation, with blades rotating at higher speed toward the rear of the intermediatepressure stage. The long-term fuel burn will benefit from increased overall pressure ratios in the two-stage intermediatepressure turbine (IPT). The short low-pressure turbine (LPT) has been scaled from that in the Trent 900 and is nine inches shorter. The lighter

LPT offsets the higher weight of the IPT. The rear fan case, made of composites material and supplied by new Trent partner ATK, has gone well, said Young. To ease portability of completed engines, Rolls-Royce has developed a transportation stand that enables a simpler separation of the fan case from the core before being are airfreighted to Airbus. A major focus for Rolls-Royce has been its plan to deliver engine maturity during–or even before– production ramp-up. Trent XWB program director Chris Cholerton said the manufacturer has matured its design processes, looking at all disruptive events occurring throughout the Trent fleet and applying the knowledge of previous failure modes to establish reliability. It has used failure-mode effects and critical analysis (FMECA) and the Pareto principle–the idea that, say, 20 percent of causal events generate perhaps 80 percent of consequent effects– on some 400 parts and has 1,200 mitigation plans in progress. Huge investments have been made in computing capacity to support component and systems Continued on page 16 u

The Rolls-Royce Trent 1000 engine, developed to power the much-delayed Boeing 787, above, will also be a mature product when it enters service with Japan’s All Nippon Airways later this year. The manufacturer has almost 50 engines completed or in production. For its Trent XWB Rolls-Royce established a goal of delivering a mature engine even before prodution ramp up, and looks on target to meet that goal. The company is seeing positive early test results for its Trent XWB (right) and, with an accelerated work schedule, is confident it can deliver the Trent XWB as a mature engine, ready for full production before the end of 2014.

12 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Trent XWB Turbofan Put To the Test Eight Trent XWB engines–serial numbers 20990 and 20001 through 20007–are being used in Rolls-Royce’s test program. Following are descriptions of the status or goals for each of the eight: By the end of this month, the manufacturer hopes to complete pass-off tests of Trent XWB 20990, its most highly instrumented flight-test engine ever, ahead of trials aboard the Airbus A380 flying test bed. Bird-ingestion trials are to be conducted with Trent XWB 20001, on which the fan blades have been fitted with strain gauges for initial tests with a “medium” bird that will continue in July with a “large” specimen. This engine was previously used for performance-envelope expansion, compressor functional operations, and operability testing. Serial number 20002 is being used on Rolls-Royce’s Test Bed 58 at Derby for integration of aircraft interface systems. After low-pressure turbine testing in May, the unit was to be used for thermal and emissions tests, integration of buyer-furnished equipment and water ingestion trials with all work scheduled for completion before this week’ show. Next month will see engine cyclic tests performed with Trent XWB 20003. This month, 20004 is to begin endurance testing–involving “lots of hours” at high speed and high thrust, according to Trent XWB chief engineer Chris Young as the manufacturer confirms the powerplant’s maturity. Trent XWB 20005 is being used for tests in the UK and the U.S. and in late May was scheduled to undergo flutter and crosswind tests. The unit also has been involved in thermal survey work at Derby, while the U.S. program also involves fan strain-gauging, noise and thrust-reverser tests. The thermal survey has yielded positive results with Rolls-Royce saying, for example, that cooler-than-predicted disc-cavity temperatures have been demonstrated. Engine 20006 is being reconfigured ahead of altitude testing that is scheduled to begin in the U.S. in August. The powerplant has been used to validate sea-level performance, low-, intermediate- and high-pressure bearing loads, variable-frequency generators and oil-system optimization. Next month, thermal and strain-gauge testing of the intermediate pressure turbine will be performed on Trent XWB 20007. –I.G.

Towards a safer world

SEE FURTHER, GO ANYWHERE The top-of-the-range light twin helicopter with advanced avionics Low noise, low vibration and spacious cabin for the highest level of comfort High safety standards and low operating costs

agustawestland.com

CFM. always exCeeding our proMises.

CFM* customers are used to pleasant surprises. Our history proves we not only keep our word, we deliver way beyond it. Building our customers’ trust. Building our customers’ profits. With better than expected technology upgrades, engine reliability, maintenance cost reduction, time on wing performance and strong asset values. The list is nearly as long as the life of one of our engines. Visit www.cfm56.com and see why, when we make promises, they don’t melt away. CFM, LEAP and the CFM logo are all trademarks of CFM International, a 50/50 joint company of Snecma and General Electric Co.

R-R Trent XWB nears maturity

The Trent XWB’s 118-inch-diameter fan is Rolls-Royce’s largest. The blades have an increased surface area providing higher air flow and reduced drag-toweight ratio than those on the Trent 900.

uContinued from page 12 testing aimed at reproducing inservice operating conditions. Key technology contributions to the Trent XWB program have come from Rolls-Royce’s environment-friendly high-temperature and E3E two-shaft demonstrator engines. There are four Trent XWBs undergoing tests, with a further four being built for completion by July. Testing momentum is increasing in anticipation of the Airbus A380 flying-testbed (FTB) first flight with a Trent XWB later this year. Cholerton claimed that initial testing has gone “very, very well.” The engine, which initially will provide 84,000 pounds thrust, has been operated at thrust levels of more than 100,000 pounds, said Young, with the first unit exceeding expectations. Rolls-Royce invested increased resources into the early stages of the program, including proof-ofconcept work. The highly instrumented engines, from which more than 1,500 parameters– including overall gas flow–are measured, are validating all the design modules. Young said the XWB has yielded the “best-ever Trent performance” results. Cholerton added that specific fuel consumption has been “excellent; better than expected.” By late May, Rolls-Royce had

completed 63 rig-test programs as it sought to ensure engine reliability, having begun investigation of mechanical behavior at an early stage and increased its diagnostic capability. Many elements of such testing have been pushed to “extreme limits,” according to Cholerton. The company has completed a large proportion of emissions-control reliability testing. Inspections and product assessment tests covering humidity, thermal and vibration (such as that following blade loss) performance have been completed

ahead of final humidity inspection and checks. Functional operation is described as “excellent,” with “very good” surge margin demonstrated in the intermediatepressure compressor on which one of the four rows of guide vanes are fixed. Young said final nozzle optimization, balancing specific fuel consumption with operability, is a key milestone in progress toward first flight of the Trent XWB. Rolls-Royce claims that “real-time” digital X-ray equipment introduced for the Trent

XWB program is the most powerful in western Europe, showing how all the engine parts are working compared with their intended operation. The system saves weeks of time compared with earlier film technology, according to the company. Young said the digital X-ray results obtained so far will contribute to engine optimization and further improvements in performance. For example, in the first and second stages of the low-pressure turbine, the manufacturer has been able to observe movement of the blade tips relative to the blade

Next Up: Power for Boeing’s 787-10X Rolls-Royce is working “very closely” on the engine requirements for a 78710X development being considered by Boeing, according to Trent 1000 program director Simon Carlisle. “The goal is to be ready with an engine for the whole [787] family,” so if Boeing looks at payload/range or economics “so will Rolls-Royce.” The UK engine manufacturer is confident that the Trent 1000 engine, developed to power the much-delayed Boeing 787, will be a mature product when it enters service with Japan’s All Nippon Airways (ANA) later this year. Carlisle said the Trent 1000 is “the only engine certified to 74,000 pounds thrust, [approved for] 330 minutes extended-range twin-engine operations, [to have performed] over 1,000 flights [and flown] over 2,800 hours.” The 787 flight-test program has “gone very well for us,” according to R-R, which has almost 50 engines completed or in manufacture. In May, two significant Trent 1000 flight test activities remained to be conducted: extended-range twin-engine operations clearance and function and reliability trials. But the engine development had been held back by that of the airframe, which has been delayed by more than three years. “The program has been much slower than we would have liked,” said Carlisle. “I guess we’ll never know what 2007 entry-into-service would have been like, but the engine is now much more reliable.” Next month, Boeing will conduct 787 operational validation flights with ANA. Rolls-Royce said a high level of support–both people and parts–is being established ahead of service entry–initially in Japan, then in Europe and on the U.S. West Coast. The engine manufacturer, which is “seeing more [sales] campaign activity”

16 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

as airlines are “beginning to wind up acquisitions in anticipation of the end of the recession,” expects to see order decisions coming at the end of the year. It claims a 50-percent customer share, saying that one of its 21 Trent 1000 customers remains “unannounced,” while another is a private customer. At ranges below 3,000 nm, a new Trent 1000 delivers up to a 1.5 percent advantage over its competitor, according to program chief engineer Andrew Green. “The [engine’s] superior performance retention is worth an additional one percent through [more efficient] fuel burn, saving over $1 million per aircraft over 15 years,” he explained. Rolls-Royce has already developed A and B variants, and Carlisle said a planned Trent 1000C, and the 787-10X, will be “all about economy.” The manufacturer is evaluating all phases of economic fuel burn as it seeks to understand Boeing requirements so it can provide all necessary thrust. Claiming that the Trent 1000 delivers the best lifetime fuel-burn for the 787, Rolls-Royce said the engine offers very significant margins over likely future emissions standards on noise, smoke, carbon dioxide, nitrous oxide and ultrahydrocarbons. Green said the 787-8’s claimed QC0.25 noise quotient is “pretty unprecedented.” Green also said the Trent family, which has logged some 65 million flying hours, has enjoyed a 15-percent efficiency improvement since the advent of the Trent 700. The smaller engine benefits from both the Trent 800 and Trent 1000. The latter is contributing technology to the Trent 900 product-improvement program now under way and, in turn, the Trent 800. The company is considering how best to deliver new Trent 1000s from its Asian factory in Singapore to Boeing’s final assembly line in the U.S. –I.G.

seal; if tighter tip clearances can be obtained, then initial performance can be maintained further into the engine’s life. The manufacturer said much has been learned during early maintainability validation tasks. All on-wing tooling has been validated ahead of the Trent XWB installation on the FTB, which must be approved by the European Aviation Safety Agency. FTB operations mark a fourth “parallel stream” of testing, which began last year with rig work, followed by initial expansion of the performance envelope and the start of maturity testing. Function and performance testing now under way will be followed by certificationrelated activity. The FTB will sport a brandnew pylon, which introduces a new mounting that hangs the powerplant from the fan and rear engine cases, rather than– as previously–“Airbus-style” from the core, which now carries no load. “We have felt for some time that this was the preferable mounting and have worked with Airbus from very early on” to develop it, said Young. o

Helicopter Shuttle to Paris Air Show If you want to beat the crush on the roads out to Le Bourget, IXAir Helifrance offers a daily 15-minute helicopter shuttle from Paris/ Issy-les-Moulineaux heliport direct to the Paris Air Show heliport. The price is €190 ($270) per seat one way and €350 ($495) for a round trip, same-day return. The service runs from Monday, June 20, to Sunday, June 26. Exclusive VIP service carrying up to five passengers is available; contact IXAir for rates. The company is an official sponsor of the 49th International Paris Air Show. Paris/Issy-les-Moulineaux heliport is located in the southwest corner of Paris near the Balard Metro station and Porte de Sevres, and just south of the Périphérique. (Tel. +33 1 30 08 80 82; contact@ixair.com, o www.ixair.com).

Check Out the FlightSafety

Quality

•

Value

•

Service

•

Technology

Aviation Professionals From

154 Countries

Train With FlightSafety

World-Class Training. Worldwide Reach. Worldwide, FlightSafety stands for the highest

We’re the authorized trainer for the majority

quality and the best value in safety-enhancing

of aircraft manufacturers. Our training meets

aviation training. Just ask any of the thousands

or exceeds regulatory requirements – online,

of aviation professionals from around the globe

on location and at convenient Learning Centers

who rely on us to deliver training that goes well

near your aircraft manufacturer or a major

beyond basic instruction.

service center. We provide online training management through myFlightSafety.

Pilots, maintenance technicians, flight attendants and dispatchers from 154 countries train with

We tailor instruction to meet your specific

us, leveraging the unmatched resources of the

needs with professional training for business,

world’s leading aviation training company.

commercial and military aviation. And we

They know – and they let us know with every

design, engineer and support the world’s most

return visit – that our training is an investment

sophisticated simulators, training devices,

that pays dividends in safety and aircraft

displays and visual systems, with the most

dispatch reliability. We deliver exceptional

advanced features.

customer service, with more courses, more instructors, more top-level fully qualified

The world comes to FlightSafety to take

simulators and more training locations than

advantage of our unmatched training.

any other training provider.

Shouldn’t you?

For information, contact Scott Fera, Vice President Marketing

•

718.565.4774

flightsafety.com

•

sales@flightsafety.com

A Berkshire Hathaway company

Europe makes plans to expand its ballistic missile defense

An EADS schematic shows the various stages of a ballistic missile intercept system.

by Chris Pocock Are the nations of Europe serious about comprehensive ballistic missile defense (BMD)? Or are they happy to let America provide the only effective shield over their cities and populations? Despite a ringing declaration of intent at the NATO summit meeting in Lisbon last November, these questions remain unanswered. Until Lisbon, NATO’s policy was to develop only a Theatre BMD–that is, the means to protect limited areas against short- and medium-range ballistic missiles when, for instance, troops are deployed on operations. A Theatre BMD could be done by networking existing air defense systems that have a potential low-altitude (for example, terminal) BMD capability.

LOCKHEED MARTIN

Lockheed Martin’s THAAD interceptor follows a corkscrew pattern to intercept short- and mediumrange ballistic missiles.

Eight European NATO members have acquired such systems–Germany, Greece, the Netherlands, Spain and Turkey operate Patriot batteries, while France, Italy and the UK are introducing ship- and land-based systems that fire the co-developed MBDA Aster missile. NATO is paying for the software to network these national systems at a cost of €800 million ($1.1 billion). The program is called active layered theatre ballistic missile defense (ALTBMD), and the eight nations listed above are the key participants, plus the U.S. According to NATO, the ALTBMD system “will be the most sophisticated of its type in the world.” After five years of development by a transatlantic consortium led by ThalesRaytheonSystems, an “interim capability” was declared last January. Housed in transportable trailers, it is a communications, command and control battle management system that is capable of protecting a brigadesize deployment. Initially, the sensors and shooters of only five NATO members– France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and the U.S.–are being linked. At Lisbon, NATO leaders resolved to expand the ALTBMD program to protect European populations and territory against the full range of ballistic missile attacks. This effectively requires the addition of an “upper” layer of defense so that incoming missiles are intercepted in midcourse–also known as exo-atmospheric interception. But the NATO council has not yet authorized the development of

a specification for upper layer defense. However, further work to “industrialize” and fully integrate the lower layer networking capability of the ALTBMD system has been scheduled. In the meantime, only the U.S. (and Russia) has developed a mid-course interception capability against ballistic missiles. Moreover, the U.S. has just begun to deploy such a defense in Europe. The capability resides in the U.S. Navy’s Aegis-equipped cruisers and destroyers, with their SPY-1B radars and their Standard SM-3 Block 1A missiles. The promise to deploy was made by President Barack Obama in September 2009, when he scrapped the Bush Administration’s previous plan for a ground-based BMD shield in Europe. The Bush plan was to site 10 groundbased missiles capable of mid-course interception in Poland, plus a large guidance radar in the Czech Republic. The scheme would have been similar to the

The Patriot Did BMD First The Patriot air defense missile system was designed by Raytheon and first fielded in 1984. Four years later, a missile defense capability was added, mainly through changes to the guidance software. In the 1991 Gulf War, the system had mixed success against Iraqi short-range Scud missiles, and it became clear that its blast-fragmentation warhead was inadequate to the task. Lockheed Martin then leveraged its previous work on hit-to-kill technology to develop the PAC-3 missile for Patriot batteries. The combination of an agile airframe with a millimeter-wave seeker and very fast computing of the hit-to-kill algorithms, together with an upgraded acquisition radar on the ground, proved successful. Four years after it first flew, the PAC-3 missile scored operational success by destroying two Iraqi ballistic missiles during the second Gulf War in 2003. In addition to the U.S., 12 nations have bought the Patriot system. In Europe, Germany and the Netherlands have PAC-3s, while Greece and Spain operate the less capable PAC-2. –C.P.

LOCKHEED MARTIN

U.S. Navy Aegis warships have been deployed to European waters to provide ballistic missile interception capability. However, it is not clear how many ships will be sent to European waters, as the 21-ship Aegis fleet is stretched thin, meeting demand in other parts of the world.

LOCKHEED MARTIN

The Patriot PAC-3 launch was the first theater ballistic missile defense weapon. Germany, the Netherlands and the U.S. are the only NATO nations that have bought it.

20 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Block IIB version of the SM-3 that can defend against longer-range ballistic missiles. The EPAA will also be enhanced by adding ground-based versions of the Aegis system in Romania (2015) and Poland (2018). Development of this version has not yet begun, however. The terminal high-altitude air defense (THAAD) system (see below) may also be incorporated into the EPAA. Future Uncertain

At the time of writing, however, many questions remain. The U.S. has not announced which southern European country will house a powerful but transportable X-band radar–the Raytheon AN/TPY-2. This radar is deemed essential to augment the SPY-1B radars aboard the Aegis ships. (In BMD, the more radars that can detect and track the approaching missiles, the better. They have a complicated task of distinguishing between the separating missile boosters and the continuing re-entry vehicles, and must also discriminate between actual warheads and decoys. That’s why the U.S. has also upgraded its ballistic missile early warning radars, including one in the UK, so they can contribute to the BMD network). Although the U.S. Navy has begun deploying single Aegis ships to the Mediterranean, it’s not clear how many will deploy to Europe to provide a territorial missile shield. Three may be the minimum for proper coverage, but they are in demand elsewhere–in the Gulf and the northern Pacific. There are 21 Aegis

ships in the fleet today, with another 17 due by 2015. Also to be decided: whether they will be stationed in northern European waters as well as the Mediterranean; whether they will home-port in Europe and, indeed, whether they will maintain continuous coverage, or be deployed only on occasions of heightened tension. Nor is it clear when or to what extent the U.S. will allow command and control of the Aegis system to be incorporated into NATO’s ALTBMD system. NATO says the latter is already designed to communicate with AN/TPY-2 radars and Aegis ships, although “full interlinking” is not scheduled until 2017. THAAD was the first intercept system designed specifically for BMD. Conceived in 1992, it has been under development by Lockheed Martin for the past decade, with at least $16 billion spent to date (in 2011 dollars). It is a deployable system that can defend against short- and medium-range ballistic missiles during their late midcourse and terminal phases. According to Lockheed Martin, THAAD “fills the gap between lowexo and high-endo with a high, single-shot probability.” So, THAAD is a supplement to the Patriot PAC-3 and SM-3 Block 1A, and is interoperable with those systems. The THAAD radar sensor is the same Raytheon AN/TPY-2 that supplements the Aegis shipboard coverage from land. There are eight THAAD interceptors per launcher, with rapid reload capability,

NATO

ground-based midcourse (GMD) defense system that the U.S. Missile Defense Agency (MDA) has already deployed in Alaska and California as a defense against ICBMs fired from North Korea. GMD was America’s first BMD system and has been very expensive. Boeing is the prime contractor. It fires three-stage exoatmospheric kill vehicles (EKVs) after tracking of the threat by large landand sea-based X-band radars. Two-stage EKVs would have been used for the European deployment. According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, the GMD system has cost $38 billion to date (in 2011 dollars). Development continues; Boeing made the first flight of a two-stage GMD booster last June, but an enhanced version of the EKV failed two intercept tests last year. The new plan was termed the European phased adaptive approach (EPAA) and was partly driven by a reassessment of Iran’s ICBM program, which is less advanced than previously thought. However, it allows the U.S. to deploy a limited BMD shield in Europe much earlier than a GMD system, and with the added flexibility that a ship-based system brings. Moreover, the Aegis/SM-3 capability is proven after 10 years of development and eight successful intercept tests. Lockheed Martin is the prime contractor and Raytheon builds the missiles, which each cost $15 million. The MDA is planning upgrades to the SM-3 interceptor and has recently awarded contracts to define and plan a

The Arrow BMD (ballistic missile defense) system that now protects Israel was co-developed and produced by Boeing and Israeli Aircraft Industries (IAI), but funded mostly by the U.S. MDA. Designed to o ffer better protection than the Patriot PAC-3, development began in the late 1980s with Israeli industry providing the L-band radar and the command and control system. The vertically launched Arrow 2 two-stage missile provides terminal phase interception with an electro-optical sensor and a blastfragmentation warhead. There have been three successful flight tests. The system was declared operational in 2000. IAI is leading the development (with Boeing) of the Arrow 3 interceptor, an exoatmospheric missile with a high-resolution infrared sensor on a gimballed seeker. The fire-control system would not change from the Arrow 2 system. –C.P.

and up to nine launchers per battery. The hit-to-kill vehicle separates from the single-stage booster after launch. Terminal guidance is by infrared seeker. After a successful series of flight tests, some design and production issues have delayed acceptance of the first two THAAD batteries, but the MDA plans to buy another five to seven batteries for the U.S. Army. THAAD is available for export, with the UAE a likely first customer. Since its creation in 2002, the MDA has spent $7 billion to $10 billion on BMD each year. In addition to Aegis, GMD and THAAD, the MDA is responsible for developing the airborne laser test bed (see box on page 24) and satellites with infrared sensors that can provide an early cue to the radars by detecting ballistic missile launches. MDA has also put BMD sensors on airships and aerostats. Europe cannot possibly compete with this level of activity. However, two major air defense programs with BMD capability are being funded in Europe at the moment, although one of them–the NATO medium extended air defense system (MEADS)–is under threat. The MEADS is a tri-national development involving Germany (a 25-percent share; main contractor LFK), Italy (16.7 percent; MBDA Italia) and the U.S. (58.3 percent; Lockheed Martin). MEADS was conceived in the mid1990s and a development contract worth $3.4 billion was signed in 2005. The plan was to improve the Patriot PAC-3 missile and add new surveillance and fire control radars, plus a new launcher and command-and-control system. Key selling points for MEADS included 360-degree coverage, air transportability by C-130J or A400M aircraft, a netted distributed

Continued on page 24 u

MBDA

The new MEADS surveillance radar, above, includes 10,000 transmit/ receive modules made in Europe. The Mode 5 IFF system being designed by MBDA Italia is the first to be certified outside the U.S. The MBDA Aster 30 missile, right, forms part of the all-European BMD system. It successfully intercepted a ballistic missile for the first time last year. The UK adopted the Aster 30 as the Sea Viper on six new warships.

Israel’s Arrow

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 21

One heart

NAVITIMER

CHRONOMAT

Three legends With its Manufacture Caliber 01, Breitling has created the most reliable, accurate and top-performance of all selfwinding chronograph movements â&#x20AC;&#x201C; entirely produced in its own workshops and chronometer-certified by the COSC. A perfectly logical accomplishment for a brand that has established itself as the absolute benchmark in the field of mechanical chronographs.

WWW.BREITLING.COM TRANSOCEAN

Make it fly with the National Research Council Canada NRC offers a clear advantage in aircraft development: Comprehensive R&D facilities Dedicated technical specialists Expertise across the spectrum of aerospace concerns—safety, weight, cost and environment Your vision. Our solution.

Contact our team: 1-877-NRC-CNRC | nrc.gc.ca/business

Boost Phase Interception May Be Impractical, but Tracking Is Essential It was always an ambitious plan: Develop the world’s most powerful airborne laser, integrate it on a large airliner and use it to shoot down ballistic missiles at the most opportune time–during the boost phase. Go operational in 2007. But after spending almost $5 billion on the airborne laser (ABL) in 15 years, the MDA redesignated it as the airborne laser test bed (ALTB). H owever, in February last year the ALTB finally succeeded in destroying two test missiles. The p rogram continues, researching such challenges as jitter from the airborne platform and atmospheric compensation for the laser. The ALTB fires a megawatt-class chemical oxygen-iodine laser (COIL) from inside a Boeing 747-400F. Two kilowatt-class eliminator lasers are also carried in huge nose turret, to track the ascending target prior to attacking it. The airliner first flew in 2002 and the COIL was first ground-tested in 2004. Boeing is responsible for overall system integration, Northrop Grumman provides the COIL and Lockheed Martin is responsible for the tracking and fire control system. Boeing’s airborne laser test bed (ALTB) intercepts a But even if attacking ballistic missiles as ballistic missile during the boost phase last year. they ascend has proved impractical for now, there is plenty of interest in acquiring the earliest possible tracks of them from an airborne platform. In addition to developing new satellites for tracking, the U.S. Missile Defense Agency has a program called AirBorne InfraRed (ABIR), which uses a Reaper UAV equipped with a standard Raytheon multispectral targeting system turret. In Europe, Diehl has developed a combined MWIR and LWIR airborne sensor that also detects missiles plumes in the boost phase. –C.P.

BOEING

YOUR AEROSPACE INNOVATION COULD CHANGE THE WORLD

Europe to expand missile defense system uContinued from page 21

v2e_IAR-Paris_ad_BW-12024-E.indd 1

11-06-01 11:22 AM

architecture that uses open standards and capability against next-generation air and missile threats. Other types of intercept weapons, such as the surface-launched version of Germany’s IRIS-T air-to-air missile, can also be added. Flight tests of MEADS are scheduled for next year. But the U.S. Army has now recommended against production, claiming that it is too expensive and does not meet U.S. requirements. The Pentagon has not yet endorsed the Army’s decision, which has surprised the European partners. MBDA chief executive officer Antoine Bouvier recently described MEADS as an “emblematic transatlantic cooperation. We have a contract, and the German and Italian governments strongly support us,” he continued. Lockheed Martin described MEADS as “the first all-new air and missile defense system of its kind in decades.” Homegrown Defense

Last October, the MBDA Aster 30 Block 1 missile became the first European weapon to successfully carry out a ballistic intercept. The target represented a medium-range ballistic missile and was intercepted at 300-km (186 miles) range by a missile launched from a French Army Mamba battery. Mamba was previously known as the SAMP/T (Sol-Air Moyen Portee Terrestre) system, which comprises a Thales Arabel radar, a command-and-control system and up to eight vertical launch units. The Aster is a very agile hit-to-kill missile that employs an active radar seeker for terminal guidance. France and Italy combined to develop the SAMP/T and final_bmt_1-4Vad_0611outl.indd 1

24 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

6/7/11 2:26:41 PM

its ship-based counterpart, the SAAM (surface-to-air anti-missile), which also uses Aster 15 missiles. The UK subsequently adopted the Aster 30 as the Sea Viper for six new warships, with guidance from a BAE Systems radar called Sampson. Italy has also employed an indigenous radar–the Selex Empar. In test-firings, Aster missiles have also successfully intercepted various other missile and air-breathing threats, but its potential for BMD is what most excited Bouvier. “This is Europe’s own missile defense program; it’s so important,” he said. MBDA is proposing a Block 2 development of the Aster with two missile stages that could intercept at much higher altitude using an infrared seeker. It could therefore defend larger areas, perhaps approaching the coverage offered by THAAD. It’s worth noting that six THAAD batteries can defend the same area as 100 batteries of a terminal intercept system, such as the PAC-3 or Aster Block 1. Bouvier suggested that Europe should resolve to develop the Block 2 Aster, partly out of obligation to contribute more to its own defense after the Lisbon decision, but also as a hedge against the U.S. cooling on the whole EPAA plan. Given the current defense spending environment, though, he is also realistic. “We are proposing to work with a minimum budget until 2015, and then proceed,” he said. One final piece of the puzzle is beyond the scope of this article: that is Russia’s anti-missile capability and whether it could be deployed to protect part of Europe. Talks about that possibility have been going on within the NATO-Russia Council, most recently in April. o

Pilot Training Solutions

Complete

Keep one step ahead with CAE’s complete cadet-tocaptain pilot training solutions. CAE provides flexible and customized solutions designed to enhance the safety, efficiency and effectiveness of your airline: • Candidate identification, selection, training and placement with your airline • Ab initio training through the world’s largest network of CPL/ATPL/MPL flight schools • Type-rating training through the world’s largest network of commercial aircraft training centres • Innovative training science, regulatory support and aviation’s leading suite of integrated training tools, from e-Learning to full-flight simulators For over 60 years, CAE has been a trusted partner to aircraft manufacturers, airlines, business aircraft and civil helicopter operators around the globe.

Have a conversation with CAE about your pilot needs.

cae.com

conversation@cae.com

Pax power pushes demand for in-flight connectivity by Charles Alcock The market for in-flight connectivity is about to step up a gear as passenger power pushes demand to be able to use personal smart phones, laptops and tablet devices, according

to provider OnAir. The Airbus/ SITA joint venture’s CEO Ian Dawkins told AIN that experience from the just-completed first full year of availability for its GSM-service (voice, SMS

and mobile data) and in-flight Internet access has established that when this level of connectivity is assured, passengers will quickly embrace it and regard as a necessity.

OnAir, established in 2005, has some 36 operators either using its service or waiting to have the systems installed in their fleets. Most of these are airlines, with about half a

AT O W 2 US S H 24 T T SI A I R LE VI HA IS R A, C PA W RO

M O B I L I T FYO:U N D Your search for the ultimate aircraft will take you many places. But the true visionary is always led back to the PILATUS PC-12 NG. BE-THERE-IN-A-FLASH FREEDOM + SPACIOUS, SO-SEDUCTIVE CABIN TURBINE POWER, HALF-A-JET PRICE + AIRPORT DELAY GONE AWAY EXTENDED-RANGE FUEL SIPPER + SHORT RUNWAYS, LAND CLOSER + UNCOMPROMISED

SWISS CRAFTSMANSHIP

dozen being operators of executive or VIP aircraft. The Switzerland-based company said it expects to see a steep increase in new orders, even from an airline sector that is still struggling with relatively soft demand and increased operating expenses. Dawkins argued that easyaccess connectivity, for which voice calls are priced at no more than standard international roaming rates with billing directly through the customer’s own cellphone provider, is becoming a key service differentiator for carriers looking for new ways to attract and retain high-yield passengers. “We do expect to receive new orders this year,” he predicted. “The market is more buoyant and there is a real hunger for connectivity.” Phone and Internet Service

This year, OnAir expects to complete at least fleet-wide installations for four more airlines. Installations are generally done during C- or D-check overhauls, with work being performed by approved STC holders selected by OnAir. Among the launch operators are Oman Air, Saudi Arabian Airlines and Egyptair. With greater urgency to provide connectivity, supplier readiness is becoming a more significant issue in the market, according to OnAir chief commercial officer Stephan Egli. “The timing of when a supplier can deliver has become a

Bizjet Crowd Craves In-flight Comms More Than Most

PILATUS. DESTINATION: FOUND WWW.PILATUS-AIRCRAFT.COM + 41.41.619.6296

26 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

There is one segment of aviation that has been largely impervious to the economic downturn–the highest of the high fliers; namely, owners and passengers in large-cabin business jets. They have proved to be early adopters of the most advanced inflight connectivity and so it is to this sector that OnAir has turned its attention more recently, with half a dozen of its three dozen clients in this market to date. More recent installations have included an Airbus ACJ319 operated by Comlux and a Dassault Falcon 7X in the fleet of Dasnair. Last month, OnAir signed a new partnership with TriaGnoSys to provide installation of the voice, text message, Internet and email services on business aircraft. Germany-based TriaGnoSys has extensive experience providing mobile communications for land, sea and air applications. –C.A.

has been very reliable in the first year. There have been a few teething problems involving interfaces with the satellite communication or in-flight entertainment systems, as has often been the case with new cabin systems. Ready for Ka-band Transition

Airline passengers will soon regard in-flight Internet as a necessity, says OnAir.

more competitive issue,” he said. “With the market moving more quickly now, the time to enter the market has been a big factor in recent [airline] bids and that’s good news for the industry.” OnAir claims to be the only provider offering both GSM mobile telephony and wireless Internet connectivity in one package. “We have real data on what passengers prefer to use and we’ve seen from the first year that 95 percent of passengers will want to use smart phones when they have the choice,” said Dawkins, referring to passengers who had used the service. OnAir’s market research from a first full year of operations, which ended in April, has also

shown that consumer use of the connectivity available mirrors that of smart phone roaming use on the ground, in that they are generally not downloading large amounts of data to access, for example, video streaming. “And airlines are finding that it is a way to connect with their passengers by offering additional services directly to their phones and other devices, such as letting them know where their luggage will be at the airport for their next flight departure if they are connecting,” said Dawkins. The system can also be used to pre- arrange rental cars or order limousine service. According to OnAir, the performance of the service generally

So what about the sustainability of the technology underwriting OnAir’s connectivity– a combination of Pico cells to allow GSM phones to be used in flight safely and the ubiquitous SwiftBroadband satcom service? Is this a system architecture that’s in it for the long haul, or will operators find themselves depending on technology that has been superseded by the next big idea in mobile communications? Given the global reach of Inmarsat’s SwiftBroadband, it is unsurprising that it remains the dominant satcom solution. The only anticipated change on the horizon is the availability of the Ka-band, from 2014, as a capacity-enhancing alternative to the existing L-band service. OnAir is essentially agnostic on this possible switch, which could be accommodated by the

relatively simple installation of a new Ka-band antenna. “The fact is that there is more than enough capacity for current levels of usage for four or five more years,” said Dawkins, claiming that OnAir is the service provider offering the most straightforward transition to Ka. “This is the right technology today and there is a simple upgrade path,” Dawkins maintained. “Other technologies are available but they are not

as easy to upgrade. There have been issues [for operators] with services that were stopped. But, SwiftBroadband also provides excellent clearance for roaming service around the world, and it isn’t easy to do this.” The hardware for OnAir’s service weighs little more than 75 kilograms. It can be installed in an overhead baggage bin in a typical airliner. o

Customers want phone and Internet service in one package, according to OnAir. The company provides that in a 75-kg system that can fit in an airliner’s overhead compartment.

