BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT RE-LINKING BROOMIELAW AND GLASGOW
20 / 03 / 2017 edited by Yanjun Liu prepared by: Maria Abissab / Digital Creativity Samata Chaudhari / Urban Design Ntasha de Vries / Creative Urban Practive Yanjun Liu / Urban Building Victorian view of the Broomielaw, looking East. Source: Souvenir of Scotland
Stamatia Tsatsi / Urban Design
Contents
01: Design Philosophy 02: Positioning __ Context __ Aspiration __ Function __ Beauty
__ Re-linking Historical Galsgow __ Re-linking Urban Grid __ Re-linking Public space __ Re-linking Skin and Scar __ Re-linking Making and Glasgow __ Re-linking Business and Living __ Re-linking River and People
03: Analysis __ Landuse __ Road Network __ Cylce Path __ Road Direction __ Road Crossings
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
04: Proposal __ Overall Proposal __ Digital Creativity __ Urban Design __ Creative Urban Practice __ Urban Building __ Urban Design
01 Design Philosophy
Connectivity
Identity
Permeability
Identifying Key Problems
Density
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Attractivity
01 Design Philosophy Context
Site location
INTERNAL USE ONLY
image by MVRDV
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Beauty
Function
Aspiration
100 m
1 km
image by Clyde Waterfront
01 Design Philosophy Context
Aspiration
Beauty
Function
History
_The _ Quay allowed for communication and flow between the North and the South of the City _A _ lack of heavy industry in this location made it a live and active Riverfront
100 m
1 km
100 m
Broomielaw 1750
Glasgow 1750 1 km
Studio Tom Emerson, Glasgow Atlas, Zurich: ETH Zurich, 2016
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Broomielaw District
100 m
Broomielaw 1850
Glasgow 1850 1 km
Studio Tom Emerson, Glasgow Atlas, Zurich: ETH Zurich, 2016
Broomielaw District
100 m
Broomielaw 1892
Glasgow 1892-4 1 km
Lanarkshire 006.10, National Library of Scotland online
Broomielaw District
Broomielaw now
01 Design Philosophy Context
Function
Aspiration
Beauty
History
_Creation _ of long warehouse blocks _At _ the height of industrial Glasgow, Broomielaw was also its height _Plots _ cleared for the M8
1892-1894
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
now
01 Design Philosophy Context
Aspiration
Function
Beauty
M8
_Introduction _ of the Scar
Sound Map
_Has _ lowered Air Quality in Glasgow _HIgh _ Levels of noise pollution _Permeability _ Problems
levels of Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) air pollution above the legal limit in 2014
map by:glasgow3dsoundmap.co.uk
Air Pullution Graphics by: www.foe-scotland.org.uk BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
01 Design Philosophy Context Commercial district context made in glasgow
Map by Make Works
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Aspiration
Function
Beauty
01 Design Philosophy Context Current Connectivity Problems/roads
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Aspiration
Function
Beauty
01 Design Philosophy Context
Aspiration
Function
Land use / Activity Analysis
There are 47 blocks in Broomielaw, an 24 blocks have paking space, which means almost half of the blocks are occupied by cars. BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Beauty
01 Design Philosophy Context Joining Kelvingrove and Glasgow green (lack of public space in city center)
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Aspiration
Function
Beauty
01 Design Philosophy Context Attractivity of Clyde
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Aspiration
Function
Beauty
01 Design Philosophy
Context
Aspiration
Function
Beauty
Story Line - Broomielaw
CON
NECTION
+
=? image by JDS Architects
Made in Glasgow : Linking the IFSD back to the people of Glasgow Commercial Area for local makers encouraging Glaswegian business and job growth Public Space connecting Kelvingrove and Glasgow Green Keeping Broomielaw’s historical heritage to maintain coherency with the rest of glasgow A more porous Broomielaw
01 Design Philosophy Context
Aspiration
Function
Beauty
Ambition
Broomielaw: Quay to Glasgow
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
image by JDS Architects
01 Design Philosophy Context
Function
Aspiration
Beauty
Target Users Glasgow Population Statistics, population projection: 2037
Juvenile 0-15 yrs
16.55
Youth 16-29 yrs 19.62
Adult 30-49 yrs
Middle-aged 50-64 yrs
28.78%
16.95%
Old age 65 - 74 yrs
above 75 75+ yrs
9.50%
8.60%
No. 1 Adult
Population Projection for Glasgow by age group, 2012-2037
Source: Natiional records of Scotland (2012 based projections) 100%
39.8
58.8
65-74
43.1
80%
60%
75 +
65.0
50-64
No. 2 -4 Middle-aged Youth Juvenile
30-49
99.6
116.2
16-29 0-15
172.3 197.0
40% 143.7
134.3
20% 96.3
0%
2012
Data analysis - Adult groups take the highest percentage, Middle-aged, youth and juvenile groups takes similar ratios.
