State of the Art Project by Zena Verda pesta

State of the Art Project Transforming Local Businesses into Learning Laboratories

Z.V.P.

Byâ&#x20AC;&#x201D; Zena Verda Pesta

Z.V.P.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

School of Visual Arts MFA Products of Design 2014

State of the Art Project

ÂŠ 2014 Zena Verda Pesta

Z.V.P.

Claire Hartten Thesis Advisor Carol Archer Editor Allan Chochinov Chair, MFA Products of Design

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

â&#x20AC;&#x153;The most important attitude that can be formed is that of the desire to go on learning.â&#x20AC;? x John Dewey

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

State of the Art Project

Fig. 1 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Lollard Adventure Play Ground 1946, London movement inspired by Empdrup waste material playground during the German occupation.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Say “Yes, and...” I invite you to keep the above sentiment in mind while beginning you journey through the following pages. Together we are embarking on a partnership that will be most effective if we agree to stay flexible, and open to leaping between ideas. Building on the story rather than blocking it is a common theme with improvisational acting. One can use this idea in other practices to develop imagination and creativity, yielding unintended and positive returns. On the previous page is an image of a children’s adventure playground outside of Copenhagen during the German occupation. At first glance it seems these kids are abandoned and wild, but on the contrary, they are playing in a well- balanced design for discovery. During their time spent in these environments, kids were able to learn freely about building, boundaries, and social order. This image illustrates a freedom to learn and the designers’ understanding that this freedom is available to all contributors and participants. When we engage in the act of physically “making” with others, we are learning through many non-verbal cues, and creating a better understanding of how the social space functions around us. When this “making” together includes elements of play, possibilities open up and reveal more flexible ways to engage, benefiting each participant involved. The adventure playgrounds acknowledge fundamental attributes, such as flexibility and curiosity, which allow us to experiment and grow. If we nurture these psychological neotenous behaviors well beyond kid years, we can promote and sustain a very important part of our social behavior: cooperation.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

â&#x20AC;&#x153;bodily gestures take the place of words in establishing authority, trust, and cooperation. physical gesture makes social relationships feel informal. visceral feelings are also aroused when we gesture, informally with words.â&#x20AC;? x Richard Sennett

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Preface I grew up with a crafter mom. She made golden pine-cone wreaths for my teachers, and labored for thirteen years sewing, gluing and tacking baton outfits for me. The arts were never defined for me as a youngster, but were obviously present. I got my first job when I was fifteen, and there I learned the proper way to sweep, mop, ring a till, and roll napkins. Since then I have clearly understood my role as a worker in each job I have held. I learned to communicate with the hand as a tool, helped by the patience and guidance of mentors who have been dedicated to their craft and to passing it on. We preserve history, practice and tradition through our children and students. I would not be writing this thesis book, which argues the importance of alternative learning paths and promotes the promise in reviving apprenticeship models, if it werenâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t for the countless adults and children who have nurtured my practice. Before going to graduate school, I spent ten years learning, practicing and teaching the craft, chemistry, and engineering of ceramics. There is something extremely powerful about feeling an intuitive motion that allows one to grasp strengths and weaknesses, while adapting to the surrounding environment. To have connection to process is to more fully engage with humanity, to see ourselves as part of a larger process, and consider others in that larger context. It has been with much pleasure that I have seen myself and students of all ages struggle and grow. When conceptualizing a thesis, I knew I needed my peers, my instructors, my friends, my family to trust me. To trust my instincts. The instincts that so many years of support had given me. My work evolved to include not only making, but advocating and creating space for those who need the process of making to learn. This was bringing me closer to my roots and I was stepping closer to an interaction with the physical material and the human relationships. In my graduate studies I looked for moments of trust, mentorship, and learning by doing. State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Preface These moments support the play required to learn. Products of Design allowed work with many people, brought a wealth of frameworks and models to our fingertips, and opened the door to many savvy communities. The research, theory, and experimentation stimulated my mind to be expansive and encouraged my views to practicing design ethically. This thesis embodies not only two years of discovery through methods learned in design thinking, anthropology, and sociology; but a lifelong urge to understand the world around me through a physical process. It all comes back to what inspired me to learn in the first place, and how the first people who mentored and shared their practice with me showed enthusiasm. I believe that there are many others who need this too. The past two years have allowed me to reflect on a larger lifeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s work of keeping making-based processes a part of our daily lives: opening up opportunities so we as individuals and communities can continue to understand ourselves in an ever-changing climate of technology and the evolving relationship we have to our labor.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Contents Body p.27 — Introduction

History, Theory, Influence The Process The Thesis

p.51 — Mission & Goals Universals of Culture

Social Allocation SPR Beam Camp Character Traits and Virtues

p.21 — Methodology An Active dynamic practices

Project based anthropological ethics Positive Psychology Diffusion of Innovation

p.199— Research Books

Interviews Inspirational Organizations

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

p.243— State of the Art Project The Issue

The Research The Opportunities The Intervention

Supplement p.314— Acknowledgments p.317— Bibliography

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Introduction

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Introduction

Fig. 2 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; At Beam Camp in Strafford, New Hampshire. Allowing Elis the freedom to give a clay mask. Photo courtesy of David Golann

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

History, Theory, Influence Institutionalized education in the United States is a system based on the manufacturing model of the early industrial revolution. Its purpose was to educate the masses outside of the home, it also helped promote laws concerning child labor and immigration rights. Throughout its history, the school system has reflected government, economy, and industry in our country. It has been interwoven with market and value. Alongside the shifting changes there have been theorists, psychologists, and reformers whose writings informed this thesis.

career. Most of Dewey’s work focused on learning as a social and interactive process. In My Pedagogic Creed, Dewey expresses his belief that “the teacher is not in the school to impose certain ideas or to form certain habits in the child, but is there as a member of the community to select the influence which shall affect the child and to assist him properly spreading to these influences.”74 Dewey, along with others during his time, believed that education was a holistic practice and that schools could also be places where one learns how to live. He spoke about the importance of continuing to learn no matter your age and expressed wonderful sentiments about the mutual benefits of a partnership in a learning experience. Art as Experience, one of his most celebrated texts, presents a concise analysis of “traditional” and “progressive" education. He speaks of a “reciprocal give and take, the teacher taking but not being afraid also to give”.75 Dewey’s texts are considered to be part of a foundation on which the next one-hundred years of educational reform theories were built.

Carolyn Pratt (1867-1954) is best known John Dewey (1859-1952) promoted educational reform throughout his long State of the Art Project

074 Dewey, John. “My Pedagogic Creed.” The School Journal, Volume LIV, Number 3 (January 16, 1897), pages 77-80. 075 Dewey, John. Art as Experience. New York: Minton, Balch, 1934. 72. Print.

as the inventor of unit blocks and the founder of the City and Country School of New York City in 1914. She is a notable social thinker and educational reformer, who practiced her theories of free play. In her autobiography, I Learn From Children, she states, “My own education was given to me, not in teacher-training courses, not by professors of pedagogy, but by children themselves.”76 Pratt showed an unwavering trust in children to learn from the building of community through play. She was known for her push against structured norms and blueprints inside and out of schools and expressed such sentiments as “Once you set down a formula, you are imprisoned by it”.77 Pratt also believed play to be a democratic lesson. At the City and Country school the children had to be actively engaged in an activity of their choice and play was seen as real work. This model allowed for no set curriculum. The school also incorporated real world experience and application; students would be taken on field trips and held accountable for their findings by being asked to recreate their experience. Pratt's philosophy allows that each experience a child has provides preparation for another, and each concept that is developed opens the door to another. Pratt and her followers believed in empowering children to see themselves as active agents in shaping their social world. “We are not willing to have children dominated by subject matter. We want them to form strong habits of first hand research and to 076 Pratt, Caroline. I Learn from Children: An Adventure in Progressive Education. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1948. 10. Print. 077 Pratt, Caroline. I Learn from Children: An Adventure in Progressive Education. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1948. 58. Print.

Z.V.P.

use what they find; we want them to discover relationships in concrete matter, so that they will know they exist when they deal with abstract forms, and will have habits of putting them to use. ”78

Charles B.J. Snyder (1860-1945) was an architect and engineer who transformed the design and construction of school buildings while Superintendent of School Buildings for the New York City Board of Education from 1891-1923. Snyder considered schools to be “civic monuments” for a better society. He was often quoted as calling them “palaces for the people.” He designed schools to be welcoming to the surrounding community. There were many windows and courtyards allowing fresh air; Snyder was concerned with the health and safety of all of the people engaged in his spaces. The schools acted as community centers with an auditorium open to the public . Snyder promoted vocational schools for workers which included gymnasiums, carpentry workshops, and sewing and cooking rooms. During a time when New York City industry was growing, Snyder created safe community spaces. 05 Pratt, Caroline. "Progressive Education and the Science of Education."Progressive Education(1927): 93.

Marjory Allen, Lady Allen of Hurtwood (1897-1976) was a landscape architect and promoter of child welfare in England. Her work ranged from creating play spaces for children with disabilities to campaigning for children in institutional care, which led to passing of the Children Act of 1948. She was passionate about open-air constructive play through the use of ordinary building materials such as wood and bricks. Also important, was the element of danger. This was added by the use of building fires and creating large structures. Lady Allen was directly influenced by a trip to Copenhagen when she discovered Carl Theodore Soresensons Adventure Playgrounds. These were designed and tested during the german occupation.79 After her visit development of Adventure Playgrounds across London spread. She opened up roughly twenty around London for disabled children. Lady Allen used these playgrounds to show the competency, readiness and ableness of these children. “All our experience goes to show that a child that is unhappy… is not able to learn, is not able to benefit from the experience around him, 079 Kozlovsky,, Roy. The Junk Playground: Creative Destruction as Antidote to Delinquency. Proc. of Threat and Youth Conference, Teachers College, New York, New York. N.p.: n.p., n.d. Print. Princeton University School of Architecture

State of the Art Project

and the majority of these children are not only unhappy because of the situation in which they live, but they are tremendously frustrated, because people feel that they are not able to cope with these problems with which they have got to be faced in later life.”80 She believed that adventure play gave children appetites for autonomy and self-teaching moments. Using dangerous tools, children could create their own houses, their own climbing frames, could take risks and overcome them. All of this could be done with the lightest supervision of adults and a free and permissive atmosphere. Along with many theorists who respected children as people, Lady Allen knew that children have the power to unlock lessons and teach themselves, and she rejected putting parameters on what they can achieve. “At every point these children need some kind of challenge which sets them going. We want them also to be as free as possible from adult supervision. Because I think, and I think other people think with me, that many of these children are needlessly overprotected by adults, and never given any freedom to explore and experiment, and find out what the world is all about.”81“If they are so overprotected that they are never able to meet these challenges and able to take these risks, I think they will be the poorer for it when they grow up. When they set their heart on doing something which may be 080 British Government, prod. "The Pace Makers." Lady Allen Adventure Play Grounds. London Play. Great Britian, n.d. Archive: Lady Allen Adventure Playground Chelsea, Circa 1970s. Web. Dec. 2013. min 8:15 <https://www.youtube. com/watch?v=1pqMXplAI9Y>. 081 British Government, prod. "The Pace Makers." Lady Allen Adventure Play Grounds. London Play. Great Britian, n.d. Archive: Lady Allen Adventure Playground Chelsea, Circa 1970s. Web. Dec. 2013. min 5:25 <https://www.youtube. com/watch?v=1pqMXplAI9Y>.

beyond their capabilities, they’ll stay at it and stick at it until they’ve achieved it, and this builds up a tremendous sense of self-confidence.”82

Ivan Illich (1926-2002) was an Austrian philosopher, known for his social criticism of Western culture and industrial society. His book De-schooling Society confronts the system we have developed as a capitalist commodity-driven machine. It is a critical discourse on education in relation to modern economics. He protests the institutionalization of learning, and believes that much learning can happen outside of school; he suggests if school is institutionalizing society then De-schooling could deinstitutionalize society, and that is where we should start. The text is more than a critique, it contains suggestions for changes to how we learn in our society. In 1971 he was already thinking about the use of “learning webs” via technology.“The operations of a peer-matching network would be simple. The user would identify himself by name and address and describe the activity for which he sought a peer. A computer would send him back

the names and addresses of all those who and inserted the same description. It is amazing that such a simple utility has never been used on a broad scale for publicly valued activity”83 Illich argued that the use of technology to create decentralized webs could support the goal of creating a good educational system:“A good educational system should have three purposes: it should provide all who want to learn with access to available resources at any time in their lives; empower all who want to share what they know to find those who want to learn it from them; and, finally, furnish all who want to present an issue to the public with the opportunity to make their challenge known.”84

The Process This book will take you through the journey of realizing my thesis. Within these pages there is an account of one year's exposure to a multitude of topics: learning theories, educational reform, behavioral psychology, behavioral economics, attachment theory, theory of play and experiential learning, multi-strandedness, social allocation, mentorship, apprenticeship, art as a vehicle for learning, non-profit arts organization business models and their interior infrastructure, social practice, the Department of Education's existing programs for youth workers, barter systems, and funding models from private to public. The goal was to survey a large swath of information while

082 British Government, prod. "The Pace Makers." Lady Allen Adventure Play Grounds. London Play. Great Britain, n.d. Archive: Lady Allen Adventure Playground Chelsea, Circa 1970s. Web. Dec. 2013. min 6:30 <https://www.youtube. com/watch?v=1pqMXplAI9Y>.

83 Illich, lvan. “Peer Matching.” Deschooling Society. New York: Harper & Row, 1971. 93. Print 84 Illich, Ivan. "General Characteristics of New Formal Educational Institutions." Deschooling Society. New York: Harper & Row, 1971. 75. Print.

Z.V.P.

uncovering a path and not forcing connections. Eventually, overlapping areas presented points of intervention, a place that could be looked at more closely and evaluated. The concept that force does not yield cooperation--a basic principle, Richard Sennett notes, of an extremely skilled craftsman85--applies to an immersive ecosystem, chiseling a handle for an axe, or helping someone grasp an abstract idea; force will not yield best results, better to be patient. Sennett’s writing also reminds us that “...a positive embrace of incomplete is necessary.”86 Along my journey a red thread of narrative was drawn but lateral thinking was in motion. I could act, test, and receive feedback which led the process on an expansive journey. Design presents various frameworks which one is able to use for investigation, research, and implementation. It is a toolbox which aids in gathering dense information and making it accessible to larger audiences. In the past we have used these tools to understand what consumers want out of a product; a chair, a pen, a toy to aid in elderly sitting, write with many inks, or make a child laugh and learn at the same time. The process starts by defining a problem, then gathering information and doing research, from there one pulls out learnings or insights from the large amount of qualitative and quantitative data which have been collected. When clear insights are gained and the assumptions about these insights are tested, opportunities can be identified. These 85 Sennett, Richard. "Working with Resistance." Together: The Rituals, Pleasures, and Politics of Cooperation. New Haven, CT: Yale UP, 2012. 208-12. Print. 86 Sennett, Richard. "The Troubled Craftsman." The Craftsman. New Haven: Yale UP, 2008. 43. Print.

State of the Art Project

“...a positive embrace of incomplete is necessary.” x Richard Sennet opportunities lead either to a focused conclusion or cause for a larger look at the research. This process can focus very narrow, and then be blown open wide, this process expands and contracts. In the design world we use the terms divergent and convergent thinking. This just means that when the thought process is open wide, all possibilities are considered and one does not fear failure, but at other times logical steps are taken to conclude possible solutions. Today we are seeing a shift and this approach is being applied to larger systemic problems such as education, healthcare, and poverty. These problems lie in areas where human beings are being recognized as part of a system and today’s newly focused designers are concerned with how the changes we make will affect the people involved. According to Aaron Hurst the founder of Tap Root87, Co Founder of Imperative88, and author of the Purpose Economy, we are moving into a time when people are seeking mean87 Taproot is a nonprofit organization that makes business talent available through pro-bono services to organizations working to improve society. 88 Imperative is a consultancy which helps individuals and employers pinpoint what gives them purpose in their current work to propel their career forward.

ing and purpose in their lives through community, work, and even philanthropic ventures. We as designers need to see ourselves contributing to the betterment of others and a common good. Aaron discusses the shareable and trade economies erupting, such as open source learning platforms, green markets and farming movements, as well as crowd-funding ventures. We are wanting to contribute to something which gives us hope and allows us to connect to others. Aaron dubs education and healthcare as the “two largest Purpose Economy Markets” and claims,“in the next ten years we are likely to see unimaginable change and growth” in these areas.89 The three drivers which will push this movement include serving people and the planet, self expression, and building community. Designers today are looking farther ahead because we want to have a larger capacity for understanding the consequences our designs will have. As a designer there are risks involved in all aspects of the process. Specifically condensing, as skewing any data to fit assumptions or aims can cross ethical boundaries. There is a current dialogue about the collection of data: assessing qualitative vs quantitative data, and the agenda one may have when designing for individuals or these communities. One can hope that those who take on this responsibility will understand the impact the process can have. Donnella Meadows explains in her text Thinking ins Systems how designers who wish to pull levers to create change should keep their eyes and ears open. “We can't impose our will on a 89 Hurst, Aaron. "Are We at the Tipping Point of a New Economy?" The Purpose Economy: Lessons from the Front Lines of the New Economy. N.p.: n.p., n.d. 29. Print.

Z.V.P.

“we can’t impose our will on a system. We can listen to what the system tells us, and discover how its properties and our values can work together to bring forth something much better than could ever be produced by our will alone.” x Donella Meadows system. We can listen to what the system tells us, and discover how its properties and our values can work together to bring forth something much better than could ever be produced by our will alone.” 90 Meadows also speaks at length on the issue of defying disciplines and understanding that to be truly interdisciplinary one has to go back into “learning mode” 90 Meadows, Donella H., and Diana Wright. Thinking in Systems: A Primer. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green Pub., 2008. Print.

