>hfZrgyy jZ[hlZ ih jmkkdhfm yaudm aZ deZkk
d mq_[gbdm ŠJmkkdbc yaud mq_[gbd ^ey deZkkZ h[s_h[jZah\Zl_evguo mqj_`^_gbcª F F JZamfh\kdZy b ^j ² F >jhnZ mq_[gh ijZdlbq_kdh_ ihkh[b_
AgZgb_ bklhjbb k\h_]h gZjh^Z agZgb_ iZfylgbdh\ _]h dmevlmju hldju\Z_l i_j_^ q_eh\_dhf p_euc fbj ² fbj dhlh juc g_ lhevdh \_ebq_kl\_g_g kZf ih k_[_ gh dhlhjuc iha\hey_l ih gh\hfm m\b^_lv b hp_gblv kh\j_f_gghklv AgZgb_ ijhreh]h ² wlh ihgbfZgb_ kh\j_f_gghklb Kh\j_f_gghklv ² wlh blh] ijhreh]h Z ijhreh_ ² wlh _s_ g_ jZa\b\r__ky [m^ms__ > EboZq_\
Khgguc lmfZgguc imklugguc \_k_ggbc \h_gguc \blZfbgguc [b^hgguc i_jjhgguc ^ebgguc bklbgguc
<hjh[vbguc kheh\vbguc ev\bguc ]mkbguc yklj_[bguc
khdhebguc fmjZ\vbguc mlbguc
K_j_[jyguc ]ebgyguc ^jh\yghc i_kqZguc dhghieyguc
e_^yghc dh`Zguc ieZlyghc r_jklyghc kheyghc
Keh\Z bkdexq_gby ^_j_\ygguc kl_deygguc heh\ygguc
\_lj_guc
@bag_gguc khehf_gguc lud\_gguc ebkl\_gguc y\kl
\_gguc ya\_gguc qm\kl\_gguc
>_fhgkljZpbhgguc Z\bZpbhgguc Z]blZpbhgguc dhfbkkb
hgguc w\ZdmZpbhgguc k_kkbhgguc =ebgyguc lZbgkl\_gguc i_kqZguc ey]mrbguc ^_j_\ygguc kheh\vbguc KljZ^Zl_evgh_ ijbqZklb_
AZkuiZggu_ kg_]hf k^_eZggu_ ba k_j_[jZ ijb^m
fZggu_ [jZlhf aZibkZggu_ gZ fZ]gblhnhg bkihevah\Zggu_ \ l_dkl_
M\e_q_gguc ihbkdZfb bki_q_gguc fZfhc j_rzgguc
mq_gbdhf aZg_k_gguc kg_]hf ih^f_l_gguc \_gbdhf
AZkuiZgZ kg_]hf k^_eZgZ ba k_j_[jZ ijb^mfZgZ [jZ
lhf aZibkZgZ gZ fZ]gblhnhg bkihevah\ZgZ \ l_dkl_
M\e_q_gu ihbkdZfb bki_q_gu fZfhc j_r_gu mq_gb
dhf aZg_k_gu kg_]hf ih^f_l_gu \_gbdhf
ijbe
gZj_q
Imkluggh [ueh gZ mebpZo LZbgkl\_ggh lZbgkl\_g ijbq
guc ih[e_kdb\Zeb hdgZ ^hfh\ IehsZ^v hdjm`_gZ lhiheyfb ijbq
gZj_q
KlZju_ kljh_gby kg_k_gu Haeh[e_ggh haeh[e_gguc aZ\u ijbq
\Ze \_l_j Kh[ZdZ haeh[e_gZ G_ ih^oh^bl_ d `b\hlghfm ijbq
gZj_q
dh]^Z hgh jZatyj_gh M\_j_ggh m\_j_gguc \uihegylv jZ[h gZj_q
lm Ihkl_i_ggh ihkl_i_gguc ^\b]Zlvky \i_j_^
jZ[hlZlv hj]Zgbah\Zggh gZj
Hj]Zgbah\Z g gg h f_jhijbylb_ ohjhrh hj]Zgbah\Zgh dj ijbq
^_\mrdZ h[jZah\ZggZ dj ijbe
H[jZah\Z g gg h hl\_jklb_ [ukljh h[jZah\Zgh dj ijbq
hkms_kl\eylv ijh^mfZggh gZj
Ijh^mfZ g gg h dgb]Z ohjhrh ijh^mfZgZ dj ijbq
JZkk_y g gg h
kfhlj_lv jZkk_yggh gZj
a_jgh jZkk_ygh dj ijbq
^mfZlv khkj_^hlhq_ggh gZj
Khkj_^hlhq_ g gg h \gbfZgb_ khkj_^hlhq_gh dj ijbq gZ h[t_dl_ ihklmiblv h[^mfZggh gZj
H[^mfZ g gg h j_r_gb_ lsZl_evgh h[^mfZgh dj ijbq
\kemrb\Zlvky gZklhjh`_ggh gZj
GZklhjh`_ g gg h [hcpu gZklhjh`_gu dj ijbq
o
Kbg__ kihdhcgh_ ha_jh \ ]em[hdhc jZf_ ]hj hdjue_gguo \_qguf kg_]hf l_fgh_ djm`_\h kZ^h\ iurgufb kdeZ^dZfb himkdZ_lky d \h^_ k [_j_]Z kfhljyl \ \h^m [_eu_ ^hfZ DZ`_lky qlh hgb ihkljh_gu ba kZoZjZ b \k_ \hdjm] ihoh`_ gZ lbobc khg j_[_gdZ
K_jZy e_glZ ^hjh]b [jhr_gZ \ lboh_ ms_ev_ ]hj ^hjh]Z fh s_gZ dZfg_f gh dZ`_lky fy]dhc dZd [ZjoZl ohq_lky ih]eZ^blv __ jmdhc Ih F =hjvdhfm
hdjue_gguo
hdjueblv
djue h
=hju \ hdj_klghklyo aZeb\Z Hev]b g_\ukhdb gh \ujZ
`_gu dj ijbq \_kvfZ j_adh b [hevr_x qZklvx khklhyl ba k_ jh]h ]jZgblZ d\Zjp_\h]h ihjnbjZ i_kqZgbdZ a_e_ghc yrfu <
hdj_klghklyo gZc^_gh dj ijbq fgh]h `_e_aguo f_^guo b k_ j_[jh k\bgph\uo jm^
<^hev [_j_]Z fhjy b iZjZee_evgh _fm lygmlky jy^Zfb [h
ehlZ b ^ebggu_ ijbe ha_jdb hl^_e_ggu_ ijbq ^jm] hl ^jm]Z i_kqZgufb ijbe \ZeZfb Q_f [eb`_ d [_j_]m fhjy l_f \Zeu
wlb k\_`__ b \ujZ`_gu dj ijbq j_aq_ Ih gbf ]jy^Zfb jZklml dmklZjgbdh\Zy hevoZ k dhjhldh \hehkbklufb \_l\yfb b ke_]dZ himr_ggufb ijbq ebklvyfb b [_j_ahebklguc lZ\heh`gbd
< l_o f_klZo ]^_ ^_j_\vy ih^\_j`_gu dj ijbq \ebygbx
fhjkdbo \_ljh\ hgb gbadhjhkeu b bf_xl `Zedbc \b^ <h \kydhc ehsbgd_ dhlhjZy aZsbs_gZ dj ijbq hl \_ljZ jZa\b\Z_lky
jZklbl_evghklv [he__ iurgZy q_f gZ kdehgZo h[jZs_gguo ijbq d fhjx
< :jk_gv_\
;_am^Zjguc ijh\_jy_fuc ]eZkguc \ dhjg_ keh\Z aZsbs_gZ ² aZsblZ jZa\b\Z_lky ² jZa\blb_ e_kghc ² e_k h[t_^bgblvky ² _^bguc lj_i_s_l ² lj_i_l G_ijhbaghkbfuc kh]eZkguc \ dhjg_ keh\Z hdj_klguc ² hd j_kl kljZklguc ² kljZklv f_klguc ² f_klh k_j^p_ ² k_j^_q guc jZ^hklguc ² jZ^hklv G_ijh\_jy_fu_ ]eZkgu_ b kh]eZkgu_ \ dhjg_ keh\Z ehsbgdZ \ujZ`_gu iZjZee_evgh dZfur ijh]jZffZ h\jZ] Q_j_^h\Zgb_ H : \ dhjg_ 3$&7 ² JHK jZklml jZklb l_evghklv aZjhkeb \h^hjhkeb \hajZklghc
I_kqZgufb ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ <ZeZfb dZdbfb" i_k qZgufb IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² I_kqZguc Hlghkbl iheg n Fg q L\ i <ZeZfb dZdbfb" i_kqZgufb
Himr_ggufb ² ijbqZklb_ Ebklvyfb dZdbfb" himr_g gufb IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Himrblv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Iheg n fg q L\ i Ebklvyfb dZdbfb" himr_ggufb
IZjZee_evgh ² gZj_qb_ Lygmlky dZd" iZjZee_evgh Ijb agZd ^_ckl\by H[jZaZ ^_ckl\by G_baf Lygmlky dZd" iZjZee_evgh =eZ]he b ^__ijbqZklb_ G_ fh] g_ [ue g_ ohl_e g_ ieZqv g_ ^mfZc g_ kt_rv G_ `Ze_y kbe g_ kfhljy ih^ gh]b g_ qm\kl\my [heb g_ qblZy ]Za_l G_gZ\b^_lv g_^hfh]Zlv g_^hmf_\Zlv g_\a\b^_lv g_\aex [blv g_]h^h\Zlv G_gZ\b^y g_^hfh]Zy g_^hmf_\Zy g_\a\b^_\ g_\aex[b\ g_ ]h^my IjbqZklb_ G_aZdhgq_ggh_ ibkvfh g_j_r_ggZy aZ^ZqZ g_bkijZ\e_g gZy hrb[dZ
G_ aZdhgq_ggh_ _s_ ibkvfh g_ j_r_ggZy mq_gbdhf aZ^ZqZ
g_ bkijZ\e_ggZy mqbl_e_f hrb[dZ G_ aZdhgq_ggh_ gh m`_ [ebadh_ d aZ\_jr_gbx ibkvfh g_ j_r_ggZy gh m`_ [ebadZy d hl\_lm aZ^ZqZ g_ bkijZ\e_ggZy Z ijhims_ggZy hrb[dZ
Ibkvfh g_ hdhgq_gh aZ^ZqZ g_ j_r_gZ hrb[dZ g_ bkijZ\ e_gZ Kms_kl\bl_evgh_ ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ gZj_qb_ G_jyoZ g_e_ihklv g_gZklv_ G_jyreb\uc g_e_iuc g_gZ klguc G_jyreb\h g_e_ih g_gZklgh G_kqZklv_ [_^Z g_ijZ\^Z eh`v g_ijbyl_ev \jZ] G_^jm`_kdbc \jZ`^_[guc g_jZ^hklguc ]jmklguc g_ijZ \bevgh_ hrb[hqgh_ G_fZeh fgh]h g_ykgh kfmlgh g_[ebadh ^Ze_dh G_ kqZklv_ Z [_^Z k[ebabeZ gZk g_ ijZ\^Z Z eh`v jZkkdZ aZgZ lh[hc hg fg_ g_ ijbyl_ev Z \jZ] G_ ^jm`_kdbc Z \jZ`^_[guc ijb_f gZf hdZaZeb g_ jZ^hkl guc Z ]jmklguc gZk h`b^Ze ^_gv g_ ijZ\bevgh_ Z hrb[hqgh_ j_r_gb_ ijbgylh G_ fZeh Z fgh]h [_^ fu l_ji_eb g_ ykgh Z kfmlgh \b^g_ ebkv ij_^f_lu g_ [ebadh Z ^Ze_dh _s_ b^lb Mq_gu_ gZa\Zeb hd_Zg ]b^jhdhkfhkhf >ey gZk `b\m sbo gZ kmr_ hg \k_ _s_ hklZ_lky fZeh bamq_gghc b ^Ze_dh g_ ]hkl_ijbbfghc ijbe kj_^hc Ba ]Za <i_j_^b ihdZaZebkv g_ykgu_ ijbe hq_jlZgby h]jhfguo ^_j_\v_\ gh hdZaZehkv qlh wlh g_\ukhdb_ ijbe ijb[j_`gu_ dmklu : G Lheklhc Imkl__l \ha^mo ilbp g_ keurgh ijbq [he_ N Lxlq_\ B e_k g_\_^hfuc ijbq emqZf \ lmfZg_ kijylZggh]h khegpZ djm]hf rmf_e : Imrdbg GZ q_l\_jlu_ kmldb g_gZklvy kmr lmqb g_fgh]h gZj_q jZkk_yebkv K AZeu]bg G_ mfhedZy ^__ijbq rmf_eh aZ hdghf fhj_ B ;mgbg <j_fy [_`bl [ukljh G_aZf_lgh gZj_q ijhoh^bl ^_gv g_aZf_lgh gZ j_q gZklmiZxl ihl_fdb : Q_oh\
Hd_Zg ² bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ GZa\Zeb qlh" hd_Zg Ij_^f_l G n ² hd_Zg G_h^mr gZjbp f j kde ?^ q < i GZa\Zeb qlh" hd_Zg
GZa\Zeb ² ]eZ]he Mq_gu_ qlh k^_eZeb" gZa\Zeb >_ckl \b_ G n ² gZa\Zlv G_kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde ijhr \j fg q Mq_gu_ qlh k^_eZeb" gZa\Zeb
G_ mfhedZy ² ^__ijbqZklb_ G_ mfhedZlv >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_ckl\b_ G_kh\ \b^ Qlh ^_eZy" g_ mfhedZy Fhjhaguc gbq_f g_ iZogmsbc \ha^mo ijhgbdZe ]em[h
dh \ ]jm^v < ;_eh\ DZd [m^lh \_q_g qZk ijhsZevguc dZd [m^lh \j_fy gb ijb q_f < fbgmlu fmaudb i_qZevghc g_ ]h\h
jbl_ gb h q_f G Jm[ph\ Gbdlh \ lhqghklb g_ agZ_l kdhevdh
yaudh\ kms_kl\m_l gZ a_fghf rZj_ QZs_ \k_]h gZau\Zxl pbnjm ljb lukyqb ohly hgZ \_kvfZ ijb[ebabl_evgZ H[tykgy_lky wlh l_f qlh g_j_^dh ljm^gh ijh\_klb ]jZgbpm f_`^m yaudZfb b
^bZe_dlZfb b qlh yaudh\_^Zf g_ \k_ _s_ ba\_klgh N Nbebg <g_aZigh \_l_j gZe_lbl b \ kmqvyo kimlZgguo b l_fguo g_ l_ji_eb\h ijhrmfbl B Lmj]_g_\ >Ze_dh gZ k_\_j_ gZ [_j_
]m gbdh]^Z g_ mfhedZxs_]h hd_ZgZ klhyeZ e_^ygZy ]hjZ Gbq_f
g_ bgl_j_kmykv hgZ jZ\gh^mrgh kfhlj_eZ gZ q_jg_xs__ g_[h gZ ihdjulmx g_lZxsbf kg_]hf imklugx gZ [mrmxsbc hd_Zg < ;_kiZeh\ G_ij_klZggh b `Zeh[gh g_ om`_ ibkdZ h[_avy gu a\ydZe g_[hevrhc dhehdhe m dhjfu B Lmj]_g_\
IZogms bc h[tykgy _l ky mfhedZxs _]h
IZogmsbc ² ijbqZklb_ <ha^mo dZdhc" iZogmsbc Ijb agZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx IZogmlv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j ?^ q f j B i
<ha^mo dZdhc" iZogmsbc
MfhedZxs_]h ² ijbqZklb_ Hd_ZgZ dZdh]h" mfhedZxs_ ]h IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx MfhedZlv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j ?^ q f j J i Hd_ZgZ dZdh]h" gbdh]^Z g_ mfhedZxs_]h
H[tykgy_lky ² ]eZ]he Wlh qlh ^_eZ_l" h[tykgy_lky >_c kl\b_ G n ² h[tykgylvky G_kh\ \b^ \ha\j g_i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde gZkl \j _^ q e Wlh qlh ^_eZ_l" h[tykgy_lky Gbq_f ² f_klhbf_gb_ G_ iZogmsbc q_f" gbq_f G n ² gbqlh Hljbp L\ i G_ iZogmsbc q_f" gbq_f HgZ ² f_klhbf_gb_ Ijb[ebabl_evgZ qlh" hgZ G n ² hgZ Ebqg e ?^ q ` j B i Ijb[ebabl_evgZ qlh" hgZ
Wlh ² f_klhbf_gb_ H[tykgy_lky qlh" wlh G n ² wlh MdZa ?^ q kj j B i H[tykgy_lky qlh" wlh <k_ jh`v djm]hf dZd kl_iv `b\Zy Gb aZfdh\ gb fhj_c gb ]hj KiZkb[h klhjhgZ jh^gZy AZ l\hc \jZqmxsbc ijhklhj G G_djZkh\
Fhjhagh JZ\gbgu [_e_xl ih^ kg_]hf Q_jg__lky e_k \i_j_^b KZ\jZkdZ ie_l_lky gb rZ]hf gb [_]hf G_ \klj_lbrv ^mrb gZ imlb G G_djZkh\
IZog_l Jmkv fhy kg_]Zfb : dm^Z gb dbg_rv \a]ey^ GZ jy[bgZo kg_]bjyfb =jha^vy y]h^u ]hjyl : Ojhfh\
<_l_j j_a\uc mkgme gZ imlb Gb ijh_oZlv \ e_km gb ijhclb K ?k_gbg
>_j_\gy [m^lh [hevrbf imoh\uf h^_yehf [ueZ mdju lZ lmfZghf ;eb`gb_ ^hfZ [ueb _s_ \b^gu ^Zevgb_ _^\Z ijh ]ey^u\Zeb l_fgufb iylgZfb Z _s_ ^Zevr_ d j_d_ m`_ gbq_]h g_ [ueh \b^gh b dZaZehkv gbdh]^Z g_ [ueh gb \_ljydZ gZ ]hjd_ gb ih`Zjghc dZeZgqb gb rdheu gb e_kZ gZ ]hjbahgl_ X DZaZdh\
G_ba\_klguc lZd ih]jmabeky \ kha_jpZgb_ e_kgh]h kxjijb aZ qlh ^_\hqdZ mki_eZ jZkkfhlj_lv _]h k ]heh\u ^h gh] mklZgh \b\ qlh ex^_c ih^h[guo wlhfm g_agZdhfpm _c \b^_lv _s_ gb jZam g_ ijboh^behkv I_j_^ g_c [ue g_dlh bghc dZd ba\_klguc kh[bjZl_ev i_k_g e_]_g^ ij_^Zgbc b kdZahd : =jbg
< g_f g_ [ueh kf_rZgguo hll_gdh\ h]gy e_i_kldh\ fZdZ b]ju nbhe_lh\uo beb ebeh\uo gZf_dh\ g_ [ueh lZd`_ gb kbg_ \u gb l_gb ² gbq_]h qlh \uau\Z_l khfg_gb_ : =jbg
Mdjul Z mklZgh\b\ kf_rZgg uo
MdjulZ ² ijbqZklb_ >_j_\gy dZdh\Z" mdjulZ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Mdjulv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Dj n _^ q ` j >_j_\gy dZdh\Z" [ueZ mdjulZ
MklZgh\b\ ² ^__ijbqZklb_ MklZgh\blv >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_c kl\b_ Kh\ \b^ Qlh k^_eZ\" mklZgh\b\
Kf_rZgguo ² ijbqZklb_ Hll_gdh\ dZdbo" kf_rZgguo IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Kf_rZlv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Fg q J i Hll_gdh\ dZdbo" kf_rZgguo ?klv m gZk \ kljZg_ fgh]h fZe_gvdbo ]hjh^h\ < ij_`gb_ \j_f_gZ bo gZau\Zeb aZohemklgufb ! LZdbo ]hjh^h\ g_ gZ r_^rbo _s_ k\h_]h gZklhys_]h f_klZ \ gZr_c ^_ckl\bl_evgh klb m gZk g_fZeh ! @b\ml wlb ]hjh^Z gZ djhob ba Šh[eZklbª ! b ij_^klZ\eyxl kh[hc ]jmklgh_ aj_ebs_ gbq_f g_ hijZ\ ^Zgghc aZ[jhr_gghklb ! : f_`^m l_f m dZ`^h]h ba wlbo ]h jh^h\ _klv \hafh`ghklb dZd ^ey k\h_]h [eZ]hkhklhygby b jZkp\_ lZ lZd b ^ey lh]h qlh[u \g_klb ^hex \ h[s_]hkm^Zjkl\_ggmx `bagv ! Y m[_`^_g ohly [u gZ hkgh\Zgbb k\h_]h g_[hevrh ]h hiulZ `bagb \ lZdbo ]hjh^Zo qlh ihqlb dZ`^uc ba gbo h[eZ ^Z_l kdjulufb hl kdmqgh]h b g_jZ^b\h]h ]eZaZ \hafh`ghklyfb Gm`gh lhevdh wlb \hafh`ghklb \kdjulv \ulZsblv ba ih^ kim^Z hldjulv \ gZr_c kljZg_ khlgb kms_kl\mxsbo b g_ba\_klguo fZ e_gvdbo :f_jbd ² \hl wlbo kZfuo jZchgguo ]hjh^h\ D IZmklh\kdbc
Ij_^eh]b ba ih^ ba aZ ih gZ^ Bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ ihe Zj[maZ ihe ebfhgZ ihe Fhkd\u ieZs iZeZldZ l_e_nhg Z\lhfZl k_\_jh \hklhd lhkdZ djmqbgZ ijZ\^Z bklbgZ Bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ k_\_jh \hklhqguc x]h aZiZ^guc x]h \hklhqguc ebl_jZlmjgh fmaudZevguc nbabdh fZl_fZlbq_kdbc ]Za_lgh `mjgZevguc q_jgh [_euc l_fgh djZkguc yjdh kbgbc
kbevguc kbevguc kf_euc kf_euc [hevrhc ij_[hevrhc F_klhbf_gb_ .RH dlh dh_ dhfm dh_ dh]h dlh lh qlh lh q_fm lh
dZdhc gb[m^v qlh gb[m^v h q_f gb[m^v GZj_qb_ ih gh\hfm ih hk_gg_fm ih k\h_fm
ih ^jm`_kdb ih njZgpmakdb ih k\hckdb ih aZyqvb ih j_[yqvb
\h i_j\uo \ iyluo \ lj_lvbo _e_ _e_ qmlv qmlv lhqv \ lhqv =eZ]he ih^hc^b dZ gZibrb dZ ih^mfZc dZ
=^_ lh dh]^Z lh ^Z\gh ^Z\gh lhfm gZaZ^ y ijhq_e
h^gh klbohl\hj_gb_ B Lmj]_g_\ F_eh^by l_deZ hldm^Z lh k
g_[Z < LhdZj_\Z <hl [_j_aZ miZeZ b mlhgmeZ \ jZdh\uo r_cdZo b aZjhkeZ b\Zg ^Z fZjv_c F Ijbr\bg E_lqbd \k_ ijhoZ`b\Zeky \aZ^ \i_j_^ h`b^Zy lh]h dlh _]h \ua\Ze < Lh
dZj_\Z Fg_ ih hkh[_gghfm ^hjh] ^hjh`_ \kyq_kdbo gZ]jZ^ fhc jZkibkghc a_e_guc ]hjh^ ; Dhjgbeh\
Klhx \ gZfhdr_c ieZs iZeZld_ GZ^\bgm\ dZkdm gZ ]eZaZ«
GZjh\qZlh\
Qlh \ lhf qlh ]^_ lh gZ ^Ze_dhf Fhjkdhf ih[_j_`v_ \Zemgu
;e_klyl gZ khegp_ fhdjuf [hdhf B ;mgbg
G_ y eb kZf ih qv_c lh \he_ <hh[jZabe lhl djZc fhjkdhc
B ;mgbg
DZd ih fhjx \_l_j ih gb\Zf ]mey_l
B [_euf lmfZghf ohefu h^_\Z_l
H q_f lh mdjZ^dhc k ljZ\hc ]h\hjbl B Gbdblbg
dh]^Z lh
dh]^Z lh
fhjkdhf
fhj _ kd hf
ih hkh[_gghfm ih[_j_`v_
ih hkh[_gg uc hfm
ih [_j_] >M¶v@ _
L_de Z miZe Z mlhgme Z h`b^Zy gZ^\bgm\
K_\_jh aZiZ^g__ ]hju JZaf_l \u]ey^u\Zeh rbjhdh_
]hjgh_ ha_jh mk_yggh_ a_e_gufb hkljh\Zfb =^_ lh ^Ze_dh
^Ze_dh gZ [_j_]m j_qdb `_eluf iylghf \u^_eyeky g_[hevrhc
ijbbkd Gh \k_]h emqr_ [ue e_k \uklbeZ\rbc ]hju ^h kZfh]h \_joZ ©Wo ohjhrh ª ² kdZ`_rv g_\hevgh ]ey^y gZ wlhl g_ h[tylguc ijhklhj _^\Z ljhgmluc ^\mfy lj_fy lhqdZfb q_eh\_
q_kdh]h `bevy Mljhf ]hju g_h[udgh\_ggh ohjhrb b g_\hev
gh i_j_`b\Z _rv lZdh_ [h^jh_ b ohjhr__ qm\kl\h aZ[u\Zy h[ mklZehklb b \k_o g_\a]h^Zo hohlgbqv_]h [jh^y`gbq_kl\Z =h
em[h_ g_[h lhqgh \ur_ b ^ur bl ky lZd e_]dh GZ ]hjbahgl_ m`_
djm]eylky [_eu_ ]jhah\u_ lmqdb ]^_ lh aZr_ilZeZ \ ljZ\_ i_j\Zy kljmcdZ ih^gy\r_]hky \_ljZ Klhbrv kfhlj brv b dZ`_lky g_ mr_e [u hlkx^Z
> FZfbg Kb[bjyd
<u^_eyeky ² ]eZ]he Ijbbkd qlh ^_eZe" \u^_eyeky >_c kl\b_ G n ² \u^_eylvky G_kh\ \b^ \ha\j g_i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde ijhr \j _^ q f j Ijbbkd qlh ^_eZe" \u^_eyeky Ih^gy\r_]hky ² ijbqZklb_ <_ljZ dZdh]h" ih^gy\r_]h ky IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ih^gylvky
>_ckl\ \ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j J i <_ljZ dZdh]h" ih^gy\r_]hky G_ `^b gZmljh g_ ijh]eyg_l GZ g_[_ khegp_ >h`^v b f]eZ Oheh^guf ^ufhf e_k lmfZgyl ² G_^Zjhf wlZ ghqv ijhreZ B ;mgbg
Ijhklu_ djZkdb k_\_jguo rbjhl Jmfyguc de_\_j e_g ]hem[h\Zluc B khegpZ [e_kd g_fgh]h \bgh\Zluc B ² h[eZdZ ieu\msb_ \jZa[jh^ H NhdbgZ
Ihlhf \k_ reh dZd [m^lh ih ij_`g_fm B ;mgbg G_ [ueh mljhf ]Za_l ² g_ \ureb \h\j_fy Z\lh[mku ba Gbppu B ;mgbg Ih gh\hfm kihdhcgh b kmjh\h `b\m gZ ^bdhf [_ j_]m : :ofZlh\Z @_gsbgZ \kdhqbeZ b klZeZ \kfZljb\Zlvky \^Zev k \b^hf [_kihdhckl\Z F E_jfhglh\ Ljb ^_\u \fb] y\bebkv b \djm] __ aZkm_lbebkv qlh[ gZ ghqv iurguc kgylv m[hj : Imrdbg <ke_^ aZ Zddhj^hf jZa^Zeky `_gkdbc ]h ehk B Lmj]_g_\ =heh\Z m B\ZgZ B\Zgh\bqZ ihoh`Z gZ j_^vdm o\hklhf \gba ]heh\Z m B\ZgZ Gbdbnhjh\bqZ ihoh`Z gZ j_^vdm o\hklhf \\_jo G =h]hev
GZmljh gZj_q ² gZ mljh kms k ij_^eh]hf ih ij_`g_fm gZj_q ² ih ij_`g_fm ijbe k ij_^eh]hf imlb \h\j_fy gZ j_q ² \h \j_fy kms k ij_^eh]hf dZgbdme ih gh\hfm gZj_q ² ih gh\hfm ijbe k ij_^eh]hf ieZgm \^Zev gZj_q ² \ ^Zev kms k ij_^eh]hf fhjy \fb] gZj_q ² \ fb] kms k ij_^eh ]hf hiZkghklb \djm] gZj_q ² \ djm] kms k ij_^eh]hf \ke_^ aZ ij_^e ² \ ke_^ kms k ij_^eh]hf \gba gZj_q ² \ gba kms k ij_^eh]hf j_db \\_jo gZj_q ² \ \_jo kms k ij_^eh]hf GZmljh ² gZj_qb_ G_ ijh]eyg_l dh]^Z" gZmljh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by
<j_f_gb G_baf G_ ijh]eyg_l dh]^Z" gZmljh
Ih ij_`g_fm ² gZj_qb_ Reh dZd" ih ij_`g_fm Ijb agZd ^_ckl\by H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf Reh dZd" ih ij_`g_fm <h\j_fy ² \h \j_fy ih l\h_fm ² ih l\h_fm ih fh_fm ² ih fh_fm lhlqZk ² lhl qZk gZkf_jlv ² gZ kf_jlv g_kdZaZg gh ² g_ kdZaZgh Ijbclb \h\j_fy ² \h \j_fy mjhdZ [m^_l ih l\h_fm ² ih l\h_fm j_r_gbx k^_eZx ih fh_fm ² ih fh_fm fg_gbx lhlqZk \kihjogmeZ ² \ lhl qZk dh]^Z jZkk\_lZ_l kjZ`Zlvky gZkf_jlv ² gZ kf_jlv ljm^gh kfhlj_lv jZ\gh^mrgh g_kdZaZggh jZ^ ² fgh ]h_ g_ kdZaZgh <b^_lv gZ\_jom hebfibckdbc q_fibhg m\e_q_ggh ]h\h jblv hq_gv bgl_j_kguc ljbgZ^pZluc ihk_lbl_ev ^hf gZ gZ[_ j_`ghc [ebadh hl f_gy ihkfhlj_lv nbevf ]jZffZlbq_kdZy hk gh\Z keh\h [_a ijbklZ\db \ g_ijhoh^bfhf e_km h[_sZe ihfhqv lmkdg_xsZy k\_qZ ;_j_]bl_ yaud gZr yaud ij_djZkguc jmkkdbc yaud wlhl deZ^ wlh ^hklhygb_ i_j_^Zggh_ ^hklhygb_ i_j_^Zggh_ gZf i_ j_^Zggh_ ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZfb gZrbfb ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZfb h[ jZsZcl_kv ihqlbl_evgh h[jZsZcl_kv k hjm^b_f k wlbf hjm^b_f k fh]ms_kl\_gguf hjm^b_f \ jmdZo mf_euo kh\_jrblv qm^_kZ kh\_jrblv \ khklhygbb kh\_jrblv \ jmdZo mf_euo I_j_^Zggh_ ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZfb fh]ms_kl\_gguf
Bf_ggu_ o ijbe kms qm`hc jh^bgu o gZj ijbe hq_gv jZ^hklguc o kms kms dgb]Z [jZlZ
=eZ]hevgu_ o ]eZ] kms ijbgylv ]hkly o ]eZ] kms k ij \_jbf \ ih[_^m o ]eZ] gZj `b\_l ohjhrh
GZj_qgu_ o gZj gZj hq_gv [ebadh o gZj gZj djZcg_ [he_ag_ggh
Bf_ggu_ o ijbq kms jZkdjulu_ \hjhlZ o ijbq kms g_ijb^mfZggZy bklhjby o kms kms lhihl gh] o ijbe kms iheh`bl_evguc hiul o gZj ijbe ih \_k_gg_fm k\_`bc o ijbe kms g_`gh a_e_guo ebklv_\ o kms kms ieZlv_ g_\_klu
=eZ]hevgu_ ]eZ] kms k ij ]hlh\blvky d hlt_a^m o gZj ]eZ] g_lhjhieb\h aZrZ]Ze o
GZj_qgu_
Bf_ggu_ keh\hkhq_lZgby \ [_euo ]jhfZ^Zo khkgh\uo e_ kh\ i_j\uc lmfZg =eZ]hevgu_ keh\hkhq_lZgby ijhreh \ ]me_ magZe gZgh\h dmjblky gZ^ hfmlZfb gZj_q f_kl
]eZ]
qZkl
qbke
ijbe
ijbe
kms
JZgvr_ hgb \uau\Zeb lhevdh h^bg h[uqguc kdm^guc h[jZa Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_
Kh]eZkh\Zgb_ o
ijbq kms qblZxsbc fZevqbd o f_kl kms gZr_ k_eh o qbke kms i_j\uc mq_gbd o ijbe kms gh\u_ mq_[gbdb o ijbe kms ebkbc o\hkl o f_kl kms lZdhc ihjy^hd o qbke kms h^bg ^_gv
o
MijZ\e_gb_
]eZ] kms kemrZlv gh\hklb o ]eZ] kms k ij ]hklblv m ^jm]Z o kms kms Zdpby fbehk_j^by o kms kms k ij ^\b`_gb_ gZ ^hjh]_ o ^__ij kms k ij k\_jdZy gZ kg_]m
o
IjbfudZgb_
]eZ] gZj m\_ebqblv \ljh_ o ]eZ] gZj i_j_ibkZlv gZ[_eh o gZj ijbe g_fgh]h e_]dhfuke_gguc o gZj gZj g_ijb\uqgh lboh o ]eZ] g n ]eZ] \ayeky k^_eZlv o ]eZ] ^__ij jZkkdZau\Zlv g_ lhjhiykv o qbke gZj lj_lbc ke_\Z
o
ijbq kms hldjulZy l_ljZ^v
o
kms gZj `Zjdh_ ih ^hfZrg_fm o gZj gZj ih hk_gg_fm kdmqgh
Ijb_oZlv ba Fhkd\u ijbclb ba rdheu `blv gZ MdjZbg_ \_jgmlvky ba hlimkdZ jZ[hlZlv gZ aZ\h^_ ijb[ulv gZ DZ\dZa \u[_`Zlv k [ZedhgZ _oZlv gZ DZfqZldm khclb k ih_a^Z \uclb ba ih_a^Z kh[bjZlvky gZ dhgp_jl bah[jZablv gZ dZjlbg_ `b\hibk gh_ ijhba\_^_gb_ ijbfqZlvky k ^Zqb EZklhqdb ijhiZeb : \q_jZ aZj_c <kz ]jZqb e_lZeb >Z dZd k_lv f_evdZeb <hg gZ^ lhc ]hjhc K \_q_jZ \k_ kiblky GZ ^\hj_ l_fgh Ebkl kmohc \Zeblky Ghqvx \_l_j aeblky >Z klmqbl \ hdgh : N_l
e_lZeb \q_jZ gZ^ lhc ]hjhc ebkl kmohc klmqbl \ hdgh ]eZ]
kiblky ² >kiœbpZ@ kms
kibpZ ² >kiœbpZ@ M` khegpZ jZkdZe_gguc rZj K ]eZ\u k\h_c a_fey kdZlbeZ B fbjguc \_q_jZ ih`Zj <hegZ fhjkdZy ih]ehlbeZ N Lxlq_\
JZkdZe_gguc rZj k ]eZ\u k\h_c khegpZ ^Zj kdZlbeZ rZj kdZlbeZ k ]eZ\u m` kdZlbeZ I_qZe_g ^he]bc \_q_j \ hdly[j_ Ex[be y hk_gv iha^gxx \ Jhkkbb Ex[be e_khd [Z]jyguc gZ ]hj_ Ijhklhj ihe_c b kmf_jdb ]emob_ B ;mgbg
>he]bc \_q_j \_q_j \ hdly[j_ ex[be hk_gv iha^gxx hk_gv hk_gv \ Jhkkbb ex[be e_khd [Z]jyguc e_khd e_khd gZ ]hj_ ex [be ijhklhj ex[be kmf_jdb ijhklhj ihe_c ]emob_ kmf_jdb ?klv gZ iheyo fh_c jh^bgu kdjhfgu_ K_klju b [jZlvy aZfhjkdbo p\_lh\ Bo \hajZklbeZ \_kgZ [eZ]h\hggZy < a_e_gb fZckdbo e_kh\ b em]h\ B ;mgbg
?klv gZ iheyo fh_c jh^bgu gZ iheyo jh^bgu kdjhfgu_ k_ klju kdjhfgu_ [jZlvy k_klju p\_lh\ [jZlvy p\_lh\ aZfhjkdbo p\_lh\ bo \hajZklbeZ \_kgZ [eZ]h\hggZy \hajZklbeZ \ a_e_gb \ a_e_gb e_kh\ \ a_e_gb em]h\ fZckdbo e_kh\ fZckdbo em]h\ JZkdZe_gg uc
JZkdZe_gguc ² ijbqZklb_ RZj dZdhc" jZkdZe_gguc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx JZkdZeblv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j < i RZj dZdhc" jZkdZe_gguc JZkdZeblv ² jZkdZe_gguc jZkdZeb\ jZkdZeb\rbc
<hajZklbeZ ² \hajhkeZ ² \ajZs_gguc =jZffZlbq_kdb_ hkgh\u ex[ex y ex[ex \_l_j ]gme dgb]b Keh\hkhq_lZgby ex[ex hlqbagm kljZgghx ex[h\vx ex[ex ex[h\vx ex[ex ]jham \ gZqZe_ fZy ]jham \ gZqZe_ fZy ]gme ^_j_\vy Lu `b\Z _s_ fhy klZjmrdZ" @b\ b y Ijb\_l l_[_ ijb\_l Imklv kljmblky gZ^ l\h_c ba[mrdhc Lhl \_q_jgbc g_kdZaZgguc k\_l K ?k_gbg
Ebklvy iZ^Zxl ebklvy iZ^Zeb Klhg_l \_l_j Ijhly`_g b ]emo Dlh `_ k_j^p_ ihjZ^m_l"
Dlh _]h mkihdhbl fhc ^jm]" K ?k_gbg
H [mcgu_ \_lju Khj\bl_ mfqbl_ Kdhj__ kdhj_c Fu `^Zlv g_ ohlbf Kdhj_c gZk khj\bl_ E_lbl_ e_lbl_ K ^hdmqguo \_l\_c Fu k \Zfb e_lbf N Lxlq_\
Â? Â? >reÂśbÂ? ^\Z ijÂśvMÂśZlÂśveÂśZ \ÂśvqÂśwjgÂśvMÂśm Â? itjhM@ Lu fgh]h eb \b^_e gZ k\_l_ [_j_a" ]eZ] qbke
kms
ijbe
kms
ij kms
kms
k
ijbe
kms
]eZ]
Reb ^\Z ijbyl_ey \_q_jg_x ihjhc b ^_evguc jZa]h\hj \_eb f_kl
ij
f_`^m kh[hc Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_
Keh\hkhq_lZgby ^\Z ijbyl_ey \_q_jg_x ihjhc reb \_q_j g_x ihjhc ^_evguc jZa]h\hj \_eb jZa]h\hj \_eb f_`^m kh[hc f_kl gZj
q
]eZ]
Lu fgh]h eb \b^_e gZ k\_l_ [_j_a" <hij g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_
Keh\hkhq_lZgby fgh]h eb \b^_e \b^_e gZ k\_l_ \b^_e [_j_a fgh]h eb [_j_a o
>_evguc jZa]h\hj ijbe kms Lbi k\yab ² kh]eZkh\Zgb_ o
<_eb jZa]h\hj ]eZ] kms Lbi k\yab ² mijZ\e_gb_ o
<b^_e gZ k\_l_ ]eZ] kms Lbi k\yab ² mijZ\e_gb_ F_` gZfb j_qv g_ lZd b]jb\h ev_lky : Imrdbg kdZ`_rv \ k\h_ hijZ\^Zgb_" : Imrdbg Qlh lu l_i_jv < ihe^_gv JZaf_lgh\ ijbr_e ^hfhc ihh[_^Zlv b q_j_a ^\_jpm dZebldb m\b^_e \hae_ ihjh]Z oZlu ]hem[_c F Rh ² ba\bebklZy g_]em[hdZy j_dZ D IZm ehoh\ KhehlqZ klh\kdbc <v_lky mebpZ af_y MebpZ ² fhy ^hfZ ²
FZydh\kdbc FbljZrZ \umqbeky m hlpZ ^_eZlv ^_ fhb < Ijbr\bg j_\yggmx ihkm^m [hqhgdb rZcdb ehoZgb F =jZqb me_l_eb e_k h[gZ`beky ihey himkl_eb lhevdh g_ G_djZkh\ >m[jh\kdbc fheqZe k`ZlZ ihehkdZ h^gZ G <^jm] hg ih^gye ]heh\m ]eZaZ _]h aZk\_jdZeb hg lhigme
gh]hx hllhedgme k_dj_lZjy : Imrdbg B smdm [jhkb eb ² \ j_dm B Djueh\ Y \Zk kijZrb\Zx jZ[hqbf ² gm`gh ieZlblv" : Q_oh\
ij
kms
kms
]eZ]
gZj
]eZ]
k
ij
< ihe^_gv JZaf_lgh\ ijbr_e ^hfhc ihh[_^Zlv b q_j_a
kms
kms
]eZ]
ij
kms
kms
kms
^\_jpm dZebldb m\b^_e \hae_ ihjh]Z oZlu ]hem[_c Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_