No. 5 - 6 Old age 75 above
113.3
2017
2022
G4 G3 G2
G1 2027 G5
2032
2037
Conclusion: Adult group is currently the main target user in Broomielaw; however, for growth and planning spatial planning for other social groups may be necessary
C O N N E C T I O N
01 Design Philosophy Context
Aspiration
Colors In Space Studies
THE COLORS & ATMOSPHERE CREATED IN SPACE CAN INFLUENCE USERS
PURITY LUXURY
PURE Whie tells peoople you have nothing to hide. it is one of the more eyecatching colors, and it can also denote purity and cleanliness.
DEPENDABLE NATURE
NATURE Brown is a dependable, sturdy colour that also happens to be good at hiding dirt. Although this could be a turn off for some people.
WHITE
SOPHISTICATED
COMFORTABLE
INTELLECTUALTRUSTWORTHY Blue is synonymous with being trustworthy, dependable, fiscally responsible and secure. TRUSTWORTHY DEPENDABLE FRIENDLY OPTIMISTIC INSTINCT
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
BLACK
BROWN
FRIENDLY Orange is a friendly colour and tends to appeal to an upscale market.
BLUE/ORANGE
Function
Beauty
01 Design Philosophy Context
Aspiration
Function
Color scheme - Friendly & Elegant
01
02
01 Spaical Primary Colour. 02 Secondary Colour 03 Colour Scheme Origin 03
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Beauty
02 Positioning
RE-LINKING RE-LINKING Historical Glasgow Making and Glasgow RE-LINKING Urban Grid
RE-LINKING Business and Living
RE-LINKING Public Spaces
RE-LINKING River and People
RE-LINKING Skin and Scar
02
R E - L I N K I N G
Analysis
03
Analysis - Existing landuse LAND USE LEGEND Office Mixed use Residential Car Parking Vacant / Risk Empty plot Church / Library / Theatre / Museum Hotel Green Space Warehouse / Storage Food / Drink / Entertainment Clyde River M8
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Analysis - proposal landuse LANDUSE LEGEND Office Mixed use Residential Car Parking Public Zone Dockland Church / Library / Theatre / Museum Hotel Green Space Warehouse / Storage Food / Drink / Entertainment Clyde River M8 Commercial Cycle path zebra crossings
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Analysis - landuse
Existing Blocks
Proposal Blocks
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Existing Officies
Proposal Officies
Existing Mixed use LAND USE LEGEND
LAND USE LEGEND
Office
Office
Mixed use
Mixed use
Residential
Residential
Car Parking
Car Parking
Vacant / Risk
Vacant / Risk
Empty plot
Empty plot
Church / Library / Theatre / Museum
Church / Library / Theatre / Museum
Warehouse / Storage
Warehouse / Storage
Food / Drink / Entertainment
Food / Drink / Entertainment
Clyde River
Clyde River
M8
M8
45
23
44
53
Proposal Mixed use
Analysis - landuse
Existing Residential
Proposal Residential
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Existing Car Parking
Existing Culture
LAND USE LEGEND
LAND USE LEGEND
LAND USE LEGEND
Office
Office
Office
Mixed use
Mixed use
Mixed use
Residential
Residential
Residential
Car Parking
Car Parking
Car Parking
Vacant / Risk
Vacant / Risk
Vacant / Risk
Empty plot
Empty plot
Empty plot
Church / Library / Theatre / Museum
Church / Library / Theatre / Museum
Church / Library / Theatre / Museum
Warehouse / Storage
Warehouse / Storage
Warehouse / Storage
Food / Drink / Entertainment
Food / Drink / Entertainment
Food / Drink / Entertainment
Clyde River
Clyde River
Clyde River
M8
M8
M8
18
25
7
30
13
9
Proposal Car Parking
Proposal Culture
Analysis - landuse
Existing Entertainment
Proposal Entertainment
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Existing Hotel
Existing Warehouse
LAND USE LEGEND
LAND USE LEGEND
LAND USE LEGEND
Office
Office
Office
