Watchtower (study edition) 2012

Page 1

34567 59 ˚ ) 6>56

D

˙ ) ˙ ) ˚ )

ı ˙ ) ˚ )

7> ) P 9 ˚ )

-\,* w,T/V`S,*2 b*2YZSgTx ı ; ˙ ı ıB 558E 55;

:P56 ˚ )

-\,* ,Sq,Wq2E wk\ Z14*+*`\Y Y*2 ,T/+dbSaqx ı 58 ˙ ı ıB 55:E 98

57P5= ˚ )

\Yd aWd3TZZp aWT/ ,T/,\/SbS ]1`j1 YTag1 , 3SbbTH ı 6> ˙ ı ıB ::E 5>7

6>P6: ˚ )

w p/SDDD V1`\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\Yx ı 69 ˙ ı ıB 7;E =9

34567

˚ ˚• ˙ ) ˚ )

JUNE 15, 2012

Äą Ë™ ) Ëš

) 5E 6

Vol. 133, No. 12 Semimonthly UKRAINIAN

Ëš w Äą " x ]\Wq-*2 , b\YdE k\+ ]`\aW*,WqbS \-* -\,d qV 1`f\,Z\-\ `*,Sb1Wq a1a,TbdD \/T+Z\ qV 4 ,*`b\,Sf +*jb d /*,ZSZd +dW\ /\+`1 ,S/Z\E k\ ,T/+d,*2bnaq ,/*W1hSZTE Z* ab\`TZV*f gn\-\ 3d`Z*Wd ]`\ab13d2bnaq `\4,Sb\V a,Tb\,Sf ]\/Ty d a,TbWT +T+WTyZSf ]`\`\gb,D w *`b\,* +*jb*x ]\bTj*2 Wp/1y /\+`\p Z\,SZ\p ]`\ b1E k\ \31 *`ab,\ P ,ab*Z\,W1ZSy d Z1+T d`q/ P Z14*+*`\Y ]\VW*/1 V`*y dan\Yd 4Wd T ]1`1YTZSbn 41YWp Z* `*yD *a\]Sa 4YTgZp2 ,T`d , Äąada* `Sab*E qVSy ]\Y1`E k\+ YS Y\-WS \b`SY*bS ,ThZ1 3SbbqE T qVSy b1]1` ab\^bn Z* h\WT \3\-\ *`ab,*D ,T/VS -\,S +14]1`1`,Z\ ,S/*pbn g1y 3d`Z*W 4 5<;= `\VdD TZ 2 ]\WTbShZ\ Z1yb`*WnZSY T ĹĄ`dZbd2bnaq Z* T+WT^D

1 /Wq ]`\/*3dD S/*ZZq w *`b\,\^ +*jbSx 2 h*abSZ\p ,a1a,TbZn\^ ]`\-`*YS +T+WTyZ\^ \a,TbSE qV* ]T/b`SYd2bnaq /\+O `\,TWnZSYS ]\31`b,*YSD `S gSbd,*ZZT ,`1yanVSf Sa*Zn ,SV\`Sab\,d2bnaq ]1O `1VW*/ -T2ZV* L,S/*ZZq 6>>6 `\VdE ZdY1`*gTq a*WYT, 4-T/Z\ 4 ,S/*ZZqY 5==> `\VdME * `1gnVSf Sa*Zn P w `SaO bSqZanVT `1gnVT Sa*ZZqD 1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,TbdxD ÄąZjT /31`1W* gSb*bB dWDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ dWTj*C P w 1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,Tbd ,qb\-\ SanY*x L4 ]`SYTbV*YSE *Z-WDMC \YDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ \Y1ZV*D The Watchtower (ISSN 0043-1087) is published semimonthly by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.; M. H. Larson, President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm BibelO und TraktatGesellschaft der Zeugen Jehovas, e. V.E SeltersNTaunus. Verantwortliche Redaktion: Ramon Templeton, Selters/ Taunus. 5 2012 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. aT ]`*,* 4+1`T-*pbnaqD Printed in Germany

Äą ;P5<

#\ +T+WTyZT ]`\`\gb,* -\,\`qbn Z*Y ]`\ Y*y+dbZ2H gSf /,\f ab*bbqf /1O b*WnZ\ `\4-Wq/*bSYdbnaq ]`\`\gb,* ]`\ ,1WSV\-\ +\,,*Z* 4 6O-\ `\4/TWd VZS-S Ë™*ZS^W*E * b*V\3 ]`\ /SV\-\ 4,T`* b* y\-\ \+`*4E qVT \]Sa*ZT , 57OYd T 5;OYd `\4/TW*f VZS-S +Gq,W1ZZqD \O /S,TY\anE qV T+WTq ]`\WS,*2 a,TbW\ Z* Y*y+dbZT a,Tb\,T ]\/T^D

) Ë™ ) Ëš

) 7

Äą 6>P68

f`1abS,jSanE Wp/SZ* ]\-\/SW*an ab*O ,SbS a]`*,S *`ab,* Z* ]1`j1 YTag1D \4-WqZnY\E qVT `Tj1ZZq ]`SyY*WS ,T/O /*ZT aWd3Sb1WT \-* , /*,ZSZdE T ]`\O *Z*WT4dyY\E qV YS ,SV\`Sab\,d2Y\ a,Ty h*aE aSWS T Y*b1`T*WnZT 4*a\+SD

) Ë™ ) Ëš

) 8

Äą 69P6=

Ë™ ÄąB ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZq Z* ]W*,dh\Yd `SZVd , YTabT Ë™*YZ\1Z */dO *VD #\+ /\aq-bS qV\Y\-* +TWnj\^ VTWnO V\abT Wp/1yE ,TaZSVS ]\ gTW\Yd a,TbT ]`\]\O ,T/dpbn d `T4ZSf YTagqf T ]`S +d/nOqVTy Z*-\/TD

q ab*bbq ]\V*4d2E qV +T+WTyZT ]`\`\VS T ]SanY1ZZSVS +dWS wV1`\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\Yx T h\Yd YS 4 d]1,Z1ZTabp Y\31Y\ aV*4*bSE k\ T+WTq Z*bfZ1Z* \-\Y L6 1bD 5B65MD `TY b\-\E ab*bbq ]\qaZp2E ‚ k\ /\]\Y\31 Z*Y T /*WT gTZd,*bS ,qb1 SanY\D Ë? Ëš Äą

7 Ë?Äą

Äą ) w (x

56 Äą Äą Äą ) Ëš Äą

Äą Ë™

Ëš Ëš

)

:: ;6> >>>

5= Ë›

) Äą

7> ˙& ˛ ˙ • Ĺ " • w ˙ ˚ Ĺ x

76 ˙ ˛ ( Ĺ˙ ˚ )˛ Ĺ

Äą & Äą & Äą Äą

7867 Äą & Äą & Äą Ëš Äą

<68

aWd3TZZT YS \aq-ZdWS wb*2YZSgpx ˛ ı

ı G ˙ ı ˚

w) 4Z*pE qV 3SbS , Z1ab*bV*f T qV 3SbS , /\ab*bVdD ) \aq-Zd, b*2YZSgp b\-\E qV d ,an\Yd T 4* +d/nOqVSf \+ab*,SZ +dbS aSbSY T 4Z\aSbS -\W\/DDD a1 Y1ZT ]T/ aSWd 4*,/qVS b\YdE fb\ Y1Z1 4YTgZp2x L SWD 8B56E 57MD ı *]\ab\W* *,W* ,31 /\,-Sy h*a ]T/+*/n\`ppbn Y1Z1 T Y\p /`d3SZd WTD * */*-*aV*`T YSE ]\/T+Z\ /\ *,W*E \aq-ZdWS wb*2YZSgpx b\-\E qV +dbS 4*/\,\W1ZSYE ]\,O ZTabp ]\VW*/*phSan Z* -\,dD *bS WT ]\h*W* ,S,h*bS T+WTp 4T ,T/V*O YS -\,S , 5=<6 `\gTD * b\y h*a YS 4 WT +dO WS 4*`dh1ZTD ) b13 ]\-\/S,aq Z* ,S,h1ZZqE * 4-\/\Y ]`S2/Z*W*an T WTD *abd]Z\-\ `\O Vd YS \/`d3SWSanD /`*4d ]TaWq f`1k1ZZqE 5=<9 `\VdE YS `\4]\h*WS /\]\YT3Z1 ]T\Z1`O anV1 aWd3TZZqE * , WS]ZT 5=<:O-\ P ab*W1D ,1`1aZT 5=<; `\Vd Z*a ]`S4Z*hSWS a]1gTO *WnZSYS ]T\Z1`*YS , YTab1hV\ Z* ]T,ZThZ\Yd 4*f\/T */*-*aV*`dD gn\Yd YTab1hVd Z1 +dO W\ 3\/Z\-\ 4+\`dD ˝Sb1WT */*-*aV*`d Z*W1O 3*bn /\ 5< \aZ\,ZSf 1bZThZSf -`d] b* +14WTO hT ]W1Y1ZE b\Yd ^fZT 4,Sh* ^ T b`*/SgT^ /d31 `T4ZqbnaqD eTgTyZ\p Y\,\p */*-*aV*`d 2 Y*W*-*aTyanV*E *W1 ]\jS`1ZT y `T4ZT /T*W1VO bSD \3 YS ,S`TjSWS ,S,hSbS /T*W1VbE qVSY `\4Y\,Wqpbn Y1jV*ZgT b\-\ YTab*E Vd/S Z*a ]`S4Z*hSWSE T 4-\/\Y Wp/S ]\h*WS V`*k1 /\ Z*a ab*,SbSanD #\Z1/TWT q ,S-\W\jd,*, ]d+WThZd ]`\Y\,dE ]TaWq qV\^ WSj1 WT ]W1aV*W* Y1ZTE b\Yd k\ 59 ˚ ) 6>56

+dW* Y\^Y 2/SZSY aWdf*h1YD S b*V\3 ]`\,\O /SWS ,aT ]dZVbS "V\WS b1\V`*bShZ\-\ aWdO 3TZZqD ]\V*4*f WT `\4Y\,WqW* 4 dq,ZSY -\a]\/*`1Y ]\Y1jV*ZZqD \WS Z*a ,T/,T/*, `*y\ZZSy Z*-Wq/*hE ,TZ /\+`\4ShWS,\ ]\`*O /S, a]`\abSbS ]`\-`*Yd 4T+`*ZnD )V1 3 g1 +dW\ ]\W1-j1ZZqI 1`14 b1 k\ ]\jb* ]\-*Z\ ]`*gp,*W*E YS Z1 4*,3/S \b`SYd,*WS -`\jT Z* VSj1ZnV\,T ,Sb`*bSD \Yd YS Z*,hSWSaq ,S3S,*bS , Z1O ab*bV*fD )V\an Z*Y +`*Vd,*W\ -`\j1y Z* *,O b\+daE k\+ ,T/,T/*bS `*y\ZZSy V\Z-`1aE qVSy ]`\f\/S, 4* 57> VTW\Y1b`T, ,T/ Z*j\-\ YTaO b*D \/T YS ]`S-*/*WS /\+`d ]\`*/d \/Z\-\ ,T/V*B w \4]\,T/*yb1 -\,T ]`\ a,\^ ]`\+W1O YSD ˛`1jb\pE ,S ,SV\Zd2b1 y\-\ a]`*,dxD S ]\Y\WSWSan T ,S`TjSWS ]TbS ]TjVSD W1 Z1 ,abS-WS YS ,S`djSbS , /\`\-dE qV /\ Z*a Z1O a]\/T,*Z\ 4*,Tb*, +`*b T ]\/*`d,*, Z*Y -`\O jT P a*Y1 abTWnVSE aVTWnVS b`1+* +dW\ 4*]W*O bSbS 4* ]`\^4/D

•

˚ ˝ı

)

Wpb\Yd 5==5 `\Vd Y1Z1 ]`S4Z*hSWS `*O y\ZZSY Z*-Wq/*h1YD * b\y Y\Y1Zb d Z*j\O Yd YTab1hVd ,31 db,\`SW*an -`d]* 4 /1,GqbS

7

*/*-*aV*`E qVSy k1 Z*4S,*pbn 1WSO VSY h1`,\ZSY \ab`\,\YE 2 h1b,1`O bSY Z*y+TWnjSY \ab`\,\Y Z* 41YWTD ˘`dZb Z* */*-*aV*`T h1`,\Z\-\ V\Wn\`dD * gn\Yd \ab`\,T 2 hSY*W\ dZTV*WnZSf ,S/T, `\aWSZ T b,*`SZ

,TaZSVT,E b`\2 4 qVSf \f`1abSWSaqD ˛T+`*ZZq ,T/,T/d,*W\ , a1`1/Zn\Yd 9> \aT+D `\yj\,O jS a]1gT*WnZ1 Z*,h*ZZqE q `*4\Y 4 /`d3SO Z\p ]\h*, ,T/,T/d,*bS 4+\`S , Zb*Z*Z*`T,dE ab\WSgT */*-*aV*`dD 5==7 `\gT Z*a ]`SO 4Z*hSWS , `*y\Z Z* af\/T V`* ^ZSD ˝Sbbq b*Y /d31 ,T/`T4ZqW\aq ,T/ 3Sbbq , ab\WSgTD #\+ /Tab*bSaq /\ 4+\`T, T ,T//*W1ZSf -`d]E TZ\/T YS /\W*WS ]TjVS Y*y31 589 VTW\Y1b`T, ]\ -\`*fE ,V`SbSf -dabSYS WTa*YSD S +`*WS 4 a\+\p YTZTY*WnZd VTWnVTabn `1h1yD \WS 3 d ]`\Y\,d `*y\ZZ\-\ Z*-Wq/*h* ,f\/S, ]\O V*4 aW*y/T, LqV g1 +d,*W\ , bT h*aSME Z\j* ab*,*W* ,*3h\pB WT Z1aW* ]`\1Vb\`E * q P 56O,\WnbZSy *,b\Y\+TWnZSy *VdYdWqb\`D *ab\ Z*Y /\,\/SW\an TbS ]\ 8> VTW\Y1b`T, Z* /1ZnE k\+ /\+`*bSaq /\ Z*abd]Z\-\ 4+\`dD S yjWS V`dbSYS -T`anVSYS /\`\-*YSE ]1`1O bSZ*WS `ThVS y +\W\b*D ˙1V\WS a]*WS Z* d4+ThO hTE *W1 4*4,Sh*y jdV*WS qV\-\an a1W*E k\+ ,W*jbd,*bSan Z* ZThWT-D ˛/1+TWnj\-\ YS 4dO ]SZqWSaq , 4\,aTY Z14Z*y\YSf Wp/1yD ˛Z*yO j\,jS 3SbW\E YS ]\hSZ*WS -\bd,*bS ^abSD WT ]\4Sh*W* , -\a]\/*`T, V*4*Z T yjW* ]\ ,\/d /\ `ThVS hS \41`*D SY h*a\Y q ]`\aS, a\VS`dE k\+ Z*`d+*bS /`\,D a1 g1 4*+S`*W\ +*-*b\ h*adD ıZV\WS Z*Y ,/*,*W\aq Vd]SbS 3S,d Vd`O VdE qVd YS a*YT YdaSWS 4*+SbS T \+aVd+*bSD ‹ \^,jSE YS Z*Z\aSWS ,\/SE k\+ ]\YSbSanD ıZ\/T Wp/S ]`\]\Zd,*WS Z*Y 4*Z\hd,*bS Z* VdfZTD d,*W\E k\ , ]\Y1jV*ZZT ]`\bTV*, /*fD \3E V\WS yj\, /\kE Z*Y /\,\/SW\aq a]*bS a]1`jSan /\ abTZSE k\+ 4*WSjSbSan adfSYSD

8

S 4*,3/S Z*Y*-*WSaq a,T/hSbS Wp/qYE , qVSf Z\hd,*WSD \WS YS ]`S+d,*WS Z* YTaO g1 ]`S4Z*h1ZZqE b\ ,T/hd,*WS Z*/4,Sh*yZd /\+`\bd y -\abSZZTabn +`*bT, T a1ab1`D \O ZS Z*abTWnVS `*/TWS Z*j\Yd ]`Sf\/dE k\ g1 V\Y]1Zad,*W\ ,aT Z14`dhZ\abTE qVT YS 4Z\aSO WS , /\`\4TD ˝S,dhS , \/Z\,T`gT,E YS \f\h1 /\]\Y*-*WS ^Y ]\ /\YdE T 4*,/qVS gn\Yd ,\ZS Y*WS h*aE k\+ ]TbS 4 Z*YS , aWd3TZZqD T qE ZT /`d3SZ* Z1 \hTVd,*WS `\4VTjZ\-\ ]`Sy\Yd b* ,SjdO V*ZSf ab`*,E qVSf Z*jT +`*bS T a1ab`S Z1 Y\-WS 4*]`\]\Zd,*bSD ı˛ ı˙˙ ˚ ı

*Y ]\/\+*W\an ,T/,T/d,*bS ,T//*W1ZT -`dO ]SE /1 Z* Z*a h1V*, kTWnZSy -`*eTV aWd3TZO ZqD \3WS,Tabn wb`\fS ,T/]\hSbSx ,S]*/*W* /d31 `T/V\ L *`V* :B75MD )V\an ]\/`d3O 3q ,T/VT, 4*]`\aSW\ /\ a1+1 Z* ,S,h1ZZq ,aTf a,\^f 4*gTV*,W1ZSf P +WS4nV\ 8> \aT+D WT 4 a1ab`\p ]`\,1W* V\W\ 6> ,S,h1ZnE * q 4 +`*b\Y P `1jbdD )V bTWnVS \/Z1 ,S,h1ZO Zq 4*VTZhd,*W\anE ]\hSZ*W\aq TZj1D \ \+T/T YS 4`\+SWS ]1`1`,dE k\+ ]`\,1abS 4T+`*ZZqE * b\/T ]`\/\,3SWS ,S,h1ZZqD 1y Z*]`d31O ZSy /1Zn 4*VTZhS,aq ]TaWq ,\anY\^ ,1h\`*D \WS YS ,T/,T/d,*WS TZjd -`d]dE b\ 4*]W*O Zd,*WS `*4\Y 4 ,TaZSV*YS \]`*gp,*bS /\,O V\WSjZp b1`Sb\`TpD `S+WS4Z\ \ ,\anYTy `*ZVd YS gTW\p -`d]\p ,S`djSWS , adaT/Z2 a1W\D /q-Z1ZT , ab*`Sy \/q-E YS /\,-\ yjWS h1`14 WTaD ˙\ b\-\ a1W* YS /Tab*WSaq bTWnVS ]\]\Wd/ZTD 1`1\/q-Zd,jSan d hSab1 ,+`*ZO 59 ˚ ) 6>56

ZqE YS ]\h*WS aWd3TZZq ,T/ /\Yd /\ /\YdD a1WT +dW\ WSj1 VTWnV* f*bE * Z*a P +*-*b\E b\3 YS \]`*gp,*WS b1`Sb\`Tp ,an\-\ 4* ]T,O -\/SZSD \/T YS ,S`djSWS , Z*abd]Z1 a1W\D TaWq ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZq Z*a h1V*W* ,SaZ*3WSO ,* /\`\-* /\/\YdD S b`\fS 4Z1\f\hd,*WSanE */31 ,Sb`*h*WS +*-*b\ h*ad T 4daSWnE * ]`\O ]\,T/d,*WS +WS4nV\ -\/SZSD /Z*V YTag1,T ,T/VS ZTV\WS Z1 Z*`TV*WSD \ZS ,SV\Zd,*WS aWd3TZZq 4 1Zbd4T*4Y\YD YTab1hVd *,T`*Z*Y+\E k\ `\4VSZdW\aq , -\`*fE /TqW* ,T//*W1Z* -`d]*D *Y YS ]\4Z*O y\YSWSaq 4 aTYG2p ,T/VT,E qV* 3SW* , \/Z\O VTYZ*bZ\Yd +d/SZVdD Tag1,* -`d]* ]`\,\/SO W* 4T+`*ZZq , Z1,1WSVTy a]\`d/TE k\ ab\qW* +TWq ^fZn\-\ +d/SZVdD \a]\/*` ,S-dVZd,B w `*bSIx ˛ TZj\^ -\`S fb\an ,T/T4,*,aqB w -\,Ix \/T ,TZ -\W\aZ\ ]`\V`Sh*,B w `Syj\, `*y\ZO ZSy Z*-Wq/*hIx P w˙\+`1Ix P ]`\WdZ*W* ,T/O ]\,T/nD *VSY 31 hSZ\Y 4,TabVd ]1`1/*WS TZO jSYE T Z1,/\,4T Wp/S ]\h*WS abTV*bSaq Z* 4T+`*ZZqD an\-\ ]`SyjW\ ]\Z*/ 5>> \aT+D ˙ #ı ˙ ˛ı