Ih^e_`Zs__ _^ q kdZam_fh_ hij_^_e_gb_ ijbeh`_ gb_ ^hiheg_gb_ h[klhyl_evkl\h kh]eZkh\Zgb_ mijZ\e_gb_ ijbfudZgb_ kbglZdkbk imgdlmZpby lbj_ ^_nbk ^\mkhklZ\gh_ ij_^eh`_gb_ h^ghkhklZ\gh_ ij_^eh`_gb_ bgnbgblb\ bglh gZpby keh\hkhq_lZgb_ <k_ e_kZ ohjhrb k bo ]jb[guf \ha^mohf b r_e_klhf eb klv_\ Gh hkh[_ggh ohjhrb ]hjgu_ e_kZ hdheh fhjy < gbo keu r_g rmf ijb[hy Hl h[beby \eZ]b [mcgh jZajZklZ_lky fho Hg k\_rb\Z_lky a_e_gufb ijy^yfb ^h kZfhc a_feb Djhf_ lh]h \ ]hjguo e_kZo `b\_l dZd ilbpZ i_j_kf_rgbd \_k_eh_ woh Hgh lhevdh b `^_l qlh[u ih^o\Zlblv ex[hc a\md b r\ujgmlv _]h q_j_a kdZeu D IZmklh\kdbc
Hkh[_ggh ² gZj_qb_ Ohjhrb dZd" hkh[_ggh IjbagZd ijbagZdZ F_ju G_baf Ohjhrb dZd" hkh[_ggh
;mcgh ² gZj_qb_ JZajZklZ_lky dZd" [mcgh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf JZajZklZ_lky dZd" [mcgh JZajZklZ _l ky k\_rb\Z _l ky Khegp_ yjdh k\_lbeh ² Yjdh k\_lbeh khegp_ Fheh^Zy ljZ\dZ ijh[b\ZeZkv kd\hav a_fex ² Kd\hav a_fex ijh[b\ZeZkv fheh^Zy ljZ\dZ
>h`^v ebe \_kv ^_gv ² <_kv ^_gv ebe ^h`^v Kg_] ihqlb jZklZye ² Ihqlb jZklZye kg_] Hey gZibkZeZ ibkvfh ² Ibkvfh gZibkZeZ Hey ]eZ]
IhcfZlv _jrZ beb hdmgy ² wlh lZdh_ [eZ`_gkl\h f_kl
: Q_oh\ Y \ha\jZsZeky k hohlu b r_e ih Zee__ kZ^Z f_kl
kms
B Lmj]_g_\ Qlh lh [m^lh aZ^_j`Zeh _]h \ dhfgZl_ Kgu kms
f_kl
[_ahlq_lgu yjdb djZkdb : ;ehd Dlh lh ba om^h`gbdh\ gZ
a\Ze >bhgbkby FhpZjlhf jmkkdhc `b\hibkb < Khehmobg g_jZae k k
DZ`^uc ba gZk klZg_l gZ kZfhf djZx iehsZ^db F E_jfhg ijbe
lh\ D gbf klZeb ih^oh^blv agZdhfu_ ]mey\rb_ \ kZ^m g_jZae k k
: Q_oh\ GZklmibeh gZdhg_p iylgZ^pZlh_ fZy : Dmijbg ijbq
khxa
LZgpmxsb_ l_kgbebkv b lhedZeb ^jm] ^jm]Z Wlh Š_keb q
[uÂŞ hlg_k_ggh_ bf d ijhr_^r_fm d g_\hafh`ghfm k[uehkv g_jZae k k
B Lmj]_g_\ Fu k gbf e_`Zeb gZ i_kd_ m ]jhfZ^gh]h dZf g_jZae k k
gy F =hjvdbc H^gZ`^u <_joh\gh_ Kms_kl\h \a^mfZeh
aZ^Zlv \_ebdbc ibj \ k\hbo eZahj_\uo q_jlh]Zo B Lmj]_g_\ g_jZae k k
kms
H[_ ^h[jh^_l_eb g_kdZaZggh m^b\bebkv k l_o ihj dZd k\_l f_kl
f_kl
klhye ² Z klhye hg ^Z\gh ² hgb \klj_qZebkv \ i_j\uc jZa B Lmj]_g_\
=mey\r b_ lZgpmxs b_ hlg_k_gg h_ d ijhr_^r _fm
� >gœvkdtaZgt@ ² keh]Z >gœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >F@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >d@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >a@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >D@ ² ]eZkg m^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ � G_kdZaZggh ² [md\
JhkkbckdZy N_^_jZpby h[t_^bgy_l ex^_c jZaguo gZpbh gZevghkl_c Q_jgZy kfhjh^bgZ kh^_j`bl fgh]h \blZfbgZ K ;_jbg]h\ ijheb\ jZa^_ey_l ^\Z fh]mqbo ]hkm^Zjkl\Z G_kdhevdh q_eh\_d hklZg_lky gZ ^jm]hf [_j_]m ^h mljZ Fu k ^jm]hf ex[bf oh^blv \ dbgh DZ`^uc ba ijbkmlkl\mxsbo ohl_e aZ^Zlv e_dlhjm \hijhk :dl ih^ibkZeb q_luj_ wdki_jlZ H^bg dhfivxl_j klhy\rbc hdheh hdgZ kehfZeky Wlhl ^hf ihkljhbe fZkl_j gZ \k_ jmdb kms kms ;_a i_k_g fbj l_k_g ;_a ohaybgZ ^hf ² kbjhlZ kms
f_kl
;_j_`_gh]h [h] ² [_j_`_l < `bagb \kydh_ [u\Z_l =hj kms
g_jZae k?k
qbke
[Zlh]h fh]beZ bkijZ\bl >\Z ^jm]Z ² fhjha b \vx]Z >\h_ qbke
qbke
iZrml Z k_f_jh jmdZfb fZrml &Hf_jh h^gh]h g_ `^ml � > œvjœv`hl@ ² keh]Z >[œ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >jœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >`@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >h@ ² ]eZkg m^ >l@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdh\ � ;_j_`_l ² [md\ Gbq_]h [he__ jmkkdh]h q_f yaud m gZk g_l Fu ihevam_f ky bf lZd `_ _kl_kl\_ggh dZd iv_f beb ^urbf < ]em[bg_ \_ dZ \ dhlhjhc fu gZoh^bfky keh\h Šihevah\Zlvkyª klZgh\blky \k_ [he__ [_agjZ\kl\_gguf _keb g_ ij_klmiguf <ha^mohf jZ\ gh ^urZl ex^b [_^gu_ b [h]Zlu_ jZaguo m[_`^_gbc \hajZklh\ gZpbhgZevghkl_c b \_jhbkih\_^Zgbc ;_kieZlghklv _]h gbdh]^Z g_ h[km`^ZeZkv ^h gZr_]h \j_f_gb Gh \ha^mo hdZaZeky g_ [_k ieZl_g \ i_jki_dlb\_ KhagZgb_ kh\j_f_ggh]h q_eh\_dZ lj_sbl hkeh`g_ggh_ l_i_jv _s_ wdheh]bq_kdbfb ijh[e_fZfb Gh i_j_ kljhblvky \kz _s_ g_ fh`_l <ha^mo \h^Z a_fey dZdhc [_kih e_aghc \_svx fh`_l hdZaZlvky h^gZ`^u [jbeebZgl
Yaud ² lhl `_ hd_Zg DZd [u gb [ueb h[rbjgu b ]em[hdb b lhl b ^jm]hc \ gbo ljm^gh ^h[Z\blv ohlv dZiex ohlv keh\h <k_]h wlh]h klhevdh kdhevdh _klv Gh ² g_ [hevr_ : ;blh\
Ijhklh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ Y \ha\jZsZeky k hohlu b r_e ih Zee__ kZ^Z Kh[ZdZ [_`ZeZ khkl ]eZ]
\i_j_^b f_gy <^jm] hgZ mf_gvrbeZ k\hb rZ]b b gZqZeZ djZklv ky Y ]eygme \^hev Zee_b b m\b^_e fheh^h]h \hjh[vy Hg miZe
ba ]g_a^Z b kb^_e g_ih^\b`gh [_kihfhsgh jZklhiujb\ _^\Z ijhjZklZ\rb_ djueurdb Fhy kh[ZdZ f_^e_ggh ijb[eb`ZeZkv d
g_fm dZd \^jm] khj\Z\rbkv k [ebadh]h ^_j_\Z klZjuc q_jgh
]jm^uc \hjh[_c dZfg_f miZe i_j_^ kZfhc __ fhj^hc ² b \_kv
\at_jhr_gguc bkdZ`_gguc k hlqZygguf b `Zedbf ibkdhf iju]gme jZaZ ^\Z \ gZijZ\e_gbb am[Zklhc jZkdjulhc iZklb Hg khkl ]eZ]
khkl ]eZ]
jbgmeky kiZkZlv hg aZkehgbe kh[hx k\h_ ^_lbs_ Y ihki_rbe hlha\Zlv kfms_ggh]h ikZ ² b m^Zebeky [eZ]h]h\_y KhklZ\gh_ ]eZ]hevgh_ kdZam_fh_ ij ]eZ]
<^jm] hgZ mf_gvrbeZ k\hb rZ]b b gZqZeZ djZklvky Hg jb ij ]eZ]
gmeky kiZkZlv hg aZkehgbe kh[hx k\h_ ^_lbs_ DZdbf ]jhfZ^ guf qm^h\bs_f ^he`gZ [ueZ _fm dZaZlvky kh[ZdZ B \k_ lZdb hg
g_ fh] mkb^_lv gZ k\h_c \ukhdhc [_ahiZkghc \_ld_ Y ihki_rbe ij ]eZ]
hlha\Zlv kfms_ggh]h ikZ ² b m^Zebeky [eZ]h]h\_y dZaZlvky ² >dZaZpZ@
Khj\Z\rbkv jZkdjul hc Y j_rbeky ihk_lblv agZdhfmx klhjhgm \aye \hevguo ehrZ^_c b imklbeky \ k_eh G Wlh kemqbehkv hk_gvx K_j_gvdb_ lmqb ihdju\Zeb g_[h oh eh^guc \_l_j ^me k ih`Zluo ihe_c mghky djZkgu_ b `_elu_ eb klvy kh \klj_qguo ^_j_\v_\ Y ijb_oZe \ k_eh ijb aZdZl_ khegpZ b hklZgh\beky m ihqlh\h]h ^hfbdZ : Imrdbg
AgZdhfmx klhjhgm \aye ehrZ^_c \hevguo ehrZ^_c imklbeky
\ k_eh \ k_eh G j_rbeky ihk_lblv ihk_lblv klhjhgm Ih`Zl uo mghky
Ih`Zluo ² ijbqZklb_ K ihe_c dZdbo" ih`Zluo IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ih`Zlv KljZ^ g_\ha\ kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Fg q J i K ihe_c dZdbo" ih`Zluo
Mghky ² ^__ijbqZklb_ Mghkblv >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_ckl\b_ G_kh\ \b^ Qlh ^_eZy" mghky g_jZae k k H[Z ijbyl_ey FZgbeh\ b Qbqbdh\ ^he]h `Zeb ^jm] ^jm]m
jmdb b ^he]h kfhlj_eb fheqZ h^bg ^jm]hfm \ ]eZaZ
<u^_jgm\rb KZ^h\gbd ohl_e iheblv p\_lu ² KZ^h\gbd ohl_e [u iheblv p\_lu Mqbl_ev gZqZe ]h\hjblv h ij_^klhys_f wdaZf_ g_ ² Mqbl_ev gZqZe [u ]h\hjblv h ij_^klhys_f wdaZf_g_ Y jZ^ kdZaZlv ijZ\^m ² Y jZ^ [u kdZaZlv ijZ\^m FZevqbd klZe aZkuiZlv ih^ lboh_ i_gb_ FZevqbd klZe [u aZkuiZlv ih^ lboh_ i_gb_ Fu [ueb jZ^u ihagZdhfblvky k gh\uf khljm^gbdhf bgklblmlZ ² Fu [ueb [u jZ^u ihagZdhfblvky k gh\uf khljm^ gbdhf bgklblmlZ H[Z kihjlkf_gZ ijh^he`Zeb [_`Zlv k [hev rhc kdhjhklvx ² H[Z kihjlkf_gZ ijh^he`Zeb [u [_`Zlv k [hevrhc kdhjhklvx khkl bf
FeZ^rbc \_kv ihr_e ebphf \ hlpZ D Kbfhgh\ GZ ij ]e
klhe_ klhyeZ [hevrZy eZfiZ F =hjvdbc K fbgmlm hgb kfhl ij ]e
khkl bf
j_eb ^jm] gZ ^jm]Z fheqZ b ebpZ m gbo [ueb fhdju_ F =hjv khkl bf
dbc Y [jZlhd k\h[h^guc q_eh\_d F =hjvdbc L_i_jv y khkl bf
ij ]e
m`_ g_ qm\kl\h\Ze k_[y \ lZdhc kl_i_gb h^bghdbf y `^Ze ]hkly khkl bf
< Dhjhe_gdh Hg jhklhf [ue ^\_gZ^pZlb \_jrdh\ F E_j khkl ]eZ]
fhglh\ Y g_ij_f_ggh j_rbeZkv gZihfgblv h k\h_c ^jm`[_
Ihdjh\kdhfm b qlh gb[m^v ih^Zjblv _fm N >hklh_\kdbc khkl bf
IjhklhlZ _klv g_h[oh^bfh_ mkeh\b_ ij_djZkgh]h E Lhe khkl bf
klhc Ij_djZkgh_ ^he`gh [ulv \_ebqZ\h : Imrdbg
ij ]e
ij ]e
Khegp_ aZreh AZiZ^ iueZe dZd ebph aZiuoZ\r_]hky hl khkl bf
[_]hlgb j_[_gdZ <hklhqgZy iheh\bgZ g_[Z [ueZ aZeblZ g_`gh khkl bf
Zeufb ebeh\ufb b iZe_\ufb hll_gdZfb <ha^mo [ue lbo b a\m khkl bf
q_g =jmklgZy aZ^mfqb\hklv jZaeblZ [ueZ \ _]h k\_lehf dheuoZ ij ]e
ij ]e
gbb IjhajZqgh f_jpZe \_q_j b g_aZf_lgh gZ[_]Zeb kmf_jdb ij ]e
<eZ`gZy b khggZy lbrbgZ klhyeZ gZ^ j_dhx =eZ^db_ kljmb ie_ ij ]e
kdZebkv h kujhc i_khd [_j_]Z k e_]dbf r_ihlhf keh\gh g_`gu_ ij ]e
^_lkdb_ ]m[u p_eh\Zeb fZfbgu jmdb <^Zeb gZ [_j_]m jZ^hklgh ij ]e
ij ]e
aZ`]eZkv djZkgZy a\_a^hqdZ dhkljZ lZf \b^g_eZkv ju[Zqvy eh^ dZ
AZ^mfqb\hklv
aZ^mfqb\uc
N Kheh]m[
aZ^mfZlvky
^mfZlv
AZiuoZ\r_]hky ² ijbqZklb_ J_[_gdZ dZdh]h" aZiuoZ\ r_]hky IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx AZiuoZlvky >_ckl\ \ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j J i J_[_gdZ dZdh]h" aZiuoZ\r_]hky
IjhajZqgh ² gZj_qb_ F_jpZe dZd" ijhajZqgh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf F_jpZe dZd" ijhajZqgh
?]h ² f_klhbf_gb_ < dheuoZgbb qv_f" _]h G n ² _]h Ijbly` ?^ q kj j I i < dheuoZgbb qv_f" _]h
Ijbly`Zl_evgu_ ijbeZ]Zl_evgu_ fZfbgu jmdb ju[Zqvy eh^dZ khkl bf
H[Z [ueb \ ihemrm[dZo rZidZo b ^h[jhlguo kZih]Zo ij ]e ehfZxlky
khkl bf
WdkdZ\Zlhju m gbo qZklh \uoh^yl ba kljhy =h\hjblv hg khkl ]e
klZe [hevr_ b djbdeb\__ h]emrbl_evg_c Y g_ jZkkqblu\Ze ij ]e
\_jgmlvky lZd kdhjh gh ^_eZ dhgqbebkv dZd lh hq_gv [ukljh b khkl bf
g_aZf_lgh Ihmljm hgZ klhyeZ i_j_^ gbf lZdZy `_ j_rbl_ev ij ]e
gZy b kihdhcgZy dZd \ i_j\mx \klj_qm Fu ihgbfZ_f qlh khkl bf
BgkZjh\ ^he`gh [ulv ohjhrbc q_eh\_d ;hevr_ \k_]h hg [h khkl bf
khkl bf
yeky ihdZaZlvky kf_rguf Y [ue ih^Z\e_g HgZ [ueZ fZl_fZlbdhf HgZ klZeZ fZl_fZlbdhf
HgZ kqblZeZkv fZl_fZlbdhf HgZ keueZ fZl_fZlbdhf
HgZ dZaZeZkv fZl_fZlbdhf
HgZ hklZ\ZeZkv fZl_fZlbdhf ]eZ]
ijbe
ijbe
Kug ijboh^be k aZgylbc \ha[m`^_gguc mklZeuc aZ ijbe
ijbe
]eZ]
]eZ]
iueb\rbcky aZ]hj_euc kZ^beky b hgb jZa]h\Zjb\Zeb h ]h jh^_ h agZdhfuo ^jmavyo Y Lbohgh\ <k_ gZ fbghghkp_ k ]eZ] ijbe
ijbe
mljZ oh^beb fheqZeb\u_ b ofmju_ E Kh[he_\ Lbfhn__\ ]eZ] ijbe
ijbe
]eZ]
y\beky mklZeuc b jZ\gh^mrguc K :glhgh\ Fu ijhklb ]eZ] ijbe
ijbe
ebkv Y mr_e jZkkljh_gguc aehc b \ ]hklbgbp_ m f_gy \ i_j ]eZ]
\uc jZa \ `bagb aZ[he_eZ ]heh\Z < DZ\_jbg >_gv dhg ]eZ]
qbeky g_ ihju\hf \_ljZ Z
ihke_^gbf e_]dbf ^uoZgb_f ]eZ] gZj ijbe
F Ijbr\bg B\Zg IZ\euq kb^_e hq_gv djZkguc b \j_fy ]eZ]
dj ijbe
hl \j_f_gb jZkl_jyggh ihijZ\eye mku < DZ\_jbg Ohjh rb e_lgb_ lmfZggu_ ^gb ohly
]eZ]
hohlgbdb bo g_ ex[yl
]eZ] ]eZ]
B Lmj]_g_\ Ijm^ _^\Z gZqbgZ_l ^ufblvky B Lmj]_g_\ ]eZ]
gZj_q
ijbe
ijbe
=eZaZ m g__ k^_eZebkv kh\k_f ihdhjgu_ \bgh\Zlu_ < IhlZgbg
KhklZ\gu_ bf_ggu_ kdZam_fu_ [ue i_j\uf gZklhysbf mq_guf \u^Zxsbfky ba \k_o [ueb fjZqgu_ [ueh hq_gv g_ mxlgh ]heh^gh oheh^gh [ueZ hq_gv gZijy`_gghc � Bkke_^h\Ze ² >bkeœw^t\te@ Š<k_ j_[ylZ mf_klylky \ iZjl_j_ª ² j_rbeZ GbgZ B\Zgh\gZ Mkem]Z \ ^jm`[_ ² \_sv k\ylZy B Djueh\ >he] gZr ² aZsbsZlv dj_ihklv ^h ihke_^g_]h gZr_]h ba^u oZgby : Imrdbg Y g_ njZgpma >_nhj` y >m[jh\kdbc : Imrdbg KibgZ m Zdmeu l_fgh kbg_]h p\_lZ Z [jxoh hke_ ibl_evgh [_eh_ B =hgqZjh\ JhfZglbaf ² \hl i_j\h_ keh\h h]eZkb\r__ imrdbgkdbc i_jbh^ < ;_ebgkdbc =h\hjblv k \Zfb ² lhevdh keh\Z ljZlblv : Hkljh\kdbc H[fZg ² \k_ ]^Z h[fZg N >hklh_\kdbc AgZqbl ^_\ylvx khjhd ² ljbklZ r_klv^_kyl lZd" : Ibk_fkdbc QZc iblv ² g_ ^jh\Z jm [blv Ihkeh\bpZ Ha_jh dZd kZfZ `bagv f_gy_lky dZ`^uc ^_gv Ihqlb dZ`^Zy fhy dgb]Z ² wlh ih_a^dZ D IZmklh\ kdbc <_^v wlh lZc]Z A^_kv agZ_l_ klh dbehf_ljh\ g_ jZk klhygb_ X ;hg^Zj_\
ŠI ª ² Z K\ylZy ² k\ylh k\ylhc k\ylbebs_ hk\ylblv k\ys_gguc AZsbsZlv ² aZsblZ aZsblgbd aZsblblvky aZsblguc KibgZ ² kibgdZ kibgghc kibgghfha]h\hc kibgmrdZ Hg ihjqZ hg qmfZ hg ya\Z a^_rgbo f_kl B Djueh\ <u km^Zjv dZf_gv km^Zjv e_^ : =jb[h_^h\ H[blZl_eb
=hjxobgZ [hevr_x qZklvx jhklZ kj_^g_]h : Imrdbg M g__ k_j^p_ hq_gv ^h[jh_ gh ]heh\Z [_^h\Zy B Lmj]_g_\ JmdZ
ijhklh dZd dZf_ggZy g_ \hjhqZ_lky B Lmj]_g_\ JZa\_ y k\h
_fm ^_lbsm \jZ]" E Lheklhc =hju dZd iurgu_ kdeZ^db gZ
[h]Zlhc h^_`^_ a_feb F =hjvdbc LZd \hl y dZdhc q_eh\_d Y hohlgbd E Lheklhc
DZf_gg Zy Yaud ² kZfh_ hiZkgh_ hjm`b_ jZgZ hl f_qZ e_]q_ aZ e_qb\Z_lky q_f hl keh\Z I DZev^_jhg Yaud _klv dj_iqZc r__ a\_gh fh]ms__ \hh[s_ k\yau\Zlv ex^_c ^jm] k ^jm]hf
F Ghj^Zm Yaud _klv a_jdZeh fuke_c gZjh^Z O K_oZ^hj Yaudb kmlv _kl_kl\_ggu_ hj]Zgbafu dhlhju_ g_kfhljy gZ aZ \bkbfhklv hl \heb q_eh\_dZ jh`^Zxlky jZklml klZj_xl b mfb jZxl kh]eZkgh hij_^_e_gguf aZdhgZf G_ba\_klguc Z\lhj Yaud _klv fZrbgZ b g_ ke_^m_l ^himkdZlv qlh[u ijm`bgu _x kdjbi_eb : Jb\Zjhev
Keh\h ² ^moh\gZy `bagv gZjh^Z fZl_jbZebah\ZggZy \ a\md_ aZql_f \ \uk\_q_gghf gZq_jlZgbb HliZ^Zxsb_ ihdhe_ gby mghkyl k kh[hc hlkhorb_ keh\hh[jZah\Zgby Keh\h [bheh ]bqgh jZklbl_evgh >Zev Oe_[gbdh\ ² \_ebdb_ [bheh]b keh\Z KeZ]Zlv \_sv ba keh\ ² wlh \k_ jZ\gh qlh kljhblv kl_gu ba `b\uo lj_i_smsbo ilbp ba ilbqvbo klZc Lu jZ[hlZ_rv k `b\hc bklhjb_c < ihwabb keh\h qbklh h[ gZ`_gh \ugmlh ba keh\_kghc lheiu ihklZ\e_gh hl^_evgh k djm ]h\uf h[ahjhf dZd ojZf gZ ohef_ : <hag_k_gkdbc
<eZ^bfbj B\Zgh\bq >Zev [ue q_eh\_dhf g_ h[udgh\_gguf Fhjkdhc \jZq iml_r_kl\_ggbd wlgh]jZn ibkZ l_ev hg dhe_kbe ih Jhkkbb bamqZe j_f_keZ b \k_ \j_fy qmldh ijbkemrb\Zeky d j_qb jZaguo ex^_c magZ\Ze fgh`_kl\h m^b\b l_evguo jmkkdbo keh\ b ihkeh\bp dhlhju_ ij_`^_ g_ [ueb ba \_klgu _fm >Z`_ gZ \hcg_ hg g_ aZ[u\Ze h k\h_f aZgylbb < B >Zev kh[jZe [hevrh_ dhebq_kl\h keh\ Gh ihdZ hgb ijy lZebkv m g_]h \ l_ljZ^dZo [_kp_ggh_ khdjh\bs_ ijbgZ^e_`Zeh _fm h^ghfm : qlh[u hl^Zlv wlh khdjh\bs_ \k_f k[_j_qv ^ey \k_o yaud gZjh^Z >Zev ba^Ze ©Lhedh\uc keh\Zjv `b\h]h \_eb dhjmkkdh]h yaudZª \dexqZxsbc lukyq keh\ ;hevr_ e_l ©Lhedh\uc keh\Zjv ª >Zey m^b\ey_l b \hk obsZ_l qblZl_e_c jZ^m_l lhqgufb yjdbfb gZjh^gufb keh\Zfb fm^jufb b \_k_eufb ihkeh\bpZfb : ^ey ebg]\bklh\ keh\Zjv >Zey ² g_bkkydZ_fuc bklhqgbd ba dhlhjh]h hgb q_jiZxl agZ gby h jmkkdbo keh\Zo Keh\Zjv ihfh]Z_l ^hgylv b agZq_gby fgh ]bo ^bZe_dlguo keh\ >_nbk ² kh_^bgbl_evgZy q_jlhqdZ f_`^m qZklyfb keh`gh]h keh\Z ijb ihemkeblghf gZibkZgbb Lbj_ ² agZd ij_ibgZgby \ \b^_ ^ebgghc ]hjbahglZevghc q_jlhqdb Keh\Z
^b\Zg djh\Zlv l_fgh \brg_\uc ih fh_fm ba ih^ ibrmlky q_ j_a ^_nbk F_`^m ih^e_`Zsbf b kdZam_fuf klZ\blky lbj_ LZdkb hklZgh\behkv m kdeZ^h\ aZ\h^Z Bgl_j\vx ih dZaZehkv fg_ bgl_j_kguf Dhn_ [ukljh klZe hklu\Zlv Rhkk_ hk\_s_gh ebrv \ g_dhlhjuo f_klZo KZeyfb h[eZ^Z eZ ohjhrbfb \dmkh\ufb dZq_kl\Zfb Khqb jZkiheh`_g gZ x]_ Jhkkbb JN klZeZ iheghijZ\guf qe_ghf HHG @xjb ijb km^beh i_j\h_ f_klh gZr_fm a_feydm Fgh`_kl\h ex^_c ohl_eh ohl_eb [u ih[u\Zlv gZ jh ^bg_ ihwlZ Gb kheg_qguc iey` gb fhj_ gb a_e_gv _fm g_ gjZ\ylky Kdhevdh e_l ijhreh k lh]h iZfylgh]h ^gy GZ klhe_ e_`Zeh fgh]h \_s_c ijbgZ^e_`Zsbo ohaybgm d\Zjlbju >\h_ khe^Zl _s_ g_ \_jgmebkv \_jgmehkv Q_l\_jh kb^yl \ dj_keZo Z iyl_jh ijbfhklbebkv gZ ih^hdhggbd_ Dh_ dlh oh l_e iha\hgblv gZ :LK D e_km [_`Zeb GbgZ b ^jm]b_ `_gsb gu FZfZ b k_kljZ ^h\hevgu ijhbkoh^ysbfb \ k_fv_ i_j_f_ gZfb Ijhbahreh g_fZeh kh[ulbc dhlhju_ i_j_\_jgmeb \kx `bagv \\_jo ^ghf ;hevrbgkl\h rdhevgbdh\ ijbklmibeh ijbklmibeb d \uiheg_gbx mijZ`g_gby Ijbfhklbe b kv gZ ih^hdhggbd Zo i_j_\_jgme b <k_ dlh agZeb agZe fZ^Zf Rlhev agZeb b ex[beb <Z j_gvdm E Lheklhc ;hevrbgkl\h k_jv_agh ^Z`_ fjZqgh kfhlj_eb kfhlj_eh gZ wlm `b\mx dZjlbgm [_aukoh^gh]h jZa^m fvy b kh \a^hohf hloh^beb hloh^beh E :g^j__\ Lml wlb ex^b dlh ih g_jZamf_gbx k\h_fm fZeh^mrgh iheh`beb iheh `be hjm`b_ magZeb b klu^ : G Lheklhc Fgh`_kl\h jmd klmqZl klmqbl \h \k_ hdgZ k mebpu Z dlh lh ehfblky \ ^\_jv G E_kdh\ GZ ebp_ m g_]h ihi_j_f_ggh \uklmiZe \uklmiZeb g_ lh kljZo g_ lh lhkdZ b ^hkZ^Z <hl b m gZk ^\h_ khk_^_c ijh`b\Zeh ijh`b\Zeb B Lmj]_g_\
dZdhc"
dZdmx"
o
o
KlZjuc bg\Zeb^ kb^y gZ klhe_ gZrb\Ze kbgxx aZieZ dZdh]h"
o
dZdhc"
o
Imrdbg Iheguc f_kyp lm gZ ehdhlv a_e_gh]h fmg^bjZ : dZdb_" dZdmx"
o
o qv_]h"
dZdh]h"
o
k\_lbe gZ dZfurh\mx djurm b [_eu_ kl_gu fh_]h gh\h]h `b o dZdhc"
k dZdbf"
ebsZ F E_jfhglh\ F_`^m hdgZfb klhye ]mkZj k jmfyguf qvy" o
o
dZdbfb"
o
ebphf b ]eZaZfb gZ\udZl_ B Lmj]_g_\ ?_ k_kljZ a\ZeZkv
dZdmx"
o
LZlvygZ : Imrdbg q_]h" KdZ`bl_ fg_ dZdmx gb[m^v gh\hklv dZdb_" o
o
qvb"
E_jfhglh\ Ke_au \^hogh\_gvy b \_ju gZihegbeb ]eZaZ F qvb" q_]h" dZdhc"
o Qb`Z F =hjvdbc Emq ijh`_dlhjZ ijhg_kky gZ^ h]jZ^hc b dZdhc"
o
o
q_]h" dZdhfm"
jZkkuiZeky ba\_kldh\hc iuevx \ aZjhkeyo ih kdehgm ]hju dZdh]h" o
D IZmklh\kdbc Kh[ulby djmig__ b \Z`g__ g_ [ueh \ bklh dZdh]h" dZdhc" dh]h" o
dZdZy"
o
o
jbb q_eh\_q_kl\Z : G Lheklhc DZ`^Zy f_ehqv wlh]h ^gy dZdhc" o
IZmklh\kdbc <_kv ^_gv fu [jh^beb \j_aZeZkv \ iZfylv D dZdhfm" ih dZdhfm"
dZdbo" o
o
o
dZdbo"
ih wlhfm ]hjh^m djZkguo kdZe dhr_d b klZjbdh\ [_k_^mxsbo hdheh dZdbo"
dZdbo"
dZdbfb"
o
hdheh \ulZs_gguo gZ [_j_] ih^i_jluo ba\_kldh\ufb ]eu[Zfb o
romg D IZmklh\kdbc
DZdmx gb[m^v ² f_klhbf_gb_ dlh lh qlh eb[h dh_ dlh
<ulZs_gg uo Â? Â? Â? Â? Â? Â? gtdtfurR\\MÂśm >iheguMÂś fÂśwkvp k\ÂśvlÂśbe djurm b[ÂśweuMÂśw Â? Â? klÂśwgu ftMÂśv\h gh\t\t `ueÂśbsÂśt@ Â? kh]e Hk_gg_x ^hjh]hc kh]e
kh]e
F_jdg_l ^_gv GZ^ mklZehc ih[e_dr_c a_fe_c kh]e
G_ih^\b`gu_ lmqb \bkyl
kh]e
kh]e
Ih^ ijhsZevguf m[hjhf ebkl\u ahehlhc B [_j_au b ebiu kd\hayl kh]e
>mrm h[gyeb g_`gh lhkdeb\u_ kgu kh]e
AZf_jeZ [_kdhg_qgZy ^Zev kh]e
kh]e
B jhkdhrgh [e_klys_c b rmfghc \_kgu kh]e
Ijbfbj_gghfm k_j^pm g_ `Zev
B dZd [m^lh a_fey hloh^y gZ ihdhc g_kh]e
Ih]jmabeZkv \ fhebl\m [_a keh\ kh]e
B kimkdZ_lky k g_[Z g_\b^bfuc jhc kh]e
kh]e
;e_^ghdjueuo [_afhe\guo ^moh\ < Kheh\v_\
=h^u dZdb_" q_]h" \hcgu ² \h_ggu_ ]h^u ?fm ijbrehkv i_j_`blv o
dZdb_"
o
ly`_eu_ ]h^u \hcgu ² HgZ jh^beZkv \ ly`_eu_ \h_ggu_ ]h^u dZdb_" q_]h" o
>gb hk_gb ² hk_ggb_ ^gb Ofmju_ ^gb hk_gb lygmebkv [_k dZdb_"
o
dhg_qgh ² Ohjhrh b^lb ih e_km \ l_ieu_ hk_ggb_ ^gb
JZ^hklgh_ qm\kl\h ² qm\kl\h jZ^hklb F_gy ho\Zlbeh jZ^h
dZdh_"
o dZdh_" q_]h"
o
klgh_ qm\kl\h ih[_^u ² ?_ i_j_ihegyeh qm\kl\h jZ^hklb b ]hj ^hklb
Lj_\h`gh_ qm\kl\h ² qm\kl\h lj_\h]b Fg_ g_ ^Z\Zeh aZ dZdh_"
o
kgmlv lj_\h`gh_ qm\kl\h ijb[eb`Zxs_cky hiZkghklb ² ?]h g_ o
dZdh_" q_]h"
ihdb^Zeh qm\kl\h lj_\h]b
Kj_^kl\Z yaudZ ² yaudh\u_ kj_^kl\Z :\lhj m^Zqgh bkihev o dZdb_" q_]h"
dZdb_"
ah\Ze \ k\h_c dgb]_ \ujZabl_evgu_ kj_^kl\Z yaudZ ² Yaudh\u_ o
kj_^kl\Z bkihevah\Zggu_ Z\lhjhf ih^q_jdb\Zxl djZkhlm b lZ bgkl\_gghklv abfg_]h e_kZ o
Iylbe_lgyy ^_\hqdZ ² ^_\hqdZ iylb e_l Jy^hf k gbf reZ dZdZy"
^_\hqdZ iylb e_l hljh^m ² < i_khqgbp_ ^jm`gh b]jZeb iylb dZdZy"
o
e_lgyy ^_\hqdZ b q_luj_oe_lgbc fZevqbd
Fma_c bklhjbb ² bklhjbq_kdbc fma_c GZr deZkk kdhjh ihc o dZdhc" q_]h"
dZdhc"
^_l gZ wdkdmjkbx \ fma_c bklhjbb b wlgh]jZnbb ² Bklhjbq_ o
kdbc fma_c ² deZ^_av agZgbc b mf_gbc q_eh\_q_kl\Z
I_gb_ ilbp ² ilbqv_ i_gb_ Hg hq_gv ex[be kemrZlv \ e_km
o qvz" dh]h"
i_gb_ ilbp ² ;ueh lboh b lhevdh baj_^dZ fh`gh [ueh mkeu qvz" o
rZlv ilbqv_ i_gb_ b rhjho ebkl\u Q_j_a \_kv ]hjh^ lygmeZkv ebgby h]hgvdh\ gZ gZ[_j_` ghc j_db Dmju Hkh[_ggh djZkb\u ^_j_\_gkdb_ eZklhqdb dZkZldb H <he]Z j_dZ dheu[_ev g_^h\hevkl\Z ijZfZl_jv b fZl_jv a_fgh]h ]_jhckl\Z < ;hdh\ KlZjbd hl_p kb^_e gZ aZ \Zebgd_ b ]j_eky gZ khegp_ Ijbgylv mqZklb_ \ ij_^klZ\b l_evghc \uklZ\d_ [ue ijb]eZr_g om^h`gbd ihjlj_lbkl KdZ ahqguc ]_jhc ² B\Zg pZj_\bq k q_klvx ijhr_e bkiulZgby b
h^_j`Ze \_jo gZ^ kbeZfb aeZ Ijhc^_l kdhevdh lh iheh`_g guo ^ey ^_j_\Z e_l b \ky iheygZ aZjZkl_l h^gbfb _edZfb Z [_j_ au ihdjh\bl_evgbpu aZqZogml \ l_gb F Ijbr\bg Ba[jZg gu_ fghx k_klju [_j_adb g_[hevrb_ _s_ \ jhkl q_eh\_dZ F Ijbr\bg GZ \_jrbgm ]hju Wev[jmk kihjlkf_gu ih^gy ebkv ^h aZoh^Z khegpZ b ijh[ueb lZf iheqZkZ
GZ \_jrbgm ]hju Wev[jmk kihjlkf_gu ih^gyebkv ^h aZoh^Z
khegpZ b ijh[ueb lZf iheqZkZ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g h^ghjh^gufb kdZam_fufb > b @ K_j]_c ² [hevrhc mfgbpZ >\Z wlbo mq_gbdZ [ueb q_fibhgZfb ih rZofZlZf GZrZ ]hklvy ² lZeZgleb\uc dhf ihablhj Ih imlb bf \klj_lbebkv ljb g_ijbf_lgu_ `_gsbgu Hg g_^Zjhf kqblZ_lky aZdhj_g_euf g_\_`_c >_\hqd_ \ e_l klu^gh [ulv lZdhc g_\_`^hc Ih jZ^bh ijha\mqZeb ljb \Z`guo khh[s_gby Fhc dhee_]Z Dmag_ph\Z iv_l ih mljZf lhevdh dZdZh HklZevgu_ q_luj_ ^hfZ [ueb ih^dexq_gu d we_dljhk_lb aZ iylv ^g_c Ba\_klguc ijhn_kkhj DhgklZglb gh\Z ihkeZeZ dhee_]Zf ijb]eZr_gby aZ ^\_ g_^_eb ^h gZqZeZ gZ mqghc dhgn_j_gpbb ;_a kheb [_a oe_[Z om^Zy [_k_^Z ;_eu_ jmqdb qm`b_ ljm^u ex[yl ;eb`gbc khk_^ emqr_ ^Zevg_c jh^gb ;hev rhfm dmkdm jhl jZ^m_lky < lbohf hfml_ q_jlb \h^ylky < qm`hf oe_\m h\_p g_ kqblZxl <_k_ggbc ^_gv ]h^ dhjfbl <kydZy ebkZ k\hc o\hkl o\Zebl =emihfm kugm b jh^ghc hl_p mfZ g_ ijbrv_l >ey ke_ih]h djhlZ gb d q_fm djZkhlZ >mjgu_ ijbf_ju aZjZabl_evgu Ihgylguc jZkkdZa ihgylguc ihq_jd ihgyleb\Zy ^_\hqdZ ihgyleb\u_ ^jmavy Kdjulguc kh[_k_^gbd kdjulu_ \hafh`ghklb kdjulZy m]jh aZ kdjulh_ \heg_gb_ M^Zqguc \u[hj m^Zqgh_ ijba_fe_gb_ m^Zqeb\uc Zjlbkl m^Zqeb\uc q_eh\_d GZdhg_p lh y mkeurZe [he__ f_g__ ihgylguc jZkkdZa ?keb lu m\Z`Z_rv qblZxs_]h m l_[y ^he`_g [ulv ihgylguc ihq_jd
HgZ [ueZ ^_\hqdZ ihgyleb\Zy Ihgyleb\u_ ^jmavy ihfh]ml \ keh`ghc kblmZpbb Hg ihqm\kl\h\Ze qlh ijhn_kkhj ² kdjulguc kh[_k_^gbd Wlhl f_oZgbaf bf__l kdjulu_ \hafh`ghklb < ibkvf_ lZb eZkv kdjulZy m]jhaZ < __ ebp_ [ueh aZf_lgh kdjulh_ \heg_gb_ LZlvygZ k^_eZeZ m^Zqguc \u[hj IZjZrxlbkl \kihfbgZe h k\h_f m^Zqghf ijba_fe_gbb GZr khk_^ ² m^Zqeb\uc Zjlbkl <h \k_o gZqbgZgbyo <Z^bd [ue m^Zqeb\uf q_eh\_dhf h qzf" o
f_kl
o
dh]h"
f_kl
Hgb h q_f lh dhk\ [helZeb kf_yebkv gh m\b^_\ f_gy o ih^ qzf"
kms
ijyf lhlqZk aZfhedeb lhjhieb\h ihijZ\beb ih^ ieZlhqdZfb qlh" kms
o
qlh"
kms
dhk\ k\_leu_ \hehku ijyf b k_j^blh ih^`Zeb ]m[u ijyf D IZmklh\kdbc GZdhg_p hdheh ihemghqb mklZeuc ohaybg o
qlh"
kms
qlh"
o
kms
ij_djZlbe lZgpu ijyf ijbdZaZe ^Z\Zlv m`bg ijyf Z kZf o
dh]h"
hlijZ\beky kiZlv : Imrdbg HgZ >ZrZ aZklZ\beZ B\ZgZ qlh k^_eZlv" ]eZ] o g_jZae k k
kms
qlh"
BevbqZ ijyf \uiblv g_kdhevdh qZr_d dhn_ ijyf E G Lhe o q_j_a qlh"
kms
qlh"
kms
klhc >_jkm kgZqZeZ i_j_g_k q_j_a j_dm dhk\ jm`vy ijyf qlh"
kms
o
dhfm"
f_kl
b dhlhfdb ijyf Z aZl_f ihfh] i_j_ijZ\blvky fg_ dhk\ kms q_f" o
< :jk_gv_\ IZoeh `Zj_ghc bg^_cdhc dhk\ b fZjbgh\Zg kms kms
o dhfm"
gufb \brgyfb dhk\ : Q_oh\ >he]h hg ljyk klZjbdm qlh" k q_f" kms
o
kms
dhk\ jmdm ijyf b iha^jZ\eye k gZ]jZ^hc dhk\ K ;Z[Z_\ kms
dh]h"
o
kdbc >_l_c ijyf \\h^bl \ fbj kdZadb g_ lhevdh gZjh^gZy ihwaby gh b l_Zlj D IZmklh\kdbc =_jZkbfh\bq _`beky hl qlh" o
kms
\_ljZ ^_j`Ze jmdb ijyf \ [hdh\uo dZjfZgZo ² b smieuc o
gZ dh]h"
kms
ihoh^be gZ \hjh[vy dhk\ : Khe`_gbpug
I_j_oh^g ]e k g_ kms \ J i g_ ijbagZ_l \eZkl_c g_ ihc i_k_g g_ ghkbe k_j^pZ g_ ebe ke_a g_ aZkem`be fbehklb g_ gZ^_\Ze [jZke_lZ g_ ihdZau\Ze kljZoZ g_ kl_kgyeZ ^\b`_gbc g_ kdju\ZeZ \uijZ\db g_ ijbg_keh ykghklb g_ \b^_e kgZ g_ ex[be ihwabb I_j_oh^g ]e [_a g_ kms \ \ i ijbagZ_l \eZklv ihc i_k gb ghkbe k_j^p_ ebe ke_au aZkem`be fbehklv gZ^_\Ze [jZke_l