Mixed use
Mixed use
Mixed use
Residential
Residential
Residential
Car Parking
Car Parking
Car Parking
Vacant / Risk
Vacant / Risk
Vacant / Risk
Empty plot
Empty plot
Empty plot
Church / Library / Theatre / Museum
Church / Library / Theatre / Museum
Church / Library / Theatre / Museum
Warehouse / Storage
Warehouse / Storage
Warehouse / Storage
Food / Drink / Entertainment
Food / Drink / Entertainment
Food / Drink / Entertainment
Clyde River
Clyde River
Clyde River
M8
M8
M8
8
7
20
5
7
7
Proposal Hotel
Proposal Warehouse
Analysis - Road network
Existing Road network
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal Road network
Analysis - cylce path
Existing Cycle path
Proposal Cycle path
LAND USE LEGEND Cylce path Roads Clyde River
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Analysis - Proposal road direction
Existing Road direction
Proposal Road direction
ROAD DIRECTION LEGEND One way West One way East One way South Two way Street One way North
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Analysis - Road crossings
Existing Road crossings
Proposal Road crossings
LAND USE LEGEND Road Crossings Public Zone Dockland Culture Green Space Clyde River M8
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
04
Proposal - OVERALL
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - OVERALL
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - OVERALL
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Digital Creativity
Mood Images
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Digital Creativity
Proposal - Food market
Existing site photo
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Urban Design
Industries Commercial
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Urban Design
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Creative Urban Practice
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Creative Urban Practice
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Creative Urban Practice
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Creative Urban Practice
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Urban Building
Concept SketchUp View
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Urban Building Historical Building Analysis
67 hope st. office
54-64 broomielaw, 5,9 oswald st. commercial
27-59 james watt st. warehouse
39-45 washington st. office and college
60-64 robertson st. commerical
38 Clyde place, commercial/manufacturing 60 james watt st. warehouse
mixed use residential
335-345 Argyle st. hotel
12 washington st. former public school
5,7 wellington st. corner tenement
56-64 kingston st. warehouse / showroom
15,17 hope st. commerical
mixed use residential
321-333 Argyl st. warehouse
1897 1854
1858
1863
1865
1870
1875
1878
1883
1889
1892 1893
1899 1900 1901 1902 1903
1896
43-47 hope st. atlantic chambers
361-371 Argyle st. commercial
27 washington st. Anderston rice mills
19-23 hope st. commercial
TYPE
EXISTING
WAREHOUSE MIXED USE
7
OFFICE
7
RESIDENTIAL
1
CULTURE
2
TOTAL
13
30
16 roberston st. Clyde Navigation Trust Office
11 Oswald st. storage
15-23 waterloo st. waterloo chambers commerical
40-60 wellington st. office
330-346 paisley rd. former kinston public halls library and polic office
69 James watt st. 74 York st. commercial atlantic apartment
316-336 argyle st. public house/hotel or section
43 Oswald st. commercial
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
340-344 Argyle st. office
30-46 washington st. warehouse / office
71-75 Roberston st. 33,35,41 Oswald st. office warehouse/office
Proposal - Urban Building
existing historical building land use
proposal historical building land use Public Pathway
