Kwanza
Tanzania
CORONA The Symbiotic Sisal Processing Plant Est .
1962
CORONA
CONTENTS
.01
PREFACE
02 Investigation 03 Tanga, Tanzania
A Corona - Latin, ‘c rown’ is typically an aura of plasma that surrounds the Sun and other stars, it grows, and reaches outward beyond its core.
.07
WHAT
08 The Sisal Industry 12 ReImagination
.17
This term is also the name of a particular machine used in the process of Sisal Decortication - the extraction of fibres from the sisal leaf.
WHY
19 Industrial Challenges 21 Societal Challenges 23 United Nations SDGs 25 Discourse
Corona is thus a homage to this decortication process - the central process to this project - and a nod in the direction of the attitude and thinking taken toward the potential resolution of the challenges faced by society and industry.
.29
WHERE
30 Site Imagery 35 Site Analyses
.37
HOW
38 Pragmatic Process 45 Poetic Process 49 Synthesis 53 Environmental Performance
.57
CORONA
58 Scheme T
DK
-S
UR E
TANZANIA
V
-D
ON RK IRENMA
E OL TION URCHO EXPEDI 2017
DAM L - GEORGE P JA A-A M NIS - LIN Z - AHAMED A - RL B EN ER K KEN - S - D AND K- E TS KS R MEN LE
- EMILIE J CEC IAGO D J-T HRISTOPHE B - ILIE J MIE LOUIS C EMR VE Ü NIC IE MI Y ARCHI -C U T OF KA EC
B
L F - VIKTORIA K - XAN HAE B ITA MIC A N - ED D - ALICJA - VA C - - ANN SL TO ER AN KE W M IK
Tiago Da Costa Vasconcelos AEE01 2018 Programme Tutor: Thomas Chevalier Bøjstrup Royal Danish Academy of Fine Arts School of Architecture IBT, Architecture and Extreme Environments
VID G - JAKOB S - DA K MIA - LILLI W - CHR - THO H - JACK C M ISTI AN AS AS C LHL ILLE A D EXTREM AM ANOF ARCHITECT E EN
65 Experience 69 Essence 79 Physical Models
Page.01
PREFACE Page.01
Page.02
INVESTIGATION
The sisal industry was once the economic backbone and fundamental underpinning of the region of Tanga. Its Port city, originally industrialised by the German colonialists — with the intention of supplying their war efforts — predominantly exported sisal based products and goods throughout its early development. These outputs are the result of the extraction and processing of fibre from the sisal plant, a widely cultivated cash-crop. Industry production, ultimately, fell drastically during the post-colonialist era as a result of three primary factors: Limited economic competitivity. Poor husbandry of cultivated land. Sharp decline in operation skills and experience.
Additionally, negative ecological impacts of production exacerbate negative impacts on the environment and cost effectiveness of product leading to a continued sedentary industry. This investigation positions itself within the discourse of Circular Economies, investigating the potential for speculative business modalities based on the principles of Industrial Ecology. Taking the form of a re-imagination, the project theorises an alternate paradigm for an existing plant located at the Katani Ltd Estate in Hale, Tanga Region. Katani Ltd — Tanzania’s foremost sisal producing corporation — purchased land containing existing colonial structures and occupied them with the facilities seen today. This complex plant produces output in two forms; Sisal fibres for trade, and waste for self-sustaining biogas digester feedstock. Given this ad-hoc post-occupational architectural appropriation, and diversified business modality, I have selected this site as the test bed for exercising theoretical and conceptual speculation in an attempt to identify opportunities for sustainable business development and effective environmental and societal benefit.
Page.03
TANGA Karibu Sana
Page.04
Tanzania 945 087 km2
Tanzania
75%
Tanga Region
Area: 26,677 km² Population: 2.045 million Districts: Handeni; Kilindi;
@ 26C
Average RH
(2012)
Korogwe; Lushoto; Muheza; Mkinga; Pangani; Tanga
125%
Actual vs Accepted RH
Tanga Region 26 677 km2
Page.05
A TRULY BEAUTIFUL PLACE TO BE
TANZANIA: TANGA
TEU per Month Unit
Clinker Import
TEU stands for Twenty-Foot equivalent unit. The dimensions of one TEU are equal to that of a standard 20′ shipping container.
3 50 1
2016
2015
5
kt Clinker Shipments kt each Year
At present, we have only two big customers - Tanga Cement Company and GBP whose offers for traffic we fail to satisfy adequately because of the condition of the track which is terribly in bad shape”
90%
2007 Officially Closed 2009 No Trains to Seaport
30/50 kph due to poor conditions
CITY MAPS The Urban Centre and City Greater
Analysing the urban context allows for a deeper understanding of the city dynamic and built form. We uncover the nature, character and culture of the town through its physical layout, planning and architectural tectonics. The typological distribution of Tanga informs us as to how the city evolved over time through colonialisation.