ihdZau\Ze kljZo kl_kgyeZ ^\b`_gby kdju\ZeZ \uijZ\dm ijb g_keh ykghklv \b^_e khg ex[be ihwabx DhjZ[eb rlmjfmxl [Zklbhgu Ij_iylkl\b_ ij_h^h e_\Z_l \hey FZeZy e_gv [hevrh_ ]hj_ ijbghkbl Bghc yaud f_^ ijbg_k_l ^jm]hc [_^m gZdebq_l >_j_\h lhqbl q_j\v ba gmljb h[j ^ dZd" o
K ljm^hf =jb]hjbc gZlygme gZ k_[y ihem lmemiZ e_] gZ f_ju dZd" o
kibgm F Rhehoh\ ;m^v djZkb\hc dZd fZlv b \^\h_ kqZkl ]^_"
f_klZ
f_klZ
eb\Z F =hjvdbc GZ himrd_ fheh^h]h e_kZ ebphf d OZjvdh ]^_" o
\j_f
dh]^Z"
o
\m \ujhk]^_" djZkb\uc k_juc ^hf : FZdZj_gdh >g_f a\_jv e_ dZd" o
f_klZ
o
h[j ^
`bl ]^_ gb[m^v \ qZs_ b gZclb _]h ljm^gh < :jk_gv_\ \j_f
dh]^Z"
o
Ihke_ h[_^Z Ihjnbjbc <eZ^bfbjh\bq m^Zebeky kiZlv mke
ijb dZdhf mkeh\bb" o
F KZeludh\ S_^jbg G_ \dmkb\ ]hjvdh]h g_ magZ_rv b \hij_db q_fm" mklmidb
keZ^dh]h Ihkeh\bpZ G_kfhljy gZ mklZehklv gZ g_m^Zqb k\y mklmidb
aZggu_ k g_hiulghklvx g_\abjZy gZ ij_^ijbbfqb\hklv ^y^b o
]^_"
f_klZ
o
dh]^Z"
\j_f
Xju dhlhjuc `be g_ih^Ze_dm b ijboh^be \ kZfu_ g_mjhqgu_ o
qZku Zjl_ev gZoh^beZ \j_fy ^ey aZ^mr_\guo [_k_^ < Bg[_j o
dZd"
?oZe y gZ dmjv_jkdhf \ i_j\hf deZkk_ qlh h[hrehkv j_^Zdlh ]^_" h[j ^
f_klZ
o
Q_oh\ Klhx h^bg kj_^b jZ\gbgu ]hehc Z jm g_^_r_\h : dm^Z" f_klZ
o
`mjZ\e_c hlghkbl \_l_j \ ^Zev K ?k_gbg Hgb \u`^Zeb dh dh]^Z" dZd" h[j ^
dZd"
o
\j_f
]^Z klZjbd mr_e aZ q_f lh lboh kimklbebkv b aZl_f dZd gb \ q_f h[j ^
o
g_ [u\Zeh ih^hreb dZd [m^lh kgZjm`b : =Zc^Zj
Â? iZem Â? Â? Â? ]jÂśb]hjÂśbMÂś Â? gtkÂśv[ÂśZ Â? lmemit Â? >kljm^hf gtlÂśvgme eÂśhd
Â? gZkiÂśbgm@ Nhlh]jZnby ^Z\gh e_`ZeZ ih^ kl_dehf ih^ q_f" ]^_" Q_eh\_d ^urbl e_]dbfb q_f" dZd" GZ [_j_a_ ihy\bebkv i_j\u_ ebklhqdb gZ q_f" ]^_" Ijh\_klb hlimkd m jh^guo ihf_rZeb g_ij_^\b^_ggu_ h[klhyl_evkl\Z m dh]h" ]^_" Fhc ^jm] ijb_oZe ba Fhkd\u GZ aZ\h^ ijb[ueZ ij_^klZ\bl_evgZy ^_e_]Zpby <hij_db ijbdZam ^bj_dlhjZ jZ [hqbc g_ ijbklmibe d \uiheg_gbx aZ^Zgby Wlh khh[s_gb_ ijbreh k MdjZbgu Ibkvf_ ijbg_keb fg_ ijyfh k ihqlu
Ijb_a`bc kdeZ^u\Ze \_sb \ q_fh^Zg Dh]^Z y ih^t_a`Ze d klZgpbb b ]ey^_e gZ ijbjh^m \ hdgh m f_gy ke_l_eZ reyiZ Hiylv ihr_e kbevguc kg_] b gZf ijbrehkv aZghq_\Zlv \ ]hk lbgbp_ GZ ^gyo y d \Zf h[yaZl_evgh ijb_^m K_fbgZj kh klhblky \ ^_dZ[j_ Dgb]Z ^hklZeZkv _fm ^Zjhf Ex^b `b eb \ ]hjh^_ ij_djZkgh Khegp_ kdehgyykv d aZdZlm ijbgbfZeh fy]dbc djZkgh \Zluc k\_l b emqZfb k\hbfb keh\gh iheuf_f ho\Zlbeh kl_iv IZmlbgZ dZd ahehlZy iuev ^jh`ZeZ \ lbohf \ha^mo_ l_ f_klZ gZ^ dhlhjufb ^jh`ZeZ hgZ dZaZebkv ih^_jgmlufb dZdbf lh em qbkluf dhehjblhf >ebggu_ l_gb eh`bebkv hl gbo gZ ljZ\m \u^_eyykv l_fgh a_e_gufb iylgZfb kj_^b k\_lys_]hky ijhklh jZ J_ev_nghklv hq_jlZgbc ij_^f_lh\ [ueZ bamfbl_evgZy >Zev ghklv jZkklhygby dZd [u g_ kms_kl\h\ZeZ ^ey ]eZaZ K ijbjh^u keh\gh ne_j kgyeb b hgZ \k_fb ^_lZeyfb k\hbfb yjdh [jhkZeZkv \ ]eZaZ g_`gh eZkdZy bo fy]dbfb lhgZfb : Wjl_ev
w >F\ÂśbwlÂśDsÂśb Â? \tFÂśt@ ² keh]h\ >k@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >\Âś@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >bw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >lÂś@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >D@ ² ]eZkg m^ >sÂś@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >bw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >\@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >t@ Ă&#x201E; ² ]eZkg [_am^ >kÂś@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ K\_lys_]hky ² [md\ K ijbjh^u keh\gh ne_j kgyeb b hgZ \k_fb ^_lZeyfb k\hbfb yjdh [jhkZeZkv \ ]eZaZ g_`gh eZkdZy bo fy]dbfb lhgZfb
> @ b > ²
@
o
o
IjbfudZgb_ ijbgbfZeh kdehgyykv eh`bebkv \u^_eyykv o
o
[jhkZeZkv eZkdZy g_`gh eZkdZy K\_lZ_l
Khegp_ _s_ g_ \koh^beh gh iheh\bgZ g_[Z m`_ [ueZ aZeblZ [e_^guf jhah\uf k\_lhf IjhajZqgZy b kihdhcgZy j_dZ e_`ZeZ lhqgh ]jhfZ^gh_ a_jdZeh \ a_e_ghc \eZ`ghc jZf_ h`b\rbo hjhr_gguo em]h\ E_]db_ jhah\u_ fhjsbgu ke_]dZ [hjha^beb __ ]eZ^dmx ih\_joghklv Z i_gZ ih^ iZjhoh^gufb dhe_kZfb dZaZ eZkv fhehqgh jhah\hc GZ ijZ\hf [_j_]m fheh^hc [_j_ah\uc e_k k _]h qZkluf kljh_f lhgdbo ijyfuo [_euo kl\heh\ [ue hdmlZg lhqgh lhgdhc dbk_ _c e_]dbf ihdjh\hf lmfZgZ KbaZy ly`_eZy lmqZ gbadh ih\bk rZy gZ \hklhd_ h^gZ lhevdh [hjheZkv k kbyxsbf lhj`_kl\hf gZjy^gh]h e_lg_]h mljZ Gh b gZ g_c m`_ [juagmeb lhqgh djh\Z \u_ ihlhdb l_fgh djZkgu_ rljbob : Dmijbg
FRehqgh jhah\ hc l_fgh djZkg u_
Khegp_ ² bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ G_ \koh^beh qlh" kheg p_ Ij_^f_l G n ² khegp_ GZjbp g_h^mr kj j kde ?^ q B i G_ \koh^beh qlh" khegp_
E_]db_ ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ Fhjsbgu dZdb_" ez]db_ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² e_]dbc DZq_kl\ Fg q B i Fhjsbgu dZdb_" e_]db_ ;hjha^beb ² ]eZ]he Fhjsbgu qlh ^_eZeb" [hjha^beb >_ckl\b_ G n ² [hjha^blv G_kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde ijhr \j Fg q
Fhjsbgu qlh ^_eZeb" [hjha^beb
Ih\bkrZy ² ijbqZklb_ LmqZ dZdZy" ih\bkrZy IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ih\bkgmlv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q ` j B i LmqZ dZdZy" ih\bkrZy FZfZ `^ZeZ dh]^Z `_ hg h]eyg_lky gZaZ^ <jZq gZagZqbe iZpb_glm fZkkZ` kibgu >_l_c ihl_jy\rbo \ wlhc dZlZkljhn_ jh^bl_e_c hdjm`Zl aZ [hlhc Qlh[u dmiblv l_e_\bahj khk_^b h^he`Zl m gZk ^_gv]b DjmigZy Zn_jZ k ^jZ]hp_ggufb dZfgyfb jZkdjulZ hj]ZgZfb [_ahiZkghklb Bg\Zeb^Zf gZoh^ysbfFy [Ha ^\b`Hgby gm`gZ ihklhyggZy hi_dZ JmkkdZy ]jZffZlbdZ g_dhlhjuf g_ ih^ kbem < gh\uo ykeyo kha^Zeb `b\hc m]hehd G_ijhbag kh]e ² qm\kl\h o
Kh]eZkh\Zgb_ lZdh_ qm\kl\h o
MijZ\e_gb_ ihfgx jmdb
o
IjbfudZgb_ ^\Z`^u i_j_`be :joZg]_evkd ² djmiguc lhj]h\uc ihjl ² Djmiguc lhj]h\uc ihjl ² :joZg]_evkd <_keh aZ^_eh ie_qh ² Ie_qh aZ^_eh \_keh Mljh aZf_qZl_evgh_ ² AZf_qZl_evgh_ mljh >\Z^pZlv ^g_c y [ue \ hlt_a^_ ² >g_c ^\Z^pZlv y [ue \ hlt _a^_ Lu fhc emqrbc ^jm] ² Fhc emqrbc ^jm] ² lu ;hevghc j_[_ghd \_jgmeky ² J_[_ghd \_jgmeky [hevghc Wlh mljh hg kljZ^Ze `_klhdh DZd gbdh]^Z l_jaZeZ _]h bklhjbb _]h ex[\b lhfbeZ kf_jlv ?^\Z ]h\hjy hg ihijhkbe gZj\Zlv kbj_gb Kbj_gv [ueZ k\_`Zy [e_^gh nbhe_lh\Zy k dZ i_evdZfb jhku <^uoZy __ aZiZo hg keZ[ufb iZevpZfb ljh]Ze p\_lu B meu[gmeky ]hjvdh \kihfgb\ qlh gbdh]^Z g_ fh] gZclb \ kbj_gb iylb e_i_kldh\ kqZklvy
<_q_jhf gZibkZe kugm < wlhf ibkvf_ [ueh lZdh_ f_klh ©Ih\b^Zlv l_[y :g^j_c fg_ [u ohl_ehkv Fu ^Z\gh g_ \b^_ ebkv @_eZx l_[_ ykghc b k\_lehc `bagb ihfgb ^jm] fhc qlh \_ebqZcr__ kqZklv_ q_eh\_dZ _klv ex[h\v ª Ihke_ wlh]h ibkvfZ IZ\_e :glhguq mklZe kljZrgh \kx ghqv hg ijh\_e [_a kgZ aZ^uoZykv b rbjhdbfb hl lhkdb ]eZaZfb ]ey ^y ijyfh gZ k\_qb ; AZcp_\
Wlh mljh hg kljZ^Ze `_klhdh Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_
dZdh_"o
Wlh mljh f_kl kms Lbi k\yab ² kh]eZkh\Zgb_ o dh]^Z"
KljZ^Ze mljh ]eZ] kms Lbi k\yab ² mijZ\e_gb_ o
dZd"
KljZ^Ze `_klhdh ]eZ] gZj_q Lbi k\yab ² ijbfudZgb_ ©G_hohlgh b g_kf_eh ª G_hohlgh b g_kf_eh Khegp_ kfhljbl gZ ihey Qm aZ lmq_c ijh]j_f_eh IjbgZofmjbeZkv a_fey
<_ljZ l_ieh]h ihju\u >Zevgbc ]jhf b ^h`^v ihjhc A_e_g_xsb_ gb\u A_e_g__ ih^ ]jhahc <hl ijh[beZkv ba aZ lmqb Kbg_c fhegbb kljmy ² IeZf_gv [_euc b e_lmqbc HdZcfbe __ djZy
QZs_ dZieb ^h`^_\u_ <boj_f iuev e_lbl k ihe_c B jZkdZlu ]jhfh\u_ <k_ k_j^bl_c b kf_e_c Khegp_ jZa _s_ \a]eygmeh Bkih^eh[vy gZ ihey
B \ kbygv_ ihlhgmeZ <ky kfyl_ggZy a_fey N Lxlq_\
A_e_g__ k_j^bl_c kf_e_c
A_e_g__ ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ Gb\u dZdh\u" a_e_g__ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² a_e_guc DZq_kl\ ijhkl kj kl Gb\u dZdh\u" a_e_g__ K_j^bl_c ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ JZkdZlu dZdh\u" k_j^b l_c IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² k_j^bluc DZq_kl\ ijhkl kj kl JZkdZlu dZdh\u" k_j^bl_c
Kf_e_c ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ JZkdZlu dZdh\u" kf_e_c IjbagZ\ ij_^f_lZ G n ² kf_euc DZq_kl\ ijhkl kj kl JZkdZlu dZdh\u" kf_e_c
Ijh]j_f_eh ² [_aebqguc ]eZ]he Y gZ[jZeZ jZaghp\_lguo ebklv_\ b ihg_keZ bo ^hfhc IZj_gv h]eygmeky gZaZ^ b m\b^_e gZjmrbl_ey gZ ]heh\m \ur_ k_[y Bg^__p k ]hem[ufb i_jvyfb _oZe gZ dhg_ Hkh[_ggh kbevgh_ \i_qZle_gb_ gZ f_gy ijhba\_e ^g_\gbd LZgb KZ\bq_\hc < wlh \j_fy \ \h^h_fZo h[eZklb aZij_s_gZ eh\ey ju[u \k_fb kihkh[Zfb Ebrv lu fh`_rv fg_ ihfhqv \ wlhf ^_e_ Dh ]^Z \u b^_l_ ^hfhc" < mgb\_jfZ]_ \ [hevrhf \u[hj bf_xlky mdjZr_gby aZjm[_`gh]h ijhba\h^kl\Z ^ey `_gsbg @_eZx \Zf ba[_`Zlv \k_\hafh`guo [_^ i_qZe_c b gZiZkl_c : Q_oh\
M gZk khj\Zeh h[_ fZqlu b \k_ iZjmkZ Ghqv Kb`m \ dZxl_ b ibrm Ljb qZkZ ghqb KljZrguc lj_kd Djbdb ;_ ]m d dhfZg^_ OjZgbl_ l_ji_gv_ e fg q ih\_e gZde Kem`b \_jgh e _^ q ih\_e gZde Dhfm ijbky]g_rv e _^ q [m^ \j baty\ gZde
KemrZcky gZqZevgbdh\ e _^ q ih\_e gZde AZ eZkdhc g_ ]hgycky e _^ q ih\_e gZde GZ kem`[m g_ gZijZrb\Zcky e _^ q ih\_e gZde Hl kem`[u g_ hl]h\Zjb\Zcky e _^ q ih\_e gZde Ihfgb ihkeh\bpm e _^ q ih\_e gZde ;_j_]b ieZlv_ ^ _^ q ih\_e gZde Meu[gbl_kv e fg q ih\_e gZde Ih^gbfbl_ ]eZaZ e fg q ih\_e gZde K_cl_ e fg q ih\_e gZde <b`m em] e _^ q gZkl \j baty\ gZde Keurm klmd e _^ q gZkl \j baty\ gZde <boj_f ihfqbfky e fg q [m^ \j baty\ gZde B lh]^Z ijhc^_rv e _^ q baty\ gZde ljhibgdhc AZ[m^v e _^ q ih\_e gZde aZ[hlu b i_qZeb mfqbkv e _^ q ih\_e gZde [_a p_eb gZ dhg_ \ lmfZg b \ em]h\u_ ^Zeb < ]mklhc ljZ\_ ijhiZ^_rv e _^ q baty\ gZde k ]heh\hc < lbobc ^hf \hc^_rv e _^ q baty\ gZde g_ klmqZkv Khegp_ \uc^_l haZjbl `bagv dbibl lyg_lky jZ\gbgZ ijh g_keZkv [mjy aZ]m^_e eb\_gv Lhjhibfky \ [Zkk_cg ² Fu lhjhibfky \ [Zkk_cg Ohqm aZibkZlvky \ k_dpbx ieZ\Zgby ² Y ohqm aZibkZlvky \ k_dpbx ieZ\Zgby Fu jZ^m_fky mki_oZf gZrbo kihjlkf_gh\ ² JZ^m_fky mki_oZf gZrbo kihjlkf_gh\ Ijboh^brv gZ kh j_\gh\Zgby ² Lu ijboh^brv gZ khj_\gh\Zgby Lu k \heg_ gb_f gZ[ex^Z_rv aZ [hjv[hc kihjlkf_gh\ ² K \heg_gb_f gZ [ex^Z_rv aZ [hjv[hc kihjlkf_gh\ ;m^m y lh`_ mqZkl\h\Zlv \ kihjlb\guo khklyaZgbyo ² ;m^m lh`_ mqZkl\h\Zlv \ kihjlb\ guo khklyaZgbyo ;_jm [_jb [_jbl_ dgb]m <gbfZl_evgh qblZx qblZc qblZcl_ __ JZkkdZau\Zx jZkkdZau\Zc jZkkdZau\Zcl_ h ijhqb lZgghf ^jmavyf Bgl_j_kmxkv bgl_j_kmcky bgl_j_kmcl_kv ih gjZ\beZkv eb wlZ dgb]Z Ijhrm ijhkb ijhkbl_ ^jma_c ih^_ eblvky \i_qZle_gbyfb h[ bo ex[bfuo dgb]Zo Kihc e ih\_e gZde fg_ i_kgx
Qlh \v _rv ky e baty\ gZde eZklhqdZ d hdgm qlh \hev gZy ih _rv e baty\ gZde " >Ze_dh gZ kdZeZo \ kl_ib ijbxl keur m e baty\ gZde k_[_ Lhevdh ihbsb e ih\_e gZde ² gZc^ _rv e baty\ gZde <a]eygb e ih\_e gZde gZ a\_a^u Dm^Z _^ _l_ e baty\ gZde " G_ \b^ brv e baty\ gZde qlh eb" KemrZc e ih\_e gZde ^jm] y l_[_ aZieZq m \havfb e ih\_e gZde k kh[hc ih_^ m e baty\ gZde h[jZlgh KZ^b kv e ih\_e gZde L_i_jv am[jh\ g_ lhevdh hojZgyxl e gZkl \j fg q gh b jZa\h^yl e gZkl \j ` q = Kdj_[bpdbc I_ j_e_lguf ilbpZf h^_\Zxl e gZkl \j fg q gZ eZidb dhev pZ Ihlhf bo hlimkdZxl e gZkl \j fg q b hgb e_lyl dm^Z iheh`_gh LZf ]^_ gb[m^v \ Gh\hc =\bg__ bo eh\yl e gZkl \j fg q b lZdbf h[jZa_ magZxl e gZkl \j fg q \ha^mr gu_ imlb ilbp F Ijbr\bg D [_j_]m jZah`]eb ijhr \j fg q dhkl_j gZqZeb ijhr \j fg q \Zjblv mom aZlygmeb ijhr \j fg q i_kgx <Zky ihijZ\eyeky gh \klZ\Zlv _fm _s_ g_ jZaj_rZeb ijhr \j fg q Ijh^Z\pu lhj]h\Zeb jZggbfb h\hsZfb ² Lhj]h\Zeb jZggbfb h\hsZfb Ih \_q_jZf jh^bl_eb qblZeb gZf m\e_dZ l_evgu_ dgb]b ² Ih \_q_jZf gZf qblZeb m\e_dZl_evgu_ dgb]b GZ kihjliehsZ^d_ ^_lb b]jZxl \ l_ggbk b [Z^fbglhg ² GZ kihjliehsZ^d_ b]jZxl \ l_ggbk b [Z^fbglhg Ih mljZf ihq lZevhgu jZaghkyl ]Za_lu ² Ih mljZf jZaghkyl ]Za_lu AZ hd ghf ]jhfdh djbqZeb ^_lb ² AZ hdghf ]jhfdh djbqZeb Kljhbl_eb [ukljh ebd\b^bjh\Zeb Z\Zjbx ² :\Zjbx [ukljh ebd\b^bjh\Zeb Kfhljx dZd jZ[hqb_ mdeZ^u\Zxl ZknZevl ² Kfhljx dZd mdeZ^u\Zxl ZknZevl < gZr_c k_fv_ \k_ ex[yl qblZlv ² < gZr_c k_fv_ ex[yl qblZlv M\e_dZl_evgu_ ² bgl_j_kgu_ aZgbfZl_evgu_ aZo\Zlu\Z\rb_
Ebd\b^bjh\Zeb ² ij_^hl\jZlbeb mgbqlh`beb M\e_dZl_evg u_ ebd\b^bjh\Ze b
M\e_dZl_evgu_ ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ Dgb]b dZdb_" m\ e_dZl_evgu_ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ M\e_dZl_evguc DZq_kl\ Fg q < i Dgb]b dZdb_" m\e_dZl_evgu_
Ebd\b^bjh\Zeb ² ]eZ]he Kljhbl_eb qlh k^_eZeb" ebd\b ^bjh\Zeb >_ckl\b_ G n ² ebd\b^bjh\Zlv Kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde ijhr \j fg q Kljhbl_eb qlh k^_eZeb" ebd\b^bjh\Zeb Y \ur_e gZ [_j_] gZkeZ^blvky ZjhfZlhf hk_ggbo ebklv _\ Ha_jh [ueh kh\_jr_ggh lboh_ < wlh dhjulh m]h^beZ kh[ZdZ Yjbd Dh]^Z lh ih [_j_]Zf >hgZ jhkeb \_dh\u_ ^m[jZ\u agZf_ gblu_ ^hgkdb_ e_kZ Kdhkbeb ijhr \j fg q h\ku H^gZ`^u m gZk gZ ^\hj_ ih ehkdZeb ijhr \j fg q [_ev_ b hklZ\beb ijhr \j fg q dhjulh k ih^kbgvdhc E_kZ wlb \ujm[beb ijhr \j fg q � � � ;_am^ ijh\_j ]eZkguc gZkeZ^blvky ihehkdZeb \_dh\u_ � � � G_ijh\_j ]eZkguc ZjhfZlhf dhjulh agZf_gblu_ � Q_j_^ h Z \ dhjg_ jZkl ² jhk jhkeb Ihkljhbeb l_ggbkguc dhjl >mfZeb kha^Zlv \he_c [hevgmx iehsZ^dm GZqZeb jZkqbsZlv l_jjblhjbx Ijb \_aeb klhe[u b k_ldm Ij_^iheZ]Zeb khj_\gh\Zlvky k dhfZg^hc ba khk_^g_]h ^\hjZ M`_ aZjZg__ jZ^h\Zebkv ij_^klhys_c kihjlb\ghc `bagb Ihkeh\bpu Ih h^_`d_ \klj_qZxl baty\ gZde e fg q ih mfm ijh \h`Zxl baty\ gZde e fg q Kgy\rb ]heh\m ih \hehkZf g_ ieZqml baty\ gZde e fg q ;_a ljm^Z g_ \ug_rv baty\ gZde e _^ q b ju[db ba ijm^Z Puieyl ih hk_gb kqblZxl
baty\ gZde e fg q <kdZqv a_fex g_ iZrml baty\ gZde e fg q :nhjbafu Fbgmc gZk ims_ \k_o i_qZe_c b [Zjkdbc ]g_\ b [ZjkdZy ex [h\v : =jb[h_^h\ K jZa[hjhf \u[bjZc ih\_e gZde e _^ q ^jma_c G_ ij_abjZc ih\_e gZde e _^ q kh\_lZ gbqv _]h gh ij_`^_ jZkkfhljb ih\_e gZde e _^ q _]h B Dju eh\
<ukdZau\Zgby ;u\Z_l aZc^_rv baty\ gZde e _^ q \ ]emoh_ f_klh ky ^_rv baty\ gZde e _^ q gZ i_gv hl^hogmlv b ^mfZ_rv baty\ gZde e _^ q F Ijbr\bg
Hl \_jgh]h ^jm]Z g_ hlemqZc ky ih\_e gZde e b \k_]^Z gZ g_]h gZ^_c ky ih\_e gZde e Ex[ brv baty\ gZde e dZlZlvky ex[b ih\_e gZde e b kZghqdb \hablv G_ mqb ih\_e gZde e [_a^_evx ² mqb ih\_e gZde e jmdh^_evx Qlh gZibkZgh i_jhf g_ \ujm[ brv baty\ gZde e b lhihjhf G_ ^Z\rb keh\h dj_ib kv ih\_e gZde e Z ^Z\rb ^_j`b kv ih\_e gZde e K^_eZ\rb om^h ² g_ `^b ih\_e gZde e ^h[jZ E_`Zq_]h g_ [v xl bat y\ gZde e Dh]^Z _^ _rv baty\ gZde e \ imlv hklh jh`_g [m^v ih\_e gZde e Qlh ihk_ _rv baty\ gZde e lh b ih`g _rv baty\ gZde e V gZ dhgp_ keh\ ihke_ rbiysbo =eZ]he mfgh`vl_ [_j_qv meu[Z_rvky Bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ jhkdhrv ihfhsv ^hqv jh`v GZj_qb_ gZhlfZrv gZkl_`v ijhqv baty\ gZd e
baty\ gZd e
< e_km kujh b^_rv ² gh]Z qZ\dZ_l <uoh^brv gZ ih
eygdm <hl klZjuc [_j_ah\uc i_gv b gZ g_f jZkl_l fZe_gvdZy baty\ gZd e
[hcdZy _ehqdZ <hae_ wlh]h igy `_eZggu_ kfhjqdb ;_j_rv bo Z
ay[ebd lZd b jZkkuiZ_lky K ijbe_lhf dmdmrdb e_k gZihegy
_lky ex^vfb <uklj_e dZdh]h lh [Zeh\gbdZ lZd ^_ckl\m_l qlh baty\ gZd e
baty\ gZd e
kjZam l_jy_rv gblv fukeb b m^bjZ_rv dZd fh`gh ^Zevr_
?ehqd Z jZkkuiZ _l ky dZd h]h lh
?ehqdZ ² bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ JZkl_l qlh" _ehqdZ Ij_^f_l G n ² _ehqdZ GZjbp g_h^mr ` j kde ?^ q B i JZkl_l qlh" _ehqdZ JZkkuiZ_lky ² ]eZ]he Ay[ebd qlh ^_eZ_l" jZkkuiZ_lky >_ckl\b_ G n ² jZkkuiZlvky G_kh\ \b^ \ha\j g_i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde gZkl \j _^ q e Ay[ebd qlh ^_eZ_l" jZkkuiZ_lky DZdh]h lh ² f_klhbf_gb_ ;Zeh\gbdZ dZdh]h" dZdh]h lh G n ² dZdhc lh G_hij_^ ?^ q f j J i ;Zeh\gbdZ dZdh]h" dZdh]h lh � >qœZndtMœvl@ ² keh]Z >qœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >Z@ ² ]eZkg m^ >n@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >d@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >Mœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >l@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdh\ QZ\dZ_l ² [md\ Abfgyy ijh]medZ
Ykguc abfgbc ^_gv <_k_eh \kdZdb\Z_rv k ihkl_eb Mfu\Z _rvky [ukljh aZ\ljZdZ_rv ² b \u[_]Z_rv gZ mebpm Ohjhrh <klZ_rv gZ eu`b b [_`brv d [eb`Zcr_fm e_khqdm
Kg_] ihkdjbiu\Z_l ih^ gh]Zfb ijb]j_\Z_l khegurdh M\_ j_gguf rZ]hf \klmiZ_rv \ e_khd ^\b]Z_rvky g_ lhjhiykv h[ oh^y aZ\Zeu dhqdb aZjhkeb <j_fy e_lbl g_aZf_lgh <ha\jZsZ_rvky ^hfhc hk\_`_gguf g_fgh]h mklZ\rbf gh ^h\hevguf b kqZkleb\uf G_ lhjhiykv g_aZf_lgh hk\_`_gg uf
G_ lhjhiykv ² ^__ijbqZklb_ G_ lhjhiblvky >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_ckl\b_ G_kh\ \b^ Qlh ^_eZy" g_ lhjhiykv
G_aZf_lgh ² gZj_qb_ E_lbl dZd" g_aZf_lgh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf E_lbl dZd" g_aZf_lgh
Hk\_`_gguf ² ijbqZklb_ DZdbf" hk\_`_gguf IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Hk\_`blv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j L\ i DZdbf" hk\_`_gguf Hk_gvx [ukljh kf_jdZ_lky e _^ q Ghqvx oh eh^hf \__l e _^ q hl a_feb : ;ehd Fg_ `mldh gZj_q k i_kg_c ]jhah\hc G_l dhgpZ e_kguf ljhibgdZf : ;ehd >Ze_dh gZj_q _s_ ^h i_j\uo abfgbo [mjv N Lxlq_\ ;_a ljm^Z g_ fh`_l [ulv qbklhc b jZ^hklghc `bagb : Q_oh\
M \t_a^Z \ mkZ^v[m \k_]^Z fgh]hex^gh M \ajhkeuo J i
am[jh\ ijZdlbq_kdb g_l \jZ]h\ Ljm^gh ij_^klZ\blv khkgh\u_ < i
J i
J i
e_kZ [_a ]emoZj_c Gh ]emoZj_c klZgh\blky \k_ f_gvr_ Ilbp < i
gb]^_ g_ [ueh M\b^_lv [h[jZ ^g_f g_\hafh`gh Fh`gh
g_kdhevdh ^g_c iml_r_kl\h\Zlv ih ims_ b g_ m\b^_lv gb h^gh]h < i
> i
a\_jy <k_ [ueh aZlhie_gh \_rgbfb \h^Zfb GZf ijbrehkv k\_jgmlv k rhkk_ gZ \ha\ur_gghklv b _oZlv ijhk_edZfb G >jha^h\
>h`^bd ebe oheh^guc b \_l_j k k_\_jZ gZe_lZe ihju [_ae kd
\Zfb GZ^h ieulv d ex^yf <_l_j klZgh\beky \k_ kbevg__ gZ [_ae ]e
bgn
qbgZeky kg_] Fg_ hq_gv ohl_ehkv kdhj__ mieulv k wlh]h f_klZ
Y \uibe dj_iqZcrbc qZc aZe_a \ f_rhd b ih^mfZe h lhf qlh bgn
[_ae kd
_keb y \k_ lZdb g_ ko\Zlbe \hkiZe_gb_ e_]dbo lh `blv fh`gh \ gZj_q
ex[mx ih]h^m IZeZldZ ijhl_dZeZ Gh lml m` gbq_]h g_evay ]e k\
bgn
[_ae n ebqg ]e
]e k\
bgn
[ueh k^_eZlv Q_j_a kmldb ijhykgbehkv IhjZ [ueh ieulv ]e k\
]e k\
gZj_q
D ihem^gx klZeh kh\k_f ykgh b \ureh khegp_ ;ueh hq_gv gZj_q
lboh
H Dm\Z_\
Dj_iqZcr bc \k_ lZdb gbq _]h d ihe m ^g x
Dj_iqZcrbc ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ QZc dZdhc" dj_i qZcrbc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² dj_iqZcrbc DZq_kl\ ij_\hko ij kl_i_gv kjZ\g_gby ?^ q f j < i QZc dZdhc" dj_iqZcrbc <k_ lZdb ² qZklbpZ >hi agZq_gb_ mkbe_g Fh^Zevg G_ qe_g ij_^eh`_gby Gbq_]h ² f_klhbf_gb_ q_]h" gbq_]h G n ² gbqlh Hljbp J i G_evay [ueh k^_eZlv q_]h" gbq_]h
D ihem^gx ² bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ Ij_^f_l G n ² ihe^_gv GZjbp g_h^mr f j kde ?^ q > i KlZeh kh\k_f ykgh dh]^Z" d ihem^gx
>_nbkgh_ gZibkZgb_ gZj_qbc \h i_j\uo ih j_[yqvb qmlv
qmlv ih hk_gg_fm ih ^jm`_kdb ]^_ lh
;_aebqgu_ ij_^eh`_gby GZ iheZlyo e_`Zlv bgn lZd b ehfly g_ \b^Zlv bgn Q_fm [ulv bgn lh]h g_ fbgh\Zlv bgn ;_a ^jm]Z `blv bgn kZfhfm k_[_ ihklueuf [ulv bgn ;_j_]bkv ih\_e gZde e hl [_^ h[h[s ebqg ihdZ bo g_l [_aebqg Kdhevdh \hjm gb \hjh\Zlv bgn Z dgmlZ g_ fbgh\Zlv bgn Ijhr_^r_]h g_ \ha\jZlblv bgn [_aebqg Z ^mfZc ih\_e gZde e h[hs ebqg dZd ^Zevr_ `blv bgn [_aebqg Kdhevdh \_j_\dm g_ \blv bgn Z dhgpm [ulv bgn Ijb]ey^b ih\_e gZde e aZ k\hbf Z ihlhf aZ qm`bf h[h[s ebqg
K\h_ ihl_jy\ qm`h_ g_ bsml baty\ gZde e h[hs ebqg
;_j_]bkv ih\_e gZde e hl [_^ h[h[s ebqg ihdZ bo g_l [_aebqg AZ\Zjbe baty\ gZde ijhr \j dZrm lZd g_ `Ze_c ih\_e gZde e fZkeZ h[h[s ebqg
GZ h^ghf ]\ha^_ \k_]h g_ ih\_kbrv baty\ gZde e h[h[s ebqg
G_ \k_fm \_jv ih\_e gZde e qlh keurbrv baty\ gZde e h[h[s ebqg
G_ ^h]ey^brv baty\ gZde e hdhf aZieZlbrv baty\ gZde e [hdhf h[h[s ebqg
IhiZ^_rv baty\ gZde e \ dhj_gv ^h[_j_rvky baty\ gZde e b ^h \_jrbgu h[h[s ebqg
Ijhr_^r_]h g_ \ha\jZlblv bgn [_aebqg Z ^mfZc ih\_e gZde e h[hs ebqg dZd ^Zevr_ `blv bgn [_aebqg kms kms kms Kmf_jdb kmf_jdb \_rgb_ oeZ^gu_ \hegu m gh] kms
kms
kms
: ;ehd <_ljZ l_ieh]h ihju\u ^Zevgbc ]jhf b ^h`^v ihjhc kms
kms
kms
N Lxlq_\ < h]g_ h[eZdZ Lbrv [_aex^v_ \hdjm] B Gbdb kms
kms
lbg A\_a^u gZ^ iheyfb ]emrv aZ dZfurZfb B Gbdblbg
kms
kms
kms
K_j_[jh h]gb b [e_kldb ² kms
P_euc fbj ba k_j_[jZ ]eZ]
kms
< `_fqm]Zo ]hjyl [_j_adb
Q_jgh ]heu_ \q_jZ ^\mkhkl < ;jxkh\
kms
Hiylv oheh^gu_ k_^u_ g_[_kZ kms
kms
Imkluggu_ ihey gZ[blu_ ^hjh]b kms
GZ ju`b_ dh\ju ihoh`b_ e_kZ kms
kms
B ljhcdZ m djuevpZ b kem]b gZ ihjh]_
kms
B ;mgbg
kms
KeZ\gZy hk_gv Fhjhagu_ ghqb kms
Ykgu_ lbob_ ^gb
G G_djZkh\
H]jhfguc ]hjh^ Fgh]hex^gu_ mebpu <hl ljZf\Zb :\lh[mku \_amsb_ iZkkZ`bjh\ Ihemimklu_ ljhee_c[mku Ki_ rZsb_ fZrbgu ;_kdhg_qgu_ lheiu ex^_c G_[hevrh_ k_eh Madb_ mebpu H]hjh^u lsZl_evgh moh `_ggu_ Qbkluc ijm^ <hl dmju =h]hqmsb_ ]mkb KlZ^h iZkm s__ky gZ em]m >\mkhklZ\gu_ ij_^eh`_gby Gh \hl aZlj_sZeb \ dZf_evd_ ihe_gvy K\_l wlhl b]jZ_l gZ ihem gZ kl_gZo gZ ihlhed_ H^ghkhklZ\gu_ ij_^eh`_gby IheygZ gZ \a]hjd_ ² gZ iheyg_ ² ba[mrdZ GZau\g
AZc^_rv \ lZdmx ba[mrdm abfhc ² `beuf ^mohf g_ iZog_l H[h[s ebqg
Ihlygmeh ]mkluf \he]euf aZiZohf hllZb\Zxs_c ]ebgu kh kl_g dZie_l ;_aebqg M]Zjgh ;_aebqg
Emqr_ gZ[blv iheguc dZf_e_d b \uclb gZ mebpm gZjm[blv aZ]h^y ^jh\br_d ;_aebqg
Q_j_a iheqZkZ \ ba[mrd_ l_ie__ b g_ ly`dh ;_aebqg
Fh`gh kdbgmlv ihemrm[hd ;_aebqg
< dZf_evd_ p_eZy h]g_ggh ju`Zy ]hjdZ m]e_c GZau\g
Lml `_ i_j_^ dZf_evdhf qmj[Zqhd GZau\g
Fh`gh k_klv gZ g_]h ² b ^mfZlv ;_aebqg
H^ghfm ohjhrh ^mfZ_lky ;_aebqg
L_fgh ;_aebqg
Lhevdh ba s_e_c dZf_evdZ k\_lblky ;_aebqg
B \kihfbgZ_lky ;h] agZ_l qlh ;_aebqg
gZj q ij ij kms dZd Zy " < dZf_evd_� p_e Zy h]g_ggh ju` Zy ]hjdZ m]e_c Lml `_ i_ kms kms ij f_kl � qmj[Zqhd � Fh`gh k_klv gZ g_]h ² b ^mfZlv j_^ dZf_evdhf gZj_q kms ij kms dZd hfm " qlh ^_eZ_l" ki � � � � ^mfZ _l ky L_fgh Lhevdh ba H^g hfm� ohjhrh s_e_c dZf_evdZ qlh ^_eZ_l" ki
ki
ij kms
ij
kms
ij kms
Â? B Â? gZ kl_gZo gZ ihlhed_ k\_l bl ky k\_l wlhl b]jZ _l gZ ihem qlh ^_eZ_l" ki ki Â? \kihfbgZ _l ky ;h] agZ _l qlh Kg_] ^Z kg_] gZau\g <kx ba[m aZg_keh [_aebqg Kg_] [_e__l djm]hf ih dhe_gh ^\mkhkl LZd fhjhagh k\_leh b [_eh [_aebqg : ;ehd Fu klZeb kh[bjZlvky ^hfhc h[hr eb \k_ dhfgZlu \ureb gZ b^msb_ djm]hf ^hfZ ]Ze_j_b ^\m khkl Qlh aZ \b^u gZau\g DZdhc ieZf_gguc aZdZl gZau\g DZdhc ih`Zj gZ ]hjbahgl_ gZau\g < dZdb_ djZkdb h^_ebkv wlb ^_j_\vy b p\_lu ^\mkhkl DZd `Zjdh ^urZl hgb ^\mkhkl M`_eb wlh lh khegp_ ^\mkhkl dhlhjh_ k\_lbl m gZk ^\mkhkl " Y \kihfgbe dhk\_ggu_ [e_^gu_ emqb ihlmoZxsb_ gZ [_j_aZo b khkgZo hklu\rb_ k ihke_^gbf emqhf gb\u \eZ`guc iZj aZku iZxsbo ihe_c [e_^guc ke_^ aZdZlZ gZ g_[_ ^\mkhkl B fg_ \^jm] aZohl_ehkv lm^Z \ lm fbemx klhjhgm [_aebqg ]^_ ih oheh^g__ [_aebqg B =hgqZjh\
B^ms b_
