I hereby declare that I am the sole author of this publication. I understand that my document may be made electronically available to the public.
Abstract At the turn of the 19th century our society evolved from an agricultural economy to an industrial system and the settlement of Galt, capitalized on this transformation developing a manufacturing capacity that shaped the city. Today we are facing a new economic transformation and Cambridge must again adapt as it did over one hundred years ago if the city is to remain relevant in the region and partake in the national discourse. Cambridge must take advantage of its position in Canada’s Technology Triangle and the city’s lever for economic development in the abandoned urban core is design. In contrast to Waterloo’s image of sprawl downtown Cambridge is a pedestrian friendly, scenic riverside community with a significant stock of neglected but architecturally exceptional buildings from the 19th century. The city must push beyond its initial investment in this societal shift that is currently contained in the University of Waterloo’s School of Architecture, predominantly placed on the river’s edge. Capitalizing on Cambridge’s unique position this thesis proposes to investigate the city and how the Waterloo Architecture BRIDGE Storefront student initiative can act as a catalyst for change. This project emerges from my desire to utilize architecture as driver for change within the community and as an extension from previous and current volunteer experience both locally and abroad. Developing an infrastructure for future student participation this project provokes a discourse between the University of Waterloo School of Architecture, the community of Cambridge and the University of Waterloo itself. Cambridge’s future lies in its active participation as the design centre for the Technology Triangle, a tech hub not just within the province but an innovation incubator on the international stage. This thesis emerges from a latent locus of economic activity and social engagement in Cambridge’s core, currently concealed in multiple assets that can define a cultural map and civic identity to position itself in the evolving global economy. Manifesting in design is the city’s potential future, where it can build upon the relatively recent construction of the School of Architecture and the proposed Integrated Design School. Design is emerging as Cambridge’s mechanism for economic growth, where the BRIDGE Storefront and proposed interventions can act as a catalyst, creating a lasting impact with a framework for student and community participation, a footprint in the city’s core, and a vision for the future.
Table of Contents
[foundation]
ii. iv. vi. vii.
Author ’s Declaration Abstract Table of Contents Introduction [scaffold]
1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3
Urban Identity De-urbanization of the Mid-Sized Industrial City Creative Capital Synergistic Cities: Kitchener, Waterloo, Cambridge [frame]
2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4
Cambridge: Creative Potential Human Capital Existing Infrastructure Historic Assets Existing Businesses [construct]
3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3
Provoking Action Opportunity in Absence Defining a Framework Instigation through Intervention [so far]
Introduction After I completed high school I chose to go to the University of Waterloo to study architecture. I turned down other opportunities to experience the world through co-op and the Rome program, in-spite of the fact that the school was located off campus in Cambridge; for which I had many reservations. My international experiences changed me in ways I could not imagine as I learned from the cities, my friends and colleagues. I never really wanted to be an architect. I stated just like so many other naive high school students that I wanted to study architecture because it was the perfect marriage of art and science. It was only in my third year of school that things began to crystallize as my architectural dream came into focus. My eyes had been opened to the world of design and the beauty of form and function. I had become infatuated with the landscape and our built world, its tactile qualities and the role of the architect to comprehend, render and transform it. It is though this lens that I now interpret the world as I look to improve upon the physical condition.
Following my graduation from Waterloo I decided to continue my explorations and travels, and to push myself outside my comfort zone in search of something. I found a new level of personal determination and perseverance as I cycled over 3200 km from Toronto to Newfoundland. I then took an opportunity to volunteer in Nicaragua, a third world country where I didn’t speak the native language. It was in my passion for travel and desire to help that I thought I had found my thesis in the disaster relief housing I was designing there. I returned to Waterloo to pursue this and push my ability to have an impact. I came to Waterloo because I wanted to continue this exploratory journey of self discovery. My thesis emerged from my desire to utilize architecture as driver for change within the community however as I studied the issues facing Nicaragua I felt extremely distant and my project was being pushed in a theoretical direction I had no interest in. It was at this time through my work as the Vice President of the Society of Waterloo Architecture Graduates that I came across the BRIDGE student initiative. When I first walked into the BRIDGE Storefront space that was under renovation I imagined something truly exceptional. Although BRIDGE is currently in it’s humble beginnings as a website, it has the dream to be like something unseen in any other school of architecture across the country. BRIDGE aims to connect the students to each other and the community in the promotion of architecture and design. The Storefront on Main Street felt like a space where I could have a real impact, brining something to Cambridge, my home of the past six years. Running my hands along the plaster walls I could feel another adventure beginning. I am not sure where this journey will take me but I look forward to chasing a dream and learning along the way.
Cambridge: in need of identity I too am searching for mine Professional, Personal, Urban: Development
Literature Review SynergiCity : Reinventing the postindustrial city2012. , eds. Kapp, Paul Hardin, author,editor of compilation, Armstrong, Paul J., author,editor of compilation. Urbana: Urbana : University of Illinois Press. Living in the endless city : The urban age project by the london school of economics and deutsche bank’s alfred herrhausen society2011. , eds. Richard Burdett, Deyan Sudjic, London School of Economics and Political Science and Alfred Herrhausen Gesellschaft für Internationalen Dialog. London: London : Phaidon Press Ltd. Urban identity2011. , eds. B. M. (Brian M. ). Evans, Academy of Urbanism (Organization). London ; New York, NY: London ; New York, NY : Routledge. The endless city : The urban age project by the london school of economics and deutsche bank’s alfred herrhausen society2007. , eds. Richard Burdett, Deyan Sudjic and London School of Economics and Political Science. London: London : Phaidon. Heritage property evaluation : A guide to listing, researching and evaluating cultural heritage property in ontario communities2006. , ed. Ontario. Ministry of Culture. Toronto]: Toronto : Ministry of Culture. Creativity and the city : How the creative economy changes the city2005. , eds. Simon Franke, Evert Verhagen. Rotterdam : New York, NY: Rotterdam : NAi Pub. ; New York, NY : Available in North America through D.A.P./ Distributed Art Pub. Creativity and the city : How the creative economy changes the city2005. , eds. Simon Franke, Evert Verhagen. Rotterdam : New York, NY: Rotterdam : NAi Pub. ; New York, NY : Available in North America through D.A.P./ Distributed Art Pub. City branding : Image building & building images2002. , eds. Véronique Patteeuw, Urban Affairs. (Firm). Rotterdam: Rotterdam : NAi. Small, medium, large, extra-large : Office for metropolitan architecture, rem koolhaas, and bruce mau1998. , eds. Rem Koolhaas, Bruce Mau, Jennifer Sigler, Hans Werlemann and Office for Metropolitan Architecture. New York, N.Y.: New York, N.Y. : Monacelli Press. a + t. 1992. A + t; a más t (-). Reclaim Rekediate Reuse Reccycle Issue 39-40 2008 Blaser, Werner, 1924-. 2004. Post tower : Helmut jahn, werner sobek, matthias schuler. Basel ; Boston: Birkhäuser. Bowman, Katherine, 1980-, and Katherine Bowman 1980-. 2007. A new role for student housing : Revitalizing a mid-sized city core.Waterloo, Ont. : University of Waterloo. Calvino, Italo, and Italo Calvino. 1974. Invisible cities. New York: New York : Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Esperdy, Gabrielle M., and Gabrielle M. Esperdy. 2008. Modernizing main street : Architecture and consumer culture in the new deal. Chicago: Chicago : University of Chicago Press. Florida, Richard L., and Richard L. Florida. 2012. The rise of the creative class : Revisited. New York: New York : Basic Books. ———. 2008. Who’s your city? : How the creative economy is making where to live the most important decision of your life. New York: New York : Basic Books. ———. 2005. Cities and the creative class. New York ; London: New York ; London : Routledge. ———. 2004. The rise of the creative class : And how it’s transforming work, leisure, community and everyday life. New York: New York : Basic Books. Hill, Nicholas, and Nicholas Hill. 1987. Cambridge (galt), a building facade plan, eds. Elizabeth -. Bloomfield, Cambridge (Ont.). Local Architectural Conservation Advisory Committee. London, Ont.: London, Ont. : N. Hill. Mau, Bruce, and Bruce Mau. 2004. Massive change, eds. Jennifer Leonard, Institute without Boundaries. London ; New York: London ; New York : Phaidon. Ollson, Ryan Michael, and Ryan Michael Ollson. 2012. Urban actuation : Public space as a catalyst for urban revitalization.Waterloo, Ont. : University of Waterloo. Design like you give a damn 2] : Building change from the ground up2012. , ed. Architecture for Humanity (Organization). New York ; London: New York ; London : Abrams. Holl, Steven, and Steven Holl. 2000. Parallax. New York: New York : Princeton Architectural Press. Jodidio, Philip, and Philip Jodidio. 2010. Shopping architecture now! = shopping-architektur heute! = L’architecture commerciale d’aujourd’hui!. Cologne: Cologne : Taschen. Krätke, Stefan, 1952-, and Stefan Krätke 1952-. 2011. The creative capital of cities interactive knowledge creation and the urbanization economies of innovation, ed. Wiley InterScience (Online service). Chichester, West Sussex ; Malden, MA; Malden, MA; Chichester, West Sussex, UK ; Malden, MA: Chichester, West Sussex ; Malden, MA : Wiley-Blackwell. Martin, Ray, and Ray Martin. 1996. Old galt historical walking tour, ed. Heritage Cambridge. Cambridge, Ont.: Cambridge, Ont. : Heritage Cambridge. Ritter, Arno, and Arno Ritter. 2000. Acconci, holl : Storefront for art and architecture. Ostfildern/Ruit, Germany]: Ostfildern/Ruit, Germany : Hatje Cantz.