Fig. 3 — Dynamic systems are often represented as diagrams with words and symbols, but is important to remember that they are made of people who need flexibility.

and “admit to ignorance and be willing to be taught, by each other and by the system.”91 This echoes theories collected in this text on intergenerational learning. The design in this book collaborates, and make use of disciplines and other age groups; frameworks used in this thesis parallel anthropologic research and sociology, focusing on community and systemic design while taking in consideration points of view from adults and kids alike. Jason Severs’ class on "Framing User Experience" reminded me of the abstract levels in which design is involved in our daily lives. He reintroduced the theorist John Dewey. John Dewey believed that our interactions together specifically in 91 Meadows, Donella H., and Diana Wright. "Living in a World of Systems."Thinking in Systems: A Primer. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green Pub., 2008. 183. Print.

State of the Art Project

the context of learning deserve to be paid attention and understood as a mediated experience. The experience needs to be evaluated from all points of view. Today in design we design experience, whether its one you are having waiting in line at Disneyland, eating on an airline or engaging with technology in a classroom, thought has been given to the way you navigate the world within these contexts.. Designers take cues from the works of Dewey. Here is a snippet from one of Jason’s writings that supports the view that if humans have interacted with “it,” “it” has been mediated, thus designed: “The world you take for granted everyday is being aggressively designed for you by people who don't know you.” Jason also illustrates how design can deal with almost any problem, and when using it properly, promotes craft and knowledge

“The world you take for granted everyday is being aggressively design for you by people who don’t know you” x Jason Severs through a process. “The potential of design in supporting social and personal action resides in the democratic nature of its process. Design is good for defining a vision and then crafting a plan or roadmap to guide the realization of this vision. Visions with clear paths of implementation provide a beacon for us to collaborate efficiently and optimistically on large projects.” Jason is currently the creative director at Frog Design. In the last semester, two classes directly contributed to and helped define the parameters of my thesis. The first was a class taught by Kyla FullenWider. Kyla is an educator, writer, and social designer; she is a founding member of Imperative, a consultancy firm based on theories relayed in co-founder Aaron Hurst’s book Purpose Economy. Her work promotes social values where design intersects with Z.V.P.

community-oriented projects. With Kyla we looked at asset- based models which are used in theories of positive psychology. It is important to understand the assets which are already involved in the system you are working with, and how to properly utilize them. These assets can be strengthened and used to build better infrastructure and community from within. There can be a great moment of empowerment, especially if the assets are directly related to the community members. Many nonprofit models, social justice organizations, and other types of grass roots projects that are accustomed to little funding use this model naturally, evaluating what is immediately usable. Kyla also introduced us to E.F. Schumacher, and his ideas about behavioral economics. These were influential on the aspects of my thesis that considered scale, scope, capacity and growth. Also immensely helpful was a framework devised by Everett Rogers in the 1970s called Diffusion of Innovation. This model is used by both Kyla and Aaron Hurst92, you will also see it used to more clearly understand the problems this thesis investigated. Kyla created an awareness surrounding anthropological research techniques and ethics in her class, which informed the research and interview process. Terms such as “going native” and how to treat the area of study with respect were of great help. The second class wasn’t a class at all, but a hands-on workshop in partnership with Zago, a consultancy design firm, and the 92 The Purpose Economy; lessons from the front lines of the new economy relies heavily on this framework to explore how the behavior of this budding economy is passed on throughout society.

Camden Coalition, a health care provider in Camden, New Jersey. This experience helped me to construct convictions and practice empathy. There is a history of failed urban planning and a corrupt health care system in Camden. This city has suffered from detrimental highway construction and white flight, which has left thousands of people downtown living in a food desert without a community of people to help them. Jeff Brenner started the Camden Coalition after his primary care practice couldn't stay afloat. He used hotspot data mapping to understand why people were using hospitals

Fig. 4 — Jeff Brenner of the Camden Coalition sharing the current problems faced in Camden, New Jersey. Jeff Brenner is a MacArthur Fellow for his work with the Coalition.

Fig. 5 —MFA Products of Design class during a download session at the Camden Coalition headquarters. A day long of research and observation.

State of the Art Project

Fig. 6 —A caseworker at home with a Camden Coalition Patient. Scheduled drop in home visits are a big part of the Caseworkers role, creating a relationship which nurtures.

instead of the small doctors’ offices. He found that many did not trust the small offices, and also didn’t have the health insurance to pay for the visits. Instead, low income families on Medicaid frequented the hospitals. The Camden Coalition is looking to change this in a holistic way: people giving other people hope. Now, the organization works with healthcare providers, hospitals, and physician practices to improve the care and coordination of healthcare for Camden residents while decreasing costs. Their mission is to improve the health status of all Camden residents by increasing capacity, quality, and access of care in the city. This work directly impacted the last leg of the thesis and its focus; it illuminated the importance of surveying a system holistically and understanding that it is made of people. The Camden Coalition believes that everyone from the workers to the patients should benefit, and be empowered to empower others; and that we should look at food sources and mental as well as physical health. These disparate systems need to work together to create greater lasting change. A friend of mine once told me

Fig. 7 — Simone Leigh in collaboration with Stuyvesant Mansion, provided a Free Peoples Clinic during Creative-time and Weeksville Heritage Center’s Funk, God, Jazz, and Medicine: Black Radical Brooklyn. Medicine; “engaged the critical intersections of public health, racial consciousness, and women’s work, asking viewers to consider the often-overlooked players.”

that "we as social justice advocates need to work ourselves out of a job”.93 That moment will be a great one, when we are no longer working because of other people suffering. Working on this thesis has provided me with a point of view and empowered me with convictions. We are all designers, or all have the capacity to be. We build systems together and individually. We move and alter their paths, changing something in an existing ecosystem. This has consequences. We reevaluate. And with all of this power, we need to keep in mind that most of time, these arrows and words in our diagrams are people. Recently, Creative Time in partnership 93 From an interview with social activist, arts, and teacher Kim Charles Kay

Z.V.P.

with Weeksville Heritage Center opened a show called Funk, God, Jazz, and Medicine: Black Radical Brooklyn, and in the exhibition there is a video about the history of the Weeksville Settlement. In that video the narrator is speaking about the sustainable community, and makes an eloquent statement which we designers should take to heart: “A community is measured by how it treats its people.” This thesis draws a parallel between the

The Thesis

ways in which we learn and the ways in which we should work. It celebrates the hand, the collective and the craft. It aims to create and empower communities rich in diversity and culture. It is a celebration

Fig. 8 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Pictured above is Hunterfly Road Houses 1969, 5th of July Resource Center for Self Determination & Freedom. Weeksville provided resources and support from within the community.

Fig. 9 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; The newly built Weeksville Heritage Center. This was donated by the New York Cultural Council. It is a shining new edition to the neighborhood. The old colonial houses still stand behind it, with ample open green space for the community garden, and gatherings.

State of the Art Project

“A community is measured by how it treats its people” x Weeksville of shared power and shared ownership through pathways of Art and Design. There are a multitude of problems we face today in the area of education. One could say our kids are not getting what they need from their educational experiences; there are less kids ready to work and there are less jobs for them. A startling number of 16 to 24 year-olds are facing unemployment, part-time employment or insecure, low-wage jobs. This situation increases instability and cripples economic growth as it limits young people’s capacity to contribute to the economy and society. In November 2013 The New York Times ran an article on minimum-wage workers which included a chart from a Georgetown study. The chart illustrated a decline in teenagers holding minimum wage jobs since the late 1970s, and an increase in the same period of 25 to 30 year-olds who have post-secondary degrees holding these positions. What does this say about our educational system in relationship to our workforce? Our labor and our education doesn’t match up and is a symptom of disconZ.V.P.

nected systems. In the wake of a global economic crisis, rising youth unemployment has reached a critical level that demands our urgent attention. As seen in a curated group of essays called Living Labor edited by Milena Hoesberg and Cora Fisher, a new discourse on social practice is growing. In his essay After work: what does refusal mean today?, Peter Flemings discusses how current work is disconnected from our survival; he states, “ the broader ritual of work and learning is now fairly detached from economic necessity.”94Flemings refers to social labor in his essay, and is speaking about how we are starting to integrate our work life with our lifestyle, and the start and stop time of our jobs are no longer visible. But the jobs he is referring to are not the ones we fully enjoy, or the ones that directly contribute to our survival. He goes on to talk about “purposeful work” being pursued once again. The purposeful work he is talking about is how we feed, clothe, house, entertain, and take care of ourselves on a basic level. He describes these jobs as ones “with which we take pleasure.” You can see this in the resurgence of jobs working with one’s hands for local making and process based businesses and the happiness and pride of the workers employed in rich, enjoyable and authentically endless work that is our living labor. For most of us, our jobs are becoming more intimate, we are living with our work. So while we are searching for our “purpose” it is our responsibility to create pathways for others. It is also very important to note that learning through doing and experiential learning are valid 94 Fleming, Peter. "After Work: What Does Refusal Mean Today?" Living Labor(2013): 191-99. Print. Sternberg Press

Fig. 10 —Center for Economic Policy Research, http://www9.georgetown.edu/grad/gppi/hpi/cew/pdfs/FullReport.pdf The New York Times, Greenhouse, Steven. “Low-Wage Workers Are Finding Poverty Harder to Escape.” The New York Times 18 Mar. 2014, Economy sec.: n. pag. New York Times. 18 Mar. 2014. Web. 18 Mar. 2014.

ways of navigating the world. Many of us can’t learn in a context where institutional styles of learning is the only option. Different types of learners need different types of contexts. How do you unite local making businesses and teenagers?

“...the broader ritual of work and learning is now fairly detached from economic necessity.” x Peter Flemmings

The thesis State of the Art Project addresses this problem through the revival of an apprenticeship model. You will see a very vast design process throughout this book and when you arrive at the chapter for State of the Art Project, that process will start all over again in a more focused scope. As explained prior, when used appropriately, design can be something that brings craft and knowledge together to create and build sustainable models. The research pointed to creating more opportunities for kids to work in skilled jobs

which are community oriented. Through the research, strategy, and development phases of the thesis it was important to consider the different faces of employ-

State of the Art Project

Fig. 11 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; The Rockaway Taco Shack. Owned and Operated by Andrew Field. Here you will find an all age community of Rockaway , NY and nearby neighborhoods. Many visit this establishment in the summertime for some killer tacos. Andrew Filed Employees youth from Rockaway to contribute and build community.

Fig. 12â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Apprenticeships are available and widely promoted in other areas of the world. Getting-In.com helps students in the UK find technical, educational, and agricultural apprenticeships. It is a comprehensive up to date list of organizations and schools who offer this model.

Z.V.P.

Fig. 13 — State of the Art Project uses Knowledge, Connections, and Support to build apprenticeship programs. The online component creates visablity around its efforts. Businesses, partners, and teens can find useful information about current projects, past projects, the process, and can inquire about getting involved.

ment, while investing in and valuing young people’s potential. State of the Art Project set it sights on bridging the information gap and building strategies to create a sustainable and resilient model. It helps young people understand their own capacity and can help reframe questions about their education. State of the Art Project is a non-profit consultancy that works with local businesses and local schools to create job apprenticeships. These businesses see the value in “on the job learning” and in preserving their methods; they also disperse the responsibility of learning into a larger community. Design was used to investigate and build a pilot to test assumptions about a sustainable model in preparation for launch. It was a way to communicate

to all stakeholders involved, the mission and vision of the created consultancy by the making of accessible maps and infographics, to building a peer support network, and gathering pertinent information in digestible bits. Leveraging system thinking, the thesis examines The Department of Education’s education and internship programs in New York City, and how these programs could be used in favor of Bien Cuit (partner for the current pilot project). The chapter on State of the Art Project will detail the specific research, insights, mapping, and funding frameworks used to create the model. The recommendation presents strategies to intervene in the system, using the existing infrastructure and then strengthening it with available resources. In this case, the recommendation identifies partners such

State of the Art Project

as vocational/transfer schools, learn to work programs, community based organizations, government and private funding, and local businesses. State of the Art Project partnered with a local bakery in Cobble Hill called Bien Cuit to prototype and test assumptions. Working with Bien Cuit helped me to visualize and understand what effective collaboration could look like through evaluating capacity on all ends. State of the Art Project's vision is to build and nurture community, commitment, and communication through knowledge, connections and support.

Z.V.P.

State of the Art Project

Where Adults and Teens Meet

Z.V.P.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Mission & Goals

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Mission & Goals The mission and goals of this thesis project have been shaped by the research and design process. The process has caused the focus of the project to shift and reduce while I was considering what to discuss, how to handle the subject matter, and what could be accomplished by discussing or taking action. Focus is derived from where the research points you. For this work there is an exterior mission and an interior mission. The exterior mission is the investigation of the larger process of research and design work, while the interior mission is the actual thesis project. Both missions celebrate intuition and spontaneity; play and experimentation were a central part of the subject matter and process. Stuart Brown is the founder of the National Institute of Play, clinical researcher, and producer of a three-part series called The Promise of Play. Early on in my research, it was important to establish the validity of certain concepts. Through investigation it became apparent that kids and adults alike need experimentation and imagination to navigate this world. Brown points out that through play we can unlock potential in ourselves and others; play is serious business, it is an essential part of learning, and State of the Art Project

something which shapes our lives.74 The goals for the exterior mission will be discussed first. The design research aims to understand existing systems of learning, i.e. schools, after-schools, camps, museums, and to look for connections with other fields. My discoveries are curated within these pages. I hope they will contribute to a robust research database that will serve beyond this project and lend its findings to this area of design and social values. My investigations took many forms from desktop research to extensive interviews. The prototypes and projects made during this time were a response to the ongoing research with the aim of providing feedback. I wanted to test assumptions about how we form relationships around the making process. The project focuses on crafting relationships and crafting the ways we physically make together (process), and how that relates to the learning process between youth and adults. All 74 Brown, Stuart L., and Christopher C. Vaughan. Play: How It Shapes the Brain, Opens the Imagination, and Invigorates the Soul. New York: Avery, 2009. Print.

projects that involved others are considered collaborations and contributions will be noted. Early on in the process it was decided that computers would be secondary, supplementary, and seldom used. Human connections and facilitating partnerships are an integral part to this work. . It is important for this project and the process of this project to look at assets that exist and reframe “problems” into opportunities. In the methodologies section we speak about positive psychology and the effects this has on a learning process. Without a support structure, adults can be persuaded that they do not have the expertise it takes to cultivate young minds. But if they are lead through an egalitarian collaborative process to ease apprehension, a partnership can be achieved and opportunities created. Encouraging flexibility and convincing people that they would benefit by being open to wrong turns brings stability and greater reflexive moments and outcomes. Kids are resilient, and in most cases can create their own pathways if we would be daring enough to let them drive. They would teach us many lessons about ourselves and the existing structure around us. The pursuit is to reframe the learner and teacher model so that these roles can be acknowledged as shared between the youth and the adult. Paulo Freire, a radical educational theorist of the ‘60s, argues that the state of learning should not be authoritative but collaborative with shared decision-making components, which allows for shared ownership. The two quotes below are from Pedagogy of the Oppressed, a deeply rewarding text that explores the oppressed and the oppressor in societal constructs. Freire takes us through the psychology and the social order that put these Z.V.P.

“Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction, by reconciling the poles of the contradiction so that both are simultaneously teachers and students.” x Paulo Freire constructs in place and explains the very nugget of creating and empowering equal playing fields. “Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction, by reconciling the poles of the contradiction so that both are simultaneously teachers and students.” “In problem-posing education, people develop their power to perceive critically the way they exist in the world with which and in which they find themselves; they come to see the world not as a static reality, but

as a reality in process, in transformation.”75 When discussing problem-posing education, Friere is referring to creative/critical-thinking types of learning. When he was involved with education in Brazil this was not a far-reaching philosophy, even in the United States. These types of ideas were seen as extremely radical. Even though in contemporary times this type of education has been more in favor, the ideas have been undermined by the rigorous types of evaluation used to measure its value. This means there isn’t equality for all. It became increasingly apparent through my experiences with this project that existing assumptions and restraints don’t necessarily reflect what someone of any age is actually capable of doing. Social allocation theory tells us that by not being flexible and by predicting achievement, we actually hinder ability and potential. Setting up specific types of hierarchies within a classroom setting can predetermine individual kids’ growth. When a child doesn’t have room to be the leader, the motivation for learning diminishes. Assigning a specific goal or characteristic to a child can determine their advances in learning. Allowing kids the ability to lead others and to exist within a power structure they can access and change yields results in favor of both contributors. We can see the effects of these types of environments looking at examples such as the Brooklyn Free School, Ethical Culture Fieldston School, City and Country School, and Fairhaven Schools. All allow for kids to 75 Freire, Paulo. “Chapter 2.” Pedagogy of the Oppressed 30th Anniversary Edition. New York: Bloomsbury, 2014. N. pag. Print.

State of the Art Project

Fig. 14— A diverse group of kids and adults make up Brooklyn Free School.

Fig. 15 — Alan Berger, the Brooklyn Free School’s director, center, with students in an all school meeting. Decisions are made collectively, and kids are allowed to call meetings.

have a choice and voice in what they do and how they learn; they are involved in making decisions that affect themselves and others. The students tend to become well-rounded robust individuals that understand the weight and importance of community along with an understanding that they are valued. I was involved with a similar model of learning during the summer months at Beam Camp where kids between the ages of 7 -17 are granted freedom to choose which workshops to take. I was able to see the interactions and enjoy the benefits. Beam Camp in New Hampshire, founded 10 years ago by Brian Cohen and Danny Kahn, is a celebration of

kids making things happen. This is a village of 130 people of all ages who come together and create pure magic. The kids and adults partner together to share a diverse practice, build, and explore collaboration. Ideas are exchanged and everyone learns from each other.

a dynamic system, which can be a great attribute. It is important to note that flexibility can be spontaneous and also built in. Having the ability to be flexible indicates to people involved that they are in an evolving community and they are valued. It allows for growth, and shows that people in the system are not cogs in a well-oiled machine, but humans who have different capacities and different agency. It demonstrates that listening is being done.

