REWILDING SINGAPORE
NUS School of Design and Environment | Department of Architecture LA4701 MLA Studio Quarter, 9 Aug - 22 Nov 2019 Bargotra Poornima | Cheng Jing | Chin Carissa | Dhuri Ruiee | Feng Zihan Han Cong | Lim Wenfa | Lyu Jiawei | Rakholiya Ekta | Shao Zhongran Tanaka Mamiko | Wang Haobo | Xiao Xinyan | Zhang Bingqian | Zhang Bingyi Zhang Yifei | Zhong Yixin | Zhou Xianfeng |Zhou Zuyuan Tutors: Hwang Yun Hye | Endo Kenya
As a studio product which is not censored, it may contain mistakes or deficiencies, and proposed ideas may not represent the positions of NUS.
Published by CASA Centre of Advanced Studies in Architecture Department of Architecture School of Design and Environment National University of Singapore 4 Architecture Drive Singapore 117566 Tel: +65 65163452 Fax: +65 67793078
Copyright Š 2019 Hwang Yun Hye and Endo Kenya (ed.) ISBN: 978-981-14-4217-9
THE THIRD SERIES OF REWILDING SINGAPORE Hwang Yun Hye
REWILDING SINGAPORE studios pay attention to the ecological role of landscape architects in greening of Singapore beyond tidy appearance and maintainability. The series of studios began with an understanding of spatial and temporal characteristics of the primary tropical rain forest – one of the most complex and exuberant ecosystems in the world – made up 99% of our island just a century ago. In the context of the compact tropical city, massive urban developments, disrupted and disconnected urban ecosystems are not avoidable but the urban environment alternative design strategies integrating forest ecology into the built environment. IN THE STUDIO described in this book, 19 graduate students in the Landscape Architecture program, part of the National University of Singapore, worked to develop rewilding strategies for 12 landscape typologies within 1km radius of Central Catchment Nature Reserves (CCNR) over a 14-week period (Aug – Nov 2019). Work included preliminary research to understand theory eld trips to identify opportunities and challenges within the assigned typology, and design activities visualizing relevant concepts and operational systems. MANY THANKS to the following collaborators: Dr. Shawn Lum (Nature Society (Singapore)) who framed the studio at the initial stage and guided us in CCNR through multiple eld trips; Dr. Tan Puay Yok (NUS), Ms. Boo Chih Min (Camphora), Dr. Anuj Jain (BirdLife International) who provided fundamental understanding of the forest ecosystem of Singapore; Landscape architect, Ms. Evi Syariffudin, Ms. Liu Huei Lyn (PUB), Mr. Alfred Lee (STX), Mr. Ryan Shubin (RSD), and Mr. Tan Yit Chuan (NParks) for technical and practical advice to the projects; Dr. Jessica Diehl (NUS) and Dr. Ervine Lin (NUS) who gave guest criticism and offered valuable advice. THIS BOOK is a compilation of work from the studio. The first half of the book documents the sequential studio process with the studio chronology and the group’s site analysis to explain the context and motivate subsequent design topics. It goes on to describe eld trips and ends with design suggestions. 12 design outcomes appear in the second half of the book under the following headings: WILDLIFE MATRIX, COMMON GROUND, WILDING STREETSCAPE, CONNECTED LANDSCAPES, CLIMATE SENSITIVE TAGORE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, SHOPPING IN THE FOREST, MIMIC A FOREST EXPERIENCE, TEMPORAL CONNECTIONS, FRAMING TIMELINE, RECONCILED LANDSCAPE IN HDB, WILDLIFE IN THE YARDS, and REFLOWING NATURE. ections on the process. We hope the book will launch new discussions of alternative design approach of urban greening to address long-term ecological sustainability.
STUDIO INTRODUCTION CHRONOLOGY PRELIMINARY RESEARCH PROPOSALS REFLECTIONS
5
6
STUDIO INTRODUCTION Hwang Yun Hye and Endo Kenya
The tropical ecosystem is both highly diverse and structurally complex; 90 per cent of the world’s known species are found in the equatorial zone. The vibrant and exuberant landscape results from a combination of geological conditions, historical geography, complex interactions between abundant flora and fauna, and a humid climate [i]. In theory, a rich tropical rainforest can be grown from bare fertile soil within a century [ii]. From early Victorian naturalists to modern-day ecologists, investigators have highlighted the optimal tropical conditions of the Southeast Asian region for seed propagation and plant growth, and its complex interactions that result in an abundance and diversity of species. Yet this aspect of the landscape has been de-emphasized and underappreciated in the contemporary landscape architectural industry and practice of the region. St Situated 1° north of the equator, Singapore is a biodiversity hotspot despite its small size of 719.1 km2. In his documentation of Singapore’s history, Moore talks about the vivid, full-of-life landscape of the early twentieth century, when the vegetation growth seemed almost perceivable ‘in every single moment’ [iii]. However, the intended and unintended consequences of drastic land transformation during the periods of colonization and rapid economic development heavily eroded the coverage and diversity of greenery across the city-state [iv]. As a consequence, primary rainforest remains on only 0.16 per cent of the total land cover [v]. The ever-shrinking remaining secondary forest is also being usurped by swathes of manmade nature, which is highly engineered and heavily managed. Open lawns and single-tiered vegetation with biotic homogenization constitute the majority of urban greenery in Singapore. These tidy forms of greenery are the by-product of the deliberate greening policy established by the nation in the 1960s—the Garden City vision—which emphasized giving visitors and investors a clean and favourable impression of the country [vi]. Regrettably, with the loss of the biodiversity of the rainforests, ecological services have been heavily diminished, to the detriment of the city. Urban greenery has been noted, however, to have the capacity to be an important determinant of the ecology of a city [vii], and the utilization of urban greenery in this manner is essential in space-scarce, compact cities.
and ecological landscape.
m, is a means of restoring both the physical ven now, the cityscape is not as homogeneous as it may appear. Ingo
high biological richness occurs across a wide variety of novel ecosystems in cities ecological, environmental, and social values of urban wilds have been detailed in some studies and others note that wild greenery plays multiple roles in urban landscapes and is temporally and spatially dynamic e that as it may, the process of its creation is less documented and less accepted by the general public, given the current predisposition for manicured urban greenery ban space. Sites I Central Catchment Nature Reserve (CCNR) is selected as a "Landing" site and serves as a point of reference for all design activities ー sites selected should be inspired by findings from the forest/wetlands and its surrounding context. Students should choose his/her own site in one of green spaces typologies in Singapore, based on problem statements and topics arising during the research period, aided by the various design exercises and input sessions.
7
Design questions | How can we accumulate ecological value for existing urban green space aside from simply pledging areas for green? Can we be more actively involved in selecting more ecologically valuable landscapes through multiple scale analysis? Given the city’s development requirements, how could initial landscape planning be guided towards a more ecologically sustainable direction? Can landscape architects propose design prototypes that can infuse greater ecological functions and diversity into the urban context? How can design promote a healthier lifestyle that is closer to nature for city dwellers? The studio seeks to answer these questions by devising new strategies and design applications of ecological principles, predicated on deep awareness of the multi-faceted nature of our city landscape and the intricate feedbacks between social and ecological factors in the city. Design principles and approach | The studio aims to highlight the value of natural resources and ecological services, and propose ways to integrate them into our urban environments. We capitalize on the academic nature of the studio to develop ideas and schemes free of restrictions commonly faced in the practice, and beyond any constraints of political correctness. Multiple issues such as identity, multifunctionality, and livability will be examined. Students are also expected to develop their ability to read existing landscapes, to assess the environmental impact of design and planning decisions, and to convert their vision into a feasible landscape architectural form. In this studio, we also emphasize the importance of designing with reference to principles. Specifically, we look to the field of urban ecology to provide guidelines and tenets for formulating design strategies and proposals. As a starting point, we present a set ecological urbanism concepts and their design implications proposed by Spirn [xii]; Cities are habitats; Cities are ecosystems; Urban ecosystems are connected and dynamic; Every city has a deep structure or enduring context. However, these are not meant to serve as design restrictions and limitations, and students are encouraged to also read and reference other materials to guide their project Studio structure I This is the first studio in Master programme of Landscape Architecture with participants from fourth year in NUS architecture and graduates from other universities in bachelor of Landscape architecture or associated fields. The 14-week period consists of 3 weeks of preliminary research to understand site context, with in-depth input sessions from professionals and field trips to identify problems and challenges. The next 3 weeks are devoted to applied research activities (including site observation & measurements, interviews with residents and other relevant persons, and detailed mappings) to acquire relevant knowledge while building design strategies. The last 8 weeks focus on design application, which will culminate in a convincing design solution for the issues identified by the individual designers. A group of experts including ecologists from the Nature Society Singapore and National Parks Board, housing planners from URA, and NUS MLA lecturers will assist students in avoiding the pitfalls of shallow and superficial interventions in this academic exercise. Students will be tasked to work as individuals and in groups according to the requirements of each stage of the studio. Designers may end up with an individual project or small group projects after discussing with tutors.
8
There are two exercises; 1) Exercise 01_ Infographics of tropical forests: based on the given theory of urban ecology, translating your understanding of the scientific knowledge into artistic drawings of tropical forests Refer to what a Prussian geographer, Alexander von Humboldt did xiii . The knowledge must be based on published data and information. B/W, 1 A0 posters; 2) Exercise 02_Landscape typologies as potential design sites: collective understanding of various landscape typologies in terms of contexts, functions, and systems. There are two important reviews 1 Interim review to assign typology and to finalize issues 2 Final review to assess design tactics and development. Submission format and requirement will be announced prior to one week in advance of each submission
i Peter Shaw Ashton,
n the Forests of Tropical Asia Lest the Memory Fade Richmond Kew, 201 .
ii M. Poffenberger and B. McGean eds. , Communities and Forest Management in
ast Kalimantan Pathway to
nvironmental
Stability, Centre for Southeast Asia Studies, Research Network Report no. 3 (Berkeley, CA: University of California, 1993). iii
onald Moore and oanna Moore, The First 1 0 ears of Singapore
iv
eow Chin Wee and Richard Corlett, The City and the Forest Plant Life in Urban Singapore Singapore Singapore University
etroit
onald Moore Press, 1
.
Press, 1986). v Alex Thiam Koon ee et al., ‘The egetation of Singapore an Updated Map’, Gardens’ Bulletin Singapore
2 2011 , 20
212.
vi Neo Boon Siong, une Gwee, and Candy Mak, ‘Growing a City in a Garden’, in une Gwee ed. , Case Studies in Public Governance Building Institutions in Singapore (London: Routledge, 2012), 11– 64. vii Marina Alberti, ‘The ffects of Urban Patterns on cosystem Function’, International Regional Science Review 2 2 200 , 1 1 2 Mary L. Cadenasso and Steward T.A. Pickett, ‘Urban Principles for
cological Landscape
esign and Maintenance Scientific
Fundamentals’, Cities and the Environment (CATE) 1/2 (2008), 4–16. viii Ingo Kowarik, ‘Urban Wilderness Supply, emand, and Access’, Urban Forestry
Urban Greening 2
201 ,
.
ix Norbert K hn, ‘Intentions for the Unintentional Spontaneous egetation as the Basis for Innovative Planting esign in Urban Areas’, Journal of Landscape Architecture 1/2 (2006), 46–53; Peter Del Tredici, Wild Urban Plants of the Northeast (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2010); Michael McKinney, Ingo Kowarik, and Dave Kendal, ‘The Contribution of Wild Urban Ecosystems to Liveable Cities’, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 29 (2018), 334–335. x Caragh G. Threlfall and ave Kendal, ‘The istinct cological and Social Roles That Wild Spaces Play in Urban cosystems’, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 29 (2018), 348–356. xi
oanne
u Ting Khew, Makoto okohari, and Toshinori Tanaka, ‘Public Perceptions of Nature and Landscape Preference in
Singapore’, Human Ecology 42/6 (2014), 979–988. xii Spirn, Anne Whiston. ‘ cological urbanism A framework for the design of resilient cities 201 .’ The ecological design and planning reader. Island Press, Washington, DC, 2014. 557-571. xiii
on Humboldt, A.,
Bonpland, A. 2010 . ssay on the Geography of Plants. University of Chicago Press.
9
CHRONOLOGY 15 August-22 November 2019
The studio started off with the orientation of studio “Re-wilding Singapore” by tutor, Ms. Hwang Yun Hye, associate professor and Mr. Endo Kenya followed by intorduction to the entire semester’s schedule. Introductory seminar was provided by Dr. Tan Puay Yok throwing insights into vegetation cover and ecological networks in Singapore. This learning was further more enahnced by Ms. Boo Chih Min (Camphora) who provided us the in-depth understanding of Forest dynamics vs Manicured landscapes.
15 August Studio Orientation
19 August CCNR Orientation and Field Trip Dr. Anuj Jain provided insights into Biomimicry and gave a presentation on the Human and wildlife interactions followed by introduction of Ecological Design Projects by studio tutor. After the presentation, eld trip with Dr. Shawn Lum, President of the Nature Society Singapore, to learn more about forest ecology.
12
The students had a pin-up of their group works for the Exercise 01, presenting work-in-progress drawing of four major topics covering Topography & Soil, Habitat, Water - Nutirent Cycle and Human Activity.
26 August Exercise 01 pin ups & discussion
2 September Exercise 01 & 02 presentation The students had a pin-up of Exercise 01 presentation and Exercise 02 group screen presentation for the typology study.
13
14
15
The students spend time to have a longer discussion with studio tutors regarding project direction towards mid-review preparation.
9 September Issue & site selection presentation
16 September Mid-review preparation
In preparation for the upcoming mid-review,each studnet had a series of personal consultations with our tutor; which included typology studies, sites and design approach.
16
Four guest reviewers were invited for the Mid Review, namely, Dr. Anuj Jain (BirdLife International); Dr. Shawn Lum (Nature Society Singapore); landscape architect Ms. Evi Syariffudin; Dr. Tan Puay Yok, Dr. Ervine Lin (NUS) . The reviewers gave us advice in diverse aspects regarding our typology research, site selection and design approaches.
24 September Mid Review
30 September Site visit with the tutor We divided the design site of buffer area into two parts, and conducted site vist led by Ms. Hwang Yun Hye and Mr. Endo Kenya respectively
17
The groups shared their problem statements, design approach and physical model. This was followed by more in-depth site analysis being presented during each studio session. Each person or group was to come up with their individual problem statements with regards to the site and data gathered.
1 October-3 November Design development
4 November Interm review Each of students had a 5-mins presentation with site introduction (with models) and plans with overall plan (master plan), supportive materials and narrative. Some guest reviewers were invited to give technical and practical advice to the projects; Ms. Liu Huei Lyn (PUB), Mr. Ryan Shubin (RSD), and Mr. Alfred Lee (STX).
18
consultation.
5-21 November Individual consultation
22 November Final Review During the Final Review, 5 external reviewers were invited. They were Mr. Tan Yit Chuan (Nparks); Ms. Boo Chih Min (Camphora); Dr. Tan Puay Yok, Dr. Jessica Diehl, Dr. Ervine Lin (NUS).
19
20
21
INFOGRAPHIC OF TROPICAL FORESTS Based on the given theory of ecology, translating understanding o e scientific knowledge into interpretative drawings of tropical forests. Topics investigated into were Topography & Soil Habitats Water & Nutrient cycle Human activities
TOPOGRAPHY AND SOIL SOIL IN DIFFERENT FORESTS
Comparison Humidity
. .
.
.
Particle big small
Forests Condition Humus branch big leaf small leaf animal
3.near
t
p fores
n
ark(ma
gleaf p
5.sprin
4.swam
made)
t
y fores
primar
1
beige
very loose and can processed into any sh 3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
one hour later
24
2
one day later
1
muddy
5 Springleaf Nature Park
1 Carpark
2
4
3
Central Catchment Nature Reserve
est
ary for
econd
re s 2.matu
)
nmade
ark(ma
1.carp
Soil Analysis
branch, big leaf samll leaf animal
Texture
soil 2
black
3
dark brown
4
dark brown
5
brown Touch Sense
n't be hape
Upper Seletar Reservoir
loose and sticky can be processed into some shapes
Individual grains of sand are readily felt and seen
very loose and can't be processed into any shape
muddy
muddy
clean
muddy
tratification
form a wet block and can be processed into any shape
25
MICRO-ORGANISMS AND BACTERIAL COMMUNITY
26
27
SOIL AND TOPOGRAPHY FORMATION
Hindhede Quarry
Bukit Timah Hill
Riverbank
Flatland Forest
Topsoil thin topsoil Weathering slightly weathered Plant lithophytes Key factors human activities
Topsoil medium topsoil Weathering highly weathered Plant primary forest Key factors topography
Topsoil thick topsoil Weathering highly weathered Plant wetland manmade Key factors hydrology
Topsoil thick topsoil Weathering highly weathered Plant secondary forest Key factors organisms
Bukit Timah Hill
elev. 1
avg. depth m 42 m AMSL
m AMSL
Upper Peirce Reservoir
Upper Peirce Reservoir 30 m AMSL
Hindhede Quarry Singapore Quarry
Bukit T fault imah scarp km
0m
igneo us ro ck B km ukit T imah 2 km ring g granit ra e d es G C G I R omple esidu 1 km tely W al Soil GI GIII Highly eathere Mode d We Soil P surfa GII S rately Weathered rofile ce laye athere lightly r Weath e
Bukit
Tim
d l soil idua eathere Res w tely le p d Com there wea red line Highly athe e sync w ly d erate there Mod htly wea km Slig esh rock Fr km
Weath d e GI F red resh
topso il su paren tal m bsoil ateri bedro al ck
hori A horizon B horizon C horizon R horizon zon
ah G Age: ea ranite Rock rly to middle s: Tr Mine predominan iassic (250 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; ralog tly y: quar granite; gr 235 my) Textu anod tz re: med (3 ium to 0%), feldspar iorite, adam el coarse graine (60-65%), bi lite, and dior d, light ite ot grey bu ite & hornbl ende (< t somet 10 imes pi nkish %)
-10 m -20 m -30 m -40 m
0
line
antic 1 km
km
km 2 km ariati
100
on of
0 0
the th
ickne
0 0
ss of
layers
0 0 0 20 10 0
0-5
5-10
10-15 15-20 G I thi ckness G thi
20-25 ckness 25-30 epth to rockhe ad
30-35 m
>35
Se fault s letar tructu
re
Surfa
ce Ty
polog prima y seconry forest wetla dary fore waternd forest st
28
fauNee lt s Soo tru n ctu re
Seletar fault structure
LANDFORM AND HYDROLOGY CONTOUR LINE
SLOPE
HILLSHADE
CCNR 0-2% 2-5% 5-8% 8-15% 15-30% 30-60%
CCNR 11 0.5 0
23
4
contour line
11 0.5 0
23
4
254 11 0.5 0
23
0
4
NATURAL RIVER LANDFORM
Initial Stage downward erosion and traceability
Medium Stage(1945) Downward erosion
Maturity Stage(2019) Side erosion
RIVER
POND
GOLLY
MEANDER
PLAIN
HILL
ALLUVIAL PLAIN
DAM
an
on
ti
ra
i sp
Tr
DOWNSTREAM
re
he
sp
mo
at
SOIL SOILHORIZON HORIZON
r te wa or p va
<0.2cm
O Organic A Surface
MIDSTREAM
0.3-1m
ll
y
fa
in
ra
ar ll pi r ca te wa
B Subsoil
<1m
C Substratum R Bedrock
Underground water
y
it
av
gr
y
c
pi
co r
os gr hy wate
c
pi
co r
os gr hy wate
ar ll pi r te wa
UPSTREAM
ca
c
pi co r
os gr hy wate
l
na
io at it r te wa
av
gr
RIVER EROSION nd ou gr ter wa
bed load stream bed bed
WATER IN THE SOIL Hygroscopic Water Hygroscopic water pore
cohesion adhesion
MAN MADE RIVER LANDFORM
n a o nd soil particle na a a e o soil plants particle e n o e oe e ay
Capillary Water Capillary water adhesion
gravity
MATERIALS IN RIVER BANK COIR GEOTEXTILE
PILED STONE
BRUSH MATTRESS
GROUTED RUBBLE
ROOTED COMPOSITES
DRY RUBBLE
GARBION
ECOLOGICAL CONCRETE
CONCRETE
ECOLOGICAL BAG
water
e a a a e roots an a a
a n a e e o an ne o e ona
n
n o ae
a a ona aWater e Gravitational ee a e an e a o ed by plants d a n do n a d y into groundwater
WOODEN FRAME WALL
29
NUTRIENTS AND ELEMENTS IN FOREST SOIL
30
NEE SOON SWAMP FOREST NNSF hectares approx. Swampy area in NSSF: 0 hectares approx.
Species Distribution of streams in NSSF Richness
The NSSF is connected in the lower reaches two freshwater reservoirs Upper Seletar Reservoir and Lower Seletar Reservoir via spillways and canals, with the Upper Seletar Reservoir being the nearer reservoir.
MM U U L L L L 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 3
Upper Seletar
Lower 1
A water pipeline linking the Upper Seletar Resevoir with the Lower Peirce Reservoir also runs through the NSSF. The vegetation in the NSSF consists of primary forest as well as mature secondary forest , with the plant community being adapted to the waterlogged and hypoxic substrate present. Canopy cover is generally high, except at the edges of the NSSF where there has been greater human influence.
Lower 2 Lower
Mid 1 Mid 2
Mid 3
Upper1 Upper2 Upper Peirce
Streams Water supply pipeline Firing range
Lower Peirce
DRYLAND FOREST
SLOW-FLOWING STREAM
evelopment freshwater swamp forest
DRYLAND FOREST Canopy cover
Rainfall 1 Avifauna 2
2
Spill-over of floodwater from adjacent rivers and streams Primary freshwater fish
Reptile
2 1
Amphibians
PH . - . ;mean .2 Water supply pipeline Above ground peat Coarse-grained sand wood dust Organic matter leaf silty rocks
2 5cm Silt substances —
Distance to Reservoir —
epth
Water supply pipeline Below ground 3
Mineral soil
PH .0- .
Groundwater fluctuations 3
20-40m
Bedrock
Waterlogged and anoxic soil
Lake muds Thin layer of peat
Width
Underground water Distance to Reservoir —
Aquatic Species: Periodical Flooding: NNSF contains of the primary freshwater fish, 1 of amphibians, 1 rainfall 2 spill-over of floodwater from adjacent rivers and streams 2 of the reptiles and of the avian fauna of Singapore. Important species in terms of basal area were Pometia pinnata, 3 groundwater fluctuations Pala uiwn xanthochymum,Mangzfera griffithii, Gluta wallichii and Ph mesurement and Nutrients: Strombosia ceylanica. Corner Soil Composition: Coarse-grained sand; rganic matter leaf silty rocks peat wood dust.
Stream water and soil water lay in the range . - . , mean .2. With soil PH at cm depth to be lower, .0. . 31
HABITAT
PRIMARY AND SECONDARY FOREST Shorea spp.
@ M ACR
ITC
hii
wallic Gluta
HIE @ U PPE
R S ELE
p. nga sp Macara
e of undanc as An abtes suchs in Epiphyium nidusts Asplenary fore prim
TAR
oniaia Alstif ol angust
mosa dra duies Adinanon specnd ary Commin seco found forests
ande um gr
Syzygi
1819
y & bs densit High n of shru io variat
p. nga sp Macara
evecta teris Angiop evecta teris Angiop
Durio
PRI PRI MAR MEV ALY FOR SIN EST GAP N ORE PRE ATIV E
hyllea Anisop ha distic
inus
zibeth
m ppaceu ium la Nephel
tosum sarmen Piper
1960
1950
1900
DEV VE ELO GET PME ATI NT ON Mul SIN OF due to fortiple GAP leaves ition ORE emeest fl lay driedr decompos Usurgentoor,ers, lowes N A all la un com I E TRE rate y t yer der ple SET Ear ES: ree ! sto x s COV ly A rey tru s w NDADOMI Suc Art ngiop , c ctu ith ces RY NAT o ano re; WOO wa carputeris sio b i F p g y & DY lli s s eve OREED nal ger CL ch pp ct ST fru HUM SHRIMBERii, M ., Di a, An its AN UBS S: aca pte iso . Lat Str P & U Frey rang roca pter e L ANT Suc NDE cin a s rpu a m butuctur Adi E p e R s ce e an ti p. D F S S g tre les ally ORE ssion Bautum l elagiTnOREY:a sum, Shospp., istoca es. s d si hi at al el ST Ta atr rea Glu rp ABA Usu iver mila penDavalnia sifoli la wilcca iana v spp.,ta a, s a r N O i l t l e a l n lde te r dul ia mi um, y t y o to SED no gri sum um, de bifi Ar E ree f p Aba CON s w eme rimar ang ndo Pla ntic da v toca wii foliaatran NDD T L N r ith ge y f a ned , tyc ula ar. rpu ARP ellustifREES: n eri ta, se s d o t Y A s P r mal & A I lan ipt oli Ad est mib ada um FOT M D i l I a c i i t , A n e X i , a p c cor te fid h, RET C r f nop Nep OF BAND ation SHR a, R Cam andra STON ona ris a, Art OMMON h r y e u p h U FRU ONE its riu co Ble oca SPE Ram lium but lap borBS & odamnnosperdumos D . I m, nju chn rpu CIE K T, amp an p LAN nee UND ia a, m Pte gat um s r S: fru aceum a P u D c E L ng nsi RS in aur Als it rid a, ori igi ANT LE Pla s, TOR ere icu ton ium Mac ent dus ATI FT nta Ani EY: a, i Loo ON TO aquarangale, , Asp sop Ag Syzlatum,a & k ou & N REG tion ili a s Cal len hyl ros ygi ATI ROW num pp. oph ium lea tis um Litse natrubbet for VE g , P , M yll ni t a r r i dis ach an ve edi ter oli um dus SPE t d y t r e a s i e b nd is ner sp , B cha CIE exoes! Ale fr S ens ia l p., acca tic ui ifo ati Cya ure Dur spemix ts rmi fol the a p io o c s, ia, a l arv z f i Dur i es. Tae Op ate iflo ian bethi n b fru u nit hio ro ra, it s is glo sa, ble ssu chn m FRU oid es NepIT TR ORNheliuEES: camAMENTm la Duri companulAL Pppaceo zib segmutatata,LANTSum ethin uin um, Ag : S us, l p e, HelDiefafonemathod ea ico enb a nia ach Per spp ia of centa totSingage br al por eak lan e’s dow d a n Sou rea Bulrce: let Gar Veg in, den breetati Sin ’s gap andakdowon p e ore Sou BTNRn of rcent CCN age Socrce: R iet Nat y, ure Sin gap ore
PRIA TIM MAR E I Y & NE FORLS OF ESE TC SOND ARY
32
WA SEC ABA
NDO MAJNED ORI T
Abu molndanc easuccane ily a , k
TRE FalES: A leucatarca SHRcocepia PenUBS ha maxnise(tma imu um m
@ O LD
UPP
ER
THO
MSO
N
@ S PR
ING
F P AR
K
aria Falcat ana molucc Acacia is liform auricu
30m
gent
Emer
ted gmen st Fra Faotrcehes P
nds: Woodla ! Wasterst to go Fi
r
aye py L
10m
y & tore loor ers Und st F Fore
m
mu m maxi
ZOO CT & PRECIN fect MANDAIPMENT: could afdisrupt e is on DEVELO ti it uc r qual y,s and ra. Constr wate d specien levels an ground io ts vibrat habita d an noise
etum Pennis eum purpur
AST E W CON OOD DAR LAN Y F D ORE ST
LA TY ND IN OF EXOSMALL TIC FR SPE AGME e o CIE NTS f a) Al S kee Warnbizia p d ing (F ist : alc anc The ata e! y r breia ak aci a a m aur alaoluccicul i , a f ain Mim na, orm m ply exosa Leucis, urp oti pig aen ure c s ra a um, pec Pan ies) icu : m
r
Laye
ndarared to r the ore. secoco mp ant fo Singap gh it’s Althouspecies importally in ing”, right less still be, especi “green the lue ty n just choosing& add va ca iversi t y no od by it bi not is g is future divers CCNR mix of ldginfor thecreate a i w e of e a R gnin at can s du on is st ti si . re ta th de thus fo it s vege system specie The genuous,types ofention, forest. e ecos rv mo ie te to th t ho in mented en spec differhuman frag limits posed to a ex to ting ation ghly crea fragment& is hi it The ributionon. agment distn invasi to fr urba afford ot nn We ca r. furthe
20m
Cano
a use of e ical, therefor ies Histor tion nopy spece ca th planta in om ma fr the mnants re are
Panicu
nt YAYS EW y co they KA s, nerall forest on of TAKEy forestprs imge ary nservati co ain
LEA
ENRTE PREUSTU & F CCNR
of tion ca or lo ests al F er nm ei Gr ary P
FOR
EST
TYP
E
ABO
UT
IDE
NTI
FIC
KEY SPE
Timah Bukit Reserve Nature
CIE
ATI
S
ON
d mixe for lansercial/ m re p ea Futuing/coml r a houseationa in the son recrlopmenter Thom deveeen Upp betw to Line landCCNR s Is Crosthrough t cu
er uppetarir selervo res
rce pie r er voi lowreser
chie
MacRit
ED MENT FRFAOGRESTS
33
MAMMALS
34
35
FRESHWATER FISHES
Of the 8 000 or so freshwater species, over 1000 species are found in South East Asia, a very high density and richness by any standard. Of the many groups of fishes, only the bony fishes (as opposed to those with cartilaginous or â&#x20AC;&#x153;softâ&#x20AC;? bones like sharks and sting rays) are present in Singapore freshwaters. These fishes also have typical fins which have many spines and rays.
8000
freshwater species in the whole world
1000
freshwater species in South East Asia freshwater fishes present in Singapore
about 86
However, human activities have greatly affected the survival of aquatic animals. The introduction of alien species and the change of habitat environment brought by urban construction have led to the destruction of the numbers of the balance of species.
most of them living in
CCNR
Human Activities 9
10
About 10 kinds of animals
11
8
About 8 kinds of animals
7
About 86 kinds of animals 5
6 4
About 30 kinds of animals
2
1
About 30 kinds of animals 3
seconderyconsumers
tertiar consumers
Number of species
primar consumers
phytoplankton
normally situation
(The closer you get to the top the number of species decreas (The Species Numbers began and become unstable)
bacteria
producers decomposer & detritus feeders
36
When one of the var
seconderybacteria producers consumers tertiar conprimar phytodecomposer & sumers consumers plankton detritus feeders
Before 1900
Dissolved oxygen levels in water depend, in part, on the chemical, physical and biochemical activities occurring in the water. Oxygen has a limited solubility in water directly related to atmospheric pressure and inversely related to water temperature and salinity.