5==: `\gT Z*a ]`S4Z*hSWS , -\`Sabd YTag1,Tabn Z1]\/*WTV Zb*Z*Z*`T,dD Wd3*hS

, Z\,\Yd `*y\ZTE YS 4Z\,d 4TbVZdWSaq 4 b`d/O Z\k*YSD ˙d31 ,*3V\ +dW\ /Tab*bSaq ,T//*O W1ZSf 4+\`T,E \aVTWnVS ]\-*Z\ f\/S, b`*ZaO ]\`bD ˛-T/Z\ 4 -`*eTV\Y YS Y*WS ,T/,T/*bS -`d]d , YTab1hVd 1*ZV*Z* L 1a*V*yME k\ ]`S+WS4Z\ 4* 68> VTW\Y1b`T, ,T/ Zb*Z*Z*O `T,dD S /\Y\,SWSaq 4 ,\/T2Y \/ZT2^ Z1,1WSO V\^ ,*Zb*3T,VSE k\ ,TZ /\,141 Z*a /\ YTagq ]`S4Z*h1ZZqD *VSfE qV YSE +dW\ k1 b`S/O gqbnB fb\an aS/T, d ,*Zb*3T,gTE fb\an W13*, Z* /*fdE * V\Ydan ]`SyjW\aq ]\,SaZdbS /1an 44*/dD )V g1 h*ab\ b`*]Wq2bnaqE Z1,/\,4T *,b\Y\O +TWn ]\W*Y*,aqE T YS ]`\/\,3SWS ]\/\`\3 ]TjVSD S yjWS VTWnV* -\/SZE *3 `*]b\Y Z*O /G^f*W* TZj* ,*Zb*3T,V*D \Z* ,31 +dW* 4*O ]\,Z1Z* Wp/nYS T `T4ZSYS `1h*YSE *W1 ,\/Ty ,a1 \/Z\ 4d]SZS,aqD S 4*WT4WS d ,*Zb*3T,O VdC aS/qhSf YTagnE 4,Sh*yZ\E Z1 +dW\D ˛-\/\Y YS ]T/G^f*WS /\ `ThVSE *W1 YTab +d, Z* `1Y\ZO bTD \3 Z*Y /\,1W\aq ]TbS ]TjVS /\ Z1,1WShO V\-\ a1W*E /1 3SW\ VTWnV* a]1gT*WnZSf ]T\Z1O `T,D \h* Z*j ,T4Sb +d, Z14*]W*Z\,*ZSyE YS 4Y\-WS ]\aWd3SbS `*4\Y 4 ZSYS y ]1`1h1O V*bSE /\VS ,T/`1Y\Zbdpbn YTab T 4Gq,Sbnaq qVSyan b`*Za]\`bD

/\`\4T YS h*ab\ abSV*WSaq 4 b`d/Z\k*YS

*Y /d31 ]\/\+*2bnaq ]`\,\/SbS +T+WTyZT ,S,h1ZZq

1`14 bS3/1Zn ]`\^3/3*, *,b\Y\+TWnE T YS 4Z\,d ,S`djSWS , ]dbnD ˙\`\-* +dW* daq ,V`SO b* ,1WSVSYS qY*YSD 1`T/V\ Z*Y /\,\/SW\an ]\Y*-*bS ,Sjb\,fd,*bS Y*jSZd 4 V*Wp3TE /1 ,\/S +dW\ ]\ V\WTZ*C YS a]\bSV*WSan T ]*/*WSD

* a,Tb*ZVd YS /\+`*WSaq /\ Z1,1WSV\-\ a1W* T /*WT ]TjWS h1`14 `Sa\,T ]\WqE Y*W\ Z1 ]\ ]\O qa ]\-`d4*phS , V*W*YdbZd ,\/dD S ,]1`j1 +dWS , bTy YTag1,\abTE b\Yd ,S`TO jSWS /*bS a,T/h1ZZq Wp/qYE qVT \+`\+WqWS ]\WqE T 4*]Sb*bSE /1 bdb 3S,dbn ,T/VSD SqO ,SW\aqE k\ gT ]`*gT,ZSVS +dWS Z*jSYS /dO f\,ZSYS +`*b*YSI ˛ ı ı ˙ ˝ı

)

]`\/\,3 `\VT, YS 4*\f\hd,*WS ,TaZSVT, /\ ]\,Z\h*aZ\-\ aWd3TZZq T Z*/4,Sh*yZ\ `*O /TWSE V\WS g1 ]`SZ\aSW\ `14dWnb*bSD /Z\-\ `*4d YS ,T/,T/d,*WS 4+T`E , qV\Yd +dW\ /1O ,Gqbn ab*WSf ]T\Z1`T,D S ]\`*/SWSE k\+ V\O

31Z ]T\Z1` ]\ab*,S, a\+T 4* Y1bd a]\ZdV*bS \/Z\-\ ,TaZSV* /\ ]T\Z1`anV\-\ aWd3TZZqD \O WS YS ]`S^f*WS , g1y 4+T` h1`14 ]T,`\VdE b\ ]\+*hSWSE k\ ]T\Z1`S , Zn\Yd ,S`\aWS qV -`S+SB ^f d31 +dW\ 66D ˙,T ]T\Z1`VS 4*\f\bSWS /\ ]\,Z\h*aZ\-\ aWd3TZZq a,\^f b*bT,E ab*O `TyjSZ 4+\`dD T /,\2 +`*bT, a]\ZdV*WS b`1O bn\-\ ab*`TyjSZd ]`S2/Z*bSaq /\ ZSfD 1,O /\,4T gn\-\ +`*b* ]`S4Z*hSWS a]1gT*WnZSY ]T\Z1`\YE T 4-\/\Y ,TZ 4 /`d3SZ\p `\4]\h*, `*y\ZZ1 aWd3TZZqD k\ ab*W\aq 4 bSYS /,\O Y* +`*b*YSH /SZ 4 ZSf b13 aWd3Sbn `*y\ZO ZSY Z*-Wq/*h1YE TZjSy P /\+`\,TWnZSY +dO /T,1WnZSV\Y ˛*WT, *`ab,*D S k\/Zq /qVd2Y\ -\,T 4* y\-\ ]T/b`SYO VdE */31 `\4dYT2Y\E k\ ZTh\-\ + Z1 /\aq-O WS ,W*aZSYS aSW*YSD ıZ\/T YS ,b\YWp2Y\an T f,\`T2Y\E *W1 ,T/hd,*2Y\ 4*/\,\W1ZZqE V\O WS `\4/dYd2Y\ ]`\ ]W\/S Z*j\-\ aWd3TZZqD

-\,* +W*-\aW\,Wq2 ]`*gp ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZqD S `*/TE k\ Y\31Y\ `\+SbS a,Ty aV`\YZSy ,Z1a\VE aWd3*hS b1]1` a]1gT*WnZSYS ]T\Z1O `*YSD ]`*,/TE YS \aq-ZdWS wb*2YZSgpx b\-\E qV +dbS 4*/\,\W1ZSYE ]\VW*/*phSan Z* -\O ,d P \-*E qVSy 4YTgZp2 Z*aD

S \aq-ZdWS w b*2YZSgp x b\-\E qV +dbS 4*/\,\W1ZSYE ]\VW*/*phSan Z* -\,d

59 ˚ ) 6>56

w ı˙ ıx w *]`*,/dE k\ ,*j \- P g1 \- Z*/ +\O -*YS b* *Z Z*/ g*`qYSE T TZ ,T/V`SO ,*2 b*2YZSgT x L˙ D 6B8;MD

) ı˙ ı H

)VT ]\/`\+SgT k\/\ Y*y+dbZn\-\ -\,* ,T/V`S, Z*YH

#\ aSY,\WT4dpbn ]1`jT jTabn -\WT, /SV\-\ 4,T`*H

ı d`q/S ]*Zd,*bSYdbn Z* 41YWT , b\y h*aE V\WS \31 *`ab,\ ]\VW*/1 V`*y Wp/anV\Yd ]`*,WTZZpH T/]\,T/n /*2 Z*Y -\,* P \-E qVSy w,T/V`S,*2 b*2YZSgTxD 1`14 ]Sa*ZZq ]`\`\V* ˙*ZS^W* T *]\ab\W* ı,*O Z* ,TZ ]\,T/\YS, Z*YE qVT g1 +d/dbn d`q/SD

) 6

\- ]\V*4*, bSY /,\Y h\W\,TV*Y `q/ ,S/TZnE , qVSf \/SZ 4* \/ZSY 4Gq,WqWSaq `T4ZT 4,T`TD TZ b*V\3 ]\qaZS, ˙*ZS^Wd 4Z*h1ZZq ]`\`\h\-\ aZd ]`\ ,1WSV\-\ +\,,*Z*D -\,* ]\/+*,E k\+ gT ]`\`\gb,* +dWS 4*]Sa*ZT T 4+1`131ZT 4*/Wq Z*j\-\ +W*-* L SYD 59B8MD TZ f\bT, 4YTgZSO bS Z*jd Z*/Tp Z* b1E k\ y\-\ *`ab,\ ]\b\,h1 ,aT Wp/anVT d`q/S L˙*ZD 6B88MD 7 ˛Tab*,S,jS `\4]\,T/T 4 VZS- ˙*ZS ^W* ‹ T +Gq,W1ZZqE YS /T4Z*2Y\anE qVT ,TaTY g*`T, Y*O WS 4Gq,WqbSaq Z* a,Tb\,Ty *`1ZT T , qV\Yd ]\O `q/VdD S hTbV\ 4`\4dYT2Y\ gT ]`\`\gb,* WSO j1 b\/TE V\WS ,T4nY1Y\ /\ d,*-S Z*y]1`j1 ]`\`\gb,\E 4*]Sa*Z1 , T+WT^D \YdH \Yd k\ a]\,Z1ZZq ]1`j\-\ ]`\`\gb,* P g1 \aZ\,Z* b1Y* T+WT^ T 4 ZSY ]\,Gq4*ZT ,aT TZjT +T+WTyZT ]`\`\gb,*D

ı

) ˛ ı) ı ˙ • ˛ ı

8

1,/\,4T ]TaWq +dZbd , ˚/1YT -\,* ]\O \+Tgq,E k\ ,T/ w3TZVSx1 ,Sy/1 wZ*aTZZqxD L `\O hSb*yb1 dbbq 7B59MD 1 Z*aTZZq 4Tb`1

)V ]\,Gq4*ZT YT3 a\+\p /SVSy 4,T` T +\,,*Z 4T aZd *,df\/\Z\a\`*H

1 q 3TZV* ]`1/ab*,Wq2 ]\/T+Zd /\ /`d3SZS \`-*ZT4*gTp

-\,SE qV* aVW*/*2bnaq 4 /df\,ZSf ab,\`TZn Lıa* ^ 98B5C *WD 8B6:C +Gq,D 56B5E 6MD

5E 6D #\ -\,* ,T/V`S,*2 Z*Y T /Wq h\-\H 7D #\ Z*Y aWT/ ,4qbS /\ d,*-SE k\+ hTbV\ 4`\4dYTbS ]`\O `\gb,* 4 VZS- ˙*ZS^W* y +Gq,W1ZZqE T h\YdH 8D b\ Z*W13Sbn /\ Z*aTZZq 3TZVS T k\ ,\Z\ 4`\+SbnH

;

-\W\,d 4YTpE *b*ZTD \abd]\,\ -\O ,* ,Sq,S,E k\ Z*aTZZq Y*W\ ]\O f\/SbS ,T/ ,`**Y*E Z*W13*bS /\ T4`* ^WnanV\-\ Z*`\/dE +dbS p/1O 2Y T Z*k*/V\Y g*`q ˙*,S/* L dbD 66B59P5<C 8=B5>C aD <=B8E 9C dVS 5B7>P77MD \W\,Z\p h*abSZ\p gn\-\ Z*aTZZq 2 `Sab\a ıada L *WD 7B5:MD /`d-\`q/Z\p P ]\Y*4*ZT a,qbSY /df\Y hW1ZS f`SabSqZanV\-\ 4+\O `d L *WD 7B6:P6=MD ıada T ]\Y*4*ZO gT db,\`ppbn \31 *`ab,\ P d`q/E 4* /\]\Y\-\p qV\-\ \- 4ZSkSbn *O b*Zd L dVS 56B76C SYD 5:B6>MD 9 ˛-T/Z\ 4 ]1`jSY ]`\`\gb,\YE ,S-\W\j1ZSY , ˚/1YTE d *b*ZS b13 Y*W\ 4Gq,SbSaq wZ*aTZZqxD 1 Z*aTZO Zq ,\`\-d,*bSY1 4 Z*aTZZqY 3TZO VS T +d/1 y\-\ Z1Z*,S/TbSD b\ Z*O W13Sbn /\ Z*aTZZq 4YTqH aTE fb\E ]\/T+Z\ /\ *b*ZSE Z1Z*,S/Sbn \O -* T hSZSbn \]T` y\-\ Z*`\/dD ]`\O /\,3 Tab\`T^ ˙Sq,\W \+G2/Zd,*, a,\2 Z*aTZZqE db,\`pphS `T4Z\Y*ZTbZT ]\WTbShZT aSab1YS T g*`ab,* L dVS 8B9E :MD /Z*V bTWnVS /1qVT d`q/S Y*O WS *+\ Y*pbn +14]\a1`1/ZTy ,]WS, Z* \3Sy Z*`\/ P Z* ı4`* ^Wn hS Z* 4+T` ]\Y*4*ZSf f`SabSqZD 1y e*Vb ]\qaZp2E h\Yd d ,S/TZZqf ˙*ZS^W*

9E :D *M VTWnVS Y\-dbZTf d`q/T, 4-*/d2bnO aq , VZS-*f ˙*ZS^W* b* +Gq,W1ZZqH +M #\ ]`1/ab*,Wqpbn -\W\,S /SV\-\ 4,T`*E 4\+`*O 31Z\-\ , VZS4T +Gq,W1ZZqH

<

b* ı,*Z* 4*-*W\Y 4\+`*3*pbnaq WSO j1 ,TaTY Y\-dbZTf d`q/T,D

*]`SVTZgT I ab\WTbbq ZD 1D ,\aVO `1aWSy ıada ]\V*4*, *]\ab\Wd ı,*Zd VTWnV* /S,\,S3ZSf ,S/TZn L +Gq,D 5B5MD \/Z\Yd 4 ZSf ı,*Z +*hS, /`*O V\Z*E qVSy ab\q, Z* +1`14T Y\`qD 1y /`*V\Z aSY,\WT4d2 ˙Sq,\W*D L `\hSO b*yb1 +Gq,W1ZZq 57B5E 6MD `TY b\-\E ı,*Zd +dW\ ]\V*4*Z\ /S,Z\-\ 4,T`*E k\ ,Sf\/S, 4 Y\`qD TZ Y*, aTY -\WT, T \b`SY*, ,T/ ˙Sq,\W* ,1WSO Vd ,W*/dD T4ZTj1 ı,*Z ]\+*hS, +*-O `qZ\-\ 4,T`*E qVSy b13 Y*, aTY -\O WT, T +d, \+`*4\Y 4,T`* 4 +Gq,W1ZZq 57B5D Z-1W ]\qaZS, ı,*ZdE k\ aTY -\WT, +*-`qZ\-\ 4,T`* ]`1/ab*,WqO pbn waTY g*`T,xE b\+b\ d`q/T, L +Gq,D 57B58E 59C 5;B7E =E 5>MD * h*a Z*]SO a*ZZq VZS-S +Gq,W1ZZq ]Gqbn 4 ZSf d31 ,]*WSE \/SZ +d, ]`S ,W*/TE * TZO jSy wk1 Z1 ]`Syj\,xD #\ 3 g1 4* g*`ab,*E *+\ a,Tb\,T /1`3*,SH \-\O ,\`TY\ ]`\ V\3Zd -\W\,d 4,T`*E 4\+O `*31Z\-\ , VZS4T +Gq,W1ZZqD *V\3 `\4-WqZnY\ ]`\`\gb,* ˙*ZS^W*E qVT 4*]Sa*ZT 4* a\bZT `\VT, /\ TaZd,*ZZq :

/1qVSf 4 gSf /1`3*,D •\-\ ]`\`\gbO ,* `\4V`Spbn Z*Y /\/*bV\,T /1b*WTD ˚ ı ı) P ˚ "ı ˙ ı ; 1`j* -\W\,* 4,T`* aSY,\WT4d2

-S]1bE */31 g1 ]1`j* Y\-dbZq /1`O 3*,*E qV* ]`\bS/TqW* \3\Yd Z*`\O /dD *k*/VS ,`**Y*E h1`14 qV\-\ Y*W\ 4Gq,SbSaq \+TgqZ1 Z*aTZZq 3TZO VSE ab*WS , -S]bT /\aSbn hSaW1ZZTD T/b\/T 2-S]bqZS ]\h*WS ]`S-Z\+O Wp,*bS T4`* ^WnbqZD *b*Z* Z*Y*-*,O aq ab1`bS \3Sy Z*`\/ 4 WSgq 41YWT k1 /\ ]\q,S Z*aTZZqD ˙Wq gn\-\ ,TZ a]\ZdV*, e*`*\Z* ,+SbS ,aTf T4`*O ^WnanVSf fW\]hSVT,D -\,* `\4W*/O Z*, WSfSy 4*/dY *b*ZS T ,S4,\WS, a,Ty Z*`\/ 4 2-S]1banV\-\ `*+ab,* L SfD 5B59P6>C 58B57MD ˛-\/\Y ,TZ \a1WS, T4`* ^WnbqZ , +TgqZTy 41YWTD < ˙`d-* -\W\,* 4,T`* ]`1/ab*,Wq2 aaS`TpD 1 Y\-dbZ2 g*`ab,\ b13 f\bTW\ 4ZSkSbS \3Sf aWd3Sb1WT,D #\]`*,/*E -\,* ,SV\`Sab*, *aO aS`TygT,E k\+ ]\V*`*bS /1aqbS]W1O YTZZ1 g*`ab,\ ı4`* ^Wn 4* Z1]\V\`d b* T/\W\]\VW\Zab,\D W1 ]TaWq gn\-\ aaS`Tq Z*Y*-*W*aq 4*f\]SbS `dO a*WSYD *b*Z*E \h1,S/Z\E ]W*ZdO ,*, ,S-d+SbS g*`anVSy `T/E , qV\O Yd Y*, Z*`\/SbSaq ıadaD 1y Z*]*/ Z1 ,f\/S, d Z*YT` -\,SE b\3 ,TZ hd/\Y ,`qbd,*, a,Ty ,T`ZSy Z*O `\/E 4ZSkS,jS 4*-*`+ZSVT, L6 *`D 5=B76P79C ıa* ^ 5>B9E :E 56P59MD

P ˚ ) =

`1bq -\W\,* 4,T`*E qV\-\ +*O hS, ı,*ZE aSY,\WT4d2 *,SW\ZD -\O ;D #\ aSY,\WT4d2 ]1`j* -\W\,* 4,T`* T h\YdH <D )Vd /1`3*,d aSY,\WT4d2 /`d-* -\W\,* 4,T`* T k\ ,\Z* Z*Y*-*W*an 4`\+SbSH =E 5>D *M #\ -\,* /\4,\WS, ,*,SW\ZqO Z*YH +M #\ Y*W\ ,T/+dbSaqE *+S a]\,ZSWSan ]`\`\gb,* ]`\ 1aTpH

59 ˚ ) 6>56

,* /\4,\WS, ,*,SW\ZqZ*Y 4*,\p,*O bS `da*WSY T ,4qbS y\-\ Y1jV*ZO gT, d ]\W\ZD /Z*V ]1`1/ bSY \ 4*ab1`T-*, +dZbT,ZSf T4`* ^WnbqZ ]`\ ]`Sy/1jZ2 WSf\ L6 *`D 6>B5:P5<MD TZ ]1`1/`TVE k\ `T/ Wp/anVSf g*`T,E qVT aS/TWS wZ* \a]\/Zn\Yd b`\ZTx , `da*WSYTE +d/1 4ZSk1ZSy L5 `D 6=B67MD ,bTYE -\,* ]\\+Tgq,E k\ ]`Sy/1 Z*k*/\V g*`q ˙*,S/*E qVSy wY*2 ]`*,\xE T ]\aq/1 g1y b`\Z L 41VD 65B7>P76MD 5>

˛-T/Z\ 4 \/ZSY ]`\`\gb,\YE Z* h*a ]`Sf\/d \+TgqZ\-\ 1aT^E b\+O b\ \Y*4*ZgqE p/1^ ,a1 k1 ]\VW\ZqO bSYdbnaq , `da*WSYanV\Yd f`*YT L˙*ZD =B68P6;MD TZj\Yd ]`\`\gbO ,TE 4*]Sa*Z\Yd ]1`1/ bSYE qV T4`*O ^WnbqZS ]\b`*]SWS , Z1,\Wp /\ *O ,SW\ZdE -\,\`SW\aqE k\ \Y*4*Z1gn Z*`\/Sbnaq d TeW12YT L SfD 9B5MD #\+ gT ]`\`\gb,* a]\,ZSWSanE p/1^ Y*WS 4,TWnZSbSaq 4 ]\W\ZdE ]\,1`O ZdbSan d `T/ZSy V`*y T ,T/+d/d,*bS f`*YD `\b1 ,*,SW\ZqZS ZTV\WS Z1 ,T/]daV*WS a,\^f ]\W\Z1ZSfD )V 31 \3Sy Z*`\/ ,Sy/1 4 Z1,\WTH -\,* ]\,T/\YS, g1 a,\2Yd ]`\`\Vd L YD 7B;MD 55 `\`\V ˙*ZS^W +d, a1`1/ ]\O W\Z1ZSf d *,SW\ZT L˙*ZD 5B5P:MD 1`14 Zn\-\ -\,* ,Sq,S,E qVT g*`O ab,* ,Sf\/SbSYdbn Z* a,Tb\,d *`1O Zd ]TaWq *,SW\ZdD \- ,T/V`S, g1E ,SV\`Sab*,jS ]1,ZT aSY,\WSD