INDUSTRIAL
COMMERCIAL
RESIDENTIAL 01
RESIDENTIAL 02
RESIDENTIAL 03
Zones proliferate toward Urban Centre outskirts and surrounds
Zones proliferate toward Urban Centre outskirts and surrounds
Zone exists adjacent to Urban Centre, importance on proximity
Housing toward the outskirts of Urban Centre, less favourable
Zone which builds away from industry and commerce, peaceful location
Low Density
Mixed Density
High Density
Medium Density
Low Density
Upper Income
Income Generating
Mixed Income
Lower Income
Upper Income
Mixed Construction
Mixed Construction
Colonial Construction
Informal Housing
Country Houses
Factories
Mixed
Single/Multi Dwelling
Single/Multi Dwelling
Single Dwelling
Med Rise MultiStorey
Med Rise MultiStorey
Low Rise MultiStorey
Low Rise MultiStorey
Low Rise MultiStorey
Sparse Planning
City Block Planning
City Block Planning
Courtyard Community
Gated Communities
CITY MAP The Urban Centre
500
20
kt Cargo
TRL Tanzania Railways Ltd
MAXIMUM POSSIBLE SPEED
15 10
25
TEU
CAPACITY UTILISATION RATE
75 40 12.5
2014
Passengers Aircraft Movements Cargo
In one Month
Circa 2013 the ferry route between Tanga and Pemba Island was cancelled due to poor upkeep and high danger.
2013
31k 5.5k 39t
RW Railway 3
Tanga to Pemba Cancelled
35 30
2012
In one Year (2016)
THOUSANDS OF PASSENGERS
Runway Length
Due to the short runway, bigger airplanes landing at the port are those with less than 50 passengers.
2011
1.6KM
SP Seaport 2
METERS
COMPARITAVE SCALE MAPS 4 Contextualising area and size
CITY. C ENTER AP Airport 1
2010
TANGA.CITY.TANZANIA
Assessing and Unpacking regional infrastructure and scale through comparitave maps and mapping. Tanga City’s focus on its urban centre as a node for production and industry can be clearly seen through the positioning, placement and planning of its infrastructure and nodes.
SPATIAL.CHARACTER
CITY.GREATER
LEGEND Infrastructure
26 677
35x
Tanzania is
Tanga Region
CITY WITHIN REGION Area of Tanga Region km2 26 677
Area of Tanga City km2
SP
Trunk Road Regional Road Primary Urban Road Secondary Urban Road Cycle Way Foot Path
NETWORK 33 Kilometers Primary Urban Road 178 Kilometers Secondary Urban Road
A14.S
A14.Northbound
RW
Trunk Road
1 000
1 000
A14.N
LEGEND
SP
Mabokweni Village (8km) Lunga Lunga (70km) Ramisi Ramisi (106km) Gazi Gazi (120km) Mombaasa, Kenya (175km)
A14.Southbound Pongwe (13km) Muheza (36km) Mshangalikwa (46km) Hale (63km) Dar Es Salaam (333km)
1.25 Kilometers Cycle Way
AP
2.6 Kilometers Foot Path
RW
Airport Seaport Railway Trunk Road Regional Road Primary Urban Road Secondary Urban Road Cycle Way Foot Path
LEGEND Building Types
Trunk Road
2 000
Area of Tanga Region km2
2 000
945 087
4 000
Area of Tanzania km2
500
TANGA.CITYTANGA.REGIONTANZANIA
REGION WITHIN COUNTRY
METERS
AP
Park Sports Healthcare Education Entertainment Commercial Institutional Hospitality Religious Cultural Industrial Infrastructural
SP
596
35x
Tanga City
A14.N
Hovedstaden is
10x 04x
Hovedstaden Tanga City
05
4 000
08 14
13
A14.N
07
06
1
04
2
2568
01 09 11 12
10
03
KILOMETERS
Area of Hovedstaden, DK km
2
4
CROSS REFERENCE
Tanga Region is
02
TANGA.REGION
Tanga Region is
LEGEND Trunk Road Regional Road Primary Urban Road Secondary Urban Road
8
NETWORK
Ur 01
Ru 07
Ru
Ur
02
Ru 02
Ur Ru
Ur
02
Ru 02
Ur
06
Ru 10
Ur 16
Ru 13
Ur
24
Ru 69
Ur 01
Ru 02
Other %
05
Grass %
Ur
50
Ru
Poles / Mud %
Ur
02
Ru
79
Ur
WALLS
00
Ur
29
Ru
Other %
Ur
02
Ru
00
Baked Bricks %
19
Earth / Sand %
67
Sundried Bricks %
Ur Ru
Ceramic Tiles %
Iron Sheets %
FLOORS
Ur 01
Ru 01
CITY WARD DISTRIBUTION 6 Rural Wards 382.9 km2 Pop. 43 223 Mixed Wards 173 km2 Pop. 44 232 Urban Wards 41.1 km2 Pop. 185 877
68% of the
Tanga City Population
112 inhabitants/km² 256 inhabitants/km² 4 523 inhabitants/km² lives in 6.9% of Available City Land
Ru
POLES.MUDCEMENTEARTH.SANDCEMENTTILESEARTH
13
33
RURALMIXEDURBAN
Ur Ru
Other %
01
Mud / Leaves %
Ur
02
Ru
Grass / Leaves %
82
55
Tiles %
Iron Sheets %
Ur
Kilometers Trunk Road
56 Kilometers Primary Urban Road Ur
ROOFS
Ru
42
129 Kilometers Regional Road
CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS 5 Households in Urban (Rural) Wards
Cement Bricks %
Rural Mixed Urban
TANZANIA: TANGA
Stones %
RESEARCH: TANGA REGION & CITY
Page.06
A14.Northbound
AP A14.S RW
Trunk Road Mabokweni Village (8km) Lunga Lunga (70km) Ramisi Ramisi (106km) Gazi Gazi (120km) Mombaasa, Kenya (175km)
A14.Southbound
A14.S
Trunk Road Pongwe (13km) Muheza (36km) Mshangalikwa (46km) Hale (63km) Dar Es Salaam (333km)
16
15
17 18
24 23
19
22 21 20
DEFINITIONS 7