1940
canalization
1990
pollution
2019
poaching
competition from introduced non-natives
habitat-loss
theimpoundment of streams
large standing bodies of water
s
Before 1984
2019
Human
NP
Temperature
of the food chain, ses step by step)
riables changes to fluctuate
Nitrogen and Air Pressure phosphorus content in water
O2
Water dissolved oxygen
Large amphibian, carnivorous fish Died Fish
Therefore, humans should seek better ways to improve fish habitat to ensure the balance of species in the ecosystem, such as increasing the number of protected habitats, reshaping the wild and original habitat environment and finding scientific ways to reduce the impact of human activities on the ecosystem through scientific predation and planned human intervention
Shrimp, small fish
decomposer & detritus feeders & producers
Source: https://www.nparks.gov.sg/biodiversity/wildlife-in-singapore/species-list/freshwater-fish 37 ESSAYS IN Z OOLOGY, by Chou Loke Ming & Peter K. l. Ng Local geographic range predicts freshwater fish,by Xingli Giam 1 *, Ting Hui Ng 2 , Alvin F. S. L. Lok 2 and Heok Hee Ng
BIRDS .
es
c pa . ce ies s ur t so ctivi rs. d o a at oo r f ying red nt. p se fl oi d es re tp - L imite natu res d L e or e an - M om -H
Prim
ary
For
est
1 2 bird species
Ma
cRit
chie
Diets - Fishes
Straw-Headed BulBul
Critically endangered
Crimson Sunbird
Common resident Rare resident
Brown-Chested ungle Flycatcher
Greater Racket-Tailed
rongo
ulnerable Migratory species
Rare resident
Diets - Nectar
Home
38
-R - M ich - L ore in fo Mac e ss flyin od s Ritc h o na g tu a ur ie c c P e r t e ar pre ivitie . k da s s tor pa s. ces .
ver the last 0 years, 1 2 species of birds have been recorded within the MacRitchie reservoir Forest. These make up of the total species recorded within central catchment nature reserves. ut of these 1 2 species, species are known to be nationally threatened. f these, the Brown-chested jungle Flycatcher is classified in The Singapore Red ata Book 200 as “vulnerable” U , 11 as “endangered N” and 2 as “critically endangered CR ”. The Straw-headed Bulbul being one of the twentyfive CR species is in the last stage prior to extinction.
Habitat - Primary Secondary for - Wooded areas
voir Park
Blue- ared Kingfisher
Parks Gardens Mac
Ritc
hie
Sec
ond
ary
Wetlands
Forests For
est
Forest ependent 21 bird species 36 Nationally threatened
MacRitchie Forest 1 2 bird species
CCNR 222 Bird Species Habitat - Parks and Gardens - Cultivated areas
ther parts of CCNR 0 bird species
Habitat - Moist lowland forest - Mangrove forest - Small streams Diets - Forest insects
ture Park
Windsor Na Diets chain
glea
Spri n ture
f Na Park
Diets - Forest berries - Fruits Distribution chain
U
r
ta
el e
pp er S
rest
Re se rv ar k
rP
oi
0 bird species Ch
est
The Blue-eared Kingfisher and the Greater racket-tailed rongo are two of the local rare resident species to be looked out for in CCNR. Common resident species such as the Crimson Sunbird is informally nominated by nature lovers as the national bird of Singapore since 2002, which can also be found in CCNR as well.
39
nu
tN
atu
re
Pa
rk
Lower Peirce Rese
WATER AND NUTRIANT CYCLE NUTRIANT CYCLE
Cycling nutrients include inorganic mineral salts from rocks and atmosphere. Inorganic salts will be absorbed turned back to inorganic salts by decomposers. From forest to urban vegetation, cycles are similar but the sp secondary forest are slower, leaving more leaf litter. In grassland and urban vegetation, leaves and nutrients
Legend Nitrogen Fixing Plants Leaf Litter Water Reservoir, Swamp, Stream Soil Layers Nutrient Flows
40
d by roots, cycling through the food chain,from plant to animals,then to dead organic material, and finally peed decreases. Cyclings in primary forest are fast, leaving less leaf litter and nutrients in soil. Cycling in will be carried away by wind and drainage, leading to nutrient lost and thinner cycling than forest.
41
GRASSLAND
EVAPORATION
SOIL
Evaporation is a type of vaporization that occurs on a liquid as it changes into the gas phase.
SURFACE RUNOFF
The vegetation transpiration in grassland is very small. The grass there has very short roots, which absorb so little water from the soil. And the infiltration here is 0.07.32s per 100ml water.
Surface runoff (also known as overland flow) is the flow of water that occurs when excess stormwater, meltwater, or other sources flow over the Earth's surface.
LEAVES
6.5CM
10CM
MANMADE GRASSLAND
MANMADE GRASSLAND
Leaves in grassland are usually very small, which can cause interception losses and transpiration become very small
SECONDARY FOREST SOIL
LEAVES
S
S
S
S
15.6CM
32CM
13.3CM
36CM
INFILTRATION
10.6CM PIONEER SECONDARY FOREST
4.4CM
9CM MATURE SECONDARY FOREST
5.6CM
Infiltration is the process by which water on the ground surface enters the soil. It is commonly used in both hydrology and soil sciences. The infiltration capacity is defined as the maximum rate of infiltration.
BASIC INFORMATION Fundamental analysis
Section
Changes during the peroid
The Cen Reserveis in Singa hectares in the ge city, it ho sites, inc the Nigh Safari, a facilities appreciat the HSBC The nat catchmen reservoi reservoi Seletar, Pe i rc e a reserve. S oot ng ange Chestnut Avenue Water Works
42
ppe Selata mp ng Stat on
Kallang Service Reservoir
Condensation is the change of the physical state of matter from the gas phase into the liquid phase, and is the reverse of vaporization.
TRANSPIRATION FROM VEGETATION Condensation is the change of the physical state of matter from the gas phase into the liquid phase, and is the reverse of vaporization.
PRIMARY SWAMP
LEAVES
PRECIPITATION TO LAND
precipitation is any product of the condensation of atmospheric water vapour that falls under gravity. .
35CM
ntral Catchment Nature s the largest nature reserve apore, occupying 2880 Forming a large green lung eographical centre of the ouses several recreational cluding the Singapore Zoo, ht Safari and the River as well as several newer built to encourage public tion of the reserve, such as C TreeTop Walk. t u re re s e r v e a c t s a s a nt area for the surrounding irs. The country's main irs â&#x20AC;&#x201C; MacRitchie, Upper Upper Peirce and Lower a re l o cate d w i t h i n t h e
WATER CYCLE
CONDENSATION
n the surface of
20CM PRIMARY SWAMP
SOIL
PRIMARY SWAMP FOREST 0.28.01
Water Flow Analysis This is the water flow simulation in 18 years,mainly shows the water changes during the peroid. As the topography is very flat, the water changes is very slow.
1month
2month
3month
4month
5month
6month
7month
8month
9month
10month
11month
12month
13month
14month
15month
16month
17month
18month
43
PLANT SUCCESSION
44
45
MICROCLIMATE Cause Of Microclimate 1.Canopy
.Soil Type The impact of soil type on microclimate is mainly reflected in the difference in soil moisture and water absorption, which leads to the impact on humidity.
The different openness of canopy in different part of the primary forest influence the passing rate of light, rainfall and wind, which influence the reflection of microclimate like tempeture, photon flux density, humidity, and wind speed.
Light, rainfall,wind
Pass by
Weaken
Intercept
Precipitation
Water amount
vaporation
Storage
2.Topogrpphy The influence of topography on the microclimate is mainly reflected in the change of wind direction and speed, which leads to the impact on humidity and tempeture. Wind direction
Wind speed
.Water body The influence of water body on the microclimate is mainly reflected in absorbing the light and heat from canopy and evaporating water vapor, which leads to the impact on humidity and tempeture. Light
vaporation
Effect On Forest The microclimate formed by different regions affects the species, growth and density of trees.
Moisture
Moisture
Less density More big arbors
Dense shrub More Biomass
Observation Data Of Microclimate
More herbs Complicated canopy
Less density More arbors
Less new-growth More herbs Complicated canopy
The data from primary forest are significantly different from the disturbed and the temperature rises extremely uickly within minutes in the disturbed area, while the humidity drops rapidly. The edge is cooler and drier than the interior. The valley is hotter than the hill and has a high humidity. It is the wettest area in the lowland forest. As the distance from the water increases, the temperature rises and humidity decreases.
46
HUMAN ACTIVITIES
DISSERVICES OF TROPICAL FORESTS
47
HISTORY AND CULTURE OF FORESTS
The anti uity of human occupation of Singapore is unknown but there is considerable evidence for a significant settlement before the rise of Temasik at the mouth of the Singapore River. Temasik and its predecessors were probably largely coastal trading settlements with little impact on the forested interior of the island.
1200s
1300s
At the end of the 13th century, the Palembang prince Sri Tri Buana was on an expedition in Bentan Bintan when he spotted the white sandy coast of Temasik from a distance. He decided to relocate here and rename the island Singapura.
Singapore signed the Convention on Biological iversity along with 1 2 other countries to reaffirm its stand on the protection of animal and plant life.
1992
1400s
1819
1821
1846
After Temasik’s decline, some sort of
Many Malaccans followed William Far uhar when he moved here. The British ast India Company brought prisoners to build local infrastructure. Therefore, diverse peoples from around the region and beyond came
settlement seems to have survived.
together.
The Garden City plan aimed to transform Singapore into a clean and green city. In subse uent years, thousands of trees and shrubs were planted throughout the island, not only including nature reserves, bot also in built-up areas and along roads.
1972
1967
In 1972, the Ministry of Environment was formed for the express task of creating a clean environment for the people. Singapore was one of the first few countries at the time with a ministry dedicated to environmental matters.
48
There were also populations of riverine boat-dwellers in the Kallang and Seletar estuaries, and perhaps elsewhere around the coast. These people grew no crops but must have had some impact on the forest products for subsistence and trade. Pre- uropean human occupation may have contributed to the extinction of large vertebrates in Singapore but significant deforestation is unlikely.
Stamford Raffles and his entourage landed on the island,the island was almost entirely covered in rain forest, with a flora similar to the adjacent Malay Peninsula but a relatively depauperate vertebrate fauna.
The outlook of forest reserves in Singapore improved when control of the Bukit Timah reserve was given back to the Botanic Gardens to ensure its conservation. In the following year, mangrove forests at Kranji and Pandan were gazetted as forest reserves.
1942
1938
Bukit Timah reserve suffered severe damage during the apanese invasion of Singapore. The ensuing battle troops left its toll on the reserve trenches and caves were excavated, trees were felled, and mortar shells were strewn all over.
1936
Bukit Timah had become Singapore’s only forest reserve when the government decided to revoke all the other forest reserves, citing the afforestation efforts as “unjustifiable”.
Much of the primary forest was lost to indiscriminate deforestation. nce removed, primary vegetation is lost forever as it cannot regenerate on cleared land. ver time, much of the cleared land became overgrown with lalang, a weed that was very difficult to rid of. By 1 , it was reported that some 45,000 acres of land in Singapore had been abandoned.
A forest report commissioned that put together by Nathaniel Cantley, reported the “extensive deforestation” and“no sufficient attempts have been made to conserve the forest lands”.
1859
1883
1849
Along with the boom in trade, cultivation of cash crops for export also took off.Gambier and pepper, proved to be the most economically viable crops in Singapore. Thus their cultivation flourished due to an increasing demand for gambier by the dyeing and tanning industries, which had a detrimental effect on the primary forest.
1879
1886
Most of Cantley’s recommendations had been implemented. A total of 12 reserves were demarcated Blukang, Murai, Kranji, Selitar, Ang Mo Kio, Changi, Bukit Panjang, Military, Chan Chu Kang, Mandai, Sambawang, Bukit Timah, Pandan and urong.
There was no attempt to control the rate of deforestation yet. ohn F.A. McNair conducted a survey on the state of the timber forests in the Str aits Settlements. McNair s 1 report described the dismal scene in Singapore diminishing timber trees, indiscriminate deforestation, and an absence of legislation for forest protection.
Generations of human activity on the island have wreaked disastrous conse uences on the native fauna.
The objectives of the forest reserves were not for commercial exploitation but for absolute protection to provied areas for research, education, recrration and as samples of the country s biographic history and heritage. And this remained as the guiding policy of nature conservation to present times.
1935
The government paid heed based on Cantley’s recommendations, eight forest reserves, totalling about 8,000 acres, were carved up.
Land from the Seletar, Changi, Pandan and Bukit Timah reserves were used for the cultivation of vegetables. Part of the Changi reserve was also sacrificed for the construction of a naval base. Land was cleared from Sembawang and Mandai reserves for military purposes.
1930
1927
Having lost their natural source of prey and the protection of thick forest cover, tigers ventured into the plantations and attacked workers. In response, the government offered rewards for the capture of tigers. The tiger population had shrunk drastically. The last wild tiger was shot in Singapore in 1 0.
The Wild Animals and Birds Protection rdinance was founded.Apart from the protection of birds, the new legislation prohibited the killing and capture of wild animals.
1909
The Forest Ordinance enacted
which made it an offence to “trespass, pasture cattle and cut, collect or remove any forest produce” from a reserve. Unfortunately, it was not effective in preventing further exploitation.
1904
1895
The control of the reserves was transferred from the Botanic Gardens to the Land ffice, which neglected the reserves even further as they were deemed unprofitable. ven with their protected status, the reserves suffered from further deforestation in the following decades.
49
CULTIVATED CULTIVATEDLANDSCAPES LANDSCAPESIN INFORESTS FORESTS
Tre e
AC
Le Ac uc ac nih Falc aena ia au r ot a ca taria leuco iculif rth o ag mol ceph rmis en uc ala c es is ana ss p
Ma
Ar
Tre e
Gn
etu
Sp
He My vea ris tic brasi af rag liens ran is s
ec
ies
Sh
Im
pe
Sh
rub
sS
toc
rub
rat
ac
sS
pe
cie
ylin Ana dri nas ca (L. com ) B os ea us uv.
s
Un c Pi aria ga M per Ind anih sarm mbir i g Ela ofe ot es ento Rox b. eis cu s ra gu tinc lent um ine a t en oria sis
EV
OL
pe
m
Tre e
arp
Sp
ec
Fruit Trees Orchard
ec
us Ne he t Ba phe Ave rrh erop liu cc em aure m lap oa b hyllu am s on pa ilim b c va o r. g tley eum i a ne mo na n
gn
Sp
ies
ies
Sh
rub
Dic
ran
sS
pe
op Sm teris ila x s linea eto ris sa
cie
s
Rubber Plantation
UT
cie
IO
s
N
OF
Pineapple Plantation
Food Crops
PL
Productive Landscape
AN
TA TIO
PI N
N
EA
PL
OT
S
P PL E
P TA
IO C A -G
am
c pep ult per
Played an important role in sustaining estate owners, generally harvested 18 months after planting.
r gr
ow
s
CU The plant re uires a minimum of 1 years for deplected soil nutrients to recover.
50
bie
LT IVA TIO
NT
IM
EL
CK
F R UIT
A vast number of uses not just producing fruits. The leaves serves as traditional herbal medicine and the tree’s durable timber is a valuable commodity.
Poor Soil Conditions
Invasive shrubs species
NU
Forest Clearings
TM
EG
The “nutmeg canker” disease caused the nutmeg fruits to wither before they ripened, demise of nutmeg cultivation.
U M B TA N
RA
xotic Tree Species
Hainan Village Red-breasted parakeets were observed feeding on the ripe fruits of a rambutan, consuming only the seeds.
Nutmeg Trees Rambutan Plantation La
te
a Sec ex band ond oti c s one ary fo pe d a ve pr cie gri rest lon actic rexp cu tha s lo ge e ltu r s s re itati ral t hav du on up lan e b ce po o d, e f s rt e u are en r ffe the s nsus oft ege cti o t il f ain en n ve e a pro rtil do erate b mi du ity le ag -L na d on t cti ted inc abou on o lev ricu lud l r els tur by es ers in -H tha al la Ha the ain in t n an an co d rub -A u V V ld illa illa ber nam well g g n p e is e lan o ed -kno tatio ‘Sil wn loc -S ly F ha ate oon ns da un ina set afte lon Ga nes tled r, th gU rde e m into eg n’ ppe an villa ard r Th bou en ges ght om wa wh son - Th the sc ich nat e la onv Ro lan ura te a d e d rted and l ru x fro -R to a bbe m buil of S ubb t r. da he Ra ing er p Ru mb gar apo lan bbe uta den re’s tatio np r Tr exp Gamb lan ee eco ns b and ier t is a e n pro tion ed om cam the -A d a y r gra eas ma fter uctio in 1 e la sse w in s the 903 rge n s ith a our sca intr decli ce ban odu ned le a of c don ctio n r d a om ed turn n o pidly -C me p f ca ed lan and rcia in ash c t in n a nin l to a tion the apo rop g re a s w we ma in 1 pro - La r e d jo e in 888 uc fter re r pa t tiva rge pa intr v io it ade rt no odu tion tch e c d f a r pin by of g es o e a ced a eap sec am f for si nd p ple ond bie est nifi lan s ary r w we can ta hic re s t io h t h w cle rub trad n a sb a a g or in est s u red sua to por ricultu on virg t re t lly ma gro ke ook in s wn way oil, off in a fo new in sso r the ly c cia sh lea tion iftin red wit g fore h st
Mi
d1
0s
Grassland
arl
y1
0s
Ind
us
1
0s
Ag
ric
ult
ure
Ca
sh
Cr
tria
l
ev
elo
pm
Hu
ma
nH
ab
ita
1
0s
Ab
an
do
ne
dL
an
d
tio
n
en
t
op
s
LIN
E
51
SCENIC VIEWS IN FORESTS
52
53
LEARNING FROM FOREST
REWILDING SINGAPORE
What Can We Learn From Nature ?
Singapore is a city garden which has a large amount of green designs. However, how many of them are actually useful for education What Can We Learn From Nature ducation is not only about indoor class, meanwhile, it not only targets young is a city garden could whichbe hasany a large amount of green designs. people.Singapore The teaching materials element in our forests, from leaves However, to differenthow types of trees, animals to cultivation lands. All ages have many of them are actually useful for education? the opportunities lesson. Educationtoistake notthis only about indoor class, meanwhile, it not only
?
targets young people. The teaching materials could be any element in our forests, from leaves to different types of trees, animals to cultivation lands. All ages have the opportunities to take this lesson.
JU ST
4F UN
4 yrs old Visits the forest on a field trip and plays in tree pods
54
JUST 4 UNDE
32 yrs old with 2 yrs old Attend the workshop about flora
74 yrs old Volunteers in the docent walk about disturance history during weekends
ERSTAND
secondary forest
JU
ST
4
M
ER
M
primary forest
O
R
IZ
E
CREDIT TO: XIAO Xinyan
55
LANDSCAPE TYPOLOGIES E
and iss
a e y oo e in d n i yin
s
ee
d ed y e o o n e o n e a on
d y un i n u
ys
i s y ana y in and n
n and
uni i s und s andin si
d issu s is
i din y d ns
URBAN PARKS • Use Size Shape vegetation density Physical features with urban fabric Immediate context Proximity to nature Physical features with urban fabric • Fragmentation Management practice • Time analysis Soil permiability • Issue statement
Legends Playgrounds 1Km Buffer Zone Golf Course All parks around CCNR URA SubZone
COMMERCIAL AREA COMMERCIAL AREA
Vegatation
Fajar Shopping Center
Green Ridge Shopping Center
Biodiversity
Bukit Panjang Hawker
Thomson Plaza
Upper Thomson Road South
Upper Thomson Road North
58
DEGRADED FOREST
Legends CCNR Site Boundary Building Abandoned Land Waste Woodland Forest Park Areas
N
Approx. 1km buffer away from CCNR, larger buffer patch for restoration
Less than 0. km buffer between the abandoned land and CCNR
CCNR Site Boundary
N
59
UNDERUTILIZED BUILT STRUCTURE Urban urban simplicity open
Greenland & urban complexity closed
Greenland & greenland simplicity open
0
0.
0.
1.2 km
Major roads Minor roads Parks Hydrology
Surrounding context
60
Vegetation density
Morphology Underpass context
Structure
Surrounding context
Vegetation density
Morphology Underpass context Structure
1
8
Bukit Panjang, BLK 436 Fajar 1. 20 , 10 .
Bishan, Ang Mo Kio Avenue 1 2 1. , 10 . 2
2
1.1 ha
. ha
2
Bukit Panjang, Bishan, BLK 2 1 Bangkit Sin Ming Avenue 1. 020 , 10 . 0 0 1. 0 , 10 . 1
Mostly large reserved sites with no public housing
0.
Upper Seletar Reservoir Sungei Kadut
9
ha
3
Sembawang
Bishan, Sin Ming Dr 1. 1 , 10 .
. ha
1
.
4
3
1.1 ha
5
5
7 Upper Pierce Reservoir
12
Dairy Farm, Almond Avenue 1. 0 , 10 .
8
1.
BISHAN & BRADDELL
9
ha, 1.
Bishan, Marymount Road 21 1. 1 , 10 . 01
ha
6 Dairy Farm, Petir Road 1. , 10 .
10
.2 ha
11 Macritchie Reservoir Bukit Timah
12 13
14
3
unused pocket green
13 Braddel, Braddel Road 1. 2 1 , 10 .
2
.2 ha, .1 ha
vacant land
7
14 Bishan, Ang Mo Kio Avenue 1 Braddel, 1. , 10 . 2 Thomson Road 1. 0 0, 10 . .2 ha 1.2 ha
1
patches of forested area Bukit Brown
2
0. ha, 1. ha
potential to create a network
SIZE
Large forested areas with mainly landed properties
1
ha
11
0. 0 ha
6
0
close to public housing
Bukit Panjang, Bishan, BLK 229 Pending Upper Thomson Road 1. 0, 10 . 1 10 1. 0 22, 10 .
2 4
public transport connectivity
10
Bukit Panjang, Blk 2 Bangkit 1. 21 , 10 .
BUKIT PAN ANG & DAIRY FARM
Proximity to CCNR
0. 0 ha
TYPOLOGY
Industrial area with low transport walking connectivity
CRITERIA
UNUSED OPEN SPACES
0. 0ha - 1ha 1ha - 4ha 4ha - 10ha
km
COMMON SPACE IN RESIDENTIAL AREA types of residential areas: Landed properties • Single household units • Privacy • Yards and fences used to dmarcate the house from the public streets H B flats high population density open parking lots • shared activity space accessible for public Condominiums
Comprehensive set of facilities and greenery • Accessible only for owners
61
WATER AND DRAINAGE
A Natural | Soft | Natural Lakeside | Permeable | Full Cycle
62
B Manual | Soft and Hard | Urban Vegetatio
A. Natural | Soft | Deep in Forest
B. Natural | Soft | High Accessibility to Water | Low impermeability
D. Manual | Soft & hard | Midium accessibility to water | Midium impermeability
C. Manual | Soft | High accessibility to water | Low impermeE. Manual | Hard | Midium accessibility to water| Midium impermeability
F. Manual | Hard | Low accessibility to water | High impermeability
F. Manual | Hard | Low accessibility to water | High imperme-
on | Semi-Permeable | Impeded
C Manual | Hard | Urban Vegetation | Impermeable | Severely Impeded
63
STREETSCAPE
BUKIT PANJANG RD & BKE
Petir Rd & D Rd & PCN
64
Daity farm
65
PROPOSALS Chin Carissa, Dhuri Ruiee P69 _
Rakholiya Ekta P
Cheng Jing, Lyu Jiawei P112 Feng Zihan, Zhou Zuyuan P1 Han Cong, Zhou Xianfeng P1 Zhang Yifei P210 ao
nyan
a o a oo n
a
en a ao on an
ao o
n an
an n y
on an n ana a
an a
o
68
WILDLIFE MATRIX
INJECTING BIODIVERSE HABITATS INTO DEGRADED LANDSCAPES Carissa Chin, Ruiee Dhuri
While the existing Central Catchment Nature Reserve (CCNR) forms the largest nature reserve in the geographical centre of Singaporeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s mainland, the forested areas along the periphery of it are fragmented, resulting in multiple disturbed habitats as remnants of abandoned cultivations. How can landscape architects reconfigure this forest structure into a resilient and biodiverse habitats The primary intent is to investigate and chalk out possible future scenarios at conserving and enhancing the ecological richness of these patches of degraded forests within an area of 130 Hectare, while creating interactive canvases for different user groups including fauna, to benefit from. For fauna specifically, it is done by injecting relevant plant species to mimic or create habitats for the targeted wildlife. For humans, it is done by creating experimental inserts that magnify the habitat experience of the animal. These sites of intervention are bound together by grounded and arboreal connections, for all user groups, by means of planting as well as built structures. The sites exist within the upper Thomson nature park and along the Tagore drive, towards the upcoming MRT station. With the CCNR on one side of the site and the Tagore industrial estate on the other, it makes for an interesting balance of challenges; both natural and urban. For the three different sites, the primary guiding approaches for design are on the basis of projected human activity and targeted fauna species. The project aims at primarily restoring the ecological state of the landscape and then magnifying the experience of animal habitats for humans to engage and learn from. At a larger scale, it is envisioned that such fragments of degraded forests, with specific approaches and interventions, create sanctuaries for biodiversity as well as provide interactive spaces for the community island wide
DEGRADED FOREST Timeline
• Forest
• Forest • Cultivation • Residential
• Forest • Cultivation • Residential
• • • • •
Forest Residential Commercial Industrial Transport
• • • • • • •
Forest Residential Commercial Industrial Parks Sports & Recreation Reserved
• • • • • • • •
Forest Residential Commercial Industrial Parks Sports & Recreation Reserved Utility
Patches of Degraded Forest
151 Ha. of degraded forest patch. Approx. 1km buffer away from CCNR
Proposed buffer parks as a part of the Forest Restoration Action Plan by NParks
0
70
1
2KM
PERIPHERY STUDY
Central Catchment Nature Reserve
• Larger cohesive patch of degraded forest on the CCNR buffer. • Located on the water systems network connecting Lower Seletar Reservoir to CCNR
• Multiple patches of low vegetation index within a densely forested area • Located on the periphery of CCNR, surrounded by built areas that create a disconnect within the patches of dense vegetation
• Relatively lower density of population resulting in lower disturbance • MRT cutting through indicating potential future projections for development • Forms the urban interface of forested area putting it under threat of future developments
20 YEARS LATER
1 What Could...
Legend Reserve Site
Legend Residential
Legend Reserve Site
Legend Park
2 What If
0
1
2KM
Existing vs Interventions Land use
71
DESIGN APPROACH
Food Source Types and Plant Conditions
Habitat Potential Map
Cultivated Species
Remnants of plantation tree species + Invasive exotic plant species
Legend: Habitat Potential Map Palm Civet
Intermixed Pioneer Species Existing Soil Conditions
Topsoil Residual Soil Weathered Soil Granite Bedrock
N
I
IST
EX
NG
S
ON
ITI
ND
CO
Barriers for Fauna Movement
High rise Buildings Low rise Buildings
VISUAL
Legend: Habitat Potential Map Sunda Pangolin
Roads Fencing
N Human Activity
Source : Ecological network by ABDUL RAHIM BIN ABDUL HAMID Thesis Paper 72
PHYSICAL Physical and visual barriers
Canals
DESIGN APPROACH Existing Site Sections
CANOPY (30M) UNDERSTORY (17M) SHRUBS (5M)
Secondary 2 Lane Forest Road Scale 1:750
EMERGENT (>40M)
Abandoned Forest land (Old Palm Plantation)
Secondary Abandoned Forest land (Old Palm Plantation) Forest
CANOPY (30M) UNDERSTORY (17M) SHRUBS (5M)
Waste Woodlands
2 Lane Roadside Road Planting & Pathway
Scale 1:750 EMERGENT (>40M)
Existing Industrial Building (4 Storey)
CANOPY (30M) UNDERSTORY (17M) SHRUBS (5M)
Pathway 4 Lane 2m Road Scale 1:750
3 Lane Pathway Road 2m
Pathway 3m
Open Lawn
Waste Woodlands
SITE ANALYSIS
Existing and Interventions Land use
Legend Tagore Industrial Est.
Contour Slopes Water Flow
Restricted Area
Built
Open Patches
MRT Station
Thomson Nature Park
Pedestrian Access
Proposed Changes
Electric Substation
Existing Tree Canopies 73
OVERALL DESIGN STRATEGIES Food Source + Fauna Species
Road B
Enhancin as steppin serves as movemen
Node 01 Node 03
Soil :
Restoration of existing soil conditions to promote good foundations for speciďŹ c plant species to thrive in.
N
74
Node 02
Semi Urban Open Patch :
Developing a variety of protected niches on open patches of land serving as a refuge for wildlife
Barrier:
ng and utilising fast growing pioneer trees ng stone along the road side planting which s routes of connection across roads for fauna nt
Replacing unwated invasive planting species to re-establish a rich forest structure
Urban Open Patch :
Inclusion of fauna habitats in developed industral areas to enhance coexistence of wildlife and human interaction Maximise land use towards the transitioning of wildlife diuranlity and nocturnality. Injecting a diversity of plant food sources strategically to increase and attract wildlife.