*]`SVW*/E ,*,SW\ZanV\Yd g*`1O ,T *,df\/\Z\a\`d \- d,T aZT ]\O V*4*, ,1WSV\-\ +\,,*Z*E 4`\+W1Z\O -\ 4 `T4ZSf Y1b*WT,D L `\hSb*yb1 ˙*ZS^W* 6B5E 5=E 75P7<MD -\,* ]\O ,T/\YS, ˙*ZS^W\,TE k\ 4\W\b* -\W\O ,* +\,,*Z* aSY,\WT4d2 *,SW\ZanVd 55D )VSYS aSY,\W*YS 4\+`*31Z* *,SO W\ZanV* TY]1`TqH L˙S,Tbnaq ]`SYTbVdMD

=

TY]1`Tp1D ,Tb\,* /1`3*,*E qV* Y*W* ]\ab*bS ]TaWq *,SW\ZdE ]`1/ab*,O W1Z* a`T+ZSYS -`d/nYS T `dV*YSD #\ g1 4* /1`3*,* T qV ,\Z* ab*,SW*aq /\ \3\-\ Z*`\/dH ı˙ O ˚ ı) P ˚ ˚ 56

TWnj ZT3 4* ab\WTbbq /\ h*adE V\WS 3S, ˙*ZS^WE -\,* ,T/V`S, h1O `14 ]`\`\V* ıa*p /1qVT /1b*WT ]`\ a,Tb\,d /1`3*,dE qV* Y*W* 4*,\pO ,*bS *,SW\ZD -\,* ]\,T/\YS, Z1 WSj1 b1E qVSY hSZ\Y *,SW\Z +dO /1 4*f\]W1Z\E *W1 y TYGq 4*,\y\,O ZSV*D SY Y*, ab*bS ]1`anVSy g*` T` Lıa* ^ 88B6<P89B6MD ˙*ZS^W \b`SO Y*, k1 /,* ,S/TZZq ab\a\,Z\ TO /\O 1`anV\^ a,Tb\,\^ /1`3*,SD \/O Z\Yd 4 ZSf T/\O 1`aTq 4\+`*31Z* ,1/Y1/1YE k\ ab\q, Z* \/Z\Yd +\gTD TZ \b`SY*, Z*V*4B wı3 +*-*b\ YGqO a*x L˙*ZD ;B9MD , TZj\Yd ,S/TZZT ˙*ZS^W ]\+*hS, /,\`\-\-\ +*`*Z*E qVSy aSY,\WT4d,*, gp ]\/,TyZd a,TO b\,d /1`3*,d L˙*ZD <B7E 6>MD 57 ˛* /\]\Y\-\p T/\O 1`anV\^ TYO ]1`T^ -\,* ,SV\Z*, ]`\`\gb,\ ]`\ ]*/TZZq *,SW\Zd T ]\,1`Z1ZZq T4O `* ^WnbqZ /\ `T/Z\-\ V`*p L6 `D 7:B66E 67MD W1 Z1,/\,4T T/\O 1`O aTq Y*W\ Z1 ,SZSkSW* \3\-\ Z*`\O /dD T+WTyZ* VZS-* ˚ab1` ]\,T/\YO Wq2 ]`\ ]T/abd]ZSy ]W*Z *Y*Z*E ]1`j\-\ YTZTab`* 1`aT^D TZ 4*/dO Y*, ,S-d+SbS ,aTf p/1^,E qVT 3SWS , TY]1`T^E T Z*,Tbn ]`S4Z*hS, /1ZnE V\WS g1y -1Z\gS/ Y*, ,T/+dbSaqD 1 *,SW\Z 4\+`*31ZSy 4\W\b\p -\W\,\p +\,O ,*Z*E 4-*/*Z\-\ , VZS4T ˙*ZS^W*E T b`1bn\p -\O W\,\p /SV\-\ 4,T`*E ]`\ qV\-\ y/1bnaq , VZS4T +Gq,W1ZZqD L˙S,Tbnaq af1Yd Z* aD 56E 57MD

56E 57D *M #\ ]\,T/\YS, -\,* ]`\ ]*/TZO Zq *,SW\ZdH +M \Yd T/\O 1`aTp ,WdhO Z\ 4Y*Wn\,*Z\ h1b,1`b\p -\W\,\p /SV\-\ 4,T`*H

5>

/Z*V -\,* 4Z\,d 4*fSabS, a,Ty Z*O `\/ ,T/ 3\`ab\V\-\ Z*aTZZq *b*ZS L˚abD 5B5P7C 7B<E =C <B7E =P58MD bO 31E d VZS4T +Gq,W1ZZq T/\O 1`aTp ,WdhZ\ 4Y*Wn\,*Z\ h1b,1`b\p -\W\O ,\p 4,T`*D ˚ ı) P G) 58

Gqb* -\W\,* /SV\-\ 4,T`* 4 VZSO -S +Gq,W1ZZq ]`1/ab*,Wq2 `1gTpD p 3 /1`3*,dE qV ]\qaZS, ˙*ZSO ^WE 4\+`*3*2 YT/ZSy 3S,Tb T ab1-Z* +\,,*Z*E qVSy ]`SaZS,aq *,df\/\O Z\a\`dD ˙\ b\-\ 3 ˙*ZS^W \b`SY*, /,* ,S/TZZqE qVT /1b*WnZTj1 4Y*Wn\O ,dpbn `1gTp b* ^ ^ Z*y,S/*bZTj\-\ ]`*,Sb1WqD 59 \/Z\Yd 4 gSf ,S/TZn ˙*ZS^W ]\+*hS, `1gTpE qV* +dW* ]`1/ab*,O W1Z* W1\]*`/\Y 4 h\bS`Y* V`SW*O YSD 1 ,V*4d,*W\ Z* b1E k\ `1gnV* TY]1`Tq /d31 j,S/V\ ]T/V\`qbSY1 Z*`\/S L˙*ZD ;B:E \YDMD , TZj\O Yd ,S/TZZT ˙*ZS^W +*hS,E qV V\41W 4 ,1WSVSY `\-\Y YhSbn Z* /,\`\-\-\ +*`*Z*E k\ aSY,\WT4d2 T/\O 1`aTpE T ,+S,*2 y\-\D -\,* aV*4*, ˙*ZS^O WdE k\ V\41W 4\+`*3*2 `1gTpE * ,1O WSVSy `T- P ^ ^ g*`qO4*,\y\,ZSV*D T4ZTj1 ˙*ZS^W 4*]Sa*,E k\ ,1WSO VSy `T- +d/1 4W*Y*Z\ T 4*YTabn Zn\-\ ,S`\abdbn h\bS`S Y1ZjTD \h* g1 ]`\`\gb,\ ˙*ZS^W \b`SY*, ]`S+WS4O Z\ 4* /,* ab\WTbbq /\ b\-\E qV `1O gTq ab*W* ]*ZT,Z\p /1`3*,\pE ,\Z\ a]\,ZSW\an d /`T+ZSf /1b*WqfD W1VO a*Z/` *V1/\ZanVSyE Z*y,T/\YTjSy g*` ab*`\/*,Zn\^ `1gT^E ,Sabd]S, ]`\bS 1`aT^D * ,1`jSZT aW*,SE d ,TgT 76 `\VT,E W1Va*Z/` ]\Y1` P ,1WSVSy `T- +d, 4W*Y*ZSyD ˛-\/\Y TY]1`Tp ]\/TWSWS YT3 a\+\p y\-\ h\O 58E 59D )VT ]\/`\+SgT ,Sq,S, -\,* ab\O a\,Z\ ab*`\/*,Zn\^ `1gT^H

bS`S ]\WV\,\/gTD L `\hSb*yb1 ˙*O ZS^W* <B6>P66MD 5:

˛*,\p,*,jS 1`aTpE `1gTq ]\O h*W* ]`*,SbS T Z*/ ı4`* ^W1YD * b\y h*a 2,`1^ ]1`1a1WSWSaq , +TgqZd 41YWp T ,T/+d/d,*WS f`*Y d `da*O WSYTD ı4`* ^Wn /*WT 4*WSj*,aq \3SY ,S+`*ZSY Z*`\/\YE * f`*Y P g1ZbO `\Y ]`*,/S,\-\ ]\VW\ZTZZqD W1 , II ab\WTbbT /\ ZD 1D `1gTqE ]`1/ab*,O W1Z* ]Gqb\p -\W\,\p /SV\-\ 4,T`*E Z*]*W* Z* \3Sf aWd3Sb1WT,D ZbTO \f IVE \/SZ 4T a]*/V\2YgT, ]\/TW1Z\^ TY]1`T^ W1Va*Z/`*E a]\`d/S, ]\-*ZO anVSy ,T,b*` Z* b1`Sb\`T^ `da*WSYO anV\-\ f`*YdE * bSfE fb\ a]\,T/d,*, p/* ^4YE ,,*3*, 4W\hSZgqYS T V*`*, aY1`bpD *aTZZq *b*ZSE qV1 Z1Z*O ,S/TW\ \3Sy Z*`\/E 4Z\,d 4*,/*W\ y\Yd d/*`dD * Z1,/\,4T `1gTq ]\O abd]SW*aq a,\^Y YTag1Y TZjTy a,Tb\O ,Ty /1`3*,TD )Vd /1`3*,d 4\+`*3*2 j\ab* -\W\,* /SV\-\ 4,T`*H w " • ı ı˛ •x

P " 5;

\WS ı,*Z \b`SY*, ,S/TZZq ]`\ /SV\-\ 4,T`*E d a,TbT ]*Zd,*W* SYO anV* TY]1`Tq L +Gq,D 5;B5>MD q j\aO b* -\W\,* ,T/T-`*W* VWph\,d `\Wn d a]\,Z1ZZT ]`\`\gb,*E 4*]Sa*Z\-\ , dbbq 7B59D *b*Z* aV\`Sab*,aq `SYanVSYS d`q/\,gqYSE k\+ 4*,/*O bS jV\/S Z*aTZZp 3TZVSD SYWqO ZS Z1a]`*,1/WS,\ 4,SZd,*bSWS ıadO a* , b\YdE k\ ,TZ ]T/+d`p,*, Z*`\/ /\ ]\,ab*ZZqE T ab`*bSWS y\-\ L *b,D 6;B6:MD ˙Sq,\WE b*V +S Y\,SbSE ,3*O WS, Z*aTZZq , ]GqbdD ,bTYE gq `*O Z* Z14*+*`\Y +dW* 4*-\2Z*E +\ -\,* ,\aV`1aS, ıada*D 5:D #\ 4`\+S, ZbT\f IVH 5;D )V j\ab* -\W\,* 4,T`* ,T/T-`*W* VWph\O ,d `\Wn d a]\,Z1ZZT ]`\`\gb,*E 4*]Sa*Z\-\ , dbbq 7B59H

59 ˚ ) 6>56

5<

aVTWnVS p/1yanVT `1WT-TyZT ]`\O ,T/ZSVS 4Y\,SWSaq 4 `SYWqZ*YS ]`\bS ıada*E * +TWnjTabn T4`*^WnbqZ ,T/VSZdW* y\-\E -\,* ]1`1ab*, ,,*O 3*bS ^f a,\^Y Z*`\/\Y L *b,D 67B7<C ˙T^ 6B66E 67MD \- \+`*, a\+T Z\,Sy Z*O `\/E wı4`*^Wn \3Syx L *WD 7B6:P6=C :B5:MD SY Z*`\/\Y ab*, 4+T` ]\Y*O 4*ZgT,E a1`1/ qVSf +dWS T 2,`1^E T Wp/S 4 TZjSf Z*`\/T, L˚eD 6B55P5<MD *O aTZZq 4YTq ]`\/\,3d,*W\ ,\`\-d,*bS 4 Z*aTZZqY 3TZVS Z*,Tbn ]TaWq aY1`bT b* ,\aV`1aTZZq ıada*D SYWqZS Z1 `*4 Z*Y*-*WSaq 4ZSkSbS f`SabSqZanVSy 4+T`E /`d-\`q/Zd h*abSZd Z*aTZZq1D 5= aZTE qVSy ˙*ZS^W ]\qaZS, *,dO f\/\Z\a\`dE SY 4\+`*31ZSy Z\-*YS 4 4*WT4* L˙*ZD 6B77MD ˙\ b\-\ 3 ˙*ZS^W \b`SY*, ,S/TZZqE , qV\Yd ]\+*hS, SYanVd TY]1`Tp T Z*abd]Zd a,Tb\,d /1`3*,dE k\ Y*W* 4 Z1^ ,SybSD L `\O hSb*yb1 ˙*ZS^W* ;B;E <MD b\WTbO bqYS SY +d, /Wq a,\^f ,\`\-T, Z*O h1 wab`*jZSy T -`T4ZSyE b* Z*/YT`Z\ YTgZSyx 4,T`D W1 ]`\`\gb,\ ]1`1/`TO V*W\E k\ 4 gT2^ TY]1`T^ ,S`\abdbn w/1O aqbn `\-T,x T YT3 ZSYS 4-\/\Y ,S`\ab1 k1 \/SZE Y*WSyE qVSy ]T/Z1a1bnaq Z*/ TZjSYSD #\ aSY,\WT4dpbn gT /1O aqbn `\-T,E * b*V\3 Y*WSy `T-H )V* h*abSZ* +\,,*Z* 4T aZd *,df\/\Z\O a\`* ,T/]\,T/*2 Y*W\Yd `\-dH Z*O abd]ZTy ab*bbT /Wq ,S,h1ZZq YS 4Z*yO /1Y\ ,T/]\,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZqD 1 ;> `\gT ZD 1D `SYWqZS 4`dyZd,*WS `dO a*WSYD * b\y h*a +dV,*WnZT T4`* ^WnbqZS ,31 Z1 +dWS ,S+`*ZSY \3SY Z*`\/\YD \Yd 4ZSO k1ZZq `da*WSY* Z1 Y\3Z* ,,*3*bS Z*]*/\Y Z* Z*aTZZq 3TZVS b* a]\,Z1ZZqY ]`\`\gb,* 4 dbbq 7B59D

5<D *M )VSy Z\,Sy Z*`\/ \+`*, a\+T -\,* T h\YdH +M )V Z*aTZZq 4YTq ]`\/\,3d,*W\ ,\`\-d,*bS 4 Z*aTZZqY 3TZVSH 5=D *M )V ˙*ZS^W \]Sa*, j\abd a,Tb\,d /1`O 3*,dH +M #\ YS `\4-WqZ1Y\ , Z*abd]ZTy ab*bbT /Wq ,S,h1ZZqH

55

Äą Äą Äą ) Ëš Äą

˛Tab*,S,jS ]`\`\gb,* 4 +T+WTyZSf VZS- ˙*ZS^W* ‚ T +Gq,W1ZZqE YS /T4Z*2Y\anE qVT ,TaTY g*`T, Y*WS 4Gq,WqbSaq Z* a,Tb\,Ty *`1ZT T , qV\Yd ]\`q/VdD S hTbV\ 4`\4dYT2Y\ gT ]`\`\gb,*E qVk\ ,T4nY1Y\ /\ d,*-S Z*y]1`j1 ]`\`\gb,\E 4*]Sa*Z1 , T+WT^D

Ë› Ë™ Äą

5D -S]1b

6D aaS`Tq

1WSVSy +\,,*Z LË™*ZD 6B75P89M

\bS`S 4,T`TE k\ ,Sf\/qbn 4 Y\`q LË™*ZD ;B7P<E 5;E 69M

*`*Z T V\41W LË™*ZDE `\4/D <M

7D *,SW\Z

8D T/\O 1`aTq

9D `1gTq

:D SY

;D Z-W\O Y1`SO V*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,*1 <D T-* *gTy T

1

56

Photo credits: Egypt and Rome: Photograph taken by ´ courtesy of the British Museum; Medo-Persia: Musee du Louvre, Paris

1 +S/,T TaZdpbn d h*a VTZgqD L˙S,Tbnaq ab*bbp Z* aD 5=MD

]`\/\,3 Tab\`T^ ˙Sq,\W \+G2/O Zd,*, a,\2 Z*aTZZqE db,\`pphS `T4Z\Y*ZTbZT ]\WTbShZT aSab1O YS T g*`ab,* L dVS 8B9E :MD /O Z*V bTWnVS /1qVT d`q/S Y*WS *+\ Y*pbn +14]\a1`1/ZTy ,]WS,

Z* \3Sy Z*`\/ P Z* ı4`* ^Wn hS Z* 4+T` ]\Y*4*ZSf f`SabSqZD *VSf /1`3*, +dW\ WSj1 ,TaTYE T ,aT ,\ZS 4\+`*3*pbnaq d ,SO /TZZqf ˙*ZS^W* b* ı,*Z*D

˛ G) ˚

)

˝ • ˙ 6>>> /\ ZD 1D

,`**Y

59>>

ı4`*^WnanVSy Z*`\/

˙SVSy 4,T`E k\ Y*2 aTY -\WT, L +Gq,D 57B5P5>E 5:P5<M

5>>>

˙*ZS^W

9>>

/\ ZD 1DNZD 1D

ı,*Z ı4`*^Wn \3Sy

˙,\`\-Sy 4,T`E qVSy a]\ZdVd2 Wp/1y 4`\+SbS \+`*4 /SV\-\ 4,T`* L +Gq,D 57B55P59M

9>>

5>>>

59>>

6>>> ZD 1D

) ) E w# ˚˛

ı˙ )x w +Gq,W1ZZqE ]1`1/*Z1 ıada\Y `Sab\YE qV1 /*, y\Yd \-E *+S ,SO ‹ q,SbS y\-\ `*+*YE k \ Z14*+*`\Y Y*2 ,T/+dO bSaq x L G) D 5B5MD ) ı˙ ı H

)VT h*abSZS ,1WSV\-\ +\,,*Z* aSY,\WT4dpbn Z-W\O Y1`SO V*ZanVd a,Tb\,d /1`3*,dH

˙*ZS^W* b* ı,*Z* /\]\Y*-*pbn Z*Y 4`\4dYTbS 4Z*h1ZZq +*-*bn\f adh*aO ‹ ZSf T Y*y+dbZTf ]\/TyD #\ YS /T4Z*2Y\anE ]\`T,Zq,jS /SV\-\ 4,T`* 4 ı,*Z\,\-\ ,S/TZZqE ab`*jZ\-\ 4,T`* 4 /1aqbnY* `\-*YSE qV\-\ +*hS, d ,S/TZZT ˙*ZS^WE b* ,1WSV\-\ +\,,*Z* 4T aZd *,dO f\/\Z\a\`*H ˙\ h\-\ Z*a Y*2 a]\ZdVd,*bS hTbV1 `\4dYTZZq gSf ]`\`\gb,H

6 ]\h*bVd ]\-\,\`TY\ ]`\ /SV\-\ 4,T`*E qV\-\ ı,*Z ]\+*hS, d ,S/TZZT L +Gq,DE `\4/D 57MD )V YS /\O ,T/*WSaq 4 ]\]1`1/Zn\^ ab*bbTE ]1`jT jTabn -\WT, 4,T`* aSY,\WT4dpbn -S]1bE aaS`TpE *,SW\ZE TO /\O 1`aTpE `1gTp T SYD aT gT /1`3*,S ,\`\31 ab*,SWSaq /\ Z*aTZZq 3TZVS L dbD 7B59MD SYE j\aO b* -\W\,*E 4*WSj*,aq ]*ZT,Z\p ]\WTbShZ\p aSO W\p ,]`\/\,3 ab\WTbn ]TaWq b\-\E qV ı,*Z 4*]Sa*, a,\2 ,S/TZZqD W1 4`1jb\p SY Y*, ]\abd]SbSaq YTag1Y an\YTy -\W\,TD #\ g1 4* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* T qV ,\Z* +d/1 ]\,\/SbSaq 4 Z*aTZZqY 3TZVSH

ı) ı " ( & 7

)V ı,*Z \]Sad2 4,Gq4\V YT3 Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV\p a,Tb\,\p /1`3*,\p T `-*ZTO 4*gT2p +G2/Z*ZSf *gTyH

