Journal of the Mental Environment
What I am saying is not directly obvious. I must try to make it clear. I will try to speak of the beauty of shapes, and I do not mean, as most people would think, the shapes of living figures, or their imitations in painting; I mean straight lines and curves and the shapes made from them, flat or solid by the lathe, ruler and square, if you see what I mean. These are not beautiful for any particular reason or purpose, as other things are, but are always by their very nature beautiful and give pleasure of their own, quite free from the itch of desire, and colors of this kind are beautiful too and give a similar pleasure.
Series II, N0. 2b, The Jews’ Standpoint at the birth of Jesus (1920), Hilma Af Klint
Inkblot Cards I, Hermann Rorshach
-Plato
(B1) Creeping Abstraction.indd 2
13-05-10 5:48 PM
(B1) Creeping Abstraction.indd 3
13-05-10 5:52 PM
Series II, N0. 2b, The Jews’ Standpoint at the birth of Jesus (1920), Hilma Af Klint
Inkblot Cards I, Hermann Rorshach
If the 20th century was the century of the straight line, of a yang rationality, of modernism and abstraction,
(B1) Creeping Abstraction.indd 20
13-05-10 5:53 PM
(B1) Creeping Abstraction.indd 21
13-05-10 5:53 PM
Winslow Laroche
(C1) Summer•e.indd 8
13-05-10 6:01 PM
Taking Pictures with Thomas Ruff VIII (2012), Jesse Morgan Barnett. Image courtesy of Marty Walker Gallery. jessemorganbarnett.com
It was at MoMA in New York many years ago. I saw it from a distance at first: Kazimir Malevich’s unmistakable, iconic Black Square—that perfect and immutable monolith, that palate-cleansing cipher which admits nothing but its own abstract purity. As I eagerly approached it, I saw something that I never expected to see . . . variation! This was not the mathematical gesture of flawlessness that I had been holding in my mind for decades. This was messy, blothcy, rough-hewn, down to earth . . . suddenly I got it . . . a glimpse of nothing. . . tears welled up . . . —Kalle Lasn
(C1) Summer•e.indd 9
13-05-10 6:01 PM
art end dead
We could celebrate abstraction as one of the greatest artistic pulses of the 20th century, but one day after the crash we may look back at Damien Hirst, Richard Prince and Jeff Koons, and see them as dead-end artists . . . spasms of a fucked-up culture plummeting towards oblivion, a last gasp for meaning where there’s none to be had . . .
(C1) Summer•e.indd 22
13-05-10 6:02 PM
Timothy A. Clary/AFP/Getty Images/Newscom
My Perfect Mood
(C1) Summer•e.indd 23
Mark Gilbert
13-05-10 6:02 PM
Do the Al Qaeda and Taliban fighters suffer from post traumatic stress disorder? After fighting, do they go home, get drunk, take drugs, bash up their wives and commit suicide?
(D1) Capitalismo.indd 8
13-05-10 6:07 PM
Blind Man’s Garden Pankaj Mishra
In an early scene of Nadeem Aslam’s The Blind Man’s Garden, a poor widow called Tara is commissioned to sew an American flag. In her town, where many people have stories about friends or relatives being killed, tortured or imprisoned, the flag can only be wanted for one purpose. “Can you please make sure that it is of a material that doesn’t burn too fast or too slowly?” her client asks, “the flames have to look inspiring and fearsome in the photographs.” Over several pages Aslam describes Tara at work, “setting fire to small strips of cloth to measure the texture, intensity and evenness of the various flames.” She makes the stars out of white satin then wonders “what the various elements of the flag signify. Are the white and red stripes rivers of milk and wine, flowing under a sky bursting with the splendor of stars? Or are they paths soaked with blood, alternating with paths strewn with bleached white bones, leading out of a sea full of explosions?” Tara’s speculation may seem lurid, fuelled by paranoia and ignorance, if not a primeval anti-Americanism, but Aslam appears unfazed by the possibility of provoking exasperated alienation in his readers. Beginning with Season of the Rainbirds (1993), which depicts a hardhearted small-town mullah in Pakistan, he has set himself the task of describing the ideas and beliefs of people in semi-modern lower-middleclass communities. His outspoken protagonists blithely disregard Anglo-American notions of tact and discretion. “Two of their buildings fell down,” an Afghan remarks of his American enemies in The Wasted Vigil (2008), “and they think they know about the world’s darkness, about how unsafe a place it is capable of being!” In Maps for Lost Lovers (2005), set in a small Yorkshire town, a defender of honor killing has his say: “The West is full of hypocrites who kill our people with impunity and say it’s all a matter of principle and justice, but when we do the same thing they say our definition of “principle” and “justice” is flawed.”