2.0
URBAN IDENTITY
There are a multitude of factors that have formed our cities today and the urban condition forms the scaffolding from which this project is built. The character in townscape and landscape define the identity of place. Promoting this character by responding to and reinforcing locally distinctive patterns of development, landscape and culture is how the cities of tomorrow will differentiate from each other as they compete for resources and residents in wold of rapid globalization.
1.1
De-urbanization of the Mid-Sized Industrial City Cities The sketches could not hide the fact that most of the people in love with the idea of urban super-highways did not really like cities very much. Almost all early supporters of super-highways believed that either cities would eventually wither away as society, helped by the decentralizing highways, evolved toward a pastoral, suburban ideal, or that the cities would be replaced by the new cities of a very different pattern. Rem Koolhaus [SMLXL p.130]
PROVOKING ACTION
The economic transformation that decimated Cambridge’s downtown created an absence for this project to exist. What has caused the abandonment of a once prosperous Galt core and what lessons can be learned from midscale cities in parallel situations?
APPENDIX
Over one hundred years ago the settlement of Galt transitioned from an agricultural to a manufacturing based economy. Galt’s core was focused around textile factories and the downtown was a center of highly concentrated activity and the full spectrum of economic functions that represented the highest land values in the city. However as the modern economy transitioned to textile production on a global scale these factories were abandoned and the residents evacuated to the suburbs. This chapter will focus on the negative aspects of suburbanization and the issues facing cities as a result of urban sprawl.
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
2
Vacancy
While North American cities escaped the destruction of war, great damage was inflicted to the core of cities through ill-advised urban renewal policies. traffic planning priorities, zoning policies, and the constructin of single functin large scale commercial centers. Lenard, Henry & Cowhurst Lennard, Suzanne (eds).
[The Wisdom of Cities: Architecture, Place, Community, Neighbourhood, Identity Planning and Values p. 3]
URBAN IDENTITY
4
1.2
Creative Capital
More and more businesses understand that ethos and are making the adaptations necessary to attract and retain creative class employees— everything from relaxed dress codes, flexible schedules, and new work rules in the office to hiring recruiters who throw Frisbees. Most civic leaders, however, have failed to understand that what is true for corporations is also true for cities and regions: Places that succeed in attracting and retaining creative class people prosper; those that fail don’t. Richard Florida
[The Rise of the Creative Class]
PROVOKING ACTION APPENDIX
According to Richard Florida, the Creative Class are a key driving force for economic development of post-industrial cities. Florida’s research shows the growth in the creative sector of employment and states that employment in what he defines as the creative field relates directly to higher income. The evidence for this can too be seen in the City of Cambridge and this chapter proposes to investigate his theories and how they relate to the Waterloo Region.
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
6
oriented jobs enjoy the benefits o the creative age. ertainly a lot of jobs – in the hair salon, on the construction site, or in the restaurant kitchen – already involve creative work. W e need to recogniz e and reward that creativity more than we do. Some other jobs, too, can become more creative with higher rewards. The Emerging Creative Economy There is no magic bullet. But sooner or later some jurisdiction will determine how to tap more fully the creative talents of much
W e need a dramatic transformation in both our occupational structure – what people do – and in our industrial structure – what we produce.
The share ofjobs creativity-oriented employment The increasing share of creativity-oriented is increasing
Exhibit 2
Routine-oriented and creativity-oriented jobs
Routine-oriented and(1901-2006) creativity-oriented jobs Ontario Ontario (1901-2006)
Share of workforce 100%
Routine-resource 80
Routine-service Routineoriented
60
decrease in jobs in the good-producing sector There is only so much furniture, appliances, and automobiles and an increase in the services sector – even that a family can purchase over a lifetime. But our demand for though the same people may be doing the very services Routine-physical – health care, education, financial advice, dining away 40 same jobs as before the out sourcing. That from home to name a few – continues to grow unabated. is hardly what people think of as a decline in manufacturing jobs. Like other advanced economies, we are Creativity20 As Ontarians have been growing wealthier, undergoing a significant economic oriented we spend relatively less on basic needs. For transformation here in Ontario. The rise of example, India’s consumers allocate 46 percent the creative economy is to be welcomed. of their US0 $3,700 per capita income to food3; 1901 1911 1921 1931 1941Our 1951 1971 1981 1991content 2001 in 2006 goal is1961 to raise the creativity Ontarians, with a per capita income of $36,300, all our jobs and industries. spend only 8 percent on food. Note: The 1961 and 1991 data points have been approximated due to data limitations. Note: The 1961 and 1991 data points have been approximated due to data limitations. Credit: Martin Prosperity Institute Ontario Report 2009 Source: Martin Prosperity Institute analysis based on data from Statistics Canada. Source: Martin Prosperity Institute analysis based on data from Statistics Canada.
Nearly 80 percent of jobs in Canada are in services industries
Exhibit 4
6 | Ontario in the Creative Age Percentage of employment
Exhibit 2
Employment goods- versus sector, sector, Employment in in goodsversusservices-producing services-producing Canada, 1946-2008 Canada, 1946-2008
100% Services-producing sector 80
60
40
20
Goods-producing sector
0 1946
1956
1966
1976
1986
Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from Statistics Canada.
Credit: Martin Prosperity Institute Ontario Report 2009 Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from Statistics Canada.
1996
2008
URBAN IDENTITY
8
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
highly s illed or contributing to a high value-added fir will not a degree. F ull- time workers in routine- oriented be around for the long term. This is a painful transition in our service occupations are slightly younger than econo y – but we don t have the option o ignoring it or fighting those in creativity- oriented occupations, but it. To gain a distinctive advantage for Ontario, we need to guide about the same as those in the routine- oriented the development of workers in routine- oriented physical occuphysical occupations. pations toward those that are highly skilled and where workers Single mothers are over represented in routinedraw on their full creative potential to make decisions rather oriented service occupations – 5 7 percent of lone parents are in these occupations, compared than be bound by dictated routines and processes. An important key to achieving this source of distinctive advantage is to prepare with 46 percent of all workers. W orkers in TRANSFORMATION OF THE utcurrent withinand routine-oriented occupations, we have seen a future workforce and industries for the skills service occupations are not significantly over Job Creation and Unemployment byour Occupational Group JOBS WE DO shi t. we outine-oriented physical jobs, decades. li e those in reqassive uirements will be facing in the coming represented in other poverty groups identified manufacturing, transportation, and construction, have fallen Routine-oriented occupations have higher unemployment rates and were The rise of the creative age presents us in ro percent to percent, while those in routine-oriented harder hit by the recession in the early 1990s Ontario with two great challenges: service jobs have grown from 41 percent to 46 percent.1 Our Routine-oriented occupations have higher unemployment rates and were even harder hit Exhibit 13 projections show that creativity- oriented occupations and by the recession in the early 1990s routine- oriented service occupations will continue to grow H ow do we guide the development of our much faster than routine- physical occupations ( Exhibit 3). economy so that we are moving increasingly Ontario unemployment rate by occupational groups, Percentage Ontario unemployment rate by occupational groups, 1987-2008 W hat we’re witnessing is a replay of the employment decline tounemployed one that is characteriz ed by creativity1987-2008 in ar ing, orestry, and fishing occupations in the first hal o oriented occupations? 10 the twentieth century. Around 1 9 00, fully 42 percent of Ontario workers were tilling the soil, cutting trees, or hunting and H ow do we design as much creativity 8 fishing or our ood. ecause o assive productivity i proveinto occupations that are currently ments in the agricultural and resource sectors, today we are routine- oriented? Routine-oriented occupations and able to meet the basic consumption demands of Ontarians 6 untold numbers around the world with only 2 percent of our Our economy has experienced the dramatic work force. growth of some occupational classes, alongside 4 W hile it is imperative to increase our ability to compete for the significant decline o others. ploy ent Creativity-oriented creativity-oriented jobs and industries, we ustoccupations also i prove in creativity- oriented occupations is growing the performance and pay – as well as the creative content – of faster than 2 average in Ontario. Over the those who wor in routine-oriented occupations, particularly past twenty-five years, the creativity-oriented in the large and growing service economy. W e must strive to be occupations have increased from 2 6 percent 0 the world s first jurisdiction to2002 revolutioni e2005 routine wor2008 , to of the province’s1987 work force to1990 30 percent, 1993 1996 1999 make it more creative and better paying and to have a modern while routine- oriented jobs have declined from high-paying, high-value added and secure service econo y. 74 to 70 percent. Note: The LFS produces information of number of unemployed, the unemployment rate and the labour force by industry and occupation. The basis for these categories is
New jobs in the coming decade will be in creativity-oriented and routine-oriented occupations 10 See ibid., pp. 28-45 service for a discussion of groups of Ontarians with high risk of being in low income situations.
Exhibit 3
Proportion of netProportion new jobof creation occupation group net new job by creation by occupation group 2006-20162006-2016
www.martinprosperity.org | 23
Exhibit 13
Routine-service
43%
Routine-physical
15%
Routine-oriented
Creativity-oriented
100%
50%
8%
42%
42%
Ontario
United States
APPENDIX
100%
PROVOKING ACTION
Note: The LFSindustry produces information of job number of currently unemployed, the unemployment the labour or occupation of last for those unemployed who have held a rate job inand the previous year.force by industry and occupation. The basis for these categories is industry or occupationSource: of last Martin job forProsperity those currently unemployed have held &a Prosperity job in theanalysis previous year. Institute and Institute for who Competitiveness based on data from Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey micro data for the of April. Credit: Martinmonth Prosperity Institute Ontario Report 2009 Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey micro data for the month of April.
Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Projections (2006-2016).
Credit: Martin Prosperity Institute Ontario Report 2009 Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Projections Another type of routine occupation is resource-oriented (e.g., agriculture, mining, or forestry workers) where employment has declined from (2006-2016).1 4 percent to 2 percent of the workforce, over the past 25 years.
www.martinprosperity.org | 7
Creative Influence - Opportunity for a creative identity The residential neighbourhoods that feed the established historic centres have the city’s highest concentration of creative employment and directly correlate to higher incomes and property values.
Silver Heights / Blackbridge North Cambridge Hillcrest / Cooper
Downtown Hespeler
Cambrian Hills Centennial / River Flats
Riverside Industrial Park
Preston Heights
Central Park
Lang's Farm Shades Mills / Industrial Park Northview
Blair Riverview Elgin Park Westview
Lincoln-Oaks
Victoria Highlands
City Core
Eastview / Branchton Park Glenview
Southwood
St. Andrews Hills
Southview
% of Creative Employment
% of Routine Oriented Employment
10
Legend Highway River
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip_1 URBAN IDENTITY
1 Dot = 10,000 AVERAGE_IN
CR Labour_Occupation_Education_3 Creative / Tot_Cr_Ro 0.2069 - 0.2750 0.2751 - 0.3750 0.3751 - 0.4375 0.4376 - 0.4815 0.4816 - 0.5152
0.5473 - 0.5814 0.5815 - 0.6250 0.6251 - 0.7018 0
0.7019 - 0.8261
1.5
3 km
Average Dwelling Value
PROVOKING ACTION
Average Income
0.75
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
0.5153 - 0.5472
Legend Highway River AVERAGE_IN
Legend
APPENDIX
0.000000 0.000001 - 26294.000000 26294.000001 - 29362.000000 29362.000001 - 32265.000000 32265.000001 - 35627.000000
River
35627.000001 - 39506.000000 39506.000001 - 43757.000000
<all other values>
0
43757.000001 - 50696.000000
0.75
1.5
3 km
50696.000001 - 64940.000000 64940.000001 - 101369.000000
0
0.75
1.5
3 km
1.3
Synergistic Cities Kitchener, Waterloo, Cambridge Syn·er·gy
noun
combined action or operation a mutually advantageous conjunction or compatibility of distinct business participants or elements (as resources or efforts) [Merriam Webster]
Brand·ing
noun
the promoting of a product or service by identifying it with a particular brand [Merriam Webster]
Iden·ti·ty
noun
the promoting of a product or service by identifying it with a particular brand [Merriam Webster]
Identity must be continuously assumed and immediately called into question. Rem Koolhaus [SMLXL p.76]
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
Geographically located in Canada‘s Technology Triangle, Cambridge must push its position to take advantage of the emerging economic transformation and and the region’s $30 billion tech industry and GDP growth that ranks third highest amongst Canadian cities.1 Kitchener, Waterloo and Cambridge all have unique assets and this chapter will analyze their positions and determine Cambridge’s role and identity in the region.
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
12
Community Profile 2013, Canada’s Technology Triangle Inc. www.techtriangle.ca/en/ataglance/resources/2013_Community_Profile.pdf
1
IDENTITY CRISIS
PROVOKING ACTION
37°53’S 175°28”E New Zealand, United States 18.311°N 77.901°W Jamaica, United States 37°19’2”N 96°40’2”W Kansas, United States 38°13’18”N 85°37’0”W Kentucky, United States 38°33’59”N 76°4’37”W Maryland, United States 40°1’30”N 81°35’12”W Ohio, United States 40°17’0”N 100°10’15”W Nebraska, United States 41°18’12”N 90°11’36”W Illinois, United States 41°53’55”N 93°31’47”W Iowa, United States 42°22’25”N 71°06’38”W Massachusetts, United States 42°59’50”N 73°27’06”W Cambridge, New York, United States 43°0’15”N 89°1’2”W Wisconsin, United States 43°21’30”N 80°18’50”W Ontario, Canada 44°34’18”N 116°40’41”W Idaho, United States 44°38’28”N 72°50’7”W Vermont, United States 44°39’35”N 71°06’31”W New Hampshire, United States 45°01’27”N 69°28’26”W Maine, United States 45°03’26”N 64°38’05”W Kings County, Nova Scotia, Canada 45°12’7.19”N 64°6’24.37”W Hants County, Nova Scotia 45°34’22”N 93°13’28”W Minnesota, United States 51.732°N 02.365°W Gloucestershire, England 52.205°N 0.119°E Cambridgeshire, England
APPENDIX
Cambridge
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
14
2.0
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
Cambridge is not a blank canvas. A skeleton of itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s former self it has rich assets that form a platform from which future development can be built. Clearly identifying a cultural map for the city will bring this platform into focus and creates a jumping off point for intervention, defining a vehicle for change.
2.1
Human Capital
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL APPENDIX
The socio-economic tendency of firms to cluster together is evident in the region of Waterloo and suggests that place remains important as a locus of economic activity. The Regional Municipality of Waterloo developed an environment which attracted a large talent pool of engineers and industrial leaders through a suburban business park urban planning model. While this strategy was initially successful it does not meet the desires to attract the designers and creative drivers of the emerging economy. A 1998 KPMG survey of over 1200 high-technology workers found that community quality of life was the second most important factor associated with the attractiveness of a new job, below only employment salary.2 The quality of life in the community was seen to increase the attractiveness of a job by 33%. Cambridge holds a unique position in the region with multiple assets that create a quality of life in the downtown core to attract designers for the high tech and creative industry.
PROVOKING ACTION
As a member of Canadaâ&#x20AC;&#x2DC;s Technology Triangle Cambridge is in a unique position to capitalize on the emerging economic transformation and position its self at the leading edge of the 21st Century Economy.
URBAN IDENTITY
18
2
Richard Flordia, Cities and The Creative Class. p. 82
Regional Municipality of Waterloo % Of People With Creative Employment vs Average Income
% Of People With Routine-Oriented Employment vs Average Income Legend Highway
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip 1 Dot = 9,600 AVERAGE_IN Regional Roads
Labour_Occupation_Education_ Creative / Tot_Cr_Ro 0.000 - 0.2750
Legend
0.2751 - 0.3860
Legend
Highway
0.3861 - 0.4615
Highway
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip
0.4616 - 0.5227 Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip
Legend
1 Dot = 9,600
Legend
1 Dot = 9,600
AVERAGE_IN
0.5228 - 0.5735
Highway AVERAGE_IN
Highway Regional Roads
0.5736 - 0.6200
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip Labour_Occupation_Education_
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip Labour_Occupation_Education_
0.6201 - 0.6698
1 Dot = 9,600 Routine / Tot_Cr_Ro
Dot = 9,600 Creative / 1Tot_Cr_Ro
0.076923077 - 0.194444444 AVERAGE_IN
0.000 - 0.2750 AVERAGE_IN
0.6699 - 0.7273
0.194444445 - 0.269841270 Labour_Occupation_Education_
0.2751 - 0.3860 Labour_Occupation_Education_ Routine / Tot_Cr_Ro 0.3861 - 0.4615 0.076923077 - 0.194444444 0.4616 - 0.5227
0.7274 Routine / Tot_Cr_Ro 0.269841271 - 0.328947368
- 0.8023
0.076923077 - 0.194444444 0.328947369 - 0.379310345 0.8024
- 0.9231
0
3.25
6.5
13 km
0
3.25
6.5
13 km
0.194444445 - 0.269841270 0.379310346 - 0.425531915
0.194444445 - 0.269841270 0.5228 - 0.5735
0.269841271 - 0.328947368 0.425531916 - 0.476190476
0.269841271 - 0.328947368 0.5736 - 0.6200
0.328947369 - 0.379310345 0.476190477 - 0.536842105
0.328947369 - 0.379310345 0.6201 - 0.6698
0.379310346 - 0.425531915 0.536842106 - 0.612903226
0.379310346 - 0.425531915 0.6699 - 0.7273
0.425531916 - 0.476190476 0.612903227 - 0.714285714
0.425531916 - 0.476190476 0.7274 - 0.8023 0.476190477 - 0.536842105 0.8024 - 0.9231
0
3.25
6.5
0.476190477 - 0.536842105 0.714285715 - 1.00000000
13 km
0.536842106 - 0.612903226 Regional Roads
0.536842106 - 0.612903226 0.612903227 - 0.714285714
3.25
6.5
6.5
13 km
0
3.25
6.5
13 km
0.714285715 - 1.00000000
0.714285715 - 1.00000000
0
3.25
Population Density
% Of University Graduates vs Average Income Regional Roads
0
0.612903227 - 0.714285714
Regional Roads
13 km
Legend Highway
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip 1 Dot = 9,600 AVERAGE_IN Regional Roads
Labour_Occupation_Education_ UNIVERSI7 / TOTAL_POPU
Legend Highway
0.000 - 0.004878
Legend
0.004879 - 0.01274 0.01275 - 0.01786