)Vd /1`3*,d 4\+`*3*2 an\Y* -\W\,* /SV\-\ 4,T`*E 4-*/*Z\-\ , 57OYd `\4/TWT VZS-S +Gq,W1ZO ZqH S Y\31Y\ g1 ,S4Z*hSbSE qVk\ ]\`T,Zq2Y\ /SV\-\ 4,T`*E qV\-\ +*hS, ı,*ZE 4T ab`*jZSY /1aqO bS`\-SY 4,T`\Y 4 ˙*ZS^W\,\-\ ,S/TZZq1D L `\hSO b*yb1 ˙*ZS^W* ;B;E <E 67E 68MD ˛,T`E qV\-\ \]SO ad2 ˙*ZS^WE aSY,\WT4d2 SYanVd a,Tb\,d /1`3*,dD 1 T+WT^ hSaW\ /1aqbn h*ab\ aSY,\WT4d2 ]\,Z\bdC d gn\Yd ,S]*/Vd ,\Z\ ,V*4d2 Z* ]\,Zd VTWnVTabn g*`ab,E qVT db,\`SO WSaq 4 SYanV\^ TY]1`T^D

)V ˙*ZS^W b* ı,*Z 4Y*Wn\,dO pbn VTZ1gn Wp/anVSf d`q/T,H

5E 6D *M #\ YS `\4dYT2Y\ 4*,/qVS ]`\`\gb,*Y ˙*ZS^W* b* ı,*Z*H +M )VT /1`3*,S aSY,\WT4dpbn ]1`jT jTabn -\WT, /SV\-\ 4,T`*H 7D #\ ]`1/ab*,Wqpbn ab`*jZSy /1aqbS`\-Sy 4,T` T y\-\ `\-SH

58

L˙S,Tbnaq af1Yd Z* aD 56E 57MD V ab\O WTbbT ZD 1D SYanV* TY]1`Tq ]\h*W* `\4O ]*/*bSanD ˙1aqbn `\-T,E k\ ,S`\aWS Z* -\W\,T -`T4Z\-\ 4,T`*E ]`1/ab*,WqO pbn /1`3*,SE qVT db,\`SWSaq 4 gT2^ TYO ]1`T^D 8

-`T4Z\-\ 4,T`*E qV\-\ ]\+*hS, ˙*O ZS^WE \V`TY /1aqbS `\-T, ,S`Ta wTZjSyE Y*WSyx `T-E * b`S 4 ]\]1`1/ZTf +dO WS ,S`,*ZTD )V g1 a]\,ZSW\anH `SO b*ZTqE qV* V\WSan Z*W13*W* SYanO VTy TY]1`T^E ]\h*W* Z*+S`*bS aSWSD ˙\ XVII ab\WTbbq `Sb*ZTq +dW* ,T/Z\aZ\ Z14Z*hZ\p /1`3*,\pD `S TZjT /1`3*O ,S P ıa]*ZTqE T/1`W*Z/S T `*ZgTqE b1`Sb\`Tq qVSf `*ZTj1 ,f\/SW* /\ ,\O W\/TZn SYanV\^ TY]1`T^E Y*WS 4Z*hZ\ +TWnjSy ,]WS,D `Sb*ZTq \/Zd 4* \/O Z\p 4*,\p,*W* gT V`* ^ZSE 4YTgZpphS a,\^ ]\4SgT^D a1`1/SZT XVIII ab\WTbbq `Sb*ZTq ]\h*W* ,Sf\/SbS Z* a,Tb\,d *`1Zd qV /\YTZdph* /1`3*,*D W1 Z* b\y h*a ,\Z* k1 Z1 ab*W* an\Y\p -\W\O ,\p /SV\-\ 4,T`*D 9

\h* `Sb*ZTq 4/\+d,*W* /1/*O WT +TWnj1 ,W*/SE ]T,ZThZ\*Y1`SV*ZanO VT V\W\ZT^ ,T/V\W\WSan ,T/ Z1^D a1 3 gq TY]1`Tq Z1 ]1`1jV\/3*W* ]\WdO h1ZSY "b*b*Y Y1`SVS ab*bS ]\O bd3Z\p /1`3*,\p T Z*,Tbn Z*/*,*W* ^Y /\]\Y\-d a,\^Y ,TyanV\,\OY\`anVSY eW\b\YD 5=58 `\gTE V\WS ]\h*,aq \a]\/ZTy /1ZnE `Sb*ZTq +dW* Z*yY\O -dbZTj\p TY]1`T2p , Tab\`T^ Wp/ab,*E * " P Z*y]\bd3ZTj\p TZ/dab`TO *WnZ\p /1`3*,\p Z* 41YWT1D ]`\/\,3 1 +S/,T V`* ^ZSE qVT 4-\/\Y db,\`SWS ]\/,TyO Zd a,Tb\,d /1`3*,dE TaZd,*WS k1 d XVIII ab\WTbO bTD /Z*V ı,*Z 4*4Z*hS,E k\ Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZO anV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* Y*W* ]\ab*bS Z* ]\h*bVd \a]\/Zn\-\ /ZqD S/TZZqE qVT ,TZ 4*]Sa*, d VZS4T +Gq,W1ZZqE a]\,Zppbnaq w, \a]\/ZTy /1Znx L +Gq,D 5B5>MD T/ h*a 1`j\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyO ZS " T 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTq ]\h*WS bTaZ\ a]T,O ]`*gp,*bS qV \+G2/Z*Z* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,*D

8E 9D *M #\ 4`\+S, Y*WSy `T-H +M #\ 4\+O `*3*2 an\Y* -\W\,* /SV\-\ 4,T`*H

59 ˚ ) 6>56

1`j\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyZS " `\4,SZdWS ]*`bZ1`ab,\ 4 1WSV\+`Sb*ZT2pD *V 4Gq,SW*aq an\Y* -\W\,* 4,T`* P Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,*D )V gq -\W\,* ab*,SW*an /\ Z*aTZZq 3TZVSH :

* ]\h*bVd \a]\/Zn\-\ /Zq an\O Y* -\W\,* 4/TyaZSW* Z*]*/ Z* \O 3Sy Z*`\/ P \ab*Z\V `Sab\,Sf +`*O bT, L *b,D 69B8>MD ıada ,V*4*,E k\ ]T/ h*a y\-\ ]`SadbZ\abT \ab*Z\V Z*aTZO Zq 3TZVS +d/1 *VbS,Z\ /TqbS Z* 41YWT L *b,D 68B89P8;C *WD 7B6:P6=MD Z-O W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* ab*O W* ,\p,*bS 4T a,qbSYS L +Gq,D 57B7E ;MD `\bq-\Y 1`j\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyZS gq /1`3*,* dbSaV*W* \3Sy Z*`\/E 4*+\O `\ZqW* /1qVT ^fZT ]d+WTV*gT^ T d,Gq4ZSO W* ]`1/ab*,ZSVT, ,T`Z\-\ `*+*D n\Y* -\W\,* /SV\-\ 4,T`* Z* ]1,ZSy h*a Y*y31 4d]SZSW* ]`*gp ]`\]\,T/dO ,*ZZqE a,qbT +dWSE b*V +S Y\,SbSE ,+SO bTD -\,* ]1`1/+*hS, gp ]`S-\W\YjO WS,d ]\/Tp T ]\,T/\YS, ]`\ Z1^ ı,*Z\,TD `TY b\-\E \- ,T/V`S, *]\ab\WdE k\ /`d-\`q/Z* h*abSZ* Z*aTZZq ]\,1`O Z1bnaq /\ 3SbbqE b\+b\ ,T/Z\,Sbn /dO f\,Zd /TqWnZTabn L +Gq,D 55B7E ;P55MD dh*aZ* Tab\`Tq aWd3Sb1WT, -\,S ]T/O b,1`/3d2 gT e*VbSD O ˚ & ı ˙˚ ˝ ı ˛ • ˛ ı˛ ;

)V ]\,Gq4*ZT YT3 a\+\p an\Y* -\O W\,* /SV\-\ 4,T`* T ,1WSVSy +\,,*ZH bd]ZT ,1WSV\-\ +\,,*Z* ]`1/ab*,WqO pbn b1 a*Y1E k\ y an\Y* -\W\,* /SO V\-\ 4,T`*E * a*Y1 Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZO anVd a,Tb\,d /1`3*,dD `Sb*ZTq +1`1 a,Ty ]\h*b\V ,T/ SYanV\^ TY]1`T^E b\3 Y\3Z* aV*4*bSE k\ ]\Wdh1ZT "b*bS Y1`SVS b*V\3 ]\f\/qbn 4 gT2^ TY]1`T^D \Yd abd]ZT YTabqbn 4*WT4\D W1 ,\ZS :D )V an\Y* -\W\,* 4,T`* ab*,SW*an /\ \O 3\-\ Z*`\/dH ;D )V ]\,Gq4*ZT YT3 a\+\p an\Y* -\W\,* /SO V\-\ 4,T`* T ,1WSVSy +\,,*ZH

59

YTabqbn T -WSZdD L `\hSb*yb1 Ë™*ZS^O W* 6B85P87MD *a TaZd,*ZZq abT] 4 4*O WT4* T -WSZS 4+T-*2bnaq 4 h*a\YE V\O WS an\Y* -\W\,* L Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,*M ]\aT/*2 ,S/*bZ1 ab*O Z\,Sk1D \/T+Z\ qV 4*WT4\E 4YTj*Z1 4 -WSZ\pE 2 aW*+VTjSY 4* hSab1 4*WT4\E b*V Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`O 3*,* 2 aW*+VTj\p 4* /1`3*,dE 4 qV\^ ,\Z* ,SyjW*D \Yd Y\3Z* b*V aV*O 4*bSH <

n\Y* -\W\,* 4,T`* Z1 `*4 ,Sq,WqO W* ,W*abS,\abT 4*WT4*D `SYT`\YE ,\Z* /\,1W* a,\p YTgnE 4/\+d,jS ]1`1Y\-d , 1`jTy a,Tb\,Ty ,TyZTD T/ h*a Ë™`d-\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyZS 4*WT4\]\/T+Z* aSW* an\O Y\^ -\W\,S b13 +dW* \h1,S/Z\p1D TaWq gT2^ ,TyZS an\Y* -\W\,* T /*WT ,Sq,WqO W* 4*WT4Zd YTgnD ,bTYE ,T/ ]\h*bVd TaZd,*ZZq Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV\^ a,Tb\O ,\^ /1`3*,S 4*WT4\ 2 4YTj*ZSY 4 -WSO Z\pD =

Wd3Sb1WT -\,S /\,-Sy h*a ]`*-O ZdWS 4`\4dYTbSE k\ aSY,\WT4dpbn abd]ZT +\,,*Z*D Ë™*ZS^W* 6B85 abd]O ZT y ]*WngTE qVT aVW*/*pbnaq 4 4*WT4* T -WSZSE 2 \/ZSY wg*`ab,\YxE * Z1 +*O -*bnY*D \Yd Y\3Z* aV*4*bSE k\ -WSZ* ]`1/ab*,Wq2 `T4ZT 1W1Y1ZbSE qVT Z*O W13*bn Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanVTy a,Tb\,Ty /1`3*,T T `\+Wqbn ^^ aW*+j\p 4* SYO anVd TY]1`TpE YTgZdE Y\, 4*WT4\D WSO Z\p Z*4,*Z1 wWp/anV1 Z*aTZZqxE b\+O b\ 4,Sh*yZT Wp/S LË™*ZD 6B87MD gTy /1`3*,T Wp/S ab*pbn Z* 4*fSab -`\O Y*/qZanVSf ]`*, T a,\+\/E db,\`ppbn ]`\ea]TWVS b* \`-*ZT4\,dpbn `dfS 4* Z14*W13ZTabnD `\abT Wp/S ]\aW*+O

Wppbn 4/*bZTabn Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV\^ a,Tb\,\^ /1`3*,S /TqbS 4 ]\/T+Z\p /\ 4*WT4* aSW\pD `TY b\-\E , ]\WTbShO ZSf V\W*f ]\jS`ppbnaq \]\4SgTyZT ]\-Wq/SD b`SYdphS Z* ,S+\`*f ]1O `1Y\-d 4 Z1,1WSV\p `T4ZSg1p -\W\O aT,E Z*,Tbn ]\]dWq`ZT WT/1`S Z1 Y*pbn /\ab*bZn\ ]\,Z\,*31ZnE k\+ ,]`\,*O /3d,*bS a,\p ]\WTbSVdD *Y1 g1 y ]1`1/`TV Ë™*ZS^WE aV*4*,jSE k\ wb1 g*`ab,\ +d/1 h*abV\,\ YTgZ1E * h*abV\O ,\ V`SfV1x LË™*ZD 6B86E \YDC 6 SYD 7B5P7MD XXI ab\WTbbT 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTq T " ]`\/\,3SWS bTaZ\ a]T,]`*gp,*O bSE /TphS a]TWnZ\ d ,S`Tj1ZZT +*-*O bn\f ]Sb*Zn a,Tb\,\-\ Y*ajb*+dD `\O `\gb,* ]`\ ,1WSV\-\ +\,,*Z* T /SV\-\ 4,T`* ]\V*4dpbnE k\ Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZO anV* /1`3*,* Z1 +d/1 4*YTZ1Z* TZj\p a,Tb\,\p /1`3*,\pD \]`S b1 k\ gq \ab*ZZq a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* aW*+j* 4* bdE qVd ]`1/ab*,Wqpbn 4*WT4ZT Z\-SE ,\Z* Z1 `\4]*/1bnaq a*Y* ]\ a\+TD 5>

55

1 Ë™*ZS^W ]1`1/+*hS,E qV1 3* fWS,1 a]dab\O j1ZZq g1y g*` a]`ShSZqbSY1 ,]`\/\,3 Ë™`dO -\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyZSE Z*]Sa*,jSB w TZ 4/TyaZSbn Z1+d,*W1 4ZSk1ZZqx LË™*ZD <B68E MD *]`SVO W*/E " aVSZdWS Z* a,\^f ,\`\-T, /,T *b\YZT +\Y+SD 1 +dW\ a]`*,/T Z1+d,*W1 4ZSk1ZZqD

hS Y*2 qV1an ]`\`\h1 4Z*h1ZZq VTWnVTabn ]*WngT, Z* Z\-*f +\,,*Z*H *`b\ ,4qbS /\ d,*-SE k\ , TZjSf ,SO /TZZqf Ë™*ZS^W 4-*/d2 V\ZV`1bZT hSaO W*E aV*3TY\E VTWnVTabn `\-T, Z* -\W\,*f `T4ZSf 4,T`T,D T hSaW* Y*pbn ,*-\Y1 4Z*h1ZZqD /Z*VE \]SadphS +\,,*Z*E Ë™*ZS^W Z1 Z*,\/Sbn VTWnV\abT ]*WnO gT, Z* Z\-*fD \3E \h1,S/Z\E g1 hSaW\ Z1 Y*2 4Z*h1ZZqE qV Z1 Y*2 4Z*h1ZZq VTWnVTabn `dV T ]*WngT, Z* ZSf b* VTWnO VTabn ZT- T ab\]D W1 Ë™*ZS^W 4*4Z*hS,E k\ ]*WngT Z* Z\-*f +\,,*Z* 4`\+W1ZT 4 4*WT4* T -WSZSD Ë› gn\-\ Y\3Z* 4`\O +SbS ,SaZ\,\VE k\ a*Y1 Z-W\O Y1`SO V*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* +d/1 ]*ZT,O Z\p ]\WTbShZ\p aSW\pE V\WS wV*YTZnxE qVSy aSY,\WT4d2 \31 *`ab,\E ,/*O `Sbn d ab\]S +\,,*Z* LË™*ZD 6B89MD

<E =D *M )V an\Y* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* ,Sq,WqO W* 4*WT4Zd YTgnH +M #\ ]`1/ab*,Wq2 -WSZ* d abd]Zqf +\,,*Z*H

5>E 55D *M #\ ab*Z1bnaq 4T ab\]*YS +\,O ,*Z*H +M #\ Y\3Z* aV*4*bS ]`\ VTWnVTabn ]*WngT, Z* Z\-*f +\,,*Z*H

5:

# ˛

ı w ı ı xH

`\`\gb,\ 4 ˙*ZS^W* 6B88 4*4Z*h*2E k\ \31 *`abO ,\ w]\b\,h1 y ]\VTZhSbn daT bT g*`ab,*xD gn\Yd ]`\`\gbO ,T y/1bnaq WSj1 ]`\ bT g*`ab,*E qVT ]`1/ab*,W1ZT `T4ZSYS h*aO bSZ*YS +\,,*Z*D

k\ aV*4*bS ]`\ ,aT TZjT Wp/anVT d`q/SH *`*W1WnZ1 ]`\`\gb,\ 4 VZS-S +Gq,W1ZZq ,T/V`S,*2 Z*Y jS`jd V*`bSO ZdD \Z\ ]\V*4d2E k\ wg*`T daTO 2^ Z*a1W1Z\^ 41YWTx 4+1`dbnaq ]`\bS -\,S wd ,1WSVSy /1Zn

O ˚ ı ˙ • ˙ • ˛ ı

56

\h* Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* 4\+`*3*2bnaq qV adYTj 4*WTO 4* T -WSZSE ,S/TZZqE qV1 ıada /*, ı,*Z\O ,TE ]\V*4d2E k\ , \ab*ZZT /ZT gq /1`3*O ,* ,T/T-`*,*bSY1 ,*3WS,d `\WnD )Vd a*Y1H ı,*Z ]\+*hS, /SV\-\ 4,T`*E V\bO `Sy Y*, /,* `\-S T -\,\`S, qV /`*O V\ZD #\ g1y /S,ZSy 4,T` aSY,\WT4d2H Zn\-\ /,* `\-SE b\Yd ,TZ aSY,\WT4d2 ]\/,TyZd /1`3*,dD ı,*Z 4Z\,d +*hSbn Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanVd a,Tb\,d /1`3*,dE ]`\b1 , \a\+WS,Ty `\WTD L `\hSb*yb1 +Gq,W1ZZq 57B55P59MD

/SV\-\ 4,T`* ]\ab*Z1 4Z\,dD *V T ab*O W\aq P ,SZSVW* `-*ZT4*gTq +G2/Z*O ZSf *gTy L +Gq,D 5;B<MD 58

ı,*Z V*31E k\ \+`*4 /SV\-\ 4,T`* 2 w,\anYSYx g*`1YD qV\Yd `\4dYTZZTH TZ 4\+`*31ZSy Z1 qV ,\anY* -\W\O ,* 4,T`*E * WSj1 qV y\-\ \+`*4D W*O /d gn\Yd \+`*4\,T /*pbn Z*`\/SE V\bO `T ,f\/qbn /\ aVW*/d E \a\+WS,\ Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* L +Gq,D 5;B5>E 55MD ı,*Z Z*4S,*2 \+`*4 4,T`* wg*`1YxE +\ ,TZ \b`SY*, Z1*+SqVd ,W*/dE k\+ Tab\bZ\ ,]WSZdbS Z* fT/ ]\/Ty d a,TbTD ˛ ˙ ˛ ı ˛ # ı(

57

˙,\`\-Sy 4,T` a]\ZdVd2 Wp/1y 4`\+SbS \+`*4 /SV\-\ 4,T`*E 4-*/*Z\-\ , +Gq,W1ZZq 57B5D ı,*Z Z*]Sa*,E k\ \+`*4 4,T`* 4Gq,SbnaqE 4ZSVZ1E * ]\O bTY 4Z\,d 4Gq,SbnaqD *Y1 g1 ,T/+dW\O aq 4 \`-*ZT4*gT2pE ,SZSVZ1ZZp qV\^ a]`SqWS 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTq b* " D ı^ Y1b* ]\Wq-*W* , b\YdE k\+ \+G2/Z*bS T ]`1/ab*,WqbS V`* ^ZS a,Tbd1D q \`-*O ZT4*gTqE ,T/\Y* qV T-* *gTyE +dW* db,\`1Z* ]TaWq 1`j\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyZSD /Z*V Z* ]\h*bVd ˙`d-\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyO ZS ,\Z* `\4]*W*aqD `\bq-\Y ,TyZS \3Sy Z*`\/ ]`\-\W\jd,*,E k\E 4-T/O Z\ 4 ]`\`\gb,\Y +Gq,W1ZZqE \+`*4 1 ˙S,Tbnaq VZS3Vd w +Gq,W1ZZqD •\-\ ,1WShO ZSy *]\-1y ,31 +WS4nV\IxE aD 68>E 685E 697D

56E 57D #\ aSY,\WT4d2 /,\`\-Sy 4,T` T k\ ,TZ `\+SbnH

59 ˚ ) 6>56

\-* a1Y\-dbZn\-\x L +Gq,D 5:B58C 5=B5=P65MD \3 , `O Y*-1//\ZT +d/dbn 4ZSk1ZT Z1 WSj1 g*`ab,*E ]`1/ab*,W1ZT +\,,*Z\YE * y daT TZjT Wp/anVT d`q/SD

