Cultural Specificity in a Post-Multicultural Context
Chinese Canadian Cultural Centre in Spadina-Dundas Chinatown, Toronto by Yiming Chen
Renderings and Diagrams in this publication are from Yiming Chen unless otherwise indicated.
Cultural Specificity in a Post-Multicultural Context: Chinese Canadian Cultural Centre in Spadina-Dundas Chinatown, Toronto Master of Architecture Thesis, University of Toronto, 2018 Thesis Advisor: Pina Petricone Presented on April 19th, 2018, by Yiming Chen Contact: yim.chen@mail.utoronto.ca
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5
Post-Multicultural Context and Social Cognition Studies Chinese Canadian Studies Sense of Place: Spadina-Dundas Chinatown Studies Spadina-Dundas Chinatown Mapping and Morphology Studies Cultural Centre Precedents Studies
2.1 Proposed Chinese Canadian Cultural Centre
1 5 11 19 27 31
1.1 Post-Multicultural Context and Social Cognition Studies
1
Canada is identified as a multicultural country since 1971. The current Prime Minister Justin Trudeau seldom uses the points of multiculturalism in Canada. Multiculturalism is criticized as an egocentric way to preserve and present cultures. Thus, postmulticulturalism was introduced. The famous salad bowl theory suggests that the integration of the many different cultures of residents combine like a salad. Each ingredient in the bowl represents a specific culture and is cut into small pieces. When they are mixed together, each ingredient would absorb others’ flavour, in order to make a tasty and healthy dish. By practice, post-multiculturalism allows people to get to know each other better, in order to form a dynamic and harmonious society.
2
Canada 68%
32%
United States 53%
47%
Minorities should do more to fit in with mainstream American/Canadian We should encourage cultural diversity with different groups keeping their own customs and languages
Attitudes toward Multiculturalism: Canadians v.s American
A recent survey organized by CBC and the Angus Reid Institute in 2016 concludes that Canadians exhibit adversary attitudes towards multiculturalism over time. Sixty-eight percent of Canadian respondents reported that they are not satisfied with what the minorities have done, for example, by keeping their own customs and languages immigrants are less likely to adapt to the mainstream culture. While only fifty-three percent of Americans surveyed reported saying minorities need to assimilate to the mainstream culture better.
Source: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/poll-canadians-multiculturalism-immigrants-1.3784194, organized by CBC and Angus Reid Institute
3
Satisfied with how things are going in Canada
Satisfied they feel welcom in their community
Satisfied immigrants are integrating well in the community
Satisfied with the environment
Satisfied with the amount of crime
Satisfied with your family's access to the quality education
Satisfied with your access to the health care
Satisfied with your person financial situation
Satisfied with your job opportunities 40
45
50
All Canadians
55
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
100
Immigrants here less than 10 years
Immigrants as satisfied as other Canadians with quality of life
Another survey have found that for immigrants who have been here for less than ten years, they do feel they are well integrated into the community, but when we look at all Canadians as a unit, that sense of integration is diminished.
Source: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/poll-canadians-multiculturalism-immigrants-1.3784194, organized by CBC and Angus Reid Institute
4
1.2 Chinese Canadian Studies
5
Countries and Areas - the Year of Major Chinese Community Immigration: Greater China Area: Mainland Hong Kong Taiwan Tibet
1858 1940s, 1960s,1980s 1947 1950s
Chinese Diaspora
Argentina Bangladesh Cambodia Cuba India
1988 1972 1975 1959 1962
Chinese Diaspora Map Indonesia Jamaica Laos Malaysia Mauritius
1965 1970s 1975 1970s 2000s
Myanmar Pakistan Panama Peru Philippines
1964 1995 1970s 1975 1960s
South Africa Suriname United Kingdom United States Vietnam
1990 1975 1977
Members of the Chinese Diaspora find themselves settled in Toronto after generations. The Chinese culture in Canada also embodies another level of multiculturalism.