Please visit us at the 49th INTERNATIONAL PARIS AIR SHOW — HALL 5, BOOTH B242

Innovative Cockpit and Avionics Solutions Cockpit Systems Integration and Upgrades TacView® — Portable Mission Displays PilotView® — Electronic Flight Bags IntegriFlight™ — Aviation GPS Receivers SureSight® — Enhanced Vision Systems Flight Management Systems Custom Electronic Components

MONTREAL • OTTAWA • CHICAGO • www.cmcelectronics.ca

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 27

Raytheon ups SeaVue capability by Bill Carey Raytheon’s Space and Airborne Systems division has upgraded its SeaVue maritime surveillance radar, incorporating a situational awareness package that has been fielded with the U.S. Navy and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agency and is now available for export. The SeaVue expanded mission capability (dubbed XMC) software upgrade enhances small-target detection and tracking in high sea states and significantly eases operator workload, according to Raytheon. SeaVue is a family of lightweight, modular, X-band surveillance radars. They provide inverse synthetic aperture, synthetic aperture radar and moving target indicator modes as well as a weather detection and avoidance

mode. The mechanically scanned system, consisting of a transmitter, processor and antenna, can be adapted to different fixed- or rotary-wing platforms, with nosemount or belly-mount antennas. “We try to maximize our system performance based on the constraints of the platform,” said Brad Hopper, Raytheon senior manager for business development in the intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance systems mission area. The means to detect small targets in high sea states is a Raytheon strength, he said. The capability was developed for the U.S. Navy to detect “short exposure” periscopes during high sea states, a requirement of the Cold War era. The same technology

proves useful today in detecting stealthy craft, known as self-propelled semi-submersibles, used to transport illicit drugs over thousands of miles, Hopper said. The SeaVue XMC incorporates ocean surveillance initiative technology, including streaming digital video, developed by Raytheon with the U.S. Naval Sea Systems Command, CBP and the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Lab. Attributes include automatic detection and tracking of thousands of maritime targets simultaneously, an order of magnitude improvement over standard radars tracking hundreds of targets, Hopper explained. The radar tracks are correlated with ship automatic identification system (AIS) data

The U.S. Customs and Border Protection Agency uses Raytheon’s SeaVue radar in its Guardian UAS.

EADS here at Le Bourget to recruit new talent European aerospace giant EADS and its four divisions– Airbus, Astrium, Cassidian and Eurocopter–will hold more than 20 workshops here at the Paris Air Show to help recruit more than 4,000 new-hire employees and 4,000 interns. Entitled “Work for EADS,” the workshops will take place every day this week, apart from Sunday. Participants will meet top EADS executives, engineers and human resources representatives. Highlights of the recruitment activities include Diversity Day on June 21, Intercultural Day on June 22 and Professional Day on June 25. EADS personnel will meet participants at the company’s HR lounge on the static display in front of Hall 2A. According to Jörg Kutzim, head of the EADS Recruitment Center, the workshops will give students, graduates and experienced professionals the

opportunity “to discover what it’s like to work for EADS and to meet experts and see what motivates them to continuously push boundaries.” Registration for the workshops closed in late May. EADS expects more than 1,000 participants and is providing all with entry tickets to the airshow on the day of their workshops and reimbursing part of their travel expenses. In a recent survey conducted by Sweden-based employerbranding consultancy Universum, EADS was ranked third among 100 top-preferred employers in Europe, just behind Google and Audi. The survey was conducted among 19,890 engineering students at 100 leading academic institutions across Europe. The consultancy reviewed more than 60,700 employers before choosing the top 100 for ranking. Participants in the pan-European survey represented 135 nationalities

28 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

among the continent’s top academic institutions. Last year, EADS was ranked seventh. “Our aim is to recruit over 4,000 new employees in 2011. In times of economic growth and increasing scarcity of qualified employees, it is extremely important to appeal to young people seeking a job. Our fascinating products such as the Airbus A380 or the Ariane launcher definitely support this goal,” said Jussi Itävuori, head of EADS human resources. “In order to retain talented young people… we are launching initiatives to improve professional development opportunities and career paths of our employees.” Earlier this year, EADS and its divisions were honored with the Randstad Award as most preferred employer in Germany, France and Spain. In France, personnel marketing institute trendence and Universum rated the group as most preferred company for engineers. EADS currently employs some 122,000 people and generated €45.8 billion ($65 billion) in revenue in 2010. –R.R.P.

The SeaVue radar system–consisting of an antenna, transmitter and processor–can be adapted to a number of different rotary- and fixed-wing platforms.

tracks, allowing the radar operator to quickly sort out noncooperative targets from those using AIS–the maritime equivalent of the identification friend or foe system–to identify themselves. The upgrade incorporates precision tracking algorithms designed to maintain tracks on small targets in congested littoral waters. “It’s critical in a very congested littoral environment, where there can be thousands of targets, to be able to track all of those quickly,” Hopper told AIN. “This is a significant issue for many of our customers.” According to Raytheon, the XMC upgrade significantly reduces operator workload from a standard radar system. “It allows the operator to intelligently sort through the target field with attributes such as location of the vessel, heading, speed and ship length, to name a few,” Hopper explained. “This allows the operator to quickly locate potential threats in a given area and be able to sort through those and single out the things he really needs to look at.” The CBP was the first to deploy the SeaVue XMC capability, completing flight trials in May 2010. The radar is operating on the agency’s Bombardier DHC-8 aircraft, P-3 Orion and marinized version of the General Atomics MQ-9 Predator B called the Guardian, which adds SeaVue radar and electro-optical/infrared sensor. The U.S. Navy has been using SeaVue on a classified platform. Counter-Narcotics Ops

The CBP’s office of air and marine branch operates 270 aircraft, including two Guardians and five Predator Bs. Following operational testing, the Guardian was to be deployed to “drug source and transit zones to support joint counter-narcotics operations.” The mission points to the versatility of the SeaVue radar, which can be applied for drug enforcement, border surveillance,

exclusive economic zone monitoring, oil-spill detection, antipiracy and other missions. “There is an increasing need for homeland security, not just the ability to protect your own borders, but also as part of an international coalition,” Hopper said. “It’s the small vessels that go out and highjack the large ships. The ability to monitor and detect those in a vast ocean under high sea state conditions, that’s exactly where our systems play very well.” The SeaVue XMC system used for the unmanned Guardian is divided into two parts, Hopper said. Some of the radar processing is done on the platform; the operator interface and some of the tracking algorithms are based at the ground station, controlled by the operator. The XMC situational awareness package has been upgraded incrementally to the final configuration now being offered to the U.S. domestic and international markets. “It’s had a lot of operator input into its development,” Hopper said. Late last year, the SeaVue XMC was approved for export to Morocco. Raytheon has delivered more than 1,900 maritime radars worldwide, fielded on a range of platforms including the U.S. Navy’s new P-8A Poseidon maritime patrol aircraft with upgraded Raytheon AN/APY10 radar, the P-3, Beechcraft King Air 350, De Havilland Canada DHC-8 and Predator Guardian. About 500 radars are still operating, including 150 SeaVue systems used by Japan, Mexico, Italy, Australia, the UK, Thailand, Norway, Pakistan and Taiwan. In Australia, SeaVue radar has logged 150,000 operational flight hours as part of that country’s Coastwatch program, operated by the Australian customs service. o

Total solutions. It’s in our DNA. Our world-leading solutions meet your most demanding requirements in space, in the air, on land and at sea. We aspire to redeﬁne adaptability, performance and reliability, for today and tomorrow, to fulﬁll our dream of a safer and secure world.

SEE US AT PARIS AIR SHOW 2011 Chalet A-206

Israel Aerospace Industries E-mail: corpmkg@iai.co.il

www.iai.co.il

L-3 turns its attention to high-tech export prizes

L-3 is converting 37 King Air 350s for intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance operations in Afghanistan as part of Project Liberty.

by Charles Alcock Prompted in part by the prospect of broader range of products.” Despite the inevitable pressure to consqueezed Pentagon budgets, U.S. defense groups have been consolidating operations tain costs, L-3’s strategy remains heavily in pursuit of higher value, higher technol- tipped toward strong research-and-develogy pursuits. At L-3 Communications, as opment spending. “We are investing in at both Lockheed Martin and Northrop areas where we will see further growth, Grumman previously, this means shifting such as ISR [intelligence, surveillance out of service activities where margins are and reconnaissance] for smaller aircraft, tighter and there is less scope for differen- night-vision systems and innovative ways tiation in a tight market, according to the to upgrade and maintain existing airNew York-based group’s chairman, presi- craft,” said Strianese. dent and CEO Michael Strianese. Value-Added Projects “The services segment can be a great Here at the Paris Air Show, L-3 is eager performer, but it may not make sense to make more investments here, and there to advance its ambitions to take the delivcould be others who can take this fur- ery of added value through technology to ther,” Strianese told AIN. Pricing pres- key emerging markets, such as those in Asia sure in defense services has come from and the Middle East. It has had success in the UK through programs such as the new smaller second- and third-tier providers. In Strianese’s view, it is no surprise in Integrated Broadcast Service and the RCthis respect that it has been private equity 135-based Rivet Joint program to replace companies that have been the main buy- the Nimrod signals intelligence platforms. But with the UK’s defense buders of service operations forget facing similar constraints to mally owned by defense prime those of its close ally the U.S., it contractors. Generally, these is new military requirements in deals have been heavily levermarkets further east where some aged, putting further pressure of L-3’s more exciting prospects on the companies concerned are now to be found. to achieve more fruitful profit The package it put together margins in order to clear the for the U.S. Project Liberty debt. Strianese indicated that requirement, converting Hawker L-3 could have more to say Beechcraft King Air 350s into about further consolidation of its own operations when it L-3 president and CEO MC-12 ISR platforms is a prime Michael Strianese example of the approach L-3 is gives its next earnings update looking to advance even further. in July. At L-3, the consolidation process has It has built more advanced King Air-based already seen the merging of its sensors and ISR platform that will be ready to display simulation divisions to form an Electronic at Britain’s RIAT show next month. The requirements of export clients Systems group. The same process has happened in what L-3 now calls Warrior Sys- are not always as well defined as those tems, combining products such as Insight of Project Liberty, which was conceived night-vision equipment for soldiers with by the Pentagon specifically with the other electro-optical and battlefield intelli- Afghanistan campaign in mind. But gence systems. “This consolidation reduces to L-3 this, in itself, presents an opporoverhead and concentrates research-and- tunity for early engagement with prodevelopment spending,” said Strianese. spective clients to help them define the “For the customer it does mean that we system requirements. “We can offer ISR systems for smaller present one face to them with a much aircraft at a very attractive price point compared to other systems they have seen so far,” said Strianese. “And we’re platform agnostic, so that as long as the aircraft they have in mind is suitable for our payload, we are happy to adopt to it.” Outside the U.S., Canada and the UK, L-3 does already have some presence in the Middle East, with new offices in Abu Dhabi and in the Saudi capital Riyadh, from where it is looking to exploit demand for border security infrastructure. It has been active in South Korea, mainly in terms of base support and training activity. In Australia it has been improving the sonar capabilities of the P-3 Orion aircraft–another exportable fleet life extension possibility, along L-3’s Warrior Systems produces night vision systems with upgrade options for aging combat for the military and federal law enforcement agencies. aircraft such as Boeing F/A-18s. The unit also produces tactical illuminators.

30 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

The company’s foray into airport security is the ProVision ATD, right, which detects objects that don’t belong on passengers for more focused screening.

“There aren’t so many new program starts in the international markets but all countries have an installed base to work with, and when you get to the higher end of the overhaul work, that’s where we come in,” said Strianese, arguing that L-3 has the required flexibility and agility to match its expertise to the actual needs and realities of a foreign military, rather than seeking to impose predetermined solutions. One highlight of L-3’s exhibit here at Le Bourget this week is a new application that can bring real-time video from its Video Scout system into the battlefield via Android smart phones. “The technology has been moving very fast and young service people are very up-to-date,” commented Strianese. “This puts full-motion

L-3 Beefs Up Mobius To Challenge Firebird L-3 Communications has confirmed plans to more than double the size of its Mobius optionally manned aircraft. The new version will be 140 percent larger to allow for a two-seat manned configuration. The second seat can be occupied by a second pilot and/or sensor operator. The existing development model has a maximum takeoff weight of 3,000 pounds and a wingspan of almost 27 feet. L-3 also plans to expand the package of available ISR sensors and introduce an automatic takeoff and landing system. It sees the improved Mobius as a direct competitor to Northrop Grumman’s just-unveiled Firebird unmanned aircraft in the medium-altitude, long-endurance sector. –C.A.

video from aircraft into the hands of the warfighter through a commercial, off-theshelf product, as well as giving them geolocation mapping. They can see exactly what the overhead platform is seeing.” Also being demonstrated here this week is L-3’s main offering in the still-growing airport security market. Its ProVision full-body screening machine uses millimeter-wave scanning to generate a clear picture of anything concealed on a passenger rather than X-rays, over which there are still safety concerns in some circles. But what further sets ProVision apart, according to L-3, is its new automated target detection capability. The system has been programmed to be able to pick up on objects that “don’t belong” in the standard image of a passenger passing through security. This means that the human security screeners can focus their attention on more closely scrutinizing the “exceptions” rather than wasting time and attention span to the same degree on each passenger. ProVision is already in extensive use at airports in the U.S., where the Transportation Security Administration is upgrading them to have automatic detection capability. Strianese said there are very significant export opportunities for the system in the fast-expanding airports of Asia and the Middle East. The system has already been supplied to or ordered by airports in Australia, New Zealand, Italy, Germany, the UK and Indonesia. o

YOUR AEROSPACE INNOVATION COULD CHANGE THE WORLD Re-evaluate your low-speed performance assessments NRC offers a clear advantage in aircraft development: Featuring a high-speed wind tunnel that delivers results at low speeds With Reynolds numbers greater than 8.5 million per foot at Mach 0.2

Your vision. Our solution.

Contact our team: 1-877-NRC-CNRC | nrc.gc.ca/business

v2e_IAR-Paris_ad_BW-12024-E.indd 2

11-06-01 11:22 AM

DON’T MISS A BEAT You’re covered with AIN Publications. Subscribe today! www.ain.com/subscribe Aviation International News • Business Jet Traveler • EBACE Convention News • HAI Convention News • MEBA Convention News • NBAA Convention News • Dubai Airshow News • Farnborough Airshow News • Paris Airshow News • Singapore Airshow News • AINonline.com • BJTonline.com • AINalerts • AINmxReports • AIN Air Transport Perspective • AIN Defense Perspective • AINtv

32 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Airbus Military boosts support service offerings by Chris Pocock Airbus Military wants to boost reve- (RAAF) is the launch customer for the nue derived from support services from A330MRTT. Airbus Military has signed the current 10 to 15 percent of the total to a 20-year contract with Qantas Defense between 30 and 40 percent during the next Services, which will become the prime five years. It is offering customers that are training and support contractor to the buying the A330 tanker and the A400M RAAF. Galland said this makes sense airlifter a menu of options developed from because Qantas operates A330 airliners. training and maintenance contracts for the CN235 Airbus Military has built a new training center in Seville, Spain, as and C295 military transpart of a plan to provide long-term support services to the operators port aircraft. of the new A400M airlifter (shown here), A330 tanker and lightAccording to the Euromedium military transport aircraft. pean group, integrated service offerings such as these “demonstrably minimize the life-cycle cost” for the aircraft. The recently opened training center at Seville in southern Spain will offer more than 100 courses per year and fullflight simulators. “Beyond traditional prod uct support, our first offer is Full In-Service Support [FISS],” explained Philippe For other customers, Airbus Military Galland, head of customer services. This provides maintenance on and off the air- could assume the role of prime contraccraft, spares, component repairs and a tor for support. “We are flexible–whatguarantee of the fleet’s availability. The ever is the most efficient arrangement,” contract is priced per flight hour, but with Galland added. For instance, to support the A3330MRTTs for the UAE Air Force, some fixed-price options. In commercial aviation, many airlines the company will act as a subcontractor have signed up for such deals, and defense/ to the Advanced Military maintenance, government operators are now follow- Repair and Overhaul Center (AMROC) ing this trend, said Galland. The operator that Lockheed Martin and Mubadala are achieves certainty in budgeting, and there establishing in Abu Dhabi. For the A400M airlifter, Airbus Miliare cost benefits when Airbus Military is able to manage a pool of spares for multi- tary is committed to supplying various serple operators. Airbus Military also provides vices, with options, as part of the launch continuous fleet monitoring and up-to-date contract. For the longer term, it is negotifleet configuration control. The company ating a contract that is somewhere between has signed up 15 C212, CN235 and C295 the FISS and IMSS models with the air operators for FISS, plus the Brazilian and forces of France and the UK, who have Spanish Air Forces for their P-3 Orions that agreed to cooperate in supporting their aircraft. “We recognize that the services for were upgraded by Airbus Military. each A400M nation must reflect differing Integrated Support Services operational requirements,” Galland said. Airbus Military is offering to proBeyond FISS, the company is offering integrated mission support services vide central resources, such as an A400M (IMSS). This additionally provides fully maintenance center and the training centrained aircrew, plus mission planning, ter at Seville. It has submitted national and operations support and forward mainte- total training proposals to France and the nance. The UK Royal Air Force has signed UK, the latter in cooperation with Thales. up for IMSS as part of the country’s pri- Both countries will initially train aircrews vate finance initiative (PFI) deal to acquire in Seville. The company also is expecting 14 A330MRTTs in the Future Strategic a request for proposal from Germany for support services soon, and is in discussion Tanker Aircraft (FSTA) program. The aircraft are being supplied through with the other European launch nations. Last year, Galland’s predecessor, RichAirtanker Ltd., in which Airbus Military parent company EADS has a 40-percent ard Thompson, said the company aims to stake. The IMSS contract for the FSTA achieve airliner-standard dispatch reliabilis being executed through a second com- ity for the A400M–about 98 percent. “This pany, AirTanker Services Ltd., in which compares with 85 percent for the C-17 and EADS holds a 28-percent stake. Airbus C-130J. We are also prepared to guarantee Military has signed a second IMSS con- the number of hours of downtime per year, tract with Spanish Customs for the opera- which will be 50 percent that of the C-17,” he added. Thompson has since moved to tion of six C212s. o The Royal Australian Air Force head up Airbus in the UK.

New orders set to drive up ATR production by Thierry Dubois could be firmed up next year. The ATR 72-600 received its European Aviation Safety Agency certification in late May. U.S. FAA approval is expected soon, thanks to the joint certification process the two agencies follow, ATR CEO Filippo Bagnato said last week in Paris. The six-month delay in getting the aircraft’s certification, which was planned

for 2010 at the program’s launch in 2007, is not due to any specific issue, according to Jacques Desbarats, commercial senior vice president. The aircraft on display is soon to be delivered to the Moroccan operator. The -600’s second customer is Brazilian airline Azul. The improved ATR 72 has a list price of $22.7 million ($800,000 more than its predecessor, the ATR 72-500). It is powered by a pair of Pratt & Whitney Canada PW127M engines for better hotand-high capabilities. Maximum takeoff weight and zero-fuel weight increase by 1,100 pounds. In the modernized cabin, passengers will enjoy 30-percent larger overhead bins. Bagnato told AIN that ATR engineers have found a good tradeoff between bin volume and headroom. In the cockpit, the crew will benefit from a new Thales avionics suite with five six- by eight-inch LCD displays. It is built under an integrated modular avionics architecture. An AFDX bus makes data interchange swifter. The autopilot has Cat 3A approach capability. ATR 72-600 by the Numbers The ATR 42-600 sells for $18.9 milPratt & Whitney Canada PW127M (2) lion, again $800,000 more than the -500 Engines Takeoff power 2,750 shp each version. It is to be certified by year Range with max payload 900 nm end. Bagnato specifically mentioned Mtow 50,700 pounds the autopilot as a component that calls Max payload 16,500 pounds for extensive flight-testing by ATR and Passenger seats 68 to 74 EASA engineers. The certification program involves one aircraft. In sales, Bagnato highlighted the he said he wants to have a clear idea of emerging markets of Brazil, Russia, India the technology the aircraft will use before and China as holding a lot of hope for the it is launched. Next year, ATR shareholdnear future. There are already two ATR ers will be able to make an informed decioperators in Brazil: Azul and Trip Linhas sion, he said. ATR customers are perceived as “not Aéreas. In Russia, deliveries have started to UTAir, which has ordered 20 aircraft; needing tremendous performance.” They and in India, traffic is growing again, just need a larger turboprop, Bagnato asserted. “The enemy is cost; economics Bagnato noted. But China is not as promising for ATR. are paramount,” he said. The company claims a 60-percent As Desbarats explained to AIN, the Chinese government has set a 26-percent import tax share in the regional turboprop marfor ATR-category aircraft because they ket today. According to Desbarats, the compete with a local design: Xian’s MA-60. ATR 72 has a 35- to 40-percent fuel burn In total, the so-called BRIC countries will advantage over the speedier Bombardier have accounted for 15 to 20 percent of ATR Q400. “Fuel accounts for 30 percent of an airlines’ costs,” Desbarats said. At 360 sales in the first half of 2011. Thanks to sustained sales (includ- knots, the Q400 can cruise 80-knots faster ing orders to be announced here at Le than its European rival. The 1,000th ATR aircraft should be Bourget), production is to increase from 52 or 53 aircraft this year to about 70 next delivered during the first half of 2012. o

MARK WAGNER

Here at the Paris Air Show, ATR is showcasing its newly certified ATR 72-600 in the livery of Royal Air Maroc. Meanwhile, the European airframer’s final assembly line in Toulouse is to ramp up production of the 70-seater by 40 percent–in part driven by expectations of significant new orders to be placed at Le Bourget this week. Plans for a 90-seater

34 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

year. Desbarats told AIN he would like more but Bagnato has decided to limit the ramp-up to what he sees as a reasonable level. He does not want to create too much complexity, as the ramp-up is simultaneous with the inception of the new -600 versions. He made it clear that the 70-aircraft production plan will be confirmed once the company has ensured the supply chain can accommodate the increase, and he said he hopes production will go beyond 70 in 2013 and 2014. The -500 variants will still be produced along with the newer -600s until 2013. Bagnato hinted 2014 will see the termination of the -500 production run. However, ATR does not want to rule out -500 orders too quickly, in case a -500 customer would want to keep fleet homogeneity. To support the increasing production rate, ATR is growing its workforce. From today’s 3,000, it should reach 4,500 in 2013–mainly in France and Italy–including ATR direct jobs and jobs at shareholders EADS and Alenia Aeronautica. ATR currently employs about 900 people directly. Asked about the 90-seater project, Bagnato wanted to appear conservative. Citing Boeing 787 and Airbus A380 woes,

This newly certified ATR 72-600 on display here is soon to be delivered Royal Air Maroc. The second customer for the -600 is Brazilian airline Azul.

INNOVATION IN ALL DOMAINS

Easy, boy In considerably earlier times, this could be a cavalryman calming his trusty steed. But this is 2011 and and the only one needing steadying would be the target of this F-15E’s weapons array.

GLOBAL ISR DAVID McINTOSH

For the most demanding missions, across multiple manned and unmanned platforms, from the ground to deep space — Raytheon Global ISR solutions deliver actionable intelligence when, where and how you need it.

GKN Aerospace nabs win on Falcon’s new super midsize by Gregory Polek Dassault Aviation has awarded GKN Aerospace a life-of-program contract to design and build the wing movable surfaces for its next-generation, super midsized (SMS) business jet. It is one of the first major system supplier selections to be announced for the long-anticipated program. The work likely will be done at GKN’s Filton operation in the UK, which to date has focused mainly on wing production for Airbus. “This contract opens an important and promising new relationship between our company and Dassault Aviation, one of the premier aircraft design and manufacturing businesses in the world today,” said Phil Swash, GKN’s president and CEO for the Aerostructures-Europe division. “It is a clear indication of the global competitiveness and depth of expertise of the GKN Aerospace team and, specifically, of our growing Filton-based wing-structures activity.” Complete Control

GKN (Hall 2B EF166) will take responsibility for the complete design, component manufacture and assembly of wing movable surfaces for the SMS, expected to enter service in 2016. The company aims to bring significant performance, weight and cost benefits to the wing of Dassault’s new jet and already has engineering teams working on the program, colocated in facilities in France and Bristol, UK. Separately, the UK-based group has gained a multi-year follow-on order, valued at approximately $450 million, from Lockheed Martin for engine nacelles for the C-130J military airlifter. The new fiveyear contract extension takes continuous manufacture at GKN Aerospace through to 2018–and well into its third decade. GKN plans to supply 37 full aircraft nacelle sets this year, almost doubling previous annual production rates. In total, the company expects to supply 158 nacelles, including spares, during the remainder of this year and to deliver 2000 nacelles by 2018. It expects skilled

employment on its C-130J production line to triple by the end of 2011 and to include a growing number of apprentices. Finally, GKN Aerospace has signed an agreement this week with Recycled Carbon Fibre (RCF) to recycle the uncured carbon waste from its aerostructures manufacturing operation in Cowes, Isle of Wight, UK. Recycling will take place at RCF’s carbon-recycling facility near Birmingham in the UK. GKN estimates that the Cowes site will recycle some 100 metric tons of carbon waste in the next 12 months, as part of the so-called cost-neutral agreement. Plans call for the recycled material to appear in a variety of products, including paints and coatings, thermoplastic polymers, composite tooling and deep-sea buoyancy products. In the coming five years, as GKN Aerospace sees existing orders reach full production levels, the company expects a 30-percent rise in the quantity of waste for recycling from the Cowes site alone. “Our composite research facility has been working with RCF for some time and our aim now is to commence a program that will ultimately establish recycling as an integral part of our full production manufacturing process in the UK, and globally,” said Rich Oldfield, GKN Aerospace director of technology. “To balance the performance and environmental gains achieved through using composites in aircraft operations, it is vital the industry progresses toward greener manufacture on a number of fronts and we believe an effective recycling process is at the heart of that progression,” Oldfield said. For more on GKN’s perspective on the market and its investments in new technology see page 38. o

www.raytheon.com Follow us on:

@raytheoncompany

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 35

Boeing’s not showing its hand on plans for new-gen narrowbody by Gregory Polek It seems clear now that Boeing will not announce a decision on a successor to the 737NG at this Paris Air Show. But even the extent to which it will deliver on its promise to provide more “clarity” about its deliberations remained something of a mystery as the salon was set to open. During a pre-Paris press briefing earlier this month at Boeing’s 737 plant in Renton, Washington, Nicole Piasecki, Boeing Commercial Airplanes’ vice president of business development, offered some clues, however. Most notably, she said the company would likely talk more about the size range an all-new narrowbody would occupy. She also said the “baseline” for such an airplane would include a composite fuselage, and could incorporate a single- or twin-aisle cabin. “I don’t think that’s going to solidify this year in Paris by any means, but the market is moving up a couple of seat rows,” she said, referring to the baseline size of the potential new airplane. “The heart of the market is the 737-800 [at roughly 160 seats]. We continue to see that for the next 20 years, but it is upgauging a little bit, and so our airplane would optimize the heart of the market area but a little bit gauged up.” Piasecki also stressed that Boeing will not rush its decision, regardless of the existence and early success of the A320neo. Customers want Boeing to “get it right,” she said, and the substantial backlog already in place for the existing airplane certainly doesn’t promote a sense of urgency. Piasecki insisted the 737-800, as it exists today, already offers 2-percent better per-seat operating costs than the A320neo promises to deliver in 2015. Boeing’s calculations show that a re-engined 737-800 would cost 8 percent less to operate than the Neo. An all-new airplane would deliver “at least” double

that benefit, she added. “We don’t have a decision date at the end of this year,” she said. “We will decide when we are ready. These are big, big decisions with lots of implications that we are approaching very deliberately and very carefully and we have the option to re-engine and we have the technology plans in place and team in place to do a new small airplane program.” Piasecki said Boeing spent most of the first half of this year “deeply dissecting the marketplace” and talking with a group of customers about the various configuration possibilities. The company will spend the second half of the year analyzing the existing 737 production system and gauging its ability to “transition” into a new system capable of accommodating a rate of between 50 and 60 units per month. Now building 737s at a rate of 31.5 per month, Boeing plans to raise the rate in Renton to 35 in January and to 38 in the second quarter of 2013. According to Beverly Wyse, 737 program manager, the company continues to evaluate yet another rate increase, to occur “about a year later,” to 42 per month, to help control a backlog of more than 2,000 airplanes. In fact, Piasecki reckoned that customers will continue to take delivery of the existing NG for more than a decade, regardless of whether Boeing decides to reengine or develop an all-new successor to the 737. That means years of simultaneous production of both the existing 737 and whatever succeeds it. “The transition is going to take time,” Piasecki said. “There are certain segments of customers that are going to want to keep their fleet; it’s a workhorse; it’s reliable. As the segments of the market move, you could see a lowcost type [of airline] wanting to keep [its]

existing fleet going. The rollover of these large fleets will take years to occur.” Southwest Airlines is an example. Piasecki stressed the importance of Southwest to Boeing’s thinking on the eventual size and shape of the NG’s successor. “We will address the requirements for Southwest and that may help define the sizing of the airplane,” she said. But with an all-new airplane unavailable until at least 2019, questions have arisen whether Southwest would prefer a re-engined airplane, which would arrive in the marketplace closer to the middle of this decade. “We are very engaged with [Southwest] on both alternatives,” said Piasecki. “And it is very

Boeing Vows To Defend Lower Reaches of Narrowbody Market

A new customer for a Boeing 737, like these coming down the Renton, Washington production line, would have to wait until 2016 to take delivery.

much a part of our thought process.” If Boeing does eventually decide to reengine, CFM International, the current sole-source of 737 engines, appears likely to serve at least as the lead powerplant supplier. Boeing’s work with CFM now involves what chief program engineer John Hamilton described as “trades” to determine the optimum fan size the 737 could use without extending the nosegear. o

(Water) bombs AWay

DAVID McINTOSH

With forest fires and wildfires plaguing much of the world, including lately in Siberia, this Russian Beriev Be 200 is one of the few purpose-built firebombers on the market.