Gerontology encompasses many social sciences and examines and makes conclusions about the micro self and macro societal factors in the processes of learning and aging. The Self and Society in Aging Processes explores the implications of social allocation and social reality production; how we order and allocate ourselves and how our created order grows. The editors Carol D. Ryff and Victor W. Marshall discuss ways we make decisions on behalf of others and allocate to achieve certain standards. “[Teachers] and school officials are enacting practices…. dictated by policymakers, administrators, educational and developmental experts and legislators whose collective intent imposed an answer—arguably political more than humanistic—to the question of what young children should be doing with their time.”76 Far too often do we see people making decisions from a removed perspective which do not necessarily benefit the partners involved. In times when education is monitored and assessed through unified standards, it is important for this project to create small, intimate frameworks that qualitatively measure individuals and small groups. The small-scale model aids in cultivating a perspective that is objective yet close to all participants as mediator or translator for a community. The design process allows for the perspectives of all participants to be heard and designed for, it allows for this build to be collaborative. This is an example of flexibility in

Being introduced to John Thackera and his writings was immensely helpful in carving out a tangible but large target. In September of 2012 In the Bubble was added to my library. It was the first time that the ideas of social capital, reciprocity, and redefining work appeared plainly in front of me. Thackera made ideas accessible and understandable. The chapter Conviviality discusses convivial work and convivial services, pointing to issues we are currently struggling with: happiness, technology, and labor. He cites Ivan Illich and Tom Healy when referring to the overall well being of humans through social capital.77 He argues for the complexities we have created with reciprocal relationship exchange, and how we have built and utilized social trust throughout the past. Thackera uses examples from current barter economies and alternative value systems that show real-world application of these theories, such as “Time Dollars, a currency for rebuilding the core economy of family, neighborhood, and community.”78 Below are four principles describing the mission of Time Dollars. They are taken from In the Bubble, quot-

Z.V.P.

76 Ryff, Carol D., and Victor W. Marshall. The Self and Society in Aging Processes. New York: Springer Pub., 1999. Print.

77 social capital is the expected collective or economic benefits derived from the preferential treatment and cooperation between individuals and groups. 78 Described by its founder Edgar Cahn Thackera, John. “Conviviality.” In the Bubble: Designing in a Complex World. Cambridge, MA: MIT, 2005. 126. Print.

ed from the Time Dollars website. These powerful principles provoked and inspired me in my thesis pursuit. Assets “No more throw away people. Every human being has the capacity to be a builder and a contributor.” Redefining work “No more taking the contribution of women, children, families, immigrants, for granted. No more free rides for the market economy extracted by subordination, discrimination, and exploitation. Work must be redefined to include whatever it takes to rear healthy children, make neighborhoods safe and vibrant, and care for the frail and vulnerable.” Reciprocity “Stop creating dependencies; stop devaluing those whom you help while you profit from their troubles. The impulse to give back is universal. Wherever possible, we must replace one- way acts of largess in whatever form with two-way transactions. ‘You need me’ becomes ‘We need each other’.” Social Capital “No more disinvesting in families, neighborhoods and communities. No more economic and social strip mining. Social Networks require ongoing investments of social capital generated by trust, reciprocity, and civic engagement’.” The goals described by Time Dollars and Thackera are altruistic: caring about the welfare of others in a community. Thackera is inspired by Ivan Illich’s theories about institutions and their agendas, referring to Illich’s argument for the “creation of convivial, rather than manipulative institutions of learning, health and care.” Thackera points out that these communities of practice are usually “informal, voluntary, and self organizing.” State of the Art Project

“No more throw away people. Every human being has the capacity to be a builder and a contributor.” x Time Dollars These groups also benefit greatly when they freely combine to produce goods and service for their own enjoyment: the community creating the growth from within. This was to be a basic rule of my thesis, that the work to be done was going to be for the betterment of others and for growth of a community. Later in the text Thackera introduces 63 Universals of Culture, aspects of everyday life that exist in every community and culture in the world. In 1945 American Anthropologist George P. Murdoch created the chart depicted below. Today we can identify it as an opportunity for service models. Thackera ends the chapter on Conviviality with a piece of advice concerning the chart and the advantages of using it: “These universals of culture are a gigantic “to do” list for service designers. Take one of these aspects of daily life, improve it, and figure out how to benefit from it in a non-monetary way.”80 79

79 Thackera, John. “Conviviality.” In the Bubble: Designing in a Complex World. Cambridge, MA: MIT, 2005. 133. Print. 80 Thackera, John. “Conviviality.” In the Bubble: Designing

“These universals of culture are a gigantic “to do” list for service designers. Take one of these aspects of daily life, improve it, and figure out how to benefit from it in a non-monetary way.” x John Thackera

Z.V.P.

games penal sanctions community organizations gestures personal names cooking gift giving population policy cooperative labor government postnatal care cosmology greetings pregnancy usages courtship hairstyles property rights dancing hospitality proportion of supernatural beings decorative arts housing puberty costumes divination hygiene religious rituals division of labor incest taboos residence rules State of the Art Project

dream interpretations inheritance rules sexual restrictions education joking soul concepts eschatology kin groups status differentiation ethics kinship nomenclature surgery ethnobotany language tool making etiquette law trade faith healing luck superstitions visiting family feasting magic weather control folklore mealtimes weaving food taboos medicine obstetrics, funeral rites

“Education can help us only if it produces “whole men.” The truly educated man is not a man who knows a bit of everything, not even the man who knows all the details of all subjects (if such a thing were possible): the “whole man,” in fact, may have very little detailed knowledge of facts & theories...but he will be truly in touch with the centre. Z.V.P.

He will not be in doubt about his basic convictions, about his view on the meaning and purpose of his life. He may not be able to explain these matters in words, but the conduct of his life will show a certain sureness of touch which stems from his inner clarity.â&#x20AC;? x E.F. Schumacher

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Fig. 16 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Jeremy Hawkins Contemplating his next move during a capture the flag game on Pirate Sunday. Jeremy helps with program areas at Beam Camp, is a Camper Liaison and has been a returning contributor for 4 years. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Beam We were told to think long and hard between our first and second year of graduate school about what our thesis could and should be. I spent that summer in the woods with kids ages 7-17 making stuff. Beam Camp, founded in 2005, is devoted to building together, teaching each other, and bringing smiles to the faces of everyone involved. In the spring of 2013 I was chosen to run their workshop and residency program for artists, designers, engineers, practitioners of all kinds who share their passion with kids. I was to curate, program and develop the curriculum of 120 workshops to take place over six weeks: 10 artists a week, 20 workshops a week, 90 kids a week for two three-week sessions. This was a challenge, and I took it, not knowing how big of a job it would be or how big of an impact it would have on me. The job required 15-hour days completely immersed in the community, always in the now while also anticipating the next arriving guests. The responsibilities didn’t end at the preparation; one had to consider the logistics and execution of the workshops as well as the emotional well-being of the participants. Helping people acclimate and find a groove in an established small community for one week at a time is a big challenge. That summer at Beam Camp State of the Art Project

proved to be a very intense experience that changed my perspective on myself and my work. I started to see myself as an administrator but also an artist, as a teacher but also a learner, and as an individual but also a community member. The population of the camp is diverse and the interests range in every direction. I witnessed how the organization makes a difference in these kids’ lives, and saw the importance of flexibility and choice which allows the campers to learn in an environment that also allows them to lead. Beam Camp is situated in Strafford, New Hampshire on Parker Mountain. It is two hours away from Boston, and roughly thirty minutes to the nearest gas station. It is an ecosystem that becomes self-sustaining after the set-up; this takes place shortly after arrival of the “leadership team” in early July. All food is consumed on campgrounds, and for the kids, there is no contact with the outside world, or the “other world” as it is referred to, besides written letters. There is no cell phone reception and I spent the summer without my online social media. Each week a new cast and crew (we call them Guests) joined us from the outside world. The various artists, designers, creators would arrive after a correspondence of months, weeks, or sometimes just days (this showed much trust in each party for the other) about the workshops demonstrating their practice. After the first week the Guests would enter a community already full of momentum and connected relationships. I had to reiterate the goals and mission of the camp to both the new Guests and those already residing in the ecosystem. I explained how the camp functions, and what it embodies in the greater context of learning and growing: the relationship

to the larger ecosystem of development between individuals and communities. This experience ultimately broadened my ideas about how we learn and with whom. In the months, weeks, days leading up to their arrival, each Guest would go through a similar process, somewhat customized to their communication needs. This process started out with an invitation. The invitation was sent based on prior knowledge of the individual’s skill in communicating their particular practice. Most of those invited were from our networks: friends of friends, people with whom we had previous positive interactions. The invitation was worded in a way that would set the way we speak about what they were invited to do. We called our workshops “Domains” and you were coined a “Lead Learner” or a “Domain Guest”. The shift in language aimed to help the Guest understand their role, to empower them to share what they were excited about. . This could be something closely related to their process or practice, or new interests which they felt were important to explore alongside an audience, moving in a direction of collaborative learning. People moved at different speeds when discussing the invitation. Skype was preferable to some, while phone meetings or email was better for others. I used Google docs for organizing and revising plans, which was an effective way to communicate efficiently about single or multiple ideas within lessons. I developed a language congruent to the one Beam Camp was using, realizing flexibility, not rigid guidelines, were needed. In a way, every Domain work-shopped with the prospective Domain Leader/ Guest was a collaboration. We would speak about ways in which kids could receive the information. This progressed Z.V.P.

throughout the summer to speaking about how different types of kids would receive the information or activities planned, and how to continue their engagement. The kids of all ages (7-17) co-mingled in these workshops. Allen Riley, a life-long “Beamer,” once a counselor, then a domain specialist, now a vision and mission advisor, was a great mentor in the developing phase. He set a standard, trained me in the camp’s point of view, but was also open to discuss my opinions. His experience brought much insight. Allen has been working with BEAM for 4 years now, and has continued to express his morals and ideology. Sometimes I wonder if he is aware of the larger role he plays within this organization. He is one of its beating hearts, instilling values and sharing great depth of philosophical thought. Allen is coming into his own as an educator, facilitator, and thinker. Some of the other cast of characters involved are the founders Brian Cohen, a businessman who passionately wants to create a better tomorrow for kids, and Danny Kahn, the visionary dreamer; and Kathryn Wallem, who handles enrollment and logistics year-round for the kids and their families. Kathryn is practical, strong, level-headed, expressionistic, prolific, and a forward-moving steam engine who is observant and perceptive. There are thirty people on the staff including the counselors. At camp I continued working relationships that had been established in a particular way. Our “leadership team” was relatively small, and met every morning and two nights a week. Many of the team had worked together in similar circumstances in previous years, although they said the dynamic was different this summer. At

this juncture key players were no longer at camp. Kathryn and Allen had taken over a new pilot program at Beam Center that provided city kids with day camp for nine weeks divided up into three-week segments. Ayun Halliday, who preceded me, had been a magnetic character with a strong presence. People were returning, but in different capacities, and new positions were being filled; this caused focus and perspective to shift. This shift was apparent to me and continued to be a source of anxiety for the duration of camp. Roles were not defined socially, and the job I was there to do wasnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t defined for me as an employee. I tried to gather enough information by observation to evaluate my role and get a feedback loop. I struggled the most with the self-sufficiency which was required to continue to push forward.. Never before had I been in a metaphorical machine in which the cogs had to keep moving without review or attention to the parts. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Rolling with it,â&#x20AC;? is what Brian Cohen calls it. It is a very interesting approach on the managerial side. Not a heavy hand, almost no hand at all. At camp, self-evaluation was difficult because no two jobs were the same. We worked as a group, collaborating with the adults and the kids, the counselors, domain guests, project specialists and project masters. So maybe we all had the same job: creating and continuing a partnership. This takes a great deal of maturity, patience, persistence, courage, and awareness.

That summer will always stick with me. It was a time of doing, making, learning, building, collaborating and happiness. The kids showed me the best I could be, and also taught me so much. Below are some questions I pondered while working on the thesis, inspired by my experience at Beam Camp. It was my personal goal with this thesis to answer some of these questions. Can intention evolve over time within an organic process? How does one work in a group toward a larger, greater good? What qualities does it take for one to understand a role, both work- related and social? How do we equip younger generations with an understanding of what it takes to continue to move forward in a positive, progressive way? How do we provide good experiences that will encourage kids to contribute to their communities? Is it similar being an adult working alongside kids to being a kid working alongside adults? How do we create a culture in which older generations working with younger generations is important for all? How do we turn society from one of individuals to a collaborative community? How does one understand what is expected if there are no grades? How do you know if you are doing a good job and what is the criteria one uses to self-evaluate?

I came back from Beam Camp excited, giddy, ready to take on the second year of graduate school with new experiences and new questions. I learned that experiences are made with others. I knew exactly what I wanted, and it has held true until today. State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Fig. 17 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; A slide used in the final presentation to highlight Beam Camp. Their online platform shares past projects and future opportunities to be involved.

State of the Art Project

List of Beam Camp Workshops

Z.V.P.

2013

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Fig. 18 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Sundays at camp are themed. This is determined by the counselors or fellows (older campers). Pictured here a is choreographed duel during morning rituals in the camper village. Two older campers act out an ongoing narrative which will be carried throughout the day. Younger campers watch and giggle, waiting to see what will unfold next. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

State of the Art Project

â&#x20AC;&#x153;Positive psychology focuses on three related topics: the study of positive subjective experiences, the study of positive individual traits, and the study of institutions that enable positive experiences and positive traits.â&#x20AC;? x Seligman & Csikszentmihalyi

Z.V.P.

Fig. 19 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Every summer 2 large projects are chosen to be built by a collaborative effort of 100 people ranging in the ages 7-55 years of age. These projects are proposed by designers, architects, engineers, and artists. Above is the scaffolding which surrounded and aided in building a 30 ft tall Kaleidescope designed by two Belgium Architects. PPhoto courtesy of David Golann.

State of the Art Project

Fig. 20 — Campers learn how to make two part molds with Elizabeth Guzman. Elizabeth is a painter who attended Virginia Commonwealth University. This was her second summer leading a Domain at Beam. She has also shared, weaving techniques, neon plan-air, and paper making with book binding. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

Fig. 21 — Campers in the Art Barn paint their clay replicas of human body parts. Christine Facella shared her love of anatomy and three dimensional sculpture with clay, felting and sewing. In Brooklyn Christine has her own clay studio, she also works for NGO’s understanding strategy and marketing. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

Z.V.P.

Fig. 22 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Mark Kleback helps a camper understand circuitry in his Domain Bluetooth Boom Boxes. His other Domain at camp consisted of motion sensors for a photo booth. Mark teaches at Beam Center in Brooklyn, and also is a member of the collective artist run space Death By Audio. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

Fig. 23 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Christian Gregory of Virginia Commonwealth University brought a studio in his car. Here you can see kids using oil based woodblock inks. Christian showed his domains how to make silk screens and wood blocks to print. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Character Traits and Virtues

Strength of Wisdom and Knowledge Creativity [Originality, Ingenuity] Curiosity [Interest, Novelty-Seeking, Openness to Experience] Open-Mindedness [Judgment, Critical Thinking] Love of Learning Perspective [Wisdom]

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Fig. 24 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Hannah Bigeleisen is an Artist currently enrolled in a Masterâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s program at RISD. Hannah shared techniques of forging and weaving, along with short stories and essays. Campers from her weaving domain are performing a ritual at the end of th week presentations. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Character Traits and Virtues

Strength of Courage Bravery [Valor] Persistence [Perseverance, Industriousness] Integrity [Authenticity, Honesty] Vitality [Zest, Enthusiasm, Vigor, Energy]

State of the Art Project

Fig. 25 — In the kitchen campers learn basic bread structure and baking techniques. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

Fig. 26 — Weaving and Textiles. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

Z.V.P.

Fig. 27 — Wyna Liu is a recent graduate of NYU’s program ITP. Above she is assisting a camper finish up a fellow domain guests domain. Wyna collaborated with another domain guest to execute two domains. She also runs a maker space at the Brooklyn Community College Partnership space. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

Fig. 28 — Action Painting with David Kirschoff. David Kirschoff is an Artist and Design living in Brooklyn, New York. He has brought the art of making infomercials, a domain inspired by Sun Ra, creating an own private island, and action painting to camp. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Character Traits and Virtues

Strength of Humanity Love Kindness [Generosity, Nurturance, Care, Compassion, Altruistic Love, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Nicenessâ&#x20AC;?] Social Intelligence [Emotional Intelligence, Personal Intelligence]

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Character Traits and Virtues

Strength of Justice Citizenship [Social Responsibility, Loyalty, Teamwork] Fairness Leadership

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Character Traits and Virtues Strength of Transcendence Appreciation of Beauty and Excellence [Awe, Wonder, Elevation] Gratitude Hope [Optimism, Future-Mindedness, Future Orientation] Humor [Playfulness] Spirituality [Religiousness, Faith, Purpose]

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Fig. 29 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Domain Gallery. Photo courtesy of David Golann.

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

Methodology (an active dynamic practice)

State of the Art Project

Z.V.P.

100

Methodology (an active dynamic practice)

State of the Art Project

101

Z.V.P.

102

Web Platform called Play Together Today (speculative object) Play Together Today is a speculative service brought to your workplace via online inquiry and registration. The service promises to research, evaluate, and create recommendation to make the workplace a more enjoyable and fun place. The service providers are kids, and they are serious about what they do. ‘Play’ is a verb, ‘Together’ speaks about contributors collaborating and human connections, and ‘Today’ is a context, a parameter. It targets kids as a way to simultaneously create an earnest outreach while mimicking advertising. It assumes that adults are acknowledging their need for help from kids. Coupled with testimonials from adults and office employees it allows interested parties such as parents to dive deeper into why kids perspectives are so valuable. Its intent is to speak about the absurdity of our everyday inhabitants indoors at desks in cubicles with grey walls. The work chalState of the Art Project

lenges adults removed perspectives. Open play creates all types of opportunity for the kids to start to navigate life’s difficulties such as emotion autonomously. According to Stewart Brown, Play helps us understand and control fear and excitement, contextualize memory development and helps us learn human trust which is based in play signals. These play signals are enacted when physically maneuvering through space together and include vocal, facial, body, and gestural signs. Kids invent play, they create it themselves and when we take control, it becomes something very different. Play Together Today asks the question about structures of power and how through play the absurdity of this service could contribute to overcoming these structures within the workspace. Play is for all ages, and if we want to think like kids, we need to be around them. How can kids help us understand ourselves and them more fully? Within a recent article which was released by Harvard Business Review, Lego, a toy company leading in open ended play products, describes their attempt to connect again with their consumers’ needs. This article speaks heavily to the anthropological approaches design uses for user research. Lego concluded that what they needed was to dig deep within themselves and listen to what kids were doing and saying. What they found is not so shocking. “Children play to escape their overly orchestrated lives and to hone a skill.”74 We should take a cue from our research and look and start to redefine what play can mean to multiple generations. We all have the ability to do so, as it is inherent 70 An Anthropologist Walks into a Bar by Christian Madsbjerg and Mikkel B. Rasmussen Harvard Business Magazine March 2014

103

Z.V.P.