Source: Professor. Lisa Rose Mar, Chinese Canadian Studies, Department of History, University of Toronto; Overseas Chinese Affairs Office of the State Council, P.R.C. The outline of Overseas Chinese , Jiuzhou Press, 2005
6
100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 1871
1881
1891
1901
1911
1921
1931
1941
1951
1961
1971
1981
1991
2001
2011
British Isles
Scandinavia
Western Europe
Eastern Europe
Southern Europe
United States
Caribbean and Bermuda
Central and South America
Northern Africa
Sub-Saharan Africa
Western Asia and Middle East
Eastern Asia
Southeast Asia
Southern Asia
Oceania and other
Distribution in percentage of the foreign-born population, by place of birth, Canada, 1871 to 2011
Comparing with European Canadians who have slowly stopped their migration, there is a distinct trend of increase in Asian population.
Source: Statistics Canada, censuses of population, 1871 to 2001. National Household Survey, 2011.
7
Population (in Thousands) 1,600
1,400
1,200
1,000
800
600
400
200
0 1951
1961
1971
1981
1991
2001
2011
Caribbean and Bermuda
Central and South America
Northern Africa
Sub-Saharan Africa
Western Asia and Middle East
Eastern Asia
Southeast Asia
Southern Asia
Oceania and other
Canadian population with Chinese origin
Foreign-born population in Canada, and Canadian population with Chinese origin 1951 to 2011.
The distinct trend of increase in population who has Chinese background.
Source: Statistics Canada, censuses of population, 1951 to 2001. National Household Survey, 2011.; The Chinese in Canada, Jin Tan and Patricia E. Roy
8
YT NT
NU
NL BC QC
AB
SK
MB
PE ON
YT
BC
AB
NT
SK
MB
NU
625
540,155
18,280
375
19,075
30,150
115
ON
NB
QC
849,345 121,445
NS
NL
NB
PE
NS
2,700
4,480
2,735
9,695
Chinese Canadian Distribution in Canada Ontario has the largest Chinese Canadian Community across Canada. 12% of the population in GTA has Chinese background in 2016.
Source: Statistics Canada, census of population, 2016
9
Clarington Brock Scugog Oshawa Georgina
Whitby
Uxbridge Pickering
Ajax
East Gwillimbury Scarborough
Newmarket
Markham
LAKE ONTARIO
Aurora Richmond Hill King
North York Vaughan Toronto Etobicoke
Caledon
Brampton
Mississauga
Immigration Path before 2000 Halton Hills
Oakville Milton Burlington
Immigration Path 2000s Immigration Path 2010s
Chinese Canadian Immigration Path in Greater Toronto Area Chinese Canadian usually settled in downtown first and moved to suburban area. The suburban Chinatowns has caused functional division - only serve as living communities for new Chinese immigrants.
10
1.3 Sense of Place: Spadina-Dundas Chinatown Studies
11
170 Copies
Sense of Place Survey The notion of ‘sense of place’ refers to ‘a socially, culturally and psychologically constructed man-place relationship, representative of a non-material bonding of human beings with places’. The survey is focused on: How is the sense of place about Spadina-Dundas Chinatown? Does sense of place differ among different groups? What elements help to establish Chinatown’s sense of place? What elements are missing to contribute a better Chinatown’s sense of place? Conduct three dimensions as subscales: place attachment, place identity, place dependence Place attachment refers to the emotional bonds people develop with places; Place identity refers to people’s socialization with physical space or a dimension of self that define the individual’s personal identity in relation to the physical environment by means of complex pattern of conscious and unconscious ideas, beliefs, preferences, feelings, values, goals and behavioural tendencies and skills relevant to this environment; Place dependence refers to people’s functional reliance on the amenities and resources that places provide. Questionnaires were distributed in the following areas: Dragon City Mall, Chinatown Centre, Chinese Gospel Church, Cecil Community Centre, U of T campus, Chinese-Canadian-related symposium and events.
12
3.30
Place Attachment I feel comfortable and safe in Chinatown. I would defend Chinatown if someone criticizes it. I miss Chinatown when I cannot visit it in a long time. Chinatown makes me happier than other places do. If possible, I would like to spend more time in Chinatown.
3.22
2.84
Place Identity
Place Dependence
Chinatown is important to me. I regard myself as a part of Chinatown. Chinatown is unique and irreplaceable to me. Chinatown reflects my ethnic identity as a Chinese very well.
I make a lot of friends in Chinatown. Chinatown is closely related to my personal life. Chinatown is the best place for the activities I like. I feel empowered by the experience of being in Chinatown. My demands for entertainment can be better met in Chinatown.