(D1) Capitalismo.indd 9
13-05-10 6:07 PM
Aslam writes with a special feeling for the conservative Muslim mind—unusual in someone working in the predominantly secular tradition of the novel. No character in Maps for Lost Lovers gets as much authorial attention as Kaukab, a devout housewife and mother, who chants the Koran in Arabic, a language she doesn’t know, and whose stern prohibitions, emerging from a profound fear of the outside world, have damaged many lives, including her own children’s. Here, Aslam describes her laboriously picking up the prayer beads she scattered when she slapped her daughter during an argument:
There is a sense of consolation to the activity her fingers are engaged in, almost as though contact is being made with the dead: as a child she had seen her mother and grandmothers, and the other women in the house, similarly bent over the myriad daily tasks of the day, and sometimes— but not today, not now—the feeling is close to celebration, a remembrance and a praising of those now dead and absent but still living in her mind, unsung elsewhere and otherwise. Gone so thoroughly it is as though she had dreamed them.
Aslam’s novels are marked by this alternation of brutality and sympathy; tradition is seen as a source of both oppression and consolation. In The Wasted Vigil and now The Blind Man’s Garden, he describes an overtly political lower middle class sensibility fed by reflexively anti-Western Urdu tabloids, readings in the Koran and the Hadith, and an entrenched view of the evolution of Islamic societies and the modern West. “History is the third parent,” The Blind Man’s Garden announces in its first sentence, and Aslam offers no further explanation for the instant solidarity with the Afghans felt by two young men called Jeo and Mikal and their family members in Heer. It is enough that Jeo knows of Islamic martyrs from the stories he heard as a child from his father: “They were the men he was before he was this man, the ghostly thousands stretching back through the generations and as he slept they imparted things to him not just of life and death but of eternal life and death.” Students at a school funded by the ISI,
(D1) Capitalismo.indd 10
the Pakistani intelligence agency, are told “stories of rescue and heroism from Islam’s past, of populations in distress saved by pious gallants.” The children, “becoming impassioned,” let out “cries of “Fear not! Help is on its way from Heer!” hoping to be heard across thousands of years.”
As Jeo and Mikal are thrown into the “mayhem and chaos” of a war that takes in the Taliban, Al Qaeda militants, mercenary warlords and American soldiers and spies, it becomes clear that, for Aslam, ideology is a fourth parent. Towards the end of his life, Pasternak wrote a letter to his readers in the West in which he claimed that the Russian Revolution had inaugurated a new ideological age, and a new kind of man. “However great the difference between us,” Pasternak wrote, “our revolution set the tone for you as well: it filled the present century with meaning and content … It’s us you have to thank for this new man, who is present even in your ancient society.” But novels that take ideological convictions seriously are still oddly hard to find although our age is saturated with quasi-religious belief of one kind or other. The last intense decade of war could have been expected to produce a major fictional recognition of the emotional appeal and social import of the ideological mode of thought, but it hasn’t. The TV series Homeland, which depicts a white American soldier as a Muslim convert and terrorist, seems to be alone in hinting, if cartoonishly, at its power; as the post-9/11 efforts of John Updike and Martin Amis show, it is easier to reduce ideological belief to pathologies of sexual frustration, or the ordeal of constipation. A self-dissolving post-ideological irony is the dominant mode of the few narratives about Americans engaged in the struggle against Islamofascism—where, that is, those narratives aren’t assertions, following Hemingway, Mailer and James Jones, of
13-05-10 6:07 PM
physical and existential heroism.
As always, the apparent absence of ideology merely denotes its successful concealment. Writing in 1952, Philip Rahv warned that the rapid growth of American power and wealth after the war created an illusion that “our society is in its very nature immune to tragic social conflicts and collisions.” This was prescient. The prolonged postwar limbo, when the Cold War was safely exported around the globe in the form of innumerable hot wars, helped entrench the general belief at home that “the more acute problems of the modern epoch are unreal so far as we are concerned.” The collapse of communism in 1989 created fresh illusions: that history itself had ended, and that, to put it crudely, the rest of the world consisted of aspiring Americans. The wholly unexpected attacks of 9/11 provoked some disquieting epiphanies: “Our world, parts of our world,” Don DeLillo warned, had “crumbled into theirs,” condemning us to live “in a place of danger and rage.” Nevertheless the dominant assumption until the 2008 financial crisis was that “the dramatic climb of the Dow and the speed of the internet summoned us all to live permanently in the future, in the utopian glow of cyber-capital.”
