Eight Recommendations for School Design Excellence in the 21st Century Developed at the AAF National Summit on School Design, 2005 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Design Schools to Support a Variety of Learning Styles Enhance Learning by Integrating Technology Foster a “Small School� Culture Support Neighborhood Schools Create Schools as Centers of Community Engage the Public in the Planning Process Make Healthy, Comfortable, & Flexible Learning Spaces Consider Non-Traditional Options for School Facilities
For more on the National Summit on School Design, visit www.archfoundation.org
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
1
The Voice of the Student on School Design project was undertaken in 2008 to identify how students believe the design of their schools affects their ability to learn, create, and succeed. Based on the comprehensive analysis of over 250 entries from the 2007 Redesign Your School contest, the project provides the most significant U.S. data to date on student attitudes about school design, from unwelcoming hallways and unforgiving library chairs to ideal learning environments that inspire and engage. The American Architectural Foundation (AAF) believes these findings can be a tool for meaningful change for educators, policy leaders and architects across the country, as they strive to build better schools.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
2
This overriding question guided the analysis; the answer came from the students.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
3
A high-school student in Santa Barbara, Calif., conveys the essence of what a school should be–a complex environment that inspires. Quotes included in this presentation were selected because they were representative of common ideas shared by many of the participating students.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
4
When asked, young people made the connection between education and the design of their school. Overwhelmingly, students said they believe more flexible facilities would support innovative teaching. With the words and phrases in their essays, they voted for daylighting and made clear they expect technology and “green� design to be integrated into the learning environment. And they insisted on connecting to the outdoors. They also linked the shape of a classroom to lessons learned in it.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
5
The Voice of the Student on School Design project began with a design contest called Redesign Your School: A Contest of Scholarly Proportions conducted by AAF in partnership with Target. The goal was to engage 9th through 12th grade students to envision an ideal school–in 1,000 words and a variety of visuals modes: drawings, models, computer-generated graphics, etc. Thousands of students expressed interest. Completed entries from over 250 teens in 40 states provided layers of attitudes and aspirations. This summary of the analysis offers fresh perspective on the crucial relationship students have with schools. Despite the lure of the virtual world, students still envision school as a key place to learn, but they envision that learning space very differently from their current experience of school.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
6
What is an ideal school according to students? Unfettered by budgets or zoning considerations, students sketched fantastic structures. Fundamentally, they envisioned buildings that were spacious, warm, inviting, human scale, village-like, and colorful, with plenty of fresh air and sunlight. They also identified the need for places to talk to college counselors, to convene with friends, and to read, study, or maybe hang out alone.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
7
Students drew environmentally attuned, energy-efficient buildings, with natural light, ventilation, solar or geothermal power and built with sustainable bamboo and other natural materials. Students emphasized recycling and organic food. They also wondered why schools weren’t designed as teaching tools–for instance, why couldn’t a hallway be shaped like a strand of DNA?
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
8
Students mentioned stress and anxiety, overcrowding, uncomfortable seating, prison-like classrooms and buildings, as well as chaotic hallways. Their essays made clear that studying 21st-century lessons is a daily struggle in classrooms conceived for the 1900s. Their imagery attempted to resolve those issues through complex visualizations. This student’s vision of a library in a tree seems to say that learning needs to be serious, but the process and place doesn’t have to be. This is a distinction between curriculum, process and place noted by many of the students—a distinction that is often overlooked by others.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
9
This student’s vision of school is connected to the outdoors. Research has shown that human stress levels fall within minutes of seeing green spaces, and that patients in hospitals respond positively to images of lush greenery. Without necessarily knowing this research, students intuited it. They included access to the outdoors, increased permeability of the environment to school surroundings, and indoor gardens in their images of ideal schools.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
10
This student describes bringing the outdoors inside to activate space and create new, non-traditional learning places. Further, she creatively envisions a way to spark the desire to learn, a core purpose of schools, in her description of an ideal school design.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
11
In their designs and essays, students made clear that schools must integrate the technology–laptops, cell phones and music players–that is already in their backpacks. The student essays and images clearly integrate today's technology and envisioned tomorrow’s breakthroughs. As seen above, one student created future school library technology, while another envisioned harnessing the energy of students in the hallways to generate electricity to power the lights.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
12
To determine which themes and concerns might inform the national debate on school design excellence, the American Architectural Foundation invited an interdisciplinary team to analyze the students’ contest entries.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
13
The team considered qualitative and quantitative aspects of the students’ design concepts.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
14
Students had been asked at the outset to consider eight principles for school design excellence developed at the 2005 National Summit on School Design.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
15
Student aspirations and Summit principles meshed in some areas. There was more than 75 percent support for “healthy, comfortable and flexible” learning spaces, a key tenet of the Summit. However, the student group assigned less importance to size (just 52 of 250 favored fostering a “small school” culture) and proximity to home (only 40 of 250 saw a particular need for “neighborhood” high schools) than to updated technology and adaptable space.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
16
Analysts dug deeper into the essays to elicit more subtle themes. More than 60 percent of the students mentioned the importance of outdoor access. Nearly half the students mentioned feelings and emotions. Forty percent of the students mentioned structure and organization of school programs and curriculum. Security and safety emerged as an issue for 55 of the 250 students, while 39 were especially concerned about food and fitness.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
17
This student recognizes the connection between the built environment and her experience of it.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