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip 1 Dot = 9,600
Legend
AVERAGE_IN
Highway
Legend
Regional Roads
Highway
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip
Highway Regional Roads
0.02223 - 0.02703
Regional Roads
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip Poverty / TOTAL_POPU Labour_Occupation_Education_ 1 Dot = 9,600 UNIVERSI7 / TOTAL_POPU
0.01787 - 0.02222
0.02704 - 0.03320
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip TOTAL_POPU / Shape_Area
0.000
0.000 - 0.004878 AVERAGE_IN
0.00000000 - 11250801.3
0.00010000 - 0.02439
0.03321 - 0.04020 0.04021 - 0.05102
0.004879 - 0.01274 Labour_Occupation_Education_
11250801.4 - 25250164.7
Routine / Tot_Cr_Ro 0.01275 - 0.01786
25250164.8 - 39377726.6
0.05103 - 0.06383
39377726.7 - 64065356.0
0.06384 - 0.1000
0.02440 - 0.03390
0.076923077 - 0.194444444 0.01787 - 0.02222 0.03391 0.194444445 - 0.269841270 0.02223 - 0.02703
- 0.04396
64065356.1 - 150851638
0.04397 - 0.05479
0.269841271 - 0.328947368 0.02704 - 0.03320
0.328947369 - 0.379310345 0.05480 0.03321 - 0.04020
- 0.06667
0.379310346 - 0.425531915 0.06668 0.04021 - 0.05102
- 0.08140
0.425531916 - 0.476190476 0.05103 - 0.06383 0.08141
- 0.1081
0.476190477 - 0.536842105 0.06384 - 0.1000
150851639 - 282182267 282182268 - 986140668 986140669 - 4416920730 4416920740 - 9233376300 0
3.25
6.5
0.1082 - 0.1706 0.536842106 - 0.612903226 0.612903227 - 0.714285714 0.1707
13 km
9233376310 - 204417881000
0
- 0.2917
0.714285715 - 1.00000000 0
3.25
6.5
13
3.25
6.5
13 km
0
3.25
6.5
13 km
Source: Based on data from Statistics Canada
Average Income
% Of People in Poverty
20
Legend URBAN IDENTITY
Highway Regional Roads
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip AVERAGE_IN 0.000000 0.000001 - 22388.000000 22388.000001 - 28223.000000
Legend
Legend
28223.000001 - 32569.000000
Highway
Highway
Regional Roads
Regional Roads
32569.000001 - 37664.000000
Poverty / TOTAL_POPU
AVERAGE_IN 0.000000
0.000
44481.000001 - 55421.000000
0.000001 - 22388.000000
0.00010000 - 0.02439
55421.000001 - 75495.000000
22388.000001 - 28223.000000
0.02440 - 0.03390
28223.000001 - 32569.000000
0.03391 - 0.04396
32569.000001 - 37664.000000
0.04397 - 0.05479
37664.000001 - 44481.000000
0.05480 - 0.06667
44481.000001 - 55421.000000
0.06668 - 0.08140
55421.000001 - 75495.000000
0.08141 - 0.1081
0
111276.000001 - 177866.000000
3.25
6.5
13 km
0.1082 - 0.1706
75495.000001 - 111276.000000 0
3.25
6.5
13 km
0
0.1707 - 0.2917
3.25
6.5
13 km
% Of People Unemployed
Average Dwelling Value
PROVOKING ACTION
111276.000001 - 177866.000000
75495.000001 - 111276.000000
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip 37664.000001 - 44481.000000
Income_Earnings_DA_CAN_Clip
Legend Highway Regional Roads AVERAGE_VA 0.000000 - 67245.000000 67245.000001 - 159113.000000
Legend
Highway
Highway
Regional Roads
159113.000001 - 190633.000000 190633.000001 - 221672.000000 221672.000001 - 253379.000000
Labour_Occupation_Education_ 253379.000001 - 290031.000000
Regional Roads
UNEMPLOYED / TOTAL_POPU
AVERAGE_VA
290031.000001 - 339689.000000
0.000000 - 67245.000000
0.000 - 0.007168
67245.000001 - 159113.000000
0.007169 - 0.01767
339689.000001 - 405735.000000
159113.000001 - 190633.000000
0.01768 - 0.02410
405735.000001 - 506974.000000
190633.000001 - 221672.000000
0.02411 - 0.03109
221672.000001 - 253379.000000
0.03110 - 0.03911
253379.000001 - 290031.000000
0.03912 - 0.04839
290031.000001 - 339689.000000
0.04840 - 0.06250
339689.000001 - 405735.000000
0.06251 - 0.08800
0
506974.000001 - 643375.000000
0.08801 - 0.1226
405735.000001 - 506974.000000 506974.000001 - 643375.000000
APPENDIX
Legend
0
3.25
6.5
13 km
0.1227 - 0.1712
0
3.25
6.5
13 km
3.25
6.5
13 km
the region, the lower the share There are many alternative ways to build this infras kforce in creativity-oriented occupabut we propose the province orient its infrastructure s k, globalization, and the nature around a simple goal â&#x20AC;&#x201C; to speed the movement of goo tion are changing the prosperity and ideas and reduce wasted time spent commuting. substantial resources and hard o longer enough. Creativity and are required moreConcentrations and more. Employment in Ontario Workers in creativity-oriented occupations are concentrated in a small number of Ontario regions as clustered industries draw more on creativity-oriented occupations. The Waterloo Region has a $30 billion tech industry and is home to over 150 research institutes that produce more than four times the national patents per million.
creativity-oriented occupations are concentrated in a small number city regions
E
Proportion of Ontarioâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s creativity-oriented occupations in city regions Proportion of Ontarioâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s creativity-oriented occupations in city regions
All others 27%
Toronto 47% Kitchener-Waterloo 4% London 4% Hamilton 5%
rosperity Institute analysis.
Ottawa 13%
Credit: Martin Prosperity Institute Ontario Report 2009 Source: Martin Prosperity Institute analysis.
www.martinpros
Exhibit 15
Clustered industries draw more on creativity-oriented occupations
Exhibit 8
Proportion of occupational groups across industry types, 2005 Ontario and 14 US peer states
Clustered industries draw more on creativity-oriented occupations
Exhibit 8
100% groups across industry 100%types, 2005 Proportion of occupational Ontario and 14 US peer states Proportion of occupational groups across industry types, 2005 25.0%
Routine-oriented
Ontario and 14 US peer states 48.2% 100%
100% Routine-physical Routine-service
31.6% 25.0% 19.5% 48.2%
Routine-oriented Creativity-oriented
URBAN IDENTITY
Routine-service
Routine-physical
22
31.6% 43.4%
32.3% 19.5% Dispersed industries Industry types
32.3%
Note: Full time and part time combined. Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from Canadian Census, 2006; Canadian Business Patterns, 2006; industries Dispersed industries American Community Survey, PUMS 2005; US County Business Patterns,Clustered 2005.
Industry types Note: Full time and part time combined. Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from Canadian Census, 2006; Canadian Business Patterns, 2006; American Community Survey, PUMS 2005; US County Business Patterns, 2005. Note: Full time and part time combined.
Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from Canadian Census, 2006; Canadian Business Patterns, 2006; American Community Survey, PUMS 2005; US County Business Patterns, 2005.
Exhibit 8higher earnings Creative clusters generate
Exhibit 9
Average employmentincome* income* (000 C$ 2005) Average employment (000 C$ 2005) Ontario and 14 US peer states Ontario and 14 US peer states
Exhibit 8higher earnings Creative clusters generate
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
Clustered industries 43.4%
Creativity-oriented
Exhibit 9
$87.4 PROVOKING ACTION
Average employment income* (000 C$ 2005) Ontario and 14 US peer states $68.2 $87.4 $38.7
$68.2 $28.7
$38.7
Routine-oriented occupations
Creativity-oriented occupations
Clustered industries
Routine-oriented occupations
Dispersed industries
* Weighted Average. Routine-oriented Creativity-oriented Routine-oriented Creativity-oriented Notes: Converted to 2005 Canadian dollars at purchasing power parity; Full time and part time combined. Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on data from Canadian Census, 2006; Canadianoccupations Business Patterns, 2006; occupations occupations occupations Statistics Canada, Table 380-0057; American Community Survey, PUMS 2005; County Business Patterns, 2005.
Clustered industries Dispersed industries * Weighted Average. Notes: Converted to 2005 Canadian dollars at purchasing power parity; Full time and part time combined. Credit: Martin Prosperity Institute Ontario Report 2009 * Weighted Average. Source: Martin Prosperity Institutetoand Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis oncombined. data from Canadian Census, 2006; Canadian Business Patterns, 2006; Notes: Converted 2005Institute Canadianfor dollars at purchasing power parity; Full time andbased part time Statistics Canada,Source: Table Martin 380-0057; American Survey, PUMS 2005; Countyanalysis Business Patterns, Prosperity Institute Community and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity based on data 2005. from Canadian Census, 2006; Canadian Business Patterns, 2006; www.martinprosperity.org | 17 Statistics Canada, Table 380-0057; American Community Survey, PUMS 2005; County Business Patterns, 2005.