Forest Open Patch : Creating a network of forest core species that is regenerative and requires minimal maintainence. Introducing plant species that provides suitable habitat conditions for fauna nesting Establish stepping stones to allow movement of interior fauna species between patches
75
IDENTIFYING VALUABLE VEGETATION PATCHES Proposed Zoning Interventions Core Area Nee Soon Swamp Forest
Forest Endangered Transitioning Palmpsest Buffer Area Connectivity Species Habitat Interface Old Upper Thomson Road
Thomson Nature Park
Upper Thomson Road
Protected Area
Targore Drive
Connecting Tree Canopies
Current Issues Habitats Fragmentation
Projections
Process Eliminating Invasive plants
Invasive plants species
Injecting Native Plant Species
Habitat Expansion
Over-exploited Soil
Regenerating Soil
Soil Conditions
Soil Regeneration
Lack of Food Sources
Landscape Succession (Food Source)
Fragmented home range (Fauna)
Expansion of home range (Fauna)
Creating Interfaces and Enhancing Connectivity
Creating Human Nature Interface
Enhancing connectivity for movement of humans and wildlife
76
Quality Habitation
Core Area Lower Seletar Reservoir
Native plant species Maturity
Food source for Biodiversity
Increase in Leaf Litter
10 ears Projection
High Nutrients Forest Floor
0 ears Projection
VEGETATION SPECIES MAPPING xisting Plant Identification Legend ROADSIDE TREES Samanea saman Tabebuia rosea Peltophorum pterocarpum Cacra cacauliflora Barringtonia recemosa Claxylon indicum Pterocarpus indicus Swietenia mahagoni Lagerstroemia speciosa Cyanometra ramiflora SECONDARY SUCCESSION Falcataria moluccana Spathodea campanulata Syzygium grande Terminalia catappa Vitex pinnata Andira inermis Cinnamomum iners Macaranga gigantea Ficus variegata Alstonia macrophylla FRUIT TREES Nephelium lappaceum Cocos nucifera Durio zibethinus
0
100
OLD PLANTATION
500m
Hevea brasiliensis Elaeis guineensis
Landscape Planting Typologies
RIPARIAN
Slow Growing Canopies
Understory
Legumes
Water Logging
SOIL STABILISATION
Ferns
Butterflyattracting
POLLINATORS
Fast Growing Canopies
Epiphytes
Grassland
Fruit Trees
Plantation
CONNECTIVITY
Epiphytes
FAUNA
77
MASTERPLAN Landscape Projection
NO
DE
3
Wildlife Canopy Link
Underground Wildlife Culvert
Pangolin Sanctuary
Masterplanning Concept
78
Detention Pond
Forest Theater
NO
DE
Scale Pop up Squirrel Run
1
Butterfly Trail
Bird Hideout Elevated Crossover
The Idle Place
D
Net Rest
Lizard House Old Plantation Trail
2
The Niche
E
Existing Thomson Nature Park Trail
NO River Cross
79
NODE 1
Landscape Projection
Scale Pop up
Squirrel Run Bird Hideout
Butterfly Trail
Elevated Crossover
SPECIES A linear stretch connecting the upcoming Springleaf MRT station to the Thomson Nature park. The node sits along the urban edge that faces the Tagore industrial estate. The intent is to enhance habitats for certain species by planting appropriate flora and creating experiential spaces for humans to observe and interact with these species from a distance. 80
EXPERIENCES
ECOLOGICAL Node 1
A’
Fauna Red-cheeked Flying Squirrel
Hylopetes spadiceus Nocturnal Lives on tree tops/ holes in barks Feeds on flowers, fruits & leaves even cultivations
Planting palette Syzygium chloranthum Melastoma malabathricum Syzygium polyanthum Artocarpus heterophyllus
Lesser Harlequin
Laxita thuisto thuisto Shaded areas in the forests, fields, gardens, and grasslands Flower nectar, pollen, ripe/rotting fruits
Ardisia elliptica Alstonia angustifolia Baccaurea motleyana
Straw-headed Bulbul
0
A
01 - Section AA’
100m
Pycnonotus zeylanicus Scrubland and rainforest Found higher on tree trunks and holes within. Feed on insects
Pterocarpus indicus Flacourtia inermis
Leea indica Archontophoenix alexandrae Bridelia tomentosa Ficus fistulosa Dillenia suffruticosa
KEY SECTION 01- Section AA’
Upper Thomson Road
Elevated Canopy Walk
Plan
Structure composition Look Out Point
Entrance
Axonometric Breathable Skin Lightning Protection Core 81
Artist Impression : Looking towards the bird hideout along the butterfly trail 82
83
NODE 2
Landscape Projection
Existing Thomson Nature Park Trail The Niche
Lizard House River Cross
Net Rest
Old Plantation Trail
SPECIES The niche is an activated landscape for both wildlife and humans with the means of planting strategy and structural intervention. A walkway that meanders through the various layers of landscape on site which includes creation of habitat for species that thrive in plantations. An attempt to scale up an element of a habitat, for humans to be able to experience it the way a species probably does. 84
EXPERIENCES
ECOLOGICAL STRATEGIES Node 2
Fauna Monitor Lizard
Varanus nebulosus Inhabit terrestrial Scrubland and rainforest Found higher on tree trunks and holes within. Feed on insects
Planting palette Ficus microcarpa Calophyllum inophyllum Artocarpus heterophyllus Averrhoa carambola
B
Palm Civet
Paradoxurus musangus Arboreal Found in secondary forests, fruit orchards Feed on fruits Nest in hollow trees Fully Nocturnal
Red cheeked Flying squirrel
0
100
Hylopetes spadiceus Nocturnal Lives on tree tops/ holes in barks Feeds on flowers, fruits & leaves even cultivations
B’
500m
Caryota mitis Nephelium lappaceum Coffea arabica L.
Syzygium chloranthum Melastoma malabathricum Syzygium polyanthum Artocarpus heterophyllus
01 - Section BB’
KEY SECTION Nutrients Cycle Flow
01 - Section BB’
Leaf Litter
Viewing Decks
Lizard House
Mound Walk
Decomposer
Secondary Consumers Primary Consumers
85
Artist Impression : Elevated pathway through the old plantations 86
87
NODE 3
Landscape Projection
Wildlife Canopy Link
Underground Wildlife Culvert
Pangolin Sanctuary
Detention Pond
Forest Theater
The primary approach on this site was to create arboreal and underground connections for expanding home ranges of threatened species. The creation of habitats utilises what the landscape offers and creating opportunities by mimicing their existing habitats. The forest theater is imagined to be an interactive spot which is not frequented by humans while the idle place, is a resting space derived from the structure of branching and serves as a hideout to view the monkeys in transition. 88
SPECIES
EXPERIENCES
ECOLOGICAL STRATEGIES Node 3
Fauna C’
Banded Leaf Monkey
Ixonathes recticulata
Slow Loris
Bambusa multiplex
Sunda Pangolin
0
Manis javanica Found in forested habitats and plantations Feeds wholly on ants and termites. Nest in burrows, treeholes & epiphytes.
100
Nephelium lappaceum
Presbytis femoralis Arboreal Feeds on New leaves and forest fruits. foraging areas are generally larger. Rest on higher branches of trees Very shy in nature Nycticebus coucang Found on branches and tree holes. Mainly inhabit pforests but adapt to orchards, plantations and bamboo groves. Solitary in nature Arboreal
C
Planting palette Hevea brasiliensis
Adinandra Dumosa
Ficus fistulosa Artocarpus heterophyllus Elaeis guineensis
Asplenium nidus Caryota mitis Cyrtophyllum fragrans Syzygium myrtifolium
500m
01 Section CC’
KEY SECTION Section AA’
The Idle Place
Wildlife Canopy Link
Left : Creation of habitat for Pangolins Top : forest theater - design derived from anatomy of an epiphyte 89
Artist Impression : Forest Theater within enhanced habitat for Banded Leaf Monkey and Sunda Pangolin 90
91
WILDLIFE MATRIX
Proposed Patch, Corridor, Matrix Landscape Model uantification of Habitat xpansion
TOTAL NUMBER OF EXISTING DEGRADED FOREST PATCHES : 1327 Ha. EXISTING SIZE OF CENTRAL CATCHMENT NATURE RESERVE : 2880 Ha. 47.6% OF DEGRADED FOREST TO BE RESTORED 92
93
SITE IMAGES OR YOUR PERSPECTIVE IMAGES
94
CO-HABITABLE “COMMON GROUND” Ekta Rakholiya
Co-Habitable “Common Ground” is a project with the vision to re-define Golf Course as a conjunction of the Game of Golf and ecological habitat creation with larger emphasis on ecological processes related to water, vegetation and soil. The project is situated right at the base of Upper Seletar Reservoir where currently it functions as “Mandai Executive Golf Course (MEGC)” facility. It happen to be also situated on the location where it is said (and recently mapped) that once pristine Fresh Water Swamp Forest (FWSW) thrived. Through in-depth study of the current condition at MEGC - in terms of Golf course use, management practice, flora-fauna and its relevance in a larger context of Nee Soon FWSF the issues identified are : heavy water consumption as well as contamination, forest fragmentation and degraded soil quality. The fact that it has affected the area in adverse manners but at the same time provided recreational facility cherished by many; the design proposal focuses on the re-development of MEGC as an Eco-sensitive golf course that is ecologically sound and supports habitat enhancement. To create so the water-based challenges are tackled through firstly tapping into the potential of rainwater to meet the water needs, secondly improving the golf course drainage infrastructure through a network of a vegetated open dry/wet swells and lastly enhancing irrigation system to minimize water consumption. Forest fragmentation is addressed through introduction of forest patches on the golf course with careful layering of grass, shrubs and trees clustered to form continuous corridor. An attempt is made to minimize the “Green” areas and increase natural vegetation with careful consideration of rules for the game of golf. Combination of both the strategies leads to decreased chemical-based maintenance of the course and adds to the improvement of soil quality. With enhanced water-based infrastructure and introduction of appropriate flora-fauna, larger aim is to formulate right conditions so that Fresh Water Swamp Forest can once again thrive in this region. An eco-sensitive golf course intrinsically adds to the challenge faced by a golfer during the game, hence provides them with an opportunity to master their short-range game. In a larger context, the whole proposal act as a buffer zone between forest and developed areas, which otherwise tend to have sharp edges without any provision of a niche for the forest edge species.
UNDERSTANDING THE CONTEXT
current locaiton of Mandai Executive Golf Course (Built in 1996)
1 Map showing major vegetation type (1819)
current locaiton of Mandai Executive Golf Course
2 Map showing major vegetation type (1994)
The site for the proposed design is Mandai Executive Golf Course (MEGC) which is situated right at the base of Upper Seletar Reservoir. Not only it is adjacent to Singaporeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s only surviving pristine secondary forest ecosystem, but it happen to be also situated on the ground where it is said (and recently mapped) that once Fresh Water Swamp Forest (FWSF) thrived. The MEGC was constructed in 1992. Though it has served many golf enthusiast, but had contributed not only to the forest fragmentation but the regular use of pesticides and fertilizers has contaminated water and degraded soil.
1 & 2 // Historic account for spread of Fresh water swamp forest (Indicate site area) Source// Book A first look at Biodiversity in Singpaore 1 3 Candidate FWSF Areas superimposed on current land use and roads base map. Source// Reserach paper : The freshwater swamp forest of Sungei Seletar catchment: A status Report by Tony Oâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;DEMPSEY and CHEW Ping Ting
96
Keruing (Dipterocarpus spp.)
Meranti (Shorea spp.)
Sunda Pangolin critically (Manis javanica) endangered Raffles Banded Langur (Presbytis femoralis)
Today, less than 0.5% of the original primary forest cover remains and it can only be found in small patches within the Central Catchment Nature Reserve and the Bukit Timah Nature Reserve. An even rarer forest type in Singapore is the primary freshwater swamp forest, with the most significant remaining patch being the Nee Soon Swamp Forest in the Central Catchment Nature Reserve.1 The existing habitats are home to a magnificent diversity of plants. References// 1. Central Catchment Nature Reserve. (2019, October 2). Retrieved from https://www.nparks.gov.sg/gardens-parks-and-nature/ parks-and-nature-reserves/central-catchment-nature-reserve.
Sembawang Country club
Orchid Country club
Site// Mandai Executive Golf Course
Singapore Island Country club Championâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s public Golf Course
Singapore Island Country club Legend
Key Map// Site situation with respect to CCNR and all the golf courses In-and-around CCNR 97
EXISTING SITE CONDITION Mandai Executive Golf Course
Overview The Mandai Executive Golf Course is a 9-hole, Par 29 public course situated next to Upper Seletar Reservoir. Opened in 1993, the friendly course features a nice variety of par 3s and par 4s that allows golfers to use most of the clubs in their bag and is a perfect facility for beginners as well as experienced golfers who wish to sharpen their short game skills. As a sport, from its beginning in Scotland, the game of golf has been connected to nature by playing and enjoying the game in natural surroundings. ver since it has evolved into a refined practice of molding landscapes in peculiar way in order to suit the game. The regular use of pesticides and turf management chemicals heavily impact the environment and ecology. Management Practice
Hole 1
Hole 2
Hole 3
Irrigation and Drainage Average water requirement: 100,000 to 1,000,000 gallons (378.5 m3 to 3,785 m3) of water per week in summer to maintain healthy vegetation.
Hole 4
Irrigation system: is comprised of sprinklers, field controllers, central control systems and valves. These are the components of an automatic sprinkler system. Watering program: is developed to determine the timetable for the watering and how much of water to use. Different plants need different watering timetables. Some plants do not need to be watered every day but some others require daily watering.
Turf Management/ Pitch care Mowing: though excessive mowing will compact the grass. During the growing season daily mowing is required. Verticutting: to remove excessive thatch Scarification to remove moss and stop the collection of moisture on the green. Grooming: to reduce the thickness of clumps. Aerating: to remove excessive organic matter, modify the root zone composition, improve rooting and drainage Soil surfactants and wetting agents: to manage localized dry spot Turf type and required conditions Turf: Blue serangoon grass (Digitaria didactyla) Soil Re uirement Fairly wide tolerance but definite preference for lighter soils, tolerant of low nutrient levels. Moisture: 900â&#x20AC;&#x201C;1,800 mm AAR, survives seasonal dry conditions and drought by losing all leaf.
98
Hole 5
Hole 6
Hole 7
Hole 8
Hole 9
Mandai Executive Golf Course - 9 holes course - Has varieties of Par 3s & 4s - 40 bays of Driving Range
Mandai Executive Golf Course, Base Map
Golf hole layout and area wise percent distribution 99
ISSUES IDENTIFIED Water based issues
Canalization of natural water streams contributes to break in the natural flow of nutrients and aquatic life. Through research and studies, it is evident that locating MEGC has contributed to the shrinkage of footprint of Neesoon Freshwater Swamp Forest
Forest Fragmentation
Lack of diverse fauna on the golf course. Out of 320 trees on the course, there are only 16 types planted repeatedly. List of tree speices on MEGC are:
100
Diagram illustrating vegetation fragmentation
1. Pink Poui (Tabebuia rosea) 2. Jemerlang Laut (Peltophorum ptrocarpum) 3. Callitris species (Cupressaceae) 4. Ordeal Tree (Erythrophleum suaveolens) 5. Royal Palm (Roystonea regia) 6. Kapok Tree (Ceiba Pentandra) 7. Bunga Tanjung (Mimusops elengi) 8.AmericanMahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) 9. Paper Bark Tree (Melaleua cajuputi) 10. Jenaris (Callerya atropurpurea) 11. Jambu Laut (Synzygium Grande) 12. Sena (Pterocarpus indicus) 13. Burma Padauk (Pterocarpus macrocarpus) 14. Pakul Lima (Samenea saman) 15. Northern Banglow Palm (Archontophoenix Alexandrae) 16. Emang (Hopea mengarawan)
courses demands high maintance and usage of water. Frequent use of fertilizers Soil Degradation Golf and pesticides causes leaching and degrade water quality as water drains through regular irrigation. As water percumulates, it tend to absorbe pestiside residue eventually affecting soil quality and ground water quality.
Pesticide contamination mapping (lighter the shade, higher the accumulation tendency)
Presence of green in the canal indicates the fertilizer overdoze
White and black patches are indication of presence of weed and their resistance adoptation to the fertilizer based treatments.
Sharp edge between forest and Golf course boundary
Disconnected patches within golf course
The land was clearled in 1993 for the construction of Mandai Executive Golf Course cleared up the forest existing over there creating complete segregation between regenerated forest. Within the Golf course, the lack of provision of continuous patches results into further forest fragmentation 101
MASTER PLAN Design strategies WATER BASED SOLUTIONS
Tapping into Rain water potentials Appropropriate Drainage Network Irrigation
INLET CONTROL// Bio-swale filteration strip,
RAIN WATE CATCHMEN
Shallow Po
25’Diameter no spary zone
VEGETATION
Creating continuous corridors Appropriate Plantation strategy Integrated Plant Management SOIL
Appropriate Turf Selection Decreasing Greens and allowing Natural vegetation Sound Management Practice
RAIN WATER CATCHMENT// Infilteration basin Infilteration
INLET CONTROL// Rain water run-off control , 25’ Diameter No-spray zone
O CON
Phytore
102
ER NT//
ond
RAIN WATER CATCHMENT// Shallow Pond
OUTLET CONTROL// Phytoremediation
OUTLET NTROL//
Zone
emediation Zone
RAIN WATER CATCHMENT// Bioretention area (Shallow wet land)
103
DESIGN STRATEGY - 1 // TENDING THE WATER Water based solutions
Existing network of Canal 104
INLET CONTROL To reduce the impacts of storm water on receiving water bodies, inlet control measures are designed to protect water quality by managing runoff before it is collected in the drainage system.
Vegetation Zone// Band of small trees and shrubs is used to reduce the velocity of storm water to promote infilteration into the soil and settling of solids. Bio-swale filter strip// Bands of close growing vegetaion, usually grass, planted between pollutant source area and receiving water body to reduce pollutants such as sediment, organic matter many trace metals by filtering acttion of vegetation.
CATCHMENT Bioretention cum shallow wetland area// Shallow (6-9 inches of ponded water) storm water basins filled with porous soil mixture and then planted. With time, this area have tendency to acquire Fresh Water Swamp Forest ecosystem.
Infilteration Basin// Excaved trenches filled with stone aggregate used to capture storm water run-off.
OUTLET CONTROL Phytoremediation dry-wet swale Zone// Bands of small wetland at the edge of catchment basin as well as naturallised water canals to recover polluted soils, particularly those containing toxic organic substances and heavy metals.
105
DESIGN STRATEGY - 2 // “LET IT GROW” Plantation pallet and strategies Shrubs Flowering trees Legumes or Bean trees/ Fruit Trees Timber trees/ Rain trees Overstory Tall Timber trees
Understory Semidwarf Legumes / Fruit trees
TRANSFORMED LANDSCAPE
Ground cover Flowering Trees In Swales and Ground Range of grass cover
Tall Trees Predominantly one species along the row
EXISTING CONDITION
Short Trees Occasional inbetween new plantation
106
Canal Edge plantation Hardscape edge
Ground surface cover completely missing
Patch - Corridor - Matrix Model
Source// Book: Forman Science of Cities :Spatial Patterns & Mosaics
Patch// A relatively homogeneous area that differs from its surroundings. Corridor// Narrow strip of land which differ from matrix on the either side of it. Matrix// “Background ecological system” of a landscape with high degree of connectivity. Combination of these three spatial elements are used to improve connectivity and movement from forest to the Golf course. The term “connectivity” here is defined as the measure of how connected or spatially continuous a corridor, network, or matrix is. TREES RETAINED ON SITE
r
107
DESIGN STRATEGY - 3 // â&#x20AC;&#x153;LET IT FORMâ&#x20AC;? Tending the soil
Existing
Plan view of a typical Golf Course
Out - of - play areas in proposed design (Opportunities for the use of native vegetation)
Vision Hole 2
Hole 3
Hole 4
Hole 5
Length: 250m
Length: 150m
Length: 150m
Length: 330m
Greens are decreased by 7%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees and shrubs
Greens are decreased by 18%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees and shrubs
Greens are decreased by 25%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees, shrubs, water body and swale.
Greens are decreased by 5%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees, shrubs and filteration strip.
EXISTING
Hole 1
DESIGN PROPOSAL
Length: 175m
Greens are decreased by 10%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees and shrubs
Note: The length of the proposed course is kept as it is to meet the rules for 3s & 4s Par Golf Course design. 108
MEGC - Course rating card A golf course of standard playing difficulty has a slope rating of 11 , and slope ratings range from a minimum of very easy to a maximum of 1 extremely difficult . Currently, Slop rating of MEGC is between 82-87. With the proposed changes and ecological intervention, the difficulty level of the Golf course is expeted to rise upto 110 to 120.
Hole 6
Hole 7
Hole 8
Hole 9
Length: 130m
Length: 165m
Length: 110m
Length: 175m
Greens are decreased by 35%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees, shrubs and water body.
Greens are decreased by 6%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees, shrubs and filteration strip.
Greens are decreased by 20%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees and shrubs.
Greens are decreased by 18%, surrounded by continuous corridor of trees, shrubs, water body and swale.
Driving Range: 40 bays
Driving range is shortened to accomodate FWSF creation at the edge. Maintenance room is also relocated from its original location. 109
VISION Before
110
After
111
112
WILDING STREETSCAPE OF SINGAPORE Cheng Jing & Lyu Jiawei
With rapid urbanization, the transportation system has become very complex. The current road network is 3425km long in Singapore which has resulted in severe habitat fragmentation, disconnected waterways, single-tiered vegetation, and so on. Streets have the potential to be more than just transport corridors. With an aim to strengthen the flora and fauna dynamics, and introduce hydrologically sustainable streets, two sites are selected. Located at the junction between CCNR and Pangsua Pond, the Bukit Panjang road flora species are monotonous and lack habitat connections. Petir Road is located in Bukit Panjang new town, and surrounded by CCNR and Bukit Timah nature reserve. Historically, many streams and wetlands existed here. At present, it faces the threat of increased runoff and habitat loss. Bukit Panjang Road the first strategy is to enrich the variety and structure of roadside and buffer plant species. The planting strategy of trees is sparse or dense, giving consideration to the various stages of plant succession and the changes in the surrounding environment, providing diversity in space. The second strategy is to connect animal habitats by reducing barriers, which include infrastructure, hardscape slopes, and concrete canals. The strategy is divided into four parts- tree canopy connection, hydrophilic habitat construction, slope landscape formation, and infrastructure transformation, incorporated within the specific condition of each barrier. Petir Road, a water-sensitive road design the first strategy is to reshape the waterway network in the site to lessen the increased runoff resulted from the new developments of residential along the street and improve water quality. The second strategy is to create a freshwater swamp ecosystem based on the swampy stream, which can provide a targeted habitat for woodland and aquatic animals that can adapt to the urban context, and combine human activity. Our design envisions alternative streetscape by roadside greenery, and water sensitive road design which creates a continuum of habitats and improves the street environment. Meanwhile, it provides places for drivers, pedestrians, visitors and residents for recreation.
BUKIT PANJANG ROAD DESIGN
ERINCH THE DIVERSITY AND STRUCTURE OF ROAD PLANTS
Conotonous landscape Long-tailed Macaque (Macaca fascicularis) Mlayan Colugo (Cynocephalus variegatus) Greater Racket-tailed Drongo (Dicrurus paradiseus) Asian Fairy Bluebird (Irena puella) Cicadas(Purana spp.) Branded Imperial Butterflies (Eooxylides tharis diatanti) Giant Forest Ants (Camponotus gigas)
Bukit Panjang Neighbourhood 5 Park
Otter Teerapins Fish Drafonflies
Pang Sua Pond
Olive-backed Sunbird Fiamebacke Wood Peecker Pink-necked Green Pigeon Long-tailed macaques Long-brand bushbrown butterfly Saquirrels Monitor lizards Changeable lizard Green crested lizard
Zhenghua park
Site trees Peltophorum pterocarpum
Associate trees
Khaya grandiflora
Phoenix roebelenii Phoenix canariensis
Casia fistula
Spathodea campanulata P. Beauv.
Flacourtia inermis
Garcinia cymosa forma pendula
Plumeria obtusa
Lagerstroemia langkawiensis Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp
Building Etrance
Fagraea crenulata
Grassland
Pometia pinnata Fagraea fragrance
Bridge
Khaya nyassica
Leopard Butterfly Lime Butterfly Appias libythea Olive-backed Sunbird Asians Bee Parthenos sylvia Athyma
Building
Lophanthera lactescens
Road
Khaya senegalensis Tabebuia rosea
Water
Syzygium grande
Olive-backed Sunbird Flameback Woodpecker Pink-necked Green Pigeon the Greater Racket- tailed Drongo Long-tailed Parakeet the Arctic Warbler Blue-throated bee-eater the Oriental Dollarbird
Bukit Panjang Neighbourhood 2 Park
Livistona chinensis 0
25
50m
Nature of available landuse
114
Bukit Panjang Butterfly Garden
BUKIT PANJANG ROAD DESIGN
ERINCH THE DIVERSITY AND STRUCTURE OF ROAD PLANTS Site surface condition
Disconnection area
115
HABITAT LOCATION Bukit Panjang Rd
116
overview
STRATEGY 1——NATURALIZING CANAL Barrier
Building Etrance Isolation Bridge
1、Infrastructure 2、Canal
Building Road Water Peltophorum pterocarpum
Road peripheral space type
Khaya grandiflora Casia fistula Plumeria obtusa Flacourtia inermis Sandoricum koetjape& Araucaria heterophylla Syzygium lineatum& Calophyllum soulattri Burm.f.
Associate trees
Cinnamomum iners Pithecellobium dulce Brownea grandiceps
Phoenix roebelenii Phoenix canariensis
Climber, Vine & Liana, Shru
Spathodea campanulata P. Beauv. Garcinia cymosa forma pendula
Mangifera indica
Lagerstroemia langkawiensis
Terminalia catappa
Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp
Ficus tinctoria ssp
Fagraea crenulata
Artocarpus heterophyllus& Lagerstroemia tomentosa Musa sp.&Passiflora
Pometia pinnata Fagraea fragrance
Cocos
Khaya nyassica
Durio zibethinus L.
Lophanthera lactescens Khaya senegalensis
Artificial canal Naturalize canal
Tabebuia rosea Syzygium grande Livistona chinensis
0
25
50m
Animal movement
117
STRATEGY2——DESIGNING FOCAL POINTS Road peripheral space type
Wide green belt
Narrow green belt
Node design 1、Hardscape l sope 2、Canal
Road peripheral space type
Green belt with canal
Green belt with patch
118
Slope green belt
Design
STRATEGY3——UTILIZING LANDFORMS
Legend Text (Minimum 4pt)
119
STARTEGY 4 —— SOFTEN BARRIERS LRT
Road offset 5m
120
Overpass bridge
121
MASTER PLAN
Erinch the diversity and structure of road plants
122
123
PETIR ROAD——WATER- SENSITIVE ROAD DESIGN Site Location
Site Condition
Main Canals Flow Main Canals Underground Flow Driange Flow Surface Flow
Old Secondary Forest New Secondary Forest Scrubland+Low Regeneration Forest Grassland
Historical Topographic Change 1945
1985
Legend ≤-25.19 ≤-11.84 ≤-3.83
124
≤4.18 ≤12.19 ≤19.31
≤26.43 ≤33.55 ≤40.67
≤47.8 ≤55.81 ≤63.82
≤73.61 ≤86.07 ≤100.32
≤114.56 ≤128.80 ≤143.94
≤160.85 ≤184
2019
Reservoir Freshwater Swamp
OVERVIEW OF THE SITE
Strategy
Reshaping Waterway Establishing Habitat
Land Use Changes
Nature Reserve Urban Green Space Built Area Canal
Existing Boundary
New Design Boundary
Low-lying Area
125
MASTER PLAN
Retention Pond
Bukit Pajang Park
Vegetated Swale
C C N R
Rain Garden
Vegetated Swale
Narrow Canal Retention Pond
Swampy Stream Swamp Dryland
Human Active Place
Buffer Zone
New Residential
Forebay Diary Farm Natural Stream
0
Diary Farm Nature Park 126
25
50
100
STRATEGY 1——WATERWAY DESIGN
URA Master Plan
New Residential Layout
Watershed Division
2.1 1.4
1.4
1.4 2.1
2.1
2.1
2.1
New Residential Development T
Watershed
Floor Area Plot
Increased Runoff Calculation: New Residential: Three Development Areas: 83150 46627 e 28717 According to LUSH 3.0, Minimum softscape requirement is 40 in developments Hardscape area in new residential: A1=49890 ; A2=27976 ; A3=17230 . Q=CiA I(max)=248mm/d I(min)=110mm/d I=200mm/d (from SG government) C= 0.8
Runoff Coefficient: Green: Forest: 0.05 Grassland: 0.1 Urban Green: Manicured Lawn with Trees: 0.12-0.15 Manicured Lawn: 0.2 Playground: 0.3 Streetscape: Driveway/Walkway/Pathway: 0.7 Streets: 0.9
Increased Runoff: Q1=331.27m³/h Q2=185.76 m³/h Q3==185.76 m³/h New increased waterbodies: 702.79 m³ Water System Design
Internal Recycle Inflow
Foreba y Forebay Foreba y
Treatment Marsh
Swampy Streams
Retention Pond Outflow 127
STRATEGY 1â&#x20AC;&#x201D;â&#x20AC;&#x201D;WATERWAY DESIGN Existing Water Flow
Design Plan
Retention Pond
Swale
Rain Garden
Retention Pond
Stream
Main Canals Flow
BEFORE
Main Canals Underground
Main Canals Flow
Drinage Flow Surface Flow
Surface Flow
AFTER
Main Canals Underground Natural Swale/stream/Rain Garden
Plant Structure Canopy
Canal
1) Fragaea fragrans 2) Dillenia excelsa 3) Ficus variegata blume 4) Dillenia reticulata 5) Dillenia grandifolia
Sub-canopy
1) Cyrtostachys renda blume 2) Ficus celebensis corner 3) Ficus ruginervia corner 4) Ficus rumphii Variegata blume
Understorey
1) Melastaoma malabathricum 2) Costus curvibracteatus 3) Ficus grossulariodes 4) Bougainvillaea 5) Alpinia purpurata
Tree&Palm
1) Cyrtostachys renda blume 2) Thalia dealbata 3) Pouteria obovata
Vegetated Swale
Shurb
1) Bacopa monnieri 2) Melastoma malabathricum 3) Dillenia suffruticosa 4) Alpinia purpurata 5) Costus curvilbracteatus
Grass
1) Cyperus haspans 2) Pandanus pygmaeus 3) Arundo donax 4) Piper sarmentosum 5) Cana generalis
Emergents
Retention Pond
128
1) Arundna graminifolia (Don)Hochr. 2) Canna generlis L.H.Bailey 3) Costus speciosus (koenig) Smith 4) Cyperus haspan L.var.vivipurus 5) Cyrtostachys renda blume 6) Pandanus pygmaeus thouars 7) Ploiarium alternifolium (Vahl) Melchior 8) Taxodium distichum (L.) Rich. 9) Thalia dealbata Fraser. ex. Roscoe
Rheophytes
1) Nerium sp. 2) Osmoxylum lineare (Merr.) 3) Thevetia peruviana (Pers.) K. Schum.