59 ˛* aW\,*YS ı,*Z*E aSY,\WThZ* ]\O ,Tq ^/1 ,1`fS Z* +*-`qZ\Yd /SV\Yd 4,T`\,TE qVSy 2 \+`*4\Y /SV\-\ 4,T`*E T V1`d2 ZSYD ı^ TYGq P w *,SW\Z 1WSO VSyx L +Gq,D 5;B5P:MD q ]\,Tq /\`1hO Z\ ]`1/ab*,Wq2 ,aT e*WnjS,T `1WTO -T^E -\W\,Z\ g1`V,S 4*-*WnZ\,S4Z*Z\-\ f`SabSqZab,*D 1WT-TyZT \`-*ZT4*gT^ ,T/V`Sb\ ]T/b`SYdpbn \+`*4 /SV\-\ 4,T`* T a]`*,Wqpbn Z* Zn\-\ ,]WS,D 5:

,S/TZZT *,SW\Z 1WSVSy aSO /Sbn Z* ,\/*fE k\ aSY,\WT4dpbn y\O -\ ]`SfSWnZSVT,D /Z*V d \a]\/ZTy /1Zn gT ,\/S ,SaSf*pbn L +Gq,D 5:B56C 58D qV\Yd `\4dYTZZT \+`*4 /SV\-\ 4,T`* 2 w,\anYSYx g*`1YH 59E 5:D \-\ aSY,\WT4d2 ]\,Tq T k\ ,T/+d,*O 2bnaq 4 Z1pH

5;

5;B59MD *]`SVW*/E V\WS \+`*4 /SV\-\ 4,T`* bTWnVS 4Gq,S,aqE g1`V,S 4*-*WnO Z\,S4Z*Z\-\ f`SabSqZab,* P ,]WS,\O ,* h*abSZ* *,SW\Z* 1WSV\-\ P ]*O Zd,*WS , V`* ^Z*f ˛*f\/dD n\-\/ZT 3 g1`V,S b* ^fZT aWd3Sb1WT ,b`*h*pbn ]\,*-d T ]T/b`SYVd Y*aD *-*b\ Wp/1y ,,*3*2E k\ `1WT-Tq a]`Sq2 V\ZeWTVb*Y *+\ a]`ShSZq2 ^fD /Z1 ,\y\,ZSh\ Z*O W*jb\,*Z1 \+G2/Z*ZZq 4*fT/ZSf TZb1O W1Vbd*WT, *VbS,Z\ 4*VWSV*2 ada]TWnaO b,\ ]\`,*bS `1WT-TyZT ]db*D

b*ZSZanV\^ aSab1YSE ]`1/ab*,ZSV\Y qVSf 2 E Z*]*abS Z* e*WnjS,d `1O WT-TpD \ZS ]\VW*/dbn V`*y ^^ ,]WS,d T `\4-`*+dpbn ^^ +*-*bab,*D TWnV* /1O aqbSWTbn b\Yd b*V* ]\/Tq Y\-W* 4/*,*O bSaq Z1yY\,T`Z\pD W1 ZSZT ]\,Tq ,31 W1/,1 ,b`SYd2bnaq Z* a]SZT +*-`qZ\-\ 4,T`*D ˛T a,\-\ YTagq ,\Z* Z1 a]\,4*bSO Y1 ]\,\WTB ^^ ]*/TZZq +d/1 `*]b\,SY T 3*fWS,SY L +Gq,D 5<B;E <E 59P5=MD ˛ ı ˙ & ı ˚ &

TaWq 4ZSk1ZZq e*WnjS,\^ `1WTO -T^ /SVSy 4,T`E 41YZSy ]\WTbShZSy dabO `Ty *b*ZSE +d/1 a]\ZdV*ZSy Z*]*aO bS Z* \31 *`ab,\D aVTWnVS Wp/anVT g*`T Z1 4Y\3dbn /\aq-bS Z1+*E a,Ty -ZT, ,\ZS ,SWWpbn Z* bSfE fb\ \+ab\O p2 \31 *`ab,\ Z* 41YWTD 1 ]`S4,1O /1 /\ Z1YSZdh\^ \3\^ +Sb,S L +Gq,D 5:B57P5:C 5;B56P58MD ˙1k\ ]`\ gp +Sb,d 4-*/d2 ˙*ZS^WD L `\hSb*yb1 ˙*ZS^W* 6B88MD ˙SVSy 4,T`E 4-*/*ZSy , +Gq,W1ZZq 57B5E y\-\ \+`*4 T /,\`\O -Sy /SVSy 4,T` +d/dbn 4ZSk1ZTD 5<

5;

bTYE e*WnjS,* `1WT-Tq Z1 ]`\ab\ 4ZSVZ1 a*Y* ]\ a\+TD \Z* y /*WT Y*O bSY1 ]\bd3Zd aSWd T Z*Y*-*bSY1bnaq ,]WS,*bS Z* g*`T,E k\+ bT hSZSWS ^^ ,\O WpD `\b1 Z1,/\,4T \- w/*abn ^Y /\ a1`gq 4/TyaZSbS y\-\ 4*/dYxD L `\hSO b*yb1 +Gq,W1ZZq 5;B5:E 5;MD -\O ,* a]\ZdV*2 ]\WTbShZT 1W1Y1ZbS a*O 5;D #\ Z1,/\,4T ab*Z1bnaq 4 e*WnjS,\p `1WT-T2p T h\YdH

5= S 3S,1Y\ d /ZT ]*Zd,*ZZq an\O Y\^ -\W\,SD 4,T`* +TWnj1 Z1 4Gq,Sbnaq 3\/Z\^ -\W\,SC ,TZ 4ZSVZ1 Z*4*,3/SD T/ h*a 4ZSk1ZZq e*WnjS,\^ `1WT-T^ Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* +d/1 ]*ZT,Z\p /1`3*,\pD `\`\gb,* ˙*ZS^W* b* ı,*Z* a]\,Zqpbnaq , Z*yO Y1ZjSf ]\/`\+SgqfD \3 Z1Y*2 adYZTO ,dE k\ Z14*+*`\Y ,T/+d/1bnaq Z*]*/ Z* e*WnjS,d `1WT-Tp T +Sb,* `Y*O -1//\ZD \- ,Sq,S, Z*Y g1 Z*]1`1/D S YS 4,1`b*2Y\ d,*-d Z* ]`\`\hT 4*O ab1`131ZZqH L6 1bD 5B5=MD *Y1 b1]1` Z1\+fT/Z\ ab*bS Z* +TV -\,S T `1,O Z\ ]T/b`SYd,*bS y\-\ *`ab,\ L +Gq,D 58B:E ;MD

5<D *M #\ 4`\+Sbn /SVSy 4,T` T qVSY +d/1 `14dWnb*bH +M )VSY d`q/*YE 4-T/Z\ 4 ˙*ZS^O W* 6B88E \31 *`ab,\ ]\VW*/1 VTZ1gnH L˙SO ,Tbnaq ad]`\,T/Zd TZe\`Y*gTp Z* aD 5;MD 5=D h\Yd YS ,]1,Z1ZT T k\ ,*3WS,\ `\+SO bS b1]1`H

5<

\WS Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* /1`3*,* ab*W* an\Y\p a,Tb\,\p /1`3*,\pE ]`\ qVd 4-*/d2bnaq , +T+WTyZ\Yd ]`\`\gb,TH ˇ 1WSVSy +\,,*ZE qV\-\ *,df\/\Z\a\` ]\+*O hS, d,T aZTE Z1 aSY,\WT4d2 daT a,Tb\,T /1`3*,SE k\ TaZd,*WS ]`\bq-\Y Tab\`T^ Wp/ab,* L˙*ZD 6B75P89MD TZ 4\+`*3*2 WSj1 ]Gqbn /1`3*,E qVT Y*WS ]*Zd,*bS 4 h*aT, ˙*ZS^W* T a]`*,WqO bS +14]\a1`1/ZTy ,]WS, Z* \3Sy Z*`\/D ˛ b\-\E qV ˙*ZS^W ]\qaZS, a\Z ]`\ Y1b*W1,\O -\ +\,,*Z*E ,S/Z\E k\ Z-W\O Y1`SV*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* ]\ab*Z1 4 SYdE * Z1 4*,\p2 y\-\D ˙*ZS^W +*hSbnE k\ 4*WT4ZSYS 2 Z1 WSj1 Z\-SE * y abd]ZT b* ]*WngTD L#\]`*,/*E abd]ZT b* ]*WngT 4`\+W1ZT T4 4*WT4*E 4YTj*Z\-\ 4 -WSO Z\p1MD 1y \]Sa ,V*4d2 Z* b1E k\ Z-W\O Y1`SO V*ZanV* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* ,Sf\/SbSY1 T4 4*WT4O ZSf ZT-D ıab\`Tq ]T/b,1`/3d2 b\hZTabn gn\-\ \]SadD `Sb*ZTqE qV* V\WSan Z*W13*W* SYanO VTy TY]1`T^E , /`d-Ty ]\W\,SZT XVIII ab\WTbbq ]\h*W* 4/\+d,*bS YTgnD ˛-\/\Y T ]\Wdh1ZT "b*bS Y1`SVS ab*WS V`* ^Z\pE 4 qV\p b`1+* +dW\ `*fd,*bSanD /Z*V an\Y* a,Tb\,* /1`3*O ,*E ]`\ qVd 4-*/d2 +T+WTyZ1 ]`\`\gb,\E k1 Z1 ]\ab*W*D \YdH \Yd k\ bTWnVS ]T/ h*a 1`j\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyZS `Sb*ZTq T " ]\h*WS a]T,]`*gp,*bS \a\+O WS,SY hSZ\YD

bT /ZT waSZS g*`ab,*x *VbS,Z\ /TqWS 4/1O +TWnj\-\ d " C ^fZTy ,a1a,TbZTy g1Zb` `\4O b*j\,d,*,aq , `dVWTZT L npO•\`VM L *b,D 57B7:P87MD \Y*4*ZgT `1,Z\ ]`\]\,T/d,*WS , V`* ^Z*fE qVSYS V1`d,*W* `Sb*ZanV* TYO ]1`TqD ]`\/\,3 1`j\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyZS 1O WSV\+`Sb*ZTq T " \+G2/Z*WSaq , +\`\bn+T ]`\bS a]TWnZSf ]\WTbShZSf ,\`\-T,D * bWT 4`\ab*ph\-\ Z*gT\Z*WT4YdE ]\`\/31Z\-\ ,TyO Z\pE , \+\f /1`3*,*f ]\h*W\an ]1`1aWT/d,*ZO Zq Z*aTZZq \3\^ w3TZVSxD `q/S 4*+\`\ZqWS Z*jT ]d+WTV*gT^ T d,Gq4Zp,*WS bSfE fb\ +`*, ]`\,T/ d ]`\]\,T/ZSgnVTy ]`*gT L +Gq,D 56B5;MD \3 4 +T+WTyZ\-\ ]`\`\gb,* ,S/Z\E k\ an\Y* a,Tb\,* /1`3*,* Z1 4Gq,SW*an d /`d-Ty ]\W\,SO ZT XVIII ab\WTbbqE V\WS `Sb*ZTq ab*W* 4/\+dO ,*bS ]\bd-dD *b\YTabn g1 ,T/+dW\aq Z* ]\h*bO Vd \a]\/Zn\-\ /Zq1D 1 ıZe\`Y*gTq 4 gT2^ ab*bbT \Z\,Wp2 ]\qaZ1ZZqE ]\/*Z1 , VZS3gT w˙*ZS^W\,1 ]`\`\gb,\x Z* aD 9;E *+4D 68E * b*V\3 Z* af1Y*fE k\ YTabqbnaq Z* aD 9: T 57=D

1 ˛YTj*Z* 4 4*WT4\Y -WSZ* aSY,\WT4d2 1W1O Y1ZbSE qVT Z*W13*bn 4*WT4\]\/T+ZTy Z-O W\O Y1`SV*ZanVTy a,Tb\,Ty /1`3*,TD ˛ h*a\Y gq -WSZ* ]\aW*+SW* 4/*bZTabn gT2^ /1`3*,S 4/TyaZp,*bS Y\-dbZTy ,]WS,D

TaTY +`*bT, 4 da1a,TbZn\-\ g1Zb`d \,*`Sab,* w *`b\,* +*jb*xE qVSf d,Gq4ZSWS , h1`,ZT 5=5< `\Vd

59 ˚ ) 6>56

5=

˝ı ( ı˙ ı˙ ˙

˚ "˚ ı ˚ ˝ ı H w ab* Y\ ^ \]\,T/*bSO Ydbn ]`*,/d ,\pE ]`\ a]*aTZZq ,\2 P d,1an /1Zn x L D ;5B59MD ) ı˙ ı H

SY d 3SbbT V1`d,*WSaq \yE \ya1yE `1YTq T *,W\H

#\ /\]\Y\31 b\+T ]`*,SWnZ\ `\4]\`q/3*bSaq a,\^Y h*a\YH

˛ /d31 ,T/]\,T/*WnZSy V`\VE V\WS \f`1abS,aq T ab*, ]\aWT/\,ZSV\Y `Sab*D `Sa,qbS,jSan \-\,TE bS ]`SO yZq, Z*ya1`y\4ZTj1 `Tj1ZZqD S Z1Y\,+S aV*O 4*, \-dB w -\,\E q f\hdE k\+ bS +d, \a]\/*`1Y Y\-\ 3SbbqD ) b,Ty aWd3Sb1WnD \3 bS Y*2j ]`*,\ ,S4Z*h*bSE Z* k\ Y1ZT ,Sb`*h*bS h*aE qV `\4ab*,WqbS ]`T\`Sb1bS T qV ,SV\`Sab\,d,*bS a,\^ 4/T+Z\abT y Y*b1`T*WnZT 4*a\+SxD 6 )Vk\ bS \f`1k1ZSy aWd3Sb1Wn -\,SE b\ a*Y1 g1 bS ]\\+Tgq, y\YdD 1+1 ,*`b\ ]\f,*WSO bS 4* b*V1 Yd/`1 `Tj1ZZqD -\,* ab*, b,\^Y \aO ]\/*`1YD W1 qV b\+T b1]1` `\4]\`q/3*bSaq a,\^Y h*a\YH ˛Z*ybS ,T/]\,T/n Z* g1 4*]Sb*ZZq Z*Y /\]\Y\31 ]`SVW*/ \qE \ya1qE `1YT^ b* *]\ab\W* *,W*D \31Z 4 ZSf aWd3S, -\,T ,T/ dan\-\ a1`gqD ıfZT 3Sbb2,T \+ab*,SZS +dWS /dO 31 ]\/T+ZT /\ Z*jSfD \-\,\`TY\E qV gT h\W\O ,TVS `\4ab*,WqWS ]`T\`Sb1bS , 3SbbTE T ]`\O *Z*WT4dyY\E Z* k\ YS ,Sb`*h*2Y\ h*a L *b,D 6<B5=E 6>C 6 SYD 7B5MD

˝ ) ) ˚ ˚˙ 7

\Yd bS ,S`TjS, ab*,SbS aWd3TZZq -\,T Z* ]1`j1 YTag1 , 3SbbTH

ıada ]\`T,Zq, h*aS \q 4 Z*jSYSD w)V +dW\ 4* /ZT, \qE b*V +d/1 T ]T/ h*a ]`SadbZ\abT SO Z* Wp/anV\-\xEP aV*4*, ,TZD p/S w^WSE ]SWSE 31ZSWSaq y ,Sf\/SWS 4*YT3E *3 /\ /ZqE V\WS

\y d,Tyj\, d V\,h1-E T Z1 4,1`b*WS d,*-SE ]\VS Z1 ]`Syj\, ]\b\] b* Z1 4YT, ^f daTfx L *b,D 68B7;P7=MD TWnjTabn Wp/1y an\-\/ZT Z1 4,*O 3*pbn Z* b1E , qVSy \a\+WS,Sy h*a YS 3S,1Y\D 5E 6D *M #\ 4*a,T/hd2 Wp/SZ*E V\b`* ]`Sa,qhd2bnaq

-\,TH +M )VSy ]\3Sb\V YS ]\h1`]Z1Y\E `\4-WqZd,jS ]`SVW*/ \qE \ya1qE `1YT^ b* *]\ab\W* *,W*H 7D SY Z*jT /ZT ]\/T+ZT /\ /ZT, \qH

6>

\ZS Z1 4,1`b*pbn d,*-S Z* ]\]1`1O /31ZZq \3Sf aWd3Sb1WT,D *-*b\ fb\ Z*,Tbn ,SaYTp2 /dYVd ]`\ b1E k\ \- ,b`dbSbnaq , Wp/anVT a]`*,SD *V +dW\ T , /ZT \q L6 1bD 7B7P;MD )V 4* b*VSf \+ab*,SZ \y ,SV\`SaO b\,d,*, a,Ty h*aH 8

\- ]\,T/\YS, \pE k\ 4+S`*O 2bnaq 4ZSkSbS +14+\3ZSf Wp/1yE T /*, y\Yd ,*3WS,1 /\`dh1ZZqD

\y Y*, 4+d/d,*bS V\,h1-E k\+ 4+1O `1-bS 3Sbbq Wp/1y T b,*`SZ L dbD :B57E 58E 66MD `TY b\-\E ,TZ ]\O ,SZ1Z +d, ]`\-\W\jd,*bS Z1YSZdO hSy ]`Sad/ -\,SD ]\ab\W 1b`\ Z*4,*, \q w]`\]\,T/ZSV\Y ]`*,1/O Z\abTxE */31 b\y Z*Y*-*,aq /\]\O Y\-bS a,\^Y adh*aZSV*Y 4`\4dYTbSE Z*aVTWnVS a1`y\4Z* ^fZq aSbd*gTqD L `\hSb*yb1 6 1b`* 6B9MD SE Z* b,Ty ]\-Wq/E +dW\ + Yd/`\E qV+S \y T y\-\ aTYGq ]\,ZTabp ]\`SZdWS , /TO W\,T a]`*,SE k\+ 4*+14]1hSbS a\+T V\Ye\`bZ1 3Sbbq T 4/\+dbS ,Sa\V1 ‹ ab*Z\,Sk1H ˛,TaZ\E ZTD ˛Z*phSE k\ ^f h1V*2 ]\]1`1/dE ,\ZS Z*,`q/ hS ab*,SWS a\+T b*VT gTWTD

ı"˚

) ˚ & ˚ 9 1]1` 4-*/*yY\ ]`SVW*/ \ya1qD •\-\ daSZ\,SW* e*`*\Z\,* /\hV*E T ,TZ ,S`\ab*, , 2-S]1banV\Yd ]*W*O gTD \W\/\-\ g*`1,Sh* wZ*,hSWS ,aTO 2^ Yd/`\abT 2-S]bqZx L˙T^ ;B66C SO fT/ 6B=E 5>MD b`SY*,jS b*Vd \a,TbdE \ya1y YT- aWd3SbS ]`S /,\`T e*`*O \Z*D TZ Y*, Y\3WS,Tabn 3SbS , `\4O V\j*f T /\+SbSaq aW*,S , Z*yY\-dbO ZTjTy /1`3*,T b\-\ h*adD W1 hS ,a1 g1 +dW\ ,*3WS,SY /Wq \ya1qH

8D )V \y ,SV\`Sab\,d,*, a,Ty h*aE \b`SO Y*,jS /\`dh1ZZq ,T/ -\,SE T h\YdH 9E :D *M )VT Y\3WS,\abT /*,*W* \ya1p \a,Tb* ]`S /,\`T e*`*\Z*H +M \Yd \ya1y Z1 aV\`Sab*,aq b*VSYS Y\3WS,\abqYSH

59 ˚ ) 6>56

p/S Z1 4,*3*WS Z* ]1`1ab\`\-d \q

:

`*ZZT `\VS \ya1q ,Sf\,d,*WS y\-\ a]`*,3ZT +*bnVSE b\3 ,TZE TY\O ‹ ,T`Z\E 4Z*,E k\ -\,* ]\\+Tgq, ,O `**YdE ıa*Vd T )V\,dD \ya1y +d, b,1`/\ ]1`1V\Z*ZSyE k\ \3T \+TbO ZSgT a]\,ZqbnaqD TZE Y*+dbnE -WS+\O V\ `\4/dYd,*, ]`\ a,\2 Y*y+dbZ2 b* a,\^ ab\adZVS 4 -\,\pD \YdE V\O WS y\Yd /\,1W\an \+S`*bS YT3 3SbO bqY ]`S /,\`T e*`*\Z* T bq3VSY `*+ab,\YE ,TZ ,S+`*, \ab*ZZ2D \yO a1y f\bT, w`*/j1 4*4Z*,*bS 4Zdk*Zn 4 \3SY Z*`\/\YE ZT3 \b`SYd,*bS bSYh*a\,1 4*/\,\W1ZZq ,T/ -`Tf*xD L `\hSb*yb1 ,`1^, 55B68P6:MD T4ZTj1 ,TZ ]\aWdf*,aq ,V*4T,\V

-\,S ab\a\,Z\ b\-\E qV ,SV\`Sab\O ,d,*bS a,\2 3Sbbq L SfD 7B6E :P5>MD \ya1y 4`\+S, g1E \aVTWnVS /\,TO `q, \+TgqZV*Y -\,SD TZ 4Z*,E k\E 4*WSjS,jSan d -S]bTE Z1 Y*bSY1 Y*y+dbZn\-\D ı a]`*,/TE Z1,/\,4T \Z*,T, Z* -S]1b /1aqbn V*`D `SO a,qh1ZT aWd3Sb1WT -\,S Y\3dbn ]\O h1`]ZdbS 4 ]`SVW*/d \ya1q gTZO ZSy d`\VD *Y ,*`b\ 4\a1`1/3d,*bS a,\2 3Sbbq Z* ab\adZV*f 4 -\,\p