CITY WARD NAMES 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
Central Chumbageni Nguvumali Mwanzange Duga Mabawa Mzingani Usagara Ngamiani Kaskazini Majengo Ngamiani Kati Ngamiani Kusini
13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Msambweni Makorora Chongoleani Mabokweni Mzizima Kiomoni Pongwe Kirare Marungu Tongoni Tangasisi Maweni
Trunk Road A trunk road is a road maintained by the national government body. Trunk roads are generally, therefore, the most important roads nationally; Connecting main cities and providing inter region transport routes. Regional Road A regional road is a class of road not forming a major route, such as a trunk road, but nevertheless forming a link in the national route network. These roads allow for interconnecting routes within a region or adjacent regions.
CITY MORPHOLOGY
PROPORTION 01 Vehicular Networks and 02 Primary Road Distribution 59 %
01
3.8 %
Cycle Way
02
City Center Primary Urban Road
City Wide
REFERENCES 1. “Tanzania Airports Authority,” Tanzania Airports Authority, 2016, , accessed September 25, 2017, http://www.tanzaniaairports.aero/. 2. “Port of Tanga, Tanzania.” Ports.com. 2017. Accessed September 25, 2017. http://ports.com/tanzania/port-of-tanga/. 3. Tanzania Railways Limited. 2017. Accessed September 25, 2017. http://www.trl.co.tz/. 4. “Tanzania.” Wikipedia. October 03, 2017. Accessed September 25, 2017. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanzania. “Capital Region of Denmark.” Wikipedia. September 20, 2017. Accessed September 25, 2017. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_Region_of_Denmark. 5. Tanzania. National Bureau of Statistics. Basic Demographic and Socio-Economic Profile. Tanga. Dar Es Salaam: National Bureau of Statistics, 2016. 113-115. 6. ”Africa.” (Tanzania) - Population Statistics, Charts, Map and Location. February 04, 2017. Accessed September 25, 2017. http://www.citypopulation.de/php/tanzania-admin. php?adm2id=0404. 7. “Trunk road.” Wikipedia. September 07, 2017. Accessed September 25, 2017. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trunk_road. “Regional road.” Wikipedia. July 01, 2017. Accessed September 25, 2017. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regional_road.
Throughout history, the Architecture of Tanga City has evolved to reflect its era of rule. The German and British Colonial Periods have heavily influenced the construct of the city, and it is through this Architectonical lense which we can begin to understand and unpack the Morphological Development of the city. Its planning and placement through the colonial to independence periods gives clues to the functioning and distribution of its populace.
GERMAN COLONIAL PERIOD 1 1881 - 1916
BRITISH COLONIAL PERIOD 2 1916 - 1961
POST INDEPENDENCE 3 1961 - 2017
-
The Germans invested most heavily into development of Architecture and Infrastructure. Buildings were robust and inspired by an eclectic mix of Arabic and German architecture.
During the British period, the largest gains in momentum of the Sisal Industry was seen. The British focussed heavily on driving industry and utilising production capabilities of Tanga City and some of its Region.
Today we see an exclectic mix of Architecture whichmakes up the majority of Tanga City Center. Toward the outskirts we begin to see a more informalisedsprawl developing which comes as the result of repidinhabitant influx. -
Figure 01 Old German Hospital of Tanga
Figure 02 Sisal laid out to Dry in British Tanganyika
Figure 03 Tanga (Tanzania) - Colonial Architecture
-
-
REFERENCES 1 Tanga City Council. Tourism Guide for the Tanga Region, Tanzania. Tanga City: Tanga City Council, 2012. 2. “Sisal production in Tanzania.” Wikipedia. May 03, 2017. Accessed September 25, 2017. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sisal_production_in_Tanzania. 3. Tanga City Council. Tourism Guide for the Tanga Region, Tanzania. Tanga City: Tanga City Council, 2012. Figure 01 “Old German Hospital of Tanga.” Digital image. Tripmondo.com. January 5, 2009. Accessed September 20, 2017. http://www.tripmondo.com/tanzania/tanga/bombo/. Figure 02 Flikr Account, National Archives, UK. “Sisal laid out to dry in British Tanganyika.” Digital image. Wikiwand.com. April 8, 2012. Accessed September 20, 2017. http://www.wikiwand.com/en/Sisal_production_in_Tanzania. Figure 03 Danielzolli. “Tanga (Tanzania) - Colonial Architecture.” Digital image. Flickr.com. February 25, 2011. Accessed September 20, 2017. https://www.flickr.com/photos/danielzolli/5575123424/.
