The French Antilles-Guiana in Literature: Feminine and Diseased Janice H. Kaufman Gardens of Eden or prisons of disease and death? Since Christopher Columbus described these new-found lands with terms reminiscent of the female body1 and gave them feminine names, 2 the Caribbean islands and Guiana have been associated with beauty, fertility, and life. Their lushness, primitivity, and defenselessness evoked in the colonizers the lust for possession. During the course of colonial history, the Europeans metaphorically raped these land-women, slayed their Indian lovers, 3 and turned them to a life of prostitution. In reaction to this abuse, the land-women have become frigid and sterile. Within a year of the Caribbean islands’ discovery, the explorers’ first impressions were replaced with images of corruption. During Columbus’s second voyage in 1493, a shore party lost in the forest of Guadeloupe came upon human remains and other evidence to support the Arawaks’ stories of the Caribs’ cannibalism. Later, after finding four bound, decomposing, European male bodies washed up on the shore at Monte Cristi, the expedition returned to the settlement established at Navidad to learn that all thirty-nine of the Spaniards had been massacred by Indians of Carib stock. The shock of the murders was mitigated by the continuing friendliness of the neighboring Taino Indians. It was also revealed that the slaughter had been provoked by the settlers’ greed: they had appropriated as many as five Indian women each and frequently quarreled with the natives over gold (Morison 1942, 427). But following the killings at Navidad, the Spanish revised their characterization of the Caribbean people from guileless believers4 to cruel monsters. From then on, the aggressiveness of the colonizer was morally justified (Antoine 1978, 47) to wrest the unspoiled isles from the possession of the Carib Indians, seen as incarnations of the devil. The myth of the feminized îles fortunées5 (the wealthy islands) remains to this day, but literature about the French Caribbean and French Guiana, whose territory Columbus reached in 1498, is also marked by themes of disease, defilement, debasement, and death. Another interpretation of the conquest of the West Indies and Guiana links the lands’ fate with the myth of the Garden of Eden. Columbus had started out in search of the legendary terrestrial paradise in a temperate region at the end of the Orient, and he believed that he had found it (Casas 1989, 383). The theme of the sexual and moral seduction of innocent man by woman appears and reappears in the literature of France and the Antilles-Guiana. If the natural resources and fertility of these lands can be considered part of their femininity, then one can say that European males were lured into wasting themselves on an arduous and expensive venture that eventually left them economically ruined, demoralized, and encumbered with non-productive dependencies. Volume 15, Number 1/2
FALL/SPRING 2003
phoebe
1