65

T aWd3TZZT y\YdE * Z1 -Z*bSaq 4* V*O `G2`\p b* a,TbanVSYS Z*a\W\/*YSD ˚ ı) ˛ E # ˚

• ˙ ; `\`\V `1YTq b13 ab*,S, aWdO 3TZZq \-\,T Z* ]1`j1 YTag1 , 3SbO bTD -\,* 4,1WT, `1YT^ ]`\-\W\jdO ,*bS 4,TabVd ]`\ ]`Sad/E ,SZ1a1ZSy ,T/abd]ZSgnVTy (/TD )V T YSE g1y ]`\`\V 3S, wZ*]`SVTZgT /ZT,x L `1YD 67B5=E 6>MD TZ /\+`1 4Z*,E k\ Z* p/1yanVd aSab1Yd h1V*2 4ZSk1ZZqD < )V Z* `1YTp ,]WS,*WS y\-\ ]1O `1V\Z*ZZqH TZ Z1 ]\,Gq4d,*, a,\-\ Y*y+dbZn\-\ 4 bT2p ]`S`1h1Z\p aSaO b1Y\pE +\ , gn\Yd Z1 +dW\ 3\/Z\-\ 4YTabdD W1 *`dfE ]Sa*` `1YT^E Z* qVSyan h*a ,b`*bS, ]`*,SWnZSy ]\O -Wq/ Z* \+ab*,SZSD \Yd \- Z*/SfO Zd, `1YTp aV*4*bS a,\2Yd ]Sa*`1O ,TB w an ) ]\`dyZdpE k\ ) 4+d/d,*,E * k\ ) Z*a*/S,E b1 ) ,S`,dE b*V\3 dap 41YWp ,\pD bS \an jdV*2j /Wq a1+1 ,1WSV\-\D 1 jdV*yE +\ \an ) Z*,1/d 4W\ Z* V\3Z1 bTW\DDD * b\+T /*Y /djd b,\p 4* 4/\+Sh Z* ,aTf bSf YTagqfE /1 bS +d/1j f\/SbSx L `1YD 89B8E 9MD = \hZ\ Z1 ,T/\Y\E hSY +dW\ b1 w,1WSV1xE qV\-\ jdV*, /Wq a1+1 *O `df1D /Z*V YS Y\31Y\ +dbS ,]1,Z1O ZTE k\ ,a1 g1 Z1 Y*W\ gTZZ\abTE */31 , :>; `\gT /\ ZD 1D ,*,SW\ZqZS 4*O ,\p,*WS `da*WSY T 4ZSkSWS y\-\D \-\ YS 4 gn\-\ ,hSY\aqH ˛,Sh*yO Z\E /Wq b\-\ k\+ 4*+14]1hSbS a1O +1 T a,\p aTYGpE YS aVW*/*2Y\ ]1,ZT ]W*ZS Z* Y*y+dbZ2 L `S]D :B:P55MD

1 ˙S,Tbnaq VZS3Vd w \- ]`\Y\,Wq2 /\ Z*a h1O `14 `1YTpxE aD 5>8P5>:D

;D SY aSbd*gTq `1YT^ ]\/T+Z* /\ Z*j\^H <E =D *M \Yd *`df\,T b`1+* +dW\ ,S]`*O ,SbS a,\2 YSaW1ZZqH +M `\ k\ aWT/ ]*YGqO b*bSE V\WS +d/d2Y\ ]W*ZS Z* Y*y+dbZ2H

66

* fT+* Yd/`\ ]`Sa,qhd,*bS d,1an a,Ty h*a T aSWS b\YdE k\ Z1 ]`SZ\O aSbn b`S,*W\^ V\`SabTH 1 ]`*,/*E k\ \`-*ZT4*gTq -\,S T /*WT ]W*Zd2 a]\`d/3d,*bS Z\,T ˛*WS *`ab,*E eTWT*WS b* TZjT b1\V`*bShZT \+G2VO bSD W1 b*VT ]W*ZS 2 /\`1hZSYSE +\ ]\,Gq4*ZT 4 ,SV\Z*ZZqY \3\^ ,\WTD aTY \f`1k1ZSY aWd3Sb1WqY -\,S b*V\3 aWT/ +d/d,*bS a,\2 3Sbbq /\,O V\W* b1\V`*bShZSf a]`*,D hS bS wjdV*2j Z*y]1`j1 g*`ab,* T \3\^ ]`*,1/Z\abTxH L *b,D :B77MD w ˝ ( ˚ ( ı )x 5>

*a*YVTZ1gn \+-\,\`TY\ ]`SO VW*/ *]\ab\W* *,W*D 1`1/ bSY qV *,W\ ab*, f`SabSqZSZ\YE ,TZ YT+*-*b\ h\-\ /\aq-ZdbS , 3SbbTD *,O W\ ,S,h*, p/1yanVSy 4*V\Z , \/Z\-\ 4 Z*y,S/*bZTjSf ,hSb1WT, a,\-\ h*O adD (/1yanVSy ]1`,\a,qk1ZSV /\,TO `q, y\Yd T /\`dhS, ]1,Z1 4*,/*ZZqD *,W\ 4`\+S, , p/* ^4YT +TWnjSy ]\O abd]E ZT3 TZjT 2,`1^ L˙T^ =B5E 6C 66B7C 6:B5>C *WD 5B57E 58MD W1 y\-\ 3Sbbq ]\,ZTabp 4YTZSW\aqE V\WS ,TZ da,T/\O YS,E k\ -\,* ,T/VSZd, p/1^, qV Z*O `\/D 55 *,W\ `\4dYT,E k\ y\-\ /\aq-O Z1ZZq , p/* ^4YT Z1 Y*WS 3\/Z\^ ,*-S /Wq -\,SE +\ ,TZ 4*ad/S, bd aSab1Yd L *b,D 68B6MD 1y V\WSjZTy e*`Sa1y ]T4Z*, \3T Z*YT`S T 4+*-O Zd,E Z*aVTWnVS gTZZSY 2 f`SabSqZO anV1 aWd3TZZqD 1E k\ V\WSan /Wq Zn\-\ +dW\ ,*3WS,SYE b1]1` ,TZ Z*O 4S,*, wVd]\p aYTbbqxD *,W\ ]\WSO jS, p/* ^4Y T ]`Sa,qbS, ]`\]\,T/dO ,*ZZp /\+`\^ Z\,SZS `1jbd a,\-\ 3Sbbq Z* 41YWTD L `\hSb*yb1 SO WS]GqZ 7B8P<E 59C ˙T^ =B59MD 5>E 55D *M * k\ *,W\ a]`qY\,d,*, a,\^ 4daSWWqE ]1`1/ bSY qV ab*, f`SabSqZSZ\YH +M \Yd *,W\,T gTWT /\V\`TZZ\ 4YTZSWSaqH

ı˛ • ı ı ˚ 56

\yE \ya1yE `1YTqE *,W\ b* TZjT ,T`ZT \-\,T Wp/S +*-*b\ h*ad T aSW ]`Sa,qhd,*WS aWd3TZZpD \ZS ]\/*WS Z*Y -*`ZSy ]`SVW*/D *yO +TWnj ,T//*ZSY aWd3Sb1W1Y -\,SE +14adYZT,Z\E 2 ıada L5 1b`* 6B65MD TaWq f`1k1ZZq ıada 4\a1`1/S, ,a1 a,\2 41YZ1 3Sbbq Z* b\YdE k\+ ]`\O ]\,T/d,*bS /\+`d Z\,SZd T Z1abS f,*Wd \-\,TD \Yd , 3SbbT V\3Z\O -\ f`SabSqZSZ*E qVSy ,S4Z*2 -\,d a,\^Y \a]\/*`1YE a]`*,S *`ab,* Y*pbn 4*yY*bS ]1`j1 YTag1D hS /Wq b1+1 aWd3TZZq \-\,T Z*y-\W\,O ZTj1H )V b\+T k1 ]\,ZTj\p YT`\p aWd3SbS -\,T T ,\/Z\h*a /+*bS ]`\ a,\^ \+\,Gq4VSH L `\hSb*yb1 a*O W\Y ;5B59C 589B6MD 57

31 `\V*YS \`-*ZT4*gTq -\,S 4*\f\hd2 f`SabSqZ 4 Y\WSb,\p \+O YT`Vd,*bS Y\3WS,Tabn aWd3SbS ]T\O Z1`\YD +ab*,SZS /1qVSf ,T`ZSf aWd3Sb1WT, Z1 /\4,\Wqpbn ]`S/TWqO bS ]`*gT ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZq , a1`1/O Zn\Yd ;> -\/SZ k\YTaqgqD *VSY f`SabSqZ*Y Z1 ,*`b\ 4Z1\f\hd,*O bSan L5 SYD 9B<MD qV aVW*/*pbnaq b,\^ \+ab*,SZSH S ,\ZS /TyaZ\ ]1O `1jV\/3*pbn b\+T aWd3SbS ]T\Z1O `\YH 58

\/dY*y ]`\ `*/TabnE qVd gn\-\ `\Vd ,T/hd,*W\ hSY*W\ \3Sf aWdO 3Sb1WT, d ]1`T\/ ]\YSZdD +1`14ZT /\]\YT3ZT ]T\Z1`S Y\-WS ,S+`*bSE aVTWnVS -\/SZ ]`\]\,T/d,*bS P 7> hS 9> L aD 55>B7MD ˛*,/qVS gn\Yd YTWny\ZS ,TaZSVT, aWd3SWS /\]\O YT3ZSYS ]T\Z1`*YSD 4+\`*f ]*ZdO 56D * h\Yd 4\a1`1/S,aq ıada ]TaWq f`1O k1ZZqH 57E 58D *M #\ f`SabSqZ*Y ,*`b\ \+YT`VdO ,*bSH +M ˛*,/qVS h\Yd \3T aWd3Sb1WT Y\O 3dbn ]\hd,*bSaq k*aWS,SYSH

59 ˚ ) 6>56

,*W\ Z*/4,Sh*yZ1 ]T/Z1a1ZZq y `*O /TabnD S bS YT- +S ,W*/Z*bS a,\^ a]`*,S b*VE k\+ h*abTj1 ,T/hd,*bS ]\/T+Zd `*/TabnH \WS f`SabSqZSZ aWd3Sbn ]T\Z1`\YE , VTZgT V\3Z\-\ /Zq ,TZ ]\hd,*2bnaq /d31 k*aWS,SY T Y\31 aV*4*bSB w -\,\E q 4`\+S, /Wq b1+1 ,a1E k\ +dW\ , Y\^f aSW*fxD 59

V*3TY\E bS 4*VTZhd2j jV\Wd T Y*2j /\+`1 4/\`\,Gq b* ,T/Z\aO Z\ Z1+*-*b\ \+\,Gq4VT,D \Yd + b\O +T Z1 ]\/dY*bS ]`\ b1E k\+ ,WSO bSaq , W*,S ab*WSf ]T\Z1`T,H 14 adYZT,dE ,hSb1WT 4 Z*yV`*kSf a]\O ZdV `*/qbn b\+T 4/\+dbS ,Skd \a,Tbd T ]\+d/d,*bS V*`G2`dD \ZS ]\VW*O /*pbn Z*/T^ Z* eTZ*Za\,d aSab1O Yd T Wp/anVT \`-*ZT4*gT^E qVT Z1 Y*O pbn Y*y+dbZn\-\D /Z*V qVk\ bS +d/1j ab*,SbS b1\V`*bShZT gTWTE b\ ,1abSY1j 4YTab\,Z1 3SbbqE qV1 ]`SO Z1a1 b\+T ,ThZT +W*-\aW\,1ZZqD `TY b\-\E bS Z*aWT/d,*bSY1j /\aV\Z*O WSy ]`SVW*/ ıada*D *V1 Yd/`1 `TO j1ZZq ]`SZ1a1 b\+T k*abq T /*abn 4*fSabD *V\3 bS ]\V*31jE k\ ,T/ dan\-\ a1`gq ]`*-Z1j 3SbS ,T/]\O ,T/Z\ /\ a,\-\ ]`Sa,qh1ZZq L *b,D :B5=P65C 5 SYD :B=P56MD 5:

1`T/V\ \3SY aWd3Sb1WqY /\O ,\/Sbnaq +*-*b\ -\/SZ ]`*gp,*bSE k\+ 4*+14]1hd,*bS \aZ\,ZT ]\b`1+S a,\^f aTY1yD W1 /1fb\ ]`Sa,qhd2 `\O +\bT Y*W\ Z1 ,1an a,Ty h*a L5 SYD :B<MD ,Tb V\Y1`gT^ ]\abTyZ\ ]1`1V\O Zd2 Z*aE k\ YS Z1 4Y\31Y\ ]`\O 3SbS +14 qV\^an b1fZThZ\^ Z\,SZVS hS TZj\-\ b\,*`dD a1 3 YS Z1 ]\O ,SZZT /\4,\WqbSE k\+ a,Tb *b*ZS Z*,Gq4d,*, Z*Y a,\^ gTZZ\abT L5 ı,D 59D )VT gTWT Y*pbn ab*,SbS a\+T Y\W\/T f`SabSqZSE V\b`T ,h*bnaq , jV\WTH 5:E 5;D )VT 4*]Sb*ZZq k\/\ aWd3TZZq -\O ,T Z*Y +dW\ + /\+`1 ]\ab*,SbS a\+TH

67

6B59P5;MD k\E V\WS bS ,31 ,SO yj\, Z* ]1ZaTpH *yV`*kSy a]\O aT+ ,SV\`Sab*bS h*aE qVSy d b1+1 4,TWnZS,aqEP g1 `\4]\h*bS ]T\Z1`O anV1 aWd3TZZqD *V bS 4*a,T/hSjE k\ ab*,Sj ]\VW\ZTZZq -\,T Z* ]1`O j1 YTag1 , 3SbbTD 5;

aTY ]`Sa,qh1ZSY aWd3Sb1WqY

-\,S ,*`b\ 4*]Sb*bS a1+1B w#\ /Wq Y1Z1 Z*y-\W\,ZTj1H S q jdV*p Z*y]1`j1 *`ab,*H S Z*aWT/dp a*O Y\31`b\,ZTabn ıada*H S ]`SaWdO ‹ f*pan /\ y\-\ ]\`*/S ]\abTyZ\ ybS

S bS V\WSan `\4/dYd,*, ]`\ aWd3TZZq ab*WSY ]T\Z1`\YH

4* ZSYH S Y\3d q 4YTZSbS a,Ty -`*O eTVE k\+ +TWnj1 h*ad ]`Sa,qhd,*bS ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZp b* TZjSY b1\V`*O bShZSY a]`*,*YH S q Z*Y*-*pan `\4,S,*bS ]T\Z1`anVSy /dfE Z*,Tbn qVk\ Y\^ \+ab*,SZS Z* /*ZSy Y\O Y1Zb Z1 /\4,\Wqpbn `\4jS`SbS aWdO 3TZZqHx w ı ˝

) E ı ˙ı) x 5<

*aVTWnVS 3 ]`S2YZ\ +*hSbSE 4 qV\p `1,ZTabp Z*`\/ -\,S hSO ZSbn y\-\ ,\WpI /Z*V /1qVT f`SaO bSqZSE Y*phS Y\3WS,Tabn aWd3SbS ]\,Z\h*aZ\E Z1 ,T/hd,*pbn +*3*ZZq +dbS ]T\Z1`*YSD +\ 3 ^Y 4/*2bnaqE k\ ,\ZS Z1/\ab*bZn\ 4/T+ZT /Wq gn\O -\ L SfD 8B5>C `1YD 5B:MD )Vk\ , b1+1 ,SZSV*pbn ]\/T+ZT ]\hdbbqE Y\WSan /\ -\,SD *,W\ aV*4*, a,\^Y \/Z\O ,T`gqYE k\ \-E w]`*-ZdhS ,SV\Z*bS a,\p /\+`d ,\WpE /T2 , ,*aE *+S ,S T +*3*ZZq Y*WSE T /TqWSx L SWD 6B57MD \3E qVk\ bS Z1 ,T/hd,*2j a]\ZdVS `\4jS`SbS aWd3TZZqE ]`\aS \-*E k\+ ,TZ /*, b\+T T +*3*ZZqE T 4/T+Z\aO bT L6 1bD 7B=E 55MD 5=

\yE \ya1yE `1YTqE *,W\ b* ıada +dWS ,T//*ZSYS aWd3Sb1WqYS

-\,SD \ZS ,SV\`Sab\,d,*WS a,Ty h*a T aSWSE k\+ ]`\-\W\jd,*bS \3T ]1`1ab\`\-SD T ]\VW\ZZSVS -\,S Z1 `\4]\`\jd,*WS a,\2^ d,*-S Z* Z1O adbb2,T a]`*,SD TZ1gn b1]1`TjZn\^ aSab1YS Z1YSZdhSyE b\Yd V\3Z\Yd 4 Z*aE fb\ ]`Sa,qbS, a,\2 3Sbbq \O -\,TE ]\b`T+Z\ y /*WT ,T/ dan\-\ a1`O gq Z*aWT/d,*bS ^fZTy ]`SVW*/ L *b,D 68B86C 6 SYD 6B59MD *V YS +d/1O Y\ /\-\/3*bS -\,T T ]\3Z1Y\ `qaZT +W*-\aW\,1ZZqD L `\hSb*yb1 *O W*fT^ 7B5>MD 5<E 5=D `\ k\ ,*`b\ Y\WSbSaq T h\Yd b*V1 ]`\f*ZZq ]\/\+*2bnaq -\,TH

59 ˚ ) 6>56

w (˙ DDD ˚ ı )

˙ x w `\`\gb,\ ZTV\WS Z1 4Gq,WqW\aq 4 ,\WT Wp/SZSE *W1 Wp/S -\,\`SWS ,T/ \-*E V1`\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\Y x L6 ˚ D 5B65MD ˛

) ˙ ) ˛˙ ı

)V \-E ]\aWd-\,dphSan a,qbSY /df\YE ]1`1/*,*, a,\p 4,TabVd ]SanY1ZZSV*Y T+WT^H

˛ ˙ ) 3SbbqH h\Yd y\-\ Y1b*H #\ Z*a h1V*2 , Y*y+dbZn\YdH \Yd d a,TO bT abTWnVS ab`*3/*ZnH #\ ab*2bnaq 4 Z*O YSE V\WS YS ]\YS`*2Y\H TWnjTabn Wp/1y ab*,O Wqbn a\+T b*VT 4*]Sb*ZZqD )V+S Z1 Z*bfZ1Z1 \31 W\,\E b\ YS Z1 /T4Z*WSaq + ,T/]\,T/T Z* ,aT gT b* TZjT ,*3WS,T 4*]Sb*ZZqD *jSY -\W\,ZSY ,hSO b1W1Y +d, +S WSj1 ,W*aZSy /\a,T/E T YS ZTV\WS Z1 Y*WS + b*VSf ]\hdbbT, /\ w \a]\/Zn\-\ ˛*V\ZdxE qV ]a*WY\a]T,1gnD L `\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 5=B<MD

)

6 * 3*WnE /1qVT f`SabSqZS ,b`*h*pbn ]1`jd Wp+\, /\ +T+WTyZ\^ ]`*,/SD L \`T,Zqyb1 +Gq,O W1ZZq 6B8MD \ZS +TWnj1 Z1 y/dbn bT2p /\`\-\pE qVd ,V*4d2 -\,* Lıa* ^ 7>B65MD W1 Z1 /\]daV*yY\E k\+ b*V1 ab*W\aq 4 Z*YSD *Y ]T/ aSWd 4+1`T-*bS ]\j*Zd /\ T+WT^ P +14gTZZ\-\ /*`d ,T/ Z*j\-\ Wp+Wqh\-\ ,\`gq L)VD 5B5;MD \4-WqZnY\E qV \ V1`d,*, ]SanY1ZZSV*YS T+WT^ ]T/ h*a ^ ^ Z*]SO a*ZZqE * b*V\3 /1qVT 4 hSaW1ZZSf /\V*4T, Z*O bfZ1Z\abT gT2^ VZS-SD 1 /\]\Y\31 Z*Y k1 +TWnj1 gTZd,*bS waW\,\ \-*xE 4*\f\bSbn Z*a k\/Zq hSO b*bS T+WTp T 4*ab\a\,d,*bS ^ ^ ]\`*/S L ,`D 8B56MD