STRATEGY 2——FRESHWATER SWAMP DESIGN
1. Topography Design
The slope of swamp is less than
, the flow of water through swamp is slow because of low
gradients and retarding effects of the vegetation. Freshwater swamp plan
Slope Retention Pond
Swampy Stream Swamp
1. 2 . . 1 .
Topography
Dryland
Buffer Zone
Recreational Place
Forebay Diary Farm Nature Stream
-1 . 2
2 .
- .
.
.1
2.
12.1
0.
1 . 1
.
.
1
. 2
.0
1
. 1
0. 2
1
10 . 11 .01
129
STRATEGY 2——FRESHWATER SWAMP DESIGN 2. Water supply Stream Rainfall Ground water
Forming Process
3. Vegetation
Canopy Trees Pometia pinnata Palaquium xanthochymum Mangifera griffithii Gluta wallichii
·Development Without Intervention
The slow replacement and lack of turbulence
low rate of oxygen
Incomplete decay of organic matter
accumulation of the resistant fraction
Thin peat and humid acid to reduce PH
Targeted Aquatic Animal: Parathelphusa Caridina malayensis Macrobrachium Trichopsis Vittata Trichopodus Anabas Testudineus Dermogenys Aplocheilus Panchax Monopterus Clarias Batrachus Rasbora Einthoven Barbodes Parkysis longirostris Macrobrachium platycheles Virginia Creeper Cinnamon Fern*
130
·After Design
Strombosia ceylanica Pentace triptera Palaquium rostratum Santiria rubiginosa Mussaendopsis beccariana Gonystylus maingayi
Shrubs Ixora congesta Timonius wallichianus Dicranopteris linearis Vittaria ensiformis Davallia denticulate Macaranga hypoleuca Cyathea latebrosa Macaranga bancana Bauhinia semibifida var. Macaranga gigantea semibifida
4. WIldlife
Amphibians: Calliophis intestinalis Eutropis multifasciata Fejervarya limnocharis Hylarana labialis
Ingerophrynus quadriporcatus Kaloula pulchra Leptobrachium nigrops Microhyla butleri Varanus nebulosus Limnonectes paramacrodon
Avifauna: Aethopyga siparaja Arachnothera longirostra Ceyx erithaca erithaca Chrysococcyx xanthorhynchus
0
Chrysophlegma miniaceus Megalaima rafflesii Dendronanthus indicus Treron vernans Dicaeum trigonostigma Dicrurus paradiseus Ficedula mugimaki Gracula religiosa
5
10
15
20m 131
PERSPECTIVE
Buffer zone along residential area to slow the runoff rate that provide water source for 132 the swamp.
Timber walkway and viewing paltforms along the waterway.
Swampy stream to provide habitat for various aquatic and terrestrial species.
Swampy area
Dryland 133
CONCRETE PAVEMENT LAYER + 4M-16M
RAIN WATER FLOW TREE CANOPY LAYER + 6M-9M
SHRUBS LAYER + 3M-6M
O2
N2
GROUND LAYER 0M
N2
EVAPOTRANSPIRATION
TO WATER COLLECTION STATION
GRAVEL CUSHION LAYER - 0.5M-0.8M
O2 INFILTRATION
N
S
HM
HC
SUB-GRADE SOIL
HC
P
TO OTHER BUFFER POOLS
CONNECTED LANDSCAPE FROM NEGLECT TO VALUE Feng Zihan & Zhou Zuyuan
As an important means of transportation for humans, viaducts have a wide range of social and economic value. However, Its concrete facade and linear architectural structures make it difficult for fauna to live in. Considering the potential and threats of it, our objective is to fully utilize the structure and the gray space under, making humans live in harmony with nature. Site one focuses on the more urban context. It is located in the southernmost part of the nature reserve, and the site has a viaduct with a width of about 32 meters and a height of about 10 meters. Due to the original design, planning reasons, and the perennial insufficient light conditions, the plant growth under the bridge is prolonged and lacks biodiversity. Site two has a more natural context. It is located right at the junction of Bukit Timah, Bukit Panjang, and Central Catchment Nature Reserve. For the potentials of the site, the isolated space creates a natural â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;shelterâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; for many animals. Also, relatively less light conditions facilitate the growth of shade-loving plants. The threats here include low fauna movement, fragmentation and noise and light pollution caused by the road. The design strategies of MacRitchie viaduct are 1. Use the rainwater collected from the viaduct for domestic usage. 2. Transform the space under the viaduct into a wetland. 3. Add educational function to enhance public awareness of the protection of the birds. 4. The low-temperature area formed by abundant plants under the viaduct forms an outward cold airflow, which promotes the movement and reproduction of plant seeds and small insects thus expanding the range of gene exchange. The strategy of BKE viaduct covers three aspects: 1. Transforming neglected areas into healthy habitat by soil modification and planting trees. 2. Redesign the water drainage system to provide a water source for animals and connect the three patches. 3.Building culverts, canopy bridges, and tunnels to help wildlife cross the road safely. The project explores the use of existing urban structures to create habitats conducive to animal survival, attracting animals to use while transforming unused spaces to reduce the impact of urbanization on nature. As a rainwater collector, the landscape under the viaduct makes efficient use of water while adjusting the soil conditions of the neglected gray space, and will become a prototype to be applied to other similar areas of the city.
MAPPING OF THE ELEVATED BUILT STRUCTURE Analysis of flyovers in the 1km buffer area of CCNR
0
0.3 0.6
1.2 km
Major roads Minor roads Parks Hydrology Surrounding context
136
Vegetation density
Morphology Underpass context
Structure
Surrounding context
Vegetation density
Morphology Underpass context Structure
TYPOLOGY Urban & urban + simplicity + open
Greenland & urban + complexity + closed
Greenland & greenland + simplicity + open
FAUNA IN THE SITE Elevated expressway Road Building Recreation Commercial Building selection School Residential Hosipital Park Hydrology
BUKIT TIMAH Macaques Mammals Reptiles, amphibians Birds Fishes Decapod crustaceans Semi-aquatic bugs
ragonflies Stick insects Butterflies Moths Orthoptera Bees Spiders
BUKIT PANJANG Bukit Panjang
Old secondary forest Primary forest Mature secondary forest Young secondary forest Swampy forest
millipedes carpenter bees bird insects spiders CENTRAL CATCHMENT NATURE RESERVE amphibian birds chilopoda mammals reptiles Decapod crustaceans Semi-aquatic bugs ragonflies Stick insects Butterflies Moths Orthoptera Bees Spiders
Bukit Timah
SITE CHOOSEN Reason1: The problem is severe.(threat)
Reason2: Rich biodiversity (potential) Macaques Mammals Reptiles, amphibians Birds Fishes Decapod crustaceans Semi-aquatic bugs ragonflies Stick insects Butterflies Moths Orthoptera Bees Spiders
N Green land
0 0.07 0.15
0.3
0.45
0.6 km
137
FAUNA IN SITE AND THEIR HABITAT fruit trees
insects
flowers for nectar
small mammals
leaves
seeds
fish
amphibians
megabats microbats high-flying low-flying wild pig brown rat annan- lesser plantain long-tailed common malayan birds birds daleâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s rat mousedeer squirrel macaque palm clvet colugo
mangrove forests
parks & gardens
ponds
coastal
grassland
secondary forest
birds
asian green crest- masked colugo clvets honey bee ed lizard swamp frog
primary forest
cultivated areas
STRUCTURE AS BARRIER barrier
corridor
138
barrier
collision
reptiles
corridor
urban
VEGETATION ANALYSIS
TREES ALONG THE ROAD Alstonia angustiloba Calophyllum inophyllum Cyrtophyllum fragrans Elaeocarpus mastersii Khaya senegalensis Lagerstroemia speciosa Melaleuca cajuputi Pteleocarpa lamponga Shorea acuminata
Native & Non-native native: 30%
Sunlight Preference full sun: 39%
non-native: 70%
Alstonia an
Calophyllum
Cyrtophyllu
Elaeocarpu
Khaya sene
Lagerstroem
semi-shade: 11%
Melaleuca c
Pteleocarpa
NATIVE & EXOTIC ANALYSIS Native & Non-native
Shorea acu
Preference InSunlight Native Habitat or not
Ăź
native: 30%
 �
Â?
â&#x20AC;&#x2DC; Â? non-native: 70%
Â?
Â? Â? (Â? )
 �
Fauna Attracting in native habitat: 20% full sun: 39%
fauna attracting: 40%
( )
semi-shade: 11%
There are 54 species in the site, and 22species are fauna attracting Fauna Attracting Attracting fauna: in native habitat: 20% Attracting species: fauna attracting: 40%
In Native Habitat or not
Bird Bee: Butterfly Moth Ant Beetle Fly Thrip Wasp Bat Vertebrates
Mimosa pudica Ficus hispida Urostigma Lagerstroemia speciosa Baccaurea motleyana Campnosperma auriculatum Nephelium lappaceum Cyrtophyllum fragrans Khaya nyasica Durio zibethinus yera costulata
Pometia pinnata f. alnifolia Elaeocarpus mastersii Pteleocarpa lamponga Flacourtia inermis Saraca cauliflora Gardenia tubifera Hopea odorata Sterculia macrophylla Khaya nyasica Syzygium samarangense Bridelia tomentosa 139
SITE CONDITIONS LIGHT DENSITY ANALYSIS 2
1
Light density
Conditions to be utilized
1
Drainage Pipe Pathway To be used as corridor to con- To be used as irri- To be used as irrinect CCNR and Bukit Timah gation or the plants gation or the plants under the bridge under the bridge 2
Drainage To be used as corridor
Birdsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; nests Nesting place for birds, bats, etc
SUNLIGHT & WIND ANALYSIS Prevailing wind in December-March
Prevailing wind in June-September 140
Soil Need to change
HUMAN INTERVENTION
STAKEHOLDER MAP
HUMAN ACTIVITIES Human stakeholders STAKEHOLDERS
SENARIO picnic
hike go out for relax
take the bus
walk along the road
begin activity
do sports
FAMILY
the need for shelter
the need for shelter
hike take the bus
walk along the road
have meals
begin activity
the need for restaurant
TOURISTS
appreciate scenery
RESIDENTS
CHILDREN
take a walk
education
picnic
do sports
play
141
FLOW ANALYSIS
Heavy vehicle car park
3 1 Heavy vehicle car park
2
Car park B
Car park B
Dairy farm nature park
Bus stop
Secondary huSecondary human streamline man streamline Main human Main human streamline streamline Secondary human streamline Bus stop
Dairy farm nature park
Wallace Education Centre
Main human streamline
Landscape nodes
Landscape nodes Bus stop
0
5
Wallace Education Centre 20 km
10
Landscape nodes 0
5
10
20 km
ISSUE 1
The lack of pedestrain road
2
The path is too steep to pass
3
Physical barrier
Heavy vehicle car park
Car park B
Dairy farm nature park
Secondary human streamline
Main human streamline
Wallace Education Centre
Bus stop
Landscape nodes 0
142
5
10
20 km
VEHICLE STREAMLINE ANALYSIS
Heavy vehicle car park
Car park B
Secondary vehicle streamline Main vehicle streamline
Dairy farm nature park
Bus stop Landscape nodes Road edge effect
Wallace Education Centre
0
5
10
20 km
HARDSCAPE & SOFTSCAPE
LAND USE Residential School Greenland
143
N 0 25
144
50
100
200 km
Waer body
LAYER ANALYSIS Fauna crossing layer Culverts
Water system layer Water
Vegetation
Human activity layer Bench Air corridor Pathway
Vegetation layer
Human
Vehicle layer
Culverts
145
PLANTING MANAGEMENT HORIZONTAL DESIGN Vegetationâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s function
Foraging place
Break the wind
Breeding place
Food source
N 0 25
146
50
100
200 km
PLANTING STRATEGY
Breynia disticha ‘Roseo-picta’
Cordia dichotoma G.Forst.
Carica papaya L.
Coffea arabica L.
Macaranga
Persea americana
Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam.
Ficus spp.
Passiflora platyloba
Musa acuminata (AAA Group) ‘Dwarf Cavendish’
Mangifera indica. L.
VERTICAL DESIGN
147
HABITAT MANAGEMENT HABITAT PLAN
900 Habitat 2: Open stream 1.characteristic: Vegetation Species: Canopy Layer: Cordia ditchotoma G. Forst (Bird attracting) Ficus spp. ( Bird attracting, shelter for reptiles) (jackfruit)Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam. (Bird food source) (cypress)Taxodium distichum (L.) Rich. Understory layer: Passiflora platyloba ( Bee attracting, insect attracting) Forest floor: Breynia disticha (caterpillar food plant) 2.Target species: Blue Helen Chocolate Grass Yellow Long-tailed parakeet Masked Swamp Frog Litter Frog plantain squirrel 3. Stream Light: Full light
Habitat 2: Half shaded stream 1.characteristic: Vegetation Species: Understory layer: Passiflora platyloba ( Bee attracting, insect attractin Pandanus tectorius cultivar Semishade Coffea arabica L. (Bird attracting) Forest floor: Carica papaya L. ( Bird attracting) Bridelia ovata (variegated) Semishade 2.Target species: Blue Helen Chocolate Grass Yellow Long-tailed parakeet Masked Swamp Frog Litter Frog plantain squirrel 3. Stream Light: Semi-shade Nutrient design:
+00
Habitat 2: Large jackfruit forest 1.characteristic: Vegetation Species: Emergent Layer: Mangifera indica. L. (Bird attracting caterpillar food plant, monkey food source) Canopy Layer: Nephelium lappaceum L. (Bird attracting, caterpillar food plant) (jackfruit)Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam. (Bird food source) Understory layer: Passiflora platyloba ( Bee attracting, insect attracting) Pandanus tectorius cultivar Semishade Forest floor: Carica papaya L. ( Bird attracting) Bridelia ovata (variegated) Semishade Breynia disticha (caterpillar food plant) 2.Target species: Blue Helen Chocolate Grass Yellow Long-tailed parakeet Cave Nectar Bat Lesser False Vampire 3. Forest Light: Semi-shade Nutrient design:
Habitat 1: Pond & Forest edge 1.characteristic: Vegetation Species: Emergent Layer: Mangifera indica. L. (Bird attracting caterpillar food food source) Canopy Layer: (cypress)Taxodium distichum (L.) Rich. Ficus spp. ( Bird attracting, shelter for reptiles) (jackfruit)Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam. (Bird food Understory layer: Pandanus tectorius cultivar Semishade Passiflora platyloba ( Bee attracting, insect attractin Forest floor: Carica papaya L. ( Bird attracting) Breynia disticha (caterpillar food plant) 2.Target species: Blue Helen Chocolate Grass Yellow Asian honey bee Long-tailed macaque Long-tailed parakeet plantain squirrel Masked Swamp Frog Litter Frog 3.Pond Light: Full light Nutrient design: +00
Habitat 2: Wetland swamp 1.characteristic: Vegetation Species: Canopy Layer: Nephelium lappaceum L. (Bird attracting, caterpillar food plant) Ficus spp. ( Bird attracting, shelter for reptiles) (jackfruit)Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam. (Bird food source) (cypress)Taxodium distichum (L.) Rich. ( Squirrel attracting) Cordia ditchotoma G. Forst (Bird attracting) Understory layer: Passiflora platyloba ( Bee attracting, insect attracting) Coffea arabica L. (Bird attracting) Forest floor: Carica papaya L. ( Bird attracting) Breynia disticha (caterpillar food plant) 2.Target species: Blue Helen Chocolate Grass Yellow Asian honey bee Long-tailed parakeet Masked Swamp Frog Litter Frog plantain squirrel 3. Swamp Light: Full light & Semi-shade Nutrient design:
Habitat 1: Pond 1.characteristic: Vegetation Species: Emergent Layer: Mangifera indica. L. (Bird attracting caterpillar food food source) Canopy Layer: Macaranga (Shelter for ants) Nephelium lappaceum L. (Bird attracting, caterpillar Cordia ditchotoma G. Forst (Bird attracting) (jackfruit)Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam. (Bird food Understory layer: Passiflora platyloba ( Bee attracting, insect attractin Coffea arabica L. (Bird attracting) Pandanus tectorius cultivar Semishade Forest floor: Bridelia ovata (variegated) Semishade Breynia disticha (caterpillar food plant) 2.Target species: Blue Helen Chocolate Grass Yellow Asian honey bee Long-tailed macaque Long-tailed parakeet 3.Pond Light: Full light Nutrient design:
2200
900
N 0 25
148 Â? Â?
50
100
200 km
800
TYPOLOGY Arboreal- friendly habitat
Butterflies
Bees - friendly habitat
ng)
Bat- friendly habitat
Bird & mammals- friendly habitat
plant, monkey
source)
ng)
plant, monkey
Amphibian- friendly habitat
r food plant) source)
ng)
149
WATER MANAGEMENT 1
2
3
Drainage (used to be) Naturalized water system N 0 25
150
50
100
200 km
TACTIC01 NATURALIZE THE WATER DRAINAGE Natrualize the drainage system can create habitat for fauna species. For example, it can be water source for wildlife of or a shleter for animals to forage or breed.
Drainage surface used to be imperable surface
Site condition
Naturalize the water system
TACTIC02 RUNOFF WATER COLLECTION As the vegetation under the structure cannot get rainfall, the water pipes are modified to collect rainfall for plant watering.
Site condition
Pipe modification
TACTIC03 RUNOFF WATER COLLECTION Change the shape of water to connect the patches. In particular, for wildlife. 900
900
+00
+00
2300
2300
+00
+00
4500
4500
+00
+00
2200
900
2200
900
800
Previous water system Previous connection 800
Modified water system
Connection after modification 151
FAUNA CROSSING STRATEGY CROSSINGS’ POSITION
ü
‘
( )
( )
1
2
CROSSINGS’ SECTION 2
1
2 152
CROSSINGSâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; SCALE & FUNCTION 1
Culverts under the bridge
2
Culverts under the bridge
Shelter from excessive heat, dryness and predators. For reptiles, more rocks and logs should be placed in and around culvert entrances. Most plants are a food source of native animals or attract food such as insects which other species feed on. Important or preferred food strategically planted in corridor links can be used to tempt animals near or into crossing structures.
CROSSINGSâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; PRINCIPLE
Already exist
As the already exist space are close to the road, it is more suitable for animals that are not shy.
Newly built
The newly built culvert is protected by trees and shrubs along the road, so they are more suitable for shy animals.
Culvert
Canopy bridge
Water connection
153
SOIL MANAGEMENT
2
1
SITE CONDITION
2
1
DECIDUOUS SOURCE Planting strategy
The decomposition process can generate insects to attract birds and bats. By this way, this site can be utilized as nesting place for birds and bats. Another function of this site is education. The shrubs with shaded area can be used as education place thick and for people especially kids to learn knowledge about birds and bats. This function can enhance peopleâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s awareness of wildlife protection. plant suitable vegetation for deposers
Collection from forest nearby
shrubs with thick and forest nearby collection deciduous from forest nearby
space under the structure plant suitable vegetation for deposers
collection deciduous from forest nearby
space under the structure
154
CONCEPT
FUCTION Habitat for birds, birds & amphibians
Education function
155
BUILDING HABITAT TIMELINE Phase1 2020 PHASE1
2025 PHASE
Take out the unresonable part of the site, etc, pathway. Naturalize the water drainage.
Phase2
food source
Breynia disticha 'Roseo-picta' Passiflora platyloba
host plant
Nephelium lappaceum L.
host plant
Ficus spp. Macaranga Mangifera indica. L.
Introduce plants needed by fundamental fauna. Start to build culverts.
Phase3
pollinate
pollinate shelter food source food source
shelter
food source
food source
shelter
Cordia dichotoma G.Forst.
food source
Carica papaya L.
food source
Coffea arabica L.
food source
food so
shelter
introduce plants and create diverse habitats for different animals.
Phase4
Pandanus tectorius cultivar
shelter
Bridelia ovata (variegated) Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam.
food source food source
Improve infrastructure.
Human obligates Human associates and exploiters
take advantage of anthropogenic resource subsidies food supplied by human
156
PHASE1
PHASE2
More diverse animals and forest layers. Forming complete ecosystem.
2035 PHASE4
Begin to have some insects and birds, some shrubs, flowers, and groundcovers are planted
2030 PHASE3
E2
food source
ource
Have vegetation cover, but plant species are not diverse
r
Human avoiders Human adapters utilize human resources and survive in human dominated areas, but do not necessarily receive an added benefit from living with humans
PHASE3
not expected to use urban areas, but occasionally may find themselves amongst people when attempting to disperse or migrate
PHASE4
157
158
159
HABITAT VALUE & EDUCATION VALUE
160
161
VISION PERSPECTIVE
162
163
DESIGN OF UNDER MACRITCHIE VIADUCT SITE INTRODUCTION
Site one targets urban areas . It is located in the southernmost part of the nature reserve, and the site has a viaduct with a width of about 32 meters and a height of about 10 meters, which means that there is a large amount of soil no longer has normal surface runoff and becomes dry and barren.
164
SITE CONDITION SITE HUMIDITY SAMPLING
SITE TEMPERATURE SAMPLING
SITE WIND SPEED SAMPLING
SITE CURRENT HEAT DISTRIBUTION SECTION
165
SITE HISTORY
SITE STRATEGIES
INCREASED CONNECTIVITY
166
INCREASED CONNECTIVITY
INTRODUCE HUMAN ACTIVITIES
INCREASED CONNECTIVITY
CREATE ECOLOGICAL CORRIDORS
167
INCREASED CONNECTIVITY
SECTION 01/ TREE CANOPY CONNECTION
MACRITCHIE MACRITCHIE MACRITCHIE VIADUCT MACRITCHIE VIADUCT VIADUCT MACRITCHIE VIADUCT VIADUCT MACRITCHIE VIADUCT
‘CONNECT ‘CONNECT ‘CONNECT BRIDGE’ ‘CONNECT BRIDGE’ BRIDGE’ ‘CONNECT BRIDGE’BRIDGE’ ‘CONNECT BRIDGE’
‘CONNECT ‘CONNECT ‘CONNECT BRIDGE’ ‘CONNECT BRIDGE’ BRIDGE’ ‘CONNECT BRIDGE’BRIDGE’ ‘CONNECT BRIDGE’
BIRD BUTTERLFY
6-10M level
6-10M 6-10M level6-10M level6-10M level level 6-10M level
BAT SQUIRREL INSECT
3-6M level
3-6M level 3-6M3-6M levellevel 3-6M level 3-6M level
LIZARD SPIDER
Ground level MACRITCHIE PARK
LIZARD
GroundGround level Ground level Ground level Ground level level
32M
MACRITCHIE MACRITCHIE MACRITCHIE PARKMACRITCHIE PARKPARK MACRITCHIE PARK PARK Papilio polytes romulus
INSECT
RESIDENTIAL
Cyornis rufigastra
BUTTER FLY
SQUIRREL
BAT
32M Emballonura 32M32M monticola 32M 32M
Anthreptes simplex
Graphium sarpedon luctatius
White-rumped Munia
Chilasa clytia clytia
RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL
58M
58M Taphozous 58M58Mmelanopogon 58M 58M
Yellow-breasted Bunting
Bronchocela cristatella Aeluroscalabotes felinus Calotes versicolor Aphaniotis fusca
LIZARD
Amyciaea lineatipes Cytaea oreophila Hygropoda sp. Nephila antipodiana
SPIDER
BAT BAT BAT BAT BAT Bronchocela LIZARD LIZARD LIZARD LIZARD LIZARD SPIDER SPIDER SPIDER SPIDER Bronchocela Bronchocela cristatella Bronchocela cristatella cristatella Bronchocela cristatella cristatella Amyciaea Amyciaea lineatipes Amyciaea lineatipes Amyciaea lineatipes Amyciaea lineatipes lineatipes Emballonura Emballonura monticola Emballonura monticola monticola Emballonura monticola monticola Aeluroscalabotes Aeluroscalabotes Aeluroscalabotes felinus Aeluroscalabotes felinus Aeluroscalabotes felinusfelinus felinusCytaea Cytaea Anthreptes Anthreptes Anthreptes simplex Anthreptes simplex simplex Anthreptes simplex simplex Emballonura oreophila Cytaea oreophila Cytaea oreophila oreophila Cytaea oreophila Graphium Graphium sarpedon Graphium sarpedon Graphium luctatius sarpedon Graphium luctatius sarpedon luctatius sarpedon luctatiusluctatius Hygropoda Hygropoda Hygropoda sp. Hygropoda sp. sp.Hygropoda sp. sp. CalotesCalotes versicolor Calotes versicolor Calotes versicolor versicolor Calotes versicolor White-rumped White-rumped White-rumped Munia White-rumped Munia White-rumped Munia Munia Munia Taphozous Taphozous Taphozous melanopogon Taphozous melanopogon melanopogon Taphozous melanopogon melanopogon NephilaNephila antipodiana Nephila antipodiana Nephila antipodiana Nephila antipodiana antipodiana ChilasaChilasa clytia Chilasa clytia clytia Chilasa clytia clytiaclytia clytia Chilasa clytia clytia clytia Aphaniotis Aphaniotis Aphaniotis fusca Aphaniotis fuscafusca Aphaniotis fusca fusca Yellow-breasted Yellow-breasted Yellow-breasted Bunting Yellow-breasted Bunting Yellow-breasted Bunting BuntingBunting
BUTTER FLY BUTTER BUTTER FLY FLY BUTTER FLYBUTTER FLY SQUIRREL SQUIRREL SQUIRRELSQUIRREL SQUIRREL Cyornis Cyornis rufigastra Cyornis rufigastra Cyornis rufigastra rufigastra Cyornis rufigastra
Papilio Papilio polytes Papilio polytes romulus Papilio polytes romulus polytes Papilio romulus romulus polytes romulus
INCREASED CONNECTIVITY
SECTION 02/ CONNECTION BY FOOTBRIDGE STRUCTURE MACRITCHIE VIADUCT
BAT
DRAGONFLY
INSECT
LIZARD
BIRD
BUTTERLFY
INSECT
SPIDER
5-7M level
32M 58M MACRITCHIE PARK
7m
13m 55m
CREATE HABITATS
EXISTING HABITATS
168
7-10M level
SPIDER
CREATE HABITATS
WETLAND UNDER VIADUCT
Syzygium lineatum (DC.) Merr. & L.M. Perry
Neolitsea cassia (L.) Kosterm.
Asplenium longissimumBlume
Adiantum raddianumC. Presl Delta Maidenhair Fern Dicranopteris linearis(Burm. f.) Underw. Resam
Cyathocalyx ramuliflorus(Maingay ex Hook.f. & Thoms.) Scheff. Garcinia forbesii
Sterculia parvifloraRoxb
Cyathocalyx ramuliflorus(Maingay ex Hook.f. & Thoms.) Scheff.
Desmos dasymaschala(Blume) Safford
Bird attracting trees
WETLAND UNDER VIADUCT AND POTENTIAL ANIMALS
CREATE HABITATS
169
WATER COLLECTION
RESEARCH OF VIADUCT WATER RESOURCES
WATER COLLECTION
CREATE WATER COLLECTION STATION
170
CREATE HABITATS
WETLAND SYSTEM UNDER VIADUCT
DRAINAGE HOLES (COLLECT RAIN WATER)
DRAINAGE HOLES (COLLECT RAIN WATER)
HIGH WAY RUNOFF
DRAINAGE CHANNELS CREATE MICROBIAL ACTIVITY BETWEEN POPULATIONS
NATURAL DISTRIBUTION OF SURFACE RUNOFF
CITYâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;S DRAINAGE SYSTEM WATER FROM THE CENTRAL CATCHMENT
PRECIPITATION IS EVENLY DISTRIBUTED AROUND THE WETLANDS
RAINWATER COLLECTION AND UTILIZATION PROCESS OF VIADUCT
CREATE HABITATS
WETLAND SYSTEM UNDER VIADUCT AND ITS FUNCTION
CONCRETE PAVEMENT LAYER + 4M-16M
RAIN WATER FLOW TREE CANOPY LAYER + 6M-9M
SHRUBS LAYER + 3M-6M
O2
N2
GROUND LAYER 0M
N2
EVAPOTRANSPIRATION
TO WATER COLLECTION STATION
GRAVEL CUSHION LAYER - 0.5M-0.8M
O2 INFILTRATION
N
S
HM
HC
HC
P
TO OTHER BUFFER POOLS
SUB-GRADE SOIL
171
MASTERPLAN
Legend Trees Elevated Road Buildings Groud Road Park Path (for people) Water Drainage Drainage Holes Water Collection System
1
Water Purification Station
N
0 10
30
60m
MacRitchie Reservoir Park
RAINFOREST
Rainforests grow on deeper, more fertile soils with moister soil conditions. They have a canopy greater than 30 m in height which is relatively closed (greater than 70 % canopy cover). Many rainforest plants produce fleshy-fruits and berries, which are a valuable food resource for a range of bird species, but particularly parrots and pigeons.
Cyornis rufigastra
Anthreptes simplex
White-rum ped Munia
Papilio polytes romulus
Graphium sarpedon luctatius
Chilasa clytia clytia
1 CAR PARK
Yellow-breasted Bunting
RAINWATER PURIFICATION AND STORAGE
PEDESTRIAN OVERPASS BIRD WATCHING PLATFORM
Sundasciuru Ratufa s tenuis affinis
R T
Iomys horsfieldii
WETLAND
Wetlands are low lying areas that are at least periodically inundated with water. It provide habitat for a range of species that are not present in other habitats.
Cyornis rufigastra
Papilio polytes romulus
Anthreptes simplex
Graphium sarpedon luctatius
Sundasciuru Ratufa s tenuis affinis
Emballonur a monticola
White-rum ped Munia
RESIDENCIAL
Yellow-breasted Bunting
Chilasa clytia clytia
Iomys horsfieldii
TREE
TREE 9
Taphozous melanopogon TREE 7
TREE 8
TREE 10
TREE 1
TREE 6
TREE 4
TREE 5
172
Sterculia parvifloraRoxb
Xanthostemon chrysanthus 'Variegata'
Elaeocarpus angustifolius Blume
Pritchardia pacifica
Cyrtophyllum fragrans (Roxb.) DC.
Alstonia angustiloba Miq.
Mangifera indica. L.
Garcinia forbesii
RAINWATER PURIFICATION AND STORAGE
RESIDENCIAL
FOREST
Forests are a habitat dominated by trees, with a canopy cover of between 30 % and 50 %.Wet-sclerophyll forests have a canopy that is taller than 30 metres and generally have a soft-leaved understorey, often including tree ferns. Dry-sclerophyll forests have a canopy between 10 metres and 30 metres tall, and generally have a hard-leaved understorey with wattles, peas and boronias.