104

State of the Art Project

105

in our beings. Play together today speaks about our faculty within the workplace and our resistance and removed perspective from the child within. Play together today ponders the question; How do we create and maintain spaces or experiences for Multi Generational Partnerships?

A website Called Kid Talks (speculative object) We are at a point in our society when oral histories and stories are being valued and disseminated to large audiences via the Internet. We are in period of time when individuals from all walks of life are contributing to a larger conversation around education, health care, womenâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s rights, climate change, and even technology. Individuals are getting up on these metaphorical soap boxes to represent themselves and others telling stories. This is happening all over the world and even small spin offs are being recreated in cafes, backyards and churches. All are passionate and most are persuasive but very few are under the age of 18. Kid talks challenges the ideas around who should be listening to whom. Adults should be listening more carefully to the youth. From Tavi Gevinson to Adora Svitak, all the kids who have spoken at Ted Talks can be counted on two hands. This is an alarmingly small number out of 1700 plus presenters. Kid Talks accepts the notion that brilliance surpasses age, Z.V.P.

and creates an opportunity for younger generations to take the stage and be heard. Out of the handful of kids who have spoke at Ted Talks, ages have varied but the topics have stayed the same; patience, perseverance, equality, and empathy. There is an overall understanding of what learning can do and how it can shape us in diverse and impactful ways. There is also a critical lense which all of these kids try to uncover about the media and other tactics adults use to prescribe behavior. Listening to the way others view the world and how different perspectives can create expanded palettes is a phenomenon not so new. In education and in learning Kid talks challenges the expected roles and how a young contribution can create change on levels not foreseen by adults. How kids choose to frame the world is how we can shape it for them.

Say Yes Andâ&#x20AC;Ś In two Acts (Set of Instructions) Improv, Laughter Yoga, a game of ninja and the relationship between the Meyerhold biomechanics and the apprentice workshop. A flyer outlines the reasoning behind a verbal set of instructions given to a room of twenty people at School of Visual Arts Product of Design Department. Instructors present were Richard Tyson, Allan Chochinov, and Andrew Scholes. All 2014

106

candidates for thesis masters were in attendance and instructions were verbalized and followed on Wednesday October 22, 2013. The Laughter Yoga was the the first movement in a two party act titled, Say Yes And… Participants were asked to pair up very quickly with individuals there were not necessarily close or comfortable with. This group of students spend many hours together, but because of the circumstances of the school work load, not much of that time was spent socializing. The hypothesis was that many people still might be uncomfortable with at least one or two people in the room and these would be the preferred partners. After partnering up they were given instructions to face one another. Then they were to look each other in the eyes and lock gaze, raise hands above their head, and proceed to jump up and down while laughing. This was to last at least 1 minute. A very absurd act, but during the whole time they were instructed not to loose the lock on the gaze with their partner. The outcome wasn’t as brilliant or effective as hoped. People were either not entirely engaged or hadn’t fully gained my trust as the one giving instructions. This movement in the two acts lasted for approximately 30 seconds and then dissipated. On the metaphorical table were the ideas surrounding play as a powerful learning tool for cooperation. The group didn’t fail to understand this, but were not as cooperative as one would hope. The second act in Say Yes And… ,aimed to provoke the audience in similar ways through a game. A game titled, Ninja. This game is familiar to school age youngsters and is played on playgrounds across the U.S.. Adults at conventions sometime partake in this game as an icebreaker. The game is simple and easy for all ages Luckily, a couple of the graduate students were familiar enough with this State of the Art Project

game to help instruct the rest. Everyone divided into two groups. Allan Chochinov(chair) and Joseph Weissgold(student) were particularly excited and engaged in act 2. Some were struggling to lend themselves to the exercise or experience. This demonstrated their sheepishness to put themselves out there. The hope was for everyone to let down barriers and to allow others to access their vulnerabilities through this silly and active game. For the most part many enjoyed the active experience. The intent of this was to use improvisation as a building process rather than a blocking process and use play/game tactics in the classroom to orchestrate and choreograph physical movement. The instructions borrowed from three sources. These sources concern individuals navigating space with others to create humanistic responses. The outcome was to be more fully aware of their body and others in the space and to be comfortable with their vulnerabilities to the point where they had moments to reframe. Physical movement was key in these two exercises as the intent was to stimulate other parts of the body and the mind simultaneously. Also included was inspiration drawn from a famous Russian choreographer and director, Vsevolod Meyerhold. Meyerhold was known during the late 1800’s and early 1900’s for his reform of stage art. He developed a pedagogy called Biomechanics which is still effectively used today. It is a system for actor preparation and consists of physical movement Meyerhold believed that in portraying realism in theatre the actors and audience were not challenged to use their imagination. Its aims were to create types of theatre that would engage their audience and react in different ways to the norm during that time period. Tech-

107

niques to transcend the everyday used in his methods created a distortion and exaggeration which Meyerhold leveraged to create this stylized theatrical technique. Improvisation was used for adults to tune into their neotonous behavior. Psychological neoteny is the retention of immature qualities into adulthood. These qualities allow us to be open and curious, playful, affectionate, have sociality, and create an innate desire to cooperate. We are all born with these types of qualities as it is the retention of these from our younger selves that make up the psychological neotenous behavior while we are older. It is also the ability for our surroundings and context to allow these to flourish, to nurture them through our progression of life. Improvisation is a technique used in corporate work offices to capture these moments or pull them out from fellow teams and workers. Since the mid 90’s improv has been used in the most progressive workplaces to open up the idea flow and build rather than block. The title of these instructions is the very essence of the improv practice, Say Yes And….Improv allows for continuous openness and flexible to ideas and concepts presented. It helps one not discriminate nor dismiss too quickly, continuing to move forward on the wave of information being received and projected. It is essentially the call to action, to refrain from saying “no” and just say yes and…. Kids have great imaginations which allows improvisation to be enacted in many forms in their day to day. This is a current practice at many design consultancies in particular the very famous IDEO. Their Creative directors released a book last winter around “unleashing the creative potential within us all”. The read is very accessible and extremely quick. It gives exercises and activities, companies can use to help themZ.V.P.

selves and their employees become more creative engines in the greater machine cog of work. Its important to question its existence as a text, because it is telling us something very simple. That if adults are looking to harness something that is within us all, then the very infrastructure we have built to educate our students and develop our children is lacking the guidance and nurturing for them to continue to carry out these traits. The book Creative Confidence written by Tom Kelley and David Kelley is a signal, one that tells us to redirect our attention away from businesses who produce product and to focus on issues of inequality and access on a human level.

Diffusion of Innovation (a framework) Everett Rogers was a communication scholar, sociologist, writer, and teacher. He is best known for originating the diffusion of innovations theory and for introducing the term early adopter. Diffusion of innovations is a theory which provides a framework to understand how behaviors are picked up or adopted into different segments of communities. This can be small villages or even large macro scales. It aims to predict ways innovations are disseminated to a mass audience or a larger audience and can be applied to many different cases. The framework asks one to define the issue, the ways you measure this, the audience you wish to target, your barriers and the barriers of the audience, and the levers which you will decide to pull to

108

State of the Art Project

109

create change. The levers include bright spots, or positive deviants. These are usually small scale initiatives which in the social sector are seen as grassroots organizations which gain traction in a larger market. Quantitative Research, which gets the attention of many larger inputs especially when it is cost driven and can show significant reductions, is also referred to as data and insights. The third lever has to do with the every growing industry of technology, this includes everything from new medication and new applications for tech devices. These reframe and change our understanding of current and new progressions. Creating public awareness, which is the fourth lever is ways we onboard people to new ideas. If people are unaware of how they can change things, they will most likely not join the market. If these people are not close to the cause they need persuasion, so public campaigns are an example of ways to bring awareness around a particular subject or cause. The last of the five is policy, changing public policy and policy within corporations can help move a market in one direction or another. Pivoting laws and regulations help your case if this is possible. The diffusion of innovations recommends at least three of these levers to be pulled in combinations for any type of change or shift to happen. Aaron Hurst the founder of Tap Root explains in his new text The Purpose Economy, the framework was used heavily in the late 80’s and early 90’s, it helped predict and target the right group of people for sales in an Information age that was just starting to be drive by tech. Aaron uses the Framework to demonstrate how we can plot and target social change and behavior amongst different groups if we pull the correct levers. The framework helps one understand what the “right stage” is and Z.V.P.

how to target the right market to promote change. If these aren’t in place, change will come with resistance. This echos the work of a craftsman. Richard Sennett so eloquently explains that the craftsman is aware that minimizing force within the material she or he is working with will yield better results and by “befriend(ing) one’s tool” the “master will have developed so thorough an understanding of the tool that he knows how to hold it to use minimum force”.74 Hurst and Everett would also agree with Sennett’s words that “community organizers fall within the frame of minimizing force.” They are known as respected entities of their community and most often open doors through behaving with less aggression and more open arms and understanding. Below is a study put through the model which are illustrated through infographic and text. The case study focuses on ideas around multi strandness theories and a quote from the founder and director of Beam Camp and Beam Center. The theory is borrowed from science and applied to social sciences. It explores how cities of very dense populations and diversity have greater happiness and well being levels. Because the cities are so dense there is a great chance of being with and around people who enjoy the same things that you do and are not limited by proximity/propinquity. Your friends will know more of your friends and connect you to more people who do similar work and enjoy their work. The strands from which you became involved in these networks are very few, but once involved create dense networks that overlap. People who live in rural areas tend 74 Together The Rituals, Pleasures and Politics of Cooperation, Richard Sennett page 210

110

Fig. 30 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Pictured above is the full diffusion of innovation curve. Pinpointed are individuals and groups who are in the early majority and early adopters. These people are seen as picking up a behavior well before the mainstream.

Fig. 31 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; The audience targeted are shown above. Specifically in NYC these people live and work in high density communities or villages.

State of the Art Project

111

to have the opposite, many strands and less dense networks. This is because of the distance between people. Because of our dense strands in the cities we are thought to live more fulfilling and satisfying lives. In the end it creates more opportunity to do something you love doing.75 In an interview back in October 2013, Brian Cohen the director of Beam Center, said the mission of his non profit is to nurture a community which creates authentic opportunity. This says much about behavior and role modeling and how people around you influence what you do greatly. Brian sparked an interesting investigation into what innovators we should look at to help younger generations value making and put forth positive behaviors to generate virtuous cycles. With the diffusions of innovations framework, we are going to look at this case study through the lense of creativity and arts as a way for transformation and transportation. Some very Bright Spots include Brooklyn Free School’s mission in education of social justice. From a very young age they introduce concepts which traditionally are not seen in classrooms. They advocate for young people’s voices to be heard, BFS engage students and staff in democratic decision making and problem solving through allowing the kids to call meetings and make choices. Another demonstration of passing the baton or disrupting models of hierarchy would be The artist Pilvi Takala who won this year’s Emdash Award from Frieze. The award comes with 10,000 pounds and she decided to just give it away. But her decision was not an act of charity, but a conceptual artwork that challenges 80-12 year olds from low in75 Fischer, Claude S. “The Structure of Relations and Networks.” To Dwell among Friends: Personal Networks in Town and City. Chicago: U of Chicago, 1982. 139-57. Print.

Z.V.P.

come neighborhoods in London to suggest ways to spend the prize money. She has ended up giving them 7,000 lbs or about 11,000 dollars of the total prize to allow the kids involved to decide where it goes. This shows a radical shift in trust and perceptive. She kept the remainder to run the project and document the results. Both of these examples show that adults can truly listen to kids and allow them to be leader of methods which we can learn from. This allows for this partnerships to be mutually beneficial and a level playing field is presented. We could further extrapolate on these ideas and set up centers or workspaces which concentrate on Focus Groups of kids leading discussion in adult environments and groups. Kid Makers and Doers associations, where kids are teaching skills and workshops to older generations, such as paper folding, electrical circuitry or cooking. To conclude this case study, it is important to point out that these places do exist but are not at the scales which we need to disrupt old standards of education and hierarchy.

Who Nurtures Your Practice (video) Reaching out to ones network can provide information about the community one involves themselves in. It can also reveal the way people are supported through their experiences and what influences them in their practice. The video Who Nurtures Your Practice began with informal collected qualitative data from over 20 indi-

112

viduals. On November 11th a request to answer two questions via audio recording were sent out through email and text. These two questions asked the participants to be reflective about people in their lives who contribute to their growth. The data acted as a quick prototype which picked up ethnographic research. Every response cited people who were in their close network and also people who were of inspiration to them they didn’t know. Everyone cited a collection of people who ranged in age and this indicated we have peers beyond our age group. A number of individuals made clear that they were inspired by younger generations, specifically when involved and engaged in a learning environment. All were creatives or working in a field which was related to physically making or creatively thinking. These participants ranged between 26 and 50 years of age, mostly living in New York City, the other cities include Chicago and Los Angeles. Some participants took this question of “who” as “what” inspires you. Because the main focus of the video was to celebrate and make evident that people and human systems are important to the growth of others and human networks, inanimate objects or concepts that weren’t directly related to people were omitted. The participants were extremely giving in the delivering and sharing the information, the audio recordings ranged between 30 seconds and 3 minutes. The simple premise was to prove that positive human relationships which are centered around a specific process can contribute to the outcome of the individuals involved. Simply put, people who love what they do, nurture and inspire others to do what they love. Below is the request for the audio recording, 20 people responded, their names and highlighted audio was transcribed, interviews follow. State of the Art Project

“If you could record yourself with your phone and then send me the audio via text or email i would greatly appreciate it! I am starting the work tonight, so anytime before 7 would be great! 440-667-0644, The idea is... People who love what they do, nurture and inspire others to do what they love. In the audio recording, could you answer these two questions; What do you do? Who nurtures and inspires that practice? I would appreciate your help if you have a moment. I wanted to reach out to people who inspire my practice.” Allan Chochinov Allison O’Daniels Antonio Velotta Ariel Carson Kimberly Venable Jess Langley Carolina Zamora Steve Faletti Gabrielle Kellner Julia Calabrese Kim Charles Kay Lisi Raskin Natalie Balthrop Wolfgang Kahler Fred Sherry Lisa Ramsey David Kirshoff Lauren Gregory Ian Charnas David Krofta Alison O’Daniel 12/14/2013 (recorded via iphone on her walk home) Hey, Zena. This is Alison. I’m an artist and a filmmaker and there are

113

so many people who nurture my practice. I think I come from a long line of really amazing female artist and film makers. I just saw a whole bunch of Agnes Varda films and they are incredible. In fact, after watching them I felt really sad for humanity that we just get all these films made by men in such a specific perspective. I don’t know, there’s just like so many really incredible artist and filmmakers: Yvonne Rainer, Lucrecia Martel, Claire Denis, John Cassavetes, Paul Mazerski Oh man I could go on, and on and on. I hope that’s helpful, it’s a small little handful. Hope you are doing well, Bye! Allan Chochinov 11/11/13 (interviewed) Z: Describe what you do. A: I do several things, one of the things I do is I am the chair and co-founder of a new MFA program at the School of Visual Arts called Products of Design and it is a two year masters degree in design. Design artifacts, design making, design thinking. And then I am also the editor at large of Core77 which was actually the first online design community, founded in 1995, and still very large, very strong. And them I’m a dad, I’m a husband, and I’m on the board of several organizations, and I like learning how to do things with my hands.

exchange but its very gratifying for me, that part, that direction. Antonio Velatto 11/11/2013 (Audio recorded via iphone and sent) Hello, my name is Antonio. I am a hairdresser and who inspires me is my grandmother, because she is 81 years old and still hairdressing. I have a huge record to break. She’s amazing! Thank you. Emilie Baltz 12/14/2013 (recorded via iphone and sent) My Name is Emilie Baltz and I am a food designer. I’m most inspired by the simplest of people around me. I do what I do probably because it’s half problem solving for myself to make sense of the world in which I live (but also) an attempt to make sense of the world for others. Try to make it more beautiful, a bit lighter, a little bit more joyful. And that’s why really and truly the people who inspire me the most to do what I do are just everyday humans. They’re not fancy, they’re not overly successful. I think they are the people who continue to live everyday and to continue to try and make their lives better one single step at a time.

Z: Who inspires and nurtures your practice? A: Well I learned pretty early on that I wanted to teach for all sorts of reasons. But being around students (is) when I feel the best. So it seems really clear to me that being in a creative educational environment is the way to fuel my creativity, passion, and gratification. And so I love working with science students, and I love working with creative people. Its a two way Z.V.P.

Carolina Zamora 12/14/2013 Hi, I am an educator and artist. I do what I do to share the joy that I get inhabiting the world of visual art. Students inspire me to question everything I know and ask. Together we shine new lights and share a desire to be creative.

114

David Krofta 11/11/2013 My name is David Krofta. I am a drawer and also mixed sculpture artist.

Magical enterprise acts as guidelines for all its contributors; unconditional love and honesty, absolute legitimate courage, social and community goodness, pure sophisticated fun and elegance.