Existing Typology Proposal Typology
TYPE
EXISTING
PROPOSAL
WAREHOUSE MIXED USE
6
n/a
13
16
OFFICE
8
6
RESIDENTIAL
1
4
CULTURE
2
4
30
30
TOTAL
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Urban Building Historical Building Analysis - AT RISK
67 hope st. office
54-64 broomielaw, 5,9 oswald st. commercial
27-59 james watt st. warehouse
ANT VAC
39-45 washington st. office and college
60-64 robertson st. commerical
38 Clyde place, commercial/manufacturing 60 james watt st. warehouse ANT VAC SALE FOR
335-345 Argyle st. hotel
12 washington st. former public school T PAR NCY PA CU OC
ANT VAC
56-64 kingston st. warehouse / showroom
5,7 wellington st. corner tenement
15,17 hope st. commerical
ANT VAC
321-333 Argyl st. warehouse
1897 1854
1858
1863
1865
1870
1875
1878
1883
1889
1892 1893
1899 1900 1901 1902 1903
1896
43-47 hope st. atlantic chambers
361-371 Argyle st. commercial
27 washington st. Anderston rice mills
19-23 hope st. commercial
WAREHOUSE OFFICE SCHOOL APARTMENT COMMERCIAL TOTAL
4 1 1 1 1 8
16 roberston st. Clyde Navigation Trust Office
11 Oswald st. storage
15-23 waterloo st. waterloo chambers commerical
40-60 wellington st. office
330-346 paisley rd. former kinston public halls library and polic office
69 James watt st. 74 York st. commercial atlantic apartment
ANT VAC
T PAR NT A C VA
43 Oswald st. commercial
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
340-344 Argyle st. office
316-336 argyle st. public house/hotel T PAR NT A C VA
30-46 washington st. warehouse / office
71-75 Roberston st. 33,35,41 Oswald st. office warehouse/office
Urban Building
Glasgow: City of Culture ?
Public Building in Broomielaw Saint Patrick's Primary School
Anderston Station
Glasgow CIty Mission: Christian charitable organisation
Cultural vitality is defined as the creation, participation in and supporting of arts and culture as a dimension of everyday life in communities.
25% Theatre
28%
32%
41% 55%
Libraries Live Music Museum
86%
Cinema
Figures show attendance (%) at cultural events, of Glaswegians took part in some kind of cultural activity
Data analysis - Cultural vitality is defined as the creatiion, participation in an supporting of arts and culture as a dimension of everyday life in communities. - Most popular cultural events and places in Glasgos as following: -1. Cinema 55% -2. Museum 41% -3. Live music 32% -4. Libraries 28% -5. Theatre 25% Conclusion There is only 1 Cinema / Theatre and 1 small public libarary in Broomielaw area, There is no any Museum , no any live music event in Broomielaw Area, our group will consider to use exiting vacant place to other public buildings, such as museum or cinema. Scale_1:5000 at A3 paper
Data resource: www.understandingglasgow.com BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Urban Building Proposal - Museum
60 james watt st. warehouse
Site Photo
Mood Images
Gallery & Mixed use
old Facade & new build
Courtyard
Museum & Mixed use Site photo
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Entrance
Courtyard
Proposal - Urban Building Concept SkethUp View
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Urban Building
39-45 washington st. office and college
Mood Images
43 Oswald st. retail
existing building with new on the top
old and new
Facade
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Urban Design
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Urban Design
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
Proposal - Urban Design
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
BROOMIELAW: THE PEOPLE’S DISTRICT Re-linking Broomielaw and Glasgow
THANK YOU 謝謝 σας ευχαριστώ Gracias