B^msb_ ² ijbqZklb_ =Ze_j_b dZdb_" b^msb_ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx B^lb >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j Fg q < i GZ ]Ze_j_b dZdb_" b^msb_ djm]hf ^hfZ :g^j_c I_ljh\bq Jy[mrdbg
<ukhdh_ gh\]hjh^kdh_ g_[h ijhajZqgh KlZ^h eukuo ohefh\ kimkdZ_lky d j_d_ Lb]h^_ ;_aex^gh [_aebqg Ebrv gZ ihdZlhf
kdehg_ m ^_j_\ygghc lj_gh]b fhev[_jlZ ² q_eh\_d gZau\g Jy^hf wlx^gbd iZebljZ ih^jZfgbd k oheklhf gZau\g JZa [jhkZgu dbklb G_fheh^hfm fm`qbg_ \ k_jhf l_iehf iZevlh ay[dh [_aebqg Hg kt_`beky kh]gmeky gZ kdeZ^ghf lZ[mj_l_ G_ihdhjgZy ijy^v dm^eZluo \hehk miZeZ gZ qbkluc eh[ ;e_^gh_ ebph k\_leu_ ]jmklgu_ ]eZaZ lhgdbc ojys_\Zluc ghk k hkljufb \uj_aZfb gha^j_c \iZeu_ s_db gZ kdmeZo g_^h[juc jmfyg_p gZau\g Dm^jy\blky jmkZy [hjh^dZ lhgdZy r_y h[fhlZgZ fho gZluf rZjnhf Om^h`gbd g_j\gh kp_ibe jmdb gZ hkljuo dhex qbo dhe_gyo b ijbklZevgh i_qZevgh ]ey^bl dZd g_mfhebfh [_ `bl khegp_ aZ [mjmx ]jy^m e_kZ G_[h ih \_k_gg_fm imklh b [_afhe\gh lhevdh [Z]jh\uc hl[e_kd aZdZlZ a\_gbl \ a_jdZevguo \h^Zo Lb]h^u B >he]hiheh\
Dhexq bo ih \_k_gg_fm
Dhexqbo ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ GZ dhe_gyo dZdbo" dh exqbo IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² dhexqbc DZq_kl\ Fg q I i GZ dhe_gyo dZdbo" dhexqbo
Ih \_k_gg_fm ² gZj_qb_ Imklh dZd" ih \_k_gg_fm Ijb agZd ijbagZdZ F_ju G_baf Imklh dZd" ih \_k_gg_fm
Ju[heh\gu_ ju[heh\ ju[ Z h eh\ blv H^ghkhklZ\gu_ ij_^eh`_gby Ebklvy k ^_j_\v_\ kju\Zeh djm`beh `Zjhf \\_jom [_a ebqg Kg_]hf imrbkluf e_^ aZf_eh [_aebqg GZ^ o\ZklmgZ fb qZklh ohlv kf_xlky h[h[s ebqg Z qZklh \ ^_e_`_ bf ^heb ^hklZxlky ;ulv ]jha_ [_aebqg G_ihegu_ ij_^eh`_gby >_^mrdZ jZkkdZau\Ze gZf kdZadb Z hl_p ² bklhjbb ba k\hbo iml_r_kl\bc <k_ m_a`Zeb ^hfhc h^bg y g_ m_a`Ze <_kghc
^h`^bd rZevghc AZohq_l ² \k_ kfhqbl DZd gZa\Zlv dhl_gdZ" Lb]jhf bev furhgdhf" Imikhf beb FZ_f" Beb >abgv Eb ^aygv" O\Zklmg [helmg
Furhghd
o\Zkl Zlv mg \jmg
[hel Zlv ² mg
furv hghd aZcqhghd
\_j[ex`hghd \_j[ex^ hghd Kl_iv rbjhdh gZ ijhklhj_ Ihi_j_d b \^hev e_`bl Keh\gh h]g_ggh_ fhj_ Agh_f iur_l b iZebl I <ya_fkdbc ;ukljh fqblky e_]dbc q_eg B jZklZedb\Z_l \hegu B kdhevabl ih kdehgZf \heg G Yaudh\
dZd"
E_`bl
qlh ^_eZ_l"
Kl_iv
qlh ^_eZ_l"
b
b
\j Zlv mg
aZyp hghd
Q_eg b b Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; Jm^bg ]h\hjbe mfgh ]hjyqh ^_evgh \udZaZe Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; fgh]h agZgby fgh]h gZqblZgghklb B Lmj]_g_\ JZckdbc Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; ih]ey^_e gZ g__ ijhr_eky ih dhfgZl_ b hklZgh\beky i_j_^ Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; g_c B =hgqZjh\ Gb abfZ gb \_kgZ gb e_lh gb hk_gv Â&#x17D; g_ hdZau\Zeb fZe_cr_]h \b^bfh]h \ebygby gb gZ g_]h gb gZ Â&#x17D; h[jZa _]h `bagb B ;mgbg
Mfgh ]hjyqh
Mfgh ² gZj_qb_ =h\hjbe dZd" mfgh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf =h\hjbe dZd" mfgh
=hjyqh ² gZj_qb_ =h\hjbe dZd" ]hjyqh IjbagZd ^_ckl \by
H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf =h\hjbe dZd" ]hjyqh
ihlygmeZkv a_\gmeZ b ijhreZkv
k_j^blZy b m]jxfZy
m]eu b f_[_ev
h[gxoZeZ
m]eu b f_[_ev qlh"
aZ]eygmeZ
ih dhfgZl_ ]^_"
\ i_j_^gxx dm^Z"
ihpZjZiZeZ
b g_ gZreZ
gbq_]h q_]h"
hl\hjbeZ
b \hreZ
ih^mfZ\ __ h[_bfb eZiZfb \ ke_^mxsmx dhfgZlm qlh k^_eZ\" q_]h"
q_f"
dm^Z"
Ijb\Ze Y ]hlh\ex ihkl_ev aZk\_leh [_aaZ[hlgh aZ[bjZ xkv ih^ h^_yeh gh ^he]h g_ fh]m mkgmlv <b^bfh ^Zxl h k_[_ agZlv [_kdhg_qgZy ly`_klv imlb [ukljZy kf_gZ \i_qZle_gbc `Zjdh_ h[beb_ khegpZ <h ^\hj_ gh\hjh`^_ggZy l_ehqdZ FZcdZ ijh^he`ZeZ hk\Zb\Zlvky k h[klZgh\dhc Gb i_lmo gb k\bgvy aZju\rZyky \ kujmx a_fex ih^ ie_lg_f gb khjhdZ dhlhjmx y \k_ \j_fy hlim ]b\Ze gb \hjh[vb m`_ g_ im]Zeb __ F :e_dk__\
dlh"
G_ im]Zeb gb gb gb gb M`_ ihkbg_eh gZ^ ^Ze_dbf ih\hjhlhf j_db gZ^ `_el_x sbfb i_kdZfb gZ^ h[ju\bkluf [_j_]hf gZ^ ijhfhdrbf gZ lhc klhjhg_ e_khf ]^_"
Ihkbg_eh GZ i_j_\ha_ klhye ]Zf rmf ]h\hj djbdb \hkdebpZgby kdjbi dhe_k : K_jZnbfh\bq qlh"
Klhye MadZy ^hjh]Z jy^hf k `_e_agh^hjh`ghc gZkuivx h[ju\Z eZkv lh \ ]jhfZ^gu_ i_kqZgu_ yfu lh \ [_kdhg_qgu_ g_ijhoh ^bfu_ [hehlZ G Lbohgh\
dm^Z"
H[ju\ZeZkv lh lh Fg_ hiylv ijbkgbebkv ^_[jb =emrv imklugv aZdZlZ lbrv @_eluc e_\ djZ^_lky d a_[j_ Q_j_a ljZ\u b dZfur < ;jxkh\
qlh"
Ijbkgbebkv
q_j_a qlh" dZd"
DjZ^_lky ijbq
b
ijbe
gh\hjh`^_ggZy i_kqZgu_ bgn
Hk\Zb\Z lv ky ² qlh ^_eZlv" � � � � � h[klZgh\dhc ie_l_gv ihkbg_eh ^Ze_dbf djZ^_lky mk hlj
mk hlj
mk hlj
mk hlj
hlj
gb i_lmo gb k\bgvy gb khjhdZ gb \hjh[vb g_ im]Zeb ijhfhdrbf keh` ijbe
`_e_agh^hjh`guc `_e_agZy ^hjh]Z g_ijhoh^bfu_ kde
kde
kde
]emrv lbrv dZfur Â? `_eluc `_el_lv
<^Ze_d_ [ue keur_g rmf ih_a^Z ]m^db iZjh\haZ \hc kbj_g DjZkgu_ a_e_gu_ b `_elu_ y[ehdb e_`Zeb \ dhjabg_ FZfZ dmibeZ kbgb_ djZkgu_ b [_eu_ rZju Hg h[_sZe ijbclb lh k_]h^gy lh aZ\ljZ lh q_j_a g_^_ex Eb[h iZiZ eb[h fZfZ eb[h ^_^mrdZ j_rbl aZ^Zqm Kd\hav ]mklhc lmfZg beb [_kij_ju\gh fhjhkysbc f_ev qZcrbc dZd \h^ygZy iuev k_juc ^h`^bq_d \b^gu hq_jlZgby [hevrbo a^Zgbc \ujbkh\u\Zxlky dhglmju ^ebgguo fhklh\ b \ukhdbo iZfylgbdh\ > ² @ > ² @
<b^gu kd\hav lmfZg beb ^h`^bq_d beb
Dhglmju fhklh\ b iZfylgbdh\ b <_l_j ijbghkbl klm^_gh_ ^uoZgb_ fhjy qm\kl\m_lky [ebahklv abfgbo oheh^h\
> ² @ > ² @ HqZjh\Zgb_ ² hqZjh\Zl_evguc qZju qZjmxsbc qZjh^_c F_evqZcrbc ² f_edbc f_ehqv Hq_jlZgby ² q_jlu q_jlhqdZ hq_jq_gguc <ujbkh\u\Zxlky ² jbkh\Zgb_ jbkmxlky jbkh\Zlv jbkmghd G_ijh[b\Z_fuf ² ijh[blv [blv [bluc hl[b\Zlv Qm\kl\m_lky ² qm\kl\h qm\kl\bl_evguc qm\kl\mxsbc qm\ kl\h\Zlv <ujbkh\u\Zxlky
\ujbkh\Z lv ky
\ujbkh\Z lv
jbkh\Z lv @bl_eb ijhoh^yl ijh[_]Zxl i_j_db^u\Zxlky qlh ^_eZxl"
Ijh[_]Zxl lm^Z b kx^Z dm^Z"
b < hl\_l gZ \a]ey^u gZ km_lgx gZ kmfZlhom Fu ih^gbfZeb jZa\_jlu\Zeb klZ\beb gZ qlh"
KlZ\beb l\_j`_ ae__
< k\hbo ljm^Zo ih kjZ\gbl_evgh bklhjbq_kdhfm yaudh agZgbx N N NhjlmgZlh\ kha^Ze mq_gb_ h ]jZffZlbq_kdhc nhjf_ keh\Z :dZ^_fbd kqblZe qlh hgZ fh`_l [ulv fZl_jbZevgh \ujZ `_gghc klhe ² Z b [ulv gme_\hc klhe ² hldjue aZdhg i_j_ ^\b`_gby m^Zj_gby hl gZqZeZ keh\Z d dhgpm \g_k k\_`mx ljZd lh\dm fgh]bo y\e_gbc ijhbkoh^ysbo \ ^j_\g_crmx ihjm \ bg^h_\jhi_ckdbo yaudZo \ khklZ\ dhlhjuo \oh^bl b jmkkdbc yaud H[eZdZ lh gZieu\Zeb gZ emgm lh jZae_lZebkv < Rbrdh\ Lh lmfZg lh g_ih]h^u hk_gv iha^gyy g_k_l : Imrdbg Dhl g_kky aZ gbf gZ lj_o eZiZo Z q_l\_jlhc i_ j_^g_c eZihc [be i_lmoZ ih kibg_ D IZmklh\kdbc DZd lh ghqvx m^Zjbe fhjhabs_ Ijbe_l_\rbc gZ dhjfmrdm \hjh[_c ay[dh ih^`bfZe ih^ k_[y lh h^gm lh ^jm]mx eZidm ? Ghkh\ dZd"
<hkihfbgZgb_ dhlhjh_ ijb\_eh kx^Z Exkx hlghkbehkv d ]h eh^guf ihke_\h_gguf ]h^Zf G_ lh d khjhd r_klhfm g_ lh d kh jhd k_^vfhfm <_kghc i_j_^ k_\hf Exkx hlijZ\beb [hjhgh\Zlv wlh ihe_ Ke_^h\Zeh dhg_qgh ih^h`^Zlv ihdZ a_fey ih^khog_l gh `^Zlv lh eb g_ fh]eb lh eb g_ ohl_eb Â? Â? Â? JZae_lZebkv ijbe_l_\rbc dhjfmrdm Â? Â? Ih^`bfZe ijb\_eh Ko_fu
LZdh]h k_j^_qgh]h kf_oZ b i_kgb b ieykdb lZdhc aZ q_]h"
^_gv]b g_ dmibrvÂŤ b b <hjhgZ d g_fm ih^e_l_eZ ihludZeZ ghkhf ijhreZkv qlh k^_eZe"
H dhj_gv ^j_\_kguc aZigm\rbcky iheha klmqbl b \ba`bl qlh k^_eZ_l"
b aZ k_j^p_ kdj_[_l b b Fhjhadh himklbeky ihgb`_ hiylv ihfZoZe [meZ\hc qlh k^_eZe"
<hjh[mrdh\ klZy ke_l_eZ k kghih\ gZ^ l_e_]hc \a\beZkv qlh k^_eZe"
LmfZg jZkoh^beky gh _s_ aZdju\Ze \_jrbgu e_kZ
He_gbg gZ^_\Ze h[hj\Zgguc ijbq abimg ba \heh\v_c rdm
ju jZafhq_ggmx ijbq h[m\v gZau\Z_fmx ihjrgyfb ih^ihy
ku\Ze dbg`Ze [jZe jm`v_ f_rhq_d k aZdmkdhc b lZ[Zdhf a\Ze aZ kh[hc kh[Zdm b hlijZ\beky hlijZ\eyeky qZkm \ r_klhf mljZ \
e_k aZ klZgbgm QZkm \ k_^vfhf \_q_jZ hg \ha\jZl \ha\jZsZeky ^hfhc fhjZevgh k\_`bc kbevguc b kh\_jr_ggh kqZklv_ kqZkl
eb\uc Hg g_ fh] [u kdZaZlv h q_f hg ^mfZe \k_ wlh \j_fy G_ lh fukeb g_ lh \hkihfbgZgby g_ lh f_qlu [jh^beb \ _]h ]heh\_
B ij_^klZ\ey_lky hg k_[_ beb dZaZdhf jZ[hlZxsbf \ kZ^ZoÂŤ
beb Z[j_dhf \ ]hjZo beb dZ[Zghf [_] m[_]Zxsbf hl k_[y `_ kZfh]h H]hgv f_lZeky \ jZagu_ klhjhgu k\_l hk\_sZy lh klhe[bd djue_qdZ lh klhe b ihkm^m lh [_emx kljb`_gmx hl]e
ijbe ]heh\m klZjbdZ Ghqgu_ [Z[hqdb \bebkv b kuiey iuev k djueur_d [bebkv ih klhem b \ klZdZgZo lh ihe_l \e_lZeb \ Â? h]hgv k\_qb lh bkq_a bkq_aZeb \ q_jg__l q_jghf \ha^mo_ qlh ^_eZe"
LmfZg jZkoh^beky gh aZdju\Ze gh He_gbg gZ^_\Ze ih^ihyku\Ze [jZe a\Ze hlijZ\eyeky qlh ^_eZe"
qlh" GZ^_\Ze abimg h[m\v
;jZe jm`v_ f_rhq_d qlh"
k q_f"
F_rhq_d k aZdmkdhc b lZ[Zdhf b
Hg \ha\jZsZeky fhjZevgh k\_`bc kbevguc b kh\_jr_ggh
kqZkleb\uc dZdhc"
b
;jh^beb \ ]heh\_ g_ lh fukeb g_ lh \hkihfbgZgby g_ lh qlh"
f_qlu g_ lh
g_ lh
g_ lh
Ij_^klZ\ey_lky k_[_ beb dZaZdhf beb Z[j_dhf beb dZ[Z d_f"
ghf beb beb beb Hk\_sZy lh klhe[bd lh klhe b ihkm^m lh ]heh\m qlh"
lh lh b lh ;Z[hqdb \bebkv b [bebkv lh \e_lZeb lh bkq_aZeb qlh ^_eZeb"
b
lh
lh
]^_"
;bebkv ih klhem b \ klZdZgZo b JZkoh^be ky
HlijZ\eye ky DZd lh ² gZj_qb_ DZd" dZd lh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by G_hij_^ G_baf DZd" dZd lh DZjlhrdZ gZ h]hjh^Zo \udhiZgZ h[kmr_gZ b kkuiZgZ \ ih^ihev_ Fhjdh\v [jxd\Z k\_deZ lh`_ \uj_aZgu L_i_jv RZjbdZ gZ ]jyaguc aZ[jhr_gguc h]hjh^ b dZeZqhf g_ aZfZgbrv < lZdmx \hl mguemx hk_ggxx ihjm ijh[m^beky y mljhf hl ]m eZ ]jhfZ rbi_gby b ihgZqZem gbq_]h jZah[jZlv b m\b^_lv g_ fh]
< :klZnv_\
GZk\bklu\Zy qbsm dZjlhrdm ?_ fh`gh k\Zjblv ijhklh lZd beb gZlmrblv k dhgk_j\Zfb Ihke_ aZ\ljZdZ fh`gh ihclb \ e_k b lZf gZehfZlv khkgh\uo eZihd eb[h ijhklh ih]ey^_lv aZy qvb ke_^u eb[h ihkemrZlv kbgbp J_qdZ [ueZ g_[hevrZy gh qbklZy b ]em[hdZy Q_j_a g__ [ue i_j_[jhr_g g_ lh fhklbd g_ lh ijhklh ^_j_\h <udhiZg Z gZk\bklu\Zy
<udhiZgZ ² ijbqZklb_ DZjlhrdZ dZdh\Z" \udhiZgZ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx <udhiZlv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q ` j DZjlhrdZ dZdh\Z" \udhiZgZ GZk\bklu\Zy ² ^__ijbqZklb_ GZk\bklu\Zlv >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_ckl\b_ G_kh\ \b^ Qbsm qlh ^_eZy" gZk\bklu\Zy >hebgu khogml b i_klj_xl klZ^Z rmfyl b kheh\_c m` i_e \ [_afhe\bb ghq_c : Imrdbg
qlh ^_eZxl"
b
> ² b @ > ² @ b > ² @ <ahreZ aZjy b hl^_ebeky e_k kl_ghc am[qZlhc gZ djZx g_ [_k F E_jfhglh\
> ² @ > ² @ <gbam :jZ]\Z b DmjZ h[\b\ dZcfhc ba k_j_[jZ ih^hr\u k\_`bo hkljh\h\ ih dhjgyf r_iqmsbo dmklh\ [_`Zeb ^jm`gh b e_]dh F E_jfhglh\
b b < lmfZgguc lbobc ^_gv oh`m Y qZklh \ e_k b lZf kb`m GZ g_[h [_eh_ ]ey`m >Z gZ \_jomrdb l_fguo khk_g B Lmj]_g_\
b ^Z Jhgy_l e_k [Z]jyguc k\hc m[hj Kj_[jbl fhjha m\ygm\r__ ihe_ Ijh]eyg_l ^_gv dZd [m^lh ihg_\he_ B kdjh_lky aZ djZc hdjm`guo ]hj : Imrdbg
b Keh`gu_ ij_^eh`_gby >h`^bd r_e oheh^guc b \_l_j k k_\_jZ gZe_lZe ihju\Zfb DmoeygdZ ijhfhdeZ gZkd\hav b y ijyfh ih^iju]b\Ze hl oheh ^Z <ukhdbc ]Ze_qguc [_j_] moh^be ba]b[hf b kljmy \h^u [beZ ijyfh \ g_]h J_dZ ^_ebeZkv l_i_jv gZ rbjhdb_ ie_ku b \ky wlZ fZkkZ \h^u g_m^_j`bfh b ]jhagh dZlbeZkv \gba Ijhklu_ ij_^eh`_gby Y hiZkZeky ihl_jylv khagZgb_ gh qm\kl\h\Ze k_[y ij_` gbf Eh^dZ kbevgh jZa[moeZ l_deZ b ihwlhfm kbevgh ly`_e_ eZ Q_j_a kmldb \k_ lZd `_ ^me e_^yghc \_l_j gh m`_ [_a ^h` ^y b kg_]Z Ba \h^u g_h`b^Zggh \ukdZdb\Zeb aZlhie_ggu_ kl\heu b bkq_aZeb kgh\Z L_i_jv ² gZj_qb_ >_ebeZkv dh]^Z" l_i_jv IjbagZd ^_c kl\by <j_f_gb G_baf >_ebeZkv dh]^Z" l_i_jv E_^yg hc ]Ze_qg uc
o
Imrbklh]h i_j\h]h kg_]Z o
Oheh^gu_ k_^u_ g_[_kZ o
Ih a_e_ghc khqghc ljZ\_
o
AZklhy\rbfky ly`_euf ZjhfZlhf o
;_kdhg_qguf hk_ggbf ^h`^_f o
Ebfhggufb g_`gufb ebklvyfb o
E_]db_ ih`_el_\rb_ ebklvy o
< hk_gg_f p\_lbklhf e_km
o
K ahehlufb hk_ggbfb ^gyfb
;_kdhg_qg uf ih`_el_\r b_
;_kdhg_qguf ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ >h`^_f dZdbf" [_kdhg_qguf IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² [_kdhg_qguc DZq_kl\ ?^ q f j L\ i >h`^_f dZdbf" [_kdhg_qguf
Ih`_el_\rb_ ² ijbqZklb_ Ebklvy dZdb_" ih`_el_\rb_ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ih`_el_lv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Fg q B i Ebklvy dZdb_" ih`_el_\rb_ G_h[tylguc g_[_kguc k\h^ jZa^Zeky jZa^\bgmeky _s_ g_h[tylg__ DZdh_ lh kljZggh_ mihbl_evgh_ kbygb_ ijbf_rZ ehkv d [e_kdm f_kypZ klZjbgguc ]hkih^kdbc ^hf hijhdb gm\rbkv \gba \b^_g [ue \ g_f qbkl b \ dZdhf lh ykghf \_ebqbb <f_klh fjZqguo klZ\g_c ]ey^_eb \_k_eu_ kl_deyggu_ hdgZ b ^\_jb h^bg lhevdh f_kyp lZd `_ [ebklZl_evgh b qm^gh ieue \ g_h[tylguo ijhklhjZo jhkdhrgh]h mdjZbgkdh]h g_[Z LZd `_ ij_djZkgZ [beZ a_fey \ ^b\ghf k_j_[jyghf [e_kd_ JZa^\bgme ky
Ijbf_rZe h kv KlZjbgg uc
ijbf_rZ lv
k lZjbg Z
f_rZ lv klZj uc
;ebklZl_evgh [ebklZl_evg uc [ebklZ lv o GZklmibeh `Zjdh_ ^h`^eb\h_ e_lh o
G_rbjhdZy f_klgZy j_qdZ klZeZ i_j_kuoZlv o
<k_ [_]Zeb \ e_]dhc kihjlb\ghc h^_`^_ o
R_jklygu_ abfgb_ \_sb [ueb m[jZgu
o
Y k [jZlhf m[_]Ze \ [eb`Zcrbc khkgh\uc e_k
b fu klZjZebkv hlukdZlv kZfu_ aZl_fg_ggu_ o
lZbgkl\_ggu_ f_klZ
o o
o
o
o
o
o
Gh \hl ihy\bebkv k_ju_ ]jhah\u_ lmqb
o
gZ a_fex miZeb i_j\u_ dZieb `_eZggh]h e_lg_]h ^h`^y o
H[jZah\Zebkv l_ieu_ ]em[hdb_ em`b o
o o
o
o [_aaZ[hlgZy rmfgZy ^_l\hjZ \_k_eh re_iZeZ ih gbf < lhl g_\_k_euc hdly[jvkdbc ^_gv gZf [jhkZeZkv \ ]eZaZ lhevdh mlj_ggyy km_lZ i_j_iheho < wlhc lhqd_ gZqbgZ ehkv <hehdheZfkdh_ rhkk_ ijyfbdhf ih rbjhdhfm ]eZ^dhfm ZknZevlm \_^ms__ d Fhkd\_ Hldm^Z lh ihy\beky Z^txlZgl IZgnbeh\Z fheh^_gvdbc djZkghs_dbc e_cl_gZgl KlZjhfh^ guc imaZluc kZfh\Zj lh`_ ih^Zgguc d klhem lygme lhgdmx aZ lboZxsmx ghlm IZgnbeh\ gZebe fg_ b k_[_ dj_idh]h ]hjyq_ ]h qZy k_e \lygme gha^jyfb iZj ih^gbfZxsbcky ba klZdZgZ qmlv ijbs_edgme yaudhf b meu[gmeky qlh k^_eZeb"
KlZjhfh^g uc
b
ih^Z lv
^Z lv
Ih^Zgg uc
klZj Zy fh^ Z g uc
AZlboZxs mx aZlboZ lv aZlbogm lv lbogm lv lbo bc < khqghc a_e_ghc ljZ\_ gZdhieyeky ^g_\ghc aghc @_elu_ jhah\u_ kbg_\Zlu_ p\_lu i_kljbeb `b\hc dh\_j ljZ\u lhqgh jZkkuiZggu_ kZfhp\_lgu_ dZfgb Dhjhldh_ kb[bjkdh_ e_lh lhqgh \u[b\Zehkv ba kbe qlh[u ijh]j_lv ohjhr_gvdh oh eh^gmx kb[bjkdmx a_fex Ohjhrh a_e_g_eZ ]mklZy b khqgZy ljZ\Z LZd fbeh ijylZebkv \ __ `b\hf r_edm kdjhfgu_ kb[bj kdb_ p\_lhqdb lZd kheb^gh r_ilZe ^j_fmqbc kb[bjkdbc e_k dZ dmx lh [_kdhg_qgmx kdZadm Kb[bjkdbc e_k fheqZeb\ lhqgh hg aZlZbe \ k_[_ dZdmx lh k\hx ^hfZrgxx kdhj[gmx ^mfm ;ue kheg_qguc hk_ggbc ^_gv < f]ebklhf hk_gg_f \ha^m o_ ghkblky g_\b^bfZy ]eZahf iZmlbgZ > FZfbg Kb[bjyd
Gb]^_ gb \ rdhe_ gb gZ ijh]med_ gb \ e_km ² y g_ \klj_lbeky k ^jm]hf
gb
gb
gb
²
Y gb]^_ g_ \klj_lbeky k ^jm]hf gb \ rdhe_ gb gZ ijh]med_ gb \ e_km gb gb gb Gb \ rdhe_ gb gZ ijh]med_ gb \ e_km ² gb]^_ y g_ \klj_lbe ky k ^jm]hf
gb gb gb ² B fhj_ b g_[h b [_euc i_khd ² \k_ jZ^h\Zeh ]eZa b b b ² <k_ jZ^h\Zeh ]eZa b fhj_ b g_[h b [_euc i_khd
b b b <k_ b fhj_ b g_[h b [_euc i_khd ² jZ^h\Zeh ]eZa
b b b ²« IhkZ`_ggu_ aZ[hleb\ufb jmdZfb q_eh\_dZ ^_j_\vy de_g lhihev ZdZpbb [_j_au ² a_e_g_eb ijb\_leb\h b k\_`h
² « Ijb\_leb\h b k\_`h a_e_g_eb ihkZ`_ggu_ jmdZfb q_eh\_dZ ^_j_\vy de_g lhihev ZdZpbb [_j_au De_g lhihev ZdZpbb [_j_au ² ^_j_\vy ihkZ`_ggu_ aZ[hl eb\ufb jmdZfb q_eh\_dZ a_e_g_eb ijb\_leb\h b k\_`h
² AZ]Z^hqgu_ a_feb :jdlbdb m\_gqZggu_ e_^gbdZfb hk e_ibl_evgh kbyxsb_ \ emqZo g_aZdZlgh]h khegpZ fhjy ihdju lu_ ev^Zfb b h[blZxsb_ \ gbo m^b\bl_evgu_ `b\hlgu_ ² \k_ wlh k ^Z\gbo ihj ijb\e_dZeh hl\Z`guo iml_r_kl\_ggbdh\ Ij_h^he_\Zy g_bfh\_jgu_ ljm^ghklb hgb ijhgbdZeb \k_ ^Zev r_ b ^Zevr_ gZ k_\_j hldju\Zeb oheh^gu_ Zjdlbq_kdb_ hkljh \Z b Zjobi_eZ]b b gZghkbeb bo gZ dZjlm Wlh [ueb ij_^klZ\bl_ eb jZaguo gZjh^h\ fbjZ Zf_jbdZgpu > NjZgdebg b J Ibjb ]heeZg^_p < ;Zj_gp ghj\_`_p N GZgk_g b J :fmg^k_g blZev yg_p M Gh[be_ b fgh]b_ ^jm]b_ qvb bf_gZ gZ\_qgh hklZebkv \ gZa\Zgbyo hkljh\h\ ]hj e_^gbdh\ fhj_c Kj_^b gbo b gZrb khhl_q_kl\_ggbdb N_^hj Ebld_ K_f_g Q_exkdbg [jZlvy
EZil_\u =_hj]bc K_^h\ <eZ^bfbj JmkZgh\ ŠQlh lZdh_" Dlh lZdhc"ª
Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; M ]_j[Zjb_\ lhevdh ^\Z \jZ]Z kujhklv b g_[j_`gh_ d
gbf hlghr_gb_ < Bg[_j <k_ djm]hf \u]ey^_eh g_kdZaZggh Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; jZ^hklguf b ijb\e_dZl_evguf a_e_gZy ljZ\Z gZ mebp_ rmfy
Â&#x17D; Â&#x17D; sZy ebkl\Z gZ ^_j_\vyo khegp_ gZ^ ]heh\hc : FmkZlh\
GZ i_qgmx ljm[m himklbeZkv h[udgh\_ggZy \hjhgZ lZdZy `_ dZd b \k_ ^jm]b_ \hjhgu \ fZjl_ k aZ[jua]Zgguf ]jy avx o\hklhf b \at_jhr_gguf aZ]jb\dhf AbfZ aZklZ\beZ __ ih aZ[ulv h qm\kl\_ kh[kl\_ggh]h ^hklhbgkl\Z h lmZe_l_ b hgZ ijZ\^hc b g_ijZ\^hc k ljm^hf ^h[u\ZeZ oe_[ k\hc gZkmsguc ? Ghkh\ KZfuf ihjZabl_evguf ^ey ;bfZ hdZaZehkv lh qlh \f_kl_ k ex^vfb a^_kv `b\ml jZagu_ `b\hlgu_ b ilbpu dhjh\u dmju ]mkb h\pu k\bgvb ² agZdhfkl\h k dhlhjufb khklhyehkv g_ kjZam = Ljh_ihevkdbc Gb ^hjh`_d gb iheygu ² gbq_]h g_ \b^gh gZf K =hjh^_pdbc B ie_lgb b [_e_\rZy gZ ^\hjZo kdhlbgZ b djurb ^hfh\ b kljhcgu_ iZrgb ² \k_ dZaZehkv kiZeh a^hjh\uf lbobf ljm^h\uf kghf E Lheklhc
G_ \b^gh ² ijbqZklb_ Gbq_]h dZdh\h" g_ \b^gh Ijb agZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx <b^_lv KljZ^ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ ijhr \j dj n ?^ q kj j Gbq_]h dZdh\h" g_ \b^gh Ih^ dhkufb emqZfb mlj_gg_]h k\_lZ \k_ dZ`_lky j_ev_n g__ \uimde__ yjq_ b fhklhd q_j_a dZgZ\m b ^_j_\vy < Khehmobg
b b <^jm] \k_ wlh fhj_ wlhl emq_aZjguc \ha^mo wlb \_l\b b ebklvy h[eblu_ khegp_f ² \k_ aZkljmblky aZ^jh`bl [_]euf [e_kdhf B Lmj]_g_\
b ² Gb ]jyav gb jZkimlbpZ gb k_j^blh \a^m\rb_ky j_db gb [_r_gu_ dhgljZlZdb ² gbqlh g_ fh]eh hklZgh\blv bo ihju\Z < DZlZ_\
Gb gb gb gb ² GZ kdZf_cdZo gZ lZ[mj_ldZo gZ kdZebkluo mklmiZo gZ \ha \ur_gguo a_e_guo em`ZcdZo ² ih\kx^m jZkiheh`bebkv j_[ylZ : =Zc^Zj
²
H[ebl u_ \a^m\r b_ ky \ha\ur_gg uo h[j
=eZ\gh_ j_[ylZ k_j^p_f g_ klZj_lv i_kgx qlh ijb
^mfZeb ^h dhgpZ ^hi_lv G =j_[_ggbdh\ G >h[jhgjZ\h\ h[j
E_lbl_ ]hem[b e_lbl_ ^ey \Zk gb]^_ ij_]jZ^u g_l F FZ h[j
lmkh\kdbc G_ ieZqv ^_\qhgdZ ijhc^ml ^h`^b khe^Zl \_j h[j
g_lky lu lhevdh `^b < OZjblhgh\ Hc lu jh`v ohjhrh h[j
ih_rv Lu h q_f ih_rv ahehlZy jh`v" : Ijbr_e_p Mkeurv h[j
h[j
h[j
f_gy ohjhrZy mkeurv f_gy djZkb\Zy aZjy fhy \_q_jgyy ex h[j
h[j
h[j
[h\v g_m]ZkbfZy F BkZdh\kdbc IZjgb iZjgb wlh \ gZrbo kbeZo ² a_fex hl ih`ZjZ m[_j_qv ? >hefZlh\kdbc KiZ h[j
h[j
kb[h Zbkl kiZkb[h ilbpZ lZd b ^he`gh [ueh kemqblvky < K_
f_jgbg B jZ^hklb \klj_q b ]hj_qv jZaemd ² fu \k_ bkiulZeb h[j
h[j
h[j
lh\Zjbs b ^jm] ? >hefZlh\kdbc Dm^Z [_`brv ljhibgdZ fbeZy dm^Z ah\_rv dm^Z \_^_rv" : Ijbr_e_i
KlZj_ lv ijb^mfZe b g_m]Zkbf Zy bkiulZe b Bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ kde jh`v ]hj_qv =eZ]he ih\_e gZde g_ ieZqv mkeurv =eZ]he e _^ q ih _rv [_` brv ah\ _rv \_^ _rv =eZ]he bgnbgblb\ m[_j_qv J_[ylZ aZgbfZxlky kihjlhf h[j
J_[ylZ aZgbfZcl_kv kihjlhf
Hev]Z mljhf ijb_oZeZ gZ ^Zqm h[j
Hev]Z ijb_a`Zc mljhf gZ ^Zqm g_jZkij h[j
G_ ihc djZkZ\bpZ ijb fg_ lu i_k_g =jmabb i_qZev jZkij h[j
ghc : Imrdbg OjZgb f_gy fhc lZebkfZg ojZgb f_gy \h
^gb ]hg_gvy \h ^gb jZkdZygvy \heg_gvy lu \ ^_gv i_qZeb [ue
g_jZkij h[j
fg_ ^Zg : Imrdbg Rbjhdh lu Jmkv ih ebpm a_feb \ djZk_ jZkij h[j
pZjkl\_gghc jZa\_jgmeZky B Gbdblbg DZd y ex[ex lh\Zjbs fhc \_kgu jhkdhrghc ihy\e_gv_ D ;Zlxrdh\ Ijb\_l l_[_ jZkij h[j
fhc djZc jh^ghc k l\hbfb l_fgufb e_kZfb K >jh``bg jZkij h[j
>h[ju_ ex^b kihdhcgh \u `beb fbemx ^hqv k\hx g_`gh ex jZkij h[j
jZkij h[j
[beb G G_djZkh\ =hjh^ qm^guc ]hjh^ ^j_\gbc lu \f_klbe \
k\hb dhgpu b ihkZ^u b ^_j_\gb b iZeZlu b ^\hjpu N =ebgdZ jZkij h[j
Ijbjh^Z fZlv dh]^Z [ lZdbo ex^_c lu bgh]^Z g_ ihkueZeZ fb
jm aZ]ehoeZ [ gb\Z `bagb G G_djZkh\ Ijb\_l l_[_ fhc jZkij h[j
[_^guc de_g ijhklb qlh y l_[y h[b^_e K ?k_gbg JZa\_ lu g_jZkij h[j
g_ ohq_rv i_jkbygdZ m\b^Zlv ^Ze_dbc kbgbc djZc" K ?k_gbg g_jZkij h[j
g_jZkij h[j
G_ rmfb khkgZ g_ iueb ^hjh]Z K ?k_gbg Y \_kv ij_^ g_jZkij h[j
jZkij h[j
jZkij h[j
lh[hx Jhkkby km^v[Z fhy kh\_klv fhy G Jue_gdh\
Ex[ex l_[y I_ljZ l\hj_gv_ ex[ex l\hc kljh]bc kljhcguc \b^ G_\u ^_j`Z\gh_ l_q_gv_ [_j_]h\hc __ ]jZgbl : Imrdbg Ij_djZkgu \u ihey a_feb jh^ghc _s_ ij_djZk g_c \Zrb g_ih]h^u F E_jfhglh\ Y kqZkleb\ [ue \Zfb ms_eby ]hj iylv e_l ijhg_kehkv \k_ lhkdmx ih \Zk F E_j fhglh\ Dlh [u gb [ue lu i_qZevguc fhc khk_^ ex[ex l_[y dZd ^jm]Z xguo e_l F E_jfhglh\
� >sœZkeœbn@ ² keh]Z >sœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >Z@ ² ]eZkg m^ >k@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >eœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >b@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >n@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdh\ KqZkleb\ ² [md\ Fhkd\Z ² klhebpZ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb Fgh]hex^gZy Fhkd\Z >Ze_dh g_k_l k\hb \h^u j_dZ Fhkd\Z h[j
h[j
Fhkd\Z Fhkd\Z ex[ex l_[y dZd kug F E_jfhglh\
KlhebpZ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ² Fhkd\Z
>_j_\vy Bo g_ k q_f kjZ\gblv hgb h]jhfgu dZd h[
eZdZ D Kbfhgh\ Hk_gv hk_gv Ju`Zy djZkZ @_elu_ e_kZ h[j
KlZevgu_ \h^u < Em]h\kdhc Jh^ghc fhc [Zly Re_f l_[_ ihdehg ² b y b fZlv b ^_^mrdZ K_f_g F BkZdh\kdbc Ab h[j
fZ IZogme \ ebph fg_ \ha^mo qbkluc : :imolbg EmgZ Lu
`bl_ev ]hjgbo kljZg lu [_kij_^_evguc hd_Zg [_a mlhfe_gvy ijhl_dZ_rv : Dhevph\
Ijhl_dZ_rv ² ]eZ]he Lu qlh ^_eZ_rv" ijhl_dZ_rv >_ckl\b_ G n ² ijhl_dZlv G_kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j g_i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q gZkl \j e Lu qlh ^_eZ_rv" ijhl_dZ_rv Hgb ² f_klhbf_gb_ H]jhfgu dlh" hgb G n ² hgb Ebqg e Fg q B i H]jhfgu dlh" hgb
;_a ² ij_^eh] Ijhl_dZ_rv [_a mlhfe_gvy G_baf ijhkl g_ijhba\ G_ qe_g ij_^eh`_gby
B ² khxa Kh_^bgy_l h^ghjh^gu_ ih^e_`Zsb_ Khq kh_^ g_baf G_ qe_g ij_^eh`_gby H[jZs_gb_ g_ y\ey_lky qe_ghf ij_^eh`_gby GZ^_xkv aZ\ljZ g_ [m^_l ^h`^y AZ\ljZ ih fh_fm ^h`^y g_ [m^_l AZ\ljZ ^h`^y g_ [m^_l d kqZklvx :eiZlh\m ^Zxl jm`v_ b hg dhg_qgh klj_ey_l \ iey rmsbc rZjbd > @ b > ² @ KemqZcgh _]h imey jZa[b\Z_l \^j_[_a]b rZjbd gh rZjbd hiylv ihy\ey_lky gZ kljm_ nhglZgZ b _]h :eiZlh\ ^he`_g ljb jZaZ jZa[blv Z lh fh`_l [ulv hg kemqZcgh ihiZe
> ²
@ gh > ²
@ b > ²
@ Z lh > ²
@
Ljb ² bfy qbkebl_evgh_ JZa[blv kdhevdh" ljb jZaZ Dh ebq_kl\h G n ² ljb Dhebq ijhklh_ p_eh_ dhebq_kl\h <bg i JZa[blv kdhevdh" ljb jZaZ
< i_j\hf ² bfy qbkebl_evgh_ < kemqZ_ dZdhf" i_j\hf Ihjy^hd ij_^f_lh\ ijb kq_l_ G n ² i_j\uc Ihjy^d ijhklh_ Ij_^e i _^ q f j < kemqZ_ dZdhf" i_j\hf < lj_lbc ² bfy qbkebl_evgh_ < jZa dZdhc" lj_lbc Ih jy^hd ij_^f_lh\ ijb kq_l_ G n ² lj_lbc Ihjy^d ijhklh_ <bg i _^ q f j < jZa dZdhc" lj_lbc
< ieyrmsbc ² ijbqZklb_ < rZjbd dZdhc" ieyrmsbc IjbagZ\ ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx IeykZlv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j ?^ q f j < i < rZjbd dZdhc" ieyrmsbc