www.martinprosperity.org | 17
APPENDIX
$28.7 Creativity-oriented occupations
Employment Skills Richard Florida identifies three broad skill sets that impact our economy. Our previous industrial economy developed from physical skills like lifting and manual dexterity. However in our emerging economy great importance lie in analytical and social intelligence skills. Analytical skills such as pattern recognition and problem solving and social intelligence skills for teamwork like situational sensitivity and persuasiveness are crucial to the knowledge-driven economy. Workers draw on three sets of skills Exhibit 5 Workers draw on three sets of skills Analytical Analytical skills skills Highest Highest
Biomedical engineer Biomedical Surgeon engineer Surgeon CEO CEO Dentist Dentist
General manager General manager Electrician Electrician Art director Art director Plumber Plumber
75th 75th Percentile Percentile
Drafter Drafter Accountant Accountant
Exhibit 5
Social Social intelligence intelligence skills skills Psychiatrist Psychiatrist CEO CEO Marketing manager Marketing manager Lawyer Lawyer
Physical Physical skills skills Oil and gas derrick operator Oil and gas derrick operator Firefighter Firefighter Electrician Electrician Mechanic Mechanic Roofer Roofer
Sports coach Sports coach
Film director Film director Sheet metal worker Sheet metal worker
Chef, head cook Chef, head cook Computer programmer Computer programmer Writer Writer Drafter Drafter Dental assistant Dental assistant
Median Median
Security guard Security guard Home health aide Home health aide
Nursing aide, orderly Nursing aide, orderly Fitness instructor Fitness instructor
Flight attendant Flight attendant Nurse Nurse
Massage therapist Massage therapist
Waiter Waiter
Telemarketer Telemarketer Travel agent Travel agent
Fashion designer Fashion designer
25th 25th Percentile Percentile Fashion model Fashion model Pharmacist Pharmacist
Cashier Cashier Waiter Waiter Retail salesperson Retail salesperson
Lowest Lowest
Retail salesperson Retail salesperson
Butcher and meat-cutter Butcher and meat-cutter
Waiter Waiter Telemarketer Telemarketer Fashion model Fashion model Pile-driver operator Pile-driver operator
Rental clerk Rental clerk Fashion model Fashion model
Lawyer Lawyer P.R. specialist P.R. specialist
Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on O*NET 12.0 database, skill and ability variables - developed for the U.S. Department of Labor. Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on O*NET 12.0 database, skill and ability variables - developed for the U.S. Department of Labor.
Credit: Martin Prosperity Institute Ontario Report 2009 Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on O*NET 12.0 database, skill and ability variables developed for the U.S. Department of Labour. www.martinprosperity.org | 13 www.martinprosperity.org | 13
Exhibit Exhibit 5 5
compared to its peer states – economies that from a job at the 2 5 th percentile of analytical content to one rese ble ntario s and are our ost signifithat is at the 75 th increases earnings in Ontario on average by cant trading partners. Ontario businesses do more than a third or $1 8,700. For social intelligence s ills, the ramp up is even higher – $2 5 ,1 00. not value increases in the two sets of creative But when and we take physical skills, the reverse is true. important skills nearly as much as our Ontario gets While analytical social intelligence skills pattern are generally components of peers. creative occupations, all W ages do not rise with an increase in physical skills; it’s just the a lower jump in earnings from increases in people and occupations use these skills. Earnings rise with increases in occupations’ analytical and social skills,
however this is not true with physical skills. Earnings rise with increases in occupations’ analytical and social intelligence skills but not with physical skills
24
relatively more for increased physical the creative content of its traditionally routine- oriented skills, which is a good thing for an industrial physical occupations in the automotive industry through tech90 economy, but does little to position us to age niq ues such as q uality circles, statistical training, and individual compete in the creative economy. worker authority to stop production if necessary to attack 80 This is a huge challenge for our province. q uality problems. Since Ontario employers, compared to their F our Seasons is one of the world’s leading luxury hotel chains. 70 Moving from 25th to 75thits percentile Movingvalue from 25th to 75th percentile US peers, physical skills relatively more Since modest beginnings as a Toronto- based motel in the increases earnings by $25,100 increases earnings by $18,700 than they value analytical and social intelli1 9 60s, the chain has grown to encompass eightyhotels Moving from 25th to two 75th percentile reduces earnings by $8,100 60 gence skills, workers in Ontario have a greater across thirty- four countries. Behind its many achievements lies incentive to develop physical skills. H owever, a management ethos committed to increasing the creativity 50 employment projections indicate that the content of hotel jobs that are traditionally more routineeconomy will demand more social intelligence oriented. W hile most hotel chains take a narrow view of manage40 and analytical skills and relatively fewer ment- employee relations – in which employees have little say in physical skills. This cycle drives our economy how the hotel is run and guest interactions are tightly regulated 30 to compete on yesterday’s skills and industries, – F our Seasons a different approach. There,75th employees Lowest 25th Median 75th Highest Lowest 25th Median 75thadopts Highest Lowest 25th Median Highest tuning our economy and our labour market in a are constantly solicited for feedback, and management Skill percentile way that will not achieve a distinctive advantage responsibility is distributed. The hotels have no customer service in the creative age. department, for instance; instead everyone – from dishwasher Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on Statistics Canada 2006 Census (full-time workers, excluding Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute & Prosperity analysis based on Statistics Canada 2006 Census for (full-time workers, self-employed); O*NET database, skillfor andCompetitiveness ability variables - developed for the U.S. of Labor. Building a12.0 distinctive advantage through to Department general manager – is responsible catering to excluding the guests’ self-employed); O*NET 12.0 database, skill and ability variables - developed for the U.S. Department of Labor. a creative economy req uires developing needs. By treating its employees with dignity and leveraging This illustration and simplifies the relationship skillworkers requirements and average earnings for thetalents, 728 occupations analysed –isit able showsto theoffer best-fit curve only. The valuing relevantbetween skills.the Our need their creative F our Seasons a regression level of hotel “goodness 4of fit”Exhibit as measured the r-squared for thethethree relationships 0.20earnings for thefor relationship betweenanalysed analytical skills the andbest-fit earnings, 0.41curve for social intelligence, and 6 simplifiesbythe relationship between skill requirements andare: average the 728 occupations – it shows regression only. The 0.07 for physical. Coefficients in measured each of the three relationships arerelationships statisticallyare: significant atrelationship the 1 percent level for social skills and 10 “goodness of fit” as by the r-squared for the three 0.20 for the between analytical skillsintelligence and earnings,and 0.41 physical for social intelligence, andpercent for physical. Coefficients each of theafter three controlling relationships are significant at the 1 percent level for social intelligence physical skills and 10 percent for and training. analytical skills. 0.07 The for relationships are still insignificant for statistically other factors that influence occupational earnings, e.g.,and education, experience required, analytical skills. The relationships still significantin after controlling forand other factors thatintelligence influence occupational earnings, e.g., education, experience required, and training. 7 Ontario under values are increases analytical social skills Exhibit
14 | Ontario in the Creative Age Impact on earnings as occupations move from 25th to 75th percentile in skill content
Ontario and 14 US peer states, Impact on earnings as occupations move from 25th to 2005 75th percentile in skill content Ontario and 14 US peer states, 2005
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
$100 pays
URBAN IDENTITY
the analytical and social intelligence skills necessary to command
more pronounced when it comes to social wages, and employers need more sophisticated business Average Skills’ impacthigher on earnings, Ontario employment intelligence skill: workers in peer states earn Skills’ impact models to warrant paying those wages. E mployers and workers on earnings, Ontario income considerably more than Ontario workers need to collaborate on redesigning jobs to enhance their creative (C$ 000), Analytical skills skills. Ontario Social intelligence Physical skills for2005 increased social intelligence content. The J skills apanese succeeded dramatically in enhancing
PROVOKING ACTION
analytical skills ( Exhibit 7). The pattern is even
Exhibit 6
$32,500
$24,800
$25,100
Ontario
14 US peers
Analytical skills
APPENDIX
$18,700
Physical skills
Social intelligence skills -$8,100 -$18,300
Converted to Canadian dollars at purchasing power parity. Note: ConvertedNote: to Canadian dollars at purchasing power parity. Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute Credit: Martin Prosperity Institute Ontario Report 2009 for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on Statistics Canada 2006 Census (full-time workers, excluding self-employed); Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics 2005 data; O*NET 12.0 database, skill and ability variables- developed for the US Department of Labor. Source: Martin Prosperity Institute and Institute for Competitiveness & Prosperity analysis based on Statistics Canada 2006 Census (full-time workers, excluding self-employed); Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics 2005 data; O*NET 12.0 database, skill and ability variables- developed for the US Department of Labor.
2.2
Existing Infrastructure
in路fra路struc路ture noun the underlying foundation or basic framework [Merriam Webster]
Fairway Road, Grand River Bridge
http://www.mrc.ca/mrc_projects/fairway-road-grand-river-bridge-kitchenerwaterloo-ontario/
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
26
Transit Infrastructure Regional Municipality of Waterloo
Legend Car Pool Parking Rapid Transit Station Railway
Legend
Bike Route
Raliway
RegionalCycling_Clip Regional Cycling Pedestrian Path
Rapid Transit Routes
Highway
Highway
GRT Bus Stop
Regional Roads
GRT Bus
GRT Bus Routes
Rapid TransitWaterloo Route Road
Region
Waterloo Region
0
3.25
6.5
13 km
Source: Based on data from Statistics Canada
Transit Infrastructure Cambridge
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
28
Source: Based on data from Statistics Canada
Natural Features
Located along the banks of the Historically Designated Grand River, Cambridge has a large park system and scenic riverside ambiance. Alongside the built infrastructure the natural features that exist in the city must be identified to capitalize and leverage these assets unique to the region.
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
30
â&#x20AC;&#x153;Every citizen has had long associations with some part of his city, and his image is soaked in memories and meanings.â&#x20AC;? Kevin Lynch
The Image of the City. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 1960, p.1
How can we examine urban space from our perception and subjective experiences? Traditional cartography is constrained and does not convey the ephemeral nature of psychogeographic space. Urban theorist Guy Debord and the Situationists produced mental maps based on behaviour and perception. Kevin Lynch examined the image of the city, organizing places according to a visualization of the environment and perceived movement distances. The following are experiments in the Cambridge downtown core to represent these phenomena using tools developed by the Aedas Computational Design + Research Group.