Sense of Place at three scales People prefer to give a higher score (has strongly agreed on the above sentences) for Place attachment and Place identity than place dependence. It means the functions of Chinatown are inefficient.
Source: : Sense of Place: Toronto Spadina-Dundas Chinatown survey, 2017
13
Numbers of People 25
20
15
10
5
0 1-1.5
1.5-2
2-2.5
New comers here less than 10 years
2.5-3
3-3.5
3.5-4
Immigrants here more than 10 years
4-4.5
4.5-5
Average
Canada-born Canadians
Sense of Place Distribution Comparing with immigrants living here for more than ten years and Canada-born Canadian, new immigrants who have lived here for less than ten years have a worse image of Chinatown.
Source: : Sense of Place: Toronto Spadina-Dundas Chinatown survey, 2017
14
1
2
54
54+26 5
3
5
32 7
6
15 8
10
15
13 9
9 Sense of Place Survey Images
Source: : Sense of Place: Toronto Spadina-Dundas Chinatown survey, 2017
33+18
9
Exhibition/Art Gallery Food/Restaurant Educational Cleaning Service Festival/Event Performance Recreational/Sport Field Community Centre/Gathering Place Main-stream-friendly Service Chinese-Speaking Service Consulate Service Senior Service Medical Service Directory/Tours Transit Parking Massage Housing Bigger Side Walks Immigration Service
Chinese Culture Introduction/Representation Chinese Canadianess/Chinese Canadian Community Main-stream Welcome Multiculturalism Role Model of Cultral Combination Chinese Canadian History/Heritage Preservation Gathering Place Presenting China as a Clean/Tidy/Modern Country Food Sharing/ Make Connection Business District Festival Celebration Enjoyment of Life Expansion Entertainment Diversity Art Independence Protected from Discrimination Tourist Attraction Politics Centre Service Centre Seniors Friendly Home Sense
Expectation of Spadina-Dundas Chinatown: Service Request and Role in the City Identity of Chinatown is defined as a commercial and culinary area instead of cultural place. A main stream welcoming cultural organization that introduces and represents Chinese Canadians with exhibition, art gallery, educational programs, festival and events, performance, and community centre are expected in Chinatown.
Source: : Sense of Place: Toronto Spadina-Dundas Chinatown survey, 2017
16
Julie Jai
Leo Chan
John Thai
Julie Jai
1858
1885
Haibo Zhang
Leo Chan
1924
Kellie Chin John Thai
Haibo Zhang
1947
1878
1977
1980s
Sam Ching - first registered Chinese Torontonian
Sino-Vietnamese, Sino-Laotian, Sino-Cambodian Refugee Arrived
Mass Immigrants from Mainland China and Other Countries Arrived in Canada after Pre-1924 Immigration
free entry period
restricted entry period
exclusion period
selective entry period
Chinese Canadian Immigrants Historical Background and Demand from Five Representative Interviewees 17
Kellie Chin
Five interviewees are selected as the representatives to indicate their need and expectations. - Julie Jai has a collection of invaluable Cantonese Opera artifacts (including music score, scripts, tapes, photos and music instrument) in Canada. As a third generation Chinese Canadian of the first immigration wave, she is looking for a proper organization, an archive or a museum, to house her parents’ treasures and to preserve Chinese Canadian history. Archive and Research Centre are vital to preserve and reflect history. - Leo Chan, who represents the second major immigration wave, sees himself as a real Chinese-Canadian, who has both Chinese and Canadian characters. He would like to introduce his Chinese part to Canadian and share his Canadian part with Chinese new comers. He is dedicated in leading tours and giving public lectures. A proper platform, an auditorium, would allow more people to participate in these activities. - John Thai, one of Chinese Canadian refugees fled from Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia, finally settled down in Canada to start his new life. Mr. Thai’s life story is truly inspiring. Sharing his 90-year life experience to younger generations is invaluable. At the same time, Chinese Canadian Studies Program at University of Toronto would like to establish connection and trust with the community. A proper meeting place, an oral history lab helps to build that trust. - Haibo Zhang, who immigrated to Toronto in early 1990s, had a strong relationship to Chinatown. He relied on Chinatown for many years in terms of food, grocery and the sense of Chinese Canadian-ness. In the last decades, convenient Chinese markets and restaurants were launched in GTA area. The Spadina-Dundas Chinatown became obscured to a certain extent. He emphasized that he is reminiscing Chinatown, and look forward to being attracted by cultural and art programs in Spadina-Dundas Chinatown. - Kellie Chin, an interracial second generation Chinese Canadian, sees herself as an outsider. She is interested in learning Chinese language, and would like to take part in activities related to Chinese Culture. A welcome and striking facility providing Chinese Canadian thematic workshop and performance becomes a window for many Chinese Diaspora members who are not familiar with their culture. According to quantitive questionnaires and qualitative interviews, a thematic sequence of culture – reflection, production, and celebration is formed.