I_j_h^_luc ² ijbqZklb_ Mgl_j hnbp_j dZdhc" i_j_h^_ luc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx I_j_h^_lv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j B i Mgl_j hnbp_j dZdhc" i_j_h^_luc Hq_\b^gh k_]h^gy \ha\jZsZ_lky fhc [jZl K_]h^gy d kqZklvx \ha\jZsZ_lky fhc [jZl Fhc [jZl ^mfZx \ha\jZsZ_lky k_]h^gy Ihcfbl_ k_]h^gy \ha\jZsZ_lky fhc [jZl <h i_j\uo k_]h^gy \ha\jZsZ_lky fhc [jZl
Hev]Z \b^bfh g_ h`b^ZeZ ijb_a^Z ]hkl_c D g_kqZklvx Hev]Z g_ h`b^ZeZ ijb_a^Z ]hkl_c Ih fh_fm Hev]Z g_ h`b^ZeZ ijb_a^Z ]hkl_c IhgbfZ_l_ Hev]Z g_ h`b^ZeZ ijb_a^Z ]hkl_c Dhjhq_ ]h\hjy Hev]Z g_ h`b^ZeZ ijb_a^Z ]hkl_c ;ulv fh`_l e_lhf fu k ^jmavyfb hlijZ\ey_fky gZ fhj_ E_lhf d h[s_c jZ^hklb fu k ^jmavyfb hlijZ\ey_fky gZ fhj_ E_lhf ba\_klgh fu k ^jmavyfb hlijZ\ey_fky gZ fhj_ <hh[jZ abl_ e_lhf fu k ^jmavyfb hlijZ\ey_fky gZ fhj_ F_`^m gZfb ]h\hjy e_lhf fu k ^jmavyfb hlijZ\ey_fky gZ fhj_ IhkemrZc dZ ^jm`bs_ Lu kdZau\Zxl bklhqgbd kh h[s_gby ^jm]b_ ex^b i_lv \_ebdbc fZkl_jbs_ =eZaZfb dZ`_lky kl_i_gv ^hklh\_jghklb khh[s_gby ij_^iheh`_gb_ ohl_e [u \k_o hg kt_klv Ih mebpZf KehgZ \h^beb dZd \b^gh kl_i_gv ^hklh\_jghklb khh[s_gby ij_^iheh`_gb_ gZihdZa GZ lm [_^m jZaebqgu_ qm\kl\Z kh`Ze_gb_ EbkZ [eba_ohgvdh [_`ZeZ ŠIhklhcl_ ` y kukdZe k_dj_l ² djbqbl Hk_e ² fu \_jgh kl_i_gv ^hklh\_jghklb khh[s_gby ij_^iheh`_gb_ m` iheZ^bf dhev jy^hf ky^_fª Gm keh\hf kihkh[ hnhjfe_gby fuke_c pZjkl\mxl aeZlu_ \j_f_gZ BlZd hnhjfe_gb_ fuk eb \u\h^ fhc ^jm] lu [ulv [h]Zq_ g_ `_eZ_rv" Dj_klvygbg ]h\hjbe Ebkbp_ \klj_lykv k g_x ŠY ijZ\h kl_i_gv ^hklh\_j ghklb khh[s_gby h l_[_ `Ze_x ª Q_]h dZaZehkv kl_i_gv ^hklh\_jghklb khh[s_gby ij_^iheh`_gb_ emqr_ [ueh pZj_\b qm pZjy \ mqbl_eb kukdZlv" ŠIhkemrZc ² ]h\hjbl ohlv dZ `_lky kl_i_gv ^hklh\_jghklb khh[s_gby ij_^iheh`_gb_ lu kljh] gh lu ebrv djZklv kh[Zdm ijbmqZ_rvª D g_kqZklvx jZaebqgu_ qm\kl\Z h]hjq_gb_ lh ` [u\Z_l m ex^_c B keh\hf kihkh[ hnhjfe_gby fuke_c jZah]gZe \k_o ilbp k\hbf i_gvzf : fh`_l [ulv kl_i_gv ^hklh\_jghklb khh[s_gby ij_^ih eh`_gb_ _s_ m^Zklky ih`b\blvky kujdhf bev dhklhqdhc bev q_f gb[m^v PZjv
pZj_\bq
pZjkl\m xl
A\mdb ihkl_i_ggh klZgh\bebkv kbevg__ b g_ij_ju\g__ b gZdhg_p k\yav fuke_c kebebkv \ h^bg a\hgdbc ]me E Lhe klhc AZ hdghf hiylv f_l_ev f_l_l b \b^Zlv ij_^iheh`_ gb_ g_kdhjh i_j_klZg_l F BkZdh\kdbc GZ mebp_ gZk dhev phf hdjm`beb kh[Zdb Hgb \beyeb o\hklZfb b ih \b^bfhfm ij_^iheh`_gb_ gb fZe_cr_]h `_eZgby g_ bf_eb ijbagZ\Zlv \ gZk qm`bo B Khdheh\ Fbdblh\ Dhaxey klZeZ sbiZlv ljZ\m b \b^bfh ij_^iheh`_gb_ kh\k_f f_gy g_ aZf_qZeZ = N_^h k__\
Ihkl_i_ggh ² gZj_qb_ KlZgh\bebkv dZd" ihkl_i_ggh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf KlZgh\bebkv dZd" ihkl_i_ggh Hiylv ² gZj_qb_ F_l_l dZd" hiylv IjbagZd ^_ckl\by H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf F_l_l dZd" hiylv
G_kdhjh ² gZj_qb_ I_j_klZg_l dh]^Z" g_kdhjh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by <j_f_gb G_baf I_j_klZg_l dh]^Z" g_kdhjh Kh\k_f ² gZj_qb_ G_ aZf_qZeZ \ dZdhc f_j_" kh\k_f IjbagZd ^_ckl\by F_ju G_baf G_ aZf_qZeZ \ dZdhc f_j_" kh\k_f Ih \b^bfhfm \\ ke
\b^bf uc
\b^ _lv
GZ\_jgh_ g_ \k_ agZxl h lhf qlh fmjZ\vb jZa[bjZxlky \ \\ ke
]_hf_ljbq_kdbo nb]mjZo HdZau\Z_lky hgb jZaebqZxl lj_m]hev \\ ke
gbd djm] d\Z^jZl FmjZ\v_\ gZijbf_j m^Zehkv gZmqblv ^\b
]Zlvky ih gZijZ\e_gbx d lj_m]hevgbdm b g_ h[jZsZlv \gbfZgby gZ djm]
\\ k k
\\ ke
Ih`Zemc kZfh_ bgl_j_kgh_ qlh fmjZ\vb dZd \uykgbehkv \\ k k
fh]ml ^\b]Zlvky jZa^_eyy m]eu gZ jZ\gu_ qZklb Djhf_ lh]h hgb kihkh[gu i_j_^\b]Zlvky lhqgh ih [bkk_dljbk_ \\ ke
D kh`Ze_gbx wlZ m^b\bl_evgZy hkh[_gghklv ih\_^_gby fm \\ ke
jZ\v_\ ihqlb g_^hklmigZ gZr_fm \a]ey^m ;_amkeh\gh lhevdh \
j_amevlZl_ gZmqguo wdki_jbf_glh\ ijh\h^bfuo mq_gufb [bheh]Zfb fh`gh mklZgh\blv wlb ihjZabl_evgu_ nZdlu ba `ba gb gZk_dhfuo \\ k k
;ulv fh`_l dlh gb[m^v ba \Zk \ [m^ms_f ijh^he`bl bamq_
gb_ aZ]Z^hqgh]h ih\_^_gby fmjZ\v_\ b kmf__l jZa]Z^Zlv g_fZeh lZcg `b\hc ijbjh^u Ijh\h^bf uo
Ijh\h^bfuo ² ijbqZklb_ Wdki_jbf_glh\ dZdbo" ijh\h ^bfuo IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ijh\h^blv KljZ^ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j Fg q J i Wdki_jbf_glh\ dZdbo" ijh\h^bfuo � >ZdZat\tv pt@ ² keh]h\ >Z@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >d@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >D@ ² ]eZkg m^ >a@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >\@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >p@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ HdZau\Z_lky ² [md\ \\ ke DZ`_lky r_iqml dhehkvy ^jm] ^jm]m G G_djZkh\ ²
B hk\_s_ggh]h f_klZ ljm^gh jZa]ey^_lv qlh ^_eZ_lky \
ihl_fdZo b ihlhf \[ebab \k_ dZ`_lky aZ^_jgmluf ihqlb q_jghc \\ ke
aZ\_khc B Lmj]_g_\ >h`^v dZaZehkv aZjy^be gZ^he]h B Lmj
]_g_\ ² Fhj_ gZ khlgb fbev \hdjm] dZaZehkv imklugguf \\ ke
< DZlZ_\ ©<u fh`_l ih^mfZeb qlh m` y m \Zk ^_g_] ijh rm ª ² kdZaZe lZbgkl\_gguc ]hkih^bg N >hklh_\kdbc ²
?fm ihq_fm lh \^jm] ijbreh \ ]heh\m qlh \ l_q_gb_ e_lZ hg
fh`_l ijb\yaZlvky d wlhfm keZ[hfm fgh]hj_qb\hfm kms_kl\m \\ ke
m\e_qvky b \ex[blvky : Q_oh\ Fu \_jgh g_ \klj_lbfky
aZ\ljZ ohly y b g_ [hxkv \klj_lblvky k \Zfb N >hklh_\kdbc ² ©KemrZc ² h[jZlbeky <Zgy d k\h_fm kimlgbdm ² fu \_jgh
ihreb" Lu lh f_klh ihfgbrv"ª E DZkkbev ©H ² ih^mfZeZ hgZ ² _keb wlh ijZ\^Z g_l gb h^ghc ljZ\bgdb kqZkleb\__ f_gy \\ ke
gh ijZ\^Z eb wlh" B Lmj]_g_\ ² IjZ\^Z b wlbf e_lhf ex^b hsmsZeb g_ lZdh_ m` ^Ze_dh_ ^uoZgb_ lhc iZfylghc hk_gb b ab
fu : F_`bjh\
\\ ke >h`^v dZaZehkv aZjy^be gZ^he]h \\ Ijhklh_ ih\_kl\h\Zl_evgh_ g_\hkdebpZl_evgh_ ^\mkhklZ\ gh_ jZkijhkljZg_ggh_ ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh \\h^guf keh\hf \u jZ`Z_l agZq_gb_ g_m\_j_gghklb ?fm ihq_fm lh \^jm] ijbreh \ ]heh\m qlh \ l_q_gb_ e_lZ hg fh`_l ijb\yaZlvky d wlhfm keZ[hfm fgh]hj_qb\hfm kms_kl\m m\e_qvky b \ex[blvky >
@ qlh
b
Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde keh`gh_ q h^ghkhkl [_aebqgh_ jZkij ihegh_ q ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h^ghjh^gufb kdZ am_fufb b h^ghjh^gufb hij_^_e_gbyfb \\ ke
AZ ^_j_\g_c \b^gh [hevrh_ ihe_ AZ ^_j_\g_c \b^gh
[hevrh_ ihe_
\\ k k
H^gbf keh\hf gbq_]h g_ ^hdZaZlv H^gbf keh\hf gbq_]h
g_ ^hdZaZlv
\\ k k
Lu `_ fg_ ^Ze q_klgh_ keh\h ² Ba q_luj_o aZ^Zq q_kl
gh_ keh\h y j_rbe ljb
\\ ke
Ba hdgZ ohjhrh \b^gh fhjkdmx ^Zev ² Lu \b^gh g_ mki_
_rv ijbclb d h[_^m
\\ ke
;jhkv gZ kqZklv_ \ fhj_ fhg_ldm ² Lml gZ kqZklv_ ijbr_e
\jZq
\\ ke
Hg ]h\hjbe qlh ijZ\^Z \k_]h ^hjh`_ ² IjZ\^Z aZf_qZl_ev
gh qlh fu ih_^_f gZ x]"
\\ ke
Keh\hf fh`gh kbevgh h[b^_lv ² Keh\hf hg g_ ohl_e _oZlv
k gZfb
\\ k k
Ij_^f_l fh`_l [ulv kijylZg ]^_ m]h^gh ² IZiZ fh`_l
[ulv ijb_^_l aZ\ljZ
D g_kqZklvx ijhbahr_^r_fm \q_jZ ijb[Z\bebkv k_]h^gyr \\ ke
gb_ g_ijbylghklb ² D g_kqZklvx dZgbdmeu _s_ g_ gZklmibeb \\ ke
AZ^ZqZ j_r_gZ \_jgh ² Lu \_jgh g_ ohl_e __ h[b^_lv <_^v lu g_ ohq_rv qlh[u fZfZ jZkkljhbeZkv Ba aZ k\Zeb\r_]hky ]hjy hg dZd [m^lh ihklZj_e HgZ keh\gh ihfheh^_eZ hl ihemq_ggh]h ba\_klby <u ydh[u ohlbl_ fg_ qlh lh jZkkdZaZlv ?^\Z eb klhbl lZd fgh]h jZ[hlZlv Wlh ijhbahreh ijbf_jgh ^\_ g_^_eb gZaZ^ Wlhl ibjh] [Z[mrdZ bki_deZ bkdexqbl_evgh ^ey l_[y >Z`_ iZiZ g_ kfh] j_rblv wlh mjZ\g_gb_ E_lh [ueh l_ieh_ ijblhf ^h`^eb\h_ Hg lZye [md\Zevgh gZ ]eZaZo DZd [u fg_ ohl_ehkv \_jgmlvky kx^Z _s_ jZa DklZlb \ ^h[jhihjy^hqghc k_fv_ ex[u_ \Z`gu_ \h ijhku j_rZeb gZ k_f_cguo kh\_lZo ijbq_f hldjulh ijb ^_lyo Ih \b^bfhfm ^_eh [ueh ^Z\gh j_r_gh gh dhfiZgvhgu klZjZ l_evgh ^_fhgkljbjh\Zeb qlh hgb [m^lh [u g_ bf_xl d g_fm gb dZdh]h hlghr_gby <k_ lZdb e_lh \u^Zehkv l_ieuf kheg_q guf \ijhq_f b wlh g_ jZ^h\Zeh Kb[bjp_\Z Ih`Zemc fg_ ijb^_lky k^_eZlv \b^ dZd [m^lh y \i_j\u_ \b`m wlm dZjlbgZ b
ihljyk_g fZkl_jkl\hf Z\lhjZ <jy^ eb dlh gb[m^v ba gZk g_ bkiulu\Ze qm\kl\h \hklhj]Z ijbklZevgh \]ey^u\Zykv \ ghqgh_ a\_a^gh_ g_[h D kh`Ze_gbx lZdb_ fbgmlu g_qZklh \uiZ^Zxl ^Z`_ `bl_eyf lbobo jhkkbckdbo ^_j_\_gv Z m` h[blZl_eb ]h jh^kdbo d\Zjlbj ih fh_fm kh\_jr_ggh ebr_gu wlhc jZ^hklb >h[jhihjy^hqguc ² q_klguc ihjy^hqguc >_fhgkljbjh\Zlv ² ihdZau\Zlv DhfiZgvhgu ² iZjlg_ju H[blZl_eb ² `bl_eb J_r_g h ihljyk_g \]ey^u\Zykv ebr_g u
J_r_gh ² ijbqZklb_ >_eh dZdh\h" j_r_gh IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx J_rblv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j dj n ?^ q kj j >_eh dZdh\h" j_r_gh Ihljyk_g ² ijbqZklb_ Y dZdh\" ihljyk_g IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ihljyklb KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j dj n ?^ q f j Y dZdh\" ihljyk_g
<]ey^u\Zykv ² ^__ijbqZklb_ <]ey^u\Zlvky >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_ckl\b_ G_kh\ \b^ G_ bkiulu\Ze dh]^Z" \]ey^u\Zykv Ebr_gu ² ijbqZklb_ H[blZl_eb dZdh\u" ebr_gu Ijb agZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ebrblv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j dj n Fg q H[blZl_eb dZdh\u" ebr_gu < g_m^ZqZo dZd ]h\hjbe fhc hl_p bklhqgbd khh[s_ gby lh`_ [u\Zxl ohjhrb_ klhjhgu D IZmklh\kdbc <hl m f_gy y ^mfZx f_gvrZy kl_i_gv m\_j_gghklb ihemqr_ ]eZaZ G =h]hev I_qhjbg y m`_ ]h\hjbe kihkh[ hnhjfe_gby fuk
e_c kljZklgh ex[be hohlm F E_jfhglh\ >mrZ fhy y ihf gx bklhqgbd khh[s_gby k ^_lkdbo e_l qm^_kgh]h bkdZeZ F E_jfhglh\ Hg f_gy \u agZ_l_ ijb\e_q_gb_ \gbfZgby hq_gv m\Z`Z_l B Lmj]_g_\ GZ lhc klhjhg_ rZ]Zo \ klZ hlkx ^Z hg wlh agZe [hevrZy kl_i_gv m\_j_gghklb d kZfhc j_d_ ih^ oh^beb Z\kljbckdb_ hdhiu : G Lheklhc DZd \ujZ`Zxlky fhjydb bklhqgbd khh[s_gby \_l_j dj_iqZe : Q_oh\ G_djZ kb\h]h ^h[jh]h q_eh\_dZ dZdbf hg k_[y kqblZe fh`gh iheZ]Ze hg bklhqgbd khh[s_gby ex[blv dZd ijbyl_ey E Lheklhc
IZ\_e D kh`Ze_gbx y aZ\ljZ m_a`Zx KlZeh [ulv lu k_]h^gy dh fg_ g_ ijb^_rv Hey" Y l_[y ijhrm ih`ZemcklZ FZrZ j_rb fg_ aZ^Zqm FZrbgZevgh ² Z\lhfZlbq_kdb E_klgZy ² iho\ZevgZy G_\_`^Z ² g_mq g_^hmqdZ IjhkeZ\e_gguc ² agZf_gbluc ijbagZgguc Fhe\bl ² kdZ`_l ijhbag_k_l Lh]^Z y \klZe b \uc^y ba ^hfm hlijZ\beky ih Zee__ ih dhlhjhc ² y \ lhf g_ khfg_\Zeky ² ihreZ b hgZ <hjh[_c miZe ba ]g_a^Z \_l_j kbevgh dZqZe [_j_au Zee_b b kb^_e g_ih^ \b`gh [_kihfhsgh jZklhiujb\ _^\Z ijhjZklZ\rb_ djueurdb Hjeh\kdZy ^_j_\gy fu ]h\hjbf h \hklhqghc qZklb Hjeh\kdhc ]m[_jgbb h[udgh\_ggh jZkiheh`_gZ kj_^b jZkiZoZgguo ihe_c [eba h\jZ]Z dh_ dZd ij_\jZs_ggh]h \ ]jyaguc ijm^ Hg aZklZe m gbo \ ]hklbghc k_dj_lZjy ihkhevkl\Z ba g_fp_\ ^ebggh]h ^ebggh]h [_ehdmjh]h k ehrZ^bguf ijhnbe_f b ijh[hjhf kaZ^b lh]^Z wlh [ueh _s_ \gh\_ Y g_ mki_e ohjhr_gvdh aZf_lblv _]h ebpZ dheykdZ kebrdhf [ukljh ijhfqZeZkv fbfh gh fg_ ihdZaZehkv qlh hg [ue ]em[hdh ljhgml B Lmj]_g_\
G_ih^\b`gh [_kihfhsgh ijhfqZe Z kv
IjhjZklZ\r b_ jZkiheh`_g Z jZkiZoZgg uo
ij_\jZs_gg h]h ljhgml Mldb bo [ueh r_klv dZ`^h_ mljh ^jm`gh rZ]Zeb d ijm^m
B\Zg FZl\__\bq [ue m`_ lh]^Z fu ihagZdhfbebkv k gbf e_l ^_kylv gZaZ^ q_eh\_dhf g_fheh^uf =hkih^bg ba KZg NjZgpbkdh bf_gb _]h gb \ G_Zihe_ gb gZ DZijb gbdlh g_ aZihfgbe _oZe \ KlZjuc K\_l gZ p_euo ^\Z ]h^Z k `_ghc b ^hq_jvx _^bgkl\_ggh jZ^b jZa\e_q_gby Hg [ue l\_j^h m\_j_g qlh bf__l ihegh_ ijZ\h gZ hl^uo gZ m^h\hevkl\by gZ iml_r_kl\b_ \h \k_o hlghr_gbyo hlebqgh_ >ey lZdhc m\_j_gghklb m g_]h [ue lhl ^h\h^ qlh \h i_j\uo hg [ue [h]Zl Z \h \lhjuo lhevdh qlh ijbklmiZe d `bagb g_kfhljy gZ k\hb iylv^_kyl \hk_fv e_l >h wlhc ihju hg g_ `be Z ebrv kms_kl\h\Ze ijZ\^Z hq_gv g_^mjgh gh \k_ \haeZ]Zy \k_ gZ^_` ^u gZ [m^ms__ Hg jZ[hlZe g_ ihdeZ^Zy jmd ! b gZdhg_p m\b^_e qlh k^_eZgh m`_ fgh]h qlh hg ihqlb kjZ\gyeky k l_fb dh]h g_dh]^Z \aye k_[_ aZ h[jZa_p b j_rbe i_j_^hogmlv Ex^b d dhlhjuf ijbgZ^e_`Ze hg bf_eb h[uqZc gZqbgZlv gZkeZ`^_gb_ `bagvx k ih_a^db \ ?\jhim \ Bg^bx \ ?]bi_l Iheh`be b hg ihklmiZlv lZd `_ Dhg_qgh hg ohl_e \hagZ]jZ^blv aZ ]h^u ljm^Z ij_`^_ \k_]h k_[y h^gZdh jZ^ [ue b aZ `_gm k ^hq_jvx ! FZjrjml [ue \ujZ[hlZg ]hkih^bghf ba KZg NjZgpbkdh h[ rbjguc < ^_dZ[j_ b yg\Zj_ hg gZ^_yeky gZkeZ`^Zlvky khegp_f X`ghc BlZebb ! gZqZeh fZjlZ hg ohl_e ihk\ylblv Nehj_g pbb ! \oh^beb \ _]h ieZgu b <_g_pby b IZjb` b [hc [udh\ \ K_\bev_ b dmiZgv_ gZ Zg]ebckdbo hkljh\Zo b :nbgu b Dhg klZglbghihev b IZe_klbgZ b ?]bi_l b ^Z`_ Yihgby jZamf__l ky m`_ gZ h[jZlghf imlb B \k_ ihreh ki_j\Z ij_djZkgh B ;mgbg
f_`^
M\u hg kqZklby g_ bs_l b g_ hl kqZklby [_`bl
F E_jfhglh\
f_`^
h[j
©Gm [Zjbg ² aZdjbqZe yfsbd ² [_^Z [mjZg ª : Imr
dbg
f_`^ h[j
² Wc yfsbd kfhljb qlh lZf q_jg__lky" : Imrdbg
f_`^
\\ ke
f_`^
h[j
:c 0RkvdZ AgZlv hgZ kbevgZ qlh
B Djueh\
eZ_l gZ KehgZ
Wc ijhkgbky \_l_j Ih^ufb imj]m aZ^ufb f_l_evx [_
ehx \ em]m B ;mgbg
jZkij h[j
f_`^
Kib feZ^_g_p fhc ij_djZkguc [Zxrdb [Zx Lboh kfhl
jbl f_kyp ykguc \ dheu[_ev l\hx F E_jfhglh\
Ijb[j_e kfbjbe ky [ue [eZ]hkeh\eyy mljZq_gg Zy \b^_e
Ijb[j_e ² ]eZ]he Imkluggbd qlh k^_eZe" ijb[j_e >_c kl\b_ G n ² ijb[j_klb Kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j g_i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q ijhr \j f j Imkluggbd qlh k^_eZe" ijb[j_e Kfbjbeky ² ]eZ]he Y qlh k^_eZe" kfbjbeky >_ckl\b_ G n ² kfbjblvky Kh\ \b^ \ha\j g_i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q ijhr \j f j Y qlh k^_eZe" kfbjbeky ;ue ² ]eZ]he Hg qlh ^_eZe" [ue >_ckl\b_ G n ² [ulv G_kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j g_i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q ijhr \j f j Hg qlh ^_eZe" [ue
<b^_e ² ]eZ]he Y qlh ^_eZe" \b^_e >_ckl\b_ G n ² \b^_lv G_kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q ijhr \j f j Y qlh ^_eZe" \b^_e
;eZ]hkeh\eyy ² ^__ijbqZklb_ ;eZ]hkeh\eylv >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_ckl\b_ G_kh\ \b^ G_ ^jh`bl dh]^Z" [eZ]hkeh\eyy
MljZq_ggZy ² ijbqZklb_ K\_`_klv dZdZy" mljZq_ggZy IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx MljZlblv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q ` j B i
G_ y\ey_lky qe_ghf ij_^eh`_gby l d \oh^bl \ khklZ\ jZk ijhkljZg_ggh]h h[jZs_gby w Â? Â? Â? Â? >jta[m^ÂśbÂ? fÂśbwgÂśZ aZnljt jZgt hfDMÂśD lÂśvSiÂśb eÂśb\tMÂśv
� fZlœ @ Dhg_qgh hljZ\blvky fh`gh b ghjfZevguf ]jb[hf _keb wlh i_j_klZjhd Ml\_j`^Zxl qlh \ klZjhklb dZ`^uc ]jb[ g_fgh ]h y^h\bl Gh ih gZklhys_fm y^h\bl b [_kihsZ^_g \ gZrbo e_ kZo h^bg lhevdh ]jb[ ² [e_^gZy ih]ZgdZ ?_ fh`gh kjZ\gblv lhevdh k ]xjahc beb dh[jhc Ih`Zemc ^Z`_ hgZ kljZrg__ ih lhfm qlh [u\Zeb kemqZb dh]^Z ihke_ mdmkZ b wlbo af_c q_eh\_dZ \ue_qb\Zeb ijb ihfhsb ki_pbZevguo ku\hjhlhd LZdb_ kemqZb \_jhylgh j_^db gh hgb [ueb AZlh ih ^Zgguf f_^bpbgu g_ m^Zehkv _s_ kiZklb gb h^gh]h q_eh\_dZ kt_\r_]h [e_^gmx ih ]Zgdm E_]q_ \k_]h fg_ dZ`_lky __ kimlZlv k e_kguf rZfibgvhghf HgZ \_^v ih ijbgZ^e_`ghklb b _klv eh`guc rZfibgvhg Gh \h i_j\uo b rZfibgvhgu \ gZrbo f_klZo ihqlb g_ kh[bjZxl Z \h \lhjuo l_ dlh kh[bjZ_l rZfibgvhgu agZxl _]h ijbagZd gZ klh ijhp_glh\ bkdexqZxsbc jhdh\mx hrb[dm >_eh \ lhf qlh m rZfibgvhgh\ gb`gyy klhjhgZ reyidb lh _klv _]h ieZklbgdb g_ij_f_ggh jhah\u_ \ fheh^hklb ^Z`_ kbj_g_\Zlu_ Z ihlhf \h \k_ q_jgu_ M [e_^ghc ih]Zgdb hgb \k_]^Z [_eu_ [_a fZe_cr_]h hll_gdZ jhah\h]h QZs_ \k_]h hljZ\eyxlky [e_^ghc ih]Zgdhc \ f_klZo [he__ x`guo ]^_ f_gvr_ e_kh\ Z agZqbl b ]jb[h\ gZijbf_j \ hj eh\kdbo beb \hjhg_`kdbo ]^_ kh[bjZxl ]jb[u ahglbdb b ih ieZ\db hq_gv ihoh`b_ gZ [e_^gu_ ih]Zgdb <_jhylgh gm`gh bkoh^blv ba jZkkm`^_gby qlh emqr_ g_ kt_klv \ k\h_c `bagb ^_kylhd ^jm]hc ihieZ\dh\ g_`_eb kt_klv h^gm [e_^gmx ih]Zgdm <k_ y^h\blu_ ]jb[u dZd ba\_klgh gZau\Zxlky \ gZjh^_ ih ]ZgdZfb Gh qZklh ih^ wlh gZa\Zgb_ ihiZ^Zxl kljZ^Zy g_\bggh \k_ ]jb[u dhlhju_ ihq_fm lh g_ [_jml < gZr_f k_e_ ih]ZgdZfb ah\ml b rZfibgvhgu h^gb ba kZfuo [_a khfg_gby ij_djZkguo ]jb[h\
M f_gy gZijbf_j gbdh]^Z g_ [ueh hsms_gby qlh djZkguc fmohfhj ² ]jb[ ih]Zguc GZijhlb\ y \k_]^Z ex[h\Zeky bf b ex[mxkv ^h kbo ihj dh]^Z \b`m Ih < Khehmobgm
Ih iuevghc ^hjh]_ \_^ms_c d kZ^Zf lygmebkv kdjb imqb_ Zj[u gZiheg_ggu_ q_jguf \bgh]jZ^hf E Lheklhc OZ^`b FmjZl hklZgh\beky [jhkb\ ih\h^vy b ijb\uqguf ^\b`_gb_f e_\hc jmdb hlkl_]gm\ q_ohe \bglh\db ijZ\hc jmdhc \ugme __ E Lheklhc < \ha^mo_ klhye ijhajZqguc fhjhaguc [e_kd aZo\Zlu\Zxsbc ijb ^uoZgbb ]hjeh B Dmijbg Smjykv hl \_ljZ y ]ey`m \ wlm l_fgmx ^Zev B ;mgbg
<_^ms _c gZiheg_gg u_ [jhkb\ hlkl_]gm\
aZo\Zlu\Zxs bc smjykv >h kZfhc \_kgu [_afhe\kl\m_l kdh\ZggZy ev^hf j_dZ
J_dZ kdh\ZggZy ev^hf [_afhe\kl\m_l ^h kZfhc \_kgu
Lygm\rb_ky \^hev ^hjh]b j\u ihkl_i_ggh bkq_aZeb \ e_
km J\u lygm\rb_ky \^hev ^hjh]b ihkl_i_ggh bkq_aZeb \
e_km Hk\_sZxsbc ^hjh`dm f_kyp \hl \hl kijyq_lky aZ ijb[eb`Zxsmxky lmqm ² F_kyp hk\_sZxsbc ^hjh`dm \hl \hl kijyq_lky aZ ijb[eb`Zxsmxky lmqm <i_j_^b f_gy klhyeZ h^_lZy \ ^`bgkh\uc dhklxf ^_\mrdZ ² <i_j_^b f_gy klhyeZ ^_\mrdZ h^_lZy \ ^`bgkh\uc dhklxf ;Z[mrdZ e_qbeZ gZf h[]hj_\rb_ gZ khegp_ kibgu ² ;Z [mrdZ e_qbeZ gZf kibgu h[]hj_\rb_ gZk khegp_ Ba hdgZ [ueZ \b^gZ hk\_s_ggZy fy]dbf emgguf k\_lhf ^hjh`dZ Ba hdgZ [ueZ \b^gZ ^hjh`dZ hk\_s_ggZy fy]dbf emg guf k\_lhf GZ jbkmgd_ bah[jZ`_gu ihjhkrb_ l_fguf fohf ^_j_\vy ² GZ jbkmgd_ bah[jZ`_gu ^_j_\vy ihjhkrb_ l_fguf fohf >_^mrdZ ihklZ\be d i_qd_ hqbs_ggu_ hl kg_]Z \Ze_gdb ² >_^mrdZ ^hklZ\be d i_qd_ \Ze_gdb hqbs_ggu_ hl kg_]Z Hk\_sZxs bc h^_l Zy h[]hj_\r b_ hk\_s_gg Zy
ihjhkr b_ hqbs_gg u_
Lhgdb_ hkbgdb ke_]dZ ihdZqb\Zykv gZ \_ljm kljyob \Zeb kh k\hbo \_lhq_d ihke_^gb_ dZieb ^h`^y Kg_] dZaZeky kdZahqguf ihdju\Zehf k\_jdZy ^Z khegp_ Hg kiZe ihdZqb\Zykv \ eh^d_ AZ^mfqb\h ih]ey^_\ gZ f_gy hg k_e aZ klhe b ijbgyeky qlh lh ibkZlv Ihemqb\ ibkvfh hl ^jm]Z y ihki_rbe gZ \hdaZe Ijh[u\ \ ^_j_\g_ f_kyp LZlvygZ \_jgmeZkv \ Fhkd\m aZ ]hj_eZy b ihk\_`_\rZy
IhdZqb\Zykv k\_jdZy ih]ey^_\ ihemqb\ ijh[u\ JZkdZe_ggu_ m]hevdb k lj_kdhf \uiju]b\Zeb ba dhkljZ b hibkZ\ \ \ha^mo_ bkdjbklmx ^m]m iZ^Zeb aZ gZfb KlZgh\b ehkv `Zjdh Fu jZae_]ebkv ihm^h[g__ b ^he]h \k_ ljh_ \habebkv mfbgZy ih^ kh[hc f_klh b \u]j_[Zy kmob_ \_lhqdb b khkgh\u_ rbrdb f_rZ\rb_ e_`Zlv Ihlhf \k_ ijblboeb b fheqZ ]ey^_eb gZ ieZfy ho\Zq_ggu_ l_f g_ihgylguf lbobf hqZjh\Zgb_f dh lhjh_ ghqvx lZd \eZklgh b lZd ijbylgh ijbly]b\Z_l ]eZaZ d yj dhfm h]gx : Dmijbg
<ZkbebkZ ?]hjh\gZ ijbkfbj_\rZy ih^ imeyfb \a]ey gmeZ gZ kl_iv gZ dhlhjhc aZf_lgh [ueh [hevrh_ ^\b`_gb_ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde keh`gh_ q ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h[hkh[e_g guf hij_^_e_gb_f \ujZ`_gguf ijbqZklguf h[hjhlhf q ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ > ²
@ gZ dhlhjhc wÂ? Â? Â? Â? >mpu eÂśwet baÂśwjdteÂśpt \Âśb kÂśwnrtMÂśv nijZkÂślÂśwgdÂśv@ Fhc khk_^ fZe_gvdbc g_j\guc q_eh\_d jZkkdZaZe fg_ kljZggmx bklhjbx Bf ]Z]ZjZf g_^hklmigh gZkeZ`^_gv_ [bl\u `bagb ]jhf m^Zjh\ bo im]Z_l Fg_ q_eh\_dm \ dhklxf_ [hkydZ ljm^gh [ueh \ua\Zlv _]h njZglZ gZ jZa]h\hj IZfylv wlhl [bq g_kqZklguo h`b\ey_l ^Z`_ dZfgb ijhreh]h F =hjvdbc
Gba_gvdbc b dhj_gZkluc hg h[eZ^Ze kljZgghx kbehc \ jmdZo Ih]ehs_gguc _]h keh\Zfb y g_ fh] ^mfZlv gZ^ wlhc aZ]Z^dhc G_^hmf_\Zxsbc haZ^Zq_gguc \uoh^dhc k\h_]h w
kimlgbdZ y kfhlj_e gZ g_]h b fheqZe Kfhlj_lv gZ g__ kih dhcgmx b kbevgmx dZd [hevrZy ihegh\h^gZy j_dZ ijbylgh K_]h^gy hgZ \ gh\hf ]hem[hf dZihl_ [ueZ hkh[_ggh fheh^Z b \gmrbl_evgh djZkb\Z F =hjvdbc
<_q_jhf iheguc jZa^mfvy y e_`Ze gZ ^b\Zg_ GZibkZ\ aZibkdm h[b`_ggu_ hgb mreb ^hfhc Ih^ mljh mklZeh]h b bafmq_ggh]h f_gy gZreb ^Ze_dh hl ^hfZ K_]h^gy hgb ijblborb_ b aZ^mfqb\u_ kb^_eb m dhkljZ GZ khklhy\r_fky ihke_ khj_\gh\Zgbc ijZa^gbd_ kqZkleb \h]h \a\hegh\Zggh]h gh\ufb \i_qZle_gbyfb _]h iha^jZ\beb k ih[_^hc M agZf_gblh]h \h^hiZ^Z m^b\e_ggZy wlhc g_[u\Zehc djZ khlhc hgZ k^_eZeZ g_kdhevdh nhlhkgbfdh\ GZdZgmg_ k_jv_agh]h jZa]h\hjZ k jh^bl_eyfb ih]ehs_g guc k\hbfb ^mfZfb hg g_ aZf_lbe dZd aZkgme < e_km ]em[hdbc b fy]dbc hg dZaZeky h]jhfghc imoh\hc i_jbghc < wlb ^gb gZf fheh^uf gZ^h Zdlb\gh \dexqZlvky \ `bagv kljZgu D \_q_jm y ijhf_jarbc m\b^_e h]hgvdb [eb`Zcr_c ^_j_\gb Ih g_[m [_`Zeb lmqb ]hgbfu_ kbevguf \_ljhf ² Ih g_[m [_`Zeb ]hgbfu_ kbevguf \_ljhf lmqb GZ kdZf_cd_ klhyeZ dhjabgdZ ihegZy ki_euo y]h^ ² GZ kdZ f_cd_ klhyeZ ihegZy ki_euo y]h^ dhjabgdZ >_\mrdZ jZ^hklgh ihjZ`_ggZy k\hbf hldjulb_f j_rbeZ ih \lhjblv wdki_jbf_gl ² JZ^hklgh ihjZ`_ggZy k\hbf hldjulb_f ^_\mrdZ j_rbeZ ih\lhjblv wdki_jbf_gl :g^j_c m\e_q_gguc ql_gb_f ij_^klZ\eye k_[y ]_jh_f dgb]b ² M\e_q_gguc ql_gb_f :g^j_c ij_^klZ\eye k_[y ]_jh_f dgb]b >_j_\vy ihoh`b_ gZ \_ebdZgh\ rbjhdbf rZljhf jZkijh kl_jeb k\hb \_l\b gZ^ keZ[h hk\_s_gghc Zee__c ² Ihoh`b_ gZ \_ebdZgh\ ^_j_\vy rbjhdbf rZljhf jZkijhkl_jeb k\hb \_l\b gZ^ keZ[h hk\_s_gghc Zee__c
Ba hdgZ \Z]hgZ [ueb \b^gu ihey aZjhkrb_ khjghc ljZ\hc ² Ba hdgZ \Z]hgZ [ueb \b^gu aZjhkrb_ khjghc ljZ\hc ihey Ih^gy\ ]heh\m hg m\b^_e g_[h mk_yggh_ fbeebhgZfb a\_a^ ² Ih^gy\ ]heh\m hg m\b^_e mk_yggh_ fbeebhgZfb a\_a^ g_[h Fu \hreb \ iZjd aZebluc emgguf k\_lhf ² Fu \hreb \ aZebluc emgguf k\_lhf iZjd Fhj_ l_i_jv m`_ kihdhcgh_ b [_afhe\gh_ fZgbeh d k_[_ ² L_i_jv m`_ kihdhcgh_ b [_afhe\gh_ fhj_ fZgbeh d k_[_ I_khd \eZ`guc hl lhevdh qlh ijhr_^r_]h ^h`^y g_`gh rmjrZe ih^ gh]Zfb ² <eZ`guc hl lhevdh qlh ijhr_^r_]h ^h `^y i_khd g_`gh rmjrZe ih^ gh]Zfb JZ^hklgh
=hgbf u_ kbevg uf iheg Zy ki_e uo ihjZ`_gg Zy
m\e_q_gg uc ihoh` b_ aZjhkr b_ khjg hc mk_ygg h_
aZebl uc emgg uf kihdhcg h_ \eZ`g uc [_afhe\g h_
ijhr_^r _]h L_i_jv m`_ mkihdhb\r__ky fhj_ lboh ^j_fZeh ² Fh j_ l_i_jv m`_ mkihdhb\r__ky lboh ^j_fZeh H[e_l_\rb_ k ^_j_\v_\ ebklvy rmjrZeb ih^ gh]Zfb ² Ebklvy h[e_l_\rb_ k ^_j_\v_\ rmjrZeb ih^ gh]Zfb Keur_g rmf iZ^Zxs_c kh kdZeu \h^u ² Keur_g rmf \h^u iZ^Zxs_c kh kdZeu Y ijbkemrZeky d a\mdZf g_`gh `mjqZs_]h \ ^hebg_ jmqvy ² Y ijbkemrZeky d a\mdZf jmqvy g_`gh `mjqZs_]h \ ^hebg_ o
Kbg__ kihdhcgh_ ha_jh \ ]em[hdhc jZf_ ]hj hdjue_g
guo \_qguf kg_]hf l_fgh_ djm`_\h kZ^h\ iurgufb kdeZ^dZfb o
himkdZ_lky d \h^_ Ba ^\_jb [_eh]h ^hfbdZ aZoe_klgmlh]h \b gh]jZ^gbdZfb \uoh^bl gZ\klj_qm khegpm ^j_\gbc klZj_p <
k\ys_gghc lbrbg_ \hkoh^bl khegp_ b hl dZfg_c hkljh\Z ih^ o
gbfZ_lky \ g_[h kbauc lmfZg gZkus_gguc keZ^dbf aZiZohf ah o
ehluo p\_lh\ JZa^bjZ_fh_ fhegbyfb g_[h ^jh`Zeh ^jh`ZeZ b kl_iv lh \kiuob\Zy kbgbf h]g_f lh ih]jm`Zykv \ oheh^guc o
ly`_euc b l_kguc fjZd kljZrgh km`b\Z\rbc __ AZdh\Zggu_
o
o
\ ]jZgbl \hegu fhjy ih^Z\e_gu ]jhfZ^gufb ly`_klyfb kdhev aysbfb ih _]h oj_[lZf Ih h[_bf klhjhgZf dZfbgZ klhyl nb o
dmku gbs_gkdb [_^gu_ ebklvyfb KljmcdZ ^ufZ \beZkv \ o
