Mervinskiy 406

Page 46

46 when dealing with the point later in the judgment, in my view, there was no basis whatsoever for the allegation of abuse of process or improper purpose. 9. Procedural Background 97.

FBI applied to and obtained leave to bring its judicial review proceedings from the

High Court (Meenan J.) on 14th September, 2020. Its statement of grounds was supported by an affidavit sworn by Ms. Yvonne Cunnane on 10th September, 2020. The Court ordered that there be a stay in the taking of any further steps in the inquiry pending the determination of the proceedings. 98.

On the DPC’s application, the proceedings were entered in the Commercial List on

25th September, 2020. The DPC delivered its statement of opposition on 23rd October, 2020. It was verified by an affidavit sworn by Ms. Dixon on the same date. 99.

In the meantime, Mr. Schrems obtained leave to bring his judicial review proceedings

from the High Court (Barr J.) on 12th October, 2020. Those proceedings were entered in the Commercial List on 19th October, 2020, on Mr. Schrems’ application. Mr. Schrems applied to be joined as a notice party to FBI’s proceedings on 14th October, 2020. FBI applied to be joined as a notice party to Mr. Schrems’ proceedings on 22nd October, 2020. Ultimately, it was agreed that each of FBI and Mr. Schrems would be joined as a notice party to the other’s proceedings and orders in those terms were made on 29th October, 2020. 100.

Mr. Schrems delivered a statement of opposition in FBI’s proceedings on 3rd

November, 2020 and swore an affidavit verifying that statement on 5th November, 2020. 101.

Ms. Cunnane swore a replying affidavit on behalf of FBI on 11th November, 2020.

That was the last of the affidavits sworn in these proceedings until a number of further affidavits were sworn at the direction of the court in the break in the proceedings between 21st December, 2020 and 13th January, 2021. An affidavit was sworn by Colum Walsh on 23rd December, 2020 on behalf of the DPC which provided information concerning the number of


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

JUDGMENT of Mr. Justice David Barniville delivered on the 14th day of May Index

1min
page 197

24.Abuse of Process/Improper Purpose

7min
pages 192-195

25.Summary of Conclusions

1min
page 196

22.Adequacy of DPC’s Reasons

5min
pages 181-183

23.Duty of Candour

14min
pages 184-191

21.Alleged Disproportionality of Simultaneous Inquiries

1min
page 180

20.Alleged Discrimination/Breach of FBI’s Right to Equality: Inquiry into FBI Only

23min
pages 167-179

17.Alleged Breach of Fair Procedures: Involvement of Commissioner at Investigation and Decision Making Stages

10min
pages 151-156

16.Alleged Breach of Fair Procedures: Premature Judgment

34min
pages 132-150

15.Alleged Breach of Fair Procedures: 21 Day Period for Submissions

31min
pages 114-131

Expectation

59min
pages 80-113

Decision

19min
pages 69-79

12.Whether PDD/DPC’s Procedure is Amenable to Judicial Review

28min
pages 53-68

11.Structure for Consideration of the Issues Raised

2min
pages 51-52

10.Resolution of Mr. Schrems Proceedings

3min
pages 49-50

Correspondence Post the DPC’s 28 August 2020 Letter and PDD8

19min
pages 35-45

9. Procedural Background

5min
pages 46-48

DPC’s 28 August 2020 Letter and PDD7

22min
pages 22-34

6. Developments Post Judgment in Schrems II

2min
pages 17-18

Relevant Factual Background…………………………………………………4

8min
pages 8-12

Failure to Await Guidance from EDPB and/or Failure to Take Timing of EDPB

5min
pages 19-21

Introduction

5min
pages 3-5

Structure of Judgment………………………………………………………..…….. 3

1min
page 7
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.