36 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Boeing intends to defend the segment of the market where its 737-700 resides, at least with incremental product improvements in the “medium term” future and possibly with an all new airplane to appear in 2019 or 2020, according to Nicole Piasecki, Boeing Commercial Airplanes’ vice president of business development. That bit of information might particularly interest Brazil’s Embraer, which continues to wait for Boeing to announce a decision on an eventual successor to today’s 737NG before it commits to a new program of its own. Analysts have speculated that Boeing could abandon what now constitutes the lower reaches of the narrowbody market, particularly if it opted to build an all-new airplane. Such a move, they argue, could leave an opening for Embraer to develop a 130to 150-seat narrowbody of its own and help the Bombardier C Series gain more traction in its 110- to 145-seat segment. “There is, obviously, emerging competition in the marketplace,” said Piasecki. “It is Boeing’s intention to defend the lower part of the market.” Still, she acknowledged an undeniable upward shift in the heart of the narrowbody segment “by a couple of seat rows.” In fact, Piasecki confirmed that Boeing will no longer pursue the sector of the market served by the 737-600, which typically ranges in capacity from 110 to 125 seats, due to pilot scope clause considerations in Europe and the U.S. For what Piasecki called the medium-term future, Boeing has turned its attention to the so-called NG+, which, she said, amounts to a phrase for continuous improvement. “We have a whole bunch of things that we’re taking a look at to eke out more performance in the mid-decade, 2015 time frame,” she said, in addition to the 2-percent fuel-burn improvement expected to result this year from the 737’s latest Performance Improvement Package (PIP). “We feel our NG is very competitive,” said Piasecki. “On that program we’re way down the learning curve, we’ve got a set of customers that is very strong; we have an installed fleet and so we believe [in] our ability to continue to make these incremental improvements in our program in the medium term, including going up in production rate to make our airplanes available.” The Bombardier 130- to 145-seat CS300 will deliver, according to Piasecki, a small per-seat operating cost benefit over the existing 737-700. However, “I’ll say that our numbers are different from what their claims are in the marketplace,” she said. “We don’t publicly talk about our numbers, but we have confidence that our 700 can compete very aggressively and the 737700 re-engine or new small airplane would be superior in terms of operating economics to the C Series 300.” –G.P.

The Dassault/BAE Systems Telemos will likely be based to some degree on the unmanned Mantis technology demonstrator.

INNOVATION IN ALL DOMAINS

AIR TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT Enabling the safest, most secure air traffic management systems in the world: that is our mission. It’s one we fulfill by developing and integrating advanced military and civil ATM systems, and by training those who drive their success.

BAE and Dassault team on Telmos unmanned air vehicle by David Donald Here at the Paris Air Show, Dassault and BAE Systems have joined forces to display a mockup of the UK company’s Mantis medium-altitude long-endurance (MALE) UAV technology demonstrator. The combined exhibit highlights the recent agreement between the two companies to codevelop the Telmos UAS to meet the needs of both British and French armed forces. Mantis was initially created as a joint UK government/industry program to demonstrate a deep and persistent ISTAR capability, and flew in Australia in 2009 just 19 months after the program was initiated. The vehicle incorporated a number of innovative technological and construction features and demonstrated that the capability existed in Europe to create a vehicle in this class. With the success of the first flight behind it, the UK Ministry of Defence (MoD) began to explore options for a bilateral program with another European partner, and a joint BAE/Dassault feasibility study was undertaken in 2010 on behalf of the UK MoD and its French counterpart, the DGA. The study looked at national requirements, common solutions and industrial capabilities, while analyzing cost and schedule. The conclusion was that a joint project was feasible and it was included in the UK/French defense cooperation treaty signed last November by Prime Minister Cameron and President Nicolas Sarkozy. In turn, this led to a memorandum of understanding in February between BAE Systems and Dassault to jointly pursue a proposal for the design, development, production and support of a MALE Operational Unmanned Air System (OUAS) for service entry in the 2015-2020 time frame. The name Telmos was announced just before the show. Both companies have extensive experience in the unmanned arena–BAE Systems through its Raven, Corax, HERTI, Mantis and Taranis programs, and Dassault through the AVE series, SDM MALE and Neuron–and both have complementary areas of excellence and key suppliers. The joint program allows sharing of investment and technological developments for

the benefit of both nations. At present there is no formal joint requirement for the OUAS MALE, but UK and French teams are working on an integrated requirement. According to one French industry source close to the program, the requirements are “already very close to convergence.” The requirement will be based on the provision of affordable, actionable combat ISTAR capability on a 24/7/365 basis, the ability to incorporate the rapid implementation of new technology and the ability to operate on a worldwide basis across a range of operational scenarios. OUAS MALE will be part of the UK’s Scavenger requirement for data collection and Solomon for data dissemination, as well as corresponding French requirements. One element of OUAS MALE that is still to be defined is the acquisition approach, which is constrained by European Union competition law. A decision is expected in mid- to late summer. Meanwhile, BAE Systems and Dassault have already mobilized a team to mature the joint proposal and are hoping for an early down-select to one industrial team. According to Ian Fairclough, BAE Systems’ project director for strategic UAS, “An early start would enhance the ability to de-risk the program downstream, deliver a more mature initial operating capability, get funding focused on one core design and help sustain industrial capabilities.” It is accepted that the BAE Systems/ Dassault Telmos proposal will be based to some degree on the Mantis. Dassault spokesman Yves Robins concurred, commenting that, “We are happy to see BAE as the lead. Mantis is the startpoint.” The Joint Project Office will be established in the UK at Abbeywood. Although the prop-driven Mantis technology demonstrator was designed so that it could trial jet power as an alternative, it is likely that the Telmos will retain turboprops, trading time-to-height performance for better endurance characteristics. Weaponizing the vehicle has been studied, initially by BAE Systems as part of the UK-only program but now expanded as part of the joint proposal. o

www.raytheon.com Follow us on:

@raytheoncompany

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 37

GKN set to reap lush harvest after investing in fallow years by Charles Alcock When GKN Aerospace CEO Marcus Bryson gets bullish about market conditions it is probably worth paying attention. He was quick to identify the full extent of the downturn triggered by the global financial crisis and has generally erred more toward the “glass-half-empty” view than seeing the glass as being half full. But, at a briefing ahead of this week’s Paris Air Show, he was adamant that the industry is back in growth mode and that GKN has positioned itself well to tap the fruits of growing demand. Last year, which Bryson described as having been “good but not exceptional,” GKN won new contracts that will lead to more than $1.5 billion in new business. The new work includes a contract to make fuel tanks for the General Atomics Predator UAV and

GKN Aerospace CEO Marcus Bryson is optimistic that sustained growth is returning to the aerospace industry and believes that companies that have continued to invest during the downturn will capitalize on this trend.

Eurocopter’s EC 135 helicopter, as well as for various Boeing 787 components for Japan’s Fuji Heavy Industries. Production ramp-up for GKN’s role in major new programs such as Airbus’s A400M military transport and the A350XWB airliner, as well as for the Lockheed Martin F-35 Joint Strike Fighter and the Boeing 787 widebody, are expected to bring in approximately $640 million in new revenues. In midApril, GKN signed a new long-term production contract with Boeing. Running through 2020, the contract covers titanium structural wing-to-body and wing-to-nacelle fittings for the 787. These are manufactured at GKN’s plant in St. Louis, Missouri. Just over half of UK-based GKN Aerospace’s worldwide workforce is in the U.S. For the A350, GKN is providing inboard and outboard wing flaps, as well as cabin windows. With airframers now looking to boost output fairly quickly there could be f urther opportunities for GKN to capitalize on the lack of preparedness of some rival suppliers, Bryson claimed. “As build rates grow, we will start to see some distress in the supply chain with some suppliers struggling to make the necessary investments,” he said, referring to the impact that diminished income and profitability has had in some sectors of the industry. “This is why Airbus is giving long advanced notice of production rates increasing.” Back in January 2009, GKN Aerospace took a big leap forward in expanding its own production capacity when it acquired the former Airbus wing factory at Filton in the UK. At the height of the downturn, the investment might have seemed inauspicious, but output from the facility was a big factor in boosting annual revenues by almost 50 percent from around £1 billion in 2008 to £1.45 billion in 2010.

GKN has invested heavily in automating processes for a manufacturing of composite aerostructures, vastly speeding up the process for tape laying when making structures such a wing slats.

GKN is working with Rolls-Royce to develop a new composite fan casing, but it still believes that metals have a future where their use would be more cost effective, such as in this aluminum isogrid casing.

While revenues were essentially flat between 2009 and 2010, profitability in GKN’s aerospace division last year represented a margin of 11.2 percent–above the 7.6 percent achieved group-wide. The civil side of GKN’s business accounted for 53 percent of revenues last year and by 2014 this is expected to increase to 62 percent. Other drivers in this sector include increased output for both the A320 single-aisle family and its 737 rival from Boeing, as well as for the A380, A330 and Boeing 777. Further ahead, Bryson sees more opportunity in programs such as the new A320Neo and the 747-8 (for which GKN is contracted to develop thrust struts), as well as the Bombardier C Series (ailerons and winglets) and China’s Comac C919 airliners. GKN is continuing talks with the Chinese about a possible contribution to the C919. Despite the anticipated reduction in the proportion of military business to overall sales and pressure on defense budgets, GKN still feels that this sector

Transparencies such as this cockpit window are part of GKN Aerospace’s special products division, accounting for 10 percent of revenues. The company is developing cabin windows for the Airbus A350XWB.

38 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

is largely positive for 2011 and going forward. In addition to its stake in the F-35 and A400M programs, GKN continues to generate ongoing earnings from programs such as the C-130J and C-17 military transport, as well as from Saudi Arabia’s F-15 fighters, the V-22 Osprey tiltrotor and Sikorsky’s Blackhawk family of helicopters. The group is now focusing on opportunities with new generation U.S.-led programs, such as the CH-53K heavylift assault/transport helicopter, the KC46A tanker, as well as various future unmanned combat air systems and the Armed Aerial Scout rotorcraft. Its corporate structure in the U.S. means that it is cleared to work on the Pentagon’s top-secret “black” programs. GKN also expects to grow its business with both BAE Systems and Northrop Grumman over the next three years. Earlier this year, GKN added a new airframer to its client base when HondaJet announced its selection to manufacture the entire composite fuselage for its new business jet. The first production units are due to be delivered to Honda’s U.S. factory in the spring of 2012. Aerostructures account for fully 65 percent of GKN’s business, followed by 25 percent for propulsion systems. Specialty products, including fuel tanks and inflatable aircraft recovery floats, represent 10 percent of the business. Throughout these sectors, aftermarket work generates 15 percent of all revenues. GKN’s work in aerostructures spans much more extensive sections of airframes. These include winglets, wing trailing and leading edges, vertical and

horizontal tail planes, composite and metal fuselage structures, as well as fully integrated floor structures. In the powerplant department, GKN makes both composite and metallic fan blades and cases (see box), as well as blisks (a blade/disk combination), diffusers, turbine casings, exhaust systems, fan inlet frame, inner core fairings, compressor cases, ducts and compressor and turbine vanes. Following on from a joint venture started two years ago with RollsRoyce to develop a new composite fan

INNOVATION IN ALL DOMAINS

blade, GKN is extending this alliance to develop a composite fan case. The case is intended for possible use on future large turbofans and potentially could be applied to whatever powerplant is required for the new-generation singleaisle airliners envisioned by both Boeing and Airbus. “We are now building on our proven track record of growth and profit margin progression,” concluded Bryson. He pledged that the group would continue its high levels of investment in research and technology development (see box). o

INTEGRATED AIR & MISSILE DEFENSE SOLUTIONS

GKN Bets Big on Technology To Drive Growth Even during the most unsettling periods of the recent economic downturn, GKN Aerospace continued to invest heavily in being at aerospace’s technological leading edge. Prime evidence of this is its leadership role in the establishment of the UK’s new National Composites Centre, where work is due to start this summer. To kick-start this initiative, GKN and partners from aerospace and other industries have just completed the Inspirational Composites project to define the initial R&D goals for the new governmentbacked facility, which will be based close to GKN’s Filton site and will work closely with nearby Bristol University. Also kicking off soon in Filton will be work commissioned through a new R&D collaboration agreed with Airbus parent group EADS to develop more environmentally sustainable methods for aircraft manufacturing. This too has enjoyed some financial support from the UK government. GKN has extended its role in the European Commission-backed Clean Sky program to develop and harness technology that can reduce air transport’s environmental footprint. Working with Airbus, the company is in the middle of the design phase for developing a laminar wing that will be flown on an A340 in 2014 to prove whether the anticipated reduction in drag delivers sufficient cuts in fuel burn to merit its adoption for new airliners.

‘Niche’ Technologies The engineering team led by GKN technology director Richard Oldfield is also applying itself to the development of what he called “differentiating technologies” in areas such as transparencies and coatings. “We’ve got about a dozen different technologies coming together,” he told AIN. “We’re applying niche technologies to aircraft structures to increase functionality and add value.” For instance, GKN is working on coatings that would resist the formation of ice on aerostructures to reduce the need to use energyconsuming heat for de-icing. Ice protection research work has also yielded new designs for engine inlets and exposed areas of wings. This work, and greater use of smart coatings, is also reducing the noise footprint of aircraft Providing lightning protection for composite structures has been another big issue for the GKN research team because the traditional method of fitting copper mesh inside the structure would add weight and so undermine one of the key

reasons for using composites. “So instead, we’ve been finding ways to integrate other metallic elements into the composites to replicate the effect of the copper mesh,” Oldfield explained.

Raytheon’s experience developing and integrating air and missile defense solutions makes us a key player in the United States’ Phased Adaptive Approach for missile defense in Europe, and in developing solutions to protect nations worldwide.

Pairing Composites and Metals Not so long ago, the ascent of composites in aerostructures manufacturing seemed an unstoppable progression that could happen only at the expense of metals. Fresh thinking at GKN is changing that, with engineers increasingly coming to the conclusion that the two families of materials can coexist in cooperative harmony to give manufacturers the best of both worlds. The company is making progress in the application of hybrid structures that combine titanium and composites. The company has devised a way to use degradable hooks to bind the two materials together until they are permanently bonded. What’s more, GKN also is finding ways to make more efficient use of the materials individually. With composites it is increasingly building up structures from a powder form so that the manufacturer ends up using 90 percent of the raw materials, as opposed to the traditional approach in which it would start with a composite block and then machine away 90 percent of the mass to use only the remaining 10 percent. Working with engine maker Rolls-Royce, GKN also is testing new sintering techniques in which metallic powder is formed into structures by applying heat without reaching melting point. This could reduce a four-stage forging process for making turbine blades into a single process. Other work is being done to fine-tune the material properties of metals by remixing the powder content. So for GKN, it is no longer a case of composites or metals. “What it comes down to is which material is most competitive and offers the highest [profit] margin [for a specific application], or could it be that this would be from a combination of both,” concluded Oldfield. But one of his greatest challenges remains recruiting the right engineering talent for GKN’s work, with the UK education still lagging in the production of a new generation of aerospace engineers. The company needs to find at least 300 more composites specialists and is having to implement its own training programs to cross-train people with the right aptitude but insufficient direct experience in the field. –C.A.

www.raytheon.com Follow us on:

@raytheoncompany

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 39

Power struggle intensifies over new narrowbodies by Julian Moxon Almost three full decades ago a battle was raging over the powerplant options for what was then the all-new Airbus A320. The competitors–CFM International and International Aero Engines (IAE)–were making claim and counter-claim as to the potential advantages their respective engines would bring to the aircraft, which had been developed to grab a slice of the huge single-aisle market until then dominated by the ubiquitous Boeing 737. Today, the fight to power the muchanticipated son-of-the-A320 is no less intense. But this time it is the re-engined, “sharklet” wing-tipped version: the A320neo. CFM International is still there in its original 50/50, transatlantic partnership between GE Aviation and Snecma, but this time only one of the original five IAE partners is present: Pratt & Whitney, which at the time of writing had taken all of the 332 orders and options for the

a ircraft with its all-new PW1100G geared fan engine. Rolls-Royce, the other major IAE partner, is absent from the competition, its future single-aisle strategy depending entirely on powering all-new single-aisle aircraft. The intensity of the A320neo engine fight was highlighted a few weeks before this year’s Le Bourget show, when CFM quietly revealed it had decided to increase the fan diameter of its Leap-X engine by two inches. The move resulted from Airbus’ concerns that the existing engine’s 71-inch fan would result in a significant fuel burn disadvantage compared to the PW1100G. Airbus wanted to offer potential customers a choice of engines with similar performance because the resulting A320neo order book would be more likely to be split 50/50 between the competing engines– forcing the engine manufacturers to keep their prices down and helping the aircraft

CFM has tested and evaluated all three major elements–the turbine, the combustor and the compressor–of the Leap-X core demonstrator. The company recently decided to extend the fan diameter to improve fuel burn.

The Pratt & Whitney PW1100G geared turbofan selected to power the Airbus A320neo is derived from the company’s original Pure Power 1000G geared turbofan, above. Pratt revealed a full-scale model of the original at its stand at the Farnborough International airshow in 2008.

40 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

itself to be more competitive. The fan diameter increase means the engine will have a bypass ratio closer to the 12:1 figure set by the PW1100G, with its 81-inch fan. The late decision means extra work for France’s Snecma, however, which is responsible for the all-composite fan, adding to the workload as LeapX development continues toward its early 2016 entry-into-service date. Improved Fuel Burn

Tom Brisken, general manager, customer strategies at GE Aviation, claims the larger fan will bring improved fuel burn performance without requiring major work on the core, which is approaching its first major test. “We continue to develop the core as is usual in engine development programs,” he told AIN. “I am convinced that if we can nail the core, we will have, by far, the best engine for the A320neo.” Paul Adams, Pratt & Whitney’s senior engineering vice president, disputes this. He reckons that in order to achieve the higher bypass ratio, CFM will “possibly” have had no choice but to reduce the core size of the Leap-X, in turn increasing core temperature. “The downside is that would be very negative from the maintenance point of view,” he told AIN. CFM denies it has had to do this, but the argument highlights the PW1100G versus Leap-X battleground: reliability and maintenance costs. GE’s Brisken remains adamant that reliability, besides fuel burn performance, is central to airline decision making and that an engine based on an existing highly reliably design dating back to the GE90 powering the Boeing 777 will prove its worth. “There have got to be some concerns about bringing a brand-new engine to market,” he said. Pratt & Whitney, only too aware that the gearbox reliability issue was central to sales of its engine, came under intense pressure from the airlines to provide strong maintenance guarantees. Testing of the geared fan engines already in development for the Bombardier CRJ and Mitsubishi MRJ has revealed no problems. “We also have a more conservative core [than P&W’s],” said Adams. “I have no worries with this engine at all.” The Leap-X program was launched in July 2008 as a response to the dramatic surge in fuel prices. The biggest investment in CFM’s history, the engine now represents the company’s stake in a potentially vast market for more fuel-efficient aircraft. The engine combines the best technologies of the new GEnx that powers the Boeing 787 with the proven assets of the CFM56, designed for highcycle operations typically flown by single-aisle aircraft. “It is evolutionary, not revolutionary,” said Brisken. “At entry into service we’re aiming for dispatch reliability levels in the same league as the CFM56-5 today–99.98 percent. It’s a big challenge but that’s our target.” Several A320neo order decisions are thought to be in the pipeline, including from Virgin America and Air Asia, both potentially major customers. Both Brisken and Adams reckon the market

will run for around 10 years and be worth potentially “several thousand” aircraft. What, then, of Boeing’s answer to the A320neo? Perhaps all will be revealed here at Paris, but the general opinion is that it has abandoned any plans for another re-engined version of the 737 and is concentrating on an all-new aircraft. Boeing has said only that it intends to address the single-aisle market with a 145- to 185-seat offering. All-new Engine

This is where Rolls-Royce comes in. At the 2010 Farnborough airshow Rolls’s head of strategic marketing, Robert Nuttal, insisted that an all-new engine for an all-new aircraft was the only solution that made business sense to the UK company. “First, we don’t think a re-engined aircraft offers any significant net financial benefit to the industry,” he told AIN. “Second, at manufacturing level the program will be only half as long as a new engine program, so the returns are far less, and third, if re-engining occurs it delays an all-new aircraft which would bring real benefits in terms of fuel economy and emissions.” With the A320neo, the third option has now happened, so does Rolls-Royce still believe in its strategy of a year ago? Speaking exclusively to AIN before the show, Nuttal confirmed that the company remained “unable to see a business case” for powering a derivative aircraft and was pressing ahead with an aggressive technology readiness program aimed at providing an advanced engine for an all-new aircraft. “We believe that a bespoke engine provides a viable, strong business case,” he said. The company is running two engine demonstrator programs as well as an open-rotor research effort, all aimed at providing a “range of concepts to suit the timing and size of aircraft when they appear.” The three-shaft Advance 3 program and two-shaft Advance 2 are each running core technology demonstrators, the Advance 2 core having already demonstrated, said Nuttal, a “world-leading 22:1 pressure ratio high-pressure compressor.” This core goes to its next altitude test in June and will continue testing to 2014. Testing of the first Advance 3 core is complete and the second core is on track for the third quarter of this year. “We are the only company to have three potential candidates for a future new aircraft,” said Nuttal. “Our strategy is to ensure we are in a position of technical readiness with programs that are applicable across the board. There is a tremendous amount going on at Rolls-Royce.” He is “emphatic” that the UK company will be aboard any new single-aisle aircraft. GE and P&W both claim that development versions of their respective engines will also be suitable for an all-new aircraft. Brisken said GE has been “very engaged” with Boeing developments of the Leap-X. “We have to make the right decision at the right time,” he stated. “We will not be surprised if Boeing launches this year. They like our technology and they like what we’re doing. Boeing will want the best.” Adams said the Boeing issue is “really interesting from our point of view. I think

INNOVATION IN ALL DOMAINS

Rolls-Royce open-rotor pusher

RADAR Across multiple platforms and missions, the harshest physical environments and all major frequency bands, one constant remains: Raytheon radar solutions deliver an unmatched ability to sense one’s environment, share information, strike with precision and succeed with confidence.

Rolls-Royce open-rotor tractor

Rolls-Royce is one of two manufacturers contemplating an open-rotor design for narrowbody aircraft. The company estimates that the engine could be 10 percent more fuel efficient than traditional engines, but the tradeoff would be increased noise.

they will come out with an all-new aircraft. They are very interested in our geared fan engine, which has considerable development capability.” He said that the development process would produce a PW1100G offshoot with a further 5-percent fuel burn advantage over the A320neo engine by the expected 2019-2020 in-service date. “We’re looking at a range of possibilities with Boeing,” he added. Open Rotors

Open rotors remain potential future powerplants only for Rolls-Royce and GE/Snecma. Brisken said it is still “too early for such an engine and the airframers recognize that. We don’t see an open rotor before 2030 from the technology point of view and we still question if it is the right approach.” Rolls-Royce puts the airframe requirement slightly earlier, at “mid to late decade.” Nuttal said the airframers are taking open rotors seriously and that both Boeing and Airbus have been involved in simulations of potential engine configurations. “We’re working on both pusher and tractor layouts. A rear location is more complex than

an underwing tractor, but we’re looking at all the airframe issues,” he explained. Rolls-Royce has completed the first three open-rotor test sets and is about to embark on the fourth, which will concentrate on blade optimization. Nuttal said trials to-date have shown that an open rotor could yield up to a 10-percent fuel burn advantage over a conventional engine designed at the same time, but it would be 10dB noisier. “That means it would still be quieter than anything flying today, so we’re confident that with continuing development we will have a very viable product,” he concluded. With the battle lines drawn between CFM and Pratt & Whitney on the A320neo and with Rolls-Royce putting all of its single-aisle cards on a future allnew aircraft, this year’s Paris Air Show promises to be as interesting as ever for engine industry-watchers. o

www.raytheon.com Follow us on:

@raytheoncompany

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 41

Airbus carefully ramps up production by Thierry Dubois Building on a strong upturn in global What about the transition from proairline traffic, Airbus is ramping up production of the existing A320 to the reduction of all its models–A320 family, engined A320neo family? “Transitions A330 and A380–while keeping a careful are always delicate but, fortunately, this eye on possible supply chain issues that one will be short, as we have brought could hit increased output rates for these forward the Pratt & Whitney version’s models and also for the new A350XWB entry into service to October 2015,” Bréwidebody. Meanwhile, costs and an gier answered. He forecast that, in 2018, uncompetitive euro-dollar exchange con- about 40 Neos will be produced. tinue to give headaches to the European On the A330 widebody, the production airframer’s top management. rate is to increase from nine per month, “In [airline] traffic, after minus four early in 2012, to 10 per month in the secpercent in 2009, we are now experienc- ond quarter of 2013. This ramp-up has ing a seven- to eight-percent contributed to making the supgrowth, and a five-percent pliers’ workload heavy. Aerogrowth is almost guaranlia, for example, manufactured teed,” Airbus COO Fabrice 45 percent more components Brégier emphasized in an in 2010 than in 2009. early June meeting with the Brégier predicted the A330 French aerospace journalist will continue to be manuassociation (AJPAE). This factured until at least 2020, explains the increased prodespite the A350XWB’s duction rates for the fastarrival on the market in 2013. selling A320 single-aisle He would not comment on family, for which output the anticipated end of the Airbus COO Fabrice Brégier will increase from 36 to 42 sees production increasing for A340’s 18-year production aircraft per month. This all models, but supply chain run (ended in 2010), but he year, a first target is 38, issues remain a concern. did concede that increasbut early next year the rate ing fuel prices and evolving should reach 40 and it is expected to hit ETOPS rules for twin-engine operations 42 in the fourth quarter. made the quad “less competitive.” Production is spread among Toulouse On the A380, Brégier said about 25 cop(a steady 14 aircraft per month); Tianjin, ies should be delivered this year. However, China (increasing from three to four per he said, “We are keeping a close eye on the month); and Hamburg, Germany, which uncertainties Rolls-Royce is facing with is to reach 24 per month and is thus one Trent 900 supplier.” He was referring accommodating most of the ramp-up. to problems at Japan-based turbine blade “If we could go to 45, we would have manufacturer IHI, whose factory was seria market for that,” Brégier said. But the ously damaged by the earthquake and subsupply chain would find it hard to follow. sequent tsunami in March. According to According to Brégier, those companies Brégier, after having been stopped for sevconcerned are mostly small ones, as some eral weeks, the factory has been restarted of these businesses have had financial trou- and Airbus hopes to meet nominal probles during the recent downturn. This has duction levels in July. made it hard for them to invest to be ready “On the A380, since the end of 2009, for the ramp-up and, at the same time, we have fulfilled our delivery schedairframers have continued to exert down- ule commitments,” Brégier noted. He ward pressure on prices paid for what they asserted that Airbus now has a good produce, making cash even harder to find. command of the production ramp-up. Airbus’s answer to this is that smaller, The rate is predicted to reach about 40 tier-two and -three firms should con- per year before 2020. From an accountsolidate. “They could be more efficient, ing standpoint, the double-decker is financially more robust and could more expected to contribute to Airbus’ profits, easily transfer work to low-cost coun- at last, in 2014 or 2015. tries,” Brégier suggested. To help those Having had to cope with all the aforesmall companies that are having a hard mentioned supply chain issues, how is time, Airbus is a partner in Aerofund–a Airbus preparing for the A350? Is the financial support organization that also new widebody’s supply chain ready? Spehas French engines and electronics group cifically asked about composite compoSafran as a partner. Also, Brégier is the nent providers, Brégier answered that president of “Pacte PME” (“SME com- some of them are using such materials pact”), a group of 36 large corporations for the first time. “The challenge is not that aim at a fairer relationship between really in large panels but rather in clips, them and small subcontractors. frames, stringers and so forth,” he said. But difficulties can also affect major Brégier admitted that Airbus is now solvfirst-tier Airbus partners. EADS subsid- ing teething problems in material quality iary Aerolia, an aerostructures special- and control processes. ist, has a factory in Tunisia but it had to The first A350XWB final assembly is close it during the North African coun- to start late this year. Brégier insisted systry’s revolution early this year. Growth tem installation in the airframe must be plans there have been postponed by two “robust.” This is especially important for or three months, Brégier said. electric systems in a composite fuselage,

42 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

and Airbus will be mindful of fairly recent wiring problems with the A380 program. But Brégier expressed confidence that the production ramp-up would be relatively easy, once the tooling is in place at the suppliers’ facilities. In terms of orders, Airbus is expecting 2011 to exceed 2010, which ended with 574 net sales. There were 70 cancellations last year and these are expected to stay at a similar level, between 10 and 15 percent of annual orders, in 2011. As for costs, Brégier emphasized that the Power 8 cost-cutting plan had its objectives surpassed. Running from 2007

to 2010, Power 8 envisaged a total €2.1 billion ($2.9 billion) savings but ended up with €2.5 billion ($3.5 billion) saved. A follow-on plan, Power 8+, is running through 2012 to save another €650 million ($900 million). The amount saved with Power 8 equates to a €0.25 improvement in the euro-dollar currency exchange rate, Brégier noted. “A weak dollar quickly annihilates our competitive efforts,” he said. Therefore, while half of an A320’s cost basis is in dollars, this proportion will rise to three quarters on an A350. Meanwhile, Airbus is still hiring. The company recruited 2,200 staff (half of them in France) in 2010. This year, Brégier sees 4,000 people being hired throughout Europe, with the same proportion in France. o

IAE to consider new variant of recently updated V2500 by Ian Goold flight-test, validation and certification program to be completed later this year. The upgrade–comprising an electronic engine-control software upgrade and a new data-entry plug, and available as a V2500-5 SelectOne sales order option–is planned for service entry in 2013. SelectTwo aims to provide 0.58-percent fuel-burn savings, compared with SelectOne engines, for a 500-nm A320 mission. IAE said that for a 10-airline fleet making 2,300 flights per aircraft per year, this equates to savings of $43,000 per aircraft per year at current fuel prices and 148 metric tons of carbon dioxide per aircraft per year. Recent new, or extended, customer agreements include a China Southern order for 65 SelectOne engines to be announced today as the carrier extends its V2500-powered fleet to 177 aircraft–in service or on order–making it the leading V2500 customer. Deliveries of these latest engines, which are covered by a long-term maintenance agreement and are valued at more than $750 million overall, are to begin in May 2012. Over the past several months, IAE also has reached agreements with Air Leasing, Bank of China, Sichuan, TAM, International Aero Engines is to consider a possible SelectThree Vietnam Aircraft Leasing and variant of the V2500. The four partners in the program have Vietnam Airlines. After China extended their collaborative agreement to 2045. Southern, the next four leadparticular area of engine operations and ing V2500 users are JetBlue, US Airways, that improvements could come in soft- or United Airlines and TAM, each with more hardware changes or in, say, maintenance than 100 IAE-powered aircraft. The IAE partnership, which was costs. “I’ve said, ‘Tell me what is possible’ and then I’ll see the business case. There formed in 1983, has agreed a 30-year are a lot of technologies available from extension to its collaboration agreement until 2045. There are nearly 6,500 V2500s each partner.” A new V2500 customer, Bahrain- in service with–or on firm order from– based Gulf Air, has placed the first orders almost 200 customers in more than 70 for the SelectTwo version, which will countries. The V2500 in-service fleet has power six Airbus A321s. IAE and Airbus doubled in the past five years, according o are engaged in a “rigorous” SelectTwo to International Aero Engines. International Aero Engines (IAE) will begin to consider a “SelectThree” variant of its established V2500 turbofan around the end of 2011 as a potential follow-on to the SelectTwo version unveiled earlier this year and launched by Middle East operator Gulf Air. The powerplant manufacturers making up the group have extended their partnership agreement to 2045 and Asian carrier China Southern has become the largest V2500 customer. Ian Aitken, president and chief executive of the partnership, which comprises Japanese Aero Engines, MTU Aero Engines, Pratt & Whitney and Rolls-Royce, told AIN that he expects to hear from engineers “in six months’ time” about possible further V2500 enhancements. He said IAE investment is not constrained to any

INNOVATION IN ALL DOMAINS

AIR LAND SEA SPACE CYBER Every day, Raytheon customers undertake vital missions across air, land, sea, space and cyberspace. Our mission is to provide innovative, integrated technologies across these domains to ensure customer success and deliver a true operational advantage, mission after mission.