18
1.4 Spadina-Dundas Chinatown Mapping and Morphology Studies
19
Chinese Organizations in Spadina-Dundas Chinatown Signage pointing to the Chinese cultural centre are often obscure by other business signs and make it very hard to find for the public, even for the Chinese population. However there are over eighty organizations that exist in Spadina-Dundas Chinatown, most of organizations are not mainstreamfriendly and have became dormant or only host few activities each year. This is largely due to language barriers and the lack knowledge of Chinese Canadian history. Family organizations and regional organizations are often exclusive as well. Canadian-born Chinese who are removed from their Chinese cultural background growing up are not familiar with the language. Making it more difficulty for them to integrate into these cultural related organizations. As a result, members of these organizations have decreased dramatically over the last decade. Many organizations have been reduced to a lone signage on building facades.
20
1842
1924
1890
1935
Site Transformation Timeline Parade Ground for volunteer Cavalry
1815
21
Houses strated to build by Irish and Scottish Immigrants
1880s
European Jewish moved and operated merchandise shops
1920s
Chinese community moved and operated Chinese shops
1960s
1957
1994
1974
2016 Site Transformation Map
According to the historical maps, large multicultural centres always find themselves situated at the main intersections in this area. However as the neighborhood change, these multicultural centres are abandoned or appropriated by other cultures to better serve their functions. Cultural centres should be built to exert long-lasting impact on our cultures instead of transient structures that are forgotten as time passes.
22
Year of Built Map
23
Organizations Map
Built before 1890
Shopping Malls
Built between 1890 and 1924
Religious Organizations
Built between 1924 and 1935
Community Organizations
Built between 1935 and 1957
Recreational Organizations
Built between 1957 and 1974
Family Organizations
Built between 1974 and 1994
Regional Organizations
Built between 1994 and 2016
Other Organizations
News Paper Reading
Eating Dim Sum
There are over 80 organizations distributed in Chinatown. Shopping malls, religious organizations and community organizations are widely accessible by the public. Besides travellers, students of UofT, and seniors, especially Chinese Canadian seniors are frequent visitors to this region. Lacking of proper space and gathering place, people have to occupy commercial space, for example cafĂŠ, food court, restaurants, and bakery shops, in order to read newspapers and chat.
News Eatingof dragon city mall and stare at crowds day after DozensPaper of seniors just sit inside Tai Chi to Reading Dim Sumuse parks andPlaying day. During summer time, seniors public squares as playground do outdoor activities. Ladies set up their stalls toGames sell homegrown vegetables at the Spadina-Dundas intersection.
Cultural workshops held by young people, such as calligraphy and music workshops, usually squeezed in U of T classrooms or a commercial tea house on Spadina. Workshop groups connects people by social media or through word of mouth. Although there are outstanding community organization, such as Cecil Community Centre and St. Stephen Community House, it cannot deny that the main stream has a weakened connection with them.