ghqghf \ha^mo_ iheghf \eZ]b b k\_`_klb fhjy Eh^dZ dheu o
oZeZkv gZ \hegZo rZeh\eb\h ie_kdZ\rboky h[ __ [hjlZ _e_ ^\b
]ZeZkv ih l_fghfm fhjx Z hgh b]jZeh \k_ j_a\_c b j_a\_c o
LbrbgZ ij_ju\ZeZkv a\mdZfb i_kgb ^he_lZ\r_c k j_db o
LjZ\Z k]b[Z_fZy m^ZjZfb \_ljZ b ^h`^y eh`beZkv gZ a_fex F =hjvdbc
KljZrgh gbs_gkdb rZeh\eb\h _e_ j_a\_c
Hdjue_gguo ² ijbqZklb_ =hj dZdbo" hdjue_gguo Ijb agZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Hdjueblv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Fg q J i =hj dZdbo" hdjue_gguo AZoe_klgmlh]h ² ijbqZklb_ >hfbdZ dZdh]h" aZoe_klgm lh]h IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx AZoe_klgmlv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j J i >hfbdZ dZdh]h" aZoe_klgmlh]h
GZkus_gguc ² ijbqZklb_ LmfZg dZdhc" gZkus_gguc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx GZkulblv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j B i LmfZg dZdhc" gZkus_gguc
JZa^bjZ_fh_ ² ijbqZklb_ G_[h dZdh_" jZa^bjZ_fh_ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx JZa^bjZlv KljZ^ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j ?^ q kj j B i
G_[h dZdh_" jZa^bjZ_fh_
Km`b\Z\rbc ² ijbqZklb_ FjZd dZdhc" km`b\Z\rbc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Km`b\Zlv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j < i FjZd dZdhc" km`b\Z\rbc
AZdh\Zggu_ ² ijbqZklb_ <hegu dZdb_" aZdh\Zggu_ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx AZdh\Zlv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Fg q B i <hegu dZdb_" aZdh\Zggu_ Ih^Z\e_gu ² ijbqZklb_ <hegu dZdh\u" ih^Z\e_gu IjbagZ\ ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ih^Z\blv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j dj n Fg q <hegu dZdh\u" ih^Z\e_gu Kdhevaysbfb ² ijbqZklb_ Ly`_klyfb dZdbfb" kdhev aysbfb IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Kdhevablv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j Fg q L i Ly`_klyfb dZdbfb" kdhevaysbfb Ie_kdZ\rboky ² ijbqZklb_ GZ \hegZo dZdbo" ie_kdZ\ rboky IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ie_kdZlvky >_ckl\ \ha\j g_kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Fg q ij_^e i GZ \hegZo dZdbo" ie_kdZ\rboky
>he_lZ\r_c ² ijbqZklb_ I_kgb dZdhc" ^he_lZ\r_c IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx >he_lZlv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ ijhr \j
?^ q ` j J i I_kgb dZdhc" ^he_lZ\r_c
K]b[Z_fZy ² ijbqZklb_ LjZ\Z dZdZy" k]b[Z_fZy Ijb agZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx K]b[Zlv KljZ^ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j ?^ q ` j bf i LjZ\Z dZdZy" k]b[Z_fZy
Kbg__l kihdhcgh_ ha_jh \ ]em[hdhc jZf_ ]hj hdjue_gguo \_qguf kg_]hf l_fgh_ djm`_\h kZ^h\ iurgufb kdeZ^dZfb himkdZ_lky d \h^_ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde keh`gh_ q ijhklh_ h^ghkhkl gZau\g jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h[hkh[e_gguf hij_^_e_gb_f \ujZ`_gguf ijbqZklguf h[hjh lhf q ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ > ² @ > ²
@
Y ibrm \k_ wlh hk_gg_c ghqvx Hk_gb aZ hdghf g_ \b^gh
hgZ aZeblZ lvfhc Gh klhbl \uclb gZ djuevph dZd hk_gv hdjm `bl l_[y b gZqg_l gZklhcqb\h ^urZlv \ ebph oheh^gh\Zlhc k\_
`_klvx k\hbo aZ]Z^hqguo q_jguo ijhkljZgkl\ ]hjvdbf aZiZohf o
i_j\h]h lhgdh]h ev^Z kdh\Z\r_]h d ghqb g_ih^\b`gu_ \h^u o
gZqg_l i_j_r_ilu\Zlvky k ihke_^g_c ebkl\hc h[e_lZxs_c g_
ij_ju\gh b ^g_f b ghqvx B [e_kg_l g_h`b^Zgguf k\_lhf a\_a o
^u ijhj\Z\r_cky kd\hav \hegbklu_ ghqgu_ lmfZgu
B wlh \k_ ihdZ`_lky \Zf \_ebdbf r_^_\jhf ijbjh^u p_e_[
guf ih^Zjdhf gZihfbgZxsbf h kfuke_ b agZq_gbb `bagb D IZmklh\kdbc
h\Zl hc ² ijbeZ] dZq_kl\ iheg n ` j _^ q \ha
fh`gh J i > i L i beb I i \ ^Zgghf l_dkl_ ² ^urZlv oheh^gh\Zl hc k\_`_klvx ² L i
i_j_
u\Z _l ky ² ]eZ]he g_kh\ \b^ \ha\j g_i_j_o
baty\ gZde _^ q gZkl \j e \ l_dkl_ ² i_j_r_ilu\Z lv ky ² bgnbgblb\ ijh
Z\r _c ky ² ijbqZklb_ ^_ckl\ \ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr
\j _^ q ` j \hafh`gh J i > i L i beb I i \ ^Zgghf l_dkl_ ² k\_lhf a\_a^u ijhj\Z\r _c ky ² J i >_j_\vy jZklmsb_ \ Zee__ b mdjZrZxsb_ iZjd [ueb kh\k_f fheh^u_ J_[ylZ ijb_oZ\rb_ gZ ^Zqm ki_rZl d j_d_ Wlhc iyl_jd_ ihemq_gghc fghx \i_j\u_ \ `bagb y hq_gv h[ jZ^h\Zeky <hr_^rbc h[jhkrbc [hjh^hc [ue h^_l \ \heqbc lmemi Q_eh\_d ohjhrh agZxsbc f_klghklv gbdh]^Z g_ aZ[em ^blky Kheg_qguc emq hk\_sZe iZ^Zxsb_ k ^_j_\v_\ ebklvy Iexs \vxsbcky ih kl_g_ mdjZrZ_l dhfgZlm jZ^m_l ]eZa H[\blh_ \bgh]jZ^gbdhf f_klh [ueh ihoh`_ gZ dju lmx mxlgmx [_k_^dm l_fgmx b ijhoeZ^gmx E Lheklhc
Z H[\blh_ \bgh]jZ^gbdhf f_klh ² kh]e jZkij g_h[h kh[e [ gZ djulmx mxlgmx [_k_^dm ² kh]e g_jZkij g_h[h kh[e \ [_k_^dm l_fgmx b ijhoeZ^gmx ² kh]e g_jZkij h[h kh[e JZggbc kheg_qguc k\_l iZ^Z\rbc gZ ebkl\m jy^hf k p\_lZfb rbih\gbdZ dZaZeky oheh^guf b [e_^guf D IZm klh\kdbc
Z JZggbc kheg_qguc k\_l ² kh]e g_jZkij g_h[hkh[e [ k\_l iZ^Z\rbc gZ ebkl\m ² kh]e jZkij h[hkh[e \ k p\_lZfb rbih\gbdZ ² g_kh]e g_jZkij g_h[hkh[e H]hgvdb ^Ze_db_ b fZgysb_ yjdh ]hj_eb \ ghqghf g_[_ H]hgvdb yjdh ]hj_eb \ ghqghf g_[_ ^Ze_dhf b fZgys_f <_l_j l_ieuc b e_]dbc r_\_ebe fheh^u_ ebklhqdb <_l_j r_\_ebe fheh^u_ ebklhqdb yjdb_ b khqgu_ LjZ\Z khqgZy b a_e_gZy [ueZ ihdjulZ djmigufb dZieyfb jhku LjZ\Z [ueZ ihdjulZ djmigufb dZieyfb jhku l_iehc b k\_jdZxs_c
:dZpby \ukhdZy b \_l\bklZy [jhkZeZ ijhajZqgmx l_gv gZ nhglZg :dZpby [jhkZeZ ijhajZqgmx l_gv gZ nhglZg ijhoeZ^ guc b qbkluc AZ hdghf jZkdbgmeky kZ^ [hevrhc b l_gbkluc =hjh^ kdhc kZ^ [ue [hevrhc b l_gbkluc JmkkdZy [_j_adZ ² ^_j_\h \ukhdh_ kljhcgh_ >_j_\h [ueh \ukhdh_ kljhcgh_ < fZ]Zabg \[_`ZeZ ^_\mrdZ djZkb\Zy b `bag_jZ^hklgZy HgZ \gh\v klZeZ djZkb\Zy b `bag_jZ^hklgZy GZklmibe ^_gv ykguc kheg_qguc >_gv [ue ykguc khe g_qguc GZ kdZf_cd_ kb^_eZ ^_\hqdZ fZe_gvdZy b aZ^mfqb\Zy >_ \hqdZ [ueZ fZe_gvdZy b aZ^mfqb\Zy GZ jmq_c jy[hc b i_kljuc AZ ebkldhf e_lbl ebklhd B kljmzc kmohc b hkljhc GZ[_]Z_l oheh^hd G G_djZkh\
Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde keh`gh_ q ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h[hkh[e hij_^_e_gb_f q ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h[hkh[e hij_^_e_gb_f > ² @ b > ² @ I_qZev j_kgbp kbyxsbo b q_jguo :efZau ke_a h[bevguo g_ihdhjguo B \gh\v h]hgv g_[_kguo ]eZa KqZkleb\uo jZ^hklguo kfbj_gguo ² <FH ihfgx y Gh g_l m` \ fbj_ gZk Dh]^Z lh xguo b [eZ`_gguo B ;mgbg
_ ij_^eh`_gb_ ² ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h^ghjh^gufb ^hiheg_gbyfb k h[h[ sZxsbf keh\hf b h[hkh[e_ggufb hij_^_e_gbyfb
b ² _ ij_^eh`_gb_ ² ih\_kl\ \hkde ijhklh_ h^ghkhkl [_a ebqgh_ jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h[hkh[e Hij_^_e_gb_f > @ GZ jmq_c jy[hc b i_kljuc AZ ebkldhf e_lbl ebklhd B kljmzc kmohc b hkljhc GZ[_]Z_l oheh^hd KbglZdkbq_kdbc ZgZeba kf \ mij
Keurblky kihj b ]h\hj g_bklh\h djbqbl j_[_ghd ih o
_a^ klmqbl b ]jhfuoZ_l Z khe^Zl \ gh\hc kblp_\hc jm[Zo_ b \ q_jghf ]Zeklmd_ kb^bl gZ^ kiysbfb gZ k\h_f kmg^mqd_ Qm o
^_kgu_ [Z[hqdb b \ kblp_\uo i_klj_gvdbo ieZlvbpZo b \ yihg kdbo gZjy^Zo b \ q_jgh ebeh\uo [ZjoZlguo rZeyo aZe_lZeb \ o
]hklbgmx WlZ dhfgZlZ hdgZfb gZ aZiZ^ b gZ k_\_j aZgbfZeZ qmlv eb g_ iheh\bgm \k_]h ^hfZ B]jZe a_jdZevguc hl[e_kd
fhjy \ \urbgZo khk_g b l_deZ \^hev ih dhj_ kmohc b `_kldhc kfheZ ijhajZqg__ kl_deZ
B ;mgbg
G_bklh\h ² g_mdjhlbfh [_am^_j`gh Djbqbl ² \hibl gZ^ju\Z_lky hj_l j_\_l =jhfuoZ_l ² ]j_fbl ]jhohq_l A_jdZevguc ² hljZ`_gguc Hl[e_kd hlk\_l [ebd DZq_kl\_ggu_ gh\uc q_jguc qm^_kguc i_klj_gvdbc q_j gh ebeh\uc a_jdZevguc kmohc `_kldbc ijhajZqg__ Hlghkbl_evgu_ kblp_\uc yihgkdbc [ZjoZlguc AZ klhehf aZ\Ze_gguf [mfZ]Zfb I_lj kb^_e \ klZjuo dh`Zguo dj_keZo k \ukhdhx kibgdhx m `Zjdh gZlhie_gghc i_qb GZ g_f [ue ]hem[hc ihebgyeuc b aZghr_gguc oZeZl dhlhjuc pZ j_\bq ihfgbe _s_ ^h IhelZ\kdh]h kjZ`_gby k lhx `_ aZieZlhx [he__ yjdh]h p\_lZ gZ f_kl_ ijh``_gghf ljm[dhx r_jklygZy djZkgZy nmnZcdZ k [_eufb dhklygufb im]h\bpZfb hl h^ghc ba gbo kehfZgghc hklZ\ZeZkv lhevdh iheh\bgdZ hg magZe __ b
khkqblZe dZd ihq_fm lh \k_]^Z wlh ^_eZe \h \j_fy ^ebgguo mdh jbag_gguo j_q_c hlpZ hgZ [ueZ r_klZy kgbam bkih^g__ ieZlv_ ba ]jm[h]h kbg_]h klZf_^Z k_ju_ ]Zjmkgu_ rlhiZgu_ qmedb klZju_ klhilZggu_ lmneb PZj_\bq jZkkfZljb\Ze \k_ wlb f_ehqb lZdb_ ijb\uqgu_ jh^gu_ qm`^u_ Lhevdh ebiZ [Zlxrdb ihqlb g_ \b ^_e Ba hdgZ aZ dhlhjuf [_e_eZ kg_`gZy kdZl_jlv G_\u dhkhc emq `_elh]h abfg_]h khegpZ iZ^Ze f_`^m gbfb lhgdbc ^ebgguc b hkljuc dZd f_q Hg jZa^_eye bo b aZkehgye ^jm] hl ^jm]Z > F_j_`dh\kdbc
AZ\Ze_gg uf aZlhie_gg hc aZghr_gg uc ijh``_gg hf
kehfZgg hc klhilZgg u_ M\_j_gguc \ ijb\yaZgghklb k\h_c ^hq_jb Ljh_dmjh\ gbdh]^Z g_ fh] ^h[blvky hl g__ ^h\_j_gghklb : Imrdbg G_ kfhljy gZ lh qlh Ljh_dmjh\ [ue m\_j_g \ ijb\yaZgghklb k\h_c ^hq_jb hg g_ fh] ^h[blvky hl g__ ^h\_j_gghklb H\_yg \_ s_x ^j_fhlhc ihemjZa^_luc e_k ]jmklbl N Lxlq_\ Ihem jZa^_luc e_k ]jmklbl ihlhfm qlh h\_yg \_s_x ^j_fhlhc Hr_ehfe_ggZy fZlv g_hlju\gh kfhlj_eZ gZ Ju[bgZ F =hjvdbc FZlv g_hlju\gh kfhlj_eZ gZ Ju[bgZ lZd dZd [u eZ hr_ehfe_gZ IhjZ`_gguc g_ijbylghc ^h]Z^dhc Ydh\ Emdbq himklbe ]eZaZ Zogme b ijh\hjgh aZjZ[hlZe iZevpZfb F Rhehoh\ Ydh\ Emdbq himklbe ]eZaZ Zogme b ijh\hjgh aZ jZ[hlZe iZevpZfb ihlhfm qlh [ue ihjZ`_g g_ijbylghc ^h]Z^ dhc H]emr_gguc ly`dbf ]mehf L_jdbg gbdg_l ]heh\hc > L\Zj^h\kdbc L_jdbg gbdg_l ]heh\hc ihlhfm qlh h]emr_g ly`dbf ]mehf IjhkeZ\e_gguc jZa\_^qbd LjZ\dbg hklZ\Zeky l_f `_ lbobf b kdjhfguf xghr_c dZdbf [ue ijb bo i_j\hc \klj_q_ W DZaZd_\bq Ohly LjZ\dbg [ue ijhkeZ\e_gguc jZa \_^qbd hg hklZ\Zeky l_f `_ lbobf b kdjhfguf xghr_c dZdbf [ue ijb bo i_j\hc \klj_q_ MklZeuc b ih[e_^g_\rbc f_kyp \k_ _s_ \bk_e gZ h]jhfghf g_[_ D IZmklh\kdbc Ohly f_kyp [ue mklZeuc b ih[e_^g_\rbc hg \k_ _s_ \bk_e gZ h]jhfghf g_[_ JZajhag_ggZy mklZehklvx h]jhfgZy dhehggZ fZrbg g_ kljhcgh jZkly]b\ZeZkv X ;hg^Zj_\ H]jhfgZy dhehggZ fZ rbg g_kljhcgh jZkly]b\ZeZkv ihlhfm qlh [ueZ jZajhag_gZ mk lZehklvx
M\_j_gg uc h\_yg ihemjZa^_l uc hr_ehfe_gg Zy ihjZ`_gg uc h]emr_gg uc ijhkeZ\e_gg uc
ih[e_^g_\r bc jZajhag_gg Zy ?]h kimlgbd fheh^hc q_eh\_d ih ij_`g_fm iheme_ `bl b _^\Z ibebdZ_l gZ ]Zjfhgbd_ <heh^y k_fgZ^pZlbe_l gbc xghrZ g_djZkb\uc [he_ag_gguc b jh[dbc kb^_e \ [_k_^ d_ gZ ^Zq_ m Rmfbobguo b kdmqZe :j_g^Zlhj omlhjZ ŠGbauª FZdkbf =hjqZdh\ [_j^ygkdbc f_sZgbg _oZe kh k\h_c fheh^hc `_ghc ba p_jd\b H[_ klZjrb_ ^_\hqdb DZly b Khgy klZeb ahjdh ke_^blv aZ fZevqbdZfb GZe_\h lygmeky ohef dm^jy \uc hl f_edh]h dmklZjgbdZ Ih]jm`_gguc \ k\hb fukeb Q_ q_\bpug gbq_]h g_ hl\_lbe gZ wlhl \hijhk Y qZklh gZoh^be m k_[y aZibkdb dhjhldb_ b lj_\h`gu_ Lhqgh bkim]Zgguc ih`Zjhf beb [_r_ghc kh[Zdhc hg _^\Z k^_j`b\Ze k\h_ qZklh_ ^uoZgb_ b ]h\hjbe [ukljh ^jh`Zsbf ]hehkhf GZ^ ohefhf g_ih^\b`gh klhye [hevrhc ihemf_kyp djZkguc ke_]dZ ih^_j gmluc lmfZghf b hdjm`_gguc f_edbfb h[eZqdZfb HgZ [e_^gZy g_ih^\b`gZy dZd klZlmy klhbl b eh\bl \a]ey^hf dZ` ^uc _]h rZ] ;hevr_ \k_o qm\kl\h\Ze k_[y g_eh\dh rlZ[k dZiblZg Jy[h\bq fZe_gvdbc kmlmeh\Zluc hnbp_j \ hqdZo b k [Zd_gZfb dZd m jukb Q_j_a fbgmlm B\Zg FZdZjh\bq b KZ rZ \ iZevlh b \ rZidZo kimkdZxlky \gba ih e_klgbp_ FeZ^rZy k_kljZ @_gy ihdZ ]h\hjbeb h a_fkl\_ fheqZeZ : Q_oh\
Ohaybg fhc ^hdlhj [ue \_qgh aZgyluc fheqZeb\uc q_ eh\_d X DZaZdh\ Ohjhrh qlh hg ihiZe L_jdbg \ gZrm jhlm : L\Zj^h\kdbc
H^bg ba yfsbdh\ \_kvfZ \ukhdbc fm`qbgZ \ue_a ba kZg_c fheqZ hl\yaZe k\hx ljhcdm E Lheklhc B lZf gZ ih^mrd_ ba yjdbo i_kdh\ ih^ l_gvx ]mkluo ljhklgbdh\ kibl \blyav ^h[uqZ j_\gb\hc \hegu F E_jfhglh\ Fh]mqbc e_\ ]jhaZ e_kh\ eb rbeky kbeu B Djueh\
<_kvfZ ² gZj_qb_ <ukhdbc \ dZdhc f_j_" \_kvfZ Ijb agZd ijbagZdZ F_ju G_baf
<ukhdbc \ dZdhc f_j_" \_kvfZ
FheqZ ² gZj_qb_ Hl\yaZe dZd" fheqZ IjbagZd ^_ckl\by H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf Hl\yaZe dZd" fheqZ K\hx ² f_klhbf_gb_ Ljhcdm qvx" k\hx G n ² k\hc Ijbly` ?^ q ` j < i Ljhcdm qvx" k\hx
LZf ² gZj_qb_ Kibl ]^_" lZf IjbagZd ^_ckl\by F_klZ G_baf Kibl ]^_" lZf Fhc ² f_klhbf_gb_ Ohaybg q_c" fhc G n ² fhc Ijbly` ?^ q f j B i Ohaybg q_c" fhc
<_qgh ² gZj_qb_ AZgyluc \ dZdhc f_j_" \_qgh IjbagZd ijbagZdZ F_ju G_baf AZgyluc \ dZdhc f_j_" \_qgh Hg ² f_klhbf_gb_ IhiZe dlh" hg G n ² hg Ebqg e ?^ q f j bf i IhiZe dlh" hg
< gZrm ² f_klhbf_gb_ < jhlm qvx" gZrm G N ² gZr Ijbly` ?^ q ` j \bg i < jhlm qvx" gZrm
<ue_a hl\yaZe ebrbe ky [ue ihiZe Gh \k_o fbe_c fg_ ^_\mrdZ [_j_aZ Ijbr_^rZy ba kdZahd b [uebg Kg_]mjhqdZ ex[bfbpZ fhjhaZ :e_gmrdZ ijb]hjdh\ b jZ\gbg %k Jh`^_kl\_gkdbc
A^jZ\kl\mc jmkkdZy fheh^dZ JZkdjZkZ\bpZ ^mrZ ;_ehkg_`gZy e_[_^dZ A^jZ\kl\mc fZlmrdZ abfZ I <ya_fkdbc
>h\_j_gghklv
Y B\Zgh\Z :ggZ K_j]__\gZ ^h\_jyx G_j_lbghc Hev]_ B\Z gh\g_ khljm^gbdm gZr_c eZ[hjZlhjbb ihemqblv ijbqblZxsmx ky fg_ aZjieZlm aZ n_\jZev ]h^Z fZjlZ ] B\Zgh\Z H[klhyl_evkl\h ² \lhjhkl_i_gguc qe_g ij_^eh`_gby H[klhyl_evkl\h \lhjhkl_i_gguc qe_g ij_^eh`_gby h[hagZqZ_l ijbagZd ^_ckl\by beb ^jm]h]h ijbagZdZ E_k ² gZr_ [h]Zlkl\h E_k gZr_ [h]Zlkl\h gZ^h [_j_qv b hojZgylv @Z^ghklv ² h^bg ba q_eh\_q_kdbo ihjhdh\ Hg g_gZ\b^_e `Z^ghklv h^bg ba q_eh\_q_kdbo ihjhdh\ Ebph ² a_jdZeh ^mrb ?]h ebph a_jdZeh ^mrb ij_djZkgh J_dZ ² bklhqgbd wg_j]bb J_dZ bklhqgbd wg_j]bb kem`bl ex^yf Ql_gb_ ² emqr__ mq_gb_ Ql_gb_ emqr__ mq_gb_ h[h]Z sZ_l q_eh\_dZ Fhy k_kljZ ² xjbkl Fhy k_kljZ xjbkl jZ[hlZ_l \ ghlZ jbZevghc dhglhj_ Jmkkdbc yaud ² h^bg ba [h]Zl_crbo yaudh\ fbjZ Jmk kdbc yaud h^bg ba [h]Zl_crbo yaudh\ fbjZ ihklhyggh jZa\b \Z_lky
Om^h`_kl\_ggZy ebl_jZlmjZ ² bkdmkkl\h keh\Z Om^h`_ kl\_ggZy ebl_jZlmjZ bkdmkkl\h keh\Z \dexqZ_l \ k_[y b mklgh_ gZjh^gh_ l\hjq_kl\h >_lb ² [m^ms__ kljZgu >_lb [m^ms__ kljZgu ^he`gu [ulv hdjm`_gu aZ[hlhc b \gbfZgb_f AZf_qZl_evguc jmkkdbc om^h`gbd Z Bevy ?nbfh\bq J_ibg aZf_qZl_evguc jmkkdbc om^h`gbd \ jZkp\_l_ k\hbo [h]Zlujkdbo kbe k\h_c ih[_`^Zxs_c dbklvx ^Zjbl bamfe_gghfm fbjm r_^_\j aZ r_^_\jhf [ AZf_qZl_evguc jmkkdbc om^h`gbd Bevy ?nbfh\bq J_ibg \ jZkp\_l_ k\hbo [h]Zlujkdbo kbe k\h_c ih[_`^Zxs_c dbklvx ^Z jbl bamfe_gghfm fbjm r_^_\j aZ r_^_\jhf \ Bevy ?nbfh\bq J_ibg ² aZf_qZl_evguc jmkkdbc om^h` gbd ] AZf_qZl_evguc jmkkdbc om^h`gbd ² Bevy ?nbfh\bq J_ ibg ^ AZf_qZl_evguc jmkkdbc om^h`gbd GZjbkmc g_h[tylgh_ g_[h Jh^bgu fh_c Ex[bfuc ^_lkdbc ibkZl_ev Z Dhjg_c B\Zgh\bq Qmdh\kdbc ex[bfuc ^_lkdbc ibkZl_ev `be \ I_j_^_edbgh [ Ex[bfuc ^_lkdbc ibkZl_ev Dhjg_c B\Zgh\bq Qmdh\kdbc `be \ I_j_^_edbgh \ Dhjg_c B\Zgh\bq Qmdh\kdbc ² ex[bfuc ^_lkdbc ibkZl_ev ] Ex[bfuc ^_lkdbc ibkZl_ev ² Dhjg_c B\Zgh\bq Qmdh\ kdbc ^ Ex[bfuc ^_lkdbc ibkZl_ev gZibrb ih`ZemcklZ kdZadm h fh_c kh[Zd_ GZ^_`guc ^jm] Z :g^j_c gZ^_`guc ^jm] k_]h^gy h[yaZl_evgh ijb^_l [ GZ^_`guc ^jm] :g^j_c k_]h^gy h[yaZl_evgh ijb^_l \ :g^j_c ² gZ^_`guc ^jm] ] GZ^_`guc ^jm] ² :g^j_c ^ GZ^_`guc ^jm] g_ hklZ\v f_gy \ [_^_ Bgl_j_kguc kh[_k_^gbd
Z :glhg IZ\eh\bq bgl_j_kguc kh[_k_^gbd f]gh\_ggh fh] ijb^mfZlv ex[mx bklhjbx [ Bgl_j_kguc kh[_k_^gbd :glhg IZ\eh\bq f]gh\_ggh fh] ijb^mfZlv ex[mx bklhjbx \ :glhg IZ\eh\bq ² bgl_j_kguc kh[_k_^gbd ] Bgl_j_kguc kh[_k_^gbd ² :glhg IZ\eh\bq ^ Bgl_j_kguc kh[_k_^gbd g_ [hcky mlhfblv f_gy k\hbfb aZf_qZl_evgufb bklhjbyfb Ij_ab^_gl kh\f_klgh]h ij_^ijbylby Z :e_dk_c B\Zgh\bq ij_ab^_gl kh\f_klgh]h ij_^ijbylby ijb_a`Z_l ^hfhc iha^gh Ij_ab^_gl kh\f_klgh]h ij_^ijbylby :e_dk_c B\Zgh\bq ijb_a`Z_l ^hfhc iha^gh \ :e_dk_c B\Zgh\bq ² ij_ab^_gl kh\f_klgh]h ij_^ijb ylby ] Ij_ab^_gl kh\f_klgh]h ij_^ijbylby ² :e_dk_c B\Zgh \bq ^ Ij_ab^_gl kh\f_klgh]h ij_^ijbylby Ijb]eZrZ_f <Zk ih k_lblv ij_a_glZpbx lh\Zjh\ gZr_c nbjfu Ih]h\hjbf dZ emqr_ h Jhkkbb \haex[e_gghf hl_q_ kl\_ k\h_f : Ijhdhnv_\ KZf q_eh\_d jZ[hlysbc hg g_ \ughkbe e_gb \h \k_o __ \b^Zo D Kbfhgh\ H^bg ba kugh\_c FbrZ aZ\_^m_l hiulghc bolbheh]bq_kdhc klZgpb_c gZ ha_j_ <_ebdhf D IZmklh\kdbc Hg ^Z`_ fg_ kgbeky bgh]^Z wlhl jhyev D IZmklh\kdbc
Keh\Z k gme_\uf hdhgqZgb_f kZf q_eh\_d hg g_ \ughkbe h^bg kgbeky jhyev Hlklmigbd [mjguo gZkeZ`^_gbc Hg_]bg ^hfZ aZi_jky a_\Zy aZ i_jh \ayeky Hlklmigbd k\_lZ ^jm] ijbjh^u ihdbgme hg jh^ghc ij_^_e LZf \ klZju ]h^u kZlbju kf_ehc \eZkl_ebg [ebklZe Nhg\babg ^jm] k\h[h^u AZ \_kghc djZkhc ijbjh^u e_lh aghcgh_ ijhc^_l Y klZjZeky \hh[jZablv k_[_ dZiblZgZ Fbjhgh\Z fh_]h [m^ms_]h gZqZevgbdZ b ij_^klZ\eye _]h kljh ]bf k_j^bluf klZjbdhf Dhf_g^Zgl Gb`g_ha_jghc dj_ihklb lbobc b kdjhfguc fheh^hc q_eh\_d [ue fg_ agZdhf Y \a]ey gme gZbkdhkv gZ gZi_jkgbdh\ kZfha\ZgpZ H^bg ba gbo ls_^mr
guc b k]hj[e_gguc klZjbqhd k k_^hx [hjh^dhx g_ bf_e \ k_[_ gbq_]h aZf_qZl_evgh]h djhf_ ]hem[hc e_glu gZ^_lhc q_j_a ie_qh ih k_jhfm Zjfydm G_kqZklvx \_jgZy k_kljZ gZ^_`^Z \ fjZq ghf ih^a_f_ev_ jZa[m^bl [h^jhklv b \_k_ev_ ?fm eb dZjebdm ly]Zlvky k bkihebghf" K_c >m[jh\kdbc hlklZ\ghc ihjmqbd ]\Zj^bb [ue _fm [eb`Zcrbf khk_^hf : Imrdbg
H[hkh[e ijbeh`_gby k khxahf dZd i_j_^Zxsb_ hll_ ghd ijbqbgu Bexr_ bgh]^Z dZd j_a\hfm fZevqbdm lZd b ohq_lky [jhkblv ky b i_j_^_eZlv \k_ kZfhfm : =hgqZjh\ Iv_j dZd aZdhgguc kug ihemqbl \k_ E Lheklhc ?fm dZd q_eh\_dm jh[dhfm b g_ h[sbl_evghfm ij_`^_ \k_]h [jhkZehkv \ ]eZaZ lh qlh m g_]h gb dh]^Z g_ [ueh : Q_oh\ <u dZd bgbpbZlhj ^he`gu b]jZlv ]eZ\gmx jhev < IZgh\Z DZd ebph kem`_[gh_ fbebp_ckdh_ Khrdbg ijb\ud agZdhfblvky k jZaguf gZjh^hf < :klZnv_\ Fg_ dZd ebpm \ukhdhihklZ\e_gghfm g_ ih^h[Z_l _a^blv gZ dhg d_ : Q_oh\
G_h[hkh[e_ggu_ ijbeh`_gby k khxahf dZd hl\_qZxsb_ gZ \hijhku \ dZdhf hlghr_gbb k dZdhc klhjhgu" DZd klbebkl Q_oh\ g_^hky]Z_f F =hjvdbc DZd ihwl gh\h]h \j_f_gb ;Zlxrdh\ g_ fh] \ k\hx hq_j_^v g_ aZieZlblv ^Zgb jh fZglbafm < ;_ebgkdbc DZd `b\hibk_p FZydh\kdbc m\Z`Ze b ex[be K_jh\Z < Rdeh\kdbc ;h]Zl ohjhr kh[hx E_gkdbc \_a^_ [ue ijbgyl dZd `_gbo : Imrdbg
H g_c ihxl ihwlu \k_o \_dh\ G_l \ fbj_ gbq_]h g_`g_c b djZr_ Q_f wlhl k\_jlhd Zeuo e_i_kldh\ JZkdju\rboky [eZ]hmoZgghc qZr_c DZd hg ij_djZk_g oheh^_g b qbkl =em[hdbc dm[hd iheguc ZjhfZlZ DZd ^jm`_g k gbf ijhklhc b kdjhfguc ebkl L_fgh a_e_guc ih djZyf am[qZluc
AZ e_i_klhd aZoh^bl e_i_klhd B \k_ hgb k\h_c imgph\hc ldZgvx
Kljmyl g_bkkydZ_fuc ihlhd >mrbklh]h b k\_`_]h ^uoZgvy K FZjrZd
G_`g_c djZr_ < h^gh ykgh_ oheh^gh_ mljh ba l_o dZdbfb [h]ZlZ gZ rZ jmkkdZy hk_gv B\Zg I_ljh\bq ;_j_klh\ \u_oZe ijh]meylvky \_johf gZ \kydbc kemqZc \ay\ k kh[hc iZju ljb [hjauo klj_ fyggh]h b g_kdhevdbo ^\hjh\uo fZevqbr_d k lj_shldZfb < lh `_ kZfh_ \j_fy =jb]hjbc B\Zgh\bq Fmjhfkdbc kh[eZagykv ohjhr_x ih]h^hx \_e_e hk_^eZlv dmpmx k\hx dh[uedm b ju kvx ih_oZe hdheh k\hbo Zg]ebabjh\Zgguo \eZ^_gbc Ih^t_a`Zy d e_km m\b^_e hg khk_^Z k\h_]h ]hj^h kb^ys_]h \_johf \ q_d f_g_ ih^[bluf ebkvbf f_ohf b ih^`b^Zxs_]h aZcpZ dhlhjh ]h fZevqbrdb djbdhf b lj_shldZfb \u]hgyeb ba dmklZjgbdZ ?keb [ =jb]hjbc B\Zgh\bq fh] ij_^\b^_lv wlm \klj_qm lh dh g_qgh [ hg ih\hjhlbe \ klhjhgm gh hg gZ_oZe gZ ;_j_klh\Z \h \k_ g_h`b^Zggh b \^jm] hqmlbeky hl g_]h gZ jZkklhygbb ibklh e_lgh]h \uklj_eZ >_eZlv [ueh g_q_]h Fmjhfkdbc dZd h[jZah\Zgguc _\jhi__p ih^t_oZe d k\h_fm ijhlb\gbdm b mqlb \h _]h ijb\_lkl\h\Ze ;_j_klh\ hl\_qZe k lZdbf `_ mk_j^b_f k dZdh\uf p_ighc f_^\_^v deZgy_lky ]hkih^Zf ih ijbdZaZgbx k\h_]h \h`Zlh]h < kb_ \j_fy aZyp \ukdhqbe ba e_km b ih[_`Ze ihe_f ;_j_klh\ b klj_fygghc aZdjbqZeb \h \k_ ]hjeh imklbeb kh[Zd b ke_^hf ihkdZdZeb \h \_kv hihj EhrZ^v Fmjhfkdh]h g_ [u\Z\rZy gbdh]^Z gZ hohl_ bkim]ZeZkv b ihg_keZ Fmjhf kdbc ijh\ha]eZkb\rbc k_[y hlebqguf gZ_a^gbdhf ^Ze _c \h ex b \gmlj_gg_ ^h\he_g [ue kemqZ_f ba[Z\eyxsbf _]h hl g_ ijbylgh]h kh[_k_^gbdZ : Imrdbg
dZ
=hj^h ² gZj_qb_ Kb^ys_]h dZd" ]hj^h IjbagZd ijbagZ H[j ^_ckl\by G_baf Kb^ys_]h dZd" ]hj^h
GZ ² ij_^eh] G_ [u\Z\rZy gZ hohl_ Ijhkl g_ijhba\ g_baf keh\h
G_ qe_g ij_^eh`_gby
B ² khxa \ukdhqbe b ih[_`Ze Ijhkl khqbg kh_^bg g_baf G_ qe_g ij_^eh`_gby
@_ ² qZklbpZ < lh `_ \j_fy >hi agZq mkbe_g Fh^Zevg g_baf G_ qe_g ij_^eh`_gby ^__ij h[
>_j`Z dm\rbg gZ^ ]heh\hc kms
=jmabgdZ madhx ljhihc ij kms
gZj
Koh^beZ d [_j_]m Ihjhc ij
kms
HgZ kdhevabeZ f_` dZfg_c ^__ij h[
Kf_ykv g_eh\dhklb k\h_c ^__ij h[
Bafmqb\ ^h[jh]h dhgy kms ij ijbe kms ij kms GZ [jZqguc ibj d aZdZlm ^gy
Ki_rbe `_gbo g_l_ji_eb\uc Dhl_ghd kijylZeky aZ dmklhf b gZqZe \gbfZl_evgh ke_^blv aZ klZcdhc \hjh[v_\ ² Dhl_ghd kijylZ\rbkv aZ dmk lhf klZe \gbfZl_evgh ke_^blv aZ klZcdhc \hjh[v_\ =_ggZ ^bc g_h`b^Zggh ihdjZkg_e b aZfheqZe ² =_ggZ^bc g_h`b ^Zggh ihdjZkg_\ aZfheqZe Hg ih\_jgmeky b [ukljh aZrZ]Ze \^hev j_db ih _e_ aZf_lghc ljhid_ ² Ih\_jgm\rbkv hg [ukl jh aZrZ]Ze \^hev j_db ih _e_ aZf_lghc ljhid_ Fu kb^_eb aZ iZjlZfb b l_ji_eb\h `^Zeb dh]^Z \ deZkk ijb^_l mqbl_ev ² Kb^y aZ iZjlZfb fu l_ji_eb\h `^Zeb dh]^Z \ deZkk ijb^_l mqbl_ev <ue_l_\ ba :njbdb \ Zij_e_ D [_j_]Zf hl_q_kdhc a_feb >ebgguf lj_m]hevgbdhf e_l_eb MlhiZy \ g_[_ `mjZ\eb <ulygm\ k_j_[jygu_ djuevy Q_j_a \_kv rbjhdbc g_[hk\h^ <_e \h`Zd \ ^hebgm bah[bevy K\hc g_fgh]hqbke_gguc gZjh^ G AZ[hehpdbc
<ue_l_\ mlhiZy \ulygm\ Ih^gy\rbkv gZ ]hjgmx \_jrbgm fu m\b^_eb \^Zeb fhj_ E_k klhbl fheqZ g_ih^\b`gh keh\gh \kfZljb\Zykv dm ^Z lh k\hbfb \_jomrdZfb Dh]^Z y ijhqblZe wlm dgb]m jZ ^hklv ho\ZlbeZ f_gy ² IjhqblZ\ wlm dgb]m y h[jZ^h\Zeky Dh]^Z eb\_gv dhgqbeky ^_lb \u[_`Zeb gZ mebpm Dh]^Z hgb \_jgmebkv \ ]hjh^ [ueh m`_ l_fgh <uc^y ba h[eZdh\ emgZ hk\_lbeZ [e_^guf k\_lhf hdj_klghklv Dh]^Z kl_fg_eh fu jZah`]eb dhkl_j Dh]^Z Bevy \ha\jZlbeky _]h h`b^Ze kxj ijba Ih^gy\rbkv \kfZljb\Zykv ijhqblZ\ \uc^y G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh \k_ hdgZ [ueb aZg_k_gu kg_]hf y qm\kl\h\Ze qlh ^_gv klZe k\_le__ \q_jZrg_]h M ^\_j_c eZyeZ kh[ZdZ GZkdhjh gZ^_\ \Ze_gdb y \imklbe __ hgZ jZ^hklgh ih^ [_`ZeZ d ihkl_eb b iheh`b\ gZ djZc oheh^gmx fhj^m ]ey^_eZ gZ f_gy k eZkdh\uf ^hklhbgkl\hf dZd [m^lh gZihfbgZy qlh b hgZ jZaukdb\ZeZ kh fghx ehrZ^v dhlhjZy l_i_jv j`ZeZ gZ ^\h j_ ijb\yaZggZy \ gZdZaZgb_ d klhe[m GZkljh_gb_ m f_gy [ueh [h^jh_ jZ^hklgh_ < Dhjhe_gdh
;ue b qm\kl\h\Ze klZe eZye Z \imklbe Z ih^[_`Ze Z ]ey^_e Z jZaukdb\Ze Z j`Ze Z
<k_ ² f_klhbf_gb_ HdgZ dZdb_" <k_ G n ² \_kv Hij_^_ebl Fg q B i HdgZ dZdb_" \k_ Y ² f_klhbf_gb_ Qm\kl\h\Ze dlh" y G n ² y Ebqg e ?^ q B i Qm\kl\h\Ze dlh" y
?_ ² f_klhbf_gb_ <imklbe dh]h" __ G n ² hgZ
