In This Issue

One hundred and fifty years ago a federal army of nearly two thousand soldiers under the command of Col. Albert Sidney Johnston huddled in their makeshift quarters at Camp Scott near the ruins of Fort Bridger in southwestern Wyoming to wait out the bitter winter and prepare to march into the Salt Lake Valley later in the spring of 1858. Meanwhile, Mormon spies kept watch on the soldiers from the heights of Bridger Butte a few miles west of Camp Scott while the territorial militia continued preparation of defense fortifications in Echo Canyon and elsewhere along the trail in anticipation of battle with the federal troops when they moved into the Mormon stronghold.

The year 1857 had been an eventful and difficult year for Utah and the nation. The fight over whether Kansas would be a “free” or “slave” state generated national attention to "Bleeding Kansas, " - a prologue to what became a full-scale Civil War in 1861. At the same time the United States Supreme Court increased tensions in the landmark decision in the Dred Scott case, when it decreed that all African Americans were not citizens and that the sanctity of property rights guaranteed by the United States Constitution included the human proper ty of slaveholders. As Kenneth M. Stampp wrote in his classic study of the United States on the eve of civil war, America in 1857: A Nation on the Br ink, “1857 was probably the year when the North and South reached the political point of no return—when it became well nigh impossible to head off a violent resolution of the differences between them.”

Tensions were no less severe in Utah as newly elected president James Buchanan acted in the spring of 1857 to replace Brigham Young as territorial governor with Alfred E. Cumming. Unconvinced that Mormons would accept the new governor, Buchanan directed the United States Army to provide a substantial and suitable escort for the newly appointed governor and in so doing precipitated what has long been known as the Utah War. As the Utah-bound expedition made its way along the well-traveled Oregon California Trail toward Utah, approximately one hundred and twenty California-bound emigrants were killed by Mormons at Mountain Meadows in southwestern Utah on September 11.

This special issue of the Utah Historical Quarterly examines the background, issues, individuals, and consequences sur rounding the Utah War. Not only did the North and the South stand on the brink of civil war in 1857, but so did the East and West as the Mountain Meadows Massacre, political upheavals, and the Utah War exacerbated tensions and hostilities in Utah, California, and sur rounding territories that were no less volatile than those of slavery and states’ rights in Kansas and the South.

Our first two articles offer differing, yet complementary views on the causes of the Utah War. They address such questions as how the decision was reached to send a federal army to Utah, and what roles United States President James Buchanan and Mormon leader and Utah Territorial Governor Brigham Young played in launching the impending conflict.

In an effort to give a visual under standing of important sites and events associated with the Utah War, our third article illustrates the landmarks along the more than eleven hundred mile journey undertaken by the federal army from Fort Leavenworth, Kansas to Camp Floyd, forty miles southwest of Salt Lake City Less than a decade later, Civil War photographers like Mathew Brady, would use the medium of photography to convey the death and horror of war to a shocked America.

Our fourth article, with its focus on Sam Houston, reminds us that statesmen of all generations have the right and duty to speak out on controversial matters and, as Sam Houston did with the Utah War, make their opinions and recommendations a part of the public discussion.

Although the Utah War saw no actual battles and few deaths, our final article, in recounting the thirty-year Spencer-Pike affair, instructs us that the threat of violence was real and that hostilities and animosity took decades to ease and disappear.

There is no doubt that the Utah War was a significant event in Utah and American history. 1 In 1858 Abraham Lincoln said in reference to the United States and slavery, “a house divided against its self cannot stand.” Just as the nation had to deal with the issue of slaver y to insure its continuation, so did the Territory of Utah have to come to an under standing and acceptance of its relationship with the rest of the nation. That process was accelerated, if not begun, with the Utah War

1 The Utah War is a popular topic in the Utah Historical Quarterly Nineteen articles and journals have been published beginning in 1941 with Richard Thomas Ackley’s “Across the Plains” in the July-October issue of Volume 9, and the 1858-1860 Journal of Albert Tracy as the entire volume 13 in 1945. The other articles include: “Mormon Finance and the Utah War,” by Leonard J Arrington, July 1952; “A Territorial Militiaman in the Utah War : Journal of Newton Tuttle,” edited by Hamilton Gardner, October 1954; “Journals of the Legislative Assembly, Territory of Utah Seventh Annual Session, 1857-1858,” by Everett L. Cooley, April, July, and October 1956; “Charles A. Scott's Diary of the Utah Expedition, 1857-1861,” edited by Robert E. Stowers and John M. Ellis, October 1960; “The Buchanan Spoils System and the Utah Expedition: Careers of W M F Mag raw and John M. Hockaday,” by William P MacKinnon, Spring 1963; “Camp in the Sagebrush: Camp Floyd, Utah, 1858-1861,” by Thomas G Alexander and Leonard J Arrington, Winter 1966; “The Crisis at Fort Limhi, 1858,” by David L. Bigler, Spring 1967; “Fort Rawlins, Utah: A Question of Mission and Means,” by Stanford J Layton, Winter 1974; “The Gap in the Buchanan Revival: The Utah Expedition of , 1857-58,” by William P. MacKinnon, Winter 1977; “A Crisis Averted? General Harney and the Change in Command of The Utah Expedition,” by Wilford Hill Lecheminant, Winter 1983; “125 Years of Conspiracy Theories: Origins of The Utah Expedition, 1857-58,” by William P MacKinnon, Summer 1984; “Thomas L. Kane And The Utah War,” by Richard D Poll, Spr ing 1993; “The Nauvoo Legion and the Prevention of the Utah War,” by Brandon J Metcalf , Fall 2004; “‘Unquestionably Authentic and Correct in Every Detail’: Probing John I. Ginn and His Remarkable Utah War Story, ” by William P MacKinnon, Fall 2004; “‘I Have Given Myself to the Devil’: Thomas L. Kane and the Culture of Honor,” by Matthew Grow, Fall 2005.