One of the ambiguous beneficiaries of this perennially renewed faith in the Pax Americana has been the AngloAmerican novelist, who moved rapidly in the post-1945 period from chancy bohemianism to the institutional security of corporate publishing houses, university jobs and writing fellowships. But his vastly improved material conditions also cut him off from any experience of violence and deracination, things familiar to writers from previous generations, many of whom fought
(D1) Capitalismo.indd 11
in the two world wars. Those still commonplace human ordeals have been recorded instead by writers in postcolonial countries, many of whose lives have been directly affected by the rapid unravelling of nation-building ideologies against a background of neoimperialist fiascos. Aslam was born in Pakistan to a communist poet who fled to Britain after being persecuted by the pro-American Islamist dictator Zia-ulHaq and his novels don’t ration their bleakness: he writes at what Pasternak called “misery’s full tilt.” An occasional caustic moment betrays Aslam’s own view of the Islamists who peddle roseate visions of the past and future. When strident anti-Western protesters take to the streets of Heer, a nurse says, “Would someone tell the marchers that visas to Western countries are being given away in the next street? That’ll disperse them.” But as The Blind Man’s Garden goes on to show, Aslam is not content to describe the delusions of poor, under-educated Pakistanis and Afghans struggling with real and imagined dangers. He is interested in the way ideology—and propaganda—works among affluent, highly educated elites: how it invisibly moulds thought and shuts out all complex knowledge of the world. As Mikal contemplates an American prisoner, the brother of a soldier he has accidentally killed, he notes, “The white man’s eyes are a doorway to another world, to a mind shaped by different rules, a different way of life.” Even more than the long-bearded flag-burners who have become convenient totems of “Muslim rage,” the American politicians, soldiers, interrogators and torturers in The Blind Man’s Garden are revealed to be in ideology’s grip.
13-05-10 6:07 PM
The force of that ideology isn’t always easy to discern behind the claims to a benign and universalist liberalism that help the West rationalise large-scale violence—what Camus called “massacres justified by philanthropy.” Take Zero Dark Thirty, Kathryn Bigelow’s new film about Osama bin Laden’s assassination, which renders invisible the calamitous wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and—with its grittily resourceful, liquid-eyed American heroine battling hirsute terrorists—naturalises torture into a necessary weapon in the arsenal of liberal democracy. Compared with the YouTube videos of jihadists, the films shot by American soldiers during their long combat duties—showing them urinating on dead Afghans, or goofing around with blindfolded captives—seem lighthearted: these, you might think, are not men moved by any passionate conviction.
small figures in turbans.” They write: “we are praying for you.” And: “go get the Bad Men and I hope you kill them all.”
In The Blind Man’s Garden, however, they are seen by their adversaries to be fighting with their backs to the wall to defend American power. Everyone, even children, has been enlisted into the homeland’s Manichean militarism. They send letters and exhortatory pictures to their faraway protectors in Afghanistan, sketches of soldiers with “guns shooting at men with beards and helicopters dropping bombs on
In deep twilight they cross a broad flat valley with a river and river flats in it, every bit of it scorched black where a Daisy Cutter bomb had been dropped, reducing everything to ash, pumice, lava, the sides of the hills torn up into segments, and scattered over it all is the yellow haze of the unrisen moon, the cold night falling on them out of the east, the stars beginning their slide through the black slopes.