Ebqg e ?^ q < i <imklbe dh]h" __ IhdmrZ\ gZ k\_`_f \ha^mo_ fu ihqm\kl\h\Zeb qlh m gZk ijb[Z\behkv kbe b [h^jhklb Dh]^Z Iv_j \hr_e \ kZehg _]h ebph [ueh [_ajZaebqgh Ijhkgm\rbkv hq_gv jZgh fu m\b ^_eb qlh gZ mebp_ r_e kbevguc ^h`^v Ijb_oZ\ gZ \_q_j hg bf_e mklZeuc kdmqZxsbc \a]ey^ M Dhklb ihl_deb kexgdb dh]^Z hg m\b^_e rhdheZ^guc lhjl ?keb \u jZa^\bg_l_ dmklu rbih\gbdZ lh m\b^bl_ klZjbgguc ^hf mkZ^v[m Dh]^Z fu gZ eh\beb ju[m m gZk dhgqbebkv q_j\ydb KZgy ]eZ^be ih kibg_ i_kbdZ \bey\r_]h o\hklhf ?keb ^h[jhkh\_klgh ih^]hlh \brvky d mjhdm \k_]^Z hl\_lbrv _]h ohjhrh Dh]^Z fu ih^t_oZeb d ieZlnhjf_ kh[Zdb \klj_lbeb gZk ^jm`guf eZ_f GZ fZevqbdZ hdZaZ\r_]hky \ l_fghl_ ih^meh \_ljhf H]eygm\rbkv gZaZ^ j_[ylZ m\b^_eb qlh hgb m`_ ^Ze_dh hl ^hfZ ?_ \klj_lbeb Zieh^bkf_glZfb dh]^Z hgZ ih^gyeZkv gZ ljb[mgm Iv_j aZdjue ebph b keZ[Zy meu[dZ aZ[u\rbkv hklZ eZkv gZ _]h ebp_ ohlv hgh l_i_jv \ujZ`Zeh m`Zk b kljZo GZ lZrZ ijblbogm\ \u]ey^u\ZeZ ba k\h_c aZkZ^u h`b^Zy qlh hg [m^_l ^_eZlv KlZjZykv ^_eZlv dZd fh`gh f_gvr_ [ukljuo ^\b`_gbc b ijbkemrb\Zykv d ijhe_lZ\rbf \k_ qZs_ b qZs_ fb fh iq_eZf hg ^hr_e ih ljhibgd_ ^h ba[u E Lheklhc
> ² @ b > ² @ ohlv > ² @ qlh > b @ >hqv FZfhglh\uo fbeZy b \_k_eZy <_jhqdZ ijb\e_deZ \gbfZgb_ K_jh\Z b hg ihijhkbe __ ihabjh\Zlv G_e_]dh [ueh `b\hc rZeh\eb\hc ^_\hqd_ kb^_lv qZkZfb \ dhfgZl_ Gh \k_ `_ p_euc f_kyp ihabjh\ZeZ hgZ om^h`gbdm >_\hqdZ ih^jhklhd kb^bl aZ klhehf \ jmdZo m g__ i_jkbd HgZ ]ey^bl ijyfh gZ ajbl_ey \gbfZl_evgufb ]eZaZfb e_]dZy meu[dZ aZlZbeZkv \ m]hedZo jlZ
DZ`_lky [m^lh kZfZ xghklv \hiehs_gZ \ g_c b gZk ho\Zlu \Z_l hsms_gb_ g_h[udgh\_gghc ihwlbqghklb b k\_`_klb DhfgZlZ gZiheg_gZ \ha^mohf ijhgbaZgZ kheg_qguf k\_lhf evxsbfky ba hdgZ b hk\_sZxsbf ^_\hqdm : kdhevdh ij_e_klb \ djZkdZo jhah\Zy dhnlhqdZ q_jguc [Zgl kfm]eh_ ebph a_e_gv ^_j_\v_\ aZ hdghf Khk_^kl\h wlbo dZaZehkv [u kh\k_f jZaguo p\_lh\ g_ j_`_l ]eZa GZh[hjhl gZk jZ^m_l lh dZd ohjhrh b lhgdh hgb kh_^bgy xlky ^jm] k ^jm]hf GZ jhah\hc dhnlhqd_ e_`Zl ]hem[u_ b kbj_g_\u_ [ebdb B \ wlhf khq_lZgbb lZ `_ m^b\bl_evgZy ]Zjfhgbqghklv Om^h`gbd hq_gv bkdmkgh iheh`be gZ ihehlgh lZdb_ hll_gdb ]hem[h]h b jh ah\h]h dhlhju_ ij_djZkgh ^hihegyxl ^jm] ^jm]Z : dh]^Z \ dZj lbg_ \k_ p\_lZ kh]eZkh\Zgu beb dZd ]h\hjyl om^h`gbdb gZc^_ gu p\_lh\u_ hlghr_gby lh]^Z b \i_qZle_gb_ hl dZjlbgu [m^_l _^bguf < Š>_\hqd_ k i_jkbdZfbª \k_ k\_leh jZ^hklgh <k_ ]h\hjbl gZf h fheh^hklb h ihwabb h kqZklv_ `bagb ? DZf_g_\Z
IeZq_l ]^_ lh b\he]Z kohjhgykv \ ^mieh lhevdh fg_ g_ ieZq_lky ² gZ ^mr_ k\_leh K ?k_gbg <h]gmluf ihemdjm]hf klhbl ly`_eh_ fjZfhjgh_ a^Zgb_ \hdaZeZ jZkdb gm\ k\hb djuevy lhqgh `_eZy h[gylv ex^_c F =hjvdbc B gZ^ \k_f [ebklZxsbf IZjb`_f ^h`^v f_lZeky ]jb\m jZkimklb\ < Em]h\kdhc B e_]qZcrbc lmfZg ih[_`Ze hl j_db hibjZykv gZ au[db_ [_eu_ gh]b < Em]h\kdhc @m jZ\eb ^jm] ^jm]Z hdebdZy hklhjh`gh lygmlky ]mjv[hc B ;mgbg Kl_deygguc j_^dbc b y^j_guc k \_k_euf rh jhohf ki_rZ ijhfqZeky ^h`^v b e_k a_e_guc aZlbo ijhoeZ ^hx ^urZ B ;mgbg
Ly`_e h_ fjZfhjg h_ e_]qZcr bc au[d b_ [_e u_
kl_deygg uc j_^d bc y^j_g uc \_k_e uf a_e_g uc D ijb[j_`vx fhjy ^ebggZy Zee_y <_^_l \^Zeb dZd [m^lh g_[hkdehg LZf fhj_ ih^ufZ_lky kbg_y F_` ihaZ[uluo fjZfhjguo dhehgg !
<_q_jgyy [_afhe\gZy Zee_y Ah\_l f_gy d kdZebkluf [_j_]Zf =^_ fhj_ ih^ufZ_lky kbg_y D imklugguf b ^Ze_dbf g_[_kZf B ;mgbg
>ebgg Zy fjZfhjg Zy \_q_jg yy [_afhe\g Zy d kdZebkl uf d imklugg uf ^Ze_d bf
>ebggZy ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ :ee_y dZdZy" ^ebggZy IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² ^ebgguc DZq_kl\ ?^ q ` j B i :ee_y dZdZy" ^ebggZy FjZfhjguo ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ F_` dhehgg dZdbo" fjZfhjguo IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² fjZfhjguc Hlghkbl Fg q J i F_` dhehgg dZdbo" fjZfhjguo <_q_jgyy ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ :ee_y dZdZy" \_q_jgyy IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² \_q_jgbc Hlghkbl ?^ q ` j B i :ee_y dZdZy" \_q_jgyy ;_afhe\gZy ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ :ee_y dZdZy" [_a fhe\gZy IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² [_afhe\guc DZq_kl\ ?^ q ` j B i :ee_y dZdZy" [_afhe\gZy D kdZebkluf ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ D [_j_]Zf dZdbf" kdZebkluf IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² kdZebkluc Hlghkbl Fg q > i
D [_j_]Zf dZdbf" kdZebkluf
D imklugguf ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ D g_[_kZf dZdbf" imklugguf IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² imklugguc DZq_kl\ Fg q > i D g_[_kZf dZdbf" imklugguf >Ze_dbf ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ D g_[_kZf dZdbf" ^Ze_ dbf IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² ^Ze_dbc DZq_kl\ Fg q > i D g_[_kZf dZdbf" ^Ze_dbf � >QSœbw[Sœw`Mœm@ ² keh]Z >i@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >jœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >bw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >[@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >jœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >w@ ² ]eZkg m^ >`@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >MœO ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >m@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ Ijb[j_`vx ² [md\ >dZ][mlt@ � >d@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >Z@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >]@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >[@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >m@ ² ]eZkg m^ >l@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ DZd [m^lh ² [md\
� >Fœ bwgœwMœt@ ² keh]Z >kœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >bw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >gœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >w@ ² ]eZkg m^ >Mœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ Kbg_y ² [md\ ;Z[mrdZ
=h\hjbeZ hgZ dZd lh hkh[_ggh \ui_\Zy keh\Z b hgb e_]dh md j_ieyebkv \ iZfylb fh_c ihoh`b_ gZ p\_lu lZdb_ `_ eZkdh\u_ yjdb_ khqgu_ Dh]^Z hgZ meu[ZeZkv __ l_fgu_ dZd \brgb ajZqdb jZkrbjyebkv \kiuob\Zy g_\ujZabfh ijbylguf k\_lhf meu[dZ \_k_eh h[gZ`ZeZ [_eu_ dj_idb_ am[u b g_kfhljy gZ fgh`_kl\h fhjsbg \ l_fghc dh`_ s_d \k_ ebph dZaZehkv fheh ^uf b k\_leuf Hq_gv ihjlbe _]h wlhl juoeuc ghk k jZa^mlufb gha^jyfb b djZkguc gZ dhgp_ HgZ gxoZeZ lZ[Zd ba q_jghc lZ[Z d_jdb mdjZr_gghc k_j_[jhf <ky hgZ ² l_fgZy gh k\_lbeZkv bagmljb ² q_j_a ]eZaZ ² g_m]Zkbfuf \_k_euf b l_ieuf k\_ lhf HgZ kmlmeZy ihqlb ]hj[ZlZy hq_gv ihegZy Z ^\b]ZeZkv e_] dh b eh\dh lhqgh [hevrZy dhrdZ ² hgZ b fy]dZy lZdZy `_ dZd wlhl eZkdh\uc a\_jv >h g__ dZd [m^lh kiZe y kijylZgguc \ l_fghl_ gh y\beZkv hgZ jZa[m^beZ \u\_eZ gZ k\_l k\yaZeZ \k_ \hdjm] f_gy \ g_ij_ ju\gmx gblv kie_eZ \k_ \ jZaghp\_lgh_ djm`_\h b kjZam klZeZ gZ \kx `bagv ^jm]hf kZfuf [ebadbf k_j^pm fh_fm kZfuf ih gylguf b ^hjh]bf q_eh\_dhf ² wlh __ [_kdhjuklgZy ex[h\v d fbjm h[h]ZlbeZ f_gy gZkulb\ dj_idhc kbehc ^ey ljm^ghc `ba gb F =hjvdbc
H[gZ`Ze Z mdjZr_gg hc kijylZgg uc jZaghp\_lg h_ [_kdhjuklg Zy h[h]Zlbe Z
H[gZ`ZeZ ² ]eZ]he Meu[dZ qlh ^_eZeZ" h[gZ`ZeZ >_c kl\b_ G n ² h[gZ`Zlv G_kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q ijhr \j ` j Meu[dZ qlh ^_eZeZ" h[gZ`ZeZ MdjZr_gghc ² ijbqZklb_ LZ[Zd_jdb dZdhc" mdjZr_g ghc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx MdjZkblv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q ` j J i LZ[Zd_jdb dZdhc" mdjZr_gghc
KijylZgguc ² ijbqZklb_ Y dZdhc" kijylZgguc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx KijylZlv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j ?^ q f j B i Y dZdhc" kijylZgguc JZaghp\_lgh_ ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ Djm`_\h dZdh_" jZaghp\_lgh_ IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² jZaghp\_lguc DZq_kl\ ?^ q kj j < i Djm`_\h dZdh_" jZaghp\_lgh_ ;_kdhjuklgZy ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ Ex[h\v dZdZy" [_k dhjuklgZy IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² [_kdhjuklguc DZq_kl\ ?^ q ` j B i Ex[h\v dZdZy" [_kdhjuklgZy
H[h]ZlbeZ ² ]eZ]he Ex[h\v qlh k^_eZeZ" h[h]ZlbeZ >_ckl\b_ G n ² h[h]Zlblv Kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q ijhr \j ` j
Ex[h\v qlh k^_eZeZ" h[h]ZlbeZ Dmq_j fhc ke_a fheqZ lboh b g_ lhjhiykv f_^e_ggh : Imrdbg Yaudh\ aZdjue eZ^hgvx ebph b kb^_e g_ ^\b]Zykv g_ih^\b`gh : Lheklhc G_ kfhedZy g_mfheqgh [mrm_l f_l_ev aZ hdghf B ;mgbg Dhklbg g_ dhe_[eykv m\_j_ggh hlijZ\beky d ^\_jb I Ijhkdmjbg
QZku rbiy ^\_gZ^pZlv jZa ijh[beb \ khk_^g_c aZe_ l_fghc b imklhc B ;mgbg
: kZ^ kl_ighc ]emohc b^_l l_fg_y \ kmfjZd e_lg_c ghqb ih kdZlm d [Zed_ B ;mgbg
;eZ]hmoZy khoeb ljZ\u ^ufykv dmjbebkv h[eZdZ B ;m gbg
Ihklhy\ Khehfbg b <_jZ mreb : G Lheklhc
>h\hevgu_ iZkkZ`bju ijbfhedgm\ ex[h\Zebkv kheg_q guf ^g_f D N_^bg
Hl\_jgm\rbkv hg klZe kfhlj_lv gZ kljhb\rmxky dhehg gm D Kbfhgh\
K_j]_c hlkljZgbe <_jm db\gme _c b mr_e ihk\bklu\Zy : G Lheklhc
LZf \ l_fghl_ qvb lh ]eZaZ kfhlj_eb g_ fb]Zy : G Lhe klhc
Ebey kb^_eZ g_ ^\b]Zykv : G Lheklhc
Ebkl\Z [_j_a \bkbl g_ r_ehogm\rbkv jhkZ kl_dZ_l ih [_ euf kl\heZf D IZmklh\kdbc
>\_gZ^pZlv ² bfy qbkebl_evgh_ Kdhevdh" ^\_gZ^pZlv jZa Dhebq_kl\h G n ² ^\_gZ^pZlv Ijhkl dhebq p_eh_ < i Ijh[beb kdhevdh" ^\_gZ^pZlv jZa ?c ² f_klhbf_gb_ Db\gme dhfm" _c G n ² hgZ Ebqg e ?^ q ` j > i Db\gme dhfm" _c
E_lg_c ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ Ghqb dZdhc" e_lg_c Ijb agZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² e_lgbc Hlghkbl ?^ q ` j J i Ghqb dZdhc" e_lg_c
K_j]_c ² bfy kms_kl\bl_evgh_ HlkljZgbe dlh" K_j]_c Ij_^f_l G n ² K_j]_c Kh[kl\ h^mr f j kde ?^ q B i HlkljZgbe dlh" K_j]_c Ih^t_oZ\ d ]hkih^kdhfm ^hfm hg m\b^_e [_eh_ ieZlv_ f_evdZ\r__ f_`^m ^_j_\vyfb kZ^Z < wlh \j_fy :glhg m^Zjbe ih ehrZ^b b ih\bgmykv q_klhex[bx h[s_fm b ^_j_\_gkdbf dmq_ jZf dZd b ba\haqbdZf imklbeky \h \_kv ^mo q_j_a fhkl b fbfh k_eZ <u_oZ\ ba ^_j_\gb ih^gyebkv hgb gZ ]hjm b <eZ^bfbj m\b^_e [_j_ah\mx jhsm b \e_\h gZ hldjulhf f_kl_ k_j_gvdbc ^hfbd k djZkghx djh\e_x k_j^p_ \ g_f aZ[behkv i_j_^ kh[hx \b^_e hg Dbkl_g_\dm b [_^guc ^hf k\h_]h hlpZ Q_j_a ^_kylv fbgml \t_oZe hg gZ [Zjkdbc ^\hj Kh[Zdb [ueh aZeZyeb gh ma gZ\ :glhgZ mfhedeb b aZfZoZeb dhkfZlufb o\hklZfb : Imrdbg
Ih^t_oZ\ f_evdZ\r __ ih\bgmykv \u_oZ\ magZ\ � >iZ^Mœwotn@ ² keh]Z >i@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >Z ² ]eZkg [_am^ >^@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >Mœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >w@ ² ]eZkg m^ >o@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >n@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdh\ Ih^t_oZ\ ² [md\
� >fœbweœdZnruMœv@ ² keh]Z >fœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >bw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >eœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >d@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >D@ ² ]eZkg m^ >n@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >r@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >u@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >Mœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ F_evdZ\r__ ² [md\ � >it\œbg\Mœvkœ@ ² keh]Z >i@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >\œ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >b@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >m@ ² ]eZkg m^ >Mœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >kœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d a\mdh\ Ih\bgmykv ² [md\ � >\ubotn@ ² keh]Z >\@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >u@ ² ]eZkg m^ >b@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >o@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >n@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdh\ <u_oZ\ ² [md\
>magZn@ ² keh]Z � ]eZkg [_am^ >m@ ² >a@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >Z@ ² ]eZkg m^ >n@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdh\ MagZ\ ² [md\ >gb klhyeb ^ebggu_ klZjmob mki_\Zeb \k_ b mklZ\ eh`bebkv ihke_ h[_^Z hl^hogmlv gh g_ aZkuiZeb Z jZa]h\Zjb\Z eb e_`Z < JZkimlbg GhqZfb e_`Z \ ihkl_eb KZf]bg meu [Zeky ^mfZy h lhf dZd [ukljh b ijhklh hg ijb\e_d kbfiZlbb d k_[_ F =hjvdbc
B ^_gv b ghqv ih kg_]h\hc imklug_ ki_rm d \Zf ]heh \m kehfy > =jb[h_^h\ Hg agZe qlh [jhkZ_lky hq_jly ]heh\m \ hfml dm^Z b aZ]ey^u\Zlv g_ ke_^h\Zeh B Lmj]_g_\ < ljm^ gu_ ^gb hg jZ[hlZe k gZfb jmd g_ ihdeZ^Zy = GbdheZ_\Z G_ lhjhiykv DZly hldjueZ rdZnqbd B\Zgq_gdh ij_^klZ\eyeky _fm q_eh\_dhf dhlhjuc ^_ckl\m_l hq_jly ]heh\m EhrZ^b fhlZy ]heh\Zfb mgueh [j_eb ^Zevr_ Mdhjyeb gZk aZ lh qlh jZ[hlZeb fu kimkly jmdZ\Z Ijbgy\ j_r_gb_ gm`gh klZjZlvky _]h \uihegylv Hg [ue g_h[uqZcgh \a\hegh\Zg f_lZeky ih dhfgZl_ g_ ihfgy k_[y Km^y ih \k_fm abfZ \ wlhf ]h^m [m ^_l jZggyy Kimklb\rbkv ih e_klgbp_ <ZgxrZ g_fgh]h ih klhye m ^\_jb Z aZl_f j_rbl_evgh \ur_e ba ih^t_a^Z Mkh\ [ue g_ lhl q_eh\_d dhlhjuc iha\hebe [u kb^_lv keh`Z jmdb GbdbldZ kemrZe jZkkdZau ^_^mrdb jZkdju\ jhl HgZ kemrZeZ _]h aZlZb\ ^uoZgb_ >_lb kemrZeb g_[uebpu klZjbdZ jZa\_kb\ mrb :e_dk_c [_`Ze d ih_a^m kehfy ]heh\m Ih^ dhg_p ^bklZgpbb hg [_`Ze \ukmgm\ yaud :ggZ [_`ZeZ gZ \hdaZe g_ ihfgy k_[y Klm^_glu jZ[hlZeb kimkly jmdZ\Z Hgb jZ[hlZeb g_ i_j_\h^y ^mo
EZjZ jZ[hlZeZ g_ ihdeZ^Zy jmd b [ueZ kqZkleb\Z ; IZkl_jgZd
Hg ]hlh\ jZ[hlZlv aZkmqb\ jmdZ\Z G_kfhljy gZ ^h`^v [eZ]h^Zjy ohjhr_c ih]h^_ \hij_db _]h mdZaZgbyf kh]eZkgh _]h ijbdZam \ kbem fgh]bo h[klhy l_evkl\ ijb gZebqbb hij_^_e_gguo mkeh\bc \\b^m g_^hklZldZ \j_f_gb \ke_^kl\b_ wlh]h kh[ulby G_kfhljy gZ ^h`^v j_[ylZ hlijZ\bebkv \ ihoh^ ;eZ]h^Zjy ohjhr_c ih]h^_ gZkljh_gb_ m \k_o [ueh ijbih^ gylh_ Hgb klZeb \hij_db _]h mdZaZgbyf jZa]jm`Zlv \Z]hgu Hgb klZeb kh]eZkgh _]h ijbdZam jZa]jm`Zlv \Z]hgu ?fm ijbrehkv \ kbem fgh]bo h[klhyl_evkl\ \_jgmlvky ^h fhc >Z`_ abfhc ijb gZebqbb hij_^_e_gguo mkeh\bc fh`gh lj_gbjh\Zlvky <\b^m g_^hklZldZ \j_f_gb gZ^h jZ[hlZlv g_ ihdeZ^Zy jmd <ke_^kl\b_ wlh]h kh[ulby hg g_ fh] [hevr_ k g_c \b^_lv ky Z k h[hkh[e h[klhyl_evkl\Zfb \ujZ`_ggufb h^bghq gufb ^__ijbqZklbyfb GZ_a^gbdb jZkk_ykv lhlqZk mkdZdZeb ba \b^m b kl_iv himk l_eZ F_` l_f ihf_jdgm\ kl_iv mkgmeZ KZ\_ebq ^j_fey dZ qZeky gZ h[emqd_ [ k h[hkh[e ^__ijbqZklgufb h[hjhlZfb <hl k_\_j lmqb gZ]hgyy ^hogme aZ\ue b \hl kZfZ b^_l \he r_[gbpZ abfZ >jh[ykv h fjZqgu_ kdZeu rmfyl b i_gylky \Zeu <klZ\Zy k i_j\ufb emqZfb l_i_jv hgZ \ ihey ki_rbl b mfbe_g gufb hqZfb bo habjZy ]h\hjbl ŠIjhklbl_ fbjgu_ ^hebguª Hj_e k hl^Ze_gghc ih^gy\rbkv \_jrbgu iZjbl g_ih^\b`gh kh fghc gZjZ\g_ >h`^v ebe jh\gh b h^ghh[jZagh rmfy ih ljZ\_ b ^_j_\vyf B g_ imkdZy lvfm ghqgmx gZ ahehlu_ g_[_kZ h^gZ aZjy kf_gblv ^jm]mx ki_rbl ^Z\ ghqb iheqZkZ <ha\jZlykv kh ikZj gh]h ^\hjZ DbjbeZ I_ljh\bq k_e m`bgZlv \ k h[hkh[e h[klhyl_evkl\Zfb \ujZ`_ggufb kms_kl\bl_evgufb k ij_^eh]Zfb
KZ\_evbq kh]eZkgh k fg_gb_f yfsbdZ kh\_lh\Ze \hjhlblvky >h[juc dhf_g^Zgl k kh]eZkby k\h_c kmijm]b j_rbe hk\h[h^blv R\Z[jbgZ MkdZdZe b himkl_e Z i_g yl ky gZ]hgyy ^jh[ykv rmfy Fh_]h ijbly` gZf ebqg \k_o hij_^ gbdZdbo hl jbp hg ebqg y ebqg k\hx ijbly` bf ebqg \ k\hx ijbly` hl \k_o hij_^ gbq_]h hljbp _]h ijbly` \k_fm hij_^ k gbf ebqg \k_ hij_^ hgZ ebqg Ij_^kdZaZgb yf ijhykgbe Z kv fZehe_lkl\ Z klheyjg hfm
kh[_k_^gbd Z klZjbgg hc <hegu g_kmlky ]j_fy b k\_jdZy qm`^u_ a\_a^u ]ey
^yl k \ukhlu N Lxlq_\ Rmfy b djm`Zkv dhe_[ZeZ j_dZ
hljZ`_ggu_ \ g_c h[eZdZ F E_jfhglh\ <^jm] hgZ ijh[_
`ZeZ fbfh f_gy gZi_\Zy qlh lh ^jm]h_ b ijbs_edb\Zy iZev pZfb \[_`ZeZ d klZjmo_ F E_jfhglh\ Iv_j kemrZe __ k
jZkdjuluf jlhf b g_ kimkdZy k g__ k\hbo ]eZa iheguo ke_aZfb E Lheklhc E_[_^v djZkb\h ih^ieue \ur_e gZ [_j_]
\kljyogmeky b ly`_eh i_j_\Zeb\Zykv gZ k\hbo djb\uo q_jguo gh]Zo gZijZ\beky d ba[mrd_ > FZfbg Kb[bjyd
<hl y \b`m k_[y kgh\Z \ ^_j_\g_ ]em[hdhc hk_gvx >gb klhyl kbg_\Zlu_ iZkfmjgu_ Mljhf y kZ`mkv \ k_^eh b k h^ghc kh[Zdhc k jm`v_f b k jh]hf m_a`Zx \ ihe_ <_l_j a\_gbl b ]m^bl \ ^meh jm`vy \_l_j dj_idh ^m_l gZ\klj_qm bgh]^Z k kmobf kg_ ]hf P_euc ^_gv y kdblZxkv ih imkluf jZ\gbgZf ! =heh^guc b ijhay[rbc \ha\jZsZxkv y d kmf_jdZf \ mkZ^v [m b gZ ^mr_ klZgh\blky lZd l_ieh b hljZ^gh dh]^Z aZf_evdZ xl h]hgvdb <uk_ehd b ihlyg_l ba mkZ^v[u aZiZohf ^ufZ `bevy Ihfgx m gZk \ ^hf_ ex[beb \ wlm ihjm Škmf_jgbqZlvª g_ aZ `b]Zlv h]gy b \_klb \ iheml_fghl_ [_k_^u <hc^y \ ^hf y gZ oh`m abfgb_ jZfu m`_ \klZ\e_ggufb b wlh _s_ [he__ gZ kljZb\Z_l f_gy gZ fbjguc abfgbc eZ^ < eZd_ckdhc jZ[hlgbd lhibl i_qdm b y dZd \ ^_lkl\_ kZ`mkv gZ dhjlhqdb hdheh \hjh oZ khehfu j_adh iZogms_c m`_ abfg_c k\_`_klvx b ]ey`m lh
\ iueZxsmx i_qdm lh gZ hdgZ aZ dhlhjufb kbg_y ]jmklgh mfbjZxl kmf_jdb B ;mgbg
E_lhf \ dhgp_ Z\]mklZ ohjhrh \b^gh a\_a^u Fu \klj_lbfky k_]h^gy \ iylv qZkh\ \_q_jZ GZ mebp_ \hae_ gZr_ ]h ih^t_a^Z jZa[beb ]Zahg Hg klhye gZ kdZe_ m kZfh]h djZy h[ju\Z GZ ijhk_d_ f_ljZo \ ljb^pZlb hl gZk \_ebqZ\h klhye ehkv Nml[hevguc fZlq f_`^m rdheZfb khklhblky aZ\ljZ ihke_ mjhdh\ E_k djZkb\ \h \k_ \j_f_gZ ]h^Z hkh[_ggh abfhc ;_ ]_fhl lh _klv ]biihihlZf `b\_l lhevdh \ :njbd_ Hgb jZ[h lZeb hq_gv ^he]h ^h kZfh]h \_q_jZ <k_ ^Z`_ jh^bl_eb ijb kmlkl\h\Zeb gZ ijZa^gbd_ G_dhlhju_ mq_gbdb gZijbf_j B\Zgh\ b Kb^hjh\ g_ ijhreb ljm^h\mx ijZdlbdm <k_ djhf_ f_gy gZibkZeb ^bdlZgl ohjhrh <k_ aZ bkdexq_gb_f iylb mq_gbdh\ [m^ml k^Z\Zlv wdaZf_gu Y \uihegbe \k_ ^hfZrg__ aZ^Zgb_ ihfbfh wlbo mijZ`g_gbc Kbg_xs _c kimkdZ\r _f ky ih^klmiZ\r bo Kbg_xs_c ² ijbqZklb_ < jhs_ dZdhc" kbg_xs_c Ijb agZd ijb^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Kbg_lv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \ gZkl \j ?^ q ` j I i < jhs_ dZdhc" kbg_xs_c KimkdZ\r_fky ² ijbqZklb_ < h\jZ]_ dZdhf" kimkdZ\ r_fky IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx KimkdZlvky >_ckl\ \ha\j g_kh\ \ ijhr \j ?^ q f j I i < h\jZ]_ dZdhf" kimkdZ\r_fky
Ih^klmiZ\rbo ² ijbqZklb_ Kj_^b oe_[h\ dZdbo" ih^ klmiZ\rbo IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx Ih^klmiZlv >_ckl\ g_\ha\j g_kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Fg q J i Kj_^b oe_[h\ dZdbo" ih^klmiZ\rbo
� � Qm\klm_lky ² >qœmkl\mvpt@ jZkk_yebkv ² >SDFœwveœbkœ@ g_ba � � \_klguo ² >gœvba\œwFgu[@ ^_lkl\h ² >^œwpl\t@ Wlbd_l ² mklZgh\e_gguc ihjy^hd b ijZ\beZ ih\_^_ gby ² Y klZjZxkv kh[ex^Zlv wlbd_l lh _klv mklZgh\e_gguc ih jy^hd b ijZ\beZ ih\_^_gby Hilbfbaf ² fbjh\hkijbylb_ ijhgbdgmlh_ \_jhc \ emqr__ [m^ms__ ² Hilbfbaf lh _klv fb jh\hkijbylb_ ijhgbdgmlh_ \_jhc \ emqr__ [m^ms__ k\hckl\_ g_g ^Ze_dh g_ \k_f :ll_klZl ² hnbpbZevguc ^hdmf_gl h[ hdhgqZgbb mq_[gh]h aZ\_^_gby ² < wlhf ]h^m y ihemqm Zll_klZl lh _klv ^hdmf_gl h[ hdhgqZgbb mq_[gh]h aZ\_^_gby Y ex[ex Jhkkbx ^h [heb k_j^_qghc b ^Z`_ g_ fh]m ih fukeblv k_[y ]^_ eb[h djhf_ Jhkkbb F KZeludh\ S_^jbg
Fgh]h _klv gZ k\_l_ djhf_ gZr_c kljZgu \kydbo ]hkm^Zjkl\ b a_ f_ev gh h^gZ m q_eh\_dZ fZlv h^gZ m g_]h b Jh^bgZ D Mrbgkdbc
<a^uoZxs __ h[ebl hc kdju\Zxs bo baj_aZgg hfm \hkdj_rZ_f uo Fu _oZeb [_j_]hf E_gu gZ x] Z abfZ ^h]hgyeZ gZk k k_ \_jZ H^gZdh fh]eh ihdZaZlvky qlh hgZ b^_l gZf gZ\klj_qm kimkdZykv k\_jom ih l_q_gbx j_db < k_gly[j_ ih^ Ydmlkdhf [ueh _s_ ^h\hevgh l_ieh gZ j_d_
_s_ g_ [ueh \b^gh gb ev^bgdb GZ h^ghc ba [ebadbo klZgpbc fu ^Z`_ kh[eZagbebkv qm^_kghx emgghx ghqvx b qlh[u g_ ghq_\Zlv \ ^mrghc xjl_ klZghqgbdZ lhevdh qlh kfZaZgghc kgZjm`b gZ ab
fm _s_ l_ieuf gZ\hahf ² e_]eb gZ [_j_]m mkljhb\ k_[_ ihkl_eb \ eh^dZo b mdju\rbkv he_gvbfb rdmjZfb Ghqvx fg_ ihdZaZ
ehkv h^gZdh qlh dlh lh ``_l fg_ ieZf_g_f ijZ\mx s_dm Y ijh
kgmeky b m\b^_e qlh emggZy ghqv _s_ [he__ ih[_e_eZ Djm]hf
klhye bg_c bg_c ihdjue fhx ih^mrdm b wlh _]h ijbdhkgh\_gb_ dZaZehkv fg_ lZdbf ]hjyqbf Fh_fm lh\Zjbsm kiZ\r_fm h^ghc \\ ke
eh^d_ kh fghx kgbehkv \_jhylgh lh `_ kZfh_ EmgZ k\_lbeZ _fm
ijyfh \ ebph b y \b^_e m`Zkgu_ ]jbfZku ihy\ey\rb_ky gZ g_f \\ ke
lh b ^_eh Khg _]h [ue dj_ihd b \_jhylgh hq_gv fmqbl_e_g < wlh
\j_fy \ khk_^g_c eh^d_ \klZe ^jm]hc fhc kimlgbd ijbih^gy\ ^h ob b rdmju dhlhjufb hg [ue ihdjul <k_ [ueh [_eh b imrbklh
hl bafhjhab \_kv hg dZaZeky [_euf ijb\b^_gb_f \g_aZigh \ha gbdrbf ba oheh^gh]h [e_kdZ bg_y b emggh]h k\_lZ h[j
Š;jj ² kdZaZe hg ² Fhjha [jZlpuª < Dhjhe_gdh
� >FœfœbwMœZeœbkœ@ ² keh]Z >kœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >fœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >bw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >Mœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >Z@ ² ]eZkg m^ >eœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >b@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >kœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d a\mdh\ Kf_yebkv ² [md\
Ijh\h^be j_rZe ky m[_]Zy hldbgm\rbkv [ZxdZxs _c
h[b`_gg Zy Gh [hevr_ \k_]h \ fhbo jZkkdZaZo mqZkl\h\ZeZ j_dZ
\\ k k
\\ k k
Fh`_l [ulv ihlhfm qlh klhyeb e_lgb_ `Zjdb_ ^gb fh`_l [ulv
ijhklh ihlhfm qlh y [hevr_ \k_]h ex[ex j_db Lboh_ a_jdZeh hfmlZ dhlhjh_ jZa[b\Z_rv \^j_[_a]b iju]gm\ \gba ]heh\hc k
ljZ\ygbklh]h eZkdh\h]h [_j_`dZ ojmklZevgZy \eZ]Z dhlhjZy kljmblky \^hev l_eZ hfu\Zy b hoeZ`^Zy dZ`^mx de_lhqdm dh
`b ju[bc \kie_kd gZ \_q_jg_c aZj_ lmfZgu jZkiheaZxsb_ky hl j_db gZ ijb[j_`gu_ em]Z ijygu_ aZiZob \ aZjhkeyo djZib\u lZ\he]b b fylu dh]^Z mkljhbrvky \ mdjhfghf m]hed_ <k_ b ih^emggu_ ohefu b l_fgh djZkgu_ de_\_jgu_ ihey b \eZ`gu_ e_kgu_ ljhibgdb b aZdZlgh_ iurgh_ g_[h ² \_kv hdjm`Zxsbc f_gy fbj dZaZeky fg_ ij_djZkguf b g_ [ueh gb dZdh]h batygZ \ g_f L_i_jv dh]^Z \^Zeb hl g_]h y \^hogh\_ggh jZkkdZau\Ze b \hklhj`_ggh `b\hibkZe hg dZaZeky fg_ _s_ ij_
djZkg__ _s_ kdZahqg__ Hg dZaZeky fg_ ij_djZkguf ^h keZ^dh]h aZfbjZgby \ ]jm^b JZkk\_lgu_ lmfZgu fg_ \b^_ebkv h[yaZl_ev gh jhah\ufb ieZ\Zxsb_ kj_^b \h^hjhke_c ju[db ij_^klZ\ eyebkv h[yaZl_evgh ahehlufb k djZkgufb i_jvyfb jhkZ gZ ljZ \Zo ² lh djmiguc `_fqm] lh [jbeebZglu < Khehmobg
LjZ\ygbkl h]h Ih^emgg u_
<hklhj`_ggh
ljZ\yg hc
emg Z
ljZ\ Z
\hklhj`_gg uc
\hklhj] Zlv
Iju]gm\ ² ^__ijbqZklb_ Iju]gmlv >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_ckl\b_ Kh\ \b^ JZa[b\Z_rv dh]^Z" iju]gm\
JZkiheaZxsb_ky ² ijbqZklb_ LmfZgu dZdb_" jZkihe aZxsb_ky IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx JZkiheaZlvky >_ckl\ \ha\j g_kh\ \b^ gZkl \j Fg q B i LmfZgu dZdb_" jZkiheaZxsb_ky Kfhljbl_ev h[ty\be qlh ehrZ^b ijbkeZggu_ ba Dbk l_g_\db h`b^Zeb _]h m`_ q_l\_jlu_ kmldb : Imrdbg KdZ `b dhgxom qlh[u g_ ^Z\Ze h\kZ ehrZ^yf _]h G =h]hev <^jm] ]h\hjyl fg_ ŠQ_eh\_d \Zk kijZrb\Z_lª B Lmj]_g_\ ŠDm^Z `_ \u"ª ² m`Zkgmeky KlZjp_\ dh]^Z hgZ \^jm] \klZeZ b ihreZ d ^hfm : Q_oh\ Y kijhkbe gZr_]h ijh\h`Zlh]h dlh a^_kv eh\bl kh[he_c < :jk_gv_\ DhjZ[_evsbdb \ hl\_l ŠFu h[t_oZeb \_kv k\_l ª : Imrdbg