INNOVATION IN ALL DOMAINS www.raytheon.com Follow us on:

@raytheoncompany

The CSeries aircraft delivers a 20% fuel burn advantage â&#x20AC;&#x201D; the first all-new aircraft in decades to reach this level. An achievement that gives todayâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s airlines a 15% cash

operating costs advantage and 20% less CO2 emissions*. A new choice for a changed world.

Bombardier, CSeries and CS300 are Trademark(s) of Bombardier Inc. or its subsidiaries. * 20% fuel burn advantage, 20% less CO2 emissions and 15% cash operating costs advantage vs. in-production aircraft of 110-seat & 130-seat categories @ 500 nm. The CSeries aircraft program is currently in development phase and as such is subject to changes in family strategy, branding, capacity, performance, design and / or systems. All specifications and data are approximate, may change without notice and are subject to certain operating rules, assumptions and other conditions. The actual aircraft and configuration may differ from the image shown.

A test item of Raytheonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s small tactical Missile is carried by the 10.2-foot wingspan Cobra UAV, which was developed by the company specifically to conduct UAV trials.

Raytheon develops missile for small UAVs by David Donald Raytheonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s growing p Â ortfolio of precision munitions is to expand with the development of a new smart missile to arm small UAVs that are currently unable to carry weapons. Initial flight tests have produced good results, and the small tactical missile (STM) is gearing up for more advanced testing in the coming weeks. STM development was spurred on by the experience of operators of small UAVs such as the U.S. Armyâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s RQ-7 Shadow. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Operators of these UAVs can see guys planting IEDs, but they have nothing to shoot,â&#x20AC;? explained Cody Tretschok, Raytheonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s STM capture manager, referring to operations in locations such as Afghanistan against insurgents armed with improvised explosive devices. â&#x20AC;&#x153;They can call in airstrikes but that might take 30 to 60 minutes, by which time the enemy has gotten away. The challenge is,

what can we do for these small systems? How can we dramatically reduce the kill chain?â&#x20AC;? Arming the UAVs themselves is the obvious answer, but the size and payload capacity of the vehicles demands a very small weapon. There are advantages as a small warhead significantly reduces the level of collateral damage, an important consideration when operating in populated areas. â&#x20AC;&#x153;But you can go too far,â&#x20AC;? warned Tretschok. â&#x20AC;&#x153;It doesnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t make sense to make a weapon that doesnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t have a large enough warhead to be effective.â&#x20AC;? Answering this conundrum is a seven-pound warhead developed by Nammo Talley. The small size of the warhead has allowed Raytheon to devise a missile that weighs just 13 pounds yet still delivers an effective blast. The STM is unpowered, but its wings give it a range of around four to seven kilometers when

Passion 550 x 176 Show Daily Ain:Mise en page 1 19/05/11 17:06 Page1

launched from a typical 8,000- to 12,000-foot altitude. Guidance is by semi-active laser and/or GPS. Flexibility of operation was an important driver in its design, and it incorporates a range of advanced features drawn from Raytheonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s extensive munitions range, including off-boresight launch, impact angle control, fuzing options (point, delay and airburst) and high agility to engage moving targets. The weapon is fully interfaced with the UAV operatorâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s station. Development of STM began around three years ago, and in 2010 flight tests were undertaken at the Yuma Proving Ground in the U.S. Three drops were undertaken from the Cobra autonomous UAV platform, which was developed

by Raytheon as a testbed for unmanned systems and sensors. All three drops used inert weapons, one being guided by GPS alone and two using both GPS and laser. While ground tests of the warhead continue, more flight tests are planned for the end of the summer with fuzing options added. STM drops from a tactical platform are planned for later in the year, or early next. Further developments of the STM are being worked on, including a common launch tube for two missiles for carriage by larger platforms. Although these platforms can carry larger weapons such as the Hellfire, the STM can be carried in larger numbers and offers a useful low collateral damage option.

The provision of a motor to extend range is also being examined, although the weaponâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s current glide range is well matched to the way in which small UAVs are typically employed. Helicopter- and ground-launched concepts for the STM are also under review. The STM becomes the smallest member of a family of smart weapons from Raytheon that ranges from the Paveway laser and dual-mode bombs, down through the SDB II, JAGM and Griffin. The latter is a 33-pound weapon that has been integrated with the U.S. Air Forceâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s A/MC130W Dragon Spear Hercules used by the U.S. Special Operations Command and has also been linked with larger UAVs and helicopters. o

www.safran-group.com

High technology has its own language Safran is a world leader in commercial jet engines, helicopter turbine engines, landing gear and automated

Because craftsmanship is a source of pride, Safran speaks the language of passion.

Sargent invests for coming boom by Charles Alcock This time last year, newly is targeted to grow by around restructured Sargent Aerospace 100, with 30 jobs added so far & Defense was busily expanding and up to another 40 anticiits component-making facilities in pated in the first half of next anticipation of a full-blown indus- year. In addition to existing intry recovery in the second half of production aircraft, Sargent is this year. Preparing to depart for gearing up for its contributions this week’s Paris Air Show, the to Boeing’s new 787 widebody U.S. group’s president Scott Still and the Airbus A350XWB, as well as Lockheed Marsaid this trend has since tin’s F-35 fighter. been deferred by what Despite the slow-thanhe estimates to be six to expected recovery, Still nine months, but he has told AIN that airframers no regrets about getting are already ramping up his company in growth production and there is mode and is already an increasingly prevalent reaping the benefits of view that some tier-two an investment totaling Scott Still, suppliers have not been some $20 million. Sargent able to make the necesIn August, Sargent president sary investments to be expects to open its new 70,000-sq-ft facility in Tucson, ready to boost output. “RampArizona–more than doubling up rates look like [they will be] the size of its headquarters. 30 to 40 percent above current Production equipment is being levels,” he said. “Some suppliers installed next month and work could be in trouble [in terms of is already under way to trans- lack of preparedness]. Some are fer activities from the company’s going to fall down and we could other factories in California. capitalize on that.” Another issue facing tier-two Overall, employment at the site

suppliers is the growing desire of their tier-one masters to commit them to lock in prices for contracts running as long as 10 to 15 years. This is in the context of rising raw material costs that have seen increases as high as 15 percent since 2009. Sargent has endeavored to protect itself through some material price hedging through 2012, but Still acknowledged that this is a hard calculation to get right and spells risk for him and his rivals. Sargent has a growing appetite of its own to increase its position on the global aerospace stage. After recruiting as its new vice president for aftermarket services Kevin Connelly, who has experience in the Asia Pacific region, the company has opened a sales and business development office in Singapore and is quickly realizing the opportunities now at its feet. It is also handling some customer support out of Singapore and will soon place space inventory there. The next step is a study

Sargent Aerospace & Defense manufactures actuators and valves, fasteners and pins, seals and alignment joints, specialty bearings and hot-section components for OEMs.

that could lead to the establishment of a facility for manufacturing and repair and overhaul work in China, most likely close to Shanghai. On the technology front, investment has also been made in developing new high-velocity oxygen fuel (HVOF) spray and shot-peen processes. This has great potential both to increase production rates, and also to serve as an environmentally friendly alternative to traditional chrome plating, which is fast going out of favor in the aerospace sector. The processes are just being started at Sargent’s Torrance, California factory, where it makes various fasteners and bearings. Following imminent approval by Boeing, Messier Dowty and manufacturing standards group Nadcap, HVOF should be ready

for full production in August. Still said the new approach could save three to six weeks for producing components for the 787 and A350, and he intends to extend its use to Tucson. Sargent also is in the final stages of bringing its new Kahr bearing liner for helicopters to market. “This should be ready for flight testing in the early part of the fourth quarter [of 2011] and it is performing better than we had thought [in ground tests],” said Still. The company also is seeing sustained recovery in its aftermarket business. Its focus here is to seek out high-value, niche overhaul and repair tasks in areas such as bearings, fasteners and engine rings for aircraft such as A320s, 737s and 777s now approaching the end of their warranty periods. o

Rafael adds functionality to its Litening reconn pod by Chris Pocock

Continued on page 50 u

The Rafael’s new Imilite ISR exploitation system makes possible multi-sensor feeds and fusion. A Litening III navigation and targeting pod hangs from the forward left fuselage station of a UK Royal Air Force Tornado strike fighter. It is used to guide direct smart weapons such as the Enhanced Paveway IV bomb that is carried on the forward right station.

Iron Dome from Rafael proves its worth in Israel by David Donald Having been developed in some urgency, Rafael’s Iron Dome dual-mission defense system is now operational, and in April an Israel Defense Forces (IDF) battery proved its worth for the first time when several Grad rockets were intercepted after launch from the Gaza Strip into southern Israel. The IDF currently has two batteries in place, protecting the cities of Ashkalod and Be’er Sheva, and is in production with another four or five batteries to widen the area that can be protected. Ultimately Israel hopes to have 10 to 15 batteries and plans to invest nearly $1 billion in the program. At least $205 million of that is coming from the U.S., that amount being allocated by Congress toward

RAFAEL

major partner on the Litening. The U.S. market and FMS sales account for more than half of all sales. Other partners are Zeiss in Germany, and Ultra Electronics of the UK, which has provided an alternative narrowband datalink to one designed by the Israelis. Imagery from the Litening III over Iraq and Afghanistan has been downlinked directly to forward air controllers for target verification and direction. Now comes the Litening IV, in which the sensors have improved range and accuracy, according to Haim Jacobovitz, vice president and general manager for Rafael’s NCW sector. Also, he told AIN, image-matching and processing

CHRIS POCOCK

Haifa, Israel-based Rafael Advanced Defense Systems is promoting a new version of the very successful Litening pod here at Paris, after celebrating the 1,000th sale of this targeting and navigation system. It has also developed a multi-sensor ground station from one that it previously built to handle imagery from the Rafael Reccelite reconnaissance pod. First produced in 1992, Litening pods have been sold to 26 countries and integrated on some 22 different aircraft, mostly fighters but also the U.S. Air Force’s mighty B-52. With its third-generation FLIR, improved CCD sensor for the visible spectrum, electronic image stabilization and dualwavelength laser, the Litening III offered a step-change in capability when it became available five years ago. Rafael claims that the Litening was the first pod to incorporate a FLIR sensor with a wide field-of-view to provide a display on the pilot’s HUD to enable low-level navigation at night. The system can also provide air-to-air capability by detecting targets at beyond visual range. Northrop Grumman provided the FLIR and has been a

Iron Dome development and production in April. Development of Iron Dome began in January 2008 to meet a variety of threats. It can be used in the V-SHORAD role against traditional air threats and as a counter-rockets-and-mortar (C-RAM) system. Each battery has 20 Tamir interceptor vehicles and can be carried on military vehicles for rapid redeployment. With the battery in place and communications antennas raised, the system can be linked to the command/control network and be ready to fire in around two minutes. Targets can be engaged at ranges from four to at least 70 kilometers, and the interceptor is designed to destroy the incoming threat rather than deflect it, an

Continued on page 50 u

48 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Rafael Can Help Partners Stretch Budget and Technology Gaps In defense terms, few would question the proposition is very open to work-share partnerships and joint ventures. that the state of Israel punches above its weight. And the “A key issue today is the fact that governments in many same could well be said of its defense companies. Take countries are suffering from a lack of budget,” said Biran. Rafael, for example. “Countries can decide that they won’t invest everything in “I am running a boutique [defense company], we’re not active capability on their own and will instead share techNorthrop Grumman,” Rafael’s chairman Ilan nology because no one can develop everything Biran told AIN, pointing out that most of its acthese days. But local production is also a big tivities are confined to research and developissue and we are happy to work that way.” ment and low-rate-of-production programs. Having started life as a national defense That’s true, but despite having fewer than laboratory, Rafael’s core mission has always 7,000 employees, Rafael has built an impresbeen to use innovation to bolster Israel’s desive position in the air defense and air superifenses. In this respect, explained Biran, the ority sectors that has drawn it into partnership company has always had the view that its techwith the mighty U.S. group. Biran and his team nology needs to be at least a generation ahead Ilan Biran, are here in Paris to show off Rafael’s technolof whatever its enemies might have at their Rafael chairman ogy portfolio and to remind the world that it disposal. That means working to a five-year has ambitions in the export market and is very open to part- business plan, while also considering research-and-develnership in an environment of fast-changing military require- opment objectives in terms of at least 10-year periods, and ments. The company’s extensive Le Bourget exhibit features developing manpower and leadership capability with a view its air-to-air and air-to-ground weapons, as well as compre- to the next 20 years. hensive array of C4ISR and electronic warfare technology. Biran told AIN that proving the operational value of the Currently, about 60 percent of Rafael’s income comes Iron Dome defense system had been “a real breakthrough” from exports and Biran wants to grow this to at least 70 for Rafael. He predicted that programs such as the David’s percent. He believes that today’s squeezed defense budgets Sling air defense system will also be a game-changer in could bring more nations to its door, looking for ways to providing “the ultimate solution” to knocking out just about harness its technology to modernize their defenses. Rafael any ballistic missile (see main story). –C.A.

What powers them both is the same advanced thinking.

Our expertise in civil and defence aero engines spans the globe. Rolls-Royce invests over ÂŁ900 million annually in research and development, with two-thirds of it aimed at improving the environmental performance of our products. Our civil engines portfolio and the comprehensive services we provide have created a customer base of more than

www.rolls-royce.com

650 airlines, freight operators and lessors. In defence, we are Europeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s leading manufacturer of military engines, powering around 25 per cent of the worldâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s fleet. Our focused research and advanced thinking provide reliability, integrity and innovation in aerospace power.

Trusted to deliver excellence

YOUR AEROSPACE INNOVATION COULD CHANGE THE WORLD Discover aerospace manufacturing technologies—made better Dedicated aerospace manufacturing technologies centre Experts in metallics and composite technologies Stronger, lighter, less expensive aerospace components

uContinued from page 48 has been added within the pod, which provides additional functionality, such as missile launch detection. The Litening IV pod’s external dimensions are unchanged. The new version is already in production for the Israeli air force and has been offered to India, Jacobovitz added. The use of the Litening III and similar, competing pods in a non-traditional intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance (NTISR) role has been well publicized. Fighters patrolling over Afghanistan have provided overwatch for convoys and helped to detect IEDs. Jacobovitz does not discount the pod’s value in this application, but he is keen to tout the merits of the dedicated recce pod that Rafael developed from the Litening. This is the RecceLite, which offers advantages such as geo-referencing and a wideband datalink that allows for image processing on

the ground. “A number of our Litening III customers–including Germany, the Netherlands, India and Spain–have additionally bought RecceLite,” he noted. The eight customers for RecceLite also bought Rafael’s ground station. Now this has been further developed to receive, process and exploit imagery from other sensors. The Imilite system can handle video and SAR/GMTI radar imagery, as well as EO/IR imagery, on one desktop. “We’ve spent a huge amount on image processing because there is so much value to be added there and nobody was really doing fusion,” Jacobovitz said. The Imilite system can combine nonimagery data such as targets, threats, COMINT detection and mission status within the operator’s workflow. It can generate a variety of standard and tailored reports, including annotated maps, data overlays from geo-spatial intelligence systems and visual aids. The German air force has bought and deployed the Imilite system to Afghanistan, where it is processing multiple imagery feeds from the Tornado and the Heron UAV. o

Rafael Iron Dome proves its worth

Your vision. Our solution.

Contact our team: 1-877-NRC-CNRC | nrc.gc.ca/business

v2e_IAR-Paris_ad_BW-12024-E.indd 3

Rafael updates Litening pod

11-06-01 11:23 AM

David’s Sling employs a two-stage Stunner hit-to-kill interceptor with radar and electro-optical guidance, offering a range of up to 170 kilometers. Five flight uContinued from page 48 tests have been undertaken so far to test important consideration when the threat the interceptor’s control system, the most of chemical and biological warheads is recent in January. Later this year Rafael present. The system can launch multiple and Raytheon will conduct the first intercept tests. Around nine such trials are interceptors to handle salvo attacks. Iron Dome has aroused significant planned and they will include multiple interest around the world, including that launches. Initial operational capability for from the U.S. The recent operational David’s Sling is set for the end of 2012, and Rafael expects to receive a low-rate-initial-production conIsrael now has two Iron Dome tract in the coming months. batteries in place to protect cities in the south from rocket attacks.

debut has underlined the successful test campaign, which has achieved 100 percent success so far in nearly 40 launches against a wide range of threat types. David’s Sling

www.BJTonline.com 50 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Israel is implementing a three-layered air defense system to protect its territory. Iron Dome forms the lower tier of the system, while IAI’s Arrow defends the upper tier. Occupying the middle zone will be the David’s Sling ballistic missile defense system, codeveloped by Rafael as prime contractor with Raytheon, and on behalf of both the Israel Missile Defense Organization and the U.S. Missile Defense Agency.

Spyder

Iron Dome and David’s Sling are both IDF programs, but with significant export potential. Rafael has also developed a mobile air defense system aimed at export customers, under the acronym Spyder (Surface-to-air Python DERby). As its name suggests, it is based on the company’s Derby active-radar guided missile and similar Python 5 weapon with imaging infra-red seeker, which were initially developed for air-launched employment. Rafael has developed two Spyder systems. Spyder SR is a shortrange, 360-degree, slant-launched system with a five-second reaction time, while Spyder MR is a vertical-launched medium-range system with two-second reaction time. Both are self-propelled and capable of fully networked operation. Spyder has been selected by a number of armed forces, including India, which already uses Derby in its air-to-air application. o

AEROSPACE

NEW TOOLS FOR NEW RULES

Virtual Training

Visit us at PARIS AIR SHOW 2011 ISRAEL PAVILION

Comprehensive Pilot Training School Count on Elbit Systems' Cost-Effective Solution for a Total Training Experience TARGOTM Helmet

Full Mission Simulator

Elbit Systems provides a comprehensive approach for all levels of aircrew training, from selection through operational training of ﬁghter, helicopter and multi-engine crews. Elbit Systems' solution includes School Management, Aircraft Service Provision, Logistics Services and Finance- all at best value to the customer.

W®

With the Comac C919, China eyes the big time by Bernard Fitzsimons China’s new single-aisle aircraft, the Comac C919, has amassed its first 100 orders and a heavyweight team of international suppliers as it heads for a scheduled first flight just three years from now and service entry in 2016. Only a scale model is on show here at Le Bourget this week, but the program represents nothing less than China’s first serious bid to hit the international air transport big time. The Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China (Hall 5, Stand B244) was established in May 2008 with former defense technology minister Zhang Qingwei as chairman. Its aim is to help meet the country’s need for large numbers of new aircraft to connect fast-growing cities in farflung provinces. Last November, while formally launching the C919 at the Zhuhai airshow, the company put the requirement at 2,950 single-aisle 150-seaters, 802 widebodies and 687 regional jets over the next 20 years, based on annual revenue passenger mile growth of 7.7 percent. Comac is responsible for passenger aircraft with 70 seats or more. The other group created at the same time, Aviation Industry Corporation of China (Avic), is responsible for military transports and the MA-60 commercial turboprop. But while Comac will make parts and assemble the C919 at a new Shanghai Aircraft Manufacturing (SAMC) facility in the Pudong district of Shanghai, it is subsidiaries of Avic (Hall 2a, Stand D252) that will supply the bulk of the structure. Xi’an Aircraft (XAC) will make the wings, Chengdu Aircraft the cockpit, Hongdu Aviation in Nanchang the fuselage and Shenyang Aircraft the tail, while Harbin Aircraft supplies composite parts. Alcoa has been working with Comac on new aluminum-lithium alloys and advanced structural concepts since 2009. At the Zhuhai event, Comac showed a full-scale mockup of the forward 75 feet of fuselage, including cockpit and representative cabin. During the following month, the company held rollout ceremonies for a real aluminum-lithium forward fuselage barrel plus sections of the horizontal stabilizer, aft fuselage, pylon and wing. This year the

target is to complete the detailed design of the aircraft. Engine Suppliers

CFM International, the joint venture between GE Aviation and Safran, will supply the C919’s Leap-X1C engines as part of a complete integrated propulsion system. Nacelles and thrust reversers will come from Nexcelle, the joint venture formed by Safran subsidiary Aircelle and GE Aviation’s Middle River Aircraft Systems unit. CFM and Avic Commercial Aircraft Engine (ACAE) will build a final assembly line and engine test facility. Aircelle and XAC are establishing a joint venture to make thrust reverser and door subassemblies and assemble thrust reversers, air inlets and fan cowls. Another Safran subsidiary, Labinal, is forming a joint venture with SAMC that will focus on electrical wiring interconnection systems. Italy’s Avio is positioning itself as a supplier of combustors, having signed a memorandum of understanding with ACAE and another with Xi’an Aero Engine covering the establishment of a center of excellence for combustor design and manufacture. Landing Gear and Wheels

Liebherr-Aerosapce Lindenburg and Avic Landing Gear Advanced Manufacturing will build the landing gear in Changsha, which will also be the site for wheel and brake production by a joint venture involving Honeywell Aerospace, Hunan Boyun New Materials and Changsha Xinhang Wheel & Brake. Michelin will supply Air X radial tires. Liebherr-Aerospace Toulouse will produce the integrated air management system using components supplied by Nanjing Engineering Institute of Aircraft System. Parker Aerospace is responsible for the fuel, inerting and hydraulic systems through a joint venture with Avic Systems, and for the FCS actuators–business expected to be worth more than $4 billion to the U.S. company. Moog will cooperate with Avic’s Qing’an Group on the high-lift system, including flap and slat actuators, pilot interfaces and electronic controls. Including the wheels and

52 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

At right, Safran CEO Jean-Paul Herteman (left) hosts a visit by Comac president Jin Zhuanglong to the new CFM56 final assembly line at Snecma’s Villaroche plant. CFM’s Leap-X1C will power the C919.

brakes, Honeywell has contracts worth an estimated $11.3 billion covering the fly-bywire flight control system, 1319[C9C] auxiliary power unit and Laseref VI inertial reference system. The FCS letter of intent was signed with Avic Electronics Group, and Honeywell plans to establish a joint venture with Avic’s Flight Automatic Control Research Institute. The APU partner is Avic Harbin Dongan Engine. Crane Aerospace & Electronics will provide the brake control system. Avionics Suppliers

Apart from its involvement in the engine, GE Aviation is partnering with Avic Systems to develop the avionics core processing, display, onboard maintenance and flight recording systems via the new GE-Avic Civil Avionics Systems joint venture. Eaton and Shanghai Aviation Electric will make the cockpit panel assemblies and dimming control system, a program estimated to be worth more than $425 million over a production run of 2,500 aircraft. Another $1.8 billion could come from the production and aftermarket support of fuel and hydraulic conveyance systems through a joint venture with SAMC. Rockwell Collins will contribute communication and navigation systems with China Electronics Technology Avionics (CETCA), the aircraft simulator (with Xi’an Simulation Science and Technology) and the cabin core and optional in-flight entertainment systems (with Shanghai Aero MeasurementControlling Research Institute) using a distributed passenger address system from Cobham. It will also supply an integrated surveillance system (with China Leihua Electronic Technology Research Institute) combining weather radar, TCAS, mode-S and TAWS. United Technologies subsidiary Hamilton Sundstrand stands to earn upward of $1.5

billion from the program. As well as the electric power generation and distribution system, to be supplied through a joint venture with Avic Electromechanical Systems (Avic EM), it will provide the ram-air turbine emergency power system. In addition, Hamilton Sundstrand’s Kidde Aerospace & Defense unit is developing the C919’s integrated fire and overheat protection system, while its France-based Ratier-Figeac unit will supply pilot controls, including the sidesticks and thrust control quadrant. The electric power joint venture is to be based in Xi’an, and development of the facility was due to begin this month. Interior Furnishings

In the cabin, linings, luggage bins, galleys and lavatories will be produced in Zhenjiang by a new subsidiary of Austria’s FACC, which itself was acquired by Avic Aircraft in 2009. CETCA is working with Thales on a range of IFE systems, and with Panasonic Avionics on an external communications system that will support cellphone and Internet access for passengers. Zodiac Aerospace subsidiary Monogram Systems will provide the water and waste systems. Just last month, Michelin was selected to develop and supply its Air X radial tires for the C919. This is the French company’s first involvement in a Chinese aircraft program and builds on an alliance it established with Comac back in November 2009. On the human resources side, Pratt & Whitney recently signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Comac to provide leadership training for senior executives and mid-level managers, as well as project management training and training in skills needed to achieve competitive excellence. The programs are targeted at those executives and other employees with high potential and are scheduled

to begin in mid-year. They will be conducted by Pratt & Whitney’s customer training center in collaboration with UTC sibling Hamilton Sundstrand. Despite all the joint ventures and internal modernization, Comac remains a distinctively Chinese endeavor. “Chinese characteristics” heads the list of basic principles for developing the C919: “We should set our footing on the practical situations in China, leverage on the whole nation’s strengths and wisdom, and bring into full play the political superiority of the socialist system which is capable of concentrating all of its resources in achieving great things.” The designation itself combines C for China with a 9 that signifies enduring or long-lasting plus 19 to represent the maximum passenger load of 190. The largely symbolic launch orders, half of them firm and half options, came from the country’s three biggest airlines– Air China, China Eastern and China Southern–plus Hainan Airlines, Chinese lessor CDB Leasing and GECAS. But Comac’s target is to sell more than 2,000 copies of the C919, and China’s aerospace ambitions go far beyond that. Medium-term goals include developing a Chinese engine to power the C919 from 2020. Meanwhile, the company is exploring the twin-aisle C929, with up to 290 seats, and has already carried out preliminary tests in DNW’s high-speed wind tunnel in Amsterdam. o

NEED SOMEONE TO DEPEND ON FOR AFTERMARKET SUPPORT? WE’RE RIGHT ALONGSIDE. Goodrich is one of the largest providers of aftermarket support and MRO services in the world. Our global network includes asset stocking and MRO facilities ideally positioned to deliver the solutions you need. Together with teams ready to support you 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Whatever your platforms or aftermarket requirements, you can depend on Goodrich. Contact us today at www.goodrich.com See us at the Paris Air Show – Static Display L98

We’re on it.™

right attitude/right approach/right alongside

news clips

Dassault has designed and certified a fix for the runaway elevator trim control experienced by a Falcon 7X in late May.

z Piaggio Celebrates Groundbreaking of Plant Piaggio Aero (Static Display T19) last week broke ground for a new factory, which will produce subassemblies and parts for the A180 Avanti II twin turboprop. The new facility, which will be located at Villanova d’Albenga, Italy, is scheduled to be operational by 2013. The company said it will “increase production-line efficiency and speed up lean manufacturing cycles” compared with the current Finale Ligure plant. The move will mark the end of the company’s 100-year association with the Finale Ligure plant, where it built some 55 examples of aircraft. Final assembly of the Avanti II, which has a 402-knot (Mach 0.7) maximum cruise speed, will remain at the company’s Genova Sestri Ponente facility. “I’m proud that Piaggio Aero is able to continue its industrial expansion in Italy, and with the great support of our primary international shareholders–Mubadala and Tata–will continue down the path of sustained future growth,” said Piaggio Aero Industries chairman Piero Ferrari.

z Mitsubishi Lands Third Customer for MRJ Mitsubishi Aircraft Corp. has signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Hong Kong-based aircraft lease and maintenance company ANI Group Holdings covering a firm order for five of its new MRJ regional jets. ANI Group currently leases aircraft to five Indonesian airlines. The Japanese airframer called the new order an important first step toward cultivating the fast-growing Asian market for Mitsubishi Aircraft. Until the ANI signing, Japan’s ANA stood as the only Asian customer for the MRJ. Neither ANI nor Mitsubushi specified which variant of the MRJ– the MRJ70 or MRJ90–the MOU covers. However, ANI said it would consider placing an order for 20 more airplanes once Mitsubishi launches a 100-seat version, now known as the MRJ-100X. Mitsubishi Aircraft has collected firm orders from ANA for 15 airplanes, along with options on another 10, and for 50 airplanes from Trans States Airlines of the U.S., which also holds options on another 50.

z Cebu Pacific Signs MOU for 30 A321neos Airbus got a jumpstart on its goal of boosting the backlog for its new A320neo family of airliners to 500 orders by the end of this year’s Paris Air Show by signing a deal with Cebu Pacific earlier this week. The Philippines-based carrier has signed a memorandum of understanding with Airbus for the purchase of 30 A321neos. The carrier has also exercised existing options for seven more standard A320s, increasing to 41 the total number of airplanes it has ordered from the Airbus single-aisle product line. The aircraft will join an existing fleet of A319s and A320s flying on the low-fare carrier’s domestic and regional network. Cebu Pacific’s network covers 33 domestic and 16 international destinations, including Osaka, Seoul, Beijing, Jakarta, Bangkok and Singapore. The largest model in the A320neo series, the A321neo claims fuel savings of 15 percent and additional range capability of over 500 nm (950 kilometers), or the ability to carry two tons more payload at a given range. The fuel savings alone translate into 3,600 fewer metric tons of CO2 per aircraft per year, claims Airbus.

