Research Design Concepts
Background  Differences Among Occupants  While readily visible distinctions are apparent (e.g. gender, age, etc.), many subtle
psychological, cultural, and social factors exist which may be extremely iimportant for the designer to consider but which cannot be readily identified. People have memories of past events, the baililty to learn, a cultural and biological heritage, and many other attributes which serve to distinguish individuals from one another.  For example, in the design of housing
for elderly people, bear in mind likely difficulties in walking , seeing, and hearing. These factors should be considered when planning illumination levels, passageways, emergency signals, and exists.
Background Personal and Cultural Differences – – – – – – – – – – – –
Age Gender Health Education Economic Status Social Status Nature of Employment Ethnic Heritage Previous Experience Expectations Motivations Attitudes.
Background  Hierarchy of Needs  One of the most
comprehensive and widely used schemes for defining user needs was developed by A. Maslow (psychologist), who treated human needs as an everchanging process. He assumes that complete satisfaction of needs is not possible because when one set of needs is satisfied, another one emerges.
Self Status Member of a group
Security
Food, Clothing, Shelter
Research and Design Concepts  Systems Analytic
Approaches  A system is an organized
arrangement in which each component part acts, reacts, or interacts in accordance with an overall design which adheres in the arrangement. It includes all equipment and associated personnel integrated to perform a defined task.
Research and Design Concepts  The Performance Approach  The performance concept is an
organized procedure or framework within which it is possible to state the desired attributes of a material component or system in order to fulfill the requirements of the intended user without regard to the specific means to be employed in achieving the results.  The user is considered the starting point of the design. The key to successful design is user satisfaction with the end product.
Research and Design Concepts The Performance Approach To accomplish the satisfaction of the user with
the end product we must: 1) Determine the nature of user requirements as
a prerequisite for design, and 2) Be able to evaluate buildings after occupancy
to determine whether the requirements were met.
Research and Design Concepts  Activities  Activities are a link between the
user and the physical environment. They can be considered as external manifestations of needs. They can be related to other activities and further analyzed into components. Activity descriptions enable one to identify relationships with design characteristics - at the scale of buildings and even communities, as well as at the scale of desired features of objects.
Research and Design Concepts  Analysis of Activities
Research and Design Concepts  Annotated Plan
Research and Design Concepts  Architectural Programming  The American Institute of Architects
(AIA) has defined architectural programming as the process by which criteria are developed for the design of a space, building, facility, physical environment, and for any unit of the environment. It is the means through which data about the needs of the ultimate building user are determined and expressed for the instruction of the architect in the development of a design solution.
Research and Design Concepts Architectural Programming Programming enables the owner’s needs to be defined and translated into
specific design instructions. Conflicts must be identified and resolved during the programming stage. The analyses and reports produced during programming are the basis for design. They are the link between the owner’s needs and the architect’s plans.
Research and Design Concepts Building Evaluation “Post occupancy evaluation is a means of learning how well the plan worked in practice and the extent to which the goals were achieved. “ (M. Brill, “Evaluating Buildings on a Performance Basis,” in Designing for Human Behavior: Architecture and the Behavioral Sciences, ed. J. Lang, Stroudsburg, 1974)
Evaluation of the completed projects - post occupancy or post construction
evaluations - is conducted for several reasons: – – – –
To modify or correct and existing building, To provide guidelines for future construction of the same building type, To evaluate programming criteria and design effectiveness, To provide data on how people use and respond to the built environment.
Evaluation must be an integral part of the total design process. A major difficulty with many evaluations is that they concentrate on general
attitudes and prefernces of respondents to environments, without adequately specifying the design characteristics of the building being evaluated.
Research Projects Research projects begin with a good definition of the research problem: – What do you know about the problem? – What do you want to know about the problem? – What do you want to do with the results? Then you commit yourself to a way of working: focusing on a particular
problem and deciding on the research design and setting that will solve your problem best. – What do you want to find out? – What design will give you useful information? – What setting will use your resources effectively?