Cyornis rufigastra
Papilio polytes romulus
COMMERCIAL
Anthreptes simplex
White-rum ped Munia
Graphium sarpedon luctatius
Yellow-breasted Bunting
Chilasa clytia clytia
Sundasciuru Ratufa s tenuis affinis
Iomys horsfieldii
PEDESTRIAN OVERPASS
Emballonur a monticola
Taphozous melanopogon
WOODLAND
Woodlands are a habitat type dominated by trees, but with a relatively low canopy cover of less than 30%. Eucalypts dominate the canopy and the understorey is relatively open, often containing native grasses.
Cyornis rufigastra
Anthreptes simplex
White-rum ped Munia
Yellow-breasted Bunting
RESIDENCIAL
2
Sundasciuru Ratufa s tenuis affinis
R WATE
RAINWATER PURIFICATION AND STORAGE
Iomys horsfieldii
INAG
DRA
Emballonur a monticola
E
TREE 3
Taphozous melanopogon
Syzygium lineatum (DC.) Merr. & L.M. Perry
Lepisanthes alata (Blume) Leenh.
BIRD ATTRACTING
LITTLE MAMAL ATTRACTING
E2
3 BUFFER POOL
173
174
CLIMATE SENSITIVE TAGORE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE Han Cong & Zhou Xianfeng
Located in the northeast of the Central Catchment Nature Reserve, the Tagore Industrial Estate is 300 meters away from the nature reserve and covers an area of 32 hectares. Because of the high impervious paving ratio, insufficient shaded areas and high temperature, the thermal comfort of the industrial estate are not conducive for human well-being. Also, the low biodiversity and limited green space make the site unsuitable for fauna inhabitation. The project aims to mitigate microclimate to achieve enhancement of human thermal comfort and habitat creation. The first strategy is to naturalize the drainage. Water features such as rain gardens, bio-swales and ponds can be introduced along the streets to slow down and infiltrate the rainwater while providing evaporation from plants to cool the area. The second strategy is to guide the wind to reduce temperature. The Micro topography based on existing topography is created to guide wind, bring different air pressure and create airflow. Trees along the road with proper planting methods in linear open space can guide and bring cool air to the surrounding areas. The third strategy is to reduce the hardscape and increase the softscape. This is done by selecting some existing areas with poor thermal comfort conditions and improving them - which includes building structures and linear green spaces. Consideration is given to keep valuable trees to maintain biodiversity and introducing fruiting and flowering trees to attract fauna. The fourth strategy is to add leisure and recreational spaces and replace linear green spaces with linear parks - which brings comfortable experience to users of the site. After a series of interventions, the percentage of soft landscape of the site will increase from 15% to 40% while the average temperature will drop by 1.2 degrees. The Tagore Industrial Estate will be served as a healthy habitat to provide enhanced thermal comfort and recreational working spaces where animals can transit as well.
VEGETATION & BIODIVERSITY & DISTANCE Vegetation Analysis
Biodiversity Analysis
N
N 0m
1km
2km
vegetation density
0m
1km
2km
CCNR boundary
CCNR boundary
CCNR buffer_1km
CCNR buffer_1km
Distance Analysis CCNR boundary CCNR buffer_1km industrial building
Tagore Industrial Estate 300m
Sin Ming Industrial Estate 750m
Jln Pemimpin Industrial Estate 500m
N 0m
176
1km
2km
Ta g o r e I n d u s t r i a l E s t a t e i s c o v e r e d b y vegetation, but its ecological and biodiversity value is very low.
INDUSTRIAL TYPOLOGY There are 6 types of basic industrial typology in the Tagore Industrial Estate.
Legend Warehouse Commercial and Manufacture Manufacture and Engineer Business Industrial Commercial
Legend Pavement 3 Grass Shrub Basketball Court Parking Space
Road Pedestrian Drainage ditch Pavement 1 Pavement 2
Business
N 0m
Commercial
100m
200m
Manufacture & Engineer
Underground Parking
Entrance Entrance
Garden Roof Garden
Parking
Garden Basketball Court
Entrance
Entrance Corridor Entrance
Entrance Entrance
Warehouse
Commercial & Manufacture
Industrial
Parking Entrance
Roof Greenery Entrance
Garden
Entrance Entrance
Parking
177
FLORA SPECIES ANALYSIS Native & Exotic 25
24 20
20 15 10 5 0
native
exotic
Slow-growing & Fast-growing 10
8
5 2
0
N 0m
100m
slow-growing
fast-growing
200m
Common & Endanger 25
25 20 15 10 5 0
8
7 4
critically endangered endangered vulnerable common
There are 44 tree species of trees in the industrial zone. Most are native, common and fastgrowing. 178
HARDSCAPE & SOFTSCAPE ANALYSIS Hardscape: Roads Roof Pedestrian Drianage ditch Pavement
Softscape: Herb layer only Herb layer and arbor layer Herb, shrub and arbor layer Relatively natural vegetation
N 0m
75m
150m
Softscape Type Herb layer only
Herb, shrub and arbor layer
Herb layer and arbor layer
Relatively natural vegetation
179
WATER FLOW ANALYSIS
Legend drainage
N
drainage flow
0m
75m
150m
underground flow surface flow
Drainage Type
180
TABULATIONS OF INDUSTRY SURVEY RESULTS Age
Nationality
20
30
20-25 25-30
25
30-35
15
35-40
20
40-45 45-50
10
15 10
5 5 0
0
Singaporean
Foreigner
Views on Greenery 50
good medium
40
poor
30 20 10 0
biodiversity
environment
recreation
aesthetics
health & well-being
Duration Spend in Outdoor Space
Types of outdoor activities
0-30min
sport
30-60min
rest
60-120min
shelter
120-240min
chat
>240min
amusement
0
5
10
15
Outdoor Comfort
20
25
0
10
20
30
40
50
The Demand for Outdoor Space
50
35
good medium
40
poor
30 25
30
20
20
15 10
10
5
0
0
temperature
humidity
wind
amusement rest
work
commute
181
WIND ANALYSIS Wind Speed & Wind Direction Map
Plant
air flows from the cold zone to the hot zone 14:00am, unit m/s
grass Prevailing wind in Nov Mar
Due to the its minimum air resistance, grassland has the best ventilation effect.
shrub
The shrub can reduce the wind speed.
tree Legend 1.6m/s-2.0m/s 1.2m/s-1.6m/s 0.8m/s-1.2m/s 0.4m/s-0.8m/s 0.0m/s-0.4m/s
Prevailing wind in Jun Sept
Annual wind rose (m/s)
Data from Changi Climate Station The arbor can make air circulation above the crown and lead air flow under the crown.
tree+grass
Building & Road As a guidance
type1
The temperature of the building area is much higher than the surrounding area.
type2
tree+shrub+grass
The greenery can cool down the air which can bring cooler air to the surrounding area.
type3
The good balance between the greenery and the building. The greenery becomes a cooling filter and brings cooler air to the building. 182
Trees along the road with proper planting methods in linear open space can bring cool air to the surrounding areas.
ROAD TYPOLOGY BASED ON WIND AND SHADE Road Typology
Shade Study Prevailing wind in Nov - Mar
Prevailing wind in Jun - Sept
shadow study 10:00am 30% Prevailing wind in Nov - Mar
Type A Type B Type C Type D
N 0m
Type A
Type B
Type C
Type D
Road direction is parallel to the prevailing wind. Roads are near to the forest.
100m
200m
Road direction is not parallel to the prevailing wind. Roads are near to the drainages.
Prevailing wind in Jun - Sept
shadow study 13:00am 15%
Prevailing wind in Nov - Mar
Road direction is not parallel to the prevailing wind. Wind is blocked by buildings.
Road direction is parallel to the prevailing wind. Roads are near to the drainages.
Prevailing wind in Jun - Sept
shadow study 16:00am 60% 183
THERMAL COMFORT ANALYSIS Temperature
N 0m
50m
100m
Legend 24-25℃ 26-27℃ 28-29℃ 29-30℃ 31-33℃ 34-36℃ 37-40℃
Humidity
N 0m
75m
150m
0m
75m
150m
N 0m
50m
100m
Thermal Comfort Level
Legend 48-50% 50-52% 52-54% 54-56% 56-58% 58-60% 60-62%
N
N 0m
50m
100m
Legend 90-91 91-92 92-93 93-94 94-95 95-96 96-97
184
The areas with the worst thermal comfort conditions are six buildings and a linear green space. The buildings typologies are business, commercial,comercial and manufacture.
MASTERPLAN
Some Possible Places of Intervention
Rain garden Building structure 4 Bio-swale
Ventilated corridor
Building structure 1 Rain garden
Building structure 5 Building structure 2 Bio-swale
Building structure 6 Ventilated corridor Linear Park Building structure 3
N 0m
50m
100m
Legend road
grassland
drainage
sub-canopy tree
permeable pavement
bio-swale
canopy tree
shrub 185
FLORA SPECIES
186
STRATEGY 1 | NATURALIZE THE DRAINAGE
The water features such as rain gardens, bio-swales and ponds can be introduced along the streets to induce evaporative cooling to the surrounding.
Current
Proposed
N
N 0m
50m
100m
0m
50m
100m
greenery intervention drainage rain garden drainage flow bio-swale underground flow pond surface flow
greenery drainage drainage flow underground flow surface flow
STRATEGY 2 | GUIDE THE WIND
Creat micro topography and utilize trees to make a better ventilation to cool the spaces.
Current
Prevailing wind
N
Proposed
Prevailing wind
N 0m
50m
greenery drainage air flow
100m
0m
50m
greenery drainage air flow
100m
intervention air flow 187
SECTION A-A' Road type A Road direction is parallel to the prevailing wind. Roads are near to the forest with no shadow.
188
189
SECTION B-B' Road type B Road direction is not parallel to the prevailing wind. Roads are near to the drainages with a lot shadow.
190
191
SECTION C-C' Road type C Road direction is not parallel to the prevailing wind. Wind is blocked by buildings. There are not much shadow on the road.
192
193
SECTION D-D' Road type D Road direction is parallel to the prevailing wind. Roads are near to the drainages with a little shadow.
194
195
VISION 1 Drainage: The bio-swales and rain gardens are provided to naturalize the drainages, infiltrate the rainwater and cool the area.
196
Shaded Streets: Fruit and flower trees are used to cr street landscape for workers, bringing
reate a continuous visual enjoyment.
Leisure Space: As a social gathering space for workers from different factories.
197
VISION 2 Bio-swales Section Reference: https://www.asla.org/2019studentawards/684549_Monitoring_Design_Stormwater_Management_Process_Visualization_And_Evaluation.html
VISION 3
high wind medium low
Pond & Fountain
198
Continuity of the Tree Canopies
Ventilated Corridor
STRATEGY 3 | DECREASE HARDSCAPE AND INCREASE SOFTSCAPE Heat Study Category 01
Before
Solar radiation
Sensitive heat
Grassland Category 02
Solar radiation
Before Sensitive heat
Latent heat
N 0m
100m
200m
0m
100m
200m
After Scrubland Category 03
Solar radiation
Sensitive heat
Sparse forest Category 04 Solar radiation
N
Sensitive heat
Tall forest
Create more scrubland and sparse forest areas to slow down the effects of solar radiation to cool the whole industrial estate.
Hardscape: Roads Roof Pedestrian Drianage ditch Pavement Softscape: Grassland Scrubland Sparse forest Tall forest
199
BUILDING STRUCTURE
The strategy of this part is to increase patches on 1st storey ground to rise the softscape ratio and provide shaded area, add vertical greenery on bare walls and convert rooftop to green roof. 01Business 01Business Rooftop greenery
1st storey greenery
02Commercial
02Commercial Rooftop greenery
1st storey greenery
03Business
03Business
Rooftop greenery
Vertical greenery
1st storey greenery
04Commercial
04Commercial Rooftop greenery Vertical greenery
1st storey greenery
05Commercial
05Commercial
Rooftop greenery
Vertical greenery
1st storey greenery
06Commercial & Manufacture 06Commercial & Manufacture
1st storey greenery 200
Maximise Area and Maximise experience for the workers.
Before
1.Break the space limit to optimise the potential greeney area.
After
Legend Intervention Greenery space
Legend Intervention Potential space
Before 2.Relocate the carpark and 1st storage space to free up the area in front of the entrance.
Legend Carpark Greenery space
After
Legend Carpark Potential space
Before
3.Relocate the main entrance of the building to facilitate better connectivity and prolog experience of the workers.
Legend Entrance Greenery space
After
Legend Entrance Potential space
201
PLANTING STRATEGY Species Choose
Valuable Species
Valnerable/ Threatened: Dalbergia latifolia Planchonella obovata Cleistanthus sumatranus Diospyros buxifolia Endangered: Ficus religiosa Tristaniopsis whiteana Tarenna fragrans Cratoxylum cochinchinense Pometia pinnata Cratoxylum formosum Koompassia malaccensis Critically Endangered: Cynometra ramiflora Peltophorum pterocarpum Memecylon caeruleum Barringtonia racemosa Sterculia cordata Shorea bracteolata Tristaniopsis obovata Dillenia reticulata
Phase 1: Plant 01 pioneer species that can proviede shade for open space. Phase 2: Than plant some emergents, 02 shrubs and groundcover. Phase 3: The emergents grow quickly under the shade of pioneer species. Shade tolereant shrubs and groundcover are growing.
03
04
Phase 4: The emergent trees grow big enough and pioneer species die, remove them Plant Functions: and make way for 1.Physical Contact or Spatial Experience shade love plants. (Tempoary Relief from Work) 2.Supporting the Biodiversity (Experience of Forest-Link with Aurally Stimulating Bird Calls) 3.Visually Appealling,Smell-Stimulating
Fauna Attraction: 1.Habitat: Open Land
2.Habitat: Wooded Area
Grey-faced Buzzard
Sparrowhawk
202
White-shouldered Starling
Plaintive Cuckoo
Tecoma stans (L.) Juss. Wrightia religiosa Teijsm. Nerium oleander L. ex Kunth & Binn.) Kurz
3.Habitat: Grassland
Barn Owl
Eastern Marsh Harrier
Barred Buttonquail
Savanna Nightjar
SPECIES CHOOSE PROCESS
Keep valuable trees including endangered, heritage and threatened species to maintain the species biodiversity.
Valnerable/ Threatened: Dalbergia latifolia Planchonella obovata Cleistanthus sumatranus Diospyros buxifolia Endangered: Ficus religiosa Tristaniopsis whiteana Tarenna fragrans Cratoxylum cochinchinense Pometia pinnata Cratoxylum formosum Koompassia malaccensis Critically Endangered: Cynometra ramiflora Peltophorum pterocarpum Memecylon caeruleum Barringtonia racemosa Sterculia cordata Shorea bracteolata Tristaniopsis obovata Dillenia reticulata
Enrich species through vegetation structure.
Large Canopy Trees: Acacia concinna Callerya atropurpurea Swietenia macrophylla Pterocarpus indicus Nephelium lappaceum Ficus microcarpa Ficus fistulosa Syzygium grande Terminilia catappa Calophylium putcherrimum Pellacalyx axillaris Acacia auriculiformis African tulip Adinandra dumosa Broad-leafed mahogany Samanea saman Dypsis leptocheilos Plumeria rubra Albizia saman
Choose different species due to various areas in the site.
Public Green: Durian Jackfruit Adenanthera pavoning Dillenia suffrutcosa Roadside and Garden Green: Peltophorum pterocarpum Cerbera manghas Fagraca fragrans Hymenaea courbaril Erythrina crista-gali Clerolandron deflexum Less Access Space: Eugenia grandis Pithecellobium dulce Teminalla catappa Syzygium zelanicum Albizia saman Imperata cylidrica
Edge of the forest: Oil fruit Teminalla catappa Saman saman Adinandra dumansa Acacia concinna Clerodendrum Durio zibethinus Ptercarpus indicus Syzygium cumini
Sub Canopy Trees: Deillenia suffrutcosa Cerbera manghas Eugenia grandis Imperata cylidrica Fagraca fragrans Syzygium cumini Clerodendrum Elaeocarpus mastersii Gymnacranthera forbesii Agerstroemia speciosa Cerbera manghas Hymenaea courbaril Pithecellobium dulce Syzygium zeylanicum Syzygium malaccense
Shrub: Erythrina crista-galli Plumeria obtusa Leea indica Dillenia suffruticosa Mimosa pudica Ardisa eillptica Calophyllum Pipturus Manihot carthaginensis Manihot esculenta Syzygium malaccense Kyllinga brevifolia Clerodendrum paniculatum Hevea brasiliensis Wild nutmeg
Plant flower and fruit trees to attract fauna.
Fauna predicted to attract according to the strategy.
Attracting Trees: Flower trees: Leea indica Nephelium lappaceum Ficus fistulosa Ficus variegata Syzygium grande Terminalia Catappa Fruit trees: Syzigium Durian Jackfruit Rambai Oil fruit
Avi Animals: Chestnut-belied Malkoha Square-tailed Drongo-Cuckoo Straw Head Bulbul Oriental Magpie-Robin Orange Belied Flowerpecker Red-legged Crake Emerald Dove White-throated Kingfisher Hill Myn Spiderhunter Rufous-tailed Tailorbird Aboreal Animals: Plantain Squirrel Black House Ants Pollinators: Bat Butterfly Bee
203
PLANTING STRATEGY
Different planting strategies according to different types of spaces between the industrial buildings.
Building Structure
Build Structure Big Trees: Eugenia grandis Bhesa paniculate Arn. Calophyllum pulcherrimum Wall. ex Choisy Medium Trees: Acacia mangium Cassia fistula Cinnamomuminers Baccaurea parviflora Clerodendrum laevifolium Microdesmis caseariifolia Grassland Species: Chrysopogon zizanioides (L.) Roberty Melinis nerviglumis (Franch.) Zizka Pennisetum alopecuroides (L.) Spreng Pennisetum alopecuroides 'Purple lea' Pennisetum x advena 'Rubrum' Wipff
204
Narrow Shady Space
Narrow Shady Palms: Caryota mitis lour. Crytoschys renda Orange crownshaft palm Shade-loving Shrubs: Baccaurea parviflora Clerodendruminerme Ixoracongesta Melastoma malabathricum L.
Microdesmis caseariifolia Stachytarphetaindica Timonius wallichianus Shade-loving Fragrant Species: Cratoxylum cochinchinense(Lour.) Blume Syzygium zeylanicum (L.) DC. Uvaria grandiflora Lesch. ex C. Roxb. Wrightia religiosa Teijsm. Binn. Kutrz
Wide Shady Space
Wide Shady Space Big Canopy Trees: Fargraea Fragrans
Leea indica (Burm.f.) Merr. Timonius wallichianus
Shade-loving Trees: Baccaurea parviflora Anisophyllea disticha (Jack) Baillon Ardisia lanceolata Clerodendrum laevifolium Cratoxylum glaucum Korth. Ficus heteropleura Blume Galearia fulva
Shade-loving Shrubs: Baccaurea parviflora Clerodendruminerme Ixoracongesta Melastoma malabathricum L. Microdesmis caseariifolia Stachytarphetaindica 205
VISION 4
Add vertical greenery on bare walls.
Convert rooftop to green roof o
Planting grasses and increase in shrubs and trees towards the building: As indication change in texture, smell, consistency.
206
or roof garden.
of slowing down and take in the
Planting flower trees and fruit trees to attract fauna.
Increase patches on Ist storey ground arround the building.
207
STRATEGY 4 | LEISURE AND RECREATIONAL SPACE According to our survey results, the users of the site reported a lack of leisure and entertainment space, which they were eager to incorporate into the design.
1.The linear green space is added with a pedestrian network and leisure and recreational platforms.
Before
Legend Pavement Greenery space Road Pedestrians
After
N 0m
50m
100m
2.In the buildings mentioned above, the roof and ground space were added with leisure and recreational space.
Legend Pavement Potential space Road Pedestrians Leisure and Recreational space
Before
Legend Pavement Greenery space
After
N 0m
208
50m
100m
Legend Pavement Potencial space Leisure and Recreational space
VISION 5 Keep valuable trees including endangered, heritage and threatened species to maintain the species biodiversity.
Planting flower trees and fruit trees to attract fauna.
The long and quiet garden pedestrian gives people a pleasant walking experience.
The design of several leisure entertainment platform, bring the excellent landcape experience to the site users.
VISION 6 Original
Building
Drainage Ditch Pedestrian
Less Access
Relatively Natural
15 - 30 years Rooftop Greenery Vertical Greenery
1st storey Greenery Sewage Treatment Vertical Greenery Roadside Greenery
Public Space
The edge of the forest 209
SITE IMAGES OR YOUR PERSPECTIVE IMAGES
210
SHOPPING IN THE FOREST Zhang Yifei
Commercial landscape is commonly decorative and manicured in Singapore. The indoor shopping space and outdoor greenery are completely divided with people going directly into the building rather than enjoying the outdoor landscape. Given the location within a few hundred meters distance from Central Catchment Nature Reserve and close to Bukit Panjang Park , 0 greenery rate and the unique building structure that allows multiple access to indoor and outdoor, Greenridge shopping center has great potentials to accommodate ecological functions. The project thus aims to create a new commercial prototype that integrates interior and exterior with the increased greenery and the design of nature-based commercial activities. The first strategy is to increase greenery and enhance ecological profit. This is done by providing habitat for fauna and converting the front plaza to a complex habitat that can provide niche re uirements and food sources. This also forms a continuous canopy with Bukit Panjang Park and Central CCNR at a larger scale. Based on space user analysis, the second strategy is to design nature-based commercial activities which combine the needs of customers like dining, buying fresh fruits and vegetables, getting early childhood education, medical healing, with the function of the forest like producer of fruits, spices, pigments and outdoor classrooms for kids and natural therapists for people, inviting people to the outdoors. Based on these activities, spatial design elements are introduced - which include outdoor restaurants, community gardens, outdoor classrooms, and playgrounds to learn about fauna and flora, harvest gardens, and healing gardens. Through the renovation of the Greenridge shopping center, the customers will achieve a new shopping experience here and have a better understanding of the importance of forest through the commercial and educational activities brought outdoors. Meanwhile, it also shows a good example of how to make good use of forests to get economic profit and add ecological values as the natural capital of the city.
MASTER PLAN
212
TARGET The project aims to create a new commercial prototype that integrates interior and exterior with the increased greenery and the design of nature-base commercial activities.
REASONS
1\DECORATIVE AND MANICURED COMMERCIAL LANDSCPAE IN SINGAPORE
Name
Westgate
IMM
Westgate
ION Ochard
IMM
Ngee Ann City
ION Ochard
Ngee Ann City
Paving Plaza
Paving Plaza
Bugis+
Bugis+
Marina Bay Sands
Marina Bay Sands
1st Floor
Road Greenery 1
Leisure Plaza
Road Greenery 2
Road Greenery 1
Paving Plaza
Interior
Indoor Shopping Street Greenery
Facade
Roof Greenery
Fascade Greenery
Roof Greenery
Roof Greenery
Fascade Greenery
Roof Greenery
Surrounding
Westgate 1st Floor
Interior
Roof Gardern
Fascade Greenery
1st floor is mainly road greenery and paving plaza. The interior is separted with the outdoor, is mainly uses for ornament and rest. The roof garden is occupied by a large number of artificial facilities 213
2\LOCATION ADVANTAGE Greenridge shopping center is within the few hundreds meter distance from Central Catchment Nature Reserve and has 40% greenery rate which is higher than any other commercial building in the buffer.
Greenridge shopping center is adjacent to Bukit Panjang Park where lots of birds living there. There is an opportunity to work as a continuation of the park in the urban area. Fruit and nectar
Pick necked green pigeon
Fauna in Bukit Pangjang Park
Greenridge shopping center
Bird
Fruit and nectar & Insect
Yellow-vented bulbul
Black-naped oriole
Olive-backed Sunbird
Insect Bukit Pangjang Park Pacific swallow
Spotted dove
Nuts&Twig&Fruit&Insect Park
214
Residential
Commercial
Place of Workship
Educational Institution
Park
Mam mal Squirral
Flameback Woodpecker
3\UNIQUE BUILDING STRUCTURE The unique building structure allows multiple access to indoor and outdoor.
Entrances (1F)
Entrances (2F)
Entrances (3F)
Car Entrances (2F)
Flow of people
Flow of car
STRATEGY Strategy 1: increase greenery and enhance the ecological profits of the greenery Strategy2: design nature-base commercial activities which combine the needs of customers with the function of forest, inviting people inside the building to the outdoors 215
STRATEGY1
Strategy 1 is to increase greenery and enhance the ecological profits of the greenery, providing habitat for the fauna . Where
N
0 5
10
20
What
Planting statrgy
50
What
Forming a complex canopy
Emergent Layer (food source for birds)
Canopy Layer (form the canopy) Understory Layer (food source for butterflies and birds) Shrub Layer attuact butterflies
What
Forming a continuous canopy
What
Forming a continuous canopy large scale
Plant Species In The Surrounding Area
Citharexylum spinosum L. Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp. Alstonia scholaris Xanthostemon chrysanthus (F.Muell.) Benth Saraca thaipingensis Cantley ex Prain
Overlapping
Green Ridge Shopping Center Fajar Shopping Center
Bukit Panjang Hawker
Azadirachta excelsa
Peltophorum pterocarpum
Citharexylum spinosum L.
Falcataria moluccana
Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp.
Hevea brasiliensis
Calophyllum soulattri Burm.f.
Parashorea densiflora
Phoenix canariensis
Cassia fistula
Spathodea campanulata P. Beauv.
STERCULIA FOETIDA
Azadira
Syzygium grande
Elaeocarpus mastersii
Cithare
Khaya senegalensis
Syzygium myrtifolium (Roxb.) Walp.
Syzygiu
KOPSIA FLAVIDA(K004)
Hopea odorata Roxb.
Alstonia angustifolia
Dyera costulata
Callerya atropurpurea
Sandoricum koetjape
Chrysophyllum cainito L.
Saraca thaipingensis Cantley ex Prain
Dalbergia oliveri
Dalbergia latifolia
Terminalia phellocarpa
Fagraea fragrans
Alstonia scholaris
Shorea leprosula
KOPSI
Carallia brachiata
Khaya senegalensis
Alstoni
Dryobalanops aromatica
TABEBUIA ROSEA(T002)
Callery
Maniltoa browneoides
Cinnamomum iners
Chryso
Lagerstroemia langkawiensis
KHAYA NYASSICA(K002)
Xanthostemon chrysanthus (F.Muell.) Benth
Fagraea crenulata
Plant renewal in the further step
Caloph
Phoeni
Spathod
Syzygiu
Khaya s
Dalberg
Termin
Alstoni
Carallia
Dryoba
Manilto
Lagerst
Continuous Network Of Plants
Plant Species Which Can Attract Creatures BEE
BUTTERFLY
BIRD
Azadirachta excelsa Citharexylum spinosum L. Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp. Calophyllum soulattri Burm.f. Syzygium grande Alstonia scholaris Xanthostemon chrysanthus (F.Muell.) Benth Citharexylum spinosum L. Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp.
Cassia fistula Syzygium myrtifolium (Roxb.) Walp.
Spathodea campanulata P. Beauv. Syzygium grande Carallia brachiata Maniltoa browneoides Xanthostemon chrysanthus (F.Muell.) Benth
Saraca thaipingensis Cantley ex Prain
Cassia fistula
Xanthostemon chrysanthus (F.Muell.) Benth
Fagraea fragrans
Elaeocarpus mastersii
Saraca thaipingensis Cantley ex Prain
Cinnamomum iners
Syzygium myrtifolium (Roxb.) Walp.
Alstonia scholaris
Fagraea fragrans
216
Xantho
STRATEGY2 Based on space-user analysis, strategy 2 is to design nature-base commercial activities which combine the needs of customers with the function of forest ,inviting people inside the building to the outdoors.
1F
“HAR
ST IN TH F R ST”
UT
R R STAURANT
N
Need Where 0
5
10
20
50
Food court
Food court
Need:dining Where: Ourdoor foodcourt renovation
What 6
Cook in the easiest way to enjoy the natural flavor
5
3 1
Find a place in the nature and share the natural food with frinds
Select freshest food and spices
4 2
Planting suggestion 1 2 3 4 5 6
Planting Pool Operation area Bar counter Rest lawn Bar counter Sepatate room
2F
“HEAL IN THE FOREST” NATURAL THERAPIST N
Need Where 0
5
10
What 20
Heal in the forest five sense
50
Hug A Tree
Measure The Height Of The Tree Snacks
Health care
Supermarket
Fashion wearing
Treasure Selestion
Treasure Wall(Touch)
Keeping The Treasure (Rubbing\Drying)
Need: health care, a place to relax Where Indoor space is limited backyard
Smell
217
F
"LIFE IN THE FOREST"
Need Where NEED: Buying fresh fruits and vegetables, getting early childhood education
Function\Flow of people\Hot spot of 2F
Supermarket
Education
Where: multiple access to indoor and outdoor (overwalk, canopy, rooftop)
Structure of the building
Hair
Connection between indoor and outdoor
Education(harvest in the forest): A. xtension to the canopy F I classroom Fragrant \Pigment\Nectar plant garden B.Large rooftop area F Education(Life in the forest): A.Rooftop next to the classroom F Butterfly B.Large ground area backyard through overpass
Commercial (harvest in the forest): A.Courtyard next to supermarket F
Food chain
community garden
"HARVEST IN THE FOREST" DIY CLASSROOM AND PICKING GARDEN
Outdoor DIY classroom perfume essential oil pigment fibre
Picking garden (Fragrant plants \ Pigment\ Nectar plant)
Outdoor Catwalk
Color in first floor
Harvest in the forest (Bee farm) 0
218
5
10
20
50
Smell in first floor
"LIFE IN THE FOREST" BUTTERFLY GARDEN
Connection between indoor and outdoor
Stage 1 Egg Stage 1 Egg
Stage 2 Caterpillars
Plan
Stage 2 Caterpillars
N
0
5
10
20
Plant suggestion
Stage 3 Chrysalis
Stage 3 Chrysalis Stage 4 Butterfly See the world like a butterfly
Stage 4 ButterďŹ&#x201A;y
Stage 4 Butterfly njoy the sun like a butterfly
"LIFE IN THE FOREST" CHILDREN PLAYGROUND
Bird Spy on the insects Monkey Swing between the trees
Insect Hide in the topography and plants
Squirral Zigzag walking Store food in the hole Monkey Swing between the trees Swing !