I also do objects for performance, AKA I make puppets and things. What inspires me to do what I do is (that I like to) see things that are cool, or there are ideas for things that need to be made. I am always really excited trying to figure out ways to make those exist because I think its good when fun things happen. I am also always really happy to try to hold in my mind, as level of satisfaction for myself, ...how to make things that would entertain the people that I care about and whose works that I enjoy. Sometimes I feel like I’m trying to make things (that a lot of my friends and other artists)

SOUL Magical (a brand) SOUL Magical enterprise is a brand, striving to be an empire. It references a combination of intuition driven and exaggerated aesthetics. It lives in web or screen design and claims its existence to be outside the “institution”. It’s extremely genuine in conception and naive in execution. It aims to embody a manifesto and vision which combines Jacques Tati, Charles B. Snyder, Fred Rogers, Barbarella, beavers, and Lisa Frank’s mission statement. Pulling these together, SOUL Magical creates a platform for artists, parents, and kids to engaged in authentic opportunity for all. It asks for openness around exchange and mutually beneficial partnerships between kids and adults. The manifesto for SOUL State of the Art Project

Fig. 32 —The beaver became the mascot for this brand. Beavers are highly sustainable animals and construct and change their ecosystem for themselve and for other species. About

People

Why a Beaver

FUN

Membership

MAGIC

SOUL Magical enterprise outside the institution

WHAT WE BELIEVE! Social and community goodness Unconditional love and honesty Pure sophisticated fun and elegance Absolute legitimate courage

WHO WE ARE! Nadia, Kathryn, Zack and Zena met while escaping the perils of institution. They all exercise the concepts listed above to the fullest in hopes that they incited “Learning as a political movement” in all! As well as being apart of SOUL Magical enterprise, they extend out into the community in other capacities. Nadia is an improv artists and works with Story Pirates to act out kids stories.

Fig. 33 — Mission and vision are highlighted on this page. The who, what, when, and how are answered.

115

Z.V.P.

116

State of the Art Project

117

Pure Imagination, Totally Hacked Possibility Pack (product, brand, & experience)) Adult directed play? We say, NO way! The Totally Hacked Possibility Pack is a product that was designed by Clay Kippen and myself to protest the conventional toy landscape. Our company Pure Imagination, has stemmed from an investigation into current play experiences, where a need was recognized for a new type of building platform. This brand embodies a cool, spirited, inquisitive, challenging and honest essence, one that adapts to the needs of open-ended play. When prompted in their Product, Brand, & Experience class to design a tool for protest, Clay and I took the opportunity to challenge the idea of protest, and adapt their product for a younger audience. The Totally Hacked Possibility Pack, or THPP, addresses play that is dictated by adult designs, and toys that are not gender-neutral. When surveying toy stores, it was obvious that most of the activities designed for kids are prescriptive because they have one intended use. These types of Z.V.P.

products, especially dress-up kits and role playing games do not give enough credit to the incredible imaginations of children, which already create worlds for themselves. The THPP is a platform of interchangeable objects, purpose-built for kids to use in any way they please. Clay and I promise to listen to their needs, and provide toys that allow for the development and expansion of the imagination. To promote qualities of free and creative play within their product, We have chosen materials such as velcro, spandex, wood, wool, and rope to supply textures and monochromatic color providing an honesty of materials and tactility. Diverging from the common polyethylene solution commonly used in toys, the THPP harnesses the essence of the adventure playground movement, Montessori method, and the current studies by Stuart Brown and the National Institute of Play. There is a clear need for more toys to promote the navigation of space with others. Kids have the power to learn through making, and we believe that education and personal development are important aspects of growing up.

Fig. 34 â&#x20AC;&#x201D;Clay Kippen and Myself working on an adjacent project. Clay helped inform and execute the Totally Hack Possibility Pack.

118

Fig. 35 — A slide from a presentation deck. This slide indicates the problematic toy landscape which exist in today’s market.

Fig. 36 — The needs for the problematic toy landscape are stated clearly. These also double as goals and promises to our consumers.

State of the Art Project

119

Fig. 37 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; A slide making clear what our agenda and intentions are for this project.

Fig. 38â&#x20AC;&#x201D; A brand pyramid for Pure Imagination.

Z.V.P.

120

Fig. 39 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Examples of the Adventure Playgrounds which inspired the Pure Imagination Brand and the Totally Hacked Possibility Pack Product.

Fig. 40 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Current on the market toys which set similar goals.

State of the Art Project

121

Z.V.P.

122

State of the Art Project

123

Z.V.P.

124

State of the Art Project

125

Z.V.P.

126

State of the Art Project

127

Z.V.P.

128

State of the Art Project

129

Z.V.P.

130

State of the Art Project

131

Insight Into (collaboration with Beam Center & Allen Riley) On Sunday March 30th, in collaboration with Beam Center, I presented the last workshop of two 6 week long programs. These programs extended further than 12 weeks from the internal view because of the organization, curation, and collaboration prior to and preparatory work. It will extend afterwards as well to continue to nurture these relationships and sustain a partnership with our collaborators. The conceptualization was done in collaboration with a fellow artist Allen Riley and the execution was done in collaboration with 9 artists/engineers. These artists presented a topic they were interested in and explored it with the kids. The weekend workshops were titled “Insight Into _____!”; the artist filling in the blank with the activity or interest they are presenting and exploring with the group. The first 6 week pilot showcased one 3 hour workshop on a different subject each week. \The second round focused on three different designer/artists’ practices. These ran between 2 and 3 weeks long. After the workshops were over, I followed up with the artists for feedback. They were emailed nine questions about their experience. And asked to answer any or all they would like. In the following pages you will find the call for proposals which was sent out, the email requesting feedback, and some of their answers. Z.V.P.

Workshop and their Leaders: Insight Into Pixilation! - Ben Kinsley Insight Into Smart Materials! - Sibel Deren Guler Insight Into Semaphores! - Jessica Langley Insight Into Bismuth! - Ian Charnas Insight Into Music Makey! - Jason Sigel Insight Into Kinetics! - Tim Macken Insight Into Chocolate Bar Design! - Allison Milgrom Insight Into Unleashing Design! - Tim Macken & Christina Perla Insight Into Bag Design! - Kevin Yoo Note: the call for proposal on the right shows dates only for February and March. Insight Into _____! start date was Dec. 2013 and continued through March 2014.

132

State of the Art Project

133

Z.V.P.

134

State of the Art Project

135

Dec. 1st INSIGHT INTO Pixilation! Lead Learner: Ben Kinsley

Dec. 8th INSIGHT INTO Smart Materials! Lead Learner: Sibel Deren Guler

“Pixilation” is a stop motion technique where live actors are used as a frame-byframe subject in an animated film, becoming a kind of living stop-motion puppet. In INSIGHT INTO PIXILATION, we will look at a sampling of classic examples of Pixilation by leading animators, and (using Improv game tactics) create our own collaborative animation. This animation will use props and the young creators simultaneously as puppets, animators, and directors. IMovie will be explored and Digital Cameras will be used, this is an exercise in creative use/reuse and imagination.

In this workshop, students will learn about smart materials and how they can be used to re‐invent everyday objects. Students will be introduced to an array of different state‐change materials and then design and create their own projects using tools and materials provided. Materials: String, Zipties, UV beads, hypercolor fabric, fiber optic cable, scrap fabric and cardboard, LEDs, coincell batteries Tools: Scissors, Glue, Hot‐glue, Hole punch, needle+thread, markers

Bio: Ben Kinsley is an artist and educator. His videos and animations have show at venues such as the Ann Arbor Film Festival, NEMO Film Festival (Paris) MMX Open Art Venue (Berlin), Show Cave (Los Angeles), and Artprojx Cinema (New York). He has taught courses in Electronic Media at Carnegie Mellon University and American University in Washington DC. This past summer he was a Domain Guest at Beam Camp where he led domains on Green Screen performance and Ping Pong.

Z.V.P.

Bio: Deren Guler is the mind behind Invent-abling. She is a maker, tinkerer, designer, and physicist. She has a master’s of Tangible Interaction Design from Carnegie Mellon University and has worked on many educational and community-based projects. She leads workshop at museums, universities and other venues around the world. She is interested in combining different materials, craft techniques, and computational methods to make accessible tools. She created Invent-abling in attempt to fill the gap of low-tech toolkits for children, especially for young girls.

136

Dec. 15th INSIGHT INTO Semaphores! Lead Learner: Jessica Langley “Semaphore” is a physical apparatus for visual signaling. Insight into Semaphores! is a collaborative project in communication and design. Using an abstract language of color and shape, participants will create a personalized lexicon/language of visual signals to be displayed at a distance in order to communicate with passersby or fellow Beam participants. This workshop will be using hand sewing and the sewing machine to fabricate our semaphores! Bio: Jessica Langley is an artist whose work draws from idealized nature photography and Romantic landscape painting, abstracting and obscuring images through a variety of processes and approaches. She has exhibited nationally and internationally at venues such as SPACES in Cleveland, Nathan Larramendy Gallery in Ojai, Denise Bibro Gallery in New York, Parse Gallery in New Orleans, Skaftfell Arts Center in Iceland, La Galería de Comercio in Mexico City, Kallio Kunsthalle Taidehalli in Helskinki, and Askeaton Contemporary Arts in Ireland. Jessica earned her MFA from Vir-

State of the Art Project

ginia Commonwealth University in 2008 and was awarded a J. William Fulbright Grant for research in Iceland from 20082009. She is co-founder of Ortega y Gasset Projects, a cooperative art space in Queens, NY. Jan. 5th INSIGHT INTO Bismuth Crystals! Lead Learner: Ian Charnas How would you like to use a blowtorch to melt metal, and turn the molten metal into amazing multi-colored crystals? Teams will collaborate just like in a real metalsmith shop or materials science laboratory. This workshop will explore the basic process of making Bismuth Crystals and basic techniques of jewelry making. Files, a blowtorch, and cardboard engineering will be tools we will use to talk about science and create together. Bio:Ian Charnas graduated from Case in 2005 with B.S degrees in both computer and mechanical engineering. His work blends art and technology in creatively-themed exhibits and events, including theWorld’s Largest Twin Musical Tesla Coils, a Magical Mustache Mirror, and a Waterfall Swingset. Mr. Charnas and his work have been featured on Wired.

137

com and Wired Magazine, NPR online, Popular Mechanics, IEEE Spectrum, Boing-Boing, Make Magazine, PitchFork, Hack-a-Day, He aims to inspire creativity at think[box] and the belief that you can do anything. Jan. 12th INSIGHT INTO Musical Instrument Design! Lead Learner: Jason Sigel In this workshop, we’ll design an ensemble of musical instruments. Collaborative groups will sketch ideas on paper using conductive graphite. These groups will work together to define and create a variety of samples using a virtual MIDI instrument. A MaKey Makey tool (arduino-based microcontroller) will also be introduced, to map these sounds from the computer to the physical world, allowing a glance into triggering sounds and completing circuits. At the end of the workshop, we will have an ensemble of prototypes, and will improvise some truly original music! Bio: Jason hosts radio at WFMU, where he also oversaw the Free Music Archive website until 2012. He is a master’s candidate at NYU’s Interactive Telecommunications Program and holds a BA in Computer Mu-

Z.V.P.

sic & Multimedia from Brown University. A sound designer and composer for theater productions, Jason is also a multi-instrumentalist and member of three active bands. Jan. 19th INSIGHT INTO Kinetics! Lead Learner: Tim Macken “Kinetics” deals with the effects of forces upon the motions of materials bodies or with changes in a physical system. Everyday we interact with objects, which require our motion. From wheels on a car taking us to school, to a handle on a door knob, down to the pen with one can take notes. Objects all around us move in order to help us accomplish our goals. In this workshop there is a ball which is still, but has movement dreams of its own. This ball wishes to travel from one small table to another located a short distance away, with obstacles in between. It is our job to get it there. Piece of cake, right? Using design techniques we will imagine and prototype ways we will move this ball through the obstacles. This challenge will explore the world of kinetics. Lets make it happen!

138

There is a bucket placed 5 feet off the ground. In small groups, your job is to build a contraption that will make a ping pong ball successfully land inside the bucket. The contraption that you build to complete this task must start under the height of 36 inches, and you may only trigger the contraption with a single action. Through this small challenge, we will explore the world of kinetics. To get a better understanding of kinetic ideas, check out this music video by OKGO called â&#x20AC;&#x153;This too shall pass.â&#x20AC;? Lets make it happen!

Bio: Tim Macken is an industrial designer currently attending Pratt Institute in Brooklyn and is expected to graduate in the spring of 2014. He is particularly passionate about tackling design challenges and hopes to jump into design consulting after graduation.

State of the Art Project

139

Z.V.P.

140

State of the Art Project

141

Z.V.P.

142

State of the Art Project

143

Z.V.P.

144

State of the Art Project

145

Z.V.P.

146

State of the Art Project

147

Fig. 41 — Insight Into Pixalation! with Ben Kinsley.

Fig. 42 — Insight Into Pixalation! with Ben Kinsley.

Z.V.P.

148

Fig. 43 — Insight Into Pixalation! with Ben Kinsley.

Fig. 44 — Insight Into Pixalation! with Ben Kinsley.

State of the Art Project

149

Fig. 45 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Insight Into Smart Materials! with Sibel Deren Guler.

Fig. 46 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Insight Into Smart Materials! with Sibel Deren Guler.

Z.V.P.

150

Fig. 47â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Insight Into Smart Materials! with Sibel Deren Guler.

Fig. 48 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Insight Into Smart Materials! with Sibel Deren Guler.

State of the Art Project

151

Fig. 49 — Insight Into Semaphores! with Jessica Langley

Fig. 50 — Insight Into Semaphores1 with Jessica Langley

Z.V.P.

152

Fig. 51 — Insight Into Semaphores! with Jessica Langley

Fig. 52 — Insight Into Semaphores! with Jessica Langley

State of the Art Project

153

Fig. 53 —Insight Into Bismuth! with Ian Charnas

Fig. 54 — Insight Into Bismuth! with Ian Charnas

Z.V.P.

154

Fig. 55 — Insight Into Bismuth! with Ian Charnas

Fig. 56 —Insight Into Bismuth! with Ian Charnas

State of the Art Project

155

Fig. 57 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Insight Into Musical Instrument Design! with Jason Sigel

Fig. 58 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Insight Into Musical Instrument Design! with Jason Sigel

Z.V.P.

156

Fig. 59 — Insight Into Muscial Instrument Design! with Jason Sigel

Fig. 60 — Insight Into Muscial Instrument Design! with Jason Sigel

State of the Art Project

157

Fig. 61 — Insight Into Kinetics! With Tim Macken

Fig. 62 — Insight Into Kinetics! With Tim Macken

Z.V.P.

158

Fig. 63 — Insight Into Kinetics! With Tim Macken

Fig. 64 — Insight Into Kinetics! With Tim Macken

State of the Art Project

159

Z.V.P.

160

State of the Art Project

161

Z.V.P.

162

State of the Art Project

163

Documentation System Map

Z.V.P.

164

State of the Art Project

165

Science Dreams, Product Realities (a speculative story) Science Dreams, Product Realities; A speculative story She sits, she waits, they are aware of her block. Green, yellow, turquoise. It changes quickly. She struggles with what is in front of her. Her current state is not enough. Her ability to be flexible is lacking. She canâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t find the answer. She needs help and it is visible. Green, yellow, turquoise. Someone approaches from behind. Short, young, alive. Alive in ways that she is lacking, and they know this. She recognizes the young boy from 3 weeks ago. The turquoise fades into pink and becomes iridescent. She is comforted by the youth, encouraging words are given but directions are minimal. The young boy motions for her to get up and follow. They walk down the aisle together. Many others are scattered throughout the spaces on their floor. Z.V.P.

Some are working in groups in low chairs and others are sitting individually at their desks. The youth picks up a couple more of the older workers who are showing similar signs. Green, yellow, turquoise. Green, yellow, turquoise. Its visible they all need help. They walk together down a long corridor. Some make small talk about their day. Others are quiet and withdrawn at the moment. The young boy has accumulated 15 and slowly approaches a door marked PTT with the group. He motions for everyone to gather in an open space right outside the door. Olivia has been here before, the emblem on the door is familiar. The iridescence starts to sparkle. She looks back and she sees Kevin, Cecilia, and Shawn, colleagues of hers. The rest are newbies, she notices that the pinks are showing signs of iridescence and the iridescence are sparkling collectively. The young boy introduces himself informally and PTT to the group, stating the benefits for having PTT in the office and how his duties relate to these new practices. He gives a rough back story on the founder and some brief information about the room they are going to enter. Right before the sparkling group is led into the room he gives them instructions and a few rules. They are to hang up their coats on the rack provided, there should be a suitable amount of hangers.

166

There are no shoes to be worn in the space, if they must, shoes should be placed on their hands. Movement is important in keeping the music going. So they are encouraged to dance or they can find jump ropes on hooks placed on the north wall. They are to eat the cupcakes on the table in the far corner, as a treat for today’s PTT guests. They are told not to talk about work when in the PTT Room. And they are to try and enjoy their time there. The group’s sparkles get brighter and brighter, and smiles start to erupt on their faces. The young boy opens the door and ushers everyone in. He smiles and says,”Welcome to Play Together Today” no go have some fun.

State of the Art Project

167

Proto Personas

Z.V.P.

168

State of the Art Project

169

Z.V.P.

170

State of the Art Project

171

Cybernetic Systems

Z.V.P.

172

State of the Art Project

173

Z.V.P.

174

State of the Art Project

175

Z.V.P.

176

State of the Art Project

177

Z.V.P.

178

State of the Art Project

179

Z.V.P.

180

State of the Art Project

181

Z.V.P.

182

State of the Art Project

183

Z.V.P.

184

State of the Art Project

185

Z.V.P.

186

State of the Art Project

187

Z.V.P.

188

Saturday Art School & The Feral Educators (social & project art practices)

State of the Art Project

189

Z.V.P.

190

State of the Art Project

191

Z.V.P.

192

State of the Art Project

193

Z.V.P.

194

State of the Art Project

195

Z.V.P.

196

State of the Art Project

197

Z.V.P.

198

Research

State of the Art Project

199

Z.V.P.

200

Research

State of the Art Project

201

Books

Z.V.P.

202

State of the Art Project

203

Books

Z.V.P.

204

State of the Art Project

205

Books

Z.V.P.

206

State of the Art Project

207

Interviews

Ian and I met during college in Cleveland Ohio. Ian went to school for Computer and Mechanical Engineering but spent a good amount of time at the Cleveland Art Institute. manages the Think Box, an invention cenIan ter at Case Western Reserve., which provides public access to over a million dollars of highend digital fabrication as well as traditional fabrication machines. Ian is also a contributer to a tesla coil project and the Rain Swing.

