Opinion

EDITORIAL Cancel culture: yay or nay?

There are certain topics always guaranteed to get tempers flaring at the dinner table. Namely, religion, pineapple on pizza, and cancel culture.

Banishing problematic celebrities to the annals of obscurity: Hot or not?

If you’ve got an internet connection, you’ve probably heard the phrase “cancel culture” bandied about. Dictionary.com defines it as “the practice of withdrawing support for public figures … after they have done or said something considered objectionable”. Usually accompanied by online shaming and, sometimes, career repercussions. TV shows axed, book deals dropped, sponsors abandoning ship, the works.

What’s “objectionable”? Aside from the obvious criminal examples, celebrities have been “cancelled” for everything from transphobic essays [JK Rowling], anti-Semitic conspiracies [Kanye West], racist tweets [Roseanne Barr], and covid denial [various].

Supporters argue cancel culture promotes accountability and gives a voice to communities that were previously silenced. Those opposed claim it stifles freedom of expression and is tantamount to cyberbullying.

As always, it’s complicated.

Yes, the practice of digitally calling out celebrities’ transgressions has absolutely devolved into bullying. While I find Rowling’s transgenderexclusionary “feminism” revolting, I cannot condone the avalanche of death and rape threats. We’re not going to solve transphobia with misogynist violence.

Cancel culture is also problematic when it doesn’t allow for redemption. How productive is a society that ostracises a person without the opportunity to atone for their mistakes?

There’s also a discussion to be had about separating the artist from the art. Can we, for example, be disgusted by Mel Gibson, but still acknowledge Braveheart is a brilliant [if wildly inaccurate] piece of cinema?

That said – people should have the freedom to disassociate with anyone whose behaviours do not align with their values. Some argue that “cancelling” is another way of voting with one’s wallet. From accelerating civil rights to helping dismantle Apartheid, boycotts have led to social change throughout history.

Corporations also have the power to boycott. We’ve seen Adidas distance itself from Kanye after his latest Twitter rant. In Aotearoa, rich-lister Simon Henry lost support from fellow CEOs following his sexist attack on Nadia Lim.

Isn’t this just the free market at work? Individuals and companies being able to spend as they choose?

Something I find interesting is the idea that cancel culture impinges on freedom of speech. However, there are those that view “cancellation” as a protest … and isn’t that the ultimate free speech?

This form of protest has uplifted marginalised communities – especially when institutions have proven inadequate. We know the justice system has failed victims of sexual assault [especially lowincome women, queer women and women of colour]. But the #MeToo movement allowed women to take some power back – including calling out abusers and publicly removing their support.

As academic Anne Charity Hudley put it: “If [you can’t] stop something through political means, what you can do is refuse to participate. Cancelling is a way to acknowledge you don’t have to have power to change structural inequality. But as an individual, you can have power beyond measure.”

Where cancel culture is concerned, there will be times we need to proceed cautiously. But freedom of expression doesn’t mean freedom from consequence. Accountability matters – especially when someone has such a huge sphere of influence. People like Kanye and Rowling have used their massive platforms to punch down on communities who have endured decades of systemic violence. There has to be consequences for that.

If you’re worried the “Twitter mob” is coming for your favourites – relax. You can still find Harry Potter in most bookstores. But, just as you can indulge in your nostalgic fantasy universe, others can opt out. Freedom goes both ways, after all.

Young(ish), scrappy & hungry Erin Kavanagh-Hall

PHOTO/STOCK.ADOBE.COM

The Wairarapa Midweek is subject to New Zealand Media Council procedures. A complaint must first be directed in writing to the editor’s email address. If not satisfied with the response, the complaint may be referred to the Media Council P.O Box 10-879, Wellington 6143. Or use the online complaint form at www.presscouncil.org.nz. Please include copies of the article and all correspondence with the publication.

The fictional character I would love to hang out with is...

Jocelyn Konig

Superman.

Dion Tia Haeata

Eddie Munson from Stranger Things.

Cheryl Cavanagh

The Tooth Fairy.

Christina Schofield

Winnie the Pooh. He has such a simple life.

Helen Lenton

Spencer Reid [from Criminal Minds].

Caryl Forrest

Jane Bennet from Pride and Prejudice.

Judy Morgan

Paddington Bear.

Katie Grace Milne

Edward Scissorhands.

Jean Cretney

The water horse [from the children’s book The Water Horse].

Dallas Boyd

The Easter Bunny – free chocolate.

Nicky Longhurst

Vecna [from Stranger Things]!

Karen Roberts

Shamus O’Sean The Leprechaun.

Andrea Longhurst

Sloth from The Goonies.

Ann-Marie Stapp

Olivia Benson [from Law & Order: Special Victims Unit].

Mandy Gibbins

God.

CONTACT US

You may share your opinion in print and online. To comment online, message our Facebook page and feel free to comment on any of the stories. Please email letters to midweek@age.co.nz or post to Wairarapa Midweek letters, P.O. Box 445, Masterton. Include name, address, and phone number. Noms de plume are not accepted. Letter writers’ town of origin will be published with the letter. Letters should be no more than 250 words, and may be edited for space and clarity.

f

Have you got a photo you want to share with Wairarapa?

Whether it’s a reader photo, a cutie, or a snap of you with your Midweek, email it to midweek@age.co.nz with ‘Midweek Photo’ in the subject line, and it could be featured in this segment.

CUTIES OF THE WEEK

Not the scariest witches you’ve ever come across – but definitely the cutest! Ivy Pittams, almost 5, and her little brother Raijin, 3, had a blast dressing up for Halloween. Mum Colleen said her eldest two kids were very excited to wear their tutus – and get stuck into the candy floss. Happy [late] Halloween, kiddos! PHOTO/COLLEEN PARKER

WANT TO CHARGE YOUR EV AT HOME?

We can supply and install a safe connection for you to charge your Electric Vehicle.

EV charger connections need to be protected by a Type B RCD. Don’t know what this is? Don’t worry, we do! Contact us today to learn more!