News Paper Reading
Eating Dim Sum
Playing Games
Tai Chi
Martial Art Tai Chi
Sitting Sitting
Chatting Chatting
Sitting
Chatting
Activities Organized * Organized
Street Market Vending
Activities Map
Newspaper Reading News Paper
Reading
Eating Dim Sum Eating
Dim Sum
Playing Table Games Playing
Games
Activities
24
The four adjoining neighbourhoods (UofT, Kensington Market, Queen Street West and Grange Park) to the Chinatown region give significance to Chinatown in terms educational, cultural, commercial, art, and historical values. Seniors are moving back to downtown Chinatown from outskirt because they could easily connect to others and they could conduct more activities in Chinatown. New Chinatowns in suburb areas has caused functional division whereas the downtown Chinatown carries a strong tourist and symbolic functions. The suburban Chinatowns only serve as living communities for new Chinese immigrants. Spadina-Dundas Chinatown helps new comers to adapt to Chinese Canadian Life. According to Enrolment Report by University of Toronto, there are over 10,000 Chinese students, among which are potential new Chinese Canadian, studying at UofT. Chinatown is a lighthouse for many Chinese living overseas, especially Chinese Diaspora members. It becomes a meeting space for unexpected encounters. According to a Sino-Vietnamese Canadian, he randomly met his childhood playmates and friends who are now living in USA and Europe in Spadina-Dundas Chinatown in 1980s and 1990s.
Chinatown Mapping
25
The Important Role of Spadina-Dundas Chinatown as Chinese Canadian Cultural Centre
Garage
Party Wall
Fire Escape
Victorian Housing Back Components
Victorian Housing Back Lane Morphology
Spadina Avenue Frontage Morphology 26
1.5 Cultural Centre Precedents Studies
27
Scarborough
Chinese Cultural Centre of Greater Toronto
East York North York Toronto Community and Culture Centre
York
Etobicoke
City of Toronto Tibetan Canadian Cultural Centre
Downtown Toronto
Cultural Facilities in City of Toronto
Freestanding culture centres representing Chinese Culture are far from city centre and they are not public-transit-friendly. They are barely visited by the mainstream population, and mainly used by Chinese Canadians with limited programs.
28
Chinese Cultural Centre of Greater Toronto 5183 Sheppard Ave E, Scarborough
Miles Nadal Jewish Community Centre 750 Spadina Ave, Toronto
Noor Cultural Centre 123 Wynford Dr, North York
Aga Khan Museum and The Ismaili Centre 77 Wynford Dr, North York
Korean Canadian Cultural Association of Metropolitan Toronto 1133 Leslie St, North York
Japanese Canadian Cultural Centre 6 Garamond Ct, North York
Cultural Facilities in Toronto Major cultural facilities in GTA are located on the outskirt. They usually are giant free-standing building with multi-programs. Since the location is far from city centre, the cultrual impact decreased.
29
Toronto Community and Cultural Centre 222 Spadina Avenue, Toronto, ON, Canada
Chinese Cultural Centre of Greater Vancouver 555 Columbia St, Vancouver, BC, Canada
Chinese Community Centre 62 Mott St, New York, NY, USA
Wing Luke Museum of the Asian Pacific American Experience 719 S King St, Seattle, WA, USA
Chinese Culture Centre 750 Kearny St, San Francisco, CA, USA
LanSu Chinese Garden 239 NW Everett St, Portland, OR, USA
Chinese Cultural Facilities in North American Chinatowns Cultural facilities located in North American Chinatowns are usually located in a small-scale freestanding building or inside other buildings. Chinese motifs, such as dragon gate and flared eaves, are widely used in Chinatowns. The character of the host city is often lost in the applications of such motifs, as they often result in Chinatowns looking very much alike each other.
30
2.1 Proposed Chinese Canadian Cultural Centre
31
Design Description Extracting elements from the existing Toronto-specific urban context, this thesis narrates a foreign spatial relationship to create both a sense of belonging as well as an awareness of the “hyphenated” Chinese-Canadian Experience. The collected Chinese Canadian Cultural Centre tests this idea in a post-multicultural condition. Considering the outside-in strategy of Chinese architecture, a site surrounded by four back lanes is chosen in Toronto’s Downtown Chinatown. Victorian back lane garage structures are abstracted as the modular units to develop a thematic sequence of culture – reception, reflection, production, and celebration, from public Spadina Avenue to private blocks. A raised wall made of reclaimed brick mined from the site’s Victorian structures creates a walled-in gesture at a civic-scale much like that of a Chinese Palace.