54 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Dassault boss upbeat on Falcon bizjets, Rafale by Chris Pocock Dassault chairman and CEO Charles Edelstenne was in a typically upbeat mood at the company’s pre-show media briefing on Friday. Development of the Falcon super mid-size (SMS) and 2000S business jets is proceeding apace, and sales of the company’s existing business jets are slowly recovering. The Rafale fighter has again proven itself in combat, this time over Libya, and the export market still beckons. Cooperation with BAE Systems on the medium-altitude, long-endurance (MALE) drone is ready to go. Edelstenne said that all the structure and the main systems suppliers for the SMS have now been selected–although Dassault still has not revealed their identities. The initial digital model and high- and low-speed wind-tunnel validation have been completed. The prototype will fly in 2014, with deliveries two years later. Meanwhile, the Falcon 2000S entry-level model should be certified by the end of next year. At a price of “less than $25 million,” it will offer superior airfield, climb and cruise performance and specific fuel consumption that beats smaller jets, Edelstenne claimed. Initiatives to improve the existing range include maximum takeoff weight increases; certification for steep glideslope approaches; Category 3 HUD; and the Falcon Broadcast System, a real-time reporting system for in-flight failures, which is being trialed by 10 Falcon operators. The EASy 2 newgeneration cockpit has just been certified for the Falcon 90, and approvals for the Falcon 7X and 2000 are to follow in mid-2012. Looking further ahead, the company is working on technology initiatives for the next

generation of Falcon jets, such as new control laws for the aircraft on the ground; laminar flow; a composite wing box; and Clean Sky research. China has been the leading market for the company’s business jets this year, and Edelstenne noted with approval the country’s recent progress in developing airrelated infrastructure and in regulatory reform. “The pre-owned market is beginning to show signs

CHRIS POCOCK

Embraer Defense and Security has selected LiebherrAerospace to provide the environmental and cabin pressure control system for the KC-390 military airlifter. The systems will be developed and manufactured in Toulouse, France, and will feature integrated control architecture combined with highreliability lightweight pneumatic and mechanical components. According to Francis Niss, president of Liebherr-Aerospace & Transportation SAS, the systems “will provide crew and troops with the most advanced air management system, enabling optimized conditions, as well as proven robustness under all of the aircraft’s operating situations,” The KC-390 is due to make a first flight in 2014 and enter service in the following year.

MARK WAGNER

z Liebherr Joins Embraer’s KC-390 Team

Dassault chairman and CEO Charles Edelstenne is feeling good about his company’s bizjets and Rafale fighter.

of life,” he continued. But the weakness of the U.S. dollar versus the euro still disturbs the Dassault boss because “this imbalance translates into a roughly 40-percent penalty for the French share of our production costs.” Highlights of the Rafale

combat jet’s performance over Libya have included seven-hour, buddy-refueled missions and a record-setting 57-kilometer range achieved by an AASM-guided bomb when attacking a tank. All the Scalp missiles that were fired hit their targets, Edelstenne noted. Since the French were first into the fight, before Libya’s air defense system was degraded by NATO attacks, the Rafale’s Spectra self-defense system was truly proved in action, he added (see pages 72 to 76). With the Rafale now in head-to-head competition against the Eurofighter Typhoon for the prized order of 126 from India, Edelstenne could not resist an invitation to make some comparisons. He claimed that the Rafale was ahead on the technical evaluation. As for cost, the federal nature of the Eurofighter consortium, with no prime contractor responsible, would count against the Typhoon, he believes. “I’m more than optimistic,” he continued. But Edelstenne admitted that the offset provisions in the Indian requirement are tough. “First I want to win, then we will negotiate,” he said. Elsewhere, the UAE might still become the first export customer for the Rafale, Edelstenne suggested. Brazil would not decide until 2012 at the earliest. Switzerland went unmentioned by the Dassault boss, but other company officials have been encouraged by a recent vote by the federal parliament there to resume the evaluation of a new combat aircraft. From current French orders alone, production of the Rafale is assured until at least 2018, at the current rate of 11 per year. “Beyond that, French air force requirements indicate that deliveries could continue until 2025,” Edelstenne added. As for the new Franco-British cooperation on the Mantis MALE drone, now renamed Telemos, BAE Systems will be the prime contractor while Dassault takes charge of the systems. o

Fix in Hand for Falcon 7X Trim Fault A fix has been designed and certified for the runaway elevator trim control that was experienced by a Falcon 7X in late May. Dassault chairman and CEO Charles Edelstenne said the aircraft was grounded by EASA at Dassault’s behest. “We immediately mobilized all the resources at our disposal to identify the cause of this malfunction and develop a solution,” he said. The long-range business jet’s fly-by-wire system was not to blame, he continued. All 112 aircraft in the fleet must be modified at the company’s maintenance centers, but the first few have already been done, he added. Additional layers of protection have been added to the pitch trim system, a company statement added. –C.P.

Cockpit 4000 refreshes C-130s as FMS and EFB demand grows by Matt Thurber At this year’s Paris Air Show, Esterline CMC Electronics (Hall 5 Stand 242) is showing, for the first time, the Cockpit 9000 avionics suite selected as an upgrade for Lockheed Martin C-130 cockpits. CMC also is highlighting the Cockpit

4000 system, the SmartDeck general aviation integrated avionics suite, recent FMS wins, the TacView military EFB and a new addition to the executive team, Claude Chidiac, vice president of customer support and strategic development.

www.migavia.ru

56 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

“The C-130 market has been a real strength for CMC,” said president Greg Yeldon. So far the system has been installed in seven C-130s–six for the Royal Saudi Air Force and one for the Fuerza Aérea de Chile. The Royal Saudi Air Force has a total of 23 orders and Chile two for the Cockpit 9000, and there are 10 international customers. Hundreds of C-130s qualify for the Cockpit 9000 package, said Yeldon. “We see more opportunity out there and we’re working hard at those.” The all-digital Cockpit 9000 suite is built around the company’s latest gener-

CMC’s FMS on the Sukhoi Superjet 100, which was certified in Russia in January, is also installed on the Sikorsky Black Hawk and a number of Eurocopter helicopters. “We see a lot of opportunity on the FMS front for retrofits,” he said. On the military front, CMC’s TacView portable mission display “is gaining a significant amount of acceptance within the military community,” according to Yeldon. “There has been a lot of activity this year.” In fact, CMC already has a contract from Northrop Grumman to supply TacView for the U.S. Air National Guard and Air Force Reserve Command real-time information in the cockpit (RTIC) program. The contract covers dual installations of the TacView system on board a total of 32 C-130H aircraft, with deliveries already begun this month and planned for completion by October. The touchscreen TacView display is night-vision compatible and offers a variety of Hundreds of Lockheed C-130 Hercules provide a lucrative market for capabilities for displaying misEsterline CMC’s Cockpit 9000 avionics suite. sion information, including ation flight management system (FMS)– moving maps with tactical overlays, misthe CMA-9000. This FMS has been sion planning, navigation and approach certified by Transport Canada with fully charts, checklists, live video and CMC’s coupled vertical-navigation capability for I-Series enhanced vision system. the Sukhoi Superjet 100. The Superjet Esterline CMC’s commercial EFBs 100 is equipped with dual installation have been installed in more than 40 aircraft CMA-9000 FMSs, which includes multi- types, and Yeldon doesn’t see Apple’s iPad sensor-based navigation and enhanced affecting CMC’s EFB business. “We’re in operational capability. the higher-end Class 2 [and 3] EFB marThe Cockpit 4000, a fully integrated ket,” he said, “which is still demanding glass cockpit featuring CMC’s Sparrow- aviation-grade certified products. The cusHawk HUD, is designed for the trainer mar- tomers we’re talking to, the positions we’re ket and is on display in a number of aircraft on, they’re not seeing the iPad as an alterat the Paris Air Show, including the Hawker native. There is a difference in terms of the Beechcraft T-6B and AT-6. The Cockpit level of certification that our customers 4000 also flies in or has been ordered for want from our product.” the Pilatus PC-7, PC-9M and PC-21, AerIn the aerospace marketplace, macchi M-311, Korea Aerospace Indus- Esterline CMC is benefiting from growth tries KT-1C and BAE Hawk in the airline and military segMk51/A and Mk66. So far, ments, while business aviaCMC has delivered more than tion remains stable, although 200 Cockpit 4000 systems to Yeldon said, “that is starting Hawker Beechcraft. to turn in the right direction.” Another Paris first for CMC CMC’s revenues are split Esterline is the SmartDeck inte50/50 between commercial grated cockpit, which CMC and military markets. “We’re licensed from L-3 Avionics last not dependent on one cusOctober. “We have been trantomer or one key program,” sitioning that into CMC since he said. “The military trainer October and that’s going very program is important to us. well,” Yeldon said. No OEM The retrofit portion, as budCMC TacView portable has selected SmartDeck yet, mission display is gaining gets are under pressure, reprehe said, “but there’s been a favor with the military. sents an opportunity to CMC. lot of activity surrounding Large new aircraft builds may this acquisition and everything’s been pos- be slowing down, but aircraft need to be itive with respect to the response from the upgraded to meet current requirements.” market and the opportunities that I see CMC has not yet tapped the growing for us.” CMC is retaining the SmartDeck unmanned aerial system market, but “it’s name for the avionics system, which brings on a watch list,” said Yeldon. “As UAVs technologies like synthetic vision, an intu- fly more in commercial airspace they’re itive user interface, electronic charts, data- going to need more commercial capabillink weather and enhanced vision system ity. It’s not a market that we’re in today, to general aviation cockpits. but is something we have looked at.” o CMC Esterline’s key FMS product line continues to develop and will incorporate NextGen capabilities as the FAA’s new air traffic control system phases into widespread use over the coming decade.

Thinking without limits

The Future of the Helicopter begins here. Paris Airshow - Hall 2a - Stand A253

Persistence brings new rewards for airship and hybrid projects by Chris Pocock development schedule as “very aggressive,” but nevertheless completed the critical design review of the LEMV last February. Hybrid Air Vehicles was due to deliver the engines, propulsion ducts, bow thrusters, fuel tanks and payload module from the UK last month. The fabric and envelope are being manufactured in the U.S. Northrop Grumman said it would inflate the hull this spring, fly the LEMV by late summer and ferry it to the Yuma Proving Ground for customer trials in November. Early next year, it would deploy to Afghanistan for a Joint Military Utility Assessment. Hull inflation has apparently slipped into the summer, but Northrop Grumman was not able to provide further comment in time for this article. Blue Devil 2

Meanwhile, the U.S. Air Force is sponsoring what looks like a very similar demonstration, at much lower cost. A contract worth $86.2 million has gone to Mav6, a three-year-old company that is now led by the Air Force’s former ISR chief, Dave Deptula. Mav6 describes itself as an “agile systems integrator” that customizes offthe-shelf equipment to rapidly equip frontline units with innovative new systems to fight an asymmetric enemy. Mav6 plans to add a suite of sensors to a conventional airship that would fly at 20,000 feet for up to seven days. It also is to be deployed to Afghanistan for trials early next year. The project is dubbed Blue Devil 2, after the comic-book superhero. It is related to Blue Devil 1, a separate contract that was awarded to SAIC, to integrate and operate wide-area full-motion video and COMINT sensors on a King Air aircraft. The airship will be provided by TCOM, which is best known as a supplier of tethered aerostats, but which has also produced the Skyship series of airships. However, the “Polar 1000” design that TCOM is building for Blue Devil 2 is much larger–370 feet long with an envelope volume of 1,400,000 cu ft. “It’s the biggest airship since the 1960s. Fabrication is in progress and we expect to fly in September,” said Mav6 vice president business development Dave Bithner. He told AIN that by using a traditional hull the company can focus on its specialty–customizing and integrating the wide-area sensors and the communications architecture. In particular, there will be sophisticated onboard data processing and storage so that users on the ground can “pull” the information as required down austere datalinks. Not everyone is convinced that the LEMV and Blue Devil 2 demonstrations will succeed. Ed Herlik is a former U.S. Air Force pilot and engineer, who studies UAVs and lighter-than-air technology for the Market Intel Group (see box).

Continued on page 60 u

58 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

NORTHROP GRUMMAN

A comeback for airships? How many times have you heard that before? However, thanks to generous funding by the Pentagon, four separate projects to develop very large buoyant air vehicles for unmanned persistent surveillance missions are under way in the U.S. Three of them are to take to the air within the next few months. Leading the way is Northrop Grumman’s Long Endurance Multi-Intelligence Vehicle (LEMV), which the company describes as “a revolutionary concept that will shape the future of ISR.” It’s not actually an airship, although it has a nonrigid envelope that is inflated with helium. In fact, the elliptical and cambered shape gains up to 40 percent of its forward lift through aerodynamics. This is a big beast– 300 feet long, 113 feet wide and 85 feet high, with an envelope volume of 1,340,000 cu ft. That is longer than a football field and taller than a seven-story building. The LEMV is powered by four 350-horsepower supercharged diesel engines, housed in vectoring ducts with blown vanes that direct the thrust for takeoff and landing. Pneumatic tubes contained within skids on the underside of the two outer hulls facilitate the landing by “sucking” the vehicle to the ground and securing it. Unlike an airship, therefore, the LEMV has no need for a network of enormous mooring masts or winch-and-cable arrangements. British company Hybrid Air Vehicles developed this design and is the most significant subcontractor to Northrop Grumman. The U.S. Army Space and Missile Defense Command (USASMDC) is sponsoring development of the LEMV. In June 2010, it awarded Northrop Grumman a contract worth $517 million for “up to three” systems. “This opportunity leverages our leadership positions in UAVs, C4ISR systems and integration, and moves Northrop Grumman into this rapidly emerging market space of airships for the military and homeland defense arenas,” commented Gary Ervin, president of Northrop Grumman’s Aerospace Systems sector. The LEMV is supposed to fly at altitudes up to 22,000 feet for 21 days at a time. It can be optionally piloted for long ferry flights to the region of operation. The maximum speed is 80 knots and the loiter speed is just 30 knots, with low-speed control provided by bow thrusters. The payload is a mix of sensors, such as radar, SIGINT and full-motion video, weighing up to 2,750 pounds in total. An openarchitecture design provides plug-and-play capability so that new sensors can easily be added, according to Northrop Grumman. The LEMV can be operated from the Army’s Universal Ground Control Station and its data will be fed to the Army version of the U.S. military’s standard processing and exploitation system (DCGS). Northrop Grumman described the

The U.S. Army has sponsored development of a hybrid airship under the Long-Endurance Multi-Intelligence Vehicle (LEMV) program. Built by Northrop Grumman and based on a British design, the 300-foot-long machine is due to fly this summer and deploy to Afghanistan next winter.

Commercial Markets Will Drive Stratospheric UAV Demand Stratospheric UAVs–mostly airships–that stay airborne flying for months or years will form a new communications and sensing infrastructure, according to the Market Intel Group (www.marketintelgroup.com). Government contracts are funding development of such UAVs at present, but commercial markets will eventually dwarf defense requirements. “There’s a huge commercial potential, especially in those regions that have not developed alternative ground-based infrastructure, such as Africa, China or India,” said analyst Ed Herlik. He estimated the commercial market potential at $250 billion, versus only $2 billion for defense. The applications include mobile telephony, wireless Internet, direct broadcast television and radio, and overhead imagery. Herlik’s latest report for the Market Intel Group examines the potential payloads: “How and where the money will be made,” he said. A number of mostly small and secretive companies are eyeing the potential, Herlik added. They include Swiss-domiciled StratXX and Global Near Space Services of the U.S. According to the latter’s Web site, the U.S. Naval Air War- Stratospheric airships cost so much less than satellites that fare Center awarded the company they have the potential to exploit a $250 billion market for communications services, according to the Market Intel Group. a contract to begin development of its StarLight stratoship, which would fly at 85,000 feet. Herlik said the optimum altitude for stratospheric airship UAVs is 65,000 feet. Notions of going higher are unrealistic because the gas volume of an airship (for example, the helium) doubles every 10,000 feet above 50,000 feet. But one potential drag on developments is regulatory–gaining permission from airspace authorities for these type of operations. As for the defense markets, “near-space UAVs will draw orders away from both the high-altitude [Reaper] and jet-stream [Global Hawk] markets,” Herlik predicted. -C.P.

Every day, airlines around the globe count on Rockwell Collins to get planes and passengers to their destinations safely and efficiently. From advanced displays and flight controls to our award-winning weather radar and global support network, we provide the critical solutions airlines need to successfully complete their missions. To see where weâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;re headed, visit us at rockwellcollins.com/rely. Visit us at the 2011 Paris Air Show, exhibit hall 4, stand A18.

uContinued from page 58 “They will be vulnerable to attack from the ground,” he told AIN. “Remember that their advertised operating altitude is 20,000 feet above sea level. Many areas of interest in Afghanistan are well over 10,000 feet. Also, terrain masking will negate the value of their wide-area sensors,” he continued. High-altitude Airships

Put us to the aerospace structures and materials test Structural testing on aerospace components large and small, from simple coupons to fullscale aircraft Comprehensive, world-class facilities and equipment Expertise in all aspects of aircraft structures and materials performance Your vision. Our solution.

Contact our team: 1-877-NRC-CNRC | nrc.gc.ca/business

v2e_IAR-Paris_ad_BW-12024-E.indd 4

11-06-01 11:24 AM

Private Lift Every Week BJTwaypoints is the only online newsletter that brings you the passenger the best news in business aviation every single week.

www.BJTwaypoints.com

www.BJTonline.com

60 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

fabrics that can resist persistent exposure to ultraviolet radiation. The Lockheed Martin HALE-D airship is driven by two two-kilowatt electric motors and powered by thin-film solar cells and rechargeable lithium-ion batteries. The ultimate goal for the HAA is an airship that could station-keep at 65,000 feet for months at a time with large multimission payloads. The airship should also be capable of moving to other locations. It would be recoverable to the launch site so that the payloads could be changed and periodic maintenance performed. Although the HALE-D has yet to successfully demonstrate the HAA concept, another Lockheed Martin unit is already under contract to the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) for an ambitious application of stratospheric airships. In April 2009, DARPA awarded a nearly $400 million contract to the Lockheed Martin Skunk Works and Raytheon to produce a radar surveillance platform. This is the Integrated Sensor Is

Herlik’s air force career included work on the promising area of “near-space” surveillance concepts. The concept of using unmanned, electric-powered airships for surveillance and communications at very high altitudes is seductive. They offer huge cost savings over satellites and should also be much cheaper than specialized highaltitude UAVs to deploy and operate. By floating in a geostationary position above the jetstream, an airship could survey a 600-mile diameter area and millions of cubic miles of airspace. One drawback: they must be very large, since a huge volume of helium is required to sustain lift at 70,000 feet. Conventional airships reach their “pressure height”–the altitude at which they must begin to vent helium–at about 10,000 feet. Free-floating bal- Stratospheric airships must be made from high-strength fabrics that can loons are routinely used resist ultraviolet radiation. They must also capture and store solar energy to loft scientific payloads to power lightweight electric motors. This is an artist’s impression of the Lockheed Martin ISIS, which will internally carry a huge Raytheon to very high altitude. surveillance radar to 70,000 feet. In 2005, a small stratospheric airship developed by balloon- Structure (ISIS) program in which a very maker Aerostar, together with Southwest large active-array dual-band radar will be Research Institute, reached 74,000 feet part of the airship structure. “The operational goal for ISIS is to with a 60-pound payload over New Mexico. The sponsor of that effort, named look for airborne and ground-based tarHiSentinel, was the same Army organiza- gets and to communicate directly with tion that is funding the LEMV. In 2008, the battlefield from a single antenna for the USASMDC also took over the high- up to ten years,” said Michael Wechsberg altitude airship (HAA) project that had of Raytheon Space and Airborne Syspreviously been run by the U.S. Missile tems. From 70,000 feet, the ISIS airship Defense Agency. “will have the ability to track the most advanced cruise missiles at 600 kilometers ISIS Program and dismounted enemy combatants at Lockheed Martin has worked on the 300 kilometers,” according to Lockheed HAA project for some years. The compa- Martin. The early concept of integrating ny’s Defense and Surveillance Systems unit the active array into the airship’s surface in Akron, Ohio, has an 80-year heritage area has been dropped. Still, the antenna in lighter-than-air systems and is another must be very large to compensate for the supplier of tethered aerostats. Compared relatively low power that will be available with the company’s aerostats, even the sub- to it. Artists’ concepts show the radar scale high-altitude long endurance-demon- occupying the entire central structure of a strator (HALE-D) airship that Lockheed huge airship. For the ISIS demonstration, Martin has built at Akron for the HAA Lockheed Martin is building a one-third program is more than twice as long–240 scale airship, which is due to fly in 2013. Theoretically, operational airships feet. The hull volume is 500,000 cu ft. The first flight of the HALE-D is developed from the ISIS concept could scheduled for July at Akron. The goal supplant and maybe even replace both is to fly for at least two weeks at 60,000 the E-3 AEW and E-8 JSTARS radar feet, while providing 500 watts of power surveillance aircraft. But there are major to a 50-pound communications relay challenges, such as the further developpayload. The technical challenges for ment of high strength-to-weight matestratospheric airships include developing rials, regenerative fuel cells, lightweight lightweight propulsion units, solar energy antennas, calibration of the antennas and capture and storage, and high-strength a high-bandwidth yet covert datalink. o

LOCKHEED MARTIN

YOUR AEROSPACE INNOVATION COULD CHANGE THE WORLD

Airship, hybrid projects yield new rewards

Towards a safer world.

ONE TEAM Alenia Aeronautica leads the Finmeccanica Aeronautics Sector, a closely coordinated team steeped in world-class technology and experience. Whether it is regional turboprop, a swing-role fighter, an airlifter, a commercial jet, an aircraft tailored for a special mission or an unmanned air system, each product sports the advanced materials, throughlife support, affordability and environmental qualities matured by Alenia Aeronautica and its subsidiaries since the birth of aviation.

Making Ideas Fly

www.alenia.it

development and, more important, substantiation of repairs requires more testing, more analytical tools to validate the repairs,” said Howard. “We took a decision about 12 months ago that we wanted to centralize some of our engineering functions to support those kinds of activities. We’ll be staffing up an organization that over the course of the next three years will grow to 80 or 100 engineers.” Component Capabilities

Chromalloy produces its most recent advanced coating, RT-35 Low K, at its Electron Beam Physical Vapor Disposition (EBPVD) center. The company lays claim to developing the first Deposition EBPVD coatings with ceramic materials in the 1980s.

Chromolloy expands its engine coatings business by Bill Carey Chromalloy, one of the world’s largest independent providers of advanced coatings and repairs for gas turbine engines and a manufacturer of approved engine replacement parts, this year marks its 60th anniversary with ongoing growth and a change in scenery. The company this fall will relocate its corporate headquarters from Orangeburg, New York, to Palm Beach Gardens, Florida. The new site also will serve as an engine technology center of excellence. Formed in 1951 as a researchand-development company in the metals processing field, Chromalloy has grown by partnering with engine original equipment manufacturers. As these OEMs became more aggressive in the engine aftermarket, it developed its own repair and parts design and manufacturing capabilities. On the coatings side, Chromalloy has joint ventures with Rolls-Royce in the UK to provide advanced coatings for RB211 and Trent engine hot sections. In the U.S., it works with Pratt & Whitney to provide thermal barrier protection coatings used in commercial and military engines. It also provides coating services to engine makers Honeywell and GE Aviation. On the repair side, Chromalloy says it has developed 3,000 designated engineering representative (DER) repairs approved by the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration, at a rate of 200 new DERs annually. The company counts more than 300,000 parts manufacturer approval (PMA) engine replacement parts

in operation worldwide. “Through the evolution of 60 years, the business model has developed in many ways from what was an OEM-centric base,” said Peter Howard, Chromalloy vice president of technology and quality assurance. “Today, we are the largest independent provider of aftermarket services, both repairs and replacement parts, but we still maintain close relationships with OEMs.” Chromalloy now employs 4,000 people at 37 locations in 15 countries, with annual revenue of approximately $1 billion. It is part of the Sequa company, which in turn is owned by private equity operation The Carlyle Group. Engine Expertise

The company’s primary focus is on turbine engine hot-section components, in the aft section of an engine where combustion takes place and extreme temperatures are generated. It serves the commercial air-transport, military and industrial gas turbine markets. Commercial aviation represents about 70 percent of its business. “With the advanced engines that are coming out today, the turbine inlet temperatures are about 2,300 degrees Fahrenheit. Those kinds of temperatures are close to the melting point of the material,” Howard told AIN. “Today we’re very focused on thermal barrier coatings and how we allow the turbine components to operate in those kind of temperature environments [for] long periods of time.” In March, Chromalloy unveiled

62 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

plans for a new facility that will serve as a technology center of excellence for gas turbine engine research and development, as well as its new headquarters. The leased 30,000-sq-ft facility in Palm Beach Gardens will be organized with labs, office space and a 10,000-sq-ft warehouse. Meanwhile, manufacturing operations will continue in Orangeburg, where about 350 people are employed. Chromalloy initially expects to employ 52 technical, executive and administrative staff at the new facility. Technical staff at engineering centers throughout the company, including the Turbine Design Analytics Group in Stuart, Florida, will be consolidated at Palm Beach Gardens. “As the engines advance and get more sophisticated, the

Last year, Chromalloy expanded its existing turbine engine component casting operation in Tampa by opening a 150,000-sq-ft investment casting foundry. The Chromalloy Castings center, operational since October, can produce up to one million pounds of superalloy components and parts for turbine engine hot sections, including vanes, nozzles and highpressure turbine blades. “As a company, we have the complete capability not only to design components, but also to do the complete manufacturing of the components through to certification–for example, through the FAA if it’s in the commercial arena,” said Howard. “Chromalloy’s value chain in that regard is unique because even the OEMs don’t have, typically, that value chain. They have to go outside to other companies.” Further expanding in Florida, Chromalloy this February broke ground on a $5 million, 40,000-sq-ft ceramic core facility adjacent to the casting

foundry in Tampa. Ceramic cores are used in the casting process to form cooling cavities within engine components, which is needed for components to operate effectively in hot and highly stressed sections of gas turbines. The ceramic core facility is expected to open early next year. Chromalloy’s BELAC joint venture with Lufthansa Technik and United Airlines, which designs and manufactures turbine engine components, is located nearby in Oldsmar. In still another venture, Chromalloy is partnered with Rolls-Royce as one of several founding industry members developing the Commonwealth Center for Advanced Manufacturing in Crosspointe, Virginia. The research center, a public/private effort involving the University of Virginia, Virginia State University and Virginia Tech, is intended to advance propulsion design and bridge the gap between university research and industry product development. Crosspointe is the site of a new Rolls-Royce engine component manufacturing, assembly and test facility now under development. The 50,000-sq-ft Commonwealth research center will be built on a 20-acre site adjacent to the Rolls-Royce plant. Construction will begin in 2013. “We are driving the coating technology agenda through that venture with Rolls-Royce, and we continue to work with the other OEMs in that advanced coating category,” said Howard. o

Powered glider explores electric flight Looking more like a glider than a single-engine airplane, the two-seat, battery-powered eGenius made its first flight on May 25, from Mindelheim airfield in Bavaria, Germany. Designed by the Institute of Aircraft Design at the University of Stuttgart, the concept aircraft flew for 20 minutes powered by a 60kW electric motor. The design parameters of the eGenius airplane include a max

The University of Stuttgart’s Institute of Aircraft Design is flying the two-seat, battery-operated eGenius to test the efficiency of electric aircraft.

takeoff weight of 1,874 pounds, a cruise speed of up to 127 knots, and a range of 216 nm. Its wingspan is just over 55 feet. The airplane consumes 4.75kW of power (the equivalent of about 0.6 liters of gasoline) per 100 km. “Our most important goal was to demonstrate the efficiency of a modern electric aircraft without making any compromises and not being willing to accept economizing with

the flight performance in terms of today’s state-of-the-art technology,” said Professor Rudolf Voit-Nitschmann of the University of Stuttgart. Further flight testing of eGenius will serve to verify its performance and the reliability of electric propulsion. The composite airplane’s variable-pitch propeller is mounted on the vertical stabilizer. The landing gear is retractable, the batteries are stored behind the pilots’ seats and the pilots have an unobstructed view forward and to the sides. Airbus, the main sponsor of the eGenius project, is examining the long-term potential of electricity as a major source of energy onboard aircraft. The company’s Future Projects teams will analyze data from the aircraft to further develop technology and better understand opportunities. The public debut of the airplane took place Aero-Expo in

In reality, the PurePower Engine already does. ®

Get the free app at http://gettag.mobi

By delivering double-digit fuel burn savings, Pratt & Whitney PurePower Engines provide nextgeneration benefits today. With up to 20% lower operating costs, half the noise and dramatically reduced emissions, these proven, dependable engines save operators up to $1.5 million per aircraft per year. Discover real engines that are flight years ahead. At PurePowerEngines.com.

It’s in our power.™ Visit us at the Paris Air Show next to the UTC Chalet in Static Display F210.