Page.07
WHAT Page.07
Page.08
THE SISAL INDUSTRY
SISAL
“ A coarse and strong fibre, sisal is being increasingly used in composite materials for cars, furniture and construction as well as in plastics and paper products. Sisal fibres are obtained from Agave Sisalana, a native of Mexico. The hardy plant grows well all year round in hot climate and arid regions which are often unsuitable for other crops. Sisal can be cultivated in most soil types except clay and has low tolerance to very moist and saline soil conditions. Husbandry is relatively simple as it is resilient to disease and its input requirement is low compared to other crops. Sisal can be harvested from 2 years after planting and its productive life can reach up to 12 years, producing from 180 to 240 leaves depending on location, altitude, level of rainfall and variety of plant. “ - Sisal: Future Fibres | Food and Agriculture Organisation UN
RESEARCH SITE
Agave Sisalana
Kwanza
Tanzania
HALE
Katani LTD Sisal Fibre Processing Estate Est . 1962
Page.09
THE INDUSTRY IN TANGA
CORONA
The sisal industry was once the economic backbone and fundamental underpinning of the region of Tanga. Its Port city, originally industrialised by the German colonialists — with the intention of supplying their war efforts — predominantly exported sisal based products and goods throughout its early development. These outputs are the result of the extraction and processing of fibre from the sisal plant, a widely cultivated cashcrop. Industry production, ultimately, fell drastically during the post-colonialist era as a result of three primary factors: Limited economic competitivity. Poor husbandry of cultivated land. Decline in operation skills, experience.
Exports 1914 21 000 TONS
X
10
Exports 1964 234 000 TONS
- Sisal Statistics | Food and Agriculture Organisation UN
During this time the industry also provided 1 000 000 jobs to Tanzanians.
THIS REPRESENTS EMPLOYMENT OF 9% OF THE TOTAL POPULATION OF THE COUNTRY.
Page.10
During the 1960s Tanzania produced ONE THIRD of the global Sisal Production Output
33%
Page.11
Page.12
REALITY REIMAGINED This project is an investigative reimagination which serves as a means of exploring the potential for future improvements to the industry and society in Tanzania. Through architectural intervention, systems analysis and planning; the investigation aims to unlock the hidden potentiality latent in the industry of today.
Page.13
Kwanza
Tanzania
HALE
Katani LTD Sisal Fibre Processing Estate
the REALITY
Est . 1962
Page.14
Page.15
Kwanza
Tanzania
CORONA The Symbiotic Sisal Processing Plant
the REIMAGINED
Est . 1962
Page.16
Page.17
WHY Page.17
Page.18
WHY REIMAGINE THE EXISTING PLANT? Reimagination offers an opportunity to synthesize an appropriate architecture which, by design, considers existing industry and societal challenges. It allows us to freely question, interrogate and unpack various aspects of a broader scope beyond the site and industry itself.
Page.19 INDUSTRY RISE
INDUSTRY FALL
“ Under German, then British, administrators, sisal fibre became the colony’s main export commodity, highly prized for use in cordage and carpets worldwide. When the United Republic of Tanzania was born in 1961, it was the world’s biggest sisal grower, with fibre production of 230 000 tonnes a year. Sisal was the country’s main foreign exchange earner and its cultivation and processing employed more than one million people. ”
“ By the mid-1980s the decline of the industry in Tanga saw sisal exports down to just 30 000 tons per annum. This sharp decrease is attributed primarily to the low prices of newly manufactured synthetic fibres, poor husbandry of cultivated land and a lack of knowledge and skills to maintain and sustain the production of plantations and factories. The industry has remained in this state, never gaining real traction or momentum since. ”
- Sisal in Tanzania | Natural Fibres .org
- Tanga History | Tanga Line Tripod .com
Tanzanian Sisal Production
Tanzanian Sisal Production
Exports 1914
21 000 TONS
Exports 1964 234 000 TONS
- Sisal Statistics | Food and Agriculture Organisation UN
During the 1960s Tanzania alone was responsible for one third of the total global Sisal Fibre Production.
Exports 1984
38 000 TONS
Exports 2014 37 000 TONS
- Sisal Statistics | Food and Agriculture Organisation UN 32%
AFRICA AMERICAS ASIA ENTIRE CONTINENT OF AFRICA PRODUCES 32%
Today, the of the global Sisal Output
33%
During this time the industry also provided 1 000 000 jobs to Tanzanians. This represents employment of 9% OF THE TOTAL POPULATION of the country.
The industry downfall meant the loss of 900 000 jobs to Tanzanians. Today, the industry employs a mere 0,2% OF THE TOTAL POPULATION of the country.