) ˙ ˚ H

)VT 2 /\V*4S b\-\E k\ T+WTq Z*bfZ1Z* \-\YH

7

]`\/\,3 5:5> `\VT, L4 5957 `\Vd /\ ZD 1D /\ =< `\Vd ZD 1DM ]`S+WS4Z\ 8> h\W\,TVT, ]Sa*O WS T+WTpD ˙1qVT 4 ZSf /TqWS qV ]`\`\VSE wV1O `\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\YxD L `\hSb*yb1 6 1b`* 5B6>E 65MD `1gnV1 aW\,\E ]1`1VW*/1Z1 qV wV1`\O ,*ZTxE \4Z*h*2 wZ\aSbSE ]1`1Z\aSbSE d]`*,WqbSE

#\ bS Y\31j `\+SbS V\3Z\-\ /ZqE *+S ]\-WS+SbS a,\p ,/qhZTabn 4* \31 W\,\H

5D \Yd YS /d31 ]\b`1+d2Y\ Z*bfZ1Z\-\ \3\-\ W\,*H 6D #\ /\]\Y\31 Z*Y 4+1`T-*bS ]\j*Zd /\ T+WT^E +14gTZO Z\-\ /*`d ,T/ \-*H 7D qV\Yd `\4dYTZZT +T+WTyZT ]`\`\VS T ]SanY1ZZSVS +dWS wV1`\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\YxH

69

,b\`\Y WSab* ,,*3*2bnaq b\yE fb\ ab*,Sbn Z* Zn\Yd a,Ty ]T/]Sa

aV1`\,d,*bSE a]`SqbSx b\k\1D ˙T^ 6;B59 ,3Sb\ b1 a*Y1 aW\,\E V\WS 4-*/d2bnaq V\`*+1WnE qVSy ]T/f\]SO W\ T ]\Z1aW\ ,Tb`\Y d ]1,Z\Yd Z*O ]`qYVdD T+WTyZT ]`\`\VS T ]SanY1ZO ZSVS +dWS wV1`\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\Yx d b\Yd `\4dYTZZTE k\ \- a]TWVd,*,aq 4 ZSYSE a]\ZdVd,*, ^f T V1`d,*, ZSO YS 4* /\]\Y\-\p a,\2^ /Tph\^ aSWSD \3 ,\ZS 4*]Sad,*WS Z1 ,W*aZT T/1^E * \3T /dYVSD ıZV\WS gT h\W\,TVS ]T/ Z*bfZ1ZZqY \-* ]Sa*WS hS ]1`1/`TO V*WS b1E h\-\ a*YT Z*,Tbn Z1 `\4dYTWS L˙*ZD 56B<E =MD ˙TyaZ\E wda1 Sa*ZZq Z*bfZ1Z1 \-\Yx T Z1 YTabSbn Wp/anO VSf ]\-Wq/T, L6 SYD 7B5:MD 8

qV \- ]\aWd-\,d,*,aq a,qbSY /df\YE k\+ ]1`1/*,*bS a,\^ /dYVSH 1 w˙*,Z n\-`1gnV\O`\aTyanVSy a W\,ZSVx •D D ˙,\`1gnV\-\D

8P:D \qaZTbn Z* ]`SVW*/TE qV -\,* ]1O `1/*,*, 4,TabVd ]SanY1ZZSV*Y T+WT^D

6:

S ]SanY1ZZSVS \b`SYd,*WS 4,TabO Vd /\aWT,Z\E hS bTWnVS 4*-*WnZT T/1^E qVT ,\ZS 4*]Sad,*WS a,\^YS aW\,*O YSH T4nYTY\ /Wq ]`SVW*/d /S`1Vb\O `*E qVSy Y*2 Z*]Sa*bS WSab*D )Vk\ /Wq Zn\-\ ,*3WS,1 b\hZ1 e\`YdWpO ,*ZZqE b\ ,TZ ]Sj1 WSab* \a\+Sab\ *+\ /SVbd2 a1V`1b*`1,T aW\,\ , aW\O ,\D 1V`1b*` /`dVd2 b1VabE * /S`1Vb\` ab*,Sbn a,Ty ]T/]SaD TZjSf ,S]*/O V*f ,TZ ]1`1/*2 a,\p T/1p WSj1 , 4*O -*WnZSf b14*fD \/T a1V`1b*` aVW*/*2 WSabE ,SV\`Sab\,dphS ,W*aZSy abSWn b* W1VaSVdD \bTY /S`1Vb\` Y\31 ]1O `1,T`SbS WSab T ]\]`\aSbS a1V`1b*`q ,Z1abS Z1\+fT/ZT 4YTZSD *a*YVTZ1gn /S`1Vb\` ]T/]Sad2 WSab T gSY 4*a,T/O hd2E k\ a*Y1 ,TZ 2 *,b\`\YD 9 \/T+Z\ /1qVT h*abSZS T+WT^ +dWS w]Sa*ZT \3SY ]1`ab\Yx L SfD 75B5<MD ıZ\/T -\,* /SVbd,*, a,\p 4,TabVdE qVk\ b\hZ1 e\`YdWp,*ZZq Y*W\ /Wq Zn\-\ ,*3WS,1 4Z*h1ZZqD *]`SVW*/E d SfT/ 78B6; YS hSb*2Y\B w `\Y\,S, \a]\/n /\ \ya1qB r *]SjS a\+T aW\O ,*E +\ 4-T/Z\ 4 gSYS aW\,*YS aVW*, ) 4*]\,Tb* 4 b\+\p b* 4 ı4`* ^W1YsxD *O V\3 -\,* ]`\Y\,S, /\ ]`\`\V* `1O YT^B w *]SjS a\+T ,aT bT aW\,*E k\ b\+T -\,\`S, )E /\ VZS-Sx L `1YD 7>B6MD :

W1 4/1+TWnj\-\ \- ]1`1/*,*, Z1 V\ZV`1bZT aW\,*E * /dYVSE ,VW*/*phS ^f d a1`gq T `\4dYS ]SanY1ZZSVT, T+O WT^D -\,* /\4,\Wq, ^Y a*YSY \+S`*O bS aW\,*E k\+ 4*]Sa*bS y\-\ 4,TabVdD w `\]\,T/ZSV ]SWnZd,*, 4Z*f\/SbS ]\b`T+ZT aW\,*E T ,T`Z\ ]Sa*, ]`*,O /S,T aW\,*xEP aV*4*Z\ , ˚VVW14Tqab* 56B5>D ,*Z-1WTab dV* Z*]Sa*,B w)E /\VW*/Z\ /\aWT/S,jS da1 ,T/ a*Y\-\ ]\h*bVdE ]\ab*Z\,S, ]\ ]\`q/Vd Z*O ]Sa*bSDDD ]`\ g1x L dVS 5B7MD ˛* /\]\O Y\-\p a,\-\ /dfd \- ]\/+*,E k\+ Z* y\-\ 4,TabVd Z1 ,]WSZdW* Wp/anV* Z1O /\aV\Z*WTabnD

;

\y e*VbE k\ \- ]\aWd-\,d,*,aq Wp/nYS /Wq Z*]Sa*ZZq T+WT^E a,T/O hSbn ]`\ y\-\ ,1WSVd Yd/`TabnD W\,* Y\3dbn ]1`1/*,*bS Z1 bTWnVS TZe\`O Y*gTpE * y ]\hdbbq b* 1Y\gT^D #\E qVO +S -\,* Z*V*4*, *Z-1W*Y 4*]Sa*bS a,\2 aW\,\H S Y\-WS + ,\ZS ]1`1/*O bS b*VT `T4Z\Y*ZTbZT Wp/anVT ]\hdbO bqE qV ab`*fE aYdb\V T `\4h*`d,*ZZqH ˛*,/qVS b\Yd k\ Z1/\aV\Z*WT Wp/S a*YT ]T/+S`*WS aW\,*E *+S ]1`1/*bS \3T /dYVSE T+WTq b\`V*2bnaq Z*jSf a1`/1gnD ˛ ˝ • <

ıaZd2 hSY*W\ /\V*4T, b\-\E k\ T+WTq Z*bfZ1Z* \-\YD ˝\/Z* TZO j* `1WT-TyZ* VZS-* Z1 `\4]\,T/*2 Z*Y abTWnVS ]`\ \-*E qV ,qb1 SanO Y\D `SYT`\YE a1`1/ TZ/d^abanVSf ]SO a*Zn 2 VZS-S ,1/ShZSf -TYZT,E 4+T`V* \+`q/\,Sf V\Y1Zb*`T, /\ gSf -TYZT,E eTW\a\eanVT b`*Vb*bSE ,T/\YT qV ]*O ZTj*/SE b* 1]ThZT Tab\`T^ 4* Z*4,\p w *Y*qZ*x T w *f*+f*`*b*xD *abSZ\p w *f*+f*`*bSx 2 w -*š*,*/OšTb*x P VZS-* Y\`*WnZSf ]\,h*ZnD +d//TyO anVTy ]`*gT w T]Tb*V*x Lw `S V\jSVSxM \/SZ b\Y -\W\,Z\ `\4]\,T/*2 ]`\ ]`*O ,SW* b* dab`Ty 3Sbbq Y\Z*fT, T Y\Z*O fSZnD ˙`d-Sy b\Y 4/1+TWnj\-\ ]`SO a,qh1ZSy +d//TyanVSY /\Vb`SZ*YE * b`1bTy P daZSY ]\,h*ZZqY d//SD *Y d//* ZTV\WS Z1 Z*4S,*, a1+1 +\-\Y T /d31 Y*W\ V*4*, ]`\ ]`*,O /S,\-\ \-*D Sa*ZZq V\ZedgT*Zab,* YTabqbn Tab\`ShZT ]\,T/\YW1ZZqE Y\O `*WnZT ]`SZgS]SE Y*-ThZT 4*VWSZ*ZO Zq T ]TaZTD #\]`*,/*E a,qk1ZZ* VZS-* TaW*Yd ,hSbn ,T`SbS , 2/SZ\-\ ,a14Z*O ph\-\ \-*E qVSy ]1`1/+*h*2 Y*y+dbO

Z2E *W1 ,\Z* Z*,Tbn Z1 4-*/d2 \3\-\ TY1ZTE -\,*E qV1 ,3S,*2bnaq , T+WT^ bSaqhT `*4T,D =

b\y h*a qV +TWnjTabn `1WT-TyO ZSf VZS- Y*W\ -\,\`qbn ]`\ \-* *+\ ,4*-*WT ]`\ Zn\-\ Z1 4-*/dpbnE T+O WTq `\4]\,T/*2 ]`\ -\,d T y\-\ /TO W*D \Z* /\]\Y*-*2 Z*Y ]T4Z*bS y\-\ +*-*b\-`*ZZd \a\+SabTabnD q VZS-* ,T/V`S,*2E k\ -\,* Z1 bTWnVS ,a1Y\O -dbZTyE Yd/`Sy T a]`*,1/WS,Sy \-E *W1 y Wp+WqhSyD L `\hSb*yb1 ı,*O Z* 7B5:C 5 ı,*Z* 8B5=MD `TY b\O -\E T+WTq V*31B w \- /TyaZ\ Z1d]1`1O /31ZSy T , V\3Z\Yd Z*`\/T y\Yd /\ ,]\/\+S b\yE fb\ +\^bnaq y\-\ b* hSO ZSbn ]`*,1/ZTabnx L˙T^ 5>B78E 79MD 1,O Z\p YT`\p g1 ,S/Z\ 4 b\-\E Z*aVTWnVS T+WTq an\-\/ZT ]\jS`1Z*D \,\4Z*,O gT V*3dbnE k\ d a,TbT TaZd2 ]`S+WS4Z\ :;>> Y\, T V\W\ 5>> 4 ZSf 2 4`\4dYTWSO YS /Wq => ,T/a\bVT, Z*a1W1ZZqD a1 3 T+WTq L]\,ZTabp *+\ h*abV\,\M ]1`1O VW*/1Z* +TWnj ZT3 Z* 68>> Y\,D \3 ]`SZ*yYZT h*abSZ* T+WT^ /\abd]Z* Y*y31 V\3ZTy Wp/SZT Z* 41YWTD =E 5>D #\ T+WTq `\4]\,T/*2 Z*Y ]`\ \-*H

;D )V b\y e*VbE k\ \- ]\aWd-\,d,*,aq Wp/nYS /Wq Z*]Sa*ZZq T+WT^E a,T/hSbn ]`\ y\-\ Yd/`TabnH <D \Yd Y\3Z* aV*4*bSE k\ T+WTq Z1 ]\/T+O Z* /\ 3\/Z\^ TZj\^ `1WT-TyZ\^ VZS-SH

59 ˚ ) 6>56

6;

5>

ıada aV*4*,B w Ty *bnV\ /\aT ]`*O gp2E b\Yd Z1 ]1`1ab*p ]`*gp,*bS T qx Lı,D 9B5;MD -\,* 2 \-\Y w,T/,TVd y /\,TVdxD Sj1 dq,TY\E aVTWnVS ,an\-\ ,TZ ,hSZS,I L aD =>B6MD ı bTWnVS ,qb1 SanY\ `\4V`S,*2 Z*YE k\ \- 4`\O +S, d YSZdW\YdE k\ `\+Sbn b1]1` T k\ 4`\+Sbn d Y*y+dbZn\YdD T+WTq ]\,TO /\YWq2E k\ -\,* Wp+SbnE * k\ Z1Z*O ,S/SbnE T ]\V*4d2E qV Wp/SZ* Y\31 Z*+WS4SbSan /\ Zn\-\ L)VD 8B<MD TO V\WS Z1 /\4,\WnY\ \a\+SabSY ]`*-O Z1ZZqY T bd`+\b*Y ,T/,1abS Z*a ,T/

-\,SD 55 T+WTq P VZS-* Z1]1`1,1`j1Z\ ^ Yd/`\abTE T g1 4*]1,Zq2 Z*a d b\YdE k\ ^ ^ *,b\`\Y Z1 +dW* 4,Sh*yZ* Wp/SO Z*D ]\ab\W *,W\ Z*]Sa*,B w b\ ]TO 4Z*, `\4dY -\,S T YT- +S ]\,h*bS y\O -\Hx L5 \`D 6B5:MD 1y ,T`j +*4d2bnaq Z* aW\,*f ]`\`\V* ıa* ^E qVSy 4*]Sb*, a,\^f adh*aZSVT,B w b\ \a]\/Zn\-\ ˙df* 4+*-Zd,E T /1 b* Wp/SZ*E k\ `*/S a,\^ ]\/*,*W* •\YdHx Lıa*^ 8>B57MD T/O ]\,T/n \h1,S/Z*B b*V\^ Wp/SZS Z1Y*2D \Yd Z1 /S,Z\E k\ +T+WTyZT ]\`*/S ab\a\,Z\ Y\`*WTE jWp+dE ,Sf\,*ZZq /Tb1yE ab*,W1ZZq /\ `\+\bSE ,S+\`d /`d4T, T `\4,*- ]`SZ\aqbn Z*yV`*kT `14dWnb*bSD T+WTq ZTV\WS Z1 /*2 ]\-*O ZSf ]\`*/D *b\YTabn Wp/anVT ]\,h*ZO Zq Z1 4*,3/S /T2,TE +\ Wp/S Z1 ,\W\/TO pbn b*V\p Yd/`TabpE qV \- L `1YD 5>B67MD \ZS h*ab\ ]1`1-Wq/*pbn T ,SO ]`*,Wqpbn a,\^ ]\`*/SE da,T/\YWppO hSE k\ ]\YSWqWSanD T+WTq -\,\`SbnB w \a]\/n 4Z*2 ,aT Wp/anVT /dYVSE k\ Y*`Z\b* ,\ZSx L aD =8B55MD

-dD 5:< `\gT /\ ZD 1D aS`TyanVSy g*` ZbT\f IV Z*V*4*, 4Z*ybS ,aT VZS-S ˛*V\Zd T a]*WSbS ^fD SYanVSy TYO ]1`*b\` ˙T\VW1bT*Z d 7>7 `\gT ZD 1D 4,1WT, 4`dyZd,*bS YTagq ]\VW\ZTZO Zq f`SabSqZ T a]*WSbS ^fZT Sa*ZZqD *VT ]1`1aWT/d,*ZZq b`S,*WS ]`SO +WS4Z\ /1aqbn `\VT,D ˛ XI ab\WTbbq ]*]S `SYanVT ]1`1jV\/3*WS ]\jSO `1ZZp +T+WTyZSf 4Z*Zn T 4*+\`\ZqWS ]1`1VW*/*bS ,qb1 SanY\ Z* Y\,SE qVSYS `\4Y\,WqWS ]`\abT Wp/SD `\O b1 T+WTq ,gTWTW* T /TyjW* /\ Z*j\-\ h*adE Z14,*3*phS Z* 4df,*WT Z*]*/S *b*ZS T y\-\ ]`S+ThZSVT,D -\,* ZTO V\Yd Z1 /\4,\WS, 4ZSkSbS y\-\ /*`D ˙ ˛ E ) ı ˚ ˚ & 57 ıaZdpbn k1 y TZjT /\V*4S b\-\E k\ T+WTq Z*bfZ1Z* \-\YB ^ ^ ,ZdbO `TjZq -*`Y\ZTqE Tab\`ShZ* T Z*dV\O ,* b\hZTabnE a]\,Z1ZT ]`\`\gb,* b* Z*/4,Sh*yZ* ,T/,1`bTabn ^ ^ ]SanY1ZO ZSVT,D `TY b\-\E T+WTq Y*2 aSWd 4YTO Zp,*bS Wp/1y T /*2 ,Sh1`]ZT ,T/]\,TO /T Z* 4*]Sb*ZZqE qVT YS 4-*/d,*WS Z* ]\h*bVd ab*bbTD \/S,TY\anE qV /1qVT Wp/S ]1`1V\Z*WSaqE k\ T+WTq P g1 VZS-* ,T/ \-*D 58 Z,*`1 ,S`\ab*, Z* WS4nV\Yd f\/T T +d, YdadWnY*ZSZ\YD \WS ,TZ 3S, d T,ZThZTy Y1`SgTE /\ Zn\-\ 4*O ,Tb*WS ,T/VS -\,SD w b\y h*aEP -\O ,\`Sbn Z,*`EP q Z1-*bS,Z\ ab*,S,O aq /\ f`SabSqZanVSf `1WT-TyE +\ 4Z*, ]`\ f`1ab\,T ]\f\/S b* TZV,T4SgTpD /Z*VE +d/dhS /\]SbWS,\p Wp/SZ\pE q ]\-\/S,aq Z* +T+WTyZ1 ,S,h1ZZqxD

56

ıab\`Tq b13 /\,\/SbnE k\ *,b\O `\Y T+WT^ 2 \-D YSZdW\Yd hSY*W\ Wp/1y Z*Y*-*W\aq 4ZSkSbS gp VZSO 55D )V* Yd/`Tabn YTabSbnaq Z* ab\`TZV*f T+WT^H 56D )VSf Z*]*/T, 4*4Z*,*W* T+WTq ]`\bqO -\Y ,TVT,H

6<

1 ˙1qVT TY1Z* 4YTZ1Z\D

57D )VT k1 2 /\V*4S b\-\E k\ T+WTq Z*bfZ1O Z* \-\YH 58P5:D *M ˛*,/qVS h\Yd b`\2 Wp/1y ]1`1O V\Z*W\aqE k\ T+WTq P g1 VZS-* ,T/ \-*H +M )VT /\V*4S Z*bfZ1Z\abT T+WT^ bS Wp+Sj ,SV\`Sab\,d,*bS , aWd3TZZTH

1,/\,4T ]TaWq gn\-\ Z,*` ]\,1`Zd,O aq /\/\Yd T ,b`*bS, 4,Gq4\V 4T ,T/V*O YSD 1`14 VTWnV* `\VT, ,TZ ]1`1^f*, /\

,`\]SE /1 ,T/Z\,S, ,S,h1ZZqD Z,*` 4-*/d2B w ]\,Z1ZZq +T+WTyZSf ]`\O `\gb,E ,Zdb`TjZq -*`Y\ZTq ,qb\-\ SanY*E ,T/adbZTabn d Zn\Yd ]`\bS`Th b* Wp+\,E qV* ]*Zd2 YT3 ]\VW\ZZSV*O YS -\,SEP ,a1 g1 ]1`1V\Z*W\ Y1Z1E k\ T+WTq /TyaZ\ 2 \3SY W\,\YxD 5==< `\gT Z,*` \f`1abS,aqD 59 "TabZ*/gqbS`ThZ* ^j* ,Sf\,dO ,*W*an d aTYG^ ,T//*ZSf TZ/d^abT,D \Z* `\4]\,T/*2B w) Y\WSW*an WSj1 b\/TE V\WS ]`Sf\/SW* , f`*Y *+\ abSV*W*aq 4 ]`\+W1Y*YSE *W1 ZTV\WS Z1 4-*/d,*O W* ]`\ \-*E V\WS , Y1Z1 ,a1 +dW\ /\+O `1D )V\an /\ Y1Z1 ]`SyjWS ,T/VS