Embraer awaits Boeing move as it mulls narrowbody options by Gregory Polek a relatively lightweight 130Embraer will wait as late as to 150-seat jet or re-engines year-end for Boeing to decide the current 70- to 120-seat on a plan for a 737 replaceE-Jet line. The company now ment before the Brazilian comappears “unmotivated” by the pany commits to a successor for prospect of a new turboprop its own E-Jet family of aircraft, given the relatively small size Embraer executive vice presiof the market and the footdent for the airline market Paulo hold ATR and Bombardier Cesar de Souza e Silva told AIN have achieved in the segment. in an interview ahead of the Paulo Cesar de However, Embraer CEO FredParis Air Show. Still, Embraer Souza e Silva, already knows what it will not Embraer executive v-p erico Curado on several occado: follow Bombardier into a for the airline market sions has expressed distaste for size and range category that, in Silva’s esti- a re-engining the E-Jets, repeatedly refermation, the Airbus A320neo also occupies. ring to them as modern, state-of-the-art “We believe the C Series proposition, aircraft that continue to draw respectin terms of range, is too much,” said able sales interest. Furthermore, as Silva Silva. “Airlines won’t pay for something noted, Embraer’s growth in the commercial airliner segment won’t come from the they will not use.” At 3,400 nm, the range of the Bom- segment of the market it already serves. “If we want to grow the company, we bardier CS300 also places it in a weight category that too closely approaches that definitely will have to move upward,” he of the A320neo, said Silva. Now study- said. “By changing the E-Jets we’re not ing an airplane in the 130- to 150-seat changing the size of this market…And we capacity category, Embraer would dis- continue to have the view that the E-Jet is tinguish its product largely by offering a a modern product with up-to-date [sysless range-capable but lighter airplane. “I tems]…But, of course, we have to look think the sweet spot is about 2,400 nau- ahead. I’m not saying that we would necessarily re-engine the E-Jets now, but we tical miles,” said the Embraer executive. Silva said Embraer’s options have now are looking into that.” Embraer appears to favor waiting until boiled down to whether it introduces

The successor for Embraer’s E-Jet series could be either a new 130to 150-seat model or a re-engined version of the current 70- to 120seat line. The Brazilian airframer is waiting for Boeing to commit to a plan for re-engining or developing a new airplane before announcing its own plans.

the end of the decade to re-engine the E-Jets, after it introduces an all-new product in the 130- to 150-seat category. However, if Boeing doesn’t decide to concentrate its efforts on a slightly larger replacement for the current 737, Embraer’s case for entering the mainline narrowbody market could weaken. “If Boeing does decide and make an announcement this year that they will develop a larger narrowbody [above 150 seats], this is very important information to us,” said Silva. “Because in this scenario, Boeing will not develop a brandnew aircraft in the category of, let’s say, 130, 140 or 150 seats,” leaving more room for Embraer to enter that segment. Although Boeing continues to entertain

the option of re-engining the 737, that company’s CEO, Jim McNerney, has signaled that “the bias” remains on an all-new airplane by 2019 or 2020 and, Embraer executives appear prepared to believe the Boeing boss. Said Silva of a 737 re-engining project, “This is an unlikely scenario, I think.” Of course, the availability of resources could play a key part in any decision Embraer makes. From a financial perspective, Embraer simply cannot afford a colossal misjudgment; hence, the reason for what some might consider signs of reticence. “This is a major project for us given our size,” said Silva. “So we can’t afford to make a mistake here.” o

Alcoa pits its alloys against composites by Thierry Dubois Aluminum giant Alcoa (H5 F220) is here exhibiting a fuselage section manufactured with advanced aluminum-lithium alloy sheet that was stretch-formed on existing tooling by Spirit Aerosystems’ factory in Wichita, Kansas. U.S.-based Alcoa is targeting the next generation of singleaisle aircraft (with a clear focus on Boeing’s expected decision this year) as the potential first applications. It is touting the merits of new-technology metals against composites– lower weight, better fuel efficiency, reduced cost and less risks in production–promised for aircraft entering service before 2020. “We learned the hard way that we did not innovate enough,” Kevin Lowery, communications director for Alcoa’s global rolled products, told AIN. He was referring to the decisions by Boeing and then Airbus to dramatically increase the proportion of composite materials on their new widebody programs–respectively, the 787 and the A350 XWB. After this wake-up call, research and development in aluminum has accelerated over the past decade, notably at Alcoa’s research center in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. According to Tony Morales, global marketing director for aerospace aluminum, the empty weight of rolled products, with Alcoa’s new alloys, will be cut by six to

10 percent. The starting point for this is the new material’s lower density, 3 to 7 percent below that of today’s metals. On top of that, Alcoa engineers have devised ways to add structural reinforcements only where they are really needed. Also, thanks to better crack propagation resistance, some parts can be made thinner and lighter. Other improvements have further helped to reduce fuel consumption of aircraft. First, applying these new design approaches (including the more precisely located reinforcements) allows Alcoa to achieve more aerodynamic geometries, such as a higher wing aspect ratio. Alcoa also is working on longer term wing skin technologies, targeting lower drag. Reduced skin friction holds a potential 3- to 6-percent enhancement. All told, the company predicts that fuel burn in the next generation of narrowbodies could be 7 to 12 percent better than current performance, thanks to the new metallic materials and advanced structural technologies. Boeing has said that composites allow for larger windows on the 787. Thanks to the more precisely located reinforcements on the fuselage, Alcoa offers equivalent improvements using metal, according to Lowery. In terms of cabin pressurization and moisture levels, Alcoa claims to be on

64 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

an equal footing with composites. For example, the new alloys could handle a 6,000-foot cabin pressure at cruise altitude. In the area of maintenance, a third-generation, more corrosion-resistant aluminum-lithium alloy can be inspected at intervals twice as long as before. Another factor is greater fatigue performance. Separately, a selfcleaning metal sheet is in early development. Thanks to millimeter-scale geometry features and coatings, the metal sheet essentially repels dirt. In production terms, Alcoa claims its solutions to be up to 30 percent cheaper, and Alcoa is displaying a fuselage section made of new aluminum much less risky, than compos- alloys that ambition to beat composites. ites. The company says it can ensure more timely deliveries as a result three out of four of the technical responof having “established high-volume sup- dents surveyed had a favorable percepply chains and reduced investment needs tion of aluminum as a primary structure via existing infrastructure.” It also stresses material, as opposed to 54 percent for composites. Among management and the ability to recycle aluminum. So how successful will Alcoa be in con- commercial constituencies, the results vincing manufacturers to adopt its new showed the opposite. “The better the solutions? Time will tell. To begin with, survey interviewees understand alumithe firm conducted a survey to assess alu- num, the more they are favorable to it,” o minum perception. It showed that nearly reported Alcoa.

Support

Without Limits. Whatever your aftermarket needs â&#x20AC;&#x201C; our deep experience, diverse capabilities and global infrastructure are geared to solve support challenges large and small. From basic depot maintenance to sophisticated, turnkey solutions in demanding environments, Sikorsky Aerospace Services (SAS) is the provider of choice. There is no need to decide between reduced operating costs and increased mission readiness â&#x20AC;&#x201C; customers who work with SAS can have both. No limits. For more information, contact Frank DiPasquale at FDiPasquale@sikorsky.com

www.sikorsky.com

Airbus has brought forward the re-engined A320neo program by six months, to October 2015.

Airbus Neo ups the ante in narrowbody stakes by Ian Goold The Airbus A320neo (for “new engine option”) is “the fastest selling aircraft in history” and the manufacturer set itself the target of accruing “over 500” commitments by this week’s Paris Air Show, according to chief operating officer (customers) John Leahy. By early April, the company had booked more than 330 orders and “commitments” and this prompted it to accelerate the program by six months. The European airframer now plans to deliver the new model, which was formally launched last December, for service entry in October 2015 and has confirmed the lead development powerplant as the Pratt & Whitney PW1100G geared turbofan (GTF). The alternative CFM International Leap-X engine is running about six months behind it. Re-engined variants of the A319 and A321 sibling designs each will account initially for a quarter share of deliveries, although Airbus has acknowledged that this split might evolve as the program matures. The date for delivery effectively increased the variant’s lead over U.S. competitor Boeing,

which has yet to announce its own response to the perceived market for a re-engined–rather than replacement–design. Last year, Leahy famously suggested that if the A320neo had the go-ahead by the end of 2010, Boeing would in turn launch a clean-sheet product for 2020. In the mid-years of the past decade, the two companies saw an emerging market for A320or 737-repacement capacity in the early years of the 2010s, but subsequently all best-guesses have moved to the right. Early last year, Leahy forecast that the timing for a new aircraft had moved back to at least 2022, if not later. The suggested requirement for a new single-aisle Airbus, dubbed “A30X” and incorporating advanced engine, materials and systems developments, has now moved even further into the future. Two months ago, Leahy’s perception of progress had persuaded him to look beyond 2025 to 2030–or perhaps 2035– as the moment for convergence of requisite new technologies. A major part of his considerations is that by the 2030s there

should be a new, much more efficient generation of openrotor engines. No Replacement Orders

Despite the stated aspirations of carriers such as Air Asia, the manufacturer said customers may not replace their A320 orders with bookings for the reengined model. Perhaps thinking it could stimulate Airbus through media headlines, earlier this year the fast-growing lowcost operator voiced its ambition to swap some outstanding requirements for A320neos. According to Leahy, providing such flexibility in its order book would “create too much

Long Live the A320… Alongside preparations for the re-engined A320neo, Airbus is continuing A320 product development, according to A320 family chief engineer Wolfgang Engler. Some 23 years after A320 MSN0005 pioneered the type’s airline service with Air France, the manufacturer claims a 99.7-percent “operational reliability” for the most recently delivered 250 aircraft. Middle East low-cost carrier Air Arabia’s A320s are said to be achieving almost 14.4 hours of daily utilization with other airlines, including Air Asia, EasyJet, JetBlue Airways and Tiger Airways, logging more than 10 hours per day on individual aircraft. Maximum takeoff weight for the standard A320-200 has been progressively increased from the initial 162,000 pounds to 172,000 pounds, accompanied by improved engines and aerodynamics. Sharklet-equipped A320s being delivered next year will have higher weights. With an A320 reaching the 48,000-flight-cycle design service goal for the first time during 2011, Airbus is working to establish extended service goals (ESGs). Other original “life” parameters were 60,000 flight hours, reached by the lead aircraft in October 2007, and 25 years, which the original Air France aircraft will reach in February 2013. In an initial move dubbed ESG1, intended to permit 60,000 cycles and 120,000 hours, Airbus conducted 120,000 simulated flights on four major fatigue specimens– forward fuselage, center fuselage and wings, rear fuselage and engine pylon–in Toulouse and Munich. The new limits are likely to be attained by lead aircraft in 2017 and

2022, respectively. Testing has been continued through a further 60,000 simulated flights necessary to establish the 90,000-cycle/180,000-hour ESG2 goal. An interim service goal for high-time aircraft that reduced the cycle limit to 37,500, while extending accumulated flight time to 80,000 hours (with an attendant inspection of the tailplane) was approved in 2007. The ESG program excludes A320-100s and the 30 A320-200s fitted with four-wheel landing-gear bogies. Engler said that full-scale fatigue tests are complete, related structural analysis is “on schedule” and a servicebulletin package has been defined. Airbus is establishing dossiers to support justification for life extensions to critical aircraft systems, with 85 percent of work completed with suppliers. ESG1 is expected to become available next year. Also by June, Airbus expects to have certified an A320 electronic flight bag option that permits the flight crew to plug a large variety of laptop computers into a docking station via Arinc 828-compliant wiring. Future plans call for the following goals to be addressed: to increase flight-crew situational awareness through an on-board airport-navigation system that displays an airport moving map with aircraft position information; to improve go-around decision-making using an A380derived runway overrun prevention system equipment; and to enhance pilots’ reactions to traffic-alert and collision-avoidance system warnings. –I.G.

66 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

confusion.” He said that to be able to plan for the future, the manufacturer “needs to know” the likely division of production between the two models. Leahy claims that allowing customers to switch orders between the two variants is tantamount to allowing an airline to take a second slot, “and we’re not going to do that,” he said. For programs executive vice president Tom Williams, Airbus has a story to tell and must get the message across: the A320neo represents “minimum change with maximum benefit.” He claims the latest variant in the established single-aisle family will “fulfill a rising demand from the market for ‘green’ and innovative products” by providing 15-percent better fuel efficiency, reduced noise, reduced NOx and CO2 emissions, and lower operating and maintenance costs. Minimum Changes

The official is at pains to emphasize the manufacturer’s commitment to minimum change. In reviewing available opportunities to modify the existing specification, Williams acknowledged that Airbus “clearly could end up with an all-new aircraft, but we have to be realistic.” The A320neo will include minimum change from and maximum commonality with the current design and will be covered by the existing type certificate and pilots’ type ratings, he said. He added that the aircraft will not require “a lot of new design and management tools [or] processes.” The Airbus A320neo will sport new engines, nacelles and pylons; modified wing and wingbox structures; and adapted electronic systems, Williams said. The only A320 part subject to “significant difference” is the engine pylon on which Airbus

will hang alternative Pratt & Whitney PW100G geared turbofans or CFM International Leap-X powerplants, he said. In his view, both CFM and P&W have been “extremely aggressive” in addressing requirements. “P&W is very well advanced and [CFM partner] General Electric is also working hard,” he said. The new engines will be housed in 81-inch-diameter nacelles that will provide some 18.1 inches ground clearance. Williams said the pylons will not be an issue because the A320 wing structure will be modified to accept the loads from the new engine and nacelle propulsion system and the center wingbox will be reinforced. The flight deck will not be new, with changes being confined to software adjustments to take into account the new powerplant. Development of the A320neo has involved detailed assessments of resource planning and suppliers’ capabilities, lessons learned from recent research (including that for A320 “sharklet” wingtips and the upcoming twin-aisle A350), selection of any required new risk-sharing partners and integration of all manufacturing and design disciplines. Williams explained that a “quite manageable” group of about 900 people have been involved in the exercise, but the project has not required “a whole bunch of new suppliers.” Introducing the Sharklets

Williams acknowledged that a key question for the manufacturer is how to manage the introduction both of the sharklets and the A320neo in the next few years. A very simplistic graph illustrating the new model’s ramp-up over a 30-month period from mid-2015 to the beginning of 2018 shows A320 production rising slightly–perhaps driven by current order backlog–as

production of sharkletted aircraft begins. Manufacturing rates for the current A320 aircraft then begins to decline, the trend line eventually crossing that indicating initial ramp-up of the A320neo, with completion of sharklet-equipped aircraft bridging the valley above the A320/ A320neo crossover point. The build rate for sharkletted A320s will start to fall as “old” A320 manufacturing ends (over a “relatively long period”) and as A320neo manufacturing becomes increasingly well established, the manufacturer said. As it prepares to introduce the first examples of the A320neo in October 2015, Airbus has been investing in production flexibility that will permit an easy move from the current aircraft to the new variant, or simultaneous production of both–which Williams said can be “built back-to-back” (or perhaps more accurately nose to tail). The manufacturer has been trying to consider the critical path: for example, A320neo wings will be made in essentially the A320 jigs, with tooling adapted to accommodate changes. There will not be a family of new jigs for the A320neo. Accordingly, Airbus tooling will remain in use until the prospective new technologies converge to enable development of an all-new aircraft in perhaps 25 years’ time. If that happens, the A320 family will have been endowed with a potential manufacturing life of more than 40 years. o

Sharklets Are “Go” Airbus has already started to produce the first elements of the “ sharklet” wingtips for incorporation on wings for standard A320 aircraft that are expected to enter service in about 18 months’ time, during the fourth quarter of 2012. It also has begun to convert the original A320 (MSN 0001), including installation of flight-test instruments, to act as a test bed. S harklets will then be introduced progressively during 2013 on other members of the singleaisle family in the following order: A319, A321, A318. Introduction of sharklets will improve A320 takeoff performance in terms of payload by approximately 6,600 pounds, according to Airbus customer chief operating officer John Leahy. This enhancement is seen as especially Finnair is one of eight customers for “sharklet” wingtips on the A320.

valuable when operating from runways with obstacle-clearance and secondary-segment climb limitations. Leahy cited airports such as Canberra, Chicago (Midway), Kathmandu and Quito as having such considerations for A320 operators. Alternatively, carriers might wish to use the new aerodynamic equipment to increase their range of operations through the sharklets’ claimed higher fuel efficiency. Leahy said block fuel usage could improve by more than 3.5 percent when compared with a current A320 fitted with standard wingtip fences. By April this year, Airbus had announced eight sharklet customers:

Air Arabia, Air New Zealand, lessors Air Lease and Avalon, Finnair, LanChile, Thomas Cook and Virgin America. The new wingtips are said to provide lower fuel burn and emissions; improved payload/range capability, takeoff, climb and cruise performance; and enhanced aircraft value. Flight testing of the units on A320 MSN001 are scheduled to begin in late 2011 followed in the first quarter of next year by delivery of the first new wing for final assembly on the production line. Airbus programs executive vice president Tom Williams said 2012 will see production of a significant number of sharklet-ready A320 wings. “It will be a very quick ramp-up,” he said. A320 wing changes to accommodate sharklets include a rebuilding of Rib 27, a move Williams characterized as a “very neat solution” that will allow the new tip to be plugged into the end of the wing. Sharklets can be fitted in a one-day shop visit and will be removable. Williams also said there is no requirement for fundamental redesign of the structure or the low-speed flight controls. There will be no change to materials and the wing spars will “look very much like they do now.” Because sharkletted A320s will operate at increased maximum takeoff weights, skin panels will be re-gauged over the entire wing span for a 1.3-percent higher static load. The panel gauge also will be changed to accommodate a 3-percent higher fatigue load over most of the wing outboard of the engine. Higher maximum takeoff and landing weights will require local gearrib and spar reinforcement, alongside local reinforcement of engine-pylon attachments with adapted pylon-system interfaces. The outer wing will be reinforced to take onto account higher bending yaw and torque forces; the center wingbox also will be reinforced. A weight-reduction program is being conducted in an effort to ensure that it will not be possible to differentiate between a 2010 A320 and a 2012 example with the modified wing. –I.G.

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 67

Eurocopter’s X 3 brings X-Factor to Paris show by Thierry Dubois

Mods Allow Speed Increase

During the first test campaign, between September and December 2010, the first goal had been 180 knots. That speed was attained in less than 12 flight hours and it required less power than expected, Billig told AIN. He claimed that the aircraft is so

Comparing the Eurocopter X3 and Sikorsky X2

COURTESY SIKORSKY

Both the Sikorsky X2 and the Eurocopter X3 have propellers and both are targeting higher cruise speeds; however, their respective designers have not been working to the same principles. The X2 is effectively a semi-compound helicopter, having contra-rotating main rotors and one aft propeller, while the X3 is a true compound with a single main rotor, wing stubs and two side-mounted propellers. Moreover, they are aimed at different markets. After having hit the X2’s 250-knot cruise speed target last year, Sikorsky is now applying the technology to the military X2 Raider, an armed reconnaissance prototype. Eurocopter prefers to limit the speed to around 220 knots, for economical reasons, as it focuses on commercial uses. Also, the X2 has fly-by-wire controls, while the X3 has conventional controls. This may be one of the reasons why Eurocopter reached 180 knots in three months last year, whereas Sikorsky reached that speed, in 2010, after 21 months of developing a more complex rotorcraft. Despite the difference in development schedules, it took about the same number of flight hours– between 11 and 12–for the two aircraft to reach 180 knots. –T.D.

Sikorsky’s X2 reached 250 ktas in level flight last year.

68 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

With its X3 demonstrator, Eurocopter reached 232 knots but is targeting 220 knots as an economical sweet spot. As a result of the flight tests so far, engineers have modified the information available in the cockpit.

stable it can be flown “hands off” at 180 knots. “It is as stable as a jet,” he said. A vibration problem on the empennage, visible on the video of the first flight, was solved immediately after that flight, according to Billig. Last winter, Eurocopter engineers disassembled the aircraft, thoroughly examined critical parts and analyzed the flight test data. “Our objective was to understand how parts behaved,” Billig said. Modifications were lighter than expected. To allow a speed increase from 180 to 220 knots, Billig and his team had planned to strengthen the main gearbox by installing the unit developed for the new EC175 medium twin. “However, [the original gearbox] behaved well, a change was no longer needed,” he said. The X3 is powered by a pair of the RTM322 engines developed by Rolls-Royce and Turbomeca for the NH90 military transport. They are so powerful (2,300 shp each) that their full power wasn’t even fully used to reach the higher speeds. Between the first and second test campaigns, the fuel system was modified. The engines now can be fed even at very high pitch-up attitudes. In the cockpit, the information displayed to pilots has been adapted. “At high speeds, some bits of information relating to hover are inappropriate, while the crew needs more explicit speed and slip indication,” Billig said. The second test phase will end after about 12 to 15 flight hours (not counting the hours flown here at the Le Bourget show). This means the demonstration program, at some 20 to 30 hours, will have been shorter than expected; an X3 crewmember

THIERRY DUBOIS

you will see a flying display no other helicopter can offer–I am talking not only about high speeds,” he told AIN. During the second flighttest campaign, which started in May, the X3 demonstrated a rate of climb greater than 5,000 feet per minute. The crew flew pitch-up attitudes in the 30- to 50-degree range. It performed rolls at 80-degree bank angles. “After the Paris Air Show, we’ll go even faster than 232 knots,” Billig said. That speed was sustained during approximately five minutes at 8,200 feet on May 12. Further flights this year will dig deeper into vibration phenomena and wingstub aerodynamics.

THIERRY DUBOIS

Eurocopter has delivered what it hopes will prove to be the X-Factor to this year’s Paris Air Show. The daily flying display this week features its new its X3 (“x cubed”) compound helicopter demonstrator, a modified AS 365 Dauphin with a conventional main rotor, two propellers on wingstubs and a conventional empennage. While helicopters usually cruise at 140 to 150 knots, the X3 concept is aimed at proving that 220 knots is a sweet spot where speed is profitable, and last month the demonstrator reached 232 ktas. The X3 was unveiled in September 2010 at Istres’ military flight-test center in France, near the manufacturer’s Marignane factory. According to Jean-Michel Billig, the company’s executive vice president for research and development, the X3 will impress show-goers with its maneuverability, just as the military Tiger wowed them back in the 1990s, when it began performing loops. “In Le Bourget,

had previously talked about a need for up to 100 hours. “We want to go directly where we want to be in terms of understanding high-speed flight,” Billig said, explaining the relatively small number of sorties required. “Our preparation for phase one was very good, which explains our success. I want phase two to be as successful,” he added. The crew had previously tested “99 percent of what they saw in flight” on a simulator. Not a New Concept

The idea to add propellers to a helicopter is not new. Several compound rotorcraft have flown

since the 1950s but none of them made it to the market. So why try again now? “Today’s computation and simulation capabilities are helping us a lot,” said Billig, explaining why he believes the X3 will have a more positive outcome. Eurocopter’s design engineers can predict the aircraft’s behavior and adjust parameters such as attitude, rotor rotation and speed, and so forth. Moreover, having propellers driven by shafts connected to the main gearbox is a new configuration. Previous compound models had dedicated engines for the side-mounted propellers.

Continued on page 70 u

Now, Garmin is bringing 3-D synthetic vision, electronic charts and WAAS approaches to your King Air 300/350 series. The biggest of the Beechcraft King Airs – the 300/350 series – is now approaching STC approval for retrofit with Garmin G1000®. Joining the EQUI PPED

C90 and 200 series airframes already being updated at authorized installation centers industry-wide, this top-of-the-line package offers great investment value with “dual-everything” avionics and integrated FMS through Garmin’s GFC 700 digital autopilot. Optional SVT™ synthetic vision adds 3-D situational awareness. And other noteworthy features include: Class B TAWS terrain alerting. WAAS LPV approach capability. Solid-state AHRS. RVSM compliance1. Digital radar. Electronic charts. Plus, a choice of standard XM satellite weather2 or optional Iridium-based worldwide weather service3 with available voice, text messaging and data links from virtually anywhere you’d care to fly. To learn more, see our King Air video at www.garmin.com. Or call Dave Brown at (913) 440-1406. Follow the leader.

King Air 200 and 300/350 models only. Subscription required for XM weather service (sold separately). Uses optional GSR 56 Iridium network transceiver (subscription required).

www.garmin.com

uContinued from page 68 These days, the compact design of current turboshafts allows airframers to build a compound that behaves very much like a conventional helicopter. The

architecture is relatively simple, with two outputs from the main gearbox (to the propeller’s gearboxes) instead of one (for a tailrotor). At low speed, anti-torque and yaw are controlled through conventional pedals. Instead of acting on the tailrotor, they

YOUR AEROSPACE INNOVATION COULD CHANGE THE WORLD Talk to our peak performance people Certification and performance testing of gas turbines and their components World-leading engine icing research and testing Alternative fuels development and testing

Your vision. Our solution.

Contact our team: 1-877-NRC-CNRC | nrc.gc.ca/business

v2e_IAR-Paris_ad_BW-12024-E.indd 5

70 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

11-06-01 11:24 AM

differentiate the power supplied by each propeller. In cruise, the vertical empennage suffices to control yaw. The pilot can fly the X3 like a conventional helicopter up to 80 knots. Beyond that point an additional control is needed. A trim button, located on the main rotor collective pitch lever, increases the propellers’ pitch and power output. At the same time, the pilot has to reduce the collective pitch. X3 Test pilot Hervé Jammayrac (left) and flight-test engineer Daniel Semioli test pilot Hervé Jam- were at the controls when the X3 demonstrator surpassed its speed goals. mayrac told AIN that it would just take no more than 15 min- for the hoist), border patrol and comutes for a helicopter test pilot to convert mercial passenger transport. In six to to flying the new compound. eight years, Eurocopter’s first comIn cruise, the wings take over from the pound product may be in the EC 225 main rotor to provide 40 percent of the category–20 passenger seats–for oil-andlift. The main rotor adopts a “flat” profile gas offshore operations. In military service, applications in which drag is minimal and rotor speed is reduced. Power is then transferred to include combat search and rescue, medical evacuation and troop transport, posthe propellers. Flying the X3 does not require fly-by- sibly with in-flight refueling. The concept wire controls, the crew said, and the air- is relevant to those operations where craft is stable at high speeds, even without hover is a marginal part of the flight. So how did Eurocopter’s engineering an autopilot. However, Eurocopter is considering adding fly-by-wire controls when team determine the optimal speed? At the compound concept is turned into a 220 knots, the aircraft is about 50 percent product. Such a decision should be made faster than its conventional equivalent. next year, Billig said. When the X3 gets to The additional operating cost per hour market, the price premium is expected to should be about 25 percent more in terms be about 25 percent higher than the cost of fuel burn. Balancing this is the assumption that of a conventional helicopter. for a given distance, the aircraft will Multiple Applications spend fewer hours in the air and thus Hoped-for applications for this have lower maintenance costs. Accordhigh-speed, long-range concept include ing to Eurocopter, the bottom line is a search and rescue (with a rear door 20-percent cut in costs, measured per passenger-mile. Moreover, by going faster, the aircraft can perform more missions in a given period. The operating cost of the X3 at 250 knots (if attained) was calculated to be much too high. Further testing will also help determine the longrange cruise speed–probably close to 200 knots. Jammayrac said the X3’s fuel burn (measured per nautical mile) at that setting will be lower than that of a conventional helicopter at much lower speeds. Billig did not ignore the conjecture that a purpose-designed compound might deliver more performance than the X3. For example, airframe weight was not an issue with the RTM322 engines. Also, the propellers (a standard set that Eurocopter bought from MT Propellers) might be better profiled if used with a clean-sheet design, resulting in lower noise and more efficient operations. He also was tight-lipped on the X3’s actual fuel consumption. o

THIERRY DUBOIS

Eurocopter’s X-Factor

Nouveau Monde DDB Toulouse - ÂŠ pixteur.com

CAN TECHNOLOGY, PROFITABILITY AND ECO-EFFICIENCY GO TOGETHER ?

OF TURBOPROP TECHNOLOGY

ATR aircraft offer the lowest greenhouse gas emissions, best technical solutions, and unique commonalit y while remaining the most cost efficient technology. Now, say Yes to ATR aircraft and choose the best solution for short haul flights.

Designed for economics, 40 % less on fuel bills PROFITABILITY ENVIRONMENT Reduced ecological footprint, 2.5 liters/passenger/100 Km (100 miles/gallon/passenger) TECHNOLOGY The only ETOPS 120-min turboprop

www.atraircraft.com

MBDA

Rafale M1, one of four instrumented production aircraft, undertakes carriage trials with the Meteor missile.

Rafale’s omnirole comes of age

Rafale on the prowl: Equipped with a Damoclès targeting pod, an Armée de l’Air aircraft on a swing-role mission over Libya with a load of AASM and MICA missiles.

In the coming weeks, Dassault Aviation will deliver the 30th Rafale C to the French air force–the 100th production aircraft to come from its Bordeaux-Mérignac assembly line. At the same time, the type is heavily involved in Operation Harmattan, the French contribution to NATO-led air operations over Libya, in which the Rafale is flying true swingrole missions. Moreover, the development program continues apace to add greater capability in the short term, while Dassault examines options for

a major mid-life update planned for the 2025 time frame. By 2015 the French armed forces will be down to two combat types: the Rafale and the Mirage 2000D. The out-of-service date for the latter has yet to be decided, but by at least 2030 the French air force and navy are expecting the Rafale to meet all of their combat needs. Rafale production deliveries currently stand at 98, including four instrumented aircraft for trials. The French armed forces have a total requirement for 286 aircraft –228 for the air force

and 58 for the navy, which will take the Rafale production line to 2025. To date, 180 have been ordered in four tranches, securing production until 2019. Tranche 1 comprised 10 Rafale Ms for the navy, and one Rafale C single-seater and two Rafale B two-seaters for the air force. Subsequent orders covered Tranche 2 (16 Ms, seven Cs,

Engine Improvements Extend Life and Cut Costs

EM radar-guided missiles. F2 added SCALP and AASM (also known as SBU-38 Hammer) airto-ground missiles, the infrared version of MICA, front-sector optronics (FSO) and Link 16 datalink. The current production version, to which earlier aircraft have been (F2) or can be (F1) upgraded, is Standard F3, which adds ASMP-A nuclear missile, AASM infrared version, AM39 Exocet anti-ship weapon and GBU-12 laser-guided bomb. F3 was qualified in July 2008. Standard F3 Rafales continue to receive additional capabilities as they are developed and qualified. They include the GBU-24 2,000-pound laser-guided bomb (qualified late 2010), Damoclès targeting pod, air-to-ground gun capability and the Rover downlink. The latter was certified for use last year and is initially being fitted to a batch of 30 aircraft. The Rover provides target imagery downlinked to ground forces. In the coming weeks, the first MBDA AM39 Block 2 Mod 2 Exocets will be delivered to the Navy for use with the Rafale. This variant of the well-proven anti-ship missile is fully digitized to adapt it to the Rafale’s weapon system.

25 Bs), Tranche 3 (12 Ms, 36 Cs, 11 Bs) and Tranche 4 (10 Ms, 25 Bs, 25 Cs). Production is currently running at a rate of around one aircraft per month. The Navy has now taken delivery of 32 of its planned 58, sufficient for a second squadron to form, thus Flottille 11F stands up at Landivisiau this month to serve alongside the existing 12F.

MBDA

Equipment Standards

This near-hemispherical infrared image was captured by the staring array of the DDM-NG missile warning system.

France’s Rafales have been delivered in various equipment fits. The initial Standard F1 was an interim air-to-air-only version with Magic 2 and MICA

SNECMA

From November this year, production Rafales will be fitted with a new engine. The M88-4E has been developed by Snecma to extend service life and time between inspections for key parts of the engine, with the aim of reducing total cost of ownership (TCO). The TCO program has its roots in the M88 ECO program that ran between 2004 and 2007, during which Snecma demonstrated several new technologies and showed that a nine-metric-ton-thrust engine was feasible. Elements from the ECO project were incorporated into the TCO program, which was launched in January 2008. The TCO pack replaces the aft three stages of the high-pressure compressor, and has a new HP turbine with new nozzle inner casing and outer ring. HP turbine life is increased by 30 percent. FETT (first engine to test) was achieved in September 2009, and the new engine first flew in a Rafale on March 22 last year. After a 70-flight test campaign, the M88-4E engine was cleared for use last November and endurance testing is to be completed this month. Qualification is due in October, with first deliveries slated for November. It will become the standard production engine at that point, although TCO packs will be retrofitted to existing M88-3 engines as they are serviced. The ECO/TCO programs have laid the foundation for an uprated ninemetric-ton engine, seen to be an integral part of ongoing export campaigns. Although France has not decided on any re-engining plans for its Rafales, Snecma claims that such an engine could be quickly developed once a contract has been awarded. –D.D.

ARMÉE DE L’AIR

by David Donald

Snecma is introducing the M88-4E engine to improve service life and reduce ownership costs. It could form the basis of an uprated engine that is likely to be required by export customers.

72 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Continued on page 74 u

Nothing stands prouder than a military family.

From Surveillance, to Mission Control, to Target Exploitation Hawker Beechcraft Corporation is the industry leader in Airborne Surveillance, Light Attack, and Aircrew Training around the world. At the Paris Air Show Chalet Number 406, HBC will highlight the latest in military and special mission aircraft — featuring the King Air 350ER, the King Air B200 and the T-6C on display. Learn how Hawker Beechcraft meets the demanding requirements of Intelligence Surveillance & Reconnaissance, Irregular Warfare and Aircrew Training with state-of-the-art, cost effective and sustainable solutions.

LEARN MORE, VISIT HawkerBeechcraft.com AFRICA, EUROPE & MIDDLE EAST +44 (0)124.523803 ASIA-PACIFIC +852.3756.3755 UNITED STATES & THE AMERICAS +1.316.676.0800

It will replace the current DDM sensors as a “form, fit and function” subsystem of the Rafale’s Spectra EW suite.

A naval Rafale M launches from the French aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle with a Reco NG pod. This system was first used operationally last year over Afghanistan, and is a highly important tool over Libya.