Page.20
INDUSTRY Challenges
1. Limited economic competitivity 2. Poor husbandry of cultivated land 3. Decline in operation skills and experience
Page.21 SOCIETAL CHALLENGES
Employment
Formal employment statistics remain exceedingly low in the region given its heavy emphasis on agricultural households. Around 1.6M Tanga residents are Agricultural Household Members. Unskilled Labour
Men Women
80% of Tanga Regions population are
self-reliant respect to sustenance and income.
15.9% 32.8%
80% of Tanga Regions population are self-reliant in some significant way with respect to sustenance and income.
Education
Service delivery for rural populations remains low given the challenges faced in logistics and infrastructure. Literacy Rates for the combined population of Tanga is 67%. Literacy Rate by Population
In Tanga means approximately 600 000 people are unable to read and write.
Urban 89% Rural 65%
A 33% rate of illiteracy in Tanga means that around 600 000 people are unable to read and write.
Infrastructure
Access to electricity throughout Tanzania stands at only 15.5% of the total population. Given the greater relative proportion of Rural/Urban population in Tanga, accessibility is likely even lower. - Tanga Region Statistics | Census 2012, National Bureau of Statistics Tanzania
Approximately 1 600 000 Tanga residents do not have access to electricity.
Page.22
SOCIETY Challenges
1. Literacy & Lack of Vocational Training 2. Great number of people self-subsisting 3. Widespread lack of infrastructure & utilities
Page.23
GLOBAL FRAMEWORK
The following United Nations Sustainable Development Goals were selected as the global framework within which this investigation is positioned. The investigation adopts a critical view of challenges faced in the industry and Tanga viewed from within the framework, and its responses shaped by these Sustainable Development Goals.
Page.24
Page.25
DISCOURSE
Circular Economy
“ A circular economy seeks to rebuild capital, whether this is financial, manufactured, human, social or natural. This ensures enhanced flows of goods and services. The circular economy focuses on functional re-use and renewal of products and processes such that their outputs ultimately become valuable inputs for use as productive resources.� - Circular Economy. | Ellen Macarthur Foundation
Principle 1 | Preserve and enhance natural capital by controlling finite stocks and balancing renewable resource flows. Principle 2 | Optimise resource yields by circulating products, components and materials in use at the highest utility at all times in both technical and biological cycles. Principle 3 | Foster system effectiveness by revealing and designing out negative externalities.
Page.26
Economic activity builds and rebuilds overall system health. Transitioning to a circular economy does not only amount to adjustments aimed at reducing the negative impacts of the linear economy. Rather, it represents a systemic shift
that builds long-term resilience,
generates business and economic opportunities, and provides environmental and
societal benefits.
Page.27
DISCOURSE
Industrial Ecology
“ Industrial ecology is the study of material and energy flows through industrial systems”. Focusing on connections between operators within the ‘industrial ecosystem’, this approach aims at creating closed-loop processes in which waste serves as an input, thus eliminating the notion of an undesirable by-product. ” - Industrial Ecology. | Ellen Macarthur Foundation
Industrial ecology adopts a systemic point of view, designing production processes in accordance with local ecological constraints whilst looking at their global impact from the outset, and attempting to shape them so they perform as close to living systems as possible. This framework is sometimes referred to as the ‘science of sustainability’, given its interdisciplinary nature, and its principles can also be applied in the services sector. With an emphasis on natural capital restoration, industrial ecology also focuses on social wellbeing.
Page.28
Industrial ecology aims to reduce
environmental stress caused by industry whilst
encouraging innovation, resource efficiency and sustained growth. It views industrial sites as
part of a wider ecology rather than an external, solitary entity.
Page.29
WHERE Page.29
Page.30
HALE SISAL ESTATE
ESTATE LOCALE
SITE SELECTION
The site I have selected is Katani Ltd’s Hale Sisal Biogas plant. Located in Hale, Korogwe District 1 . Located 76km south west of the Tanga City Centre 2 , this plant in addition to processing Sisal, recently (2012) implemented Biogas technologies as a means of producing its own electricity generated through biogas to electricity conversion. It uses the biomass waste generated by the decortication process as feedstock for digesters. The plant is thus already attempting to combat some of the issues which caused degradation of the sisal industry in Tanzania, by producing a more cost effective product and thus I felt it an appropriate site for this Investigation.
Situated on the fringes of Hale 0 — a small size town with little urbanisation and technical development — The Estate consists of the primary entry point from the main road 1 , ancillary administrative buildings 2 , outdoor drying fields 3 and finally the two part production plant 4 . This Investigation will focus primarily on the plant 4 as the subject for interrogation and exploration.