Fheh^uo ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ Ebklv_\ dZdbo" fheh^uo IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² fheh^hc DZq_kl\ Fg q J i Ebklv_\ dZdbo" fheh^uo
H^bghdbc ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ >jm] dZdhc" h^bghdbc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ
G n ² h^bghdbc DZq_kl\ ?^ q f j B i >jm] dZdhc" h^bghdbc < ij_^eh`_gbb \oh^bl \ khklZ\ jZkijhkljZg_ggh]h h[jZs_gby dhlhjh_ g_ y\ey_lky qe_ghf ij_^eh`_gby Š<hl gZ wlhf f_kl_ ² kdZaZe Gha^j_\ ² jmkZdh\ lZ dZy ]b[_ev qlh a_feb g_ \b^ghª G =h]hev ŠFZfZ ² kdZaZe Fbly ² ^Z\Zc y iZoZlv [m^m fg_ ihjZ ª : IeZlhgh\ Š>Z ^_lb ² \a^hogme i_ohlbg_p ² Hgb ih ^jm]hfm d `bagb ijb \yau\Zxlª = ;ZdeZgh\ ŠG_l lu kfhljb ² ihjZ`Zeky :g^ j_c ² Dh]^Z hgb jh^bebkv" Dh]^Z hgb \k_ \ujZklb mki_eb"ª = ;ZdeZgh\ ŠDZd \Zf ihdZaZeky ]hjh^" ² ijhfhe\beZ FZ gbeh\Z ² Ijbylgh eb ijh\_eb lZf \j_fy"ª G =h]hev ŠL_ i_jv ² ih^mfZe y ² ljhibgdZ dm^Z gb[m^v ijb\_^_lª < :j k_gv_\ ŠIhoheh^Zeh DZl_jbgZ I_ljh\gZ ² [h^jh kdZaZe Lbohg b k [_kihdhckl\hf ihkfhlj_e gZ k\hx rZidm ² Kg_] kdhjh \uiZ^_l Hgh b d emqr_fm ª F Rhehoh\ Š$[ i_j_ klZgvl_ IZ\_e Ydh\e_\bq ² \hajZabeZ g_ [_a ^hkZ^u ^_\mrdZ ² hlq_]h \u gbdh]^Z g_ ]h\hjbl_ kh fghc k_jv_agh"ª B Lmj]_ g_\
ŠI ² Z ² iª ŠI ² Z ² i ª ŠI ² Z ² Iª ŠI ² Z ² I" I"ª ŠI" ² Z ² I"ª ŠI ² Z ² iª ŠI ² Z ² I I ª ŠI ² Z ² i"ª ŠG_ ibr_rv eb lu klboh\"ª ² \^jm] kijhkbe I_lj B\Zgh\bq B =hgqZjh\ ŠDZd wlh kljZggh ² ^mfZ_l <_jhqdZ ² \_^v y kZfZ \k_ wlh i_j_^mfZeZ i_j_qm\kl\h\ZeZ qlh hg ]h\h jbl b h [_^guo b h `_gsbgZoª G Q_jgur_\kdbc H]ey^_\ \gbfZl_evgh gh\bqdZ k gh] ^h ]heh\u hg [mjdgme ŠNZfbeby"ª : Dmijbg ŠGm ² kdZaZe y k jZ^hklvx ² [ebadh ghqe_]ª < Dhjhe_gdh Š: lu f_gy <Zky g_ im]Zc ª ² jZ\gh^mrgh
ihijhkbeZ hgZ F =hjvdbc ŠM`_ \_q_j" ² kijhkbeZ hgZ k g_^hmf_gb_f ² IjZ\^Z l_fgh Gh \_^v \_kv ^_gv [ueh l_fgh dZd ghqvx Dhlhjuc qZk"ª =h\hjbl bf dgyav lh]^Z Š>h[juc imlv \Zf ]hkih^Zª : Imrdbg Š>_eZcl_ qlh ohlbl_ ² hl \_qZe bf kmoh >m[jh\kdbc ² y m`_ a^_kv g_ ohaybgª ŠG_^Z jhf gZ g_f wlZ dhevqm]Z ² ih^mfZe y ² m` hg \_jgh qlh gb[m^v aZfurey_lª F E_jfhglh\ ŠAZq_f \u ih\yaZgu ieZldhf"ª ² kijhkbe y <eZ^bfbjZ B Lmj]_g_\ ŠH^gZ`^u ijboh^be dh fg_ wlhl RmjdZ ² kdZaZe ^bj_dlhj ² IhgjZ\beky fg_ iZj_g_d mfguc kZfhklhyl_evgucª : Yrbg
>mfZ_l ² ]eZ]he <_jhqdZ qlh ^_eZ_l" ^mfZ_l >_ckl\b_ G n ² ^mfZlv G_kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q gZkl \j e <_jhqdZ qlh ^_eZ_l" ^mfZ_l
Ijboh^be ² ]eZ]he RmjdZ qlh ^_eZe" ijboh^be >_ckl \b_ G n ² ijboh^blv G_kh\ \b^ g_\ha\j g_i_j_o kij Baty\ gZde _^ q ijhr \j f j RmjdZ qlh ^_eZe" ijboh^be
>h[juc ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ Imlv dZdhc" ^h[juc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² ^h[juc DZq_kl\ ?^ q f j < i Imlv dZdhc" ^h[juc Mfguc ² bfy ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ IZj_g_d dZdhc" mfguc IjbagZd ij_^f_lZ G n ² mfguc DZq_kl\ ?^ q f j B i IZj_g_d dZdhc" mfguc ŠGZf ijb^_lky a^_kv ghq_\Zlv \ lZdmx f_l_ev q_j_a ]hju g_ i_j__^_rv ª ² kdZaZe FZdkbf FZdkbfuq FZdkbf FZd
kbfuq kdZaZe ŠGZf ijb^_lky a^_kv ghq_\Zlv \ lZdmx f_l_ev q_ j_a ]hju g_ i_j__^_rvª ŠGZf ijb^_lky a^_kv ghq_\Zlv ² kdZ aZe FZdkbf FZdkbfuq ² \ lZdmx f_l_ev q_j_a ]hju g_ i_j_ _^_rvª Djueh\ aZj_\_e ŠGbq_]h \u g_ mfj_l_ b g_ ^mfZcl_ K_c qZk y \Zk e_qblv [m^mª ŠGbq_]h \u g_ mfj_l_ b g_ ^mfZcl_ K_cqZk y \Zk e_qblv [m^m ª ² aZj_\_e Djueh\ ŠGbq_]h \u g_ mfj_l_ b g_ ^mfZcl_ aZj_\_e Djueh\ ² K_cqZk y \Zk e_qblv [m ^mª IZ\dZ kdZaZe j_adh ŠLu ihlbr_ g_ gZe_lZc Z lh h[h` `_rvkyª ŠLu ihlbr_ g_ gZe_lZc Z lh h[h``_rvky ª ² j_adh kdZaZe IZ\dZ ŠLu ihlbr_ ² j_adh kdZaZe IZ\dZ ² g_ gZe_lZc Z lh h[h``_rvkyª G_ h^bg jZa hl_p ]h\hjbe Š@Zedh qlh k gZfb g_l jm `vyª Š@Zedh qlh k gZfb g_l jm`vy ª ² g_ h^bg jZa ]h\hjbe hl_p Š@Zedh ² g_ h^bg jZa ]h\hjbe hl_p ² qlh k gZfb g_l jm`vyª ŠGm l_i_jv fu k lh[hc gZ ijbiZk ^h[ueb ª ² h[tykgbe klZjbd kh[Zd_ KlZjbd h[tykgbe kh[Zd_ ŠGm l_i_jv fu k lh[hc gZ ijbiZk ^h[uebª ŠGm ² h[tykgbe klZjbd kh[Zd_ ² l_i_jv fu k lh[hc gZ ijbiZk ^h[uebª Mey kdZaZeZ ŠDZd ohjhrh fh]eb [u `blv \k_ ex^b gZ k\_l_ _keb [u hgb lhevdh aZohl_eb _keb [u hgb lhevdh ihgb fZeb ª ŠDZd ohjhrh fh]eb [u `blv \k_ ex^b gZ k\_l_ _keb [u hgb lhevdh aZohl_eb _keb [u hgb lhevdh ihgbfZeb ª ² kdZaZeZ Mey ŠDZd ohjhrh fh]eb [u `blv \k_ ex^b gZ k\_l_ ² kdZaZeZ Mey ² _keb [u hgb lhevdh aZohl_eb _keb [u hgb lhevdh ihgb fZeb ª ŠLu ]eygv dZ \hl dZd jZag_keh ª ² kdZaZe Pu]Zghd ijb ih^gy\ jmdZ\ ihdZau\Zy fg_ ]hemx jmdm ^h ehdly \ djZkguo jm[pZo Ijbih^gy\ jmdZ\ ihdZau\Zy fg_ ]hemx jmdm ^h ehdly \ djZkguo jm[pZo Pu]Zghd kdZaZe ŠLu ]eygv dZ \hl dZd jZag_k eh ª ŠLu ]eygv dZ ² kdZaZe Pu]Zghd ijbih^gy\ jmdZ\ ihdZau \Zy fg_ ]hemx jmdm ^h ehdly \ djZkguo jm[pZo ² \hl dZd jZa g_keh ª G_kqZklguc klZjbd ih\lhjye p_emy f_jl\h]h ^jm]Z ŠFma ]Zjdh Fma]Zjdh Qlh y l_i_jv ^_eZlv [m^m [_a l_[y"ª ŠFma]Zj
dh Fma]Zjdh Qlh y l_i_jv ^_eZlv [m^m [_a l_[y"ª ² ih\lhjye g_kqZklguc klZjbd p_emy f_jl\h]h ^jm]Z ŠFma]Zjdh Fma]Zj dh ² ih\lhjye g_kqZklguc klZjbd p_emy f_jl\h]h ^jm]Z ² Qlh y l_i_jv ^_eZlv [m^m [_a l_[y"ª ŠIha\hevl_ ² aZf_lbe h^bg kd_ilbd ² g_ hl ebfhgZ eb wlhl ysbd"ª H^bg kd_ilbd aZf_lbe ŠIha\hevl_ g_ hl ebfhgZ eb wlhl ysbd"ª ŠIha\hevl_ g_ hl ebfhgZ eb wlhl ysbd"ª ² aZf_ lbe h^bg kd_ilbd ŠY fh]m qblZlv ² aZ]h\hjbe I_ljmkv ² b kdhjh \umqmkv ibkZlv i_jhfª I_ljmkv aZ]h\hjbe ŠY fh]m qblZlv b kdhjh \u mqmkv ibkZlv i_jhfª ŠY fh]m qblZlv b kdhjh \umqmkv ibkZlv i_ jhf ª ² aZ]h\hjbe I_ljmkv � >kœbwqœZk@ ² keh]Z >kœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >bw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >qœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >Z@ ² ]eZkg m^ >k@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdh\ K_cqZk ² [md\ >t[Z`œhrkœv@ ² keh]Z
>t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >[@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >Z@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >`œ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >h@ ² ]eZkg m^ >r@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >kœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ H[h``_rvky ² [md\ ² Y y y ih_^m k \Zfb ² \kdjbdgme I_ly ² Kh\k_f l_[_ g_ gm`gh _a^blv ² kdZaZe >_gbkh\ h[jZsZ ykv d >hehoh\m ² Z m` _]h y gb aZ qlh g_ imsm ² <hl ij_djZkgh ² \kdjbdgme I_ly ² Hlq_]h `_ fg_ g_ _oZlv"
² >Z hllh]h qlh g_aZq_f ² Gm m` \u f_gy ba\bgbl_ ihlhfm qlh ihlhfm qlh y ih_^m \hl b \k_ <u \havf_l_ f_gy ² h[jZlbeky hg d >hehoh \m ² Hlq_]h ` ² jZkk_yggh hl\_qZe >hehoh\ \]ey^u\Zykv \ ebph njZgpmakdh]h [ZjZ[ZgsbdZ ² >Z\gh m l_[y fheh^qbd wlhl" ² kijhkbe hg m >_gbkh\Z ² Gugq_ \ayeb ^Z gbq_]h g_ agZ_l Y hklZ\be _]h ijb k_[_ E Lheklhc
Y g_ klZe jZkkijZrb\Zlv fh_]h \_jgh]h kimlgbdZ aZ q_f hg g_ ^h\_a f_gy ijyfh \ l_ f_klZ B Lmj]_g_\ DZjZkv ]h\hjbe qlh fh`gh gZ k\_l_ h^ghx ijZ\^hx ijh`blv Z _jr ml\_j`^Ze qlh g_evay [_a lh]h h[hclbkv qlh[ g_ kemdZ\blv F KZeludh\ @_^jbg H^gb ]h\hjbeb [m^lh hg g_kqZklguc kug [h]Zluo jh^bl_e_c E Lheklhc FZlv kijhkbeZ jZ[h lZ\r_]h \ ihe_ jZ[hq_]h ^Ze_dh eb ^h ^_]lyjgh]h aZ\h^Z F =hjvdbc Ih^t_oZeb hgb d ba[_ kijZrb\Zxl ]^_ lml jZ aukdZlv ohayckl\_ggmx qZklv > NmjfZgh\ IZ\_e >fbl jb_\bq Dhjbg ihdZau\Zy fg_ k\hx emqrmx \ Jhkkbb Z agZqbl b \h \k_f fbj_ qZklgmx dhee_dpbx bdhg ]h\hjbe qlh hg \k_ ^_gv]b aZjZ[hlZggu_ ljm^hf om^h`gbdZ \eh`be \ wlh kh[jZ gb_ Hg jZkkdZau\Ze qlh _fm ihgZ^h[behkv khjhd e_l qlh[u khklZ\blv wlh kh[jZgb_ bklbggh ij_djZkguo bdhg < Kheh mobg
KlZe ih\_a ]h\hjbe ml\_j`^Ze ]h\hjbe b
kijhkbe Z ih^t_oZe b jZ[hlZ\r _]h aZjZ[hlZgg u_
\eh`be jZkkdZau\Ze ihgZ^h[be h kv Y kijhkbeZ ^h\hevgh g_dklZlb ih ^_eZf eb hg aZ_oZe \ gZrm klhjhgm JZaj_rbl_ magZlv ]^_ \u dhgqbeb dmjk Hg kdZaZe qlh _]h i_qZev [_a]jZgbqgZ J_[ylZ djbqZl qlh[u bf ihfh]eb ijhclb ih wlhfm fhklm Imlgbd kijhkbe [_a ij_^b keh\bc fh`_f eb fu hl\_alb _]h gZ ijhlb\hiheh`guc [_j_] DZiblZg \_k_eh kdZaZe qlh[u y h[jZlbeky d g_fm FZevqbd bkim]Zggh kdZaZe [Z[mrd_ qlh [hblky Y hl\_lbe qlh gbq_]h g_ ihfgx Lu kijZrb\Z_rv ihq_fm y g_
\ha\jZsZx l_[_ ^_gv]b Khljm^gbd fbebpbb hl\_qZ_l \h^bl_ ex [m^lh hg jZa[_j_lky k gbf \ hl^_e_gbb ;Z[mrdZ mdhjba g_ggh ijhbag_keZ qlh \Zf ^he`gh [ulv klu^gh >bj_dlhj aZ \_jbe gZk qlh ijbf_l j_rbl_evgu_ f_ju GZqZevgbd klZgpbb khh[sbe qlh ihfh`_l gZf \ ijbh[j_l_gbb [be_lh\ Mq_gbd \kihfgbe b kdZaZe FZjv_ GbdheZ_\g_ qlh gZr_e j_r_gb_ aZ^Z qb <_jgm\rbkv hijh\_j]Zy � >\Mœva\eœhguMœ@ ² keh]Z >m@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >MœO ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >a@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >\@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >eœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >h@ ² ]eZkg m^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >u@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >MœO ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d a\mdh\ Myat\e_gguc ² [md\ >Mœmgtru@ ² keh]Z � >Mœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >m@ ² ]eZkg m^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >r@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >u@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ Xghrb ² [md\
� >klZ\œvpt@ ² keh]Z >k@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >l@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >Z@ ² ]eZkg m^ >\œ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d
>v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >p@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ KlZ\ylky ² [md\ ?keb dZ`^uc [m^_l ]h\hjblv dZd hg ohq_l fu fh`_f g_ ihgylv ^jm] ^jm]Z Yaud j_qv gZrZ ba kj_^kl\Z h[s_gby ij_\jZ lblky \ kj_^kl\h jZah[s_gby : wlh]h lh ^himklblv g_evay Bg kljmf_gl ex[h]h ljm^Z ^he`_g [ulv ohjhrh hllhq_g gZeZ`_g gZkljh_g Lhevdh lh]^Z bf fh`gh jZ[hlZlv b [ukljh b ijZ\bev gh b djZkb\h Ebl_jZlmjgu_ ghjfu ² wlh b _klv gZeZ`_gguc bgkljmf_gl gZr_]h h[s_gby Lhqg__ lh qlh gZeZ`b\Z_l ebl_jZ lmjguc yaud ^_eZ_l _]h ijZ\bevguf \ujZabl_evguf h[s_ih gylguf E Kd\hjph\
� >bgkljmfœwgl@ ² keh]Z >b@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >F@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >l@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >j@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >m@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >fœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >w@ ² ]eZkg m^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >l@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdh\ Bgkljmf_gl ² [md\ >]kkkk]k]kk@ JZah[s_gb y
Ex[h]h ² f_klhbf_gb_ Ljm^Z dZdh]h" ex[h]h G n ² ex[hc Hij_^_ebl ?^ q f j J i Ljm^Z dZdh]h" ex[h]h
?keb \ [ulh\hc j_qb wlb hkh[_gghklb b ijhbaghr_gb_ y\eyxlky ^himklbfufb lh \ im[ebqghf \uklmie_gbb bo g_h[ oh^bfh ba[_]Zlv K[b\qb\ uc
>\mo ² bfy qbkebl_evgh_ Klbe_c kdhevdbo" ^\mo Dheb q_kl\h G n ² ^\Z Ijhkl dhebq p_eh_ J i HkhagZgby q_]h" ^\mo klbe_c Ibkvf_ggZy b mklgZy nhjfu j_qb bf_xl jZagmx fZl_jb Zevgmx hkgh\m ^\b`msb_ky kehb \ha^moZ a\mdb ² \ mklghc j_qb b djZkdZ [md\u ² \ ibkvf_gghc j_qb K wlbf jZaebqb_f k\yaZgu [h]Zlu_ bglhgZpbhggu_ \hafh`ghklb mklghc j_qb b hl kmlkl\b_ lZdh\uo \ ibkvf_gghc j_qb ² BglhgZpby kha^Z_lky f_eh^bdhc j_qb f_klhf eh]bq_kdh]h m^Zj_gby \ gZqZe_ k_j_ ^bg_ beb dhgp_ njZau _]h kbehc baf_g_gbyfb \ bgl_gkb\ghklb ]jhfdhklb kl_i_gvx q_ldhklb ijhbaghr_gby gZebqb_f beb hlkmlkl\b_f iZma Ibkvf_ggZy j_qv g_ \ khklhygbb i_j_^Zlv \k_ wlh < __ jZkihjy`_gbb lhevdh agZdb ij_ibgZgby imgdlmZpby dhlhju_ g_evay gZa\Zlv ^Z`_ [e_^ghc l_gvx bglhgZpbhggh]h jZaghh[jZaby j_qb H KbjhlbgbgZ
� >bgluwgœkœb\gtkœlœb@ ² keh]h\ >b@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >l@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >uw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >gœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >kœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >b@ ² ]eZkg m^ >\@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >kœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d
>lœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >b@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ Bgl_gkb\ghklb ² [md\
Ibkvf_gg Zy bglhgZpbhgg u_ @_gvdZ r_e ih madhc ^hjh]_ ihqlb g_ hibjZykv gZ iZe dm b kh\k_f g_ hsmsZy jZg_ghc gh]b M^Zjbe fhjha_p b \ha ^mo i_j_kus_gguc \eZ]hc ih\bk gZ^ a_fe_c Ojmkl_eZ ih^fh jh`_ggZy a_fey b \ \ha^mo_ klhyeZ lmfZggZy f]eZ < l_q_gb_ \k_]h imlb ih klhjhgZf kl_ebeZkv k_j_[jygZy hl bg_y ljZ\Z Jmdb ^Z\gh ijb\udeb h[oh^blvky [_a i_jqZlhd m`_ g_ f_jaeb Gh \hl lmfZg \i_j_^b ihj_^_e b dZd ihdZaZehkv @_gvd_ ijb h[j_e g_`gh jhah\uc hll_ghd G_h`b^Zggh \ ]ms_ wlh]h [_k ihdhcgh]h \ha^moZ hldjueky bkklmie_ggh djZkguc ]eZa Hg klZe m\_ebqb\Zlvky gZ[moZlv p\_lhf b \^jm] ba gbq_]h jh^b ehkv g_qlh Wlh \klZeh khegp_ b hk\_lbeh ih gh\hfm \k_ \h djm] Ih < L_g^jydh\m
� >iœvjœbwkusœvguMœ@ ² keh]h\ >iœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >jœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d >bw@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >F@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >u@ ² ]eZkg m^ >sœ@ ² kh]e ]emo fy]d >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >u@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >Mœ@ ² kh]e a\hgd fy]d a\mdh\ I_j_kus_gguc ² [md\ Ih gh\hfm
gh\ uc
<i_j_^b ² gZj_qb_ Ihj_^_e ]^_" \i_j_^b IjbagZd ^_c kl\by
F_klZ G_baf Ihj_^_e ]^_" \i_j_^b
M^Zjbe fhjha_p b \ha^mo i_j_kus_gguc \eZ]hc ih\bk gZ^
a_fe_c
> ² @ b > ²
@
o
Y i_j_r_e q_j_a rbjhdmx ^hjh]m hklhjh`gh ijh[jZeky
kd\hav aZiue_ggmx djZib\m b ijbkehgbeky d gbadhfm ie_lgx o
G_ih^\b`gh e_`Ze i_j_^h fghc g_[hevrhc kZ^ \_kv haZj_gguc
b dZd [u mkihdh_gguc k_j_[jbklufb emqZfb emgu \_kv [eZ]h gZj_q
o
\hgguc b \eZ`guc JZa[bluc ih klZjbgghfm hg khklhye ba h^ ghc ijh^he]h\Zlhc iheygu Ijyfu_ ^hjh`db koh^bebkv gZ kZ o
fhc __ k_j_^bg_ \ djm]emx demf[m ]mklh aZjhkrmx ZkljZfb \ukhdb_ ebiu hdjm`Zeb __ jh\ghc dZcfhc < h^ghf lhevdh f_k
l_ ij_ju\ZeZkv wlZ dZcfZ kZ`_gb gZ ^\_ b kd\hav hl\_jklb_ \b^ \\ k k
g_eZkv qZklv gba_gvdh]h ^hfZ k ^\mfy d m^b\e_gbx fh_fm hk o
\_s_ggufb hdgZfb K h^ghc klhjhgu kZ^Z ebiu kfmlgh ijbe o
a_e_g_eb h[eblu_ g_ih^\b`guf [e_^gh yjdbf k\_lhf k ^jm]hc o
² hgb klhyeb \k_ q_jgu_ b g_ijhajZqgu_ KljZgguc k^_j`Zg o
guc rhjho \hagbdZe ih \j_f_gZf \ bo kiehrghc ebkl\_ <k_ g_
[h [ueh bki_sj_gh a\_a^Zfb lZbgkl\_ggh kljmbehkv k \urbgu o
\\ k k
bo ]hem[h_ fy]dh_ f_jpZgv_ hgb dZaZehkv k lbobf \gbfZgb_f ]ey^_eb gZ ^Ze_dmx a_fex
B Lmj]_g_\
Ih klZjbgghfm g_ih^\b`g uf bki_sj_g h lZbgkl\_ggh G_ih^\b`gh e_`Ze i_j_^h fghc g_[hevrhc kZ^ \_kv haZj_g guc b dZd [u mkihdh_gguc k_j_[jbklufb emqZfb emgu \_kv [eZ]h\hgguc b \eZ`guc Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij hkeh`g_gh h[h kh[e hij_^_e_gbyfb
:jobl_dlmjZ ² wlh kljhbl_evgh_ bkdmkkl\h mf_gb_ ijh _dlbjh\Zlv b kha^Z\Zlv ]hjh^Z `beu_ ^hfZ iehsZ^b mebpu kZ ^u b iZjdb <h fgh]bo ]hjh^Zo gZr_c kljZgu \u \klj_lbl_ ^j_\gb_ dj_f eb b p_jd\b ^\hjpu b hkh[gydb kh\j_f_ggu_ a^Zgby i_j_^ dh lhjufb aZohq_lky hklZgh\blvky b ih\gbfZl_evg__ bo jZkkfhl j_lv LZd `_ \u klhyeb [u \ fma__ i_j_^ bgl_j_kghc dZjlbghc b kdmevilmjhc Wlh ihlhfm qlh a^Zgby b mebpu iehsZ^b b iZjdb dhfgZlu b aZeu k\h_c djZkhlhc lh`_ fh]m \hegh\Zlv \hh[jZ`_ gb_ b qm\kl\Z q_eh\_dZ dZd b ^jm]b_ ijhba\_^_gby bkdmkkl\Z R_^_\ju Zjobl_dlmju aZihfbgZxlky dZd kbf\heu gZjh^h\ b kljZg <k_fm fbjm ba\_klgu Dj_fev b DjZkgZy iehsZ^v \ Fhkd \_ Wcn_e_\Z [Zrgy \ IZjb`_ ^j_\gbc :djhihev \ :nbgZo H^ gZdh \ hlebqb_ hl ^jm]bo bkdmkkl\ ijhba\_^_gby Zjobl_dlmju fh`gh g_ lhevdh kha_jpZlv gh b bkihevah\Zlv ŠQlh lZdh_" Dlh lZdhc"ª
:jobl_dlmjZ ² ah^q_kl\h R_^_\j ² h[jZaph\h_ kha^Zgb_ KdmevilmjZ ² klZlmy Kbf\he ² agZd wf[e_fZ Kha_jpZlv ² jZkkfZljb\Zlv Kh\j_f_gg u_ ba\_klg u
� Bkihevah\Zlv [md\ ² >bkiheœat\tlœ@ ² a\mdh\ � JZkkfhlj_lv [md\ ² >jtkfZljœwlœ@ ² a\mdh\ <k_fm fbjm ba\_klgu Dj_fev b DjZkgZy iehsZ^v \ Fhkd\_ Wcn_e_\Z [Zrgy \ IZjb`_ ^j_\gbc :djhihev \ :nbgZo qlh"
b
Imrdbg ^h lh]h m^b\be f_gy baysghc ijhklhlhc b fmau
dhc klboZ qlh ^he]h_ \j_fy ijhaZ dZaZeZkv fg_ g__kl_kl\_gghc
^Z`_ qblZlv __ [ueh dZd lh g_eh\dh b g_bgl_j_kgh Ba\_klguc ijheh] d ŠJmkeZgm b Ex^fbe_ª gZihfgbe fg_ emqrb_ kdZadb [Z [mrdb k`Z\ bo \ h^gm < fh_f \hh[jZ`_gbb ykgh jbkh\Zebkv ke_
^u g_\b^Zgguo a\_j_c dhlhjufb ijbfylZ ljZ\Z _s_ g_ kljyo ijbq h[hjhl
gm\rZy dZi_ev mlj_gg_c jhku Ihegha\mqgu_ kljhqdb klboh\
aZihfbgZebkv m^b\bl_evgh e_]dh ij_l\hjyy \h qlh lh ijZa^gbq gh_ \k_ h q_f [u hgb gb ]h\hjbeb Wlh ^_eZeh f_gy kqZkleb\uf Z `bagv fhx e_]dhc b ijbylghc keh`gh_ g_ihegh_ F =hjvdbc
� Z >a`Zn@ ² keh] ² kh]e a\hgd l\ ` ² kh]e a\hgd l\ Z ² ]eZkg m^ n ² kh]e ]emo l\ a\mdZ K`Z\ ² [md\u [
\
]
K`Z\ K`Z\ ² ^__ijbqZklb_ K`Zlv >h[Z\hqgh_ ^_ckl\b_ Kh\ \b^ GZihfgbe dZd" k`Z\ K`Z\
M^b\be dZaZe Z kv H^gZ`^u \ ^hf_ ihy\beky _s_ h^bg h[blZl_ev <hl dZd wlh ijhbahreh <ha\jZsZykv dZd lh k ^_`mjkl\Z ^hdlhj m\b^_e ke_ih]h ikZ K h[ju\dhf \_j_\db gZ r__ hg kb^_e aZ[b\rbkv f_`^m [j_\gZfb b ^jh`Ze >hdlhj b jZgvr_ g_kdhevdh jZa \b ^_e _]h L_i_jv hg hklZgh\beky jZkkfhlj_e _]h \h \k_o ih^jh[ ghklyo ihqfhdZe ]m[Zfb ihk\bklZe ihlhf \ayeky aZ \_j_\dm b ihlZsbe ke_ih]h d k_[_ ^hfhc >hfZ ^hdlhj \ufue _]h l_iehc \h^hc k fuehf b gZdhjfbe Ih ijb\uqd_ i_k \a^jZ]b\Ze b ih^`bfZeky \h \j_fy _^u ?e hg `Z^gh ki_rbe ^Z\beky Eh[ b mrb _]h [ueb ihdjulu ih[_e_\ rbfb jm[pZfb ŠGm l_i_jv klmiZc ª ² kdZaZe ^hdlhj dh]^Z i_k gZ_eky b ih^lhedgme _]h k l_jjZku I_k mi_jky b aZ^jh`Ze Š=f ª ² ijhbag_k ^hdlhj b k_e \ dZqZedm GZklmiZe \_q_j g_[ ihl_fg_eh gh g_ ]Zkeh kh\k_f AZ]hj_ebkv kZfu_ djmigu_ a\_a^u =hgqbc i_k me_]ky gZ l_jjZk_ b aZ^j_fZe X DZaZdh\
Ki_rbe ² ki_rdZ gZki_o ki_rgh DZqZedZ ² dZqZlv dZq_eb ihdZqgmlvky <ha\jZsZykv ihdjulu
\ha\jZsZ lv ky aZ[b\rbkv
ihdju lv ih[_e_\rbfb
aZ[b lv ky
ih[_e_ lv
DZd lh ² gZj_qb_ <ha\jZsZykv dh]^Z" dZd lh IjbagZd ^_ckl\by G_hij_^ G_baf <ha\jZsZykv dh]^Z" dZd lh o
F_`^m ² ij_^eh] AZ[b\rbkv f_`^m [j_\gZfb L i Ijhkl g_ijhba\ g_baf G_ qe_g ij_^eh`_gby
Gh ² khxa Ihl_fg_eh gh g_ ]Zkeh Khqbg ijhlb\ ijhkl g_baf G_ qe_g ij_^eh`_gby Klhbl eb i_j_qblu\Zlv jmdhibkgu_ dgb]b jZkkfZljb \Zlv ihq_jg_\rb_ hl \j_f_gb nj_kdb \ ^Z\gh aZ[jhr_gguo p_jd\yo ^mfZlv h agZq_gbb \hegbklhc ebgbb hjgZf_glZ \uk_ q_ggh]h gZ aZfr_ehf dZfg_" ?klv eb kfuke khojZgylv [j_\_gqZ lu_ ba[u ^hfhldZgu_ ihehl_gpZ jZkrblu_ djZkgufb gblyfb \Zevdb mdjZr_ggu_ aZ]Z^hqgufb ]_hf_ljbq_kdbfb mahjZfb"
Q_eh\_d g_ ih^h[_g [Z[hqd_ h^gh^g_\d_ \_k_eh ihjoZxs_c
ijb khegp_ g_ agZxs_c h lhf qlh [ueh \q_jZ b qlh _c kmebl
aZ\ljZ < _]h km^v[_ kie_lZxlky \ _^bguc ma_e [ueh_ gug_rg__ kms
kms
b aZ\ljZrg__ Q_eh\_d ² kug k\h_]h \j_f_gb b k\h_c kljZgu kms
ijbe
qm\kl\h Jh^bgu \k_]^Z g_hl^_ebfh hl qm\kl\Z bklhjbb ? Hk_ljh\
� <j_f_gb ² >\jœwfœvgœb@ ² >kk]k]k]@ � Qm\kl\h ² >qœmkl\t@ ² >k]kkk]@
Ihq_jg_\r b_ aZ[jhr_gg uo \uk_q_gg h]h jZkrbl u_
mdjZr_gg u_
Jmdhibkg u_ Kie_lZxlky ² ie_klb ie_lv
KhojZgylv ² hojZgZ ojZgblv M`_ [ueh gZqZeh bxgy dh]^Z dgyav :g^j_c \ha\jZsZ ykv ^hfhc \t_oZe hiylv \ lm [_j_ah\mx jhsm \ dhlhjhc wlhl klZjuc dhjy\uc ^m[ lZd kljZggh b iZfylgh ihjZabe _]h ;m[_g qbdb _s_ ]emr_ a\_g_eb \ e_km q_f f_kyp lhfm gZaZ^ \k_ [ueh ihegh l_gbklh b ]mklh b fheh^u_ _eb jZkkuiZggu_ ih e_km g_ gZjmrZeb h[s_c djZkhlu b ih^^_eu\Zykv ih^ h[sbc oZjZdl_j g_`gh a_e_g_eb imrbklufb fheh^ufb ih[_]Zfb P_euc ^_gv [ue `Zjdbc ]^_ lh kh[bjZeZkv ]jhaZ gh lhevdh g_[hevrZy lmqdZ [juagmeZ gZ iuev ^hjh]b b gZ khqgu_ ebklvy E_\Zy klhjhgZ e_kZ [ueZ l_fgZ \ l_gb ijZ\Zy fhdjZy ]eygp_ \Zy [e_kl_eZ gZ khegp_ qmlv dheuoZykv hl \_ljZ <k_ [ueh \ p\_lm kheh\vb lj_sZeb b i_j_dZlu\Zebkv lh [ebadh lh ^Ze_dh E Lheklhc
Kh[bjZeZkv ² kh[_jmkv kh[bjZl_ev ;e_kl_eZ ² [ebklZlv [e_kgmeZ <ha\jZsZykv Z
[
� >jZkuitguv@ ² keh]h\ >j@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >Z@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >k@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >u@ ² ]eZkg m^ >i@ ² kh]e ]emo l\ >t@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >g@ ² kh]e a\hgd l\ >u@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ >v@ ² ]eZkg [_am^ a\mdh\ JZkkuiZggu_ ² [md\
JZkkuiZgg u_
\ JZkkuiZggu_ ² ijbqZklb_ ?eb dZdb_" jZkkuiZg gu_ ijbagZd ij_^f_lZ ih ^_ckl\bx JZkkuiZlv KljZ^ g_\ha\j kh\ \b^ ijhr \j Fg q B i
]
?eb dZdb_" jZkkuiZggu_
JZkkuiZgg u_
<k_ [ueh \ p\_lm kheh\vb lj_sZeb
b
i_j_dZlu\Zebkv
lh [ebadh lh ^Ze_dh Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde keh`gh_ q ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl g_jZkij ihegh_ q ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h^ghjh^ gufb kdZam_fufb b h^ghjh^gufb h[klhyl_evkl\Zfb > ² @ > ² b @ =hjh^ dZaZeky \uf_jrbf imkluggu_ mebpu aZf_eh kg_ ]hf oheh^gu_ ]jhfZ^u ^hfh\ abyeb jZgZfb [_a`bag_ggh ih \bkeb khj\Zggu_ ijh\h^Z ljhee_c[mku gZf_jl\h \f_jaeb \ km] jh[u Gh jZg_guc bafmq_gguc ]hjh^ ijh^he`Ze `blv l\hjq_kdhc `bagvx \ hkm`^_gghf ]hjh^_ RhklZdh\bq gZibkZe k\hx agZ f_gblmx kbfnhgbx gZa\Zggmx ŠE_gbg]jZ^kdhcª \ ih^\ZeZo WjfblZ`Z jZ[hlZeb ijhkeZ\e_ggu_ om^h`gbdb Zjobl_dlhju mq_gu_ hldZaZ\rb_ky g_kfhljy gZ ij_dehgguc \hajZkl b ]Zk gms__ a^hjh\v_ m_oZlv ba E_gbg]jZ^Z ;beb[bg aZf_qZl_ev guc om^h`gbd kdZahqgbd ^h ihke_^g_]h k\h_]h ^gy hg mf_j \ n_\jZe_ ]h^Z jZ[hlZe gZ^ h[jZaZfb [uebgguo jmkkdbo [h]Zluj_c GZ \k_ ij_^eh`_gby m_oZlv klZjuc om^h`gbd g_ba f_ggh hl\_qZe ŠBa hkZ`^_gghc dj_ihklb g_ [_]ml Z h[hjhgy xlkyª Ih B Gbdbnhjh\kdhc
GZf_jl\h IjhkeZ\e_ggu_ ² keZ\Z keZ\guc Bafmq_gguc ² fmqblvky fmdZ DZaZeky \uf_jrbf ² khklZ\gh_ bf_ggh_ kdZam_fh_
;beb[bg aZf_qZl_evguc om^h`gbd kdZahqgbd ^h ihke_^g_]h \klZ\g d pby
k\h_]h ^gy hg mf_j \ n_\jZe_ ]h^Z jZ[hlZe gZ^ h[jZaZfb
[uebgguo jmkkdbo [h]Zluj_c Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\mkhkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh` g_gh h[hkh[e jZkij ijbeh`_gb_f \klZ\ghc dhgkljmdpb_c