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
32
Spheres of Influence
UWSA, City Hall, & the BRIDGE Storefornt 50 metre radi drawn on a 15 metre vector grid
View Corridors
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
34
Pedestrian Connections Walking Distances to Art Centers from the BRIDGE Storefront
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
36
Pedestrian Connections Walking Distances to Historic Designated Buildings from the BRIDGE Storefront
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
38
2.3
Historic Assets
How can the city better leverage its neglected but architecturally significant buildings?
The Galt Wreck (1956) / The Pillar of Hope (today)
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
40
Construction of the High Level Bridge Galt Archives 19738126000 http://galtmuseum.blogspot.ca/2013_02_01_archive.html
While select buildings have been officially designated historical there are a large number of historically significant buildings in Cambridge that are not officially designated that define the urban character of Cambridge`s city core. These buildings need to be identified and defined as assets for future development and civic identity. Creating a municipal inventory to identify and evaluate the full range of cultural heritage resources in Cambridge so that these resources can be protected and enhanced was a key recommendation of the Cambridge Heritage Masterplan. One proposition was to link the inventory to the Cityâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s GIS mapping system so that links from the property address to a location map are made available and shared with the community. Developing a historical cartography of the city is one avenue for research on the city. My interest also lies in the stories of Cambridgeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s past that the buildings tell. The brick and stonework that comprise a large number of buildings in the city core give Galt a character and sense of place unique to the region. For this portion of the thesis I envision an experimentation through painting and creative writing to uncover the past and connect with the cultural history of the city that can help to shape its civic identity.
Historic Designated Buildings Regional Municipality of Waterloo
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
42
APPENDIX
Legend Regional Roads
Legend Regional Roads
Heritage Designation Highway
Heritage Designation 0
Highway
3.25
6.5
13 km
Source: Based on data from Statistics Canada
0
3.25
6.5
13
0
20
40
80 m
1:3,000
Historic Buildings Cambridge City Centre
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
44
Legend Religious Building Legal Service Financial Service Medical Professional Community Outreach Recreation Facilities Libraries University Arts
Resturant Shopping Community Centres Vacant
0
Abandoned Site
Legend Building River Land Parcel Heritage Character Heritage Designation Heritage Designated Area Cambridge City Core
Legend
20
40
Building
0
50
100
0
20
80 m
0
50
100
200 m
1:8,000
0
50
100
200 m
1:8,000
1:3,000
1:3,000
Building
Legend River Land Parcel Vacant Heritage Character Abandoned Site Heritage Designation Building Heritage Designated Area River Cambridge City Core Land Parcel
80 m
40
APPENDIX
Hair & Body
Legend
River
Vacant
Land Parcel
Abandoned Site
200 Heritage Character 1:8,000 m
Building
Heritage Designation
River
Heritage Designated Area
Land Parcel
Cambridge City Core
Cambridge City Core
Source: Based on data from the University of Waterloo Map Archive 0 50 100 200 Cambridge City Core m 1:8,000 *Buildings of Historic Character are defined as brick or stone buildings were built with quality in the past century
2.4
Existing Businesses
Cambridge Mill Wedding Collection
cambridgemill.ca/cambridge-mill-wedding-collection/files/assets/basic-html/page6.html
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
46
APPENDIX
There are a few business in Cambridge that capitalize on the cities unique character with The Mill Restaurant, depicted left, being an excellent example. Perched along the riverâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s edge the restaurant draws patrons from across the region and is a frequent wedding spot. In contrast to this the core is filled with a large number of less desirable business. It is a combination of massage parlours, money marts, pawn shops, dive bars and empty buildings that give the core itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s seedy reputation. Where the Galt core was once a desirable place to be it has been replaced by the suburban ideals of the big box strip malls that line Hespler, the major arterial road of the city. This chapter proposes to examine existing shopping habits and business in order to determine a proposed program that would add to the mix of commercial activity.
0
20
0
50
40
100
80 m
200 m
1:3,000
1:8,000
Existing Places Cambridge City Centre The quality of life in the community was seen to increase the attractiveness of a job by 33%. -KPMG Report
Legend Legend
Religious Building Legal Service
Religious Building
Financial Service
Legal Service
Medical Professional
Financial Service
Community Outreach
Medical Professional
Recreation Facilities
Community Outreach
Libraries
Recreation Facilities
University
Libraries
Arts
University
Hair & Body
Arts
Resturant
Hair & Body
Shopping
Resturant
Community Centres
Shopping Community Centres Vacant Abandoned Site
Vacant Abandoned Site Building Legend
Building
River Building Land Parcel
River
River Character Heritage
Land Parcel
Land Parcel Heritage Designation Heritage Character Heritage Designated Area Heritage Designation Cambridge City Core Heritage Designated Area
Heritage Character Heritage Designation Heritage Designated Area Cambridge City Core
Cambridge City Core
Legend Building
0
20
Abandoned Site Heritage Designation
80 m
0
20
80 m
0
50
100
200 m
1:8,000
0
50
100
200 m
1:8,000
1:3,000
1:3,000
Legend
River Legend Land Parcel Vacant Heritage Character
40
40
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
48
Vacant Abandoned Site 0
50
Building 200m
100
1:8,000
River
Building Heritage Designated Area
Land Parcel
River Cambridge City Core
Cambridge City Core
Land Parcel 100 200 Cambridge City Core Source: Based 0on 50data m 1:8,000 from the City of Cambridge and Google Maps
Key Players
Province of Ontario
City of Cambridge
Toyota
University of Waterloo
Cambridge Libraries and Galleries
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
Regional Municipality of Waterloo
URBAN IDENTITY
50
PROVOKING ACTION
Perimeter Development Corporation
APPENDIX
University of Waterloo School of Architecture
3.0
PROVOKING ACTION
Hap•pen
intransitive verb
You’re missing the point. We don’t arrange things in an order (that’s the function of the utilities). Quite simply, we are facilitating the process so that anything may happen. Rem Koolhaus [SMLXL p. 671, 716]
3.1
Opportunity in Absence
Ab·sence
noun
The most beautiful is not to be present. Absence is the highest form of presence. Rem Koolhaus
[SMLXL p. xviii and p.130]
the nonexistence or lack of [Oxford English Dictionary]
a state or condition in which something expected, wanted, or looked for is not present or does not exist [Merriam Webster]
Op·por·tu·ni·ty
noun
a set of circumstances that makes it possible to do something [Oxford English Dictionary]
URBAN IDENTITY CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
Urban sprawl has created a void where the heart of Cambridge once stood. The absence of activity and occupancy on Main Street provides the opportunity for real change. The vacant spaces are a blank canvas in which Cambridge can re-invent itself, redefined through development. David Gibson of Perimeter Developments seized this opportunity by purchasing a large number of buildings on Main Street and convinced the city to renovate the streetscape in return for his investment in the abandoned core. However for reasons currently unknown his buildings remain vacant. It was in the summer of 2012 that my graduating class rented one of these spaces to host our Rome Show and exhibit work from the previous term’s studio in Rome. This event, in combination with the students pecha kucha evening at the neighbouring, newly renovated, Mexican restaurant, captured Mr. Gibson’s attention. He proposed that the students at the school of architecture occupy one of his spaces for a mixed use space to promote our work. This has been a dream currently unrealized that I wish to pursue in the promotion of architecture, design and the profile of Waterloo School of Architecture.
PROVOKING ACTION
Bishop, P. and Williams, L., 2012. The Temporary City
54
APPENDIX
“In an era of increasing pressure on scarce resources, we cannot wait for long-term solutions for vacancy or dereliction. Instead, we need to view temporary uses as increasingly legitimate and important in their own right. They can be a powerful tool through which we can dripfeed initiatives for incremental change — as and when we have the resources — while being guided by a loose-fit vision.”
0
20
40
80 m
1:3,000
Visibly Vacant Buildings Cambridge City Centre
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
56
Legend Religious Building Legal Service Financial Service Medical Professional Community Outreach Recreation Facilities Libraries University
Hair & Body Resturant Shopping Community Centres 0
20
40
Vacant
80 m
Vacant
0
50
Abandoned Site
Legend Building
River
River
Vacant
200 Land Parcel m
Land Parcel
Abandoned Site
1:8,000
Heritage Character
Heritage Character
Building
Building
Heritage Designation
Heritage Designation
River
River
Heritage Designated Area
Heritage Designated Area
Land Parcel
Land Parcel
Cambridge City Core
Cambridge City Core
Cambridge City Core
Cambridge City Core
0
50
100
200 m
20
80 m
0
50
100
200 m
1:8,000
0
50
100
200 m
1:8,000
1:3,000
Legend
Building
100
0
1:3,000
Abandoned Site
Legend
40
APPENDIX
Arts
1:8,000
Source: Primary Visual Analysis
BRIDGE
OON STORE S G IN M O CFRONT
WATERLOO ARCHITECTURE
Executive Directors
Zak Fish Michael Kim Vikkie Chen
Bridge
Graduate Advisors
Faculty Program Advisor
Andrea Hunniford . Connor â&#x20AC;&#x2122; rady Kam Tam
Dr. Mona El Khafif
Community Advisor
Faculty Admin Advisor
noun
a time, place, or means of connection or transition [Merriam Webster]
Without failing, no bridge, once spanned, can cease to be a bridge. Rem Koolhaus
Eric Haldenby
[SMLXL p. 72] Building Admin Directors
Communication Directors
Program Director
Executive Directors
Zak Fish Michael Kim Vikkie Chen
Graduate Advisors
Faculty Program Advisor
Andrea Hunniford . Connor â&#x20AC;&#x2122; rady Kam Tam
Dr. Mona El Khafif
Community Advisor
Faculty Admin Advisor Levels of Responsibility
Eric Haldenby
Executive Directors
Directors Building Admin Directors Managers
Communication Directors
Program Director
Levels of Responsibility
Coordinators
Curation Legend
Primary Comittie Member Comittie Member Advisor
URBAN IDENTITY CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
The BRIDGE Storefront is our physical presence in the heart of the community that reaches beyond the limitations of our academic institution. As an experimental lab for ideas and exhibition the storefront is our opportunity to create a hub for student activity. As a multipurpose space for various events and initiatives the project aims to activate downtown Cambridge in the process of revitalizing the once prosperous region of Galt. It is a space for informal gatherings and curated exhibitions. It is a salon for social interaction and intellectual discussion; a space to present, to relax, to coalesce and connect. The physical presence provides the space to promote a discourse that engages community values through the lens of design. In the act of occupying a previously vacant space, we have the opportunity to fill the absence with a dialogue that can provoke and inform the community of its creative potential.