-\,SE T ,T/b\/T Y\2 3Sbbq V*`/SZ*WnO Z\ 4YTZSW\anxD ^j* ]\h*W* ,S,h*O bS T+WTp T `\4,SZdW* /`d3+d 4 \O -\YD #\ ]1`1V\Z*W\ ^ ^ , Z*bfZ1Z\abT T+WT^H ˙T,hSZ* V*31B w T+WTq ,T/]\,TO W* Z* ,aT 4*]Sb*ZZqE qVT Y1Z1 bd`+dO ,*WSD \Z* /\]\Y\-W* Y1ZT ]\,T`SbS , \-*E qV\-\ Z1Y\3WS,\ ]\+*hSbSD ) 4+*-ZdW*B k\+ `\4,SZdbS ,T`dE Z1]\O b`T+Z\ f\/SbS /\ f`*Yd b* ,VW\ZqbSO aq T/\W*YxD 5: *dW* Z*`\/SW*an d `\/SZT V*O b\WSVT,E *W1E ab*,jS /\`\aW\pE ,\Z* ,,*3*W* a1+1 *-Z\abSV\YD * Z1,/\,4T , ^ ^ 3SbbT ,T/+dW*aq ,*3WS,* ]\/TqD w) 4dab`TW* /`d-*E qV\-\ Z1 +*hSW* VTWnO V* YTaqgT,EP ]`S-*/d2 *dW*DP \/T +dW* ]\]dWq`Z\p VdWnbd`* fT]TD \WS q ]\+*hSW*E k\ ,TZ ,S-Wq/*, k*aWSO ,SY T ]\ab`S- ,\W\aaqE b\ 4*]Sb*W* y\-\B r#\ 4 b\+\p ab*W\aq T /1 bS ]`\O ]*/*,Hs W\]1gn aV*4*,E k\ ,S,h*2 T+WTp 4T ,T/V*YS -\,SE T ]\h*, Y1O ZT a,T/hSbSxD \+*hS,jSE Z*aVTWnVS aSWnZ\ +T+WTyZ* ]`*,/* ,]WSZdW* Z* ^ ^ /`d-*E qVSy V\WSan b13 adYZT,*,aq , TaZd,*ZZT ,\`gqE *dW* 4*gTV*,SO

59 ˚ ) 6>56

W*an 4,TabV\p 4 T+WT^ T 4-\/\Y ]1`1V\O Z*W*anE k\ g1 VZS-* ,T/ \-*D w˙ ) ı P ı & x 5;

T+WTq P /S,\,S3ZSy /*` -\,SE qVSy ,TZ /*, Wp/qYE ]\aWd-\,dphSan a,\^Y a,qbSY /df\YD #\/1ZZ1 hSb*ZO Zq T+WT^ Z1\/YTZZ\ ]`SZ1a1 b\+T Z*O a\W\/d T ]\-WS+Sbn Wp+\, /\ ^ ^ *,b\`* L aD 5B5E 6MD 1`1/ bSY qV hSb*bS T+O WTpE k\`*4d ]`\aS , -\,SE k\+ y\-\ /df V1`d,*, b,\^YS /dYV*YS L dVS

#\/1ZZ1 hSb*ZZq T+WT^ ]\-WS+Sbn b,\p Wp+\, /\ ^^ *,b\`* 55B57MD T+WT^ 4*]Sa*ZT /dYVS -\,SE b\3 qVk\ bS +d/1j `\4YT`V\,d,*bS Z*/ ]`\hSb*ZSYE b\ ]1`1yY*bSY1j \3Sy ]\-Wq/ Z* bT hS TZjT ]Sb*ZZqD 5<

*+d,*phS b\hZ\-\ 4Z*ZZq ]`*O ,/SE Z*Y*-*yaq 3SbS 4-T/Z\ 4 Z1pD L `\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 55=B5>9MD /S,Wqyaq d ,qb1 SanY\E Z1Y\, d /41`V*W\D \WS bS +*hSjE k\ Z1O \+fT/Z\ 4`\+SbS 4YTZSE `\+S ^f +14 4,\WTV*Zn L)VD 5B67P69MD SV\`Sab\O ,dy \31 W\,\ qV Y1hE k\+ 4*fSk*O bS a,\^ ]1`1V\Z*ZZq T ,SV\`TZp,*bS e*WnjS,T ,h1ZZq T4 a1`/1gn aYS`1ZO ZSf Wp/1y L˚eD :B5;MD Sq,Wqy ,/qhO ZTabn \-\,T 4* b1E k\ +T+WTyZT ]`\O `\VS T ]SanY1ZZSVS +dWS wV1`\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\YxD 5;D )V b\+T /\]\Y\31 k\/1ZZ1 hSb*ZZq \3\-\ W\,* T `\4/dYS Z*/ ZSYH 5<D \Yd bS ]`*-Z1j T /*WT ,S,h*bS T+O WTpH

6=

d/n `\4ad/WS,Sy T jdV*y wYd/`\-\ V1`T,ZSgb,*x Ë?Sbbq h*ab\ ]`S`T,Zppbn /\ Y\`anV\^ ]\/\`\3TD ,bTYE +*-*b\ fb\ Z1 b`SY*2bnaq ]`*,SWnZ\-\ Vd`adE +\ V1`d2bnaq WSj1 Wp/anV\p Yd/`TabpD *VT Wp/S 4*4Z*pbn wV\`*+1WnZ\^ *,*`T^x d +d`fWS,Sf ,\/*f 3Sbbq L aD 5>;B67E 6;MD \Yd gq Y1b*e\`* 2 b*V\p ,WdhZ\pH

/*,ZT h*aS ]\/\`\3 Y\`1Y ,SY*-*W* aSW T /\a,T/dD Sab1gb,* V1`d,*bS V\`*+W1Y ,hSWSO aq , /\a,T/h1ZSf Y\`qVT,E aV*3TY\ , ab1`Z\,Sf LË™T^ 6;B=P55MD SY*W\ fd/\3ZSVT, d YSZdW\Yd 4\+`*3*WS ab1`Z\,\-\ +TWnjSY 4* TZjSf Y\`qO VT, T bSY a*YSY ]T/V`1aWp,*WS y\-\ ,*3WS,d `\WnD #\+ V1`d,*bS ad/Z\YE Y\`1]W*,gT ,S,h*O WS 4\`TE ,Tb`S b* TZjT \`T2ZbS`SD T+WTq Z*,Tbn Z*4S,*2 Y\`1]W*,gT, wYd/`1gqYSx L 41VD 6;B<MD Ë?Sbb2,T ]`\+W1YS TZ\/T +d,*pbn b*VSYS 3 ,SaZ*3WS,SYSE qV ]\/\`\3 `\4+d`f*ZSY Y\O `1Y d ab*`\/*,ZT h*aSD #\ Y\31 Z*Y /\]\O Y\-bSH ˙˚ Ë› • w Ë™ Ëš Ëš Äą xH

*YGqb*phS ]`\ 4-*/*Z1 ,Sk1 ]\`T,ZqZO ZqE `\4-WqZnY\ \/Zd +T+WTyZd /dYVdB w d/`Sy ]\hd2 b* ]`SyY1 +*-*b\ ]\`*/E T `\4dYZSy ]\O aWdf*2bnaq Yd/`\-\ V1`T,ZSgb,* x L `S]D 5B9E :E MD ,`1yanVSy ,SaWT,E ]1`1VW*/1ZSy qV wYd/`1 V1`T,ZSgb,\xE Y\31 ab\ad,*bSaq ,YTW\-\ ]`\,\/dE qVSy 4/TyaZp2 V*]Tb*Z V\`*+WqD 1y ,SaWT, \]Sad2 a]`\Y\3ZTabn Yd/`\ d]`*,WqbS hSY\an *+\ aV1`\,d,*bS k\an d Z1\+fT/Z\Yd Z*O ]`qYVdD ˛Z*ybS wYd/`1 V1`T,ZSgb,\x T Z*,hSbSaq daO ]TjZ\ ]\/\`\3d,*bS Y\`1Y 3Sbbq Z1W1-V\E *W1 Z*Y g1 ]T/ aSWdD )V ,S/Z\ 4 VZS-S `SO ]\,Tab1yE YS YdaSY\ ]\aWd-\,d,*bSaq wYd/`TaO bpxE w`\4ad/V\Yx T w`\4,*3ZTabpx L `S]D 5B6P:C 6B5P=MD *Y Z1 aWT/ Z1fbd,*bS ]\`*/*YS ,T/

7>

#\+ ]T/V`1aWSbS ,*3WS,d `\Wn W\gO Y*Z*E d YSZdW\Yd fd/\3ZSVS h*ab\ 4\+`*3*WS y\-\ +TWnjSY 4* TZjSf Y\`qVT, Su concessione del Ministero per i ` Beni e le Attivita Culturali. It is forbidden to reproduce or duplicate this image in any way or by any means.

-\,SE */31 Z*,Tbn +14+\3ZT Wp/S ,YTpbn V1`dO ,*bS a,\^Y 3SbbqYE k\]`*,/*E a]`qY\,dpbn y\O -\ , fS+Z\Yd Z*]`qYVd L `S]D 56B9MD b\3 /d31 ,*3WS,\ ab*`*ZZ\ /\aWT/3d,*bS \31 W\,\D Ë›*,/qVS gn\Yd YS +d/1Y\ 4/\+d,*O bS gTZZT 4Z*ZZq ]`\ -\,d T ]`\ Äąada* `Sab*E qVSy Z*yWT]j1 ,T//41`V*Wp,*, \a\+SabTabn \O -* LÄą,D 58B=MD `TY b\-\E YS \b`SYd2Y\ +*-*b\ Yd/`Sf ]\`*/ Z* f`SabSqZanVSf 4T+`*ZZqfD S Y\31Y\ b*V\3 Z*,h*bSaq 4 /\a,T/d TZjSfE d b\O Yd hSaWT Z*jSf +*bnVT, L `S]D 67B66MD Äą

) ˚ ˚˙ Ĺ˙ Ĺ • ˙ Ĺ Ĺ"˚

)

]SZqphSan d Z1a]\VTyZSf ,\/*f 3SbbqE YS ,V`*y ]\b`1+d2Y\ wYd/`\-\ V1`T,ZSgb,*xD )Vk\ , aVW*/ZTy aSbd*gT^ YS ,*-*2Y\anE qV1 `Tj1ZZq ]`SyZqbSE adYZT,S Y\3dbn ]*`*WT4d,*bS Z*aE T g1 Y*bSY1 ]\-*ZT Z*aWT/VS L)VD 5B9E :MD

TV*,\E k\ ,SaWT, wYd/`1 V1`T,ZSgb,\x ,3SO ,*2bnaq T b\/TE V\WS y/1bnaq ]`\ ,TyanV\,T /T^D T+WT^ YS hSb*2Y\B w `\,*/n ,TyZd Yd/`SYS `*/*YS wYd/`\p ab`*b1-T2pxE w S]`*,W1ZSy ]1O `1VW*/ *Z-WTyanV\^ T+WT^ x E +\ a]*aTZZq P , hSaO W1ZZ\abT `*/ZSVT,x L `S]D 6>B5<C 68B:MD \/T+Z\ /\ ]1`1/+*hWS,\-\ ,TyanV\,\-\ ab`*O b1-*E YS Y*2Y\ 4,*3*bS Z* ]\b1ZgTyZT Z1+14]1O VS T \+/dYd,*bSE qV 4*fSabSbS a,\p /df\,ZTabn L `S]D 66B7MD V*3TY\E b\+T ]`\]\Zdpbn Z\,d `\+\bd *+\ ,Skd ]\a*/dD SE Z*]1,Z\E ,T4nY1j /\ d,*-SE qVd Y*bSY1j 4*`\+TbZd ]W*bdE qV /\,O -\ /\+S`*bSY1jaq Z* `\+\bd b* TZjT hSZZSVSD /Z*V ,*`b\ \+/dY*bS T b*VT 4*]Sb*ZZqB hS gq `\+\b* Z1 ad]1`1hSbn +T+WTyZSY ]`SZgS]*YH )V Z\,Sy -`*eTV L\a\+WS,\ qVk\ g1 `\+\b* ]\ 4YTZ*fM ,]WSZ1 Z* b,\p f`SabSqZanVd /TqWnO ZTabnH L dVS 58B6<P7>MD /Z* a1ab`*E Z* TYGq \`1bb*E Y*W* /\+`d `\O +\bdD \WS eT`Y*E , qVTy ,\Z* ]`*gp,*W*E ]1`1O ^3/3*W* Z* Z\,1 YTag1E ^y 4*]`\]\Zd,*WS V`*O kd ]\a*/dD *h*Wnab,\ ]1`1V\Zd,*W\ a1ab`dB w 1 dZTV*WnZ* Z*-\/*E qV* ,S]*/*2 `*4 d 3SbO bTD S Z*,Tbn /T4Z*WSaqE k\ , bTy YTag1,\abT 2 ˛*W *`ab,*xD `\b1 \`1bb* ]`*-ZdW* a]`\aO bSbS 3Sbbq T +TWnj1 h*ad ]`Sa,qhd,*bS aWd3TZO ZpD 1ab`* `\4dYTW*E k\ h1`14 b*Vd ]\a*/d ,\O Z* Z1 4Y\31 aWd3SbS ,\`g1,T ]\,Z\p YT`\pD \3 \`1bb* ,S`TjSW* 4,TWnZSbSanE f\h* /SO `1Vb\` 4T4Z*,aqE k\ ,\Z* 2/SZSy ]`*gT,ZSVE 59 ˚ ) 6>56

qV\-\ Z1 f\bTWS ,b`*bSbSD T/b\/T \`1bb* d31 +WS4nV\ 6> `\VT, aWd3Sbn ab*WSY ]T\Z1`\YD \O Z* ]1`1V\Z*Z*E k\ \b`SY*W* hSY*W\ +W*-\aW\O ,1ZnE */31 ]`SyZqW* `Tj1ZZqE ]`SaWdf*phSan /\ wYd/`\-\ V1`T,ZSgb,*x 4 \3\-\ W\,*D \O `1bb* 4YTgZSW* a,\^ ,4*2YSZS 4 -\,\p T Y*W* h1abn /\]\Y\-bS VTWnV\Y \a\+*Y ]T4Z*bS +T+WTyO Zd ]`*,/dD w d/`\-\ V1`T,ZSgb,*x ]\b`1+dpbn T aTYG^E 4\VO `1Y* d ,Sf\,*ZZT /Tb1y P Z1W1-VTy T /\,-\O b`S,*WTy ]`*gTD Tj1ZZqE qVT +*bnVS ]`SyY*O pbn ab\a\,Z\ /df\,ZSf T Y*b1`T*WnZSf ]Sb*ZnE ,]WS,*pbn Z* Y*y+dbZ2 ,aT2^ aTYG^ L `S]D 66B:MD `SabSqZanVT +*bnVSE ]`SYT`\YE Y\-WS + a1+1 4*]Sb*bSB w S a,\^YS `\4Y\,*YS T ,hSZV*YS YS ]`Sk1]Wp2Y\ /TbqY /df\,ZT gTZZ\abTE qVT /\]\O Y\3dbn ^Y Yd/`\ ]\,\/SbSan d /\`\aW\Yd 3SbO bTH S a,\^Y a]\a\+\Y 3Sbbq YS Z*,h*2Y\ ^f 4*/\,\WnZqbSaq Z*yZ1\+fT/ZTjSY T 4\a1`1/3dO ,*bSan Z* f`SabSqZanV\Yd aWd3TZZTHx L5 SYD :B:P5>E 5<E 5=MD ]`*,3ZTy da]Tf Z1 ,S4Z*h*2bnaq eTZ*Za\,SO YS *+\ ada]TWnZSYS /\aq-Z1ZZqYSE qVSf b*V ]`*-Zdbn Wp/S d a,TbTD 1 ,S4Z*,*, g*` \W\O Y\ZD T/ Z*bfZ1ZZqY \-* ,TZ Z*]Sa*,B w SY +dO /1 /\+`1E fb\ \-* +\^bnaqE fb\ ]1`1/ \+WShhqY •\-\ Y*2 ab`*fx L˚VVWD <B56MD •\-\ aW\,* ]T/O V`1aWppbnE Z*aVTWnVS `\4dYZ\ jdV*bS wYd/`\O -\ V1`T,ZSgb,*xE qV1 d4-\/3d2bnaq 4 \3SY W\O ,\Y L6 SYD 7B5:E 5;MD

75

˙\+`\b* `\4b\]Wp2 WT/ Z1]`Sq4ZT

ı˙˚ ˙ WTbZq 3TZV*E Z* TYGq T1E /d31 Z1]`S,TbZ\ 4dab`TW* 1\`-* T *O Z\Z P ]\/`d33q ,T/VT,E qV1 Z*Y*-*O W\aq a,T/hSbS ^y ]`\ *`ab,\D 1\`- T *Z\Z /T4Z*WSaqE k\ , gT2^ 3TZVS ]\Y1`WS /,* h\W\O ,TVS T aSZE * a*Y* ,\Z* aSWnZ\ ab`*3/*W* ,T/ *`b`SbdD T/ h*a `\4Y\,S 3TZV* b`\fS 4*a]\O V\^W*anE \/Z*V Z1 ,Sq,WqW* ,1WSV\^ ]`Sq4ZTD ,bTYE 1\`- 4*]`\]\Zd,*, /`d3SZT Vd]SbS /Wq 3TZVS +dV1b V,TbT,E +\ ,\Z* ,S-Wq/*W* /dO 31 \/SZ\V\p T 4*aYdh1Z\pD \WS ,\ZS 4Z\,d ^ ^ ,T/,T/*WSE -\a]\/SZq +dW* ]`S2YZ\ ,`*31Z*D \Z* Z1 Y*W* h*ad ]\`\4Y\,WqbSE b\Yd 1\`T *Z\Z /\Y\,SWSan 4dab`TbSaq 4 Z1p ]T4ZTj1D W1E ]`Syj\,jS , ]`S4Z*h1ZSy h*aE ,\ZS ZTO V\-\ Z1 4*ab*WSD 1\`- T *Z\Z 4*f\/SWS /\ 3TZVS k1 VTWnV* `*4T,E b* ^ ^ Z1 +dW\ ,/\Y*D ıY 4/*W\aqE k\ ,\Z* ^f dZSV*2D /Z\-\ /Zq 1\`- T *Z\Z b*VS 4dab`TWSO aq 4 T1D \Z* ,S+*hSW*an 4* b1E k\ Z1 4Y\-W* 4 ZSYS ]\+*hSbSan d ]`S4Z*h1ZSy /1ZnD ˝TZO V* `\4]\,TW*E k\ W13*W* , WTV*`ZTD w S ZTV\WS Z1 4/\-*/*2b1anE k\ q 4`\+SW* \/`*4d ]TaWq ,*O j\-\ ,T4SbdEP aV*4*W* ,\Z*DP ) ]\h*W* hSb*O bS T+WTpIx ˛*,Gq4*W*an ]`S2YZ* `\4Y\,*E T 4 3TZV\p +dW\ `\4]\h*b\ +T+WTyZ1 ,S,h1ZZqD

www.jw.org

S,h*phS T+WTpE T1 ]1`1b,\`p,*W*an Z* `*/TaZd T ]`S,TbZd Wp/SZdD \h* ,\Z* +dO W* Z1 , ab*ZT ,Sf\/SbS 4 /\YdE ]`\b1 \/`*4d ]\h*W* `\4]\,T/*bS ]`\ a,\p ,T`d bSYE fb\ /\ Z1^ ]`Sf\/S,D ˛/\`\,Gq Z1 /\4,\WqW\ T1 `1-dO Wq`Z\ ,T/,T/d,*bS 4T+`*ZZqE b\3 /\ Z1^ h*ab\ ]`Sf\/SWS +`*bS y a1ab`SE k\+ ]T/+*/n\`SbS ^ ^D \WS T1 +dW\ <6 `\VSE ]T/ h*a `*y\ZZ\O -\ V\Z-`1ad ,\Z* \f`1abSW*an Z* aSY,\W a,\-\ ]`Sa,qh1ZZq \-\,TD

* 3*WnE h1`14 VTWnV* YTaqgT, T1 ]\Y1`W*D ˛-\/\Y d Z1^ ,/\Y* 4Z*yjWS ,T`jE qVSy ,\Z* aVW*W*D gn\Yd ,T`jT T1 \]Sa*W*E Z*aVTWnVS -T`V\p 2 a*Y\bZTabn d ]\fSW\Yd ,TgT T qV1 4Z*O h1ZZq /Wq Wp/SZS Y*2 /\+`\b*D w T`j -WS+\V\ b\`VZd,aq Y1Z1EP ]\/TWSW*an *Z\ZDP ) `*O /*E k\ -\,* a]\ZdV*, Z*a ,Sq,SbS /\ T1 /\+O `\bdxD

-\,* ,W*aZSY ]`SVW*/\Y 4*\f\hd2 Z*a WpO +SbS TZjSf T ab*,SbSan /\ ZSf 4 /\+`\b\p L˚eD 9B5E 6MD *j1 aWd3TZZq ]`SZ\aSbSY1 hd/\,T ]W\/SE qVk\ YS w`1V\Y1Z/d2Y\ a1+1 qV \O 3T aWd3Sb1WTDDD a]\,Z1ZTDDD /\+`\bSx L6 \`D :B8E :MD

w12 06/15-K

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.