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Kalle Lasn
WEB DEVELOPER Karim Ratib
EDITOR-AT-LARGE Micah White
WEB ENGINEER Jeremy Teale
SENIOR EDITORS Darren Fleet, Stefanie Krasnow
TECH ASSOCIATE
CREATIVE DIRECTOR Pedro Inoue ART DIRECTOR Ellen Lee FRONT-END DEVELOPER Abdul Rehman Khewar
Kyle Robertson OFFICE MANAGER Wendee Lang CIRCULATION MANAGER Meaghan McAneeley INTERNS Dugan Nichols, Barbara Matthews, Andrew Mills
Aslam’s novel has some unexpected turns: at one point Mikal helps his American captive escape a group of vengeful locals. But moments like this—intimations of a common humanity—only occur in Aslam’s writing after he has categorically established the real differences and incompatibilities (socioeconomic, political, cultural) between human beings, after he has described a reality in which the rule of local tyrants can be preferable to the mayhem of war or the massacres justified by Western philanthropy. History, in this view, isn’t about progress: it is a nearly senseless accumulation of incidents and episodes. The novel is an anatomy of chaos, of murders, mutilations, bombedout villages and long wanderings through devastated landscapes:
There’s also a love story, a romance between Mikal and Naheed, Jeo’s wife, which gives
VOLUNTEERS Kevin Estrada, Mike Rae, Allison Thompson, Robyn Lord SPANISH EDITION David Leal Garcia (Senior Translator), Omar Prieto Méndez, Joan Quesada Navidad (Associate Translators), César González Gutiérrez (Associate Designer) PUBLISHERS Kalle Lasn, Bill Schmalz NEWSSTAND SERVICES Disticor
EMAIL editor@adbusters.org, artdirector@adbusters.org, campaigns@adbusters.org, subscriptions@adbusters.org
TELEPHONE tel: (604) 736-9401 toll-free: (800) 663-1243
POST 1243 West 7th Avenue, Vancouver, British Columbia, V6H 1B7 Canada
PRINTING: Quad/Graphics
For reprint permission, contact reprints@adbusters.org. Portions of the magazine may be photocopied for educational purposes. Adbusters magazine is published by Adbusters Media Foundation. GST# R127330082, ISBN/ISSN 0847-9097. ©Copyright 2013 by Adbusters Media Foundation. All Rights Reserved. Printed in the USA. Every care has been taken to trace copyright holders for images and text in this issue. However, if we have omitted anyone we apologize and will, if informed, make corrections.
(D1) Capitalismo•e.indd 12
COVER Photo: Untitled, Andrew Kodama Treatment by Gil Inoue
13-05-14 1:13 PM
Aslam’s packed account of suffering some moments of serenity: “What woke them was the sound of the rain stopping, the sudden calm in the middle of the night. A silence packed with distances.” But Aslam doesn’t need a love story to generate his arresting visions. He moves smartly from scene to scene, but his prose still has time to register a “vehicle’s paintwork smeared here and there with petals where the roadside wild flowers, dew-covered, must have thrashed against it during the journey.” The novel contains some quasi-surreal images: horses held captive underground which burst out of the soil, a snow leopard that is passed from one hand to another and a graveyard of lichen-covered Soviet planes and helicopters. Many of these scenes could be counted as sins against realism. Mikal, for instance, encounters the brother of the American he has murdered in the middle of a desert. Much of Aslam’s skill, though, lies in showing the way such coincidences become normal during war, as people are tossed aside and thrown up against one another. Even so, it would be a mistake to see him as a conventional realist. The most striking thing about The Blind Man’s Garden is its resemblance to a fairy tale. Dramatic partings and reunions, stories of betrayal, captivity, exile and rescue, historical legends, Islamic folklore, rumours, superstition: the novel aims at a kind of enchantment that has something in common with the Hamzanama and the fables of the Pakistani writer Intizar Husain; the cavalcade of characters as they embark on long journeys, fall in love, endure
pain and loss, and die, wouldn’t be out of place in the friezes of Borobudur. But the apparent lack of individuality and psychological depth in the Western sense doesn’t mean that Aslam’s claim on realism is false, or that he is just another writer serving up postcolonial tragedy with the spices of magical realism. The last decade of heedless war and the traumas it has inflicted on voiceless peoples makes itself felt throughout The Blind Man’s Garden. As the book ends, there is an ambiguous hint that Mikal may be reunited with Naheed: She looks up from the page she has been reading just as the gate opens to admit Mikal. Perhaps it is his ghost, here to convince her to continue with her life without him. He raises his hand slowly and she stands up and walks towards him, her own hand held out. The insects weave a gauze of sound in the air. She moves towards him and her eyes are full of a still intensity—as though aware of the unnamed, unseen forces in the world, and attempting in her mind to name and see them. This invocation of invisible, omnipotent powers is a rejection of the modern world’s third and fourth parents. Against the historical necessity of violence insisted on by liberal humanitarians and Islamist millenarians, Aslam is here describing the way history in the raw, bereft of faith in the future or a grand project, feels to the people most exposed to it —the ancients called it fate, hidden and incalculable. Pankaj Mishra is an acclaimed novelist and political essayist. This article is abridged from his review of Nadeem Aslam’s book The Blind Man’s Garden, “Postcolonial Enchantment,” which appeared in the February 2013 London Review of Books. Mishra’s current book is From the Ruins of Empire: The Revolt Against the West and the Remaking of Asia.
adbusters.org/trialsub or Call Wendee at 1-800-663-1243
(D1) Capitalismo.indd 13
13-05-10 PM Every care has been taken to6:07 trace copyright holders for images and
A utopian realm of pure form
STRINGER Mexico/Reuters
The wrapped bodies of two dead people hang from an overpass as three more dead bodies lie on the ground in Saltillo March 8, 2013.