Research Strategies Research Approaches – – – –
Diagnostic Descriptive Theoretical Action
Research Designs – Case study – Survey – Experiment
Research Settings – Natural – Contrived
Research Approaches  Diagnostic Studies  Diagnostic studies help you deepen your understanding of a setting: they
provide suggestive evidence on a broad realm. They offer insight into the structure and dynamics of a whole situation. For trustworthiness of findings, diagnostic studies rely on the consistency, clarity, and coherence of the insights they develop in the situation being studied. Researchers who want more precise measurements of particular attributes of a group or situation may carry out a descriptive study based on conceptual frameworks developed in diagnostic ones.  Example: The Urban Villagers
Research Approaches Descriptive Studies Descriptive studies describe and measure as precisely as possible one or more
characteristics and their relations in a defined group. Developing clear concepts and translating these into something that can be counted as a manifestation of the concept are particularly crucial problems in descriptive research. Example: Study of Fear Among Residents of the Pruitt-Igoe Housing Project in St. Louis
Research Approaches Theoretical Studies Theoretical studies set specific
hypotheses suggested by experiences elsewhere or primarily derived from more comprehensive theory. Such studies tend to increase general insights and to focus more on the conceptual framework of a problem than on the precise nature of the group they are observing. Example: Social Pressures in Informal groups
Research Approaches Action research Studies In action research studies changes are made and analyzed that have direct and
lasting consequences on people beyond those in the research project. Comparative action research settings may occur naturally or may be created analytically by careful sampling. Example: Twin Rivers New Town
Research Design  Case Study  Researchers use a case study design when they
want to develop intensive knowledge about one complex object. They are used to describe and diagnose single, internally complex objects: individuals, buildings, episodes, institutions, processes, societies.  A case study is appropriate when investigators are interested mainly in information specific to the particular study object and context, rather than information easily generalizable to a large population.
Research Design Survey A survey design is useful when
investigators want to find out in detail about a phenomenon, such as housing satisfaction, or about a class of elements. Survey researchers who study large populations often choose to gather data that are easy to quantify and therefore less time-consuming to analyze than qualitative data. For this reason frequent research methods used in surveys are mail questionnaires, observing physical traces, observing behavior, and interviews.
Research Design Experimental An experimental design is
appropriate when investigators want to measure the effects that an action has in a particular situation. In an experiment you want to be able to focus observation on a small number of attributes at one time. To do so, you need control, so that you can be as sure as possible that the effects you observe result from experimental changes. – Control group and Experiment group – Before and After the action
Research Design  Parametric Study  Parametric research
consists of the systematic manipulation of one variable (Independent), and making measurements on another variable (Dependent) though to be directly influenced by the independent variable, while keeping all other conditions constant by means of control variable
Research Design  Multivariant Study  In many situations, identifying one or even a
restricted set of variables is difficult - especially in the case of behavioral studies of building environments where many physical and personal factors are present.
Research Settings  Natural Settings  Natural settings offer researchers the unique
opportunity to observe people in settings they choose to come to, engaged in activities a contrived setting could not re-create. Natural settings are particularly appropriate for diagnostic studies in which investigators want to find out what is actually going on what elements, relationships, and dynamics are salient.  In natural settings you can also carry out an experiment, by manipulating a part of a physical environment, a particular social behavior, or a policy.
Research Settings  Contrived Settings  Contrived settings are planned and controlled research environments in which to
observe people and gather data from them. One such setting is the experimental laboratory, in which investigators control the setting, choose participants randomly, effect controlled changes, and measure some attribute of the subjects after those changes.
Research Evaluation  Validity  The validity of a measurement is concerned with
whether the property being measured is what should be measured - i.e., are we measuring the right thing?
Research Evaluation  Reliability  Reliability refers to
whether other researchers performing similar studies obtain equivalent results.
END