PROVOKING ACTION
The BRIDGE website is digital platform that spans the divide created by the multiple stream co-op program and the physical distance from main campus connecting the students with each other and projects our presence beyond our physical bounds. As a open and accessible platform the digital space aggregates events and announcements to define a network that strengthens the ties of the student body and community encouraging participation, engagement and action. As a showcase for student work the website is a space for digital publication that gives our community a voice to project our values of design excellence and collaboration.
58
APPENDIX
BRIDGE Waterloo Architecture is a student initiative that strives to connect the students at the University of Waterloo School of Architecture with the City of Cambridge, the University of Waterloo itself and the design community. It is a manifestation of collaborative work in the promotion of architecture and design and embodies the zeitgeist of our collective conscience.
3.2
Designing a Framework Ar·ma·ture noun the arrangement of parts that gives something its basic form [Merriam-Webster]
“At at time when the dynacism of images and information dominates everyday life, the traditional association of architecture with permanence and durability has become suspect.“ [Stan Allen]
Design for Design
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL PROVOKING ACTION APPENDIX
In this chapter I would look at defining a permanent BRIDGE Storefront infrastructure from which many activities and design opportunities could exist. This section would investigate program and precedents for design. While a permanent gallery structure may not be built in my time at school it represents a goal to work towards and would provide a base for sponsorship and grant applications. While I would provide the design I would meet with BRIDGE members for critiques as a part of the design review process to allow input from the student population.
URBAN IDENTITY
60
Thesis Machine
a desigend infrastructure to support
frameâ&#x20AC;˘work
instigated production + curated social engagement
REVIEW + FEEDBACK SURFACE DESIGN 4 DESIGN
REPETITION
ORGANIZATION
SERVICE provision of services to provide future program
REP ETIT
R C
STRUCTURE ION
Y R
I O ST EO Y R
TH O
IV IC C N TE
SPACE / FRAME SOURCE
X T CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
ANIZ
ATIO N URBAN IDENTITY
MACHINE
ANTICIPATION
INSTIGATING PROVOKING ACTION
N
BA
ITY IDE EN NT GA GE ITY ME NT
APPENDIX
www.bridge
U
UN
CHANGE
CE FA
H
EA TE PROVOKE DISCOURSE
ORG
ANTICIPATION
MM
MINIMAL FUNDING
CO
MULTI-FUNCTIONAL
R SU
TEMPORARY
E TUR UC STR
VACANT SPACE
CR
62
OUTPUT
Precedent: Storefront for Art and Architecture
Wikipedia - Artandarch
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
Vitto Acconci, Stephen Holl 64
Ingredients of Reality: the Dismantling of NYC
007 Urban Songline
Lake Joseph Boathouse
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
INDOOR
INDOOR
PHYSICAL
PHYSICAL
O
Wikipedia - Artandarch
INTERACTIVE SPECTORAL INSTALLATION ART
ART
P Performance S Symposium
BEFORE THY WERE ALL FAMOUS CAPITAL CITY CAPITAL C TOWARD A NEW COSMOPOLITANISM SECRET SOUNDS OF THE CITY
INTERROGATING GREEN
P
FEB
TOWARDS A THEORY OF MISBEHAVIOR
JAN 2012
SYMPOSIUM ON PUBLISHING PRACTICES
007 URBAN SONGLINE PERFORNAMCE
SB
A Art Event
DOUBLE DAVID
SMALL SCALE BIG CHANGE INSIDE PRE-FAB
B Book Launch
S
S
S
P A S B P
P
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
N
D
Archizines + Arch-Art! Books
David (Inspired by Michelangelo)
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
J
F
M
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
URBAN IDENTITY
66
PHYSICAL
SPECTORAL
SPECTORAL
ART
ART
B
P
NOV
PROJECT
OCT
CRITICAL HALLOWEEN 2012
S
SEP
SOCIALIST ARCHITECTURE
P
AUG
THE AFTER-MATCH
JUL
PERFORMING REPRESENTATIONS
To make an architecture exhibition means (...) to work with waste and out of this waste to try to create a new reality that is self-sufficient and in respect to its expression autonomous. [Rémy Zaugg]
B
DEC
PROVOKING ACTION
PHYSICAL
APPENDIX
INDOOR
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
OUTDOOR
AESTHETICS/ANESTHETICS
The Post-Olympic City
Lake Joseph Boathouse
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
OUTDOOR INDOOR
INDOOR DIGITAL
Wikipedia - Artandarch
PHYSICAL
PHYSICAL
SPECTORAL
SPECTORAL
INTERACTIVE
ART
ARCHITECTURE & URBANISM
O
N
D
Past Futures, Present, Futures
In the Dark
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
INDOOR
INDOOR
PHYSICAL
PHYSICAL
DIGITAL
INTERACTIVE
INTERACTIVE SPECTORAL
ARCHITECTURE & URBANISM
SPECTORAL ARCHITECTURE & URBANISM
O
N
D
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
M
PROVOKING ACTION
F
APPENDIX
J
URBAN IDENTITY
68
CLOSED â&#x20AC;&#x153;If one thinks of architecture as the result of different thought and decisionmaking processes, then a gallery for architecture becomes a space for reflection and communication about the conditions of the genesis and the 0% 0 forms of perception of 0% 0ideas.â&#x20AC;&#x153; architectonic
2 77m 2
77m % LEGEND 0
[Steven Holl]
%
9
Street Front Exhibition Space
m
0% 77m2
12% 86m2
4%
MIN
0 0
2 77m 77m2
MAX
60% 60%
9 9
160m 160m
2 2
80m2
2 1%
79m2
78m2
78m2
10% 2
12! = 479, 001 600
2 4% 4%
81m22 81m
0 10% 10%
85m22 85m
2 3% 3%
79m22 79m
0 4% 4%
78m
2
4%
0 1%
76.6m2
86m 86m
2 2
2 1%
80m2
1%
2 12% 12%
85m
78m2
80m
77m22 77m
2
0 4%
2
1 0% 0%
0 10%
1%
80m22 80m
1
2 2 10%
2
85m2 1 1
2%
79m2 2 2
1%
2
0
078m2 0
10%
2
1 2 185m
0
0 2% 2%
2 4% 2
0
79m22 79m
80m2
1% 1%
0 0 1%
85m22 85m
76.6m
0 4% 0 80m2
1%
0 10% 10%
2
0
0
79m2
2 2%
2%
3%
0
85m2
79m2
2
85m2
1 10%
85m2
1%
10%
2
2 3%
79m2
1
81m2
85m2
0 4%
85m
Assuming each of the panels can either be open or closed there are 12 factorial ways to arrange 12 the distinct panels.
1 10%
3%
10%
1
81m2
79m2
4%
4%
2 4%
2
86m2
2
86m2
85m2
80m2
0% 0%
12%
0 12%
0
77m2
0
77m2
10%
2 2 160m of Entry Points 160mNo.