Locale Map SITE LOCATION WITHIN TANGA REGION
0
1
2 3 2
1 4
Page.31
HALE
Katani ltd Sisal Estate
Page.32
Page.33
Page.34
Page.35
LOCALITY Analysis Plan
250
1
Hale Town
2
500
Scale Meters
1 000
HydroElectric Plant
3
Estate Entry off A14
4
Estate Drying Fields
1
Pangani River
3 2 4
A14 Regional Road
5
5
Sisal Biogas Plant
Page.36
SITE
Analysis Plans 25
1
2
Site Entry
50
Scale Meters
100
3
Sisal Processing
4
Biogas Production
5
Waste Discharge
Prevailing Wind
Waste Discharge 0-2
4-6
Meters Second
256
266
258
260
1
2-4
2
272
Water Source 270
10%
20%
30%
254
268
252
3
266
250 248 246
264
244 262 242 254 240
254
4
Pangani River
242
Solar Path
5
Terrain Fall
Path
Hour
+12m
Radiation
238 252
250 JUN
18
17
16
15
14
13
12
14
13
12
11
10
09
07
08
JUN
Vegetated Coverage 236
252
16 17
238 240
242
246
244
248
250
252
236
DEC
18
15
11
10
09 08 07 DEC
+0m
Page.37
HOW Page.37
Page.38 PRAGMATIC PROCESS
The plant consists of Sisal Processing 1 - 8 , and Biogas Production 9 - 16 . It is situated in an area of approximately 300 x 300 m ( 9 ha ), moderately sloped and largely surrounded by open grassland and some sparsely populated forest.
WHY RE-IMAGINE THE PLANT?
Its structures were not intended to be Plant buildings. Thus, this opens an opportunity to re-imagine an appropriate architectural configuration which by design, responds to existing industry challenges.
Production Plant Map
1
7
1
3
6 2
5 4
8
3
2 14
15
14
6
5 8
16
12
12
11
14 11
9 10
13
9
10 13
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Fibre Laboratory (Canceled) - 17 x 8 m Delivery Yard - 46 x 28 m Pulp Squeezing - 12 x 12 m Leaf Processing - 38 x 25 m Brushing - 35 x 15 m Bundling - 20 x 15 m Loading Bay - 14 x 12 m Drying Yard (Inactive) - 28 x 17 m
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Collection Tank - 5 x 5 m Hydrolysis Tank - 7.5 x 7.5 m Biogas Digester - 18 x 18 m Storage Tank - 8.5 x 8.5 m Fertilizer Tank - 10 x 10 m Conversion Generators - 8 x 6 m Laboratory - 10 x 7 m Administration - 17 x 7 m
7
15 16
Page.39
SYSTEM Flow Analysis
25
Yard 1 Delivery Receiving Sisal Leaf Processing 2 Leaf Decortication, Washing Field 3 Drying Wet Fibre Transport Delivery 4 Fibre Dry Fibre Transport 5 Brushing Fibre Treatment 6 Grading Fibre Assessment 7 Baling Fibre Bundling Bay 8 Loading Bale Distribution
50
Scale Meters
100
3
Squeezing 3 Pulp Separating Fibre & Biomass Transport 4 Biomass Channel to Biogas Plant Tank 5 Collection Biomass Storage Tank 6 Hydrolysis Wastewater Preparation Digester 7 Biogas Anaerobic Digestion Tank Tank 8 Storage Biogas Storage Generators 9 Conversion Biogas Electricity Tank 10 Fertilizer Slurry Storage
4
8 7 1 5
2
6
3
9
8 4
7 5 6
10
3 4 1
2
5 3
7
6
8
4 8
9
5
7 6
10
Page.40
SYSTEM
Opportunity Diagram Sisal Processing
Biogas Production
Vermicomposting
Research & Learn
Safety Gear Locker Rooms
Communal Amenities Laboratories
Short Stay Residences
Delivery Yard
Learning Centre
Dry Decorticator
Break Space and Canteen
Grow Gardens
Fibre Washing
Ablutions and Changerooms
Visitor and Demon stration Centre
Waste to BioMethane Transport
Phytoremediatory Garden
Short Fibre Hammer
Collection
Two-Stage Fungal Pretreatment
Safety Gear Locker Rooms
Fibre Drying
Hydrolysis
Biogas Digester
Slurry to Vermicompost ing Transport
Storage
Feedstock Conditioning and Aeration
Integral Biogas Upgrading
Vermicomposting Digester Units
Bottling and Storage
Screening
Brushing
Grading
Conversion Generators
Baling and Storage Combined Loading and Distribution Bay
Safety Gear Locker Rooms
Packaging and Storage
Page.41
PROGRAMME Visual Diagram
Sisal Leaves Decortication Anaerobic Digestion
Biomass Feedstock
Processing Fibre Extracted Fibre Slurry Feedstock Biogas Upgrading
Sisal Fibre Bales VermiComposting
Electric Generation
BioMethane Bottling
Page.42
PROGRAMME Matrix Analysis
Functions
Programme
Delivery Yard Dry Decorticator (Raspador) Waste to BioMethane Transport Fibre Washing Short Fibre Hammer Fibre Drying (Indoor | Outdoor) Brushing Grading Baling and Storage Phytoremediatory Garden Observation Decks Collection Hydrolysis Two-Stage Fungal Pretreatment Biogas Digester Storage Slurry to Vermi Transport Conversion Generators Integral Biogas Upgrading Bottling and Storage Feedstock Conditioning, Aeration Vermicomposting Digester Units Screening Packaging and Storage Grow Gardens Safety Gear Locker Rooms Ablutions and Changerooms Break Space and Canteen Loading and Distribution Bay Laboratories and Administration Learning Centre Visitor and Demonstration Centre Short Stay Residences
Research and Education