Rafale’s omnirole comes of age uContinued from page 72 Another important role recently added to the Rafale’s repertoire is reconnaissance, with the qualification of the Thales Reco NG pod, also known as Areos. The air force declared the pod operational in November last year, and it has been used by navy Rafales flying over Afghanistan. Air force Rafales began using the Reco NG over Libya. French Roadmap

With the Thales RBE2 AA AESA radar set to enter service in 2013, the Rafale will become the first European fighter with an active electronically scanned radar.

for delivery in 2013. At present, the series AESA radar is in the final evaluation campaign at the Direction Générale de l’Armement’s Essais en Vol (DGA EV) facility (formerly CEV) at Cazaux in southwest France. The task of these trials is to evaluate the radar as a stand-alone sensor

DASSAULT

Team Rafale is now engaged in further work that will see a significant change to the Rafale’s

capability. Known as Standard F3-O4T, or the “French roadmap” aircraft, the new configuration is due for qualification next year and service entry in 2013. It will feature important new systems such as the Thales RBE2 AA AESA radar, MBDA’s DDM-NG missile warning system and the Thales FSO-IT improved technology optronics that adds a TV channel to the existing infrared capability. The AESA RBE2 radar is the centerpiece of the “French roadmap” improvements, and in February was validated in production form on the Rafale. Thales is preparing to deliver radars for the Tranche 4 Rafale production batch, the first of which is scheduled

THALES

MARINE NATIONALE

Near-term Development

Rafales take shape at Dassault’s Mérignac plant. Rather than move down a traditional line, the aircraft remain in their bays while components are brought to them. Dassault uses a mobile facility known as Osiris to run system tests throughout the assembly process.

74 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

against its predicted performance and requirements. The DGA EV is using Falcon 20 No. 104 and Mirage 2000B No. 501 as the testbeds for the radar, and has a pair of Mirage 2000Cs (Nos. 2 and 64) to act as instrumented, RCS-characterized target aircraft. The last of three phases of the evaluation comprises around 25 flights, during which around 140 radar runs are being performed. All operating modes of the activescan radar are being cleared. From this month, the DGA EV is conducting AESA/Link 16 integration trials. The DDM-NG missile warning system is another important development program for the Rafale. Imaging infrared sensors on either side of the Rafale’s fin provide a near-spherical view around the aircraft, able to detect missile plumes at great distance and with the angular precision required for the future application of directional infrared countermeasures. In February, the DGA EV completed a second campaign of data-gathering in a real environment, including the presence of real firings, and the DDM-NG is due for qualification next year.

The DGA EV is engaged in ongoing test work associated with various aspects of the Rafale, including improvement of the Sagem SLPRM mission planning system, Reco NG and Damoclès pods, and new weapons. Included are the laser/GPS version of the Sagem AASM for the F3-O4T Rafale, and the use of GPS/IR AASM in the anti-tank role, the latter being seen as an urgent operational requirement stemming from the Libya campaign. Another topic that has arisen from Libya operations is the need for a low-collateral-damage-effect weapon. The RAF’s MBDA dual-mode Brimstone has impressed in Libya and is under evaluation for integration with the Rafale, although alternatives such as laser-guided rockets have been mooted. Further areas that are being studied are improvements to the radar, electronic warfare suite and human-machine interface, and a Link 16 upgrade is planned. Later this year, a new laser designation pod program is to be launched with additional TV channel. Meteor and Beyond F3-O4T

During next year, MBDA is scheduled to deliver the first production examples of the Meteor beyond-visual-range missile. An initial 200 missiles was ordered by the DGA last December to equip the Rafale from 2018, or 2016 if demanded. Early fielding is largely associated with the export campaigns currently running in Brazil, India (for which the Rafale has been short-listed alongside the Typhoon), the UAE and others. Around 2025 it is expected that the Rafale will undergo a major mid-life update. Although the specifications for the MLU are far from defined, several areas are already under review, including radar crosssection reduction, greater data fusion, provision of satellite communications and softwaredriven radio, and more powerful engines. Topics such as thrustvectoring and UCAV control will also be considered, as well as making changes to the flight control system cheaper and quicker to undertake. o

Long live your engine. Chromalloy repairs give new life to engine components, while our coatings provide unsurpassed durability in the harshest engine conditions. By incorporating these capabilities with revolutionary engineering, machining, tooling, the worldâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s most advanced independent casting facility and re-engineered parts, Chromalloy extends engine life like no other company can. Itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s a testament to 60 years of innovationâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;and it can make an impact today. Learn more at chromalloy.com.

Learn more at chromalloy.com

Coatings / Repairs / Parts

Rafale: leading the way over Libya by David Donald

Operation Harmattan, the French participation in the Libya operations, has seen the first use of the Reco NG pod by air force Rafales.

capabilities by being dual-tasked on each mission. “We’re flying strike missions while policing the air,” observed Lt. Col. P [identity security-protected], “and we are doing time-sensitive targeting.” The same is true for the aircraft launching with the Reco NG reconnaissance pod, which are also undertaking simultaneous air-to-air missions. For the air force, it is the first time Reco NG has been used operationally and it has proven to be a major advance in intelligence-gathering capabilities compared with the film-based Presto pod used by the three Mirage F1CR aircraft allocated to the Libyan operation. Both systems share a deployable air intelligence cell (DAIC) at Solenzara that processes and analyzes imagery. The air force Rafale detachment, which typically numbers seven aircraft, normally flies two waves of two to four aircraft daily. A typical mission begins

ARMÉE DE L’AIR

A mix of Rafale Bs and Cs lines up at Solenzara during missions over Libya. The aircraft in the foreground has Damoclès pod and AASM missiles. The Rafales also carry two MICA EMs on the fuselage and two MICA IRs on the wingtips for air-to-air duties.

76 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Rafales have fired the MBDA SCALP missile for the first time over Libya and the weapon remains available to both air force and navy. This example (above) is seen at Solenzara, Corsica, next to the heavily protected canisters that are used to transport the missiles. Hammer time: (below) an armourer moves GPS/INS-guided, 250-kilogram SBU-38 Hammer (AASM) missiles along the Rafale flightline at Solenzara.

ARMÉE DE L’AIR

out to Souda Bay in Crete. By the start of June, the French air force Rafale detachment was awaiting approval from Italian authorities to move to Sigonella, to cut flying time for each sortie by one to two hours. Meanwhile, the navy’s Rafales have been operating from the aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle. Over Libya, the Rafale has been demonstrating its omnirole

ARMÉE DE L’AIR

Since the first day of the U.N.-backed Operation Unified Protector over Libya (March 19) the Dassault Rafale has been in the forefront of air operations. Although the first few missions were flown from the Rafale’s home base at Saint-Dizier, the focus of operations soon shifted to Solenzara in Corsica, which was rapidly dubbed “Rafaletown,” especially after the French Mirage 2000 component moved

MARINE NATIONALE

DAVID DONALD

A Rafale M prepares for a dusk launch from the French aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle, sailing off the Libyan coast. The aircraft is equipped with a buddy refueling pod to support other Rafales.

with a meal three hours before takeoff and an intelligence brief with around 90 minutes to go. For missions from Solenzara, the Rafales refuel south of Sicily after about 1 hour 45 minutes in the air, and then enter the operational area. They refuel midway through their time on station and return to base after about six hours flying. Some missions have lasted as long as eight hours. Missions are planned around the master air ops plan, which is received 48 hours beforehand, and the detailed air tasking order that is received the day before, complete with call signs, IFF codes, tanker plans and anchor points. The Rafales work closely with AWACS and they can often be retasked in flight. In the early days of the campaign, the primary attack weapon was the SBU-38 Hammer (AASM), but as the weather has improved, the cheaper GBU12 laser-guided bomb has been increasingly employed, although often a flight of aircraft carries both weapons. More than 100 of these two types of precision weapon had been dropped by the end of May. The Libya campaign has seen the combat debut of the SCALP missile, a few of which have been launched. On March

24, SCALPs were fired by two air force Rafales (which can each carry two) flying from Saint-Dizier and two Rafale Ms (which can carry one) from the aircraft-carrier, as well as by Mirage 2000Ds. As with other Unified Protector aircrew, Rafale crews face threats from SA-2 SAMs and ground fire. “You see lots of fire at night,” said pilot Lt. Col. P. “It has decreased since the beginning [of the operation] but you never drop your guard. Any anti-aircraft targets we detect become priorities, and are fed into a very quick decision loop for attack.” One constant concern is avoiding civilian casualties, made difficult by the tactics of Col. Muammar Gaddafi’s forces. “I’ve seen lots of evidence of anti-aircraft guns and tanks being moved to near civilian buildings, and you cannot shoot,” said Lt. Col. P. “With the Rafale system, though, you can clearly see the distance between the target and the no-go areas in the display. There’s no estimation anymore, which is very reassuring.” o

aircraft sold at the 2009 show

d e ul th at w, co for us ho u t e irs yo ke Se s A and tic w! ri - tor ho Pa D56 isi irs v A et E i al RE ba Ch a F Du in w

52,978 trade visitors in 2009

The Dubai Airshow WHERE BUSINESS DELIVERS

13-17 NOVEMBER 2011 WWW.DUBAIAIRSHOW.AERO

YOUR AEROSPACE INNOVATION COULD CHANGE THE WORLD Consider using our flight test services for your reality check Fleet of nine research aircraft, both fixedand rotary-wing Flight simulator model development services Specialized pilot and engineer training

Your vision. Our solution.

Contact our team: 1-877-NRC-CNRC | nrc.gc.ca/business

v2e_IAR-Paris_ad_BW-12024-E.indd 6

11-06-01 11:25 AM

AINonline & BJTonline iPhone Apps

NOW AVAILABLE

BUSINESS JET

TRAVELER

www.AINonline.com

www.BJTonline.com

78 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

TE Connectivity touts ‘intelligent’ electronics by Gregory Polek One of the newest names in aerospace technical trends that the whole industry is is also one of the biggest, but even before evolving to,” said Graves. “So, [I’m referTyco Electronics became TE Connectiv- ring to] better use of power consumption ity this past March, few in the industry on the aircraft, more reliable power. As would have guessed that the company fuel costs increase, everybody’s looking provides more aircraft part numbers to for weight and size reduction. As they the OEMs than any other company in put more electronics on and as they’re putting more sophisticated systhe world. Now, in the age of tems in every area–like sensors the “more electric” aircraft, TE or monitoring what’s going on Connectivity might also claim in the aircraft and IFE systems– the mantle as one of the most they’re looking at higher speeds technologically dynamic, if not and more bandwidth in terms by design, by necessity. of the electronics. All that has No longer simply a supplier to happen with improved reliof electronic parts, TE Conability because aircraft are staynectivity has become what the ing in flight longer that they company’s aerospace business Russ Graves were designed to do years ago.” development manager, Russ The imperative for more effective Graves, called a provider of integrated “solutions.” For example, the company power management is further driven by offers more “smart” electronics, in which the fact while aircraft may have been it embeds “intelligence” into the elec- designed for a 20-year life, they are trical components to aid functional- increasingly being required to put in 30 ity. Such multifunction capacity means years of service. Such trends and the 1996 crash of components not only conduct electricity, they also monitor currents, for instance, TWA Flight 800 have led to more oversight of electrical “interconnects” by explained Graves. Here at the Paris Air Show, TE Con- aviation authorities, explained Graves, nectivity’s Harrisburg, Pennsylvania- leading to an entirely new certification based aerospace, defense and marine regime dedicated to an aircraft’s EWIS group represents the company’s inter- (electrical wire interconnection system). ests in “backbone” wiring and electrical In effect since late 2007, the new EWIS interconnect for both power and signal requirements mean OEMs must certify distribution in aircraft. The major sup- their electrical interconnect system the plier of such systems to aircraft OEMs same way they would an avionics system, such as Boeing and Airbus as well as for example. TE Connectivity specialsub-tier suppliers such as Honeywell and izes in the supply and integration of the Rockwell Collins, TE builds the primary vast range of components that comprise means by which virtually all of an air- an EWIS–from connectors, to wires, to craft’s electronic components integrate terminations, said Graves. “We’re actually the company that is probably best and work in harmony. “Basically we’re playing to the positioned to address the EWIS requirements,” he stressed. Although the new regulations don’t apply to the Boeing 787 because the manufacturer applied for the type certificate before the effective date, they do apply to the Airbus A350 and Bombardier C Series. EWIS aftermarket repair products on display here in Paris accompany a range of what Graves called solution sets that address technology trends such as advanced power management systems, lightning strike protection for aircraft with composite skins, high-speed electrical interconnects and fiber-optics. “We’ve got a couple of demonstrations on fiber-optics; one would be fiberoptic and electrical conversions,” said Graves. “And then we’re also going to be doing inside-the-box applications. So for the avionics manufacturers, if they are now processing a lot of information, they’re going to higher and higher Designed to meet the rising need of small aircraft speeds. We’ve been working with various for automated power, TE’s advanced power industry committees and have created load management system combines software, some solutions around very high-speed embedded microcontrollers, an intuitive GUI, CAN ‘backplane’ solutions that we’re also bus technology, hall effect current monitoring and Hartman contactors. demonstrating.” o

Airbus braces for struggle to keep A350XWB on track

Assemblies for the Airbus A350 include the structure around the flightdeck windscreen.

by Ian Goold As Airbus prepares to put together the first A350XWB, the European manufacturer acknowledges the stiff task it faces to open the final assembly line (FAL) by the end of this year and to fly the aircraft within 12 months thereafter. It says significant challenges remain to start the FAL by year’s end with “an appropriate level of quality to prepare the ramp-up.” Here at the Paris Air Show, Airbus will confirm that first delivery of the new A350 twin-aisle twinjet–which broadly addresses the same airline requirements as the much-delayed Boeing 787, and some of those at which the 777 is aimed– will be made before 2014. This week’s show also could see first official news of a more powerful engine for the largest A350 model, the -1000. Louis Gallois, head of Airbus parent company European Aeronautic Defence and Space (EADS), told shareholders in mid-May that the A350 first delivery is still scheduled for the second half of 2013, although the timetable remains “challenging.” At the beginning of June, Airbus chief operating officer Fabrice Brégier conceded that some A350 suppliers had suffered problems with quality in preparing for full production of carbonfiber-reinforced plastic (CFRP) composites parts to an unfamiliar high standard (see related story on page 42). “This is the moment of truth, where everything that’s been designed has to be produced,” said Brégier. Airbus has learned from the A380 that assembly should not begin too early: “It’s more important to get everything right, so we’re not taking any shortcuts.” Next steps in the program include the start of what Airbus terms prefinal assembly, where major component assembly (MCA) takes place before completed structures are shipped to the FAL. These pre-FALs at the Airbus factories in Broughton (UK), St. Nazaire (France) and Hamburg (Germany) are to start

their work on the first A350 before October, followed by the beginning of system installation and equipping in the fourth quarter. Airbus told AIN this month that large parts for the A350 (MSN 001) have been made and that new CFRP technology is ready for manufacturing. Before this week, Airbus had taken orders for 574 aircraft of all three variants–the A350-800, -900 (the first to enter service) and -1000. Last year the OEM enjoyed a net increase of 63 orders, the business comprising new or further orders from Air China, Cathay Pacific, TAM and United Airlines. Despite calls for higher capacity in recent months, the manufacturer has been adamant it would not stretch the A350-1000, for which definition freeze is expected by year-end. Nor has it confirmed there would be no change to this 350-passenger model, which competes against the 370-seat Boeing 777-300ER. Airbus does acknowledge that the -1000 would benefit from higher thrust from its Rolls-Royce Trent XWB engines, albeit with consequent increased fuel consumption, larger-diameter fan (or re-worked core) and a stronger pylon. Two weeks ago, Airbus and Rolls-Royce declined to comment on an airlinesourced report that a bigger engine variant was to be developed. In April, the manufacturer had said it would consider offering a Pratt & Whitney geared turbofan (GTF)-powered version should the U.S. engine company suggest it. Airbus chief commercial officer customers John Leahy was quoted by aviation commentator AirInsight as saying: “We certainly could consider the GTF for the A350 if Pratt & Whitney propose it. They haven’t yet [but] I know they have looked at airplanes in that category. If [P&W] wants to propose an engine, we’d certainly look at it. If [RollsRoyce] wants to give us reasons to go exclusively with them, we’d certainly take Production of major component assemblies for the Airbus A350 are under way at EADS aerostructures subsidiary Aerolia in Méaulte, France.

a look at that, too.” He confirmed that the A350-1000 might require more power to increase range or payload and that he was against an increase in size. Also in April, Thales announced it is working with Airbus to equip the A350 with its TopConnect Ka-Band communications equipment, which is designed to provide global broadband connectivity at “an affordable and consistent price,” including the potential for Internet protocol-based broadcast. Early Maturity for A350

A major consideration for the European manufacturer from the beginning has been to ensure early A350 maturity once it enters service, which Airbus said is “developing well” through major bench tests now under way. “Large systems integration benches, such as ‘Iron Bird [0] and High Lift 0’ [are] already in place 18 months before first flight,” said Airbus. “Commissioning of other benches– ‘Landing Gear 0’ and ‘Cabin 0’–will follow this year.” According to Airbus, some early maturity has been achieved through a new systems strategy deployed at A350 suppliers. “We have adopted a new approach based on risk-sharing partners working in the extended enterprise environment,” said Airbus, which reports that new tools and work methods have been deployed in the past two years. It claims the strategy has been proved by the “finalization of the detail design in a collaborative environment, such as full three-dimensional [design of electrical wiring] harnesses.” The airframer has said that current challenges for partners are focused on managing “the volume of tasks, such as assembly drawings, and on their own supply-chain management.” Risk-sharing suppliers are coached “through business operational support and resident teams.” A valuable contribution to the A350 development has come through adoption of a “realistic human experiment analysis [RHEA] platform.” Developed by EADS Innovation Works, RHEA is said to offer “a virtual-reality space for ergonomics studies on future products and their manufacturing process.” It permits assembly and maintenance workers to train on products to which access is normally difficult and has been deployed in the Hamburg, St. Nazaire and Toulouse factories. Airbus claims to have established

“robust” foundations for the composites-based A350, with many program risks having been mitigated. Such mitigation has occasionally been at the expense of more time having been spent on, for example, the wing-root joint, damage tolerance on stringers, and electrical systems installation–but always to the benefit of maturity. The manufacturer claims that lessons drawn from previous programs have led to the following: • A new development process and ways of working, based on “application of strict maturity gates; • Configuration-control processes being driven by digital mock-up (DMU) management; • Common tools and processes enabling optimized design work in areas such as interfaces between systems and structures; • Comprehensive demonstrator program to train teams in CFRP technology; • Catalog-based customization to ease “head of version” development and enable ramp-up; and • Production control through launch teams and “rigorous” alert processes. Technical challenges with the A350 have included commissioning of very large tooling, development of optimized composites lay-up and curing processes, and nondestructive testing of complex CFRP parts. “The challenge in the coming months will be the release of [DMU] manufacturing data [50,000 assembly drawings] to enable manufacturing, structure assembly, systems installation and ‘attestation’ with the right level of quality,” reported Airbus. Suppliers Come On Line

Achievements this year include the delivery of A350-900 main- and nosewheel undercarriage units by Messier-Dowty and Liebherr Aerospace, respectively, and their installation for integrated systems testing in the Landing Gear 0 rig at Filton (UK). A prime testing focus is enhanced operational performance to provide improved maintenance economics. According to Messier-Dowty, increased use of titanium and use of corrosion-resistant materials and more environmentally responsible processes have contributed to weight saving and improved maintainability. Full integration testing involving all three

Continued on next page u

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 79

The outer shell of the BAE Systems HMSS helmet is covered with LED pimples. The tracking systems selects the three optimum LEDs to precisely plot the pilot’s head position.

BS074, a single-seat Typhoon for the Royal Air Force, was the 100th aircraft to be delivered from the Warton assembly line. So far 260 Typhoons have been delivered.

Ton-up for Warton Line

Typhoon helmet nears front line by David Donald Typhoon pilots with Britain’s Royal Air Force will soon be flying with a helmet-mounted system that will significantly increase their situational awareness (SA), particularly in the airto-air role. Known as the helmet-mounted symbology system (HMSS), the helmet is built by the BAE Systems Platform Solutions facility at Rochester in the southeast of England. The HMSS is currently undergoing operational evaluation and tactical development with the RAF’s No. 17 Test and Evaluation Squadron at Coningsby, with the aim of fielding it later this year. Other Typhoon operators will follow and are modifying aircraft for use with the HMSS, but different clearance procedures

means it is the RAF that is taking the lead. Weighing in at just over four pounds with the mask, the HMSS comprises an outer helmet covered with an array of pulsing LEDs. Three fixed tracking sensors are mounted in the cockpit (one on each side and one behind the seat) that measure the angles of three of the LEDs to establish a highly accurate position of the pilot’s head. The tracking system automatically selects which three LEDs are measured in order to provide the most accurate information, in turn allowing precise headtracking across the entire range of possible head movement. The HMSS is fully integrated with the aircraft’s weapon system so that fuzed sensor

Airbus A350XWB on track for ramp up uContinued from preceding page undercarriage units is scheduled to begin in about six months’ time. Another milestone earlier this year was opening of the Harbin Hafei Airbus Composite Manufacturing Centre joint venture in Harbin, China, to make A350 rudders and elevators, fuselage fairings and Section 19 (rear fuselage) maintenance-access doors, many of which comprise more than 50 percent composites materials. Last month saw the cabin-systems test platform in Hamburg powered for “verification and validation” of components. Airbus claims the rig is unique: “ATA chapters such as water/waste, communications and air supply [can] be examined individually [for proper working and] can be tested for smooth interplay in a real aircraft for the first time.” Production of the A350’s Section 11-12 structure around the flightdeck windscreen is under way at EADS’s

information–from both onboard and offboard sources–is presented along with crucial flight data on the helmet visor. Targets that are outside the cockpit’s visual limits can still be “seen” through the skin of the aircraft. Voice command allows targets to be locked and prioritized Weapons Systems Cues

In the air-to-air role, in which it is usually the weapon system telling the pilot where targets are, the HMSS combines with advanced weapons to provide a clear advantage in air combat at shorter ranges. “With the HMSS, the ‘knife fight in a phone box’ is a thing of the past,” said Mark Bowman, chief test pilot of BAE Systems MAI. “Combining this big SA

aerostructures subsidiary Aerolia in Méaulte, France. Since May, an Airbus working party has been preparing A380 MSN-001 to act as a flying test bed for the Trent XWB later this year. Airbus said that manufacturing of large CFRP components for A350 MSN001 is under way at all plants and that production of parts can proceed. “Only [the] very last few open tasks will have to be completed in the [coming] weeks.” Fuselage Assembly Under Way

In March, A350 partners Premium Aerotec and Spirit AeroSystems reported curing of the largest A350 fuselage panel, which had been made at their respective Nordenham (Germany) and Kinston (U.S.) sites. The 1,000-sq-ft panel, which is part of the starboard forward fuselage (Section 13-14), includes cutouts for the second right-hand passenger and lowerdeck cargo doors. Large panels were chosen because their thicknesses can be tailored locally to absorb different loads, according to Premium, which also produces A350 forward-crown panels. “This enables Airbus

80 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

In late May the final assembly line at BAE Systems’ Military Air & Information plant at Warton delivered its 100th Typhoon (BS074), becoming the first of the partner companies to achieve this milestone. Over 260 aircraft have now been delivered by the four assembly lines. Warton’s total includes the first 24 aircraft for the Royal Saudi Air Force. It was planned to move final assembly of the remaining 48 Saudi aircraft to the Kingdom itself, but the final decision on this has yet to be taken, and it is likely that they will be completed at Warton. Adding these aircraft to those under contract for the RAF will see the Warton assembly line in business at the current rate of 25 aircraft per year until the end of 2017. –D.D.

with the digital ASRAAM gives a very high kill rate.” For air-toground work, the HMSS can be used to cue the weapons system to look at particular areas of interest, slewing the radar and other sensors to where the pilot is looking. Currently, the HMSS can be used to steer the Captor radar, Pirate IRST and missiles. It does not yet have a full nightvision capability so that, for the time being, night-vision goggles are used, with some limits on maneuvering imposed by aeromedical concerns. Development work is under way to provide night-vision

to optimize the airframe [for] enhanced performance, greater robustness and less weight,” said Premium. After ultrasonic inspection, trimming and drilling, the panel was joined to other forward-fuselage components. Spirit AeroSystems manufactures the center fuselage crown. Manufacturing of lower wing covers and rear-fuselage barrels has begun at Illescas, Spain, and upper wing covers in Stade, Germany. The center wing box and keel beam are being constructed at Nantes, France. Another element of the A350 earlymaturity program involves the first “virtual” flights scheduled to begin later this year on the “Iron Bird” test rig in Toulouse. Next year the rig will be used for extensive integration testing of the electric, hydraulic and flight control systems. “Starting well ahead of the [real] first flight and entry into service is the key to delivering full in-service maturity from Day 1,” said Airbus. High-lift system tests are being conducted in Bremen, Germany. Airbus said the A350-900 flapassembly full-scale mock-up measures 111.5 feet long by 23 feet wide.

functionality and to increase the amount of imagery that can be displayed. Other efforts are aimed at preparing the HMSS for use with the Meteor air-to-air missile and e-scan radar, for which new symbology sets are being devised. BAE Systems is working toward greater customization of the human-machine interface to tailor displays and information to both operational requirements and personal preferences. The concept of a helmet system that can be set up to a pilot’s display preferences, and then individually refined and used throughout their career is one avenue being explored. o

Currently, the manufacturer is preparing for the start of pre-FALs at Broughton, Hamburg, St. Nazaire and Getafe (Spain). It plans to start all major-component assembly during mid-2011 so that the first units can be delivered to the FAL at the end of the year. The preFALs assemble structures such as the vertical tailfin and horizontal tailplane, wing, fuselage Sections 11/14, 16/19, and 15/21, and install systems, including ducts, electrical harnesses, pipes and tubes. The A350 FAL building has been completed and installation of jigs and tools is under way. Airbus is determined to meet its A350 schedule by starting final assembly of the first aircraft “at the end of this year,” but remains acutely aware of the need to manage the program well. As Gallois said in mid-May, “This program continues to require our closest attention.” o

Sikorsky debuts Canadian multi-role CH-148 Cyclone by Bill Carey Sikorsky Aircraft Corp. is displaying the Canadian Forces CH-148 Cyclone multi-mission helicopter at this year’s Paris Air Show. The aircraft on show (Static Display F210) was built under Sikorsky’s Canadian Maritime Helicopter Project (CMHP) and is one of 28 CH-148s that will be produced for the Canadian Forces to replace CH-124 Sea King helicopters, in service since 1963. Sikorsky, headquartered in Stratford, Connecticut (Hall 3 D108), was awarded the CMHP contract from the Canadian government in November 2004. The first “fully compliant” helicopter is scheduled for delivery in July 2012, with delivery of all 28 by December 2013, according to the Canadian Forces. Primary subcontractor General Dynamics Canada, Ottawa, Ontario (Hall 3 E63), is providing the aircraft’s integrated mission system (IMS) software and hardware. The Cyclone’s IMS integrates acoustic, radar,

electro-optical and self-defense sensors. The first aircraft with complete mission system hardware installed–No. 802–made its maiden flight in July 2009. Powered by twin GE Aviation CT7-8 turboshafts, the Cyclone is a derivative of Sikorsky’s S-92A commercial search-andrescue helicopter, designed for shipboard operations with folding main and tail rotors and a deck haul-down and handling system. It will operate from Halifax-class frigates for missions including anti-submarine warfare, anti-surface warfare and search and rescue. The Cyclone has a Rockwell Collins glass cockpit and digital fly-by-wire flight control system. Among other suppliers, Flir Systems provides the Star Safire III electro-optical/infrared sensor; Lockheed Martin, AN/ALQ-210 passive electronic support measures; BAE Systems, ALQ144 infrared jammer; and Symetrics, ALE-47 flare and chaff dispensers.

Sikorsky said the CH-148 recently completed ship/helicopter operating limits testing, verifying flight and deck operations, as well as demonstrating onboard maintenance. The company is proposing a helicopter based on the Canadian CH-148 to the German navy as a “low-risk solution” to that service’s helicopter requirements. Partners in that effort include Rheinmetall Defence Group, Ruag, MTU Aero Engines and ZFL. “We believe the Cyclone helicopter represents the ‘aircraft of the future’ for

maritime forces around the globe,” said Carey Bond, Sikorsky Global Helicopters president. “This is a helicopter that offers significant advancements in technology. It is clearing a path for delivery of an extremely sophisticated, flexible aircraft that will be among the most capable maritime helicopters in its class.” o

Crane raises global profile with four new contracts

DAVID McINTOSH

Crane Aerospace (Hall 4 A188) has just signed several new international agreements as part of its strategy to raise its global profile. First, the U.S. company is to be a channel partner with Aero Precision (Hall 3 Stand

Gregg Herman, Crane Aerospace Group director, displays one of his company’s antiskid brake controls. Crane recently agreed to provide antiskid control systems for international C-130 operators.

C132) providing carbon brake control systems to international Lockheed Martin C-130 operators. Aero Precision will provide sales and distribution services for the Crane’s Mark IV antiskid brake control system. Lynwood, Washington-based Crane has also signed a representation agreement with Brazil’s Jetstar Aviation to

provide support in the local marketplace. “Since 2009 we have increased our support presence by four. We have put people in Asia, Europe and Brazil to support Airbus, Comac and Embraer, and are signing partnership agreements to provide local support,” said Gregg Herman, Crane’s Aerospace Group director, OEM Sales and Customer Management. He pointed to new aircraft production programs that offer new opportunities, such as the Embraer 450/500, as well as the Comac C919 and the Airbus A350XWB. Crane will also provide transformer rectifier units (TRUs) on the electrical power distribution systems (EDPS) for the Airbus A350XWB. There are seven TRUs in the EDPS, which control and monitor the electrical DC power distribution to the loads on the aircraft. In a separate agreement, another Crane division will provide the fuel-flow transmitter for the Rolls Royce Trent XWB engine. Esterline Advanced Sensors (Hall 5 B242) will integrate the transmitter with a suite of sensing products. Herman added that Crane’s MRO division is also expanding its capabilities internationally and said that his appointment book for Paris is completely full. “The Airbus A320neo is likely to be a big show story, and we are already providing the landing gear control and interface unit for the A320,” he said. –L.M.