32
Qianlong Garden
Beijing - Forbidden City
35.63m
138.89m
35.63m
138.89m
39.00m
160.00m
160.00m
39.00m
Qianlong GardenVictorian Housing
Beijing - Forbidden City Toronto - Cabbagetown
Qianlong Garden
Beijing - Forbidden City
Urban Fabric Comparison Photo Source: : Qianlong Garden: Liu, Chang (2010). Qianlong’s Collector’s: the studies and master conservation plan for Qianlong Garden. Beijing: Tsinghua University Press. Victorian housing: Baldwin Collection, Toronto Reference Library, Wellington St.W., s. side, between York & Simcoe Sts. 33
Victorian Housing
Toronto - Cabbagetown
Victorian Housing
Toronto - Cabbagetown
35.63m
138.89m
160.00m
39.00m
Qianlong Garden
Victorian Housing Toronto - Cabbagetown
Building
Building
Courtyard
Front/Back Yard
Path
Laneway
Courtyard Wall
Party Wall
Trees
Trees
Rock
Hearth
Porch and Pavilion
Porch
Beijing - Forbidden City
Hyphenated Chinese-Canadian experience is the key element of designing a Chinese Canadian Cultural Centre. Typical block layout of Toronto Victorian housing and Beijing Courtyard garden are selected to make comparison. Different from Victorian housing using street and back lane to connect housings, Chinese architecture, by practicing outside-in strategy, let path to organize individual buildings and create courtyards in between.
Urban Fabric Requisite Comparison 34
Huron Street
Beverley Street
Spadina Avenue
Cecil Street
Baldwin Street
- - - - - - -
Spadina frontage Pedestrian Perception Assembly space of both indoor and outdoor More intimate single group space A civic scale instead of private scale (10,000+ UofT student) Public space for events Accessibility and universal design
Site Plan 35
Wall
Reclaimed Bricks / Victorian Housing Party Wall
Bridge
Fire Escape
Building
Modular Garage Structures
Garden
Path : Outside-in Strategy
Hyphenated Chinese-Canadian Experience Components 36
9 3 10
4
5
25
10 13 15 12 14
24 23
22
16
21
19 40
8
10 2
11
1 7
6
5
16 16 17 18 19 19
2 20 10 10 10 40
Ground Floor Plan
Underground Floor Plan 37
26
27 2 10 10
29 19 28
30
16 16 16 16 16 32 31
3
20
36
10 10
26 35
36
35 33
37
11
38
39
35
21
40
2
28
34
36
36
Second Floor Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Chinese Canadian Portrait Gallery Lobby Reception History Exhibition Family History Exhibition Temporary Exhibition Shop Outdoor Pavilion
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Cloak Room Washroom Archive Research Area Oral History Lab Interview Room Meeting Room Office
17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Lab Loading and Receiving Storage Staff Lounge Language Workshop Brush Painting and Calligraphy Workshop Meditation Workshop Dance and Workout Workshop
25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32
Outdoor Bicycle Parking Theatre Waiting Room Tea House Outdoor Play Ground Service Parking Social Service Centre Consulting Room
33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
Tax Clinic Photo Studio Community Meeting Area Outdoor Wood Terrace Art Gallery Hand Craft Workshop Community Meeting Room Service Room
38
Brush Painting and Calligraphy Workshops Cantonese Language Workshops Craft Workshops Dance and workout Workshops English Language Workshops Mandarin Language Workshops Meditation Workshops Community Lounge Community Meeting Room Computer Lab
M M U N IT Y
SQ
U
AR E
PS
SPORTS FIELD
CO
CO
CO M
M
U
N
W A
IT SH M M Y LO ROO U U N M N IT GE O Y CE WO FFIC R E N TR KSH O E
PE TE RM M A P N EX ORA ENT H RY E EXH IB XH IB IT IB ITIO IO ITIO N N N
E
Programs
M ROO AGE M M LO U N TEA BBY IT H Y OU TH SE EA TR
CULTURAL EVENTS
W S AS TO R H
RY LE
HURON ST.