Communal Amenities
Vermicom posting Facility
BioMethane Production Facility
Sisal Processing Facility Reimagination
Building Function
Area Reqs
Height Reqs
~600 Open to Air ~100 5 4 As Needed 4 ~100 5 ~150 6 ~600 | ~6000 6 ~200 ~250 6 5 ~350 ~1000 Open to Air 5 As Needed ~40 4 ~80 5 4 ~100 8 ~300 10 ~150 4 As Needed 4 ~20 4 ~220 *REF ~150 5 5 ~150 *REF 6 ~250 *REF 5 ~100 *REF ~150 *REF 5 ~2000 Open to Air 4 ~30 ~90 4 ~150 6 ~300 6 4 ~250 ~500 4 5 ~300 4 ~800
Day
Night
Orientation
Solar Access
Daylighting
Views
Ventilation
Water
Acoustics
Privacy
Security
Servicing
Sequence
08H00 - 17H00
18H00 - 06H00
N - O - S
Less 1 - 5 More
Less 1 - 5 More
Less 1 - 5 More
Nat 1 - 5 Mech
Less 1 - 5 More
Noise 1 - 5 Quiet
Less 1 - 5 More
Less 1 - 5 More
Less 1 - 5 More
A1 A2 B3 A3 C3 A4 A5 A6 A7 B4 D E1 E1 E2 E3 E4 E4 F G4 G5 H1 H2 H3 H4 I1 J K I2 L M M N O
100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 75%
0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 25%
O S O O S N S S O N O
3 4 1 4 4 5 4 5 3 5 4
4 4 1 4 4 5 5 5 4 5 5
1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 1 4 5
1 1 2 1 1 3 1 1 3 1 2
1 3 4 5 1 1 1 1 1 4 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 3 3 3 3 2
3 3 4 3 3 3 3 3 4 1 2
4 4 5 4 4 4 4 4 5 2 4
5 5 4 3 4 5 3 3 4 3 1
100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
O O O O O O O O O
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 4
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3
1 1 1 1 1 3 2 4 3
1 5 3 1 1 1 1 1 2
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3
3 3 3 3 3 4 5 5 4
3 3 4 3 3 4 4 4 4
2 4 4 4 2 4 5 4 4
100% 100% 100% 100%
0% 0% 0% 0%
S S O O
3 2 4 3
5 4 5 4
3 1 3 3
1 3 2 3
2 4 2 2
4 4 3 3
3 3 4 4
3 3 4 4
5 4 3 4
100% 100% 50% 75% 100%
0% 0% 50% 25% 0%
N O O N O
5 3 3 4 3
5 4 4 5 4
3 1 1 5 1
1 3 2 1 3
5 3 4 4 2
4 3 4 5 3
2 5 4 2 4
1 5 3 2 5
3 2 3 4 5
100% 50% 75% 25%
0% 50% 25% 75%
S S N S
3 4 5 4
5 5 5 4
4 5 3 4
2 2 2 2
5 4 4 4
5 5 4 5
4 2 1 3
5 3 3 4
4 3 3 3
Page.43
Page.44
AERIAL DRONE MAPPING Photogrammetry
Step One
Step Two
A set of 160 aerial images of the site were taken and stitched together. Covering the (approx) 300 x 300 m site area, each of these images include geographic metadata for site information.
Mapping software then analyses the images according to altitude and reflectance to determine the relative distance each observable point is in relation to the drone’s camera. An ‘Altitude Map’ is generated which includes all observed objects on site.
Step Three
Step Four
The software then calculates and assesses objects and points which could be seen as ‘anomalies’ across the primary altitudal gradient. These anomalies are the removed, leaving behind a gradated Altitude map better resembling the lay of the land.
This refined Altitude gradient map then allows for interval contours to be generated and pulled from the software. The contour map below represents an interval of 1m altitude gain at each contour line.
Page.45
POETIC PROCESS
INTEGRATION “To put together parts or elements and combine them into a whole”
Page.46
POETIC PROCESS
SPECTACULARISATION “of or like a spectacle; marked by or given to an impressive, large-scale display. ”
Page.47
Constructivism IAKOV CHERNIKHOV
Chernikhov’s book The Construction of Architectural and Machine Forms is not a narrowly specialist technical investigation or handbook; It is an investigation of theoretical principles which touch upon certain problems of the philosophy of art. While taking into account the methodological value of abstract solutions and structures, he also knows that we must not build forms which are beyond the realm of the useful, that we must not prop up the concept of a self-sufficient, “pure” art. His book rests upon a recognition of the profound commonality of the constructive principles underlying art and technology. And with that, on a recognition that the creative handling of materials can become a great organizing force, if it is directed towards the creation of useful, utilitarian forms.
IN T EGRAT ION
Page.48
The Fun Palace CEDRIC PRICE
The notion of an architecture of movement has always remained problematic given the immobility of typical built environments. And yet, Cedric Price, a British architect, not only theorized that movement was integral to architecture but he reflected this in his architectural practice. They began to envision a built form that was no longer merely static, but instead comprised of spaces in time that both informed and were informed by the complex social, economic and cultural changes of dynamic societies.