Ka-32A11BC

BEYOND COMPETITION IN EXTREME SITUATIONS

A bi-turbine helicopter with a dual rotor system. Highly efficient in fire fighting operations, due to large water discharge capacity, manoeuvrability and fast cruising speed. Used in different application versions: firefighting, SAR, HEMS, land and sea surveillance, ecological monitoring, transportation of fire brigade, external lift, heliborne operations and transport. more at www.rus-helicopters.ru

E X P E R I E N C E & I N N O VAT I O N

2a, bld 2, Sokolnicheskiy Val st. Moscow, 107113, Russian Federation Tel: +7 (495) 981-6373 Fax: +7 (495) 981-6395 E-mail: info@rus-helicopters.com

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 81

Two conventional takeoff and landing (CTOL) F-35A versions for the U.S. Air Force fly in formation. The first two production aircraft are now at Edwards Air Force Base, California, and two more will be delivered to Eglin AFB, Florida, shortly.

program on its own dollar; • the last four of 13 development aircraft made their first flights, and the first two F-35A production aircraft (AF6 and AF7) were delivered; • static testing was completed five months ahead of schedule with no failures (but a bulkhead on the F-35B fatigue test article cracked). In a recent briefing, Steve O’Bryan, Lockheed Martin vice president F-35 customer engagement, talked up progress. “We’re seeing very reliable flight-test airplanes. We are 20 percent ahead of the TBR on flight tests, and 30 percent ahead on test points,” he said. The development fleet has already flown more than 350 times this year, and more than 800 times in total. Another 500plus test flights are scheduled this calendar year. (O’Bryan did not mention the in-flight generator failure last March, which was attributed to excess lubrication, but did not materially affect flight-test progress). “Software stability is good compared to legacy platforms,” O’Bryan said. The Block 1 software, which provides an initial training capability, is now flying on the next two production F-35As (AF8 and AF9). They are due for delivery to Eglin AFB, the F-35 training base, shortly. The pace of mission system software development will be accelerated by the addition of another test line manned by 190 people this summer, as mandated by the TBR. The Block 2 software is now being loaded into the CATbird flying test bed. This adds about one million lines of code (LOC) to the six million already written for Blocks 0.5 and 1. Block 2 provides the F-35 with networking capability and therefore “an initial war-fighting capability.” It will be on the low-rate initial production (LRIP) Lot 3 and 4 jets. Eventually, another two million LOC must be written and tested for the definitive Block

Stealthy F-35 stalked by cost, technical issues by Chris Pocock The Lockheed Martin F-35 development program has met or exceeded the revised flighttest schedule that was written following a technical baseline restructuring (TBR) last August, according to Lockheed Martin officials. But some significant technical issues remain, and affordability continues to be a key concern for the new-generation combat aircraft. The Pentagon is expected to make further adjustments to the F-35 development and production plan shortly. Since around this time last year: • the fourth low-rate initial production batch was contracted, comprising 31 aircraft costing from $127 million to $158 million each, depending on version; • Israel confirmed that it would receive 19 F-35As worth $2.75 billion; • after a defense review, the UK switched its order from F-35B STOVL versions to

F-35C carrier landing versions; • the Pentagon ordered a further stretchout in production, added 13 months and $4.6 billion to the development phase, and put the F-35B STOVL version on a “two-year probation.” Lockheed Martin and Pratt & Whitney admitted four F-35B development problems, but described solutions for each one; • the new head of the F-35 Joint Program Office (JPO) said the projected costs to produce and sustain the F-35 were “simply unacceptable.” He also said that initial operating capability cannot be achieved in 2016, as planned; • night-vision problems with the Israeli-designed helmet emerged. The F-35 has no headup display (HUD), so this helmet is the pilot’s primary flight display; • work on the alternative F136 engine stopped when Congressional funding lapsed, although the GE/Rolls-Royce team pledged to continue the

The F-35B short-takeoff and vertical landing (STOVL) version is in some technical trouble. Lockheed Martin says fixes are in hand, but weight concerns persist. The U.S. Marine Corps and Italy are still counting on the F-35B, but the UK switched to the F-35C version last year.

82 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

3 with full data fusion, which should be flying by 2015 in time for initial operational test and evaluation the following year. To speed the process, the TBR re-allocated three of the early LRIP jets to mission systems software development (and another three to other development tasks). The first flight tests of the F-35’s low observability have produced “very, very good results,” according to JPO chief vice admiral David Venlet. Development aircraft AF3 flew against radars and signature measurement devices on the Nevada Test Range and validated the results previously achieved in ground tests. Now the challenge is to replicate the same degree of

stealth on each aircraft off the production line. And, for sure, the first two production aircraft–AF6 and AF7–did recently pass the stealth test in the anechoic chamber and in pole testing. The F-35 pilot’s helmet is supplied by Vision Systems International (VSI), a U.S.-based joint venture between Rockwell Collins and Elbit Systems. O’Bryan said it is flying successfully in daytime flight, although there have been reports of jitter in the projected symbology. In addition, the challenge of providing night vision by importing medium-wave infrared imagery (MWIR) from the aircraft’s distributed aperture system has proved difficult

What Will the F-35 Cost? After the preliminary design review was completed on schedule in April 2003, every subsequent milestone in the F-35 program was missed by at least one year. Yet Lockheed Martin continued to exude optimism, rejecting criticism that production was being ramped up before development and producibility issues were solved. The company’s credibility having been dented, its predictions that the ultimate unit cost of the first stealthy international fighter jet could still be $60 million (F-35A CTOL version, 2010 dollars) are raising eyebrows–especially when the cost has been contradicted by various U.S. government reports. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) talks of a “near doubling” in average unit prices since the program began. When the F-35 program breached the Nunn-McCurdy Act 12 months ago, the Pentagon predicted to Congress an average unit production cost of $133 million in current dollars. But the unit cost of an F-35 will vary greatly depending on sub-type, and whether it is contracted within the low-rate initial production (LRIP) Lots or the supposedly much more efficient multi-year buys (MYBs) that will follow. As things stand, however, the MYBs will not begin until fiscal year 2018, two years later than previously planned. So there will now be 11 LRIP buys. Lockheed Martin said the ramp-up rate is the key to affordability. It is still planning for a peak production rate of 20 aircraft per month. But as the GAO noted, the F-35 program places unprecedented demands for funding–an average $11 billion per year for the next two decades–on a shrinking defense budget. The implication is that the U.S. will not be able to afford anything like the 2,443 aircraft that it currently plans to buy. The 30 LRIP Lot 4 jets are the first to be contracted on a fixed-price-incentive-fee basis. When the separately contracted cost of the F135 engine is added ($15 million for the F-35A CTOL and F-35C CV engine, and $32 million for the F-35B STOVL engine), the unit cost comes to $126.6 million each for the 11 F-35As, S141.4 million each for the 17 F-35Bs and $157.9 million for the four F-35Cs. Lockheed Martin will receive another $511 million for the logistics and sustainment of these aircraft, on a cost-reimbursable, not-to-exceed basis. The F-35 Joint Program Office (JPO) said it cannot yet adequately identify and price risk to negotiate fixed-price contracts for support. Further, Lockheed Martin received a contract worth $820 million to prepare for increased production rates in future years, again on a cost-reimbursable, not-to-exceed basis. Negotiations on logistics and sustainment packages continue and are a major focus for the JPO this year. The GAO now says “current F-35 life-cycle cost estimates are considerably higher than the legacy aircraft it will replace.” Last year, the U.S. Navy predicted that total life-cycle costs for the F-35 program would exceed one trillion dollars. How does Lockheed Martin react to that startling statistic? “That figure is based on all 2,443 planned aircraft for the U.S. flying for 52 years from more than 50 bases, using cost data derived from legacy aircraft in then-year dollars,” O’Bryan said. “The F-35 is subject to more key performance parameters (KPPs) relating to sustainment than any other fighter jet,” he said. “For instance, after 200,000 fleet hours it must be twice as reliable as an F-16 or an F-18.” –C.P.

so far. Therefore, Lockheed Martin has recently issued an RFP for “traditional” night-vision goggles hoping that this unanticipated add-on would require only a minimal modification of the aircraft’s cockpit displays. An alternative view of F-35 development progress was offered by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) in its latest audit of the program two months ago. “As of December 2010, about four percent of F-35 capabilities have been completely verified by flight tests, lab results, or both. Only three of the extensive network of 32 ground test labs and simulation models are fully accredited to ensure the fidelity of results,” the GAO reported. “Engineering changes continue at higher than expected rates...and more changes are expected as testing accelerates,” it added. Software development is a moving target, it noted; the total lines of code predicted to be needed for the F-35 is already 40 percent greater than originally anticipated. What of the troubled F-35B program? Was U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates being unduly pessimistic when he spoke of the possible need to “redesign the aircraft’s structure and propulsion...changes that could add yet more weight and more cost to an aircraft that has little capacity to absorb more of either.” According to O’Bryan, reliability problems with the STOVL version’s liftfan actuators and rudder pedals that limited flight test sorties last year have been overcome. A design to strengthen the auxiliary inlet doors so that they can be opened at high speed (250 knots) has passed preliminary design review, and will be flight tested early next year. Driveshaft spacers that solve a thermal expansion problem have already been

fitted to the five development aircraft. The problem of unexpected heating at the wingtip roll-post actuators will be solved by adding extra insulation. Additional cooling air may be supplied to the lift-fan clutch, which has also been overheating slightly. A steel patch has been designed to strengthen the F-35B rear fuselage bulkhead, which cracked during ground durability tests. But this adds a bit more weight to an aircraft that may already be uncomfortably close to the maximum for vertical landings with a full weapons load.

The helmet-mounted display (HMD) on the F-35 replaces the head-up display, and is thus essential to the pilot’s situational awareness. Problems in projecting the night-vision scene provided by the aircraft’s sensors onto the HMD may not be overcome, forcing a second-best solution of night-vision goggles.

The weight that was saved in the big redesign of the F-35 structure in 2005 was driven by the F-35B’s power/weight ratio, but was evidently not enough to address this problem. The contractor and the prime customer (the U.S. Marine Corps) are still discussing what the final margin should be. Could Pratt & Whitney provide some increased thrust in the F135? Possibly, but this might further raise engine operating temperatures and possibly negate the fixes to the driveshaft, clutch and roll post actuators described above. The F-35B may need all of the two years “probation” that has been directed by the program office. A total of 63 aircraft have now been ordered in four LRIP lots. At Fort Worth, a further two final assembly stations are being added this summer, making seven and thus supporting a rate of four aircraft per month. o

F-35’s Unit Cost Not the Whole Story

Lockheed Martin

According to some observers, there is unquantifiable value in some of the avionics advances in the Lockheed Martin F-35. In a presentation at the Mitchell Centre for Airpower Studies last year, Barry Watts, Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessment, said, “If you look at F-117 and B-2 missions, low observability doesn’t give you [total] invisibility to air defenses, particularly to radar-guided SAMs. “Those routes [to the target], relative to the defenses that we were aware of, had to be carefully planned prior to the mission,” Watts continued. “This airplane’s going to be able to do that in real time [thanks to] the huge amount of computational power that’s available.” In another presentation given at the same According to some commentators, even if the F-35 costs more than expected, the much-expanded event, Lt. Gen. David Deptula, former U.S. Air avionics capabilities are worth the money. This slide Force Deputy Chief of Staff, A-2, stated, “With compares the synthetic aperture radar-mapping the ability to rapidly collect, analyze, transmode, offered by the aircraft’s Northrop Grumman mit, display and share decision-quality inforAPG-81 radar, with legacy systems. mation across a wide battlespace rapidly...we create...a value that becomes more important than individual unit cost. “The F-35 can take a SAR [synthetic aperture radar] map down to a very fine degree, add that SAR image to its ground moving target indicator and display the difference between fixed and moving, land or maritime,” said Deptula. –C.P.

MARKET INTELLIGENCE, FORECASTING AND CONSULTING SERVICES FOR THE AEROSPACE, DEFENSE, POWER SYSTEMS AND ELECTRONICS INDUSTRIES

Visit us at Hall 3, Booth C-145 AINParishalf1.indd 1

5/12/2011 11:36:35 AM

www.ainonline.com • June 20, 2011 • Paris Air Show News 83

747-8 production line returns to ‘balance’ produced twenty-one 747-8s, five of which participated in Freighter flight testing and two of which have flown tests for the certification of the Intercontinental (the 787-8 passenger version), due by the end of the year. By June 2 Boeing had finished some 87 percent of the test items needed for certification, said Lund, and the first test airplane had finished all its flight test duties. With four airplanes remaining in the Freighter flight-test program, Boeing has “retired” all of its high-risk testing, she added. Earlier this month, Freighter airplane number-one needed to accomplish about a week-anda-half of stability and control testing; airplane number-two was finishing propulsion certification testing; airplane number-three performed what Lund called some miscellaneous testing and the Freighter program’s last airplane, airplane numberfive, began flying functionality and reliability testing on June 1. Meanwhile, the two flighttest articles used to test the 747-8 Intercontinental had already finished some 25 percent of their required flying since the first example took to the air in March and the second in April. The first airplane has completed the first phase of the stability and control program, during which Boeing gains an understanding of its handling and performance characteristics and runs through “tuning cycles” for software programs related to items such as autoland and autoflight. The second Intercontinental, a Lufthansa aircraft equipped with a full interior, has begun testing changes made to the environmental control system

DAVID McINTOSH

The so-called “pause” or “rebalance” of the Boeing 747-8 production line officially ended on June 7 as the company prepared to bring both new versions of its venerable jumbo jet–the Freighter and the Intercontinental–to Paris for this year’s salon. Although it never stopped work on the line, Boeing instituted the “rebalancing” to prepare for an eventual rate increase from one-and-a-half airplanes to two per month, starting this September or October with “on the job training.” According to Elizabeth Lund, 747-8 vice president and general manager, the actual rate break will happen in December, and the first delivery at the new rate will occur next May. “We called it a rebalance– a pause–and there’s reason we called it a rebalance,” said Lund. “I think some people have asked, ‘Is it a shutdown?’ A shutdown has a connotation that we’ve had to shut down the line because we don’t have enough parts and things, and that’s absolutely not where we’re at right now. “This is an established supply chain; it’s really the traditional 747 supply chain, and the supply chain is healthy. And we’ve just taken this chance to really work through all of our engineering issues, get them all back in sequence, get in position so we can go into rate break healthy.” Although Boeing said it did not expect the measure to affect the schedule for first delivery of the 747-8F Freighter to Cargolux when it announced the pause in line movement in early May, Lund told reporters during an early June briefing in Everett, Washington, that first delivery would happen some time this summer. The program has now

84 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

Now having accumulated some 300 hours of flight testing, the 747-8I has traveled along a far smoother track toward certification than its freighter sibling, although engineering changes associated with the Intercontinental had contributed to a monthlong production line “rebalancing.”

(ECS) to accommodate the new, larger interior, said Lund. “We also just finished our NAMS [nautical air mileage survey] testing for the Intercontinental,” she said. “And we are understanding exactly what the fuel performance and fuel burn will be on the aircraft.” An early problem involved buffeting at flaps setting 30 on the Freighter, forcing an adjustment to the detents to make them identical to those on the Intercontinental. Another problem centered on a 2.3-hertz vibration at the tip of the wing. Although Lund said the one-inch of movement didn’t amount to a safety issue, test pilots could feel it and it didn’t dampen itself on its own, technically signaling flutter. Boeing solved that problem with an outboard aileron modal suppression system dampens pitch, counteracting the oscillation in the wing tips and effectively removing the vibration. “So the big [problems] that you’ve been hearing us talk about that delayed the program are behind us,” said Lund, who added that Boeing has applied all the fixes to the Intercontinental as well. Featuring new General Electric GENx-2B engines, a redesigned wing, new alloys in the fuselage and a new interior in the Intercontinental that can hold 51 more passengers and 26 percent more cargo in the lower

Left to right, Boeing Company CEO Jim McNerney, 747 chief test pilot Mark Feuerstein, Boeing Business Jets president Steve Taylor, 747-8 program manager Elizabeth Lund, Boeing Commercial Airplanes CEO James Albaugh and BCA v-p and general manager of airplane programs Pat Shanahan celebrate the arrival of the 747-8I here in Paris.

lobe than the 747-400 can carry, the 747-8 also uses a completely new flight management computer that Lund admitted “absolutely” presented “challenges. “What’s made this a difficult development program is just the complexity of the FMC [flight management computer] and the brand-new architecture,” said Lund. Although Honeywell’s

FMC will not immediately deliver all the functionality its designers had initially planned, it will do everything the computer on the 747-400 can do, and more, she insisted. In fact, by the time the Intercontinental enters service, Boeing expects the FMC to prove itself even more capable after some further software development. o

India selects Pilatus PC-7 for urgent trainer needs by David Donald India has selected the Pilatus PC-7 Mk II to answer its requirement for a basic trainer. The procurement of the new aircraft was hastened by the grounding of the piston-powered HAL HPT32 Deepak fleet in July 2009, following 17 crashes. While waiting for the new trainer to enter service, India’s pilots have begun their instruction in the jet-powered HAL Kiran Mk II or BAE Systems Hawk advanced trainers. Seven companies responded to India’s urgent request for information, including Aermacchi (M311) and Embraer (Super Tucano). Five were invited to trials and were issued with a request for proposals. Last October, the Pilatus PC-7 Mk II, EADS PZL-130 Orlik TC-II, Grob G-120TP, Hawker Beechcraft T-6C and Korean Aerospace Industries KT-1B were put through their paces in a five-day evaluation at Jamnagar air base, with trials being conducted by test pilots and Indian Air Force instructors. Following the evaluations a shortlist of the PC-7, T-6 and

KT-1 was reportedly drawn up, after which acquisition proposals were examined, leading to the selection of Pilatus, announced last week, as reportedly the lowest bidder. The deal is in the final stages of negotiation and a contract is expected to be signed soon. The initial requirement covers 75 aircraft, procured off the shelf as dictated by the program’s urgency. However, the vast training requirement of the IAF could lead to up to 200 being acquired. The first aircraft are expected to be delivered within six months of the contract award. The Indian selection represents potentially the biggest single deal in Switzerland-based Pilatus’s history, and is believed to be worth about $1 billion. The company is thought to have initially offered proposals based on all three of its turboprop trainer designs: PC-7 Mk II, PC-9 and PC-21. The selection is the PC-7 Mk II’s second success of the year, Botswana having ordered five in April to replace its firstgeneration PC-7s. o

DAVID McINTOSH

by Gregory Polek

PHOTOS: CHRIS POCOCK

The U.S. Air Force fleets of U-2S, above, and Global Hawk UAV, right, high-altitude reconnaissance aircraft are both operated by the 9th Reconnaissance Wing and home-based at Beale AFB, California.

USAF extends life of U-2 as Global Hawk fails OT&E by Chris Pocock The U.S. Air Force is adding new sensors to the Lockheed Martin U-2 Dragon Lady and postponing retirement of the veteran spyplane after the Northrop Grumman Global Hawk UAV failed an operational test and evaluation (OT&E). Meanwhile, Northrop Grumman has mounted a stout defense of its high-altitude reconnaissance drone, and Pentagon acquisition czar Ashton Carter said the Global Hawk is still “essential to national security.” The planned out-of-service-date for the U-2 has been changed from Fiscal Year 2013 to FY 2016, therefore justifying some new investment. It still flies daily reconnaissance missions from bases in the Mediterranean, the Gulf and Korea. The BAE Systems spectral infrared remote imaging transit testbed (SPIRITT) sensor will be added to the U-2 by mid-2012. This hyperspectral system can detect, classify and identify camouflaged and concealed targets, according to BAE Systems. It was originally designed for the U-2 and Global Hawk, but to date has instead found limited application on the Raytheon shared reconnaissance pod (Sharp) for U.S. Navy F/A-18s, C-130s and two testbed aircraft. 26-strong U-2S Fleet

The U-2 can already carry the sevenband multispectral SYERS-2A imaging system, and an additional two of these long-range oblique sensors have been ordered from Goodrich, making eight available for the 26-strong fleet of operational U-2S models. The USAF is also buying an additional four extended tether pods (ETPs, also known as Spur pods) from L-3 Communications, making 12. This pod is mounted on top of the U-2 fuselage, and provides a wideband satellite datalink of the aircraft’s imaging and signals intelligence payloads. In his report released last month, the Pentagon’s director of OT&E declared that the Global Hawk “is not operationally effective for conducting nearcontinuous, persistent ISR [intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance].” During the 41-day evaluation last year, four Block 30 Global Hawks were evaluated in 19 missions over North America that took off from Beale and Edwards Air Force Bases. Because of low air-vehicle reliability,

exacerbated by shortages of spare parts, the Global Hawk could “provide only about 40 percent of requested coverage when used at planned peacetime or non-crisis operational tempos,” the report concluded. At a media briefing today at the Paris Air Show, Ed Walby, Northrop Grumman business development director, will try to put the OT&E report in context. Some of the faults were already identified and fixes were in hand, when the evaluation began, he told AIN last week. These included an unreliable oil pump on the main electrical generator. The system has been underfunded for spare parts, he added. Further, airspace integration issues that contributed to the poor rating affect all unmanned aircraft systems, and won’t be solved

Honeywell goes green uContinued from page 1 biofuel blend, but burning it in all four engines on a nonstop flight from Seattle to Paris. Of course, neither of these two can trump the solar-powered Solar Impulse aircraft also debuting here in Le Bourget– although this isn’t even close to being ready for an intercontinental hop, having taken 16 hours to arrive here from Brussels. According to James Rekoske, v-p and general manager of renewable energy and chemicals for Honeywell UOP, which has led the two-and-a-half-year biofuel development program, the flight accomplished two goals. First, it demonstrates the willingness of the aviation industry to participate in the search for more environmentally friendly fuel sources, and second, it advances approval by the U.S. FAA of the 50/50 Green Jet Fuel blend, which Honeywell expects to receive in mid-July. American Society of Testing Materials (ASTM) approval was granted early this month. The fuel is produced for UOP under license by a Houston, Texas refinery. It was developed under a grant from the U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) and is based on hydro-processing technology commonly used in today’s refineries to produce transportation fuels. The process works by adding hydrogen to remove oxygen from natural

“until FAA regulations or policies are changed,” he said. And since the evaluation, Walby continued, Global Hawks deployed to the European and Pacific theaters had flown 114 “real-world” missions in 45 days supporting NATO operations over Libya and monitoring the Japanese nuclear reactor failure. “The average mission effectiveness rate was 92 percent,” he noted. But some of the issues identified by the evaluation are puzzling, given that Global Hawks from low-rate initial production have already been deployed for most of the past decade. Global Hawk Miscues

Among other items, the report identified “incomplete maintenance technical data, inadequate training and an ineffective integrated diagnostic system.” It also tagged the lack of anti-icing systems, which could restrict operations from cold locations, or during climb and descent. And it stated that it still takes over 100 hours to fully program a mission plan for a new operating area, plus an optional four weeks “to verify flight plant oils. It is further refined to produce a bio-synthetic kerosene, which is then blended with standard jet fuel for use in flight. A half-dozen sources–ranging from algae to the jatropha plant common Brazil– are typically employed in producing biofuels. UOP used the camelina plant–a hardy, inedible species with high oil content–to create Green Jet Fuel, but according to Rekoske, the technology is feedstock-flexible, meaning it can work with any natural oil. Camelina is indigenous to both North American and Europe and provides up to 150 gallons of oil per acre. “It will be four or five years before Green Jet Fuel will be available on a commercial scale at parity with jet fuel,” said Rekoske. And even then, the use of a pure, unblended biofuel is unlikely in the foreseeable future. It may be 30 years before 50/50 blend is in common use across the aviation industry worldwide. As for sustainable biofuel blends becoming the main aviation fuel of the future, Honeywell sees it as unlikely. “The larger issues of economics and sustainability will be the predominate forces surrounding the overall future of biofuels and their penetration into the aviation market,” according to Phoenix, Arizona-based Honeywell Aerospace. “We believe there is no single magic bullet.” There are other hurdles as well. Approximately 85 to 90 percent of the cost of producing any transportation biofuel

plan accuracy and preclude programming errors that could result in the loss of the air vehicle.” Regarding sensors, the report noted that two modes of the UAV’s enhanced imagery sensor suite (EISS) supplied by Raytheon do not meet operational requirements: wide area search and ground moving target indication (GMTI). Moreover, although the high-resolution spot modes of the EISS got good marks, they “cannot provide target-quality coordinates,” according to the report. Deficiencies identified with the other key sensor are more understandable. Only one Block 30 Global Hawk had been equipped with Northrop Grumman’s own airborne signals intelligence payload (ASIP) by the time of the evaluation. The company expressed confidence that three forthcoming software releases will resolve most of the issues, and noted that ASIP has already been “proven with over 300 operational missions on another platform.” Ironically, that platform is the U-2, for which an additional two ASIP sensors are being ordered, making five. o is determined by the cost of the feedstock. The actual conversion makes up the remaining 10 to 15 percent. The cost of conversion of biofuel is competitive with petroleum-based technology, so that the cost of the feedstock is the determining factor. Today, the cost of the resources remains higher than the cost of crude oil, so there is still technological development needed to drive down the cost of harvesting, gathering and processing. “As production increases and more fuel is available, we believe that Green Jet Fuel will be cost competitive,” said Rekoske. In the long term, he expects the price of biofuels to run about 10 to 15 cents more per gallon than jet-A, assuming a global price for petroleum crude of about $100 a gallon. Not only do sustainable biofuels reduce carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, when compared with petroleum-based Jet-A, they also emit less particulate matter and less than one part per million of sulfur. Despite its work in the initial development of its Green Jet Fuel, Honeywell says it does not plan to go into the biofuel business, but will license the process and allow others to continue further development and distribution. o

www.ainonline.com www.ainonline.com • April • June 2011 20, • Aviation 2011 • Paris International Air Show News 85 00

by Julian Moxon Major orders for the new CFM International Leap-X turbofan engine are due to be announced during the first four days of the Paris show, intensifying the battle with Pratt & Whitney to power the Airbus A320neo. “We’re set for this to be one of our best shows ever,” said the company. Pratt & Whitney won all but one of the early engine competitions with its PW1100G geared turbofan, securing firm orders for 480 engines from Lufthansa, ILFC and IndiGo. Just before the show opened, however, CFM launched the Leap-X orderbook with a deal for 60 engines from Virgin America for its 30 A320neos. The airline was an existing CFM customer, but is understood to have selected the Leap-X only after the engine manufacturer met tough performance guarantees. With Airbus predicting that A320neo orders would top 500 aircraft by the end of the show and 1,000 by the end of the year, the engine competition is being particularly hard-fought. Speaking just before the show began, CFM vice president Chaker Chahrour attacked Pratt & Whitney for spreading “myths and propaganda” about the LeapX that claimed it would run hotter than the PW1100G because its direct-drive fan system would require higher turbine entry temperatures. “We absolutely dispute this,” he told AIN. “The Leap X-1A will run at exactly the same temperature as today’s CFM56, which remains onwing for 40,000 hours, the equivalent to around ten years of operations.” Olivier Savin, also CFM v-p, admitted that the recent critical decision to increase the fan diameter of the Leap engine by two inches, to 78 inches (to meet Airbus’s demand for an equivalent fuel burn to the PW1100G), has driven changes to the rest of the engine. “But we weren’t yet at design freeze,” he said. “This is part of a normal design process. The fan is now at its optimum diameter.” Although the change has added some weight to the Leap engine, the bigger fan increases bypass ratio from 10:1 to 11:1, bringing a corresponding 2 percent reduction in fuel burn. Both engines now offer a 15-percent improvement in fuel burn over existing A320 powerplants, enabling Airbus to offer them with fuel-burn parity. “Customers are putting reliability at entry into service as their highest priority,” said Savin. He insisted the LeapX, although a new engine, benefits from mature technologies developed in the GE90 and GEnx programs. “We’ll also have 800 million hours of highly reliable CFM experience by service entry,” he said. On the question of what Boeing will do to compete with the A320neo, Chahrour said CFM is in constant discussions with the airframer. “We have a new engine if they want to go with a new

aircraft, and we can re-engine the existing 737. Boeing knows it will eventually have to come out with a new aircraft, probably by 2019. We want to do whatever is right for them.” If Boeing elects to re-engine the 737, CFM could either offer a smaller version

Honeywell and Safran link on electrically powered taxiing Airline fuel savings of 4 percent and quieter, cleaner airports are predicted for an electrically powered “green” taxiing system for airplanes being developed by Safran and Honeywell. The two companies signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) on Sunday to form a joint-venture company to develop the system. In operation, electric motors mounted on each of the main landing gear bogies would power the wheels from the ramp to a point near to the runway, eliminating the need to taxi with the main aircraft engines at idle, running inefficiently and often for a considerable time. Power for the electric motors would come from the aircraft’s existing auxiliary power unit, which is also a jet-fuel-burning turbine engine. But APUs are much smaller than the main aircraft engines and therefore burn much less fuel. Nevertheless, while the proposed system is described as “electric” and “green,” it will

86 Paris Air Show News • June 20, 2011 • www.ainonline.com

not be completely either one. Pilots would operate the system using cockpit controls, which have not yet been defined. “We’re working with the manufacturers on cockpit philosophy,” said a Honeywell spokesman. “Pilots will feel no difference in the way the aircraft behaves.” Short-haul airlines would reap the maximum benefit, as taxiing accounts for a larger proportion of the total engine running time, consuming up to five million tons of fuel a year. While single-aisle airliners, such as the A320neo, would be the first application, the taxi system would eventually be available for all major airliner types. The two companies say the MOU will enable them to get it to market as rapidly as possible. Initial development began in January, and prototypes will be fitted to an Airbus A320 testbed by mid-2013, with service entry set for 2016. The taxi system (which has yet to be

“headwinds” caused by the rise in oil prices, the tsunami in Japan and Middle East unrest, demand remains strong. “The next 20 years look very positive,” he added. The Leap-X program is ahead of schedule with testing of the second development core having begun in May, a month earlier than scheduled. “So far we’ve had outstanding results,” Savin said. Testing of the third and final versions is planned to begin in early 2013, with the first engine test later in the year. Certification is set for 2015 and service entry a year later. o named) will be available for both new and retrofit aircraft, but Honeywell and Safran were unable to confirm what likely costs would be, or how long it would take to achieve payback on the initial investment. They said only that it would save airlines “several hundred thousand dollars a year per aircraft.” Other advantages of the system include no requirement for tow trucks, reducing time, less use of brakes during taxing, noise and pollution reduction at the ramp, improved safety for ground personnel and reduced ingestion of foreign objects while taxiing. Both companies told AIN they think the deal will pave the way for further joint enterprises. “We’ve found we get on really well together,” said Safran chairman and CEO Jean-Paul Hertemann. The companies are perfectly matched for the enterprise, he said, explaining that Honeywell brings its APU experience and Safran its knowhow on landing gear, wheels and brakes. Together the “companies will bring their expertise in electric power, mechanical systems and system integration, as well as their combined credibility for innovation,” Hertemann added. –J.M.

follow me, little buddy One of the Patrouille de France Alpha Jets flies in trail with the Airbus A400M cargo lifter over LeBourget. The French aerobatic team will perform in the daily aerial demonstration. The A400M also was scheduled to fly at the show, but it has been grounded by an engine problem.

DAVID McINTOSH

CFM promises orders blitz in A320neo battle with Pratt

of the Leap-X or apply Leap-X technology to the existing CFM56-7BE, the latest development of the engine now powering the 737, due for entry into service this month. Despite the global recession, CFM president and CEO Jean-Paul Ebanga predicted that the global single-aisle fleet will double by 2030, to 23,550 aircraft, equivalent to $400 billion worth of engine business. The manufacturer currently holds a backlog of around 5,600 engines and this year has sold 680 engines worth $6.8 billion. Ebanga said that even in a year of

SINGAPORE AIRSHOW 2012, WHERE MINDS MEET AND DEALS ARE SEALED Asia’s largest aerospace and defence event will once again attract the biggest names in our industries. In 2012, we’ll be welcoming the heads of the international aviation community, international government delegations, key political and military leaders and many more. Attend Singapore Airshow 2012 to tap into the unprecedented business opportunities in Asia Pacific’s fastest growing market. Register from 20 to 26 June 2011 via www.singaporeairshow.com and enjoy a waiver of registration fee.

Singapore Airshow 2010 Attendance Figures 259 foreign government and international delegations from 80 countries 897 companies from 36 countries 62 of the top 100 aerospace companies 43,459 trade attendees from 133 countries 27 Airline CEOs

Organised by:

14 - 19 February 2012 Changi Exhibition Centre • Singapore www.singaporeairshow.com

Supported by:

Endorsed by:

Held in:

Official Media Partner:

Supporting Publications:

DELIVERING

A WORLD OF

INNOVATION.

THIS IS HOW From next-generation aircraft and ships to cutting-edge systems for outer space and cyber space, Lockheed Martin innovation leads the way. How? Through trusted partnerships. Deep understanding. And unmatched capabilities. Meeting global security challenges with affordable, proven solutions is all a question of how. And it is the how that Lockheed Martin delivers.

lockheedmartin.com/how