18
In their choice of words–such as “project-based,” “campus,” and “real world”–the students signaled readiness for varied teaching models as well as a desire for educational links to the community. They saw collaborative studies as a path to leadership and responsibilities. They understood that boxed-in classrooms and rows of desks did not put them on that path. Students incorporated corridors, areas under stairs and around lockers in their concepts of alternative learning spaces.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
19
Students envisioned teachers as “facilitators� rather than lecturers. In the role of facilitator teachers support new learning opportunities in the eyes of the student. Then, like the students, these facilitators would benefit from more flexible space.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
20
Without necessarily realizing it, this student envisions a possible avenue for school reform and the acquisition of 21st century skills.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
21
Students drew clear pictures with their words–“one on one,” “interact,” “studio,” and “small group.” They envisioned the need for dormitories for children with problems at home; daycare for students with children, and a café for anyone who missed breakfast. One student suggested covering the walls with canvas to encourage budding Van Goghs.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
22
The desire for flexibility can be read as a vote for changing the scenery to suit the educational assignment or to fit the changing needs of young adults. The educational implication is compelling: students want variety built into space and schedule.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
23
This quote illustrates students’ awareness that education already happens outside the classroom but could be more effective if given as much attention as classroom design.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
24
Students used a fluid vocabulary to describe the variety of social interactions that occur in the course of a school day. The importance of peer-to-peer communication and small group study emerged clearly, along with their desire to “hang out” with fellow students. This aligns with developmental theory that explains how social interaction is necessary for the maturation of young adults. Thoughtful space planning could accommodate this form of “social learning.”
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
25
The concepts behind the words imply a need for welcoming social spaces in which to engage other students, or even teachers, in a meaningful way. Students wished schools were more comfortable.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
26
A recurring theme in the contest entries was that school requires students to turn off their personal technology and use outdated and often inadequate school technological resources. This causes a disconnection with the real world, especially as better technology might exist in their own backpacks.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
27
The use of technology by this generation is a dominant theme. For good or bad, their world is open content, open source. With file sharing, blogs, wikis, tagging, social bookmarking, podcasts, video logs, and peer-productions students can speak their minds on almost any topic, at any time of day, without filters. Students made clear that technology is already integrated in their lives and they want it fully integrated in school to enhance their learning.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
28
The students’ understanding of technology extends beyond personal gadgets to high-performance building systems and geothermal heat sources. The students recognized the potential of technology to enhance the lessons they are learning; for instance, virtual reality headsets to experience history, or video conferences to speak with native speakers in language classes.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
29
As the quote indicates, students are constructing their own pathways to information rather than simply receiving information from the teacher. At the same time, they value the teacher as one who helps construct a framework for learning that will last a lifetime.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
30
Across the board, students from urban, rural and suburban schools expressed a need for greater connection to the outdoors.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
31
Students valued the outdoors for varied reasons. For them, a school garden could promote healthy eating; skylights could reduce stress; fresh air could decrease illnesses; time outside could promote a love of nature; and using outdoor spaces could reduce energy costs.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
32
Students continue to react against the old models of school design. They feel that the very structure of schools need to be rethought and updated to reflect 21st century expectations they have for themselves.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
33
The Voice of the Student offers a unique opportunity to understand critical issues about the learning environment, as perceived by the most underrepresented voice in school design—the students. AAF anticipates the project findings will inform educators, policy makers, and architects who make decisions that affect these young clients each school day. It is time to listen to the voices of students.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
34
The American Architectural Foundation (AAF) is a national nonprofit organization that seeks to educate individuals and community leaders about the power of architecture to transform lives and improve the places where we live, learn, work, and play. Through numerous outreach programs, grants, and education resources, the AAF inspires to become more thoughtful and engaged stewards of the built environment. AAF’s Great Schools by Design initiative aims to improve the quality of America’s schools by promoting good design, encouraging collaboration in the design process, and providing leading-edge resources that empower schools and communities to transform themselves. At AAF, we seek to make individuals and communities aware of their vital role in shaping the world around them. For more information, please visit us online at www.archfoundation.org. Great design is the essence of the Target brand. Target partners with world-class designers to offer amazing products at affordable prices. Since day one, Target company founders recognized that the appeal of smart, stylish, well-designed products and stores would set Target apart. Today, Target operates more than 1,613 stores in 47 states nationwide. Committed to local communities, Target gives back near $3 million a week through grants and special programs in the fields of education, the arts, disaster preparedness and relief. With AAF, Target is a presenting sponsor of Great Schools by Design and Redesign Your School: A Competition of Scholarly Proportions. For more information about Target, visit www.target.com. On behalf of AAF, OWP/P conducted a comprehensive analysis of the Redesign Your School contest entries and presented initial findings to a national audience on November 13, 2008, on which this pdf is based. With offices in Chicago and Phoenix, OWP/P provides integrated architecture, interior design, engineering and consulting services to clients worldwide. OWP/P collaborates with public and private clients in civic, corporate, education, finance, health care, hospitality, law, and retail industries to design healthy, energy-efficient solutions that work from the inside out. For more information about OWP/P, visit www.owpp.com.
American Architectural Foundation | Voice of the Student on School Design
35