â&#x20AC;&#x153;takes all these people to make the real world happen x Ian Charnas

Z.V.P.

208

Kim and I met in Portland Maine. Courtaney Finn (then the Curator of Art In General and now the Curator of Aspen Museum of Art) introduced us. Kim is the Co-founder of Motor Park, and on going project wit Lisi Raskin. She is also a painter and teaching artist at The Drawing Center and Socrates Sculpture Park. She works with all ages in learning environments.

State of the Art Project

“it’s problematic to continue institutions that are build and need others to be in suffering” x Kim Charles Kay 209

Interviews

Jim Bader is the executive director of the Leonard Gelfand STEM Center at Case Western Reserve University. In this capacity, he has overall strategic and operational responsibility for the Center’s staff, programs, and execution of its mission. hrough the work of the Center, he draws upon the expertise of faculty, staff, and students in the College of Arts and Sciences and the Case School of Engineering to design and implement exemplary and high impact precollege STEM initiatives that increase the number and diversity of students pursuing study in the STEM disciplines at Case Western Reserve University and elsewhere.

“It’s challenging because teachers are not interested in inquiry and the majority of them are not going to change” x James Bader

Z.V.P.

210

Jim and I were introduced through Ian Charnas.

Chris and I were introduced through Ian Charnas. Chris Dickey is a bio chemical engineer in undergraduate school at Case Western Reserve. He volunteers and mentors high school students for the First Robotic Competition.

State of the Art Project

“Professors are too well versed to pass on knowledge...I don’t want to loose the ability to communicate.” x Chris Dickey 211

Interviews

Petrushka and I were introduced through Courtaney Finn. They attended California College of Art in San Fransisco together and both received a MA in Curatorial Practice. Petrushka Bazin Larsen is an independent curator and arts administrator committed to finding new ways of making art more accessible. At The Laundromat Project, she works with artists to present engaging art programs in unconventional spaces like laundromats, libraries, sidewalks, and parks. As an independent curator, Bazin Larsen has organized exhibitions at The Kitchen, NURTUREart, along New York City’s 14th Street for Art in Odd Places, among other venues.”

“Kids are often the conduit to which adults participate” x Petrushka Bazin Larsen

Z.V.P.

212

Emilie Batlz and I met at the Pratt Institute. I was working there and she was visiting an old instructor of hers. We then reconnected when I decided to pursue my Masters Degree at SVA Products of Design. Emilie teaches at Products of Design and the Pratt Institute. She currently is designing and facilitating creative workshops on sensory technology between designers, technologists and cultural influences for MUZSE, a partnership between Intel and Milk Studios that promotes the development of content and relationships at the intersection of fashion, technology and culture.

â&#x20AC;&#x153;enter or disrupt didactic education, codify it through playâ&#x20AC;? x Emilie Baltz

State of the Art Project

213

Interviews

In the second semester Spring 2013, Brian Cohen gave a talk at SVA Products of Design about Beam Camp. Since that day Brian and I have been in collaboration with Beam Camp and Beam Center. Brian spent 18 years as a marketing executive in the music industry. In 2004, he left his role as Senior Vice President of Marketing for Elektra Records to pursue his dream of starting a summer camp. Inspired by his formative camp experiences at Lighthouse Arts and Music Camp in Pine Grove, PA, he started Beam Camp with Danny Kahn.

â&#x20AC;&#x153;create a culture where kids care about opportunity and they take itâ&#x20AC;? x Brian Cohen

Z.V.P.

214

During the IDEO “Creative Confidence” book launch Q & A, Erica asked a question which had been on my mind throughout the panel. I had the pleasure of interviewing Erica. Erica Kohl-Arenas is an Assistant Professor at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management, and Urban Policy and is the first recipient of The New School award in Outstanding Achievements in Diversity and Social Justice Teaching. She earned her PhD from the Social and Cultural Studies in Education program at the University of California, Berkeley (2010), an MS in Community Development from the University of California, Davis (1999), and a BA in Sociology from Reed College (1991). State of the Art Project

“to be human is to create an act upon the world” x Erica KohlArenas 215

Interviews

Kyla Fullenwider lead a class in the Products of Design Department which centered on Social Innovation. Kyla Fullenwider is a social designer, educator, and entrepreneur who works to improve the quality of life of communities. She has designed and implemented other programs and initiatives with the City of New York, the City of Los Angeles, the City of Baltimore, the Cooper Hewitt Design Museum, UCLA, Etsy, GOOD, and the Legacy Foundation among others. A former Fellow in Social Design at the Maryland Institute College of Art, her work has been featured in the NY Times, LA Times, NY Magazine, and Fast Company and in case studies authored by the Harvard School of Business and the Annie E. Casey Foundation. Her writing has been Z.V.P.

published by Metropolis Magazine, Next City, GOOD Magazine, and Outpost Journal, among others. Kyla speaks and has lectured at schools and institutions including the Smithsonian American Art Museum, Columbia University, the University of Pennsylvania, and the Ashoka Future Forum.

“it’s problematic to continue institutions that are build and need others to be in suffering” x 216

photo agency VII, and as National Director of Social Engagement for Design for Good at the AIGA. He is currently an Advisory Board Member of MindLab, a Danish cross-governmental innovation unit which involves citizens and businesses in developing new solutions for society. He is a faculty member in the Products of Design masters program at SVA.

Manuel lead a workshops at Products of Design Department in partnership with the Camden Coalition. I worked with Manuel on this project. As the CEO of Zago, Manuel Toscano helps his clients bridge business and design by combining an expertise in innovation with compelling visual storytelling. In 1996 he joined New York design firm Zago. Under his leadership the studio broadened its scope of services, leveraging design, visual media, and digital innovation to reach target audiences and foster environmental, cultural, and social change. Zagoâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s clients include Fortune 500 companies, international nonprofits, start-ups and global brands. In addition to his role at Zago, he served in the communications advisory board at Human Rights Watch, on the board of the State of the Art Project

217

Interviews

the Rocket Projects grant funded by the Charlotte Street Foundation and the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, and a United States Presidential Scholars Program Teacher Recognition Award. Warren is Co-Creator/Co-Director of the faux public access television show â&#x20AC;&#x153;Whoop Dee Dooâ&#x20AC;?. Whoop Dee Doo is a traveling, artist-led project that creates ambitious installations and live performances internationally, generally through universities, festivals, arts organizations, and museums. Our programming heavily engages the immediate community of the organizations with which we partner, and we work closely with underserved youth groups to research, conceive and create our projects. Our process emphasizes collaboration, encourages respect for diversity, and seeks to initiate a cross-generational and cross-cultural dialogue.

Jaimie and I were introduced through Thu Tran. Her projects are endlessly inspirational and can be found later in this texts. Jaimie Warren is a photographer and performance artist living in Kansas City, MO and Brooklyn, NY. She is the recipient of the 2014 Baum Award for an Emerging American Photographer, and has had a solo artist monograph published by Aperture. She has exhibited solo projects at The Hole and Higher Pictures (NYC), the Kemper Museum (Kansas City, MO) and the Miami Dade College Museum of Art (Miami, FL). Her work has been featured in numerous publications including the New York Times, i-D, the Huffington Post, New York Magazine, Paper, and Dazed & Confused. Warren is a recipient of the Lighton International Artist Exchange Program grant, Z.V.P.

Whoop Dee Doo has created commissioned projects and events for organizations including the Smart Museum (Chicago), Deitch Projects (New York), The Kemper Museum for Contemporary Art (Kansas City), Loyal Gallery (Sweden), the Time-Based Arts Festival/Portland Institute of Contemporary Art (Portland, OR), the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts (Philadelphia, PA), Luminaria (San Antonio, TX), City Arts/Maryland Institute College of Art (Baltimore, MD), POP Montreal and DHC Contemporary Art (Montreal), and Miami Dade College and LegalArt (Miami, FL).

218

middle class womenâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s lives. I was eager to speak with him again to explore ways this could apply to non profit arts organizations working with kids and artists, and their networks. This phone call lasted approximately 30 mins because both Matt and myself were on time constraints. I had prepared a couple of questions to ask within this time frame. I asked Matt to explain the office dynamics at Very Nice, and what internal bureaucracy there is, if any. The current office is all managerial positions, which include 7 people. The space accommodates those 7 comfortably and being a young company, everyone is content. The managing of all production is done in house, hence everyone in house being managerial. They have 1 large pool of resources & employees and the projects are split into 2 buckets. One of the buckets is for profit and the other is pro-bono work. The large pool of employees change roles and some serve as volunteers on one project but are paid while working on another. Notes regarding phone meeting with Matthew Manos of Very Nice on Feb 7th at 4pm: I reached out to Matt because of his company Very Nice, a for profit design consultancy which uses a business model which allows them to dedicate 50% of their efforts to pro bono design. He has just released a book called How to Give Half of your Work Away for Free. This book gives access to the business structures his company uses to sustain the pro bono model. I was very excited to meet Matt a couple of weeks ago at the Center for Social Innovation. We spoke about a variety of topics from the release of his book, to the history of philanthropy and its roots in upper State of the Art Project

Dynamics change depending the type of work, paid or volunteer. When it comes to project time lines, incentives, and ownership/flexibility the paid and volunteer work is managed differently. Matt and I discussed these differences and why they are applied to these different buckets. The paid dynamic is very simple, someone is hired specifically for a task, there is a firm timeline and requirements are met. When speaking about volunteers incentives and reciprocity starts to get more complicated. This I find extremely interesting. When doing work for free, or when exchanging alternative currency such as social capital, there is an exchange, but how is this monitored, what is the feedback and how do we know its working? Matt and I explored this

219

through the model they use at Very Nice. In order for volunteers to work they have to be given some flexibility, the volunteer has to stay engaged and a way to accomplish this is making them part of the process of managing their time. The volunteer experience has to be a positive one for the individual or group to want to participate and continue to work in this manner again. Continuing to keep a genuine excitement is also important. What i didnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t ask but comes to mind, is identifying those physical or non physical touch points. These could be emails, phone calls, contracts, forms, or other ways to engage a contract. I also wonder what are ways that excitement is carried. Skype meetings, availability to chat through difficulties one might be having on a project, or a certificate for a job well done. Do people earn points, or is it invisible and if it is invisible does the accumulation only happen by the individual for the individual? I did not take away a feeling of competitive or gamifying this system from Matt, but believe that Very Nice is drawing from the Purpose Economy; people who are trying to place meaning in their lives through putting meaning into their work.

The biggest takeaway from this conversations is that non profit art spaces may have created the alternative structure of business and thrive on them currently. This hypothesis makes sense, because of the constraints that a non profit is up against in monetary currency, that they would work to find alternative ways to do business. This in turn would allow them to continue to create and maintain value in the work outside of a market that depends on monetary capital. This value is not monetary but contributes to the community within and its outlying boundaries. I realized through this system, that my perspective in the dose i was ready to intervene, may not be what is needed. It also made me consider that others maybe need my perspective much more. I concluded that I still want to work in this space, and will look at the problem area from a different angle so that my involvement is a â&#x20AC;&#x153;newâ&#x20AC;? contribution.

We discussed where the majority of his clients fell in terms of subject area and mission and specifically who Very Nice works with in the social sector. I was very surprised to learn that Very Nice works with Public policy, Health Initiatives, and Human Rights organizations, but is a small percentage of their business. And that very rarely do they work with Non profit art sector organizations. When inquiring deeper into why this is so, Matt told me these places exist on alternative structures already an are well versed in working within these constraints.

Matt is a neo-philanthropist, creative director, and author that is dedicated to disrupting the economic models of service-oriented business. Matthew began his freelance design career at the age of 16, which is the same year he took on his first pro-bono client, and launched his first company. Three years later, he founded verynice, a global design and innovation consultancy that dedicates over 50% of its efforts toward free services for non-profit organizations. Matthew has helped build 350+ brands in every sector and industry across the globe, and his studio works with a diverse clientele that range from Fortune 500 companies to small local shops. As of 2013, verynice has also provided over $1,000,000 worth of pro-bono design and consulting services in 40+ countries spanning 6 continents to benefit 250+ organizations thanks to a volunteer staff of 275+ practioners located around the

Z.V.P.

220

world. Now with offices in Los Angeles and New York, the company is on track to donate the equivalent of over $10,000,000 worth of pro-bono services by 2020. Notable clients of verynice have included UNICEF, NASA, MTV Networks, NRDC, Edison International, Facebook, Kaiser Permanente, and Disney Imagineering.

State of the Art Project

221

Interviews

Sarah co taught, Design Research and Integration with Ingrid Fetell, a class sponsored by ebay and IDEO. Sarah Lidgus is a writer and strategist from IDEO’s New York studio. Whether it’s print, audio, or film, storytelling has always been core to Sarah’s professional work and personal explorations. Sarah has worked in industries spanning from fashion to financial services, and has crafted stories in collaboration with American Express, Eileen Fisher, and Harvard Business Digital. Since joining IDEO in 2007, Sarah has earned two IDSA awards and her work has been featured in publications like The Boston Globe, Fast Company, and The New York Times.

“bridge your language gap and show your impact” x Sarah Lidgus

Z.V.P.

222

Carolina and I met during my tenure at the Pratt Institute teaching ceramics. She was a undergraduate sculpture major. Through this process Carolina has been an immensely helpful and supportive friend and mentor. I asked Carolina to be an unofficial thesis advisor. Her expertise is in experiential learning environments. Carolina is the Education Coordinator for the Learning Through Art program at the Guggenheim Museum. In the photo above she is in special training for “The Touchy Subject” lead by contemporary artist, Carmen Papalia. Carolina is also a founding member and curator for the Poetry Club space in Brooklyn, New York. She is an artist, educator, and life long learner.

“Institutions loose flexibility” x Carolina Zamora

State of the Art Project

223

Inspirations

auditorium with stadium seating. When creating the floor plan of the installation, one of our objectives was to subvert the original or intended use of the space. Our goal was to undermine the implicit authority of the presenter’s podium as well as transform the space beyond its commonplace use in hopes to disorient students and faculty who regularly use the space for its designed purpose. Theme

Whoop Dee Doo Projects Text which follows is taken from Whoop Dee Doo’s Website; http://whoopdeedoo.t v/education /ar tist-statement/ Whoop Dee Doo projects are directly reflective of the specific social, financial, and cultural environments within which we are working. As artists, our approach is to understand the constraints, limitations, and opportunities within our project environment and allow theses constraints to serve in the conception and creative development of the final project and performance.

When we begin a project, often one of the first creative decisions we make is to set a theme for the show. Whoop Dee Doo themes have varied from simply “Anatomy” or “Water” to the more complex, like our 2012 “Science and Royalty” themed show at Gallery CA in Baltimore, MD. In our process, setting a theme creates a common ground for the individuals, artists, and performers to connect and collaborate within. In a recent example, our theme for our project titled Frigerator Follies in Cincinnati was “Landscape”. Within the auditorium, we created both an interior space and an exterior landscape. The stadium seating was used to create the illusion of depth you might associate with landscape painting. We created scenery and props that varied in scale, placing the smaller ones toward the rear of the auditorium. From a specific vantage point in the center of the auditorium’s stage, also the typical position of presenter’s podium, when one looked “out” at the stadium seating an illusion of great depth was created using simple principles of linear and atmospheric perspective. Materials

For a recent project titled Frigerator Follies (sic) at the University of Cincinnati in 2013, our exhibition space was a four hundred-seat

We aim to use common basic materials in innovative, unique, and unexpected ways. As with all the creative components of a Whoop Dee Doo production, our vision is to be resourceful and to create art without discrimination. We aim to use these recognizable materials

Z.V.P.

224

Site – Specific Installation

State of the Art Project

225

and approachable processes so that artists and non-artist alike, of all ages, can participate in the creative process. We pride ourselves in the multi-media effects we are able to achieve through this experimental transformation of common materials. Collaboration Full production of a Whoop Dee Doo installation and performance requires the talents of many artists and volunteers. We consider the experience of everyone working on a specific project and allow their interests, ideas, and personality to influence the details of the show. During pre-production we aim to highlight and utilize the strengths of every individual working on the project and then allow the installation and script to change and be refined in the moment throughout production. Overall, a Whoop Dee Doo installation is a lead by directors who thoughtfully match the skills and interests of a multitude of artists with varying degrees of skill to create cohesive and thoughtful sets, props and costumes. The environments and collaborations we create are catered to each situation to match the needs of the organization we work with, the artists we bring to lead the structure of the process, the youth we teach and create with, the community and performers who alter and enhance our artistic decisions, and the audience that participates in the final production. It is a collaboration to the fullest extent of our abilities, which is what makes the experience so strange, so unique, and so exceptional.

nity, cultivates ideas for potential collaborations, and ideally sheds new light on the diversity of their immediate community. Whoop Dee Dooâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s projects range in scale and levels of collaboration with and between performers. There are two basic structures we have been following, which are tailored more specifically upon our arrival. Our first form of performance is a full variety show, which focuses on presenting as wide and diverse of an array of performers as possible, paired with skits, contests and dancing. With this structure, the audience plays a large role in the outcome and content of the live show, and our youth group focuses more on the conceptualization and creation of our installations. These surreal environments create an equal playing field, as the community participants are immersed in an eccentric and unfamiliar, yet welcoming and vibrant setting. They are sharing a community experience and fully engrossed in a high-energy variety show featuring wild amalgamations such as American Indian ceremonial dancing, vegetable-eating contests, live faux amputations, R&B singers, clogging troupes, UFO lectures, and moulage demos by the National Guard followed by disco dancing competitions, or other similarly bizarre and unique experiences.

Whoop Dee Doo artists and our college students or youth groups research performers within the local communities of where we are traveling to, sometimes up to six months in advance. This practice gives us a greater sense of the commu-

A more involved and direct collaboration is structured with one or more performance group and a youth workshop group. The goal is to bring together all participants in a more prolonged and intimate collaboration that significantly but respectfully alters the standard approach of the performers. This process includes presentations from the performance group/s providing historical and cultural context to their work. Whoop Dee Doo and the youth group work with the performers to make decisions on costuming, tone, and setting that create a new context for the performance as well as providing a new audience.

Z.V.P.