Squirral Zigzag walking Store food in the hole
Pangolin Live in the hole
Zigzag walking overwalk Watch tower Hide in the topography and plants Bird Spy on the insects
Insect Hide in the topography and plants
Pangolin Live in the hole N
0
5
10
20
219
I LOVE STUDYING HERE ! Because the classroom is no longer limited in the building!
I LOVE SHOPPING HERE ! Because I never see a show in the forest before, and the product selling here are environmental-friendly.
220
I LOVE DINNING HERE WITH MY FAMIL Because we can enjoy the beauty of nature here.We all enjoy the lemon grass tea we picked and drunk here.
BEFORE
Function of rd floor
Function of 2nd floor
Function of 1st floor
AFTER
"Life in the forest" play ground
"Harvest in the forest" DIYclassroom
"Harvest in the forest" T SHOW
"Harvest in the forest" picking garden
"Harvest in the forest" community garden
Life in the forest Butterfly garden
"Harvest in the forest" outdoor restaurant
b50068
221
MIMIC A FOREST EXPERIENCE XIAO Xinyan
In the overall analysis of all playgrounds within 1km buffer of the Central Catchment Nature Reserve, almost all sites are found offering similar experiences and lack variety and creativity. Therefore, three sites with their own characteristics (in terms of functions and surrounding environmental conditions) are selected for a more detailed analysis. Site 1 (Teacherâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s estate playground) is close to the former Lentor forest which is rich in species, and surrounded by villas. In the future planning, a PCN will be built to connect the site with forests and Lentor forest will be replaced by new buildings. Site 2 (Thomson green playground) is only 10 minutesâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; walk from Teacherâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s estate playground, surrounded by villas as well, and will be used as a regular outdoor classroom by two private kindergartens. However, due to the limited materials available in the site, teachers do not use the playground for long. Site 3 (Soo chow walk playground) is very close to CCNR , surrounded by shops and villas. As there is no planned entrance for CCNR, nearby residents cannot enjoy being close to nature. According to a previous research on forest and urban parks, there is an obvious difference found in experience between them. Forests are overwhelmed by the variety of flora, fauna and the rich spatial composition. People are likely to have multiple experiences in forest which are beneficial for both mental and physical health. Therefore, the following three design strategies will be proposed from my personal experience in nature, combined with the site conditions, and inspired by the restoration of forest in urban context. For site 1, based on the existing terrain and trees, the features of the site are amplified, and different heights are designed in combination with the new structure, to change the way of experiencing fauna and flora by children. In site 2, specific plants and natural elements including fragrant, flowering, fauna attracting and productive flora will be inserted to create a different experience and awaken the five senses of children - aiding them to feel nature, different from traditional experiences. For site , through the contrast of lightness and darkness and the variations in spatial scale - the concept is to mimic mysterious and unpredictable experiences in the forest, allowing the surrounding residents to have a glimpse of nature even though it is a small patch. The three sites are expected to provide people living in the urban environment (especially children) with a quick but valuable time to experience the forest. Additionally, the rewilding of these urban playgrounds are expected to create stepping stones for fauna in CCNR and raise awareness to protect existing forests.
ANALYSIS OF URBAN PARKS Overview of urban parks
There are official parks within this 1KM buffer. Most of them are tiny patches which are lack of creativity and variety serving neighbourhood areas. Thus, in order to have better understanding of all of them, parks are divided into seven types according to the surroundings.
Distance & Size Analysis 23
7 1
2
>4 Hac
1-4 Hac
0.5-1Hac
<0.5 Hac
Classification of urban parks
1 roadside + 3 buildings
4 roadsides (isolation)
3 roadsides + 1 building
1 roadside + 3 open space
224
2 roadside + 2 buildings
4 buildings (surrounded)
1 roadside + 1 building + 2 open space
PROPOSED STRATEGY FOR THREE SITES Inspiration from site visits
During the early stage, some scenarios have offered inspirations. Combined with users interviews and personal experience, some key words will play an important role in the further design.
HILL SHADOW DEEP CHANGE TUNNEL ADVENTURE SLOPE DARK PARASTITIC GAINT LEAVES MISTERIOUS NARROW WATER WEIRD SPECIES RATTAN CANOPY BIRD COLORFUL INSECT MULTIPLE FRAGRANCE MONKEY FALLEN LEAVES TASTY MUD LOG SOIL LIGHT
225
SITE SELECTION & CURRENT CONDITION Teacher's estate playground Size: 1.2 Hac Users: residentials> regular oldness
Thomson green playground Size: 0.76 Hac Users: school kids> teachers> residentials
Bus stop
Soo-chow walk playground Size: 0.83 Hac Users: residentials> customers> shop owners
Bus stop Plaza
CCNR
Trees Tebebula rosea Samanea saman Xanthostemon chrysanthus Syzygium myrtifolium Cocos mucifera Adonidia merrillii
Tagore forest (be cut out soon)
Kindergarten
Kindergarten
226
Trees Roystonea oleracea Syzygium lineatum Xanthostemon chrysanthus Cordia sebastena Callistemon citrinus Cassia fistula Terminalia mantaly Lagerstroemia speciosa Libidibia ferrea Plumeria rubra Citharexylum spinosum Xanthostemon chrysanthus Bauhinia x blakeana Magnolia x alb Mimusops elengi Cerbera odollam Tebebuia rosea Hopea odorata Dalbergia Tatifolia Pterocapus indicu
Shrubs & Herbs Lantana camara Brunfelsia latifolia Excoecaria cochinchinensis Tecoma stans (L.) Juss. ex Kunth Loropetalum chinenese var. rubrum
Trees Rhodamnia cinerea Xanthostemon verdugonianus Dypsis decaryi Tabebuia rosea Sterculia rubiginosa Planchonella obovata Peltophorum pterocarpum Garcinia atroviridis Ficus benjamina L. Samanea saman Mangifera imdica Archontophoenix alexandrae Cyrtostachys renda Podocarpus rumphoo Lagerstroemia floribunda Cleistanthus malaccensis Araucaria excelsa Plumeria rubra Araucaria cunninghamii
Shrubs & Herbs Syzygium myrtifolium Pluchea Indica Dypsis lutescens Bougainvillea spectabilis Chinese ixora Duranta repens Caesalpinia pulcherrima Leea indica (Burm. f.) Merr. Gardenia jasminoides
Phyllanthus urinaria Wedelia chinensis (Osbeck) Merr.Asplenium nidus
Hamelia patens
STRATEGIES PROPOSED FOR THREE SITES
Crawl with fruits
Swing like monkeys
Run between trees
Shuttle in forests
Body Text - 8pt font size, 10pt leading space (Sentence Case)
Running through trees and animals makes me wanna forget computer games!!
I feel like becoming a monkey!
The fruits are just near my hands eh!
It feels amazing surrounded by fruits and birds!
Climb with monkeys
Lie on flora
Hide like bats
Legend Text (Minimum 4pt)
Explore in dark forest
Obseve in small hole
Performe in natural stage
It feels like I’m having an adventure!!
The forest show starts!!
It’s so different to observe outside in this hole!
HAHA! They can’t find me when I hide in this tunnel!
Follow light in long tunnel
Pass in shadow
Stand with weird leaves
Follow fragrance in maze
Create music whith flora
I never knew bamboo could sing!!
I’m gonna collect all the plants I like!!
Observe micro organism
Wow!! The leaves sound like burning fire!
Find gate in bamboo forest
Recognize plants by mouth
Touch nature-beings
Playing with mud is so interesting~
Tread on crispy leaves
Walk on different materials
227
TEACHER’S ESTATE PLAYGROUND Play with Height Large canopy tree Fruit tree
Log stair
0 20 50
100m
Brush pile
Kept tree Wooden hill Shrub&herb cluster Crawl web
Look-out house
Stream/ ditch Jogging trail
Nest house Monkey moving line
Bird gather point Topography
Cave
large canopy tree
Slide
Samanea saman Jacq.) Merr.
Ficus virens Aiton Falcataria moluccana Boardwalk Star fruit tree Rope tunnel
Spider web
Wooden platform Areca vestiaria
Muntingia calabura
Musa acuminata var. sumatrana
Averrhoa carambola L.
Bamboo Musa × paradisiaca ‘Ae Ae’ Dracaena porteri Baker Dianella ensifolia (L.) DC. Platycerium coronarium (J. Koenig ex O. F. Müll.) Desv.
Dieffenbachia amoena
Pennisetum Wipff × advena ‘Rubrum’
Planting strategies
228
Point 1
DESIGN DETAILS Play with Height
0 10 20
50m
0
1
2
5m
A
Point 2 A B E D
C
A’
Point 2
Point 1
Tree net
20m 15m
6m 3m 1m A
B
C
4m 3m 1m
BrushEHill
Offer different levels for childeren to climb, meanwhile will attract birds to nest. Children will have opportunities to encounter birds.
D
Stepping log
Using logs to create different distance and levels to enhance children’s balance ability.
Section A-A’ 229
SOO-CHOW WALK PLAYGROUND Play with Light & Shadow 0
10 20
50m
Body Text - 8pt font size, 10pt leading space (Sentence Case)
Shadow
Dark with light
Light
Shadow
Dark
Shadow Shadow
Large Canopy Tree Shrub & herb cluster
Wooden stage
Bamboo gate Large canopy tree Bamboo web corridor
Rock tunnel
Hanging shelf
Log barrier
Crawl web
Look up tower 1
Trail
Fagraea fragrans
Vernonia arborea Buch.-Ham. ex Buch.-Ham.
Fruit tree
Kept tree
Bamboo
Syzygium grande (Wight) Walp.
Baccaurea motleyana (Müll.Arg.) Müll.Arg.
Cratoxylum cochinchinense
Stream Look up tower 2
230
Adenanthera pavonina
Adinandra dumosa Jack
Ficus virens Aiton Samanea saman Jacq.) Merr. Falcataria moluccana Shrub & Herb Malayan Ixora, Jarum Jarum Hoya latifolia Piper porphyrophyllum Molineria capitulata (Lour.) Herb. Homalomena rostrata Griff. ohannesteijsmannia magnifica . ransf. Licuala triphylla Griff. Adiantum hispidulum Bird nest fern Dracaena porteri Baker Platycerium coronarium (J. Koenig ex O. F. Müll.) Desv. Epipremnum pinnatum (L.) Engl.
DESIGN DETAILS Play with Shadow & Light
Two main trails are designed for kids to experience different light condition and misterious atmosphere. The continous and unpredictable small spaces will activate this tiny patch and stimulate their interst in exploring.
Trail 1
B
Bâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;
Light cage Rock tunnels to different adventure
Which road should I choose????
Section B-Bâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;
Section of Trail 1
231
THOMSON GREEN PLAYGROUND Play with Five Senses
10
20
50m
C
0
Large Canopy Tree Samanea saman Jacq.) Merr.
Shrub & Herb
C’
Freycinetia angustifolia Blume Edible Scolopia macrophylla (W. Cocculus orbiculatus (L.) DC. & A.) Clos Uvaria grandiflora Lesch. ex C. Roxb. Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp. Piper sarmentosum Roxb. ex W.Hunter Piper sarmentosum Roxb. ex W.Hunter Flower Ixora congesta Tarenna fragrans Malayan Ixora, Jarum Jarum Aeschynanthus pulcher Foliage Malayan Ixora, Jarum Jarum Fagraea ceilanica Thunb. Dendrobium crumenatum Sw. Hoya latifolia Poikilospermum suaveolens Piper porphyrophyllum (Blume) Merr. Molineria capitulata (Lour.) Herb. Homalomena rostrata Griff. ohannesteijsmannia magnifica . ransf. Licuala triphylla Griff. Adiantum hispidulum Bird nest fern Dracaena porteri Baker Platycerium coronarium (J. Koenig ex O. F. Müll.) Desv. Epipremnum pinnatum (L.) Engl. Fragrant xyceros longiflorus Lam. T. amaz. Volkameria inermis L. Uvaria grandiflora Lesch. ex C. Roxb. Syzygium myrtifolium (Roxb.) Walp.
Large canopy tree
Deciduous tree
Deciduous tree
shrub&herb cluster
Bamboo shelf
shrub&herb cluster
Edible Tree
shrub&herb cluster Seed tree
Spathodea campanulata P. Beauv.
shrub&herb cluster Tree with giant leaves shrub&herb cluster Fragrant tree
Edible tree
Bamboo
Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp.
Cave
Ixora congesta
Bamboo instrument
SMELL
TOUCH
SOUND
Kept tree
Plants loom
Sand
Singing seed
Slide
Seed plate
Mud
Grwoing house
Jogging trail
Observe point
Vernonia arborea Buch.-Ham. ex Buch.-Ham.
Bentinckia nicobarica
Rock hill
Log
Ficus microcarpa Linn. f.
Baccaurea motleyana (Müll.Arg.) Müll.Arg.
Cratoxylum cochinchinense
Fagraea fragrans
Terminalia catappa
Adinandra dumosa Jack
Pterocarpus indicus
Fragrant tree
Seed tree
Syzygium grande (Wight) Walp.
Hevea brasiliensis
VIEW TASTE
Stream
232
Corridor farm
Peltophorum pterocarpum (DC.) Backer ex K.Heyne
Adenanthera pavonina
DESIGN DETAILS
Sub Heading - 8pt (Sentence Case)
Sense of view Sense of smell
Sense of taste
Plants loom
Forest TV Forest TV
Sense of sound
Section C-C’ seat
Bamboo instrument
Singing seed
seed
Flora plate
Sense of touch
Bouea macrophylla Griff. Garcinia hombroniana Pierre Gnetum gnemon L. Cocculus orbiculatus (L.) DC. Uvaria grandiflora Lesch. ex C. Roxb. Syzygium polyanthum (Wight) Walp. Piper sarmentosum Roxb. ex W.Hunter Ixora congesta Malayan Ixora, Jarum Jarum Musa yunnanensis Häkkinen & H.Wang Averrhoa carambola L
233
234
TEMPORAL CONNECTIONS Bargotra Poornima
Public housing in Singapore (Known as HDB’s) are usually designed as non-gated “vertical communities” with a significant amount of open space left for residents’ use. More often than not, these spaces are disconnected, stagnant and lack a sense of place. The chosen site is located in Bukit Panjang one of the oldest H B estates in Singapore and a special one due to its very close proximity to the Central Catchment Nature Reserve. This project aims to ameliorate the experiential and programmatic quality for the existing and future residents by proposing an intervention that uses the powerful magnitude of time as the main catalyst. It explores and magnifies the possibility of an everchanging and continuous dialogue between the users and the spaces that evolve over time. Various strategies will be implemented to selectively introduce a “wild” aesthetic in a typically manicured landscapes of an HDB to encourage greater levels of public acceptance for less heavily managed landscapes This is done by introducing temporal interventions. The first strategy is to implement succession/dynamic planting schemes that allow changes in population and provides opportunities for more biologically diverse communities to develop over time. This then allows for a more appropriate planting approach and species selection which will be introduced in phases. This is done by learning from Singapore’s tropical forest succession and retrofitting it to the urban, dense residential context of the HDB estates. The second strategy is to strengthen and improve the relationship of humans with nature by a process of dynamic programming of the various spaces. This is accomplished by periodically introducing structures, pathways and seating areas that are flexible in its form and materiality, allowing them to adapt over time through the phases. Programmatic activities will also begin to alter as time and nature progresses, carving out a temporal landscape in its true form. The third strategy explores the possibility of involving the residents in the entire process of the various interventions. This is done by the introduction of community gardens, providing designated planting beds and instilling activities that educate people about the forest, plant species and its value. By offering people an active role in the shaping of their outdoor nature and sensory experiences, it enables the users to be emotionally connected with the neighborhood and its landscape. Public housing in Singapore usually have a fixed lease period due to constant demands and rapid urbanization. As the lease expiry of the HDB estate approaches, a new landscape has already been established through the years and by the introduction of the various strategies. This now dictates the design of a new development a housing typology where “landscape comes first” done by directly and indirectly involving the residents who have witnessed a progressive change in the development of this dynamic landscape.
SITE HISTORY & PHOTOS
Understanding the site through historical analysis
Fig.1: Historical Map from 1945
Fig. 2: Historical Map from 1975
Fig. 3: Historical Map from1993
Fig. 4: Historical Map from 2005
Fig. 5: Map Showing Sites at Present
- Presence of rubber & gambier plantations -Natural water streams ďŹ&#x201A;owing accorss the sites -Presence of plantation estates due to cultivation lands
- New roads built due to rural towns getting developed - New housing developments along the roads - Plantations still persist
- Depletion of water streams - Roads are further developed with the presence of new highways (BKE built) - HDB estates are formed - High deforestation due to the development of a new town
- LRT line built for a better public transport connectivity in Bukit Panjang - Construction of moew HDBâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s - More roads are set up for better connectivity
-Dense built up area, consisting mostly of public housing, community centers & markets -Introduction of park connectors to enhance the ecological corridors -Huge disconnect from adjacent CCNR
CCNR Focus Site Bukit Panjang 1
CCNR
0
1
2
0 0.1 0.2
4
2
0.4km
Legend Total Site Area: 5.6ha GPR: 2.8 (URA MASTER PLAN) Age of current development: 31 YEARS Lease term left: 68 YEARS Current no. of units: 992
CCNR Buffer (1km)
CCNR Boundary Line
Existing Parks
Roads
Unused Site Locations LRT Station
Water Bodies
Unused Spaces found on site:
Carpark Area
1
Vegetation Density Bukit Panjang, -Low to medium BLK 251 Bangkit 1.380208, 103.773040 Size: 0.65 ha 236
2
URA masterplan - Residential
Private Apartments HDB
LRT Line
Landed Properties Other Buildings Bukit Panjang Boundary
Vegetation Density Bukit Panjang, -Low to medium Blk 274 Bangkit 1.379213, 103.775396 Size: 4.4 ha
URA masterplan - Park
EXISTING HUMAN ACTIVITIES Existing circulation mapping HOME
CORRIDORS
LIFT LOBBY/ STAIRS
VOID DECK
NEIGHBORHOOD AREAS
PATHWAYS
External
Hawker
LRT Station
Carparks
Internal
Outdoor Fitness
Community Gardens
Playgrounds
Bus stop
Nearby markets
TOWN
Neighborhood Parks
Work Place
School
Weekend Entertainment
Human usage mapping high activity time
usage level
low activity time
high activity time
low activity time
high medium low
y
erl
eld
ts
adul
time
ren
child
gers
ena
& te
06:00
08:00
10:00
12:00
elderly socialising
going to school
elderly taking a walk
nearby shops & office workers going for lunch
14:00
18:00
16:00
20:00
22:00
00:00
routine activities families eating at nearby hawker
children back from school
going to office
adults evening jogs
targeted activities naturalist starts their tour
elderly using fitness
elderly using community gardens
children and teens playing
dog walkers
family picnics in the evening
Opportunity: Unused Open Spaces Between & Near HDB Estates
outdoor evening resting
naturalist starts their night tour to spot nocturnal animals
Opportunity for improved and exciting pocket gardens between HDB blocks
The need of space for residents to have their own private planting
Presence of exotic species on existing site Unused green areas in close proximity to HDB’s
The need for larger and more exciting community planting areas
The need for more attractive seating and resting spots in void decks
237
UNDERSTANDING HDB USERS REQUIREMENTS
Surface
soft
Acceptable noise level
semi hard
loud
moderate
Acceptable crowd level
silent
Desires
open
Requirements
Naturalist
- Learn about nature
Desires
dense
m
Desires
Requireme
- Exclusive, designated zones where they can observe animals & birds
- Space to run around and play in after school
Teenager (13 - 20)
secluded
TARGETED ACTIVITIES
AGE BASED Child (3 - 13)
populated
Acceptable cano
Requirements
- Space to hang out with friends
Amateur Gardener
Desires
Family Picnic
Desires
- Outdoor quiet study spots
Requireme
- A quiet space to plant and escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life
-Outdoor play courts
Adults (20 - 55)
Desires
Requirements
- Space to enjoy a relaxed evening after work
- A quiet and soft space where families can bond with one another after a hectic week
- Outdoor ďŹ tness areas and jogging trails
Local elderly (55+)
Desires - Space to hang out with friends and play mahjong
Requirements
Exercise & Fitness
Desires
Dog Walkers
Desires
- Enjoy peace and quiet during off-peak hours
- Space to exercise with fresh air and forested zones
- A safe place to throw a ball around and let them be free
238
Requireme
Requiremen
opy cover
moderate
ents
ents
ents
Nature of space
open
space to relax
exciting trails
Required cover
active zones
seating areas
TARGETED ACTIVITIES Joggers
Desires
shelter
covered walkways
TARGET GROUPS Requirements
Couple
Desires
Requirements
Desires - A peaceful place for intimacy secluded from other people
- Exclusive, designated trails/paths for residents to enjoy a run
Outdoor Resting
exposed to tree shade the elements
Family
- Exclusive spaces for people to rest outdoors amidst a green environment
Desires - A vibrant place for families to spend time together
Friends
Desires - A comfortable place for friends to catch up
nts
239
EXISTING SITE CONDITIONS
Understanding the site through site photos & their character
SPACE CHARACTER Flexible use Designated use
DESIGNATED USE HUMAN ACTIVITY SPACES Active playgrounds Neighbourood green Nearby facilities Void decks
PLAYGROUNDS
NEIGHBOURH
FLORA & FAUNA Opportunistic Community gardens Neighbourood Parks Infrastructure green
COMMUNITY GARDENS
OPPOR
GEOLOGY & WATER History Topography Drainage Flow
HISTORY
TOPOGRAPHY
INFRASTRUCTURE Existing buildings Road network Public transport
EXISTING BUILDINGS 240
ROAD NE
HOOD GREEN
RTUNISTIC
ETWORK
FLEXIBLE USE
NEARBY FACILITIES
NEIGHBOURHOOD PARKS
VOID DECK
INFRASTUCTURE GREEN
DRAINAGE FLOW
PUBLIC TRANSPORT 241
EXISTING SITE ANALYSIS Existing Schematic Site Plan
Surface Car Park Blk 250
87m Blk 251
d Bukit Panjang Ring Roa
50m
110m 22m
Bangkit LRT Station Blk 252
Blk 254
Blk 255
Blk 253
Trees Identified in Zhenghua Park adjacent to CCNR: Syzygium polyanthum, Adinandra dumosa, Agathis borneensis, Carallia brachiata, Cinnamomum iners, Durio zibethinus, Hopea odorata, Neobalanocarpus heimii,Shorea leprosula Highlighted in red are the species are native primary or secondary forest species that thrive well in urban areas. These trees also attract birds and therefore, are important key flora species.
B. Panjang Ring Road
UNUSED LAND USE: RESIDENTIAL Gentle mounds
Small pathway with landscaped edges
B. Panjang Ring Road 0
242
25
B. Panjang LRT Station 50
Chosen Site Open Green Space (Carpark behind) 100m
Informal Pathway
UNUSED LAND USE: RESIDENTIAL Gentle mounds, between two HDB blocks
HDB Block (11 floors) With Void Deck
Chosen Site Open Green Space
Potential to create an Ecological Network
Zhenghua Park
BKE
CCNR
1
Pang Sua Pond
2 3
Zhenghua Park Petir Park
4
Chosen Intervention Sites Existing Public Parks Existing Water Bodies Ecological Network Small birds distribution range (200m)
Bukit Timah Expressway (BKE) Zhenghua Park Surface Carpark & Road
UNUSED LAND USE: GREEN Gentle mounds Close to highway
Recreational park with secondary forest species
Surface Carpark & Road
Blk 253 4 floors
CCNR Boundary
Disconnection with HDB Spaces
Unused Open Green Space
Zhenghua Park
Bukit Timah Expressway (BKE)
CCNR
243
EXISTING SITE PLAN
Greenridge Secondary School
Plan showing existin trees, site drainage & activity areas
Blk 247
Blk 244
1
LEGEND 1 Existing Playgrounds 2 Existing Community Gardens 3 Unused Open Space 4 Unused Pocket Spaces Existing Trees in Zhenghua Park: Alstonia angustiloba
3
Carallia brachiata Cinnamomum iners
Pometia pinnata Adinandra dumosa Neobalanocarpus heimii Treed identified as roadside trees: Khaya grandiflora
1
Bangkit LRT
Bukit Panjang
Ring Road
Shorea leprosula
Khaya senegalensis Calophyllum soulattri
Blk 255
Blk 254
Trees identified on site: Caesilpinia ferrea (exotic species) Bucida molineti
Bangkit Road
Agathis borneensis Existing Site Drainage: Open Drain (600mm wide) Drain with grating cover (every 2.5m) Bukit Panjang Town Council
Underground Drain Connection
0
25
50
100m
THE CHOSEN SITE The chosen site is located in Bukit Panjang â&#x20AC;&#x201C; one of the oldest HDB estates in Singapore and a special one due to its very close proximity to CCNR. This project aims to ameliorate the experiential quality for the residents by proposing an intervention that uses the powerful magnitude of time as the main catalyst. It explores the possibility of an everchanging and continuous dialogue between the users and the spaces that evolve over time. 244
Small pathway with landscaped edges
B. Panjang Ring Road
B. Panjang LRT Station
Chosen Site Open Green Space (Carpark behind)
Informal Pathway
2 Blk 248
Blk 249
4
Central Catchment Nature Reserve
Blk 250
1 Zhenghua Park
Blk 251
4 Blk 252
Blk 253
2
Recreational park with secondary forest species
Chosen Site Open Green Space
CCNR Boundary
HDB Block (11 floors) With Void Deck
Surface Carpark & Road
Blk 253 4 floors
Unused Open Green Space
Zhenghua Park
Bukit Timah Expressway 245 (BKE)
CCNR
0-10 YEARS PLANNING STRATEGY
Greenridge Secondary School
Blk 247
Blk 244
4
5
LEGEND 1 Community Built Forest
Extension to LRT Station
4
Planting Beds
5
Fruit Tree & Event Planting Beds
6
Existing playground
7
Existing community gardens
8
Fruit Trees & Open Areas
9
Connection to Zhenghua Park
2 3
Ring Road
Open spaces for activities
3
1 4
Bangkit LRT
6
Bukit Panjang
2
Existing Site Drainage Open Drain (600mm wide)
Blk 255
Drain with grating cover (every 2.5m)
Blk 254
Underground Drain Connection
TREE SPECIES LEGEND
Bangkit Road
Pioneer Species Emergent Species Nitrogen Fixing Species Fruit Trees Bukit Panjang Town Council
Existing Trees
0
25
50
Amended topography
100m
0-10 YEARS - 1ST PHASE - PREPARE The first phase will focus on preparing the existing ground, by making amends to the existing conditions of the unused open spaces on site. This is done through learning from a primary forest succession and retrofitting it to the urban, dense residential context of Singaporeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s HDB estates. This phase will also focus on educating and training the residents. 246
B. Panjang Ring Road
B. Panjang LRT Station
Unused open space used as Community Forest
Informal Pathway
2 Blk 248
Blk 249
8 Central Catchment Nature Reserve Blk 250
1 Zhenghua Park
Blk 251
5 Blk 252
Blk 253
2
Unused site used as event planting beds with fruiting trees
CCNR Boundary
HDB Block (11 floors) With Void Deck
Surface Carpark & Road
Blk 253 4 floors
Unused Open Green Space
Zhenghua Park
Bukit Timah Expressway (BKE)
CCNR
10-20 YEARS PLANNING STRATEGY
Greenridge Secondary School
Blk 247
Blk 244
4
5
LEGEND 1 Community Built Forest Extension to LRT Station
4
Planting Beds
5
Fruit Tree & Event Planting Beds
6
Existing playground
7
Existing community gardens
8
Fruit Trees & Open Areas
9
Connection to Zhenghua Park
2 3
Ring Road
Smaller open spaces for activities
3
1 4
Bangkit LRT
6
Bukit Panjang
2
Existing Site Drainage Open Drain (600mm wide)
Blk 255
Drain with grating cover (every 2.5m)
Blk 254
Underground Drain Connection
TREE SPECIES LEGEND
Bangkit Road
Pioneer Species Emergent Species Nitrogen Fixing Species Fruit Trees
Bukit Panjang Town Council
Existing Trees
0
25
50
100m
10-20 YEARS - 2ND PHASE - FACILITATE The second phase will encourage the residents to facilitate the growth of native species by a timely planned out process and introduce activity areas that can benefit from this stage of the landscape. Boardwalks and pathways will be built after careful study of how the residents have been using the space in the first phase.
248
B. Panjang Ring Road
B. Panjang LRT Station
Unused open space used as Community Forest
Informal Pathway
2 Blk 248
Blk 249
8 Central Catchment Nature Reserve Blk 250
1 Zhenghua Park
Blk 251
5 Blk 252
Blk 253
2
Unused site used as event planting beds with fruiting trees
CCNR Boundary
HDB Block (11 floors) With Void Deck
Surface Carpark & Road
Blk 253 4 floors
Unused Open Green Space
Zhenghua Park
Bukit Timah Expressway (BKE)
CCNR
30 YEARS PLANNING STRATEGY
Greenridge Secondary School
10
Blk 244
6
15 4
LEGEND Connection to LRT Station
3
Elevated Boardwalk
4
Eco-Pond
5
Open Lawn Area
6
Event Based Planting Beds
7
Propagation Beds
8
Tree Grove
9
Community Play
1 Ring Road
Community Built Forest
2
Bangkit LRT
2
Bukit Panjang
1
11
10
10
10 Sky Bridge Garden 11 Pick Up Drop Off 12 Extended Community Gardens 13 Park Connections
Bangkit Road
14 Zhenghua Park Existing Trails
TREE SPECIES LEGEND
Tree species developed overtime Tree species introduced through propagation
Bukit Panjang Town Council
Existing Trees
0
25
50
100m
20-30 YEARS - 3RD PHASE - INVENT As the lease expiry of the HDB estate approaches, a new landscape has already been established through the years and by the introduction of the various strategies. This forest now dictates the design of a new development– a housing typology where “landscape comes fi r st” d one b y d irectly a nd i ndirectly involving the residents who have witnessed a progressive change in the development of this dynamic landscape.”
