Tackling Trans Theory Vol. I
Throughout this course the concept that really resonated with me was intersectionality. Having an intersectional lens plays an important role in diversifying the content of a certain topic because it avoids essentializing and universalizing a topic. An intersectional analysis points out this idea that not all men and women within the same race or class share similar interests, and so we must work to avoid universal prescriptions in order to successfully address inequality. This is why I wanted to focus my project on analyzing trans theory from an intersectional perspective. Since trans theory is a relatively new concept that is slowly being accepted and talked about in the western world, I think it is important to create a dialogue amongst people within and outside of the trans community to get a sense of their understanding or lack thereof, in order to address their concerns, and move towards a more accepting society. By analyzing trans theory through an intersectional lens magnifies the concept and unveils each individual’s personal thoughts or concerns about it. Throughout my conversations, which focused on various individual’s thoughts on the trans community, it became apparent that everyone’s response was different because it was so personal to their own life experiences. Trying to link trans theory to international relations is a relatively new concept that has not had much space within the IR world and like feminism, discussions in IR fail to include trans theory as a viable subject. However, Laura Sjoberg has dismantled this idea by introducing this new dialogue that includes trans theory into the world of IR and most importantly, addressed how it could contribute to feminist IR analysis. In order for this dialogue to continue and grow within the IR discussions, the issue of heteronormativity must be addressed. Heteronormativity is a present concept that dominates our social norms and perpetuates the idea that men and women are subscribed to gendered. It creates this notion that essentializes males and females, which is what trans theory challenges. Because IR is heavily influenced by heteronormative views, the topic of trans theory has had a difficult time in finding a place in IR. Ultimately, trans theory will become more widely accepted, when we start to dismantle the patriarchichal foundation of IR and the first step towards its dismantling, is by engaging in these dialogues.
J. Axe, 22, Gay, Portland “Although I identify as a gay male I am often perceived as trans because I do not have a problem openly expressing my feminine qualities. The society we live in, or at least the society I live in, is more comfortable categorizing things as ‘masculine or feminine’ and ‘gay or straight’ but it’s never that simple. These categories leave very little room for people whole break those barriers and choose to express their entire self. I believe sexuality is fluid and relative to each person and their experience. One is never just a woman or just a man. One is never just gay or straight. One is never just transsexual. I understand that it might be hard for people to figure out exactly where I fit in the large spectrum of sexual orientation but it is even more difficult for me to figure it out. Yes I paint my nails and I have beautiful, long, curly hair but none of those things define my sexuality.”
A. Hayes, 22, Queer, Los Angeles “People in the trans community need to be respected, and protected at all costs. There is no reason why human beings should have to fear persecution, violence, and especially not death, simply because they choose to present themselves as their authentic selves. It’s truly unacceptable, and people need to see this community for what they are - human. And they need to educate themselves so that things like misgendering will stop happening, which in itself is an act of violence. But most importantly, an open dialogue around the safety of trans people really needs to happen. It breaks my heart and angers me that trans people, especially black transwomen are being murdered at a historic rate, and no one is talking about it. And those are only the deaths that are reported. So this group really needs cisgender and trans advocates to really speak up and show out for them.�
C. Kirk, 22, Heterosexual, Los Angeles “I just have an issue with the idea that we are trying to get rid of gender binaries yet it is perpetuating that same notion by wanting to declare oneself as a certain gender. Why can’t you be a super feminine male without having to declare yourself a woman.”
P. Davis, 27, Trans Female, Los Angeles “I don’t have many trans friends here in LA. Like that I talk to on the phone or hangout with. But I do see a few familiar faces at the same events I go to and we acknowledge each other and say hello chat etc. I feel that the community here is very spread out. Like every community there is a class system. At night where I live i often see a lot of trans women working on Santa Monica BLVD. I recently did a fashion collection about trans awareness called the Working Girl. The working girl does what she has to do to survive. It’s really hard for us to survive out here. It’s all about passing “looking real.” I do have a few older trans friends who often give me advice and tell me stories and just keep it real with me about life. And I cherish every moment. I will continue to make art and bring awareness about the trans community. I often feel that we are just always on the go so we can eat out here. Most of the black trans community are homeless and don’t have many recourses. There is also a lot of hiding, by that I mean trying to stay safe.”
Tracy Castillo IR 366 12.12.16