226

Performance

Conclusion Upon completion of a Whoop Dee Doo production, our collaborators and audience leave the show having witnessed and/or participated in a diverse exhibition of visual art and performance created and executed entirely without pretention. Through our projects, Whoop Dee Doo is creating successful community and contemporary art that truly engages and is meaningful to the populations in which we work, and is simultaneously on par with successful and challenging contemporary art. Whoop Dee Doo strives to breaks down stereotypes and barriers between age, gender, culture and sub-culture, and to form and foster unique collaborations between unlikely pairings of community members, which ultimately blossom into exceptional and meaningful interactions. This chaotic mix creates an unexpected and endearing experience that invites a cross-generational and cross-cultural dialogue.

State of the Art Project

227

Inspirations The Center for Urban Pedagogy (CUP) is a nonprofit organization that uses design and art to improve civic engagement. CUP projects demystify the urban policy and planning issues that impact our communities, so that more individuals can better participate in shaping them.

and policymakers, and our staff. Together we take on complex issuesâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;from the juvenile justice system to zoning law to food accessâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;and break them down into simple, accessible, visual explanations. The tools we create are used by organizers and educators all over New York City and beyond to help their constituents better advocate for their own community needs.

We believe that increasing understanding of how these systems work is the first step to better and more diverse community participation. CUP projects are collaborations of art and design professionals, community-based advocates

Z.V.P.

228

Fig. 65 — Center For Urban Pedagogy’s Staff.

State of the Art Project

229

Inspirations

The Laundromat Project believes art, culture, and engaged imaginations can change the way people see their world, open them up to new ideas, and connect them with their neighbors. When artists have the opportunity to build and contribute their unique skills and perspectives to the needs of their neighborhoods, they can be invaluable assets in furthering community wellbeing. When the skills and strategies for igniting creativity are made broadly available to everyday people and purposefully applied as tools for visioning a new and better world, these can be powerful forces for positive, transformative change. We know we have been successful when, over time, our neighborsâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;artists and everyday people, newcomers and old-timers, individually and collectivelyâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;become more involved in the civic and cultural affairs of their communities, feel more deeply connected to the places and people where they live and work, and bring a sense of creativity to community concerns.

Z.V.P.

230

State of the Art Project

231

“When doing art in Public Space, there

is nothing more beautiful and more persuasive than to proceed from Art as Art. And by insisting on the notion of Art, doors are open for the other, open to encounter what the other does not know and does not want. Precisely because Art can achieve something which one does not want. This is what is unique about art, and philosophy. Therefore I do not distinguish between a person who could be a ‘receptive participant’ and the person ‘hanging around’. Not making a difference can only be justified in regard to the principle of Equality – which demands making no difference in regard to all differences. It is not always easy to insist upon this, but if I resolutely keep to it, this assertion can lead to miraculous and enchanting moments, which - to me - are the most sublime and beautiful moments in my work.” Z.V.P.

232

x Thomas Hirschorn

State of the Art Project

233

Z.V.P.

234

State of the Art Project

235

Inspirations

space and the collaboration of residents, questioned and confronted the ideas of authorship. Hirschhorn called it a project of “presences and production”, he referred to this as a rejection of the term “participatory artwork” and used this to describe his physical impression on the site. His daily physical presence created a “noble task” for him to claim responsibility for the piece and the impact it has on the residents. This is a nice sentiment. It tells us, that the work Hirschhorn is pursuing is of a serious nature. He understand the temporality the work brings, along having the awareness to question and address the impact it has on the residents. “Such an important decision can only be made after a long process of fieldwork, it cannot be made by an institution or an administration, its’ an artistic decision and such, has to be out of of a process, this process is fieldwork.”

In the summer and fall of 2013 an artist/ practitioner’s created a work in a public space produced by the Dia Art Foundation. Thomas Hirschhorn created a monument to Antonio Gramsci, a Marxist Theorist at the Forest Housing Projects in the Bronx. The duration of this project on site was from July 1st to September 15th and open everyday. In the center of the Forest Houses a daily schedule was held including; children’s class, newspaper highlighting one tenant a day, a radio station, lectures, and workshops. Weekly programing consisted of theater, events, field trips, and open microphone. Hirschhorn invited and offered lectures on Gramsci himself by philosophers from around the world. The piece which involved public Z.V.P.

236

State of the Art Project

237

Z.V.P.

238

State of the Art Project

239

Z.V.P.

240

State of the Art Project

241

Z.V.P.

242

State of the Art Project

243

Z.V.P.

244

State of the Art Project Transforming Local Businesses into Learning Laboratories

Z.V.P. State of the Art Project

245 245

Z.V.P.

246

â&#x20AC;&#x153;the most memorable and celebrated thesis projects are nearly always indepth explorations of a reallife exampleâ&#x20AC;? x John Thackera

State of the Art Project

247

Z.V.P.

248

State of the Art Project

249

Z.V.P.

250

State of the Art Project

251

Z.V.P.

252

State of the Art Project Revisiting prior research and experience I knew the essence of the work could be turned into an actionable design intervention. The essence was clear; craft in relationships and craft in making together. In the previous months of this thesis it was materializing into a service which helped artist connect to organizations working with kids. This service was provided to make the barrier of entry easier for these opportunities, and allow for more access. I found difficulty defining the term artist and practitioner even when introducing a lexicon. It appeared that my net was cast too broadly. The essence needed a problem to sit on. A problem which would create a context to start the design process over again. This context came after a series of meetings and rediscovered research. In January I skyped with John Thackara. We looked over my work. He confirmed the assumption myself and others had. The email is included in this book, as it made clear that I needed to find an individual or a group to partner with, something real and happening now. That same month, I volunteered to help with an Arts N Parts event. This event was also a chance to State of the Art Project

discuss my thesis. I created conversation cards to get a better handle on attendeeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s. These cards ask questions about motives

Fig. 65 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Conversation cards above at Active Activities, an event hosted by Arts in Parts.

253

Fig. 66 — A contract

Fig.67 — Arts in Pars in action located in Rockaway Beach, New York.

Z.V.P.

254

Fig. 68 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Rockaway Taco during an Arts in Parts Benefit.

and understanding in learning environments. Heather Kramer and Ceci de Corral live and work running a project in the Rockaways called Arts N Parts. Arts N Parts is a summer camp and after school program which promotes creating community. During this event, I met Andrew Field. Andrew and I had a conversation in regards to his capacity to hire teens. An-

Fig. 70 â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Andrew Field, owner and operator of Rockaway taco.

State of the Art Project

drew is the owner and operator of Rockaway Taco. This moment excited me, and I was interested in learning more about the role an employer (mentor) could play in a teens development and on a community. Testimonials and first hand experiences are very powerful. In the following weeks, I tried to get in touch with Andrew to follow up, and did so successfully but only for another chat. I videoed an interview with Andrew where he described the impact working with local teens had on his taco shack and on him. Shortly after meeting with Andrew, I was sitting at my local coffee shop reading the New York Times. I encountered an article on the front page which spoke about minimum wage workers. Personal stories were told, along with alarming statistics. These numbers included the average age of the minimum wage worker, along with education history. This problem is a cause for huge concern for our economy. It was the problem i

255

Fig. 71 —Center for Economic Policy Research, http://www9.georgetown.edu/grad/gppi/hpi/cew/pdfs/FullReport.pdf The New York Times, Greenhouse, Steven. “Low-Wage Workers Are Finding Poverty Harder to Escape.” The New York Times 18 Mar. 2014, Economy sec.: n. pag. New York Times. 18 Mar. 2014. Web. 18 Mar. 2014.

Z.V.P.

256

was looking for. There was/is a problem. According to the Center of Economic Policy Research for Georgetown, there are less teens entering the workforce than ever before. From this report the statistics show there are few to no teenagers between the ages of 16-19 in our current workforce making minimum wage. And this doesnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t mean they are making 20 an hour. These jobs have been filled by people between the ages of 25-35 with some post-secondary education. This makes one wonder what is happening in the larger educational system. Our teens do not have access to skilled jobs. We are streamlining them straight to college. The only place we as society are educating our youth are through the large engine of the institution. The opportunity was clear, create pathways to skilled jobs. Offer alternative ways to learn. These moments

State of the Art Project

of learning could be community oriented, and would involve mentorship. The objective is to help young people understand their own capacity so they can help us reframe questions around their education. Teen and adults can come together to learn and work in a few ways. They come together at home. This has innate hierarchies and there is less autonomy for the teen. They come together at school, but in this context there are many challenges which reformers have been fighting for decades. There are also after-school programs and alternative areas. The people who run these are dedicated. I am involved with these and enjoy participating. Using cues from the nonprofit model, we will apply techniques and focus on the local business. An apprenticeship is a learn and earn model, which provides the scaffolding a teen may need. It is mentorship,

257

Teens and Adults Meet

Z.V.P.

258

State of the Art Project

259

Teens and Adults Meet

Z.V.P.

260

State of the Art Project

261

Fig. 71 — Source: Department of Labor, German Feral Statistics Office, World Bank

and allows for real world application of a trade. This has the potential for the teen to understand themselves as a team member and understand a larger context. The apprenticeship model celebrates choice, anatomy, and collaboration. The Research Apprenticeship models are not new innovations. They have history, and in places like Germany are widely used. An article published in the Wall Street Journal asks why apprenticeship models are in decline, if they aid in closing the skill gap? It sites that “apprenticeship model helps us show people there’s a career path.” According to The U.S. Department of Labor, and German Federal Statistics Office, the United States has 285,041 apprentices to Germany’s 1,423,000. Brad Neese, the director of Apprenticeship Carolina, a program of South Carolina Technical College System reports, “employers are seeing a real lack of applicability in terms of skill level from college graduates.” And according to the Labor Department, formal programs that combine on-the-job learning with mentorships and classroom education fell 40% in the U.S. between 2003 and 2013.74 Why is 74 Webber, Lauren. “Apprenticeships Help Close the Skills

Z.V.P.

“It’s a great model for transferring skills from one generation to the next” x John Ladd this happening? And what are programs in New York City area which are leading Teenagers to these opportunities? The investigation lead to a population of students called Over Aged and Under Credited Youth. These were students who are currently enrolled in a Transfer School in New York City. The students as categorized were over the age of the typical high school student yet under credited. They range in ages 15 to 19. Many are behind in credits and some have dropped out because of personal circumstances, but had persevered and enrolled themselves back in school to get a degree. Transfer Schools have personalized small classroom settings and help students with college and career options. They are full time highs schools which designed to re-engage students who have dropped out or fallen behind. They offer support in areas of academics, counseling, college preparation, job and career Gap. So Why Are They in Decline?” The Wall Street Journal. N.p., 27 Apr. 2014. Web. 29 Apr. 2014. <http://online.wsj. com/news/articles/SB10001424052702303978304579473 501943642612>.

262

development, and paid internships. There are sixteen transfer schools in Brooklyn and forty eight across the five boroughs. Included for reference in this text is a list of these transfer schools in the five boroughs. Another opportunity for aged and under credited youth to finish or catch in high school are through YABCs or Young Adult Borough Centers. These differ as they accommodate late afternoon and evening programs. They are designed to serve the older population of this group, ones who are in their fifth year of high school. These students might be on the verge of dropping out because they are behind or have other responsibilities that make attendance during daytime hours difficult. These students are usually between the ages of 1721. There are nine located in Brooklyn and twenty three total in the five boroughs. In this text there is also a list of these organization for reference. Both of these programs engage in the Learning to Work initiative from the DOE. This is lead through YABCs and transfer schools for youth to develop skills to graduate high school and find employment. The program is for the teens to expand their knowledge of careers and also secure themselves with paid internships. When participating in the LTW programs, teens are able to receive support and counseling, college preparation such as fairs and workshops, and career development. The programs are ran by individuals in the schools and YABCs who monitor and continue to keep in contact with the placement of the internships and the process. The internships are paid, as the DOE helps subsidy the wage. I have included the requirement and assessment sheet for more in depth information of this program and what it aims to achieve.

State of the Art Project

I turned to Tom Pendleton of New York City’s Department of Education. Tom is The Deputy Executive Director of Career and Work Readiness Office of Postsecondary. He is primarily in charge of internship programs, like ones described above. It was great to speak with him, and hear what he had to say about the future of the DOE’s involvement. Apparently the Obama Administration had just given a 4 million dollar grant to New Yorks Department of Education to be used in preparing kids for the jobs of tomorrow. Tom was very open about his career and the work being doing in his department. He was also very knowledgeable about on the ground happenings, and where the weak links in the system could be. Coordinators work with 50 or so teens, and providing support and infrastructure for that many people can be taxing. The weight of this can cause for quick burnout or if it becomes to much and there aren’t others involved it can collapse. He was interested in understanding why i was pushing for physical making based practices and invited me to continue the conversation. Something

“Coordinators of these programs at highschools do not have enough support or infrastructure” x Tom Pendleton 263

Z.V.P.

264

State of the Art Project

265

Z.V.P.

266

State of the Art Project

267

Fact

SHEET

New York Youth Works Information for Youth

New York Youth Works: Returning in 2014 The highly successful New York Youth Works Program, which assists young people in finding a job is coming back beginning in 2014.

And, fit into any of these categories: • 18 years old, no longer in school, without a high school diploma, GED certificate or high school equivalency diploma

In 2012, the New York Youth Works program was very successful in connecting thousands of youth to jobs across New York State. A total of 1,270 New York businesses hired 12,866 at risk youth.

• A veteran

Due to its success in 2012, the legislature and Governor Andrew M. Cuomo have re-authorized the New York Youth Works program. It began again on January 1, 2014 and will continue for four program years concluding on December 31, 2018. Am I eligible? You are eligible if you are: • 16 to 24 years old and unemployed (youth ages 16 -17 must be in school or attending classes to earn their high school equivalency diploma and need permission from a parent or guardian) • Living in one of these areas of New York State*: City of: New York Utica Buffalo Rochester Syracuse New Rochelle Town of: Brookhaven

Mount Vernon Yonkers Schenectady Albany White Plains

• A member of a family that receives: » Aid from Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) » SNAP benefits (food stamps) » Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits » Free or reduced-cost school lunch • Referred by a rehabilitation agency approved by the State, or an employment network under the Ticket to Work Program • Served time in jail or prison • On probation or parole • Pregnant or a parent • Homeless • Is now or has been in foster care or the custody of the New York State Office of Children and Family Services • The child of a parent who is: » In jail/prison, or has been in the past two years » Collecting unemployment insurance • Another risk factor not identified above but approved by the Commissioner of the State Labor Department

Hempstead

*You must live within the town or city limits, not a nearby area or suburb that shares the name for postal or other reasons.

Z.V.P.

268

Fact

SHEET

New York Youth Works The highly successful New York Youth Works Program, which assists young people in finding a job, is back. Success in 2012 In 2012, the New York Youth Works program was very successful and connected 12,866 at-risk youth to jobs with 1,270 New York businesses across 12 target areas in New York State. Renewed under Revenue Budget Bill Due to its success in 2012, the legislature and Governor Andrew M. Cuomo re-authorized the New York Youth Works program to encourage businesses to continue to hire at-risk youth. The reauthorized program began on January 1, 2014 and continues for four program years concluding on December 31, 2018. More information about the program is below: • Eligibility is unchanged for youth or for businesses. • The amount of tax credit allocated is up to $10 million for each year. • The amount of tax credit allocated per youth is the same, with a maximum of $5,000 for full-time work per year and $2,500 for part time work per year. • The target areas where youth must reside has been expanded from cities with a population of 62,000 or more to cities with a population of 55,000 or more, and towns with a population of 480,000 or more.

New York Youth Works Information for Businesses City of: New York Utica Buffalo Rochester Syracuse New Rochelle Town of: Brookhaven

Mount Vernon Yonkers Schenectady Albany White Plains

Hempstead

Program Year 2014 Businesses must apply for certification through the New York State Department of Labor by November 30, 2014. The tax credit only applies to hiring employees age 16 to 24 who are certified to participate in the program. The Department of Labor will refer certified youth who are appropriate candidates for your business or help you get youth that you hire yourself certified. The certified youth must start work between January 1 and December 31, 2014. Please note you may not ask a certified youth why he or she is eligible to participate in the program, as that information is considered confidential. Businesses may earn tax credits equal to the following amounts. Furthermore, if the amount of credit exceeds your tax liability, you may receive the excess as a refund.

• This adds White Plains to the twelve target areas previously established in 2012: NYC, Hempstead, Brookhaven, Utica, Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, Albany, Schenectady, New Rochelle, Mt. Vernon and Yonkers.

State of the Art Project

269

which became apparent through the conversation with Tom and Sonia, was that most of the internships were in sectors of policy and healthcare, placing students in offices. Very few partnered with local practitioners who focus on a craft. Also researched, was the way the New York State supports vocation and learn to earn models. It was important to understand all funding and aide available to local businesses. Gathering this information would make a compelling case when approaching one to offer services. The NY Labor Youth-works is a program run through New York State for Teens and Businesses. If enrolled a business can earn up to 4,000 dollars a tax credit for every teen employed. The state will also pay a minimum wage hourly to the teen for compensation. There are requirements and a mandatory application and registration of the business. Facts sheets for both businesses and teens are included for reference. Next came conversations with two Coordinators of internship programs. One worked within the transfer schools system and one outside. Sonia Phelps was contacted via a cold call to Brownsville Academy High School. Speaking with her briefly, she outlined the responsibilities it took to keep students engaged and in attendance. Most of the businesses she worked with to form internship programs were local, but some were supplied by connections from the LTW programs. Her position as a Counselor gave good insight into the heavy lifting on the schools part to create and sustain these partnerships for the teens. Their partnerships reflected what Tom Pendleton had said and were mostly banks, hospitals, colleges, policy offices, and other administrative occupations. Again, local craft based businesses Z.V.P.