2
0%
81m2
60%% Open 60% 9 9
2
0%
78m 78m
2 2
10% 10%
2 2 78m2
76.6m2 2 2
0
Half of All Vertical Surfaces
Half of All Horizontal Surfaces
HALF of ALL VERTICAL SURFACES
HALF of ALL HORIZONTAL SURFACES
5
5
7
5
5
7
5
5
5
5
116m2
2
10%
0
10%
0
10%
0
10%
0
85m2
5
10%
0
85m2
119m2
35%
20%
85m2
116m2
38%
1
85m2
115m2
35%
10%
85m2
116m2
34%
0
93m2
117m2
35%
10%
85m2
123m2
36%
2
85m2
119m2
44%
20% 93m2
118m2
38%
0
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
Wikipedia - Artandarch
12% 87m2
123m2
37%
2 URBAN IDENTITY
5
119m2
44%
22% 93m2
115m2
38%
70
PROVOKING ACTION
34%
0
85m2
115m2
Lake Joseph Boathouse
10%
5
11% 86m2
0
APPENDIX
34%
All Vertical Surfaces
All Horizontal Surfaces
HALF of ALL VERTICAL SURFACES
HALF of ALL HORIZONTAL SURFACES
34%
5
5
5
7
123m2
37%
5
5
7
5
5
5
5
116m2
1
20%
2
10%
0
10%
0
10%
0
10%
0
85m2
5
10%
0
85m2
119m2
35%
10%
85m2
116m2
38%
0
85m2
115m2
35%
10%
85m2
116m2
34%
2
93m2
117m2
35%
20%
85m2
123m2
36%
0
85m2
119m2
44%
12%
93m2
118m2
38%
2
87m2
119m2
44%
22% 93m2
115m2
38%
0
85m2
115m2
34%
10%
5
11% 86m2
0
This facade is not a cover, not a surface – it’s a space-maker; its an instrument between the inside and the outside. [Stephen Holl]
1
72
3
URBAN IDENTITY
2
2. Bookstore: 5.9m2
3. Bathroom: 2.7m2
Fixed Display Space
Operable Display Space
Space DisplayFixed: Operable Display Space Display Space: Fixed Display Space Fixed Display Operable Space
115.5m2
46.6m2 29%
West Wall: 3.5m2 Back Wall: 71.6m2 East Wall: 10.5m2 Pannel Wall: 76.5m2 Flexible Pannels: 46.6m2
71%
162.1m2
Flexible
APPENDIX
Operable Display Space
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
1. Gallery: 80.6m2
Precedent: PS1 MOMA - Young Architects Program HWKN Wendy 2012
Interboro Partners Holding Pattern 2011
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
74
PROVOKING ACTION
“A diagram is therefore not a thing in itself but a description of potential relationships among elements, not only an abstract model of the way things behave in the world but a map of possible worlds.“ [Stan Allen]
APPENDIX
SO-IL Pole Dance 2010
Program - Winter Term Deployment WORK An exhibition of student work in Cambridge
Wikipedia - Artandarch
THESIS TALKS Presentations of Graduate Student work
UNCOVERED LECTURE SERIES A lunch time lecture series, featuring talks by faculty and students, about projects pursued beyond their academic focus.
ARCHITECTURE + FILM A weekly film screening and discussion of architectureâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s relation to the film industry
Program - Long Term Deployment
76
LECTURE URBAN IDENTITY
- Seating - Podium - Screen -Projector
- Coffee Carafe - Coffee Maker - Espresso Pot
STOREFRONT SALES
$
- Display Case - Cash Box - P.O.S.
- Books - Jewlery
WORKSHOP -
Tables Chairs Power Bars Maker Bot (Idea Exchange)
EXHIBITIIONS - Physical & Digital - Panels - Models - Installations
- Projecton - Screen - Sound
PROVOKING ACTION
No Pluming Cooler Beer Boxes Water Tank
APPENDIX
-
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
CAFE BAR
Gallery Infrastructure - Initial Study
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
78
3.3
Instigations through Intervention
Instigate to bring (something volatile or intense) into being [Merriam-Webster]
“To cause a public memory of a place that will again metamorphose and acquire still new and different meanings in the continually transforming urban landscape.”[1] Eds. Pars, Hieke & Schutten, Iris. Interfering: A Publication About Contextual Interventions in Public Space. p 10.
...our discipline’s most enduring moments are its least permanent Rafkin, J., Preface in Lahman, S., Absolutely Public , Images Publishing Group,2006
PROVOKING ACTION APPENDIX
To fill the void in Cambridge a series of temporary installations will be developed to provoke the public and create a discourse on the issues facing the city and to raise awareness about the BRIDGE initiative. The intension is that these would be design build projects to gauge public reaction and to learn from the process of building and through experimentation with materials.
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
80
STAIR CHAIR Rise Run Sit
Rem Koolhaus [SMLXL p.76]
Reclaimed materials have emerged as an affordable resource from which to experiment and construct initial prototypes. The Stair Chair (depicted left) was constructed from stair treads and risers from the local Habitat for Humanity ReStore. These recycled materials have a character not unlike Cambridge. Beaten and worn each piece has its own history, peeling back the layers of led paint on these solid red oak boards reveal moments of a previous time. These materials also provide constraints that set a framework to build within. Damaged and full of nails they present a difficulty to safely machine. However the consistent dimensions of the dismantled stair created a simple modular framework that only required two machined cuts to create the desired form. Reinforced in two planes it has the ability to hold multiple functions as a chair, table, bench, bar or display podium. Left unattended in the school loft it has already been apprehended to display models, hold materials and as a projector stand for the Winter Graduate Soir茅e. While working with reclaimed materials present challenges and dictate design though their unique defects they also present an opportunity to connect with the material and its embedded history.
URBAN IDENTITY CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
1. To take salvageable parts from (as a disabled machine) for use in building or repairing another machine. 2. To deprive of an essential part or element in creating or sustaining another facility or enterprise... 3. To use or draw on material of (as another writer or an earlier work)[a volume... that not only ~s previous publications but is intended itself to be cannibalized - R.M. Adams]. 4. To make use of (a part taken from one thing) in building or repairing something else.
82
PROVOKING ACTION
verb
APPENDIX
Can路ni路bal路ize
Tadashi Kawamata, Garden Tower http://mcfcrandall.wordpress.com/tag/chairs/
Vincent Skoglund, Waste Management Series www.vincentskoglund.com/the-waste-management-series/
Arne Quinze, The Sequence, 2008
vyick.wordpress.com/2012/04/03/nothing-bitter-sprouting-here/
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
Habitat for Humanity ReStore - Stairs
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
84
Habitat for Humanity ReStore - Doors
TEMPORARY INFRASTRUCTURE DISPLAY SPACE
DISPLAY SPACE
SERVICE BAR / WORKBENCH
86
Continuing from previous experiments with reclaimed materials this temporary prototype infrastructure proposes to use recycled doors from the Habitat for Humanity ReStore. While doors are constructed in a variety of sizes many are built to standard dimensions that provide a modular framework to work with. The doors themselves have a history and connection Cambridge from where they were reclaimed and also serve a metaphor for opening a temporary Storefront space to the public. Assembled in multiple orientations they can be used to form benches, tables, podiums, and display panels. Many of the doors also come with hardware which enables them to be easily hinged together allowing for movable pieces to create a transformable space.
PROVOKING ACTION
LECTURE / ASSEMBLY SPACE
APPENDIX
SERVICE BAR / WORKBENCH
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
LECTURE / ASSEMBLY SPACE
UNSILENT NIGHT
88
PROVOKING ACTION
Unsilent Night is Cambridgeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s winter music and lights event that has occurred yearly since the inauguration in 2008. Invited to participate my desire was to use this event to raise awareness for the BRIDGE initiative and to create an installation that could be re-purposed afterwards for a temporary gallery infrastructure. While Unsilent night is one example there are multiple civic events where the lessons learned here can be applied for future engagement.
This installation was envisioned as a promotional piece to raise awareness for the BRIDGE Storefront initiative and to collect and experiment with materials that could be used for a temporary gallery infrastructure. This project evolved from multiple constraints due to the availability of space and volunteers for assembly. Selecting reclaimed doors from the Habitat for Humanity ReStore capitalized on a readily available and affordable material. In addition to being large and capable of supporting a fair amount of weight the doors come in a relatively standard size that allow for simple aggregation without the need for machining on the inaccessible workshop tools. More importantly the doors carry a certain connotation as a recognizable element that have the history of the city embedded in them, donated to the restore from homes across the region. Assembling the doors out of place in an unconventional manor creates a memorable and contrasting effect. Painted using the bright colours from the BRIDGE website provocative messages stencilled on to the doors stand out; illuminated in the winter night and instigating a discourse with the citizens passing by.
Project Team Volunteers: Sarah Gunawan Michael Kim Vikkie Chen Dan Blachinsky Claire Lubell Andrea Hunniford Connor Oâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Grady Mark Tam Mark Zupan
PROVOKING ACTION
90
Habitat for Humanity ReStore - Cambridge
92
PROVOKING ACTION
Workshop Assembly
PROVOKING ACTION
94
PROVOKING ACTION
96
Online Opportunity In addition to the physical space which I investigated for the BRIDGE Storefront, BRIDGE currently exists as a digital platform. There is a desire to restructure the website in the coming year and this presents the opportunity for my investigations to have a digital presence that can extend beyond current physical limitations. Although I do not know how I would capitalize on this initiative it is an opportunity worthy of investigation.
APPENDIX
PROVOKING ACTION
CAMBRIDGE: CREATIVE POTENTIAL
URBAN IDENTITY
98
[so far]
so far
phrase of far
to a certain limited extent (of a trend that seems likely to continue) up to this time [Google Dictionary]
source material method
[ [ [
water rushes by the mill ice forms beneath the bridge local limestone chiseled by masons brick work beaten through the passage of time strokes of paint stain a canvas grain exposed by the tables blade perforations frame a negative sketches fill the page
a lens to explore the city impressions etched in our mind
technique
[ [ [
Conceptual Outline
RePost Tri-City Exhibition
Networked Cities Elective Urban Theory 1.0 - 2.0
M3
M2
Sketching Elective
Exploration
URBAN THEORY
Provocations 3.0
This thesis is constructed at the intersection of built form and urban theory. Through multiple built experiments that examine tactile and spatial constructs the projects are simultaneously informed by their urban context and aim to provoke a discourse on our evolving society.
SOCIOECONOMICS
REVITILIZATION GALLERY TYPOLOGY
BUILT FORM
CITY BRANDING ART
FURNITURE
UnSilent Night
Writing
M4
M5
Design Build
Snowflakes fall from midnight skies. Our paths traced on the snow covered streets. A sleeping city waits in the darkness of night. There is beauty in the absence; not for what was, or what is, but for what is yet to come.