CHINATOWN CIVIC SQUARE
39
CULTURAL EVENTS
BUSINESS EVENTS
CELEBRATION
CO
CO M
PRODUCTION
W M INT AS EE E H TIN RV RO G IEW O RO RO M O RE O M OM F SE FIC AR AR E C R CH O ESEA HIVE RA RC CE L H H N ISTO ARE TR R A E Y LA B
Chinatown Safety Program Chinese Students Career Fair Consulting Service Immigrant Program Photo Studio Senior Health Fair Tax Clinic Youth Program
REFLECTION
AL
W O A F
Archive Seminar Interview Chinese Canadian Studies
U
Chinese Canadian Art Gallery Chinese Diaspora in Canada Portrait Gallery
M
N S FI SE CO ITY HRO CE M O RV M E M IC MU ETIN E G N CE IT AR EA N Y TR E
RECEPTION
G
Canadian Chinatowns History Exhibition Chinese Canadian Immigrants History Exhibition Family Associations in Chinatown Exhibition Family’s History Exhibition Chinese Art and Craft Exhibition Special Exhibitions produced by UofT Chinese Canadian Studies
AR T
O G FFI CO IFT CE E M SH M O RE XHI U P S N CE BI IT R TO T PT IO Y ME ECEP RAG ET TI E IO N IN ON N G AR EA
CL O W AK L AS R OB H O BY RO O O M M
Mahjong Social Newspaper Reading
HURON ST.
PUBLIC EVENTS
Canada Day Celebration Chinatown Festival Chinese New Year Festival Dragon Ball Dragon Boat Festival Dragon Festival Mid-Autumn Festival South Asia Alliance Culture Show Under the Movie Night Under the Sky Concert Chinese Food Festival Farmer’s Market Night Market Taste of China Festival Dragon Dance and Lion Dance Practice Martial Art Practice Play Ground Chinese New Year Gala Chinese Opera Concert Dance Performance Movie Night Orchestra
Public Lecture Seminar
$ Government
Stakeholder
Chinatown Business Purchase
st Inve ate/
y
lH
isto
Art + Culture + History
Art Gallery
ry
Partner
CHINESE CANADIAN STUDIES
ate
Don
e
as rch Pu
r
Sponso
erial rch Mat
UNIVERSITY COLLEGE UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO
Visitors
Exhibition
ate Don rial e Mat
w Ho
r of isto on l H ati Ora c u d Ed cor Re to
Ora
Chinese Canadian Community
Fund
Don
Tickets
Resea
Shop
Research Centre
lic Pub
Partner Sponsor
Neighbourhood
ce
Spa
Research Material
Square
Archive
Ticket / Rent
Education Work/Co-op Opportunity
Venue for Art
Community Service Centre
er
Volunte
r
ee nt
lu Vo
10,000+ Chinese Students (Chinese Canadian Candidates)
it un
yS
er
e vic
m
m Co
Senior
Audience/ Performance Organizer
se rti ve Ad ce du ro Int
ice
Serv munity
Com
Theatre
Community Centre
Membership
Class/ Workshops
... FUNDING
Other Organizations
INDIRECT BENEFITS Member
SERVICE
Management 40
Bicycle Parking Area
Exhibiton and Art Gallery Entrance Entrance on Spadina Avenue Frontage
Cultural Reception
41
Exhibition
Pavilion in the Garden
North Elevation
Skywalk over Garden
Cultural Reflection
42
Community Hall Lobby
Chinese Canadian Research Centre Outdoor Wood Terrace
Cultural Production
43
Spadina
Huron
Beverley
College
Cultural Celebration
Outdoor Play Ground
Pedestrain Bridge towards Theatre
Theatre Interior
Huron Street and the Community Hall
Cecil
CCCC square Baldwin
Dundas
Huron square
Proposed Chinatown Festival Market Stalls Existing Chinatown Festival Market Stalls
Huron Street could be closed for Chinatown Festival from Dundas Street Huron Street Square to Cecil Street.
44
I would like to thank all those individuals and institutions that assisted in the research and development of the thesis: University of Toronto Pina Petricone, Aziza Chaouni, Lisa Mar, Rick Halpern, Jeffery Reitz, MArch Class of 2018. Sense of Place Survey Team Jiahuan Zhou and Yuxin Yue. Chinese/ Chinese Canadian Community Julie Jai, Leo Chan, Arlene Chan, ThuanHoa Thai, Haibo Zhang, Kellie Chin; Alice Chan, Louis Lim, Lily Liu, Chieh Schen Teng, Juni Yeung, Rui Zhang; Wenjin Han, Qi Meng, Luyi Song, Zhiwei Wang, Kui Xia, Xiaoyu Yuan; Jiaxin Shi, Tong Zhao, Bingchi Zhu, Chenxuan Meng, Yazhuo Wang, Jinqin Xiao, Xiaolong Li. Family and Friends