â&#x20AC;&#x153;for every 25 business I contact, about 1 repliesâ&#x20AC;? x Scott Jackson were omitted from their official list, but Sonia did say that there was a beauty shop in the neighborhood which participated in their program. The next contact came through Brian Cohen of Beam Center. He directed me to the Brooklyn International High School, as they work with kids from this school. Brooklyn International is not a transfer school or a YABC, and their population is immigrant based, with most kids not speaking English when they are enrolled. Here Scott Jackson was immensely helpful in helping to understand the dynamic of being a teacher and also organizing other programs. What was needed was closer to the ground understanding and an in depth interview with someone who could lend their per-

270

sonal experience. I was connected to Scott Jackson of Brooklyn International High School by Brian Cohen. Scott is a teacher but also fulfills the role of a “Growth Team Member”. The Growth Team matches their students with appropriate internships. He confirmed an assumption, that most of the heavy lifting was done on the schools side. That the process of recruiting, prepping, and acclimating businesses was complex work. Scott confessed that it was hard as well, “for every 25 businesses I contact about 1 replies.” This is on top of coordinating 30 or so students to work in these businesses. A total of 5 members are on the Growth Team and all teach full time at Brooklyn International. It is clear that the infrastructure which handle these programs come within, but are also extremely fragile. They simply need help to grow their programs. But when growing programs that are centered on human beings’ development, it is important to understand that goals of scale and scope should not be efficiency. Effectiveness is not always efficient, and we are not building a machine. It is important to remember that the arrows and words in the diagrams in this chapters are people, dynamic systems made of people. And because this, we need to treat these relationships with care. These people need support and teens need mentorship. It became apparent that internships are not apprenticeships and sometimes lack the seriousness of what a mentorship can accomplish. A book by Paul Tough called, How Children Succeed shares the theory of attachment and how mentorship can change children’s lives. In the 60’s a psychologist named Ainworth invented a method which aimed to measure a child’s emotional capacities. It was called the Strange Situation. This situation set up State of the Art Project

a separation between toddlers and their parents. It observed the way attachment was made and categorized the different types of attachment a child may have to a parent. The results of the child’s response directly correlated to the parents degree of responsiveness in the first year of the infants life. In 1972 this experiment was taken a step farther and became a 30 year long study of 267 families from the Minneapolis area, all low income mothers and their children. The two researchers Byron Egeland and Alan Sourfe co authored a book in 2005, The Development of the Person, which shared their findings and became a full evaluation of long lasting effect of early parental relations on a child’s development. The study concluded that positive attachment in a child’s life in the first two years can make a world of difference in every aspect of their lives from anxiety, to forming proper relationships in the future. These kids were also more curious, had self confidence, and were better able to deal with setbacks. The ones with negative attachments spent less time with their peers, more time with counselors, and more time alone. The question was asked if one can turn kids around from this type of behavior. The older one gets the consequences for their actions build. Teenage years are difficult for many of us, but growing up in adversity, your teenage years can mark an ugly turning point towards bad behavior/choices which can yield horrible results. Can bad attachments during childhood be overridden and positive ones made to change the path in life? Chicago‘s schools believe so. YAP is involved with the city’s ultra high risk teenagers. Youth Advocate Programs is a nonprofit organization exclusively committed to the provision of community based alternatives to out of

271

“executive functions and the ability to handle stress and manage strong emotions can be improved, sometimes dramatically, well into adolescence and even adulthood” x Paul Tough home care through direct services. They are committed to “the creation of substitute or supplemental family structures for children who don’t have them.”75 Tough goes on to highlight cases where YAP has succeeded with teens. It is a journey which requires patience, perseverance, and persistence from all parties. But the outcomes can be extremely powerful and positive. They have found that programs can be quite effective later on in childhood as well, “Pure IQ is stubbornly resistant

to improvement after about age eight. But executive functions and the ability to handle stress and manage strong emotions can be improved, sometimes dramatically, well into adolescence and even adulthood.” YAP believes that “teenagers also have the ability - or at least the potential to rethink and remake their lives in a way that younger children do not.”76 Creating environments which help build positive relationships and behaviors outside the classroom are a positive addition to the classroom. Mentorship is also a key component in this infrastructure. A Friday afternoon in April, I attended a mentorship workshop at the Mentoring Partnership of New York Foundation. I have included a handout from this workshop. There I was joined by many of the Big Brother and Big Sister caseworkers. It proved to be a very informative experience on understanding proper protocols and appropriate closure procedures. This is Social Work. The Opportunity Claire Hartten my thesis advisor listened

75 Tough, Paul. “How to Fail (And How to Not To).” How Children Succeed: Grit, Curiosity, and the Hidden Power of

76 Tough, Paul. “How to Fail (And How to Not To).” How Children Succeed: Grit, Curiosity, and the Hidden Power of

Character. N.p.: n.p., n.d. 43. Print.

Character. N.p.: n.p., n.d. 48. Print.

Z.V.P.

272

State of the Art Project

273

Z.V.P.

274

State of the Art Project

275

to this direction, and with it had some recommendations. She knew someone who had tried to recruit and execute a program at his local business. It had failed. She made the connection, and introduced us. Zachary Golper, along with his wife, own and operate Bien Cuit Bakery in Cobble Hill. It is situated on a busy street near downtown Brooklyn Bien Cuit specializes in a craft of making artisanal baked goods with heirloom grains. Bien Cuit was featured in an April Dining Issue of the New York Times which was called the “The Bread Issue”. The article highlighted Bien Cuit and other Bakeries for their dedication to quality and craft. During our first meeting Zachary and i connected and agreed upon the transformation a hands on process can lend. He believe that “hands on making lends a sense of involvement that no other experience can”. Zachary and his wife stand behind the no-

tion of making local business a hub for dynamic cultural experiences and a place of sustainable training for alternate learning environments. Zachary and I decided to work together to investigate the failed pilot, and move forward to create and launch a successful apprenticeship program. We met and he spoke about the process he had envisioned and why he thought it had failed. We spoke about where he sees it going next. I took notes and made maps for him to understand. State of the Art Project at its final iteration formed. It was currently dedicated to understanding the ecosystem and building an apprenticeship model infrastructure for a business, specifically Bien Cuit. Second and third meetings were scheduled. I then unleashed a 40 page packet of information regarding building a peer support network/potential partners, effective mentorship strategies, funding models (included paperwork),

Z.V.P.

276

State of the Art Project

277

Z.V.P.

278

State of the Art Project

279

Z.V.P.

280

State of the Art Project

281

Z.V.P.

282

State of the Art Project

283

Z.V.P.

284

State of the Art Project

285

Z.V.P.

286

workshop schedules, building curriculum and additional information including appropriate time-lines. We spoke about the specific problem sets that Zachary faces in this endeavor, such as abundance of baked goods from the workshops, capacity for growth, what could be handled with their current staff, and possible peer support networks. In the following pages diagrams will illustrate the process and partners involved. There is also a curriculum which Zachary decided upon. The 2nd improved pilot will launch in late October to early November with 3 teens from the local high school. Bien Cuit has partnered with State of the Art Project, Family Cook Productions, and Matt Frankel a culinary teacher from the local high school. Through this project and others, we are excited to build and nurture community commitment and communication to further engagement and empowerment of teens.

State of the Art Project

It is also apparent that if Bien Cuit, Rockaway Taco, and Caracas are interested in hiring teens, there are more. This audience sees their jobs as very intimate; they live with their work and their work lives with them. Through conversation, it was obvious these business owners knew that they

287

State of the Art Project is a consultancy. One which uses knowledge, support, and connection to build and launch apprenticeship programs in process and making businesses. The goal is to work with a diversity of local process making business to leverage their networks to build and sustain community through teen development. A consultancy based model felt right because a consultancy understands the need for flexibility and can design for it. All small businesses have different problem sets outside trying to build an apprenticeship model and deal with barriers in this process. The process is simple, and in the border since we are dispersing the responsibility of learning amongst a larg-

er community. Specifically targeting the local business to build strategies for effective collaboration. In the first phase we investigate what the business can handle. It is important to understand the capacity as nurturing existing partnerships are important to understand. This capacity includes how many teens the business can take on effectively, what type of teens (i.e. audience), and any special problem sets the business has, whether it be a taco shack, bakery, or bike builders. The next step is to build infrastructure: create stability. As mentioned prior, nurturing existing relationships and facilitating new ones is a sustainable act. To build infrastructure we have to ask some specific questions. First, is there funding? And if so, where can that funding find support? Secondly, Build a peer support network and understand who you need on your team. Once this team is assembled, roles and responsibilities need

Z.V.P.

288

have responsibilities to a larger community to help create pathways for others. To give back to the community by sharing their craft.

to be clear, flexible of course, but clear. Once these have all been established creating curriculum for the workshops, setting dates and times, along with documenting through notes, interviews and photos can happen. This part of the process is called execute and measure. Launch and see if it works, review and make it better. Understand that it is an intimate experience and people can be asked for feedback. It is important to find ways to measure what is true to the context and creates a more robust program for teens and mentors. The last part would be to share, and shed light on the process. Let people in the community know how they can support and get involved. The teens and the local business could host an event, decide together what makes the most sense in the case of the craft. Outfacing workshop given by teens is an example, community events to create awareness around getting involved. Then

State of the Art Project

289

Z.V.P.

290

State of the Art Project

291

Z.V.P.

292

State of the Art Project

293

Z.V.P.

294

State of the Art Project

295

Z.V.P.

296

State of the Art Project

297

Z.V.P.

298

State of the Art Project

299

Z.V.P.

300

State of the Art Project

301

Z.V.P.

302

State of the Art Project

303

Z.V.P.

304

State of the Art Project

305

Z.V.P.

306

State of the Art Project

307

Z.V.P.

308

State of the Art Project

309

Z.V.P.

310

State of the Art Project

311

Z.V.P.

312

State of the Art Project

313

Special Thanks Courtaney Finn Carolina Zamora Claire Hartten Petrushka Bazin-Larsen Danny Kahn John Thackera Marko Manriquez Janna Gilbert Gabrielle Kellner Amy Whitaker Abby Covert Allan Chochinov Carol Archer Brian Cohen Fred Sherry Allen Riley Andrew Schols Kathryn Wallem Matt Barber Brent Arnold Benjamin Critton Rona Binay Samantha Moore Fran Argone Richard Clarkson Heather Kramer Clay Kippen Andrew Field Damon Ahola Zachary Golper Tom Pendleton Charlotta Hellichius Kim Charles Kay gaia orain Emi Yasaka Ian Charnas Z.V.P.

314

Willy Chan Mansi Gupta Cassandra Michel Joseph Weissgold Kathryn McElroy Oscar Brett Caroline Woolard Rosa Jurjevics Anne Nash Lisa Ramsey Sinclair Smith James Bader Chris Dickey Emilie Baltz Kyla Fullenwider Erika Kohl-Arenas Scott Jackson David Thonis Lynn Fredricks Matt Frankle Jaimie Warren Matt Manos Manuel Toscano Natalie Balthrop State of the Art Project

Alex Satin Morgan Street Jeremy Hawkins Bryan Daly Kim Korr Manda Louise Pesta Tim Macken Ben Kinsley Jessica Langley Jason Severs Rob Walker Richard Tyson David Kirshoff

315

Z.V.P.

316

Bibliography An Anthropologist Walks into a Bar by Christian Madsbjerg and Mikkel B. Rasmussen Harvard Business Magazine March 2014 British Government, prod. “The Pace Makers.” Lady Allen Adventure Play Grounds. London Play. Great Britian, n.d. Archive: Lady Allen Adventure Playground Chelsea, Circa 1970s. Web. Dec. 2013. min 5:25 <https://www.youtube.com/ watch?v=1pqMXplAI9Y>. Brown, Stuart L., and Christopher C. Vaughan. Play: How It Shapes the Brain, Opens the Imagination, and Invigorates the Soul. New York: Avery, 2009. Print. Center for Economic Policy Research, http://www9.georgetown. edu/grad/gppi/hpi/cew/pdfs/FullReport.pdf The New York Times, Greenhouse, Steven. “Low-Wage Workers Are Finding Poverty Harder to Escape.” The New York Times 18 Mar. 2014, Economy sec.: n. pag. New York Times. 18 Mar. 2014. Web. 18 Mar. 2014. Chudacoff, Howard P. Children at Play: An American History. New York: New York UP, 2007. Print. Dewey, John. Art as Experience. New York: Minton, Balch, 1934. 72. Print. Dewey, John. “My Pedagogic Creed.” The School Journal, Volume LIV, Number 3 (January 16, 1897), pages 77-80. Fischer, Claude S. “The Structure of Relations and Networks.” To Dwell among Friends: Personal Networks in Town and City. Chicago: U of Chicago, 1982. 139-57. Print. Fleming, Peter. “After Work: What Does Refusal Mean Today?” Living Labor(2013): 191-99. Print. Sternberg Press Foerde, Karin, Erin Kendall Braun, and Daphna Shohamy. “A Trade-Off between Feedback-Based Learning and Episodic Memory for Feedback Events: Evidence from Parkinson s Disease.”Neurodegenerative Diseases 11.2 (2013): 93-101. Web. Dec. 2013. Freire, Paulo. “Chapter 2.” Pedagogy of the Oppressed 30th Anniversary Edition. New York: Bloomsbury, 2014. N. pag. Print. Gatignon, Hubert, and Thomas S. Robertson. Diffusion of Innovation. Brussels: European Institute for Advanced Studies in Management, 1989. Print.

State of the Art Project

317

Z.V.P.

318

Bibliography Gray, Peter. Free to Learn Why Unleashing the Instinct to Play Will Make Our Children Happier, More Self-Reliant, and Better Students for Life. Washington: Basic, 2013. Print. Gray, Peter. “Beyond Attachment to Parents: Children Need Community.”Psychology Today Freedom to Learn (2013): n. pag. Web. Aug. 2013. <http://www.psychologytoday.com/ blog/freedom-learn/201307/beyond-attachment-parents-children-need-community>. Gray, Peter. “Children Are Suffering a Severe Deficit of Play â Peter Gray â Aeon.” Aeon Magazine. N.p., n.d. Web. 24 Oct. 2014. Greenhouse, Steven. “Low-Wage Workers Are Finding Poverty Harder to Escape.” The New York Times 18 Mar. 2014, Economy sec.: n. pag.New York Times. 18 Mar. 2014. Web. 18 Mar. 2014. <http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/17/business/economy/low-wage-workers-finding-its-easier-to-fall-into-povertyand-harder-to-get-out.html?gwh=094CA6F821BA0F4642AD55BA0AA810BA&gwt=pay>.

Hurst, Aaron. “Are We at the Tipping Point of a New Economy?” The Purpose Economy: Lessons from the Front Lines of the New Economy. N.p.: n.p., n.d. 29. Print. llich, lvan. “Peer Matching.” Deschooling Society. New York: Harper & Row, 1971. 93. Print Illich, Ivan. “General Characteristics of New Formal Educational Institutions.” Deschooling Society. New York: Harper & Row, 1971. 75. Print. Kelley, David, and Tom Kelley. Creative Confidence: Unleashing the Creative Potential within Us All. N.p.: n.p., n.d. Print. Kim, Kyung Hee. “The Creativity Crisis: The Decrease in Creative Thinking Scores on the Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking.” Creativity Research Journal 23.4 (2011): 285-95. Tandfonline. Nov. 2011. Web. Aug. 2013. Kino, Carol. “The New York Times.” The Work Behind Child’s Play. N.p., July 2013. Web. Aug. 2013. Kolb, David A. Experiential Learning: Experience as the Source of Learning and Development. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1984. Print. Kozlovsky,, Roy. The Junk Playground: Creative Destruction as Antidote to Delinquency. Proc. of Threat and Youth Conference, Teachers College, New York, New York. N.p.: n.p., n.d. Print. Princeton University School of Architecture

State of the Art Project

319

Z.V.P.

320

Bibliography Leland, John. “A Hip Hop Experiment.” Editorial. New York Times Nov. 2013, N.Y./Region sec.: n. pag. Print Lippard, Lucy R. Get the Message?: A Decade of Art for Social Change. New York: E.P. Dutton, 1984. Print. Meadows, Donella H., and Diana Wright. Thinking in Systems: A Primer. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green Pub., 2008. Print. Peterson, Christopher, and Martin E. P. Seligman. Character Strengths and Virtues a Handbook and Classification. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 2004. Print. Pratt, Caroline. I Learn from Children: An Adventure in Progressive Education. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1948. 10. Print. Pratt, Caroline. “Progressive Education and the Science of Education.”Progressive Education(1927): 93. Ryff, Carol D., and Victor W. Marshall. The Self and Society in Aging Processes. New York: Springer Pub., 1999. Print. Thackara, John. “Conviviality.” In the Bubble: Designing in a Complex World. Cambridge, MA: MIT, 2005. 126. Print. Schumacher, E. F. Small Is Beautiful; Economics as If People Mattered. New York: Harper & Row, 1973. Print. Sennett, Richard. “Working with Resistance.” Together: The Rituals, Pleasures, and Politics of Cooperation. New Haven, CT: Yale UP, 2012. 208-12. Print. Sennett, Richard. “The Troubled Craftsman.” The Craftsman. New Haven: Yale UP, 2008. 43. Print.

The Third Teacher: 79 Ways You Can Use Design to Transform Teaching & Learning. New York: Abrams, 2010. Print. Together The Rituals, Pleasures and Politics of Cooperation, Richard Sennett page 210 Tough, Paul. “How to Fail (And How to Not To).” How Children Succeed: Grit, Curiosity, and the Hidden Power of Character. N.p.: n.p., n.d. 43. Print. Tough, Paul. Whatever It Takes: Geoffrey Canada’s Quest to Change Harlem and America. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2008. Print.

State of the Art Project

321

Z.V.P.

322

Bibliography Sennett, Richard. The Craftsman. New Haven: Yale UP, 2008. Print. Sennett, Richard. Together: The Rituals, Pleasures, and Politics of Cooperation. New Haven, CT: Yale UP, 2012. Print. Webber, Lauren. “Apprenticeships Help Close the Skills Gap. So Why Are They in Decline?” The Wall Street Journal. N.p., 27 Apr. 2014. Web. 29 Apr. 2014. <http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702303978304579473501943642612>.

State of the Art Project

323

Z.V.P.

324

State of the Art Project

325

Z.V.P.

326

School of Visual Arts MFA Products of Design 2014

State of the Art Project

ÂŠ 2014 Zena Verda Pesta zpesta@gmail.com www.soulmagical.com

327