This view also contributed to a shift in the thinking of the ‘city’ as well. It was no longer conceived as a cohesive structure but instead as an unstable series of systems, in continual
transformation, constantly reorganizing and rearranging itself through processes of both expansion and retraction.
SPEC TACULARISAT ION
Page.49
SYNTHESIS Sketch Process
Page.50
Page.51
Page.52
Page.53
ENVIRONMENTAL PERFORMANCE Simulation
04 APRIL 2018
13 APRIL 2018
14 MAY 2018
MODEL MILESTONE 01
MODEL MILESTONE 02
MODEL MILESTONE 03
- Emphasis on the circular layout - Strict adherence to preceding compositional process - Underdeveloped Site to Volume Relationship
- Continued Emphasis on the circular layout - Looser adherence to compositional process - Further Developed Relationship to Site - Slight Planning Consolidation
- Breakaway from circular layout - Compositional process serves as underlying informant - Considered Volume to Site Relationship - Consolidated Planning scheme
N
N
N
N
N
N
Page.54
Sun Shading
08 a.m
08 a.m
21 DECEMBER / SUMMER SOLSTICE
12 p.m
21 JUNE / WINTER SOLSTICE
12 p.m
04 p.m
04 p.m
Page.55
Solar Insolation
N
Cumulative Insolation ( kWh/m2 ) 386
193
0
Study Start Date: 21 . 12 . 2018 Study End Date: 19 . 03 . 2018
N
Page.56
CFD Wind Flow
N
Wind Velocity ( m/s ) 8
6
4
2
0
Direction: South Easterly
N
Page.57
CORONA Page.57
Page.58
FLOOR PLANS Upper & Lower Floors
UPPER FLOORS
LOWER FLOORS
Page.59
Page.60
Page.61
SECTION Cross
Page.62
Page.63
SECTION Longitudinal
Page.64
Page.65
Kwanza
Tanzania
CORONA The Symbiotic Sisal Processing Plant Est . 1962
Page.66
TOWER
Observation & Drying
Page.67
CORE
Indoor Drying & Interior Feel
Page.68
DECORTICATION Diversification & Quality of Work
Page.69 PHASE 03
01
Vermicomposting
03 02
01 Communal Grow Gardens 02 VermiComposting Bins 03 Packaging & Distribution
01
PHASE 02 Biogas Production
02 09
03 06
08
04
05
01
Short-Stay Facilities Laboratories & Administration 03 Collection & Hydrolysis 04 Anaerobic Digestion & Storage 05 Slurry Overflow Storage 06 Electrical Conversion Generator 07 Integral Upgrading 08 Bottling 09 Storage & Distribution
02
07
EXPLODED AXO Phasing Breakdown
PROGRAMME OVERVIEW AND UNPACKING
Given industry relevancy, existing challenges within social dynamics and inherent opportunity in dialogue between the two. The following outlines my Investigation Programme and expands on its relevancy with respect to learnings covered in this document, and too, the intention toward an Industrial Ecology: - Sisal Processing Facility Reimagination
Aim | Process fibre in a more efficient systems loop whilst optimising arrangement on site with respect to other functions. Improving working and safety conditions. - BioMethane Production Facility
Access Point
PHASE 01
N
Sisal Processing
03 04
06
01 02
Solar Orientation
05
08 09
07 11
12
11
10
13
13
01 Welcome Centre 02 Communal Spaces 03 Leaf Delivery 04 Decortication 05 Washing 06 Drying 07 Brushing 08 Grading 09 Storage 10 Baling
Storage & Distribution 12 Distillery Constructed Wetland
Aim | Production of refined BioMethane for trade and power. More efficient waste input utilisation systems for digestion and output energy flows as usable inputs for other functions. - Vermicomposting Facility
Aim | Production and packaging of high grade organic compost from digester slurry and additional biodegradable waste — to be expanded upon in the coming section. - Research and Education Facility
Aim | Offer teaching programmes for residents and stakeholders coupled with accommodation for study period. Undertake research into material product diversity and lifecycle analyses. - Communal and Shared Facilities
Aim | Add value to existing functions and provide spaces for stakeholders to gather and socialise. Providing additional functions for stakeholder engagement and plant enrichment. Pangani River
South Easterly Wind
Page.70
Page.71
Page.72
APPROACH
Page.73
Karibu Sana
FUNCTIONAL, BEAUTIFUL
Page.74
WELCOME, KARIBU
COURTYARD
Page.75
Communitty
MORE STAKEHOLDERS
Page.76
AN EVER-CHANGING, ‘PERFORMING’ SPACE
GROW GARDENS
Page.77
Integrated Learning
PRODUCT MEANS PRODUCE
A GREAT NUMBER OF PEOPLE ARE SELF-SUBSISTING
SCALE BUILDS
Page.78
Integrated Learning
DECENTRALISE UTILITIES
THERE IS A LACK OF VOCATIONAL TRAINING
Page.79
CORONA MODEL Full Site Model
1:250
Page.80
Page.81
Page.82
Page.83
Page.84
Page.85
Page.86
STRUCTURAL MODEL Modular Unit
1:50
Page.87
Asante sana Thank You