(E1) Politico.indd 4
13-05-10 6:11 PM
I could be walking through the latest exhibitions at MoMA in New York or the Tate Modern in London. I could be questioning the intention of the artist. Commenting on their use of form and space. Stoking their ego with claims about “daring”and“moving beyond.” I could even add a final note about materiality, the superb sublimation of art in the inflicted and brutalized bodies. Art pushes. That is its nature. It must. And it is the same with violence. How could cold-blooded murder look so much like contemporary modern art? How can these dangling bodies orchestrate such movement without motion? Am I seeing more than just the expression of whose corners are whose? Do these bodies represent a new era of symbolic abstraction?
bridge is geopolitical unravelling. What lies in the street is the Enlightenment, mutilated, on its disembodied march in an unknown direction. On both sides of the crime are the rural and urban youth without future. Each pile of heads they collect looks more and more like the world to come, rather than the past behind. Only the most resilient emotional defenses inside of the most ignorant minds can cling to the idea that this degree of violence is an exception, that it isn’t America’s insatiable appetite for cocaine that feeds this public art nouveau. I fear there is no solution for this. Only further unravelling. Further impressions. Further brutality. Narco-capitalism is proving every bit as efficient in turning out profit and corpses as corporations and empires.
I have to give my head a shake.
Turn back again and look. Can you honestly conceive of another end? You eventually hope the dangling bodies are reality. Because as art, the gore is even more infectious, more telling, more real.
Underneath those sacks of spun cloth are real bodies with wounds, with lacerated tendons, with shredded flesh, with drill holes in their skulls, with their skin peeled back, with their dicks cut off, human forms wasted at the hands of real killers. What dangles from the
—Darren Fleet
STRINGER India/Reuters
body politic
(E1) Politico.indd 5
Skin. Gasoline. Match. Since 2011, more than 100 Tibetan monks have immolated themselves in the hope that their martyrdom will bring international attention to the Chinese occupation of their land. But lately the torrent of images is slowing to a trickle as China flexes its capacity to erase the monks’ deaths from cultural memory and historical record. Leaked official documents reveal that China has outlawed Tibetans from “taking pictures and filming the actual scene of self-immolation and mass gatherings” and from distributing such photos to others. Domestic censorship and aggressive international diplomacy does the rest.
13-05-10 6:11 PM
The mainstream consensus is that everything is swell in America, and that the nation is just moments away from a major comeback. But there are ominous signs that this may not be the case . . . that it’s not just the economy, not just the corpotocracy, but rather that there is something much deeper inside the guts of America that has gone rotten, something that may not be so easy—or even possible—to fix.
(F1) Fate.indd 2
13-05-10 6:15 PM
In 1960, 90% of working class families were married, now it’s 40% . . . that’s a social collapse! Perhaps even more foreboding is the rise of single person households—one in four Americans now live alone.
In early May, Secretary of State John Kerry traveled to Moscow to broker a Syrian peace deal with Russian President Vladimir Putin. His larger mission was to reassert America’s unique role as a global superpower. It was an urgent high level assignment— so it came as a shock that Putin kept Kerry’s entourage waiting in the cold of the Red Square for three long hours. The international prestige of America wavered just a little bit more that day.
Americans have always been proud of their nation’s values and integrity. But what happens when a nation abandons the moral path and begins to believe that it is okay to cheat and venture upon a path of least resistence? That it’s OK to be fat . . . OK to be greedy . . . OK to torture and to assassinate . . . OK to fuck around and then abort anything unwanted . . . A deep ethical degeneration is now percolating throughout the land. — Kono Matsu
(F1) Fate.indd 3
13-05-10 6:15 PM
(H1) Inner Balance.indd 12
13-05-10 6:22 PM
Is abstraction the crowning achievement of the Western imagination . . . or its fatal flaw?
(H1) Inner Balance.indd 13
13-05-10 6:22 PM
Let’s have some fun in front of Goldman Sachs’ 73 offices worldwide
Let’s thrill the world by putting this company out of business.
,
killcap.org
(J1) Back Cover.indd 2
13-05-10 5:47 PM
Liked the preview? Subscribe today to get the complete issue!
http://adbusters.org/subscribe