MSCP
B. Panjang Ring Road
B. Panjang LRT Station
Community built Forest kept untouched
Sky Bridge Gardens
12
10
11
10 9 Central Catchment Nature Reserve
5
Zhenghua Park
7
3 7
8
10
13
11
12
Sky Bridge Gardens
Elevated walkways that work around the existing trees
New Development
CCNR Boundary
6
13
Unobstructed connection to Zhenghua Park and CCNR
Zhenghua Park
Bukit Timah Expressway (BKE)
CCNR
PLANTING STRATEGIES
Planting fast growing sun tolerant pioneer species to provide shade for the propagation of emergent species
The emergent species soon project over the pioneers. Pioneer shrubs die back and make way for shrubs that are shade loving.
The emergent species grow under the shade of mature pioneer species, giving way to shade tolerant shrubs/ groundcover
Emergent species Pioneer species
Tree Species
Forest Type
Size at maturity
Longetivity
Dispersal
Dyera costula
Primary
> 30m
> 80 Years
Birds
Targeted Birds
Shorea leprosula
Primary
> 30m
> 80 Years
Birds
Koompassia malaccensis
Primary
> 30m
> 80 Years
Wind
Alstonia angustiloba
Primary, Secondary
> 30m
> 80 Years
Wind
Repels crows
Carallia brachiata
Primary, Secondary
> 30m
> 80 Years
Birds
Long Tailed Parakeet
Cinnamomum iners
Secondary
10 - 30m
20 - 80 Years
Birds
Syzygium grande
Secondary
10 - 30m
20 - 80 Years
Birds, Small Mammals
Crimson Sunbird
Syzygium lineatum
Secondary
10 - 30m
20 - 80 Years
Bird, Small Mammals
Oriential Pied Hornbill
Syzygium polyanthum
Secondary
10 - 30m
20 - 80 Years
Birds
Oriential Pied Hornbill
Macaranga bancana
Secondary
10 - 30m
20 - 80 Years
Birds
Long Tailed Parakeet
Gnetum Gnemon
Secondary
10 - 30m
20 - 80 Years
Birds, Small Mammals
Greater Racket Tailed Drongo
Litsea elliptica
Secondary
10 - 30m
`
Birds, Small Mammals
Cratoxylum cochinchinense
Secondary
<10m
<20 Years
Birds
Streblus elongatus
Primary, Secondary
10 - 30m
20 - 80 Years
Bird, Small Mammals
Fragrea fragrans
Secondary
> 30m
> 80 Years
Birds
Proposed Tree Species* Most are found in adjacent henghua Park and can be propagated on site.
252
TEMPORAL CONNECTIONS
Proposing activities that change overtime, with nature
Year 0
Year 30
Year 0
Year 30
“Watch a tree grow as you grow”
Community Gardens >> Community Forest
YEAR 0 - 10
YEAR 10 - 20
PHASE 01 PREPARE
To prepare the ground by making amends to the existing conditions of the unused space
PHASE 02 FACILITATE
To facilitate growth of native species by a timely planned out process and with the help of the existing community
YEAR 20 - 30 PHASE 03 EXTEND
Propagation of species to other nearby developments and neighborhood parks in order to extend the habitat range
YEAR 30
PHASE 04 INVENT End of the existing HDB lease and the beginning of a new housing typology
Planting strategy in phases
253
0-10 YEARS
Pioneer Species in open conditions
planting beds
Designated planting areas
Materials that change overtime
254
ďŹ&#x201A;exible pavilions
open activity areas
Habitat logs from nearby parks movable benches
255
10-20 YEARS
Sightings of shade loving understorey
Logs from nearby felled trees Sighting of leaf litter
Materials that change overtime
256
ï¬&#x201A;exible pavilions
Mushroom picking
257
AT 30 YEARS
Fruit trees attracting avifauna
Pathways and boardwalks built following the TPZ of existing trees
Planting valuable fern species as undergrowth layer
258
New development follows landscape
Broken down habitat logs, now adding nutrients and structure to the soil
259
A DYNAMIC LANDSCAPE Introduced pathways Modular seating areas Undulating play areas
0-10 years 260
10-20 years
â&#x20AC;&#x153;Landscape Comes Firstâ&#x20AC;? 1. Re-use site resources such as top soil and plant materials and recycle what exists on site rather than transporting large quantities of material in and out. 2. Implement succession/dynamic planting schemes that allow changes in population and provides opportunities for more biologically diverse communities to develop over time. 3. Incremental development plans to avoid sudden erasure of an old landscape while meeting the needs of the new economy/population.
20-30 years
30+ years 261
262
FRAMING TIMELINE Lim Wenfa
Situated next to Bishan Ang Mo Kio Park (BAMKP) and opposite Lower Peirce Reservoir Park (LPRP), the 5ha site has great potential to home uncommon native avian and arboreal species but has failed in doing so because the ecosystem network is disconnected and degraded, even though they are physically close to each other. Predicted to be kept untouched till future residential development in 20 years, the site is home to large healthy fig trees that provide habitats to common fauna species. Fertile soil potentially can also be utilized as a natural resource for neighbouring/ own future development. The project hence aims to rewild the site with three development phases across a duration of 0 years. Injecting beneficial ecological values by proposing a landscapecome-first development model to challenge the current notion of land-use. Given that the site is big enough to supply trees for reforestation at the degraded forest of LPRP, the site is developed into a tree nursery in the first phase. The siteâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s existing drainage system will be integrated with the design of the bio-detention pond as part of the nature irrigation system of the nursery. In the second phase, selectively remained trees from the nursery become mature and the site turns into a potential ecological hotspot, focusing on fauna movement and habitat creation. In the meantime, a segment of future residential housing development is constructed. The landscapecomes-first development model will give way to a design framework that proposes to keep at least half of the ecological hotspot untouched to provide strong ecological connectivity. The third phase is the completion of all residential developments after 30 years. Green and blue networks from the previous phase is integrated into the new residential development, offering active human-fauna interaction opportunities as part of their daily life experience. The project envisions to enrich the siteâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s biological value by providing a healthier and wider pool of genetic diversity across the region. Human behaviour towards nature is also changed through the proposed timeframe. The proposal can serve as a prototype, duplicable to another temporary vacant state land as a sequential rewilding approach, rather than letting the land being temporarily unused.
263
ISSUES AND POTENTIALS
Lower Peirce Reservoir Park Degraded forest Area To Species Ratio
Unused State Land - Healthy fig trees - Fertile soil - Habitat to common species (mynas & crows) - Predicted to be untouched till residential development in 20 years.
Bishan, Ang Mo Kio Avenue 1 1.367695, 103.833829 5.29ha 264
Existing Green Networks Disconnect Ang Mo Kio Town Garden West Nature urban park Potential Green Network Low Vegetation Density
Reserved Site 265
KEY TARGET SPECIES
266
PRIMARY FORESTS KEY MAMMALS: Lesser Mousedeer, Banded leaf monkey MATURE SECONDARY FORESTS KEY MAMMALS: Long-Tailed Macaque, Slow loris, Plantain Squirrel, Common Palm Civet, Wild Pig, Sunda Pangolin KEY BIRDS: Greater Racke-Tailed Drongo, Dollarbird YOUNG SECONDARY FORESTS KEY MAMMALS: Long-Tailed Macaque, Slow loris, Plantain Squirrel, Common Palm Civet, Wild Pig, Sunda Pangolin, Common Fruit Bat KEY BIRDS: Greater Racke-Tailed Drongo, Dollarbird, Long-tailed Parakeet, Oriental Pied-hornbill. WETLAND KEY MAMMALS: Long-Tailed Macaque, Plantain Squirrel, Common Palm Civet, Wild Pig KEY BIRDS: Greater Racke-Tailed Drongo, Dollarbird, Long-tailed Parakeet, riental Pied-hornbill, Collared kingfisher WETLAND MARSH KEY MAMMALS: Plantain Squirrel, Common Palm Civet, Common Fruit Bat K BIR S Long-tailed Parakeet, riental Pied-hornbill, Collared kingfisher PARKS & GARDENS KEY MAMMALS: Plantain Squirrel, Common Palm Civet, Common Fruit Bat KEY BIRDS: Long-tailed Parakeet, Oriental Pied-hornbill, Collared kingfisher, Crimson Sunbird
“High Count” is the highest count of a species submitted on a single checklist within a specified date range and region. SINGLE CHECKLIST: WEEKLY DATE RANGE: JANUARY 2019 - 19 SEP 2019 High Count Data Source: The CornellLab of Ornithology https://www.birds.cornell.edu/home/about/
267
FAUNA BARRIERS Barriers analysis
TIMEFRAME
Historical maps and Landuse maps
Forested
Residential
Rubber plantation
School
Garden/Park
Vacant state land
268
Reserved Land
FRAMING TIMELINE
Landscape-comes-first, Strengthen human-nature connectivity Phase 1
Incubation Reforestation at LPRP - Fertile soil can be utilized as a natural resource. - Improved degraded forest for wider range of fauna. Construction of Waterbodies - Improve existing water system for self-sufficient. - Primary stage for habitation.
Phase 2
Habitation Facilitate fauna movement - Develop forest fringe from previous phase. - Pockets of shrubland created for fauna activity. - Wetland created from previous waterbodies. - New trees planted to connect existing trees. First stage of residential developments - Landscape-come-first design framework - Nature closer to human by expanding waterbodies and more trees.
Integration Completion of residential developments plan - Landscape-come-first design model. - Green and blue networks intergrated. - Active humans-ature interaction opportunities.
269
FRAMING TIMELINE - INCUBATION Design Processes
Existing drain Existing drain Detention Pond (0.26ha, 3613L)
Ground level (GL: 0.00m)
Ground level (GL: -1.00m)
Vacant land (Size of 2.43ha)
Existing trees (Patch size of 1.37ha)
Existing Building (Patch size of 1.49ha)
Under-utilised state land (Total size of 5.29ha)
Degraded forest of LPRP (Degraded patch size of 3.86ha)
270
Retention Pond Irrigation for nursery (0.16ha, 1608.9L)
Planting grid (2500mm C-C)
271
PHASE 1 MA
Framing Timelin
272
ASTER PLAN
ne - Incubation
273
FRAMING TIMELINE - INCUBATION
A A
At the macro scale, trees from the nursery can be utilise to enhance the current green network First phase planting list (trees)
Tree Nursery
Section A-A
274
Bio-detention pond
Before
After
FIRST PHASE - KEY TARGET SPECIES First phase key target species Fauna species (urban adaptor)
Types
Ecological Status Status
Requirements
Habitat
high flyer
Common
Food source
Parks and Gardens Day / Disturbed Area
Active
BIRDS Asian Koel
Already there
Long-Tailed Parakeet
high flyer
Common
From BAMK park
Tall trees landing
Moist Lowland
Pink-Necked Green Pigeon
high flyer
Common
Already there
Food source
Parks and Gardens Day / Disturbed Area
Day
Crimson Sunbird
low flyer
Common
From surrounding parks
Nectar plants
Parks and Gardens Day
Yellow-Vented Bulbul
low flyer
Common
Already there
Food source
Parks and Gardens Day / Disturbed Area
Asian Glossy Starling
low flyer
Common
From LPR park
Food source
Parks and Gardens Day
Plantain Squirrel
Common
From surrounding parks
Woody vegetation
Parks and Gardens Day / Disturbed Area
Common Fruit Bat
Common
From surrounding parks
Food source
Parks and Gardens Night / Disturbed Area
Common Flying Lizard
Common
From surrounding parks
Woody vegetation
Parks and Gardens Day & night / Disturbed Area
Green Crested Lizard
Common
From surrounding parks
Woody vegetation
Parks and Gardens Day & night / Disturbed Area
Grasshoppers
Common
Already there
Food source
Parks and Gardens Day & night / Disturbed Area
Bees
Common
Already there
Food source
Parks and Gardens Day / Disturbed Area
Spiders
Common
Already there
Food source
Parks and Gardens Day & night / Disturbed Area
Food source
ARBOREAL ANIMALS/GROUD ANIMALS
INSECTS & AQUATIC ANIMALS
Seeds Germination
Drain
Saplings Zone
Tree Nursery Parks and Gardens Day / Disturbed Area
Butterflies
Common
Already there 0
Fruit Frog Red-eared tortoise Four-ridged Toad
Common Common
From surrounding parks Moist vegetation From surrounding parks Food source 10 From surrounding parks Moist vegetation
20
Moist Lowland Moist Lowland Moist Lowland
Day & night Day & night 40M Day & night
275
FRAMING TIMELINE - HABITATION Urban Adapters Species Key fauna species
Habtitats
Locations
High-Flying Birds Oriental Pied Hornbill Asian Koel Dollar Bird Long-Tailed Parakeet
Dense Mature Secondary Forest
Pink-Necked Green Pigeon Greater Racket Tailed Drongo Blue-Throated Bee Eater Straw-Headed Bulbul
Young Secondary Forest
Low-Flying birds Red Junglefowl Crimson Sunbird Blue-Crowned Hanging Parrot Primary Forest Common Flameback Collared Kingfisher Yellow-Vented Bulbul Shrubland Olive-Winged Bulbul Asian Glossy Starling Ground Animals Wild Pig Rat
Forest edge/ Forest fringe
Lesser Mousedeer Arboreal Animals Plantain Squirrel Long-Tailed Macaque Moist lowland/ Mangrove forest Common Palm Civet Malayan Colugo Common Fruit Bat Sunda Pangolin Banded Leaf Monkey
Park and Garden
Slow Loris Green Crested Lizard Common Flying Lizard Insects Butterflies Bees
276
Disturbed area
Diets
Key fauna species
Plant Diet Fruit/seed Bearing Plants
Musa acuminata Colla (Banana) Carica papaya (Papaya) Nephelium lappaceum (Rambutan) Artocarpus integer (Chempedak) Ficus benjamina (Weeping Fig) Ficus microcarpa (Malayan banyan) Ficus exasperata (Sandpaper Tree) Muntingia calabura (Indian Cherry) Ptychosperma macarthurii (Macarthur Palm) Syzygium grande (Sea Apple) Syzygium polyanthum (Salam) Leea indica (Red Tree-vine) Macaranga bancana (Common Mahang) Maesopsis eminii (Umbrella Tree) Archontophoenix alexandrae (Alexandra palm) Dillenia suffruticosa (Simpoh Ayer) Cinnamomum iners (Wild Cinnamon) Plants With Nectar Saraca (Yellow Saraca) Heliconia spp. (Heliconias)
High-Flying Birds Oriental Pied Hornbill Asian Koel Dollar Bird Long-Tailed Parakeet Pink-Necked Green Pigeon Greater Racket Tailed Drongo Blue-Throated Bee Eater Straw-Headed Bulbul Low-Flying birds Red Junglefowl Crimson Sunbird Blue-Crowned Hanging Parrot Common Flameback Collared Kingfisher Yellow-Vented Bulbul Olive-Winged Bulbul Asian Glossy Starling Ground Animals Wild Pig Rat Lesser Mousedeer Arboreal Animals Plantain Squirrel Long-Tailed Macaque Common Palm Civet Malayan Colugo
Hibiscus rosa-sinensis (Hibiscus) Etlingera elatior (Torch Ginger) Spathodea campanulata (African Tulip tree) Animal Diet Small Animals (Reptiles, Birds, Mammals, Fishes)
Common Fruit Bat Sunda Pangolin Banded Leaf Monkey Slow Loris Green Crested Lizard Common Flying Lizard
Arthropods (Grasshoppers, Bees, spiders, ants, caterpillars, grubs, stick insects)
Insects Butterflies Bees
277
FRAMING TIMELINE - HABITATION Design Processes
Wetland
(Detention pond)
Shrubland Forest fringe (Nursery trees)
New trees
(Connecting existing trees)
Reforestation (From Nursery)
Degraded forest of LPRP
278
Enhancement to fauna movement
Directing nature closer to human (Further expansion of waterbodies and trees)
50% greens (2.65ha)
35% building footprint (1.85ha)
15% roads/pathways (0.79ha)
279
PHASE 2 MASTER PLAN
Framing Timeline - Habitation
280
281
FRAMING TIMELINE - HABITATION Urban Adapters Species
B
B
Before
Second phase planting list trees
High flyers movement
Ground fauna movement
Lower Peirce Reservior Park Upper Thomson Road
Section B-B 282
Drain
Forest fringe habitat
Shrubland
Moist lowland
Bio-dentention pond
d
After
SECOND AND THIRD PHASE - KEY TARGET SPECIES
SECONDphase AND THIRD - KEY TARGET SPECIES Second keyPHASE target species Types Fauna species (urban adaptor) Ecological Status Status
Requirements
Habitat
Active
Birds Fauna species (urban adaptor)
Types
Ecological Status
Status
Requirements
Habitat
Active
Birds Oriental Pied Hornbill
high flyer
From LPR park
Oriental Pied Hornbill
high flyer
Uncommon local resident Uncommon local
Dollar Bird
high flyer
resident Common
Dense vegetation Carnivore Dense vegetation
From LPR park
Woody area/ Parks Day and Gardens Woody area/ Parks Day and Gardens Woody area Day
Dollar Bird
high flyer
Common
From LPR park
Greater Racket Tailed Drongo
high flyer
Rare local resident
From LPR park
Greater Racket Tailed Drongo
high flyer
From LPR park
Common Flameback
low flyer
Common Flameback
low flyer
Rare local resident Uncommon local resident Uncommon local
Olive-Winged Bulbul
low flyer
resident Common
From LPR park
Carnivore Fruits eater
Olive-Winged Bulbul
low flyer
Common
From LPR park
Fruits eater
Uncommon local resident Uncommon local
From LPR park
Dense vegetation Omnivore, mainly fruits Dense vegetation
From LPR park
From LPR park From LPR park
Carnivore Tall trees landing Insects eater Tall trees landing
Woody area Insectsvegetation eater Dense Woody area Insects,vegetation fruits, nectar eater Dense Woody area Insects, fruits, nectar eater Woody area/ Parks Dense vegetation Carnivore and Gardens Dense vegetation Woody area/ Parks
Day Day Day Day
Day and Gardens Parks and Gardens / Day Disturbed Area Parks and Gardens / Day Disturbed Area
ARBOREAL ANIMALS/GROUD ANIMALS ARBOREAL ANIMALS/GROUD ANIMALS Long-Tailed Macaque Long-Tailed Macaque
resident Uncommon local resident Uncommon local
Common Palm Civet Common Palm Civet
resident Uncommon local resident Uncommon local
Otters Otters
resident
From LPR park From LPR park From LPR park From BAMK park From BAMK park
Snakes
Common
From LPR park
Snakes
Common
From LPR park
Omnivore, mainly fruits Dense vegetation Omnivore, mainly fruits Dense vegetation Omnivore, mainly fruits Wetland enviroment Carnivore Wetland enviroment Carnivore Dense vegetation Carnivore Dense vegetation Carnivore
Woody area/ Parks Day and Gardens Woody area/ Parks Day and Gardens Woody area Night Woody area
Night
Moist Lowland
Day
Moist Lowland
Day
Woody area/ Parks Day & night and Gardens Woody area/ Parks Day & night and Gardens
INSECTS & AQUATIC ANIMALS INSECTS & AQUATIC Copper-cheeked FrogANIMALS
From LPR park
Wetland vegetation
Moist Lowland
Day & night
Copper-cheeked Frog Four-lined Tree Frog
From LPR park From LPR park
Wetland vegetation Wetland vegetation
Moist Lowland Moist Lowland
Day & night Day & night
Four-lined Tree Frog
From LPR park
Wetland vegetation
Moist Lowland
Day & night
Forest fringe habitat
shruband
283
PHASE 3 MASTER PLAN Framing Timeline - Integration
284
285
FRAMING TIMELINE - INTEGRATION Design processes
-Void deck (Visually connected)
-Intermediate garden -Rooftop garden
Elevated buildings (9m above ground)
â&#x20AC;&#x153;Landscape-comes-first Design development model
C
C
High flyers movement
Ground fauna movement
Lower Peirce Reservior Park Upper Thomson Road
Section C-C 286
Drain
Forest fringe habitat
Shrubland
Moist lowland
Bio-dentention p
pond
Before
After
Forest fringe habitat & shruband
287
FRAMING TIMELINE
Landscape-comes-first, Strengthen human-nature connectivity
Incubation
Habitation
- Reforestation at LPRP provides better fo
- All existing trees are retained and are uniďŹ ed wh
- Landscape-come-first development model enables humans-nature i
288
Integration
orest depth habitat for a wider range of fauna.
hole with habitats created to facilitate fauna movement.
interaction with minimum disturbances to established ecosystems.
289
CLOSE TO NATURE: RECONCILED LANDSCAPE IN HDB
SHAO Zhongran
Biophilia is an innately emotional affiliation of human beings to other living organisms. However, the unpredictable wild, including the undulating landforms, capricious animals and dense canopies can make people feel insecure. In the surrounding areas of Segar Road HDB, there is distinct segregation between forested areas and residential common spaces. The limited internal space of H B has formed a strong contrast with the openness of green space adjacent to it. The project aims at creating reconciliation between human intervention and ecology restoration by bridging the gap between humans and nature by bringing people closer to nature and making the wild less intimidating. This is done by introducing two main strategies. The first is enhancing the visibility and accessibility of the wild to eliminate the segregation between buildings and open space as well as extend human movement into a larger loop. The topography of an area about 0.54 hectares is manipulated in the periphery of building blocks. The rooftop of a carpark, as well as Zhenghua Park, is transformed to replace the original activity space among the blocks. Series of trails and programs including a community garden are proposed across the site, providing visual guidance and physical entrances to the wild for both residents and existing pipeline trail hikers. The second strategy is inserting natural habitats into HDB green spaces. Native low-growing species are selected to attract birds, butterflies and small mammals such as s uirrels on the current open grassland above the pipelines. Open activity spaces and greenery patches that are enclosed by the H B blocks will be aggregated for breaking the landscape homogeneity and forest flora species will be introduced. By guiding people to get close to nature and enhancing the connection of the existing habitats, the project envisions an interwoven landscape as well as a biophilic lifestyle in an urban environment.
SITE ANALYSIS Site Selection
Vegetation
Biodiversity High: 6.7
Missing data
Vegetated area with low biodiversity Missing data
Positive correlation between vegetation and biodiversity
Vegetated area Low: 0
Unvegetated area
Negative correlation between vegetation and biodiversity
URA Planning The site is located in the northeast of Bukit Panjang,next to K BK . It is mainly composed of dense HDB blocks and open green space of ZhengHua Nature Park. A distinct differentiation between nature and urbanized space is shown here.
Residential
Sports & Recreation
Commercial & Residential
Waterbody
Open Space
Reserve Area
Park
Special Use
Distribution of Housing Types in Singapore
Area
292
1 hactares
High canopy (>10 m) Low canopy (<10 m) High shrubs (>3 m) Low shrub (>0.3 m) Lawn Drainage Open activity space Sheltered activity space Corridor Multi-storey car park Railing Barrier gate Informal trail
293
Existing Tree Species Undefined 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Native species Adinandra dumosa Alstonia angustifolia Calophyllum soulattri Cyrtophyllum fragrans Macaranga bancana Pteleocarpa lamponga Sandoricum koetjape Shorea leprosula Syzygium glaucum Terminalia catappa Tristaniopsis whiteana Vitex pinnata
Common Name Tiup Tiup Red-leaved Pulai Malang-Malang Tembusu Hutan / Tembusu Tikus Santol Lentang / Ketapang Pelawan Malayan Teak
Family Pentaphylacaceae Apocynaceae Calophyllaceae Gentianaceae Euphorbiaceae Boraginaceae Meliaceae Dipterocarpaceae Myrtaceae Combretaceae Myrtaceae Lamiaceae (Labiatae)
13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Exotic species Agathis robusta Agathis borneensis Alstonia scholaris Artocarpus heterophyllus Callerya atropurpurea Dalbergia oliveri Delonix regia Dipterocarpus baudii Hopea odorata Khaya grandifoliola Khaya nyasica Khaya senegalensis Mimusops elengi Pentaspadon motleyi Saraca thaipingensis Schizolobium parahyba Shorea roxburghii Sterculia foetida
/ Malayan Kauri White Cheesewood Nangka Jenaris Black Rosewood Semarak Api Bulu Merawan Siput Jantan Benin Mahogany White Mahogany African Mahogany Bunga Tanjung White Pelong-Tree Talan Brazilian Fire-Tree Temak Kalupat
Araucariaceae Araucariaceae Apocynaceae Moraceae Fabaceae (Leguminosae) Fabaceae (Leguminosae) Fabaceae (Leguminosae) Dipterocarpaceae Dipterocarpaceae Meliaceae Meliaceae Meliaceae Sapotaceae Anacardiaceae Fabaceae (Leguminosae) Fabaceae (Leguminosae) Dipterocarpaceae Malvaceae
History Map
The site remained Road network formed. underdeveloped and Drainage system basically a natural state. established. Residential area emerged in the south of the site.
Segar Road HDB blocks were built up. Regional accessibility was enhanced.
More infrastucture was built up. The extension of Zhenghua Nature Park was yet to establish.
Condos and new HDB were built up. An extension of Zhenghua park was opened.
Survey and Interview
internal space of residence
extension of Zhenghua Park
linear corridor of Zhenghua Park 294
unsecured
Streamlines Residents streamline
Vehicle streamline
Waterflow
Visibility and Accessbility
295
296
Legend Barrier gate Shrubs Existing trees Castanopsis inermis Samanea saman Syzygium grande Rhopaloblaste singaporensis Ficus benjamina L. Cassia fistula L.
Lawn Roof Garden Sunken Square Public patio Treetop Walk Elevated Boardwalk Fitness area Childrenâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s playground Waterfront space Viewing deck Bridge Community Garden Platform under the expressway
297
DESIGN STRATEGIES
The overall goal of the design is creating reconciliation between human intervention and ecology restoration by bridging the gap between humans and nature to bringing people close to nature while making the wild less intimidating.
Strategy 1
Bringing people close to nature Enhancing the visibility and accessibility of the wild to eliminate the segregation between buildings and open space as well as extend human movement into a larger loop. Providing visual guidance and physical entrances to the wild for both residents and existing pipeline trail hikers. 1. Manipulating the topography The topography of an area about 0.54 hectare is manipulated in the periphery of building blocks, providing physical entrance to the residents.
298
2. Replacing The rooftop of a carpark, as well as Zhenghua Park, is transformed to replace the original activity space among the blocks, extending peopleâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s movement into a larger loop.
3. Adding
Series of trails and programs including a community garden are proposed across the site, providing people with opportunities to experience in nature with different senses.
299
Strategy 2
Bringing nature close to people Inserting natural habitats into HDB green spaces. 1. Aggregating Open activity space and greenery patches that are enclosed by the HDB blocks will be aggregated for breaking the landscape homogeneity. Biodiversity and the area of public space will be increased. Scattered Large patches & corridors
300
eggplant
marigold
castor
hibiscus
fennel
tomato
rosemary
ash gourd
ladyfinger
lemon grass
bitter melon
cauliflowe
2. Planting a . Native low-growing species are selected to attract birds, butterflies and mild mammals such as squirrels on the current open grassland above the pipelines. b). The drainage is softened from a concrete and railed up one into an accessible vegetated one. c). Native tree species extensively found on the other side of BKE are introduced into the space among the HDB blocks. Target bird species are supposed to be attracted.
Castanopsis inermis (Lindl. ex Wall.) Benth. & Hook.f. Samanea saman Jacq.) Merr. (small leaves) Syzygium grande (Wight) Walp. Rhopaloblaste singaporensis Ficus benjamina L. Cyrtophyllum fragrans (Roxb.) DC. Cassia fistula L.
mint
jasmine
Melastoma malabathricum
Schismatoglottis wallichii
Pluchea indica
rose
cucumber
Ixora congesta
Aglaonema nitidum
Tarenna fragrans
r
grape
guava
Tristellateia australasiae
Hanguana malayana
Panicum repens
er
coriander
holy basil
Acrostichum aureum
Leea rubra
Scleria ciliaris
301
302
303
304
WILDLIFE IN THE YARDS:
BREAK THE BARRIERS BETWEEN RESIDENCE AND WILD NATURE Zhong Yixin & Zhang Bingqian
Compared to other types of residential areas, the landed property is closer to the CCNR and has a higher green land rate per capita. Hence, land property residents might be more tolerant of wildlife. The first site is a 12-hectare residential area on the north-east part of the CCNR 1-kilometer buffer, near endangered Nee soon swamp. The second site Windsor Park Property has a dynamic housing form that sits on an undulated terrain and surrounded by Windsor Natural Park. Having faced intense urban expansion pressure, biodiversity has decreased on the edges of these two residential areas. Therefore, the two projects explore how to reconnect the urbanized environment and nature, making the residents and wild nature live in harmony. The first project focuses on encouraging wildlife movements and minimizing the disservices of wild nature by mitigating human-wildlife conflicts. The first strategy is to break the current barriers, by naturalizing the existing concrete canal, enlarging the road tree canopy, and de-fencing the private residential area. The second strategy is to design new housing typologies. Some mature plants will remain, while more animal-friendly plants will be introduced to provide a movement corridor. Furthermore, new land properties will be built with a second-story viewing deck which is connected with a treetop boardwalk for residentsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; to walk and observe wildlife. The second project is to take advantage of the siteâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s uni ue topography and create a rich vegetation landscape. The first strategy is to enable residents to experience the beauty of ecological gardens by the restoration of the public space(roads, edge, playground). The second strategy is to utilize the private spaces that are underutilized due to the complex terrain as a semi-public space that supports local habitats as well as recreational areas in daily life. Consequently, the last strategy is to suggest a better yards plan for residents and promote native and useful plants. The projects aims to allow residents to appreciate the wild nature that is around them. As time goes by, residents or their later generations will invite nature to their home. It can be a typical module for further sustainable residential developments in Singapore and finally achieve the goal for Rewilding.
EXISTING SITE CONDITION Site location
The site is a 12-hectare residential area on the north-east part of the CCNR 1-kilometer buffer, near endangered Nee soon swamp. URA planning Reserve site
Residential
Special use
Residential with commercial at 1st story
Park
According to URA planning, the current central green space in this residential area will be constructed into new land properties. Existing site condition
Gardening plants Street tree Grass turf Scrubland
Nephelium lappaceum(Hairy Lychee)
Syzygium polyanthum
Musa acuminata(Banana)
Pterocarpus indicus(Sena)
Durio zibethinus (Durian)
Ficus benjamina Malayan Banyan
Cocos nucifera(coconut)
Cassia fistula Golden Shower
Artocarpus heterophyllus (Jackfruit)
Planchonella obovata (Menasi)
Adonidia merrillii (Christmas Palm)
Peltophorum pterocarpum (Jemerlang Laut) Neolitsea cassia
306
Canal Surfaceflow Underground drainge Semi-fence Contrete fence
1-storey house 2-storey house 3-storey house 4-storey house Residential area(URA) Land properties will be demolished
SURVEY AND RESEARCH Survey of the residential area
KINDS OF ENCOUNTERED ANIMALS
ACCEPTANCE LEVEL OF WILDLIFE
MAIN ACTIVITIES IN RESIDENTIAL AREA
ANIMALS CAN BE ACCEPTED
acceptable
slightly acceptable
stay at home
runnning
disinterest
monkey
boar
rooster
neutral
slightly unacceptable
walking to reservior
walking around
all
monkey
boar
rooster
birds
butterfly
lizard
snake
unacceptable
planting
dog-walking
butterfly
lizard
snake
birds
Research: Disservice elements in tropical forests
307
BARRIER ANALYSIS
Urban barriers for ground animals
High
Low
Building Fence Water High building
Hardscape
Low building Concrete fence Semi-fence Canal Surface flow
Concrete road Hardscape
308
Urban barriers for birds
High
Low
Building Fence Hardscape High building
Water
Low building
Semi-fence
Concrete fence
Concrete road Hardscape Canal Surface flow
Various barriers such as road, buildings, canal, fence have cut off the communication between wild nature and human, which resulted in a residentsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; low interest and affinity for nature.
309
CHARACTERISTICS OF CURRENT STREAM Canal-overground Canal-underground Surface flow Drainage-underground Pipeline Water direction
310
DESIGN VISION
Wildlife distribution (before)
Break the barriers between human and wild nature Wildlife distribution (after)
311
MASTER PLAN 1.Nee soon stream 2.Small pond 3.Nature fence in residential area 4.New land properties 5.2nd storey tree top broadwalk 6.Viewing deck 7.Community forest garden
Nephelium lappaceum(Hairy Lychee)
Artocarpus rigidus Blume
Ficus benjamina(Malayan Bany
Musa acuminata(Banana)
Syzygium polyanthum
Planchonella obovata(Menasi)
Durio zibethinus(Durian)
Pterocarpus indicus(Sena)
Peltophorum pterocarpum(Jem
Cocos nucifera(coconut)
Neolitsea cassia
Artocarpus heterophyllus (Jackfruit)
Samanea saman(Rain Tree)
Adonidia merrillii(Christmas Palm)
Ficus microcarpa Cassia fistula(Golden Shower)
312
yan)
merlang Laut)
Syzygium cumini(L.)
Grass turf
Water
Ficus fistulosa
Scrubland
Underground drainge
Leea guineensis â&#x20AC;&#x2DC; Burgundyâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;
Shrub fence
Semi-fence
Chinnamomum iners
Gardening plants
New style fence Treetop walk Boardwalk 313
STRATEGY 01
NATURALIZE THE CONCRETE CANAL
Pavement
Pavement
House Private garden Canal
House
Road
Private garden
House
Hedge wall Natural stream Hedge wall Private garden
Private garden Underground canal
House
Haha wall
Private garden House
Natural stream Hedge wall Private garden
Pavement
Open green space
Canal
Open green space
Pavement
Open green space
314
Retention pond
Open green space
ENLARGE THE ROAD TREE CANOPY
Larger canopy tree Animal food tree Green roof Widen flower bed Green roof Walkway
DE-FENCING THE PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL AREA
House Haha wall Natural stream
Private garden
House Hedge wall Natural stream Private garden
Natural stream fence
Hedge fence
Fence with ferns
Shrub fence
315
BEFORE
AFTER
316
BEFORE
AFTER
317
STRATEGY 02
Design new housing typologies
1. Highlight the existing huge canopy trees and surface waterflow to be kept as a permanent green area.
2. Buffering the waterflow and existing planting species while introducing more valuable plant species to provide a movement corridor that can attract wildlife.
3. New land properties and some paths will be built on the remaining ground part.
4. Layouting the 2-story boardwalk for residentsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; walking and observation of the wildlife.
318
Water Underground drainge New style fence Treetop walk Boardwalk Grass turf Scrubland Shrub fence Gardening plants
Artocarpus rigidus Blume Syzygium polyanthum Pterocarpus indicus(Sena) Ficus benjamina(Malayan Banyan) Planchonella obovata (Menasi) Peltophorum pterocarpum(Jemerlang Laut) Neolitsea cassia Samanea saman(Rain Tree) Ficus microcarpa Cassia fistula(Golden Shower)
Syzygium cumini(L.) Ficus fistulosa Leea guineensis â&#x20AC;&#x2DC; Burgundyâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; Chinnamomum iners
Nephelium lappaceum(Hairy Lychee) Musa acuminata(Banana) Durio zibethinus(Durian) Cocos nucifera(coconut) Artocarpus heterophyllus (Jackfruit) Adonidia merrillii(Christmas Palm)
319
Gentle slope
320
Sparse planting
g
1. Forest species
6. Fence with fern species
3. Community gathering space
8. New land property with French window
2. 2-storey boardwalk 4. Gentle slope
5. Natural stream
7. Fruit tree on yard 9. Hedge fence 10. Green roof
321
DISTANCE BETWEEN CCNR AND RESIDENTIAL AREA
HISTORYLINE
WINDSOR NATURE PARK
VILLAS DEVELOPTED IN DIFFERENT TIME Originally, parks and grounds were planted secondary forests.After 50 years, the park has become a secondary forest with relatively complex ecological structure, but the site is a residential area with few trees and fragile ecology.
pine tree road tree pine tree shade tree shade
distribution villa_type 01 pavement villa_type 02 villa_type 03
322
POTENTIAL AREA FOR WILDLIFE FIND POSSIBLE PLACE TO BUILD HABITATS
POTENTIAL AREA=TOTAL AREA-HOUSES-ROADS-PAVEMENT -SWIMMINGPOOL-PUBLIC EQUIPMENTS MAINLY=PLAYGROUND+BACKYARDS+FRONTYARDS+ROADSIDES +UNDERUTILISED PLACES
POTENTIAL POTENTIAL
CONSTRUCTED CONSTRUCTED
CONSTRUCTED AREA IN SITE
ROADS HOUSES PATHWAY PAVEMENT SWIMMINGPOOL ROADSIDES ROADS MOTORROADS PATH
BUFFER AREA TREES
323
TREE ANALYSIS
AGE, HEIGHT, SPIECES NATIVE TREES COMPARISON
WINDSOR NATURE PARK NATIVE PLANTS SURVEY
12%
88%
4. Alstonia scholaris
5. Peltophorum pterocarpum 17. Ficus microcarpa
324
1. Lagerstroemia floribunda 2. Samanea saman 1 . Mangifera indica 13. Xanthostemon chrysanthus 14. Artocarpus heterophyllus 1 . Arfeuillea arborescens 23. Roystonea regia 2 . Carallia brachiata 2 . Syzygium grande 0. Sterculia oblongata 8. Dipterocarpus alatus 9. Cratoxylum cochinchinense 10. Magnolia champaca 12. Sterculia rubiginosa 1 . Adonidia merrillii 21. Rhodamnia cinerea 22. Adinandra dumosa 2 . Gardenia carinata 2 . Ficus celebensis 2 . Sterculia oblongata 3. Syzygium myrtifolium 6. Elaeocarpus mastersii . Terminalia buceras 11. Flacourtia rukam 19. Syzygium lineatum 20. Cocos nucifera 2 . Sterculia parviflora
NATIVE
NON-NATIVE
FUTURE PLAN
ROADS PLAN+EDGE PLAN+LANED HOUSE PLAN
Lagerstroemia floribunda Samanea saman Syzygium myrtifolium Alstonia scholaris Peltophorum pterocarpum Elaeocarpus mastersii Terminalia buceras Dipterocarpus alatus Cratoxylum cochinchinense Magnolia champaca Flacourtia rukam Sterculia rubiginosa Xanthostemon chrysanthus Artocarpus heterophyllus Mangifera indica Archontophoenix alexandrae Arfeuillea arborescens Ficus microcarpa Adonidia merrillii Syzygium lineatum Cocos nucifera Rhodamnia cinerea Adinandra dumosa Roystonea regia Sterculia parviflora Carallia brachiata Gardenia carinata Ficus celebensis Syzygium grande Sterculia oblongata Cerbera manghas Sterculia cordata
ROADS PLAN The road in the residential area is a two-way driveway with green belts and sidewalks on both sides and water flow under the surface.Rainwater flows into the sewer system through a drain in the tree pool. BEFORE
AFTER
ROAD PLANTING
ROAD PLANTING
Landed House
Landed House
Landed House
Landed House GATE
DRAINAGE SYSTEM
RUBBISH BIN
Pavement Planting pool
Drainage pipe
Drainage pipe Drainage pipe
Drainage pipe
325
THE EDGE PLAN
THE EDGE BETWEEN WINDSOR NATURE PARK AND THE RESIDENTIAL AREA
Use the surrounding edge of the park to create an ecological garden, using the spontaneous planting to make people living in the surrounding area feel the power of nature.
1. MAIN ENTRANCE TO THE PLAYGROUND AND
2. TO
OPEN SPACE OPEN PLAYGROUND
TARRAIN
open playground
10M
9M 8M
HERBS SLOPE
7M 6M
5M
BOTTOM
4M
3M 2M
1M
326
open space
ECOLOGICAL POOL
TREES
11M
bushes and shrubs
EAST DIRECTION
bo�om landscape
WINDSOR PARK PROPERTY
4. THE END OF THE EDGE
3. ENTRANCE TO RESTORATION PART
WINSDOR NATURE PARK
D PARK
ENTRANCE O THE PLAYGROUND AND PARK
2. MAIN ENTRANCE TO THE PLAYGROUND AND PARK
WINDSOR NATURE PARK TOURIST PATH slope plan�ng
SECTION OF THE EDGE PLAN open space Slope vegeta�on
Ecologically connected forest
WEST DIRECTION
327
UNDERUTILIZED SPACES Due to the site’s unique topography, there is much underutilized land. During the construction process, many of these slopes were created by the construction of the house platform. People can’t get there because of the steep slope, and the plants can not grow.
TYPE
1.
PATH BE FOR AN RESIDE AR
EST
OR YF AR ND
G
IN LIV EEN ES ETW SPAC B ILD ION ECT AND W NN CO AREA
O SEC
V WEEN LI TION BET CE CONNEC ND WILD SPA A EA R A
PATH BETWEEN FOREST AND RESIDENTIAL AREA
UNIQUE TYPOLOGY IN WINDSOR PARK PROPERTY LOCATION IN THE SITE
328
SLOPE MODIFICATION SCHEME
BY CREATING PLATFORMS AND STEPS FOR WATER TO STAY
SLOPES BETWEEN HOUSES
ETWEEN REST ND ENTIAL REA
VING ES
RAINFALL FLOW ORIGINAL MODEL OF THE SLOPE
LANDED HOUSES ON THE SAME PLATFORM
CHANGE MODEL OF THE SLOPE
SLOPE WITH PLANTS COVERING
VISION OF THE FUTURESLOPE 329
LANDED PROPERTY YARDS Sub Heading - 8pt (Sentence Case)
Plants can be used to make fences on unused slopes and edges in a proper way to form a
LOCATION IN THE SITE
330
PLANTING DETAIL
steps to build the nature fence LANDED HOUSE ON THE PLATFORM
TREE FENCE
PLANTING STRATEGY
SITE PHOTO
331
VISION OF EDGE
Sub Heading - 8pt (Sentence Case)
0~1years
0~1years
0~1years
332
Sub Heading - 8pt (Sentence Case)
BEFORE
Body Text - 8pt font size, 10pt leading space (Sentence Case)
50 years
AFTER
0~4years 50 years
0~2years
0~2years
333
VISION OF VILLAS
Legend Text (Minimum 4pt)
BEFORE 334
VISION OF THE UNDERUTILIZED PLACE connect residential area to nature
Legend Text (Minimum 4pt) 0~10years 0~10years
0~2years
0~2years
0~1years
0~5years
AFTER 335
336
RE-FLOWING NATURE IN WINDSOR NEIGHBORHOOD Wang Haobo & Tanaka Mamiko & Zhang Bingyi
Located in the south-western edge of CCNR where the freshwater swamp forest stream ends, 0ha Windsor residential area has great potential to be re-connected with forest flora and fauna. Currently, urban fabrics interrupt the natural streamflow, distribution of green spaces are not ideal for wildlife movement, and increasing dense developments require engineered infrastructure with high impermeable concrete spaces and less human-nature interaction. The project thus attempts to re-flow nature in the neighbourhood as a part of a forest ecosystem that facilitates mutual growth of nature and neighbourhood. The main design intent of this project is to design the flow, and two design strategies will be proposed - spatial increment and inventory evolvement. For rearranging and reshaping available spaces for a better flow, this design will reconfigure open spaces for interconnecting flows of nature water, flora, fauna and human traffic, pedestrian, recreation . Tracing from historical forest streams, the project restores and diversifies water flow by introducing recreational forest streams, historic stream and naturalized drainage, followed by improving fauna and flora movement, and human circulation along the waterways. All these flows become a dynamic network that intersects with built environments. The first strategy is spatial increment. This design will improve the uality of existing spaces, such as widening roads aggregation of available spaces (private yards, ecological swimming pools, dismantling buildings of low price, and waterside naturalization or activity space) and improving the natural cycle. Space with different conditions (current space, new space, expanded space) will be designed according to context, function, and texture. The second strategy is inventory evolvement for both human and nature over time. The intent is to optimize wildlife habitats, water uality, water level, and flowing speed which are key elements for aquatic habitats; and canopy cover, vegetation structure, and food resource will be considered for terrestrial habitats. The living environment and experience will be improved by diversified blue and green spaces. Introducing forest elements into the residential area near CCNR, enhancing habitats based on water flow, the biodiversity, including uni ue flora and fauna - All these will provide an essential base for both human and wildlife communities in the Windsor neighborhood. The integration of the natural ecosystem with human activities will enrich the lives of both humans and nature.
DRAINAGE TYPOLOGY
0
338
50m
339
RODASIDE GREENERY TYPOLOGY
340
Typology 1
Typology 2
Typology 3
Typology 4
Typology 5
341
SITE ANALYSIS SUN PATH
0
25 50
100m
HARD AND SOFT MATERIAL
25 50
0
100m
HOUSE PROPERTY
FENCE
park gas station 1 storey 2 storey solid wall
3 storey 4 storey
fence
5 storey 6 storey
green slope | wall 0
25 50
100m
VALUABLE TREE
0
0
25 50
fruit trees
high canopy trees
water tolerant trees
low canopy trees
dry condition trees
shrub
fast growing trees
yard and grassland
25 50
100m
CURRENT HABITAT
100m
GREENERY CONDITION
0
25 50
100m
CURRENT FAUNA MOVEMENT
Olive-winged Bulbul Brown-throated Sunbird Plantain Squirrel Common Palm Civet 0
342
25 50
100m
0
25 50
100m
ELECATION AND WATER FLOW
SEED DISPERSE
LAND USE
343
DESIGN STRATEGY DESIGN PROPOSAL
esign the flow to re-connect Windsor residential area with forest, so that dynamic natural organisms, resource and energy will re-flow in this site.
BUILDING NEW WATERBODY
CHANGING WATERFLOW
344
DESIGNING THE FLOW DIAGRAM CONNECTING GREEN PATCHES
CONNECTING FAUNA MOVEMENT
PEDESTRIAN FLOW RE-ORGANIZATION Current Pedestrian Flow
Pedestrian Flow
Proposal Pedestrian Flow Pedestrian Flow Add and Improve Flow
CHANGING TRAFFIC FLOW
Current Traffic Flow
Traffic Flow
Traffic Flow
Parking Lots
Parking Lots
345
DESIGN STRATEGY - SPATIAL INCREMENT BUILDING
ROAD
SWIMMING POOL
346
YARD
AVAILABLE SPACE
0
50m
347
DESIGH VISION | WATER
0
348
50m
DRAINAGE BEFORE AND AFTER NATURALIZATION
349
DRAINAGE NATURALIZATION STRATEGY
THREE WAYS TO NATRUALIZE THE DRAINAGE
350
DRAINAGE NATURALIZATION STRATEGY
MATERIAL CHANGE A. COIR GEOTEXTILE
B. BRUSH MATTRESS
C.ROOTWAD COMPOSITES
WATER STORAGE AND FISH POND A.
B.
D.GARBION
C. rainwater collection
WATER PURIFICATION
351
SECTION AND STREETSCAPE LONG SECTION A-BEDORE
LONG SECTION A-AFTER
LONG SECTION B-BEDORE
LONG SECTION B-AFTER
352
353
NUTRIENT FLOW DESIGN Nutrient flow and cycle is significant but easy to be ignored for natural flows in this neighborhood. Our design also cares about enhancing the nutrient cycles, connecting disrupted urban cycles to the natural forest cycle, connecting the flow and movement of soil organisms like fungi and decomposers , so that a healthy nutrient cycle will be rebuilt to support the flowing nature for our project.
NUTRIENT CYCLE-BEFORE
NUTRIENT CYCLE-AFTER
354
355
DATAILED NUTRIENT CYCLE
NUTRIENT FLOW AND CYCLE IN THE ROAD SCALE
356
STRUCTURAL SOIL
DETAILS OF STRUCTURAL SOIL
ROAD SECTION DETAIL
357
DESIGN APPROACH FOR HUMAN
358
359
KEY ACTIVITY SPACES_in ainy days
360
361
KEY ACTIVITY SPACES_in sunny days
362
363
364
365
UNDERSTORY DESIGN PLAN
366
367
DETAILED PLAN - HISTORICAL STREAM
4
5
2
1
0
368
16
48m
1
2
PERSPECTIVES
3
369
TARGET SPECIES
370
HABITAT SUCCESSION PLAN
0
50m
371
TARGET FAUNA SPECIES MOVEMENT
372
373
HABITAT DISTRIBUTION MAP
Recreation stream
Roadside shrub and tree corridor
Fish drainage
Roadside shrub
Upper historical stream
Disturbed secondary forest
Fresh swamp
Wild grassy slope
Flood plain
Urban remanent woodland
Fish pond
374
SCENERIES OF HABITAT
375
HABITAT MAP
376
377
378
REFLECTIONS
379
My undergraduate major is the environmental art design , so my ability of logical thinking on landscape design was very weak, I decided to study the master course because I had the awareness of my weakness. During this semester, I spent a lot of time on the site analysis and design strategy, which also reflects my sweaty and lack in this aspect. I was not good at group cooperation on design, and it took me a long time to adapt to this method of teamwork in landscape design. I had to change my typology from commercial area to industrial area on the halfway through the semester. The study process of this semester can be said to be full of challenges and setbacks, but I had overcame these and I will work harder in the further study.
Astrid Han Cong
The studio offered me with a more refreshing way of designing with ecology, especially after having had a few years of work experience prior to the MLA course. We were taught to think about every aspect and make the design solid through research, analysis and a thorough understanding of the sites chosen. The academic process started off with a rigorous research phase, where we visited parts of CCNR to get a better understanding of forests, how they function and their various complex layers. This helped and opened up various possibilities of how we can select our typologies and develop our design through the weeks. The importance of critical thinking, time management and prioritizing ideas are three major things I learned and hope to get better at. Though the process was intense and sometimes tough, I am excited to learn from this experience and apply it to future opportunities in the upcoming landscape studios.
Bargotra Poornima
Before having this studio, l havenâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t had clear clarification of ecology, l used to connect it to just green. But this period helps me to know more about fauna, flora, people, nutrient, etc. Every layer in nature has its function. I began to learn more about the in-depth knowledge of nature. My design is about connection. It is a design trying to deal with the fragments separated by viaducts. In the beginning, l was struggling because it seems impossible to utilize the gray space under the structure. The low light density and concrete facet make it hard for animals to use. But more essay readings and professorsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; instructions help me to find a way. The issue is challenging but interesting. I hope to deal with all kinds of challenging problems and learn more in the future.
Brynn Zhou Zuyuan
380
This first MLA studio was indeed a fruitful experience for me. It gave me an entirely different perspective on the importance of landscape ecology and design. Through the entire studio experience, we were tasked to uncover the value of what Central Catchment Nature Reserve represents in Singapore’s landscape identity. Striking the balancing between landscape ecology and human experience to create various design proposal was challenging yet rewarding. I have come to appreciate the fact that wildlife is an essential part of the ecosystem and that landscape design plays a vital role in protecting wildlife and augmenting the human experience. The site visit arranged with Dr Shawn Lam in identifying existing plant species was very helping and enriching. I’ve gained many insights into tree identification methods and would continue to apply this knowledge in future projects. Overall, this studio taught me to be analytical throughout the whole planning process and be bold in exploring new landscape design ideas.
Carissa Chin Qiwei
At the beginning, I was not fully adapted to the graduate study method, which required me to research, discover and obtain results.For example, when I started exercise 01, I started to use my original conventional thinking to study the forest. In fact, this part requires me to observe forest and consult materials to understand the forest succession. But then came the question of how do I present it, what kind of supporting material, to explain the succession of plants, the changes in species, soil and nutrients.At the end of the presentation, my Exercise assignment was not perfect.Back to my design project, streetscape.The first thing I need to do is to choose a road that fits with my exercise 01 project, plant succession.Therefore, I chose the relatively spacious Bukit Panjang Rd as my design site. Later, the multilateralism and complexity of this road brought me some troubles.I am constrained by my own ideas and hesitate to make design decisions.Rewilding’s theme is to be bold, to be brave.Maybe in the next studio, I will seek some more bold and innovative design methods. Cheng Jing
Having background in Architecture since last six years, MLA definitely provided me with a very new perspective towards importance of knowledge regarding Landscape processes. Its integration with Built environment it very intricate. As part of “Re-Wilding Singapore” studio, we were asked to identify specific landscape typologies within 1KM buffer zone of CCNR and carry forward one of the area as study. My early exploration in Urban Park typology provided me an in-depth understanding of integral importance of their presence in an Urban Fabric. Further exploration of outdoor sports and recreational activities landed me into the world of Golf Courses and its impact. Through out the studio, as I explore golf courses in detail and make an attempt to strike a balance between its impact and importance as a buffer; it provided me with the insights related to various complex issues that a land goes through when transformed and molded to suit urban environments and recreational needs. Indeed, the exploration during the studio was a journey of life long learning and my very first foot into the world of Landscape Architecture. I am excited to push my limits and learn more in upcoming studios. Rakholiya Ekta
381
Prior to this studio, which also happens to be my first encounter with landscape architecture formally, my approach to designing was more anthropocentric. As an architect, even though I was inherently sensitive towards the existing landscape while designing, I never really imagined giving fauna the centre stage and let it guide the creative process. The studio “Rewilding Singapore” has hence been an exciting and challenging journey which pushed me to understand other elements and user groups within a landscape and value them while designing. I really enjoyed the investigation into the real ecological value of green Singapore, and I feel we’ve barely scratched the surface but atleast it was a start! The structure right from exercise 1 to the final design was well put out for us so we just seamlessly moved on from one stage to another. Right from selection of site to designing experiences, it has a been a very real and immersive experience.And I believe it has changed the way I conventionally looked at designing of landscapes.
Dhuri Ruiee
Learning in tropical city, and studying tropical forest, the first MLA studio “rewilding Singapore” gives me many opportunities as well as inspiration to understand tropical landscape in courter scale. I am a beginner in landscape architecture, yet I get myself devoted into the landscape design with the help of the instructions from exercise 01 to exercise 02, and to final project. I obtained a wide range of knowledge about tropical forest, including the process, fauna and flora species, animal behaviors, water and nutrients, which push me deeper and deeper in landscape project for Windsor Neighborhood. I have a detailed and elaborate study of waterscape typology, drainage typology in our group, as well as the analyzing process of waterscape in a logical procedure. From major watershed of the whole island, to sub watershed in site, from major canals to tiny drains, from upper stream forest to down stream city, we learn about the water systems deeply and finish our project in order. Group work also gives me a different experience as we try to divide and organize each individuals’ responsibility. Moreover, the studio encourages to try new thoughts and ideas, which I will continue to learn in future study. Wang Haobo
This semester had been enjoyable. I had learned about the importance of site research and how it helps to inform and shapes our design thinking process. To “design with time” is the main challenge I encounter this semester. As I had never done any time-related project in my previous studios, I am glad to be guided and allowed to learn something new this semester. Overall, I felt that this semester had been a tough one but with a rewarding learning journey. I am also glad the studio invites various guests with different areas of expertise to share with us their knowledge and views. It was an eye-opening experience to see things from their perspectives and receive comments from the guests.
Lim Wenfa
382
The first MLA studio has given me a brand new experience in this field which is so different from my undergraduate studies. During the early stage, the whole class spent a long time together to do research about the entire Singapore. We were divided into small groups and each group focused on different landscape typologies. The information and analysis I done played a critical role in my designing process. Additionally, the method and framework I learned from other courses such as Geodesign and biology has shaped my design to be more convincing eventually. Although I had a time struggling with dealing the conflict and transforming, I landed softly and my independent thinking is enhanced. I sincerely hope for the further explore in landscape, I could gain more.
Xiao Xinyan
The first studio in NUS ended, for me, it is a completely different field from my undergraduate study. I am delighted to have the opportunity to experience how to design a naturalized design with ecological knowledge in this semester. This is also the first time for me to use different layers for group operations, it is also a brand-new experience for me to learn how to complete this project from the macro and micro perspectives using the GEO Design. Of course, I still have shortcomings in many aspects. I hope I can continue to improve myself in the following study in the studio.
Zhang Bingyi
For me, the whole â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Rewildingâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; project is a relatively new field. The first studio in NUS focuses on more research, which is quite different from the study during my undergraduate period. From my perspective, the gradual process of the final project is derived from a plurality of different exercises. In the process, I have learned a lot of ecological knowledge, how to deduce my site in a convincing way and how to overcome the difficulties I encountered during the process. Furthermore, it is an excellent benefit for me to communicate with my classmates with different educational and cultural backgrounds, the different opinions and the way to solve the problems. I am ready to welcome the challenges to be posed for me in the next studio.
Zhong Yixin
383
This studio was an unforgettable start to my MLA program. Undeniably, working on these projects was difficult at the beginning, but after field research, material reading and tutorial guidance, I found that I could make my project more logical and reasonable step by step. It is a brand-new experience for me to complete a natural design under the guidance of ecological knowledge. I realized the importance of combining design with nature and trying to create a sustainable and resilient habitat for both humans and wildlife. Every moment spent on the studio is worthwhile because of the new things I could learn every step of the way. Finally, I really appreciate the help from tutors and classmates in the learning process.
Zhou Xianfeng The studio in this semester is really an enjoyable learning experience for me. It is different from the design I have done before in my undergraduate. Firstly, we had exercise 1 to research the interesting field we chosen and tried to learn more in it. The part I chosen is freshwater swamp forest, which guided my design later. Next, the exercise 2 we analyzed the different landscape typology, and our individual work was based on the analysis and research we have done. I learned that the independent and logical thinking is critical for a landscape architect. I used to focus on the some superfluous aspects, now I know learning deeper and careful about the site and the materials supported my design are very necessary. This is the first semester in my graduate, I hope to get better and further in the next steps.
Lyu Jiawei This studio makes me understand many aspects that I had not paid attention to in my previous study and work design and I began to pay more attention to the ecological value brought by the landscape and the intervention from the biological level required in the process of sustainable urban development. Although I encountered many challenges in the design process (such as solving the contradiction between plant growth and urban environment), these problems pushed me to think more deeply. I hope that I can keep my research direction in the future studio study, have a deeper understanding and thinking about the operation mode of the ecosystem, and apply it to my design.
Feng Zihan In this first semester of graduate study, I have learned to develop a design project in a brand-new approach compared to that in my undergraduate stage. The project started from a series of researches upon both CCNR and the selected landscape typologies. It was quite challenging for me, but it has extended my understanding of forest ecology and ecological design. When it came to the individual design project, based on a very detailed analysis of my site, I was inspired to come up with specific strategies. Then, the whole design process followed closely with my strategies, and all the previous research I had done became strong supports to the design. During these three months, I also learned about the importance of time managing and stress management. It was sometimes painful but finally turned out to be sweet. I am happy to learn from so many excellent professors and classmates in this studio.
Shao Zhongran
384
I’ve learned about how to make fully use of the data I gathered and find out the problems and the opportunities based on the comprehensive analysis of the data . In this way, I’ve learned about how to design more logically and scientifically .I enjoyed the working process here to study the site as a group and share the results with each other. In this way, I achieved a more comprehensive and deeper understanding of the site. I was amazed by the power of corporation.“Rewilding Singapore” is an interesting and challenging topic for me. I’ve learned about how to design with the consideration of the life of fauna and flora in the urban area, and tried to combine the outdoor and indoor the shopping mall with spatial design and design of natural-ba se commercial activities in my personal design which was a totally new try for me.
Zhang Yifei Rewilding Singapore is an exciting project. This topic deeply discusses the boundary that can be reached by the coexistence of humans and nature in modern cities. It not only broadens my horizon to see the world, but also continually changes my understanding of the relationship between man and nature through learning and recognizing new creatures. Singapore is a country with plenty of rain and the warm climate. The fauna and flora here show incredible vitality and life forms. In the process of learning food chain, plant growth law and other knowledge, I increasingly feel that nature has a complete structure of life. As a landscape architect, the way to genuinely wild Singapore, based on familiarity with plants, is to complicate and localize the structure of natural habitats constantly.That’s how landscape architects really design nature
Zhang Bingqian Looking back on the semester, the first day of the studio seems like yesterday. Honestly, the studio was too fast for me to keep up with my classmates. On the other hand, I tried to keep thinking about the relationship between humans and nature because my part was the scenery in CCNR for exercise 1, and the human flow in the Windsor neighborhood based on the water flow. Rewilding seems to be a concept opposite human activities. However, through my research with the group members and seeing my classmates work, I realized the forest would give us the bleeding when we build a nutual relationship with a respectful attitude. It is significant to appreciate nature as the pioneers and the people in the old times used to feel when they initially developed Singapore. Finally, although it took a lot of time, I think that I was able to put the things which I captured in CCNR into my design, responding to the water flow and flora and fauna movement which my co-members worked on. I would like to pursue landscape in the region while improving my work speed. Tanaka Mamiko
385
Editors: Bargotra Poornima Cheng Jing Chin Carissa Dhuri Ruiee Rakholiya Ekta Zhang Yifei Zhong Yixin Zhou Zuyuan
Copyright © 2019 Hwang Yun Hye and Endo Kenya (ed.) ISBN: 978-981-14-4217-9
387